Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/272039481
CITATIONS READS
3 31
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
EFFECT of USING DUAL FUEL (BIOGAS-DIESEL) on the PERFORMANCE and EMISSIONS of a LOW HEAT
REJECTION DIESEL ENGINE View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Mustafa Atmaca on 30 June 2017.
The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file. All in-text references underlined in blue are added to the original document
and are linked to publications on ResearchGate, letting you access and read them immediately.
Arab J Sci Eng (2014) 39:2263–2270
DOI 10.1007/s13369-013-0773-0
Received: 22 May 2012 / Accepted: 13 July 2013 / Published online: 8 September 2013
© King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals 2013
123
2264 Arab J Sci Eng (2014) 39:2263–2270
123
Arab J Sci Eng (2014) 39:2263–2270 2265
123
2266 Arab J Sci Eng (2014) 39:2263–2270
specific volume in the cycle and it is shown in the following 3 Results and Discussion
form [9]:
In the real compression ignition engine, temperature of cylin-
Ẇ ṁcv [k(T3 − T2 ) − (T4 − T1 )]
Ẇd = = (2) der changes in the 300–400 K temperature range at the start of
vmin v2
the compression stroke and the maximum temperature can
where v2 is the minimum volume of the gas in the cylinder. exist in the cylinder at the combustion process changes in
In order to write Eqs. (1) and (2) in more suitable form, a new the 1,200–2,500 K temperature range [3,4,33]. Because the
term, volume ratio, can be defined in the following form: formation of NOx emission is highly dependent on maxi-
(k−1) mum temperature, the maximum temperature in cylinder is
v2
θ= (3) restrained at reasonable value. Therefore, α changes between
v1
3 and 9 in the real compression ignition engine. But in
where v1 is the maximum specific volume of the gas in the Fig. 2, α is given in 2–10 range so that results can be eval-
cylinder, v2 is the specific combustion chamber volume and k uated in wide perspective. The specific α value given below
is the specific heat ratio. Using the Eq. (3), adiabatic relations is also numerically found near the 2.
Eqs. (1) and (2) can be written as The variations of the normalized power (Ẇ /Ẇmax ), power
1 density (Ẇd /Ẇdmax ) and efficient power (Ẇη /Ẇηmax ) with
Ẇ = ṁcv T1 k α − − (αθ )k + 1 (4) respect to the thermal efficiency are shown in Fig. 2a, b
θ
and c, respectively in variation of the cycle temperature ratio
ṁcv T1 1 1 (α). It can be seen from Fig. 2, the mp, mpd and mep had
Ẇd = θ 1−k k α − − (αθ )k + 1 (5) a tendency to increase as the thermal efficiency increased
v1 θ
until they reached a maximum value, and then decreased
where, T1 is the temperature at the engine inlet and α is the
as the thermal efficiency continued to increase. While the
cycle temperature ratio (α=T3 /T1 ). In a similar way, thermal
increasing rates of the mp, mpd and mep decrease with
efficiency of a Diesel cycle can be written as
increasing α, their decreasing rates increase with increas-
(αθ )k − 1 ing α. The decreasing rate of mpd is also maximum. Ther-
η =1−θ (6)
k(αθ − 1) mal efficiency at mp (ηmpd ), the thermal efficiency at mpd
(ηmpd ) and the thermal efficiency at mep (ηmep ) increase
To find mp, Eq. (4) can be differentiated with respect to θ ,
with increasing α. The ηmep and ηmpd are always greater
set the resultant derivative equal to zero (i.e., ∂ Ẇ /∂θ = 0).
than the ηmp . The ηmep is greater than the ηmpd until the
The optimum θ value obtained for mp as
specific α and then the ηmpd is greater than the ηmep . It can
−k
θopt = α k+1 (7) be also concluded from these figures that, when α increases
the global performance curves get closer for all performance
Substituting Eq. (7) into Eq. (4), the mp can be found as
criteria.
k
Ẇmax = ṁcv T1 kα − (k + 1)α k+1 +1 (8) It can be concluded from these figures that the thermal
efficiency increases with increasing the cylinder mean tem-
The thermal efficiency at mp can be found by substituting perature at the combustion process. The ηmep , ηmpd and ηmp
Eq. (7) into Eq. (6) as follows: also increase with increasing the cylinder mean temperature
⎡ ⎤ at the combustion process. For obtained higher the ηmep , ηmpd
k
−k α k+1 − 1
and ηmp diesel engine must be run at high combustion tem-
ηmp = 1 − α k+1 ⎣
1 ⎦ (9)
k α k+1 −1 peratures condition. It is available to keep high combustion
temperatures with insulating combustion chamber by ther-
The efficient power, which is defined as multiplication of the mal barrier coating and ceramic materials which are used for
power by the efficiency of the cycle as making low heat released engines. High combustion temper-
Ẇη = ηẆ (10) ature also improves fuel consumption and exhaust emissions
except NOx .
Substituting Eqs. (4) and (6) into Eq. (10), efficient power Normalized power, normalized power density and nor-
can be written as malized efficient power are plotted together for α = 1.5 and
α = 4 in Fig. 3a and b, respectively. It can be observed from
1 (αθ )k − 1
Ẇη = ṁcv T1 k α − − (αθ)k + 1 1 − θ Fig. 3a that, the slope of normalized power curve is greater
θ k(αθ − 1)
(11) than the slope of normalized power density curve and the
slope of normalized power density curve is greater than the
The optimum θ values for mpd and mep are calculated slope of normalized efficient power curve until they reach
numerically in following section. maximum values.
123
Arab J Sci Eng (2014) 39:2263–2270 2267
The decreasing of normalized efficient power and nor- at higher α values, normalized power density is lowest for
malized power density is very similar and their decreas- lower thermal efficient of diesel engine while normalized
ing rates are greater than decreasing rate of normalized power density is greatest for higher thermal efficient of
power. The similar variation is detected from the Fig. 3b diesel engine. It can be also observed from these figures
for increasing stage but the performance curves only go that, for the small α values (α = 1.5) ηmep is greater than
away from each other. For small α values increasing rate ηmpd and for a higher α (α = 4) ηmpd is greater than
of normalized power density is greater than rate of normal- ηmep . In addition, the ηmp is always lower than ηmpd and
ized efficient power but for higher α values rate of normal- ηmep . This finding can be seen more clearly from Fig. 4
ized efficient power is greater than rate of normalized power which shows the comparison of three maximum efficien-
density. The decreasing rate of normalized power density cies for different cycle temperature ratios, α. As it can be
is greater than the decreasing rate of normalized efficient seen from the figure, ηmep is greater than ηmpd until a spe-
power and the decreasing rate of normalized efficient power cific α value and after this value ηmpd becomes greater than
is greater than normalized power. At small α values, nor- ηmep .
malized efficient power is lowest for lower thermal effi- The specific α value is numerically found to be 1.85 for
cient of diesel engine while normalized efficient power is k = 1.4. From the above evaluations an expression among
greatest for higher thermal efficient of diesel engine. But the alternative efficiencies can be written as
123
2268 Arab J Sci Eng (2014) 39:2263–2270
123
Arab J Sci Eng (2014) 39:2263–2270 2269
ηmep > ηmpd > ηmp for 1 < α < 1.85 In this context, the optimum θ value which maximize the
ηmpd > ηmep > ηmp for 1.85 < α (12) power output of the cycle and the thermal efficiency at mp
ηmep = ηmpd > ηmp for α = 1.85 are calculated analytically. The optimum θ values and ther-
mal efficiency values for mpd, mep are calculated numer-
α = 1.85 is very small value and it is not meaningful ically. The analysis showed that maximizing the efficient
for realistic Diesel cycle. In the realistic Diesel cycle, α is power function gives a compromise between power and effi-
greater than 3. Therefore ηmpd is greater than ηmep and ηmep ciency. Additionally, the mp criterion, the mpd criterion, the
is greater than ηmp for realistic Diesel cycle. mep criterion have to be considered in the engine design
Power outputs at mp, mpd and mep conditions can be for engine power output, engine fuel consumption and both
seen with respect to α in Fig. 5. Both of the power outputs at engine power and fuel consumption, respectively. Finally, the
mpd and mep conditions are lower than the mp output of the efficient power criterion is more suitable for design of prac-
cycle as expected. Despite the efficiency disadvantages, the tical Diesel engines which must be more effective and emit
mep criterion has a significant power advantage compared to lower carbon dioxide and other toxic emissions.
mpd criterion for α >1.85. While the power loss of the mpd In the analysis, the major irreversibilities in real heat
criterion is great after α = 1.85, the power output at mep con- engines were not considered, hence it would be appropri-
ditions is very close to the mp output. Because of α >1.85 in ate to carry out the analysis with the same methodology for
the modern Diesel engines, it is possible to say that the mep the totally irreversible (externally and internally) engines in
conditions are suitable to compromise the power and effi- the next studies.
ciency of the Diesel engine cycles. It can be concluded from
Figs. 4 and 5 that, the mp, mpd and mep criteria have to
be considered in the engine design for engine power out- References
put, engine thermal efficiency and both engine power and
1. Ge, Y.; Chen, L.; Sun, F.; Wu, C.: Reciprocating heat-engine cycles.
engine thermal efficiency, respectively. Therefore, the results
Appl. Energy 81, pp. 397–408 (2005)
obtained in this study provide good guidance for performance 2. Chen, J.; Zhao, Y.; He, J.: Optimization criteria for the important
evaluation and improvement of practical Diesel engines. parameters of an irreversible Otto heat-engine. Appl. Energy 83,
pp. 228–38 (2006)
3. Ge, Y.; Chen, L.; Sun, F.: Finite-time thermodynamic modeling and
analysis of an irreversible Otto-cycle. Appl. Energy 85, pp. 618–24
4 Conclusion (2008)
4. Chen, L.; Sun, F.; Wu, C.: Optimal performance of an irreversible
dual-cycle. Appl. Energy 79, pp. 3–14 (2004)
In present paper, a performance optimization has been car- 5. Zhao, Y.; Chen, J.: An irreversible heat engine model including
ried out based on power, power density and efficient criteria three typical thermodynamic cycles and their optimum perfor-
for reversible Diesel engines. The power density criterion is mance analysis. Int. J. Therm. Sci. 46, pp. 605–11 (2007)
6. Chen, L.; Zhang, W.; Sun, F.: Power, efficiency, entropy-generation
defined as the power per minimum specific volume in the rate and ecological optimization for a class of generalized irre-
cycle and the efficient power criterion is defined as multipli- versible universal heat-engine cycles. Appl. Energy. 84, pp. 512–25
cation of the power by the efficiency of the cycle. (2007)
123
2270 Arab J Sci Eng (2014) 39:2263–2270
7. Parlak, A.: Comparative performance analysis of irreversible Dual 21. Zhao, Y.; Lin, B.; Zhang, Y. et al.: Performance analysis and
and Diesel cycles under maximum power conditions, Energy Con- parametric optimum design of an irreversible Diesel heat engine.
version and Management. 46, 351–9 (2005) Energy Convers Manag. 47, pp. 3383–3392 (2006)
8. Parlak, A.; Sahin, B.: Performance optimization of reciprocating 22. Ebrahimi, R.: Performance optimization of a Diesel cycle with
heat engine cycles with internal irreversibility. J. Energy Inst. 79, specific heat ratio. J. Am. Sci. 6(1), pp. 157–161 (2010)
pp. 241–6 (2006) 23. Ozsoysal, O.A.: Effects of varying air-fuel ratio on the performance
9. Bhattacharyya, S.: Optimizing an irreversible Diesel cycle-fine tun- of a theoretical Diesel cycle. Int. J. Energy 7(6), pp. 654–666 (2010)
ing of compression ratio and cut-off ratio. Energy Convers. Manag. 24. Ge, Y.; Chen, L.; Sun, F. et al.: Performance of an endoreversible
41, pp. 847–52 (2000) Diesel cycle with variable specific heats of working fluid. Int. J.
10. Blank, DA.; Wu, C.: The effect of combustion on a power optimized Ambient Energy 29(3), pp. 127–136 (2008)
endoreversible diesel cycle. Energy Convers. Manag. 34, pp. 493–9 25. Al-Sarkhi, A.; Jaber, J.O.; Abu-Qudais, M.; Probert, S.D.: Effects
(1993) of friction and temperature- dependent specific-heat of the working
11. Hou, SS.: Heat transfer effects on the performance of an air standard fluid on the performance of a Diesel-engine. Appl. Energy 83, pp.
Dual cycle. Energy Convers. Manag. 45, pp. 3003–15 (2004) 153–165 (2006)
12. Yilmaz, T.: A new performance criterion for heat engines: efficient 26. Fallahipanah, M.; Ghazavi, M. A.; Hashemi, M. et al.: Comparison
power. J. Energy Inst. 79, pp. 38–41 (2006) of the performance of Biodiesel, Diesel, and their compound in
13. Yilmaz, T.: Performance optimization of a Joule-Brayton engine Diesel air standard irreversible cycles. International Conference on
based on efficient power criterion. Proceedings of the Institution Environmental and Agriculture Engineering 15, pp. 7–13 (2011)
of Mechanical Engineers Part A: Journal Power and Energy. 221, 27. Ebrahimi, R.: Thermodynamic simulation of performance of an
pp. 603–617 (2007) endoreversible Dual cycle with variable specific heat ratio of work-
14. Yilmaz, T.; Durmusoglu, Y.: Efficient power analysis for an irre- ing fluid. J. Am. Sci. 5(5), pp. 175–180 (2009)
versible Carnot heat engine. Int. J. Energy Res. 32, pp. 623–8 (2008) 28. Ge, Y.; Chen, L.; Sun, F.: Finite time thermodynamic modeling and
15. Rocha-Martinez J.A.; Navarrete-Gonzalez T.D.; Pava-Miller C.G. analysis for an irreversible Dual cycle. Math. Comput. Model. 50,
et al.: Otto and Diesel engine models with cyclic variability. Revista pp. 101–108 (2009)
Mexicana De Fisica. 48(3), pp. 228–234 (2002) 29. Aithal, S M.: Impact of EGR fraction on diesel engine performance
16. Ebrahimi, R.: Performance of an irreversible Diesel cycle under considering heat loss and temperature-dependent properties of the
variable stroke length and compression ratio. J. Am. Sci. 6(1), pp. working fluid. Int. J. Energy Res. 33, pp. 415–430 (2009)
58–64 (2010) 30. Ebrahimi, R.: Effects of variable specific heat ratio of working fluid
17. Hou, S.S.; Lin, J.C.: Performance Analysis Of A Diesel Cycle on performance of an endoreversible Diesel cycle. J. Energy Inst.
Under The Restriction Of Maximum Cycle Temperature With Con- 83, pp. 1–5 (2010)
siderations Of Heat Loss, Friction, and Variable Specific Heats. 31. Ebrahimi R Chen L. Effects of variable specific heat ratio of work-
Acta Physica Polonica A. 120, 979–986 (2011) ing fluid on performance of an irreversible Diesel cycle. Int. J.
18. Parlak, A.: The effect of heat transfer on performance of the Diesel Ambient Energy 31(2), pp. 101–108 (2010)
cycle and exergy of the exhaust gas stream in a LHR Diesel engine 32. Gumus, M.; Atmaca, M.; Yilmaz, T.: Efficiency of an Otto engine
at the optimum injection timing. Energy Convers. Manag. 46, under alternative power optimizations. Int. J. Energy Res. 33, pp.
pp. 167–179 (2005) 745–52 (2009)
19. Parlak, A.; Yasar, H.; Eldogan, O.: The effect of thermal barrier 33. Lin J.C.; Hou S.S.: Effects of heat loss as percentage of fuel’s
coating on a turbo- charged Diesel engine performance and exergy energy, friction and variable specific heats of working fluid on per-
potential of the exhaust gas. Energy Convers. Manag. 46, pp. 489– formance of air standard Otto cycle. Energy Convers. Manag. 49,
499 (2005) pp. 1218–27 (2008)
20. Al-Hinti, I.; Akash, B.; Abu-Nada, E.; Al-Sarkhi, A.: Perfor-
mance analysis of air-standard Diesel cycle using an alternative
irreversible heat transfer approach. Energy Convers. Manag. 49,
pp. 3301–3304 (2008)
123