PROJECT: 37 MLD WTP ,AIZAWL

STRUCTURE: FILTER HOUSE BUILDING

SUBJECT: COMMENTS ON DESIGN DOCUMENT, NUMERATION DRAWING & RC DRAWING .
General Comment:
1. Please remove all unassigned loads and details input in staad-pro file. – Noted & Incorporated.
2. Increase the sizes of section lines and texts in all drawings. Please show the dimension clearly (in a too congested manner).
– Noted & Incorporated.
3. Increase the size of section line or differentiate it with some markings-– Noted & Incorporated.
4. Openings (windows, ventilators etc..) are not shown in any of the section. Please show it -
5. Change the North Direction according to the Layout Plan - – Noted & Incorporated.
6. Add Company mark in Client name and in consultant name.
7. Please correct the document number in Numeration drawing as well as in RC drawing accordingly. Numbers are not fond
to be in row, Sheets numbers are wrong.
8. Please make the RC details visible in PDF format. Line thickness is heavy and not visible.

S.No.
Eco-Protection Comments (Preliminary) Reply
,

Along Z the dimension taken in Staad Pro for design are mismatching with M26-A26 of
GA.(Reference drawing AZWS/WTP/FH/GA/01)

Along X the dimension taken in staad Pro for design are mismatching with M1 to M26
1. of GA.(Reference drawing AZWS/WTP/FH/GA/01) Noted & Revised Accordingly.

Distance between column C1 and C1 in 1.1 grid measurement is not matching with GA
drawing. The same has been fed in Staad Pro file.
 Beams 64 3203 and 3205 are provided with same UDL 5.6k N/m but the levels of beam
2. Noted & Revised Accordingly.
are different.
Temperature Load not get assigned in STAAD file. Crane Load CL 2 not provided with
3. Noted .
load detail, Please add if any otherwise remove it .

4. Load 12.05 k N/m has been added and assigned under live load also. Please check. Noted & it is mentioned as staircase load.

Beam Number 3180 and 63 is loaded with UDL 2.9k N/m (it s calculations are missing
5. Noted & maximum load applied.
in design document under dead load ) .Also please check for the load .

6. Please correct RCC wall load as brick wall load under Parapet wall load on roof beam. Noted and Revised Accordingly.

7. The Unit weight of Submerged bed is taken as 10 k N/m3 . Noted & found to be ok.

Height input for brick load calculation on staircase room region are mismatching with
8. Noted & Revised Accordingly.
staad Pro.

9. Pressure due to outer soil is noted with unit weight of sand in fist line (correct it as soil). Noted & Revised Accordingly.

1
In the dead load calculation due to platform slab ,Please check the span of Platform Noted & Revised Accordingly.
0.
11 In manifold wall design the unit of soil is taken as 18 k N/m3 but in the previous context
Noted & Revised Accordingly.
. it was taken as 20 k N/m3
1 Additional load is a roof load and it is not
In the lumped mass load combination 1.0DL+0.5LL,live load addition is missing.
2. taken into account.
1 In design of stair cases the dimension of sketch shown is height of the flight.Showing on
Noted & Revised Accordingly.
3. a horizontal dimensions its confusing. Please check and add notes accordignly.
Give Column numbers uniformly according to the centre line position. Most of the
1
columns are mismatching. Noted & Revised Accordingly.
4.
Example-Corner column present in M26 grid. (Ref., Drwg-AZWS/WTP/FH/NU01)
1 Please add column numbers to M27 and M28 column(Ref., Drwg-
Noted & Revised Accordingly.
5. AZWS/WTP/FH/NU01)
In Foundation plan add footing number to c3 column present in B’2 grid. (Ref., Drwg-
1
AZWS/WTP/FH/NU01) Noted & Revised Accordingly.
6.

1 Please check the dimension given as approx.., and in cut lines with the approved WTP
Noted & Revised Accordingly.
7. layout. If dimensions mismatch mark as hold.
1
Please add Plan at level 183.0 Noted & found to be ok.
8.
1
Please revise the handrail detail according to the Mechanical GA. Noted & Revised Accordingly.
9.
2
In the cross sectional details Please add parapet wall height in section 1-1. Noted & Revised Accordingly.
0.
2 In the cross sectional details in section1-1 187.15 level is mentioned as FFL. Please
Noted & Revised Accordingly.
1. change.
2
Mention the depth of foundation from the FGL. Noted & Revised Accordingly.
2.
2 In section 3-3 top level is 189.95 but it is shown as 191.30.Pls check.
Noted & Revised Accordingly.
3. For sec 5-5 ,6-6 , show the top level.
2 In section 6-6 two different levels on the right side are shown with same level. Please
Noted & Revised Accordingly.
4. correct it.
In Plan at 183.00 ,187.15,191.30(STAIRCASE DRWG) please change the corner
2
column as c3 according to the plan shown. Also change FFL AS TOC for levels 187.15 Noted & Revised Accordingly.
5.
and 191.30
2 In stair case elevation the level shown in second Mid landing is marked as 181.15.Please
Noted & Revised Accordingly.
6. correct it.
2
Pipe supporting details are not shown. Please add. It was added in notes as tentative one.
7.
2
In Plan at 189.450 level Please add TOC. Noted & Revised Accordingly.
8.
2
Please add side face reinforcement to RB20. Noted & Revised Accordingly.
9.
3 Please add column details and foundation details . No column details and foundation
Noted & Revised Accordingly.
0. details are shown.