Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
382
Does nursing education promote ageism^
(Amencan Association of Retired Persons 1992) And m expenences on two groups of nursmg students They
the Umted Kmgdom as many as 48% of the total popu- uncovered mcrrased negative attitudes m the first group
lation will be over 75 by the year 2000 (Slevm 1991) who only attended class, but decreased negative attitudes
Apparently, nursmg is not gomg to meet the needs of older m the second group who expenenced class and an mter-
people, and smce we cannot meet the needs some of us active project with older people
are gomg to say that they do not exist
Effects of education on students
REVIEW OF AGEISM AND ATTITUDES
More researchers studied the effects of their educational
The first, and most common, research m gerontological interventions on nursing students and perceived beneficial
nursmg was on the attitudes of nurses and students toward effects (Hart et al 1976, Wilbite & Johnson 1976, Robb
canng for older people (Haight 1989) Smce then numer- 1979, Tobiason et al 1979, Heman 1981, Langland et al
ous projects reported that education does and does not 1986, Miko 1986, Olson & Logan 1986, Snape 1986, Heine
affect ageism Underlying the assumption that education & Streit 1987) Other researchers reported specific n^ative
affects ageism are the basic premises that (a) decreased correlations for instance, that the functional disability of
ageism will contnbute to better nursmg ceire, and (b) edu- older people was related to negative attitudes of nurses
cation and changing the attitudes of nurses toward older (Elliott & Hybertson 1982), that lack of mteraction lnfiu-
people will recruit nurses to the speciality of gerontologi- enced students more negatively (Baer & Lowery 1987) and
cal nursmg To date, these basic premises are unfounded that the social orgamzation mfiuenced attitudes (Brower
and do not provide a foundation for the work and research 1981)
m ageism and attitudes The question then is is the work As the 1980s prc^essed, tbere were more analyses of
on education and ageism prolific because it is convenient nurses' and nursing students' attitudes toward older
and serves as a needed research study for faculty to gain people Melanson & Downe-Wamboldt (1985) analysed the
promotion and tenure, or is there a gut feeling among edu- relationships between student psycbosocial vanables and
cators that education m£ikes a difference and thus we must their attitudes toward ageing Individually, the vanables
explore its effects on ageism'' did not account for a large proportion of the variance
Campbell (1971) studied the attitudes of nursing person- GreenbiU & Baker (1986) tested the effects of a leammg
nel towards tbe genatnc patient usmg the Tuckman Lorge expenence with well elderly adults and found no differ-
scale and concluded that all groups of nursing personnel ences between the group bavmg the expenence and those
(RNs, LPNs and aides) held stereotypical attitudes toward who did not, while Ross's (1985) expenence produced
ageing The most educated part of tbe sample were less converse results, students workmg with well elderly
stereotjrpical, but knowing the facts still prefeiTed to work scored higher on attitude surveys than those who worked
less with older people with the ill elderly Hooper (1981) reinforced the theory
Taylor & Hamed (1978) also examined the attitudes of tbat those with higher educational levels bave more posi-
those who work with older people usmg the Kogan Old tive attitudes, wbile Buschmann et al (1981) indicated
People Scale (Kogan 1961a) Their results contramdicated that a previous good expenence with older people contri-
the results of Campbell m that they found those who dis- buted to a more positive attitude
played positive attitudes were younger, with less expen- As the 1990s evolve, other health care professionals are
ence in nursing, and less experience m canng for older examining tbeir attitudes toward ageing Apparently this
people Other researchers both agreed and disagreed with IS not ]ust a nursmg phenomenon Using Lisrel, Belund &
these premises Thorson et al (1974) supported the con- Maheux (1990) examined the attitudes of medical caregiv-
cept of increased education associated with increased ers and found that females and those who chose &mily
positive attitudes, but also established that mcreased age practice had more positive attitudes toward elderly people
caused increased negative attitudes Gillis (1973) found Recreational therapists' attitudes were generally positive,
no significant differences in age groups and attitudes, but but they did not want to work with older people (MacNeil
discovered that education and expenence positively 1991), while respiratory therapists found that coursework
mfiuenced attitudes about older people improved attitudes toward older people
The researchers of the 1970s disagree more than support (Perkins 1991) In a study of physical therapists. Brown
one another, leadmg future researchers to contmue to et al (1992) determined that their coursework about older
examine the effects of education on attitudes Auerbach & people caused no significant differences m attitudes
Levenson (1977) studied the effects of shared classroom toward older people
expenence between students and older people and deter- Nurses are also becoming more introspective m the
mined that these shared expenences promoted negative 1990s Dellasega & Cumero (1991) not only looked at atti-
attitudes Chamberland et al (1979) used the Tuckman tude change m their students, they looked at work prefer-
Lorge scale to examme the effects of classroom and climcal ence They tested their students three times and found that
383
BK
although their prc^amme improved students' attitudes avid mterest m agemg taught the course If &culty mem-
toward older people, the programme did not change the hers were not formally educated m gerontology, they went
students' work preference Students still chose not to work about acquinng the necessary mformation themselves
with older people Finally, Trehame (1990), like so many This group of faculty designed a course at entry level to
others before her, confirmed that the course she offered provide positive expenences for students with elderly cli-
ahout ageing made attitudes worse ents and to emphasize health promotion and mamtenance
384
Does nursing education promote ageism?
Figure 1 Students'
professional areas of mterest
385
BJC Haight etal
Table 2 Correlations of
instrument mean scores Correlations YlSl Y2S1 Y3S1 Y1S2 Y2S2 Y3S2
(Rosencranz & McNevin)
YlSl 1 0000 0 6397 0 5087 0 5181 0 5432 0 6545
(0) (37) (40) (27) (34) (38)
P= P=0 000 P = 0 000 P = 0 003 P = 0 000 P=0 000
Y2S1 0 6397 10000 0 6074 0 5937 0 6235 0 6663
(37) (0) (42) (27) (37) (37)
P=0 000 p P=0 000 P=0 001 P=0 000 P=0 000
Y3S1 0 5087 0 6074 10000 0 6185 0 7177 0 8339
(40) (42) (0) (30) (43) (42)
P = 0 000 P=0 000 p= P=0 000 P=0 000 P = 0 000
Y1S2 0 5181 0 5937 0 6185 10000 0 5326 0 6927
(27) (27) (30) (0) (25) (24)
P=0 003 P = 0 001 P=0 000 p P = 0 003 P=0 000
Y2S2 0 5432 0 6237 0 7177 0 5326 10000 0 7527
(34) (37) (43) (25) (0) (35)
P = 0 000 P=0 000 P=0 000 P=0 003 P= P=0 000
Y3S2 0 6545 0 6663 0 8339 0 6927 0 7527 10000
(38) (37) (42) (24) (35) (0)
P = 0 000 P=0 000 P=0 000 P = 0 000 P=0 000 p
(Coefflcient/(Cases)/l-t£uledsigmficance)
" " I S pnnted if a coefficient cannot be computed
Y=year, S=semester
51 = Entry into that year (before exposure)
52 =Exit from that year (after exposure)
Most correlated significantly
386
Does nursing education promote ageism^
Ycarl Ycarl
reviewing the hterature where some of the ideas of nurses First, It appeared that previous eissociations with older
and students are examined to leam about their attitudes people and the value of these associations to the student
towards older people, it seemed relevant to try to gam a would have a strong effect m fonnmg their attitudes That
more hohstic view of the students' background and expen- supposition was correct m that grandparents had a strong
ence before looking at their educational process m nursing positive influence on student attitudes, and that grand-
as a cause or byproduct of their attitudes parents were also the most admired older people in the
387
BK
Table 3 Reputed-measures ANOVA - Kc^jan's scale students' hves, even more than parents Other associations
with older people did not prejudice the students' attitudes
Source SS df F-value P-value Thus, one can postulate that an influential role model for
ageing must have a close and positive relationship with
Between suhject eflFects* the student
Other expenences, such as working in long-term care
Withm cells 3947 54 15
and previous education m gerontology, had neither a posi-
Constant 226169618 1 8594 06 0000
tive nor a negative impact, neither did the personal van-
Semester withm subject efFects*
ables, such as sex and race, which differed from other
studies One student said sex was an important factor as
Within 462 84 15 females of all age groups felt more kmdly toward older
Semester 354 81 1 1150 0 004** people than males A^e was the only weighty factor, and
It had a linear effect smce attitudes unproved as age
Year within subject effects' mcreased at least up to age 40 One outlier existed m
the group over the age of 40, and this person possessed a
Withm cells 1784 38 30 negative attitude towards older people
Year 2363 81 2 19 87 0 000*** Fmally, we can look at the effect of nursmg education
on student nurses' attitudes toward ageing Exposure to
Semester x year withm subject effects* older people who are well, happy and thnving is a defimte
plus for positively influencing student nurses' attitudes
Withm cells 1706 78 30
To recruit students to work in gerontology, educators must
Semester x year 1226 01 2 10 77 0 000***
influence students at the imdergraduate level before stud-
ents become imbued with negative attitudes
**P<0 001
***P<0 0001 Graduate programmes m gerontological nursmg con-
•Number=16 tmue to close for lack of students Educators must develop
student mterest in gerontology sooner to develop a cadre
of master's-prepared nurses to take care of the increasing
number of older adults It is unhkely that undergraduate
students who do not have positive role models, chmcal
Table 4 Repeated-measures ANOVA - Resencranz & McNevm expenences with well and sick older clients, and specific
scale gerontological content, will express an mterest in the gena-
tnc-speciality graduate programme The presence of good
Source SS df F-value P-value faculty role models, also reported as important m the
hterature, probably added to the positive attitude change
Between subject effects' for yeeir 1
Withm cells 9357 77 14
Year 2 found these same students m the hospital with
Constant 1804975 22 1 2700 39 0 000** sick older people, no course content in gerontology and
no defined role models Their attitudes towards older
Semester within subject effects' people contmued to improve Based on these data, we
might venture to say that nursuig education does not pro-
Withm 1867 84 14 mote ageism Of course, these students had not practised
Semester 14 55 1 011 0 746 m a nursing home It would be mteresting to study the
effect of that expenence m a similar study to see the
Year withm subject effects' differences that the nursing home expenence makes
Fmally, the students in the last year of their educational
Withm cells 2366 69 28 expenence are canng for very ill people, and they have
Year 1352 04 2 8 10 0 002* had a little more lllness-onented content about older
people On one scale their scores fall, on another they
Semester x year within subject effects'
improve only slightly, but it should be remembered that
they are higher than when they started the programme
Withm cells 3458 67 28
Semester x year 2921 08 2 11 82 0 000**
The students are motivated, eager and ready to teike state
boards, and to start their careers One out of 57 has chosen
*P<0 05 to work with older people, the majonty are heading toward
***P<0 001 paediatncs and surgery This outcome makes sense to us
•Number=16 New graduates need to practise skills Once they are
388
Does nursing education promote ageism^
comfortable with the skills, they can begm to look at the ajffect nursmg student's hke or dislike of canng fca patients
people Perhaps, when they are ready to work hohstically Nursmg Research 36(5), 298-302
with people, they will choose the challenge of older Beland F & Maheux B (1990) Medical care for the elderly
people Attitudes of medical caregivers Joumal of Aging and Health
2(2), 194-214
Brower HT (1981) Social orgamzation and nurses' attitudes
toward older persons Joumal of Gerontological Nursing 7(5),
CONCLUSIONS 293-298
Brown D S , Gardner D L , Pemtt L & Kally DG (1992)
Several conclusions can be drawn from this study with Improvement m attitudes toward the elderly following tra-
implications for nursmg education and for the develop- ditional and genatnc mock clmics for physical therapy stud-
ment of good attitudes toward ageing They are as follows ents Physical Therapy 72(4), 251-257
Buschmami M B , Bums E M & Jones F M (1981) Student nurses'
1 older nurses have improved attitudes towards older attitudes towards the elderly Joumal of Nursing Education
people, 20(5), 7-10
2 grandparents create positive role models for ageing, Campbell M E (1971) Study of the attitudes of nursing personnel
3 exposure to well elderly people as clients has a lasting toward the genatnc patient Nursing Research 20(2), 147-151
effect on nursmg students' attitudes towards older Chamberland G , Rawls B , Powell C & Roberts M J (1979)
people, Improving students' atutudes toward aging Joumal of
Gerontological Nursing 6(1), 44-45
4 nursing education does not cause ageism m fact, nurs-
Cryns A G & Monk A (1973) Attitudes toward youth as a function
ing education promotes more positive feelings towards
of adult age a multivariate study m mtergenerational dynamics
older people
Intemational Joumal of Agmg and Human Development 4,
23-33
Recommendations DellasegaC ScCumeroFC (1991) The effects of msUtuUonal and
community experiences on nursing students' intentions toward
Before there is more research examining the attitudes of work with the elderly Joumal of Nursing Education 30(9),
caregivers, nurses and nursmg students toward older 405-410
people, there needs to be an integrated review of the litera- Elhott B & Hybertson D (1982) What is it about the elderly that
ture Attitude researchers need to begin their work based elicits a negative response'' Joumal of Gerontological Nursing
on the existing body of knowledge An integrated review 8(10), 568-571
will provide direction for future research, so that research Giardma-Roche C & Black M E A (1990) AtUtudes of diploma
student nurses toward adult chents Joumal of Nursing
on attitudes may grow m all directions, become more valu-
Education 29(5), 208-214
able and provide more definitive answers Researchers
Gillis M (1973) Attitudes of nursing personnel toward the aged
need to look at all mtervening vanables as well as whole Nursing Research 22(6), 517-520
educational programmes, so that they may provide com- Gordon S K & Hallauer D S (1976) Impact of a fnendly visiting
plete answers to the question of the effect of nursmg edu- program on atUtudes of college students toward the aged The
cation on attitudes towards agemg The examination of Gerontologist 16, 371-376
just one course on ageing will not answer the larger ques- GreenhiU E D & Baker M F (1986) The effects of a well older
tion, 'What IS the effect of nursing education and educators adult chmcal experience on students' knowledge and attitudes
on ageism''' Joumal of Nursing Education 25(4), 145-147
After educators answer the larger question, they must Haight B K (1989) Nursing research m long-term care Nursing
and Health Gare 10(3), 147-150
devote themselves to developing new cumcula to encour-
Hart L K , Freel MI & Crowell C M (1976) Changing attitudes
age positive a^emg attitudes New cumcula should
toward the aged and mterest m canng for the aged Joumal of
explore new strategies and clinical experiences should Gerontological Nursmg 2(4), 10-16
encourage positive ageing attitudes Presently, nursing Heine C & Streit L A (1987) A wellness clinic for older persons
education does not promote ageism nor does nursing a posiUve expenence for nursing students and older persons
education prevent it Joumal of Nursing Education 26(6), 244-246
Heman J A (1981) Effect of a gerontological education expenence
on adolescent girls' attitudes toward the elderly Joumal of
Gerontological Nursing 7(1), 45-49
References
Hooper JE (1981) Genatnc patients and nurse learner's atti-
Amencan AssociaUon of Retired Persons (1992) A Profile of Older tudes-2 Nursing Times 77, 43-44
Amencans (PF3049 (1292) D996) AARP, Washington, DC Kogan N (1961a) Attitudes toward old people the development
Auerbach D N & Levenson R.L (1977) Second impressions atti- of a scale and an examination of correlates Joumal of Abnormal
tude change m college students toward the elderly and Social Psychology 62, 44-54
Gerontologist 17(4), 362-366 Kogan N (1961b) Attitudes toward old people m an older sample
Baer E D & Lowery B J (1987) Patient and situationalfoctorsthat Joumal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 62, 616-622
389
BK Haightetal
Langland R M , Raithel J A , Benjamin G , Benson R., Cnin B & Ross M M (1985) The impact of chent selection on chnical teach-
Kunz C (1986) Change m hasic nursmg students' attitudes ing Joumal of Advanced Nursing 10, 567-573
toward the elderly after a nursmg home expenence Joumal of Slevm O D'A (1991) ^ e i s t attitudes among young adults impli-
Nursing Education 55(1), 31-32 cations for a carmg profession Joumal of Advanced Nursing
MacNeil RD (1991) Attitudes toward the aged and identified 16, 1197-1205
employment preferences of therapeutic recreation students Snape J (1986) Nurses' attitudes to care of the elderly Joumal of
Educational Gerontology 17(6), 543-558 Advanced Nursing 11, 569-572
Melanson P M & Downe-Wamholdt B L (1985) Antecedents of Taylor K H & Hamed T L (1978) Attitudes toward old people a
haccalaureate student nurses' attitudes toward the elderly Jour- study of nurses who care for the elderly Joumal of
nal of Advanced Nursing 10, 527-532 Gerontological Nursing 4(5), 43-47
Miko P S (1986) College students and institutionalized elderly Thorson J A , Whatley L & Hancock K (1974) Attitudes toward
attitudinal effects of interactive contact Gerontology and the ^ e d as a function of age and education Gerontologist 14,
Genatncs Education 6(3), 37-42 316-318
Naus P J (1973) Some correlates of attitudes toward old people Thorson J A & Perkins M L (1976) AtUtudes toward the ^ e d as
International Journal of Aging and Human Development 4, a function of personality characteristics Paper presented to the
229-243 29th Annual Meeting of the Gerontological Society, New York
Olson JK & Logan J (1986) Pairmg students with the well elderly Tohiason S J , Knudsen F , Stengel J C & Giss M (1979) PosiUve
a unique relationship for learning Joumal of Nursing attitudes toward agmg the aged teach the young Joumal of
Education 25(9), 386-388 Gerontological Nursmg 5(3), 18-23
Perkins S (1991) Attitudes and knowledge of respiratory therapy Trehame G (1990) Attitudes towards the care of elderly people
students concerning the elderly Respimtory Gare 36(12), Are they gettmg hetter'' Joumal of Advanced Nursing 15,
1391-1397 777-781
Rohh S S (1979) Attitudes and intentions of haccalaureate nursmg Wilhite M J & Johnson D M (1976) Ghanges m nursmg students'
students toward the elderly Nursing Research 28(1), 43-50 stereot3rpic attitudes toward old people Nursing Research
Rosencranz H A & McNevm T E (1969) A factor analysis of atti- 25(6), 430-432
tudes toward the aged The Gerontologist 9, 55-59
390