Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Liduino Pitombeira
02/22/06
1
The starting point
COMBINATORIALITY
A Bb Eb B E F# C C# G Ab D F
Ab A D Bb Eb F B C F# G C# E
Eb E A F Bb C F# G C# D Ab B
G Ab C# A D E Bb B F F# C Eb
D Eb Ab E A B F F# C C# G Bb
C C# F# D G A Eb E Bb B F Ab
F# G C Ab C# Eb A Bb E F B D
F F# B G C D Ab A Eb E Bb C#
B C F C# F# Ab D Eb A Bb E G
Bb B E C F G C# D Ab A Eb F#
E F Bb F# B C# G Ab D Eb A C
C# D G Eb Ab Bb E F B C F# A
9T3E46 PRIME FORM = 012578. Does this hexachord have inversional combinatoriality?
Which form of the row can be combined with P0 to produce aggregate?
2
P9H1 P9H2 Array
I2H1 I2H2
DERIVATION
Webern’s music has a high degree of motivic concentration by employing derived series. The
row below is used Webern’s Concerto for Nine Instruments, Op.24
G B Bb D# D F# E F C# C Ab A
What kind of combinatoriality this row has?
D# G F# B Bb D C C# A Ab E F
E Ab G C B D# C# D Bb A F F# ____________________
B D# D G F# Bb Ab A F E C C#
C E D# Ab G B A Bb F# F C# D Prime form of H1 = 014589
Ab C B E D# G F F# D C# A Bb
Bb D C# F# F A G Ab E D# B C
A C# C F E Ab F# G D# D Bb B
C# F E A Ab C Bb B G F# D D#
D F# F Bb A C# B C Ab G D# E
F# Bb A D C# F D# E C B G Ab
F A Ab C# C E D D# B Bb F# G
3
014 is called generator of the series. Any trichord (except 036) can be a generator.
Any tetrachord that excludes interval class 4 can also be a generator.
Example: 015
Example: 0127
T8(G) = B
T8(P7)=P3
……
T6I(G)=B
T6I(P7)=I11
4
Webern’s Concerto for Nine Instruments, Op.24 – Segmentation II
In the segmentation below the notes of the violin and viola create 014. Also the highest notes of viola,
violin and flute create 014
Babbitt was quick to realize that despite its surface similarities to tonal forms, Schoenberg’s
twelve-tone music represented a syntactic and perceptual shift from tonal composition. He
saw that although twelve-tone syntax can support the dramatic strategies of tonal forms, it
may also lead to entirely new compositional strategies vibrant and musically compelling in
themselves. (MEAD, 9)
See in the example above how the derived series shaped form, register, and pitch
distribution.
5
First Compositional Period Trichordal Arrays (1947-1960)
D Eb Db E F C Bb G B F# G# A
Db D C Eb E B A F# Bb F G G#
Eb E D F F# Db B G# C G A Bb
C Db B D Eb Bb G# F A E F# G
B C Bb Db D A G E G# Eb F F#
E F Eb F# G D C A Db G# Bb B
F# G F G# A E D B Eb Bb C Db
A Bb G# B C G F D F# Db Eb E
F F# E G G# Eb Db Bb D A B C
Bb B A C Db G# F# Eb G D E F
G# A G Bb B F# E Db F C D Eb
G G# F# A Bb F Eb C E B Db D
The first hexachord has the prime form 012345, which is an all-combinatorial hexachord.
P2 D Eb Db E F C Bb G B F# G# A
R2 A G# F# B G Bb C F E Db Eb D
I11 B Bb C A G# Db Eb F# D G F E
RI11 E F G D F# Eb Db G A C Bb B
From Schoenberg, he is using the principle of combinatoriality; from Webern, he is using
the principle of trichordal partition of the row. The trichords are not the same, as in
Webern’s example showed before, but they are related by a very interesting type of
transformation.
6
These trichords are also subsets of the hexachord 012345:
F# A F G# E G Db Bb D B Eb C G# E G F# A F B Eb C Db Bb D
Eb F# D F Db E Bb G B G# C A C G# B Bb Db A Eb G E F D F#
G Bb F# A F G# D B Eb C E Db A F G# G Bb F# C E Db D B Eb
E G Eb F# D F B G# C A Db Bb Bb F# A G# B G Db F D Eb C E
G# B G Bb F# A Eb C E Db F D G Eb F# F G# E Bb D B C A Db
F G# E G Eb F# C A Db Bb D B B G Bb A C G# D F# Eb E Db F
B D Bb Db A C F# Eb G E G# F F Db E Eb F# D G# C A Bb G B
D F Db E C Eb A F# Bb G B G# Db A C B D Bb E G# F F# Eb G
Bb Db A C G# B F D F# Eb G E E C Eb D F Db G B G# A F# Bb
Db E C Eb B D G# F A F# Bb G Eb B D Db E C F# Bb G G# F A
A C G# B G Bb E Db F D F# Eb F# D F E G Eb A Db Bb B G# C
C Eb B D Bb Db G E G# F A F# D Bb Db C Eb B F A F# G E G#
By moving around the trichords, in order to produce trichordal arrays, Babbitt creates another
row, not related to the original one.
P6 F# A F G# E G Db Bb D B Eb C
I1 Db Bb D B Eb C F# A F G# E G
TP8 G# E G F# A F B Eb C Db Bb D
TI11 B Eb C Db Bb D G# E G F# A F
RI1 G E G# F A F# C Eb B D Bb Db
R6 C Eb B D Bb Db G E G# F A F#
TRI11 F A F# G E G# D Bb Db C Eb B
TR8 D Bb Db C Eb B F A F# G E G#
7
The trichordal transformations in the trichordal array are (the tables above side by side):
a b c d b a d c
c d a b d c b a
b a d c a b c d
d c b a c d a b
In order to create more variety when using these arrays in an actual composition, Babbitt
devised another kind of distribution inspired by the subsets of a set of four elements. As we
know from basic set theory, a set of four elements has 16 subsets. For example the set
{a,b,c,d} has the following subsets:
{ }, {a},{b},{c},{d},{a,b},{a,c},{a,d},{b,c},{b,d},{c,d},{a,b,c},{a,b,d},{a,c,d},{b,c,d},
{a,b,c,d}
Therefore the same trichordal array show in the table above can be rearranged in the
following way:
In this distribution one can find 15 vertical combinations of the 16 possible subsets of a four-
element set:
Column Sets
If we associate this table with four instruments, for
1. ABC D
example, it could mean:
2. CD AB
3. BCD A 4 solos
4. BC AD 6 duets
5. ACD B 4 trios
6. AC BD 1 complete ensemble
7. C ABD
8. ABCD
This is the way Babbitt distributes the instruments in his Composition for Four
Instruments, which is the second piece written in the First Compositional Period.
8
Distribution of Ensembles
P6 F# A F G# E G Db Bb D B Eb C
I1 Db Bb D B Eb C F# A F G# E G
TP8 G# E G F# A F B Eb C Db Bb D
TI11 B Eb C Db Bb D G# E G F# A F
Trichordal array
See how Babbitt used the trichords in the opening solo of the piece (layers of register). Also,
the first trichord is alone and the other three overlapped. This microstructure follows the
same model used in the distribution of ensembles (see the next aggregate)
9
But Babbitt does not use only the trichord 014 and the partitions above for the entire piece.
If we take a look in the cello solo (m.139) and apply the same principle of registral
distribution shown in the top of the previous page, it only works if the trichord is different
from 014. Look the example above (cello solo) and identify the trichord he is using in the
cello solo.
_________________
Cello solo showing registral distribution – compare with the table of ensemble distribution
The row, in which the piece is based, is actually the one shown below. This row appears for
the first time only in the last system of the piece (score page 20):
G E Ab Gb F A Eb D C B C# Bb
014 014 013 013
10
The rhythm in this piece is also determined by serial procedures. Babbitt takes the series
1432 and applies the four basic serial transformations:
In addition, these four duration patterns are each expanded into longer duration patterns by
multiplying each member of a given pattern by its own successive members.
Example: 1 4 3 2 - 4 16 12 8 - 3 12 9 6 - 2 8 6 4
The figure below shows the rhythmic patterns of the opening solo:
• Three Composition for Piano, the first piece he wrote in his First Compositional
Period. We will describe some of the techniques he used in this piece.
• String Quartet No.2
• Semi-Simple Variations
• All Set, for jazz ensemble
Bb Eb F D C Db G B F# A Ab E
027 012 015 015
The first hexachord has a prime form of 023457, which is all-combinatorial. Look the table on
page 2. Therefore it is possible to produce aggregates using all four transformations of the
row. See the matrix below.
11
Bb Eb F D C Db G B F# A Ab E
F Bb C A G Ab D F# Db E Eb B
Eb Ab Bb G F F# C E B D Db A
F# B Db Bb Ab A Eb G D F E C
Ab Db Eb C Bb B F A E G F# D
G C D B A Bb E Ab Eb F# F Db
Db F# Ab F Eb E Bb D A C B G
A D E Db B C F# Bb F Ab G Eb
D G A F# E F B Eb Bb Db C Ab
B E F# Eb Db D Ab C G Bb A F
C F G E D Eb A Db Ab B Bb F#
E A B Ab F# G Db F C Eb D Bb
The table below provides the combinatorial transformations for each form of the row. The
forms indicated with arrows are the only ones used in the piece.
12
13
14
Formal Structure:
The only forms of the row used in the piece are shown above. See also that the index
numbers of the forms of the same type are a tritone apart (P4 – P10,…). The diagram below
shows the chain of combinatorial row in the B section.
15
The dynamics are serialized by attachment, i.e., for each transformation of the row there are
two dynamics associated. These associations change only in the final section (49-end).
P mp (pp)
R mf (p)
I f (mp)
RI p (ppp)
Register appears to be left open except in the voicing of the trichords. When Babbitt
segments the pitch series into vertical trichords, he voices them in relation to the row in the
following way:
R10 (m.10) –
I11 (m.11) –
P = 5142 R = 2415
I = 1524 RI = 4251
Each number equals the number of sixteenth notes. The blocks of sixteenth notes are
separated by rests or long notes, or indicated by accents or slurs.
Other works of the first period: All Set, String Quartet No.2
16
Second Compositional Period All-partition Arrays (1964-1980)
The major change between Babbitt’s first and second periods is the use of all-partition arrays,
i.e., arrays in which the partitions are not only trichords. As in Babbitt’s first period, each
array is made up of hexachordally combinatorial lyne pairs, but unlike most trichordal arrays,
all the lyne pairs employ members of a given row class. Like his earlier practice, Babbitt has
restricted himself to the all-combinatorial hexachord in constructing his row classes.
It is another technique that Babbitt uses to serialize rhythm. The basic structure is called
time point modulus and consists of twelve equal divisions of each measure.
All the transformations used for pitch rows also apply to rhythmic rows. Rhythmic aggregates
can also be used:
17
Below is the beginning of Tableaux:
Write down the pitch classes for each of the five registers:
2 2 2 3 3 partition
18
In his Post-Partitions the serialization is even more complex:
Arie da Capo
String Quartet No.3
String Quartet No.4
My Complements to Roger
19
Third Compositional Period Superarrays and all-trichord rows (1981- )
Babbitt’s last period is marked by the use of superarrays, consisting of all-partition and
trichordal arrays assembled into larger contrapuntal networks. For example, in his Ars
Combinatoria he takes four arrays, each one with four transformations, and builds a network
based on the 15 possibilities of grouping 4 elements together (16 minus null set):
20
Catalog of Compositions by Milton Babbitt
Unpublished works
1935 Generatrix for orchestra (unfinished) MS - withdrawn
1940 Composition for String Orchestra (unfinished) MS - withdrawn
1940 Music for the Mass I for mixed chorus MS
1941 Music for the Mass II MS
1941 Symphony (unfinished) MS - withdrawn
1941 String Trio MS
1946 Three Theatrical Songs for voice and piano CF Peters
1948 String Quartet No. 1 MS - withdrawn
1949 Film Music for Into the Good Ground MS - withdrawn
1954 Vision and Prayer for soprano and piano MS
Published works
First Period
Second Period
21
Third Period
Lester, Joel. Analytic Approaches to Twentieth-Century Music. New York: W.W. Norton, 1989.
Mead, Andrew. An Introduction to the Music of Milton Babbitt. Princeton: Princeton University
Press, 1994.
Straus, Joseph. Introduction to Post-Tonal Theory, 2nd Ed. Upper Saddle River: Prentice Hall,
2000.
23