Sei sulla pagina 1di 15

Influence of Ambient Temperature Conditions on

Main Engine Operation of MAN B&W Two-stroke Engines

Contents: Introduction .......................................................................... 3

Chapter 1
Temperature Restrictions and
Load-up Procedures at Start of Engine ............................. 3

 Normal start of engine .......................................................................... 3


 Start of cold engine ............................................................................... 3
 Preheating during standstill periods..................................................... 3
 Jacket cooling water systems with a builtin preheater ................. 4
 Preheater capacity ................................................................................ 4

Chapter 2
Engine Room Ventilation .................................................... 5
 Air temperature...................................................................................... 6
 Air supply ............................................................................................... 6
 Air pressure ............................................................................................ 7

Chapter 3
Main Engine Operation under Normal, High and
Extremely Low Ambient Temperature Conditions ............ 7

 Standard ambient design temperature conditions ......................... 7

 Design recommendations for normal ambient temperature running


conditions ...................................................................................... 9

 Design recommendations for specified high tropical temperature


running conditions ..................................................................... 10

 Design recommendations for extremely low air temperature running


conditions ............................................................................... 12

Closing Remarks ................................................................. 15

MAN Diesel • Copenhagen, Denmark


Influence of Ambient Temperature Conditions on
Main Engine Operation of MAN B&W Two-stroke Engines

Introduction Chapter 1 Start of cold engine


Fixed pitch propellers
In exceptional circumstances where it is
Diesel engines used as prime movers on Temperature Restrictions not possible to comply with the above-
ships are exposed to the varying climat- and Load-up Procedures mentioned normal recommendations,
ic temperature conditions that prevail at Start of Engine a minimum of 20oC can be accepted
in different parts of the world, and must
therefore be able to operate under all before the engine is started and run-up
ambient conditions from winter to sum- In order to protect the engine against slowly to 80% of SMCR rpm.
mer and from arctic to tropical areas. cold corrosion attacks on the cylinder
liners, some minimum temperature re- Before exceeding 80% SMCR rpm, a
As the temperature variations on the strictions and load-up procedures have minimum jacket water temperature of
surface of the sea are rather limited, to be considered before starting the 50oC should be obtained before the
the diesel engine will not normally be engine. above-described normal start load-up
exposed to really extreme tempera- procedure may be continued.
tures. However, the changes that do Below stated load-up procedures are
occur in the ambient conditions will, valid for MAN B&W two-stroke engines Controllable Pitch Propellers
among other things, cause a change with a cylinder bore greater or equal to In exceptional circumstances where it is
in the specific fuel oil consumption, the 80 cm, and may with benefit also be not possible to comply with the above-
exhaust gas amount and the exhaust gas applied for engines with a smaller bore. mentioned normal recommendations,
temperature of the diesel engine. These a minimum of 20oC can be accepted
changes are already described in our However, if needed, the existing load- before the engine is started and run-up
Project Guides and will therefore not be
up program recommendation (from slowly to 50% of SMCR power.
discussed in this paper.
90% to 100% in 30 minutes) is still valid
Also the scavenge air, compression and for engines with bore sizes from 70 cm Before exceeding 50% SMCR power,
maximum firing pressures of the diesel and down. a minimum jacket water temperature of
engine will change with climatic changes 50oC should be obtained before above
and, at very low ambient air tempera- Normal start of engine described normal start load-up proce-
tures, unrestricted engine operation Fixed pitch propellers dure may be continued.
requires adjustments of individual en- Normally, a minimum engine jacket
gine parameters. water temperature of 50oC is recom- The time period required for increasing
mended before the engine may be the jacket water temperature from 20°C
This paper describes our recommenda- started and run-up gradually from 80% to 50°C will depend on the amount of
tions on engine startup, the supply of to 90% of specified MCR speed (SMCR water in the jacket cooling water system,
ventilation air to the engine room and and on the engine load.
rpm) during 30 minutes.
engine operation under normal, high
and extremely low ambient temperature Note: The above recommendations are
conditions. For running-up between 90% and
based on the assumption that the en-
100% of SMCR rpm, it is recommend-
gine has already been well runin.
The paper is divided into three chapters ed that the speed be increased slowly
which, in principle, may be read indepen over a period of 60 minutes.
dently of each other, and all of which Preheating during standstill
have the ambient air temperature as a Controllable Pitch Propellers periods
common parameter. Normally, a minimum engine jacket wa- During short stays in ports (i.e. less than
ter temperature of 50oC is recommend- 45 days), it is recommended that the
The three chapters are entitled: ed before the engine may be started engine is kept preheated, the purpose
and run-up gradually from 50% to 75% being to prevent temperature variations
• Temperature Restrictions and Load- of specified MCR load (SMCR power) in the engine structure and correspond-
up Procedures at Start of Engine during 30 minutes. ing variations in thermal expansions,
and thus the risk of leakages.
• Engine Room Ventilation For running-up between 75% and
100% of SMCR power, it is recom- The jacket cooling water outlet tempera
• Main Engine Operation under Normal, mended that the load be increased ture should be kept as high as possible
High and Extremely Low Ambient slowly over a period of 60 minutes. (max. 7580°C), and should – before
Temperature Conditions.

3
Temperature
increase Preheater capacity in %
of jacket water of nominal MCR power
o
C 1.50% 1.25% 1.00% 0.75%
60

Preheater 50

Preheater 40
bypass
Preheater
30
pump
20

10

0
Jacket water main pumps 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 hours
Preheating time

Diesel engine Direction of main water flow The temperature increase and corresponding
preheating time curves are shown for the different
Direction of preheater circulating water flow preheater sizes indicated in % of nominal MCR power

Fig. 1: Preheating of jacket cooling water system – System A Fig. 3: Preheating of diesel engine

startingup – be increased to at least the jacket water main pumps, and the Preheater capacity
50°C, either by means of the auxiliary water flow direction is the same as for When a preheater is installed in the jacket
engine cooling water, or by means of a the jacket cooling water system. cooling water system, as shown in Figs.
builtin preheater in the jacket cooling 1 and 2, the preheater pump capacity,
water system, or a combination of both. In both cases, the preheater operation should be about 10% of the jacket water
is controlled by a temperature sensor main pump capacity. Based on experi-
Jacket cooling water systems after the preheater. ence, it is recommended that the pres-
with a builtin preheater
For two different jacket water preheater
systems, A and B, the positioning of a
preheater in the jacket cooling water
system is shown schematically in Figs.
1 and 2, respectively.
Preheater Preheater
pump Preheater
For system A, the circulating water bypass
flow is divided into two branches, one
going through the engine and one go-
ing through the cooling water system
outside the engine. As the arrows indi-
cate, the preheater water flows in the
opposite direction through the engine,
compared with the main jacket water
flow. As the water inlet is at the top of
the engine, the engine preheating is Jacket water main pumps
more effective in this way.
Diesel engine
For system B, the preheater and circu-
lating pump are placed in parallel with Fig. 2: Preheating of jacket cooling water system – System B

4
sure drop across the preheater should Chapter 2 openings can be used in all weather
be approx. 0.2 bar. The preheater pump conditions. Care should be taken to
and the jacket water main pump should ensure that no seawater can be drawn
be electrically interlocked to avoid the Engine Room Ventilation into the ventilation air intakes.
risk of simultaneous operation.
In addition to providing sufficient air for Furthermore, the ventilation air inlet should
The preheater capacity depends on the combustion purposes in the main engine, be placed at an appropriate distance
required preheating time and the re- auxiliary diesel engines, fuel fired boiler, from the exhaust gas funnel in order to
quired temperature increase of the en- etc., the engine room ventilation sys- avoid the suction of exhaust gas into
gine jacket water. The temperature and tem should be designed to remove the the engine room.
time relationships are shown in Fig. 3. radiation and convection heat from the
The relationships are almost the same main engine, auxiliary engines, boilers Major dust and dirt particles can foul air
for all engine types. and other components. coolers and increase the wear of com-
bustion chamber components.
If a temperature increase of for example A sufficient amount of ventilation air Accordingly, the air supplied to the
35°C (from 15°C to 50°C) is required, should be supplied and exhausted engine must be cleaned by appropri-
a preheater capacity of about 1% of through suitably protected openings ate filters. The size of particles passing
the engine’s nominal MCR power is arranged in such a way that these through the air intake filter should not
required to obtain a preheating time of exceed 5μm.
12 hours.

When sailing in arctic areas, the re-


quired temperature increase may be Air outlet
Engine room
higher, possibly 45°C or even higher,
ventilation fans
and therefore a larger preheater capac-
ity will be required. The curves in Fig. 3
Air inlet Air inlet
are based on the assumption that, at
the start of preheating, the engine and
engine room are of equal temperature.
It is assumed that the temperature will
increase uniformly all over the engine
structure during preheating, for which
reason steel masses and engine surfaces
in the lower part of the engine are also
included in the calculation.

The results of the preheating calculations


may therefore be somewhat conservative.

ME
AE AE AE

ME: Main engine


AE: Auxiliary engines

Main ducts for supply


of combustion air

Fig. 4: Engine room ventilation system

5
An example of an engine room ventilation For arctic running conditions, a ducted sponds to about 1.75 times the air con
system, where ventilation fans blow air air intake system directly to the turbo- sumption of the main engine at SMCR.
into the engine room via air ducts, is charger can be an advantage in order Accordingly, 2.0 times the air consump-
shown in Fig. 4. to maintain sufficiently high temperatures tion of the main engine at SMCR may
for the crew in the engine room. With a be sufficient.
Air temperature ducted air intake, the turbocharger’s
Measurements show that the ambient intake air temperature may be assumed On the other hand, for a compact engine
air intake temperature (from deck) at sea to be approximately equal to the ambient room with a small twostroke diesel
will be within 1 to 3°C of the seawater outside air temperature. engine, the above factor of 1.5 is rec-
temperature, i.e. max. 35°C for 32°C ommended to be higher, at least 2.0,
seawater, and max. 39°C for 36°C sea- Air supply because the radiation and convection
water. In the case of a low speed twostroke heat losses from the engine are relatively
diesel engine installed in a spacious en- greater than from large twostroke
Measurements also show that, in a nor- gine room, the capacity of the ventilation engines, and because it may be difficult
mal ventilation air intake system, where system should be such that the ventila- to achieve an optimum air distribution in
combustion air is taken directly from tion air to the engine room is at least 1.5 a small engine room.
the engine room of a ship, the engine times the total air consumption of the
room temperature is normally 1012°C main engine, auxiliary engines, boiler, To obtain a correct supply of air for the
higher than the ambient outside air tem- etc., all at specified maximum continu- main engine’s combustion process,
perature. This temperature difference ous rating (SMCR). about 50% of the ventilation air should
is even higher for winter ambient air be blown in at the top of the main en-
temperatures, see Fig. 5. In general, the As a rule of thumb, the minimum en- gine, near the air intake to the turbo-
engine room temperature should never gine room ventilation air amount corre- chargers, as shown in Fig. 4.
be below 5°C, which is ensured by stop-
ping one or more of the air ventilation
fans, thus reducing the air supply to
and thereby the venting of the engine
Engine room temperature TER
room.
and difference DT
This means that the average air tem- o
C
perature in a ventilated engine room will
60
not be lower than 5°C and not higher TER
than 39 + 12 = 51°C, say 55°C, as
often used as maximum temperature 50
for design of the engine room compo-
nents. 40

Since the air ventilation ducts for a 30


normal air intake system are placed
near the turbochargers, the air inlet 20 D
DT = TER  Tamb.
temperature to the turbochargers will
be lower than the engine room tem- 10
perature. Under normal air temperature Amb. air temp. Tamb.
conditions, the air inlet temperature to 0
the turbocharger is only 15°C higher than o
the ambient outside air temperature. 20 0 20 40 C
The engine room temperature TER and the engine
This means that the turbocharger suc-
tion air temperature will not be higher room/ambient air temperature difference DT are shown
than about 39 + 5 = 44°C (ref. 36°C as functions of the ambient air temperature Tamb
S.W.), say 45°C.
Fig. 5: Engine room temperature

6
Otherwise, this can have a negative ef- quire extensive ducting and a pressure Chapter 3
fect on the main engine performance. head as stated below.
Thus, the maximum firing pressure will
be reduced by 2.2% for every 10°C the Lowpressure fans, Main Engine Operation
turbocharger air intake temperature is Δp = 60100 mm WC under Normal, High and
raised, and the fuel consumption will go Extremely Low Ambient
up by 0.7%. For further information, please consult Temperature Conditions
engine room ventilation standard ISO
Furthermore, a correct air supply near 8861: 1998 (E).
the turbochargers will reduce the de- Standard ambient design
terioration of the turbocharger air filters temperature conditions
(from oil fumes, etc., in the engine room For the purpose of determining a refer-
air), and a too draughty engine room ence for fuel consumption and exhaust
can be avoided. gas data of diesel engines, the following
standard reference ambient conditions
Moreover, a sufficient amount of air defined by ISO (International Standards
should be supplied to areas with a Organisation) are to be used:
high heat dissipation rate in order to
ensure that all the heat is removed, for ISO 30461:2002(E) and
instance around auxiliary engines/gen- ISO 15550:2002 (E):
erators and boilers. Ventilation ducts for Barometric pressure .......... 1000 mbar
these areas are not shown in Fig. 4. Turbocharger air
intake temperature ................... 25°C
In the winter time, the amount of air Charge air coolant temperature .. 25°C
needed to remove the radiation/con- Relative air humidity.................... 30%
vection heat from the engine room may
be lower. The corresponding ambient seawater
temperature may be equal to or lower
than the abovementioned charge air
Air pressure coolant temperature, depending on and
The air in the engine room should have
influenced by the design of the cooling
a slightly positive pressure, but should
water system and on the operation of
not be more than about 5 mm WC (Wa-
the system (whether and to what extent
ter Column) above the outside pressure
at the air outlets in the funnel. IACS M28 ambient reference
conditions (1978)
Accommodation quarters will normally For the purpose of determining the power
have a somewhat higher overpressure, of main and auxiliary reciprocating internal
so as to prevent oil fumes from the en- combustion engines, the following ambient
gine room penetrating through door(s) reference conditions apply for ships of un-
into the accommodation. restricted service:

The ventilation air can be supplied, for Total barometric pressure.......1,000 mbar
example, by fans of the lowpressure Air temperature............................... +45°C
axial and highpressure centrifugal or Relative humidity.............................. 60%
axial types. The required pressure head Seawater temperature....................... 32°C
of the supply fans depends on the re- (Charge air coolantinlet)
sistance in the air ducts.
Note:
All ventilation air is normally delivered The engine manufacturer shall not be
by lowpressure air supply fans which, expected to provide simulated ambient
to obtain sufficient air ventilation in all reference conditions on the test bed.
corners of the engine room, may re-

7
SFOC The standard layout data for the main dard. This paper also describes such
g/kWh engines are based on ISO ambient ref- situations.
o
Turbocharger air intake temperature: 10 C erence conditions, with the maximum
allowable tropical ambient conditions of At the opposite end of the ambient tem-
45°C air and 32°C seawater/36°C cool- perature scale, too low a turbocharger
36°C. C.W ing water, for which unrestricted service air intake temperature may limit the
10°C. C.W
at 100% SMCR is still possible. engine operation in service if no special
2 g/kWh
precautions have been taken. This
In some few cases, the owner requires paper also describes this situation.
operating conditions at tropical ambient
40 50 60 70 80 90 100% SMCR
temperature conditions higher than stan-
Engine shaft power

Fig. 6: Influence on SFOC of the cooling Turbocharger


air intake
water (scavenge air coolant) temperature
temperature
Special
High temperature
the cooling water is recirculated). Standard matched engine
The engine must be able to operate in 55 ISO temperature
matched engine Special
unrestricted service under the special 50 Max. tropical
maximum ambient temperature condi- Normal temperature
Max.
tions required by the ship. 45 tropical
45 °C
temperature
40
According to IACS (International As-
35
sociation of Classification Societies) Special ISO based
Special
rule M28, these requirements (special 30 design design
basis
maximum ambient temperature condi- ISO temperature layout
Standard ISO design
tions) – normally referred to as tropical basis 25 25 °C layout
ambient reference conditions – are as 20
stated in the box. 15 For engine loads
higher than 30% SMCR
a low scavenge air
All MAN B&W twostroke engines fulfil 10
coolant temperature
the above rule as standard. 5 is recommended
(Giving low SFOC and
0 low scav. air press. )
The above standard values are normally Lowest
used for oceangoing ships, whereas 5 Min. ambient air
for stationary power plants, specific Normal min. temperature
Min. ambient air
10
climatically determined conditions at 10 °C
temperature Low ambient air
site may require that different values be 15 temperature exhaust
gas bypass will be
used for matching of the engine (site 20 needed below min.
Possible low ambient
conditions instead of ISO) and unre- air temperature temperature
stricted service. 25 exhaust gas bypass
for operation under
30 extremely low ambient
Depending on the cooling water sys- temperature conditions
tem, the scavenge air coolant tem- 35

perature may be equal to or somewhat 40


higher than the abovementioned
Up to 100% SMCR running is not allowed
seawater temperature. Thus, if a cen-
Up to 100% SMCR running is allowed
tral cooling water system is used, the
charge air coolant temperature will Up to 100% SMCR running only allowed when low
ambient temperature exhaust gas bypass (C1+2)
normally be about 36°C i.e. 4°C higher is installed
than the seawater temperature.
Fig. 7a: Principles for standard and special high ambient air temperature matched engine

8
The scavenge air pressure will also be
Standard Special
ISO temperature high temperature reduced when using a low scavenge air
matched engine matched engine coolant temperature. Therefore, when
Standard air cooler Special air cooler operating at low ambient air tempera-
Temperature design design tures giving a high scavenge air pres-
°C
Scavenge air Scavenge air
sure, it is recommended to use as low
56 temperature limit temperature limit a scavenge air coolant temperature as
Standard 55 °C Max. 55 °C
54 possible.
52
In general, the MAN B&W two-stroke
50 Maximum Maximum
scavenge air scavenge air
engines are recommended to be oper-
Standard 48 °C 48 Max. 48 °C
temperature temperature ated with as low a scavenge air coolant
at 100% SMCR at 100% SMCR
46 temperature as possible.
44
Shipyards often specify a constant
42 High tropical
scavenge air
(maximum) central cooling water tem-
40 Max. 40 °C
coolant perature of 36°C, not only for tropical
Standard temperature
38
tropical ambient conditions, but also for winter
scavenge air High tropical
Standard 36 °C 36
coolant seawater Max. 36 °C ambient conditions. The purpose is to
34
temperature temperature reduce the seawater pump flow rate
Standard tropical when possible, and thereby to reduce
Standard 32 °C 32
seawater the electric power consumption, and/or
temperature
30 ISO based to reduce the water condensation in the
High scavenge
design Max. 29 °C
air coolant
28 temperature
layout air coolers.
ISO based
26 ISO
Standard scavenge air
basis 25 °C coolant
design However, when operating with 36°C
24 layout
temperature cooling water instead of for example
22 10°C (to the scavenge air cooler), the
Up to 100% SMCR running is not allowed (scavenge air) specific fuel oil consumption (SFOC) will
Up to 100% SMCR running is allowed (scavenge air) increase by approx. 2 g/kWh, see Fig.
Up to 100% SMCR running is allowed (scavenge air coolant/central cooling water) 6. Any obtained gain in reduced electric
Up to 100% SMCR running is allowed (seawater) power consumption, therefore, will be
more than lost in additional fuel costs of
Fig. 7b: Principles for layout of scavenge air cooler for standard and special high scavenge the main engine.
air coolant temperature (illustrated for a central cooling water system)
The cooling water temperature will nor-
mally be higher than 10°C – achieved
by recirculating the cooling water – as
Design recommendations for for the above standard temperature
this is the minimum permissible cooling
normal ambient temperature matched engine is about –10°C.
water temperature for the lubricating oil
running conditions cooler. This means that, in practice, the
Under these normal running conditions,
scavenge air temperature will never be
Normal running conditions i.e. at turbocharger air intake tempera-
lower than 1012°C and, therefore, has
As mentioned earlier, the main engine tures between +45°C and –10°C, and
no restrictive influence on the operation
is, as standard matched/designed with a service power higher than 30%
of the engine.
for ISO ambient reference conditions SMCR, it is recommended to keep both
(25°C air/25°C cooling water) and max. the turbocharger air inlet and scavenge
As a general rule, normal running of a
tropical ambient conditions of 45°C at air temperatures as low as possible,
diesel engine is possible, i.e. without any
the turbocharger air inlet, and a 32°C so as to reduce the specific fuel oil con-
precautions being taken, at any tur-
seawater/36°C cooling water tempera- sumption of the diesel engine.
bocharger air inlet temperature below
ture to the scavenge air coolers. The
45°C and above some –10°C, see Fig.
lowest allowable air intake temperature
7a. Lower temperatures may result in
a too high scavenge air pressure and

9
higher temperatures may involve a too Design recommendations specified with an increased scavenge
low scavenge air pressure. In both cases, for specified high tropical air pressure. Therefore, part load optimis
special precautions have to be taken. temperature running ation, in combination with engines speci-
conditions fied for high ambient air temperature op-
Operating at part load in special As already mentioned, the standard eration, can result in a higher than nor-
inland, bay and harbour areas layout data of the diesel engine is given mally acceptable scavenge air pressure.
An increase of the seawater temperature at ISO ambient reference conditions,
and, thereby, the scavenge air tempera i.e. at 25°C air intake to turbocharger In principle, when unrestricted operation
ture has a negative impact on the heat and 25°C cooling water temperature at increased tropical ambient air tempera
load conditions in the combustion at inlet to the scavenge air cooler. The ture is required, the engine design layout
chamber. Therefore, all twostroke corresponding maximum allowable has to be based on a higher design
engines for marine applications have tropical temperature is 45°C air and temperature than the ISO temperature,
an alarm set point of 55°C for the scav- 32°C seawater/36°C central cooling but now with the normal ISO based en-
enge air temperature for protection of water. gine parameters (heat load and scavenge
the engine. air pressure) valid for the higher design
Specified tropical air temperature temperature. Thus, if the engine is
When operating at an increased seawa- higher than 45°C required to be specified for a max. air
ter temperature existing in some inland, An increase of for example 5°C of the intake temperature of for example
bay and harbour areas, the maximum maximum turbocharger air intake tem- 45 + 5 = 50°C, this involves that the
power output of the engine should be perature from 45°C to 50°C will involve engine instead of being matched to the
reduced to an engine load resulting in a a reduction of the scavenge air pressure. ISO based air temperature of 25°C has
scavenge air temperature below the level The pressure reduction can be compen to be matched to the 25 + 5 = 30°C air
of the scavenge air temperature alarm. sated by specifying a higher scavenge intake temperature and obtaining ap-
air pressure at ISO ambient conditions. proximately the original ISO based en-
The engine’s obtainable load level will gine heat load conditions for this higher
nevertheless in any case be much It has to be mentioned that part load ambient air temperature matching point.
higher than required to secure safe optimised/matched engines are already In this example where a max. air intake
manoeuvrability (46 knots) of the ship
even at an extreme seawater tempera-
ture of for example 42°C. Air intake casing

When sailing in, for example, the har- Exhaust gas system
bour area during manoeuvring, the
Air intake
engine load will normally be relatively Exhaust gas preheater
Turbine
low (1530% SMCR), and the cor- receiver
responding scavenge air temperature
will then only be slightly higher than
the scavenge air coolant temperature. A
Turbocharge r
Therefore, a seawater temperature as
high as for example 42°C in harbour
areas is not considered a problem for the
main engine. Scavenge
air cooler Compressor

In general, when sailing in areas with a


high seawater temperature, it is possible Scavenge
to operate the main engine at part load air receiver A Control valve
as long as the scavenge air temperature For preheating the intake air in order to
alarm limit is not reached. If the alarm keep the air temperature above 10 °C
is activated, the engine load has to be Diesel engine
reduced.
Fig. 8: Preheating of intake air

10
temperature of 45 + 5 = 50°C is required, perature. The maximum allowed cool- water temperature of 25°C, has to be
the allowable air temperature range will ant flow velocity of the air cooler must, matched to the 25 + 3 = 28°C cool-
change from –10°C/45°C to –5°C/50°C, of course, not be exceeded. ing water temperature and obtaining
see Fig. 7a. If unrestricted operating at approximately the original ISO based
–10°C is still required for this high air As a ΔT of 8°C is considered to be the engine heat load conditions and scav-
temperature matched engine, a low lowest possible temperature difference enge air temperature at the higher cool-
ambient air temperature exhaust gas to be used for a realistic specification ing water temperature matching point.
bypass (see later) is needed in order to of a scavenge air cooler, accordingly,
avoid a too high scavenge air pressure MAN B&W two-stroke engines have Engine design specification
at low ambient air temperatures. 48 – 8 = 40°C as the maximum accept- If an engine has to be specified for
able scavenge air coolant temperature operation in high ambient temperature
Specified tropical cooling water tem for a central cooling water system, see conditions (i.e. higher than 45°C air and
peratures higher than 32°C seawater/ Fig. 7b. higher than 32°C seawater/36°C cool-
36°C central cooling water ing water), this should be stated in the
The standard marine air cooler layout is If the engine is required to be specified design specification order to the engine
specified with a ΔT of maximum 12°C for a maximum central cooling water designer in order to ensure that the
from water inlet to air outlet of the sca temperature of for example 36 + 3 = 39°C, correct engine and turbocharger are
venge air cooler, which gives a scavenge this means that the engine, instead of delivered.
air temperature of 36 + 12 = 48°C and, being matched to the ISO based cooling
accordingly, a margin of 7°C to the sca
venge air temperature alarm limit of
55°C at 100% SMCR.

It is relevant to keep this temperature 3CAVENGEæAIR


margin of 7°C as a fouling margin for all BYPASS
kinds of applications. This means that
!IRæINTAKEæCASING
the scavenge air temperature of 55 – 7
= 48°C is the maximum temperature to %XHAUSTæGASæSYSTEM
be used for layout of the scavenge air
cooler. %XHAUSTæGAS 4URBINE
RECEIVER

An increase of for example 3°C of the


maximum scavenge air coolant tem-
perature from 36°C C.W. to 39°C C.W. 4URBOCHARGE R
may involve a similar increase of the
scavenge air temperature from 48°C to
51°C, which has a negative impact on $ 3CAVENGE
the combustion chamber temperatures. #OMPRESSOR
AIRæCOOLER
3CAVENGE
AIRæRECEIVER #
The increased maximum scavenge air
coolant temperature can be compen-
sated by specifying a scavenge air cooler "
with a reduced temperature difference, $IESELæENGINE
see Fig. 7b, illustrated for an engine with
a central cooling water system.
"ææææ3CAVENGEæAIRæBYPASSæVALVE
A reduction of the temperature differ- #ææ#ONTROLæDEVICE
%NSURESæTHATæTHEæSCAVENGEæAIRæPRESSUREæDOESæNOT
ence can be obtained by a combination EXCEEDæTHEæ3-#2)3/æVALUE
of increased water flow and/or a big-
ger scavenge air cooler. Approx. 15% $ææ%LECTRICæMEASURINGæDEVICE
increased coolant flow is necessary in 3CAVENGEæAIRæPRESSURE
order to obtain a 1°C lower scavenge
air temperature at a given coolant tem- Fig. 9: Scavenge air bypass system

11
Preheating of intake air (shipyard
Air intake casing
application)
Exhaust gas bypass Exhaust gas system
Exhaust gas Considering that a low ambient tem-
receiver perature is the reason for the high den-
sity of the turbocharger intake air, the
B first idea that comes to mind is simply
Turbine
to heat the air. A diagram of such a sys-
tem is shown in Fig. 8.

1 C1+2 Turbocharge r It should be mentioned, however, that


preheating of the intake air is normally
not acceptable, as the air preheating in-
D1 stallation required is rather expensive.
Scavenge Compressor Alternative methods should therefore
2 air cooler be considered.
Scavenge
air receiver
If the ship sometimes operates at
D2 B Exhaust gas bypass valve low (arctic) and sometimes high air
Controlled by the scavenge air pressure temperatures, a bypass solution is
Diesel engine recommended. With such a bypass,
C1+2 Control device
the engine is matched on the basis of
Ensures that the loaddependent scavenge air pressure
does not exceed the corresponding ISO based pressure ISO ambient conditions, while at low
air temperature running conditions the
D Required electric measuring device scavenge air pressure may be control-
D1 Scavenge air pressure led by opening the bypass.
D2 Engine speed and engine load

The bypass arrangements, which in


Fig. 10: Standard loaddependent low ambient air temperature exhaust gas bypass system
principle can be either a scavenge air
or an exhaust gas bypass system, are
Design recommendations for Possible different measures shown schematically in Figs. 9 and 10
extremely low air temperature For inlet air temperatures below approx. and are described below.
running conditions –10°C, the precautions recommended
The density of the air will be high when will depend very much on the actual Scavenge air bypass system
the ship is operating in arctic condi- operating profile of the ship. In this con- (not MAN B&W two-stroke standard)
tions with a low turbocharger air intake text, the following different measures In Fig. 9, excessive air supply to the
temperature. As a result, the scavenge should be mentioned: engine is adjusted by blowing off part
air pressure, the compression pressure of the air, via a silencer keeping the scav-
1. Preheating of intake air
and the maximum firing pressure will be enge air pressure close to the pressure
high. (shipyard application)
valid at SMCR/ISO operating conditions.
2. Scavenge air bypass system
In order to prevent excessive pressures The air must not be blown off directly to
(not MAN B&W two-stroke standard)
under such ambient air temperature the engine room as it contains oil fumes
conditions, the turbocharger air inlet 3. Exhaust gas bypass system and creates noise.
temperature should be kept somewhat (MAN B&W two-stroke standard)
higher than the ambient air temperature The principle of controlling the scav-
(by preheating, if possible). A reduced power output of the engine enge air pressure, using control device
could also be a solution if there is no C1, is shown in Figs. 9 and 11. Fig. 11
Furthermore, the scavenge air coolant demand for 100% SMCR power output shows that in the upper power range of
temperature should be kept as low as under low ambient air temperature op- the engine, part of the air will blow off,
possible (reducing the scavenge air eration. thus reducing the scavenge air pres-
pressure), and/or the engine power sure, see arrow C1.
output in service should be reduced.

12
In fact, Fig. 11 also indicates that a variable adjustment of the bypass valve For this bypass, a more applicable sys-
reduction (limitation) of the maximum opening. tem with control device C1+2 is applied
permissible engine power output in ser- where the loaddependent scavenge
vice could be a solution when sailing at The C1 control system is only possible air pressures are kept close to the cor-
low ambient air temperature, if – under for low air temperatures not lower than responding ISO pressures.
this condition – there is no demand for about –15°C.
operation at 100% SMCR. The principle of controlling the scav-
The scavenge air bypass system is not enge air pressure by means of control
Thus, when occasionally operating at, an MAN B&W two-stroke engine stan- device C1+2 is shown in Fig. 11, which
for example, –15°C air (and with 10°C dard system and is not recommended. shows that the exhaust gas bypass
cooling water), up to about 90% SMCR can be activated (variably open) over
power may still be maintained for a Exhaust gas bypass system the entire load range of the engine if the
normal engine without any adjustments (MAN B&W two-stroke engine standard) air temperature is sufficiently low, i.e. if
being made. With an exhaust gas bypass system the scavenge air pressure is sufficiently
(which is the MAN Diesel standard rec- high.
The scavenge air bypass C1 control ommendation), as shown in Fig. 10,
system is a variable low ambient air tem- part of the exhaust gas bypasses the The standard low ambient air tempera-
perature bypass system, which is elec- turbocharger turbine, giving less energy ture exhaust gas bypass system C1+2
tronically controlled, PLCbased (Pro- to the compressor, thus reducing the air is based on an exhaust gas bypass valve
grammable Logic Controller) and with supply to the engine. of the butterfly type, with variable ad-
an electrical or pneumatical actuator for justment of the bypass opening. The
opening of the bypass valve is activated
by means of an electrical or pneumatical
valve actuator, which is electronically
4URBOCHARGER controlled based on a PLC (Program-
3CAVENGEæAIRæPRESSUREæP 3# AIRæINTAKE mable Logic Controller).
TEMPERATURE
BARæABS
çæª# ANDææª#æ# 7 As an option, the variable low ambient
P3#æ3-#2)3/ çæª# ANDææª#æ# 7 air temperature bypass system C1,
# æª# ANDææª#æ# 7 as described for scavenge air bypass,
æª# ANDææª#æ# 7 )3/ can also be applied for the exhaust
æª# ANDææª#æ# 7 gas bypass system for moderate low
# ambient air temperatures. However,
because the bypass flow area for low
#  air temperatures is relatively large, the
load dependent C1+2 system is recom-
#ONTROLæDEVICEæ# mended.
# P3# P3#æ3-#2)3/
P3#æ)3/ "YPASSæOPENSæWHENæP 3# If an engine is to be specified for opera-
EXCEEDSæP 3#3-#2)3/ SOMEæOFFSET
F
tion in special low ambient air tempera-
ture conditions, i.e. with a low ambient
#  P3# P3#æ)3/ temperature exhaust gas bypass sys-
EXHæGASæBYPASS tem, this should be stated in the design
"YPASSæOPENSæWHENæP 3#
specification to the engine designer.
EXCEEDSæP 3#)3/ SOMEæOFFSET
The installation of the low temperature
dependent exhaust gas bypass system
should only be introduced after consult-
ing MAN Diesel, Copenhagen.
     æ3-#2
%NGINEæSHAFTæPOWER

Fig. 11: Bypass valve controlling the scavenge air pressure psc (example)

13
Design features of the standard
loaddependent exhaust gas bypass 3TEAMæPRODUCTION
system C1+2
KGH
The installation of the adjustable   3-#ç#-%ç# 4OTALæSTEAM
loaddependent exhaust gas bypass 3-#2ææ æK7æATææRMIN PRODUCTION
system C1+2 ensures and maintains WITHæEXHAUST
the optimal bypass flow area. This !IRæINTAKEæTEMPERATUREæª# GASæBYPASS
means that the bypass system, com-
pared with C1, has a more advanced  
control device C1+2, which includes 3URPLUSæSTEAM
both scavenge air pressure and engine
4OTALæSTEAM
load parameters.
PRODUCTION
  WITHOUTæBYPASS
Besides the gauge for scavenge air
pressure, the control system therefore 3TEAM
requires a shaft power measuring de- CONSUMPTION
vice for measuring the shaft torque and %XTRAæSTEAM
engine speed (rpm), together with a fuel NEEDED
index transmitter.  

For the electronically controlled ME


engine, the bypass control C1+2 can
be incorporated in the Engine Control
System (ECS) as an addon. Engine 
load, fuel index and scavenge air pres-
sure signals are already available for the
ME software and, therefore, additional
measuring devices are not needed for
ME engines. 
       3-#2
This exhaust gas bypass system ensures %NGINEæSHAFTæPOWER
that, when the engine is running at part
load at low ambient temperatures, the Fig. 12: Expected steam production by exhaust gas boiler at winter ambient conditions
loaddependent scavenge air pressure (0°C air) for main engine 6S60MCC7/MEC7 with/without a loaddependent low air
is close to the corresponding pressure temperature exhaust gas bypass system
on the scavenge air pressure curve
which is valid for ISO ambient condi-
tions. When the scavenge air pressure perature. The loaddependent exhaust same, whereas in winter time it may be
exceeds the readin ISObased scav- gas bypass system will ensure that the different, as the scavenge air pressure
enge air pressure curve, the bypass exhaust gas temperature after the tur- is controlled by the bypass valve.
valve will variably open and, irrespective bochargers will only fall by about 0.3°C
of the ambient conditions, ensure that per 1.0°C drop in the intake air tem- As an example, Fig. 12 shows the influ-
the engine is not overloaded. At the perature, thus enabling the exhaust gas ence of the loaddependent exhaust
same time, it will keep the exhaust gas boiler to produce more steam under gas bypass system on the steam
temperature relatively high. low ambient temperature conditions. production when the engine is oper-
ated during winter, with an ambient air
During normal operation at low ambi- Irrespective of whether a loaddependent temperature of 0°C and a scavenge air
ent temperatures, the exhaust gas exhaust gas bypass system is installed cooling water temperature of 10°C.
temperature after the turbochargers or not, the exhaust gas boiler steam
will decrease by about 1.6°C for each production at ISO (25°C air/25°C C.W.) The calculations have been made for a
1.0°C reduction of the intake air tem- or higher ambient conditions will be the 6S60MCC7/MEC7 engine equipped

14
with a highefficiency turbocharger. • Increased preheater capacity for Closing Remarks
Fig. 12 also shows that, in winter time, it jacket water during standstill
is questionable whether an engine with-
• Different grades of lubricating oil for Diesel engines installed in oceangoing
out a bypass will meet the ship’s steam turbochargers
demand for heating purposes (indicated ships are often exposed to different cli-
for bulk carrier or tanker), whereas with • Space heaters for electric motors matic temperature conditions because
a loaddependent exhaust gas bypass of the ship’s trading pattern, but as the
• Sea chests must be arranged so temperature variations on the sea sur-
system, C1+2, the engine can meet the
that blocking with ice is avoided. face are normally relatively limited, the
steam demand.
engines will normally be able to operate
In general, a turbocharger with a normal worldwide in unrestricted service with-
Ships with ice class notation
layout can be used in connection with out any precautions being taken.
For ships with the FinnishSwedish ice
an exhaust gas bypass. However, in a class notation 1C, 1B, 1A and even 1A
few cases a turbocharger modification Even if the ship has to sail in very cold
super or similar, all MAN B&W twostroke
may be needed. areas, the MAN B&W two-stroke en-
diesel engines meet the ice class de-
gines can, as this paper illustrates, also
mands, i.e. there will be no changes to
Special low temperature precautions operate under such conditions without
the main engines.
in the diesel engine and auxiliaries any problems as long as special low
Lube oil viscosity at low ambient tem- temperature precautions are taken.
However, if the ship is with ice class
peratures notation 1A super and the main engine
Special recommendations for low sea- The use of the standard loaddependent
has to be reversed for going astern (Fixed
water temperature conditions may be low ambient air temperature exhaust
Pitch Propeller), the starting air compres
considered. The cooling water inlet gas bypass system may – as an ad-
sors must be able to charge the starting
temperature to the lube oil cooler should ditional benefit – also improve the ex-
air receivers in half an hour, instead of one
not be lower than 10°C, as otherwise haust gas heat utilisation when running
hour, i.e. the compressors must have
the viscosity of the oil in the cooler will at low ambient air temperatures.
the double size compared to normal.
be too high, and the heat transfer inad-
equate. This means that some of the Furthermore, at the other end of the
For other special ice class notations,
cooling water should be recirculated. temperature scale, if the ship should
the engines have to be individually
need to sail in unrestricted service in ar-
checked.
Furthermore, to keep the lube oil vis- eas with very high ambient air tempera-
cosity low enough to ensure proper tures, higher than 45°C, this will also be
The exhaust gas bypass system to
suction conditions in the lube oil pump, possible provided a high temperature
be applied is independent of the ice
it may be advisable to install heating matching of the engine is applied. Even
classes, and only depends on how low
coils near the suction pipe in the lube oil when sailing should be needed at very
the specified ambient air temperature
bottom tank. high seawater temperatures, this will be
is expected to be. However, if the ship
possible provided a specially designed
is specified with a high ice class like 1A
Other recommendations scavenge air cooler is installed on the
super, it is advisable to make preparations
Depending on the situation, one might diesel engine.
for, or install, an exhaust gas bypass
consider introducing the following ad- system.
ditional modifications of the standard
design practice:
• Larger electric heaters for the cylin-
der lubricators or other cylinder oil
ancillary equipment
• Cylinder oil pipes to be further heat
traced/insulated
• Upgraded steam tracing of fuel oil
pipes

15

Potrebbero piacerti anche