Sei sulla pagina 1di 27

 

 
 
 

 
 
 
 

Access  to  Information  


For  Youth  and  their  Communities  
in  Uganda  
Report  prepared  by:  Seth  Herr,  Paradox  Alley  
March  –  June  2010  

 
 
 
 

 
 
 

 
Handover  Notes  from  Meeting  with  UNICEF  Fellow  Jean-­  Marc  
Lefebure  
 

Digital  Drum  Reconstruction/  Information  Access  


A  majority  of  what  was  discussed  during  the  handover  meeting  with  Jean-­‐Marc  
Lefebure  was  details  of  the  design  and  manufacture  process  of  the  Drum  as  it  
currently  exists    (second  revision  prototype).    Jean-­‐Marc  detailed  the  current  
revision  and  we  discussed  the  areas  of  the  design  that  could  be  improved  for  the  
next  revisions  

 
Basic  DD  design  and  build  process  needs  to  be  addressed  

• Waterproofing  
• Reduce  keyboard  expense  
• Harden  solar  power  data  collection  system  
• Create  out-­‐of-­‐band  management  system  (GPRS,  power  management)  
• Display  brightness  concerns  
• Lower  overall  power  envelope  
• Explore  alternative  battery  chemistries  and  compare  TCO  /  lifespan  /  impact  
of  operating  environment  /  availability  
 
Overall  needs  to  be  addressed:  

• Locate  suppliers  of  routinely  used  parts  in  Kampala  


• Identify  local  businesses  capable  of  supporting  drum  build,  painters,  metal  
shops,  electronic  technicians,  etc.  
• Develop  sustainable  model  for  support  and  maintenance  of  the  Drum  
• Develop  a  user-­‐friendly  interface  for  Drum  
• Refine  security  of  operating  system  on  the  Drum  
 
We  discussed  some  possible  approaches  to  interest  the  private  sector  in  developing  
and  maintaining  the  Drum  such  as  it’s  potential  to  be  used  as  a  pay-­‐per-­‐use  internet  
access  point,  potential  use  as  a  cellular  phone  charging  station  and  subsidizing  
production  and  operating  expenses  through  advertising  on  the  device  (physical  
branding  on  the  case).  
Solar  Power  in  Rural  Uganda:  Use  Cases  and  Recommendations  
 
The  purpose  of  this  document  is  to  detail  potential  use  cases  for  solar  power  in  rural  
Uganda  as  well  as  providing  some  purchasing  recommendations  for  solar  systems  to  
suit  each  use  case  based  on  currently  available  technology.  
 
As  technology  becomes  more  involved  in  every  aspect  of  our  lives,  the  need  for  
generation  of  sustainable,  clean  electricity  to  power  the  devices  we  rely  upon  
increases.    While  advances  are  being  made,  Uganda  lacks  a  reliable  electrical  utility  
infrastructure  beyond  the  cities  of  Entebbe  and  Kampala,  driving  a  need  for  small-­‐
scale  generation  systems.  While  fossil  fuel-­‐based  generators  have  a  place  in  some  
environments,  they  prove  to  be  too  expensive  and  difficult  to  maintain  for  smaller-­‐
scale  installations.  There  are  quite  a  few  situations  where  power  generation  is  
required  but  the  cost  of  installing,  maintaining  and  fuelling  a  traditional  generator  
outweighs  the  benefit.  Solar  power  is  a  solution  perfectly  suited  for  these  
installations.  
 
This  document  will  focus  on  three  primary  use-­‐cases:  Youth  Center  computer  
facilities,  Primary  teacher  colleges  and  Maternity  clinics  in  rural  health  centers.  All  
three  facilities  require  more  power  than  is  generally  available  to  them  via  
conventional  means  but  rarely  have  the  funding  to  install  and  upkeep  fossil-­‐fueled  
generating  systems.  These  facilities  have  been  identified  as  having  the  greatest  
potential  impact  for  Unicef  Uganda's  Keep  Children  Alive  and  Keep  Children  
Learning  initiatives.    
 
 
I.  The  available  and  emerging  technologies:  
 
Currently  available  solar  collector  technologies  can  be  summarised  as  being  of  two  
available  categories:  Crystalline  and  Thin-­‐film.  Both  have  their  advantages  and  are  
suitable  for  certain  installations.  Crystalline  modules  are  generally  more  efficient  
(20%-­‐28%  as  opposed  to  7%-­‐15%)  and  have  a  lower  power  generating  threshold  
than  thin-­‐film  collectors.  This  means  that  crystalline  modules  will  output  useable  
power  even  on  overcast  days  whereas  thin-­‐film  modules  generally  require  direct  
sunlight  to  output  close  to  their  rated  capacity.  An  advantage  of  thin-­‐film  modules  
over  crystalline  modules  is  that  they  are  flexable  and  can  be  adapted  to  many  
installations  not  suited  for  traditional  modules  or  in  areas  where  glass-­‐based  
modules  are  simply  not  rugged  enough.    
 
Development  is  underway  on  various  forms  of  printed  solar  cells.  These  
technologies  are  generally  manufactured  using  roll-­‐to-­‐roll  processing  which  allows  
for  large  scale  rapid  production  at  extremely  low  cost.  Printed  thin-­‐films  can  be  
integrated  into  building  technologies  allowing  for  relatively  theft  proof  installations  
without  the  additional  costs  associated  with  traditional  solar  installations.    
 
The  decision  of  what  type  of  technology  is  appropriate  must  be  made  on  a  case  by  
case  basis  with  the  primary  influencing  factor  being  what  technology  is  widely  
available  at  the  time  of  installation.  Historically,  crystalline  modules  have  been  the  
most  commonly  imported  technology  in  Uganda  and  will  likely  be  the  solution  of  
choice  for  the  next  2  to  5  years.  It  should  be  noted  that  as  production  of  thin-­‐film  
and  roll-­‐to-­‐roll  printed  solar  cells  increases,  the  cost-­‐per-­‐Watt  of  this  technology  
should  dramatically  decrease.  Thin-­‐film  and  printed  modules  are  more  tolerant  of  
impact  and  resistant  to  damage  during  shipping  than  crystaline  modules,  which  
should  make  them  more  widely  available  in  the  coming  years.  It  is  likely  that  thin-­‐
film  technology  will  become  a  viable  replacement  in  the  mid  to  long  term  but  as  it  is  
not  currently  widely  available,  we  will  focus  on  crystalline  panels  for  the  duration  of  
this  document.  
 
 
II.  The  use  cases:  
   
Youth  Centers:  
Many  rural  communities  have  no  libraries  and  very  little  access  to  information.  The  
presence  of  computers  with  readily  available  reference  materials  and  educational  
programs  has  proven  to  have  a  significantly  positive  influence  on  children  and  
young  adult.  Not  only  does  having  information  available  to  them  encourage  learning,  
the  ability  of  young  people  to  familiarize  themselves  with  computers  will  give  them  
a  significant  advantage  later  on  in  life.    Another  key  element  is  the  provision  of  
lighting  to  facilitate  learning  and  safety  after  dark.  There  are  very  few  places  
accessible  to  youth  in  rural  communities  that  have  artificial  lighting  so  school  work  
cannot  be  done  after  sunset  which  competes  with  (and  is  usually  forsaken  for)  other  
tasks  such  as  water  collection  and  husbandry.  
 
Installation  recommendations  
 
1  Digital  Drum  unit  -­‐  to  act  as  both  server  and  client  access  point  (Power  
requirement:  60W  @  12VDC  for  1440Watt  hr/day  at  full  load  full  runtime)    
20  12W  fluorescent  type  LED  bulb  (Power  requirement:  240W  @  12VDC  for  total  of  
1440  Watt  hr/  day  at  6  hours  of  use  per  day  for  all  lights)  
 
This  gives  a  preliminary  requirement  of  ~3KW  hours  per  day  for  laptops  and  
lighting.    
 
6  pcs  130W  solar  panels  
4  pcs  12VDC  225  Ah  Gel  deep  cycle  batteries  
1  50  Amp  charge  controller    
Wire,  switches  and  circuit  breakers  as  needed  per  installation  and  safety  code  
requirements  
Mounting  brackets  and  hardware  as  needed  for  solar  panels  
 
 
Expected  solar  power  system  costs  (Preliminary  cost  estimate  based  on  most  recent  
information):  $8,000  
 
See  Appendix  A  for  notes  
 
 
Primary  Teacher  Colleges:    
Primary  Teacher  Colleges  (PTCs)  are  the  starting  point  for  Uganda's  future  
educators.  The  education  students  receive  in  their  PTC  will  set  the  stage  for  the  
education  of  thousands  of  Ugandan  children.  It  is  vital  that  the  students  following  
the  course  for  graduation  from  the  National  Teacher  Colleges  have  the  best  
foundation  of  knowledge  so  they  can  better  serve  as  educators  to  the  thousands  of  
children  that  will  pass  through  their  classrooms  later  in  life.  A  massive  jump  in  the  
quality  of  education  students  in  PTCs  receive  can  be  realized  by  simply  providing  
access  to  educational  materials  and  basic  lighting  for  students.  Most  PTCs  have  at  
least  limited  access  to  electricity  during  the  early  evening  but  could  benefit  from  
reliable  and  self-­‐sufficient  power  systems,  this  will  allow  PTC  students  to  extend  
their  learning  day  well  into  the  evening  and  provide  unprecedented  access  to  
information  in  even  the  most  remote  PTCs  in  Uganda.  
   
Installation  recommendations  
 
2  Digital  Drum  units  (1  unit  per  approximately  150  students)  -­‐  (Power  requirement:  
120W  @  12VDC  for  2,880Watt  hr/day  at  full  load  full  runtime)  
12  low-­‐cost  laptop  -­‐  to  be  used  in  computer  lab  (Power  requirement:  10W  @  12VDC  
/  ea.  for  total  of  1200Watt  hr/day  at  10hours  of  use  per  day  for  all  laptops)  
40  12W  fluorescent  type  LED  bulb  (Power  requirement:  480W  @  12VDC  for  total  of  
2880  Watt  hr/  day  at  6  hours  of  use  per  day  for  all  lights)  
 
Preliminary  power  requirement  is  ~7KW  hours  per  day.  The  Digital  Drums  for  this  
installation  should  be  fitted  with  mains  power  supplies  as  well  as  standard  solar  
systems  to  allow  for  reduced  solar  requirements.  
   
12  pcs  130W  solar  panels  
8  pcs  12VDC  225  Ah  Gel  deep  cycle  batteries  
1  50  Amp  charge  controller  
Wire,  switches  and  circuit  breakers  as  needed  per  installation  and  safety  code  
requirements  
Mounting  brackets  and  hardware  as  needed  for  solar  panels  
 
Expected  solar  power  system  costs  (Preliminary  cost  estimate  based  on  most  recent  
information):  ~$16,000.00  
 
See  Appendix  B  for  notes  
 
 
Maternity  clinic  in  a  rural  health  center  
In  Uganda,  UNICEF  supported  health  centers  consist  of  “type  2”  and  “type  3”  
designations.  Type  2  health  centers  are  smaller,  just  above  village  level  clinics.  They  
provide  basic  primary  care,  immunization,  natal  care  and  limited  normal  deliveries  
when  a  midwife  is  available.  Type  3  health  centers  provide  the  same  care  with  the  
addition  of  minor  surgery  and  caesarian  birth.    Both  facilities  suffer  from  lack  of  
consistent  power  supply  creating  limited  hours  of  available  care  and  difficulty  
during  emergency  procedures.    
 
Installation  recommendation  
 
6  12W  fluorescent  type  LED  bulb  (Power  requirement:  72W  @  12VDC  for  total  of  ~  
460  Watt  hr/  day  at  6  hours  of  use  per  day  for  all  lights)  
4  24W  LED  surgical  lights  (Power  requirement:  96W  @  12VDC  for  total  of  ~  400  
Watt  hr/day  at  4  hours  of  use  per  day)  
 
2  -­‐  60  Amp-­‐hour  SLA  or  Gel  deep  cycle  battery  
1  –  Phocos  CX10  10  A  charge  controller  
2  –  100  Watt  Solar  panel  
2  –  LED  headlamps  with  internal  rechargeable  battery  or  AAA  rechargeable  
batteries  
4  –  sets  batteries  for  LED  headlamps  and  12VDC  charging  station  
Wire  and  switches  as  needed  per  lighting  and  installation  requirements  
Mounting  brackets  and  hardware  as  needed  for  solar  panels  
 
Expected  system  costs  (Preliminary  cost  estimate  based  on  most  recent  
information):  ~$2,000.00  
 
see  Appendix  C  for  notes  

III.  Looking  forward:  


These  use  cases  outlines  should  serve  to  act  as  a  basic  template  for  sizing  and  
estimating  systems.  They  are,  however,  based  on  a  number  of  generalizations  and  
assumptions  and  will  likely  need  tailoring  to  specific  applications.  Every  scenario  is  
influenced  by  numerous  variables  that  are  far  beyond  the  scope  of  this  document  
but  this  should  serve  as  a  starting  point  for  estimating  power  solutions  in  rural  
Uganda  and  will  be  updated  with  real-­‐life  Use  cases,  solutions,  pricing,  systems  
sizing  and  outcomes  as  they  become  available.    
 
 
Notes:  
In  every  case,  solar  sizing  is  based  on  a  20%  overage  to  allow  for  battery  charge  
states  to  remain  over  50%  thus  prolonging  battery  lifespan.  All  price  estimates  for  
Digital  Drum  are  based  on  prototype  costs  and  are  likely  to  decrease.  Solar  system  
cost  estimates  are  based  on  competitive  bid  pricing  form  Kampala  circa  April  2010  
and  are  likely  to  fluctuate.  
 
Access  to  Information  and  Internet  Connectivity  Solutions  for  
Rural  Areas  
The  maxim  that  knowledge  is  power  has  never  been  truer  than  it  is  today.  In  the  
developed  world  we  have  a  virtually  unlimited  amount  of  information  available  
which  enables  us  to  make  much  better  and  more  informed  decisions  in  much  less  
time.  In  the  past,  critical  decisions  would  be  held  up  or  misdirected  by  a  lack  of  full  
information.  This  lack  of  timely  communication  can  result  in  anything  from  poor  
education  to  the  death  of  those  unfortunate  enough  to  be  on  the  wrong  side  of  the  
gap.    
 
UNICEF  is  exploring  how  greater  connectivity  can  facilitate  not  only  the  
dissemination  of  educational  materials  in  rural  Uganda  but  also  the  collection  of  
relevant  data  to  allow  a  more  streamlined  logistics  process.  Up-­‐to-­‐the  minute  
information  on  vital  indicators  will  allow  UNICEF  Uganda  to  divert  medication,  
supplies,  and  other  resources  to  areas  where  they  can  have  the  most  impact  to  those  
in  need.  The  first  step  in  this  process  will  be  the  introduction  of  self-­‐contained  solar-­‐
powered  "hub"  systems.  These  will  be  located  in  areas  such  as  Youth  centers,  Health  
centers  and  PTCs.  They  will  primarily  serve  the  purpose  of  dissemination  of  
educational  materials  but  will  also  serve  web-­‐based  applications  for  logistics  and  
supply  management  that  are  currently  being  developed  by  Uganda’s  T4D  team  as  
well  as  the  Innovation  section  in  New  York.    The  eventual  aim  is  to  have  a  two-­‐way  
communications  network  that  covers  the  most  under  served  areas  in  Uganda  and  
provides  a  conduit  for  educational,  safety  and  health  information  to  the  
communities  where  they  are  installed.  
There  are  three  basic  steps  to  the  rollout  of  this  type  of  infrastructure:    
1. Remote  stand-­‐alone  sites  with  limited  internet  connectivity  
2. Linking  remote  site  to  each  other  via  high-­‐speed  wireless  or  other  available  
technology  to  create  webs  of  sites  
3. Linking  the  webs  to  each  other  and  the  internet  as  a  whole  once  funding  and  
connectivity  options  allow  for  greater  bandwidth  
The  first  step  requires  that  content  and  applications  are  stored  locally  on  devices  
installed  in  remote  communities.  There  are  two  major  aspects  to  the  initial  phase  of  
this  process,  device  development  and  deployment  (hardware)  and  content  and  
interface  development  (software).  Development  of  the  hardware  is  well  under  way  
in  Uganda  with  projects  such  as  the  Digital  Doorway,  the  Community  Computing  
system  (Digital  Drum),  the  Rachel  Initiative,  Inveneo  and  others.    The  Community  
Computing  system  is  now  entering  it’s  third  round  of  development  and  will  be  
drawing  on  the  lessons  we  have  learned  to  overcome  some  of  the  last  remaining  
obstacles  relating  to  hardware  deployments  in  rural  areas.    
One  of  the  most  crucial  aspects  of  this  phase  of  development  is  the  cohesive  
collection  of  relevant  content  and  development  of  an  intuitive  and  easy  to  use  
interface  to  that  content.  This  will  require  the  active  participation  of  all  sections  and  
Ministries  that  intend  to  contribute  to  the  project.  Content  will  need  to  be  
standardized  into  a  format  that  is  not  only  truly  portable  and  accessible  across  all  
available  computing  platforms  today  but  also  free  from  the  encumbrances  of  
restrictive  licensing.  It  is  vital  to  the  success  of  this  phase  of  the  project  that  all  
content  can  be  distributed  through  any  available  channel  to  drive  interest  and  co-­‐
operation  from  as  many  parties  as  possible.    
During  the  initial  phases  of  the  rugged  computing  rollout,  it  is  to  be  expected  that  
some  if  not  all  sites  will  have  limited  to  no  Internet  access,  the  main  channel  for  
distribution  and  collection  of  data  will  therefore  have  to  rely  on  human-­‐based  data  
transportation.  Technicians  who  are  trained  to  maintain  the  machines  at  the  initial  
installation  sites  will  be  responsible  for  the  distribution  and  collection  of  data  via  
external  drives  which  will  than  be  collated  and  approved  at  the  central  update  
server  prior  to  being  distributed  to  the  remainder  of  the  network  on  subsequent  
visits.    

Once  stand-­‐alone  sites  have  been  established  in  central  areas,  it  will  be  possible  to  
link  nearby  areas  via  high-­‐speed  wireless  internet  solutions  as  have  been  
demonstrated  by  organizations  such  as  BOSCO  in  the  Acholi  region  (See  Annex  D).  
This  will  allow  many  sites  to  share  content  and  create  communications  channels  
between  currently  separated  facilities.    Internally  developed  curriculum  and  content  
collected  from  connected  sites  will  be  sharable  though  all  connected  facilities  
instantaneously.  Communities  can  be  developed  around  common  interests  and  
information  about  surrounding  areas  will  be  quickly  available  to  linked  installations.  
This  extending  of  the  networks  will  allow  schools,  PTCs  and  Community  Centers  
with  their  own  computer  labs  to  freely  access  the  content  and  communities  
established  around  the  Digital  Doorway  and  Community  Computing  sites.  
The  final  phase  of  this  project  will  be  the  interconnecting  of  the  phase  two  “webs”  
and  connecting  the  greater  networks  to  the  Internet  as  a  whole.  This  phase  will  
require  a  close  re-­‐evaluation  of  the  technology  available  and  the  overall  cost  to  
maintain.  It  is  hoped  that  interconnected  sites  would  be  able  to  share  the  cost  
burden  of  Internet  access  thus  lowering  the  overall  cost  to  connect  diverse  sites.  

 
Currently  available  technology  for  internet  connectivity  in  rural  Uganda:  

3g  /  GPRS  /  cellular  connectivity  –  this  technology  is  available  in  almost  all  parts  
of  Uganda.  Cellular  connectivity  is  relatively  inexpensive  but  does  not  have  the  
bandwidth  to  support  more  than  1  or  2  users  in  a  live  environment.    Speeds  vary  
from  14kbps  to  1300kbps  depending  on  provider,  infrastructure,  transmission  
technology  and  environmental  factors.  It  is  possible  to  allow  for  time-­‐delayed  
synchronizing  of  data  over  a  cellular  connection  and  it  is  being  considered  as  a  
management  and  maintenance  channel  for  the  initial  ruggedized  computing  
systems.  Cellular  connectivity  tends  to  be  billed  on  a  “total  traffic  per  month  basis”  
where  inbound  and  outbound  bandwidth  is  aggregated  and  a  set  limit  is  imposed  on  
devices.  As  of  August  2010,  3G  cellular  connectivity  in  Uganda  at  the  rate  of  3GB  
transferred  per  month  is  85,000  /=  (UGX)(1)(2),  EDGE/GPRS  64kbps  unlimited  
transfer  plans  are  available  from  UTL  for  220,000  /=  (UGX)(3)  and  Zain  for  
200,000/=  (UGX)(4).  
VSAT  –  this  technology  is  available  at  virtually  any  rural  location.  It  is  more  
expensive  than  cellular  connectivity  but  can  provide  much  greater  bandwidth.    Due  
to  it’s  high  latency,  VSAT  connectivity  is  not  recommended  for  environments  where  
VoIP  or  similar  live  audio  /  video  conferencing  applications  will  be  required.  Low  
cost  VSAT  solutions  tend  to  have  a  much  higher  download  bandwidth  than  upload  
bandwidth,  this  would  allow  for  relatively  fast  deployment  of  data  and  content  but  a  
relatively  slow  path  for  collection  of  data.  Most  low  cost  VSAT  systems  operate  on  a  
bandwidth-­‐sharing  basis  where  actual  available  bandwidth  will  fluctuate  based  on  
total  number  of  users  on  a  provider’s  network  (usually  referred  to  as  a  “shared  
contention  ratio”).  VSAT  startup  costs  are  usually  fairly  high  in  comparison  to  other  
connectivity  solutions  with  average  equipment  costs  exceeding  $2000.00  (USD).  As  
of  August  2010,  VSAT  from  Intersat  Africa  is  available  at    $550  (USD)  /  mo.  For  
128kbps  uplink  and  384kbps  downlink(5)  and  $350  (USD)  for  a  64kbps  uplink  
256kbps  downlink(6)  both  at  1:16  shared  contention  ratio.    
DSL  –  this  technology  is  starting  to  become  more  available  in  rural  locations  but  is  
usually  limited  to  relatively  short  distances  from  population  centers  (5-­‐10Km  from  
telephone  “Central  Offices”).  DSL  can  provide  symmetric  or  asymmetric  bandwidth  
and  is  generally  sold  as  an  unlimited  bandwidth  product.  DSL  is  a  fairly  stable  
product  but  can  be  affected  by  mains  outages  and  is  vulnerable  to  outages  due  to  
failures  in  the  carrier  telephone  cabling  it  travels  on.  DSL  startup  costs  are  fairly  low  
but  monthly  costs  can  increase  dramatically  beyond  256kbps.  Most  low-­‐cost  DSL  
services  use  a  sharing  contention  scheme  similar  to  VSAT,  no  numbers  are  currently  
available  detailing  contention.  Current  pricing  for  shared  bandwidth  through  UTL  as  
of  August  2010(7)  is:  64kbps  -­‐  $100  (USD)/mo.  ;  128kbps  -­‐  $180  (USD)  /  mo.  ;  
256kbps  –  $310  (USD)/month.  Pricing  for  dedicated  bandwidth  from  UTL  as  of  June  
2010  in  the  Gulu  area  is:  512kbps  symmetric  ~  $350-­‐$425/mo.;  768kbps  ~  $575-­‐
$675/mo.  Both  require  ~$3200  (USD)  startup  costs  in  equipment  and  installation.  
WiMax  –  WiMax  is  a  relatively  new  wireless  technology  that  operates  on  line-­‐of-­‐site  
at  high  speed  and  non-­‐line-­‐of-­‐site  at  lower  speeds.  Pricing  of  WiMax  is  generally  
similar  to  DSL  but  front-­‐end  equipment  costs  can  be  considerably  higher.  WiMax  is  a  
fairly  stable  technology  but  is  susceptible  to  radio  and  environmental  interference.  
It  is  expected  that  WiMax  will  likely  supplant  DSL  as  a  more  rural  connectivity  
option  due  to  lower  deployment  costs  for  the  provider.  Pricing  for  Wimax  solutions  
is  not  currently  available  but  will  be  appended  upon  receipt.  
 
 

 
Notes  regarding  connectivity  solutions:  
Any  of  these  connectivity  solutions  may  be  extended  via  802.11  wireless  over  100s  
of  Kilometers  to  join  more  installations.  The  major  benefit  of  this  option  is  overall  
higher  bandwidth  and  lower  expense  for  connected  facilities.    When  sharing  a  single  
point  of  connectivity  between  multiple  sites,  it  should  be  expected  that  at  times  
there  will  be  contention  for  bandwidth.  QOS,  conservative  firewall  rules  at  gateways,  
liberal  gateway  proxy  caching  and  vigilant  network  administration  are  all  methods  
that  can  be  used  to  counter  this  effect.  
Pricing:  

1. http://orange.ug/mobile-­plans/internet-­everywhere.php  
2. http://mtn.co.ug/MTN-­Internet/MTN-­Mobile-­Internet.aspx  
3. http://utl.co.ug/utl.php?i=124  
4. http://www.ug.zain.com/opco/af/core/home/channel.do;jsessionid=3
9EB09F5FE7D0B242DC16D0A0E38F1DE.node14?channelId=-­
10682&selectedChannels=-­10556,-­10682#&lang=en  
5. http://www.intersatafrica.com/index-­‐products3.html  
6. http://www.intersatafrica.com/index-­‐products2.html  
7. http://utl.co.ug/utl.php?i=9  
 
 
Appendix  A  (Youth  Center  Solar  Power  Use  Case)  
The  lighting  specified  for  this  use  case  should  be  sufficient  to  provide  illumination  to  
read  for  a  single  100  square  meter  space.  It  is  expected  that  the  Digital  Drum  should  
operate  continuously  in  this  environment  and  be  reachable  at  all  times  via  network  
access  but  only  physically  accessible  during  the  normal  operating  hours  of  the  Youth  
Center.  
Recommendations  are  based  on  the  following  conditions:  

The  youth  center  has  no  existing  mains  power  


The  public  space  will  be  lit  for  a  maximum  of  6  hours  per  day  and  is  100  square  
meters  
 
Appendix  B  (PTC  Solar  Power  Use  Case)  
40  lights  should  be  enough  to  provide  sufficient  illumination  to  read  for  200  square  
meters  of  space,  if  this  space  is  divided  into  multiple  areas,  the  overall  illumination  
will  decrease.  I  am  operating  on  the  assumption  that  it  is  safe  to  divide  the  200  
square  meters  into  two  spaces  before  more  supplemental  lighting  will  need  to  be  
provided  but  this  should  be  tested  in  actual  use  cases  before  it  is  committed  to.  The  
solar  system  specified  in  this  use  case  is  not  intended  to  provide  power  for  the  PTC  
in  the  absence  of  available  mains  power,  it  is  merely  intended  to  supplement  
unreliable  mains  supplies  for  lighting  and  the  overall  accessibility  of  mains  power  is  
a  necessity  for  this  system  to  function  correctly.  

Recommendations  are  based  on  the  following  conditions:  


PTC  has  limited  access  to  mains  power  for  at  least  3  hours  per  day  
PTC  has  a  lockable  room  that  can  be  dedicated  to  act  as  a  computer  lab  and  someone  
will  be  monitoring  the  lab  when  access  is  allowed  
PTC  has  a  student  population  of  approximately  300  who  all  live  on-­‐site  in  dorms  
PTC  has  requirements  for  lighting  in  public  spaces  such  as  libraries,  classrooms  and  
dorms  
 
Appendix  C  (Health  Center  Solar  Power  Use  Case)  
Recommendations  are  based  on  the  following  conditions:  
Health  Center  has  no  mains  power  
Health  Center  has  a  secure  area  where  batteries  and  charge  controller  and  
headlamp  battery  chargers  can  be  installed  
Health  Center  has  a  secure  location  for  headlamps  to  be  stored  when  not  in  use  
 
 
     
Annex  D:  BOSCO  bandwidth  distribution  model  
 
BOSCO  is  an  NGO  that  has  been  operating  a  rural  wireless  network  in  the  Acholi  
region  of  Uganda  for  the  past  four  years  based  around  the  concept  of  sharing  a  
single  connection  to  the  internet  with  a  number  of  disparate  sites  linked  by  low-­‐
power  wireless  networks.    Over  the  course  of  the  past  year,  the  number  of  users  
being  served  by  BOSCO’s  network  has  more  than  doubled  from  485  to  the  current  of  
approximately  960  (with  total  number  of  users  doubling  in  the  last  year.  Over  the  
same  period  of  time,  BOSCO’s  internet  egress  has  only  increased  from  256kbps  to  
512kbps.    While  the  overall  results  of  BOSCO’s  network  have  been  overwhelmingly  
positive,  the  capacity  of  the  network  has  been  overshadowed  by  its  users’  demands.    
BOSCO  estimates  that  to  supply  their  current  user  load  they  will  need  to  increase  
egress  bandwidth  to  1Mbps.  
 
 The  pricing  model  of  Uganda’s  DSL  providers  favors  the  low-­‐end  and  shared  line  
user.  In  an  effort  to  maximize  return  from  their  fixed  operating  costs,  UTL  resells  
their  available  bandwidth  many  times  over  and  offers  it  to  consumers  as  a  ‘shared  
line’  DSL  connection  with  a  maximum  bandwidth  of  512kbps.  These  connections  are  
considerably  less  expensive  than  a  DSL  connection  that  has  a  fixed,  dedicated  
bandwidth  and  a  majority  of  the  time  the  end  user  is  unaware  or  unaffected  by  the  
nature  of  sharing  overall  bandwidth.  Once  the  number  of  users  on  a  connection  
increases  beyond  a  certain  point,  the  shared  connection  can  no  longer  support  the  
demands  and  the  connection  must  be  upgraded  to  a  “dedicated  bandwidth”  line,  
which  can  be  provisioned  for  up  to  1.5Mbps.    
 
   Throughout  it’s  history,  BOSCO  has  distributed  the  cost  of  internet  connectivity  to  
it’s  25  installed  sites.  The  pricing  difference  between  dedicated  lines  and  shared  
lines  creates  a  gap  in  the  ability  of  the  users  on  a  BOSCO  style  network  to  pay  for  the  
connection.    Currently  BOSCO  pays  approximately  $300  USD/mo.  for  internet  
access,  increasing  available  bandwidth  to  1Mbps  will  increase  monthly  cost  to  
~$800  USD.  This  presents  a  financial  dilemma  for  the  hosting  organization.  
Traditionally  this  bourdon  would  be  solved  by  increasing  the  monthly  contributions  
of  the  users.  Some  of  the  organizations  that  BOSCO  provides  bandwidth  to  cannot  
afford  the  added  expense  and  would  likely  drop  out  of  the  program  altogether  if  
presented  with  this  increase,  thus  increasing  the  financial  load  on  BOSCO  and  it’s  
networks  users.  
 
Subsidy  of  internet  access  until  the  network  is  extended  to  the  point  that  the  overall  
cost  to  users  is  the  same  as  it’s  current  rate  of  approximately  $0.32USD  /  user  would  
require  about  2500  users  to  distribute  the  financial  load  and  would  quickly  create  
the  same  disparity.    An  alternative  solution  would  be  to  install  additional  egress  
points  and  provide  distributed  access  for  the  network  depending  on  overall  
bandwidth  availability  at  egress  points.  This  combined  with  aggressive  caching  and  
distributed  cache  storage  on  the  network  would  allow  for  slow  growth  of  the  
network  without  undue  economic  constraints  on  it’s  users.    
Internet

Cellular connectivity

VSAT

802.11
Wireless link

Gateway Site

Youth Center

PTC

Health Center

Community Center

Traditional distribution model has one egress point and distributes


to all sites along a relatively linear path
Internet

Cellular connectivity

Internet

Gateway Site
VSAT with load balancing
and caching proxy
802.11
Wireless link

Gateway Site
with load balancing
and caching proxy

Youth Center

Community Center PTC

Health Center

Distributed connectivity allows for load balancing across connections as well as maintaining
a cache of requests to accelerate browsing at all egress points
Update Server

Content is delivered via


external drive from
Update Server to remote
sites during routine maintenance

Youth Center

School

Content propagates to additional


machines over 802.11 links 802.11
Wireless link

802.11
Wireless link
802.11
Wireless link
PTC

802.11
Wireless link

Health Center

Community Center

Technician-based data distribution for installations with no internet connectivity


Update Server

Content is collected via external drive


from remote sites and delivered to
Content Server during routine maintenance

Youth Center

School

Content propagates from additional


machines over 802.11 links 802.11
Wireless link

802.11
Wireless link
802.11
Wireless link
PTC

Health Center
802.11
Wireless link

Community Center

Users generate content at remote sites

Technician-based data collection for installations with no internet connectivity


External contributor
Update Server

Internet

Cellular Modem
VSAT

Main (Gateway) Drum installation


Stores locally available content and
serves to connected facilities

802.11
Wireless link

802.11
Wireless link
802.11
Wireless link
PTC

802.11
Wireless link

Health Center

Community Center

When Internet connectivity is provided,data collection


and distribution are handled automatically
20 week drum production timeline
SEPTEMBER OCTOBER NOVEMBER DECEMBER JANUARY FEBRUARY
week 1 week 2 week 3 week 4 week 5 week 6 week 7 week 8 week 9 week 10 week 12 week 13 week 14 week 15 week 16 week 17 week 18 week 19 week 20
define weeknesses in
define weeknesses in current current design and
Drum hardware design and engineer solutions engineer solutions for
development for next iteration build and document limited number of prototypes (4-5 units) deploy and field testlimited deployment (4-5 units) next iteration Build and document large scale deployment (25-50 units)

Note: This timeline is dependant on all materials and equipment being available
at the start of production cycle (week2 and week 16). Any delays in
procurement or delivery of components will cause a similar delay in production.
General configuration of second revision Digital Drum prototype
Electrical and network system block diagram

Batteries Charge Controller Solar Panels

12V DC Power

Voltage and Amperage sensors

USB or Serial Communication Microcontroller Relay controls

Backhaul wireless Switched Power


5Ghz 802.11a

100 Mbps Ethernet

Gateway Computer with


cellular modem

Secondary Computer Relays

100 Mbps Ethernet


!00 Mbps Ethernet switch

Local wireless
2.4Ghz 802.11b/g

2 USB connectors
for handset charging
Power control and sensor schematic for Digital Drum

+12V
1K VR 8.2K
Hall Effect v+
- LM324 Arduino analog in
Sensor
+
v- Arduino GND
100K Pot

Sensor Schematic for battery voltage monitoring and load current monitoring

Voltage
spike
protection

Load

Driver
circuit

Arduino Digital I/O

Arduino ground
Grayhill 70-ODC5

Relay schematic for controlling loads


Basic Solar powered "Digital Drum" installation with local and long-distance wireless
links, fully self-contained power

Rugged community computer (as we are focusing on the components, I will not
estimate the cost of the shell of this unit)

2 pcs OIT LITE vandal-resistant keyboards with P.O.M. keys & integrated touchpad (1)
2 pcs WinMate R15I93S-OFA2 Panel PC - (2)
1 pc GSM/GPRS/HSDPA cellular modem (usb with external antenna) Such as ZadaCOM
3G+ 7.2 (3)
1 pcs B&B Electronics EIR205 5 port ethernet switch (4) or Garrettcom S14H-12VDC
Ethernet switch (5)
1 pc Arduino Duemilanove microcontroller (6)
1 pc Arduino Ethernet shield (7)
2 pcs Bulgin PX0839/IDC IP68 Ethernet connectors (8)
2 pcs Bulgin PX0845/A IP68 USB connectors (9)
4 pcs Bulgin PX0713 Caps for IP68 connectors (10)

Wireless equipment

1 pc Ubiquiti Bullet 2HP (11)


1 pc 7 dbi omni directional antenna w/ Female N connector (12)
1 pc Ubiquiti Bullet M5 (13)
1 pc 29dbi parabolic antenna w/ female N connector (14)

Solar system

Phocos CX20 Charge controller (15)


3 pcs ~125 W solar modules (or equivalent 350W+) (16)
4 pcs 31.6Ah 12V Gel (maintenance-free) deep cycle batteries (Deka 8GU1-DEKA or
equivalent 125Ah+) (17)

Misc components

4 pcs 30V 3A schottky diodes - ST Microelectronics 1N5821 or similar (18)


20 meters 24 gauge solid copper cat5e or cat6 (19)
20 meters 10 gauge (3.25mm - 3.5mm) two conductor copper power leads for solar
system (20)

32 Amp 2 pole 12-24VDC DIN rail-mount circuit breaker - CHINT NB1-B32-2P or


equivalent (21)
5 pcs MAX232 (22)
1 pc Arduino Screw Shield (23)
1 meter DIN rail (35mm standard height) (24)
4 Pcs 3-60VDC 3.5A solid state relay - Grayhill 70-ODC5 or equivilent (25)

(1) http://www.oitkeypad.com/pdf/QVPPlastickeyfront.pdf
(2) http://www.winmate.com.tw/PanelPc/
PPcSpec.asp?Prod=03_0581&Typeid=B0108010901&Typeid=B0108010901
(3) http://shop.zadako.com/hsdpa_3g_modemy/usb/zadacom_3g_plus_7.2.html
(4) http://www.bb-elec.com/
product_multi_family.asp?MultiFamilyId=68&TrailType=Sub&Trail=4
(5) http://www.garrettcom.com/s14.htm
(6) http://arduino.cc/en/Main/ArduinoBoardDuemilanove
(7) http://www.sparkfun.com/commerce/product_info.php?products_id=9026
(8) http://www.bulgin.co.uk/Products/Buccaneer/Buccaneer_Ethernet.html
(9) http://www.bulgin.co.uk/Products/Buccaneer/Buccaneer_USB.html
(10) http://www.bulgin.co.uk/Products/Buccaneer/Buccaneer.html
(11) http://ubnt.com/bullet
(12) http://lairdtech.thomasnet.com/item/ice-provider-wisp-base-station-and-client-
antennas/omnidirectional-antennas/od24-9?&seo=110
(13) http://ubnt.com/bulletm
(14) http://www.mtiwe.com/uploads/product/485.pdf
(15) http://www.phocos.com/datasheet_sm_cx.html
(16) http://www.bp.com/
sectiongenericarticle.do?categoryId=9019638&contentId=7036951
(17) http://www.eastpenn-deka.com/default.aspx?pageid=443
(18) http://mouser.com/ProductDetail/STMicroelectronics/1N5821/
?qs=sGAEpiMZZMutXGli8Ay4kOnWbBYZueaHA8JfCq5pWm4%3d
(19) locally sourced
(20) locally sourced
(21) http://www.bb-elec.com/bb-elec/literature/NB1-63_CircuitBreakers.pdf
(22) need to speak to J-M about exact part numbers for this
(23) http://www.sparkfun.com/commerce/product_info.php?products_id=9282
(24) http://www.bb-elec.com/bb-elec/literature/ers35.pdf
(25) http://search.digikey.com/scripts/DkSearch/dksus.dll?Detail&name=GH7019-ND

Costs:
1. $200/ea - $400
2. $1,150/ea - $2,300 (includes $800/ea base price and $350/ea shipping to
Uganda)
3. $215
4. $89
5. $100
6. $45
7. $50
8. $20/ea - $40
9. $10/ea - $20
10. $6/ea - $24
11. $80
12. $60
13. $80
14. $80
15. $100
16. $650/ea - $1950
17. $100/ea - $400
18. $0.50/ea - $2
19. $
20. $
21. $15
22. $
23. $15
24. $10
25. $10/ea - $40
Other Potential Keyboard vendors:
Key Tek K-TEK-B420TP http://www.key-tek.cn/en/productsview.asp?id=174
iKey PMU-5K-TP2 http://www.ikey.com/ProductsList/
index.aspx?productID=45&menu=1&prodListID=2&

Potrebbero piacerti anche