Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
ControversiesandConclusions
PatrickDuerr
History210
Prof.T.Mays
4/26/16
Therainsfellonthemarshlandatthefootofthegreathillastheyhadforweeks,carrying
awaywhatpoorharvesttheunseasonalcoldhadgranted,whiledesperationandhungerrandeep
amongstthevillage.Akingonceglorious,nowfedonchaff,nakedforallbutanarmbandoffox
furandanoosebywhichhewasleddownthewickertrackwaytothecenterofthebog,where
thewaterwasdeepest.Theentirevillagefollowedastheyhaltedatthewatersedge.Themanby
hissideraisedtheclubhighandbroughtitcrashingintothelegofthegreatking,forcinghimto
kneel.Hedidnotfightashisheadwastiltedbackandtheknifelowered,theknifewhichcuthim
fromeartoear.Arubymessageofpropitiationsprayedthepoolasthegarrotingcorddrewtight.
Theheadoncegracedbyacrown,nowgracedbyaclubsblow,andhefell,atlonglast,forward
intothebog.Thethreefolddeathcomplete,thepunishmentwascarriedout.Afailedhusband,
thegodsofthelandwerenotpleasedbyhisreign,butperhapshispunishmentsatedthespiritof
thefamine.
Accusationofhumansacrifice,eveninprehistoriccontexts,isasensitivetopicformany
differentpeopleacrossmanydifferentcultures,rangingfromCentralAmericatoScandinavia.
ThesurvivingCelticculturesoftodayarenoexception,andrecentdevelopmentsontheissue
stillreverberateinnewsheadlinestopresent.Forcenturies,fewhavetrulyquestionedthe
indictmentbyancientMediterraneanauthorsofhumansacrificethroughoutthenortherlyCeltic
regions.Today,theissuehasgrownmorecomplexanddrawsmoreandmoreattentionasthe
recorddevelops.Modernscholars,drawingfromprimarysourcematerialofboththeliteraryand
archaeologicalrecords,havediscoveredthatthesubjectofsacrificeamongtheCeltsisfarmore
complexthansimplemurder,andindeed,mostcasesmorecloselyresemblecapitalpunishment.
Inordertotrulyunderstandtheancientpastofthediversepeoplegroupunderthelabelof
3
Celtic,onemustdrawfrommultiplesourcesinordertogainamorewholesome,accurate,and
helpfulperspective,answeringthewhy?behindthesacrificeand/orexecutionofselect
individualsbyancientCeltictribes.
ThehistoriographyandpoliticalsignificanceoftheancientCelticpeoplegroupsisa
murkytopic,withinterestinancientWesternrootsgrowingwiththenationalistsentimentsofthe
earlymodernera.AuthorSamSmilesdealswithaprominentviewonthetopicinhisdayas
beingheavilyromanticized,withnationsdevelopingpersonalizedimagesofanoblepast,andthe
constructedperspectiveofantiquarianismsayingmoreaboutthemodernerathanaboutthe
ancientinhabitantsofCelticBritain.1 AnothercontenderthroughoutthefieldistheNeoclassical
andEnlightenmentstyledisdainforthesavageinhabitantsofthepastandtheirsacrificial
practices,retractingfromtheirlinearideaofthehistoryofcivilizedprogress.Smilesdoesan
exceptionaljobofseparatingallopposingperspectivesfromthecorehistoricalevidenceand
whatitsaysforitselfthroughthedevelopingfieldofprofessionalandobjectivearchaeology,as
wellasdistinguishingthetwomajorvoicesinCeltichistory,andthusonthedebatesregarding
thesacrificeofhumanbeings.
ThemainsourceforthehistoryoftheancientCeltsandtheirsacrificialritesarethe
ancientGreekandRomanauthors.ClassicalcitationsfortheCelticreverenceforhuman
sacrificegobacktosomeoftheearliestsurvivingrecordsontheCelts,suggestingthat,ifthe
evidenceissolid,itwasacommonenoughconcerntobewidelyknownthroughouttheClassical
world,andthatitwasstartlingtotheoutsiderswhobeheldit.PhilipFreemancitesareferenceby
theRomanpoetSopaterastheearliestmentionofCelticreligionaroundthelatefourthcentury
SamSmiles,
1
TheImageofAntiquity:AncientBritainandtheRomanticImagination,
(London:Yale
UniversityPress,1994),12.
4
B.C.,alludingtothepracticeofsacrificingprisonersofwartothegodsaftergreatvictories.2
AnotherearlyreferenceismadebyEudoxusofRhodesinthethirdcenturyB.C.,whichnotes
thattheCeltsheldcapitalpunishmentforinfractionsofthesacred,supposedlyinpropitiationfor
theircrimessothattherestofthetribewouldnotbepunished.3
AuthorandscholarJ.A,MacCullochinterpretedthemanyRomanaccountsofsacrificial
ritesbytheirrespectivemotives:propitiatorytowardoffdiseaseoraffliction,ontheprincipleof
alifeforalife,inthanksgivingforsuchmattersasvictoryinbattle,orinordertodivinethe
futureduringuncertaintimes.4CaesarandMacCullochagreethatmostevidencepointstotheuse
ofcriminals,slaves,orcaptivesasthesacrificialvictims.This,then,raisesquestionsregarding
thenatureofthesacrificialrites.RomansandGreekswerecertainlyfamiliarwiththeirown
versionsofsacrifice,andhistorianGrahamWebsternotesthat,thoughtheRomanswereas
ruthlessasanyofthetimetowardsanimals,theyconsideredhumansacrificeunacceptable.Yet,
apracticeofthrowingeffigiesofmenintotheTiberontheIdesofMaystrikessomehistorians
asadescendantofhumansacrifice.5Nevertheless,themeaningtheyascribetotheproceedings
maynotnecessarilyfittheCelticattitudetowardshumansassacrifices.Anextraneousexample,
aRomanauthorwitnessinganexecutionbyhanginginthe19thcenturyAmericanWestmight
observethepresenceofclergyortheadministeringoflastrightsaspartsofaritualizedhuman
sacrificeifheknewlittleoftheinnerworkingsoftheculture.
Thediscerninghistorianeasilycallsintoquestionthemotivesofimperialistssuchas
JuliusCaesarifoneacknowledgesthathewouldhavebeentryingtorallysupportfromRomeby
2
PhilipFreeman,War,Women,andDruids:EyewitnessReportsandEarlyAccountsoftheAncient
Celts,(Austin,UniversityofTexasPress),3334.
3
Freeman,35.
4
J.A.MacCulloch,TheReligionoftheAncientCelts,
(Edinburgh:T.&T.Clark,1911),233237.
5
GrahamWebster, CelticReligioninRomanBritain,
(Totowa:BarnesandNobleBooks,1987),36.
5
perhapspaintingthenortherntribesasmorebarbaricthanwasquitehonest.Wheretheclassical
authorsenjoyedpaintingtheCelticandGermanicterritoriesaspathlesswilderness,themodern
scholarfindsthatdiscoveriesofroads,welldevelopedsettlements,andwellmanaged
agriculturalsystemstelladifferentstoryentirely.Romanaccountsofreligiousproceedingsmay
betaintednotonlybybias,butalsobyignoranceandcreativelyfillinginthegaps.TheDruidic
traditionwaswellknownamongsttheClassicalauthorsasbeingsecretiveandexclusive,and
presenceatreligiousritesseemstobeacommunalmatter,asnotedbyCaesaronthewoesof
beingbannedfromsacrificialrituals.6Further,manyclassicalauthors,especiallywhenwritingof
religiousactivitiesoftheCelts,areconsiderednottohavebeenwritingfirsthandaccounts,but
citingtherecollectionsofothers,andoftenpreviousauthorsonthetopic.Thedangersof
generalizationoftheCelticpeoplesfromtheeventswhichtheRomansmayhavebeenwitnessto
arealsoapparent.Suchclaimsofambiguousdocumentationofreligiousritesamongtheancient
CeltshavebeenusedagainsttheClassicalauthorsfordecadesnow,andmanypeopleturntothe
archaeologicalrecordorotherliterarysourcesforanswers.Thankfully,theserecordshavebeen
farmoreenlightening.
Asthefieldhasdevelopedoverthepasttwocenturies,archaeologyhasgivenhistorians
muchtoconsiderregardingtheancientCelts,andattheforeoftheissuestoberevisedarethe
ideasofhumansacrifice.Whereallhadbeenspeculationbefore,preservedbodiesrecovered
fromthepeatbogswhichcandatebackasfarasapproximately2000B.C.allowhistoriansto
crossreferenceandgetadeeperideaofthecontext.Especiallyfascinatingarethoseconcretely
heldasvictimsofhumansacrifice.Archaeologistshavedeterminedthisthroughtheunusual
6
EverydayLifeofthePaganCelts,
AnneRoss, (NewYork:G.P.PutnamsSons,1970.)132.
6
circumstancesoftheirdeathandtheplacesinwhichthebodieshavebeenfound,rangingfrom
thedetailsoftheirlastmeal,theindicatorsoftheirsocialstatus,andthemanneroftheirdeath.It
isthelatterofthesefactorsthatisthemainindicatorforhistorianssuchasNedKelly,whonotes
inarecentarticlethattheuseofexcessiveviolence,isastrongsuggestionofritualkilling,
especiallyasarepeatingfactorinmultiplebogbodies.KellynotesthebodyoftheOldCroghan
Man,abogbodynamedforthelocationofhisdiscovery,asoneexample,havinghadholescut
inhisupperarmsthroughwhicharopewaspulledthroughinordertorestrainhim.Hewas
stabbedrepeatedlyandhehadhisnipplesslicedbeforehewasfinallycutinhalf.Anotherbody,
theClonycavanMan,wasdisemboweledandstruckthreetimesacrosstheheadwithanaxeand
onceacrossthebodyandalsohadhisnipplescut.7Commonthemessuchasthecuttingofthe
nipples,whichwerealsonotedbyKellyasbeingsymbolicallyassociatedwithkingshipin
ancientIreland,makeastrongcasethatthesebodiesareevidenceofhumansacrifice,yetthe
contextisstillinvestigatedbyarchaeologistsandhistorianswhohaveaferventdesireto
understandexactlywhythesemendied.
RecentstudiesincludedintheBBCdocumentary
4,000YearOldColdCase:TheBodyin
theBog
(aired2013)revealnotonlythattheancientliteratureofIrelandbackstherunning
theoriesregardingkillingaspunishmentforafailedking,butthatparallelscanbedrawn
betweenachangingclimateandtheappearanceofbogsacrifices.Kellyappearsagaintocite
ancientIrishliteraturewhichmentionsthemultiplemethodsusedinexecutinganIrishkingatop
asacredhill,aswellasthelongstandingtraditionofIrishkingsbeingceremoniallymarriedto
theland.Further,aroundtheinterchangeoftheBronzeandIronAges,Europesclimategrew
7
IrishCentral
JamesOShea,BogBodiesareKingsSacrificedbyCelts,SaysExpert, ,n.d..
http://www.irishcentral.com/news/bogbodiesarekingssacrificedbyceltssaysexpert1292895482374101
31.html(accessedApril10,2016)
7
colderandwetterthanbefore,whichwouldhavebeendetrimentaltoagricultureacrossCeltic
territories.Ifthesewellgroomedmenwithmarksofritualkillinghadindeedbeenkings,
historiansnotethedirectresponsibilityofIrishkingsforthelandsproductivitythroughthe
inauguralceremony,involvingmarriagetotheland.Thus,iftheweatherandcropsturnedforthe
poorer,itislikelythattheresponsibilityforthesefailingswouldbeheldagainsttheking.The
burialproximitytoancientinauguralsitesbacksthisideainsuchmindsasKellys.Thisseemsto
blendcapitalpunishmentandhumansacrifice,ifindeedthevictimswerecondemnedbythelaws
oftheirsociety.HistorianMirandaAldhouseGreenremarksthatthefateoftheIrishbogbodies
arereminiscentofthedescriptionsofcapitalpunishmentbyTacitusinhisobservationsofthe
northerntribes.Theseincludedtheweightingdownofcowardsanddisreputableofbodyin
marshes.8GreenagainquotesTacitustowarnagainsthastilyascribingevidenceofviolenceto
Germania
humansacrifice,asTacituswritesinthe thatcapitalpunishment,imprisonment,and
evenfloggingareallowedtononebutthepriests,andarenotinflictedmerelyaspunishmentsor
ontheleadersorders,butinobediencetothegodwhomtheybelievetopresideoverbattle.9
TheCelticattitudetowardsdeathasevidencedinothersourcescontributesmuchtotheir
trialforhumansacrifice.TheancientCeltsasobservedbytheGreeksandtheRomanswere
famousforfearlessnessinbattle,anditisthisattributewhichmadethempopularmercenaries
andterrifyingadversaries.TheGreekpoetNicanderisquotedbyTertullianassayingthatthe
Celtsbelievebecauseofvisionsindreamsthatthedeadtrulylive,andbecauseofthistheywill
spendthenightnearthetombsoftheirfamousmen.10 DiodorusSiculus,anotherGreek
8
CaesarsDruids:StoryofanAncientPriesthood,
MirandaAldhouseGreen, (London:YaleUniversity
Press,2010),74.
9
AldhouseGreen,74.
10
Freeman,35.
8
historian,notedthatteachingsimilartothoseofPythagorasweretaughtamongstthetribesof
Gaul,andthusthattheybelieveinreincarnation,ortherebirthofsoulsintoanewbodyafter
death.Hefurthernotesthepracticeofburningmessagesforthedeadonfuneralpyres.11
TheancientCelticattitudetowardsthedeadwasneverambiguousabouttheideaofan
afterlife.Countlessgravesandburialchambershaveyieldedrichandelaborategravegoods:
giftstothosewhopassedonwhichtheywouldrequireinthenextlife.Anotherrecentdiscovery
byarchaeologistsnearmoderndayYorkshirehasintriguedhistoriansoftheancientCeltsfor
multiplereasons.12 Theuncoveringofapproximately150skeletonsin75gravesdatingtothe
Britishironageissignificantenough,but23oftheseskeletonsrevealremarkablecircumstances
regardingtheCelticattitudetowardsdeathandhighstatusindividuals.Eachofthe23,most
likelyfallenwarriors,hadmultiplespearsthrownatthem,piercingtheircorpsespriortoburial.
Speculationreignsastowhetherthiswasafinalsalute,orinsuranceagainstthemrisingfromthe
dead,orperhapsaproceduretofreetheirspiritfromthecorpsepostburialrites.
EvershockingandabhorrenttotheauthorsofRomewasthesacrificeofprisoners
amongsttheCelts,whoallegedlynevertookransomfortheircapturedinwar.Oneofthemajor
sourcesbackingthisisSopatersearlyreferencetotheGauls,mentionedabove.13 Asthetopicof
capitalpunishmentandtheactofcowardicehavebeenmentioned,onemustagainconsiderthem
inanewlight.TheCeltsviewedcowardiceandsurrenderastheultimatedishonor,and
potentiallyasaninsulttothegodspresidingoverwar.Therefore,thosewhohadsurrendered
11
Freeman,37.
12
PeterHalkon,BonesofIronAgewarriorsmayreveallinkbetweenYorkshiresspearpeopleandthe
ancientGauls,HeritageDaily
,March182016.
http://theconversation.com/bonesofironagewarriorsmayreveallinkbetweenyorkshiresspearpeoplean
dtheancientgauls56458(accessedApril10,2016)
13
Freeman,34.
9
wereperhapsconsideredforfeitoftheirlives.Thetruenatureofthisactisdebatable,andthe
slaughterofprisonersofwarwasnotunknownelsewhereintheancientworld.Giventhat
cowardicewaspunishablebydeath,theirtreatmentofprisonersassacrificestoappeasethegods
maybeseenaspunishmentforaninfractionagainstsaidgods.TheauthorAlainDeyber,a
specialistinGallicmilitaryhistory,notesthatforcertainmeetingsofwar,theGaulswould
sacrificethelasttoarrive.14WeseeinthistherigidlymartialcultureoftheCelticpeoples.
CaesarwasextremelydescriptiveoftheGaulsfromafirsthandperspective,unlikeotherRoman
authors,butminimizesthecommentaryonthesacrificeofhumans,alsounlikeRomanauthors.
Hedoes,however,remarkoncapitalpunishmentasbeingcommonplace.15 Onemightalsonote
thatCaesarmentionedseveraltimeshowmobiletheGallicarmieswere:thismaybeattributed
simplytotheirlighterattireandhighcountofcavalrytroops,butitcouldalsotieintotheir
limitedusesforwarcaptives,whicharenotoriousforslowinganarmydown.Again,itis
difficult,withinthescopeoftheculture,todistinguishbetweensacrificeorexecutionfor
infractionswhichourperspectivescannotfullyunderstand.
OntheGaulishscornforcowardiceanddefeat,twounusualactsarenoteworthy:inthe
eventofvictory,theharvestingofhumanheads,andindefeat,suicidalacts.Multipletimes,
includingtheaccountofthebattleofTelamon,theGaulsareknownasbeingrecklesslybravein
desperatesituationstothepointofappearingsuicidaltotheirfoes.Thisagaintiesintothe
conceptofafterlifesointensivethroughoutCelticmaterialculture.Gallicwarriorshave
allegedlyfallenontheirownswordsratherthanbetakenasprisoners,whichbacksthetestament
14
AlainDeyber,
LesGauloisenGuerre:Stratgies,TactiquesetTechniques:Essai
d'HistoireMilitaire
,unpub.translationbyKevinBeckham,(Paris:EditionsErrance,2009),
15
7778.
Deyber,
10
againstcowardicewhichwaspunishablebyadeathconsideredlessnoble.Thiswasapparently
suchastrikingfeatureofCelticmartialculturethatitinspiredastatue.16Theharvestingof
humanheadsisubiquitousinclassicalaccounts,especiallynotedbyPolybius,andtheywere
usedastrophiesondisplayathomeafterbeingpreservedandcarefullytransportedtotheirplace
ofdisplayaftergrandvictories.AuthorssuchasAnneRossnotethattheheadwasconsideredby
theCeltstobetheseatofthesoul,theessenceofbeing.Itsymbolizeddivinityitself,andwas
thepossessorofeverydesirablequality.17AncientIrishliteraturementionstheharvestingof
TheCattleRaidofCooley
headsasastatussymbolforwarriorssuchasCuChulainnin .18The
materialcultureoftheCeltssupportsthisnotonlyinplacesofsacrificialdeposition,including
theheadsofbothanimalsandhumans,butintheirartaswell.Humanheadsaretotedby
warriorsonmanyCelticcoinsoftheIronAgeera,andaregivenmuchattentionincountless
carvingsinwoodandstoneaswellastheGundestrupcauldron.
Notably,somehistorians,Piggottamongstthem,believethatthiscauldronalsodisplays
theactofhumansacrifice.19 Oneonpanel,warriorsstandinranksbeforeadivinefigureis
shownloweringawarriorheadfirstintothecauldron,possiblytodrownhim.Mountedwarriors
arethenshownridingawayintothesun,whichcouldbeavisualpresentationoftheCelticideals
surroundingtheafterlifeandtheirattitudetowardsdeathassimplyapassage.Onanother,aslain
16
MartinVanNieuwkoop, TheGalatianSuicide:UnravellingtheLudovisiGaulkillinghimselfandhis
wife
,(LiedenUniversity:FacultyofArchaeology,April2012).
https://www.academia.edu/5180896/The_Galatian_Suicide_Unravelling_the_Ludovisi_Gaul_killing_himself_
and_his_wife (accessedApril13,2016)
17
Ross,156157.
18
TomPeeteCrossandClarkHarrisSlover,eds.,AncientIrishTales
,(1936,repr.,Totowa:Barnesand
NobleBooks1981.)281
19
Piggot,7779.
11
mananddoglayatthebreastofagoddessfigurewhoisgroomedbyattendants.Thesacrificeof
dogswasnotunknownamongsttherangeofvictimsinwhichtheGaulsindulged.
Thearchaeologicalrecordandtheliteraturebothhavemuchtosayabouttheworldofthe
ancientEuropeansknownasCelts.Sacrificewasundoubtedlyadailypartoflifeasfaras
materialcultureisconcerned.Votiveofferingsofspecialitems,likelytocurrythefavorofthe
gods,aswellastheburialandburningofgravegoodsshowusareligioussystemofexchange
withstrictrulesandstandards.Goodscouldbeexchangedtosupposedlyensuregoodharvests,
or,asinIreland,theroleofsuchinsurancemayhaverestedonthekingsshoulders.Asa
warriorbasedsociety,theCelticcultureisnaturallymartialandrigid,andcapitalpunishment
wascertainlynotanexclusivemattertotheCelts.TheancientGermansallegedlybelievedthat
thepowertotakeafreemanslifeinexecutionwasamatterforthegods,andthusreligious,and
practicedformostoffencesthepayingoffines.20 Thus,whendeathwastobeadministeredbythe
tribalsystemoftheCelts,onecaninferthatitwasamatterforthegods,andsotothegodsthe
offenderwouldbesentinpropitiation.
AccusationsofritualcannibalismamongsttheancientBritishdruidshaverecentlybeen
underheavierinvestigationthanbefore,itbeingtypicallyrecognizedevenbythelessgenerous
historiansasRomanpropagandadirectedagainstthemoreprimitiveinhabitantsoftheIsles.As
isdrylynotedbyStraboregardingIreland,concerningthisislandIhavenothingcertaintotell,
exceptthatitsinhabitantsaremoresavagethantheBritons,sincetheyaremaneatersaswellas
herbeaters.21 Therecentarchaeologicalfindswhichsuggesttheirvalidityhaveevenbeen
20
Germania
Tacitus, ,sec.12.
21
AldhouseGreen,75.
12
groundshakingenoughtoattracttheattentionofNationalGeographic.22Greenisacclaimedfor
dealingwiththesetopicsasobjectivelyandcomprehensivelyasmosthistorianscouldhopeto.
Certainevidenceforthedefleshingofhumanbonesdoesexist,butthecontextremains
ambiguous,andwiththeoccasionaloffhandremarksregardingthesavageryofthefringeCeltic
regions,discerninghistoriansarehesitanttorushtoconclusions.Theremovaloffleshevidenced
inaselectfewbonesexcavatedfromtheeraoftheRomanoccupationinBritainmayverywell
havebeenanothermanifestationoftheoverkillwhichthebogbodiesofIrelandexperienced.
Yet,perhapscannibalismwasusedasadesperateritualprocedurebytheundergroundfewwho
refusedtocomplywiththeRomanbanonhumansacrifice.Accusationsofcannibalism
neverthelessremainedacommontoolinEuropethroughtheMiddleAgesandupintotheeraof
NewWorldcolonization,andwererarelyfoundedinfactsomuchasfearoffringeterritories.
Again,notonlyareconclusionsdifficulttodraw,butisolatedevidencecannotbeappliedona
broadspectrumorevennecessarilyassociatedwiththedruids.
AllofthisevidencesuggeststhattheancientCeltsofGaul,Britain,andIrelandhad
vastlydifferentviewsindeathandsacrificethantheRomansandGreeksdid,andthuseven
moreforeigntomostmodernpeopletoday.Tounderstandthecontextofritualizedhumandeath
inancientCelticsociety,itisnecessarytoattempttounderstandasmuchasonecanaboutwhat
thedeathmeanttothoseinvolved,andthuswhattheendpurposewas.Aphilosophysuchasthat
ofPythagoras,teachingthedeathlessnessofthehumansoul,canbothmakespecialallowance
formoreabundantviolence,andalsosubtractsomeofthesignificancewhichtermssuchas
humansacrificeconjureuptothemodernmind,withthepropitiatorytortureandmurderof
22
JamesOwen,DruidsCommittedHumanSacrifice,Cannibalism?NationalGeographic ,2009.
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2009/03/090320druidssacrificecannibalism.html
(accessedApril
19th,2016)
13
innocentsunderreligiousprotection.WhatscholarsseeintheevidenceforCelticsacrificesdoes
notseemtomatchthis.Nowidegeneralizationscanbemadewithanydegreeofcertainty,but
certainly,thepracticeofhumansacrificehasmuchmoretoitthansensationalizednewsarticles
anddocumentariesmayprovide.ThemodernWesternmindviewssuchoccurrencesmuchasthe
Romanmindofantiquitydid:unjust,despicable,andignorantbutthroughthecomplexand
alienlensofCelticreligiousandsocialphilosophy,ittakesonanentirelynewappearance
altogether.Thisperspectiveisperhapsnotabetterormoreacceptableappearance,butamore
sensibleandaccurateonethaneitherrecord,Romanorbogbody,canprovidealone.
14
References
Primary
Cross,TomP.,andClarkH.Slover,eds. AncientIrishTales .1936.Reprint,Totowa:Barnes&
NobleBooks,1981.
Freeman,Philip.War,Women,andDruids:EyewitnessReportsandEarlyAccountsofthe
AncientCelts .Austin:UniversityofTexasPress,2002.
TheBogPeople:IronAgeManPreserved
Glob,P.V.. ,trans.RupertBruceMitford.NewYork:
CornellUniversityPress,1969.
OnBritainandGermany:aTranslationoftheAgricolaandtheGermania,
Tacitus. trans.H.
Mattingly.Baltimore:PenguinBooks,1948.
Secondary
AldhouseGreen,Miranda. CaesarsDruids:StoryofanAncientPriesthood .NewHavenand
London:YaleUniversityPress,2010.
Deyber,Alain.LesGauloisenGuerre:Stratgies,TactiquesetTechniques:Essaid'Histoire
Militaire,unpub.trans.KevinBeckham.Paris:EditionsErrance,2009.
Green,Miranda. SymbolandImageinCelticReligiousArt .London:Routledge,1989.
Halkon,Peter.BonesofIronAgewarriorsmayreveallinkbetweenYorkshiresspearpeople
andtheancientGauls. HeritageDaily.March182016.
http://theconversation.com/bonesofironagewarriorsmayreveallinkbetweenyorkshir
esspearpeopleandtheancientgauls56458(accessedApril10,2016)
MacCulloch,J.A..TheReligionoftheAncientCelts.Edinburgh:T.&T.Clark,1911.
MacCulloch,J.A..TheCelticandScandinavianReligions .1948.Reprint,Westport:Greenwood
Press,1973.
VanNieuwkoop,Martin. TheGalatianSuicide:UnravellingtheLudovisiGaulkillinghimself
andhiswife.LiedenUniversity:FacultyofArchaeology,2012.
https://www.academia.edu/5180896/The_Galatian_Suicide_Unravelling_the_Ludovisi_Gaul
_killing_himself_and_his_wife (accessedApril13,2016)
OShea,James.BogBodiesareKingsSacrificedbyCelts,SaysExpert. IrishCentral
.N.d.
http://www.irishcentral.com/news/bogbodiesarekingssacrificedbyceltssaysexpert1
29289548237410131.html (accessedApril5th,2016)
15
Owen,James.DruidsCommittedHumanSacrifice,Cannibalism? NationalGeographicNews .
March20th,2009.
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2009/03/090320druidssacrificecannibalism.h
tml(accessedApril5th,2016)
TheDruids
Piggott,Stuart. .1968.Reprint,NewYork:ThamesandHudsonInc.,1985.
Ross,Anne.EverydayLifeofthePaganCelts.NewYork:G.P.PutnamsSons,1970.
Smiles,Sam.TheImageofAntiquity:AncientBritainandtheRomanticImagination
.London:
YaleUniversityPress,1994.