Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Patrick Holstrom, Yuki Hata, Mallory Siebuhr, Clay Simons, Tyler Kist,
Madeline Williams, Corina Ramos, Amanda Mariano
Abstract
Introduction: Caffeine has been used as a performance booster for various exercise regimens
and sports. Research has shown high intensity interval training to result in superior adaptations
compared to moderate intensity continuous training. Body weight resistance exercises have been
shown to demonstrate VO2max in as little as 4 minutes during HIIT. Methods: This study used
five active men and women (N=10) who underwent three days of high intensity circuit training
exercise. Subjects underwent a VO2max test on the cycle ergometer to establish a baseline
fitness level prior to testing. Each day, there were 2 bouts that lasted 7 minutes, with a 2-min
recovery in the middle. Each bout is made up of twelve 30 second exercises with a 10 second
rest between exercises. Measurements were taken for VO2, Heart Rate, Kcal, BLa, and
repetitions. Results: Significance was shown in Blood Lactate levels (F=3.740, p<0.05) between
the various levels of caffeine. Upper body and lower body repetitions, heart rate, VO2 average,
VO2peak and Kcal did not show significance (p<0.05) amongst the various levels of caffeine.
Discussion: The 7 Minute App is widely used to provide a high intensity full body workout for
people in a short amount of time. This application can be used to improve overall fitness
Introduction
3
Caffeine (CAF) is widely ingested by adults across the United States (Mitchell et al. 2013).
Over 30 years of data has shown that CAF is ergogenic for endurance performance (Bell et al.
2003). More recently, its performance-enhancing properties have been identified for short-term
intense exercise performance including resistance training (Hoffman et al., 2008, Hudson et al.,
2008, Astorino Et al., 2008), repeated sprints (Wiles et al. 2006), and team sports (Paton et al.
2001). In these studies, CAF is typically ingested in powder form, which is feasible in a
Research studying the effects of CAF on different exercise protocol has shown
conflicting results. Numerous studies have shown that CAF elicits ergogenic benefits in
endurance exercises (Burk, 2008; Cole et al. 1996; Costill et al. 1978, Graham, 2001; Kovacs,
1998). In a sprint performance/resistance study, 24 male rugby players given 0, 200, 400, and
800 mg of CAF elicited greater sprint performance (Beaven et al. 2008). Collegiate shot putters
given 100 mg of CAF, increased their distance throw by 6.4% (Bliss et al.). However, in a
resistance training study involving 36 untrained men and women given either 300 or 600 mg
CAF, no difference in peak extension and flexion torque was observed (Jacobson and Edwards,
1991). Also in this study, reaction time and movement speed increased with the 300mg dose, but
not the 600 mg (Jacobson and Edwards, 1991). Lastly, a study looked at the effects of 6 mg/kg of
CAF on 15 strengthed trained men. Significance was seen in the number of repetitions in leg
extension but not in upper body exercise suggesting there is a difference in CAF effect between
High intensity interval training (HIIT) has been consistently shown to elicit similar and in
(MICT). Significant increases in VO2max (Astorino et al. 2011; Astorino et al. 2014), fat
4
oxidation (Astorino et al. 2011; Burgomaster et al. 2008), and oxidative capacity (Burgomaster et
al. 2008; Perry et al. 2008) have been shown in response to various forms of HIIT. Although the
efficacy and safety of HIIT are well-documented, it has been criticized for only being doable in a
lab environment, in which all sessions are supervised by trained individuals who oversee the
sessions and motivate participants. High intensity circuit training (HICT)/HIIT training has the
potential for fast and efficient methods for weight/fat loss. Body weight resistance in large
muscle groups with little recovery time generates aerobic and metabolic effects for up to 72
hours post-exercise (Heden et al., 2011). Research has shown increases in VO2max can be
achieved in just 4 minutes of exercise while exercising at or around 100% of a persons VO2max
(Tabata, 1996).
We recently showed (Riegler et al. 2017 in review) that this regime elicits intensities as high
as 90 %VO2max, which would represent a form of HIIT. The 7 min app was designed to address
the needs of those with a busier lifestyle. If performance during the 7 Min App could be
consistently enhanced with a product such as CAF, it may augment the daily training stimulus
and potentially optimize adaptations to training. All exercises in the 7 Min App are body weight,
The aim of this study is to examine the effects of CAF consumption on performance of the
7Min App in active men and women. We hypothesize that compared to placebo, CAF will show
We also hypothesize that compared to placebo, caffeinated trials will show significant increases
in blood lactate (BLa) levels, VO2 averages, peak VO2, calories (Kcal) burned, as well as heart
rate (bpm).
Methods
5
Design
Each subject attended a total of 4 different sessions. Initially, subjects underwent a VO2max test
on the cycle ergometer (Velotron Dynafit Pro, RacerMate Inc., Seattle, WA). Gas exchange data
was collected using a metabolic cart (ParvoMedics True One, Sandy, UT) During exercise, work
rate increased in a ramp-like manner until volitional fatigue, and gas exchange data and heart rate
(HR) was obtained. 10 minutes post VO2max test, the subjects were taken through with a
familiarization baseline session of the 7 Min App exercises they would be experiencing during
the three trials. Subjects were instructed to perform a 5 min warm up on the cycle ergometer at
25 watt resistance. After warm up, subject were hooked up to the metabolic cart and subjected to
the three trials where they underwent two sets of the 7 Minute Workout Program. Prior to each
Trial subjects were instructed to refrain from intense exercise for 48 hours, arrive rested,
hydrated, and in the postabsorptive state (> 2 hours). Each trial, subjects were randomly given a
caffeinated drink (placebo (PL), 2 mg/kg bw, 5 mg/kg bw) mixed with orange tang 1 hour prior
to exercise. A minimum of two days rest were required between workout sessions to ensure
results were not affected by muscle soreness and residual fatigue. Participants were instructed to
Subjects
Ten total subject with moderate physical activity levels; five active men and five active women
who exercise a minimum of 2 days per calendar week will be used for the study. All subjects will
need to be free from any upper or lower extremity injury, impairment, or condition that may
affect the results. Subject descriptions can be seen in table 1. Subjects with elevated levels of
fitness with exposure to interval training or have taken more than 5 mg/kg bw on a regular basis
The 7 Minute Workout Program is designed as a HICT program. It is meant to be inexpensive and
provide numerous health benefits for its users. The program includes 12 exercises arranged in a
specific order which consists of the following; 1. Jumping Jacks 2. Wall Sit 3. Push-ups 4.
Abdominal crunches 5. Step-ups onto chair 6. Squats (>90 degree knee flexion) 7. Triceps-dips on
chair (>90 degree flexion) 8. Plank 9. High knee jog in place (>90 degree knee flexion) 10.
Bilateral lunges 11. Push-ups with 90 degree rotation 12. Side plank. Each exercise is performed
for 30 seconds at maximal effort and is followed with a 10 second rest/transition period. A two
HR measurements
A heart rate monitor was placed around the chest of the subject. This measure was used to assess
intensity of the exercises with the different doses of CAF. Heart rate will be taken for all three
trials during rest, after every exercise (i.e., during the first 3 second of rest following jumping
jacks), at the end of the 2 minute rest period, and 3 minutes after trial two. In total, 27
BLa concentration will be measured using a fingertip lancet and a blood lactate meter. There will
be three measurements taken; pre-exercise, during the two minute recovery, and 3 minutes post-
exercise of trial 2. BLa will be analyzed in this study to determine if CAF has significant effects
on the type of metabolic pathway being used during this type of exercise.
VO2 Measures
Subjects were initially subjected to a VO2max test to determine the level of our subjects fitness.
Average VO2 will be analyzed for both trial 1 and 2 for each dosage of CAF. Similarly VO2max
7
Kcal measures
There has been research to suggest that CAF can affect the number of calories burned during
exercise. The metabolic cart calculates the amount of Kcal burned during the trial through the gas
exchange data. The number of Kcal burned was compared between the three trials of the 7 Minute
Workout Program.
Repetitions
Because the 7 minute workout program is HICT that lasts for extended periods of time, repetitions
were counted for each measurable exercise and compared between the three doses of CAF to see
if CAF increased the amount of repetitions produced. Repetitions for upper body and lower body
were then separated and totaled because research suggests that caffeine may affect these muscle
groups differently.
Data Analysis
All data was analyzed using SPSS version 20.0 (Chicago, IL) and expressed as mean standard
deviation (SD). A two-way ANOVA with repeated measures test was used to compare changes
across time and dose of CAF in heart rate, BLa, average VO2, and repetitions. A one-way
ANOVA with repeated measures test was used to compare changes in peak VO2 and Kcals.
Results
BLa Levels
A two-way ANOVA with repeated measures revealed significant change between PL, 2mg/kg,
and 5mg/kg (F=3.740, p<0.05). These changes can be observed in GRAPH. Pre exercise
revealed no significant change between PL, 2mg/kg, and 5mg/kg (2.6 1.1mmol/L, 2.4
8
0.9mmol/L, and 3.1 1.0mmol/L respectively). Readings taken during the two minute rest
between sets was significant between the 2mg/kg and 5mg/kg trials (13.2 2.6mmol/L and 15.1
trend can be observed from PL to 2mg/kg to 5mg/kg (14.3 3.7mmol/L, 15.2 3.3mmol/L, 15.9
2.6mmol/L respectively).
KCal
When running a one-way ANOVA with repeated measured, no significance was observed (F =
2.889, p>0.05). Results can be seen in GRAPH. There was a slight increase in calories burned
between PL, 2mg/kg bw, and 5mg/kg bw (157.4 43.9Kcal, 160.9 46.3Kcal, and 161.0
45.1Kcal respectively). Despite no significance being observed, there was an increasing trend in
Kcals burned.
9
Using a two-way ANOVA with repeated measures there was no significant change in lower body
repetitions between trials (F=2.698, p>0.05). A consistent increase between CAF doses can be
reps, 221.9 37.8, and 231.0 40.8 reps respectively). Set 2 showed a consistent decrease in
repetitions in each trial, however the same increase can be observed from PL to 2mg/kg to
5mg/kg at 208.3 32.9 reps, 213.5 32.7 reps, and 218.6 34.3 reps respectively. All data can
be seen in TABLE.
10
A two-way ANOVA with repeated measures revealed no significant change in upper body
repetitions (F= 1.771, p>0.05). GRAPH shows the increase from PL to 2mg/kg to 5mg/kg. Set 1
increased from 123.028.2 reps to 126.8 40.1 reps to 133.7 37 reps (PL, 2mg/kg, 5mg/kg
respectively). Set two decreased in repetitions compared to set 1. Set two increased from PL to
2mg/kg to 5mg/kg (117.0 33.7 reps, 119.4 43.0 reps, 125.2 40.7 reps respectively). Data
Upper Body Reps 123.0 28.2 126.8 40.1 133.7 37.3 117.0 33.7119.4 43.0 125.2 40.7
11
Lower Body Reps 213.2 31.7 221.9 37.8 231.0 40.8 208.3 32.9213.5 32.7 218.6 34.3
Average VO2 showed no significant difference (F= 3.002, p>0.05) when using a two-way
ANOVA with repeated measures. Set 1 showed no significant increase between PL, 2mg/kg,
5mg/kg (1.69 0.44 l/min, 1.72 0.46 l/min, 1.73 0.47 l/min respectively). Set 2 increased in
2mg/kg (1.81 0.53 l/min) and 5mg/kg (1.80 0.55 l/min) compared to PL (1.75 0.49 l/min),
however this showed no significant change. Set 2 can also be seen in GRAPH as having larger
There was no significant change between peak VO2 (F=3.271, p>0.05) when using a one-way
ANOVA with repeated measures. Significance was found to be p=0.061 which means it was
very close to showing significant change. A slight increase can be seen between PL (2.59 0.70
l/min) and 2 mg/kg (2.64 0.73 l/min), and a fairly large decrease can be seen between the
Average heart heart showed no significant change between trials when using a two-way ANOVA
with repeated measures (F=0.183,p>0.05). GRAPH and TABLE shows that heart rate between
the three trials is practically the same. Resting heart rate was shown to start around the same
between PL, 2mg/kg, and 5mg/kg (79.3 13.0 bpm, 74.7 13.1 bpm, and 76.8 17.8 bpm
13
respectively.) Peak heart rates at each of the three levels stated above were measured at 178.1
12.7 bpm, 176.1 10.5 bpm, and 177.3 14.6 bpm respectively.
Discussion
The primary aim of this study is to observe the effects of CAF on performance in active
men and women during the 7 Minute App workout. To our knowledge, this is the first study to
examine the ergogenic effects of caffeine on a circuit training routine. Our primary findings
suggest that there was a significant change in BLA between all three trials. All other variables
were not found to be significant however trends can be seen in repetitions, Kcals burned, and
VO2peak and averages. Heart rate showed no change between the three levels of caffeine.
Our data suggests there is a significant change in blood lactate levels when CAF is
ingested. Similar finding can be seen in Lee et al. (2014) where they looked at the effects of
6mg/kg CAF on repeated bicycle sprint exercise in eleven female athletes. This study found a
significant increase in BLA between PL and CAF trials (Lee et al. 2014). Lee and colleagues
suggest that caffeine may activate anaerobic glycolysis sooner, increasing lactate sooner (Lee et
al. 2014). This study also suggests that CAF may impair sprint based exercise due to the increase
in lactate and other products of anaerobic metabolism (Buchheit et al. 2009) Caffeine acts as an
antagonist on adenosine, a cellular component that increases with muscle contraction and causes
fatigue (Davis et al. 2003). Future studies should examine the exact chemical effect leading to
increased BLA.
When analyzing and comparing upper body repetitions to lower body repetitions, both
had no significant change due to CAF ingestion. For upper and lower body repetitions, a definite
15
increase can be observed. This increase could be observed more clearly in lower body repetitions
than upper body repetitions suggesting that CAF may affect certain muscle groups differently. A
study done by Hudson had 15 strength trained men ingest 6mg/kg CAF and perform four sets of
arm curl and leg extensions to fatigue (Hudson et al. 2008). This study showed a significant
increase in the number of repetitions in leg extension, however no significant increase was
observed in the arm curl (Hudson et al. 2008) This data supports our findings showing a greater
increase in repetitions for lower body repetitions as opposed to upper body repetitions. A larger
sample size may help us to reveal significance in lower body repetitions by reducing variability.
Recent studies have suggested that variations in genotype may alter caffeine metabolism
and in turn affect performance in response to caffeine. A single difference in the genotype
responsible for the metabolism of caffeine in the liver will cause some subjects to be slow
caffeine metabolizers and others to metabolize caffeine more rapidly (Butler et al., 1989). This
individual's response to caffeine (Cornelis, 2007). Similar discrepancies can be observed in our
subjects suggesting only some individuals may experience improved performance with acute
caffeine intake.
Our findings also showed no significant difference in Peak VO2, average trial VO2 as
well as average heart rates. Heart rate stayed nearly identical ( 2-3 bpm) however a trend can be
observed in the peak VO2. This leads us to believe that CAF influences cardiac output,
specifically stroke volume. One study looked at the effects of Red Bull on different
hemodynamic pathways and concluded that Red Bull significantly increased stroke volume
(Miles-Can, 2015). Another study looked at the effects of 4mg/kg CAF on resistance training on
15 subjects and concluded a fall in stroke volume from pre exercise CAF to post exercise CAF
16
(Souza, 2014). Further research involving cardiac output and CAF use in the 7Min would be
In addition to the physical effects of caffeine, some psychological benefits exist as well.
Caffeine promotes the release of serotonin. This hormone release increases sympathetic activity
which may reverse symptoms of fatigue (Tarnopolsky, 2000). This may explain why subjects
Limitations
One limitation we faced was that subjects tolerance to caffeine. Every person reacts
differently to the substance, therefore it is difficult to maintain effects. Some subjects ingest
caffeine on a regular basis in lower quantities than what was studied and may have built up a low
tolerance. Another limitation we encountered was a glitchy heart rate monitor. With the dynamic
movements the subjects took place in, the heart rate monitor sometimes had a hard time
connecting to the watch giving us mildly inaccurate readings. A possible explanation as to why
we didn't see a significant difference in areas other than BLa levels between subjects could be
that we simply did not have enough subjects to compare results within. We tested 5 men and 5
women. If we could test 2 more men and women, this could remove some of the variability and
Conclusion
weight exercises performed continuously with 10 second recovery time. Utilizing this app can
help people who want to get healthy do so without devoting a large amount of time out of their
day to exercise. Our research suggests that caffeine would not offer many benefits to improve
performance within the application. Significance was found in BLa however we did not observe
17
any significant differences in Kcals burned, heart rate, upper and lower body repetitions, or peak
VO2 and average VO2. In order to further these results, it would benefit us to obtain four more
participants to remove variability between subjects. It would also be beneficial for future
References
Astorino, TA, Allen, RP, Roberson, DW, Jurancich, M, Lewis, R, McCarthy, K, Trost, E.,
111(7):1279-86, 2011.
Astorino, TA, Firth, K, and Rhomann, RL. Effect of caffeine ingestion on one-repetition
127-32.
Astorino, TA, Schubert, MM., Individual responses to completion of short-term and chronic
Beaven, CM, Hopkins, WG, Hansen, KT, Wood, MR, Cronin, JB, and Lowe, TE. Dose effect
of caffeine on testosterone and cortisol responses to resistance exercise. Int J Sport Nutr
Bell, DG, Mclellan T., Effect of Repeated Caffeine Ingestion on Repeated Exhaustive Exercise
Endurance. Med Sci. Sports Exerc., Vol. 35, No. 8, pp.1348-1354, 2003.
Bliss, MV, Bellar, D, Kamimori, GH, Glickman, EL, Barkley, JE, Ryan, EJ, and Bellar, A. The
effect of caffeine supplementation on performance in the standing shot put throw. Med
Buchheit M, Cormie P, Abbiss CR, Ahmaidi S, Nosaka KK, Laursen PB: Muscle deoxygenation
during repeated sprint running: Effect of active vs. passive recovery. Int J Sports Med. 2009, 30:
418-425.
Burgomaster, K.A., et al. 2008. Similar metabolic adaptations during exercise after low volume
sprint interval and traditional endurance training in humans. Journal of Physiology, 586
(1), 151-60.
Burke, LM. Caffeine and sports performance. Appl Physiol Nutr Metab 33: 13191334, 2008.
Butler, MA, Iwasaki, M, Guengerich, FP, and Kadlubar, F. Human cytochrome P450A (P-
Clarke, N., Baxter, H., Fajemilua, E., Jones, V., Oxford, S., Richardson, D., Mundy, P. (2016).
Coffee and Caffeine Ingestion Have Little Effect on Repeated Sprint Cycling in
Cole, KJ, Costill, DL, Starling, RD, Goodpaster, BH, Trappe, SW, and Fink, WJ. Effect of
caffeine ingestion on perception of effort and subsequent work production. Int J Sports
Cornelis, MC, El-Sohemy, A, and Campos, H. Genetic polymorphism of the adenosine A2A
receptor is associated with habitual caffeine consumption. Am J Clin Nutr 86: 240244,
2007.
Costill, DL, Dalsky, GP, and Fink, WJ. Effects of caffeine on metabolism and exercise
Davis, JM, Zhao, Z, Stock, HS, Mehl, KA, Buggy, J, and Hand, GA. Central nervous system
19
Graham, TE. Caffeine and exercise: Metabolism, endurance, and performance. Sports Med 31:
785807, 2001.
Heden L, Lox C, Rose P, Reid S, Kirk EP. One set resistance training elevates energy
expenditure for 72 hours similar to three sets. Eur J Appl Physiol. 2011;111(3):477-84.
Hoffman, JR, Ratamess, NA, Ross, R, Shanklin, M, Kang, J, and Faigenabum, AD. Effect of a
Hudson, GM, Green, JM, Bishop, PA, and Richardson, MT. Effects of caffeine and aspirin on
light resistance training performance, perceived exertion, and pain perception. J Strength
Jacobson, BH and Edwards, SW. Influence of two levels of caffeine on maximal torque at
selected angular velocities. J Sports Med Phys Fitness 31: 147153, 1991.
Kovacs, EMR, Stegen, JHCH, and Brouns, F. Effect of caffeinated drinks on substrate
metabolism, caffeine excretion, and performance. J Appl Physiol 85: 709715, 1998.
Lee, CL, Cheng, CF, Astorino, TA, Lee, CJ, Huang, HW, Chang, WD. Effects of carbohydrate
combined with caffeine on repeated sprint cycling and agility performance in female
Mitchell, Diane C., Carol A. Knight, Jon Hockenberry, Robyn Teplansky, and Terryl J.
Hartman. "Beverage Caffeine Intakes in the U.S." Beverage Caffeine Intakes in the
U.S.N.p., 2013.
Paton, CD, Hopkins, WG, and Vollebregt, L. Little effect of caffeine ingestion on repeated
sprints in team-sports athletes. Med Sci Sports Exerc 33: 822825, 2001.
20
increases fat and carbohydrate metabolic capacities in human skeletal muscle. Appl
Riegler, M, Stotz, G, Fitzgerald, K, Munoz, CK, Lewis, J, Ring, S, Astorino, TA. Is the 7
intensity intermittent training on anaerobic capacity and VO2max. Med Sci Sports Exerc.
1996;28(10):1327-30.
Tarnopolsky, MA and Cupido, C. Caffeine potentiates low frequency skeletal muscle force in
habitual and non habitual caffeine consumers. J Appl Physiol 89: 17191724, 2000.
Wiles JD, Coleman D, Tegerdine M, Swaine IL (2006) The effects of caffeine ingestion on