Rubric for Individual Oral Defense in Distribution Management (Prelim)

Student Name: ________________________________________ Section: _______ Date: ________

(SURNAME, FIRST NAME M.I.)

CATEGORY/Rate 4 3 2 1 Weight Rate Score

Knowledge / Very high degree Considerable Moderate Insufficient
Understanding of understanding of understanding of understanding of understanding of
(Scope of ideas/concepts/ ideas/concepts/ ideas/concepts/ ideas/concepts/
Knowledge) arguments/evidence arguments/evidence arguments/evidence arguments/evidence 5
on topic of topic of topic of topic

Content Shows a full Shows a good Shows a good Does not seem to
understanding of the understanding of the understanding of parts understand the topic
topic. topic. of the topic. very well. 5

Ability to Answer Anticipates and Does not anticipate Does not anticipate Either makes no effort
Questions understands facilitators and understands the facilitators questions. to respond to questions
questions. Can integrate facilitators Makes an effort to or does so poorly
knowledge to answer questions. Can address question. Can
questions. Thoroughly integrate knowledge address some
responds to all questions to answer the questions. Overlooks
question. obvious questions. 5
Thoroughly Often responds poorly
responds to most to questions
questions
TOTAL

Maximum Possible Score: 60

REMARKS:

Accepted:

______________________________________
(Signature / Date)
 Rubric for Individual Oral Defense in Distribution Management (Prelim)

Student Name: ________________________________________ Section: _______ Date: ________

(SURNAME, FIRST NAME M.I.)

CATEGORY/Rate 4 3 2 1 Weight Rate Score

Knowledge / Very high degree Considerable Moderate Insufficient
Understanding of understanding of understanding of understanding of understanding of
(Scope of ideas/concepts/ ideas/concepts/ ideas/concepts/ ideas/concepts/
Knowledge) arguments/evidence arguments/evidence arguments/evidence arguments/evidence 5
on topic of topic of topic of topic

Content Shows a full Shows a good Shows a good Does not seem to
understanding of the understanding of the understanding of parts understand the topic
topic. topic. of the topic. very well. 5

Ability to Answer Anticipates and Does not anticipate Does not anticipate Either makes no effort
Questions understands facilitators and understands the facilitators questions. to respond to questions
questions. Can integrate facilitators Makes an effort to or does so poorly
knowledge to answer questions. Can address question. Can
questions. Thoroughly integrate knowledge address some
responds to all questions to answer the questions. Overlooks
question. obvious questions. 5
Thoroughly Often responds poorly
responds to most to questions
questions
TOTAL

Maximum Possible Score: 60

REMARKS:

Accepted:

______________________________________
(Signature / Date)
 Rubric for Individual Oral Defense in Distribution Management (Prelim)

Student Name: ________________________________________ Section: _______ Date: ________

(SURNAME, FIRST NAME M.I.)

CATEGORY/Rate 4 3 2 1 Weight Rate Score

Knowledge / Very high degree Considerable Moderate Insufficient
Understanding of understanding of understanding of understanding of understanding of
(Scope of ideas/concepts/ ideas/concepts/ ideas/concepts/ ideas/concepts/
Knowledge) arguments/evidence arguments/evidence arguments/evidence arguments/evidence 5
on topic of topic of topic of topic

Content Shows a full Shows a good Shows a good Does not seem to
understanding of the understanding of the understanding of parts understand the topic
topic. topic. of the topic. very well. 5

Ability to Answer Anticipates and Does not anticipate Does not anticipate Either makes no effort
Questions understands facilitators and understands the facilitators questions. to respond to questions
questions. Can integrate facilitators Makes an effort to or does so poorly
knowledge to answer questions. Can address question. Can
questions. Thoroughly integrate knowledge address some
responds to all questions to answer the questions. Overlooks
question. obvious questions. 5
Thoroughly Often responds poorly
responds to most to questions
questions
TOTAL

Maximum Possible Score: 60

REMARKS:

Accepted:

______________________________________
(Signature / Date)
 Rubric for Group Oral Presentation in Distribution Management (Prelim)

CATEGORY/Rate 4 3 2 1 Weight Rate Score

Delivery Expressed ideas fluently Displayed interest Presenter unenthused Presenter unsettled,
in own words. and enthusiasm. and monotonous. uninterested, and
Genuinely interested Occasionally Voice mannerisms, unenthusiastic.
and enthusiastic. struggled to find body language, and Inappropriate voice
Exceptional voice words. Generally communication skills mannerisms, body
mannerisms, body appropriate voice sometimes language, and poor
language, and mannerisms, body inappropriate. communication skills. 10
communication skills. language, and
communication
skills.

Presentation Presenters were all very Presenters were Presenters were not Presenters were
(Clarity and confident in delivery. occasionally consistent with the unconfident and
preparation) Preparation is very confident with their level of confidence / demonstrated little
evident. presentation. preparedness they evidence of planning 5
Preparation is showed during prior to presentation.
evident. presentation but had
some strong moments.
TOTAL

Maximum Possible Score: 60

Members: (SURNAME, FIRST NAME M.I.) Accepted: (Signature / Date)

_______________________________________________ ____________________________________________

_______________________________________________ ____________________________________________

_______________________________________________ ____________________________________________

_______________________________________________ ____________________________________________

_______________________________________________ ____________________________________________

Section: ______________ Date of Presentation: _______

REMARKS: