Sei sulla pagina 1di 7

Construction

and Building

Construction and Building Materials 21 (2007) 539545


MATERIALS
www.elsevier.com/locate/conbuildmat

Inuence of nano-SiO2 addition on properties of hardened cement


paste as compared with silica fume
a,b,*
Ye Qing , Zhang Zenan c, Kong Deyu a, Chen Rongshen a

a
College of Architecture and Civil Engineering, Zhejiang University of Technology, 310014 Hangzhou, PR China
b
Department of Civil Engineering, Quzhou College, 324006 Quzhou, PR China
c
Department of Physics, Zhejiang University of Technology, 310014 Hangzhou, PR China

Received 4 March 2005; received in revised form 5 September 2005; accepted 7 September 2005
Available online 24 October 2005

Abstract

The inuence of nano-SiO2 (NS) addition on properties of hardened cement paste (hcp) as compared with silica fume (SF) has been
studied through measurement of compressive and bond strengths of hcp, and by XRD and SEM analysis. Results indicated that the
inuence of NS and SF on consistency and setting time of fresh cement paste showed dierent. NS made cement paste thicker and
NS accelerated the cement hydration process. Compressive strengths of hcp and bond strengths of pasteaggregate interface incorporat-
ing NS were obviously higher than those incorporating SF, especially at early ages. And with increasing the NS content, the rate of bond
strength increase was more than that of their compressive strength increase. With 3% NS added, NS digested calcium hydroxide (CH)
crystals, decreased the orientation of CH crystals, reduced the crystal size of CH gathered at the interface and improved the interface
more eectively than SF. The results suggest that with a small amount of added NS, the CH crystals at the interface between hcp
and aggregate at early ages may be eectively absorbed in high performance concrete (HPC).
 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Keywords: Hardened cement paste; Interface; Nano-SiO2; Mechanical property; Silica fume

1. Introduction belongs to the category of highly pozzolanic materials be-


cause it consists essentially of silica in non-crystalline form
In this new century, the technology of nano-structured with a high specic surface, and thus exhibits great pozzo-
material is developing at an astonishing speed and will be lanic activity. But the activity of SF at early ages is low
applied extensively with many materials. Although cement according to the literature [69]. Mitchell et al. [6] reported
is a common building material, its main hydrate CSH gel that the XRD pattern of SF, put into saturated calcium
is a natural nano-structured material [15]. hydroxide (CH) solution, changed little up to 7 days and
The durability and mechanical properties of HPC are extensive CSH formation had occurred after 120 days.
mainly dependent on the gradually rening structure of Li et al. [9] showed that only 75% of SF was consumed
hcp and the gradually improving pasteaggregate interface in a cement paste after 90 days of hydration.
incorporating additions and admixtures. Many researchers The aggregatepaste interface is regarded as the most
have applied slag, y-ash and silica fume (SF) to improving sensitive area within the structure of concrete, where a
cement-based materials, and have achieved great successes, number of defects exist and the concrete failure process
such as HPC and reactive powder concrete and so on. SF commences easily. Through SEM and XRD examinations
of the interfacial transition zone in pastes cast against glass
*
Corresponding author. Tel.: +86 571 85816061; fax: +86 571
slides, Barnes et al. [10] and Grandet and Ollivier [11] re-
88320124. ported the occurrence of duplex lms, comprising a layer
E-mail address: zjutyeqing@163.com (Q. Ye). of CH crystals in contact with the glass and oriented with

0950-0618/$ - see front matter  2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2005.09.001
540 Q. Ye et al. / Construction and Building Materials 21 (2007) 539545

their c-axes normal to its surface, and a layer of CSH 2.0 min at a paddle speed of both 62 rpm (revolution)
further out into the paste. With additions of pozzolanic and 140 rpm (rotation), a 15 s stop and a total of
materials such as slag, y-ash and silica fume added, the 2.0 min at a speed of both 125 rpm (revolution) and
interface structure has been improved, especially in HPC 285 rpm (rotation).
[1215]. (2) Test of consistency and setting time of fresh pastes.
In this paper, using the experience of nano-technology The consistency and the setting time of fresh pastes
in ceramics and polymer for reference, the inuence of were tested according to ISO 9597:1989. The consis-
NS on properties of hcp was studied as compared with sil- tency was ascertained by putting the paste in a
ica fume, in order to improve the microstructure of hcp, mould consisting of a steel ring (40 mm in height)
thus to enhance the durability and mechanical properties on a sheet of glass and by determining the penetra-
of cement-based materials. Furthermore, for HPC contain- tion depth of a plunger applied to the top surface of
ing SF or y-ash or slag, with the addition of 13% NS, we the paste specimen. The initial and the nal setting
hope to produce a new high performance concrete with time were determined with the needle of the Vicat
much better properties. apparatus.
(3) Test of paste compressive strength. The fresh paste was
2. Experimental procedure cast into cubic molds (25 25 25 mm) to prepare
specimens on a vibrating table for a measurement of
2.1. Raw materials compressive strength. Three cubes were tested for each
sample at the given age, by a hydraulic press with
A commercial Chinese ordinary Portland cement (C) 100 kN capacity and 0.5 MPa/s loading speed. Each
(42.5 grade, Blaine specic surface 310 m2/kg) complying strength value was an average of three specimens.
with Chinese standard (GB 175) was used. Its composition (4) Test of bond strength of pasteaggregate interface (or
(wt%) is 81% clinker, 13% slag and 6% gypsum, and the paste exural strength set with glass plate). The fresh
Bogue composition of the clinker is 56% C3S, 18% C2S, paste was cast into square-bar moulds 40 40 160
8% C3A and 12% C4AF. Both NS and SF in this study mm on a vibrating table, and then a glass plate
were commercially available undensied materials, sup- (39.8 39.8 3 mm) was set into the middle of the
plied by Mingri Nano-material Ltd. and Zhunyi Ferroalloy square-bar specimen with the plate parallel to the
Ltd. in China, respectively. A superplasticizer (SM) used bar cross-section. With ISO method for cement ex-
was a commercial sulphonated melamine formaldehyde ural strength test for reference, three specimens were
polymer (liquid solution, water content 70%) with special tested for each sample at the given age. The span for
gravity 1.2 g/cm3 and water reduction up to 20%. Tap exural strength test and the compressed area for
water (W) was used in all experiments. Chemical composi- compressive strength are 100 and 40 40 mm, respec-
tions and physical properties of clinker, slag, gypsum, SF tively. Namely, the bond strength is represented by
and NS are shown in Table 1. exural strength.
(5) Preparation of pasteaggregate interface specimen for
2.2. Experimental programs microstructure analysis. At rst, glass plate
(19.8 19.8 3 mm) was prepared, and the plate
(1) Preparation of paste specimen. Cement pastes incor- was set into the bottom of cubic mold
porating NS or SF were prepared at (near) standard (20 20 20 mm). Then the fresh paste was cast into
consistency using a planetary mixer (ISO). For all the cubic molds on a vibrating table.
the pastes, a cement plus addition:water:superplasti- (6) Microstructure analysis at interface. At the given age,
cizer ratio of 1:0.22:0.025 was used, as shown in Table when glass plate was split apart between hcp and
2. Cement with NS or SF was fully mixed under the glass, the fracture surface (interface) on hcp was ana-
condition of dry process beforehand. The mixing con- lysed by XRD and SEM immediately, in order to
sists of a sequence of mixings that involve a total of determine the degree of interaction between CH and

Table 1
Chemical compositions and physical properties of clinker, slag, gypsum, silica fume and nano-SiO2
Chemical composition (wt%) Physical properties
SiO2 Al2O3 Fe2O3 CaO MgO SO3 Average of diameter Specic surface Density Loose density
(nm) (m2/g) (g/cm3) (g/cm3)
Clinker 21.05 5.56 4.03 64.27 1.02 0.75
Slag 31.55 13.95 1.08 41.42 8.20
Gypsum 4.96 0.46 0.26 29.61 1.45 37.56
SF 92.10 2.04 1.08 0.45 0.58 0.44 180 21.5 2.22 0.21
NS 99.90 15 160 2.12 0.15
Q. Ye et al. / Construction and Building Materials 21 (2007) 539545 541

Table 2
Mix proportions, compressive and bond strengths of pastes made out of cement and NS or SF
Sample Mix proportion in mass Consistencya Setting time Compressive strength (MPa) (%) Bond strength (MPa)
(mm) (%)
C NS SF W SM Initial Final Dt 1d 3d 28d 60d 7d 28d
CO 100 0 0 22 2.5 34 2h57m 4h23m 1h26m 48.9 (100) 61.1 (100) 79.2 (100) 94.9 (100) 5.1 (100) 5.8 (100)
A1 99 1 0 22 2.5 34 2h57m 4h05m 1h08m 49.2 (101) 71.6 (117) 94.7 (120) 101.6 (107) 5.9 (116) 7.3 (126)
A2 98 2 0 22 2.5 33 2h55m 3h50m 0h55m 49.8 (102) 72.6 (119) 95.8 (121) 102.5 (108) 6.2 (122) 8.3 (143)
A3 97 3 0 22 2.5 33 2h48m 3h40m 0h52m 52.0 (106) 82.2 (135) 97.6 (123) 105.8 (111) 6.6 (129) 10.0 (172)
A5 95 5 0 22 2.5 32 2h16m 3h06m 0h50m 53.0 (108) 86.1 (141) 98.8 (125) 108.8 (115) 7.3 (143) 10.9 (188)
B2 98 0 2 22 2.5 35 3h50m 4h45m 0h55m 47.5 (97) 61.0 (100) 84.2 (106) 101.5 (107) 5.2 (102) 6.3 (109)
B3 97 0 3 22 2.5 35 4h35m 5h20m 0h45m 47.3 (97) 60.4 (99) 92.0 (116) 104.3 (110) 5.0 (98) 6.7 (116)
B5 95 0 5 22 2.5 36 4h45m 5h28m 0h43m 47.0 (96) 60.0 (98) 95.3 (120) 106.9 (113) 4.9 (96) 7.1 (122)
a
Penetration depth.

NS or SF, and to observe the orientation, size and creased with increasing the SF content. The results indicate
morphology of CH crystals or other hydration prod- that the inuence of both NS and SF on consistency and
ucts at the interface. setting shows dierent, and NS makes cement paste thicker
(7) Curing conditions for specimens. All paste specimens, and accelerates the cement setting process as compared
which were cured at (20 2) C and above 90% r.h. with SF.
moisture, were demolded after 24 h, and then stored
in water at (20 1) C. 3.3. Compressive strength of pastes

The above consistency, setting time, compressive and Table 2 also gives the variation of the compressive
bond strength tests were repeated three times. strength development of hcp with NS or SF added. It is
found that all paste strengths of sample A-series were obvi-
2.3. Equipment and test conditions ously higher than those of control sample CO especially at
3 days. Furthermore, with increasing the NS content, paste
X-ray diraction analyzer used is Rigaku D/Max-3B strengths increased. For example, compared with sample
type with the following conditions: Cu Ka radiation, tube CO, the strengths of sample A3 increased by 6%, 35%,
electric current 40 mA and tube voltage 40 kV, and scan- 23% and 11% at ages of 1 day, 3 days, 28 days and 60 days,
ning speed 1/min. Scanning electron microscope used is respectively.
Hitachi S570 type. However, with increasing the SF content, all paste
strengths of sample B-series were slightly lower than those
3. Results of sample CO at ages of 1 day and 3 days. But at ages of 28
days and 60 days, strengths with increasing the SF content
3.1. Degree of crystallinity of NS and SF were obviously higher than those of sample CO, and the
strengths were slightly lower than those of sample A-series
Fig. 1 shows XRD powder patterns of NS and SF. Strong with the same content of addition. For example, as com-
broad peaks of NS and SF were centered on 23 and 22 pared with sample CO, the strengths of sample B3 de-
(2h), respectively, which was in keeping with the strong creased by 3% and 1% at ages of 1 day and 3 days, and
broad peak of a characteristic of amorphous SiO2. The re- increased by 16% and 10% at ages of 28 days and 60 days,
sults show that both NS and SF are in an amorphous state. respectively.
These results show that the compressive strength of hcp
3.2. Consistency and setting time of fresh pastes is enhanced with NS addition added, especially at early
ages, and the pozzolanic activity of NS is much greater
The inuence of NS or SF addition on consistency and than that of SF.
setting time of fresh pastes is presented in Table 2. With
increasing the NS content, fresh pastes for sample A-series
grew thicker gradually and their penetration depths (con-
sistency value) decreased gently as compared with that of
control sample CO. While with increasing the SF content,
the pastes for sample B-series grew thinner and their depths
increased. The setting of fresh pastes (sample A-series) was
slightly accelerated but the dierence between the initial
and the nal time decreased with increasing the NS con-
tent. While the setting of fresh pastes (sample B-series)
was obviously retarded and the dierence was also de- Fig. 1. XRD powder pattern of nano-SiO2 and silica fume.
542 Q. Ye et al. / Construction and Building Materials 21 (2007) 539545

3.4. Bond strength of pasteaggregate interface

The variation of bond strength of pasteaggregate inter-


face made from cement and NS or SF with time is shown in
Table 2. Similarly to the compressive strengths, all bond
strengths of sample A-series were obviously higher than
those of control sample CO and than those of sample
B-series. Moreover, with increasing the NS content, the
rate of bond strength increase was more than that of their
compressive strength increase. At the ages of 7 and 28 days
bond strengths of sample A3 were, respectively, 6.6 and
10.0 MPa and were, respectively, 29% and 72% higher than
that of sample CO, and were, respectively, 32% and 49%
higher than that of sample B3. The results show that the
bond strength at the interface between aggregate and hcp
incorporating NS increases obviously and NS addition
can improve the interface structure more eectively than
SF.

3.5. Consumption of CH crystals gathered at the paste


aggregate interface

Fig. 2 shows the variation of interaction between CH


and NS or SF at the interface with time determined by
XRD pattern. The consumption of CH (crystals) content
at the interface between glass plate and paste containing
NS or SF can be demonstrated approximately by intensity
changes of main diraction peaks of CH crystals, such as
(0 0 1) crystal face, as well as (1 0 0) and (1 0 1) crystal faces
(d = 0.490, 0.310 and 0.263 nm, respectively), neglecting
the eect of orientation on the intensity. At the same ages,
diraction peak intensities of (1 0 0) and (1 0 1) crystal faces
of CH at the interface of sample A3 were almost equal to
those of sample CO, but the intensity of (0 0 1) crystal face
was much less than that of sample CO. For example, as
compared with sample CO, the intensities of (0 0 1) crystal
face at the interface of sample A3 decreased by 67%, 61%
and 64% at ages of 1 day, 7 days and 28 days, respectively.
Similarly to sample A3, intensities of (1 0 0) and (1 0 1)
crystal faces of CH at the interface of sample B3 were al-
most equal to those of sample CO, but the intensity of
(0 0 1) crystal face was less than that of sample CO. For in-
stance, as compared with sample CO, the intensities of
sample B3 decreased by 29%, 19% and 12%, respectively,
at the same above ages.
The results indicate that NS can consume more CH
crystals at the interface and can improve the interface
structure more eectively than SF.
Fig. 2. Variation of interaction between nano-SiO2 and Ca(OH)2 at the
3.6. CH orientation at the pasteaggregate interface
interface between paste and aggregate with time determined by XRD as
compared with silica fume.
The inuence of NS or SF on CH orientation at the
pasteaggregate interface can be determined by XRD pat-
tern as shown in Fig. 2. The orientation in this paper is de- and glass plate, orientation indexes of control sample CO
ned as R = 1.35I(0 0 1)/I(1 0 1), where I(0 0 1) and I(1 0 1) is were very great and were 3.9, 3.6 and 3.6 at ages of 1
(0 0 1) and (1 0 1) crystal face peak intensity, respectively, day, 7 days and 28 days, respectively, and the indexes of
and R is orientation index. At the interface between paste sample B3 were 3.4, 3.1 and 3.3. But those of sample A3
Q. Ye et al. / Construction and Building Materials 21 (2007) 539545 543

were very small and were just 1.8, 1.6 and 1.5 at the same As shown in Fig. 3(c), for sample B3, CH plates also oc-
above ages. The results reveal that NS can decrease the ori- curred with their c-axes perpendicular to the glass surface.
entation of CH crystals more eectively than SF. Edges of hexagonal plates were clear similarly to sample
CO and the size of the biggest crystal CH reached 7 lm.
3.7. CH micrographs at the pasteaggregate interface The results show that NS can reduce the size of CH crys-
tals at the interface more eectively than SF.
The variation of SEM micrographs of CH crystals gath-
ered at the pasteaggregate interface with NS and SF 4. Discussion
added is presented in Fig. 3. Fig. 3(a) shows that, for sam-
ple CO, hexagonal plates of CH crystals occurred with It is common knowledge that SF has a high pozzolanic
their c-axes perpendicular to the glass surface. Edges of activity and is normally considered as the best mineral
hexagonal plates were clear and the size of the biggest crys- addition used for concrete up to now. When SF is added
tal CH was up to 10 lm in the SEM micrograph. to cement or concrete, it acts both as a chemical inert ller,
CH micrographs at the interface of sample A3 are improving the physical structure and providing nucleation
shown in Fig. 3(b). It can be seen that the big CH plates sites for hydration products, and as a pozzolan, reacting
occurred with their c-axes also normal to the glass surface. chemically with CH formed during hydration of cement,
But edges of hexagonal plates with eroded phenomenon which will probably improve the pasteaggregate bond
were unclear, and the size of the biggest crystal CH was [15,16]. However, the pozzolanic activity of SF at early
up to 4 lm in the SEM micrographs. ages is low according to the aforementioned literature

Fig. 3. SEM micrographs of Ca(OH)2 crystals at the interface between aggregate and paste made from cement and nano-SiO2 at 28 days: (a) without NS;
(b) with 3% NS; (c) with 3% SF.
544 Q. Ye et al. / Construction and Building Materials 21 (2007) 539545

[811,16]. It is reported that the pozzolanic reaction be- 1) for NS [17]. So, NS can accelerate the cement setting
tween SF and CH formed during cement hydration begins process and the hydration process.
to occur after 3 days of hydration. It is the surface eects of nano-structured particles that
With ultrane particle size reducing to nano-structured cause the superiorities of cement paste incorporating NS to
one, such as SF particle size to that of NS, specic surface that incorporating SF. For this reason, NS can provide
and the number of atoms in the surface increase rapidly. much more nucleation sites for hydration products than
Owing to atoms in surface of nano-meter particles not SF at early ages, and NS has a higher pozzolanic activity
being full of other coordinate atoms, there exit a lot of than SF. Therefore, incorporating NS can increase com-
free bonds and unsaturated bonds or residual valence pressive strengths of hcp and bond strengths of paste
forces in the surface which lead the particles to be unstable aggregate interface, especially at early ages, and can
state of thermodynamics. On the other hand, with the par- improve the interface structure more eectively than incor-
ticle size reducing, there exit many uneven atom steps porating SF. So, using a small amount of NS can enhance
which increase chemical reaction area [17]. For this rea- the durability and the mechanical properties of cement-
son, the nano-meter particles, such as NS, have high sur- based materials.
face energy; and atoms in the surface have a high activity,
which leads the atoms to react on outer ones easily. Con- 5. Conclusions
sequently, the pozzolanic activity of NS at early ages is
higher than that of SF. The following conclusions may be drawn from the ob-
The mechanisms that addition of NS has dierent ef- tained experimental data:
fects on the properties of the cement paste, as compared
with addition of SF, can be illustrated as follows. When (1) Both nano-SiO2 and silica fume are in the amorphous
a material with high specic surface is added to cement state.
or concrete, it acts as the micro-ller of the cement parti- (2) The inuence of nano-SiO2 and silica fume on consis-
cles, which can reduce the amount of water that lled in tency and setting time are dierent. Nano-SiO2 makes
the void of the blending materials. However, replacing ce- cement paste thicker and accelerates the cement
ment with a high specic surface material would increase hydration process.
the wettable surface area and the amount of water ad- (3) Compressive strengths of hcp increase with increasing
sorbed. Thus, the nal water requirement will depend on the nano-SiO2 content, especially at early ages. How-
which of the two above-mentioned factors will be supe- ever the strengths of hcp decrease slightly with
rior. With replacement of less than 5% in this paper, the increasing the silica fume content at early ages, but
former factor may be superior for SF. But the later factor increase at later ages.
may be superior for NS, due to the very high specic sur- (4) Bond strengths of pasteaggregate interface incorpo-
face area of the nano-meter sized particles, which would rating NS are higher than those of control sample
increase greatly the wettable surface area and the amount CO and than those incorporating SF. With increasing
of water adsorbed. Thus addition of NS can make cement the NS content, the rate of bond strength increase is
paste thicker. more than that of their compressive strength increase.
Because the specic surface of NS with 160 m2/g is much (5) The pozzolanic activity of nano-SiO2 is much greater
greater than that of SF with 21.5 m2/g, the reaction be- than that of silica fume. Nano-SiO2 consumes CH
tween SiO2 and Ca(OH)2 shows dierences between the ce- crystals, decreases the orientation of CH crystals,
ment paste incorporating NS and that incorporating SF. reduces the size of CH crystals at the interface and
For NS having many unsaturated bonds SiO and improves the interface structure more eectively than
Si in the surface, the reaction process between SiO2 silica fume.
and Ca(OH)2 may be as follows:
BSiO HOH ! BSiOH react quickly 1
Acknowledgements
BSi OH ! BSiOH react quickly 2
BSiOH CaOH2 ! CSH 3 The authors wish to thank the Center of Science Re-
search, Zhejiang University of Technology of China for
For SF having many saturated bonds SiOSi and a
nancial support.
little unsaturated bonds in the surface, the process may
be as follows:
References
BSiOSiB HOH ! BSiOH react slowly 4
[1] Taylor HFW. Nanostructure of CSH: current status. Adv Cem Bas
BSiOH CaOH2 ! CSH 5
Mater 1993;1:3846.
[2] Richardson IG. The nature of the hydration products in hardened
In the cementwater system, the bond SiO of SF is not cement paste. Cem Concr Compos 2000;22:97113.
easy to break down owing to its higher bond energy. The [3] Zhang XZ. Nanostructure of calcium silicate hydrate gels in cement
rst step reaction (Eq. 4) for SF is slower than that (Eq. paste. J Am Ceram Soc 2000;83(10):26004.
Q. Ye et al. / Construction and Building Materials 21 (2007) 539545 545

[4] Richardson IG, Groves GW. Models for the composition and [11] Grandet, J, Ollivier, JP. In: 7th ICCC, vol. 3, VII-63; 1980.
structure of calcium silicate hydrate (CSH) gel in hardened [12] Duval R, Kadri EH. Inuence of silica fume on the workability and
tricalcium silicate pastes. Cem Concr Res 1992;22:1001. the compressive strength of high-performance concretes. Cem Concr
[5] Chatterji S. Comment on mesostructure of calcium silicate hydrate Res 1998;28:53347.
(CSH) gels in Portland cement paste: short-range ordering, [13] Zhang MH, Lastra R, Malhotra VM. Rice-husk ash paste and
nanocrystallinity, and local compositional order. J Am Ceram Soc concrete: some aspects of hydration and the microstructure of the
1997;80(11):295960. interfacial zone between the aggregate and paste. Cem Concr Res
[6] Mitchell DRG, Hinczak I, Day RA. Interaction of silica fume with 1996;26:96377.
calcium hydroxide solutions and hydrated cement pastes. Cem Concr [14] Bentur A, Cohen MD. Eect of condensed silica fume on the
Res 1998;28:157184. microstructure of the interfacial zone in Portland cement mortars. J
[7] Larbi JJ, Fraay ALA, Bijen JM. The chemistry of the pore uid of Am Ceram Soc 1987;70:73843.
silica fume blended cement systems. Cem Concr Res 1990;20:506. [15] Taylor HFW. Cement chemistry. London, UK: Academic Press;
[8] Papadakis Vagelis G. Experimental investigation and theoretical 1990. p. 3057, 3748.
modeling of silica fume activity in concrete. Cem Concr Res [16] Zelic J, Rusic D, Veza D, Krstulovic R. The role of silica fume in the
1999;29:7986. kinetics and mechanisms during the early stage of cement hydration.
[9] Li S, Roy DM, Kumar A. Quantitative determination of pozzolanas Cem Concr Res 2000;30:165562.
in hydrated systems of cement or Ca(OH)2 with y ash or silica fume. [17] Zhang YL, Li CD. Nano-structured technology and nano-structured
Cem Concr Res 1985;15:1079. plastics. Beijing, China: China Light Industry Press; 2002 [in Chinese]
[10] Barnes BD, Diamond S, Dolch WL. Cem Concr Res 1978;8:233. p. 815, 3869.

Potrebbero piacerti anche