Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Volume 3
Prepared for:
Milwaukee Metropolitan
Sewerage District
Prepared by:
in association with
September 2006
PORT WASHINGTON ROAD RELIEF SEWER
Volume 3
Prepared for:
Prepared by:
September 2006
PORT WASHINGTON ROAD RELIEF SEWER
Prepared for:
Prepared by:
November 2005
CONTENTS
REFERENCES ...............................................................................................................11
APPENDICES
i
Appendix C Completed Monitoring Well Construction Forms and Borehole
Abandonment Forms
TABLES
FIGURES
ii
PROJECT OVERVIEW
Introduction
The Milwaukee Metropolitan Sewerage District (MMSD) commissioned Brown and
Caldwell to perform preliminary design of alternatives for mitigation of overflows from
the 39-inch diameter Metropolitan Interceptor Sewer (MIS) in northeastern Milwaukee
County. As part of the design effort, a subsurface investigation was completed. This
report summarizes the results of a study of available historical subsurface information
and the new field investigation and laboratory testing program.
The exploration program was conducted to investigate subsurface conditions along two
alignments, the 27th Street and Milwaukee River Alignments. Shallow, mid-level and
deep tunnel alternates were originally considered, but the shallow soil alternative was
abandoned after review and evaluation of existing geotechnical and as-built information
[Appendix A]. Hence, the exploration plan focused on the remaining mid-level and deep
alternatives.
• Geologic references
• Available MMSD reports on previous subsurface investigations and construction in
the vicinity of the proposed alignments
• Borehole logs for five, new deep borings
• Laboratory test results from selected soil and rock samples
• Installation and monitoring of two new piezometers and monitoring of water levels
• Preliminary evaluation of the rock stratigraphy and groundwater conditions along the
proposed tunnel alignments
• Water well information from local municipalities
This report is primarily intended for use by the MMSD and the project design team. It is
expected that once a recommended alignment has been selected, additional site
investigation work will be conducted.
• North Shore Interceptor, Phase IIA, MMSD Contract No. I36G15 [1]
• North Shore Interceptor, Phase 1, MMSD Contract No. I36G11 [2]
1
• North Side High Level Relief Sewer, MMSD Contract Nos. I48G11, G12, G13, G14,
G15 and As-Builts [3]
• Northeast Side Relief Sewer System East Branch, Contracts 287 and 288. MMSD
Contract No. I45541 and As-Builts for Contract 287 only. [4]
• North Shore Interceptor Phase IIA Lining Report No. 2. [5]
• Rust/Harza, 2002, Estabrook Parkway and Glendale Avenue Relief Project, Design
Contract CO48DE001 Alternative Analysis [6]
• Published literature on local geology and soil properties [7, 10, 11]
• Records of residential and high capacity city wells from the City of Glendale
• Geologic maps of the North Shore Interceptor, Phase II tunnel
The borings were surveyed to determine state plane coordinates and ground surface
elevations. These data are shown on the boring logs and in Table 1. Elevations are
reported in terms of the MMSD datum, which is the same as Milwaukee City datum.
2
Lo
Port Washington Road Relief Sewer
Sugar Ln W
Seneca Ave N
gv
ie
Lo m
w
b ar
Fairchild Cir dy R
D
PS0502
d
rN
Range Line Rd W Service Rd
Boring Locations 70509
Te uto
Be
Crestwood Blvd N
Rochelle Ave W
Bethmaur Ln N
Beech Tree Rd N
r
Green Tree Rd W Greentree Rd
wy
Bernar d Ln W Green Tree Rd N
Geotechnical Boring Location
n
nA
ia S e
Valanna Ct W
CA-3
ve
Sanitary Sewer Overflow Location
N
rvice
Foxdale Rd
DC0406
Ne il Pl N
Ironwood Ln N
Proposed Workshaft
Glen Sh or
Elm Tree Rd N
W
Seville Ave N
Yates Rd
Vera Ave
D ri
BS0404
Reynard Rd
Suelane Ave W
ve A v
Dropshaft
Sid n
Braeburn Ln N
Da rien St
Proposed Dropshaft
e
eN
y Pl
Dr N
Green Tree Rd W
Proposed Ventilation Shaft
N
P kw y
43
N
Daphn e Rd W Coventry Ct
Pump Station
R d)
Ct
43
Ap ple Tr ee
lly
Rd W
Diversion Chamber
(P a rk
Ho
Daphne Rd W Daphne Rd W
Ke
n
Elm Tree Rd N
Milwaukee River Storage Relief Sewer Mo u
Braebur n Ln N
tA
Sid
Birch Hill Ct
rN
nt
Riv er
Bethmaur Ln N
Range Line Rd N
Elm St W R o ya
Rd
ve
lD
l Rd
ne
N
Crestwood Blvd N
W
MIS
ah
ne
Sun ny Poin t Ln N
yP
Apple Tree Rd W
Ri
Ct
Ap p le
ke e
ph
Santa Monica Blvd
ve
Tr e e
At
r
Ci
lN
er ta
Da
R
Collector
rR
dW
Milwa u
r
so
Acacia Rd W
d
Al b
i nd
Cedar Ridge Ln N
N
Acacia Rd
ISS
Sunn y Point Rd N
Clover nook Ln W
Alberta Ct N
Brantwood Ave W
Garden Grove Ln N
Rd N
Hyacinth Ln N
0 500 1,000 2,000
Figure 1
Glenhills Ct W
Bittersweet Ln W
W
Su nset Ln
El m Tree
d
il l
R Feet
Mil w
School Rd
Te uto
Mill Rd W
Fa irfi
au
eld C
DC0409
n
N
t W
ke e
ia A ve
Riv e
Lydell Ave N
Lake Dr
N
r
(P a rk
CA-2
Berkeley Blvd N
Bender Rd W
R d)
Devon St E
Bender Rd W
Bridgewood Ln N
P kw
Port Washington Rd
Park Rd N
Lake Ter E
Camden Rd W Monrovia Ave W
y
Monrovia Ave W
Flint Rd N
Monrovia Ave E
Baker Rd N
Pa rk Rd N
ve W
la ir e A
Sunny Point Rd N
Florist Ave W Florist Ave W Mo n tc Montclair Ave E
Si d
Berkeley Blvd N
Kent Ave N
yPne
Wren Ave W M
35th St N
ar
lN
ne Belle Ave E
w Dr W
Shorelan d Ave N
Bobolink Ave W e
Av Riv er vi
Maitland Ct N
Glen Park Rd N
Ct W
32 n d
e
W r e sa
d
Wi
eR
Oriole Dr W Civic Dr Th e
tte
St N
34th St N
g
27th St N
nta
Day Ave E
Ln
Ar g y
rN
Fr o
Am e
Carmen Ave W
N
Co
tD
33rd St N
W
le
m A ve Carlisle Ave E
le t
s
Pl N
or
re s
A ve
Av Ar b
ico
A ve
Fo
nN
e
W Lakeview Ave E
W
Si evers
Av
Ln N
Pa
N
er
ea
Thurston Ave W
h
Riv
r ad
CA-1
ig
/J
le
Ra
t
i se
Beaumont Ave E
Su n se
BS0514 43
Reichert Pl W Kendall Ave W Ih -
LnN
Mohawk Ave N
Ct W
33rd St N
34th St N
De
Birch Ct W
Birch
xte
Iroquois Ave N
27th St N
12th St N
Ne
r
Sheridan Ave W
13th St N
Shoreland Ave N
Sheridan Ave W
Av
Shasta Pl N
il
25th St N
eN
Pl
Birch Ave E
W
Lo
19th St N
Kinzie St W
n g
Diversey Blvd N
Navajo Ave N
Is l
24 th St N
Custer Ave W
N
nd
Le xin
te r L n
g to n A
Dr
Custer Ave W ve W
33rd St N
Lawn Ave W
N
Kent Ave N
Lawn Ave W
Hollywood Ave N
a
Iro nw oo d
Iroquois Ave N
28th St N
DC0508
26th St N
29th St N
Ln
Villa rd
A ve W Henry Clay St E
Dr M a
19th St N
Eggert Pl W
BS0505
rt
Eggert Pl W
in L u th
20th St N
Lancaster Ave E
19th Pl N
19th St N
Lancaster Ave W
e
23rd St N
r Kin g
Colfax Pl W
33rd St N
DC0507
31st St N
Ca Fairmount Ave W M
Jr Dr
m Fairmount Ave W ar
er ne
on
30th St N
22nd St N
Av
Av
25th St N
e e Chateau Pl E
W W
Stark St W Chateau Ave W
20th St N
31st St N
21st St N
27th St N
Navajo Ave N
Stark St W
Linwal Ln W
DC0509/BS0504
24th Pl N
d
DC0504
18th St N
kR
P ar
ar k
26th St N
P
c ol n
Li n
22nd St N
23rd St N
W
34th St N
NS-2 i ls
on
Courtland Ave W Pl W Dr
32nd St N
Ro ck
Pa r
N
Pu r
kwa
du e
BS0516
31st St N
St Eula Ct W
y
W
A ve
Port Washington Rd N
35th St N
Glendale Ave W
29th St N
N
24th St N
23rd St N
26 th S
24th Pl N
BS0515 DC0503
20th St N
21st St N
22nd St N
tN
Ruby Ave W
Deluxe Pkwy W
Ho p
25 t
eW
Law ren ce Av Cornell St W
kin s
h
26 th
St N
27th St N
St N
NS-3
W Estabrook Blvd
26th St N
Congress St W Dr
e lt
St N
ev
os
15th St N
14th St N
19th Pl N
19th St N
18th St N
17th St N
16th St N
Ro
35th St N
13th St N
h Pl
24 t
Hemlock Rd W
Mohawk Rd N
Skyline Ln
Bell Rd
Port Washington Road Relief Sewer
Rd
Seneca Rd
Crossway Rd
Navajo Rd
Daisy Ln W
Skyline Rd W
Lo ng acre
27th Street Alignment:
38th St N
Pheasant Ln
Fa irla ne Ave
River Rd N
Boring Locations
The Mall
Lake Dr
Pierron A ve N
Dr N
Geotechnical Boring Location
W aysid e
Range Line Rd N
Lom
Gr
Rd
Y a te s
Sanitary Sewer Overflow Location PP
ee
Navajo Ave N
Te u to
bar
nB
Proposed Workshaft
dy
a
Seneca Ave N
yA
n
Sugar Ln W
Rd
ia S e
32n
Dropshaft PS0502
ve
3 7 th
3 8 th
Fairchild Cir
70509
N
rvic e
Beech Tree Rd N
D ri ve
Bethmaur L n N
Braeburn Ln N
Kiley Ave W Bernar d Ln W Green Tree Rd N Greentree Rd
Ct W
Pump Station Valanna
d
Av e
a B lv
Edward Ln W
Ironw ood Ln N
Da Edward Ln W
W
DC0406
Foxdale Rd
Diversion Chamber
Elm Tree Rd N
r
M o n ic
Seville A ve N
ie
Rey nard Rd
n Vera A ve W
S
BS0404
S id n
tN
27th Street Storage Relief Sewer Suelane A ve W
Yates Rd
S a n ta
ey P
Collector
43
Daphn e Rd W Coventry Ct
ISS
Ct
43
l ly
Apple Tree Rd W
Ho
Daphne Rd W Daphne Rd W
Birch Hill Ct
S id
rN
Daphne Rd
0 Elm 500
St W 1,000 2,000
Figure 2
Crestwood B lvd N
Braeburn Ln N
ney
lD
N
ah
Ct
Ri
Apple Tree Rd W Apple Tree Rd
KiehnauFeet
Pl N
ve
e r ta
A ve W At
rR
Cedar Ridge Ln N
d
Acacia Rd W
A lb
Sunn y Point Rd N
N
Acacia Rd
Alberta Ct N
Garden Grove Ln N
Clover nook Ln W
Hyacinth Ln N
Brantwood A ve W
WA-2 DC0409
Bittersweet Ln W
Su nset Ln
Fa irfi
e ld C t
N
W
n
Lydell Ave N
ia A ve
Lake Dr
Glen River Rd W
N
Berkeley Blvd N
Douglas Ave W
Bender Rd W Devon St E
Bridgew ood Ln N
Lake Hill Ct E
A lb e
Pa rk Rd N
rta L
36th St N
Sunny Point Rd N
nN
37th St N
ney
35th St N
Wren A ve W M
ar
Pl N
ne
Dr W Belle Ave E
Glen P ark Rd N
Maitland Ct N
Shore Dr N
Bobolink Ave W Av ie w
32n
Rive rv
d
e
eR
34th St N
Shorela nd Ave N
d St
Oriole Dr W
itte
Civic Dr
ta g
A rg y
Ln
Day Ave E
r on
N
Am
N
Carmen Ave W C
N
Dr
tF
le A
om
es A
Pl N
Carlisle Ave E
le
st
o
ico
A or e
W
ve
nN
e
S ie ve rs
rF
t Ln N
W
Pa
Av
Lakeview Ave E
W
ea
ra d
gh
Lasalle Ave W
Ri v
ei
/J
i se
l
S u n se
BS0514
Beaumont Ave E
Ra
43
Ih -
N
Marlb oroug h Dr N
Danbury Rd N
Silver Spring Dr W
Mohawk Ave N
Silver Spring Dr W
13th St N
11th St N
32nd St N
34th St N
33rd St N
31st St N
De
Iroquois Ave N
x
27th St N
Shoreland Ave N
te r
12th St N
25th St N
Ne
Shasta Pl N
Av
i lP
Birch Ave E
eN
19th St N
20th St N
Lo
38th St N
lW
Navajo Ave N
24 th St N
Isl
an
Hollywood Ave N
d
g to n
Dr
A ve
33rd St N
Custer A ve W W
Lawn A ve W Lawn A ve W
N
Iro nw oo d
Lexington Blvd E
Kent Ave N
34th St N
Rohr Ave W
29th St N
26th St N
Ln
V il la rd
A ve W
Dr M a
BS0505
rtin L u
Eggert P l W
Lancaster Ave W
WA-1
20th St N
th e
DC0507
r K in g
33rd St N
Colfax Pl W
19th St N
38th St N
M
28th St N
Fairmount A ve W
22nd St N
ar
J r Dr
ne
30th St N
29th St N
Av
e
W Chateau P l E
NS-2
20th St N
19th Pl N
27th St N
25th St N
Stark St W Chateau A ve W
Stark St W
Linwal Ln W DC0509/BS0504
24th Pl N
21st St N
DC0504
Hampton A ve W
22nd St N
Idlewild Ave N
23rd St N
Ho p
34th St N
k in
32nd St N
36th St N
s St
lW
Pa
P
Ro c k
31st St N
rk w
Pu
N
rd u
18t
ay
e
BS0516
St Eula Ct W
W
hS
Av
35th St N
29th St N
eN
Glendale Ave W
t
24th St N
N
23rd St N
24th Pl N
2 6 th S
30th St N
DC0503
28th St N
20th St N
22nd St N
21st St N
BS0515
tN
Cornell St W
At
ki
20th St N
n so
15th St N
14th St N
e
Cong ress St W
19th St N
18th St N
17th St N
16th St N
19th Pl N
NS-3
35th St N
St
W
13th St N
N
St
th
Pl
th
26
th
25
24
Table 1
Summary of Boring Elevations
Preliminary Geotechnical Investigation
Port Washington Road Relief Sewer
Top of Piezometer
Surface
Casing Elevation
Boring No. Elevation (Feet,
(Feet, MMSD
MMSD Datum)
Datum)
Terracon, Inc. using a CME-750 rubber-tired, all-terrain drill rig, completed the borings.
Drilling inspection and initial soil classification was done principally by a technician,
assisted by a geologist, both of HNTB.
The borings at shaft locations (WA-2, WA-2, CA-3) were sampled at 5-foot intervals in
the soil. Piezometers were also established in the rock at these locations. The rock was
cored using double-tube HQ wireline equipment and water return in general accordance
with ASTM D2113, Standard Practice for Diamond Core Drilling and Site Investigation.
The core was removed from the core barrel and laid out in a trough. The field technician
then measured the core and established core recovery and Rock Quality Designation
(RQD), which he then recorded on the inside lid of the core box. The core was also
photographed in the core box before daily transfer to the MMSD core storage and logging
facility. A geologist subsequently logged the cores. The logging included a detailed
lithologic description of the core and descriptions of significant discontinuities, such as
faults, bedding and joints. Mechanical breaks were identified and the RQD adjusted
accordingly. After the draft logs were produced, a senior geologist checked the lithologic
descriptions and formation boundaries.
Soil samples were obtained using a split-barrel sampler driven according to ASTM
D1586 Standard Method for Penetration Test and Split-Barrel Sampling of Soils.
The soil samples were placed in appropriately labeled seal top glass jars and transported
to the MMSD storage facility. Subsequently, a geotechnical engineer checked the soil
classifications made by the field technician.
All of the rock portions of the borings were water pressure tested using four pressure
increments: 25 psi, 50 psi, 75 psi, 25 psi again. The double packer pressure tests were
conducted for 20-foot depth increments from the bottom of the borehole upwards.
The field technician observed the drilling and completed the appropriate field logs for
both rock and soil. He also recorded the data from the water pressure testing conducted
in the rock, the details of the piezometer, placement and recorded standing water levels in
the boreholes and piezometers.
3
Groundwater Measurement and Borehole Abandonment
During drilling, the field technician noted the presence of inflows, or wet conditions, in
the boreholes while drilling and sampling in the soil and loss or gain of drill water return
while in the rock. Standing water levels were recorded in the boreholes when possible.
Piezometers were constructed in boreholes WA-1 and WA-2 to sense the piezometric
level within the rock. The levels recorded are noted on the borehole logs and presented
in Table 2. Copies of completed Monitoring Well Construction Forms, as required by the
Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (WDNR), are included in Appendix C.
Piezometric water levels should be recorded periodically in the final design phase and the
piezometers specified for abandonment under the construction contract after use in the
construction phase.
The drilling crew backfilled and abandoned the remaining boreholes in accordance with
WDNR regulations. Because of artesian conditions in boring CA-2 (water level
approximately 11 feet above the ground surface), an inflatable packer was inserted in the
rock to cut-off the upward flow and allow grouting of the borehole. Copies of the
completed borehole abandonment forms are included in Appendix C.
The packer test set-up consisted of two inflatable packers enclosing a 20-foot piece of
perforated steel pipe through which water was introduced from the surface under
pressure. The test zone was tested at gauge pressures of 25, 50, 75 and subsequently 25
psi. Using these data, the permeability (hydraulic conductivity) was calculated for each
pressure increment and reported in cm/sec. Using the approach suggested by Houlsby [9]
which compares the trend of volume of water take for each pressure increment, a
representative value of permeability was selected and recorded on the boring logs. The
pressure test data and the values of permeability calculated are presented in Appendix D.
The field technician visually examined in the field the recovered Standard Penetration
Test (SPT) samples to initially classify the samples in accordance with the Unified Soil
Classification System (USCS) as described in the HNTB Field Manual. After
examination, the soils were placed in glass jars with moisture-proof lids and labeled. The
sample jars were transported to the MMSD storage facility where a geotechnical engineer
examined them, the soil classifications were verified and laboratory test samples selected
for testing. The soil testing was done by Terracon and consisted of moisture contents,
unconfined compression, Atterberg Limit tests and unit weight measurement on the
cohesive soil samples. Grain size analysis tests were done on selected granular soil
samples. The results of some of the soil test results are shown on the logs. All of the soil
test results are presented in Appendix E.
4
Table 2
Summary of Piezometric and Standing Water Elevations
Preliminary Geotechnical Investigation
Port Washington Road Relief Sewer
Date
Boring/Piezometer No. 10/7/2004 10/15/2004 12/15/2004
WA-1 Piezometer
-42.53 -41.78 -42.30
Groundwater Elevation
WA-2B Piezometer
---- 65.77 70.82
Groundwater Elevation
CA-1 Open Borehole
---- ---- -10.95
Groundwater Elevation
CA-3 Open Borehole
---- 47.18 ----
Groundwater Elevation
Exploration Plan
The initially conceived exploration plan focused on the Milwaukee River Alignment.
After review of existing geologic data and the results of flow tests in existing facilities, it
was decided to explore the 27th Street alignment as well. Hence, the originally planned
borings were spread over two alignments, two on the 27th Street Alignment and three on
the Milwaukee River Alignment. The rationale was that this exploration data, coupled
with existing geologic data, would be sufficient to characterize the alignment for the
purpose of confirmation of the general stratigraphy, ground water conditions, soil
conditions and top of rock at potential shaft sites. Once a preferred alignment has been
selected and the required tunnel storage capacity decided upon, additional borings may be
drilled during this preliminary phase.
Soil Conditions
The characteristics of the soils along the two alignments are most important at the
potential shaft sites. Therefore, soil sampling was only conducted at these sites in
borings WA-1, WA-2 and CA-3. This report does not provide detailed soil descriptions
at these shaft locations because they are preliminary.
The thickness of soil at boreholes WA-1, WA-2 and CA-3 was 124.0, 59.4 and 46.5 feet.
Appendix A provides a compilation of soil and rock tunneling experience and geologic
conditions in the project area.
Rock Conditions
Bedrock Topography
The bedrock topography in the study area is formed by the Milwaukee, Thiensville,
Waubakee and Racine Formations [Refer to Figure 4, Appendix A]. Tunneling
experience has shown that where Devonian Age rocks form the top of rock, topographical
relief of tens of feet over plan distances of 100 feet of the bedrock surface is common.
There are indications of a bedrock valley broadly extending from 27th Street and Villard
Avenue to the east northeast, encompassing borings WA-1, CA-1 and CA-2. This
bedrock valley is likely fault controlled and will be discussed further below.
5
The five borings drilled during this exploration phase [see Appendix B for boring logs]
on the Milwaukee River and 27th Street Alignments all penetrated to approximately 20
feet below the proposed tunnel inverts (refer to Figures 3 and 4) respectively. The
thickness of the soil and rock formations encountered is presented in Table 3. Note that
the Milwaukee Formation was not present at any of the boring locations and that soil
depths ranging from 124 to 144.5 feet thick at borings WA-1, CA-1 and CA-2 indicate a
bedrock valley trending east northeast across the project area. The lithology of the rock
formations encountered is described on the boring logs and conforms generally to that
previously encountered in prior MMSD exploration borings [Appendix A].
Thiensville Formation
The Thiensville Formation formed the top of rock at boreholes WA-2 and CA-3 at the
north end of each alignment. These are the probable locations of workshafts and/or
dropshafts. The formation consists of solutioned limestones with very soft to moderately
hard mudstone, siltstone and calcareous sandstone interbeds, the whole being moderately
to severely weathered. Refer to Table 4 for the ranges of core recovery, defined as the
percentage of core recovered from a given core run length. Also, the Rock Quality
Designation (RQD), defined as the percentage of total length of pieces of core greater
than four inches in length in a given core run length.
The contact between the Thiensville Formation and the underlying Waubakee Formation
is an unconformity. A relief of eight feet in 500 feet was recorded on this unconformity in
an 8-foot diameter rock tunnel further west on N. 43rd Street.
Waubakee Formation
The Waubakee Formation was encountered in borings WA-2, CA-1, CA-2 and CA-3
with thickness ranging from 43.2 to 89.7 feet and formed the top of rock at borings CA-1
and CA-2. The formation generally consists of very thin to thinly bedded dolomite with
thin, alternating brown and light and dark gray bands. The typical bedding plane parting
is very thin shale across which the core readily separates, giving a smooth planar surface.
In borehole CA-1, bedding dips of 10 to 12 degrees, very frequently with clay infill, were
noted. The bedding dip is likely due to the presence of a nearby reef in the Racine
Formation over which the Waubakee beds have draped, creating inclined flank beds.
Refer to Table 4 for ranges of core recovery and RQD. The RQD was likely reduced
when the core was removed from the barrel because of its propensity to part readily as
previously described.
Racine Formation
The Racine Formation was encountered in all five borings in thicknesses ranging from
75.8 to 187.4 feet and forms the top of rock at boring WA-1. The formation generally
consists of fine-grained, thin to medium bedded dolomite with argillaceous partings on
bedding planes, stylolite zones and is slightly to moderately weathered.
An artesian flow condition was intercepted in this formation during the drilling of run
number 27 [depth increment 227.5 to 236 feet] in borehole CA-2. The head above the
6
Table 3
Thickness of Soil and Rock Formations at Boring Locations
Preliminary Geotechnical Investigation
Port Washington Road Relief Sewer
Boring No.
Thickness (feet)
WA-1 WA-2B CA-1 CA-2 CA-3
Soil 126.5 59.4 130.5 144.5 46.5
Thiensville
---- 29.1 ---- ---- 67.3
Formation
Waubakee
---- 55.7 89.7 43.2 66.7
Formation
Racine Formation 126.2 178.1 76.1 114.3 113.5
Waukesha
47.8 16.7 ---- ---- ----
Formation
Total Depth (Feet) 300.5 339.0 296.3 302.0 294.0
Waukesha Formation
Because the planned tunnel will intersect with the existing North Shore Phase II Tunnel,
the geologic information from borings and geologic tunnel maps will be used for the rock
mass characterization in this study. To facilitate the use of this information, it was
decided to conform to the same criteria used for selecting the boundary between the
Racine and Waukesha Formations; the principal criterion being the first appearance of
chert.
The Waukesha Formation was encountered in borings WA-1 and WA-2 with partial
thicknesses (bottom of formation not encountered) of 39.7 and 6.6 feet respectively. The
formation generally consists of thinly bedded, fresh to slightly weathered dolomite, with
frequent chert nodules and few stylolites. Refer to Table 4 for the range of core recovery
and RQD.
Bedrock Structure
Relevant generalized descriptions of the rock structure at the proposed tunnel depth are
presented in the Geotechnical Report for the North Shore Phase II Tunnel [1] and Lining
Report No. 2 [5] for this tunnel. Sections from this report discussing pertinent aspects of
the geology, water inflow and construction experience are presented in Appendix A.
Because joint spacing orientation and their detailed characteristics are more readily
obtained during tunnel mapping than from vertical borings, these parameters will be
reproduced here from Lining Report No. 2.
The majority of faults and joints observed in the North Shore Phase II Tunnel
belong to two joint sets. Based on the geological mapping of the entire tunnel,
the mean orientation of the two sets are: strike N47 W, dip 89 NE; and strike
N41 E, dip 89 NW.
True joint spacings (measured perpendicular to joint strike) are shown below:
Joint filling characteristics for the Phase IIA tunnel are tabulated below.
7
Joint Filling
Clay Shale Silt Mineralized Unfilled
Characteristics
Mean Width
0.13 0.02 0.06 0.04 0.01
(ft)
NE Occurrence
16 18 14 7 30
(%)
More than one-third of the discontinuities are mapped as faults. The sole
geologic criterion used to identify features as faults is evidence of
displacement of the 162 faults; about three-quarters of them have widths of
less than 0.1 foot. Sixteen of the faults have widths 0.1 to 0.5 foot and 26 of
the faults have widths greater than 0.5 foot. A shear zone located at station
361+65 has a width of about 10 feet. Most of the observed faults have
apparent vertical displacement less than one foot. Less than 10% of the faults
have displacements greater than one foot, with the maximum displacement
being about 15 feet.
The adjacent as-built geologic profiles (Figures 8 & 9, Appendix A) is in the East-West
direction and shows the formation boundaries dipping downwards towards the east as
expected, at about 76 feet per mile. Also noted in the tunnel geologic maps are a series of
fault zones in between stations 405+40 and 400+43, a distance of about 500 feet. The
tunnel maps indicate the following fault zones:
Station 404+20 to 405+20; 11 faults trending northeast with offsets up to 10 feet and
up to two feet gouge width.
8
Station 402+50 to 402+73; four faults trending northeast with offsets up to 2.2 feet
and up to two feet gouge width.
Station 401+76 to 402+10; three faults trending northeast with offsets up to 1.6 feet
and up to three feet gouge width.
Station 400+43 to 401+00; five faults trending northeast with offsets on one fault of
15 feet, another to 15 feet and gouge thickness to 1.5 feet.
The total tunnel inflow at the time of mapping (do not know how long after initial
excavation) from station 400+25 to 405+50 was 313 gpm. The ground was supported
with the design pattern of rock dowels, additional dowels, wire mesh, minestraps and
rolled channel pieces. No steel sets were placed in the 19.5 foot excavated diameter
tunnel.
It is believed that these North-East trending fault zones bound a series of blocks which
have been progressively displaced downwards on the north side of the fault zone.
Additional evidence is provided on Figure 3, the 27th Street Geologic Profile, where an
offset of the Racine-Waukesha Formation boundary of about 95 feet is observed between
boreholes I30-02-NS and WA-1, a distance of about 3,200 feet in a North-South
direction, i.e., generally along the regional strike and therefore expected to be sub-
horizontal to horizontal. Similarly, on Figure 4, the Milwaukee River Geologic Profile,
an offset of about 80 feet is observed in the Waubakee-Racine Formation boundary
between boreholes I30-NS-AL-11 and CA-1, a distance of about 5,800 feet in a North-
South direction. An offset in the same boundary (except upwards) of about 50 feet is
observed between boreholes CA-1 and CA-2, a distance of about 3,500 feet.
Subsequently, the boundary is almost horizontal between boreholes CA-2 and CA-3.
This reversal of the fault throw direction indicates a graben effect, with blocks displaced
progressively downwards towards the north and then the sequence reversed with the
blocks stepping upwards.
Further evidence of this fault zone is the deep, broad bedrock valley which appears to
trend east- northeast and encompasses borings WA-1, CA-1 and CA-2. The faulting
previously discussed is most likely a significant contributory cause to the formation of
the bedrock valley due to preferential weathering and glacial scouring.
Groundwater
Water Wells
Groundwater occurs in the post-glacial and glacial soils and in the bedrock. High
capacity industrial wells are present (Table 3, Appendix A) in the study area; however,
their operating status has yet to be ascertained. Shallow domestic wells developed in the
near-surface soils also exist (Tables 2 and 3, Appendix A) and may still be used for lawn
watering.
9
Bedrock Groundwater
The principal storage and means of transfer of groundwater in the Silurian dolomites are
the discontinuities, such as bedding, joints and fault systems. Solutioning of these
features provides greater capacity for storage and higher initial inflows when intercepted
in tunnels. Experience in deep rock MMSD tunnels shows generally that when not
overlain by the Thiensville Formation (a major aquifer), the inflows diminish rapidly
with time as storage is depleted. Conversely, when overlain by the Thiensville
Formation, such as in the North Shore Phase 1 tunnel, inflow rates were high and did not
attenuate rapidly. Solutioned openings, such as pipes yielding high inflows, were also
encountered in the Racine Formation in this tunnel [11].
Water pressure testing was conducted in all of the rock portions of the boreholes as
described in Field and Laboratory Testing Programs. The calculated permeability (used
interchangeably with hydraulic conductivity in this report) values are presented in
Appendix D and selected values are shown at the test depth on the borehole logs. The
tests indicate a range of values in the Silurian dolomites from 1 x 10-7 to 3 x 10-2 cm/sec.
The high values occur at the following locations: 3 x 10-2 cm/sec in the Racine
Formation from 229 to 249 foot depth in Boring CA-2; a value of 3.5 x 10-2 cm/sec for
the depth increment 197 to 237 feet in borehole CA-3. A fault was logged in this depth
increment. Generally, the values for the Silurian dolomites in boreholes WA-1, CA-1,
CA-2 and CA-3 were in the 1 x 10-5 cm/sec and higher range. However, borehole WA-2
has a permeability value of 3.6 x 10-2 cm/sec for depth increment 229 to 249 feet in the
Racine and the remaining values in the range of 3 x 10-3 to 5 x 10-4 cm/sec.
As expected, the Devonian Age Thiensville Formation, which forms the top of rock at
boreholes WA-2 and CA-3, yielded very high permeability values ranging up to 1 x 10-1
cm/sec at borehole CA-3 and up to 1.6 x 10-3 cm/sec at borehole WA-2.
10
REFERENCES
1. North Shore Interceptor, Phase IIA, MMSD Contract No. I36G15
3. North Side High Level Relief Sewer, MMSD Contract Nos. I48G11, G13, G14,
G15 and As-Builts
4. Northeast Side Relief Sewer System East Branch, Contracts 287 and 288. MMSD
Contract No. I45541 and As-Builts for Contract 287 only
7. Singh, P.N., Tatioussian, S.V. and Flagg, C.G., 1983. “A Study of Geotechnical
Properties of Milwaukee Area Soils,” Geologic Environment and Soil Properties,
American Society of Civil Engineers, Geotechnical Special Publication, pp. 269-
30.
9. Houlsby, A.C., 1990. “Construction and Design of Cement Grouting,” pp. 221-
222, J. Wiley & Sons.
11. Pennock, E.S., Fradkin, S.B. and Ilsley, R.C., 1991. “Impacts of Solution
Features on Mining of the North Shore Tunnel in Milwaukee, Wisconsin,” in
Proceedings: Association of Engineering Geologists 34th Annual meeting,
Chicago, pp. 38-47.
11
APPENDIX A
CONTENTS
Introduction.................................................................................................................1
Construction Experience...........................................................................................10
NSHLRS .......................................................................................................10
Section 1............................................................................................10
Section 2............................................................................................10
Encountered Ground Conditions and Excavation Rates...................10
NESRS (Contract 287)..................................................................................11
i
APPENDIX A
INTRODUCTION
The study area is bounded east to west by Lydell Avenue and 43rd Street and north to
south by Green Tree Road and Hampton Avenue. Within the study area, three north to
south corridors have been identified. These are the East Alignment along Lydell Avenue
(equivalent to 1st Street); the Central Alignment along Sunny Point Road (equivalent to
13th Street); and the West Alignment on 27th Street (meeting Hampton Avenue
somewhere between 27th and 32nd Streets).
Because of the relative lack of tunnel construction experience along the East Alignment
and the likely similarities in the soil and rock conditions, the East and Central Alignments
will be described together. The West Alignment merits a separate discussion. The
sources of information used are the Geotechnical Reports and As-Built Reports as listed
below. The locations of these project alignments are shown in Figure 1 (Appendix A).
• North Side High Level Relief Sewers, or NSHLRS, (Contracts I48G11, G12, G13,
G14, G15); Geotechnical Report and As-Builts
• Northeast Side Relief Sewer System East Branch, or NESRS, (Contracts 287 & 288
[I45541]); Geotechnical Report and As-Built for Contract #287 only
• North Shore Interceptor—Phase IIA Main Tunnel Grouting (Contract I36G15);
Tunnel Maps only
• North Shore Interceptor (Contracts I36G11, 12, 13, 21, 22, 23, 24, 31, 32, 33, 34, 51,
42, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 61, 62, 63, 64); Geotechnical Report
Physiography
The following is from the NSHLRS Geotechnical Report:
1
Soil
The following discussion is from the NSHLRS Geotechnical Report. The alignment is
shown in Figure 2 (Appendix A). The following sections are referenced in the text:
Section 1, Station 0+00 at Dropshaft NS-3 to Station 45+00 at Port Washington Road;
Section 2, Station 45+00 to Station 116+00 at 24th Street.
The lacustrine clays and clay till soils are typically found to be in a
stiff to hard condition. The latter soil type extends to the bedrock
surface, which occurs at depths of 8 to 30 feet below grade, generally
increasing to the north.
The soil conditions of Section 2 include four major soil types. The
surficial soils, extending to depths in the range of 5 to 10 feet, are fill
materials of variable composition and density. In the general area of Lincoln
Park, the fill is typically underlain, in order, by strata of silty sand alluvium
and silty clay of lacustrine origin. The sandy soils, a postglacial deposit, are
generally in a medium dense condition. The clay soils are generally in a stiff
to very stiff condition. The combined thickness of these soils extend to
approximately elevation 20.0 to 30.0 feet, terminating above the sewer
envelope. Further west in this section, the soils below the surficial fill are
generally postglacial granular alluvium. These soils, extending
approximately to elevations 25.0 to 30.0 feet and including fine, to fine to
coarse sands with variable silt content, are generally in a loose to medium
condition to depths of approximately 15 feet, and medium dense to dense at
greater depth.
2
The following discussion is from the Contract 287 Geotechnical Report. The alignment
is shown in Figure 3 (Appendix A). Of particular interest is the north-south section on
Green Bay Road and Green Tree Road and the east-west section along Green Tree Road
between Green Bay Road and Port Washington Road.
Near the Milwaukee River, extensive alluvial sands and other river bed
deposits should be expected within the glacial sediments. Borings did not
yield samples of this type soil but it is likely that it exists. Groundwater levels
are above the crown in this area.
East of the river, clayey glacial sediments (till 2) predominate. Within these
sediments are extensive deposits of waterlaid stratified drift. These deposits
exhibit varves, or silty layers, which may tend to conduct large amounts of
water. Groundwater east of the river varies from above crown to below the
invert at the eastern extreme of the project.
Rock will be encountered near the beginning and end of the project. Mixed
face conditions govern at transitions. Top of rock may be weathered and
broken. A fault zone is possible at the rock section at the east end of the
project. Groundwater is above the crown in the western rock section and
below the invert in the eastern rock section. Pinnacles of rock may be
encountered between boreholes elsewhere, especially west of the river.
Extreme variability in soil and rock conditions with location should be
expected. Boulders, including possible granite glacial erratics, were not
encountered during exploration but are likely to be found during excavation.
Rock
The predominant bedrock forming the top of rock in the study area consists of the
Milwaukee and Thiensville Formations of Devonian Age. Figure 4 (Appendix A) is from
Reference 1 and is a map showing the extent of the outcrop of the Milwaukee,
Thiensville and Waubakee Formations. Below the Waubakee and increasing in age are
the Racine, Waukesha and Mayville Formations. However, the Mayville will not be
intercepted in the East and Central Alignments. Table 1 of Appendix A (Table 3-6 Area
Stratigraphic Section) shows the thicknesses of the formations and Figure 5 (Appendix
A) is a geologic section of the North Shore Phase II tunnel in the east-west direction,
generally along Hampton Avenue until about Station 405+00 where the tunnel turns due
south beneath 32nd Street and terminates at NS-12 Dropshaft at Capitol Drive. The
3
following rock formation descriptions are from the North Shore Interceptor Geotechnical
Report.
Milwaukee Formation
The Milwaukee Formation has been subdivided into units based upon
differences in lithology. The Milwaukee 1 (Mil-1) unit is a green, soft,
pyritiferous mudstone that slakes or breaks down rapidly when immersed in
water (Appendix B). It forms the bedrock surface at the Humboldt Yards
access shaft site. The bedding plane spacings are predominantly close. The
Milwaukee 2 (Mil-2) unit is a greenish, gray argillaceous dolomite that
becomes highly argillaceous towards the base. It forms the bedrock surface
at Sites NS-7, NS-6 and NS-5. The Milwaukee 3 (Mil-3) unit is generally a
greenish gray, moderately soft to hard, occasionally very soft dolomitic
mudstone with close to medium bedding and is not susceptible to slaking
(Appendix B). The Milwaukee 4 (Mil-4) unit is a greenish gray, hard,
argillaceous dolomite, with close to medium bedding and occasional thin clay
partings. It forms the bedrock surface at the sites of dropshafts NS-3, NS-8
and NS-11 and the Schlitz Terminal access shaft.
Thiensville Formation
The Thiensville Formation consists of interbedded dolomites and limestones
with occasional mudstone beds. The dolomite beds vary from brown
(generally bituminous) to gray and from slightly to highly weathered. The
limestone beds are weathered and solutioned. A weakly cemented, breccia
has been noted principally at the base of the formation, but occasionally
above the base. It consists of angular fragments of dolomite and limestone in
a silty clay matrix.
Tunnel mapping in local projects and cores from this project indicate that the
lower part of the Thiensville Formation is weathered. Mapping in MMSD
Contracts 289 and 867 north of the North Shore Interceptor site revealed that
various beds were subaerially weathered before the deposition of overlying
beds. The degree of weathering ranged from moderate to high. One of the
features mapped was a 50-foot long crevice filled with rock debris and
cemented by secondary calcite. Boring evidence of weathering includes high
core loss and weathered samples.
The contact between the Thiensville Formation and the underlying Waubakee
Formation is an unconformity. The bedding above and below the
unconformity are essentially parallel. Mapping in MMSD tunnel contract 867
indicates that locally the unconformity is an undulating surface with an
amplitude of 1 to 2 feet. The average dip of the unconformity appears to be
parallel to the dip of the adjacent formations. Borehole pressure testing of the
unconformity and the adjacent Waubakee formation resulted in permeability
calculations as high as 2x10-3 cm/sec. This indicates that the unconformity
could yield high groundwater inflows.
4
Waubakee Formation
The Waubakee Formation is a very close to closely bedded dolomite with thin,
alternating brown and light and dark gray bands. The typical bedding plane
parting is very thin shale across which the core readily separates giving
smooth, planar surfaces. Low RQD values generally reflect the presence of
numerous bedding plane partings. The bedding planes are generally
horizontal but dips of up to 25 degrees were measured in core from I30-NS-
MR-4D, about 1,100 feet east of the alignment where the Waubakee Strata are
flank beds on a Racine formation reef.
Racine Formation
The Racine Formation is a uniform, light gray, dense dolomite with bedding
plane spacings that range from close to medium. There are occasional zones
of very closely spaced, thin, shaly partings and rock containing small pores or
vugs.
Waukesha Formation
The Waukesha Formation, generally a dense, gray dolomite, is divided into
three units on the basis of lithologic variations as shown below. Unit WA-1 is
generally dense, very close (less than 0.2 foot) to close (0.2 to 1.0 foot)
bedded, and cherty. Its midportion is typically fossiliferous, finely vuggy and
medium bedded. Unit WA-2 is characterized by the general absence of chert.
The top part is medium to widely bedded with stylolites and is generally
fossiliferous and finely vuggy. The bottom part of the unit is very close to
close bedded with shale partings and is dense. Unit WA-3 is a light gray,
dense dolomite and is very close to close bedded with thin shale partings.
Chert occurs as coarse nodules and layers throughout the unit. Bedding
plane fillings in the Waukesha Formation are predominantly shale and range
up to 0.05 inch in thickness. Most of the other fillings are clay with mean
thicknesses of 0.25 inch in Unit WA-1 and 0.02 inch in Units WA-2 and WA-3.
5
deposits or occasionally sandy and silty lacustrine deposits. The alluvial
aquifers are located in the lowland areas along the valley courses of rivers
and streams. They can be extensive and continuous within those confines.
The glacial aquifers are considerably more widely distributed and indefinitely
defined.
Groundwater flow through the soil aquifers is dependent on their grain size
characteristics, their extent, the degree of confinement provided by
surrounding aquicludes, and their connection to sources of recharge. In
addition, all of the glacial soils may include layers or pockets of permeable
soils that could produce groundwater inflow. Fine-grained deposits of
alluvial and sandy or silty lacustrine soils, such as occur along the Milwaukee
River and Lincoln Creek, have all, on occasion, been observed to loosen in
boreholes when hydraulic pressures were not maintained above in-situ
hydrostatic pressures. This indicates that these soils may become unstable
even under low hydraulic gradients.
The generally low measured permeability coefficient of the soils indicates that
dewatering by use of gravity wells or vacuum assisted wellpoints would
probably not be effective, except for shallow depth excavations in the more
coarsely grained alluvium along Lincoln Creek.
6
In the area of the C&NW Railroad crossing of the Milwaukee River, which
corresponds to the alignment crossing the river approximately between
stations 69+90 and 71+90, the 10-year flood is estimated to cause a rise in
river level to about elevation 39 feet, and the 100-year flood is estimated to
cause a rise in river level to about elevation 42 feet {12}. In the river channel
areas, groundwater level elevations in the soil are generally about equal to
the surface water levels in the Milwaukee River. In the upland areas,
groundwater levels range up to elevation 75 feet (generally 5 to 15 and
occasionally as deep as 30 feet below ground surface). Water levels
measured in piezometers and observation wells along the North Side High
Level Relief Sewer system are listed in Table 4.
The following discussion is from the Contract 287 Geotechnical Report. Refer to Figure
3 o f Appendix A for the alignment.
West of the Milwaukee River, water level observations indicate full saturation
along the proposed interceptor and a water table configuration consistent
with the general groundwater gradient toward the Milwaukee River. Water
levels vary from near ground surface to about 20 feet below surface.
In general, sand content of Pleistocene deposits is higher and more uniformly
distributed on the west side of the Milwaukee River than elsewhere along the
project. For purposes of evaluating interceptor and shaft dewatering
feasibility, the deposits west of the river should be treated as one
hydrogeologic unit.
East of the Milwaukee River, water levels are generally near tunnel crown
elevations or lower. Depth of water ranges from about 30 feet to about 85
feet below the surface. Ten test borings are dry. The water level in hole EB-
17 appears anomalous. Based on water levels measured in adjacent test
borings and type of material logged in this hole during drilling, it is believed
that the high water elevation measured in boring EB-17 is due to piezometer
construction rather than groundwater conditions.
7
feet to 25 feet above tunnel crown. This data indicates that piezometric levels
in the upper bedrock are at or near the river levels.
The groundwater table was encountered at depths in the range of 2.2 feet to
28.3 feet below present grades. A tabulation of groundwater levels observed
in each of the piezometer/observation well installations along the alignment is
presented in Table 4.
The following general discussion of the Dolomite Aquifer which includes the Devonian
and Silurian Age Formations and applies generally to the existing North Shore Phase II
alignment along Hampton Avenue (refer to Figure 5 of Appendix A). A review of the
packer test data for the exploration borings along the North Shore Phase II alignment
show that for the Waubakee Formation the measured permeability was generally in the
range of 4x10-3 to > 1x10-7 cm/s; and for the Racine and Waukesha Formations generally
in the range of 7x10-5 to > 1x10-7 cm/s. A further evaluation of potential water inflows
during construction will be discussed below based on tunnel mapping of the North Shore
Phase II Tunnel.
8
is not known. The following discussion is from the Contract 287 and 288 Geotechnical
Report.
The total depth of the wells ranges between 73 and 460 feet. The production
zone thickness is reported to be from 4 feet to 292 feet. Although no
correlation was established between length of production zone and well yield,
it seems that wells with long production zones also demonstrate large
drawdowns (or small specific capacities). Well yields at time of completion
ranged from about 7 to 50 gpm.
Few of the domestic wells exhibited confined (or artesian) conditions at time
of completion. No such wells were recorded within two miles of the proposed
tunnel.
The domestic well logs can be used to confirm and verify depth to top of
bedrock in places where test borings did not penetrate bedrock. Well drillers’
logs must be assigned a limited reliability because of the crude mode of well
installation.
Each property along West Green Tree Road (between the Milwaukee River
and Port Washington Road) has its own well. Based on conversations with
home owners in the area, it was determined that these wells have quite
uniform characteristics. Most are about 100 feet in total depth and were
drilled into the upper part of the bedrock. At the time of completion, these
wells yielded between 10 and 30 gpm.
Appendix H of the NSHLRS Geotechnical Report lists wells indicated to exist within
1,000 feet of that alignment. These locations are presented in Tables 2 and 3 of
Appendix A.
9
CONSTRUCTION EXPERIENCE
The following information is derived from the As-Built Profiles for tunnels and
constructed in the study area.
NSHLRS
The NSHLRS was constructed under two separate contracts.
Section 1
Section 1 extends from Station 0+00 at the NS-3 Dropshaft to Station 45+00 at Port
Washington Road and was principally excavated within the Thiensville Formation.
Sections 2, 3 from Station 45+00 to Station 116+00 at 24th Street was the second
contract. Section 1 was excavated to a 10.5 foot diameter using a Robbins Tunnel Boring
Machine (TBM) except for the last (approximately) 200 feet which was excavated by
drill and blast. This was because high water inflows washed the fines out of the mined
rock in the face into the tunnel invert from where it had to be hand-mucked. The
contractor did not attempt to dewater and submitted a claim for an alleged Differing Site
Condition. The peak water inflow experienced was 1100 gpm at Station 7+00. The
mixed face conditions were excavated using a shield with drill and blast.
Section 2
Section 2 from Station 45+00 to 116+00 at 24th Street was excavated at 7.5 feet diameter
using a Lovat TBM equipped with flood doors (can be closed to prevent soil/water
inflow) and “pressure relief gates” which are hydraulically operated gates within the
plenum that are used to control the amount of soil exiting the plenum onto the conveyor.
The system affords good ground control when in poor soil conditions and can be “opened
up” when in good ground conditions. Of the three river crossings, two were made in
open cut and one completed by tunneling under the Milwaukee River, which was 250 feet
wide at this point. The tunnel support throughout was provided by jacked concrete pipe.
From Station 45+00 to 76+00 the finished diameter was seven feet. From 76+00 to
Station 214+00 the finished diameter was six feet.
The excavation for the six-foot diameter jacked pipe tunnel between Station 75+00 to
89+50 (just east of Lincoln Creek Crossing No. 1) encountered principally silty clay,
occasionally soft and wet with a few boulders on one shift. Progress ranged from 7.5 to
90 feet and averaged 47 feet per shift (assumed eight hour shift). The total length of
continuous jacked pipe was 1,160 feet.
10
The section between stations 95+66 to 115+14 at the east side of Lincoln Creek crossing
No. 2, encountered primarily “silty clay” which was “wet” for 57% of the total length of
1,918 feet. The excavation rate ranged from 17.5 to 73 feet with an average of 32.5 feet
per shift. The depth of cover to the tunnel invert averaged about 28 feet.
The 1,258 foot section between stations 119+05 and 131+63 at Villard Avenue and 27th
Street, encountered principally “damp, sticky, silty clay, in lumps:” cobbles and boulders
were encountered over a length of 105 feet (8.5% of length).
The excavation rate ranged from 7.5 to 45 feet and averaged 29 feet per shift. The depth
of cover above the tunnel invert averaged about 22 feet. The occurrence of sticky clay
likely had an adverse affect on tunnel excavation rates. Note that the majority of this
tunnel excavation was completed in the flood plain of the Milwaukee River and Lincoln
Creek at shallow depths up to 42 feet. The soils encountered were silty clay and sandy
clay, with very occasional sands and no gravel and few cobbles and boulders. These soils
are described as “glacial lacustrine deposits” in the project Geotechnical Report.
The following discussion relates to the section of the alignment from Station 34+80 at
Green Bay and Mill Road north along Green Bay Road to the junction with Green Tree
Road at Station 61+50. The tunnel was excavated in Till 1 which is very hard, very
consolidated silt, gravel with cobbles and boulders and virtually dry; it lies directly on the
Thiensville bedrock. Occasionally the overlying Till 2 would dip down into the tunnel.
The Till 2 consisted of either moist clays or wet sand and/or gravel. Excavation rates in
the Till 1 averaged 43 feet and ranged from four to 96 feet per shift (assumed to be eight
hours). At two locations, wet sand and gravel in the crown led to sink holes, the larger
being about 60 feet long and seven feet deep. Ground modification using chemical grout
was done. The tunnel progress was impacted such that over a period of 11 days the
average progress was 15.5 feet and ranged from six to 29 feet.
From Station 61+50 to 75+65 (west of Milwaukee River Crossing) and from 86+90 at N.
River and Green Tree Roads, to station 120+80 at Green Tree and Port Washington
Roads. The tunnel was excavated in Till 1. At two locations, wet sand and gravel was
intercepted that led to major sinkholes, both about 10 feet deep and 70 feet long. Some
chemical grouting of the tunnel ahead of the excavation was done between the sinkholes.
Rock was intercepted in the invert at two locations: one 60 feet, the other 155 feet long.
It appears the TBM was able to excavate through the rock with some blasting. All of the
domestic wells along the section from station 86+90 to 113+00 were dried up by the
project dewatering and were serviced by tanker truck. Excavation rates for 4,800 feet
averaged 70.5 feet per shift and ranged from four to 164 feet per shift.
11
STUDY AREA GEOLOGY—WEST ALIGNMENT
This alignment extends along 27th Street in a northerly direction from Hampton Avenue
between 27th and 32nd Street, to an east-west line of Green Tree Road extended (about the
junction with Vera Street). This alignment has the following differences with the Central
and East Alignments:
• It is the furthest away from the Milwaukee River, Lincoln Creek and their confluence.
• The predominant soils are likely to be Till 1 on bedrock and overlain by Till 2 with
very little recent post-glacial soils.
• The Thiensville Formation forms the TOR and is closer to the ground surface in the
Mill Road vicinity.
• The density of domestic wells decreases, but four highcap wells are shown on Figure
6 of Appendix A.
• The thickness of Thiensville diminishes towards the west and the contact with the
Waubakee Formation is closer to the ground surface as shown in Figure 5 (Appendix
A).
Soil
The following description is from the NSHLRS Geotechnical Report. The alignment is
shown in Figure 2 (Appendix A). Sections 3 and 4 are from Station 116+00 at 24th and
Villard Avenue, north along 24th to Station 214+60 at Mill Road and Sydney Place. The
soils are described as follows:
Glacial lacustrine soils occur below approximately 20.0 to 30.0 feet elevation
throughout Section 2 and will comprise the sewer envelope soil. These soils
generally consist of horizontally laminated clayey silt and silt with occasional
layers of fine sand and silty clay. They are generally in a medium dense
condition (granular soil) or stiff to very stiff condition (cohesive soil). These
lacustrine soils, in particular the silt soil, exhibit a high degree of dilatency
and are considered to be moderately to highly sensitive to disturbance. That
is, they experience a dramatic loss in strength upon remolding and are,
therefore, susceptible to disturbance by construction activities.
Glacial till soils are the predominant soil type in Section 3, extending
approximately from 24th Street to the southernmost crossing of the Soo Line
railroad. Excluding a limited amount of overlying lucustrine and alluvial
soils (as described for Section 2 above) occurring near the east end of Section
3 (refer to borings ULC-13, ULC-13A and ULC-13B) and isolated fill and
topsoil deposits near the surface, the soils of the area are generally moderate
strength, low to moderate plasticity, silty clay. These soils generally exhibit
unconfined compressive strengths in the range of 2 to 3 tsf. Occasional lenses
of lacustrine silt and clayey silt were observed interlayered with the till.
These soils contain a trace of sand and gravel and the occurrence of boulders
12
or cobbles is considered infrequent, none having been encountered in the
borings in this area.
Till soils are also the predominant soil type in the northernmost portion of the
alignment, Section 4. However, two distinctly different till types occur. The
upper portion of the profile (generally extending 20 to 40 feet in depth) is
similar to that described for the preceding section and consists of moderate to
high strength clay till. At greater depth, a second till with texture ranging
from sandy clayey silt to sandy silt occurs. This soil type is characterized by a
much greater sand and gravel fraction and an extremely dense condition.
Boulders and cobbles are known to be prominent in this latter till. The
borings in this section were terminated in this till except boring ULC-22 at the
northern terminus of the Upper Lincoln Creek alignment which encountered
bedrock at a depth of 64 feet.
The Geotechnical Report for Contract 287 NESRS describes the glacial soils along the
alignment between Station 0+00 at Mill Road and Sydney Place and 34+80 at Mill Road
and Green Bay Road as follows:
Till 1 is composed primarily of sand and silt mixtures with random cobbles
and boulders. It is generally found directly above bedrock along most of the
alignment. It is overlain by Till 2. Till 1 is generally gray to gray-brown. It
is a hard, dense soil with a water content lower than that of the overlying soil.
It is assumed that Till 1 is a remnant of the first stages of Wisconsin glaciation
in the region.
Rock
Figure 5 (Appendix A) is the geologic profile of the North Shore Phase II Tunnel which
is generally east-west along Hampton Avenue. At about Station 405+00 the tunnel turns
due south down 34th Street. Also, at Station 405+00 the invert of the tunnel is at the
stratigraphic boundary between the Waukesha Formation overlying the Mayville
Formation. The Racine Formation forms the top of rock. No packer tests were done in
borehole I30-2-NS, the only deep boring at this location. A tunnel bored to the north
along 27th Street at this same depth would likely be at or slightly above the
Waukesha/Mayville boundary. The Waukesha has been described previously, the
following description of the Mayville is from the North Shore Interceptor Geotechnical
Report.
13
Mayville Formation
The Mayville Formation is a light gray and gray mottled dolomite, with light
brown, finely vuggy nodular zones. Many of the vugs are coarse and clay- or
gypsum-filled. The formation becomes dense towards its base. It is close to
medium bedded with thin shaly partings.
About 35 percent of the bedding plane fillings recovered during coring are
clay with a mean thickness of 0.22 inch. Shale fillings constitute more than 50
percent of the remaining filling types, with a mean thickness of 0.10 inch.
Figure 9 shows the tunnel passing upwards through the boundary between the Waukesha
and Racine Formations and continuing east in the Racine Formation before turning south
to join with the 32-foot diameter North Shore Phase I tunnel. Note that Boring I30-NS-
AL-11 is very close to the junction of the central alignment (Milwaukee River) and the
North Shore Phase IIA Tunnel. The report also indicates that the frequency of solutioned
bedding planes was higher than anticipated in the Geotechnical report. An example is
given of a single bedding plane intersected between about Stations 329+00 to 306+00
which was solutioned for much of its length, in parts up to one to two feet wide. Portions
of the bedding plane were filled with red claystone and the open portions produced
significant amounts of groundwater inflow. A summary of water inflows into the tunnel,
measured on three different occasions in the period 12/19/89 to 2/19/92 are presented in
Table 4, Sheets 1 and 2. A histogram showing the cement (sacks) per 100 feet of tunnel
placed during the post-excavation grouting program is presented in Figure 11 (Appendix
A).
14
Fielding Rd
King Rd
Deerb
Iroquois Rd
Greenbrook Rd W
Ki
Bayside Dr
Lodgewood Ct
Mohawk Rd
Arbon
Tennyson Dr
ld
Navajo Rd
Deer Creek Ct
Seneca Rd
51st St N
55th St N
M
ee
ro
ali
rC
ok Trl
bu
Green Bay Rd
Dr
tN
Dr
Port Washington Road Relief Sewer Brown Deer Rd
Spruce Rd N
Brown Deer Rd
32
Mano
Hawthorne Rd N
n
Riv
Su
Pkwy
54th St
53rd S
(! Sanitary Sewer Overflow Location
43rd St N
er
b
De
ur
Betty Ln W
Regent Rd
r
Rd
ba
an
Ct
Heather Ln
Pelham
n
Ci
!
( Dropshaft
tN
Dr
N
r
59th St N
Berg
N Point Dr
Green Bay Ct
r Ln
58th St N
en D
57th St N
Wabash Ave W r
Fox Croft Ln
’
4 Pump
Mano
Terry Station
Ave W River Rd N Buttles Pl
Range Line Rd
Indian Creek Ct
Donna Dr W Donna Dr W BS0506
!
(
"
) Diversion Chamber
Dr
Greenvale Rd
Dean Rd Service
De
Dean Rd Dean Rd
Dean Rd W Graylog Ln
Allen Ln
DC0407
48th St N
N
nR
Pheasant Ln
Nokomis Rd W
MIS Nokomis Ct ter Ln
Whitney Rd
"
)
Poplar Dr
dW
Ct Bywa
55th St N
37th St N
38th St N
ee
ok
Cedarburg
Collector
Churchill Ln W
her Fox Ln
C
Willow Rd W
Ln
Links Way
an
ISS Winkler Ln
45th St N
Willow Rd
lic
St N
Quarles Pl
h Dr
53rd St N 53rd St N
Pe
Goodrich Ln W
27th Street Storage Relief Sewer Rd N
c
54th
Bradley Rd Goodrich Ln
Bea
Bradley Rd Bradley Rd
Mohawk Rd N
Brown Deer Par
k Park Rd
D
Links Cir
Ave W b
45th St N
Chadwick Rd N
Ci
46th St N
Ed Hunter Cir W Li l r
Lydell Storage Relief Sewer ac
River Rd N
ge
Fa
wo Cul-De-Sac Ln
irc
r th Clubview Dr W
Dr Hyde Way
Van Dyke Rd
G
hild
N untain Av Fo Dunwood Rd W Club Cir
North Side Highe WLevel Relief
Ave WSewer
Boyd Way
Links Way
¯
Rd
Fountain
51st St N
59th St N
W Spring Ln W Kenboern Dr W
Bell Rd
Ln
Spring
Calumet Rd
Northeast W
Side Relief
CalumetSewer
Rd W Woodbury Ln W
Ca
lum Calumet Rd Thorn PS0401
Seneca Rd
Navajo Rd
Ln
et Ln
Ct
’
4
Pheasant
Portage Ave W Bayfield Av
eW Portage
Greenwood Ter W Greenwood Rd W Rd
Cl North Shore Interceptor
Hem - Phase IIA
lock S Wy Beach Ct
Hemlock Rd W e
Skyline Ln
in tW Ln
Appendix A - Figure 1
Crossway Rd
to
n Daisy Ln W
51st St N
Av
Br
id
e
Pierron Ave N
W Clinton Ave W
ge
The Mall
L o mb
Ln
Navajo Ave N
Barnett Ln
PP
ardy
Cr
Seneca Ave N
Village of River Hills
os
Kil
42nd St N
Rd
55th St N
41st St N
sw
e
32n
yA
ay
Crestwood Blvd N
ve
PS0502
Beech Tree Rd N
n
W Helena St W
tL
Ave W 70509 DC0406
Bethmaur Ln N
d
Rochelle
58th St N
on
Braeburn Ln N
lm
44th St N
Valanna Ct W
Ironwood Ln N
Glen Shore
Yates Rd
Be
Elm Tree Rd N
(N
l
BS0404 !
(
wP
Rd
Da
53rd St N
Vera Ave W
Neil Pl N
Vie
ee
rien
Cheyenne St W
58th St N
Tr
en
43
St
e
e Rd W
N
Dr N
Gr
Daphn Coventry Ct
City of Milwaukee
Green Bay Ave N
Daphne Rd W Daphne Rd W
Sidn
Crestwood Blvd N
Braeburn Ln N
Elm St W Daphne Rd
56th St N
40th St N
58th St N
Hassel Ln W
55th St N
ey
Apple Tree Rd W
Atwah
Apple Tree Rd
42nd St N
Kiehnau Ave W
Pl N
Sunny Point Rd N
53rd St N
Acacia Rd W
Alberta Ct N
52nd St N
Pine Shore Dr N
Milwauk
Acacia Rd
51st St N
Hyacinth Ln N
l Dr N
49
Sunset Ln N
th
DC0409
Ct
ee Riv
School Rd
N
Mill Rd W Mill Rd W
"
) Fairfield Ct W
Sherman Blvd N
Woolworth Ave W
Berkeley Blvd N
Lake Dr
er (Pa
rk
Port Washington Rd
Teutonia Av
Kau
Flint Rd N
W
Douglas Ave W
y
Sid
eW BS0513
eN
!
n
Florist Ave W (
ey
M
37th St N
ar
P
42nd St N
ne Riverview Dr W
lN
Shore Dr N
Bobolink Ave W Av
rN
39th St N
38th St N
41st St N
e
34th St N
Day Ave E
40th St N
33rd St N
Carmen Ave W
ore
es A
yle
Ln N
rF
55th Pl N
56th St N
Dex
Ave Ave N
ve N
58th St N
Lasalle Ave W
Riv
t er
Kendall Ave W
W
Sunse
Reichert Pl W
G
Mohawk Ave N
Silver Spring Dr
E
Silver Spring Dr W !
26th St N
35th St N
BS0514
(
33rd St N
34th St N
Glen Ave E
27th St N
Iroquois Ave N
Hollywood Ave N
Shoreland Ave N
§
¨
¦
N Birch Av
eW
Shasta Pl N
Sheridan Ave W 43
De
lW Birch Ave E
Diversey Blvd N
Navajo Ave N
Lo
31st St N
Circle Dr E
te
Ironw
ng
rA
Isl
33rd St N
34th St N
46th St N
ood L
N
13th St N
50th St N
Lexington Blvd E
dD
Sylvan Ave E
48th St N
n
53rd St N
49th St N
W
Hop
ve
Dr Ma
19th St N
BS0505 !V DC0508"
)
22nd St N
56th St N
Meadow Pl E Pa
kins
lis
21st St N
Eggert Pl W
rtin Lu
Eggert Pl W
PS0501 Lancaster Ave E ad
24th Pl N
47th St N
La
57th St N
St N t N
23rd St N
es
41s
27th St N
51st Blvd N
Colfax Pl E
ke
28th St N
Rd
DC0507
ther K
Dr
’
tS
4 N
Wildwood Ave N
Fairmount Ave W
"
)
20th St N 20th St N
46th St N
19th St N
Newhall St N
38th St N
52nd St N
Cameron Ave W
ing Jr
Cumberland Blvd N
18th St N
19th Pl N
50th St N
48th St N
25th St N
Ardmore Ave N
Av
36th St N
DC0504NS-2
Idlewild Ave N
Dr
e
Woodburn St N
N
40th St N
DC0505
DC0405 Hampton (Park Rd) Rd W
22nd St N
"!
(
21st St N
Ave W
DC0509"
)
Hampton
NS-1 )
23rd St N 23rd St N
Elkhart Ave N
52nd St N
38th St N
Sheffield Ave N
!"
() Derby Pl W
Pa
32nd St N
Pa
48th St N
53rd St N
!BS0516
54th St N
rkw
Port Washington Rd N
(
24th Pl N
Courtland Ave W
rk
30th St N
50th St N
Pur
49th St N
w
d
ay
ue Eula Ct W
ay
35th St N
Peck Pl W St W
44th St N
Cramer St N
A
Dr
24th St N
45th St N
Wildwood Ave N
ve
Newhall St N
! BS0515
(
29th St N
W
Morris Blvd N
N
47th St N
Wi
39th St N
DC0503 NS-3
lso
58th St N
Ruby Ave W
Woodburn Ave N
28th St N
56th St N
"
nD
§
¨
¦
r N Esta
18th St N
17th St N
16th St N
Marion St E
Fo
N
42nd Pl N
At
Hu
Rd
br
k
nd
Marion St W in
Newhall St N
36th St N
Le ac
ook
be
mb
41st St N
so
Lydell Ave N
D
o n Av
44th Pl N
u
46th St N 45th Pl N
om n
15th St N
14th St N
21st St N
old
Av
L
Larkin St N
rc
Ho
26th St N
( Pa
Te e W
48th St N
Olive St W
tN
Se e
tA
rW
W
12th St N
20th St N
M
Hope Ave W
kin
47th St N
rk R
19th St N
49th St N
50th St N
10th S
o n hur
ve
24th St N
Bartlett Ave N
s
El
31st St N
tre st
NS-12
St
Wi
m
Ex
8th St N
d) P
Fiebrantz Ave W
!
(
al Rd
13th St N
W
34th St N
lso
tN
24th Pl N
St
DC0502
54th St N
53rd St N
k wy
nD
N
"!
Capitol Dr W
)(
rN
22nd St N
2nd St N
N
30th St N
Holton St N
DC0506"
) NS-11
11th St N
18th St N
Cramer St N
Melv
H
STH 57
lE
27th St N
8th St N
o w enc
in a St rt P
Abert Pl E Abe
10th St N
7th St N
Sp
9th St N
W W
ie er
lvd N
19th Pl N
Pl
57th
12th St N
Pl Pl
t
Fratney St N
3rd St N
oy
W W
4th St N
Booth St N
54th Blvd N
58th B
6th St N
H
Ho
St N
2nd St N
Vienna Ave W
Singer Cir E Menlo Blvd E
pk
Nash St W
ins
Nash St W Feet
St