Cliff Kincaid – Muslim, Christian, or Marxist?

MUSLIM, CHRISTIAN, OR MARXIST?

Author: Cliff Kincaid

Date: August 24, 2010
http://newswithviews.com/Kincaid/cliff445.htm

When questions came up during the campaign about Barack Obama’s religious affiliation, his
aides flatly asserted that he was a “practicing Christian” and was “baptized” in the Trinity
United Church of Christ. However, some of the same questions have come up again in the
wake of opinion polls finding people confused about Obama’s religious identity. Our media
cannot understand the confusion.

For most in the media, it is cut-and-dried: Obama is a Christian. People who don’t believe it
are dumb or misled.

But calling yourself something is not the same thing as proving it is the case. This claim
deserves to be scrutinized, even when it involves a sensitive and personal matter such as
religious belief.

Unfortunately for Obama and his backers, the same Obama campaign apparatus which
claimed that he is a baptized Christian asserted that the mysterious “Frank” in Obama’s book,
Dreams from My Father, was just a black civil rights activist. It turned out that “Frank”
was Frank Marshall Davis, a Communist Party member under surveillance by the FBI who
served as a mentor for a young Obama in Hawaii. The 600-page FBI file1 on Davis even
suggests he was an espionage agent on behalf of the Soviet Union.

Dupes, a forthcoming book2 by Professor Paul Kengor, promises to take another close look at
Obama’s Frank Marshall Davis connection.

So what the Obama presidential campaign says about Obama’s religious affiliation is not
something to be taken at face value. They have a vested interest in making Obama look more
acceptable to the American people.

As President, he has gone to church only a few times, which undermines the claim that he is a
practicing Christian. People see him playing golf on Sunday; they don’t see him going to
church.

In fact, however, being a Christian is not just a function of attending church services. Rather,
it is related to being baptized. Did this critical development occur in Obama’s life?

In this context, it is important to take a look at what Obama’s own books, Dreams from My
Father and The Audacity of Hope, say about the President’s religion, or lack thereof.

Page 1 of 5 
 
Cliff Kincaid – Muslim, Christian, or Marxist?
 
He acknowledges in Dreams that his grandfather was a Muslim (page 104) and that he spent
two years in a Muslim school in Indonesia studying the Koran (page 154). In The Audacity of
Hope, he says (page 204) that “my father had been raised a Muslim” but that by the time he
met his mother, his father was a “confirmed atheist.”

His stepfather was not particularly religious and his mother professed “secularism,” Obama
wrote (pages 204-205), but as a child he went to a “predominantly Muslim school,” after
being first sent to a Catholic school. His mother, he said, was concerned about him learning
math, not religion.

Obama’s reference to being baptized is found in his second book, The Audacity of Hope,
published in 2006, not in Dreams, published in 1995. Obama wrote on page 208, “I was
finally able to walk down the aisle of Trinity United Church of Christ one day and be
baptized.”

Traditionally, Christianity teaches that baptism is a sacrament involving the use of water to
signify acceptance of Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit. Since Obama was not born and
baptized a Christian, in order to become a Christian he had to enter into the sacrament of
baptism some time later in life.

In this regard, Obama does not indicate anywhere in his books that he came into contact with
what Christians regard as the “living water.” Instead, he says that, in his baptism, he made “a
choice,” knelt beneath a cross, and “felt God’s spirit beckoning.” He said, “I submitted myself
to His will, and dedicated myself to discovering His truth.”

This sounds like a powerful religious experience but it is not what Christians regard as
baptism.

In Dreams from My Father, Obama discusses his pastor, Jeremiah Wright, noting that he
had been “dabbling with liquor, Islam, and black nationalism in the sixties” but that “the call
of faith had apparently remained” and that he went on to study religion, including “the black
liberation theologians.” For his part, Obama visited Wright to discuss membership in the
Trinity United Church of Christ as an extension of his community organizing activities and
the hope that he could get “involvement” in this effort from churches like Wright’s.

As Obama contacted the churches and their ministers, he reveals that they thought he was a
Muslim (page 279) or, he jokes, an Irishman, “O’Bama.”

Obama talks about hearing a Wright sermon, “The Audacity of Hope,” which inspired the title
of his second book. However, there is no mention of any baptism in this—his first—book. The
reference to being baptized came in the second book, as Obama was preparing to launch his
presidential campaign. The timing is significant.

These are the facts as Obama himself reported them. So how have the media handled them?
Needless to say, there has been no serious investigation into whether the claims are true and
what they mean.

“Obama’s religious biography is unconventional and politically problematic,” Newsweek’s

Lisa Miller reported.3 “Born to a Christian-turned-secular mother and a Muslim-turned-
Page 2 of 5 
 
Cliff Kincaid – Muslim, Christian, or Marxist?
 
atheist African father, Obama grew up living all across the world with plenty of spiritual
influences, but without any particular religion. He is now a Christian, having been baptized in
the early 1990s at Trinity United Church of Christ in Chicago.”

The phrase, “having been baptized,” is apparently based on Obama’s claim about being
baptized. Our major media haven’t questioned the claim.

Miller went on to say, “His baptism presents its own problems. The senior pastor at Trinity at
the time of Obama’s baptism was the Rev. Jeremiah Wright Jr., the preacher who was seen
damning America on cable TV…”

Notice the formulation, “at the time of Obama’s baptism.” She carefully does not say that
Wright performed the baptism. In fact, there’s no evidence it was a baptism in the traditional
sense that it was performed by Wright or anybody else. It looks like Obama walked down the
aisle and made a profession of faith. That is not a Christian baptism.

The Canada Free Press published a very interesting article in February by Madeline Brooks,
who asked,4 “Where is the baptism certificate? We do not see one because there was no
baptism. That central part of Christianity was not required at Obama’s former church, the
Trinity United Church of Christ, during the years Obama attended…”

She cites the research of a pastor, Usama Dakdok, who had called Obama’s church to ask
about membership:

“Do I have to be baptized to join the church?” asked Pastor Dakdok. “No, you don’t,” was the
answer. “You can be a member without being baptized.”

“And what exactly is required to become a member?” The answer: “You attend two Sunday
school classes in a row about membership, and then you walk the aisle.”

Walk down the aisle? That sounds exactly what Obama described in his book. This is how one
becomes a member. But it is not a baptism into Christianity.

“I called the Trinity United Church of Christ and they confirmed that baptism is merely
optional for members,” Brooks added.

Pastor Dakdok reports5 that he also asked a spokesperson for Trinity, the membership
director:

“If I am a Muslim man, and I believe in the prophet Mohammed, peace be upon him, but I
also believe in the prophet Jesus, do I have to give up my Islamic faith to join your church?”

The answer was, “Absolutely not! We have so many members of our church who are
Muslims.”

Dakdok asked the Trinity spokesperson, “Is that how Senator Barack Obama became a
member?” The membership director of the church refused to answer.

Page 3 of 5 
 
Cliff Kincaid – Muslim, Christian, or Marxist?
 
Madeline Brooks calls this “Muslim Christianity,” which she says is theologically impossible.

In fact, the contradictions don’t end there. Obama’s pastor for 20 years, Jeremiah Wright,
could be described as a “Marxist Christian,” which is also theoretically impossible, since
Marxism is materialistic and atheistic. Yet, as we revealed last November,6 Wright gave a
speech in which he praised Marxism and faulted the media for claiming that communism and
Christianity were somehow opposed to one another.

So the question regarding Obama is not just whether he is a Muslim but a Marxist, based not
only on his attendance at Jeremiah Wright’s unusual church but the influence exercised over
him during his growing-up years by Communist Frank Marshall Davis.

Dakdok, who was brought up in Egypt, a Muslim country, is adamant that Obama is a
Muslim, based on the fact that his birth father was a Muslim and that there is no evidence
that Obama ever specifically rejected Islam. Christian radio host Brannon Howse interviewed7
Dakdok, at the urging of conservative columnist David Limbaugh, brother of the national talk
show host, Rush Limbaugh. Dakdok was also interviewed8 recently on Stacy Harp’s Christian
radio show. He speaks around the country in front of Christian audiences.

While Obama may have been a Muslim by birth, that doesn’t mean that he accepts the
Muslim faith or philosophy. Instead, Islam may be seen as just another religion/ideology that
can be used for his own political purposes.

The case for Obama being a Marxist is far more convincing. He was exposed to Marxist
ideology in church under Wright, as well as from Frank Marshall Davis.

The American people now seem to get it, even though the truth about Obama’s relationship
with Davis has never been thoroughly explored by the major media. A poll9 from the
Democracy Corps, a Democratic Party firm, found that 55 percent said that Obama could
accurately be described as a socialist.

This is far more than the number of people who see him as a Muslim.

If and when the media start examining the Frank Marshall Davis connection, the “socialist”
label could take on more sinister connotations.

This is why, of course, they will avoid it.

                                                            
End Notes:

1 http://www.usasurvival.org/marshall.fbi.files.html

2 http://www.isi.org/books/content/isi_books_front_list_fall_2010.pdf

3 http://www.newsweek.com/2008/07/11/finding-his-faith.html

4 http://www.canadafreepress.com/index.php/article/20441

Page 4 of 5 
 
Cliff Kincaid – Muslim, Christian, or Marxist?
 
                                                                                                                                                                                                           
5 http://www.thestraightway.org/frequentlyaskedq.php

6 http://newswithviews.com/Kincaid/cliff364.htm

7 http://www.worldviewweekend.com/worldview-radio/episode.php?episodeid=17030

8 http://blogforbooks.com/archives/2010/08/14/3238/

9 http://www.democracycorps.com/wp-content/files/dcor062210fq6.web_.pdf

Cliff Kincaid, a veteran journalist and media critic, Cliff concentrated in journalism and
communications at the University of Toledo, where he graduated with a Bachelor of Arts
degree.

Cliff has written or co-authored nine books on media and cultural affairs and foreign policy
issues. One of Cliff's books, "Global Bondage: The UN Plan to Rule the World" is still
awailable.

Cliff has appeared on Hannity & Colmes, The O’Reilly Factor, Crossfire and has been
published in the Washington Post, Washington Times, Chronicles, Human Events and
Insight.

Web Site: www.AIM.org

E-Mail: cliff.kincaid@aim.org

###

Page 5 of 5