Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Pediatric liquid medicaments (PLM) are popular and are easily accepted by both parents and children. They
are widely prescribed and easily available. However the sugar content and properties of these preparations
determines their cariogenic potential. Aims and Objectives: This study assessed the pH and viscosity of
pediatric liquid medicaments, type and concentration of sugars present in them and their effect on the
growth of Streptococcus mutans. Methodology: PLM included two each of the most commonly prescribed
analgesics, antibiotics, nutritional supplements, antitussive and antiepileptic preparations. The endogenous
pH was measured using a digital pH meter and the viscosity was measured using a digital Brookefield vis-
cometer. Analysis of sugars (sucrose, glucose and sorbitol) was performed using High Performance Liquid
Chromatography. The effect of PLM on Streptococcus mutans was done by ditch plate method. Results: The
pH of PLM ranged from 3.70 to 7.04 and viscosity varied from 307.33cP to 2408.33cP. Fifty percent of the
PLM contained sucrose, glucose and sorbitol, and sucrose was present in nine of the PLM. The antibiotic
preparations showed zones of inhibition against growth of streptococcus mutans. Conclusions: The physi-
cal properties of Pediatric Liquid Medicaments as well as the type and concentration of sugars present in
them can be indicative of their cariogenic potential.
Keywords: pediatric liquid medicaments, cariogenic, pH, viscosity, sucrose, streptococcus mutans.
JClinPediatrDent36(3):357362,2012
S
ystemic administration of drugs include oral, sublin- necessaryforimprovementormaintenanceofhealth,some
gual,rectal,cutaneous,inhalation,nasalandparental oftheinactiveingredientsposearisktodentalhealth.1 The
routes.Amongtheseroutes,theoralrouteistheoldest AAPDcariesriskassessmenttool(CAT)stipulatesthatchil-
and the most common mode of drug administration. drenwithchronicconditionsandwhoaretakingmedicines
Pediatric liquid preparations are popular and are easily maybeathigherriskfordentaldiseases.2,3 Mostoftheseliq-
acceptedbybothparentsandchildren.Syrupshavealong uidpreparationsaremadepalatableinordertogainpatient
history of use in pediatric medicine. They are widely compliance and are used extensively in children.4,5,6 The
prescribed,andareeasilyavailable.Theiruseisusuallyfor inclusionofsugars,inchildrensmedicinesis,primarilyto
a short duration, but for some children it may be a daily maskthelesspleasanttasteofactiveingredients.7 However
occurrence. sugarsaddedtomedicinescanbefermentedbyoralbacteria
leadingtoacidformationandadropinintraoralpH.Only
fewstudiesprovideinformationabouttheconcentrationof
* Priya Subramaniam, MDS, Professor and Head, Department of freesugarspresentinliquidmedicinesandtheyareusually
Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry, the Oxford Dental College, basedondruglabelsandoninformationfrompharmaceuti-
HospitalandResearchCentre,Bommanahalli,HosurRoad,Karnataka, calindustries.8,9,10
India.
Thereisgrowingconcernamongpediatricdentistsabout
** NandanN,BDSPGStudent,TheOxfordDentalCollege,Hospitaland
Research Centre, Bommanahalli, Hosur Road, Bangalore-560068, the increased consumption of hidden sugars by children,
Karnataka,India,DepartmentofPedodonticsandPreventiveDentistry, especially those who are chronically ill. It is important to
the Oxford Dental College, Hospital and Research Centre, assess the cariogenic potential of commonly used PLM.
Bommanahalli,HosurRoad,Karnataka,India. Hencethepurposeofthisstudywastoassesstheendoge-
Send all correspondence to: Dr. Priya Subramaniam, Department of nouspHandviscosityofpediatricliquidmedicaments,type
PedodonticsandPreventiveDentistry,TheOxfordDentalCollege,Hospital andconcentrationofsugarspresentinthemandtheireffect
and Research Centre, Bommanahalli, Hosur Road, Bangalore-560068, onthegrowthofStreptococcus mutans
Karnataka,India
The Journal of Clinical Pediatric Dentistry Volume 36, Number 4/2012 357
Pediatric Liquid Medicaments
358 The Journal of Clinical Pediatric Dentistry Volume 36, Number 4/2012
Pediatric Liquid Medicaments
Antibiotic Amoxicillin and potassium Mox Clav Rexcel (A division of Ranbaxy 6.010.01* 1396.6715.28
clavulanate Laboratories Limited)
Antitussive Codeine phosphate Mits Linctus Vivimed Labs Ltd 5.020.01 307.333.06
Chlorpheniramine maleate Codeinate Co
Antitussive Dextramethorphan Chericof Sobrex Pharmaceuticals 4.660.01 1755.005.00
Hydrobromide,Chlor- Company (for Ranbaxy
pheniramine maleate, Laboratories Limited)
Phenylephrine hydrochloride
Nutritional Multivitamins Visyneral Z Crest healthcare (P) Ltd 3.810.01 2408.332.89*
supplement
Nutritional Multivitamins and minerals Zincovit Apex laboratories private 3.840.02 708.332.89*
supplement limited
The Journal of Clinical Pediatric Dentistry Volume 36, Number 4/2012 359
Pediatric Liquid Medicaments
strengthoftheacidoreasewithwhichtheacidwillgiveup sorbitoliscommonlyused.
freeH+ ions(pKa).27 Theexactcontributionofvariousacidic The percentage of pediatric medicines with sucrose in
componentsofmedicinesinerodingenamelisunclear,espe- theircompositionsvariesfrom0%to58.30%.9,33 Pomorico
ciallyin vivo.14 Ourstudydidnotaimtoanalyzetheextentto et al reported that sucrose present in 7 of the 10 samples
whicheachPLMmightcauseerosion.Ratheritfocusedonly studiedrangedbetween5to54g%.18 Anotherstudydetected
oninherentcharacteristicsthatcouldinfluencedentalcaries. sucrosein10ofthe23samplesinvestigated,withconcen-
Hence only the endogenous pH of the PLM was assessed trations ranging from 11.36 g% to 85.99 g%.9 The other
usingadigitalpHmeter,whichismoreaccurateandefficient sugarthathasbeencommonlyidentifiedinpediatricmedi-
thanaconventionalelectrodepHmeter.9,11,18 ThepHof70% cines is glucose. Brazilian studies have reported the pres-
ofPLMwasbelow5.5,thatissimilartothatofaBrazilian ence of glucose in several PLM, with the range varying
study.9 ThepHofPLMshowedawiderangeof3.70to7.04, between2.10g%and40.19g%.9,12,18 Inourstudy,7PLMhad
which is in accordance with earlier studies.9,18 However, in glucoserangingfrom0.84g%to5.49g%.
anotherstudythatusedapHelectrodemeter,higherpHval- Presentlyanumberofproductsforinfantsandchildren
ueswerereportedforallPLM.1 includingPLM/medicineshavebeenformulatedusingsugar
However,itisnotjustthepH,thatisimportant,butrather substitutes.Although some parents are aware of the avail-
the titratable acidity. The greater the buffering capacity of abilityofsugar-freemedicines,theyaremorelikelytopur-
theliquid,thelongeritwilltakeforthesalivatoneutralize chase sugar-containing medicines that are prescribed by
theacid.9,28 most practitioners or use medicaments that are recom-
Decreasedsalivationandlackofmasticatorymovements mendedbypharmacists.
during the night increase the cariogenic potential of medi- Polyalcohols such as sorbitol and xylitol are important
cines.19 Sugar-containing analgesics are given at night to sugar substitutes since they are not efficient substrates for
relievepainandanight-timecoughmaybesoothenedbya plaquebacteriaandthereforeproduceonlyaminimalplaque
coughsyrup,soastohelpthechildsleep.Veryoftenthelast pHdrop.Polyolsaresugarderivativesinwhichthereactive
daily dose of antibiotic syrup may be given at bedtime. aldehyde or keto groups have been reduced to hydroxyl
These viscous syrup medicines with prolonged oral clear- groups.Themetabolismofpolyalcoholsisrelatedtothatof
ance can constitute a risk to dental health.29 Information sugars:theyareoxidizedtoeitherketoseoranaldosegroup.
about the relation between viscosity and dissolution of the Inourstudy,sorbitolwasdetectedin7PLM,withthesor-
dentalhardtissuesisrareinliterature.Inourstudyviscosity bitolcontentrangingupto26%.Thiswasinaccordancewith
varied from 307 cP to 2408 cP. Neves et al reported that reportsonPLMinBrazil.11,18 However,Neveset al foundthe
the viscosity of PLM in their study ranged between 4.7 to sorbitolcontentofPLMtorangefrom5.39%to46.09%.14
412.3cP.9 Masters suggested that the large number of antibiotics
An unrecognized and significant supply of cariogenic prescribedassyrupstothechildreninhisstudymayhave
carbohydratesisintheformofsugar-containingliquidoral contributed to the observed reduction in dental caries,
medicines. Medicines intended for pediatric use have a althoughthiseffectdisappearedafter4yearsofage.34 Other
meansugarcontentofapproximately50%andsyrupscon- researchershaveclaimedthatantibacterialsyrupmedication
tain10%to80%sucrose,mostcommonlyabout55%.The is associated with a significant decline in dental caries.35
sugar content of 24 liquid medicines frequently prescribed Although zones of inhibition were expected with both
for infants and young children showed a range of 29.4- antibiotic PLM, we wanted to know which one was more
61.2%.30 effectiveagainststreptococcusmutans.Thezoneofinhibi-
Barring the sugar free medicines, we observed that the tionwassignificantlygreaterwithMox-Clavincomparison
drug labels only provided information on the presence or toTaxim-O.ThiscouldalsobeduetothehigherpHofMox-
absenceofsugarsinthesyrupmedicines,rarelymentioning Clavanditsnegligiblesucrosecontent.Althoughantibiotics
thetypeofsugarpresent.Asimilarfindingwasalsoreported areantimicrobialinnature,theiruseoverlongtermcannot
in PLM available in Brazil.31 High Performance Liquid beignored.Thesepreparationsarealsoofconcernduetothe
Chromatography (HPLC) used in our study,9,12 enables the sweetenerspresent.
discrimination of individual sugars present in the syrup as A zone of exhibition was seen with Zincovit probably
wellasitsconcentrationwithremarkableaccuracy.12Studies because nutritional supplements contain constituents that
have concluded that although Paper Chromatography (PC) can promote growth of microorganisms. This preparation
andThinLayerChromatography(TLC)ofsugarsarehigh hadalow pHandahighercontentofsucrose.Thepresence
speed and require simple instrumentation their results are of sodium selenite equivalent to 10 mcg of selenium in
limitedandcanonlybeusedasareferenceaboutconstituent Zincovit could have also contributed to the promotion of
mono-oroligosaccharidesidentification.32 Streptococcus mutans growth.36 Although,theothermedica-
Theselectionofsugarsforanalysiswasbasedonthefre- mentsstudiedshowedneitherzoneofinhibitionnorexhibi-
quencyoftheirinclusioninPLM.Sucrose,followedbyglu- tion their other properties should be considered for
cose, are the commonly added bulking and sweetening ascertainingtheircariogenicpotential.
agentspresentinalmostallPLM.Fructoseisnotusedfre- Pharmaceutical preparations with acidic pH and high
quentlyinmostpreparations.Amongthesugarsubstitutes, sugarcontentshaveapotentialforincreasingdentalcaries
360 The Journal of Clinical Pediatric Dentistry Volume 36, Number 4/2012
Pediatric Liquid Medicaments
whenusedseveraltimeseachdayoverlongperiodsoftime. 5. MaguireA,Rugg-GunnAJ.Prevalenceoflongtermuseofliquidoral
Ithasbeenshownthatchildrenaged3-7yearshavelarger medicinesbychildreninnorthernregion,England.CommunityDent
Health,11:9196,1994.
variations and slower salivary sugar clearances and also 6. NevesBG,PierroVS,MiaLC,PediatriciansPerceptionsoftheUseof
lower salivary flow rates than older children and adults.37 Sweetened Medications Related to Oral Health. J Clin Pediatr Dent,
Primaryteethareknowntobelessmineralizedthanperma- 32(2):133138,2007.
nentteethandsincetheirenamelsurfaceisnotasmatureas 7. BradleyM,KinironsM.Asurveyoffactorsinfluencingtheprescribing
ofsugarfreemedicinesforchildrenbyagroupofgeneralmedicalprac-
thatofpermanentteeth,theyaremoretodentalcariesand titioners in Northern Ireland. Int J Paediatr Dent, Dec; 6(4): 2614,
erosion. 1996.
Parentsshouldbeinformedaboutthepresenceofhidden 8. Rekola M. In vivo acid production from medicines I n syrup form.
sugarsinmedicines.Itcanberecommendedthatallsugar CariesRes,23(6):4126,1989.
9. LimaKT,AlmeidaICS,SennaETL.SweetenersandendogenouspHof
containing medicines particularly for paediatric use should
pediatricmedicines[AbstractB-110].JDentRes,79:11302000.
belabelledwiththetypeofsweeteneranditsconcentration. 10. Fiegel RJ, Jensen ME, Mensing CA. Dental caries related to liquid
Whenever possible, paediatric dentists should take the medicationsPediatrics,68:416419,1981.
responsibilityofinformingpediatriciansabouttheprofileof 11. SunithaS,PrashanthGM;Shanmukhappa,ChanduGN,SubbaReddy
theroutinelyprescribedmedications. VV.Ananalysisofconcentrationofsucrose,endogenouspH,andalter-
ationintheplaquepHonconsumptionofcommonlyusedliquidpedi-
Thisin vitro studywaslimitedtoasmallnumberofPLM atricmedicines.JIndianSocPedodPrevDent,Jan-Mar;27(1):448,
andcouldhaveassesseddifferentsugarspresentineachof 2009.
them. In vivo studies using the same PLM could further 12. PierroVS.AbdelurJP,MaiaLC,TrugoLC.freesugarconcentration
relate the effect of composition and properties of these andpHofpaediatricmedicinesinBrazil.CommunityDentalHealth,
22,180183,2005.
preparations on the primary dentition and/or oral environ-
13. MilanoM.Across-SectionalStudyofMedication-RelatedFactorsand
ment. CariesExperienceinAsthmaticChildren.PediatrDent,28:415419,
2006.
CONCLUSIONS 14. Neves BG, FarahA, Lucas E, de Souza VP, Maia LC.Are pediatric
1. Thecoughsyrup,Chericofcanberegardedcariogenic medicinesriskfactorsfordentalcariesanddentalerosion?Community
DentHealth,27(1):4651,2010.
becauseofitsacidicandviscousnature,togetherwith 15. Prashanth GM, Chandu GN, Muralikrishna KS, Shafiulla MD. The
its high sucrose content. This preparation can be effect of mango and neem extract on four organisms causing dental
potentially harmful on night-time administration caries:Streptococcusmutans,Streptococcussalivavius,Streptococcus
and/or when frequently given to children in-between mitis,andStreptococcussanguis:aninvitrostudy.IndianJDentRes,
18(4),148151,2007.
theregularprescribeddoses. 16. AkpataES,AkinrimisiEO.Antibacterialactivityofextractsfromsome
2. Withregardtodentalhealth,Mox-clavappearstobe Africanchewingsticks.OralSurg,44:71722,1977.
less detrimental due to its relatively higher pH, sor- 17. Asuquo BI, Montefiore D. Preliminary studies on the anti-bacterial
bitolcontent,negligibleamountsofothersugarsand propertiesofchewingsticks.JDent,177:5;1237,1998.
18. PomoricoL,CzauskiG,PotelaMB,KneippL,deAraujoSoaresRM,
higherinhibitionofStreptococcus mutans growth.
deAraujo Castro GFB. Cariogenic and erosive potential of the med-
3. Zincovit can be considered to be the PLM with the ication used by HIV infected children: pH and sugar concentration.
most cariogenic potential due to its acidic pH, high CommDentalHealth,25,170175,2008.
viscosity and promotion of Streptococcus mutans 19. Bigeard L. The role of medication and sugars in pediatric dental
growth. patients.DentClinNorthAm,Jul;44(3):44356,2000
20. MentesA.pHchangesindentalplaqueafterusingsugar-freepediatric
4. For long term use in children with convulsive disor- medicine.JClinPediatrDent,Summer;25(4):30712,2001.
ders,GardenalwouldbelesscariogenicasithasapH 21. KennyDJ,SomayaP.Sugarloadoforalliquidmedicationonchroni-
ofabove7andapartfromsorbitol,itdoesnotcontain callyillchildren.JCanDentAssoc,Jan;55(1):436,1989.
any other sugar. The other anticonvulsant Eptoin, 22. CostaCC,AlmeidaIC,CostaFilhoLC.Erosiveeffectofanantihista-
mine-containingsyruponprimaryenamelanditsreductionbyfluoride
though less viscous was acidic and had a very high
dentifrice.IntJPaediatrDent,May;16(3):17480,2006.
sucrosecontent. 23. RobertsGJ,RobertsIF.Dentaldiseaseinchronicallysickchildren.J
DentChild,48:346351,1981.
REFERENCES 24. Fry J, Brooks D, McColl I. NHS data Book. Lancaster; MTP Press,
1. BabuKL,RaiK,HegdeAM.pHofmedicatedsyrupsdoesitreally 1984
matter?anin vitro study:Part-II.JClinPediatrDent,Winter33(2): 25. ParmeshH.EpidemiologyofAsthmainIndia.IndianJPediatr,69(4):
13742,2008. 309312,2002.
2. Policy on Caries Assesment Tool (CAT). Oral Health Policies 26. MarathakiE,PollardMA,CurzonME.Theeffectofsucroseinmedi-
American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry Guidelines. Pediatr Dent, cinesonplaquepH.IntJPaediatrDent,Dec;5(4):2315,1995.
2005. 27. Rugg-GunnAJ, MaguireA, Gordon PH, McCabe JF, Stephenson G.
3. MilanoM.Across-SectionalStudyofMedication-RelatedFactorsand Comparisonoferosionofdentalenamelbyfourdrinksusinganintra
CariesExperienceinAsthmaticChildren.PediatrDent,28:415419, oralappliance.CariesRes,32:337343,1998.
2006. 28. LussiandJaeggi;Chemicalfactors.InLussiA.editor.Dentalerosion.
4. SahgalJ,SoodPB,RajuOS.Acomparisonoforalhygienestatusand MonographsinOralScience.Basel:Karger,20,11218,2006.
dentalcariesinchildrenonlongtermliquidoralmedicationstothose 29. MaguireA,BaqirW,NunnJH.Aresugars-freemedicinesmoreerosive
thansugars-containingmedicines?Aninvitrostudyofpaediatricmed-
notadministeredwithsuchmedications.JIndianSocPedodPrevDent,
icineswithprolongedoralclearanceusedregularlyandlong-termby
Dec;20(4):14451,2002.
children.IntJPaediatrDent,Jul;17(4):2318,2007.
The Journal of Clinical Pediatric Dentistry Volume 36, Number 4/2012 361
Pediatric Liquid Medicaments
30. Nik-HusseinNN,RazakIA,KarimMN.Ananalysisofsugarcontent 34. Masters NJ. Medication caries: a dental myth? Practitioner, (231):
of commonly used pediatric liquid medicinesits revelance in den- 5664,1987.
tistry.SingaporeDentJ,13(1):246,1988. 35. Karjalainen S, Rekola M, Stanberg MR. Long term effects of syrup
31. NeivaA,SilvaVS,MaiaLC,TrugoLC.Analiseinvitrodaconcentra- medications for recurrent otits media on the dental health of 6 to 8-
cao de sacarose e pH de antibacterianos de uso pediatrico. Pesquisa year-oldchildren.CariesRes,26(4):3104,1992.
BrasileriaemOdontopediatriaeClinicaIntegrada,1:916,2001. 36. Nizel AE, Papas AS. Nutrition in Clinical Dentistry, 3rd Ed
32. MossSJ.Dentalerosion.IntDentJ,Dec;48(6):52939,1998. Philadelphia,PA:W.B.Saunders,p.132140,2002.
33. DrumondMRS,LealC,OliveraCB,MederiosLADM,FonsecaJGJ. 37. JohanssonAK,SorvariR,BirkhedD,MeurmanJH.Dentalerosionin
AnalisedaconcentracaodesacaroseepHdemedicamentospediatricos deciduousteethanin vivo &in vitro study;JDent,(5):33340,2001.
disponiveis na cidade de Jaoa Pessoa-PB. Odontolgia Clinico-
Clentitca,supl4,56,2005.
362 The Journal of Clinical Pediatric Dentistry Volume 36, Number 4/2012