Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
BACKGROUND: Misoprostol exposure in the rst trimester of pregnancy has been related to congenital malformations, particularly the
Mobius sequence and terminal transverse limb defects. CASES: Neuropathological ndings of three patients with Mobius sequence related
to misoprostol are reported. No previous pathological studies have shown these abnormalities to be associated with misoprostol exposure
in utero. The brain stem was cut serially, from the rostral mesencephalum to the caudal aspect of the medulla, and all fragments were
stained with hematoxylin-eosin and cresyl violet. Old ischemic-anoxic foci of gliosis, with necrosis and calcication, dorsally situated, were
present from the pons to the medulla, involving some cranial nerve nuclei (especially the IV, VII, and XII) that were partially or completely
depopulated of neural cells. CONCLUSIONS: The ndings suggest a circulatory mechanism to the Mobius sequence, with vascular
disruption involving the territory of the subclavian artery, occurring in a critical period of embryonic life between six to eight weeks
postconception. These cases add further evidence of the role of misoprostol as a teratogen. Birth Defects Research (Part A) 67:10021007,
2003. 2003 Wiley-Liss, Inc.
Key words: Mobius sequence; misoprostol; vascular disruption; prenatal brain stem ischemia
Birth Defects Research (Part A): Clinical and Molecular Teratology 67:10021007 (2003)
MOBIUS NEUROPATHOLOGY IN MISOPROSTOL EXPOSURE 1003
spontaneous normal movements of the limbs. In his hands NEUROPATHOLOGICAL FINDINGS
there was agenesis of distal phalanges on the ngers 2, 3 Methods
and 4, absent nails on ngers 1 and 5, complete bilateral
transverse palmar creases, and bilateral equinovarus feet. All of the brains were xed in 10% formalin for at least
Due to difculties in sucking and swallowing, he was fed 21 days and then sectioned serially in the coronal axis.
by nasogastric tube from birth. The diagnosis was MS Representative fragments were taken from each lobe of the
(affected cranial nerves were V, VI, VII, IX, X, and XII) with cerebral hemispheres, hippocampus, basal ganglia, thala-
associated limb anomalies. mus, and cerebellum. The brain stem was sectioned seri-
Fundoscopy, karyotype, TORCH, cerebral spinal uid, ally from the rostral mesencephalon to the caudal aspect of
electroencephalography, auditory and visual evoked po- the medulla. All fragments were stained with hematoxylin-
tentials, and abdominal ultrasonography identied no ab- eosin and cresyl violet (Nissls stain).
normalities. Cranial ultrasonography revealed a large third
ventricle; radiographs of the hands showed agenesis of Case 1
distal phalanges and bilateral hypoplasia of the medial The brain weighed 654 gm (normal 714 gm) and
phalanges of the second, third, and fourth ngers. On the appeared normal macroscopically. Histological examina-
24th day of life, he had a reversible cardio-respiratory tion showed lesions limited to the brainstem, which in-
arrest and generalized convulsions, and needed ventilator cluded diffuse old reactive gliosis and necrotic calcied
support for ve days; between the second and eighth foci bilaterally, next to the oor of the IVth ventricle,
month, he had several apneic episodes, and died at eight around nerve nuclei VI.
months of age, as a result of a further apneic episode. The nuclei of the facial nerve (VII) were gliotic, shrunken,
and poorly populated. Gliosis was also present next to the
Case 2 nuclei of nerve X and XI that could not be traced. There was
unilateral necrosis of the nucleus of nerve XII (Fig. 1).
This boy was the rst child of nonconsanguineous and
healthy parents. His mother attempted to abort at the sixth
week of pregnancy, using 400 g of misoprostol; mild Case 2
bleeding and cramping occurred some hours afterward. The brain weighed 1300 gm ( normal 1064 gm) and
He was born in good condition and weighed 3300 gm (50th was moderately edematous. Microscopically, there was a
centile). Due to poor sucking and swallowing, he was fed mild neuronal loss with ischemic neurons through the
by tube in the rst days of life. Physical examination cerebral cortex, mainly in layer III and Sommer sector of
showed bilateral facial and abducent palsies and an equi- the hippocampus. Similar lesions were observed in the
novarus club foot deformity. When rst seen in our center quadrigeminal plate and the substantia nigra. At the pon-
at one year and seven months of age, his weight was 14 kg tine level, there were foci of calcication symmetrically
(75th90th centile) and the occipitofrontal circumference situated in the tegmentum, next to the VI nerve nuclei
was 48.5 cm (50th centile). He had a prominent forehead (Figs. 2 and 3). One was gliotic and almost completely
with mild hirsutism, downward eye slant, bilateral epican- devoid of neurons. Both VII nerve nuclei were depopu-
thal fold, micrognathia, a long philtrum, extruded lateral lated, shrunken, and gliotic. There was a diffuse mild
incisors, and partial syndactyly of toes 2 and 3. He had an gliosis of the tegmentum, extending from pons to medulla.
expressionless face, strabismus, difculties with sucking, The bulbar nuclei appeared normal.
mild motor delay, and difculties in word articulation. On
neurological examination, he had bilateral asymmetric, fa-
cial (VII), and abducent (VI) nerve palsies, limited mouth
Case 3
opening (V), and hemiatrophy of the tongue (XII). CT and The brain weighed 450 gm (50th centile). Except for the
auditory evoked potentials were normal. The patient died fact that the insulae could still be visualized on both sides,
at age two years and three months, after receiving sedation the external aspect of cerebral hemispheres, brainstem, and
for a CT scan. cerebellum was normal. There was moderate dilatation of
the lateral ventricles, mainly at their posterior horns (col-
pocephaly). The corpus callosum was very thin. Microscop-
Case 3 ically, the lesions were limited to the brainstem. Unfortu-
This girl was the rst child of young, healthy and non- nately, for technical reasons the mesencephalon could not
consanguineous parents. Her mother attempted to abort in be studied. There were symmetrical foci of calcication in
the rst trimester, using 600 g of misoprostol by mouth. the lateral aspect of the tegmentum, which were observed
This was followed by mild vaginal bleeding a few hours from the upper pons to the lower medullar level. The
later. Otherwise, the pregnancy was uneventful. Prenatal nuclei of the VII nerve could not be traced. There was
ultrasonography three weeks before birth revealed poly- severe gliosis throughout the pons, mainly in the tegmen-
hydramnios, hydrocephalus, and poor sucking. Delivery tum and around the oor of the IVth ventricle. The me-
was by cesarean section, and the child had difculty estab- dulla was severely deformed and narrowed in the dorso-
lishing respiration. Apgar scores were 1, 1, 2, and 1 at 1, 2, ventral direction. The tegmentum was athrophic; the
5, and 10 min, respectively. Birth weight was 2980 gm inferior olives were malformed, poorly circumvolute, and
(10th25th centile) and occipitofrontal circumference was dorsally displaced. The pyramids were shrunken, gliotic,
37 cm. Physical examination revealed macrocrania, a and almost devoid of neurons. Around the lateral aspect of
mask-like face, microstomia, microretrognathism, and the caudal pons and medulla, there was a rim of glioneural
right equinovarus foot deformity, and it was difcult to ectopia formed by dysplastic nervous tissue, which lled
open her mouth. She died 40 min after birth, despite in- the arachnoidal space. An area of cerebellar micropo-
tensive resuscitation attempts. lygyria was noted beneath this ectopic tissue (Fig. 4).
DISCUSSION varied. They were most evidence in the area of the cranial
The neuropathological ndings in these three cases are nerve nuclei V, VI, and VII, as predicted by the clinical
characterized by symmetrical bilateral necrotic foci in dif- ndings in MS. Also, diffuse gliosis was present through-
ferent levels of the brain stem, with neuronal loss, gliosis, out the tegmentum of the brainstem, mainly at the pontine
and calcication, suggesting old hypoxic-ischemic lesions. level, involving reticular formation subnuclei.
Similar lesions in the brainstem have been identied in Kinney et al. (1989) and Cortez and Kinney (1996) have
children suffering from cardiac arrest (Gilles, 1963; Damb- previously discussed central apnea in three newborns with
ska et al., 1976; Janzer and Friede, 1980), transient circula- tegmental necrosis and olivary atrophy; Igarashi et al.
tory arrest, and asphyxia (Schneider et al., 1975; Leech et (1997) and Nunes et al. (1999) have also suggested that the
al., 1977). The intensity and distribution of the lesions central dysfunction presented by their patients with MS
would be the result of lesions in the proximity of respira- ship between in vivo brainstem calcications seen by CT
tory nuclei. and gliosis with calcied gliotic foci identied in neuro-
We conclude that the diffuse tegmental gliosis from the pathological sections (Thakkar et al., 1977; Govaert et al.,
caudal pons to the medulla (where the nucleus of olivary 1989; DCruz et al., 1993; St. Charles et al., 1993; Yoon et al.,
tract and dorsal respiratory nuclei group are located) and 1997; Squier, personal communication). Leong and Ash-
near the X, XI, and XII nuclei, in all cases, and the evident well (1997) have provided further evidence for the concept
olivary atrophy in case 3, was responsible for the respira- of a watershed zone in the paramedian dorsal region of the
tory difculties and apneic spells in these patients. brainstem. They show that this region, the most compro-
Bouwess-Bavinck and Weaver (1986) reported the asso- mised in Mobius syndrome, is especially vulnerable to
ciation of MS with transverse limb defects and proposed a ischemia due to particularities of its vascular anatomy. The
unifying mechanism for these abnormalities. They pro- authors showed in rats that the region is a watershed zone
posed that a disruptive process in the vascular territory of due to the inability of the vessels of the paramedian region
the subclavian artery, occurring between the sixth and to anastomose across the vascular midline. Moreover, Le-
eighth weeks of gestational age, was the most likely patho- ong and Ashwell (1997) also suggested that efferent motor
genic mechanism for these disorders and suggested that nuclei in this region have a high oxidative metabolic activ-
the Poland, Klippel-Feil, and Sprengel anomalies may have ity, which could render their constituent neurons more
a similar etiology. At that period of embryonic develop-
susceptible to hypoxia.
ment, a change in the arterial blood supply to the hind-
Several disruptive noxious events occurring in early ges-
brain, from an exclusive carotid supply to a vertebral one,
tation have been reported in association with Mobius syn-
leads to a reversal of blood ow within the basilar artery,
drome. Lipson et al. (1989) showed that abdominal trauma,
from a rostral caudal to a caudalrostral pattern. Any
pathogenic event that disturbs the circulation in this criti- uterine vessel clamping with handling, and hyperthermia
cal period will cause brainstem alterations or even more caused bilateral brainstem lesions in fetal rats. In a series of
widespread developmental defects, such as the failure of 15 patients with MS, noxious events, including hyperther-
segmentation of cervical vertebrae (Klippel-Feil anomaly), mia, previous uterine surgery, electric shock, failed abor-
absence of the muscle pectoralis major (Poland anomaly), tion, prolonged rupture of membranes, or alcohol abuse,
hypoplasia of the scapulae (Sprengel anomaly) or limb occurred early during their mothers pregnancy in eight of
malformations. All of these abnormalities can be features them.
of the Mobius syndrome. Teratogenic causes of MS have been postulated by sev-
Lipson et al. (1989), in their experimental studies of an eral authors, including: hyperthermia during pregnancy
animal model of MS, described typical brainstem lesions (Graham et al., 1988); cocaine use (Hoyme et al., 1990;
with relative sparing of cerebrum. In the three cases de- Kankirawatana et al., 1993); ergotamine use (Graf and
scribed in this article, there was relative sparing of the Shepard, 1997); thalidomide use (Newman, 1985); and cho-
cerebrum when compared with the brainstem. The dyspla- rionic villus sample (CVS) (Firth et al., 1991).
sia observed in the arachnoidal space and cerebellum of Cortez et al. (1996) have proposed that some pathologies
case 3 could also be the result of a hypoxic ischemic event. of the caudal pons (at the level of cranial nerve VI) and the
Prenatal brainstem ischemic lesions have been reported medulla (at the level of cranial nerves IX, X, and XII) could
in association with MS and, in particular, a close relation- result from abnormal development of the respective rhom-
Figure 4. Case 3. Medullameningeal glioneural ectopia and malformation of the inferior olive.
bomeres due to a defect in the homeobox genes that reg- ture (Coelho et al., 1993, 1994; Faundes et al., 1996). Yip et
ulate the development of those segments. al. (2000) have determined signicant increase in Doppler-
In mouse and frog embryos, Hox genes have been resistance indices of uterine arteries 1 hr after a single oral
shown to be activated after treatment with retinoic acid, a dose of misoprostol in women seeking legal termination of
metabolite of vitamin A, both in cultured cells and in vivo pregnancy at 715 completed gestational weeks. Although
(Boncinelli, 1999). Homeobox-containing genes EN-1 and these changes were not associated with fetal death at that
EN-2 have been implicated in the control of pattern forma- time, the authors believe that subtherapeutic doses of mi-
tion during development of the central nervous system in soprostol could explain the congenital abnormalities by a
experimental animals. Expression of EN genes was dem- vascular mechanism that caused a transient ischemic-hy-
onstrated in all neuronal groups of the medulla and cere- poxic insult.
bellum after in situ hybridization with human EN-1 and Two series of infants with congenital abnormalities with
EN-2 RNA probes in the medulla and cerebellum of hu- or without MS exposed in utero to misoprostol used as an
man embryos (18 21 weeks gestational age) (Zec et al.,
abortifacient were reported by some of us (Gonzalez et al.,
1997).
1993, 1998) in 1993 and 1998; in those two series, 25 of the
One could speculate that misoprostol would interact,
49 affected infants also had MS.
like retinoic acid, with certain homeobox genes that act in
the pontine and medullary development of the human Pastuszak et al. (1998), in a cohort study, compared the
fetus. However, based on the clear pathologic evidence of frequency of misoprostol usage during the rst trimester of
old marks of hypoxic-ischemic insult in the same region, pregnancy by mothers of 96 children with MS and mothers
we consider a vascular disruption mechanism as a more of 96 children with neural tube defects. The study showed
plausible cause of our ndings. Specically, uterine arterial that attempted abortion with misoprostol was associated
vasoconstriction, caused by the drug, would lead to reduc- with a signicantly increased risk of MS in infants.
tion in arterial blood ow to the fetus, causing the isch- Clemens et al. (1997), working with rabbits, found evi-
emia, hemorrhage, and tissue loss. dence for the teratogenicity of misoprostol. They demon-
Misoprostol, a prostaglandin E1 analog, which has po- strated an increase in spina bida, caudal vertebral defects,
tent uterotonic properties, has been used for illegal medical umbilical hernia, and gastroschisis after exposure to miso-
termination of pregnancy in Brazil, where its use in an prostol on days 79 of gestation. In rats exposed to mater-
uncontrolled fashion has been well reported in the litera- nal cocaine, Webster and Brown-Woodman (1990) and