Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
EUROCONTROL
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
CONTENTS
1. INTRODUCTION.......................................................................................................................................... 1
2. REVIEW OF PAST ATM NETWORK CAPACITY PERFORMANCE ................................................................. 1
3. MEDIUM-TERM TRAFFIC FORECAST.......................................................................................................... 2
4. MEDIUM-TERM CAPACITY REQUIREMENTS............................................................................................... 4
4.1. OVERALL NETWORK CAPACITY REQUIREMENTS .................................................................................................. 4
4.2. ACC CAPACITY REQUIREMENTS...................................................................................................................... 5
4.3. IMPACT OF TRAFFIC DISTRIBUTION ON MEDIUM-TERM CAPACITY PLANNING............................................................... 7
5 MEDIUM-TERM CAPACITY PLANNING PROCESSES AND TOOLS............................................................. 10
5.1 CAPACITY PLANNING PROCESSES ......................................................................................................... 10
5.2 TOOLS ..................................................................................................................................................... 10
5.2.1 CAPAN......................................................................................................................................................................10
5.2.2 DEMAND DATA REPOSITORY (DDR)...........................................................................................................................11
5.2.3 NEVAC......................................................................................................................................................................11
5.2.4 SAAM .......................................................................................................................................................................11
5.3 DEMAND FORECASTING.......................................................................................................................... 12
6 ENROUTE & TERMINAL CAPACITY ENHANCEMENT ................................................................................ 13
6.1 THE AIRSPACE ACTION PLAN ....................................................................................................................... 13
6.2 THE FLIGHT EFFICIENCY PLAN ..................................................................................................................... 13
6.2.1 ACTION POINT 1: ENHANCE EUROPEAN AIRSPACE DESIGN ................................................................................ 14
6.2.2 ACTION POINT 2: IMPROVE AIRSPACE UTILISATION AND ROUTE NETWORK AVAILABILITY ......................................... 20
6.2.3 ACTION POINT 3: EFFICIENT TERMINAL AIRSPACE............................................................................................ 21
6.2.4 ACTION POINT 4: OPTIMISE AIRPORT OPERATIONS .......................................................................................... 22
6.2.5 ACTION POINT 5: IMPROVE PERFORMANCE AWARENESS ................................................................................... 24
6.2.6 NEXT STEPS ............................................................................................................................................. 24
7 ACC CAPACITY ENHANCEMENT MEASURES........................................................................................... 25
7.1 ADDITIONAL CONTROLLERS ......................................................................................................................... 25
7.2 INCREASED SECTOR THROUGHPUT AND THE USE OF OPTIMUM CONFIGURATIONS .................................................... 25
7.3 NEW ATM SYSTEMS AND ATM SYSTEM UPGRADES .......................................................................................... 25
7.4 OTHER LOCAL CAPACITY ENHANCEMENT MEASURES ....................................................................................... 26
8 PAN-EUROPEAN CAPACITY ENHANCEMENT PROGRAMMES.................................................................. 27
8.1 LINK 2000 PROGRAMME ............................................................................................................................ 28
8.2 8.33 KHZ BELOW FL195 ............................................................................................................................. 28
8.3 AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION MANAGEMENT PROJECTS ................................................................................... 29
8.4 NAVIGATION INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS...................................................................................................... 30
8.5 MODE S PROGRAMME ................................................................................................................................ 31
8.6 CASCADE ................................................................................................................................................. 33
8.7 FASTI ...................................................................................................................................................... 33
8.8 SAFETY NETS ........................................................................................................................................... 34
8.9 TECHNICAL SUPPORT FOR TMAS ................................................................................................................. 34
9 AIRPORTS................................................................................................................................................ 36
9.1 AIRPORT ACTIVITIES IN SUPPORT OF THE DMEAN FRAMEWORK PROGRAMME ...................................................... 36
9.1.1 DMEAN IMPLEMENTATION TARGETS ............................................................................................................. 37
9.1.2 TARGET AIRPORTS .................................................................................................................................... 38
9.1.3 ANALYSIS AND DELAY REDUCTION ACTIVITIES ................................................................................................. 39
9.1.4 AIRSIDE CAPACITY ENHANCEMENT (ACE) ACTIVITIES ....................................................................................... 40
9.1.5 ASSESSMENT OF OPTIMUM LOCATION OF RAPID EXIT TAXIWAYS (RETS) .............................................................. 41
9.1.6 PLANNED CAPACITY ENABLERS .................................................................................................................... 42
9.1.7 AIRPORT COLLABORATIVE DECISION MAKING (A-CDM) .................................................................................... 43
9.1.8 CONTRIBUTION TO NETWORK OPERATIONS PLAN (NOP)................................................................................... 48
9.2 ACTION PLANS IN SUPPORT OF DMEAN ACTIVITIES.......................................................................................... 49
i
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ii
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
iii
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
iv
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The European Medium-Term ATM Network Operations Performance Plan Assessment
consolidates all local capacity plans into one single document and provides an outlook of the
expected network performance for the period 2011-2014 with increased focus on 2011/12.
This document has been developed in the context of the European ATM network operations, planning
and management. The intent is to provide a medium-term outlook of capacity performance at
network level and of capacity enhancement measures planned for each ACC, as well as a
description of the airport capacity assessment and enhancement work in progress at the most
constraining airports. The Plan identifies potential bottlenecks and gives early indications to States
and ANSPs on the need to plan for additional resources, on network interactions and on the need to
implement improvements at network level.
States, ANSPs, Airports and aircraft operators have worked together with the Agency to address the
ATM capacity gap and have fully supported the interactive approach for the development of sound
local capacity plans in the context of the Local Single Sky Implementation Plan (LSSIP) development.
The document identifies the airspace structure development activities that balance the deployment of
additional capacity against increased flight efficiency over the European ATM network.
The latest EUROCONTROL STATFOR Medium-
Term Forecast (MTF) predicts that between
2009 and 2014, the average baseline annual
traffic growth in Europe will be 2.8. This is an
improvement on last year’s forecast, indicating
initial signs of economic recovery from the
global recession.
Although traffic growth at network level remains
fairly low, States on the critical south-east axis
are expected to experience higher demand
growth, increasing the need for robust capacity
planning and implementation.
Summer Traffic, Delay & Capacity Evolution At European network level, the delay forecast for
35000 5,5 6,0
the period 2011-2013 shows that network delay
30000
Traffic will continue to be higher than the target set by
Enroute delay per flight (min)
5,0
the Provisional Council of 1 minute per flight
Movements per day
25000
20000
3,6
3,1
Effective capacity 4,0
enroute, in spite of minimal traffic growth in many
15000
3,0 areas. Delays in Summer 2011 are likely to be
higher than initially expected, resulting from
2,0
1,8 1,6 2,0
1,4 1,4 1,4
10000 1,2 1,2 1,3
planned reduction in capacity during the training
1,2 1,2 1,1
1,0
1,0
v
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
vi
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
1. INTRODUCTION
The European ATM Network Operations Performance Plan Assessment for the period 2011-
2014 has been prepared by EUROCONTROL in the context of the cooperative process
between the Air Navigation Service Providers (ANSPs), airports and the Agency for the
development of local capacity plans. It is part of the consolidated planning process already
implemented through the Dynamic Management of European Airspace Network (DMEAN)
Framework Programme.
The document provides a medium-term outlook of the capacity situation at network and local
level, identifies possible bottlenecks and gives early indication of the need for additional
measures, details of network interactions and improvements required at network level. It allows
an early assessment of the ability of the network to provide the required capacity and enable a
jointly agreed course of action with respect to local actions and network developments.
Included is a brief review of past capacity performance, an assessment of the expected
performance of the European ATM network in 2011 and 2012 and a summary of capacity
enhancement measures planned for each Area Control Centre (ACC) for the period 2011-2014,
as agreed with individual ANSPs during the development of capacity plans included in the Local
Single Sky Implementation Plans (LSSIP) 2010-2014.
As part of the continuing drive towards the full integration of airports into the network capacity
planning process, a description of the airport capacity assessment and enhancement work in
progress is included, as well as specific information on the expected evolution of capacity at the
most constraining airports.
Details of expected network and local performance for Summer 2010 may be found in the
Network Operations Plan for each ACC and for some airports, available through the NOP
Portal.
1
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
The effective capacity of European ATM network increased by 0.6% for the Summer period and
by 0.4% for the whole year 2009. The considerable reduction in demand should have enabled
complete closure of the capacity gap, but yet again the Summer enroute delay target was not
met. This was due to a small number of critical ACCs, mainly on the south-east axis, that did
not have sufficient controllers available to open optimum sector configurations. Ongoing staff
management problems and system limitations resulting from the postponement of major
projects were contributing factors.
More than two-thirds of the total ECAC enroute delay during Summer 2009 was the result of
ATFM regulations in just 8 ACCs: Athens, Karlsruhe, Langen, Madrid, Nicosia, Warsaw,
Vienna and Zurich.
Indicators for the evolution of flight efficiency in terms of route network design, route availability
and flight planning show positive results, showing a steady and measurable decrease since
monitoring began.
The reduction in air traffic following 9/11, combined with improved capacity planning processes,
enabled sufficient closure of the capacity gap to almost achieve the Summer delay target of 1
minute per flight enroute in 2003 and 2004, but in subsequent years delays again increased as
a result of controller shortages and the postponement of some major projects. Summer 2009
saw enroute delay once again close to the target, but this is attributed to the considerable
decrease in air traffic caused by the continuing recession.
The loss of revenue (for service providers and users), has shifted focus from increasing
capacity and reducing delay to improving flight efficiency and reducing overall cost.
Unfortunately, for a number of ANSPs, this has meant cutting back on the recruitment of air
traffic controllers and/or costly projects (in terms of cash and staff). These short-term
economies will have an adverse impact on long-term capacity provision across the European
ATM network, the effects of which may only be apparent when traffic growth again accelerates
and capacity and delay move once more into the spotlight.
3. MEDIUM-TERM TRAFFIC FORECAST
The latest EUROCONTROL STATFOR Medium-Term Forecast (MTF) was published in
February 2010 and covers the period 2010-2016. It indicates that, over this period, the average
annual traffic growth in Europe is expected to be between 1.6% and 4.0% with a most likely
value of 2.8% per year. This is an improvement on the previous year’s forecast, indicating initial
signs of economic recovery from the global recession.
The traffic forecast per ACC assumes that the airspace structure will continue to exist in its
current form. In reality it will continue to develop and change over the period of this report. The
maps below show the traffic increase in 2014 compared to 2009 at ACC level, for the baseline
and the high traffic growth scenarios with traffic distributed over the current route network. This
traffic increase was derived through the capacity planning process of EUROCONTROL for a
representative period of the Summer season, on the basis of the origin-destination zones (ODZ)
growth provided by STATFOR as part of the Medium-Term Forecast 2010-2016 released in
February 2010.
2
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
See paragraph 5.3 for more information on the traffic forecasting methodology and the
individual ACC pages in Annex 1 for the % growth per ACC.
3
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
The following chart illustrates the historical and forecast evolution of the enroute ATFM delay,
traffic and “effective capacity”.
5,0
Movements per day
25000
3,6 Effective capacity Forecast 4,0
20000 3,1
3,0
15000 2,0
1,8
1,6 2,0
1,4 1,4 1,4
10000 1,2 1,2 1,3 1,2 1,2 1,1
1,0
1,0
5000
Average ER delay PC delay target
0 0,0
19 20 20 20 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
99 00 01 02 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014
4
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
The capacity requirement profiles are based on the following planning assumptions:
Achieving (by Summer 2010) and maintaining the PC average enroute delay target of 1
minute per flight;
Traffic growth according to the STATFOR medium-term forecast (Mar 2010), low, baseline
and high traffic growth scenarios;
Forecast traffic distributed over the current and the shortest routes available on the future
ATS Route Network, with generally unconstrained vertical profiles.
For the medium-term capacity planning of the European ATM network, capacity profiles are set
for existing and future ACC configurations (i.e. those planned to be operational between 2010
and 2014) in the ECAC area, by considering the whole ATM network and giving due
consideration to airport capacity constraints.
The 2011-2015 ACC capacity profiles are linked to the ACC capacity baselines that were
assessed during Summer 2009, and are agreed to be used as a reference for medium term
capacity planning. 2009 capacity baselines were also assessed for ACC configurations planned
for implementation between 2010 and 2015, thus allowing the derivation of capacity profiles for
future configurations.
The 2011-2015 planning cycle takes into account the following changes to areas of
responsibility for ACCs implemented or planned by various ANSPs:
Germany
Karlsruhe UAC with the Upper Airspace of Munich ACC as from Winter 2012/13
Munich ACC without the upper airspace as from Winter 2012/13
Turkey
Ankara ACC – all Turkish airspace above FL235 from Winter 2010/11
Istanbul and Izmir APP units – extended areas of responsibility below FL235 from
Winter 2010/11
UK
Merge of Manchester and Scottish ACC into new Prestwick Centre from Winter 2009/10
Finland
Merging of Tampere and Rovaniemi ACC into new Tampere Centre from Winter
2010/11
Capacity profiles are also provided for certain sector groups, on a bilateral basis, when
requested by ANSPs.
Note: the capacity requirement profiles will be used as a basis for local capacity planning for
the next LSSIP cycle 2011-2015. Current capacity plans cover the period 2010-2014. Even
though the latest STATFOR traffic forecast is available for 2016, local capacity plans are
currently available only until 2014 (ref. LSSIP 2010-2014), and therefore this document covers
only the period 2011-2014.
5
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
The following maps illustrate the capacity increases per ACC required by 2014 for the baseline
(medium, or reference) and high traffic growth scenarios.
6
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
4.3.1 Effect of traffic distribution via shortest and cheapest available routes
The impact of the traffic distribution (shortest/cheapest routes) remains high and the trend that
started 3-4 years ago still continues. The effect is significant on the SE Axis. These effects are
assessed through the capacity planning process and communicated on a regular basis to the
ANSPs. It is important to note that the traffic distribution differences might have a significant
impact as some ACCs experience a traffic growth depending on the choices made by the
aircraft operators, despite indications of traffic decrease given by the current forecasts. This
requires a certain flexibility in the preparations for the Summer 2010 to accommodate the user
preferred routes.
The maps below show the average daily differences in traffic demand between the shortest and
cheapest available routes and the routes flown during Summer 2009.
7
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
It is also important to note that in 2009 the aircraft operators used, to the largest possible
extent and whenever possible, the cheapest available routes. Nevertheless capacity
problems on the SE Axis prevented the full use of the available options in terms of route
network to the aircraft operators
8
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
To ensure the required delivery of capacity in the medium-term, detailed capacity plans are
developed by the ANSPs for each ACC. The information included in this document is taken
from the medium-term capacity plans included in Local Single Sky Implementation Plan (LSSIP)
2010-2014. Details of ACC capacity enhancement initiatives can be found in the individual
ACC pages at the end of this document. The map below indicates the overall percentage
capacity increases planned for Summer 2014 with respect to the 2009 agreed ACC capacity
baseline.
Note that these capacity plans are based on the capacity requirement profiles 2010-2014, which
were calculated according to the STATFOR September refresh of the 2009 Medium Term traffic
Forecast (MTF).
The ACC capacity requirements shown on the maps in para. 4.2 reflect the new profiles,
updated in March 2010, based on the February 2010 STATFOR MTF. New capacity plans will
be developed in Autumn 2010 in response to these ACC capacity requirement profiles, and
these will be published in the LSSIP 2011-2015.
Comparison of current capacity plans (LSSIP 2010-2014) with the current reference profile
(March 2010, baseline traffic growth, shortest routes) can be found for each ACC in Annex 1.
9
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
5.2 Tools
The following tools are widely used in the Airspace Design and Capacity Planning process.
5.2.1 CAPAN
Within the past year, ANSPs in Austria, Belgium, France, Greece, Ireland, Maastricht UAC,
Switzerland, Turkey and Ukraine have requested the Agency to assess their sector capacities
with a CAPAN (Capacity Analyser) analysis. This uses the EUROCONTROL Airspace Model
as the simulation engine in a fully cooperative process involving operational controllers at the
10
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ACCs concerned, to determine the workload of simulated controller positions for a given traffic
sample. The capacity of the sector is deemed to be reached when the workload on any of the
simulated working positions (generally the radar controller or the planning controller position)
reaches a predetermined threshold. As a direct result of this analysis, a number of ACCs plan
to increase, or have already increased sector capacities.
11
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
This new approach will considerably improve the powerful ‘what if’ function necessary for the
efficient evaluation of airspace design proposals. When fully implemented, it will ensure
improved accuracy of the database and facilitate the inclusion of changes.
www.eurocontrol.int/saam
12
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Full details of improvements already achieved in response to the Flight Efficiency Plan are
available in the Network Operations Report for 2009 – the web version may be downloaded
from the EUROCONTROL Capacity Enhancement Function website: www.eurocontrol.int/cef
reference documents page.
Action point 1 is to improve the airspace structure through the gradual implementation of
successive versions of the ATS Route Network (ARN Vn). ARN V6 is in its implementation
phase and the development of ARN V7 is well underway. The following diagram shows the
time-frame for the short-term and medium term airspace structure development.
The Advanced Airspace Scheme (AAS) is based on an advanced concept for airspace design
and is an evolving roadmap for the European ATS Route Network from which successive
versions of the ATS Route Network and annual improvements are derived, in close cooperation
with States’ civil and military authorities, ANSPs and airspace users.
ARN V7 fully embraces the AAS Route Network and is being developed on the basis of a
coherent integration of network, ECAC interface, FAB, sub-regional, State/ANSP or local plans.
The following elements are covered:
ATS route network improvement projects;
Resectorisation projects;
Terminal Airspace redesign projects;
Night Route/weekend route projects;
Free Route Airspace projects;
Airspace adjustments to facilitate the implementation of RVSM by the Russian Federation
on 17 November 2011;
14
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
To synchronise the European airspace network developments with the requirements set in the
SES II Implementing Rule on the Performance Scheme, the timeframe of the ARN Version-7
has been extended by one year, with the development phase, including the validation, running
until Spring 2012 and the phased implementation of ARN Version-7 commencing in Spring
2011 and continuing until Autumn 2013. The ARN Version-7 will be a major contributor to the
achievement of the SES II performance scheme targets
The first Concept of Operations and Catalogue of projects for ARN Version-7 will be available
by the end of 2010. All medium-term projects will be integrated into a coherent plan, providing
a consolidated overview of the European airspace design improvements planned for 2011,
2012, 2013/2014.
Some of the projects currently under development impact the overall European ATS route
network and it is essential that any inconsistencies are resolved prior to implementation. In this
respect, it is necessary that all States, ANSPs, FAB initiatives and sub-regional group activities
proactively provide the information to the Route Network Development Sub-Group on a timely
basis to support the required network approach. This will ensure transparency and coherency
of all the airspace design work.
The consolidation of all medium-term projects into one single view of the European airspace
design for 2011 and beyond ensures:
Clear visibility of the evolution of the European airspace structure until 2014;
Identification of network effects;
Identification of inconsistencies between FAB, sub-regional or national projects;
Identification of corrective actions to ensure an integrated approach and to maintain
consistency of the overall European airspace design, including at its interfaces;
Harmonisation of operations in the European airspace;
Clear identification of benefits.
The ARN V7 airspace improvement proposals range from minor ATS route alignments and
designation changes to large scale reorganisation of busy airspace. The following paragraphs
describe the major airspace changes foreseen to be implemented, that are expected to result in
significant airspace improvements.
15
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
16
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
As part of the coordinated ATM network development approach. the Route Network
Development Sub-Group supports FAB developments through the provision of operational
expertise and skilled tools manipulation for the detailed airspace design projects, the evaluation
of flight efficiency and capacity benefits, the integration of military airspace requirements, and
the preparation of prototype and real time simulations.
The support provided by the Agency allows step-by-step consolidation of the airspace proposals
in the context of an individual FAB and the integration of these proposals into the network
airspace structure development. This supports the interconnectivity of the overall network and
the consolidation of individual projects inside a FAB and at the interface.
17
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
RNDSG ROLE:
FAB
Regular FAB briefings AAS: Advanced
Initiatives Airspace Scheme
o Current developments
Pan-European
o Share best practice Network
o Long term projects
o Project synchronisation
o New Ops Concepts
Regional Consolidate AAS network
Groups o Interconnectivity ARN VST, V6, V7
o Complete network view o Short and Medium
term projects
o Derive new projects
State
o Derive new ARN Versions
Proposals
18
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
UK-Ireland FAB
The IAA and NATS have jointly
published the 2010-2013 FAB Plan, to
integrate North Atlantic, Domestic
(Irish/UK) and European traffic flows,
establishing even more operational
synergy across the airspace of the two
countries. Good cooperation and
support continued in the context of the
development of the NAT Night Fuel
Saving Routes Initiative. Appropriate
links are in place to ensure a good
interconnectivity with similar initiatives
within the FABEC or other adjacent
airspace.
Airspace Structure Development
o Optimisation of ATS route network, Free Route Airspace Operations and Night routes
o FAB UK/Ireland review interfaces of FAB EC developments/ Summer 2013.
o Optimisation of sectorisation within FAB and at interfaces/2013
19
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Danube FAB
20
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
For the 50 most penalised city pairs, EUROCONTROL has coordinated the development of a
comprehensive catalogue of improvement proposals, together with their operational feasibility
assessments. Detailed implementation projects are further developed by States and/or by FAB
initiatives and are coordinated by expert groups.
Route network improvement proposals for the most penalised city pairs are gradually being
deployed, with some aiming initially at a limited implementation of an improved night route
network. Most of the proposals are for direct segments that are offered by ATC on a tactical
basis. By making these available for flight planning even for limited periods, users will be able to
reduce the fuel carried.
6.2.2 Action point 2: Improve Airspace Utilisation and Route Network Availability
Actively support and involve aircraft operators and the computer flight plan service
providers in flight plan quality improvements
Gradually apply route availability restrictions only where and when required
Improving the utilisation of civil/military airspace structures
In 2011, one of the tasks is to further improve this process, making it a more dynamic, rolling
process. The driving idea behind this concept is to introduce the possibility to upload changes to
the airspace structures to the CFMU database, as part of the Airspace Data Repository (ADR),
and to provide notification to the users as they occur.
The focus is on the improvement of the planning process, following a review of current
procedures; in particular there is a need to assess the parameters for when and how changes
within a certain timeframe can be effectively notified to users and processed for flight plan
purposes.
ASM Solutions
The ASM solution aims at improving the present practices in order to overcome capacity
constraints and provide efficient flight operations of both civil and military airspace users.
The main objective of the ASM Solutions development is to identify “hidden” airspace capacity
and flight efficiency solutions by taking advantage of the full potential of airspace management.
To deliver extra capacity and flight efficiency, the design of TRA/TSA and their associated
airspace planning and allocation processes and procedures will be reconsidered. The enhanced
ASM processes will consider various levels of flexibility, either in time or in spatial location
(vertical or horizontal), permitted within the planned civil or military flight operations.
The ASM solutions are particularly important in the context of the ARN V7 that will include further
solutions for the most penalised city pairs, the further deployment of the European night direct
route network, and solutions offering the airspace users several routing options.
ATFCM
The CFMU continues to develop Air Traffic Flow & Capacity Management (ATFCM), working with
ANSPs and aircraft operators to achieve a better utilisation of ATM capacity and a better
integration of ATFCM and ASM processes. Major airspace changes, the implementation of new
ATM systems and other special events are coordinated at European level through extensive
preplanning and coordination process carried out between the key players, under CFMU
coordination.
22
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Note: for full details on all airport initiatives, please see Chapter 9
23
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
There has been good progress to implement the actions foreseen in the Flight Efficiency Plan.
Nevertheless, more emphasis is needed for:
The further development and implementation of dynamic and flexible airspace design
solutions to support improved flight-plannable routes between the most penalised 50 city
pairs;
A more open approach to solutions involving ATS delegation, cross-border areas and shared
civil/military use of airspace;
A more flexible approach towards airspace utilisation, particularly in respect of the RAD
applicability;
Prioritisation of the development of ATM system support for improved airspace utilisation;
Rapid expansion of free-route-like initiatives;
A harmonised and accelerated deployment of A-CDM.
24
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
25
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
The map below shows major ATM system and airspace changes planned during the period, that
are likely to result in a short term temporary reduction in capacity.
These system changes pose a significant challenge to the smooth operation of ATM in Europe. A
high level of cooperation and preparation at ATM network level is essential, starting with the
medium term planning phase through to tactical operations. A fully integrated planning,
encompassing all phases, will need to be in place to ensure that operational performance is
maintained at acceptable levels.
The EUROCONTROL Agency provides support to ANSPs involved in the implementation of new
ATM systems in terms of simulation, coordination, technical expertise, airspace & capacity
planning, and ATFCM during the transition period, and full involvement and cooperation will be
required from all ATM partners.
26
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ND Technology Deployment
All ATSUs
5 ACCs 20 ACCs
ELS-EHS ELS-EHS
extension extension
ADS-B ADS-B
Forward-fit Retro-fit
20 Airports
10 Airports 30 Airports
+ 5 ACCs
27
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ANSPs Whole of EU
1st Jan 2011 7th Feb 2013 5th Feb 2015
28
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
These proposals will follow the formal consultation stages of the regulatory process described
below prior to any firm decisions being taken.
European Commission Regulation (EC) No 1265/2007 of 26 October 2007 addresses 8.33 kHz
implementation above FL195. This Regulation will be updated to address implementation below
FL195,in three main stages:
- Regulatory approach development and consultation,
- Draft Implementing Rule production and consultation,
- Updated Rule adoption
The figure below shows the timetable for the above process and the expected dates for the
consultation workshops (WS) and the 8.33 Programme Steering Group (PSG) meetings.
29
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Implementation Milestones:
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
ICAO Anx 15 Amdt 36 ADQ IR ICAO Anx 15 Amdt 37
Digital AIM - AIXM 5.1 published - AIXM 5.1 export - Digital NOTAM - Digital NOTAM
by ECTRL & FAA from EAD Increment 1 Increment 2
- Digital SNOWTAM - eAIP 1.x released Operational in EAD operational in EAD
trials
eTOD - Area 2 conclusion - Guidance material - Training, Support - Area 2 operational - Project close-out
Development to States &
Helpdesk
DMEAN ADR
ADR - Electronic
Support AirSpace Mngt msg
operational
Guidance - ICAO publication of - European AISAIM - AISAIM guidance - AISAIM support - AIM impl
material AISAIM Roadmap Roadmap dev - Competency update
update completed
- SWIM Course - GNSS NOTAM - Charting harm.
- ADQ Helpdesk Guidelines
- ADQ Support
Tools - DQTS support - ICARD handed
terminated over to ICAO
- Skyview
integrated into NOP
Relevant regulations are: ICAO Annex 15 Amendments (36-2010, 37-2013), the ADQ
Implementing Rule, Community Specifications (Data Origination, AIXM5.1, eAIP, Data Quality
Requirements (DQRs) and Data Assurance Levels (DALs).
In addition to the regulatory material the following supporting material is foreseen:
Provision of Means of Compliance
Support to Implementation of Provisions
Support to National Supervisory Authorities (NSAs)
Support for Overall Monitoring
30
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Milestones/ timelines:
2010: APV operations deployed for 30% of runways
2010/11: EGNOS certification
2011: GBAS CAT I certification
2014: APV operations deployed for 70% of runways
2016: APV operations deployed for all runways
2015/17: ADS-B and A-RNP mandates will require the use of GNSS
2015/16: GBAS CAT III certification
2018: Dual constellation/dual frequency GNSS
2012/25: Rationalisation/removal of NDB and VOR
Regulatory material: ICAO Annex 10 SARPS. The IR on A-RNP is in preparation and the IR on
APV is under discussion.
Reference material:
Mo SESAR Master Plan
Strategic guidance material in support of the implementation of the ATM Master Plan.
ESSIP NAV 06, 07 and 08 objectives
ICAO Assembly resolution
To achieve the 2012 Initial Operating Capability, it is necessary to integrate the operational
deployment of the three code management procedures and processes within Air Navigation
Service Provider systems across the European region in a coordinated and structured manner.
At all times the implementation must ensure that the operational methods to establish and
maintain aircraft identification within one airspace of the region are seamless and completely
interoperable with the methods employed in other airspace volumes of the region. The three
operational methods to be used for establishing and maintaining aircraft identification by February
2012 are:
Elementary Surveillance enabled by Mode S;
CCAMS;
Enhanced ORCAM environment.
The 2012 Initial Operating Capability will be underpinned by EC Regulation and by ICAO &
EUROCONTROL agreements for non EC states. In May 2009, the Stakeholder Consultation
Group endorsed the Aircraft Identification 2012 Initial Operating Capability concept as mature and
ready for operational implementation.
31
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
The following map shows the regions in which the three aircraft identification methods will apply:
To achieve the Initial Operating Capability a specific implementation programme has been
developed; the Aircraft Identity (ACID) programme. This programme is endorsed by the
Provisional Council and managed by the EUROCONTROL Agency. Programme oversight is
assured by the dedicated steering group of the ANSB.
Airspace legislation currently requires the carriage and operation of Mode S ELS transponders
for certain categories of aircraft flying in France, Germany, Luxembourg, Netherlands and
Switzerland, and will be extended to cover the additional participating states as appropriate.
The Surveillance Performance and Interoperability Implementing Rule will require Mode S ELS
(and EHS) carriage requirement for certain categories of aircraft flying in EU European airspace
and interoperability between ground surveillance systems. The draft provisions require airborne
equipment forward fit by 2012, and retrofit by 2015.
32
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
8.6 CASCADE
The objective of the CASCADE Programme is to increase ATM efficiency, reduce ATM delays
and increase safety through the deployment of ADS-B surveillance technology and the
associated ADS-B Out and ADS-B In ATM applications. The main operational benefits will be
obtained from the provision of enhanced situational awareness to pilots and controllers, the
introduction of advanced automation and some re-distribution of the ATS tasks between
controllers and flight crews. CASCADE will deliver the generic Preliminary Safety Case and the
generic Business Case in preparation for implementation, inputs to international standardisation,
pre-operational systems, validation tools, and implementation support, including regulatory
material.
In recognition of the potential benefits and complementary nature of combined ADS-B / Wide
Area Multilateration (WAM) surveillance systems in a number of airspace environments, WAM
elements are now formally integrated into all aspects of the CASCADE Programme tasks.
An important element of the CASCADE approach is a trials campaign based on the local
operational needs of the stakeholders in order to validate and accelerate deployment. Pioneer
projects for operational trials on and deployment of ADS-B ATSAW (including ADS-B ITP) and
ADS-B Out applications (where appropriate in combined ADS-B/WAM systems) have been
established in partnership with aircraft operators, airframe and avionics manufacturers, air
navigation service providers, and regulators.
Cascade is due to end in 2013, and operates under the provisions of SESAR IP1.
Pioneer Projects:
2009-2012: ADS-B ATSAW
2009-2012: ADS-B Out
The SPI IR will require carriage of ADS-B Out for certain categories of aircraft flying in all EU
European airspace. The draft provisions are indicating forward fit by 2012 and retrofit by 2015.
Reference material:
ED-126 /DO 303 AMC 20-24
ED 161 / DO ***
ED-159 / DO-312
ED-160 / DO-134
Preliminary Safety Case ADS-B NRA
CRISTAL Trials – Reports
Business Case – report and web-based CBA tool
ESSIP: SUR 05 ADS-B NRA
All reference material is available on www.eurocontrol.int/cascade and
http://www.eurocontrol.int/surveillance/public/standard_page/library.html#wam
8.7 FASTI
FASTI is coordinating the implementation of controller support tools in a harmonized way across
37 European states before 2012. The programme scope comprises conflict detection,
monitoring aids (MONA) and system supported coordination (SYSCO) tools. The deployment of
FASTI is an integral part of SESAR IP1 and the ATM Master Plan, forming part of the baseline for
the SESAR concept. The FASTI Operational Concept promotes harmonised implementation of
support tools and controller working methods, seamless operational processes/procedures and
system services covering tactical and planning tasks at sector, group-sector level and single
person operation. The Concept is seen as highly relevant to FAB implementation and initial
operations with impact on FDP systems, HMI and OLDI/SYSCO.
33
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Implementation Milestones:
1/1/10: Phase 3 Wide scale deployment starts
31/12/11: 5 ACCs FASTI capable
31/12/13: 20 ACCs FASTI capable
The main drivers for implementation are the ESSIP/LSSIP Objectives (e.g. ATC12 Conflict
Detection and Conformance Monitoring, ATC3.1 Coordination and Transfer). A new ESSIP
object is under development Implement enhanced procedures for inter and intra centre
coordination and transfer. The use of OLDI 4.1 SES Community Specification forms the basis of
SYSCO implementation.
Reference material:
FASTI Operational Concept version 2.0
FASTI ATC Manual
FASTI Specifications and Guidance Material for implementation of MTCD, Trajectory
Prediction and Monitoring Aids.
34
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Implementation Milestones:
31/12/09: Implementation and Support Plan agreed
1/1/10: Wide scale deployment starts
31//1/10: 10 ACCs Basic AMAN capable
31/12/13: 20 Airports and 5 ACCs
The main drivers for implementation are the ESSIP/LSSIP Objectives e.g. ATC7.1 AMAN. A new
ESSIP object is currently under development.
Reference material:
AMAN Information Extension to Enroute Sectors - Concept of Operations April 2009
EATCHIP AMAN ORD Edition 2.0 1998.
35
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
9 AIRPORTS
The full integration of airports into the European capacity planning process is essential for
planning the development of the European air traffic system. Improved availability and accuracy
of information on airport capacity as well as local airport plans ensures the timely development of
airspace capacity enhancement measures, providing maximum benefit to the European ATM
network as a whole.
In order to sustain growth an airport must engage in airside capacity planning to meet future
demand. Airports are being integrated into the European capacity planning process, with the
primary objective being to provide a method to identify and target the constraints that limit current
and/or future ATM network capacity. Key stakeholders from all areas of an airport must be
involved, including airlines, ATS providers, airport operations, etc.
This section aims at providing information on European airports that is relevant to the Medium
Term ATM Capacity Planning Process by reporting all available and public information on:
Current and forecast traffic demand
Information on capacity constraints
Information on all areas associated with the development of an airport
This information supports the early identification of issues that affect capacity (either positive or
negative), and the need for improvements.
The initiatives currently being explored by EUROCONTROL aim to improve airport and network
capacity and to increase the operational efficiency of airports.
36
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
These targets are only achievable with agreement and commitment between the key local airport
partners. In order to secure the achievement of these implementation targets and provide a
baseline for the SESAR Programme, the following joint action plans have been established:
ACI EUROPE/ EUROCONTROL Memorandum of Understanding
Flight Efficiency Plan
AENA / EUROCONTROL Joint Action Plan
DFS Action Plan
Airport Unit / CFMU Action Plan
All these action plans, produced in a close coordination with airport partners, aim at accelerating
the implementation of best practices and thereby enhancing capacity and efficiency at airports
which, in turn, will have a positive effect upon the network. For details on these plans, refer to
section 9.2.
37
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
38
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
For more details on planned and/or on-going Airport Unit activities at the above airports, refer to
Annex 2 : AIRPORTS.
This activity has been developed in support of the DMEAN objectives that aim at implementing a
dynamically managed European airspace network through the integration of Airspace
Management (ASM) and Air Traffic Flow and Capacity Measures (ATFCM), network information
sharing and airport-network integration. The latter aims at improving airport capacity for airports
critical to network operations by enhancing capacity and reducing delays (DMEAN Master Plan
for Phases III and IV_v012 dated 28 August 2008, Par. 6.3.2.2, page 183).
The DMEAN high level work breakdown structure converted this operational improvement (OI) in
a series of sub-projects and tasks. The identification and analysis of causes for delays is part of
this work breakdown with a view to reducing or mitigating delays.
Initial analysis confirmed that the reasons for delay are a very complex domain and that in most
cases reduction of delays can only be achieved throughout a detailed local analysis at each
airport.
The work involved a number of workshops at some of the most constraining European airports
where “most constraining” was defined as the airports causing the majority of Air Traffic Flow and
Control Management (ATFCM) delays within a given period (normally a year, but also focussed in
the summer period).
Workshops were held at the following airports: Vienna, Rome Fiumicino, Zürich, Munich, Istanbul,
Heraklion, Budapest, Milan Malpensa, Frankfurt, Prague, Brussels and London Heathrow.
The workshops highlighted the complexity and difficulty in identifying the reasons for delay.
Therefore a Delay Reduction Task Force (DRTF) was established to collect proven solutions that
could mitigate or even remedy the delays. The Terms of Reference for the DRTF state the
objectives as:
To identify and analyse the real reasons for delays at airports based upon previous work and
inputs from Task Force members,
To collect best practices in mitigating delays at airports,
To develop structured guidelines to avoid delays at airports.
39
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
around times. As part of this report, the various issues identified from the delay analysis
workshops were distilled into five main categories, namely:
Reporting of delays
Improved efficiency in the application of ATFCM regulations to balance capacity and demand
at airports, to minimise levels of delay
An understanding of the airport capacity declaration process, including:
the airport coordination and the airport scheduling processes to understand how IATA
and EC 95/93 rules are applied at coordinated airports,
how a “sustainable airport capacity” is understood and reflected in the schedule,
how slot monitoring is undertaken to manage the process.
Improved efficiency in the management of airport resources to ensure maximum capacity at
peak times (particularly early morning periods to reduce reactionary delays)
An understanding of the real effect of weather on airport delays and to identify the potential
actions for mitigating weather delays.
The results from the DRTF were presented to the EUROCONTROL Airport Operations Team
(AOT) 27 in April 2010, where the work was endorsed for presentation to the Operational
Consultation Group (OCG). However, it is proposed that the work of the DRTF should continue,
in two elements.
Firstly, further work is required on the proposed solutions identified above in order to validate
their applicability at as many airports as possible. This work should be undertaken in
collaboration with existing members of the DRTF.
Secondly, the items listed in this report are not a complete list of the reasons for delay that were
identified by the DRTF. A number of issue areas were investigated in a qualitative way but were
not fully quantified and it is hoped that endorsement to continue the work and investigate these
additional elements will be provided.
The following identifies a list of additional items that cause delay, as identified by the DRTF:
Airport infrastructure
Inefficient runway layout
Position of holding points
Taxiway (congestion, pushback blocking taxiway)
Works in progress - planning
Airport equipment
Unrealistic turnaround times
TMA and airport capacity do not match
ATC procedures (speed management, separations on final approach)
Security issues
Staffing levels (waiting for crew, ATC staff shortage)
Environment & political issues
1
http://www.eurocontrol.int/airports/public/standard_page/APR1_Projects_ACE.html
41
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Factual data collected at seven airports have been carefully analysed which resulted in a set of
empirical RET-locations based on less conservative deceleration values. Indeed, the
performance of today’s modern types are much better, notably a deceleration rate for the Airbus
family of 1,85m/s2 and 3,00 m/s2 respectively to low and medium auto-brakes on A320 and A330
versus of 1,5m/s2 as considered in Airdrome Design Manual.
The empirical RET locations were validated in a certified level D flight simulator (a simulator that
emulates real aircraft and environment performance with 99,9% accuracy) and executed by a TRI
(Type Rating Instructor). For the occasion, the simulators were configured to simulate braking
distances for medium and heavy type aircraft. The simulator enabled to validate empirical results
in different scenarios such as extreme weather conditions, maximum landing weight etc.
42
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
43
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Prime attention has been given to the 40 airports identified as having a potentially adverse effect
upon the network. These airports have been selected for an A-CDM gap analysis study,
conducted by the EUROCONTROL A-CDM project, followed by full A-CDM implementation.
There is an urgent need for full collaboration between airport partners, to share operational data
in a coherent and transparent manner in the context of arrivals, ground operations and
departures. Action is needed now to avoid a negative impact on the network, resulting in more
delays and increased operating costs.
2
http://www.euro-cdm.org/implementation_manual.html
44
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Benefits to date
Airport CDM is seen as the mechanism to integrate airports in the network. The CFMU, has been
testing and validating the Departure Planning Information (DPI) messages with a number of
European airports and first results have proven very positive.
Munich airport became the first European airport to fully implement Airport CDM. One of the
significant outputs was exchange of DPI messages with CFMU Enhanced Tactical Flow
Management System (ETFMS). These messages are now fully processed by the operational
system for all flights departing from Munich Airport. DPI messages provide the CFMU with
accurate predictions of off-block times and take-off times, based on collaborative procedures.
With this real-time data the CFMU updates its operational flight profile calculations and shares
the information with downstream arrival units.
The local benefits of implementing Airport CDM at Munich Airport are significant. These include
enhanced operational efficiency, reduction in delay, use of available infrastructure and resources,
predictability and a 10% average reduction in taxi times for departures. The fuel saving at Munich
alone is €2.65 million per annum.
The network benefits derived from the implementation of Airport CDM in Munich are expressed in
terms of an 85 % slot adherence for 2008, increasing by 5 % compared to 2007 and 90.3% slot
adherence in 2009 increased by 5.9% over 2008. The data measured in Munich also show that
the last ATFM slot allocated by the CFMU to a flight before departure is within 15 minutes of the
target take off time (CDM data calculated taking account of the local constraints) for 70 % of the
flights. While the average ATFM delay has slightly increased in Europe, it has decreased in
Munich since the enhancement of the exchanges between the CDM airport and the CFMU 3 .
These results show that Airport CDM helps better integrating the airports into the ATM network by
considering the airport constraints. The integration brings benefits both to the airports and the
network.
The predicted main benefit is an increase in en-route capacity of 0.5%. This estimation was
provided by CFMU, based on expert judgment and results obtained out of the on-going trials.
It is important to note that in the network capacity, only en-route capacity was considered in the
network benefits quantification process and not airport capacity.
3
All the results for Munich airport are extracted from the document Airport CDM Munich – Results 2009, Version 1.0, DFS /
Munich Airport Operator. See http://www.euro-cdm.org/library/airports/munich/airport_cdm_munich_results_2009.pdf for further
information.
4
Generic Cost Benefit Analysis Version 1.4 – April 2008. See http://www.euro-cdm.org/library/cdm_cba.pdf for further
information.
45
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
In terms of flow and capacity management, the benefits would not come solely from the reduction
of delays. Airspace users would possibly benefit to an even greater degree from an increased
freedom of choice, where they are able to consider trade-offs to suit their particular business
needs in respect of the flights concerned (e.g. less delay but longer route).
Network benefits will grow as the number of airports implementing Airport CDM increases.
Enhanced data for quantification will become available by the time additional airports have
entered into the message exchange process with the CFMU.
In 2008, the EUROCONTROL Experimental Centre produced a study which aim was to assess
the impact on the network if 42 airports were to implement Airport CDM, assuming the same level
of benefits that Munich Airport has been achieved and provide the CFMU with accurate Target
Take Off Times via DPI messages.
Munich Airport currently has the most accurate take off estimate of the 42 airports considered
and this accuracy was used as the baseline for the other airports in order to evaluate the impact
on sector capacities within the European core area.
The study concluded that, following a wider implementation of Airport CDM, the benefits will be:
It could be possible to increase sector capacity within the core area by up to 4% which
equates to between 1-2 aircraft per sector
A room for improvement for an en-route delays of between 33%-50%
Some sectors which are expected to be saturated are not actually saturated. Therefore if the
declared capacities are maintained then some regulations may not be required.
The positive results recorded in this study show that the expected benefits from the
implementation of Airport CDM could extend from the local airport environment to the network
level, with emphasis on the European core area. However, the achievement of these potential
gains depends on a number of airports reaching the same level of Airport CDM implementation
as Munich and supplying data to the CFMU to the same level of accuracy.
The 2nd part of the study performed in 2009 indicated that network benefits will start becoming
significant from the moment 16 largest airports have implemented A-CDM and will continue to
increase until we reach around 100 airports. Implementation in more than 100 airports will only
provide marginal benefits 5 .
Current status
The CFMU continues to further refine the DPI message exchange also during adverse conditions
and certain upgrades are required to further enhance the processing of these messages. In the
meantime Brussels airport is operational since June 2010 and Zurich is expected to become
operational by the end of 2010 while six major airports have planned with CFMU to join the
network in the next two years.
Way forward
Due to diverse local airport issues it is difficult to predict when an airport will be mature enough to
start exchanging DPI messages with the CFMU. To facilitate this process CFMU and the Airport
CDM team have defined the minimum Airport CDM Completeness Criteria for airports to
commence data exchange with the CFMU.
5
All the results for the network impact assessment are extracted from the EUROCONTROL Experimental Centre Note No. 09-08,
Airport CDM Network Impact Assessment, issued in February 2009. See http://www.euro-
cdm.org/library_eurocontrol_analysis.html for further information.
46
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Joint Action Plan between the EUROCONTROL Airport CDM team and the CFMU
With the rapid increase in airports currently implementing Airport CDM, it is essential to put in
place the necessary means to connect airports to the network (DPI messages sent to CFMU) as
soon as they reach the required implementation maturity level. In this way the overall benefits are
achieved in the shortest period of time.
To support this need a joint action plan between the EUROCONTROL Airport CDM Project team
and the CFMU has been defined.
The main objective of this joint action plan is to extend the number of airports exchanging
messages with CFMU leading to quicker achievement of overall network benefits.
The action plan includes: a list of airports, definition of minimum A-CDM requirements
(Completeness Criteria), implementation timescales for both airports and CFMU developments
and full planning for DPI processing, including a list of actions to be taken by partners and
requested resources.
This action plan aims to secure resources for the operational deployment of sending DPI
messages to CFMU from 4 to 5 additional airports per year during the 2010 to 2014 period.
47
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
The last data collection campaign (Summer 2010 NOP) managed to obtain good quality of data
from 28 airports out of the 30 addressed. The intention is to expand to 40 airports by the summer
2011.
48
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
49
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
50
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
5,0
Movements per day
25000
3,6 Effective capacity Forecast 4,0
20000 3,1
3,0
15000 2,0
1,8
1,6 2,0
1,4 1,4 1,4
10000 1,2 1,2 1,3 1,2 1,2 1,1
1,0
1,0
5000
Average ER delay PC delay target
0 0,0
19 2 0 2 0 2 0 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
99 00 01 02 003 004 005 006 007 008 009 010 011 012 013 014
51
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
The following maps give an indication of the Summer delay forecast at ACC level, assuming
baseline traffic growth, for the years 2011, 2012 and 2014.
52
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
The figure below shows the en-route ATFM delay forecast for Summer 2014 based on the present
capacity improvement plans from ANSPs and the three traffic scenarios of the STATFOR traffic
forecast (Feb. 2010).
3
per flight (min.)
2.5
2
1.5
1.0
1
0.4
0.5
0
Low Base High
Traffic scenario (STATFOR)
The enroute ATFM delay forecast for the baseline traffic scenario currently shows a satisfactory
level of performance at system level for Summer 2014. However, due to the exponential nature
of delay, the outlook for the high traffic scenario gives reason for concern.
53
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
54
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
55
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
11 CONCLUSIONS
The introduction of the SESII Performance Framework and the implementation of ARN V7,
(including the coordinated implementation of Functional Airspace Blocks, the expansion and
consolidation of Free Route Airspace operations and the implementation RVSM at the eastern
interface), combined with the identification and implementation of efficient ASM/ATFCM solutions
and improved flexibility in flight planning and rerouteing, will contribute to improved performance
and flexibility of the future ATM network. However, due to the ongoing recession, and the
associated cutting back on costs by many ANSPs, the full benefit of many of these initiatives is
unlikely to be realised in this planning cycle.
At European network level, the delay forecast for the period 2011-2013 shows that network delay
will continue to be higher than the target set by the Provisional Council of 1 minute per flight
enroute. Delays in Summer 2011 are likely to be higher than initially expected, resulting from
planned reduction in capacity during the training and implementation of major ATM system
upgrades and/or airspace reorganisation, combined with a shortage of available controllers.
Even though there are plans to increase structural capacity, the shortage of available qualified
controllers remains an obstacle to the enhancement of performance. In spite of significant efforts
to ensure a more effective and flexible resource utilisation, a number of ACCs, particularly those
on the SE axis are expected to operate less-than-optimum sector configurations during peak
hours. This magnifies the need for robust and realistic capacity planning and implementation.
Although traffic growth at network level remains relatively low, States on the critical south-east
axis are already experiencing higher than average demand growth. This further increases the
need for robust capacity planning and full commitment to implementation by ANSPs on the axis,
particularly in Austria, Croatia, Cyprus and Greece.
The establishment of the European ATM Network Manager in 2011 will ensure full integration of
capacity planning, civil-military cooperation, airspace structure design and management, airport
operations and flow and capacity management into a fully coordinated network approach .
56
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Traffic forecast
The 2011-2014 traffic forecast per ACC is derived using NEVAC from the EUROCONTROL STATFOR
MTF that was released in March 2010.
The impact of realignment along the shortest available routes with generally unconstrained vertical
profiles is determined using SAAM.
Enroute Summer delay forecast for the years 2011 and 2012
The delay forecast is derived for each ACC with the support of the tools used in the capacity planning
process. The delay forecast is based on the current capacity plans as described in the LSSIP 2010-2014
and on the latest baseline medium term traffic forecast (EUROCONTROL STATFOR Origin Destination
Zone (ODZ) released in March 2010).
57
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
58 59
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution % growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast
Austria: Capacity Plan Vienna LOVV ACC Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Azerbaijan: Capacity Plan Baku UBBB ACC
ATS route network improvements Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Improved operational procedures
ATS route network optimisation in cooperation with neighboring States.
Sector configuration management
New automated ATC systems in Baku, Ganja and Nakhchivan.
Measures planned Static cross border sectorisation (FAB CE) Measures planned Resectorisation of
ATM system upgrade including COOPANS/NG-AATMS Data link Airspace Structure
Net Additional controllers Preparation phase Installation Installation
Improved sectorisation
Max sectors 4 + 1APP 4 + 1APP 4 + 1APP 4 + 1APP
Additional Sectors
Anticipated Training activities for the new Capacity increase Sufficient capacity to meet demand
Significant Events Reference profile 0% 0% 0% 0%
ATM System COOPANS
Max sectors 12 12 12 15 Additional information
Capacity increase p.a. 2% 0% 2% 5%
Low profile / capa target 7% 7% 7% 3%
Enroute Summer Delay Forecast
No major airspace changes will take place 2011-2012 due to the need to freeze the ATM
environment for the implementation of COOPANS. Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for Baku
Training of ab-initio controllers will have an impact on availability of controllers for ACC is zero minutes per flight.
operations in 2010 and 2011.
Additional information
There will be a continuous improvement regarding staffing issues over the planning
period. Expected Summer Performance
Constraints regarding the airport capacity using the two existing (converging) RWYs will
remain. A third RWY is planned beyond 2014. No problems are expected at Baku ACC.
60 61
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
62 63
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
Croatia: Capacity Plan Zagreb LDZO ACC Cyprus: Capacity Plan Nicosia LCCC ACC
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014 Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Additional controllers (net increase of 5 per year) ATS route network and sectorisation optimisation
Improved sector opening times Implementation of
Consolidation of
Application of sector occupancy techniques: further benefits after impl.of CPR the new ATM system Capacity benefits th
operations of new 5 enroute sector
Optimisation of ATS route network and sectorisation LEFCO and new from new TMA
system and ACC
Further increase of sector capacities ACC
Measures planned
OLDI with Athens
New Cyprus TMA Additional staff (radar
Additional Sector and possibly with
implementation and APP)
Group-Phase 2 - full Egypt
Measures planned lateral and vertical Additional Sectors Additional staff (radar th
implementation of 4 enroute sector
and APP)
Central sector
Significant Events Presidency of the EU
Modernisation of Max sectors 3 4 4 5
Extension of CroATMS with Capacity increase p.a. 2% 5% 5% 5%
CroATMS to major enhanced High profile (ACC) 7% 8% 5% 9%
APP and TWR functionalities (Mode The additional staff will be used immediately to increase the opening hours of maximum
S and data link) available sectors.
Operations of the new Larnaca TMA in 2012 will increase the capacity of the West
BH ACC (capacity
enroute sector.
impact on airspace,
system and
Significant Events Additional information LEFCO
procedure changes
- Testing of the system: May-July 2010
for Zagreb ACC to be
- Training: Winter 2010/2011 (Oct-Feb)
evaluated)
- Start of operations February 2011
Max sectors 9* 10* 11* 11* - Transition phase February-May 2011
Capacity increase p.a. 7% 8% 6% 5%** - 3 months with reduced capacities
Reference profile 9% 8% 5% 4%
*a higher number of sectors is possible, depending on traffic growth, additional ATCOs
Additional information and regional developments (BiH ACC and FAB CE development) Enroute Summer Delay Forecast
**capacity increase to be further confirmed depending on new ATM system
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for
Enroute Summer Delay Forecast Nicosia ACC is 2.3 minutes per flight.
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for Zagreb
ACC is 0.4 minutes per flight. Expected Summer performance
Expected Summer performance Nicosia ACC is not expected to close the capacity gap until staff management issues are resolved and all measures are
in place to enable the opening of optimum sector configurations.
Zagreb ACC is not expected to close the capacity gap until staffing issues are resolved and sufficient controllers are
available to open optimum sector configurations. Following many years of postponement, the implementation of the new ATM system is now needed as a matter of
urgency, together with reassessment of the enroute and terminal airspace structure, sectorisation, ATM procedures,
Potential bottleneck sectors: all collapsed sectors
sector capacities and working practices.
The capacity plan is sufficient to cope with expected demand on current routes, but traffic could increase significantly if
Potential bottleneck sectors: all collapsed sectors.
flows are realigned on the shortest available routes.
64 65
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
66 67
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Traffic forecast
Traffic forecast
ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014
ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014 H 8% 13% 17% 22%
H 10% 19% 27% 34% B 4% 8% 11% 15%
Maastricht
B 5% 14% 19% 24% L 0% 2% 5% 7%
Tallinn
L 0% 4% 9% 14% Shortest Routes: + 3%
Shortest Routes: - 4% % growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast
% growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast
68 69
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Integration of
Enroute Summer Delay Forecast Measures planned
Rovaniemi airspace Consolidation of operations as one ACC
in Tampere ACC
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute 2010 Summer delay forecast for
Rovaniemi ACC is zero minutes per flight. Max sectors 5* 5* 5* 5*
Capacity increase Sufficient capacity to meet demand
Reference profile 0% 0% 0% 0%
Expected Summer performance Additional information *Number of sectors to be determined - planning is ongoing
No problems are expected at Rovaniemi ACC.
70 71
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
72 73
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014 ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014
H 7% 13% 18% 23% H 6% 11% 15% 19%
B 4% 7% 11% 14% B 4% 7% 10% 13%
Marseille Paris
L -1% 1% 3% 6% L 0% 2% 4% 6%
Shortest Routes: - 3% Shortest Routes: + 5%
% growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast % growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
France: Capacity Plan Marseille LFMM ACC
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Improved Airspace Management and ATFCM Procedures France: Capacity Plan Paris LFFF ACC
Staff deployment / Flexible rostering Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Reorganisation of Improved Airspace Management and ATFCM Procedures
Reorganisation of lower airspace and Measures planned Staff deployment / Flexible rostering
interface with LECB delegation of ATS to IRP/Harmonie
(LUMAS) APP units below Max sectors 24 UCESO 24 UCESO 24 UCESO 24 UCESO
Measures planned FL145 Capacity increase p.a. 3% 3% 3% 3%
Reference profile 2% 4% 3% 2%
Full Provence project Additional information
Airspace
improvements in Enroute Summer Delay Forecast
Nice terminal area
Max sectors 30 UCESO 30 UCESO 30 UCESO 30 UCESO
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for Paris
Capacity increase p.a. 3% 3% 3% 3% ACC is 0.2 minutes per flight.
Reference profile 2% 2% 2% 3%
Additional information
Expected Summer performance
No significant problems are expected for Paris ACC, but UJ remains a potential bottleneck sector.
Enroute Summer Delay Forecast
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for
Marseille ACC is 0.1 minutes per flight.
74 75
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
France: Capacity Plan Reims LFEE ACC FYROM: Capacity Plan Skopje LWSS ACC
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014 Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Improved Airspace Management and ATFCM Procedures Controller ratings
Staff deployment / Flexible rostering Airspace structure development
Measures planned
Re-organisation of Optimisation of sectorisation (Closely related to availability of Kosovo airspace)
lower airspace and Swap UN852/UN853 New ATM system
Measures planned delegation of ATS to (FABEC) Max sectors 3 3 (4) 3 (4) 3 (4)
APP LFST Capacity increase p.a. 0% 0% 0% 0%
Reference profile (ACC) 0% 3% 3% 0%
IRP/Harmonie
Additional information
Higher DFL for low
level sectors
Max sectors 16 UCESO 16 UCESO 16 UCESO 16 UCESO
Enroute Summer Delay Forecast
Capacity increase p.a. 4% 4% 4% 4%
Reference profile 4% 3% 4% 4% Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for Skopje
Additional information ACC is zero minutes per flight.
76 77
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute 2010 Summer delay forecast for Additional information
Bremen ACC is zero minutes per flight.
78 79
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014 ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014
H 9% 14% 19% (+15%) 25% (+15%) H 8% 13% 18% (-27%) 24% (-27%)
B 5% 9% 13% (+15%) 17% (+15%) B 4% 8% 11% (-27%) 15% (-27%)
Karlsruhe Munich
L -1% 3% 5% (+15%) 8% (+15%) L -1% 2% 4% (-27%) 7% (-27%)
Shortest Routes: + 5% Shortest Routes: No significant Impact
% growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast % growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast
Relocation of Munich upper airspace to Karlsruhe adds an extra 15% traffic in 2013. Relocation of Munich upper airspace to Karlsruhe reduces traffic by 27% in 2013.
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
Germany: Capacity Plan Munich EDMM ACC
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Germany: Capacity Plan Karlsruhe EDUU UAC
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014 Ongoing recruitment of ab initio controllers
Ongoing recruitment of ab-initio controllers and “ready entries”
Implementation of Relocation of Munich Implementation of
P1/VAFORIT (Dec Reduction of staffing problems Upper airspace to SAS Upper sector in
Upgrade of P1/ATCAS system (PSS)
2010-Feb 2011) Karlsruhe (Nov.2012 - connection with the
Feb.2013) new Berlin airport
Effects of the new ATS system (P1/VAFORIT)
Measures planned
Split ALB sector in
Relocation of Munich Measures planned
Low and High, Split
Upper airspace to
Implementation of INN sector in East
Karlsruhe (Nov.2012 -
new CHIEM TOP and West
Feb.2013) sector Implementation of
one sector above
Max sectors 26 26 34 34 RDG/EGG
Capacity increase p.a. 2% 5% 2% (+15%) 7% Implementation of
Reference profile 6% 5% 18% 4% new function
4th runway Frankfurt “Satellite” Munich
Airport, New Berlin Max sectors 26+4 26+4 22+5 23+5
BBI Airport Olympic Games in 3rd runway Munich Capacity increase p.a. 1% 1% 4% (-30%) 1%
Special Impacts Reference profile 0% 1% -28% 2%
Capacity reduction London Airport
due implementation Training for
3rd runway Munich
P1/VAFORIT Special Impacts FIFA Women Cup relocation to
Airport
Karlsruhe UAC
Additional Information Additional information
80 81
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014 H 11% 17% 23% 30%
82 83
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
Hungary: Capacity Plan LHCC ACC Ireland: Capacity Plan Dublin EIDW ACC
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014 Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Optimisation of airspace structure FAB with UK/NATS
Recruitment and training of controllers
Measures planned New ATCC Multi sector planning Improvement of route
Improvement of route
New PC based network at
New ATM software Measures planned network at New Control Tower Parallel Runway
hardware Manchester &
Manchester interface
London interface
Max sectors 9-12 9-12 9-12 9-12
Capacity increase p.a. 4% 4% 4% 4% ATM System
Point Merge
Upgrade
Reference profile (ACC) 0% 0% 1% 2%
Significant Events
Additional information 10 ACC and 3 APP controllers are planned to be licensed in Autumn 2010
Max sectors 2 2 2 2
Capacity increase p.a. 10% 5% 5% 30%
Reference profile 2% 6% 6% 8%
Enroute Summer Delay Forecast Additional information
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for
Budapest ACC is 0.1 minutes per flight.
Enroute Summer Delay Forecast
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for Dublin
Expected Summer performance ACC is 0.1 minutes per flight.
No problems are expected at Budapest ACC.
84 85
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014 ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014
H 7% 12% 17% 23% H 9% 17% 23% 30%
B 5% 8% 11% 14% B 5% 10% 15% 20%
Shannon Brindisi
L 1% 3% 5% 7% L 0% 3% 6% 10%
Shortest Routes: No significant Impact Shortest Routes: +4%
% growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast % growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
Italy: Capacity Plan Brindisi LIBB ACC
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Ireland: Capacity Plan Shannon EINN ACC Revised sector loads and sector optimisation
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Route network improvements
FAB with UK/NATS VDL Mode 2
Measures planned Extra sectors as required DMEAN actions
Datalink Measures planned
Flight Efficiency Plan – ENAV 2009-2014
Significant Events Operational Improvements as a result of BLUMED FAB
Max sectors 15 16 16 16
Improved Mode S
Capacity increase p.a. 5% 3% 5% 0% ADSB
infrastructure
Reference profile 0% 0% 1% 1% Max sectors 6* 6* 6* 6*
Additional information Capacity increase p.a. 0% 0% 0% 0%
Reference profile 0% 0% 0% 0%
Additional information * max. 8 sectors could be opened depending on traffic demand and staff availability
Enroute Summer Delay Forecast
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute 2010 Summer delay forecast for
Shannon ACC is zero minutes per flight. Enroute Summer Delay Forecast
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for
Expected Summer performance Brindisi ACC is zero minutes per flight.
86 87
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Traffic forecast
Traffic forecast
88 89
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014 ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014
H 8% 14% 20% 27% H 9% 19% 26% 33%
B 5% 9% 13% 17% B 5% 14% 18% 24%
Rome Riga
L 0% 3% 5% 8% L 0% 4% 9% 13%
Shortest Routes: No significant Impact Shortest Routes: -5%
% growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast % growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
Italy: Capacity Plan Rome LIRR ACC
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014 Latvia: Capacity Plan Riga EVRR ACC
Revised sector loads and sector optimisation Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Optimum maximum configurations Measures planned Various ATM system improvements (RNP1 in Riga TMA, AMAN etc.)
VDL Mode 2 Significant Events
DMEAN actions Max sectors 3 + 1 APP 3 + 1 APP 3 + 1 APP 3 + 1 APP
Flight Efficiency Plan – ENAV 2009-2014 Capacity increase Sufficient capacity to meet expected demand
Measures planned Operational Improvements as a result of BLUMED FAB Reference profile 0% 0% 2% 2%
Improved Mode S Additional information
ADSB
infrastructure
Implementation of
PRNAV in Roma Enroute Summer Delay Forecast
TMA
Max sectors 21* 21* 21* 21 * Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for Riga
Capacity increase p.a. 3% 4% 3% 5% ACC is zero minutes per flight.
Reference profile 2% 2% 2% 4%
Additional information * max. 23 sectors depending on traffic demand and staff availability
Expected Summer performance
No problems are expected at Riga ACC.
Enroute Summer Delay Forecast
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for Rome
ACC is zero minutes per flight.
90 91
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014 ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014
H 10% 20% 28% 37% H 12% 21% 30% 39%
B 6% 13% 20% 26% B 8% 13% 19% 28%
Vilnius Malta
L -2% 3% 9% 15% L 2% 5% 10% 15%
Shortest Routes: No significant Impact Shortest Routes: No significant Impact
% growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast % growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
92 93
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014 ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014
% growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast % growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
94 95
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Norway: Capacity Plan Bodo ENBD ACC Flexible rostering of ATC staff
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014 Recruitment and training of air traffic controllers
Flexible rostering of ATC staff Measures planned Revision of FUA operations
Implementation of
Measures planned Recruitment and training of air traffic controllers Oslo ASAP (New
Revision of FUA operations Airspace Structure)
Significant Events Significant Events
Max sectors 5 + 1 oceanic 5 + 1 oceanic 5 + 1 oceanic 5 + 1 oceanic Max sectors 8 8 8 8
Capacity increase Capacity increase
Reference profile 0% 0% 0% 0% Reference profile 0% 0% 0% 0%
Additional information Additional information
96 97
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014 ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014
% growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast % growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
Poland: Capacity Plan Warsaw EPWW ACC
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Norway: Capacity Plan Stavanger ENSV ACC Additional controllers
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014 Minor ATS route network improvements Polish 2010+ airspace project
Flexible rostering of ATC staff Improved sector
Improved sector configurations
Measures planned Recruitment and training of air traffic controllers opening schemes
Revision of FUA operations Training and testing
Significant Events for the new ATM Re-evaluation of sector capacities
Max sectors 3 + 1 helicopter 3 + 1 helicopter 3 + 1 helicopter 3 + 1 helicopter Measures planned system
Capacity increase 12 elementary
Reference profile 0% 0% 0% 0% horizontal sectors - Implementation of vertical sectorisation
improved flexibility
Additional information
Operational
availability of the new Consolidation of operations of the new ATM
ATM system (Winter system
Enroute Summer Delay Forecast 2011/12)
Significant Events EURO 2012
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for
Max sectors 8 9-10 10-11* 12*
Stavanger ACC is zero minutes per flight. Capacity increase p.a. 0% 10% 15% 10%
Reference profile 8% 6% 6% 7%
*Depending on traffic demand and staff availability
Expected Summer performance New ATM system
No problems are expected at Stavanger ACC. - Training: September/October 2010 till December 2011
Additional information - Switch over: December 2011
- Transition period: Dec 2011 – March 2012
- Reduction in staff availability due to training for new system and OJT in 2010/11
- Training for the new system will also concern TWR units
98 99
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Traffic forecast
Traffic forecast
ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014
H 9% 14% 19% 24%
B 5% 9% 12% 15% ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014
Lisbon
L 1% 2% 3% 4% H 14% 24% 34% 44%
Shortest Routes: No significant Impact B 9% 17% 24% 32%
Bucharest
% growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast L 2% 8% 14% 20%
Shortest Routes: No significant Impact
% growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
Portugal: Capacity Plan Lisbon LPPC ACC
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014 Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
Improved rostering and sector opening schemes
Romania: Capacity Plan Bucharest LRBB ACC
Additional controllers Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Update traffic volume definition for free Measures planned ATS route network and sectorisation improvements
Area Proximity warning (APW)
route + Casablanca Significant Events
OLDI links with Max sectors 20 20 20 20
MTCD and conformance monitoring New sector
Measures planned GCCC Capacity increase Sufficient capacity to meet demand
New Upper sector* Minimum Safe Altitude Warning (MSAW) Reference profile 0% 0% 0% 0%
New BRNAV ATS route structure Additional information
Casablanca FIR
Sector Design Optimisation according to
Casablanca project
Football World Cup Enroute Summer Delay Forecast
Significant Events
in Brazil
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for
10 10 10 10 -12
Max sectors
(8 ENR+2 TMA) (8 ENR+2 TMA) (8 ENR+2 TMA) (8-9 ENR+2-3 TMA) Bucharest ACC is zero minutes per flight.
Capacity increase p.a. 3% 3% 3% 3%
Reference profile 0% 4% 2% 4%
Additional information * Depending on the traffic evolution in 2010-2011 Expected Summer performance
No problems are expected at Bucharest ACC.
Enroute Summer Delay Forecast
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for Lisbon
ACC is 0.2 minutes per flight.
100 101
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Traffic forecast
Traffic forecast
102 103
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014 ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014
H 10% 17% 23% 30% H 7% 12% 17% 22%
B 5% 10% 15% 20% B 3% 7% 10% 13%
Ljubljana Barcelona
L -1% 2% 5% 9% L -3% -1% 1% 3%
Shortest Routes: +24% Shortest Routes: No significant Impact
% growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast % growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
Slovenia: Capacity Plan Ljubljan LJLJ ACC Spain: Capacity Plan Barcelona LECB ACC
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014 Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
ATS route network and traffic organisation changes ATC system upgrades
Improved ATFCM Optimised sector configurations
Additional ATCOs will be recruited as necessary Staff rostering improvement
4 sector configuration Measures planned Route structure
Flexible sector configurations (max 5 sectors) PRNAV structure for
for longer periods improvements
Measures planned TMAs
Madrid - Baleares
Upgrade of radar One additional sector interface sector New sectorisation of
to Mode S (if required) reorganisation Barcelona TMA
Implementation of New building
new ops room Significant Events Valencia TACC
ASMGCS-1 at LEBL
Significant Events 14ACC 14ACC 14ACC 14ACC
Max sectors 4 5 5 5 Max sectors 6 APP LEBL 7APP LEBL 7APP LEBL 7APP LEBL
Capacity increase p.a. 3% 7% 5% 3% 4 APP LECL 4 APP LECL 4 APP LECL 4 APP LECL
Reference profile 5% 6% 7% 3% apacity increase p.a. (ACC 4% 4% 4% 4%
Reference profile (ACC) 2% 2% 4% 5%
Additional information *Depending on traffic growth
Implementation of the new ops room (winter 2011-2012) will not affect capacity. Additional information
104 105
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014 ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014
H 9% 14% 19% 24% H 6% 10% 14% 18%
B 6% 9% 12% 16% B 3% 5% 8% 10%
Canaries Madrid
L 0% 1% 3% 5% L -2% -1% -1% 1%
Shortest Routes: No significant Impact Shortest Routes: No significant Impact
% growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast % growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
Spain: Capacity Plan Canarias GCCC ACC
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014 Spain: Capacity Plan Madrid LEMD ACC
ATM system upgrade Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Optimised sector configurations ATC system upgrades
Measures planned
PRNAV structure for Optimised sector configurations
TMAs Staff rostering improvement
Significant Events ASMGCS-1 at GCXO
Measures planned Independent parallel
Max sectors 9 (5 APP/3+1ENR) 9 (5 APP/3+1ENR) 9 (5 APP/3+1ENR) 9 (5 APP/3+1ENR)
0% 0% 0% 0% runway ops at LEMD
Capacity increase p.a.
Reference profile 0% 0% 0% 0% PRNAV structure for
Additional information TMAs
Significant Events
18 ACC 18 ACC 18 ACC 18 ACC
Max sectors
Enroute Summer Delay Forecast 10 APP 10 APP 10 APP 10 APP
apacity increase p.a. (ACC 6% 4% 4% 4%
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for Reference profile (ACC) 3% 5% 4% 4%
Canarias ACC is zero minutes per flight. Additional information
106 107
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014 ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014
H 8% 12% 17% 22% H 8% 14% 19% 24%
B 4% 7% 10% 13% B 5% 8% 12% 16%
Palma Sevilla
L -4% -2% 0% 2% L 0% 0% 2% 5%
Shortest Routes: No significant Impact Shortest Routes: No significant Impact
% growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast % growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
Spain: Capacity Plan Palma LEPA ACC
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Spain: Capacity Plan Seville LECS ACC
ATC system upgrades
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Measures planned Optimised sector configurations
ATC system upgrades
PRNAV structure for
TMAs Optimised sector configurations
Significant Events Staff rostering improvement
Measures planned New airspace
Max sectors 3 (+5 APP) 3 (+5 APP) 3 (+5 APP) 3 (+5 APP)
Capacity increase p.a. 2% 2% 2% 2% structure for Malaga
Reference profile 2% 1% 1% 2% TMA based on
Additional information PRNAV
TLP - European Military activity (every 2 months)
Significant Events
ASMGCS-1 at LEMG
Enroute Summer Delay Forecast Max sectors 6ACC+2 APP 6ACC+2 APP 6ACC+2 APP 6ACC+2 APP
Capacity increase p.a. 3% 3% 3% 3%
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for Palma Reference profile 1% 1% 3% 4%
ACC is 0.1minutes per flight. Additional information
108 109
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014 ACC Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014
H 9% 15% 20% 25% H 7% 13% 16% 20%
B 5% 10% 14% 18% B 3% 8% 11% 14%
Malmo Stockholm
L 0% 3% 5% 8% L -1% 2% 4% 6%
Shortest Routes: No significant Impact Shortest Routes: No significant Impact
% growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast % growth per ACC v. 2009, based on STATFOR MT Forecast
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
Sweden: Capacity Plan Stockholm ESSO ACC
Sweden: Capacity Plan Malmo ESMM ACC Year 2011 2012 2013 2014
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014 Gradual availability of additional controllers
Gradual availability of additional controllers DK/SE FAB Implementation
DK/SE FAB Implementation Eurocat platform (COOPANS)
Eurocat platform (COOPANS) implementation
implementation Measures Planned
Measures Planned
FRAS Phase 4
FRAS Phase 4
(including evolving
(including evolving
traffic above FL 285
traffic above FL 285
South of 61 N)
South of 61 N)
Significant Events Significant Events
Max sectors 10+1* 10+1* 10+1* 10+1* Max sectors 10+3 10+3* 10+3* 10+3*
Capacity increase p.a. Sufficient capacity to meet expected demand Capacity increase p.a. Sufficient capacity to meet expected demand
110 111
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
112 113
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Turkey: Capacity Plan Ankara LTAA ACC A/G and G/G communications infrastructure
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014 improvements
ATS route structure development Improved surveillance infrastructure
Additional controllers (replace current stations and add new
sensors)
Improved civil/military coordination
Implementation of
A/G and G/G communications infrastructure Measures planned
Mode S SMART system
p improvements
(replace current stations and add new Additional
sensors) controllers*
Transfer of airspace
Measures planned New Ankara ACC +FL235 to Ankara
(Max 25 physical Consolidation of ACC
sectors + 5 otpional) - operations with new Additional sectors for
Implementation of Ankara ACC Istanbul APP below
SMART system FL235
114 115
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Traffic forecast
Traffic forecast
116 117
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution Planned capacity enhancement measures and Sector evolution
118 119
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
120 121
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Enroute Summer Delay Forecast Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for
London TC is 0.1 minutes per flight.
Based on the current capacity plan and assuming baseline traffic growth, the enroute Summer delay forecast for
London ACC is 0.3 minutes per flight.
Expected Summer performance
Expected Summer performance No significant problems are foreseen for London TC.
Training for the new ATM system combined with increased demand on busy sectors during peak hours could lead to
reduced configurations and higher than expected delays.
122 123
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Measures planned
Complexity reduction and improved traffic presentation between sectors / ANSPs INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
UK/Ireland FAB intiatives
Electronic Flight Data
Manchester TMA
(EFD)
Upper Sectors
Montrose
Project
Summer Olympic Rugby League Commonwealth
Significant events
Games World Cup Games
Max sectors 23 23 23 23
Capacity increase p.a. 2% 1% 1% 3%
Reference profile 0% 1% 1% 1%
Additional information
124 125
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ANNEX 2 : AIRPORTS
This section presents information about each of the 28 airports identified as having a potential effect upon the network
in terms of ATFCM delays. The following data is reported if available:
Airport location, IATA and ICAO airport code
Declared Capacity
Maximum runway capacities for both, arrivals and departures, as well as the global capacity.
(source: Airport Unit - Airport database – info provided by the airports March 2010)
Planned Activities
Local Airport Capacity Enhancement Measures - Mid-/Long Term (1 to 15 years)
(source: Airport Unit - Airport database – info provided by the airports March 2010 / LSSIP documents)
126
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
4. TMA / APPROACH
Does TMA / Approach constrain airport capacity? Changes foreseen in TMA
5. TRAFFIC MIX
Changes foreseen in traffic mix?
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Actual 2.5% 4.4% 2.2% -7.9% 6. OPERATIONAL CONTACTS
Base -4.0% 5.3% -0.3% -1.0% 3.7% Airport Operator:
High -1.3% 5.6% 5.8% 0.5% 0.3% Elisa Callejo Tamayo
Low -7.3% 2.8% -1.6% -2.1% 2.5% Jefa del Departamento de Area Terminal
Division de Operaciones
2. DECLARED CAPACITY Direccion de Operaciones y Sistemas de Red - Aena
18 18 30 ANSP:
Jose Luis de la Calle
3. PLANNED ACTIVITIES:
jldelacalle@aena.es
Airport Capacity Enhancement Measures
Head of ATFCM - AENA – Spain
Mid- / Long-Term (1 to 15 years)
On going / Planned: Benefits:
Implementation date(s):
There are no planned actions in Alicante airport for the
2010-2014 period with direct and positive foreseen effect
on capacity.
127 128
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
3. PLANNED ACTIVITIES:
AMSTERDAM AIRPORT – AMS/EHAM
Airport Capacity Enhancement Measures
Mid- / Long-Term (1 to 15 years)
1. TRAFFIC AND FORECAST On going / Planned: Benefits:
5. TRAFFIC MIX
2. DECLARED CAPACITY
Changes foreseen in traffic mix?
Capacities for different runway configurations
KLM will stop operating FK50
Runway Config.: Max Arrivals : Max Departures: Global : Optimum
129 130
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
3. PLANNED ACTIVITIES:
BARCELONA AIRPORT – BCN/ LEBL
Airport Capacity Enhancement Measures
Mid- / Long-Term (1 to 15 years)
1. TRAFFIC AND FORECAST On going / Planned: Benefits:
Implementation date(s):
Not reported
131 132
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
3. PLANNED ACTIVITIES:
BRUSSELS AIRPORT – BRU/ EBBR Airport Capacity Enhancement Measures
Mid / Long-Term (1 to 15 years)
1. TRAFFIC AND FORECAST On Going / Planned Implementation Date(s) Benefits
A-SMGCS level 2 2010-2011 Airport capacity
Implement Airport Airside Capacity Planning 2011-2013 enhancement
Method 2011-2014
Construction of two RETs 2014
Due to the partial night curfew there will be no more airport slots distributed with take-off times on the
6. OPERATIONAL CONTACTS
following days & between the following hours (always LT): Airport Operator:
Saturday between 01.00 & 05.59 Kristoff De Winne
Sunday between 00.00 & 05.59 ANSP:
Monday between 00.00 & 05.59 Marc Matthys - Belgocontrol - Capacity, CDM & Punctuality - 0032-2-2062618
133 134
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
New RETs for RWY 13R 2014+ Increase arrival capacity ANSP: Mr. Peter Szaloky - Hungarocontrol Pte Ltd, Head of Aerodrome ATS -
Terminal building expansion project at Budapest 05/2008 Terminal 2AB capacity increase up peter.szaloky@hungarocontrol.hu
135 136
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
4. TMA / APPROACH
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Does TMA / Approach constrain airport capacity? Changes foreseen in TMA
No No
Actual -3.8% -0.3% 2.6% -10.6%
Base 1.5% 0.9% 2.4% 1.5% 1.8%
5. TRAFFIC MIX
High 3.9% 1.0% 3.4% 2.3% 2.6%
Changes foreseen in traffic mix?
Low -1.4% -1.1% 1.5% 0.7% 1.0%
No
2. DECLARED CAPACITY
6. OPERATIONAL CONTACTS
Capacities for different runway configurations Airport Operator:
Runway Config.: Max Arrivals : Max Departures: Global : Optimum Mr. Dan Meincke - Director of Operations, +45 32 31 33 33, d.meincke@cph.dk
22L/R 48 48 83 Y ANSP:
04L/R 48 48 83 Y Pernille Ladefoged - FMP Manager - Naviair - D: +45 3247 8239 M: +45 2023 7117, plg@naviair.dk
Additional Information:
The capacity is determined tactical based on the weather conditions and runway configurations on the given
day. Usually it is only changed when operating single runway or in bad weather. There is an option to use a
crossing RWY 12/30 when the crosswind is too hard for the optimal configuration of either 04L/R or 22L/R.
3. PLANNED ACTIVITIES:
Airport Capacity Enhancement Measures
Mid- / Long-Term (1 to 15 years)
On going / Planned Implementation date(s) Benefits
New Low Cost Carrier Terminal is under 2010 (2010+)
construction
137 138
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
139 140
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
4. TMA / APPROACH
Does TMA / Approach constrain airport capacity? Changes foreseen in TMA
Yes
5. TRAFFIC MIX
Changes foreseen in traffic mix?
No
6. OPERATIONAL CONTACTS
Airport Operator:
AdF Luca ERMINI l.ermini@aeroporto.firenze.it Tel +39 055 3061771
ANSP:
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Actual -15.1% 27.9% 2.3% -15.6% ENAV SpA Aldo Daniele CRISAFULLI aldo.crisafulli@enav.it
Base -0.0% 1.7% 2.6% 2.4% 2.5% Tel +39 055 3372434
High 2.1% 2.6% 4.5% 3.6% 3.6%
Low -1.7% -0.0% 0.9% 1.1% 1.3%
Maurizio Paggetti
2. DECLARED CAPACITY
ENAV SpA
Capacities for different runway configurations
Airport Operation Manager
Runway Config.: Max Arrivals : Max Departures: Global : Optimum
maurizio.paggetti@enav.it
10 Not available 15
3. PLANNED ACTIVITIES:
Debora Palombi
Airport Capacity Enhancement Measures
Mid- / Long-Term (1 to 15 years) ENAV SpA
On going / Planned: Benefits: ATFCM Performance
New project for new Runway and new Manoeuvring area. Increasing of arrival and departure capacity.
debora.palombi@enav.it
Implementation date(s):
141 142
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
New 4th RWY, only certified for landings 30 Oct. 2011 the new RWY we
expect a global
RWY capacity of 90 that will
FRANKFURT AIRPORT – FRA/ EDDF Enlargement of Terminal 1 2011/2012 be expanded.
New parking positions at future Terminal 3 30 Nov. 2011
1. TRAFFIC AND FORECAST
(called Apron G)
Terminal Enlargement Apron G and Cargo Apron 2015
Finishing Apron G around construction site for 2017
Terminal 3
New Terminal 3 2017 (plans
not yet
published –
scheduled
beginning of
construction
2015)
Runway Config.: Max Arrivals : Max Departures: Global : Optimum Integration of Airports into the network (DPI, FUM)
Status: Data-Exchange (DPI, FUM) is part of A-CDM project development. Trials are planned for Q4 2010.
41-44 43-52 75-84 Plan to be operational by June 2011.
Additional Information: 4. TMA / APPROACH
Main operational runway configuration is Runway 25 and 18 (only Departures). If runway in use is changed to Does TMA / Approach constrain airport capacity? Changes foreseen in TMA
direction 07 the capacity value remains unchanged as long as wind situation allows using Runway 18 for
departures. Yes
For maximum traffic flow, RWY18 (only available for departures) is generally assigned to departures to the W, 5. TRAFFIC MIX
SW, S and SE. (if tailwind component is fewer then 15kts).
Changes foreseen in traffic mix?
3. PLANNED ACTIVITIES:
6. OPERATIONAL CONTACTS
Implementation
On going / Planned date(s)
Benefits Airport Operator:
S and R at eastern apron, connect with TWY F 30 Oct. 2011 Mr. S. Mauel (mauel@fraport.de);
TWYs at the new RWY 30 Oct. 2011 Alexandra Weil-Tziannis (Capacity Planner-+ 49 (69) 9573 9858-a.weil@fraport.de)
S and R between RWY18 and GAT Increase of declared ANSP:
New W parallel RWY18 2012 hourly global capacity
through several steps Mr. Kurt Oschlies (kurt.oschlies@dfs.de)
TWYs High Speed Turnoff RWY25L; S3
to 126. Michael Schwaderer (Michael.Schwaderer@dfs.de) - +49 (0) 6103 707 1574
Link of the parts of S and R 2015
At implementation of
High Speed Turnoff RWY25L; S2, S4, S5, S6
143 144
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
145 146
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Integration of Airports into the network (DPI, FUM)
Actual 12.2% 5.3% -1.3% -0.0% Status: No plans
Base 1.4% 2.0% 2.3% 2.7% 4.3%
High 4.8% 2.9% 4.1% 3.8% 5.4% 4. TMA / APPROACH
Low -2.1% 0.1% 0.7% 1.6% 3.2% Does TMA / Approach constrain airport Changes foreseen in TMA: TMA is extended to the east
2. DECLARED CAPACITY
capacity? to include SID's STAR'S for LGST (SITIA) airport
Capacities for different runway configurations No
Runway Config.: Max Arrivals : Max Departures: Global : Optimum
10 12 22 5. TRAFFIC MIX
147 148
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
planned to be
Installation of the Surface Movement Guidance and
completed May
Control System (ASMGCS)
ISTANBUL AIRPORT – IST/ LTBA 2010
1. TRAFFIC AND FORECAST The studies for installation of AMAN are ongoing.
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
implementation of A-CDM at LTBA was officially launched by DHMI on April 2009, in close collaboration
with EUROCONTROL.
Actual 10.1% 8.2% 5.7% 4.0%
Airport Capacity Enhancement Measures Mr. Kemal UNLU - General Manager -TAV Istanbul (International & Domestic Terminal)-
kemal.unlu@tav.aero
Mid- / Long-Term (1 to 15 years)
ANSP:
On going / Planned Implementation Benefits
date(s) Mr. Olcay Kilicoglu - Deputy Chief Manager DHMI - olcaykilicoglu@gmail
Positive impact on
New runway 2012-2014 Kagan Ertas - (Air Traffic Controller - DHMI HQ) kagan.ertas@dhmi.gov.tr
2010-2015 declared capacity (from
Two RETs 2010+
40 to 46 movements) Mustafa KIVRAK - ATC Manager - mustafa.kivrak@gmail.com
The SMART (Systematic Modernization of ATM planned to be
Resources in Turkey) project involves construction of completed 2011
new ATC units and a centralized ACC in Ankara.
149 150
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 4. TMA / APPROACH
Actual -0.2% 0.9% -0.6% -2.5%
Does TMA / Approach Changes foreseen in TMA
Base -0.9% 2.7% 1.0% 0.0% -0.0% constrain airport capacity? TMA / Approach can constrain capacity as the geographical position of
High 0.9% 1.9% 0.0% 0.0% -0.0% Yes LHR has the potential to generate routing bias delay (either TMA or en
Low -2.6% 2.3% 2.4% 0.8% -0.0% route)
2. DECLARED CAPACITY
5. TRAFFIC MIX
Capacities for different runway configurations
Changes foreseen in traffic mix?
Runway Config.: Max Arrivals : Max Departures: Global : Optimum Currently a small increase in Super Heavies (A380) with a corresponding drop in Mediums. The economic
downturn has lead to a small change in traffic mix due to consolidation and an increase in the use of LHR by
44 44 88 GA traffic. However any subsequent recovery may see a reverse of this.
3. PLANNED ACTIVITIES:
6. OPERATIONAL CONTACTS
Airport Capacity Enhancement Measures
Airport Operator:
Mid- / Long-Term (1 to 15 years)
Colin Wood - Airside Operations Director - Tel: 0208 745 2089 - colin_wood@baa.com
On going / Planned:
Government has given the go ahead for BAA to begin the planning application process for a third runway at Pete Leeming - BAA - Airside Assurance Manager 07919 057022 - peter_leeming@baa.com
Heathrow. Opportunities to increase the resilience (as opposed to the capacity) of the Heathrow operation ANSP:
continue to be explored. As a result of a British Government white paper in Jan 2009 the restriction on using 09L Jon Proudlove General Manager Air Traffic services (NATS) Tel: 02087502600 - jon.proudlove@nats.co.uk
as the departure runway has been lifted (with the aim of sharing noise alleviation within the local community
more equitably). However the existing departures capacity of that runway is not sufficient to meet demand so full
easterly alternation has not been implemented. Planning is now underway to increase departures capacity on
09L and arrivals capacity on 09R to enable a 09L departures operation to be mounted. Current planning
estimates indicate this will not be before 2013. Whilst this delivers an alternative operational configuration on
easterlies it does not increase capacity. A raft of longer term initiatives are being explored with a view to delivery
in this timeframe (including time based separation, EORA, CROP's / CREDOS, CDM, tactically enhanced
departures of the arrival runway, influence of the schedule, routing bias etc)
151 152
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Note: Limited information is available as Lisbon Airport is not yet participating in the EUROCONTROL airport
Actual 6.2% 5.3% 0.4% -5.8%
information reporting process.
Base 2.9% 1.7% 3.2% 2.5% -0.1%
2. PLANNED ACTIVITIES:
Airport Capacity Enhancement Measures
Mid- / Long-Term (1 to 15 years)
On going / Planned:
In 2006 ANA started the project “Lisbon Airport Expansion Plan” that aims at enhancing the punctuality and
airport capacity (40 movements per hour in 2011). The project will be concluded in 2011 and aims at meeting
short and medium-term forecast traffic growth.
Planned airport infrastructural and/or operational procedure changes (until 2013);
Re-development of 2 taxiways;
CAT II/III Operations on RWY 03.
153 154
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
4.TMA / APPROACH
Does TMA / Approach constrain airport capacity? Changes foreseen in TMA
Yes
5.TRAFFIC MIX
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Changes foreseen in traffic mix?
Actual 4.4% 11.1% -2.8% -7.4%
Base 0.9% 1.4% 0.7% 1.8% 1.8% 6.OPERATIONAL CONTACTS
High 2.8% 2.0% 3.2% 1.7% 3.4% Airport Operator:
3.PLANNED ACTIVITIES:
Airport Capacity Enhancement Measures
Mid- / Long-Term (1 to 15 years)
On going / Planned Implementation date(s) Benefits
Implementation of A-SMGCS level 1 2010 The quantitative impact on
(2010) declared capacity of these actions
has not been assessed for the
A-CDM 2012
moment.
155 156
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
4. TMA / APPROACH
Does TMA / Approach constrain airport Changes foreseen in TMA
capacity? It has been foreseen a revision of approach sector and a
Yes revision of SIDs&STARs
E.g. TMA/approach structure improvements,
additional approach sectors, segregation arrival/departure)
5. TRAFFIC MIX
Changes foreseen in traffic mix?
No
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Actual 6.4% 2.4% -4.2% -5.6%
6. OPERATIONAL CONTACTS
Base -0.5% 0.6% 3.7% 3.6% 3.5%
Airport Operator:
High 1.4% 1.8% 5.6% 4.7% 4.7%
SEA spa - PH Area di Movimento
Low -2.3% -1.2% 1.8% 2.2% 2.4%
Mauro Zanini
02-74853905
2. DECLARED CAPACITY ANSP:
Capacities for different runway configurations Claudio Biagiola Milano Linate ATS Manager
claudio.biagiola@enav.it
Runway Config.: Max Arrivals : Max Departures: Global : Optimum
157 158
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
3. PLANNED ACTIVITIES:
MILAN MALPENSA AIRPORT – MXP/ LIMC
Airport Capacity Enhancement Measures
Mid- / Long-Term (1 to 15 years)
1. TRAFFIC AND FORECAST
On going / Planned Implementation date(s) Benefits
Third Parallel Runway 2014/2015 Increasing of arrival capacity
Cargo Area Apron extension Spring 2011 More stands for Heavy Aircraft
New design for North Apron Summer 2010 to Summer 2011 Better stand allocation in North
Apron
40 40 70 5. TRAFFIC MIX
159 160
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 4. TMA / APPROACH
Actual 3.0% 5.2% 0.2% -8.3%
Base -0.6% 2.1% 2.8% 2.1% 2.3% Does TMA / Approach constrain airport capacity? Changes foreseen in TMA
High 1.8% 2.5% 4.1% 3.1% 3.3% Yes
Low -3.3% 0.8% 1.6% 1.2% 1.3%
161 162
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
4. TMA / APPROACH
Does TMA / Approach constrain airport capacity? Yes Changes foreseen in TMA
5. TRAFFIC MIX
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Changes foreseen in traffic mix?
Actual 4.3% 3.7% -2.1% -8.2%
Base -1.6% 4.4% 2.7% 2.4% 2.6% 6. OPERATIONAL CONTACTS
High 1.1% 4.4% 4.2% 3.7% 4.0% Airport Operator:
Low -5.2% 2.0% 1.4% 1.4% 1.5% Elisa Callejo Tamayo
Jefa del Departamento de Area Terminal
2. DECLARED CAPACITY
Division de Operaciones
Capacities for different runway configurations
Direccion de Operaciones y Sistemas de Red - Aena
Runway Config.: Max Arrivals : Max Departures: Global : Optimum 91 321 13 25
ecallejo@aena.es
32 33 60
ANSP:
Jose Luis de la Calle
3. PLANNED ACTIVITIES: jldelacalle@aena.es
Main actions planned in Palma de Mallorca airport for the Capacity increase in LVC is expected 2010+. The
2010-2014 period with positive effect on capacity are quantitative impact on declared capacity of this
implementation of A-SMGCS level 1. action has not been assessed for the moment.
Implementation date(s):
2010
163 164
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
165 166
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
167 168
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
4.TMA / APPROACH
Does TMA / Approach constrain airport capacity? Yes Changes foreseen in TMA
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Actual 2.4% 6.1% 3.5% -6.4% 5.TRAFFIC MIX
Base 0.4% -0.1% 3.6% 3.2% 3.4%
High 2.3% 0.9% 5.4% 4.6% 4.8% Changes foreseen in traffic mix? No
Low -1.2% -1.7% 2.0% 1.9% 2.0%
6.OPERATIONAL CONTACTS
2.DECLARED CAPACITY
Airport Operator:
Capacities for different runway configurations
Elia Pistola - pistola.e@adr.it
Max Arrivals : Max Departures: ANSP:
Runway Config.: Global : Optimum
Giovanni Giarratano - ENAV SpA Fiumicino Airport ATM Manager - giovanni.giarratano@enav.it
54 60 90 +390665650200
Additional Information:
Best configuration 16L16R for ARR, 25 for DEP and 34L/34R for ARR DEP 25. Arianna Santacroce - NOP Focal Point Fiumicino Airport -arianna.santacroce@enav.it
Parallel use of 16L for ARR and 16R both for ARR & DEP.
34L for DEP/ARR and 34R for ARR. Maurizio Paggetti -ENAV SpA - Airport Operation Dept. Manager - maurizio.paggetti@enav.it
Most penalising configuration is the use of 25 as the main RWY for ARR & DEP (Regulations applied about
22x60 arr; 22x60dep) Debora Palombi -ENAV SpA - ATFCM Performance - debora.palombi@enav.it
3. PLANNED ACTIVITIES: Corrado Fantini -ENAV SpA - ATM Performance Dept. Manager -corrado.fantini@enav.it
169 170
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Actual 1.3% 6.2% -4.4% 4.8%
Base 0.2% 1.8% 2.4% 2.8% 4.3%
High 2.8% 2.7% 4.2% 4.0% 5.5%
Low -2.7% -0.1% 0.8% 1.7% 3.2%
Note: Limited information is available as Thessaloniki Airport is not yet participating in the EUROCONTROL airport
information reporting process.
171 172
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Actual 4.2% 12.5% -3.4% -17.4% Integration of Airports into the network (DPI, FUM)
Status: Not Planned
Base -4.8% -2.0% -6.4% 2.5% 2.5%
High -0.7% 2.4% -4.5% -6.2% 3.9% 4. TMA / APPROACH
Low -9.2% -5.6% -8.1% 1.6% 1.4%
Does TMA / Approach constrain airport capacity? No Changes foreseen in TMA
173 174
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
4. TMA / APPROACH
Does TMA / Approach constrain airport capacity? Yes Changes foreseen in TMA
5. TRAFFIC MIX
Changes foreseen in traffic mix? None
6. OPERATIONAL CONTACTS
Airport Operator:
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Actual 4.5% 7.9% -10.0% -5.1% SAVE S.p.A. / Rocchetto Francesco - frocchetto@veniceairport.it +390412606400
Base 0.9% 2.6% 3.6% 3.2% 3.4% ANSP:
High 2.9% 3.4% 5.3% 4.4% 4.4% ENAV S.p.A.
Low -0.9% 0.9% 2.0% 2.0% 2.2%
Massimo Maniccia Director (massimo.maniccia@enav.it)
2. DECLARED CAPACITY Antonio Prete: Operations Manager/Deputy Director (antonio.prete@enav.it)
175 176
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Benefits: Improved resource management, improved punctuality records, shorter system recovery times in
case of adverse weather or other disruptions.
Integration of Airports into the network (DPI, FUM)
Status: planned for Q2 2012
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Actual 3.1% 7.7% 4.4% -10.0% 4. TMA / APPROACH
Base 2.1% 2.8% 3.5% 2.7% 2.9%
High 4.6% 3.2% 5.1% 3.8% 4.0% Does TMA / Changes foreseen in TMA: TMA structure dependant on the very close vicinity to the
Low -0.7% 1.4% 2.1% 1.6% 1.8% Approach constrain FIR border and to adjacent units; Capacity constraints due to environmental obligations
airport capacity? with regard to RWY usage plan and SID routeings; Enhanced DEP spacing.
Yes
2. DECLARED CAPACITY
Capacities for different runway configurations
5. TRAFFIC MIX
Runway Config.: Max Arrivals : Max Departures: Global : Optimum Changes foreseen in traffic mix? Restructuring of Hub-Carrier may cause change in Prop/Jet Mixture. LCC
48 48 66 share decreased due to bankruptcy of one carrier
Additional Information:
Single RWY: ARR 25/60, 6. OPERATIONAL CONTACTS
Two RWY configuration: ARR 40/60 Airport Operator:
RWY 16/11 simultaneously: ARR 48+ /60
Anton Pfeffer- Aviation Infrastructure Development - Vienna Intenational Airport - a.pfeffer@viennaairport.com
3. PLANNED ACTIVITIES: Dariusz Graniczkowski- Aviation Infrastructure Development - Vienna International Airport -
Airport Capacity Enhancement Measures d.graniczkowski@viennaairport.com
Mid- / Long-Term (1 to 15 years) ANSP: Daniel Schaad - Austrocontrol GmbH Air Traffic Management / Expert Operational Performance -
Implementation
On going / Planned date(s)
Benefits daniel.schaad@austrocontrol.at
Re- evaluation of AMAN landing Improvement of Airside Capacity in Vienna
time prediction 2010+ due to better resource allocation through
enhanced arrival prediction
Evaluation of actual TMA Better knowledge of actual capacity, better
capacity through Eurocontrol 2010+ resource allocation
CAPAN-TMA study (ongoing)
177 178
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Actual 9.3% 5.0% -1.3% -10.5% 4. TMA / APPROACH
Base 1.6% 3.5% 5.4% 3.1% 4.2%
Does TMA / Approach constrain airport Changes foreseen in TMA
High 4.2% 4.0% 7.5% 4.0% 5.7%
Low -1.2% 2.1% 3.6% 2.4% 2.9% capacity? Yes TMA will change its boundaries to allow maximum capacity.
2. DECLARED CAPACITY
Capacities for different runway configurations 5. TRAFFIC MIX
Runway Config.: Max Arrivals : Max Departures: Global : Optimum Changes foreseen in traffic mix?
RWY 11 & RWY 15 24 36
6. OPERATIONAL CONTACTS
RWY 29 & RWY 33 24 36
Airport Operator:
Additional Information:
There are no delays and capacity change for 2 most important configurations (11/15 and 29/33). There are Rafal Marczewski - Head of Operational Processes and Implementations Division - r.marczewski@polish-
delays predicted for the summertime, as the single runway operations will be available only. ATFM airports.com
measures might be imposed, but the capacity will be managed flexibly. ANSP:
Refer to AIP for dates of modernization.
Strong caution required - airport will be unavailable for some periods in September. Mrs. Hanna Kalita - International Programs Specialist, PANSA - (h.kalita@pansa.pl)
3. PLANNED ACTIVITIES: Mr. Jaroslaw Newinski - Deputy Director Aerodrome Control, PANSA - j.niewinski@pansa.pl
Airport Capacity Enhancement Measures Mr. Krzysztof Kosarzycki - Head of Warsaw Tower, PANSA - k.kosarzycki@pansa.pl
179 180
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014 EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
4. TMA / APPROACH
Scenario 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Does TMA / Approach constrain airport capacity? Changes foreseen in TMA
Actual -2.3% 2.8% 3.1% -4.9%
Base 2.2% 2.0% 2.6% 2.1% 2.4% Yes P-RNAV transitions have been implemented in April.
High 4.8% 2.5% 3.6% 3.0% 3.0% Until now no further changes planned.
Low -0.8% 1.0% 1.8% 1.4% 1.6%
2. DECLARED CAPACITY
5. TRAFFIC MIX
Capacities for different runway configurations
Changes foreseen in traffic mix?
Runway Config.: Max Arrivals : Max Departures: Global : Optimum No
TKOF RWY28 LDG RWY14 36 32 66 Y
30 6. OPERATIONAL CONTACTS
TKOF RWY10 LDG RWY14 31 61 Airport Operator:
TKOF RWY32/34 LDG RWY28 27 30 57 Sonja Zoechling - sonja.zoechling@unique.ch
Additional Information : ANSP:
All concepts outside the best configuration decrease the capacity. Jonas Wobmann, FMP Manager Skyguide, Zuerich jonas.wobmann@skyguide.ch
3. PLANNED ACTIVITIES:
Airport Capacity Enhancement Measures
Mid- / Long-Term (1 to 15 years)
On going / Planned Implementation Benefits
date(s)
2 Rapid Exit Taxiways RWY 28 2011 No significant increase of
capacity is planned within the
2 Rapid Exit Taxiways RWY 34 2012
next years.
Implement Advanced Surface Movement Guidance 2010
and Control System (A-SMGCS) Level 2
181 182
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
ACRONYMS
183
EUROPEAN ATM NETWORK OPERATIONS PERFORMANCE PLAN ASSESSMENT 2011-2014
186
Contact details
CND/CoE/ATM/Airports
maria-christina.meyer@eurocontrol.int
CND/Network Development
razvan.bucuroiu@eurocontrol.int
EUROCONTROL
June 2010 - © European Organisation for the Safety of Air Navigation (EUROCONTROL)
www.eurocontrol.int