Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
INSTITUTE OF ENGINEERING
PULCHOWK CAMPUS
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
M .Sc. Program in Structural Engineering
February, 2011
TRIBHUVAN UNIVERSITY
INSTITUTE OF ENGINEERING
PULCHOWK CAMPUS
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
M .Sc. Program in Structural Engineering
A Thesis Submitted By
AJAY KUMAR GUPTA
MASTER OF SCIENCE
IN
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING
February, 2011
COPYRIGHT
The author has agreed that the Library, Department of Civil Engineering, Institute of
Engineering, Pulchowk Campus, may make this thesis freely available for inspection.
Moreover, the author has agreed that permission for extensive copying of this thesis
for scholarly purpose may be granted by the professor who supervised the thesis work
recorded herein or, in his absence, by the Head of the Department or concerning
M.Sc. program coordinator or the Dean of the Institute in which thesis work was
done. It is understood that the recognition will be given to the author of this thesis and
to the Department of Civil Engineering, Institute of Engineering, Pulchowk Campus,
in any use of the material of this thesis. Copying or publication or other use of the
thesis for financial gain without approval of the Department of Civil Engineering,
Institute of Engineering, Pulchowk Campus and the authors written permission is
prohibited. Request for permission to copy or to make any other use of the material of
this thesis in whole or in part should be addressed to:
..
Head
Department of Civil Engineering
Pulchowk Campus
Institute of Engineering
Lalitpur, Nepal.
i
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the work contained in this thesis entitled Study on Reinforced
Concrete Frame with Solid Infill Brick Masonry using Artificial Neural
Network submitted by Mr. Ajay Kumar Gupta (Roll No. 065/MSS/r/102) for the
award of partial fulfillment of the degree of Master of Science in Structural
Engineering of Institute of Engineering, Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu is a
bonafide record of work carried out by him under my supervision and guidance, no
part of it has been published or submitted elsewhere for the award of degree.
.. .
Assoc. Prof. Prajwal Lal Pradhan Date
Department of Civil Engineering
Institute of Engineering
Pulchowk Campus
Lalitpur, Nepal
ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I owe a debt of gratitude to many other seniors and colleagues who provided
technical support and social encouragement, especially Mr. Sujan Tripathi, Mr.
Dinesh Gupta, Mr. Anup Chaudhary, Mr. Arvind Jha and Mr. Chandan Karna. And
they, all, by virtue of proximity, became living sounding boards of ideas.
iii
TRIBHUVAN UNIVERSITY
INSTITUTE OF ENGINEERING
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
M .Sc. Program in Structural Engineering
ABSTRACT
Despite being the most common construction practice throughout the ages, infills
have not found the space it deserves, in the structural design. There is lack of proper
and easy method to consider the effect of the in-filled. So, this research is a small
effort in the search of the alternative approach for analyzing the infill frames. The
FEM Models are normally incapable of considering all the effecting factors such as
non-linear behavior of the infill materials, lack of fit, non-homogeneity of the
materials, etc. This research gives some idea to the structural engineer how to guess
initially the parameters of interest during the design of infills. Structural design
process is an iterative process and an approximate initial guess can reduce the time
and cost involved in the analysis. The tentative design parameters can be predicted
using the Artificial Intelligence and this computing power of the modern day
computers has been used to fulfill the intended purpose. The data sets, which are
generated by computer from the simulation of the infill-frame structure done in
sophisticated software (ANSYS v10.0) capable of non-linear analysis, are used for the
training of Neural Network. Few other unique data sets are taken for the validation of
the Network trained. The comparison of the results from the ANN and that of
software were in reasonable agreement with each other except in few rare cases.
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS
COPYRIGHT . i
CERTIFICATE .. ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT . iii
ABSTRACT iv
LIST OF SYMBOLS .. ix
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION 1
2.1 General 8
2.2 Experimental Studies 8
2.3 Analytical Studies 9
2.4 About ANN 12
2.4.1 Back-Propagation Neural Network 13
2.4.2 The Back-Propagation Training Algorithm 14
3.1 General 16
3.2 Masonry 16
3.3 Bricks 17
3.4 Mortar 18
3.5 Reinforced Concrete 19
v
CHAPTER 4: FINITE ELEMENT MODEL . 22
7.1 General 48
7.2 Conclusions 50
7.3 Recommendations for the future works 51
APPENDIX 53
REFERENCES .. 70
vi
LIST OF TABLES
Table 2-1: Analogy between biological and artificial neural networks 13
vii
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1-1: Structure of Artificial Neural Network model 3
Figure 1-3: Flow Chart for Analysis of Infill Wall using ANN 6
Figure 2-1: Single Diagonal Strut Models (Smith and Carter 1969) 9
Figure 4-2: Beam3 element used for Modeling Beam and Column 25
Figure 5-2: Error reduction graph during Back-propagation Neural Network Training 31
viii
LIST OF SYMBOLS
p number of step
wij weight assigned to a hidden layer node in between ith and jth nodes
stress at a node
strain at a node
ix
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
1.2 Background
Infill frame construction represents a common type of construction in urban
areas. Infill walls change the behavior of frames considerably under lateral loads and
affect mainly the strength, rigidity, energy dissipation, etc. characteristics. In the
conventional design, the building frames are designed for dead and live loads. Hence,
they cannot withstand lateral loads, especially when they are very tall. On the other
hand, post-earthquake damage reports often note poorly detailed reinforced concrete
frames that have failed due to localized forces produced by the infill. Any attempt to
increase the size of the structural elements to withstand these occasional loads is both
expensive and undesirable. The concept of the infill frame considers the integral
structural action of walls and slab with the frames, and provides increased lateral
force resisting capacity for frames.
The use of computers as we all know is inevitable these days in any portion of
the structural design of any type of the structures. And the use of artificial intelligence
in the field of computers is one of the most fascinating and interesting as the use these
days is recommended in almost any field of real life and practical applications. The
field being related to computer applications has not found much of the place in
structural field and especially in the context of Nepal the use has been found to be
very limited. The method based on the Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) can
accommodate all parameters and uncertainties like non-linear behavior of infill, lack
of fit at the frame infill interface, non-homogeneity of the materials. The main
advantage of this method is that the size of the output vector can be increased to meet
all the requirements. The inherent tolerance mechanism and the ability to learn from
the new patterns (data sets) make it an ideal method.
The origins of Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) are in the field biology. The
biological brain consists of billions of highly interconnected neurons forming a neural
2
network. Human information processing depends on this connectionist system of
nervous cells. Based on this advantage of information processing, neural networks can
easily exploit the massively parallel local processing and distributed storage
properties in the brain. Generally speaking, an ANN is an informational system
simulating the ability of a biological neural network by interconnecting many simple
neurons (Fig. 1-1). The neuron accepts inputs from a single or multiple sources and
produces outputs by simple calculations, processing with a predetermined non-linear
function. Therefore, the primary characteristics of an ANN can be presented as
following: (1) the ability of learning; (2) distributed memory; (3) fault tolerance and
(4) operating in parallel.
To train the computer for the development of ANN tool for the
prediction of non linear results associated with the infill masonry wall.
1.5 Methodology
The analysis comprise of a series of steps which are briefed as under in a
systematic manner.
5
Non-linear Analysis of Infill
Figure 1-3: Flow Chart for Analysis of Infill Wall using ANN
6
1.5.3 Modeling of the Structure
Four different Ansys elements are used for preparation of Reinforced Concrete
infill model in Ansys. Three different materials reinforced concrete, brick and mortar
are considered. In which Ansys element Plane42 is used for both brick and mortar,
and the element Beam3 is used for both beam and column. Link10 element is used for
connection between line and plane element. Using these three elements 2D model is
prepared in Ansys. Different aspect ratios were considered providing the data sets a
wide range and two thickness of infill were used for analysis.
7
CHAPTER 2: REVIEW OF LITERATURE
2.1 General
Recent earthquakes have clearly shown that the damages done to the buildings
with infills were considerable less than those without infills and the difference was
quite a bit significant. Therefore, the structural contribution of infill walls cannot
simply be neglected particularly in regions of moderate and high seismicity where, the
frameinfill interaction may cause substantial increase in both stiffness and strength
of the frame. A review of analysis and design provisions related to masonry infill RC
frames in seismic design codes of different countries shows that only a few codes
have considered the effect of infill in analysis and design of masonry infill RC frames
(Kaushik et al. 2006). On the other hand, the stiffness and strength of the infill frames
are not taken care of by most of the codes. Hence, the behavior of infill frames needs
to be studied extensively in order to develop a rational approach or guidelines for
design.
8
frame expressed as a function of geometry of frame and infill, and of the compressive
strength of the infill.
Figure 2-1: Single Diagonal Strut Models (Smith and Carter 1969)
9
During the last three decades, different approaches have been proposed for the
prediction of the ultimate strength of infill steel frames subjected to monotonic lateral
load. Holmes (1961) proposed that the infill wall be replaced by an equivalent
diagonal strut having a width equal to one-third of the diagonal length of the infill
wall. Stafford Smith (1966) proposed an expression relating the width of the
equivalent strut to the properties of the frame and infill wall. The width of the
equivalent strut varied with value of the following non-dimensional factor:
1/ 4
E th 3 sin 2
h = c (2-1)
4Es I
Where,
Ec = elastic modulus of the infill material, ksi
Es = elastic modulus of the frame material, ksi
t = thickness of the infill wall, inches
h = height of a single story, inches
4
I = moment of inertia of the frame columns, inch
= slope of the infill diagonal relative to horizontal
Stafford Smith and Carter (1969) further related the width of the equivalent
strut not only to factor h, but also to the variation of the elastic modulus of the infill
material at different stress levels. Makino (1984) proposed a simplified formula to
calculate the width of the equivalent strut based on Stafford Smith and Carters work.
In his formula, the width of the equivalent strut was only related to the diagonal
length of the infill wall or the thickness of the infill wall. Liauw and Kwan (1983a)
expressed the equivalent strut width as a fraction of hcos:
0.86
b= (h cos ) 0.45(h cos ) (2-2)
h
d
WdS = (Holmes 1961) (2-3)
3
0.445 0.064
l
WdS = 0.58 (h )0.335d l (Smith and Carter 1969) (2-4)
h h
WdS = 0.16h0.3 d (Mainstone 1971) (2-5)
WdS =
(0.95h cos )
(Liauw and Kwan 1984) (2-6)
.h
d
WdS = (Paulay and Priestley 1992) (2-7)
4
d
WdS = (Angel At. Al 1994) (2-8)
8
WdS = 0.175(h )
0.4
d (FEMA 274, 1997) (2-9)
FEMA 356
The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) code 356 explains
clearly enough how to take infills into account: the effect of infills has to be
considered by a FEM analysis or, alternatively, by introducing a diagonal pin-jointed
strut equivalent to the infill. For the first option no more is said, unlike the second
one, which is derived from an experimental observation: under lateral forces the
frame tends to separate from the infill near the windward lower and leeward upper
corners of the infill mesh. For FEMA 356 the equivalent strut is to have the same
thickness and modulus of elasticity as the infill panel (but it is not clear along which
direction the modulus of elasticity must be calculated) while the width w is given by
the following equation
W 0.4
= 0.175( ' h') (2-10)
d
Ed tSin(2 )
' = 4 (2-11)
4E f I c h
11
Figure 2-2: Geometric characteristics in Equations. (2-8) and (2-9)
12
neural networks. The ease with which they can learn led to attempts to emulate a
biological neural network in a computer.
Soma Neuron
Dendrite Input
Axon Output
Synapse Weight
13
First, a training input pattern is presented to the network input layer. The
network propagates the input pattern from layer to layer until the output pattern is
generated by the output layer. If this pattern is different from the desired output, an
error is calculated and then propagated backwards through the network from the
output layer to the input layer. The weights are modified as the error is propagated.
Where, ek ( p ) = y d ,k ( p ) y k ( p ) (2-16)
Step 4: Iteration- Increase iteration p by one, go back to Step 2 and repeat the process
until the desired error criterion is satisfied.
15
CHAPTER 3: REINFORCED CONCRETE INFILL FRAME
MATERIALS
3.1 General
Reinforced Concrete, mortar & brick are the major components of masonry
units. Masonry possesses distinct directional properties due to the mortar joints. A
number of influence factors (such as anisotropy of units, size of units, mortar
thickness, material properties of units and mortar, arrangement of bed as well as head
joints, and quality of workmanship) make simulation of masonry structures extremely
difficult. The frame-masonry interaction in infill makes it even harder for the
computer simulation.
3.2 Masonry
Masonry is the building of structures from individual units laid in and bound
together by mortar; the term masonry can also refer to the units themselves. The
common materials of masonry construction are brick, stone such as marble, granite,
travertine, limestone; concrete block, glass block, and tile. Masonry is generally a
highly durable form of construction. However, the materials used, the quality of the
mortar and workmanship, and the pattern in which the units are assembled can
significantly affect the durability of the overall masonry construction.
Masonry units, such as brick, tile, stone, glass brick or concrete block
generally conform to the requirements specified in the 2003 International Building
Code (IBC) Section 2103.
Masonry is commonly used for the walls of buildings, retaining walls and
monuments. Brick and concrete block are the most common types of masonry in use
in industrialized nations and may be either weight-bearing or a veneer. Concrete
blocks, especially those with hollow cores, offer various possibilities in masonry
construction. They generally provide great compressive strength, and are best suited
to structures with light transverse loading when the cores remain unfilled. Filling
some or all of the cores with concrete or concrete with steel reinforcement (typically
rebar) offers much greater tensile and lateral strength to structures.
16
Masonry is broadly classified as i) Stone masonry and ii) Brick masonry.
Apart from the load-bearing capacity, the following aspects also are considered while
selecting the most suitable type of masonry unit: (a) adequate thermal and sound
insulation capacity of masonry, especially in the case of external walls, (b) reduction
of the weight of the building in order to reduce the seismic loads, and (c) economy of
construction.
3.3 Bricks
A brick is a block of ceramic material used in masonry construction, usually
laid using various kinds of mortar. The term brick refers to small units of building
material, often made from fired clay and secured with mortar, a bonding agent
comprising of cement, sand, and water. Long a popular material, brick retains heat,
with-stands corrosion, and resists fire. Masonry construction are being made of either
burnt clay brick, concrete or light-weight concrete units in different sizes and shapes,
either solid or perforated. As a rule, they must meet national standard requirements.
When selecting the most suitable type of unit, one has to consider, apart from the
load-bearing capacity, the following aspects:
1. That can provide adequate thermal and sound insulation capacity, especially
in external walls.
2. Which can minimise the weight of the building and of seismic horizontal
forces.
Build houses using brick masonry is a common practice in this part of the
world. Generally there can be a few types of brick available anywhere in the world.
Here also we intend to use three different types of brick, based on their properties and
not dimensions. The types of the brick and their corresponding properties used in the
modeling are tabulated in Table 3-1.
17
Figure 3-1: Stress-strain characteristics of different bricks used.
3.4 Mortar
Mortar is a mixture of sand, lime and Portland cement, mixed with water to a
workable consistency. It is used as a bond in masonry or for covering a wall. Mortar
are referred as any of various bonding materials used in masonry, surfacing, and
plastering, especially a plastic mixture of cement or lime, sand, and water that hardens
in place and is used to bind together bricks or stones. Sometimes, additives are added
to mortar to improve its workability, or for other reasons. Mortars must be sufficiently
strong, durable, capable of keeping the wall intact, and must create a water-resistant
barrier. It is applied with a bricklayer's trowel, and sets solid in a few hours. There are
many different mixes and admixtures used to make mortars with different
performance characteristics.
18
3. Lightweight mortar, designed mortar with a dry hardened density lower
than 1500 kg/m3.
The types of the mortar and their corresponding properties used here for
modeling are stated as below.
The common practice observed in this part of Nepal and almost everywhere in
the country is to use reinforced concrete for frame materials and brick masonry for
infill materials. So here we have intended to get closer to the real practice by
modeling the structure using these four distinct materials and use their non-linear
characteristics as far as possible.
The properties of the concrete and the reinforcing bars used for the modeling
purpose are listed as under:
20
Figure 3-3: Stress-Strain Characteristics of Reinforced Concrete
21
CHAPTER 4: FINITE ELEMENT MODEL
22
4.2 Modelling Strategy
A parametric study is performed to obtain lateral stiffness of infill frames with
varying aspect ratios. The FE model is prepared for the purpose. The FE model is first
calibrated using published results of experimental specimens available in the
literature. This calibrated model is used in the parametric study to determine the
lateral stiffness of infill frames. The width of equivalent diagonal strut for the infill
frame using other established relations is compared to that estimated from the FE
method. That is, equivalent width of diagonal strut is to be determined that will give
correct approximation of lateral stiffness. In the parametric study, five parameters,
i.e., aspect ratio, brick property, mortar property, thickness of infill and lateral load
are varied considerably to get the sufficient data for Neural Network training. A
single-bay single-story is considered for the study and their lateral stiffness is
determined by non-linear analysis considering material non-linearity. The single-bay
single-story infill frame considered is shown in figure bellow. Thus a total of 200
models have to be analysed in the parametric study. All the analyses are performed
using the software ANSYS v10.0.
23
Mortar thickness of 12mm provided in between consecutive bricks.
Plane42 element can be used either as a plane element (plane stress or plane strain) or
as an axi-symmetric element for 2D analysis of structure. According to name of the
element Plane means aerial, 4 means four nodes i.e. quadrilateral and 2 means two
degree of freedom (translations in the nodal x and y directions) at each nodes.
Beam3 is a linear element. This element is used for modelling of the members which
has bending capabilities. The element has three degrees of freedom at each node,
translations in the nodal x and y directions and rotation about the nodal z-axis.
24
Figure 4-2: Beam3 element used for Modeling Beam and Column
Link10 is a linear element. This element is used where only compressive or tension
property of the material has to be considered. When it is used as compressive only, at
that time tension property of that material is taken to be zero. This element is used for
modelling of cable, non-tension element etc.
Two degrees of freedom are considered for all the nodes of infill. The
displacements in X- and Y- directions in the plane of frame are considered at all
nodes for the infill and for this Plane42 element is used. The element having
translations in the nodal x and y directions and rotation about the nodal z-axis i.e.
Beam3 element is used for modelling of Beam and Column. Link10 element is used
for connection between Frame (i.e. line element) and infill (i.e. Plane42 element) by
taking only compression feature of this element.
25
Figure 4-4: Sample model prepared for the analysis
Three different materials reinforced concrete, brick and mortar are used for
modeling to incorporate the complex heterogeneity involved in the infill as far as
possible. The area for the link element is computed using average spacing of the link
elements throughout the run of the infill and the thickness of the beam and column
element. The material non-linearity is also considered. An overview of the material
properties used for the analysis purpose is presented in the tabular form below.
26
4.3.4 Model Descriptions
The above mentioned materials and geometries were combined to generate the
models which ensured the combination of materials in a systematic way and thus
creating the desired variation in the analysis that was intended to be given to this
research. The respective combination of geometries with their respective material
properties are given in the table below.
27
LU, LU RU, RU
C, C
LB, LB RB, RB
Hz L ML Hz R
MR
V
Figure 4-5: Salient nodal points considered for the output
Where,
HzL - Horizontal reaction at Left Support.
HzR - Horizontal reaction at Right Support.
V - Vertical Reaction at each Support
ML - Moment at the Left Support.
MR - Moment at the Right Support.
28
Ansys were taken as the reference for the preparation of the training sets. Another 16
data sets were also prepared using Ansys for validation purpose. The 200 data sets
that were collected for the training purpose of the neural network comprised of
variation of single height, five spans, two brick-types, two mortar-types, two
thicknesses of infill and five loads thus making a total of 5 x 2 x 2 x 2 x 5 = 200
models to be analysed. The validating 16 data sets were taken in order to check the
accuracy of the data predicted from the trained network.
29
CHAPTER 5: TRAINING THE DATA SETS USING ANN
30
Figure 5-1: Back-propagation Neural Network used for Training
Figure 5-2: Error reduction graph during Back-propagation Neural Network Training
31
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
Modulus of Elasticity
Aspect Ratio
of Brick In-plane Lateral
Modulus of Elasticity Stiffness
Thickness of wall
of Mortar
The variation is the parameters on the above mentioned interest are tabulated
below making the sum total number of analysed models 200. Combination of five
aspect ratios, two thicknesses of wall, two different bricks, and two different mortars
are anylysed for five loading conditions. The schematic variation in the considered
parameters is shown in the table below.
32
Table 6-2: Parametric characteristics of infilled frames analysed
Wall
Aspect Lateral load
Analyses Brick Mortar Thickness
Ratios (KN)
(mm)
110
Machine 1:4 100,200,300,400,500
230
Made
110
Brick 1:6 100,200,300,400,500
230
1 40 1
110
1:4 100,200,300,400,500
230
Local Brick
110
1:6 100,200,300,400,500
230
41 - 80 0.85 Same as in 1 - 40
81 120 0.75 Same as in 1 - 40
121 160 0.67 Same as in 1 - 40
161 200 0.60 Same as in 1 - 40
33
(a) Aspect Ratio 1.0 (3m x 3m) (b) Aspect Ratio 0.86 (3m x 3.5m)
(c) Aspect Ratio 0.75 (3m x 4m) (d) Aspect Ratio 0.67 (3m x 4.5m)
34
near linear relationship between the wall thickness and the infilled frame stiffness, as
well as between the wall thickness. The Ratio of stiffness is increasing as the aspect
ratio is decreasing, i.e., the ratio of stiffness is increasing with increase in the span.
However, the trend for the ratio of stress and strain is opposite. The ratio of stresses
and strains at the specified nodal points seems to be decreasing with the decrease in
aspect ratio (i.e. increase in span).
35
Table 6-4: Response variation due to aspect ratio
37
found to increases with decrease in aspect ratio. The stresses and strains were found to
be decrease with decrease in aspect ratio and also with the increase in wall thickness.
38
(a) MB4 (b) LB4
39
(c) 4m (d) 4.5m
(e) 5m
40
Figure 6-4 : Equivalent Strut Model
The finite element (FE) effective widths have been determined by replacing
the infill wall with a strut that results in the same infilled frame stiffness as from the
corresponding finite element analysis. Calculations based on Mainstone (1971)
method, and the FEMA 306 (1998) method are in reasonable agreement with each
other while that obtained from the current FE analyses shows the results on a higher
side for the estimates of the effective widths of the equivalent diagonal struts.
41
MB4 0.483 0.527 1.090 0.551 1.140 0.621 1.285
MB6 0.497 0.535 1.077 0.558 1.122 0.621 1.249
0.67
LB4 0.492 0.533 1.083 0.556 1.130 0.621 1.262
LB6 0.501 0.542 1.082 0.563 1.123 0.621 1.239
MB4 0.536 0.575 1.072 0.600 1.120 0.674 1.258
MB6 0.542 0.584 1.078 0.608 1.122 0.674 1.244
0.6
LB4 0.538 0.582 1.081 0.606 1.126 0.674 1.254
LB6 0.546 0.591 1.083 0.613 1.124 0.674 1.235
This was done for all the 16 outputs those were desired to be produced from the
network. The validation of the predicted data sets was done in reference to those data
sets from Ansys analysis. The predicted data and the desired data and their
corresponding difference in percentage which indicates the accuracy of the predicted
data are shown in the table below.
42
Table 7-1: Comparison of Results obtained from ANSYS and ANN
LB (N/m2) 2033 1849 9.022 1118 1074 3.879 528 465 11.894 4778 5438 13.810
LU (N/m2) -4795728 -4737439 1.215 -3475204 -3565439 2.597 -1653769 -1858448 12.377 -6301922 -5778220 8.310
C (N/m2) -606176 -611721 0.915 -430130 -434327 0.976 -197155 -189955 3.652 -993716 -1009572 1.596
RB (N/m2) -4817533 -4989542 3.570 -3718866 -4037448 8.567 -1511038 -1508890 0.142 -6231407 -5653019 9.282
RU (N/m2) 6144 5980 2.661 4348 4268 1.853 2093 1876 10.370 10183 10634 4.430
LB 3.870E-07 3.928E-07 1.487 3.035E-07 3.382E-07 11.428 1.556E-07 1.648E-07 5.901 8.622E-07 8.048E-07 6.652
LU -9.583E-04 -1.004E-03 4.808 -7.266E-04 -7.915E-04 8.933 -3.319E-04 -3.175E-04 4.335 -1.985E-03 -1.962E-03 1.161
C -1.900E-04 -1.947E-04 2.496 -1.347E-04 -1.366E-04 1.444 -5.894E-05 -5.702E-05 3.261 -3.942E-04 -3.937E-04 0.144
RB -1.418E-03 -1.443E-03 1.768 -1.003E-03 -1.095E-03 9.162 -4.427E-04 -4.558E-04 2.959 -2.276E-03 -2.172E-03 4.592
RU 1.047E-06 9.798E-07 6.381 8.407E-07 9.091E-07 8.128 2.883E-07 2.672E-07 7.299 2.181E-06 2.320E-06 6.336
Model 11-MB6 23-MB6
Load 250 450 150 350
Responses ANSYS ANN % Error ANSYS ANN % Error ANSYS ANN % Error ANSYS ANN % Error
Hz L (N) -100560 -100822 0.261 -182510 -181804 0.387 -58495 -57538 1.635 -137790 -135330 1.785
Hz R (N) -149440 -149582 0.095 -267490 -268872 0.517 -91505 -89219 2.498 -212210 -212342 0.062
V (N) 163550 163207 0.209 293250 292111 0.388 99461 98058 1.411 231490 233048 0.673
M L (N-m) 75332 75896 0.749 138180 139530 0.977 41834 41200 1.516 99041 98977 0.064
M R (N-m) 98313 98861 0.557 179240 180898 0.925 56706 56212 0.871 133400 133916 0.387
Disp (mm) 13.163 13.337 1.322 24.498 24.706 0.850 7.064 6.934 1.842 16.879 16.809 0.414
LB (N/m2) 2129 1896 10.956 5772 5819 0.815 528 465 11.894 1179 1089 7.575
LU (N/m2) -4953283 -4798553 3.124 -6470576 -5717876 11.633 -1653769 -1858448 12.377 -3603996 -3646379 1.176
C (N/m2) -643746 -630214 2.102 -1165171 -1119811 3.893 -197155 -189955 3.652 -457402 -451793 1.226
RB (N/m2) -4967742 -5091107 2.483 -6165900 -5832554 5.406 -1511038 -1508890 0.142 -3890035 -4183064 7.533
RU (N/m2) 6881 6180 10.189 12541 10981 12.443 2093 1876 10.370 4873 4457 8.539
LB 3.856E-07 3.405E-07 11.689 3.745E-07 3.337E-07 10.919 1.556E-07 1.648E-07 5.901 3.230E-07 3.444E-07 6.619
LU -9.901E-04 -1.061E-03 7.187 -1.535E-03 -1.655E-03 7.831 -3.319E-04 -3.175E-04 4.335 -7.226E-04 -7.968E-04 10.274
C -2.026E-04 -1.939E-04 4.295 -3.675E-04 -3.544E-04 3.568 -5.894E-05 -5.702E-05 3.261 -1.438E-04 -1.374E-04 4.451
RB -1.467E-03 -1.476E-03 0.602 -2.120E-03 -2.075E-03 2.122 -4.427E-04 -4.558E-04 2.959 -1.061E-03 -1.123E-03 5.911
RU 1.078E-06 9.972E-07 7.466 2.146E-06 1.866E-06 13.062 2.883E-07 2.672E-07 7.299 8.339E-07 9.100E-07 9.125
44
Model 11-MB4 23-MB4
Load 250 450 150 350
Responses ANSYS ANN % Error ANSYS ANN % Error ANSYS ANN % Error ANSYS ANN % Error
Hz L (N) -100640 -100821 0.180 -182490 -182535 0.024 -58594 -57519 1.835 -137330 -136552 0.566
Hz R (N) -149360 -149124 0.158 -267510 -268607 0.410 -91406 -89400 2.194 -212670 -210674 0.939
V (N) 163420 162810 0.373 293230 292447 0.267 99367 98049 1.326 231590 231613 0.010
M L (N-m) 75703 76678 1.288 138530 139091 0.405 42077 41032 2.483 98821 98036 0.795
M R (N-m) 98491 99194 0.714 179010 179778 0.429 56862 56070 1.393 133160 133232 0.054
Disp (mm) 13.249 13.459 1.586 24.421 24.434 0.054 7.124 6.913 2.952 16.832 16.632 1.187
LB (N/m2) 1938 1757 9.321 4778 5438 13.810 487 446 8.546 1166 1029 11.726
LU (N/m2) -4435134 -4587174 3.428 -6301922 -5778220 8.310 -1490799 -1690440 13.392 -3275523 -3411099 4.139
C (N/m2) -562581 -578272 2.789 -993716 -1009572 1.596 -173548 -175490 1.119 -402957 -414469 2.857
RB (N/m2) -4489361 -4800765 6.936 -6231407 -5653019 9.282 -1371119 -1329601 3.028 -4157936 -3812790 8.301
RU (N/m2) 5461 5980 9.501 10183 10634 4.430 1676 1801 7.477 3901 4268 9.406
LB 4.740E-07 4.279E-07 9.735 8.622E-07 8.048E-07 6.652 1.756E-07 1.954E-07 11.268 3.664E-07 4.162E-07 13.585
LU -1.218E-03 -1.258E-03 3.310 -1.985E-03 -1.962E-03 1.161 -3.663E-04 -3.683E-04 0.541 -8.288E-04 -9.125E-04 10.101
C -2.225E-04 -2.298E-04 3.298 -3.942E-04 -3.937E-04 0.144 -7.053E-05 -7.342E-05 4.100 -1.592E-04 -1.678E-04 5.407
RB -1.671E-03 -1.708E-03 2.187 -2.276E-03 -2.172E-03 4.592 -4.778E-04 -4.338E-04 9.191 -1.210E-03 -1.316E-03 8.815
RU 1.270E-06 1.428E-06 12.464 2.181E-06 2.320E-06 6.336 3.589E-07 3.662E-07 2.025 8.354E-07 8.799E-07 5.335
45
Model 11-MB4 23-MB4
Load 250 450 150 350
Responses ANSYS ANN % Error ANSYS ANN % Error ANSYS ANN % Error ANSYS ANN % Error
Hz L (N) -101230 -101758 0.521 -183690 -183992 0.165 -58715 -57684 1.756 -137890 -136786 0.800
Hz R (N) -148770 -148815 0.030 -266310 -267203 0.335 -91285 -88847 2.671 -211110 -210329 0.370
V (N) 162970 162562 0.250 292140 291252 0.304 99277 97952 1.335 230400 231858 0.633
M L (N-m) 76832 77282 0.585 141160 143211 1.453 42311 41680 1.492 99861 99622 0.239
M R (N-m) 99283 99877 0.598 181010 182771 0.973 57013 56395 1.084 133730 134214 0.362
Disp (mm) 13.524 13.637 0.832 25.135 25.550 1.652 7.179 7.063 1.610 17.094 16.980 0.665
LB (N/m2) 1886 1803 4.432 4986 5622 12.753 492 451 8.306 1130 1043 7.684
LU (N/m2) -4587630 -4657419 1.521 -5828512 -5683134 2.494 -1561059 -1751616 12.207 -3392969 -3492311 2.928
C (N/m2) -602243 -600434 0.300 -1065036 -1048822 1.522 -185955 -183159 1.504 -430671 -432644 0.458
RB (N/m2) -4663352 -4926436 5.642 -6328377 -5708711 9.792 -1459303 -1449315 0.684 -3821021 -3980147 4.164
RU (N/m2) 6338 6180 2.492 11861 10981 7.425 1947 1876 3.622 4522 4457 1.443
LB 4.003E-07 3.638E-07 9.117 9.378E-07 8.283E-07 11.679 1.816E-07 2.011E-07 10.738 3.768E-07 4.227E-07 12.185
LU -1.158E-03 -1.254E-03 8.329 -1.957E-03 -1.890E-03 3.422 -3.958E-04 -3.835E-04 3.101 -8.593E-04 -8.957E-04 4.242
C -2.395E-04 -2.342E-04 2.222 -4.249E-04 -3.983E-04 6.253 -7.377E-05 -7.096E-05 3.807 -1.710E-04 -1.682E-04 1.651
RB -1.741E-03 -1.734E-03 0.385 -2.367E-03 -2.180E-03 7.908 -5.372E-04 -4.830E-04 10.096 -1.278E-03 -1.339E-03 4.795
RU 1.365E-06 1.448E-06 6.097 2.556E-06 2.327E-06 8.961 3.892E-07 3.584E-07 7.930 9.738E-07 8.800E-07 9.625
46
From the above tables it can be noted that the percentage of error in prediction
of data from the ANN tool so developed is varying from maximum of 13.81% to
minimum of 0.01%. Hence ANN can be taken as a powerful tool for the prediction of
initial design parameters related to any field especially if the mass data regarding that
field is available. For the data sets given above it can be noticed that error percentage
is relatively high in stress and strain fields whereas the error percentage is almost
negligible in reaction fields (displacements, shear and vertical reaction). This is a
good sign that the parameters of interest was predicted more accurately by the tool so
developed and the variation in data predicted for stress and strain fields can be
attributed to the reason that the data taken was not uniform enough as the
recognisation of nodes at the exact place was almost impossible for all the models
prepared thus creating a more varying data for the training sets itself and hence the
prediction showing the results afterwards.
47
CHAPTER 7: CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
7.1 General
Infilled frame has been studied by various researchers; this research represents
the yet another effort to investigate the behaviour of infill walls using various
materials. The peculiarities of brick and mortar combinations along with varying
thickness being practiced traditionally are still unknown. It was therefore considered
necessary to carry out an experimental and numerical investigation in order to
describe the structural behaviour of such infilled frames.
The influence of several geometrical, material and interface parameters on this
behaviour has been investigated. In this research the behaviour of reinforced concrete
frame infilled with brick masonry units subjected to in-plane lateral loads has been
described. Simplified expressions for prediction of the stiffness and other macro
responses of these types of infilled frames have been proposed. Infill walls are already
commonly used as partitions and claddings on building structures. Accounting for
their contribution in resisting loads leads to more efficient use of materials.
Evaluating the stiffness and strength of the infills also leads to reduced risks of
damage to the infills, bounding frames and the finishes. This in turn can lead to
significant reductions in maintenance and rehabilitation costs of buildings.
48
Several modifications were proposed in the equivalent strut models. The outcomes of
this research are in reasonable agreement with the one proposed by FEMA356.
A series of two hundred full scale analyses was conducted using finite element
model to simulate each model. The finite element model was used to carry out
parametric studies. The model utilises 4-noded plane stress elements for masonry
units, 2-noded link elements for frame-to-wall contact and again 2-noded beam
element for the modelling of beam and column. A simplified approach to formulate an
equivalent strut width for the infills has been proposed in this research. With the aid
of software, reactions, deflections and other responses at several nodes on each
specimen were recorded. Load deflection responses showed that infills increased the
stiffness of frames by 2.5 times.
7.2 Conclusions
The following conclusions are drawn from this study:
Three strut models considered, two performed okay but the one fitting best
with the current FE analyses is the one proposed by FEMA; the locations for
the strut and the formula for the calculation of their strut width best represent
the scenario of an infill bounded by reinforced concrete frame.
The responses from the non-linear analysis of the infill model prepared in
ANSYS were used as training data sets. Standard Neural Network software
was used to train the network and later some data sets were used for validation
of the results predicted. The results were found to be satisfactory with error
ranging from 0.01% minimum to 13.81% maximum.
For the quick prediction of the design parameters, neural network can be
extremely useful. The network needs to be trained with data sets of similar
types though. A typical neural network was fed into 200 data sets as training
data sets for the training purpose and the network with just one hidden layer
containing 5 nodes produced accuracy as high as 99.99%. However the
accuracy on the predicted data heavily depends upon the anomalies present in
the data that is being used to train the network.
The research conducted above makes it clear that infill materials present a
very complex scenario for structural engineers when it comes to the simulation of the
real structures in computers. The material heterogeneity and complex interaction
among several infill-masonry components make it extremely difficult to idealise the
50
structure and thus the computer simulation to represent the characteristics of the infill
becomes extremely tedious and monotonic. Thus the prediction of correct initial
design parameters, if possible, can be a boon to structural engineers. These days
computers come with extra-ordinary computing capabilities and hence computing
powers of modern day computers can be used to an optimum extent to predict the
responses of the infill due to in-plane lateral load analysis. This is where the Artificial
Neural Networks can be extremely useful.
51
Variation in masonry properties
Although some variation in the properties of masonry units are considered in
the current study, a broad investigation on the influence of masonry properties
on response parameters is felt necessary as strength of a masonry wall depends
on the individual properties of brick units and mortar mix.
52
APPENDIX
53
Figure A-3 : Shear Stress contour plot
54
B. Output Result from ANSYS
Table A-1: ANSYS Results for Span 3m
Input Reactions Displacement
Thickness Load HzL HzR V ML MR (mm)
Mortar Brick
(m) (KN) (N) (N) (N) (N-m) (N-m)
0.11 1:4 MB 100 -42976 -57024 93155 31126 36911 5.88350
0.11 1:4 MB 200 -85901 -114100 185750 63191 74552 12.04600
0.11 1:4 MB 300 -128270 -171730 278220 95425 112400 18.28000
0.11 1:4 MB 400 -170410 -229590 370720 127600 150230 24.51000
0.11 1:4 MB 500 -212200 -287800 463090 159980 188260 30.82300
0.11 1:4 LB 100 -43132 -56868 92979 31447 37115 5.96880
0.11 1:4 LB 200 -86227 -113770 185420 63803 74935 12.20900
0.11 1:4 LB 300 -128860 -171140 277730 96344 112960 18.52100
0.11 1:4 LB 400 -171230 -228770 369960 129010 151110 24.88200
0.11 1:4 LB 500 -213330 -286670 462030 161930 189480 31.33900
0.11 1:6 MB 100 -43069 -56931 92936 31509 37183 5.99620
0.11 1:6 MB 200 -85691 -114310 185380 63819 75049 12.24000
0.11 1:6 MB 300 -127850 -172150 277750 96210 113030 18.53400
0.11 1:6 MB 400 -169660 -230340 370060 128700 151130 24.87400
0.11 1:6 MB 500 -211450 -288550 462320 161250 189280 31.24100
0.11 1:6 LB 100 -43221 -56779 92756 31838 37393 6.08470
0.11 1:6 LB 200 -86058 -113940 185040 64438 75429 12.40300
0.11 1:6 LB 300 -128420 -171580 277210 97216 113660 18.80100
0.11 1:6 LB 400 -170530 -229470 369260 130170 152050 25.26600
0.11 1:6 LB 500 -212670 -287330 461220 163290 190550 31.77800
0.23 1:4 MB 100 -42568 -57432 93712 30112 36251 5.60320
0.23 1:4 MB 200 -85231 -114770 187330 60393 72610 11.26100
0.23 1:4 MB 300 -127870 -172130 280400 91606 109690 17.18300
0.23 1:4 MB 400 -170160 -229840 373410 122880 146880 23.13700
0.23 1:4 MB 500 -212200 -287800 466360 154250 184170 29.13600
0.23 1:4 LB 100 -42655 -57345 93614 30292 36365 5.65120
0.23 1:4 LB 200 -85383 -114620 187150 60719 72818 11.34600
0.23 1:4 LB 300 -128120 -171880 280120 92113 110020 17.31900
0.23 1:4 LB 400 -170510 -229490 373040 123570 147310 23.32200
0.23 1:4 LB 500 -212700 -287300 465910 155080 184680 29.35300
0.23 1:6 MB 100 -42583 -57417 93664 30198 36310 5.62830
0.23 1:6 MB 200 -85304 -114700 186900 61140 73166 11.47500
0.23 1:6 MB 300 -127630 -172370 279870 92495 110400 17.45200
0.23 1:6 MB 400 -169620 -230380 372790 123910 147730 23.46600
0.23 1:6 MB 500 -211180 -288820 465670 155360 185130 29.51000
0.23 1:6 LB 100 -42669 -57331 93560 30388 36432 5.67940
0.23 1:6 LB 200 -85469 -114530 186700 61496 73392 11.57100
0.23 1:6 LB 300 -127890 -172110 279580 93020 110730 17.59300
0.23 1:6 LB 400 -169990 -230010 372410 124600 148160 23.64900
0.23 1:6 LB 500 -211750 -288250 465210 156220 185650 29.73500
55
Input Stress (N/m2)
Thickness Load
(m)
Mortar Brick
(KN) LB LU C RB RU
0.11 1:4 MB 100 1.846E+03 -1.627E+06 -2.237E+05 -1.453E+06 2.259E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 200 3.581E+03 -2.730E+06 -4.416E+05 -2.580E+06 4.450E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 300 5.371E+03 -3.791E+06 -6.595E+05 -3.648E+06 6.671E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 400 7.194E+03 -4.904E+06 -8.800E+05 -4.694E+06 8.881E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 500 9.044E+03 -5.945E+06 -1.101E+06 -5.605E+06 1.108E+04
0.11 1:4 LB 100 1.881E+03 -1.513E+06 -2.068E+05 -1.313E+06 2.089E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 200 3.654E+03 -2.551E+06 -4.087E+05 -2.352E+06 4.128E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 300 5.472E+03 -3.555E+06 -6.101E+05 -3.306E+06 6.166E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 400 7.378E+03 -4.567E+06 -7.933E+05 -4.227E+06 8.009E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 500 9.357E+03 -5.561E+06 -9.795E+05 -5.055E+06 9.901E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 100 1.688E+03 -1.524E+06 -2.354E+05 -1.502E+06 2.376E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 200 3.339E+03 -2.673E+06 -4.643E+05 -2.663E+06 4.693E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 300 5.051E+03 -3.781E+06 -6.947E+05 -3.755E+06 7.016E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 400 6.808E+03 -4.865E+06 -9.249E+05 -4.689E+06 9.346E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 500 8.594E+03 -5.978E+06 -1.155E+06 -5.600E+06 1.167E+04
0.11 1:6 LB 100 1.728E+03 -1.429E+06 -2.200E+05 -1.380E+06 2.223E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 200 3.418E+03 -2.532E+06 -4.353E+05 -2.452E+06 4.397E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 300 5.156E+03 -3.545E+06 -6.509E+05 -3.418E+06 6.570E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 400 6.982E+03 -4.571E+06 -8.470E+05 -4.280E+06 8.569E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 500 8.869E+03 -5.623E+06 -1.046E+06 -5.106E+06 1.059E+04
0.23 1:4 MB 100 9.394E+02 -8.260E+05 -1.121E+05 -7.363E+05 1.133E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 200 1.858E+03 -1.654E+06 -2.265E+05 -1.486E+06 2.288E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 300 2.729E+03 -2.228E+06 -3.369E+05 -2.022E+06 3.404E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 400 3.614E+03 -2.788E+06 -4.470E+05 -2.570E+06 4.520E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 500 4.511E+03 -3.292E+06 -5.569E+05 -3.125E+06 5.633E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 100 9.662E+02 -7.689E+05 -1.030E+05 -6.678E+05 1.039E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 200 1.916E+03 -1.565E+06 -2.116E+05 -1.354E+06 2.138E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 300 2.813E+03 -2.099E+06 -3.147E+05 -1.864E+06 3.180E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 400 3.724E+03 -2.624E+06 -4.179E+05 -2.352E+06 4.218E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 500 4.648E+03 -3.105E+06 -5.216E+05 -2.847E+06 5.271E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 100 8.812E+02 -8.857E+05 -1.219E+05 -8.163E+05 1.228E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 200 1.706E+03 -1.574E+06 -2.393E+05 -1.492E+06 2.414E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 300 2.532E+03 -2.159E+06 -3.563E+05 -2.078E+06 3.594E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 400 3.380E+03 -2.711E+06 -4.722E+05 -2.694E+06 4.766E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 500 4.247E+03 -3.265E+06 -5.891E+05 -3.252E+06 5.948E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 100 9.096E+02 -8.317E+05 -1.135E+05 -7.480E+05 1.146E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 200 1.766E+03 -1.493E+06 -2.261E+05 -1.386E+06 2.284E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 300 2.622E+03 -2.055E+06 -3.368E+05 -1.940E+06 3.402E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 400 3.499E+03 -2.582E+06 -4.474E+05 -2.495E+06 4.515E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 500 4.390E+03 -3.108E+06 -5.591E+05 -3.007E+06 5.650E+03
56
Input Strain
Thickness Load
(m)
Mortar Brick
(KN) LB LU C RB RU
0.11 1:4 MB 100 5.745E-07 -4.934E-04 -6.736E-05 -4.463E-04 1.034E-06
0.11 1:4 MB 200 1.115E-06 -8.231E-04 -1.330E-04 -7.871E-04 2.050E-06
0.11 1:4 MB 300 1.672E-06 -1.142E-03 -1.986E-04 -1.108E-03 3.055E-06
0.11 1:4 MB 400 2.240E-06 -1.477E-03 -2.650E-04 -1.423E-03 4.068E-06
0.11 1:4 MB 500 2.816E-06 -1.791E-03 -3.315E-04 -1.695E-03 5.076E-06
0.11 1:4 LB 100 7.377E-07 -5.821E-04 -7.883E-05 -5.115E-04 1.315E-06
0.11 1:4 LB 200 1.433E-06 -9.751E-04 -1.558E-04 -9.100E-04 2.610E-06
0.11 1:4 LB 300 2.146E-06 -1.358E-03 -2.326E-04 -1.274E-03 3.898E-06
0.11 1:4 LB 400 2.894E-06 -1.744E-03 -3.025E-04 -1.624E-03 5.247E-06
0.11 1:4 LB 500 3.671E-06 -2.123E-03 -3.735E-04 -1.937E-03 6.640E-06
0.11 1:6 MB 100 5.291E-07 -4.594E-04 -7.091E-05 -4.592E-04 9.844E-07
0.11 1:6 MB 200 1.047E-06 -8.050E-04 -1.399E-04 -8.086E-04 1.942E-06
0.11 1:6 MB 300 1.584E-06 -1.139E-03 -2.093E-04 -1.136E-03 2.902E-06
0.11 1:6 MB 400 2.134E-06 -1.465E-03 -2.786E-04 -1.416E-03 3.866E-06
0.11 1:6 MB 500 2.694E-06 -1.801E-03 -3.478E-04 -1.688E-03 4.844E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 100 6.824E-07 -5.462E-04 -8.388E-05 -5.347E-04 1.251E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 200 1.350E-06 -9.658E-04 -1.659E-04 -9.436E-04 2.474E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 300 2.036E-06 -1.352E-03 -2.481E-04 -1.310E-03 3.697E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 400 2.757E-06 -1.743E-03 -3.229E-04 -1.636E-03 4.973E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 500 3.503E-06 -2.144E-03 -3.988E-04 -1.949E-03 6.298E-06
0.23 1:4 MB 100 2.924E-07 -2.505E-04 -3.377E-05 -2.263E-04 5.251E-07
0.23 1:4 MB 200 5.785E-07 -5.017E-04 -6.822E-05 -4.567E-04 1.051E-06
0.23 1:4 MB 300 8.497E-07 -6.727E-04 -1.015E-04 -6.188E-04 1.568E-06
0.23 1:4 MB 400 1.125E-06 -8.406E-04 -1.346E-04 -7.841E-04 2.079E-06
0.23 1:4 MB 500 1.404E-06 -9.922E-04 -1.677E-04 -9.521E-04 2.589E-06
0.23 1:4 LB 100 3.789E-07 -2.958E-04 -3.927E-05 -2.603E-04 6.746E-07
0.23 1:4 LB 200 7.517E-07 -6.027E-04 -8.069E-05 -5.278E-04 1.350E-06
0.23 1:4 LB 300 1.103E-06 -8.035E-04 -1.200E-04 -7.237E-04 2.015E-06
0.23 1:4 LB 400 1.461E-06 -1.003E-03 -1.593E-04 -9.101E-04 2.674E-06
0.23 1:4 LB 500 1.823E-06 -1.186E-03 -1.989E-04 -1.100E-03 3.333E-06
0.23 1:6 MB 100 2.762E-07 -2.678E-04 -3.674E-05 -2.503E-04 5.031E-07
0.23 1:6 MB 200 5.347E-07 -4.744E-04 -7.208E-05 -4.558E-04 1.003E-06
0.23 1:6 MB 300 7.938E-07 -6.502E-04 -1.073E-04 -6.325E-04 1.492E-06
0.23 1:6 MB 400 1.060E-06 -8.165E-04 -1.422E-04 -8.183E-04 1.979E-06
0.23 1:6 MB 500 1.332E-06 -9.833E-04 -1.774E-04 -9.855E-04 2.467E-06
0.23 1:6 LB 100 3.591E-07 -3.189E-04 -4.325E-05 -2.907E-04 6.464E-07
0.23 1:6 LB 200 6.972E-07 -5.703E-04 -8.619E-05 -5.367E-04 1.289E-06
0.23 1:6 LB 300 1.035E-06 -7.838E-04 -1.284E-04 -7.482E-04 1.918E-06
0.23 1:6 LB 400 1.382E-06 -9.846E-04 -1.706E-04 -9.599E-04 2.548E-06
0.23 1:6 LB 500 1.734E-06 -1.185E-03 -2.131E-04 -1.154E-03 3.178E-06
57
Table A-1: ANSYS Results for Span 3.5m
Input Reactions
Displacement
Thickness Load HzL HzR V ML MR (mm)
Mortar Brick
(m) (KN) (N) (N) (N) (N-m) (N-m)
0.11 1:4 MB 100 -41315 -58685 79952 30142 37526 5.425
0.11 1:4 MB 200 -83003 -117000 159550 60994 75564 11.055
0.11 1:4 MB 300 -124450 -175550 238960 92222 113930 16.785
0.11 1:4 MB 400 -165500 -234500 318280 123580 152440 22.571
0.11 1:4 MB 500 -206370 -293630 397540 155060 191050 28.404
0.11 1:4 LB 100 -41508 -58492 79753 30565 37801 5.534
0.11 1:4 LB 200 -83383 -116620 159170 61813 76091 11.267
0.11 1:4 LB 300 -125090 -174910 238350 93513 114760 17.118
0.11 1:4 LB 400 -166590 -233410 317380 125490 153670 23.061
0.11 1:4 LB 500 -207910 -292090 396290 157720 192760 29.083
0.11 1:6 MB 100 -41463 -58537 79812 30438 37721 5.507
0.11 1:6 MB 200 -83077 -116920 159180 61750 76121 11.257
0.11 1:6 MB 300 -124280 -175720 238450 93233 114690 17.072
0.11 1:6 MB 400 -165080 -234920 317620 124900 153440 22.960
0.11 1:6 MB 500 -206120 -293880 396590 156960 192480 28.948
0.11 1:6 LB 100 -41657 -58343 79606 30875 38004 5.620
0.11 1:6 LB 200 -83495 -116500 158780 62613 76673 11.478
0.11 1:6 LB 300 -124990 -175010 237800 94610 115580 17.425
0.11 1:6 LB 400 -166270 -233730 316670 126930 154740 23.476
0.11 1:6 LB 500 -207630 -292370 395270 159790 194270 29.664
0.23 1:4 MB 100 -40721 -59279 80528 28917 36733 5.110
0.23 1:4 MB 200 -81494 -118510 161040 57869 73491 10.230
0.23 1:4 MB 300 -122610 -177390 241300 87342 110600 15.518
0.23 1:4 MB 400 -163830 -236170 321250 117410 148200 20.935
0.23 1:4 MB 500 -204740 -295260 401200 147480 185820 26.365
0.23 1:4 LB 100 -40824 -59176 80421 29146 36881 5.169
0.23 1:4 LB 200 -81704 -118300 160830 58322 73785 10.347
0.23 1:4 LB 300 -122910 -177090 240980 88014 111040 15.691
0.23 1:4 LB 400 -164230 -235770 320830 118310 148780 21.168
0.23 1:4 LB 500 -205290 -294710 400670 148610 186550 26.656
0.23 1:6 MB 100 -40774 -59226 80481 29019 36799 5.135
0.23 1:6 MB 200 -81757 -118240 160820 58333 73798 10.367
0.23 1:6 MB 300 -123050 -176950 240760 88426 111400 15.798
0.23 1:6 MB 400 -163860 -236140 320640 118630 149130 21.266
0.23 1:6 MB 500 -204420 -295580 400470 148910 186950 26.778
0.23 1:6 LB 100 -40882 -59118 80366 29263 36956 5.198
0.23 1:6 LB 200 -81967 -118030 160600 58808 74105 10.489
0.23 1:6 LB 300 -123370 -176630 240440 89123 111840 15.977
0.23 1:6 LB 400 -164310 -235690 320200 119580 149730 21.509
0.23 1:6 LB 500 -205050 -294950 399910 150110 187710 27.084
58
Input Stress (N/m2)
Thickness Load
(m)
Mortar Brick
(KN) LB LU C RB RU
0.11 1:4 MB 100 4.411E+02 -1.203E+06 -2.302E+05 -1.323E+06 2.324E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 200 1.135E+03 -2.306E+06 -4.574E+05 -2.655E+06 4.617E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 300 1.695E+03 -3.406E+06 -6.834E+05 -4.036E+06 6.903E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 400 2.265E+03 -4.549E+06 -9.102E+05 -5.430E+06 9.193E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 500 2.840E+03 -5.884E+06 -1.138E+06 -6.664E+06 1.149E+04
0.11 1:4 LB 100 4.224E+02 -1.125E+06 -2.161E+05 -1.242E+06 2.184E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 200 8.158E+02 -2.173E+06 -4.296E+05 -2.497E+06 4.337E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 300 1.212E+03 -3.183E+06 -6.415E+05 -3.764E+06 6.480E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 400 1.624E+03 -4.253E+06 -8.355E+05 -5.081E+06 8.438E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 500 2.045E+03 -5.513E+06 -1.032E+06 -6.244E+06 1.042E+04
0.11 1:6 MB 100 5.084E+02 -1.258E+06 -2.392E+05 -1.377E+06 2.422E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 200 1.161E+03 -2.383E+06 -4.731E+05 -2.634E+06 4.779E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 300 1.750E+03 -3.560E+06 -7.069E+05 -4.137E+06 7.140E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 400 2.352E+03 -4.922E+06 -9.392E+05 -5.362E+06 9.487E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 500 2.952E+03 -6.119E+06 -1.169E+06 -6.056E+06 1.181E+04
0.11 1:6 LB 100 4.378E+02 -1.181E+06 -2.263E+05 -1.308E+06 2.294E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 200 8.615E+02 -2.246E+06 -4.486E+05 -2.505E+06 4.535E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 300 1.295E+03 -3.328E+06 -6.707E+05 -3.886E+06 6.783E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 400 1.748E+03 -4.609E+06 -8.730E+05 -5.092E+06 8.825E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 500 2.202E+03 -5.904E+06 -1.077E+06 -5.823E+06 1.088E+04
0.23 1:4 MB 100 2.229E+02 -6.076E+05 -1.164E+05 -6.674E+05 1.171E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 200 4.451E+02 -1.220E+06 -2.329E+05 -1.345E+06 2.349E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 300 8.674E+02 -1.779E+06 -3.482E+05 -2.067E+06 3.514E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 400 1.145E+03 -2.321E+06 -4.626E+05 -2.743E+06 4.673E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 500 1.426E+03 -2.873E+06 -5.766E+05 -3.514E+06 5.826E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 100 2.154E+02 -5.726E+05 -1.106E+05 -6.306E+05 1.118E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 200 4.301E+02 -1.150E+06 -2.209E+05 -1.275E+06 2.231E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 300 6.302E+02 -1.689E+06 -3.304E+05 -1.963E+06 3.338E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 400 8.290E+02 -2.205E+06 -4.390E+05 -2.603E+06 4.437E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 500 1.031E+03 -2.721E+06 -5.481E+05 -3.320E+06 5.536E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 100 2.605E+02 -6.459E+05 -1.218E+05 -6.991E+05 1.229E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 200 5.154E+02 -1.272E+06 -2.429E+05 -1.411E+06 2.453E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 300 8.831E+02 -1.835E+06 -3.626E+05 -2.111E+06 3.664E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 400 1.176E+03 -2.410E+06 -4.804E+05 -2.882E+06 4.850E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 500 1.475E+03 -2.982E+06 -5.990E+05 -3.650E+06 6.065E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 100 2.270E+02 -6.102E+05 -1.166E+05 -6.687E+05 1.179E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 200 4.478E+02 -1.207E+06 -2.323E+05 -1.354E+06 2.348E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 300 6.625E+02 -1.750E+06 -3.469E+05 -2.026E+06 3.503E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 400 8.820E+02 -2.291E+06 -4.606E+05 -2.740E+06 4.650E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 500 1.105E+03 -2.824E+06 -5.752E+05 -3.468E+06 5.809E+03
59
Input Strain
Thickness Load
(m)
Mortar Brick
(KN) LB LU C RB RU
0.11 1:4 MB 100 1.336E-07 -3.660E-04 -6.992E-05 -4.024E-04 6.319E-07
0.11 1:4 MB 200 3.422E-07 -6.985E-04 -1.389E-04 -8.096E-04 1.262E-06
0.11 1:4 MB 300 5.110E-07 -1.031E-03 -2.076E-04 -1.224E-03 1.890E-06
0.11 1:4 MB 400 6.829E-07 -1.375E-03 -2.766E-04 -1.641E-03 2.518E-06
0.11 1:4 MB 500 8.562E-07 -1.778E-03 -3.458E-04 -2.011E-03 3.147E-06
0.11 1:4 LB 100 1.612E-07 -4.320E-04 -8.286E-05 -4.779E-04 8.237E-07
0.11 1:4 LB 200 3.111E-07 -8.317E-04 -1.647E-04 -9.632E-04 1.646E-06
0.11 1:4 LB 300 4.622E-07 -1.217E-03 -2.461E-04 -1.443E-03 2.461E-06
0.11 1:4 LB 400 6.191E-07 -1.625E-03 -3.206E-04 -1.943E-03 3.304E-06
0.11 1:4 LB 500 7.797E-07 -2.106E-03 -3.961E-04 -2.384E-03 4.169E-06
0.11 1:6 MB 100 1.592E-07 -3.828E-04 -7.289E-05 -4.188E-04 6.454E-07
0.11 1:6 MB 200 3.540E-07 -7.226E-04 -1.442E-04 -8.000E-04 1.287E-06
0.11 1:6 MB 300 5.338E-07 -1.078E-03 -2.155E-04 -1.251E-03 1.934E-06
0.11 1:6 MB 400 7.173E-07 -1.489E-03 -2.864E-04 -1.618E-03 2.584E-06
0.11 1:6 MB 500 9.008E-07 -1.854E-03 -3.567E-04 -1.825E-03 3.244E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 100 1.694E-07 -4.541E-04 -8.709E-05 -5.034E-04 8.198E-07
0.11 1:6 LB 200 3.341E-07 -8.604E-04 -1.727E-04 -9.626E-04 1.632E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 300 5.027E-07 -1.274E-03 -2.584E-04 -1.486E-03 2.445E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 400 6.795E-07 -1.762E-03 -3.365E-04 -1.944E-03 3.288E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 500 8.584E-07 -2.261E-03 -4.152E-04 -2.222E-03 4.163E-06
0.23 1:4 MB 100 6.752E-08 -1.849E-04 -3.536E-05 -2.030E-04 3.198E-07
0.23 1:4 MB 200 1.349E-07 -3.711E-04 -7.073E-05 -4.091E-04 6.401E-07
0.23 1:4 MB 300 2.615E-07 -5.398E-04 -1.057E-04 -6.297E-04 9.602E-07
0.23 1:4 MB 400 3.450E-07 -7.035E-04 -1.404E-04 -8.356E-04 1.278E-06
0.23 1:4 MB 500 4.300E-07 -8.702E-04 -1.751E-04 -1.067E-03 1.596E-06
0.23 1:4 LB 100 8.220E-08 -2.201E-04 -4.241E-05 -2.427E-04 4.212E-07
0.23 1:4 LB 200 1.641E-07 -4.420E-04 -8.471E-05 -4.906E-04 8.433E-07
0.23 1:4 LB 300 2.404E-07 -6.477E-04 -1.267E-04 -7.562E-04 1.266E-06
0.23 1:4 LB 400 3.161E-07 -8.441E-04 -1.683E-04 -1.004E-03 1.684E-06
0.23 1:4 LB 500 3.930E-07 -1.041E-03 -2.102E-04 -1.274E-03 2.102E-06
0.23 1:6 MB 100 8.139E-08 -1.971E-04 -3.712E-05 -2.127E-04 3.278E-07
0.23 1:6 MB 200 1.615E-07 -3.872E-04 -7.400E-05 -4.293E-04 6.563E-07
0.23 1:6 MB 300 2.693E-07 -5.573E-04 -1.104E-04 -6.434E-04 9.820E-07
0.23 1:6 MB 400 3.588E-07 -7.309E-04 -1.464E-04 -8.752E-04 1.309E-06
0.23 1:6 MB 500 4.499E-07 -9.042E-04 -1.826E-04 -1.105E-03 1.636E-06
0.23 1:6 LB 100 8.771E-08 -2.352E-04 -4.487E-05 -2.574E-04 4.207E-07
0.23 1:6 LB 200 1.734E-07 -4.641E-04 -8.939E-05 -5.215E-04 8.431E-07
0.23 1:6 LB 300 2.569E-07 -6.716E-04 -1.334E-04 -7.811E-04 1.261E-06
0.23 1:6 LB 400 3.423E-07 -8.782E-04 -1.773E-04 -1.052E-03 1.679E-06
0.23 1:6 LB 500 4.288E-07 -1.082E-03 -2.215E-04 -1.328E-03 2.096E-06
60
Table A-1: ANSYS Results for Span 4m
Input Reactions
Displacement
Thickness Load HzL HzR V ML MR (mm)
Mortar Brick
(m) (KN) (N) (N) (N) (N-m) (N-m)
0.11 1:4 MB 100 -40118 -59882 69917 29529 38302 5.147
0.11 1:4 MB 200 -80713 -119290 139610 59584 76987 10.500
0.11 1:4 MB 300 -122000 -178000 209000 90150 116000 15.900
0.11 1:4 MB 400 -162000 -238000 278000 121000 155000 21.400
0.11 1:4 MB 500 -203000 -297000 348000 152000 195000 26.900
0.11 1:4 LB 100 -40347 -59653 69710 30032 38628 5.271
0.11 1:4 LB 200 -81158 -118840 139200 60575 77627 10.694
0.11 1:4 LB 300 -122330 -177670 208410 91755 117120 16.262
0.11 1:4 LB 400 -163400 -236600 277440 123330 156920 21.943
0.11 1:4 LB 500 -204400 -295600 346340 155210 196940 27.708
0.11 1:6 MB 100 -40302 -59698 69794 29826 38500 5.226
0.11 1:6 MB 200 -81179 -118820 139250 60428 77585 10.656
0.11 1:6 MB 300 -121850 -178150 208550 91358 116960 16.181
0.11 1:6 MB 400 -162170 -237830 277670 122660 156650 21.819
0.11 1:6 MB 500 -199080 -300920 345420 156670 199130 28.474
0.11 1:6 LB 100 -40535 -59465 69576 30355 38842 5.355
0.11 1:6 LB 200 -81636 -118360 138810 61484 78264 10.915
0.11 1:6 LB 300 -122660 -177340 207840 93068 118060 16.599
0.11 1:6 LB 400 -163510 -236490 276680 125080 158180 22.403
0.11 1:6 LB 500 -201030 -298970 344350 159450 200650 29.049
0.23 1:4 MB 100 -39422 -60578 70519 28067 37355 4.789
0.23 1:4 MB 200 -78888 -121110 141030 56140 74720 9.580
0.23 1:4 MB 300 -118680 -181320 211380 84611 112360 14.501
0.23 1:4 MB 400 -158910 -241090 281530 113540 150340 19.523
0.23 1:4 MB 500 -199220 -300780 351570 142700 188520 24.591
0.23 1:4 LB 100 -39547 -60453 70408 28338 37531 4.856
0.23 1:4 LB 200 -79106 -120890 140810 56687 75070 9.714
0.23 1:4 LB 300 -119050 -180950 211050 85424 112880 14.699
0.23 1:4 LB 400 -159450 -240550 281060 114670 151080 19.801
0.23 1:4 LB 500 -199890 -300110 350990 144100 189430 24.935
0.23 1:6 MB 100 -39486 -60514 70470 28187 37434 4.818
0.23 1:6 MB 200 -79180 -120820 140850 56584 75014 9.705
0.23 1:6 MB 300 -119410 -180590 210970 85569 113040 14.747
0.23 1:6 MB 400 -159750 -240250 280950 114880 151320 19.851
0.23 1:6 MB 500 -199830 -300170 350860 144320 189740 25.008
0.23 1:6 LB 100 -39620 -60380 70349 28480 37623 4.890
0.23 1:6 LB 200 -79442 -120560 140610 57161 75387 9.845
0.23 1:6 LB 300 -119780 -180220 210630 86408 113570 14.955
0.23 1:6 LB 400 -160280 -239720 280460 116060 152090 20.141
0.23 1:6 LB 500 -200550 -299450 350230 145850 190730 25.382
61
Input Stress (N/m2)
Thickness Load
(m)
Mortar Brick
(KN) LB LU C RB RU
0.11 1:4 MB 100 3.331E+02 -1.732E+06 -2.428E+05 -1.531E+06 2.452E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 200 6.311E+02 -3.306E+06 -4.836E+05 -3.367E+06 4.885E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 300 9.259E+02 -4.779E+06 -7.203E+05 -5.676E+06 7.276E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 400 1.227E+03 -6.377E+06 -9.584E+05 -7.503E+06 9.678E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 500 1.525E+03 -7.956E+06 -1.191E+06 -8.529E+06 1.203E+04
0.11 1:4 LB 100 4.111E+02 -1.601E+06 -2.327E+05 -1.425E+06 2.351E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 200 7.862E+02 -3.060E+06 -4.635E+05 -3.115E+06 4.684E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 300 1.147E+03 -4.488E+06 -6.929E+05 -5.120E+06 6.999E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 400 1.514E+03 -6.022E+06 -9.040E+05 -6.855E+06 9.130E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 500 1.883E+03 -7.457E+06 -1.118E+06 -8.117E+06 1.129E+04
0.11 1:6 MB 100 2.131E+02 -1.787E+06 -2.430E+05 -1.649E+06 2.454E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 200 3.972E+02 -3.314E+06 -4.812E+05 -3.789E+06 4.864E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 300 5.928E+02 -4.711E+06 -7.162E+05 -5.590E+06 7.233E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 400 7.954E+02 -6.018E+06 -9.489E+05 -6.035E+06 9.584E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 500 1.243E+03 -5.864E+06 -1.167E+06 -6.335E+06 1.179E+04
0.11 1:6 LB 100 2.850E+02 -1.684E+06 -2.364E+05 -1.544E+06 2.388E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 200 5.384E+02 -3.113E+06 -4.685E+05 -3.448E+06 4.731E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 300 7.906E+02 -4.607E+06 -6.993E+05 -5.213E+06 7.063E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 400 1.039E+03 -6.036E+06 -9.124E+05 -6.181E+06 9.214E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 500 1.485E+03 -5.787E+06 -1.117E+06 -6.356E+06 1.129E+04
0.23 1:4 MB 100 1.681E+02 -8.693E+05 -1.234E+05 -7.642E+05 1.252E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 200 3.363E+02 -1.764E+06 -2.457E+05 -1.559E+06 2.485E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 300 4.866E+02 -2.615E+06 -3.673E+05 -2.450E+06 3.713E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 400 6.320E+02 -3.412E+06 -4.887E+05 -3.855E+06 4.934E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 500 7.786E+02 -4.130E+06 -6.085E+05 -5.264E+06 6.134E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 100 2.095E+02 -8.071E+05 -1.212E+05 -7.183E+05 1.208E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 200 4.186E+02 -1.645E+06 -2.378E+05 -1.461E+06 2.398E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 300 6.102E+02 -2.443E+06 -3.558E+05 -2.295E+06 3.591E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 400 7.941E+02 -3.174E+06 -4.735E+05 -3.505E+06 4.781E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 500 9.782E+02 -3.884E+06 -5.904E+05 -4.820E+06 5.956E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 100 1.114E+02 -9.367E+05 -1.218E+05 -8.174E+05 1.232E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 200 2.136E+02 -1.839E+06 -2.467E+05 -1.694E+06 2.493E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 300 3.046E+02 -2.632E+06 -3.687E+05 -2.836E+06 3.721E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 400 3.972E+02 -3.381E+06 -4.887E+05 -4.331E+06 4.935E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 500 4.945E+02 -4.063E+06 -6.084E+05 -5.219E+06 6.146E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 100 1.489E+02 -8.805E+05 -1.215E+05 -7.728E+05 1.230E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 200 2.891E+02 -1.753E+06 -2.426E+05 -1.603E+06 2.450E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 300 4.169E+02 -2.499E+06 -3.627E+05 -2.619E+06 3.662E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 400 5.449E+02 -3.204E+06 -4.810E+05 -4.022E+06 4.854E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 500 6.748E+02 -3.857E+06 -5.998E+05 -4.934E+06 6.055E+03
62
Input Strain
Thickness Load
(m)
Mortar Brick
(KN) LB LU C RB RU
0.11 1:4 MB 100 1.003E-07 -5.223E-04 -7.558E-05 -4.618E-04 1.381E-07
0.11 1:4 MB 200 1.902E-07 -1.000E-03 -1.509E-04 -1.017E-03 2.778E-07
0.11 1:4 MB 300 2.786E-07 -1.454E-03 -2.242E-04 -1.709E-03 4.162E-07
0.11 1:4 MB 400 3.699E-07 -1.947E-03 -2.984E-04 -2.261E-03 5.507E-07
0.11 1:4 MB 500 4.590E-07 -2.445E-03 -3.726E-04 -2.575E-03 6.822E-07
0.11 1:4 LB 100 1.567E-07 -6.112E-04 -9.177E-05 -5.441E-04 1.541E-07
0.11 1:4 LB 200 2.997E-07 -1.173E-03 -1.829E-04 -1.191E-03 3.091E-07
0.11 1:4 LB 300 4.374E-07 -1.729E-03 -2.735E-04 -1.954E-03 4.608E-07
0.11 1:4 LB 400 5.771E-07 -2.335E-03 -3.573E-04 -2.618E-03 6.104E-07
0.11 1:4 LB 500 7.178E-07 -2.909E-03 -4.420E-04 -3.102E-03 7.590E-07
0.11 1:6 MB 100 6.421E-08 -5.386E-04 -7.555E-05 -4.982E-04 1.612E-07
0.11 1:6 MB 200 1.197E-07 -1.006E-03 -1.497E-04 -1.142E-03 3.233E-07
0.11 1:6 MB 300 1.786E-07 -1.434E-03 -2.228E-04 -1.685E-03 4.820E-07
0.11 1:6 MB 400 2.396E-07 -1.839E-03 -2.952E-04 -1.818E-03 6.353E-07
0.11 1:6 MB 500 3.746E-07 -1.786E-03 -3.624E-04 -1.908E-03 6.819E-07
0.11 1:6 LB 100 1.087E-07 -6.429E-04 -9.315E-05 -5.902E-04 1.781E-07
0.11 1:6 LB 200 2.052E-07 -1.196E-03 -1.847E-04 -1.316E-03 3.564E-07
0.11 1:6 LB 300 3.014E-07 -1.783E-03 -2.758E-04 -1.989E-03 5.286E-07
0.11 1:6 LB 400 3.960E-07 -2.355E-03 -3.603E-04 -2.360E-03 6.994E-07
0.11 1:6 LB 500 5.660E-07 -2.236E-03 -4.407E-04 -2.423E-03 7.726E-07
0.23 1:4 MB 100 5.064E-08 -2.621E-04 -3.845E-05 -2.304E-04 6.969E-08
0.23 1:4 MB 200 1.013E-07 -5.319E-04 -7.648E-05 -4.703E-04 1.395E-07
0.23 1:4 MB 300 1.466E-07 -7.891E-04 -1.143E-04 -7.403E-04 2.103E-07
0.23 1:4 MB 400 1.903E-07 -1.033E-03 -1.521E-04 -1.164E-03 2.810E-07
0.23 1:4 MB 500 2.345E-07 -1.254E-03 -1.895E-04 -1.587E-03 3.515E-07
0.23 1:4 LB 100 7.987E-08 -3.082E-04 -4.787E-05 -2.741E-04 7.856E-08
0.23 1:4 LB 200 1.596E-07 -6.279E-04 -9.375E-05 -5.577E-04 1.571E-07
0.23 1:4 LB 300 2.326E-07 -9.334E-04 -1.403E-04 -8.774E-04 2.369E-07
0.23 1:4 LB 400 3.027E-07 -1.217E-03 -1.868E-04 -1.339E-03 3.163E-07
0.23 1:4 LB 500 3.729E-07 -1.493E-03 -2.329E-04 -1.840E-03 3.948E-07
0.23 1:6 MB 100 3.356E-08 -2.824E-04 -3.782E-05 -2.467E-04 8.141E-08
0.23 1:6 MB 200 6.436E-08 -5.544E-04 -7.668E-05 -5.119E-04 1.637E-07
0.23 1:6 MB 300 9.178E-08 -7.972E-04 -1.146E-04 -8.558E-04 2.462E-07
0.23 1:6 MB 400 1.197E-07 -1.027E-03 -1.520E-04 -1.305E-03 3.287E-07
0.23 1:6 MB 500 1.490E-07 -1.236E-03 -1.893E-04 -1.573E-03 4.097E-07
0.23 1:6 LB 100 5.678E-08 -3.361E-04 -4.787E-05 -2.951E-04 9.092E-08
0.23 1:6 LB 200 1.102E-07 -6.690E-04 -9.557E-05 -6.127E-04 1.828E-07
0.23 1:6 LB 300 1.589E-07 -9.583E-04 -1.429E-04 -1.001E-03 2.747E-07
0.23 1:6 LB 400 2.077E-07 -1.232E-03 -1.896E-04 -1.535E-03 3.665E-07
0.23 1:6 LB 500 2.572E-07 -1.485E-03 -2.365E-04 -1.883E-03 4.556E-07
63
Table A-1: ANSYS Results for Span 4.5m
Input Reactions
Displacement
Thickness Load HzL HzR V ML MR (mm)
Mortar Brick
(m) (KN) (N) (N) (N) (N-m) (N-m)
0.11 1:4 MB 100 -39266 -60734 62023 29192 39202 4.992
0.11 1:4 MB 200 -78893 -121110 123880 58808 78722 10.111
0.11 1:4 MB 300 -119070 -180930 185480 89090 118770 15.378
0.11 1:4 MB 400 -159320 -240680 247000 119530 158960 20.693
0.11 1:4 MB 500 -199570 -300430 308420 150250 199380 26.086
0.11 1:4 LB 100 -39524 -60476 61811 29771 39577 5.130
0.11 1:4 LB 200 -79426 -120570 123450 59984 79485 10.389
0.11 1:4 LB 300 -119920 -180080 184790 90948 119980 15.819
0.11 1:4 LB 400 -160620 -239380 245990 122300 160760 21.347
0.11 1:4 LB 500 -201480 -298520 307000 154100 201880 26.993
0.11 1:6 MB 100 -39433 -60567 61908 29505 39409 5.070
0.11 1:6 MB 200 -79483 -120520 123530 59741 79386 10.331
0.11 1:6 MB 300 -119780 -180220 184990 90364 119690 15.690
0.11 1:6 MB 400 -160170 -239830 246310 121330 160300 21.158
0.11 1:6 MB 500 -205210 -294790 306200 155390 204200 27.917
0.11 1:6 LB 100 -39697 -60303 61683 30120 39805 5.215
0.11 1:6 LB 200 -80011 -119990 123070 60988 80189 10.627
0.11 1:6 LB 300 -120700 -179300 184250 92394 121000 16.170
0.11 1:6 LB 400 -161550 -238450 245200 124350 162240 21.862
0.11 1:6 LB 500 -206340 -293660 305020 158810 206080 28.566
0.23 1:4 MB 100 -38487 -61513 62642 27504 38110 4.593
0.23 1:4 MB 200 -76982 -123020 125280 55015 76225 9.188
0.23 1:4 MB 300 -115730 -184270 187810 82815 114550 13.878
0.23 1:4 MB 400 -154960 -245040 250150 111090 153250 18.686
0.23 1:4 MB 500 -197742 -302257 309158 139892 191614 23.689
0.23 1:4 LB 100 -38630 -61370 62527 27816 38312 4.667
0.23 1:4 LB 200 -77275 -122730 125050 55645 76633 9.338
0.23 1:4 LB 300 -116190 -183810 187450 83784 115180 14.109
0.23 1:4 LB 400 -155570 -244430 249670 112380 154090 18.992
0.23 1:4 LB 500 -195200 -304800 311770 141280 193240 23.927
0.23 1:6 MB 100 -38559 -61441 62591 27642 38199 4.625
0.23 1:6 MB 200 -77258 -122740 125120 55450 76520 9.305
0.23 1:6 MB 300 -116510 -183490 187420 83819 115280 14.131
0.23 1:6 MB 400 -139186 -260813 266527 119077 163891 20.069
0.23 1:6 MB 500 -195620 -304380 311700 141370 193470 23.962
0.23 1:6 LB 100 -38713 -61287 62466 27982 38419 4.706
0.23 1:6 LB 200 -77563 -122440 124870 56130 76959 9.465
0.23 1:6 LB 300 -116980 -183020 187040 84855 115950 14.376
0.23 1:6 LB 400 -156660 -243340 249080 113920 155210 19.355
0.23 1:6 LB 500 -199225.1 -300774 307676 139491 190884 23.639
64
Input Stress (N/m2)
Thickness Load
(m)
Mortar Brick
(KN) LB LU C RB RU
0.11 1:4 MB 100 3.025E+03 -1.271E+06 -2.533E+05 -1.079E+06 2.552E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 200 6.100E+03 -2.480E+06 -5.056E+05 -2.175E+06 5.107E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 300 9.216E+03 -3.614E+06 -7.556E+05 -3.342E+06 7.632E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 400 1.238E+04 -4.705E+06 -1.006E+06 -4.592E+06 1.016E+04
0.11 1:4 MB 500 1.561E+04 -5.787E+06 -1.256E+06 -5.947E+06 1.269E+04
0.11 1:4 LB 100 2.894E+03 -1.195E+06 -2.423E+05 -1.018E+06 2.447E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 200 5.849E+03 -2.332E+06 -4.839E+05 -2.061E+06 4.886E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 300 8.894E+03 -3.396E+06 -7.254E+05 -3.122E+06 7.323E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 400 1.213E+04 -4.439E+06 -9.515E+05 -4.260E+06 9.608E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 500 1.554E+04 -5.503E+06 -1.179E+06 -5.529E+06 1.190E+04
0.11 1:6 MB 100 3.066E+03 -1.303E+06 -2.545E+05 -1.118E+06 2.578E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 200 6.185E+03 -2.484E+06 -5.060E+05 -2.273E+06 5.117E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 300 9.365E+03 -3.589E+06 -7.543E+05 -3.549E+06 7.619E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 400 1.260E+04 -4.587E+06 -1.001E+06 -4.854E+06 1.011E+04
0.11 1:6 MB 500 1.587E+04 -4.457E+06 -1.229E+06 -5.914E+06 1.241E+04
0.11 1:6 LB 100 2.959E+03 -1.242E+06 -2.470E+05 -1.066E+06 2.499E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 200 5.985E+03 -2.366E+06 -4.913E+05 -2.168E+06 4.966E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 300 9.114E+03 -3.413E+06 -7.351E+05 -3.324E+06 7.422E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 400 1.244E+04 -4.404E+06 -9.641E+05 -4.619E+06 9.736E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 500 1.580E+04 -4.385E+06 -1.180E+06 -5.714E+06 1.192E+04
0.23 1:4 MB 100 1.535E+03 -6.443E+05 -1.290E+05 -5.503E+05 1.304E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 200 3.070E+03 -1.294E+06 -2.566E+05 -1.088E+06 2.588E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 300 4.625E+03 -1.918E+06 -3.844E+05 -1.638E+06 3.883E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 400 6.195E+03 -2.506E+06 -5.121E+05 -2.199E+06 5.187E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 500 7.799E+03 -3.043E+06 -6.338E+05 -2.877E+06 6.402E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 100 1.483E+03 -6.106E+05 -1.263E+05 -5.171E+05 1.274E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 200 2.968E+03 -1.231E+06 -2.479E+05 -1.037E+06 2.505E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 300 4.478E+03 -1.829E+06 -3.716E+05 -1.568E+06 3.753E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 400 6.007E+03 -2.379E+06 -4.953E+05 -2.103E+06 5.002E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 500 7.561E+03 -2.939E+06 -6.188E+05 -2.658E+06 6.248E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 100 1.558E+03 -6.712E+05 -1.277E+05 -5.742E+05 1.304E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 200 3.126E+03 -1.325E+06 -2.588E+05 -1.131E+06 2.607E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 300 4.709E+03 -1.931E+06 -3.875E+05 -1.715E+06 3.912E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 400 6.604E+03 -2.637E+06 -5.434E+05 -2.372E+06 5.486E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 500 7.926E+03 -3.087E+06 -6.416E+05 -2.999E+06 6.484E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 100 1.521E+03 -6.430E+05 -1.271E+05 -5.433E+05 1.288E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 200 3.053E+03 -1.277E+06 -2.539E+05 -1.090E+06 2.574E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 300 4.605E+03 -1.864E+06 -3.803E+05 -1.658E+06 3.842E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 400 6.180E+03 -2.426E+06 -5.054E+05 -2.245E+06 5.105E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 500 7.691E+03 -2.985E+06 -6.265E+05 -2.762E+06 6.331E+03
65
Input Strain
Thickness Load
(m)
Mortar Brick
(KN) LB LU C RB RU
0.11 1:4 MB 100 9.112E-07 -3.993E-04 -8.054E-05 -3.308E-04 8.153E-07
0.11 1:4 MB 200 1.837E-06 -7.766E-04 -1.608E-04 -6.661E-04 1.629E-06
0.11 1:4 MB 300 2.776E-06 -1.129E-03 -2.404E-04 -1.020E-03 2.454E-06
0.11 1:4 MB 400 3.729E-06 -1.468E-03 -3.203E-04 -1.398E-03 3.284E-06
0.11 1:4 MB 500 4.702E-06 -1.807E-03 -4.002E-04 -1.809E-03 4.119E-06
0.11 1:4 LB 100 1.103E-06 -4.750E-04 -9.751E-05 -3.950E-04 9.964E-07
0.11 1:4 LB 200 2.230E-06 -9.239E-04 -1.948E-04 -7.989E-04 1.992E-06
0.11 1:4 LB 300 3.391E-06 -1.343E-03 -2.924E-04 -1.208E-03 3.001E-06
0.11 1:4 LB 400 4.624E-06 -1.754E-03 -3.841E-04 -1.645E-03 4.049E-06
0.11 1:4 LB 500 5.925E-06 -2.176E-03 -4.764E-04 -2.135E-03 5.137E-06
0.11 1:6 MB 100 9.234E-07 -4.093E-04 -8.089E-05 -3.425E-04 8.157E-07
0.11 1:6 MB 200 1.863E-06 -7.766E-04 -1.609E-04 -6.938E-04 1.635E-06
0.11 1:6 MB 300 2.821E-06 -1.120E-03 -2.400E-04 -1.080E-03 2.468E-06
0.11 1:6 MB 400 3.796E-06 -1.431E-03 -3.188E-04 -1.477E-03 3.304E-06
0.11 1:6 MB 500 4.778E-06 -1.373E-03 -3.924E-04 -1.809E-03 3.953E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 100 1.128E-06 -4.935E-04 -9.940E-05 -4.135E-04 1.004E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 200 2.282E-06 -9.357E-04 -1.979E-04 -8.387E-04 2.013E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 300 3.475E-06 -1.347E-03 -2.964E-04 -1.283E-03 3.039E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 400 4.745E-06 -1.739E-03 -3.894E-04 -1.780E-03 4.104E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 500 6.025E-06 -1.712E-03 -4.780E-04 -2.207E-03 5.025E-06
0.23 1:4 MB 100 4.623E-07 -2.026E-04 -4.103E-05 -1.690E-04 4.129E-07
0.23 1:4 MB 200 9.246E-07 -4.069E-04 -8.157E-05 -3.338E-04 8.258E-07
0.23 1:4 MB 300 1.393E-06 -6.019E-04 -1.222E-04 -5.023E-04 1.238E-06
0.23 1:4 MB 400 1.866E-06 -7.850E-04 -1.628E-04 -6.718E-04 1.651E-06
0.23 1:4 MB 500 2.392E-06 -9.676E-04 -2.046E-04 -9.066E-04 2.093E-06
0.23 1:4 LB 100 5.656E-07 -2.428E-04 -5.090E-05 -2.008E-04 5.098E-07
0.23 1:4 LB 200 1.132E-06 -4.896E-04 -9.977E-05 -4.027E-04 1.020E-06
0.23 1:4 LB 300 1.707E-06 -7.264E-04 -1.495E-04 -6.087E-04 1.529E-06
0.23 1:4 LB 400 2.290E-06 -9.427E-04 -1.994E-04 -8.138E-04 2.040E-06
0.23 1:4 LB 500 2.883E-06 -1.164E-03 -2.493E-04 -1.026E-03 2.557E-06
0.23 1:6 MB 100 4.692E-07 -2.112E-04 -4.057E-05 -1.762E-04 4.149E-07
0.23 1:6 MB 200 9.415E-07 -4.163E-04 -8.224E-05 -3.468E-04 8.293E-07
0.23 1:6 MB 300 1.419E-06 -6.050E-04 -1.232E-04 -5.235E-04 1.244E-06
0.23 1:6 MB 400 1.920E-06 -7.996E-04 -1.663E-04 -7.108E-04 1.688E-06
0.23 1:6 MB 500 2.388E-06 -9.644E-04 -2.041E-04 -9.108E-04 2.088E-06
0.23 1:6 LB 100 5.798E-07 -2.559E-04 -5.115E-05 -2.110E-04 5.165E-07
0.23 1:6 LB 200 1.164E-06 -5.076E-04 -1.022E-04 -4.233E-04 1.033E-06
0.23 1:6 LB 300 1.756E-06 -7.387E-04 -1.531E-04 -6.412E-04 1.550E-06
0.23 1:6 LB 400 2.356E-06 -9.597E-04 -2.036E-04 -8.657E-04 2.074E-06
0.23 1:6 LB 500 2.803E-06 -1.130E-03 -2.421E-04 -1.006E-03 2.484E-06
66
Table A-1: ANSYS Results for Span 5m
Input Reactions
Displacement
Thickness Load HzL HzR V ML MR (mm)
Mortar Brick
(m) (KN) (N) (N) (N) (N-m) (N-m)
0.11 1:4 MB 100 -38574 -61426 55649 29068 40188 4.923
0.11 1:4 MB 200 -77472 -122530 111160 58528 80685 9.961
0.11 1:4 MB 300 -116980 -183020 166410 88705 121770 15.161
0.11 1:4 MB 400 -156650 -243350 221590 119050 163000 20.412
0.11 1:4 MB 500 -196600 -303400 276650 149720 204530 25.761
0.11 1:4 LB 100 -38848 -61152 55434 29722 40610 5.074
0.11 1:4 LB 200 -78056 -121940 110720 59866 81551 10.269
0.11 1:4 LB 300 -117910 -182090 165700 90836 123150 15.652
0.11 1:4 LB 400 -158110 -241890 220520 122280 165120 21.155
0.11 1:4 LB 500 -198650 -301350 275170 154190 207440 26.776
0.11 1:6 MB 100 -38711 -61289 55551 29363 40380 4.989
0.11 1:6 MB 200 -78088 -121910 110810 59534 81409 10.195
0.11 1:6 MB 300 -117810 -182190 165930 90088 122770 15.495
0.11 1:6 MB 400 -158550 -241450 220770 121270 164900 21.087
0.11 1:6 MB 500 -203820 -296180 274110 156130 210800 28.048
0.11 1:6 LB 100 -39007 -60993 55318 30072 40838 5.153
0.11 1:6 LB 200 -78677 -121320 110340 60971 82330 10.525
0.11 1:6 LB 300 -118820 -181180 165150 92447 124300 16.036
0.11 1:6 LB 400 -159390 -240610 219760 124470 166740 21.713
0.11 1:6 LB 500 -204990 -295010 272850 160190 213060 28.813
0.23 1:4 MB 100 -37731 -62269 56280 27151 38951 4.482
0.23 1:4 MB 200 -75471 -124530 112560 54311 77909 8.966
0.23 1:4 MB 300 -113430 -186570 168750 81711 117060 13.532
0.23 1:4 MB 400 -151850 -248150 224770 109570 156580 18.214
0.23 1:4 MB 500 -190560 -309440 280660 137800 196410 22.964
0.23 1:4 LB 100 -37885 -62115 56163 27506 39180 4.564
0.23 1:4 LB 200 -75787 -124210 112320 55025 78372 9.132
0.23 1:4 LB 300 -113920 -186080 168390 82795 117760 13.781
0.23 1:4 LB 400 -152510 -247490 224280 111050 157540 18.553
0.23 1:4 LB 500 -191430 -308570 280040 139670 197620 23.392
0.23 1:6 MB 100 -37808 -62192 56228 27307 39053 4.517
0.23 1:6 MB 200 -75727 -124270 112410 54739 78203 9.076
0.23 1:6 MB 300 -114180 -185820 168390 82725 117810 13.787
0.23 1:6 MB 400 -152980 -247020 224230 111110 157740 18.573
0.23 1:6 MB 500 -191930 -308070 280010 139630 197810 23.404
0.23 1:6 LB 100 -37974 -62026 56100 27695 39303 4.607
0.23 1:6 LB 200 -75976 -124020 112190 55418 78627 9.220
0.23 1:6 LB 300 -114670 -185330 168010 83893 118550 14.052
0.23 1:6 LB 400 -153680 -246320 223700 112720 158780 18.940
0.23 1:6 LB 500 -192820 -307180 279320 141720 199160 23.883
67
Input Stress (N/m2)
Thickness Load
(m)
Mortar Brick
(KN) LB LU C RB RU
0.11 1:4 MB 100 2.184E+03 -1.318E+06 -2.553E+05 -1.126E+06 2.579E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 200 4.376E+03 -2.568E+06 -5.100E+05 -2.311E+06 5.152E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 300 6.588E+03 -3.719E+06 -7.662E+05 -3.863E+06 7.739E+03
0.11 1:4 MB 400 8.839E+03 -4.828E+06 -1.026E+06 -5.596E+06 1.036E+04
0.11 1:4 MB 500 1.114E+04 -5.855E+06 -1.288E+06 -7.585E+06 1.301E+04
0.11 1:4 LB 100 2.286E+03 -1.239E+06 -2.349E+05 -1.055E+06 2.371E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 200 4.600E+03 -2.409E+06 -4.696E+05 -2.169E+06 4.743E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 300 6.973E+03 -3.500E+06 -7.086E+05 -3.473E+06 7.157E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 400 9.478E+03 -4.553E+06 -9.362E+05 -5.012E+06 9.459E+03
0.11 1:4 LB 500 1.211E+04 -5.634E+06 -1.162E+06 -6.822E+06 1.174E+04
0.11 1:6 MB 100 2.291E+03 -1.365E+06 -2.706E+05 -1.190E+06 2.738E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 200 4.593E+03 -2.561E+06 -5.392E+05 -2.576E+06 5.443E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 300 6.949E+03 -3.669E+06 -8.107E+05 -4.352E+06 8.191E+03
0.11 1:6 MB 400 9.448E+03 -4.291E+06 -1.081E+06 -6.099E+06 1.091E+04
0.11 1:6 MB 500 1.236E+04 -4.289E+06 -1.329E+06 -7.943E+06 1.343E+04
0.11 1:6 LB 100 2.419E+03 -1.297E+06 -2.528E+05 -1.119E+06 2.548E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 200 4.874E+03 -2.435E+06 -5.048E+05 -2.389E+06 5.091E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 300 7.414E+03 -3.490E+06 -7.618E+05 -3.920E+06 7.687E+03
0.11 1:6 LB 400 1.011E+04 -4.397E+06 -1.006E+06 -5.696E+06 1.017E+04
0.11 1:6 LB 500 1.310E+04 -4.200E+06 -1.229E+06 -7.613E+06 1.241E+04
0.23 1:4 MB 100 1.166E+03 -6.692E+05 -1.296E+05 -5.672E+05 1.310E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 200 2.219E+03 -1.345E+06 -2.591E+05 -1.139E+06 2.619E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 300 3.332E+03 -1.992E+06 -3.884E+05 -1.725E+06 3.926E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 400 4.448E+03 -2.599E+06 -5.176E+05 -2.443E+06 5.231E+03
0.23 1:4 MB 500 5.569E+03 -3.202E+06 -6.472E+05 -3.308E+06 6.537E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 100 1.174E+03 -6.335E+05 -1.178E+05 -5.360E+05 1.190E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 200 2.349E+03 -1.279E+06 -2.409E+05 -1.078E+06 2.434E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 300 3.533E+03 -1.896E+06 -3.613E+05 -1.642E+06 3.650E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 400 4.731E+03 -2.465E+06 -4.818E+05 -2.296E+06 4.862E+03
0.23 1:4 LB 500 5.945E+03 -3.036E+06 -6.044E+05 -3.072E+06 6.103E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 100 1.245E+03 -6.976E+05 -1.379E+05 -6.001E+05 1.390E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 200 2.338E+03 -1.380E+06 -2.756E+05 -1.210E+06 2.790E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 300 3.511E+03 -1.999E+06 -4.129E+05 -1.933E+06 4.178E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 400 4.693E+03 -2.602E+06 -5.499E+05 -2.768E+06 5.562E+03
0.23 1:6 MB 500 5.893E+03 -3.175E+06 -6.883E+05 -3.686E+06 6.960E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 100 1.248E+03 -6.677E+05 -1.300E+05 -5.695E+05 1.313E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 200 2.498E+03 -1.347E+06 -2.606E+05 -1.151E+06 2.629E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 300 3.763E+03 -1.929E+06 -3.903E+05 -1.835E+06 3.943E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 400 5.043E+03 -2.503E+06 -5.210E+05 -2.617E+06 5.266E+03
0.23 1:6 LB 500 6.351E+03 -3.053E+06 -6.537E+05 -3.483E+06 6.603E+03
68
Input Strain
Thickness Load
(m)
Mortar Brick
(KN) LB LU C RB RU
0.11 1:4 MB 100 6.930E-07 -4.183E-04 -8.236E-05 -3.453E-04 4.077E-07
0.11 1:4 MB 200 1.388E-06 -8.126E-04 -1.646E-04 -7.060E-04 6.935E-07
0.11 1:4 MB 300 2.089E-06 -1.174E-03 -2.475E-04 -1.169E-03 1.046E-06
0.11 1:4 MB 400 2.803E-06 -1.524E-03 -3.316E-04 -1.692E-03 1.401E-06
0.11 1:4 MB 500 3.533E-06 -1.848E-03 -4.167E-04 -2.296E-03 1.761E-06
0.11 1:4 LB 100 9.259E-07 -4.972E-04 -9.575E-05 -4.089E-04 4.887E-07
0.11 1:4 LB 200 1.862E-06 -9.642E-04 -1.916E-04 -8.375E-04 9.782E-07
0.11 1:4 LB 300 2.822E-06 -1.399E-03 -2.895E-04 -1.332E-03 1.481E-06
0.11 1:4 LB 400 3.835E-06 -1.817E-03 -3.832E-04 -1.919E-03 2.009E-06
0.11 1:4 LB 500 4.898E-06 -2.252E-03 -4.763E-04 -2.616E-03 2.562E-06
0.11 1:6 MB 100 7.261E-07 -4.337E-04 -8.744E-05 -3.651E-04 3.582E-07
0.11 1:6 MB 200 1.455E-06 -8.098E-04 -1.744E-04 -7.821E-04 7.180E-07
0.11 1:6 MB 300 2.202E-06 -1.158E-03 -2.624E-04 -1.317E-03 1.085E-06
0.11 1:6 MB 400 2.995E-06 -1.348E-03 -3.501E-04 -1.856E-03 1.443E-06
0.11 1:6 MB 500 3.925E-06 -1.336E-03 -4.311E-04 -2.464E-03 1.746E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 100 9.767E-07 -5.209E-04 -1.033E-04 -4.344E-04 5.052E-07
0.11 1:6 LB 200 1.967E-06 -9.736E-04 -2.065E-04 -9.190E-04 1.013E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 300 2.992E-06 -1.392E-03 -3.120E-04 -1.503E-03 1.538E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 400 4.078E-06 -1.754E-03 -4.128E-04 -2.187E-03 2.088E-06
0.11 1:6 LB 500 5.295E-06 -1.657E-03 -5.052E-04 -2.971E-03 2.599E-06
0.23 1:4 MB 100 3.713E-07 -2.125E-04 -4.179E-05 -1.742E-04 2.071E-07
0.23 1:4 MB 200 7.041E-07 -4.272E-04 -8.359E-05 -3.495E-04 4.143E-07
0.23 1:4 MB 300 1.057E-06 -6.318E-04 -1.253E-04 -5.288E-04 5.280E-07
0.23 1:4 MB 400 1.411E-06 -8.228E-04 -1.670E-04 -7.413E-04 7.043E-07
0.23 1:4 MB 500 1.766E-06 -1.013E-03 -2.090E-04 -9.991E-04 8.830E-07
0.23 1:4 LB 100 4.755E-07 -2.544E-04 -4.803E-05 -2.080E-04 2.509E-07
0.23 1:4 LB 200 9.513E-07 -5.137E-04 -9.821E-05 -4.180E-04 5.020E-07
0.23 1:4 LB 300 1.431E-06 -7.607E-04 -1.473E-04 -6.361E-04 7.527E-07
0.23 1:4 LB 400 1.915E-06 -9.871E-04 -1.965E-04 -8.818E-04 1.005E-06
0.23 1:4 LB 500 2.406E-06 -1.214E-03 -2.468E-04 -1.174E-03 1.262E-06
0.23 1:6 MB 100 3.959E-07 -2.218E-04 -4.457E-05 -1.845E-04 2.129E-07
0.23 1:6 MB 200 7.411E-07 -4.382E-04 -8.908E-05 -3.715E-04 3.649E-07
0.23 1:6 MB 300 1.112E-06 -6.329E-04 -1.335E-04 -5.866E-04 5.473E-07
0.23 1:6 MB 400 1.487E-06 -8.231E-04 -1.779E-04 -8.367E-04 7.326E-07
0.23 1:6 MB 500 1.867E-06 -1.003E-03 -2.227E-04 -1.114E-03 9.196E-07
0.23 1:6 LB 100 5.040E-07 -2.684E-04 -5.313E-05 -2.214E-04 2.607E-07
0.23 1:6 LB 200 1.009E-06 -5.417E-04 -1.065E-04 -4.469E-04 5.217E-07
0.23 1:6 LB 300 1.519E-06 -7.728E-04 -1.596E-04 -7.056E-04 7.816E-07
0.23 1:6 LB 400 2.036E-06 -1.001E-03 -2.132E-04 -1.001E-03 1.047E-06
0.23 1:6 LB 500 2.563E-06 -1.220E-03 -2.676E-04 -1.332E-03 1.317E-06
69
REFERENCES
Bryan Stafford Smith and C. Carter, A Method of Analysis for Infilled Frames,
University of Southampton, Southampton College of Technology, February
1970
FEMA 306, Evaluation Of Earthquake Damaged Concrete And Masonry Wall Buildings,
Basic Procedures Manual, Prepared by: Applied Technology Council (ATC-43
Project) 555 Twin Dolphin Drive, Suite 550, Redwood City, California 94065,
Prepared for: The Partnership for Response and Recovery, Washington, D.C.,
Funded by: Federal Emergency Management Agency, 1998
FEMA 356, Prestandard and commentary for the seismic rehabilitation of the buildings,
Prepared by: American society of Civil Engineers(ASCE), Reston, Virginia,
Prepared for: Federal Emergency Management Agency, Washington, D.C., 1998
Ngandu, B.M., Bracing Steel Frames with Calcium Silicate Element Walls, Eindhoven
University of Technology, the Netherlands, 2006
Paulay, T. and Priestley, M.J.N., Seismic Design of Reinforced Concrete and Masonry
Buildings, John Wiley & Sons, U.S.A., 1992
70
Polyakov, S.V., Masonry in framed buildings (Godsudarstvenoe Isdatel stvo
Literatury Po Stroidal stvui Architecture. Moscow, 1956). Translated by G. L.
Cairns in 1963. National Lending Library for Science and Technology, Boston
Spa, Yorkshire, U.K.
Pradhan, P.L., Composite Actions of Brick Infill Wall In RC Frame under In-Plane
Lateral Load, Institute of Engineering, Tribhuvan University, Ph. D. Thesis,
2009
Rooij, A., Steel frames with precast reinforced concrete infill panels, January 2005.
Smyrou, E., Implementation and Verification of a masonry panel model for nonlinear
dynamic analysis of infilled RC frames, 2006
71