Sei sulla pagina 1di 11

Addressing issues related to geropsychiatry and the well-being of older adults Aging Matters

How Exercise Influences Cognitive Performance


When Mild Cognitive Impairment Exists
A Literature Review
ABSTRACT
Older adults who present with mild
cognitive impairment (MCI) have an
increased risk of developing more
advanced dementia. However, no
pharmacological treatment cur-
rently exists to slow the progres-
sion of or reverse MCI. The purpose
of the current systematic review is
to summarize evidence surround-
ing the impact of exercise interven-
tions on the cognitive performance
levels of community-dwelling older

2015 Shutterstock.com/StockLite
adults with MCI. Computerized data-
base and ancestry search strategies
located distinct intervention trials
between 1990 and 2015. Results in-

T
dicated that physical exercise may
he U.S. population of individuals per year (Ward, Arrighi,
benefit cognitive function among individuals 65 and older is Michels, & Cedarbaum, 2012). Older
older adults who have MCI, including expected to increase greatly adults who present with MCI have a
improvements in global cognition, in upcoming decades, from 43 to greater risk of developing dementia
92 million by 2060 (U.S. Cen- (Petersen et al., 2014), with a con-
executive function, memory, atten-
sus Bureau, 2012). Prevalence of version rate of 10% to 40% per year
tion, and processing speed. Physical dementia and other cognitive dis- to Alzheimers disease. With a world-
exercise may also positively impact orders is predicted to rise substan- wide aging population, the societal
the physiology of the aging brain. tially. Major population-based stud- impact of MCI is rising. No pharma-
ies reported an average prevalence of cological treatment currently exists
However, evidence surrounding the
mild cognitive impairment (MCI) of to slow the progression of or reverse
characteristics of effective physical 18.9% (Das et al., 2007; Di Carlo et MCI (Petersen et al., 2014). Given
exercise interventions in terms of ex- al., 2007; Lopez et al., 2003; Palmer, the high prevalence and conversion
ercise type, intensity, duration, and Bckman, Winblad, & Fratiglioni, rate to dementia, identifying effec-
2008; Petersen et al., 2014; Purser, tive nonpharmacological approaches
frequency remains limited. [Journal
Fillenbaum, Pieper, & Wallace, to maintain or improve cognition
of Psychosocial Nursing and Mental 2005). Average incidence rates are is urgent to control the epidemic of
Health Services, 54(1), 25-35.] 47.9 (range = 21.5 to 71.3) per 1,000 dementia. The current article focuses

Yun Cai, AGPCNP-BC, MS; and Kathleen Abrahamson, PhD, RN

Journal of Psychosocial Nursing Vol. 54, No. 1, 2016 25


Aging Matters

on the effect of physical exercise on MCI and provide insight regarding et al., 2014). Although older adults
cognitive performance. the impact this evidence can have on are usually defined as those 65 and
The definition of exercise is inten- nursing and primary care practice. older, it is common to find research
tional physical activity for improving articles defining the cutoff as 55 to 60
health and fitness, based on the METHOD (Baker et al., 2010; Lam et al., 2012;
American College of Sports Medicine A review of studies published from Lautenschlager et al., 2008). Thus, the
position stand (Garber et al., 2011). 1990 to 2015 was conducted. Data- current authors established age 60 as
Epidemiological studies have proposed bases searched included CINAHL, the cutoff for the inclusion of studies.
that physical exercise is associated PubMed, PsycINFO, SportDiscus, and The Table displays the identified
with various cognitive benefits (Hamer Cochrane Library. Medical Subject studies designs (i.e., publication year,
& Chida, 2009; Kramer et al., 1999). Headings used in the search included country, study design, and sample
Physical exercise reduces cognitive MCI/cognitive impairment, cognition [number, background demographic
decline associated with aging and may disorders, exercise, or physical therapy characteristics]), intervention char-
reduce the risk for MCI and dementia modalities. Searches were limited to acteristics (i.e., setting, duration,
in older adults who maintain higher English language and human studies delivery mode, theoretical framework,
levels of physical activity (Hamer & in all databases and clinical trials in cognitive measures, and time points),
Chida, 2009; Kramer et al., 1999). PubMed. In addition, relevant sources and key cognitive findings. Studies
However, cognitive benefits of physical cited in identified publications were were arranged by type of interven-
exercise among older adults with MCI included in the review (ancestry tions: aerobic exercise, Tai Chi exer-
are still unclear. method). The Preferred Reporting cise, functional task exercise, resis-
A number of mechanisms exist by Items for Systematic Reviews and tance training, and multicomponent
which exercise may impact the aging Meta-Analyses guidelines provided physical training.
brain (Kirk-Sanchez & McGough, a structure for manuscript review
2014). Exercise has a demonstrated (Moher, Liberati, Tetzlaff, & Alt- RESULTS
impact on cardiovascular function, man, 2009). Articles were included Search Outcome
and multiple cardiovascular risk fac- if: (a) participants were community- The initial computerized search
tors, such as hypertension and circula- dwelling adults 60 or older; (b) par- yielded 387 citations. After screening
tory health, are associated with risk for ticipants had MCI; (c) experimental abstracts, 19 duplicates and 355 arti-
cognitive decline (Grodstein, 2007). or quasi-experimental studies were cles that did not meet inclusion crite-
Increased risk for cognitive impair- reported; (d) physical exercise or ria were rejected. Reasons for exclusion
ment has also been linked to diabetes, physical therapy interventions were were primarily because participants did
depression, and high levels of inflam- described; and (e) cognitive perfor- not have MCI or were institutional-
matory markersconditions that mance was directly measured as an ized, studies were nonexperimental,
may be impacted by level of physical outcome. studies had nonphysical interventions,
activity (Nelson et al., 2007). Exercise The current authors defined MCI or cognitive performance was not mea-
may also increase the release of protec- using a combination of four major sured. One additional study was identi-
tive agents, such as neurotrophins, and definitions from the Mayo Clinic fied through ancestry searches on pre-
impact the nervous system and brain (Petersen, 2004; Winblad et al., viously published review articles and
physiology in ways that promote cog- 2004), National Institute on Aging all potential primary studies. A total of
nitive performance (Erickson et al., Alzheimers Association workgroup 13 studies were included in the current
2011; Rasmussen et al., 2009; Seifert et (Albert et al., 2011), and fifth edi- review.
al., 2010; Vaynman & Gomez-Pinilla, tion of the Diagnostic and Statistical
2005). Manual of Mental Disorders (Ameri- Sample Characteristics
There is an established body of can Psychiatric Association, 2013). Four of 13 studies were conducted in
literature surrounding the influence Core clinical criteria according to the United States, with the remaining
of interventions focused on physical these definitions include: (a) self- or nine conducted in Japan, Hong Kong/
experience on cognitive function in informant-reported memory or cogni- China, Australia, Canada, Brazil, and
older adults with and without cognitive tive complaint; (b) objective memory Spain. The 13 studies represented a
impairment. The purpose of the cur- or cognitive impairment; (c) essen- total of 1,171 participants with mean
rent article is to systematically describe tially preserved general cognitive ages from 70 to 78. Study samples
what is known regarding the impact of functioning; (d) preserved indepen- ranged from 11 to 389. The range of the
exercise interventions on community- dence in functional abilities; and percentage of males was 0% to 63%,
dwelling older adults with identified (e) no dementia diagnosis (Petersen with an average of 38%.

26 Copyright SLACK Incorporated


TABLE
STUDY CHARACTERISTICS AND FINDINGS BY TYPE OF EXERCISE INTERVENTIONa
Author/Location/
Study Design Sample Characteristics Intervention Measures/Time Points Findings
Aerobic Exercise
Baker et al., 2010/ N = 29 (TX n = 19; VA memory clinic and local YMCA EF by SDMT, verbal Intervention versus control: no
United States/RCT control n = 10) High-intensity aerobic exercise at fluency, Stroop, TMT-B, and significant findings at 3 months
Ages 55 to 85 (average = 70 75% to 85% of HR reserve; 45 to 60 task switching For women, improved
years) minutes/day, 4 days/week Memory by story recall, performance on multiple tests of
48% male Control: stretching activities, list learning, and DMS EF at 6 months
Mean MMSE (25.6 to 28.6); HR 50% Baseline and 3 and 6 For men, a favorable effect
mean DRS Duration = 6 months months only on TMT-B performance
Doi et al., 2013/ N = 16 Setting unclear Changes in oxy-Hb in the During DTW versus NW:
Japan/uncontrolled Age >65 (average = 75 years) DTW and NW sessions: NW-1, prefrontal area higher oxy-Hb values

Journal of Psychosocial Nursing Vol. 54, No. 1, 2016


pretestposttest 63% male DTW-1, NW-2, DTW-2, NW-3, DTW-3; EF by Stroop interference Oxy-Hb in LIFG but not RIFG
MMSE >23; without ADL 60 seconds each Baseline, posttest was significantly correlated with
impairment Duration = one session EF during DTW; no significant
correlation during NW
Lautenschlager et al., N = 170 (TX n = 85; Participants homes Cognition by ADAS-Cog Intervention versus control
2008/Australia/RCT control n = 85) Home-based physical activity Baseline, post- over time: greater improvement
Ages 60 to 77 (average = 69 motivation program, three 50-minute intervention, and 12- and of ADAS-Cog scores
years) sessions/week; workbook, physical 18-month follow up
58% male activity diary, newsletters, and
SMC only, aMCI, or non-aMCI telephone calls
Education and usual care
Duration = 6 months
van Uffelen, N = 152 (TX n = 77; Community centers Cognitive functions by Intervention versus control: no
Chinapaw, van control n = 75) Group-based moderate-intensity AVLT, SCWT-A, DSST, and VFT significant effect of walking on
Mechelen, & Ages 70 to 80 (average = 74 to walking, twice weekly Baseline and 6 and 12 cognition at 6 or 12 months
Hopman-Rock, 2008/ 76 years) Low-intensity placebo activity months
Australia/RCT 56% male program
SMC, MMSE 24, and Duration = 12 months
objective memory impairment
(10 WLT delayed recall 5 and %
savings 100)
Aging Matters

27
28
TABLE (CONTINUED)
STUDY CHARACTERISTICS AND FINDINGS BY TYPE OF EXERCISE INTERVENTIONa
Author/Location/
Study Design Sample Characteristics Intervention Measures/Time Points Findings
Varela, Ayan, N = 48 (TX1 n = 17; TX2 Residential care homes Cognition by MMSE Interventions versus control: no significant
Cancela, & Martin, n = 15; control n = 15) TX1: supervised aerobic exercise Baseline and 3- and between-group difference on MMSE at 3- or
Aging Matters

2012/Spain/RCT Age >65 (average = 78 (cycling) at 40% of HR reserve; 6-month follow up 6-month follow up
(pilot study) years) three 30-minute sessions/week
44% male TX2: same aerobic exercise at
Clinical diagnosis of MCI; 60% of HR reserve
mean MMSE = 20 to 22 Control: recreational activities
Duration = 3 months
Tai Chi Exercise
Chang et al., 2011/ N = 11 Senior centers and residential Cognitive function by Posttest versus pretest: no significant
United States/ Average age = 85 complexes the five screening tools, difference in cognition; a significant dose-
uncontrolled 9% male Sun-style 12 from Tai Chi; 20 to and physical and mental response relationship
pretestposttest MMSE (15 to 27), Digit 40 minutes/session twice per week function by SF-36
(pilot study) Symbol-Coding on the Duration = 15 weeks Baseline and 15 weeks
WAIS-III (6), Digit Span on
the WAIS-III (6), Stroop
Color and Word test (39),
or Hopkins Verbal Learning
Test (39)
With chronic pain;
without depression
Lam et al., 2012/ N = 389 (TX n = 171; Community centers, residential Cognitive functions by No change in MMSE scores in both groups
Hong Kong/RCT control n = 218) homes, or participants homes ADAS-Cog, digit span, delay Intervention versus control
Age >65 (average = 77 to 24 forms simplified Tai Chi; 30 recall, CVFT, TMT, and MMSE at 12 months: no significant between-group
78 years) minutes/day, 3 days/week Baseline and 5, 9, and difference on any cognition parameters
24% male Control: stretching and toning 12 months Intervention versus control at
CDR 0.5 or aMCI exercise 12 months, completers
Duration = 12 months only: greater improvement in delayed recall
Li, Harmer, Liu, & N = 46 (TX n = 22; Senior centers Global cognitive function Intervention versus control
Chou, 2014/United control n = 24) TJQMBB; 60-minute session by MMSE at post-intervention: greater improvement
States/non-RCT Age 65 (average = 76 twice/week Baseline, post- on MMSE scores
(pilot study) years) Control: usual daily physical intervention
30% male activity
MMSE = 20 to 25 Duration = 14 weeks

Copyright SLACK Incorporated


TABLE (CONTINUED)
STUDY CHARACTERISTICS AND FINDINGS BY TYPE OF EXERCISE INTERVENTIONa

Author/Location/
Study Design Sample Characteristics Intervention Measures/Time Points Findings
Tsai, Chang, Beck, N = 55 (TX n = 28; Senior centers and residential Cognitive functions by Intervention versus control
Kuo, & Keefe, 2013/ control n = 27) complexes MMSE post-intervention: no significant
United States/RCT Age >60 (average = 79 years) Sun-style Tai Chi classes, Baseline, every 4 weeks, difference in MMSE (p = 0.096)
(pilot study) 27% male 3 sessions/week and post-intervention
Ethnicity: 93% Caucasian Control: health and culture classes
MMSE = 18 to 28 and OA Duration = 20 weeks
Functional Task Exercise
Law, Barnett, Yau, N = 83 (TX n = 43; Outpatient clinic Cognition by NCSE, CVVLT, Intervention versus control
& Gray, 2014/Hong control n = 40) Functional task exercise CVFT, TMT-A, and TMT-B post-intervention and
Kong/RCT Age >60 (average = 74 years) Control: active cognitive training Baseline, post- 6-month follow up: greater

Journal of Psychosocial Nursing Vol. 54, No. 1, 2016


40% male Duration = 10 weeks intervention, and 6-month general cognitive functions,
SMC or suspected CI follow up memory, and EF
Resistance Training
Nagamatsu, Handy, N = 77 (TX1 n = 26; TX2 n = 24; Setting unclear EF by Stroop and TMT TX1 versus control post-
Hsu, Voss, & Liu- control n = 27) TX1: resistance training (stretching, Working memory by intervention: greater improved
Ambrose, 2012/ Age = 70 to 80 (average = 75 range of motion, balance exercise, verbal digits tests performance on the Stroop Test
Canada/RCT years) relaxation techniques); 60 minutes, Associative memory by and associative memory task
0% male twice per week memorizing face-scene pairs TX2 versus control post-
MoCA (<26/30) and SMC TX2: aerobic training (outdoor Everyday problem-solving intervention: no significant effect
walking program); 60 minutes, twice ability by Everyday Problem on cognitive function measures
per week Test
Control: balance and tone training; Baseline, post-
60 minutes, twice per week intervention
Duration = 6 months
Multicomponent Physical Training
Nascimento et N = 45 (TX n = 24; Setting unclear Cognitive functions by Intervention versus control
al., 2015/Brazil/ control n = 21) Multimodal physical training MoCA post-intervention: improved
CT (randomization Age >60 (average = 66 to 69 (muscular resistance, aerobic fitness, Peripheral concentrations cognitive functions, especially
unclear) years) motor coordination/balance) at of BDNF the EF, and significantly
41% male 60% to 80% of max HR; three 1-hour Baseline, post- increased peripheral BDNF level
MCI reported by participants sessions per week intervention
and caregivers; without Control: usual activity
depression Duration = 4 months
Aging Matters

29
30
TABLE (CONTINUED)
STUDY CHARACTERISTICS AND FINDINGS BY TYPE OF EXERCISE INTERVENTIONa

Author/Location/
Study Design Sample Characteristics Intervention Measures/Time Points Findings
Suzuki et al., 2013/ N = 50 (TX n = 25; Community center Cognitive functions by Intervention versus control
Aging Matters

Japan/RCT control n = 25) Supervised multicomponent MMSE, WMS-LM, DSC, LVFT over time from baseline
Age 65 to 93 exercise (aerobic exercises, muscle and SCWT to 12 months: greater
(average = 75 years) strength training, postural balance Baseline and 6 and 12 improvements on MMSE, logical
54% male retraining); 90 minutes/day, months memory of immediate recall
aMCI 2 days/week (WMS-LM I), and LVFT
Control: three sessions of
education classes regarding health
but not exercise-specific
Duration = 12 months

Note. RCT = randomized controlled trial; TX = intervention group; MMSE = Mini-Mental State Examination; DRS = Dementia Rating Scale; YMCA = Young Mens Christian Associations;
HR = heart rate; EF = executive function; SDMT = Symbol Digit Modalities Test; TMT-B = Trail Making Test B; DMS = delayed-match-to-sample; ADL = activities of daily living; DTW = dual-task
walking; NW = normal walking; oxy-Hb = oxygenated hemoglobin; LIFG = left inferior frontal gyrus; RIFG = right inferior frontal gyrus; SMC = subjective memory complaints; aMCI = amnestic-
mild cognitive impairment; ADAS-Cog = Change in Alzheimer Disease Assessment Scale-Cognitive Subscale; WLT = word learning test; AVLT = auditory verbal learning test; SCWT-A = Stroop
color word test-abridged; DSST = digit symbol substitution test; VFT = verbal fluency test; WAIS-III = Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale (3rd ed.); SF-36 = Short Form-36; CDR = clinical dementia
rating; CVFT = category verbal fluency test; TJQMBB = Tai Ji Quan: Moving for Better Balance; OA = osteoarthritis; NCSE = Chinese version of Neurobehavioral Cognitive Status Examination;
CVVLT = Chinese version verbal learning test; TMT-A = Trail Making Test A; MoCA = Montreal Cognitive Assessment; BDNF = brain-derived neurotrophic factor; WMS-LM = Logical Memory
subtest of the Wechsler Memory Scale-Revised; DSC = digit symbol coding; LVFT = letter and categorical verbal fluency test; SCWT = Stroop color word test.
a
Unless otherwise stated, all reported findings are significant at p < 0.05.

of 78.2%.
studies (Table).

activities (Table).
Methodological Attributes

ence, the study also delivered a social


Suzuki et al., 2013). In control groups,
Voss, & Liu-Ambrose, 2012). The

tion (nine of 13 studies), followed by


physical activity, and recreational
and/or toning training, nonexercise-
activity, stretching exercise, balance
porated resistance training, aerobic
et al., 2014). One study used resistance
single-limb movements, simultaneous
exercise (e.g., walking) as the targeted
Five of 13 studies used aerobic
randomized controlled trials (RCTs),

Copyright SLACK Incorporated


executive function (seven studies,)
nitive outcome was global cogni-
The most common measured cog-
calls, which comprised information on

time management, barriers to activity,


exercise programs, rewards, goal setting,
a manual, newsletters, and telephone
intervention package via workshop,
cognitive theorybased behavioral
utes per week of moderate-intensity
physical activity. To enhance adher-
ticipants to perform at least 150 min-
program that aimed to encourage par-
nitive training, low-intensity placebo
related health education, active cog-
activities used included usual daily
training) (Nascimento et al., 2014;
exercise, and coordination/balance
ponent physical training (i.e., incor-
remaining two studies used multicom-
training only (Nagamatsu, Handy, Hsu,
body midline crossing exercises) (Law
hand movements, task switching, and
tional task exercises (i.e., incorporated
exercise. One study conducted func-
intervention. Four studies used Tai Chi
two were uncontrolled pretestposttest
two were non-RCTs, and the remaining

(2008) reported a high adherence rate


alized home-based physical activity
2008). The study provided an individu-
nitive theory) (Lautenschlager et al.,
behavior theorybased (i.e., social cog-

and safe exercise. Lautenschlager et al.


Only one of 13 studies was health
Of 13 studies included, nine were
Aging Matters

verbal learning and memory (five 44 older adults. An Australian study per week) in the intervention group
studies), and memory (i.e., delay or randomized 170 participants with and controlled with health and culture
immediate recalls) (four studies). Other MCI for either a 6-month home-based classes. Varela et al. (2012) conducted
cognitive outcomes included attention, physical activity motivation program a supervised aerobic exercise program
visual attention and task switching, (50-minute sessions, three times per (low- and moderate-intensity cycling) for
processing speed, and brain activation week) or an education group. At the 3 months. The remaining study was an
measured by peripheral oxyhemoglobin end of the intervention, the exer- uncontrolled pretestposttest study with
or brain-derived neurotrophic factor cise group showed an improvement a sample of only 11 older adults involved
(BDNP) level. of 0.26 points on the ADAS-Cog, in a 15-week sun-style Tai Chi program
Intervention settings included com- whereas the control group showed a (20 to 40 minutes per session, two times
munity settings, participants homes, decrease of 1.04 points (Lautenschlager per week) (Chang et al., 2011).
or both. Intervention setting was not et al., 2008). Another RCT in Hong
clearly described in three studies. Nine Kong/China studied the effect of a Executive Function, Memory, Attention,
studies (69%) had an intervention 10-week functional task exercise pro- and Other Cognitive Domains
duration of 6 months and ranged from gram on cognition as compared to an Seven (54%) of 13 studies evaluated
10 weeks to 6 months; the remaining active control group (existing cognitive the effects of exercise on executive
four interventions lasted 12 months. training) (Law, Barnett, Yau, & Gray, function. Four (57%) of these seven
Ten (77%) studies measured cogni- 2014). The program comprised 13 ses- studies found modest positive effects.
tive performance immediately post- sions of 30-minute simulated functional Commonly used assessment tools
intervention, whereas only three task exercises. After the intervention, included the verbal fluency test (Troyer,
measured follow-up outcomes at 3 or participants showed an improvement Moscovitch, & Winocur, 1997), Stroop
12 months post-intervention (Table). on global cognitive function measured Color and Word Test (Stroop, 1992),
by the NCSE. Suzuki et al. (2013) and Trail Making Tests A and/or B
Efficacy of Interventions examined the effects of a 12-month (TMT; Reitan, 1958). Seven (54%)
In general, nine (69%) of 13 studies multicomponent exercise program of 13 studies tested the effects of exer-
reported some positive findings on (90 minutes per day, 2 days per week; cise on memory, which was measured
cognitive improvement in global cog- aerobic exercise, strength training, bal- by story recall, list learning, delayed
nition, executive function, and/or ance, and dual tasking) in Japan. After match-to-sample, Hopkins verbal
memory (Table). the intervention, participants showed learning test, auditory verbal learning
an improvement on the MMSE but not test, and digit span test. Four (57%)
Global Cognition on the ADAS-Cog. A recent non-RCT of these seven studies demonstrated
Nine (69%) of 13 studies exam- reported positive results for a 4-month efficacy (Table).
ined the effect of physical exercise multimodal physical training program In a RCT, Baker et al. (2010)
on global cognition using the Mini- (muscular resistance, aerobic fitness, examined the effect of a 6-month high-
Mental State Examination (MMSE; and motor coordination/balance) on intensity aerobic exercise on executive
Folstein, Folstein, & McHugh, 1975), general cognitive function (especially function and memory (45 to 60 min-
Alzheimers Disease Assessment executive function) measured by the utes, four times per week). Favorable
Scale cognitive subscale (ADAS- MoCA (Nascimento et al., 2014). effects of physical exercise were found
Cog; Rosen, Mohs, & Davis, 1984), In contrast, the remaining four studies in all executive function measures
Clinical Dementia Rating Sum of did not yield significant improvements (i.e., verbal fluency, TMT-B, and task
Boxes (Morris, 1997), Chinese version on global cognitive function post- switching) among female participants
of Neurobehavioral Cognitive Status intervention. A RCT with a large sample at the end of the intervention, whereas
Examination (NCSE; Man, Chung, & (N = 389) conducted in Hong Kong/ for males, there was a favorable effect
Mak, 2009), and Montreal Cognitive China did not show improvements only on TMT-B performance. No
Assessment (MoCA; Nasreddine et al., on the MMSE or ADAS-Cog after a improvement on memory was found.
2005) (Table). 12-month Tai Chi exercise program (at In contrast, another RCT reported
A positive effect was observed in five least 30 minutes per day, 3 days per week) positive findings on memory (delayed
(56%) of these nine studies (Table). (Lam et al., 2012). Two other RCTs were recall) and negative findings on execu-
The study by Li, Harmer, Liu, and Chou pilot studies with samples of 55 (Tsai, tive function at the end of a 12-month
(2014) was a pilot RCT on the effect of Chang, Beck, Kuo, & Keefe, 2013) and Tai Chi program (Lam et al., 2012).
a 14-week Tai Chi Quan: Moving for 48 (Varela, Ayan, Cancela, & Martin, Three other RCTs reported con-
Better Balance program on global cog- 2012). Tsai et al. (2013) led 20-week sistent negative findings on executive
nitive function, with a total sample of sun-style Tai Chi classes (three sessions function and memory for a 12-month

Journal of Psychosocial Nursing Vol. 54, No. 1, 2016 31


Aging Matters

multicomponent exercise program study by Nascimento et al. (2014). nition, executive function, memory,
(Suzuki et al., 2013), 10-week func- Significant increases in the peripheral attention, and processing speed. The
tional task exercise program (Law et concentration of BDNP and cogni- current findings of improved global
al., 2014), and 6-month resistance tive functions were observed after cognition and executive function
training program (Nagamatsu et al., the 16-week period of multimodal after aerobic exercise interventions
2012) post-intervention. The details of physical training, whereas no signifi- are consistent with previous review
the studies by Suzuki et al. (2013) and cant changes were observed in the articles (Cooper, Li, Lyketsos, & Liv-
Law et al. (2014) are discussed above. control group. In another RCT, van ingston, 2013; Hahn & Andel, 2011;
Nagamatsu et al. (2012) conducted a Uffelen, Chinapaw, van Mechelen, Langa & Levine, 2014; Teixeira et al.,
RCT in Canada comparing the effects and Hopman-Rock (2008) tested the 2012). The current article adds new
of resistance and aerobic training inter- efficacy of a 12-month group-based, evidence that other types of exercise
ventions with an active control group moderate-intensity walking program (i.e., resistance training, functional
(balance and tone training), with the as compared to a low-intensity placebo task exercise, and multicomponent
same training doses (60 minutes per activity program among 152 older exercise) may have positive effects not
session, twice per week). They found adults. The authors did not find only on global cognition and execu-
that, as compared to the control group, intervention effects on immediate and tive function, but also on memory and
Stroop test and associative memory delayed recall and executive function brain activation. However, currently,
task performance improved in the resis- post-intervention. specific evidence to direct primary
tance training group post-intervention, Attention and processing speed were care practitioners toward recommend-
but not in the aerobic training group. less commonly measured in included ing an exercise type, intensity, dura-
tion, and frequency to impact cogni-
tive function is limited.
Physical exercise may benefit older adults with mild In many studies, exercise inten-
cognitive impairment, including improvement in... sity was high (up to moderate in-
tensity), but training session atten-
global cognition, executive function, memory, dance or participants acceptance of
attention, and processing speed. the exercise intervention was rarely
described. Duration of the interven-
tions was relatively short, from 10
Two pretestposttest studies with studies. Two studies (one pretestposttest weeks to 6 months. Participants
small samples did not yield improve- and one RCT) reported negative find- adherence to exercise after the in-
ments in executive function or ings on attention after a 15-week Tai tervention period and maintenance
memory performance (Chang et al., Chi program (Chang et al., 2011) and of positive effects on cognition were
2011; Doi et al., 2013). The study by a 12-month moderate-intensity walk- not examined in the included stud-
Chang et al. (2011) is discussed above. ing program (van Uffelen et al., 2008). ies, and could be a significant issue
Doi et al. (2013) provided a walking Similarly, three studies that measured when implementing these interven-
intervention in Japan with alternated processing speed did not yield efficacy tions in community settings. Many
normal walking and dual-tasking (Chang et al., 2011; Suzuki et al., 2013; cognitive tests were used to measure
walking (i.e., walking while per- van Uffelen et al., 2008). cognitive outcomes. Tests measur-
forming a verbal letter fluency task). ing global cognitive function, ex-
Changes in oxyhemoglobin levels DISCUSSION ecutive function, and memory were
were recorded while participants per- Physical exercise programs in the most commonly used. Recent studies
formed the normal walking and dual- current review comprised several have started examining the effects of
tasking walking tests. The authors different types of exercise, including physical exercise on specific cogni-
found that oxyhemoglobin levels were aerobic exercise, resistance training, tive domains in addition to general
higher during dual-tasking walking functional task exercise, multicom- cognitive function. More research
than normal walking, and the level in ponent exercise, and a mindbody is needed to measure the impact of
the left inferior frontal gyrus was sig- exercise (i.e., Tai Chi) that was also community-based exercise interven-
nificantly correlated with executive considered a multicomponent exer- tions using tools that are accessible
function during dual-tasking walking cise (Li et al., 2014). Results indicated to the primary care nurse or physi-
but not during normal walking. that physical exercise may benefit cian, and targeting the aspects of
Another objective measurement was older adults with MCI, including im- cognition that are most meaningful
the peripheral BDNF measured in the provement in the areas of global cog- to older adults with MCI.

32 Copyright SLACK Incorporated


Aging Matters

LIMITATIONS fidelity control was described in only needed. To further understand the
Findings in the current review two studies (Li et al., 2014; Tsai et al., effect of physical exercise on cogni-
should be interpreted in the context of 2013). For example, Li et al. (2014) tive function, RCTs with large sam-
several limitations. First, the rigor of stated that the intervention teaching ples are needed. Physical exercise
the included studies varied. Given the protocol was monitored by the first interventions guided by health be-
limited amount of research targeting author per criteria described in the havior theories may be helpful in im-
community-dwelling older adults with article. Fourth, inclusion criteria of proving adherence during or after in-
MCI, the search was not limited to MCI participants were inconsistent. terventions. Future large studies may
only RCTs. Instead, non-RCTs and As discussed previously, MCI is a con- include gender as a predictor variable
pretestposttest studies were included cept in evolution. Some studies found to better understand sex differences
to achieve a broader view. For exam- that participants were not diagnosed on intervention effects. Intervention
ple, Chang et al.s (2011) study found a correctly at baseline when they might durations of >6 months with follow-
trend of positive effect of Tai Chi exer- have dementia already, which might up data are needed to explore long-
cise on global cognition, cognitive pro- have blurred the effects of the physical term effects of exercise interventions
cessing speed, and memory. However, exercise intervention on cognitive on cognitive function and mainte-
the small-scale, pretestposttest study changes. Many studies also did not nance of positive effects over time.
might not have had enough power to report participants baseline physical
detect the effect of Tai Chi on cogni- activity levels. For example, some IMPLICATIONS FOR NURSES
tive function, especially specific cog- studies found that most participants Nurses are the largest segment of
nitive domains. Second, participants experienced moderate-intensity exer- the health care workforce and, despite
ages and health conditions may affect cise at baseline, which may result in the potential that nursing care may
study results. For example, participants less sensitivity to an exercise interven- have on impacting the outcomes of
in Chang et al.s (2011) study were of tion of a similar intensity (van Uffelen exercise-focused interventions, nurses
old age (average = 85 years) and had et al., 2008; Varela et al., 2012). were involved in only one of 13 studies.
a chronic pain condition. These facts In the current review, only one Public health and community health
may interfere with the compliance of intervention was guided by health and home care nurses are well suited
exercise intervention and detection of behavior theoretical frameworks to to provide exercise interventions to
cognitive changes post-intervention. encourage participant adherence to community-dwelling older adults
Similar issues were found in another an exercise program. Recent meta- because they (a) see patients in their
small-scale RCT with a comparable analyses show that interventions natural environment and can involve
study design (Tsai et al., 2013). In ad- strongly guided by health behavior families and community members in
dition, gender-specific intervention theory significantly impact physi- the intervention; (b) have education
effect was analyzed in only one (19%) cal activity outcomes of participants that has emphasized the need to estab-
study (Baker et al., 2010). Relatively (Gourlan et al., 2014; Young, Plot- lish a trustful relationship with patients
small samples in most studies limited nikoff, Collins, Callister, & Morgan, and provide individualized exercise
their ability to analyze the gender dif- 2014). For example, when examining plans; and (c) have ongoing contact
ference of intervention effects on cog- social cognitive theorybased physical with patients over an extended period
nitive function. activity interventions, this health be- of time, which may help motivate
Third, median adherence (<75%) to havior theory explained 31% of vari- patients to better adhere to interven-
exercise programs was reported in most ance in physical activity (Young et al., tions. Thus, evidence encouraging the
studies. For example, van Uffelen et al. 2014). However, mechanisms that ex- use of exercise interventions with the
(2008) reported a 63% adherence rate plain these larger effects are not clear MCI population could potentially ben-
among 152 participants in a 12-month (Gourlan et al., 2014; Young et al., efit from research specifically aimed at
walking program. In addition, the ad- 2014). Theory-based strategies may nursing practice.
herence rate of female participants be developed with greater care, fidel-
was as low as 45% in comparison to ity, and structure. In the implementa- CONCLUSION
75% for males. Overall, 20% of par- tion of exercise interventions among The causal effect of physical exer-
ticipants did not attend any interven- older adults, motivational/supportive cise interventions on cognitive perfor-
tion session, but were still included in contacts guided by health behavior mance in community-dwelling older
final analyses of intervention effects. theories may increase participants ad- adults is unclear due to insufficient
An additional analysis including com- herence to exercise programs. evidence. It remains unclear which
pleters may only be helpful to present The mixed findings of these studies intervention characteristics are more
more accurate results. Intervention indicate more primary research is effective in terms of exercise type,

Journal of Psychosocial Nursing Vol. 54, No. 1, 2016 33


Aging Matters

Tsutsumimoto, K., Uemura, K., & Suzuki, comparing mind body exercise (Tai Chi)
intensity, and duration. Future rig- T. (2013). Brain activation during dual-task with stretching and toning exercise on cogni-
orously designed, large intervention walking and executive function among older tive function in older Chinese adults at risk
studies with longer durations are adults with mild cognitive impairment: A of cognitive decline. Journal of the American
needed to explore the effect of physi- fNIRS study. Aging Clinical and Experimental Medical Directors Association, 13, 568.e515-
cal exercise programs on cognitive Research, 25, 539-544. doi:10.1007/s40520- e520. doi:10.1016/j.jamda.2012.03.008
013-0119-5 Langa, K.M., & Levine, D.A. (2014). The
performance in older adults with MCI. Erickson, K.I., Voss, M.W., Prakash, R.S., Basak, diagnosis and management of mild cogni-
Theory-based interventions with C., Szabo, A., Chaddock, L.,Kramer, A.F. tive impairment: A clinical review. Journal of
sex difference and follow-up data are (2011). Exercise training increases size of the American Medical Association, 312, 2551-
preferred. Moreover, clearly reported hippocampus and improves memory. Proceed- 2561. doi:10.1001/jama.2014.13806
intervention design, participants ings of the National Academy of Sciences of the Lautenschlager, N.T., Cox, K.L., Flicker, L.,
United States of America, 108, 3017-3022. Foster, J.K., van Bockxmeer, F.M., Xiao, J.,
baseline activity level, compliance, doi:10.1073/pnas.1015950108 Almeida, O.P. (2008). Effect of physical
acceptance, and intervention fidelity Folstein, M.F., Folstein, S.E., & McHugh, P.R. activity on cognitive function in older adults
control should be encouraged to fa- (1975). Mini-mental state. A practical at risk for Alzheimer disease: A randomized
cilitate appropriate interpretation of method for grading the cognitive state of trial. Journal of the American Medical Associa-
future studies. patients for the clinician. Journal of Psychiatric tion, 300, 1027-1037.
Research, 12, 189-198. Law, L.L., Barnett, F., Yau, M.K., & Gray, M.A.
Garber, C.E., Blissmer, B., Deschenes, M.R., (2014). Effects of functional tasks exercise
REFERENCES Franklin, B.A., Lamonte, M.J., Lee, I.M., on older adults with cognitive impairment
Albert, M.S., DeKosky, S.T., Dickson, D., Dubois, Swain, D.P. (2011). American College of at risk of Alzheimers disease: A randomised
B., Feldman, H.H., Fox, N.C.,...Phelps, Sports Medicine position stand. Quantity controlled trial. Age and Ageing, 43, 813-820.
C.H. (2011). The diagnosis of mild cogni- and quality of exercise for developing and doi:10.1093/ageing/afu055
tive impairment due to Alzheimers disease: maintaining cardiorespiratory, musculoskel- Li, F., Harmer, P., Liu, Y., & Chou, L.S. (2014).
Recommendations from the National In- etal, and neuromotor fitness in apparently Tai Ji Quan and global cognitive func-
stitute on AgingAlzheimers Association healthy adults: Guidance for prescribing tion in older adults with cognitive impair-
workgroups on diagnostic guidelines for exercise. Medicine and Science in Sports ment: A pilot study. Archives of Gerontology
Alzheimers disease. Alzheimers & Dementia, and Exercise, 43, 1334-1359. doi:10.1249/ and Geriatrics, 58, 434-439. doi:10.1016/j.
7, 270-279. doi:10.1016/j.jalz.2011.03.008 MSS.0b013e318213fefb archger.2013.12.003
American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diag- Gourlan, M., Bernard, P., Bortholon, C., Romain, Lopez, O.L., Jagust, W.J., DeKosky, S.T., Becker,
nostic and statistical manual of mental disorders A., Lareyre, O., Carayol, M.,Boich, J. J.T., Fitzpatrick, A., Dulberg, C.,Kuller,
(5th ed.). Washington, DC: Author. (2014). Efficacy of theory-based interven- L.H. (2003). Prevalence and classification
Baker, L.D., Frank, L.L., Foster-Schubert, K., tions to promote physical activity. A meta- of mild cognitive impairment in the Car-
Green, P.S., Wilkinson, C.W., McTiernan, analysis of randomised controlled trials. diovascular Health Study Cognition Study:
A.,Craft, S. (2010). Aerobic exercise Health Psychology Review, 1-74. doi:10.1080/ Part 1. Archives of Neurology, 60, 1385-1389.
improves cognition for older adults with glu- 17437199.2014.981777 doi:10.1001/archneur.60.10.1385
cose intolerance, a risk factor for Alzheimers Grodstein, F. (2007). Cardiovascular risk fac- Man, D.W., Chung, J.C., & Mak, M.K. (2009).
disease. Journal of Alzheimers Disease, 22, 569- tors and cognitive function. Alzheimers Development and validation of the Online
579. doi:10.3233/jad-2010-100768 & Dementia, 3, S16-S22. doi:10.1016/j. Rivermead Behavioral Memory Test
Chang, J.Y., Tsai, P.F., Beck, C., Hagen, J.L., Huff, jalz.2007.01.001 (OL-RBMT) for people with stroke. Neuro-
D.C., Anand, K.J.,Beuscher, L. (2011). Hahn, E.A., & Andel, R. (2011). Nonpharma- Rehabilitation, 24, 231-236. doi:10.3233/nre-
The effect of tai chi on cognition in elders cological therapies for behavioral and cogni- 2009-0473
with cognitive impairment. Medsurg Nursing, tive symptoms of mild cognitive impairment. Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J., & Altman,
20, 63-70. Journal of Aging and Health, 23, 1223-1245. D.G. (2009). Preferred reporting items for
Cooper, C., Li, R., Lyketsos, C., & Livingston, doi:10.1177/0898264311422745 systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The
G. (2013). Treatment for mild cognitive Hamer, M., & Chida, Y. (2009). Physical activity PRISMA statement. British Medical Journal,
impairment: Systematic review. British Journal and risk of neurodegenerative disease: A 339, b2535. doi:10.1136/bmj.b2535
of Psychiatry, 203, 255-264. doi:10.1192/bjp. systematic review of prospective evidence. Morris, J.C. (1997). Clinical dementia rating:
bp.113.127811 Psychological Medicine, 39, 3-11. doi:10.1017/ A reliable and valid diagnostic and staging
Das, S.K., Bose, P., Biswas, A., Dutt, A., s0033291708003681 measure for dementia of the Alzheimer type.
Banerjee, T.K., Hazra, A.M.,Roy, T. Kirk-Sanchez, N.J., & McGough, E.L. (2014). International Psychogeriatrics, 9(Suppl. 1),
(2007). An epidemiologic study of mild Physical exercise and cognitive performance 173-176.
cognitive impairment in Kolkata, India. in the elderly: Current perspectives. Clinical Nagamatsu, L.S., Handy, T.C., Hsu, C.L., Voss,
Neurology, 68, 2019-2026. doi:10.1212/01. Interventions in Aging, 9, 51-62. doi:10.2147/ M., & Liu-Ambrose, T. (2012). Resistance
wnl.0000264424.76759.e6 cia.s39506 training promotes cognitive and func-
Di Carlo, A., Lamassa, M., Baldereschi, M., Kramer, A.F., Hahn, S., Cohen, N.J., Banich, tional brain plasticity in seniors with prob-
Inzitari, M., Scafato, E., Farchi, G., & M.T., McAuley, E., Harrison, C.R., able mild cognitive impairment. Archives of
Inzitari, D. (2007). CIND and MCI in Colcombe, A. (1999). Ageing, fitness and Internal Medicine, 172, 666-668. doi:10.1001/
the Italian elderly: Frequency, vascular neurocognitive function. Nature, 400, 418- archinternmed.2012.379
risk factors, progression to dementia. Neu- 419. doi:10.1038/22682 Nascimento, C.M., Pereira, J.R., de Andrade,
rology, 68, 1909-1916. doi:10.1212/01. Lam, L.C., Chau, R.C., Wong, B.M., Fung, A.W., L.P., Garuffi, M., Talib, L.L., Forlenza,
wnl.0000263132.99055.0d Tam, C.W., Leung, G.T.,Chan, W.M. O.V.,Stella, F. (2014). Physical exercise
Doi, T., Makizako, H., Shimada, H., Park, H., (2012). A 1-year randomized controlled trial in MCI elderly promotes reduction of pro-

34 Copyright SLACK Incorporated


Aging Matters

inflammatory cytokines and improvements age. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 8, 271-276. Walking or vitamin B for cognition in older
on cognition and BDNF peripheral levels. doi:10.2466/pms.8.7.271-276 adults with mild cognitive impairment? A
Current Alzheimer Research, 11, 799-805. Rosen, W.G., Mohs, R.C., & Davis, K.L. (1984). randomised controlled trial. British Journal
Nasreddine, Z.S., Phillips, N.A., Bedirian, V., A new rating scale for Alzheimers disease. of Sports Medicine, 42, 344-351. doi:10.1136/
Charbonneau, S., Whitehead, V., Collin, I.,... American Journal of Psychiatry, 141, 1356- bjsm.2007.044735
Chertkow, H. (2005). The Montreal Cogni- 1364. Varela, S., Ayan, C., Cancela, J.M., & Martin, V.
tive Assessment, MoCA: A brief screening Seifert, T., Brassard, P., Wissenberg, M., (2012). Effects of two different intensities of
tool for mild cognitive impairment. Journal of Rasmussen, P., Nordby, P., Stallknecht, B., aerobic exercise on elderly people with mild
the American Geriatrics Society, 53, 695-699. Secher, N.H. (2010). Endurance training cognitive impairment: A randomized pilot
doi:10.1111/j.1532-5415.2005.53221.x enhances BDNF release from the human study. Clinical Rehabilitation, 26, 442-450.
Nelson, M.E., Rejeski, W.J., Blair, S.N., Duncan, brain. American Journal of Physiology, 298, doi:10.1177/0269215511425835
P.W., Judge, J.O., King, A.C.,Castaneda- R372-R377. doi:10.1152/ajpregu.00525.2009 Vaynman, S., & Gomez-Pinilla, F. (2005).
Sceppa, C. (2007). Physical activity and Stroop, J.R. (1992). Studies of interfer- License to run: Exercise impacts functional
public health in older adults: Recom- ence in serial verbal reactions. Journal of plasticity in the intact and injured central
mendation from the American College of Experimental Psychology: General, 121, 15-23. nervous system by using neurotrophins. Neu-
Sports Medicine and the American Heart doi:10.1037/0096-3445.121.1.15 rorehabilitation and Neural Repair, 19, 283-295.
Association. Circulation, 116, 1094-1105. Suzuki, T., Shimada, H., Makizako, H., Doi, T., doi:10.1177/1545968305280753
doi:10.1161/circulationaha.107.185650 Yoshida, D., Ito, K.,Kato, T. (2013). A Ward, A., Arrighi, H.M., Michels, S., &
Palmer, K., Bckman, L., Winblad, B., & randomized controlled trial of multicompo- Cedarbaum, J.M. (2012). Mild cognitive
Fratiglioni, L. (2008). Mild cognitive nent exercise in older adults with mild cog- impairment: Disparity of incidence and prev-
impairment in the general population: nitive impairment. PLoS One, 8, e61483. alence estimates. Alzheimers & Dementia, 8,
Occurrence and progression to Alzheimer doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0061483 14-21. doi:10.1016/j.jalz.2011.01.002
disease. American Journal of Geriatric Teixeira, C.V.L., Gobbi, L.T.B., Corazza, D.I., Winblad, B., Palmer, K., Kivipelto, M., Jelic, V.,
Psychiatry, 16, 603-611. doi:10.1097/ Stella, F., Costa, J.L.R., & Gobbi, S. (2012). Fratiglioni, L., Wahlund, L.O.,...Petersen,
JGP.0b013e3181753a64 Non-pharmacological interventions on cog- R.C. (2004). Mild cognitive impairment
Petersen, R.C. (2004). Mild cognitive impair- nitive functions in older people with mild beyond controversies, towards a consensus:
ment as a diagnostic entity. Journal of Internal cognitive impairment (MCI). Archives of Report of the International Working Group
Medicine, 256, 183-194. doi:10.1111/j.1365- Gerontology and Geriatrics, 54, 175-180. on Mild Cognitive Impairment. Journal of
2796.2004.01388.x Troyer, A.K., Moscovitch, M., & Winocur, G. Internal Medicine, 256, 240-246. doi:10.1111/
Petersen, R.C., Caracciolo, B., Brayne, C., (1997). Clustering and switching as two j.1365-2796.2004.01380.x
Gauthier, S., Jelic, V., & Fratiglioni, L. components of verbal fluency: Evidence from Young, M.D., Plotnikoff, R.C., Collins, C.E.,
(2014). Mild cognitive impairment: A con- younger and older healthy adults. Neuropsy- Callister, R., & Morgan, P.J. (2014). Social
cept in evolution. Journal of Internal Medicine, chology, 11, 138-146. cognitive theory and physical activity: A
275, 214-228. doi:10.1111/joim.12190 Tsai, P.F., Chang, J.Y., Beck, C., Kuo, Y.F., & systematic review and meta-analysis. Obesity
Purser, J.L., Fillenbaum, G.G., Pieper, C.F., & Keefe, F.J. (2013). A pilot cluster-randomized Reviews, 15, 983-995. doi:10.1111/obr.12225
Wallace, R.B. (2005). Mild cognitive impair- trial of a 20-week Tai Chi program in elders
ment and 10-year trajectories of disability in with cognitive impairment and osteoarthritic Ms. Cai is DNP Student, and Dr. Abrahamson
the Iowa Established Populations for Epide- knee: Effects on pain and other health is Assistant Professor, School of Nursing, Purdue
miologic Studies of the Elderly cohort. Journal outcomes. Journal of Pain and Symptom University, West Lafayette, Indiana.
of the American Geriatrics Society, 53, 1966- Management, 45, 660-669. doi:10.1016/j. The authors have disclosed no potential
1972. doi:10.1111/j.1532-5415.2005.53566.x jpainsymman.2012.04.009 conflicts of interest, financial or otherwise.
Rasmussen, P., Brassard, P., Adser, H., Pedersen, U.S. Census Bureau. (2012). U.S. Census Address correspondence to Kathleen
M.V., Leick, L., Hart, E.,Pilegaard, H. Bureau projections show a slower growing, Abrahamson, PhD, RN, Assistant Professor,
(2009). Evidence for a release of brain-derived older, more diverse nation a half century from School of Nursing, Purdue University, 502 North
neurotrophic factor from the brain during now. Retrieved from http://www.census. University Street, West Lafayette, IN 47907; e-mail:
exercise. Experimental Physiology, 94, 1062- gov/newsroom/releases/archives/population/ kaabraha@purdue.edu.
1069. doi:10.1113/expphysiol.2009.048512 cb12-243.html Received: August 1, 2015
Reitan, R.M. (1958). Validity of the Trail Mak- van Uffelen, J.G.Z., Chinapaw, M.J.M., van Accepted: October 13, 2015
ing Test as an indicator of organic brain dam- Mechelen, W., & Hopman-Rock, M. (2008). doi:10.3928/02793695-20151109-03

Journal of Psychosocial Nursing Vol. 54, No. 1, 2016 35

Potrebbero piacerti anche