Sei sulla pagina 1di 41

SPONSORED BY ALL GAMING ALL THE WORLD

EYES ON
THE PRIZE
The latest gaming resort security
and surveillance trends
CONTENTS
COVER STORY COLUMNS

4 Casinos Look Beyond Surveillance 36 The Growing and Changing Role


By Paul Doocey, Casino Journal of Casino Surveillance
By Derk Boss, DJ Boss Associates
SPONSOR CONTRIBUTIONS
39 Bolster your Casino Cyber Security
10 American Public University Systems By Chard Pinson, Stroz Friedberg &
15 Cognitec Jason Smolanoff, CISO Advisory & Investigations
18 iView Systems
42 Preparing Operators for Internal Fraud
& Theft with Surveillance
FEATURES
By Derk Boss, DJ Boss Associates
21 Applying Consistency to Complexity
in Resort Security
By Claire Meyer, Security Magazine

25 Eye on Information
By Paul Doocey, Casino Journal
4 25
29 Developing Low-Profile Surveillance
for High-Profile Security Published by Casino Journal, October 2016. Copyright 2016, BNP Media. All Rights
By Claire Meyer, Security Magazine Reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or used in any manner, except as
permitted by the U.S. Copyright Act, without the express written permission of the pub-
lisher. Every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information presented
32 Streamlining Guard Tours with Technology in this book. However, BNP Media does not guarantee its accuracy. Any error brought to
By Claire Meyer, Security Magazine the attention of the editor will be corrected in a future edition.

2
CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
FROM THE EDITOR

C
asino resorts are under constant threat from individuals looking to scam money off
unsuspecting players, employees and operators through cheating, robbery, identity
theft, false damages and a host of other nefarious means. Fortunately, there are cut-
ting-edge products and applications coming to the fore that can make the casino enterprise
more secure. There are also industry experts who are more than happy to share their insight
and knowledge on how to make gaming resorts safer. Articles involving the latest security and
surveillance product applications and best practice advice from experienced executives regu-
larly grace the pages of Casino Journal and Security Magazine, and have been gathered into this eBook
for easy reference and reading. Enjoy!

Paul Doocey
Editor
Casino Journal
dooceyp@bnpmedia.com

3
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
COVER STORY

CASINOS LOOK BEYOND SURVEILLANCE


Surveillance technology is only one of many products and practices casinos should
employ to better detect and prevent increasingly sophisticated gaming scams and cheats
BY PAUL DOOCEY, CASINO JOURNAL

D
arrin Hoke, vice president of operational protection with a light adhesive or colored ink in a pattern that only they
for LAuberge Casino Resort Lake Charles, agreed can detect, an illegal practice commonly referred to as daub-
with his surveillance staff that there was something ing. Unfortunately, this individual left the property before
very odd about the way a Mississippi Stud poker player was they fully realized what he was doing, but from the surveil-
handling his cards. lance tape they were able to capture his image and send a
The player in question was moving his hand under the table warning about him to area casinos.
as cards were dealt, and then pressing two right hand fingers Shortly thereafter, this same player showed up at the LAuberge
against these cards as he was looking at them. Finally, he was sister property in Baton Rouge, where he was once again playing
betting in a way that did not make sense with the face cards he Mississippi Stud and exhibit the same card handling behavior.
was receiving, and he was winning steadily with this strategy. This time the surveillance department had a chance to
To Hoke and the experienced surveillance team at switch their cameras to a UV setting that usually detects the
LAuberge, these actions pointed to someone who was likely inks and substance used in daubing. The cameras revealed
marking the value of individual playing cards on their backs nothing unusual.
4
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
COVER STORY

Despite this setback, LAuberge felt it had enough evidence him daubing the cards. During questioning, someone noticed
to pull this player out of the game and confront him. They he was wearing contact lenses and eyeglasses. He admitted that
searched him and found a cell phone, cash, chips and a con- the lenses were infrared and allowed him to read the markings
tact lens case. The player voluntarily gave his winnings back to he left on the cards.
LAuberge and casino officials, lacking proof of cheating, de- Unfortunately these invisible inks and color matching
cided to let him go. The playing cards used in the game were lenses are readily available online, so you can expect more such
bagged for further inspection. scams in the future, said Hoke to a gathering of security pro-
While examining the cards the next day, someone decided fessionals at the Global Gaming Expo (G2E) conference in Las
to try viewing them through the infrared filter of a surveil- Vegas. The good news is there are tools like security cameras
lance camera. What they found were a plethora of daubing already inside your operations that can help you detect this. A
marks. When they viewed the game felt under the same lens, lot of you already have IP systems; you should also have some
the sport occupied by the player was also covered with notice- kind of mechanism that allows you to toggle back and forth
able smudges and fingerprints. The player had been marking with cut filters. Then its just the simple process of scanning
the cards with invisible luminous ink. The only mystery that table layouts in the various filters to see if there is a problem.
remained was how he was able to view these marks since the It is important to understand there are a lot of technolo-
ink he used was invisible to the naked eye. gies and procedures out there that will have you looking at
The answer came when he eventually showed up to play casino security in a different way.
a Mississippi Stud game at Mohegan Sun in Connecticut. By Indeed, few would argue that surveillance cameras remain
this time, casinos throughout the U.S. were on alert for him, the front line of defense at most gaming properties, and are al-
and when facial recognition software spotted him playing a ways instrumental in uncovering and protecting the enterprise
card game at a Delaware casino, neighboring gaming facilities against cheats. But its becoming increasingly apparent that
were warned. A Mohegan Sun surveillance officer eventually more than just a cutting-edge camera system is needed to com-
spotted him at a table game, cut to an infrared filter and taped bat increasingly sophisticated gaming scams and criminals. In
5
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
COVER STORY

fact, camera surveillance is of limited value in one of the latest


gaming scams growing in popularity across the country.

CHIPPING AWAY
Officials at the Borgata Hotel Casino & Spa in Atlantic City
realized there was a problem at their 2014 Winter Poker Open
when a mid-tournament chip inventory revealed something
strangethere was a lot more money in the game that there
should have been. A close examination of the chips revealed
some were counterfeit, evidently introduced into the tourna-
ment by one of the players. The event was immediately can-
celled and an investigation launched by the Borgata and the
New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement.
A week later at neighboring Harrahs Resort & Casino,
maintenance workers responding to a plumbing issue found
someone had tried to flush $2.7 million in Borgata chips down
a room toilet. The chips were counterfeit and it was quickly
ascertained that a player from the tournament had been stay-
ing in the room. In fact, the man was the day two chip leader
before busting out. It was later determined that he had intro-
duced more than $1 million in bad chips into the game.
Unfortunately for casino operators, counterfeit chip scams
are on the rise. Hanover, Md.-based Maryland Live! Casino was
6
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
COVER STORY

actually hit twice in 2014. One scheme involved a couple that looking for, and get as many as they want sent to them. And
had altered $1 chips from West Virginia casinos to look like now we also have 3D printer technology to consider. I cant
the black $100 chips used at Maryland Live!. They were able imagine it would be all that tough to make a credible coun-
to exchange the fake chips for real ones of lesser denomina- terfeit chip using a 3D printer.
tions at Maryland Live! tables, which they then cashed out at Hoke believes the best way to prevent counterfeit chip
the cashiers cage. The fakes were discovered and investigators crime is to be proactive. To start, properties should purchase
used surveillance footage to trace them back to the couple, chips with modern security features such as UV coding and
who were identified and arrested. microprinting. He also proposes regular chip inventories, with
The second counterfeit chip case was far more alarming the understanding that whole denominations of chips be re-
and potentially problematical. It too involved $100 Maryland placed once a certain percentage of counterfeits are detected.
Live! casino chips. However, instead of doctoring the chips Finally, he suggests table and cage staff be specially trained to
himself, this time the scammer went online and purchased spot and recognize counterfeits.
$150,000 counterfeit, look-alike chips for a reported $12,000. The key to preventing [counterfeit chip crime] is to real-
Eventually, $4,000 of the chips were passed before the cheat ize where they are likely to be passed and have staff in those
was discovered. Forensic surveillance once again uncovered areas trained to identify them, Hoke said.
the people using the chips and a search of their home and
nearby property found $115,000 in counterfeit Maryland Live! SORTING OUT A PROBLEM
chips dumped and floating in a local lake. Training and following established procedures is also key
It was never really all that hard to counterfeit table game in preventing another growing table game concernplayers
chips, Hoke said. Anyone with an arts and crafts back- who use card sorts to gain an advantage over the house and
ground can probably do it. But now people can just go on- fellow players on certain games.
line, search for offshore manufacturers who are willing to Card or edge sorting involves players who are using a defect
make casino chips, give the specifications and style they are in card design to gain an illegal edge, according to casinos. Ide-
7
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
COVER STORY

ally, playing cards should all have the same identical pattern on change some of the rules of the game and now lets see how
the back. But sometimes during the production process, cards much damage can be done.
are miss-cut and the pattern on the back of cards is slightly Besides adhering to rules, Hoke believes sorts scams can
different for different denominations. Some card players are be disarmed by better card security and inspection. Dealers
observant enough to notice these off patterns, and if the cards need to make sure its not an off-pattern deck before the game
are placed a certain way, can determine a range of denomina- begins. Operators should look into cards with fade designs that
tions the card may be without seeing the face. This is especially avoid pushing patterns to the edge, and only do business with
helpful in games such as baccarat, were a small range of single playing card vendors that vouch for quality control during the
cards (6, 7, 8, and 9) are more desirable than others. production process.
However, in order for this advantage to work, at some time
during a game the player needs to convince the dealer to turn INTERFERENCE CALL
cards in a certain way, whether they are winners or not, in or- Flaws in equipment can lead to security vulnerabilities in
der to discern and interpret the faulty edge pattern. On paper, a whole host of table games. The same can be said for slot ma-
this should make the crime easy to prevent. chines as well.
Look at recent sort issues and they all have a common de- On paper, slot machines would appear to be a much more
nominatora high-limit player requests cards be exposed and secure device than table games, especially considering the me-
turned over in a very specific manner, Hoke said. And we chanical and linked nature of the devices which would seem
do it, despite the fact we have rules in place telling us not to, to make any crime against them easy to detect and prevent.
because they are such a great customer. This is a mistake that But historically, this has not been the case. Monkey Paws and
is made consistently because we cater to the high roller and Light Wands have been used to fool video slots in the past. And
that high roller, at least in my estimation, can cause the most now a new generation of slot cheat is looking take advantage
damage to your operation. Think about what a high roller can through the use of electronic communication devices that can
do if they are on a good streak, but then we also allow them to interfere with the function on the machine.
8
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
COVER STORY

We have to realize that there are people out there who with the machine using a communication device linked to a
spend their days looking for ways to get into the slot machine, foreign server, allowed the defendants to predict the behavior
Hoke said. Im relatively confident that the machine program of thegames and obtain winnings from the games that far
is safe. It is the peripheral devices I have a worry withall exceeded what would be expected from fair play.
these other things that now go on a slot that we are not fa- What worries Hoke is that these slot scammers have
miliar with and that can create the environment needed for a been coming to the U.S. since 2012 and have only been dis-
cheater to take advantage. covered now.
To underscore this point, the FBI recently uncovered and It underscores an important thing, Hoke added. We
indicted a team of Russian slot cheats who hit 10 casinos in dont know enough about slots from a surveillance and game
Missouri California and Illinois. The group targeted a specific protection perspective that can prevent some of these newer
type and model of machine and, by allegedly communicating threats from happening. And that is scary.

9
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
SPONSOR CONTRIBUTION

WORKPLACE VIOLENCE:
ITS MORE COMMON THAN YOU THINK
Addressing the growing threat of workplace violence

W
orkplace violence incidents have tripled in the ACTIVE SHOOTER INCIDENTS RISING
last decade, and its now the fastest-growing cat- An active shooter represents one of the worst examples
egory of murder in the U.S. Its also the second of workplace violence. The years 2013 to 2015 saw the worst
leading cause of death for women in the workplace (Bureau of rate of deaths due to active shooters in a two-year span. From
Labor Statistics, 2016). 2000 to 2015, over 1,000 active shooter casualties occurred
In fact, the rates of murder and other violent incidents have in the workplace.
intensified to the point that the U.S. Department of Justice According to an analysis by CNN, the U.S. accounted for 31
declared the workplace as one of the most dangerous places percent of all public mass shootings between 1966 and 2012
to be. Its an escalating concern for employees and employers in the world, despite the U.S. only having five percent of the
nationwide, with many cases going unreported. According to worlds population.
OSHA, 2 million workers in America are victims of workplace Active shooter incidents have tripled in the last eight
violence each year. years, with an event occurring in the U.S. once every three
10
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
SPONSOR CONTRIBUTION

weeks. Alarmingly, you are 18 times more likely to encoun- One option is active shooter insurance. This coverage is
ter workplace violence and an active shooter situation than provides additional financial security for businesses.
a fire. While each policy is different, they may reimburse busi-
ness income expenses, security consultants, medical services,
WHAT ARE THE FINANCIAL AND rehabilitation costs, independent security guards, employee
INSURANCE RAMIFICATIONS OF counseling, public image management, and wages for victim
WORKPLACE VIOLENCE? employees and replacement employees. They may also impart
No amount of training, security guards, and warnings can death benefits to families or other beneficiaries of employees.
totally eliminate the chance of an active shooter launching an
attack. No employers are 100 percent immune from this phe- WHAT SHOULD COMPANIES
nomenon, nor can they totally prevent it and the financial DO TO BE BETTER PREPARED
costs are staggering. Workplace violence researchers assess that FOR WORKPLACE VIOLENCE?
the cost to American business ranges from $6 billion to $36 Despite the escalating numbers associated to violence in
billion each year (FBI, 2011). the workplace (according to a report issued by the National
According to the Workplace Violence Research Institute, Institute for the Prevention of Workplace Violence), the aver-
neglectful hiring and negligent employee retention out-of- age spend on workplace violence prevention by organizations
court disbursements due to workplace violence lawsuits aver- is $4.50 per employee annually. There is opportunity for im-
aged more than $500,000. Jury rulings in these cases averaged provement with regard to workplace violence training, prepa-
$3 million (2012). ration, and prevention.
Workers compensation policies usually omit coverage for Employers can adopt these effective steps to lessen the risk
acts of lethal force or the threat of lethal force. You need sepa- of violence in their work environment and safeguard the lives
rate coverage to shelter you against the aftermath of work- of their staff:
place violence. Identify workplace risk and vulnerability factors. Organi-
12
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
SPONSOR CONTRIBUTION

zations should perform a realistic and comprehensive risk as- safeguard their employees by training them to respond ap-
sessment to identify the security vulnerabilities of the business propriately to active shooters. Seventy percent of active shooter
and facilities to an active shooter event. incidents occur in businesses versus campuses. Training con-
Use security controls. These safeguards may include ducted before such an incident actually occurs will help to bol-
coded card keys and employee photo ID badges for access ster prevention protocols at your workplace.
to secure areas; camera surveillance systems, on-site guard Regular performance of active shooter drills. Drills should
services; and other appropriate security measures such as be established and conducted in such a way so as not to fright-
metal detectors. en or alarm employees. They should have an education focus
Foster a culture of respect and trust amongst work- and be designed to aid employees in retaining information that
ers and between employees and management. Companies may save lives.
must eradicate a bad culture of bullying or harassment by
creating a zero-tolerance workplace violence policy. The PREPAREDNESS RESOURCES
policy should be plainly worded and specify how the em- Department of Homeland Security Pocket Card:
ployer classifies workplace violence, the conduct the policy Active Shooter Response Pocket Card
prohibits, methods for reporting violations, and how these Department of Homeland Security Booklet:
reports will be investigated. Active Shooter Response Booklet
Develop a workplace violence prevention program. This Department of Homeland Security Poster:
program can stand alone or it can be integrated into your in- Active Shooter Response Poster
jury and illness prevention program. Regardless, its essential Active Shooter Preparedness Website
that all employees (to include managers and supervisors) be American Public University System
familiar with the company policy and program. Active Shooter ACTION Online Training Course in
Provide regular workplace violence prevention training. Multi-Hazard Crisis Safety, developed in exclusive coop-
Simply put, its every employers duty of care to protect and eration with the FBINAA
13
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
SPONSOR CONTRIBUTION

ABOUT THE AUTHOR: BIBLIOGRAPHY


DeAnn Wandler is responsible for American Public University Corporate Liability: Sharing The Blame for Workplace Vio-
Systems Center for Applied Learning (CAL) within the government
contracting, finance, and insurance industries.She is also the lence. Corporate Liability: Sharing The Blame for Work-
product manager for CALs Active Shooter ACTION Online place Violence. Workplace Violence Research Institute,
Training Course in Multi-Hazard Crisis Safety, which was developed 2012. Web. 12 Aug. 2016.
in exclusive cooperation with the FBINAA.
Hart, Jay. Saving Lives with a Test: Active Shooter Response
Prior to joining APUS, DeAnn served as vice president of
admissions operations, overseeing the strategic direction Training for Employees. Security. BNP Media, June 2016.
and management of 24 career-college campuses throughout Web. 28 Aug. 2016.
the United States.She has more than 15 years of increasingly
Romano, Stephen J., M.A., Micl E. Levi-Minzi, M.A., M.S.,
responsible and successful experience in all areas of higher
education, including vice president of eduction outreach, Eugene A. Rugala, and Vincent B. Van Hasselt, Ph.D.
vice president of enrollment and director of admissions. Her Workplace Violence Prevention. FBI. Law Enforcement
background includes positions at University of Phoenix, Grantham
Bulletin, Jan. 2011. Web. 9 Aug. 2016.
University, and Vatterott Educational Centers.
DeAnn currently serves on the National Contract Management Table 3. Fatal Occupational Injuries by Occupation and
Association (NCMA) Board of Advisors. She has served as vice Selected Event or Exposure, 2014. U.S. Bureau of Labor
president of educational standards on the Greater Kansas City Statistics. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 15 July 2016. Web.
Association of the United States Army (AUSA) and sat on the Board
of Directors for the Kansas City Executive Women International 22 Aug. 2016.
(EWI). DeAnn Wandler can be reached via T 571-358-3109 | E WorkplaceViolence911. National Institute for the Prevention
dwandler@apus.edu. of Workplace Violence. N.p., n.d. Web. 14 Aug. 2016.
The American Public University System (APUS) Center for
Applied Learning (CAL) provides a wide range of online training
and educational solutions to help public and private organizations
attain their workforce development and performance goals. To
learn more, visit: www.apus.edu/CAL

14
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
SPONSOR CONTRIBUTION

COGNITECS FACE RECOGNITION TECHNOLOGY


SUPPORTS SEARCHES IN VIDEO FOOTAGE AND
REAL-TIME SURVEILLANCE

T
he video screening and analytics technology from use of filters that specify age ranges, gender and ethnicity.
Cognitec, FaceVACS-VideoScan, now allows users to For real-time surveillance applications, FaceVACS-Vid-
perform complex searches and analyses on persons eoScan applies Cognitecs premier face recognition technology
appearing in real-time camera streams and video footage. to compare faces to image databases and instantly find known
The latest product release introduced a user-friendly inter- individuals. Casinos can detect and prevent unwanted behavior
face to quickly import sets of recorded video and then carry in much faster and more efficient ways, as operators can track
out detailed investigations. For example, security and law en- individuals in real time, or receive alerts on mobile devices to
forcement agents can upload the video files of a specific loca- act within the immediate vicinity of a suspect.
tion at a specific time to find possible participants in or wit- On the other hand, the software can identify high rollers,
nesses to a crime. members or authorized individuals in real time. Positive au-
Users can find a person that was previously enrolled in an thentication can alert personnel to provide special treatment or
image database or search for an unknown person and find their allow access to restricted areas.
appearances in multiple videos. Person searches can also make FaceVACS-VideoScan also employs leading-edge face recog-
15
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
SPONSOR CONTRIBUTION

nition technology to analyze the count, flow, demographics as a component of its FaceVACS-VideoScan product, therefore
and behavior of people visible in video streams. Surpassing eliminating the need to identify and source suitable cameras.
traditional video surveillance systems, the technology detects The FaceVACS-VideoScan C5 camera provides optimal image
and extracts peoples faces in live video streams or video foot- quality for real-time face recognition, even under challeng-
age and uses anonymous facial analysis to count individuals, ing conditions, while requiring low computing hardware and
generate demographical information, track people movement bandwidth resources.
in time and space, detect frequent visitors and crowds, and Cognitec will demonstrate the product once again at the
much more. World Game Protection Conference in Las Vegas on February
For example, operators can receive an alarm if too many 21-23, 2017.
people gather in a specific area and measure waiting times to Cognitec develops market-leading face recognition technol-
direct traffic. The analysis of traffic patterns and demographi- ogy and applications for industry customers and government
cal statistics can provide businesses with precise visitor data to agencies around the world. In various independent evaluation
make interior design, advertising placement, staffing and other tests, our FaceVACS software has proven to be the premier
operational decisions. technology available on the market. Cognitecs portfolio in-
Since the technology can analyze a face for gender, age and cludes products for facial database search, video screening and
ethnicity as people approach a camera, it can trigger the dis- analytics, border control, ICAO compliant photo capturing and
play of a targeted message on a digital sign or other advertis- facial image quality assessment.
ing/message devices.
Last year, Cognitec introduced a highly specialized IP video MORE INFORMATION AND CONTACT:
camera with built-in face detection and tracking technology www.cognitec.com | info@cognitec.com
Phone: +1-781-616-0600

16
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
SPONSOR CONTRIBUTION

THE ITRAK PLATFORM STREAMLINES


REPORTING & RISK MANAGEMENT
FOR CASINO RESORTS

S
ecurity, surveillance and responsible gaming opera- subject information, which expedites and improves the inci-
tionsrely on timelyand accurate information, and dent reporting and notification process, with the ability to in-
high technology gaming environments are faced with stantaneously share incident and exclusion information within
handling and processing vast amounts of both real-time and the network of properties by easily identifying and tracking
recorded video information from hundreds of cameras. persons of interest.
iView Systems security management reporting solu- By combining a casinos existing auditing, incident report-
tion optimizes the way you report and manage incidents by ing, investigation workload, and the task of identifying self-
strengthening security measures by mitigating risk and li- excluded patrons and other undesirables becomes highly de-
ability through analysis and reporting of evidence, activities manding.
or events; providing a complete audit trail for accountability, iViews experience with gaming operations provides logi-
compliance & enforcement. cal, proactive security layers which include:
The iTrak incident reporting and risk management soft- Security Reporting
ware platform provides a snap-shot of real-time incident and Surveillance Reporting
18
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
SPONSOR CONTRIBUTION

Case Management Suspicious Transaction Reporting


ID Recognition Patron Trespass Management
Player Risk Analysis and Identification Patron/Activity Monitoring, Alerting
Personnel Management & Dispatch and Custom Notification
Business Intelligence System Interfacing
Mobile Guard Patrol
Detailed Investigations To streamline everyday tasks quickly and satisfy reporting
Facial Recognition requirements with an easy to use interface and intelligent busi-
License Plate Recognition ness logic to simplify the end user experience, contact iView
Responsible Gaming & Reporting Systems or visit www.iviewsystems.com.
Compliance Reporting (AML, etc.)

20
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
FEATURE

APPLYING CONSISTENCY TO
COMPLEXITY IN RESORT SECURITY
For MGM Resorts, having renowned gaming properties throughout the U.S.
and the world means having to broaden its risk awareness
BY CLAIRE MEYER, SECURITY MAGAZINE

T
he Las Vegas Strip, despite being just 4.2 miles in day-to-day matter and during large-scale events, such as city-
length, is a massive economic center for the state of wide celebrations on New Years Eve.
Nevada, and a tourism mecca, drawing more than 40 However, this partnership cannot be expected to serve
million visitors each year. This also paints it as a target for each resorts unique needs fully, and resorts cannot rely on
crime anything from petty theft to more nefarious plots. the public-private partnership alone to gather actionable intel-
In July 2007, the Southern Nevada Counter-Terrorism Cen- ligence which is where MGM Resorts Intel Ops Center and
ter was formed. This 24/7 fusion center a public-private new Corporate Watch Center come into play.
partnership between local, state and federal law enforcement According to MGM Resorts Executive Director of Corpo-
as well as local stakeholders in the area, including casinos and rate Security, Tom Lozich, each resort is practically a minia-
resorts strives to keep residents, tourists, businesses and in- ture city, with many complex events and operations being
frastructure safe. The fusion center collects data and analyzes simultaneously managed. On the Las Vegas Strip alone, MGM
crime trends, and it also acts as a base of operations for resorts Resorts has 10 major resorts, including MGM Grand, Bellagio
and law enforcement to collaborate and share information on and ARIA. The enterprise also has properties outside of Ne-
21
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
FEATURE

vada, including properties in Detroit, Mississippi and Macau, moved toward being entertainment spaces, not just gambling
China. New resorts are currently being built in Maryland, businesses. An MGM Resort is a hospitality company, an en-
Massachusetts and Macau. tertainment company, a convention center, a shopping and
In years past, the main source of revenue for these proper- dining destination and a casino, all rolled into one complex
ties had been casino-based profits, and the business was cen- enterprise. On any given day, the resorts security teams may
tered around the casino accordingly. However, Lozich says, in be managing security for a convention, a UFC prizefight, a
order to remain competitive in a growing market, enterprises high-profile concert, 10 casinos, hotels and the protection of
thousands of guests. Because of this complexity, consistency
was absolutely imperative.
The Corporate Watch Center now operating 24/7 is
functioning as an in-house fusion center. Because each MGM
property is so different, both in clientele and operations, the
Watch Center is a single-stop service station for resort person-
nel (security or otherwise) to report suspicious activity, gain
insight into trends and connect with corporate resources. Law
enforcement also knows that they can reach out to the Watch
Center for information instead of having to chase down the
appropriate security contact at each resort.
A dedicated staff of investigators at the Watch Center mon-
itors the properties and even street views around MGM prop-
MGM Grand is one of 10 MGM Resort properties on the Las Vegas erties, and they gather suspicious activity reporting through
Strip, all of which coordinate security through the companys Intel the robust See Something, Say Something initiative in Las
Ops and Corporate Watch centers. Vegas. They vet that information with the fusion center and
22
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
FEATURE

follow up with law enforcement or security personnel for around time is much shorter when you have one answer point
incident resolution. instead of trying to reach out to all of our 10 properties when
While the Watch Centers establishment was strongly sup- trying to gather information.
ported by security-minded executives, Lozich said that MGM Knowledge is power. Information is power, adds Lozich.
Resorts security is based around top-down support and bot- From this information, the fusion center can then share
tom-up sustainability. threat intelligence or reports of suspicious activity to other re-
Our See Something, Say Something messaging is still non- sorts and stakeholders in the Las Vegas area.
stop for our employees, he adds. At the line level, those are In one regard, we look at the others on the Strip as com-
the employees who can make or break anything that happens. petitors, but from our standpoint, from the security stand-
Maintaining an open channel of communication for employees point, theyre partners. We want to look at how we can gather
and visitors to report suspicious incidents or other events up information, analyze information, for any risks or threats and
through security and into the Watch Center is vital to the resorts to disseminate that information not only up to the fusion cen-
intelligence gathering efforts and mindful leadership. ter but out to our other resort partners. We do know that pre-
The Watch Centers goal is to support and assist proper- vention is job number one, Lozich said, but if a response is
ties vice presidents and directors of security, and we have a needed, having as much detailed, collected information as pos-
de-centralized approach, Lozich said. Our security vice pres- sible enables a faster, more effective reaction.
idents report directly to the property presidents. The property In addition to local threats, the Watch Center is on alert for
presidents are like the captains of a ship, and security is a big any activity around the world that could potentially impact an
factor for them. Were here to assist them in gathering data, MGM Resorts property.
long-term reports and critical analysis, and being that link be- Were a global company, and we have to be mindful of the
tween the fusion center and our properties. security risks in the world that could impact not only our ability
Were also a one-stop-shop for public safety and law en- to function but (our ability) to protect our guests. The Watch
forcement, when they have enquiries. The information turn- Center enables us to maintain visibility in those areas and try to
23
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
FEATURE

look at some of those threats or crises that are occurring. They At the Corporate Watch Center, investigators and law en-
may seem innocuous or may not be of concern now, but were forcement are taking a more global approach, tracking New
looking ahead to see if they could be of concern later. Years Eve events throughout the world. As the ball drops in
This plays out in the security awareness operations on New York City, for example, what incidents are happening that
New Years Eve, Lozich said. For that holiday, MGM Resorts could impact Las Vegas? Would inclement weather in South
activates a separate Intel Ops Center that is dedicated to the Asia impact what could happen in the Macau resorts festivities?
Strip itself. It takes the white noise of all of the data that Generally, how could outside events impact MGM properties?
flows in (surveillance, reports from employees or law en- The casino, entertainment, event and hospitality industries
forcement, crowd management) and determines what is ac- have a unique intersection in resorts, and each resort is unique
tionable, suspicious or deliverable, and pushes that intelli- in and of itself. Having this centralized reporting and analysis
gence out to the resorts. For example, if a show isnt opening center, however, forms a unifying link and resource for MGM
its doors on time, there may be a crowd management prob- Resorts ongoing security efforts.
lem outside, and the theater and security personnel would (The Watch Center) applies consistency, said Lozich.
be notified so they could monitor the situation more closely What we try to do from a company standpoint is apply consis-
and find solutions. Local, state and federal law enforcement tent standards to all of our properties. We have to. That becomes
partners are embedded in the Intel Ops center for the eve- even more critical with the complexity of our resorts Our job
ning, as are representatives from each property and resort is to support and assist security officers and management at each
partners on the Strip. location, and we do that every day.

24
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
FEATURE

EYE ON INFORMATION
Advances in imaging technology and systems interoperability are
transforming the functionality and use of casino surveillance cameras
BY PAUL DOOCEY, CASINO JOURNAL

S
urveillance systems within casinos are designed, in bounds over the past decade. IT people now come to security
part, to deter cheating, theft and other crimes from sessions, which shows you how far the marriage between se-
taking place on the gaming floor and throughout the curity and technology has come over the past 10 years. For
entire casino resort. But to accomplish this goal, security prod- years, convergence was the buzzword you always heard. Well,
uct and system designers, engineers and producers have had now we are converged at least when it comes to IT; computer
to borrow technological advancements in surveillance from technology is firmly entrenched in our industry.
other industries and adapt them for casino use. Pradys observations were part of a session he gave at
As surveillance technology evolves in other industries 2015 Global Gaming Expo that explored emerging trends
such as broadcasting, computing and retail, we take advantage in casino surveillance. During that discussion, he described
of those improvements and apply them to the casino space, two emerging technology trends that are having and will
said Robert Prady, CPP, PSP, CHS, field sales engineer for Axis have an important impact on casino surveillance products,
Communications and member of the ASIS Gaming and Wager- systems and strategiesthe Internet of Things (IoT) and Big
ing Council. Surveillance technology has grown by leaps and Data analytics.
25
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
FEATURE

As defined by Wikipedia, IoT is the network of physical


objects, devices, vehicles, buildings and other items which are
embedded with electronics, software, sensors and network con-
nectivity, which enables these objects to collect and exchange
data. From a surveillance perspective, IoT entails the placement
of Internet and network connectivity into cameras and record-
ing/storage systems. In the past, a surveillance camera was
simply a camera, Prady said. It linked to the VCR or DVD and
performed a simple recording function. Now these cameras
are being linked to each other and to other devices and systems
throughout the casino. This connectivity makes the cameras
and recording systems more intelligent, and that opens up a lot Technology is now available that allows surveillance cameras to
better recognize and identify visitor faces.
more possibilities for us.
Indeed, thanks to IoT, Prady envisions a future where, po- As surveillance product developers and users contemplate an
tentially, some surveillance personnel and investigators can IoT future, they also have to grapple with another potentially dis-
work from home and still provide quality protection. This ruptive technology: Big Data, which is a broad term for data sets
technology also clears the way for creation of centralized sur- so large or complex that traditional data processing applications
veillance offices that can handle the surveillance needs of are inadequate, according to Wikipedia. Challenges with Big Data
multiple casinos wherever they are located in the U.S. You include analysis, capture, data curation, search, sharing, storage,
can also have one casino perform surveillance on a number transfer, visualization, querying and information privacy.
of other casinos, Prady said. You can centralize your sur- Prady describes the current combination of surveillance
veillance operations in one location and can monitor several and Big Data as an information firehose, in which a lot of
other locations. data can be collected and disseminated, but very little of it is
26
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
FEATURE

instantly usable. However as Big Data evolves and its link to IoT ics. It used to be that all the analytics of surveillance information
becomes stronger, he sees it playing a transformative role in has to take place in the server; now, with the right program, it
how security and surveillance systems are viewed throughout can take place on the edge in the camera itself.
the entire casino resort enterprise. The modern surveillance camera can indeed perform a lot
You hear the term necessary evil a lot when it comes to of functions that would have been considered miraculous just
surveillance systems, Prady said. As Big Data and IoT tech- a few years ago. These include:
nology expands, I believe surveillance systems will start to be Wide dynamic range technologyMany surveillance cam-
viewed as an asset instead of just a cost center. Surveillance will eras now contain wide dynamic range capabilities that greatly
become an information collecting asset that can mine data and improve picture images. These cameras can take over- or under-
share the results with marketing, management and other de- exposed images, compress them, map them at the frame or pixel
partments within the gaming resort. Everyone will benefit as level and create a new picture that is sharper and easier to view.
security and customer service improves and loss goes down. Auto-tracking PTZBy incorporating auto-tracking pan,
tilt and zoom (PTZ) in camera, surveillance staffs now have the
PICTURE THIS ability to follow a single patron throughout the property. The
Of course, this Big Data and IoT transformation of security technology is also being adapted to better monitor game play,
departments could not take place without the ongoing techno- with programs that let the camera actually track and count
logical improvements to the central components of all surveil- table game play by recognizing the pips on cards.
lance systemsthe cameras. Simply stated, surveillance cameras Freedom of placementIt used to be that internal surveil-
are now intelligent, thanks in large part to the integration of lance cameras could only be placed in ceilings or on walls. But
computer technology into the devices. Todays IP camera is es- thanks to divided camera technology pioneered by the ATM
sentially a computer that is set in the ceiling, Prady said. Not industry, smaller sensors linked to nearby camera units allow
only can it process information and transmit it throughout the for the placement of very small cameras in a variety of places,
network, it can also accept programs and run advanced analyt- such as the alligator rail on a table game or security bar within
27
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
FEATURE

a casino cage. This allows us to take the cameras out of the number of people entering the facility, as well as track
ceiling and place them just about anywhere, Prady said. when they came in and the general direction of traffic. This
Heat mappingA program that can be installed in newer information can be put into a database to determine visita-
surveillance cameras creates a heat map of the entire casino tion against time of day and other information that can help
that can be used to determine usage and traffic patterns. This marketing departments.
information can be shared with other casino departments to Facial recognitionTechnology is now available that allows
determine which areas of the casino are most popular during surveillance cameras to better recognize and identify visitor fac-
a certain time period, which can help with employee staffing es. This is obviously helpful from a protection standpointif
and marketing campaigns. Heat mapping is really helpful to the camera recognizes someone that is on a black list, security
casino management and marketing departments, Prady said. personal can be notified and the person tracked. The system can
It provides a myriad of information that can be used to im- also be programmed to notice someone on a white list, im-
prove operations. portant customers that warrant contact from a casino host.
License plate recognitionSome outdoor surveillance Wearable surveillancePolice departments across the
cameras can now read and record the license plates of arriving country are equipping officers with wearable surveillance
and departing cars. From a property protection standpoint, this cameras to help combat claims of brutality and other improper
ensures the right car is returned to the right person if the valet is conduct. Chances are these devices will migrate toward casino
used and the condition of the car when it arrived in case there is security personnel for similar reasons. Indeed, there is already
a complaint about damage. License plate reading technology can technology in place that allows casino personnel to use the
also be used as a marketing toolwhen the license plate of an camera function on a smart phone to record interactions with
important customer is read, a notice can go through to the ca- casino guests to the propertys security system.
sino host and property front desk alerting them of their arrival. Wearable cameras are just one of many surveillance tech-
People CountingSurveillance cameras can now be nologies that are evolving and will likely play a greater role in
programmed with an app that allows them to count the casino operations going forward, Prady said.
28
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
FEATURE

DEVELOPING LOW-PROFILE SURVEILLANCE


FOR HIGH-PROFILE SECURITY
In the continually moving environment of a casino, adding covert
surveillance tools proves an unobtrusive way to get unobstructed images
BY CLAIRE MEYER, SECURITY MAGAZINE

I
ts not Spy vs. Spy; its good security. agement in the environment were in casino and gaming.
Despite the installation on numerous ceiling-mounted Cameras can be seen as a necessary evil those black domes
surveillance cameras, important details can still be missed. hanging on the ceiling and you start talking about bringing
If a person is wearing a ball cap, or looking down at his phone, cameras down to eye level, you start having issues about get-
ceiling-height cameras might be unable to provide the positive ting the most cooperation, and thats understandable, Under-
identification needed for investigations. wood said. Were trying to make sure we do this in the most
According to John Underwood, manager of surveillance seemly fashion, not being a distraction, hanging black dome
technology for Cherokee Nation Entertainment, which in- cameras on the wall to look like a black eye on the design of
cludes the Hard Rock Hotel and Casino in Tulsa, Okla., among the building. We wanted to do this in a way that wont disturb
their 10 casino properties, the goal is to get the right surveil- anyone or take away from the experience being marketed, but
lance coverage without disturbing visitors experience. In this, we can do our due diligence in gathering all the information
he turned to more covert surveillance tools. possible, whether thats for data mining with analytics or for
For a long time, this was taboo with operational man- video investigations internal loss prevention or law enforce-
29
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
FEATURE

ment Im able to deploy more tools to be more effective. in the casino, so he prefers ATM cameras activated on
There are three main areas of focus for covert surveillance movement, so they provide another eye-level point of
installations around the casino, Underwood said. view for situational awareness, not limited to footage
DOORFRAMES/ENTRY POINTS: Adding eye-level during the time of the transaction.
surveillance at these choke points for incoming and Underwood also adds more discreet surveillance tools in
exiting traffic enable security less-trafficked areas such as stair-
personnel to maintain more wells. There is an expectation of
accurate awareness of who surveillance in elevators, he says, so
is entering the establishment potential bad actors duck into stair-
and when. wells or other lesser used areas for
CASHIER STATIONS: Pin- illicit acts.
hole cameras or other discreet Yes, by having overt surveil-
tools at these locations enable lance in busy areas, you will deter
security personnel to verify (bad actors) to a point, but if you
identities to help either pre- Tulsa, Okla.-based Hard Rock Hotel and Casino uses
have something covert in (lesser-
vent or investigate ID, tax, or convert products to augment its surveillance coverage with used) places, you may actually cap-
check fraud, as well as to get the goal of making resort guests safer and more secure. ture the incident rather than having
Photo courtesy of the Hard Rock Hotel and Casino
a better image of the visitors to assume that something may have
face as he or she interacts with the cashier. just happened, because youre being a bit more discreet.
ATMs: While ATMs often have covert cameras installed, Underwood was inspired by an analytics program at the
many are only activated during a transaction, both for Dallas Cowboys Stadium, which utilizes video analytics to deter-
efficient searching and to save on storage. However, for mine which advertisements are most effective and eye-catching
Underwood, many ATMs are near heavy-traffic areas to visitors, to find items around the casino that would draw the
30
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
FEATURE

eye and install surveillance there. He works with the market- With so many cameras in play, however, challenges do
ing department for the casino to get fixtures or signage to add a arise. Underwood and his internal team test potential cameras
discreet, covert camera so that when visitors look at the display and tools against a number of parameters and situations. De-
or sign, the security team also gets a clear image of their faces. vices that they do adopt and use must:
If we have a guy who wants to come in with sunglasses Be non-intrusive;
on and pass a counterfeit check now hes got his low-brim Provide a proper image, despite interference from con-
baseball cap on or cowboy hat, and Im now no longer ob- tinuous motion and lights from slot machines, bar ven-
structed by those, said Underwood. Ive been able to provide ues and employees, and smoke; and
to law enforcement agencies or those at other casinos or other Offer options to ease storage burdens, such as H.264
companies tangible data and intelligence to help these people or H.265 compression standards, Zipstream technology,
be caught, prosecuted or at least be able to ensure that we can lowering frame rates or being able to turn off or
work on the next stage of the investigation when they arrive. avoid certain high-storage features, such as wide
Theres no longer the question mark of is this the right guy or dynamic range.
not? Now Im seeing past the brim of that ball cap because Im With covert (surveillance), Im not always seeing inci-
no longer looking from the 24-foot ceiling trying to get the dents in most of those areas, Im gathering information. Im
right angle to see him sitting down Im seeing directly into providing other tangible features of quality video or quality
his face. Also, in working with law enforcement agencies, still shots to provide over to the investigative side and help to
weve become the go-to for any type of video intelligence, identify somebody, Underwood said.
Underwood adds.

31
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
FEATURE

STREAMLINING GUARD TOURS


WITH TECHNOLOGY
A security officer is often one of the most expensive and necessary tools
in a security leaders arsenal, but new technology is helping to maximize the investment
BY CLAIRE MEYER,, SECURITY MAGAZINE

W
hen Mark Paige first entered the security in 1984, In an increasingly technology-driven world, security of-
all security officers reports were hand-written, ficer is really a skilled position, said Paige. In a variety of
with a lack of standardized forms and tedious enterprises, officers can be responsible for monitoring surveil-
storage solutions. Now, as the director of security for Red Rock lance, access control systems and alarms, as well as physically
Resort in Las Vegas, Paige can take advantage of technology- patrolling locations.
based reporting, complete with easy document searching and For telecommunications company TELUS in Canada, Dana
compiling, trend analysis and real-time reporting. Adams, CPP, CISSP, director of security, said integrating tech-
For example, manual reports are time-consuming, per- nology and the services of its own security resources and a
forming an audit can take several weeks, and if a case in litiga- contract guard force through Securitas is the key to successful
tion requires a document of all slip-and-fall cases in the resort physical security. TELUS needs to secure large office buildings
for the past three to five years? That could take an administra- and events as well as hundreds of remote sites and many thou-
tor days. Now, all Paige needs to do is hit a button to collect sands of miles of infrastructure.
report histories. The default is to say we should place a guard there, but
32
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
FEATURE

thats not feasible at a remote site or along all our infrastruc-


ture. Its also not feasible to secure a large office building with
guards alone, said Adams. If you dont leverage your security
efforts with technology, youre going to fail.
In larger buildings, in addition to using security cameras,
alarms, and video analytics TELUS makes use of systems such as
Vision to electronically acknowledge guard rounds and track in-
cidents that a guard must respond to. At smaller sites and along
our critical infrastructure, TELUS makes use of creative solutions
such as security camera surveillance and alarmed doors, enhanc-
ing the security of classic target-hardened physical structures
through active monitoring by trained security professionals.
Its too easy to dump too many duties on the guards with
their boots on the ground, such as asking them to patrol too
many areas, as well as perform value-add functions such as
equipment checks, maintenance and other odd jobs, he said.
Technology helps TELUS streamline their operations while
optimizing security by eliminating busy-work and keeping
guards focused on the important services only a professional
on the ground can provide.
At the Red Rock Resort and Casino in Las Vegas, security officers use
Better technology and better training mean a better re- their Android-based guard tracking devices to check in throughout
sponse. Moving forward, companies are going to demand a the facility, note incidents, attach photographs to reports and more,
providing accountability and insight for the enterprise.
better-trained, tech-savvy guard force, adds Adams.
33
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
FEATURE

And now, security-supplementing technology is moving team can program the tour management devices to ask ad-
outside the command center and into the hands of security of- ditional questions specific to an issue to prompt the officer to
ficers. Guard tour tracking and tools can help enterprises better add more relevant data. A water leak might warrant a simple
audit and monitor security officers efficiency and actions, as information-only report, while a trip and fall might need
well as gain insight into incidents as they occur. Some solutions more context (what was the person doing, was it an employee
even enable security dispatchers or enterprise security leaders to or a customer, what were the results, etc).
request more information from the security officer reporting an This system is a living, breathing organism, and it chang-
incident while it is occurring, reducing the need to wait for a full es with the needs of the client, said Strother. Daily activity
debriefing after an event to gain insight and adjust procedures. paper logs are gone; officers can complete documents elec-
Bill Strother, CPP, is the director of corporate security for tronically, and they can be checked and followed up on more
Weingarten Realty, a commercial and retail property manage- quickly. We use these systems together to maintain awareness
ment company with properties in 21 states. While not every and determine needed action.
property has security through Weingarten, those that do most- There are also auditable trails that accompany each report.
ly utilize G4Ss security officer force as well as Secure Trax If a supervisor sends a request for response, there is a record.
guard tour management tools and Insight GPS tracking. As the security officer moves to respond, his or her GPS coor-
The system helps Strother and other property stakehold- dinates can be attached to that report. As the response is sent
ers better understand what happens at the properties in a back with photos, video or just text, all of that is stored. Hav-
real-time basis. The tools can also be used to alert officers to ing these records electronically available means that Strother
be aware of different things, such as BOLO alerts, updated and his team can be more agile in creating an appropriate to
directives and more. show stakeholders where the challenging areas are.
Security officers can use the tool to complete incident re- At Red Rock Resort, the iView Systems security officer
ports from the field, cutting down on report time and en- tracking system (Tour Trax) enables Paige to better perform
abling officers to add more contextual information. Strothers risk assessments, as the system can accurately show where
34
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
FEATURE

there have been issues in the past, such as trouble spots for slip capability, so if an officer is not responding for whatever
and fall incidents. This helps to improve the accountability for reason, such as a medical condition or injury and cannot
the resort, as the reporting program provides insight into these communicate, the GPS on Tour Trax will give you the of-
trends and can help demonstrate improvement. ficers location, Paige said.
Guard tracking tools can also provide proof of presence at This system has not reduced our security staff, he adds.
locations that are difficult to track without the help of technol- It simply makes the officers jobs easier to manage.
ogy, such as multi-level parking garages. At the resort, secu- The iView system features a number of modules that help
rity officers use their tracking tool to scan different RF chips provide value to the resort as a whole, not just the security
on each level, which can also be used to send new directives function. For example, as of January 2016, Red Rock Resort is
through, such as to check lighting on the third floor or to re- using this system to also track internal maintenance tasks, such
spond to a lost-looking customer on the second. as sweep records to track when areas such as restaurants or re-
If an officer does not check in at all of his or her loca- strooms were last attended or cleaned and by whom. The team
tions in the time allotted, an tour alarm is sent to supervi- member goes into the area and uses his or her Android-based
sion through email or on the system dashboard. The dis- device to note that they are there, and they use a dynamic tour
patcher can make a note of the reason why the tour was system to check their completed tasks off of a customized ac-
incomplete (perhaps there was an incident that required the tion list, which is stored in the system, and then they scan out
officers time), or can investigate. The system also has GPS of the area when theyre done.

35
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
COLUMN

THE GROWING AND


CHANGING ROLE OF
CASINO SURVEILLANCE
BY DERK BOSS, DJ BOSS ASSOCIATES

N
ot too long ago, surveillance departments spent al- What changed? We now have to be concerned about what
most all of their time watching table games. is happening around the world, and how that may affect our
We looked for cheaters, advantage players, and guests, employees, and our property. Its no longer all about
thieves working inside and outside the pit. That was the work- card cheats and small-time criminals. Its about ensuring that
ing model for almost all surveillance rooms, and it worked our employees and guests are not attacked or shot.
then. That was a different world. We never really had to worry about that before. We are
Today, our world is changing. In earlier, and some would in the midst of a continuing threat environment that should
say better, times, our gaming world would not be affected by change how we approach the security of our properties.
what was happening outside of it. The dice would continue to I think a real sign of the times is the recent decision by
roll, the cards would hit the felt, and the wheel would contin- Disneyland and other major theme parks to add security mea-
ue to turn, no matter what happened outside in the real world. sures, including metal detectors and bag checks. Disneyland
Thats no longer true, and probably hasnt been for a long time. and Disney World have long been recognized by security pro-
We just didnt know it. fessionals and the general public as safe places to take your
36
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
COLUMN

family. Im sure that they will continue to be so. But it is in- First, surveillance (and security) should be constantly look-
teresting to note that they did feel that it was time to enhance ing for suspicious individuals or unusual circumstances any-
their security in order to protect their guests and employees. I where on the property. Again, its not just gaming that we have
think we in gaming need to start thinking the same way. It is a to worry about anymore. We should patrol all areas in order to
different world with different security challenges. protect the property as a whole. We need to be on the lookout
We dont have to look far for examples of our new world. for dangerous individuals and situations, and do our best to
Weve had the terrorist attacks in Paris, and then in San Bernardi- respond appropriately.
no, Calif. In Las Vegas, a few days before Christmas, a homeless Secondly, I think it is important to understand that we
young woman ran over thirty-six people on the Strip, killing must be prepared for any of these events to occur. Its certainly
one and critically injuring others. Why? I dont know, and nei- been demonstrated that they can occur. For example, our secu-
ther does anyone else at this point. And its not the first time that rity and surveillance teams must be prepared to immediately
someone has attacked our tourists or employees, or that they react properly to an active shooter. It is, sadly, an event that we
became victims of someone who had an ax to grind and didnt may have to handle one day. Our duty and responsibility in
care who they hurt. Today, security and surveillance teams must that situation is to help our guests and employees find safety.
be constantly prepared for a critical event or emergency, such as We should also be able to provide first aid to those who may
an active shooter, workplace violence, or someone who just de- be injured. Remember, the police will respond as fast as they
cides that theyre going to use whatever they have at hand to hurt can, but they will, on average, be seven to 10 minutes out. And
people. This has become a continuing saga, and unfortunately it when they get there, their first job is to engage the shooter.
isnt going away for a while, if it ever does. Emergency medical personnel will not enter your property
Surveillance isnt trained for that. Maybe they should be. until it is secure. Knowing that, our security and surveillance
How can our surveillance and security departments pre- teams should be prepared to work together to locate, aid, hide,
vent any of these events or scams from happening, and if they or evacuate guests and employees to safety. This requires an
do happen, what can they do about it? emergency plan to be in place, executives and staff thoroughly
37
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
COLUMN

trained, as well as regular drills for all personnel. We must do an event occur, security and surveillance can work together to
this now, not during an actual event. It will be too late. assist guests and employees, and provide intelligence to law
Traditionally, the surveillance department watches the enforcement when it is most needed during the crisis.
money, and the security department takes care of all other se- Our world has changed, and so has protecting our casi-
curity issues and concerns. It is time to change that model. no property. Surveillance (and security) must adapt to these
Surveillance must be included in emergency planning and re- changes. Make it part of your surveillance program to consid-
sponse. The surveillance department brings considerable ex- er, planand prepare for todays security challenges. You wont
pertise, skill and the necessary ability to see all areas of the be sorry that you did.
property at once, providing real-time information to security,
Derk Boss, principal of DJ Boss Associates and a Raving Consulting
law enforcement and other first responders. partner, is an author, instructor and speaker specializing in the
Security and surveillance working together can quickly fields of surveillance training and methodology, gaming protection,
identify potential threats, and apply appropriate countermea- loss prevention and the detection of internal and external theft
and fraud. He is an adjunct instructor for the International Gaming
sures to prevent a critical event from taking place. Should such Institute at University of Nevada, Las Vegas.

38
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
COLUMN

BOLSTER YOUR CASINO


CYBER SECURITY
BY CHAD PINSON & JASON SMOLANOFF

T
he gaming industry has long been known for its Fort their sprawling network perimeters. Its a sad truth: enterprise
Knox-level security. But casinos and online gaming networks must be considered semi-permeable. Operators must
operators are clear targets of cyber attackers, and the be ready to respond to an attack. Some security experts call this
extensive, best-in-class preventative security measures of years notion assumption of breach, but this only captures incidents
past only go so far. of improper access to confidential data. Assumption of incident
A gaming operation could spend a billion dollars to deter reflects the various other risks facing gaming businesses, includ-
an attack, but without effective internal defenses and a compre- ing gameplay hacks, theft of electronic funds, money launder-
hensive, well-rehearsed plan outlining clear attack remediation ing, and cyber attacks that knock online gaming operations of-
and recovery steps, operators will find themselves exposed and fline or cause full-on business disruption.
unprepared when an incident occurs. Gaming industry security programs must be based on the
This new reality means leaders in the gaming industry must assumption that cyber incidents of all kinds can and will oc-
adopt a philosophy that we call assumption of incident. Casi- cur, and that companies must be prepared to fight, survive
nos can no longer hope to achieve flawless cyber security across and recover. Optimizing cyber defenses, while being ready to
39
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
COLUMN

respond to and recover from an incident, is better known as his place of entry into your digital vault? Company leader-
cyber resilience. ship, legal counsel, compliance executives, IT/human resourc-
In practice, this means hunting for signs of intrusion, per- es professionals and security experts must work together to
forming rapid damage mitigation and rehearsing plans for a identify where sensitive and regulated data is stored and make
quick rebound. At the heart is a dedication to resilience, be- sure these systems are tightly controlled in accordance with the
cause the games must go on, the money must be safe and the current threat environment and business needs.
players must have confidence in the game and the house. Have a plan for disasters.In a data breach scenario, seconds
Below are the three key pieces of advice for a realistic, bud- matter. This is not the time to figure out who to call, what to say
get-friendly and effective cyber resilience program for casinos and how to avoid additional damage. Writing and practicing an
in todays when-not-if environment: incident response plan gives a gaming organization the power
Know your greatest risks.It all begins with knowledge. to act immediately in case of an attack. Often this includes iden-
You have to address your greatest risks firstand budget the tifying a team of first responders. The same multi-disciplinary
greatest proportion of resources to these areas. Your first in- group that worked together to identify valuable data should be
clination may be to think about slot machines, chips or cash involved, plus public relations executives. For gaming compa-
and accounts on hand. Yes, these are valuable assets that need nies particular care should be placed on PR, third-party assis-
to be protected, powered on and uncompromised. But what if tance and getting the business back up and running.
table games were forced to close, too? What if the data casi- Public relations and crisis management professionals should
nos possess on players and patrons were compromised? In a be an integral part of the incident response plan, ready to be-
cyber risk assessment, appropriate questions include: Is game- gin providing counsel immediately following the discovery of
play code stored securely? How is the personal information of an incident. For casinos, reputation is everything. To attract
players protected in the gaming environment, and networks of and keep players, customers must believe games are free from
the hotel, retail operations and restaurants? Are there internal tampering and that the money in play and in their accounts is
network barriers that prevent an intruder from pivoting from safe and secure. Competition is tight and trust is a major factor.
40
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
COLUMN

Outside legal and technical counsel are particularly valu- security issues, consider security policy and practice and prepare
able in the highly regulated gaming industry. If you wait until updates for the board. They meet more often if an issue arises.
thegaming commission is headed your way or a lawsuit is filed The gaming industry has the attention of cyber criminals.
to bring them on board, its too late. Thats because one of the Like retailers, a casino holds payment transaction information
primary advantages of engaging third-parties is the opportuni- related to buying chips, hotel rooms, and food. Like a bank, it
ty to extend legal privilege to an investigation as its happening. manages the storage and transmission of vast amounts of money.
Business continuity considerations include planning for the Like a cryptocurrency operation, online gaming businesses may
immediate and professional preservation of data to avoid any offer the possibility of anonymous transactions through the use of
additional losses, having copies of essential data stored else- chips. These risks could lead to paralyzing cyber incidents, and no
where, back-up power supplies and back-up servers. one has the budget to guarantee cyber-attack prevention. The best
Create a culture of resilience.People are securitys weak- answer to these challenges lies in accepting that at some point,
est link. Just clicking on the wrong e-mail or accessing a critical failure is inevitable. Prepare the board of directors, the CEO and
system from an insecure Wi-Fi network can set off a chain of all levels of your companys operations for it. Scream it from the
disasters. Cyber security has to become central to core business hilltops the worst can happen, and theres no doubt something
operations and practiced throughout the enterpriseit cannot bad will. The time to prepare is now. Ignoring the inevitable will
be dependent upon a single tool or the IT group. Therefore, ca- only ensure more serious consequences when it occurs.
sino leadership must evangelize and incentivize security through-
Chad Pinson is managing director and head of office for cyber
out the company. Leadership must take what theyve learned in security, investigations and risk management firm Stroz Friedbergs
the risk assessment and use the incident response team to create Dallas office. He can be reached atwww.strozfriedberg.com.
strong, multidisciplinary security policies that complement exist-
Jason Smolanoff is the president of CISO Advisory &
ing operations and culture. Many of our clients create a security Investigations, an information security, risk management and
committee, with a multidisciplinary composition similar to the investigative firm providing outsourced chief information security
one described earlier, who meet on a quarterly basis to review officer services. He can be reached atwww.cisoadvisory.com.
41
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
COLUMN

PREPARING OPERATORS
FOR INTERNAL FRAUD AND
THEFT WITH SURVEILLANCE
BY DERK BOSS, DJ BOSS ASSOCIATES

T
he nightclub is packed and the music is loud and Unfortunately for him, surveillance did watch the club and
pulsating. did figure out what he was doing.
Bartenders are making drinks and slinging beers as In surveillance, we often talk about training our agents to
fast as they can. One bartender grabs a wad of cash from a cus- protect the property. Knowing how a scam operates is very
tomer, takes it over to his register, enters the transaction, looks important for its detection. This means that a lot of our focus
around to see if anyone is watching, voids the sale and places is preparing our staff to know what to look for. I think it is im-
the cash into his toke bucket. portant that we continue to do this, but I think its even more
The bartenders been stealing for several weeks and doesnt important that we place ourselves in a position to detect the
expect to get caught. He knows surveillance rarely watches scam quickly.
the club, and even if they did, they would never figure out Let me explain what I mean. Nowadays, there is a lot of
what hes doing. He smiles thinking about how much money criminal activity occurring in casinos. There is, of course,
hell have at the end of his shift. Hes still smiling when secu- the traditional cheating at gaming. In addition, we now must
rity grabs him and marches him away. be concerned with losses that can occur (and do) in any of
42
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
SECURITY

a propertys departments or venues. If that is so, then the the property, or who play suspiciously, we must look at to
way we must operate is to find ways to put our surveillance ensure that their win is legitimate. Surveillance must get to
personnel in a position to detect them. If you think about it, those players and stop them, if necessary, before they beat us
almost every scam thats caught is usually reported by a guest for too much money. This is an operational issue that can be
or employee, or is caught by accident. Unfortunately, most resolved quickly. I just make it standard operating procedure
scams are caught too late to prevent the loss of thousands of that surveillance must be notified (via a tripwire) when a
dollars. We just get there too late. player wins a certain amount and require that surveillance
We need to do more besides knowing how a scam works. perform a thorough review and evaluation to ensure that the
There are so many new scams or variations of old ones that play is normal. We evaluate the player at a lower amount to
we can never know all of them. Surveillance must operate detect suspicious activity in order to prevent it from becom-
in such a fashion that we are able to place ourselves where it ing a larger amount.
is likely well detect the activity, regardless of how well the In todays gaming world, with the myriad scams and
scam is hidden. internal frauds that continuously occur, surveillance must
Thats not as hard as it sounds. What Im saying is that in- use their operational procedures to isolate, identify and fo-
stead of randomly moving surveillance cameras in the hopes cus on those issues requiring their attention. Focusing on
that well see something suspicious, we use tripwires and data getting into a position to detect those issues allows surveil-
analysis to drive the surveillance team to where they need to lance to operate proactively and detect losses quickly wher-
be, and allow them to focus their considerable ability and re- ever they occur.
sources on a particular issue or concern.
Heres an example. In table games and slots, we will have Derk Boss, principal of DJ Boss Associates and a Raving Consulting
partner, is an author, instructor and speaker specializing in
players win. Most of them are not going to win very much, the fields of surveillance training and methodology, gaming
and what they do win will be legitimate. They are not of protection, loss prevention and the detection of internal and
concern. The winners who win a lot, who are unknown to external theft and fraud.

43
BACK TO CONTENTS CASINOJOURNAL.COM NEXT ARTICLE
ALL GAMING ALL THE WORLD

would like to thank its sponsors


for supporting this eBook

We hope you enjoyed learning more about


gaming resort surveillance and security trends.

Potrebbero piacerti anche