Sei sulla pagina 1di 6

ISSN 0975-8437 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DENTAL CLINICS 2010:2(3): 31-36

REVIEW ARTICLE

Retention Appliances A Review


Rami Reddy.M.S, Suma.S, Chandrasekhar.B.R, Ankur Chaukse

Abstract
In Orthodontics the stability of the achieved result remains a fundamental issue of concern and debate.
Usually a retention phase is required after active Orthodontic tooth movement to hold teeth in its ideal aesthetic and
functional relation and prevent the teeth to return to their former position. Keeping in mind the importance of
Retention in orthodontic treatment, this article makes an attempt to refresh our knowledge on retainers by exploring
the literature.

Key words: Retention, Retainers, Relapse, Stability.

Received on: 07/06/2010 Accepted on: 13/08/2010

Introduction
In Orthodontics the stability of the achieved Retainers: The retainers in Orthodontics can be
result remains a fundamental issue of concern and chiefly classified into Removable and Fixed retainers
debate. Tirk has said The result of Orthodontic and visible and invisible retainers.
therapy good, bad or indifferent is only evident Removable retainers: The removable retainers serve
many years out of retention (1). Maintaining teeth in as retention for intra-arch stability and are useful as
their corrected positions after Orthodontic treatment retainers in patients with growth problems. The
has been and continues to be a challenge (2). available removable retainers are discussed briefly.
A phase of retention is normally required Hawleys retainer (4): The most commonly used
after active Orthodontic tooth movement to hold teeth retainer, designed in 1920s as an active removable
in ideal aesthetic and functional relation and combat appliance. It incorporates clasps on molar teeth and a
the inherent tendency of the teeth to return to their characteristic outer labial bow with adjustment loops,
former position(3). Stability can only be achieved if spanning from canine to canine. The outer bow
the forces derived from the periodontal and gingival provides excellent control of the incisors even if it is
tissues, the orofacial soft tissues, the occlusal forces not adjusted to retract them. When first premolars are
and post treatment facial growth and development are extracted, one function of a retainer is to keep the
in equilibrium (3). Keeping in mind the importance extraction space closed, which the standard design
of retention in orthodontic treatment, this article cannot do. A common modification of the Hawley
makes an attempt to refresh our knowledge on retainer for use in extraction cases is a bow soldered
retainers by exploring the literature. to the buccal section of Adams clasp on the first
molars, so that the action of the bow helps hold the

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DENTAL CLINICS VOLUME 2 ISSUE 3 JULY-SEPTEMBER 2010 Reddy et al 31


ISSN 0975-8437 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DENTAL CLINICS 2010:2(3): 31-36

extraction site closed. Alternative designs for The whole procedure requires about fifteen minutes
extraction cases are to wrap the labial bow around the of working time and produces a smooth,
entire arch, using circumferential clasps on second inconspicuous, easily fitted retainer that will do a
molars for retention or to bring the labial wire positive job of controlling corrected lower rotations.
extension distally to control the canines. Removable 6-6 Metal retainer(6)
Circumferential clasps on the terminal molar may be The lingual arch is formed of 0.045" hard SS
preferred over the more effective Adams clasp if the wire. Adams clasps are formed of 0.028 or 0.035" SS
occlusion is tight. wire. Bend clasp tails over arch wire so that stress is
Removable wrap around retainer(4) wire to wire and not on solder. In soldering, use
The wrap around or clip-on retainer, which Hydro flame or electro soldering. Heat expendable
consists of a plastic bar along the labial and lingual part of clasp tails. Use solder as heat sink to avoid
surfaces of teeth. A full arch wrap around retainer overheating clasp. Add buccal wires, tubes, lingual
should allow each tooth to move individually, finger springs, ball end clasps, and distal extensions
stimulating reorganization of the periodontal to second molars.
ligament. In addition, a wrap around retainer, though Positioners as retainers(4)
quite esthetic, is often less comfortable than a A tooth positioner can also be used as a
Hawley retainer and may not be effective in removable retainer, either fabricated for this purpose
maintaining overbite correction. A full arch wrap alone, or more commonly, continued as a retainer
around retainer is indicated primarily when after serving initially as a finishing device.
periodontal breakdown requires splinting of teeth Positioners are excellent finishing devices and under
together. special circumstances can be used to an advantage as
Removable cuspid to cuspid retainer (5) retainers. For routine use, however, a positioner does
These types of retainers can be made not make a good retainer. The major problems with
relatively quickly and by untrained personnel. The positioners as retainer are as follows.
construction of the appliance is with the use of two The pattern of wear of a positioner does not
0.025" wires, bent and placed in the embrasure match the pattern usually desired for retainers.
between the lower cuspids and lateral incisors after Because of its bulk, patients often have difficulty
separating medium is placed on the cast. The salt and in wearing full time or nearly so.
pepper method is used to apply a quick- cure acrylic Positioners do not retain incisor irregularities and
covering the labial surfaces from cuspid to cuspid rotations as well as standard retainers. Also,
and the lingual surfaces from first bicuspid to first overbite tends to increase while a positioner is
bicuspid or second bicuspid if first bicuspids have being worn.
been extracted. When the acrylic has set, the retainer The positioner has one advantage over a
is removed from the cast, trimmed, pumiced and standard removable or wrap around retainer it
polished. The acrylic should be cut down on the maintains the occlusal relationships as well as intra-
labial to avoid being struck by the maxillary central arch tooth positioners. For a patient with a tendency
incisors, but left at the incisal edge on the lingual. towards class III relapse, a positioner made with the

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DENTAL CLINICS VOLUME 2 ISSUE 3 JULY-SEPTEMBER 2010 Reddy et al 32


ISSN 0975-8437 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DENTAL CLINICS 2010:2(3): 31-36

jaws rotated somewhat downward and backward may to relieve bracket impingement until the bite can be
be useful. opened.
Thermoplastic retainers: Essix retainers(7) FIXED RETAINERS(4)
Essix thermoplastic copolyester retainers are They are normally used in situations where
a thinner, but stronger, cuspid to cuspid version of the intra-arch instability is anticipated and prolonged
full arch, vacuum formed devices. Essix retainers can retention is planned, especially the mandibular
be placed on the same day the fixed appliances are incisor area. There are mainly four major indications,
removed. The vinyl polysiloxane impression is taken they include the following.
immediately after debonding. Minor incisor rotations 1. Maintenance of lower incisor position
can be corrected by altering the cast, since the teeth An excellent retainer to hold these teeth in
will be slightly mobile. In no case, however, should alignment is a fixed lingual bar, attached only to the
more than two days elapse between appliance canines and resting against the flat surface of the
removal and retainer delivery. Seat the retainers over lower incisors above the cingulum. This prevents the
the incisors with firm finger pressure. If a retainer incisors from moving lingually and is reasonably
will not seat properly, it is usually because of internal effective in maintaining correction of rotations in the
plastic ridges formed by interproximal undercuts that segment. Fixed canine to canine retainers must be
were not adequately reduced. These ridges can be made from a wire heavy enough to resist distortion
smoothed out at chair side with a scalpel. It is critical over the rather long span between these teeth.
that the retainer does not slip easily over the teeth, Usually 28 or 30 mil stainless steel is used for this
but requires a reasonable amount of pressure to flex purpose with a loop bend in the end of the wire to
over the interproximal undercuts gingival to the improve retention. These fixed retainers are
contact points. First the patient may report that the categorized into three generation as follows:
retainer feels tight, but as the material warms in the The three different generations are(8)
mouth this sensation will dissipate. A slight fog may The first generation is designed in plain,
initially appear in the microspace between the round 0.032 to 0.036"blue elgiloy wire with a loop at
appliance and the teeth, but this will disappear within each end. In 1983, this was replaced by a twisted,
a minute or so. three stranded 0.032"wire. The second generation
Essix retainers have proven quite versatile. retainer did not have terminal loops, since adequate
Their flexibility and positioner effect make them an retention was provided by the wire spirals and was
alternative to spring retainers in correcting minor thus neater and easier to fit. This second design has
tooth movements. They can be used to reduce worked well for more than 10 years, with long- term
occlusal forces from the opposing arch when moving bond failure rates of about 10-15%. Although the
posterior teeth with air-rotor stripping mechanics. twisted wire does not appear to be any more plaque-
They can serve as a temporary bridge for a missing retentive than the round wire, some disadvantages
anterior tooth, when thermoformed over a pontic have emerged. First, the largest-diameter twisted wire
placed in the edentulous space on the cast. They can available (0.032") is not as stable as would be
also act as night guard for bruxism and as bite planes desirable. In few cases, it has been dislodged,

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DENTAL CLINICS VOLUME 2 ISSUE 3 JULY-SEPTEMBER 2010 Reddy et al 33


ISSN 0975-8437 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DENTAL CLINICS 2010:2(3): 31-36

probably by the force of mastication and has then Maintenance of pontic or implant space
become slightly distorted. Furthermore, the twists in A fixed retainer is also the best choice to
the wire seem to be less comfortable to the tongue maintain the space where a bridge pontic or implant
than a smooth, round wire is. eventually will be placed. Using a fixed retainer for a
The third generation 3-3 retainer is more few months decreases the mobility of the teeth and
solid and easier to place than the twisted 0.032" often makes it easier to place the fixed bridge.
version. This allows the retainer to conform more Implants should be placed immediately after the
closely to the lingual surfaces of the incisors during orthodontic treatment is completed, so that
bonding, reducing the risk of unwanted side effects integration of the implant can occur simultaneously
due to distortion in bonding of from mastication. The with the initial stages of retention. The preferred
present design also has advantages over mandibular orthodontic retainer for maintaining space for
retainers in which all six anterior teeth are bonded. posterior restorations is a heavy intra coronal wire,
The only disadvantage of the third generation 3-3 bonded to adjacent teeth.
retainer may be that even if the retainer bar is well
contoured at the time of fabrication and the incisors Keeping extraction space closed in adults
A fixed retainer is both more reliable and
fit snugly against the wire, slight labial movement
better tolerated than a full time removable retainer
may still be possible. However, labial movements are
and spaces reopen unless a retainer is worn
generally prevented by the maxillary incisors when
consistently.
there is a normal horizontal overbite.

Bonded flexible wire lingual retainer(9)


Diastema Maintenance
The flexible spiral wire retainers were found to be
A second indication for a fixed retainer is a
excellent in the following indication:
situation where the teeth must be permanently or
In midline diastema cases
semi permanently bonded together to maintain the
Spaced anterior teeth
closure of space between them. This is encountered
Adult cases with potential post orthodontic tooth
most commonly when a diastema between maxillary
migration
central incisors has been closed. Even if frenectomy
Accelerated loss of maxillary incisors, requiring
has been done, there is a tendency for a small space
the closure and retention of large anterior space.
to open up between the upper central incisors. The
Severely rotated tooth.
best retainer for this purpose is a bonded section of
flexible wire. The wire should be contoured so that it
4-4 Crozat retainer(10)
lies near the cingulum to keep it out of occlusal
A 4-4 Crozat appliance has cribs on the first
contact. The object of the retainer is to hold the teeth
bicuspids, recurved double lapping lingual finger
together while allowing the some ability to move
springs and a labial bow. It combines may of the
independently during function. An alternative is a
advantages of other types of retainers and has been
solid wire to avoid the tooth contacts to facilitate
well received by patients. Its advantages include the
flossing, which also can incorporate stops to prevent
following.
deepening of the bite.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DENTAL CLINICS VOLUME 2 ISSUE 3 JULY-SEPTEMBER 2010 Reddy et al 34


ISSN 0975-8437 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DENTAL CLINICS 2010:2(3): 31-36

Firm retention, because of the Crozat clasping mouth. Because no metal wires are used, additional
mechanism. material can be applied to the teeth or the fiberglass
Labiolingual control of anterior teeth to maintain or both. Many patients need only the canines to be
or restore arch form in the lower or upper arch retained. In cases of severe incisor rotations,
Flexible, because it is all wire. It can be left out however, this technique is flexible enough to allow
for months and still fit the incisors to be bonded as well.
Maintenance of adequate oral hygiene, because it Osamu active retainer for correction of mild
is removable. relapse(13)
Esthetic, because only a single labial wire shows. The transparent removable appliance that
The major disadvantages of the appliance can correct individual tooth position during the
are: a- it must be fabricated at a quality laboratory, retention phase. The retainer consists of two
making it cost prohibitive and b- it is breakable. superimposed layers. The inner layer, made of
Molar to molar mandibular retainer(11) 1.5mm ethylene vinyl acetate copolymer adapts to
The molar to molar mandibular retainer is the interproximal areas and covers the palatal and
done with the heavy gauge wire and with the use of lingual aspects of the teeth. The outer layer, made of
molar bands. The advantages of molar to molar 0.75mm hard elastic polycarbonate, covers the
mandibular retainer over a Hawleys or a cuspid to occlusal aspects of the teeth and makes the retainer
cuspid retainer include the following. elastic and stable. The Osamu active retainer is
Allows the mandibular canines and molars inexpensive and simple to make. It is well accepted
to settle naturally. by patients because it is transparent and does not
Mandibular arch can be expanded or impair speech. It can correct individual tooth
contracted positions while maintain close adaptation to the
Rotations can be corrected by ligating the remaining teeth.
teeth to the lingual arch Vander linden retainer(14)
Resin fiberglass bonded retainer(12) The Vander linden retainer is constructed to
The Resin fiberglass bonded retainer was offer complete control over the maxillary anterior
developed by Michael a direct technique that solves teeth, with firm fixation provided by clasps on the
the major problem with cuspid to cuspid retainer and canines. The continuous 0.028"labial arch and left
takes 20 minutes or less with previsit preparation. and right three quarter 0.032"molar clasps are
The system uses glass fiber from woven fiberglass embedded in the palatal acrylic plate. The premolars
fabric or fiber bond. and molars should be of acrylic, except where there
The main advantages of the resin fiberglass are clasps. This retainer does not usually interfere
retainer have proven rigid and impervious. Patients with the occlusion, because most maxillary lateral
appreciate the tooth colored material and the comfort incisors have rounded disto-incisal corners with
that is provided by smoothing the margins with suffient space for the retainer wire on the palatal side.
rubber abrasive points or wheels. Retainer sections Nevertheless the patients occlusion should be
can easily be recontoured, removed or repaired in the checked to ensure that an 0.028" wire can pass

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DENTAL CLINICS VOLUME 2 ISSUE 3 JULY-SEPTEMBER 2010 Reddy et al 35


ISSN 0975-8437 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DENTAL CLINICS 2010:2(3): 31-36

between the lateral incisor and canine without 7.Sheridan J, LeDoux W, McMinn R. Essix retainers:
fabrication and supervision for permanent retention.
causing interference.
Journal of clinical orthodontics: JCO1993;27(1):37-
Conclusion 45.
8.Zachrisson B. Third-generation mandibular bonded
The next quarter century may witness the
lingual 3-3 retainer. Journal of clinical orthodontics:
much needed additional of a more scientific JCO1995;29(1):39-48.
9.Bearn D. Bonded orthodontic retainers: a review.
dimension to the retention literature such as clinical
American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial
reports of the duration of a variety of retaining Orthopedics1995;108(2):207-13.
10.Owen 3rd A. 4-4 Crozat retainer. Journal of
appliances and the observations and opinions
clinical orthodontics: JCO1985;19(3):194-7.
advocated by many orthodontic innovations and 11.Christie TE. Molar-to-molar mandibular retainer.
J Clin Orthod1985 Jul;19(7):500-4.
clinical scholars(15).
12.Diamond M. Resin fiberglass bonded retainer.
Journal of clinical orthodontics: JCO1987;21(3):182-
Affiliation of Authors: 1. Prof. Dr. Rami Reddy M.S, 3.
MDS, Professor and HOD, 2. Dr. Suma .S, MDS, Senior 13.Fernandez Sanchez J, Pernia Ramirez I, Martin
Lecturer, 3. Dr. Chandrashekar BR, MDS, Reader, 4. Dr. Alonso J. Osamu active retainer for correction of
Ankur Chaukse, MDS, Senior Lecturer, Peoples dental mild relapse. Journal of Clinical Orthodontics 1998;
academy, Bhopal, Madhyapradesh, India. 32:26-8.
14.Linden F. The Van der Linden Retainer. Journal
References of Clinical Orthodontics2003;37(5):260-7.
15.Kaplan H. The logic of modern retention
1.Burke S, Silveira A, Goldsmith L, Yancey J, Van procedures. American journal of orthodontics and
Stewart A, Scarfe W. A meta-analysis of mandibular dentofacial orthopedics: official publication of the
intercanine width in treatment and postretention. American Association of Orthodontists, its
Angle Orthodontist1998;68:53-60. constituent societies, and the American Board of
2.Blake M, Bibby K. Retention and stability: a Orthodontics1988;93(4):325-40.
review of the literature. American Journal of
Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics 1998; Address of Corresponding Author
114(3):299-306.
3.Melrose C, Millett D. Toward a perspective on Prof. Dr. Rami Reddy M.S, MDS
orthodontic retention? American Journal of Head of the Department,
Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics 1998;
113(5):507-14. Department Of Orthodontics,
4.Proffit W, Fields H, Sarver D. Contemporary Peoples Dental Academy, Peoples Campus,
orthodontics: Mosby Inc; 2007.
5.Knierim R. Invisible lower cuspid to cuspid Bhanpur, Bhopal, Madhyapradesh, India.
retainer. Angle Orthod1973;43:218-9. Phone: +0091.8008857945
6.Hoffman. CS. Technic clinic. A back-action arch. J
Clin Orthod1973 Aug;7(8):520-1. E-Mail: morarami@yahoo.co.in

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DENTAL CLINICS VOLUME 2 ISSUE 3 JULY-SEPTEMBER 2010 Reddy et al 36