Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
T
he cultural demographics within schools are the cultures, while not havingfiallownership in
changing and appreciadng the implicadons of any. Although elements fiom each culture are
these changes is important for school counselors assimilated into the TCK's life experience, the
in the delivery of an effecdve, comprehensive, devel- sense of belonging is in reladonship to others of
opmental school counseling program (American similar background. (Pollock & Van Reken,
School Counselor Association [ASCA], 2005; 2001, p. 19)
Owens, Bodenhorn, & Bryant, 2010). However,
school counselors are challenged to gain knowledge Therefore, the first culture for TCKs is their par-
and understanding of the ever-changing ctiltural dif- ents' home country (or countries); the second cul-
ferences among students and stakeholders and mod- ture is the one they are raised in during their primary
ify their counseling skills and delivery of services to developmental years (Gilbert, 2008); and their third
match their students' diverse needs (Holcomb- ctilture (intersddal culture) is an abstract culttu-e that
McCoy, 2004). Therefore, the development of is created from their shared experiences and rela-
school counselors' muldcultural competencies and donships with people fiom other cultures living the
ability to employ culturally sensidve and creadve same lifestyle (Pollock & Van Reken, 2001). "The
counseling strategies is paramount to the delivery of 'third' culture refers to a created ctilture that is nei-
an effecdve school counseling program (Alexander, ther the 'home' culture nor the 'host' culture; it is
Kruczek, & Ponterotto, 2005; ASCA, 2010; the culture between cultures" (Walters & Auton-
Popadiuk & Ardiur, 2004). Cuff, 2009, p. 755). Hence, defining die first two
A populadon of students about which limited cultures is simplisdc, but conceptualizing the third
research has been published in the counseling field is culture is complex and unique. The third culture is
third culture kids (TCKs). The term TCKs was orig- an abstract definidon; however, understanding and
inally developed in the 1950s by sociologists John appreciadng these three cultures is valuable for
school counselors in their work with this student
Dodie Limberg is a doctoral student in the Department populadon.
of Educational and Human Sciences, University of The purpose of this rdele is to (a) provide school
Central Florida. E-mail: dlimberg@knights.ucf.edu counselors with knowledge regarding TCKs, (b)
Glenn W. Lambie is an associate professor, also with the describe the transidonal stages TCKs experience,
Department of Educational and Human Sciences, and (c) discuss pracdcal school counseling strategies
University of Central Florida. to support these students' academic achievement
1S:1 O C T O B E R 2 0 1 1 I ASCA 45
and hoUsdc development. School counselors may set of skiUs, disposidons, and behaviors that support
transfer informadon regarding TCKs to immigrant counselors in promodng effecdve services to all their
students, as many qualides and educadonal needs of students and stakeholders (Parham, 2002).
these two student populadons are simUar. This ard- Multicultural counseling competencies' include
cle also provides a case iUustradon of a middle school school counselors' (a) awareness of their own beUefs
counselor working with a TCK and employing the and atdtudes toward diverse cultures and people, (b)
suggested school-based strategies. knowledge and appreciadon of diverse cultures, and
(c) counseUng skiUs to address the diverse needs of
THIRD CULTURE KIDS their students and stakeholders (ASCA, 2010; Sue,
1992). Thus, school counselors require knowledge
A broader definidon of TCKs includes immigrant and understanding of TCKs, self-reflecdon when
chUdren who Uve in a culture that differs in eco- working with TCKs, and counseUng strategies that
nomic status, educadonal resources, or poUdcal foster these students' funcdonaUty and achievement.
views (Lee, Bain, & McCaUum, 2007). The term All school counselors have an ethical obUgadon to
TCKs may be appUed to all social classes and provide competent and effecdve services to their
includes immigrant and refugee students (Dewaele students. SpecificaUy, the American CounseUng
8c van Oudenhoven, 2009). A disdncdon between Associadon (ACA, 2005) Code of Ethics state that
immigrant students and TCKs is that immigrant stu- "Counselors acdvely attempt to understand the
Third culture kids dents remain in the country to which they immi- diverse cultural backgrounds of the cUents they
grated more often than TCKs (Lytde, Barker, & serve" (p. 4). Addidonally, die ASCA (2010) Ethical
are defined as CornweU, 2011). However, the experiences of Standardsfor School Counselors advocates that ethical
TCKs are similar to new immigrant non-western counselors "monitor and expand personal muldcul-
students raised in a students' experiences when they relocate to western tural and social jusdce advocacy awareness, knowl-
countries (Cockburn, 2002). Hoefner, Rydna, edge and skiUs. School counselors strive for exem-
culture different Baker, and Monger (2010) reported that approxi- plary cultural competence by ensuring personal
mately 1.7 miUion immigrant children (legal and beUefs or values are not imposed on students or
from that of their unauthorized) under the age of 18 were Uving in the other stakeholders" (Standard E.2.a). Furthermore,
United States. Addidonally, an increase in immigra- the Council for Accreditadon of Counseling and
parents or primary don, globalizadon, internadonal business, and mili- Related Educadonal Programs (CACREP, 2009)
tary placement has resulted in families relocadng to Standards note that a competent school counseUng
caregivers. other countries (Dewaele & van Oudenhoven, student "understands muldcultural counseling
2009). Many famiUes relocate temporarily or immi- issues, as weU as the impact of ability levels, stereo-
grate to a new country for professional opportuni- typing, famUy, socioeconomic status, gender, and
des; therefore, growing up in another culture is sexual idendty, and their effects on student achieve-
prevalent (Cockburn, 2002). The children of these ment" (p. 42). Therefore, school counselors and
families can be defined as TCKs because they are Uv- school counselor educators have a professional
ing and receiving educadon in a country that differs responsibiUty to learn about TCKs and their diverse
from their first culture. The number of TCKs in needs.
schools has increased; homogenous cultures in
TCKs have common characterisdcs in their idend-
schools are an excepdon (PoUock & Van Reken,
ty development and experiences during transidon
2001). School counselors working in Internadonal
between cultures (e.g., Cockburn, 2002; Fail,
Schools and Department of Defense Schools often
Thompson, & Walker, 2004; Gilbert, 2008; Hervey,
work with TCKs, and counselors in the United
2009; PoUock & Van Reken, 2001; Useem &
States work with TCKs entering or re-entering
Downie, 1976); however, these qualides are gener-
schools due to a family's relocadon. Therefore,
alizadons that should not be used to label or cate-
school counselors need to possess the awareness,
gorize individual students. Nevertheless, under-
knowledge, and skills to support the diverse needs of
stancUng of TCKs' idendty development and transi-
TCKs in new academic environments (Holcomb-
donal experiences is necessary for school counselors
McCoy, 2004).
to provide both ethical and effecdve services to these
students.
An Ethical Obligation to Third Culture Kids
All educators (e.g., administrators, teachers, coun- Third Culture Kids' Identity Development
selors) have both an ethical and professional respon- Students' culture influences aU aspects of their devel-
sibiUty to promote a safe and culturally competent opment. Students come to school ftom diverse cul-
school cUmate to support the hoUsdc development tures and subcultures, impacdng their thoughts,
of all students (ASCA, 2010; Buder, 2003). For die feelings, and behaviors (Buder, 2003). Adler (1977)
purpose of this ardcle, competencies are defined as a defined cultural idendty as "the symbol of one's
The Role of the School Counselor with Third School counselors' awareness of the negative
Culture Kids during Transitional Stages impact transition may have on TCKs is crucial. Fail
Schools serving TCKs should be able to identify both and colleagues (2004) found in their qualitative TCKsappear to feel
the negative and positive impacts on TCKs when two investigation that TCKs reported feeling like out-
cultures combine to create a third culture siders at school in their first culture, and had no real at home in most
(Cockburn, 2002). Attending a new school in a stu- sense of belonging. When students return to their
dent's own country is difficult enough, but this chal- first culture, they experienced reverse culture shock cultures, but a true
lenge increases and becomes more intimidating for and questioned their sense of belonging (Fail et al.,
students transitioning to a new school in another 2004; Hervey, 2009). American-born TCKs who sense of belonging,
country where the language of instruction may be an moved back to the United States identified that their
additional change (Dixon 8c Hayden, 2008). The transition was difficult due to their unmet expecta- comfort, and
concept of change becomes an expectation and is one tions of how their return to their first culture would
of the few constants in TCKs' lives (Gilbert, 2008). be (Hervey, 2009). The lack of understanding of reassurance occurs
School provides an environment for TCKs to cultural context may impede TCKs' creative prob-
increase their social skills and provides students with lem-solving skills in social and academic situations. when they are with
a consistent social community (Cockburn, 2002). Lee and colleagues (2007) suggested providing
This article identifies and reviews general descriptors TCKs with explicit instruction in the classroom in people who have
of TCKs (Pollock 8c Van Reken, 2001; Useem 8c order to enhance their creative problem-solving
Downie, 1976); however, empirical support for spe- skills. Davis and colleagues (2010) found that TCKs had similar
cific interventions for TCKs is limited (Davis et. al., showed a decrease in levels of depression, anxiety,
2010). Nevertheless, counselors need to be equipped and stress and an increase in levels of functioning experiences.
with school-based strategies to support TCKs' aca- when they participated in a school-based transition
demic, personal-social, and vocational development. program. Hervey (2009) compared transitions dur-
15:1 O C T O B E R 2 0 1 1 | ASCA 51
clarified the type of instruction and currictilum used ing activity for the school. Another opportxmity for
in the school; and (c) reviewed logistical school pro- students to educate their peers about their first cul-
cedures, such as school policies, attendance, class- ture was during scheduled school assemblies. I asked
room behavior, and extra-curricular activities. We Camron to do a small presentation about his cul-
also discussed and clarified student and parental ture, with other TCKs, at the upcoming assembly. I
expectations. I invited Camron's ESL teacher to the was also part of the committee that organized a
TCKs showed a
meeting, briefly, to allow them time establish a con- diversity week to promote cultural awareness within
nection. the school.
decrease in levels of
Next, I created a brief fact sheet about Camron, With other school leaders, I co-led a cultural trip.
depression, anxiety, including where he lived previously, his likes/dis- These semi-structured trips consisted of one or
likes, his schedule, any academic and/or social con- more days and all students (TCKs and non-TCKs)
and stress and an cerns, and anything else Camron and his family were invited to attend. Camron attended a multi-
wanted his teachers to know. The fact sheet was day trip that included camping in the national park,
approved by Camron and his parents then provided a tour of many famous sites, and dinner at tradition-
increase in levels of
to all of Camron's teachers and the administration al restaurants. All students who went on this trip
before Camron's first day of school. The factilty at were assigned to complete a self-refiection of what
functioning when
my school had already received professional devel- they learned about culture and themselves. The
opment training on multicultural issues and TCKs. funding of this trip was provided by the district, the
they participated in PTA (Parent Teacher Association), and SGA
(Student Government Association). Parents/care-
a school-based Entering Transitional Stage
givers were also asked to donate, but were not
The second transitional phase that Camron experi-
enced included adjusting to and living in the new required to financially support the trip.
transition program.
culture. The goal during the entering stage was to I was involved in a unique program called the
allow Camron opportunities to embrace his new cul- Faculty Family Program, which replaced an advisory
ture (the second culture), keep a connection to his class. In the program, each member of the faculty
first culture, and understand and develop the third was paired with another faculty member and was in
culture. On Camron's first day of school, I assigned charge of eight to ten students. The factilty members
him to the buddy program, which was a peer-to- were the "parents" and the students were the "chil-
peer program to develop connections between stu- dren." The "families" would meet once a week for
dents to make the transition easier for TCKs. an hour to discuss academics and, more important-
Current students (TCKs and non-TCKs) were nom- ly, social and personal issues. The families would also
inated by a teacher to be a buddy and, after being celebrate birthdays together, have family ltmcheons
nominated, would choose whether to participate in together, and sometimes travel together on a day
the program. AH buddies completed a two-day train- trip. The Faculty Family model provided TCKs a
ing co-led by a teacher and me, and I was responsi- consistent and stable group that they cotild use as a
ble for all aspects of the program. At the beginning resource. The Faculty Family also allowed students
of the year, the program held a buddy day trip to a ftom many cultures to interact and be exposed to
location that exemplified the local culture. different cultural family dynamics and traditions.
Unfortunately, Camron arrived in the middle of the The Factilty Family may not be pragmatic in all
year so he was not able to attend the buddy trip. schools, but was a significant experience for myself
Throughout the year, buddies were assigned to new and my students.
TCKs when they arrived, and I would host buddy
luncheons. I also encouraged Camron to join the Leaving Transitional Stage
Friendship Circle, which was a group of TCKs and The final phase Camron experienced was leaving our
students dealing with friendship issues that met school and going back to Peru, his first culture.
every other week during lunch. Before his departure, I arranged for Camron to
I was part of the leadership team for events that spend time in my office during homeroom and
allowed Camron to keep a connection to his first ltmch with his closest friends or anyone who would
culture and be exposed to the second culture. One like to say goodbye. I provided Camron with a
event was International Night, an exhibit event in school t-shirt and journal in which students could
which each student or group of students had a table write farewell notes or their contact information. If
to display items from his or her first culture. The this goodbye meeting ran over into class time, I
exhibits included food and musicfi-omthe student's allowed extra time because it magnified the impor-
first culture. Non-TCKs also participated in this tance of closure. I informed the teachers that
event by contributing with their ancestors' culture. Camron would be leaving, allowing them time to
International Night was an evening event partnered say goodbye as well. Camron's homeroom teacher
with a choral and band concert, and was a fundrais- and Factilty Family gave Camron a simple going-