Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Apogee Components, Inc. Your Source For Rocket Supplies That Will Take You To The Peak-of-Flight
3355 Fillmore Ridge Heights
Colorado Springs, Colorado 80907-9024 USA
www.ApogeeRockets.com e-mail: orders@apogeerockets.com
You can subscribe to receive this e-zine FREE at the Apogee Writer: Tim Van Milligan
Components web site (www.ApogeeRockets.com), or by Layout / Cover Artist: Tim Van Milligan
sending an e-mail to: ezine@apogeeRockets.com with SUB- Proofreader: Michelle Mason
SCRIBE as the subject line of the message.
Why Doesnt The Ares 1-X Have Fins? The thrust will control
the up movement of the
rocket, but it is the swiveling
of the nozzle that controls
the rockets movement to the
upwind/downwind, cross-wind,
and the orientation of the
rocket with respect to the pitch
and yaw axis. That is ve out
of the six degrees of freedom
of the rocket as shown in
Figure 4 (see Newsletter 186
at www.ApogeeRockets.com/
Education/Downloads/News-
Figure 2: An outboard motor on a boat uses gimbal
letter186.pdf for more informa-
system control to steer the boat.
tion about what 6 Degrees-of-
creates a thrust force that pushes the boat forward in the Freedom means).
water. The motor can be turned side-to-side to direct the
The movable nozzle of the Figure 3: The Ares 1-X
thrust force. Once it is turned, the boat turns too.
Ares 1 is ofcially called the rockets nozzle can point
Where the boat moves through water, the rocket moves Thrust Vector Control system, in any direction to control
through air. But the principle of how it is steered is exactly or TVC system for short. It the rockets trajectory
the same. Orient (or turn) the nozzle to the right, and the shares the same two hydraulic
rocket will also turn to the right. Turn it to the left, and the actuators as used on the Space Shuttle. These hydraulic
rocket goes to the left. rams literally push on the nozzle to move it side-to-side.
The one big difference is that the boat can only swivel Since it is the same hardware as the Space Shuttle, I antici-
left or right. This is the yaw axis of the boat. A rocket pate that the deection of the nozzle on the Ares is similar.
nozzle can also pivot up/down (along the pitch axis). Basi- The NASA web site does not state the gimbal angle, so I
cally, it can point the rocket in any direction you might want had to dig this information out from other sources.
it to go in space.
Continued on page 4
www.ApogeeRockets.com/Scale_Rocket_Kits.asp
Why Doesnt The Ares 1-X Have Fins? Model rocketeer Matt Steele, who worked
on the Space Shuttle, helped me to nd this
information. The criteria for the Space Shuttles
TVC system is this:
The SRB TVC subsystem shall have
a gimbal angle capability of 5 in both the
actuator extend and retract directions. The
Flight Control System software shall limit the
gimbal angle to 2 or less in both directions
for all times less than SRB ignition command
plus 2.5 seconds. For all times greater than
SRB ignition command plus 2.5 seconds,
the FCS shall limit the gimbal angle to 4.5
in both directions.
What this means is that for the rst 2.5
seconds of ight, they dont want the nozzle to
move very much (less than 2). Why not? Be-
cause you dont want the rocket steering itself
into the gantry. Makes sense, doesnt it? 5 Maximum
Deflection
www.ApogeeRockets.com
Roam In Our Forest of Over 170 Different Types
Unique and exotic kits
from over 20 different
manufacturers
Skill Levels range from
easy to endish
Sizes from 1/4A motor
to level-2-high-power
We build & y them to
nd out what theyre
like, saving you grief
More new ones arriv-
ing all the time
Educational bulk packs
available too
www.ApogeeRockets.com/All_rocket_kits.asp
Page 4 ISSUE 248 NOVEMBER 17, 2009
Continued from page 4
Why Doesnt The Ares 1-X Have Fins? the Thrust Vector Control system do on the ight?
Matt says that you have to leave some room for error in I asked a friend at NASA, and he shared some of the
the system, in case the actuators push a little too fast and actual ight data for the rocket. Figure 6 is a chart that
accidentally overshoot. I would be willing to bet that there shows how far the nozzle was rotated at any point during
is some sort of hard-stop, or a block of steel that prevents the entire ight. The top chart shows the chamber pressure
it from ever going past 5. If the nozzle ever had to go that inside the solid rocket motor. This gives you some indica-
far, there is something seriously wrong in the trajectory, and tion of where lift-off was, and when burn-out occurred.
the rotation of the rocket in an attempt to correct it would be You can see from the bottom two charts that about 30
so fast that it could probably knock the astronauts uncon- seconds prior to lift-off, the hydraulic pump is turned on,
scious. and then the two actuators that controlled the tilt-angle of
With the rst launch of the Ares now behind us, how did
Continued on page 6
B
G H
D
A F
E
B
D
A F
Figure 6: Actual ight data from the Ares 1-X launch. Top: Chamber pressure inside the solid motor. Middle and
bottom: The nozzle deection in degrees on the rock and tilt actuators. They are called rock and tilt
instead of pitch and yaw because they are from shuttle and are oriented 45 from the actual pitch and yaw
axes. Callouts: A) Hydraulic actuators turned on. B) Actuators slewed to test the control system. C) Ignition of the
motor. D) The motions during the rst 10 seconds are a tower clear manuever, followed by a pitch&roll to align
the vehicle onto the planned trajectory. E) Peak deection of the actuator. F) While it is hard to see, during this
portion, there are the 3 programmed test input manuevers lasting 10 seconds each, followed by a step function
(just before it smooths out) for data gathering purposes. G) Calmest portion of the ight. H) Actuators deect
more because thrust level is dropping off at the end of the burn.
ISSUE 248 NOVEMBER 17, 2009 Page 5
Continued from page 5
Why Doesnt The Ares 1-X Have Fins? sonic at T+39, and Max Q was T+55.
the nozzle are intentionally tested by slewing the nozzle You might be asking who is Marc Lavigne. Youll be
in both directions by exactly 1 degree. This is actually a proud to know that hes another rocket modeler, who hap-
very critical test. If the nozzle does not respond correctly, pens to be the guy you heard in the background giving the
the computer onboard the rocket will sense the failure, and ofcial description of the launch on NASA TV. Marc, aka:
the countdown will be aborted before the motor is ignited. Moose, is a dear friend, and if you were at the NARAM-50
Why? Because once the solid motor starts ring, there is no reunion in 2008, you probably met him there. He is pictured
way to stop it until it burns out of all its propellant. So it is in Newsletter 238 (www.ApogeeRockets.com/education/
mission critical that the steering system be glitch-free and downloads/Newsletter238.pdf). It is so cool that the guys in
fully operational before the thrust from the motor kicks in. control in the real space program are also model rocketeers
As the motor was ignited, there appears to be a spike and are just like you and I. If youre a parent or a teacher,
in the position of the nozzle in both the pitch and the yaw youll be happy to know that the model rocketry that your
direction. This is probably because the entire rocket is students are doing today is a great stepping stone to help
shaking a little bit because it was jarred by the spike in them get a good job in the future. Thats why youre glad
pressure inside the motor. The nozzles reacted instantly to you came to Apogee Components for your rocketry knowl-
this. edge and supplies, isnt it?
The farthest deection of the nozzle during the ight There are a couple of other things that you can pick up
was nearly 2, and occurred about 20 seconds after igni- from the ight data charts that are of interest. Toward the
tion. My own personal guess was that might be the added end of the ight (about 30 seconds prior to engine burn-
stress on the rocket when it was going through Max Q. out), is the quietest portion of the ight, where the nozzle
Max Q stands for maximum dynamic pressure. This is the movement is the smallest. That makes sense, doesnt it? At
point in the ight when the aerodynamic forces acting on that point in the ight, the rocket is so high that it is above
the rocket are at their peak. It is the most stressful part of most of the atmosphere. There arent hardly any aerody-
the entire ight, except for maybe the moment of ignition. namic forces on the rocket trying to push it off its intended
path.
I asked Marc Lavigne what happened at this time dur-
ing the ight. He said it was probably the rocket reacting During thrust tail-off, which begins about 10 seconds
to a wind shear. He mentioned that the rocket went super- before burnout (the point where the chamber pressure
Continued on page 7
Figure 7: The Ares 1-X immediately performed a pitch manuever on lift-off in order to avoid strking the shuttle
gantry. The heat from the exhaust toasted the tower so intensely, that the elevators were rendered inoperable.
Page 6 ISSUE 248 NOVEMBER 17, 2009
Continued from page 6
For more information, and to order this hefty book, visit the Apogee web
site at: www.ApogeeRockets.com/design_book.asp
Apogee Components
3355 Fillmore Ridge Heights
Colorado Springs, Colorado 80907 USA
telephone: 719-535-9335
website: www.ApogeeRockets.com
Launch It.
v9
www.RockSim.com
Space Foundation certied
as an excellent teaching aid. For further information, call Apogee Components at: 719-535-9335.
www.ApogeeRockets.com
Reusable Rocket Motors Save Money
Holds Aerotechs Reload Propellant
Sizes: 24mm To 98mm Diameter
Power Range: E Through N
Cases For Any Project
Rouse-Tech Quality
Affordable!
www.ApogeeRockets.com/Rouse-Tech_Monster_Motors.asp
ISSUE 248 NOVEMBER 17, 2009 Page 9
Continued from page 9
www.ApogeeRockets.com
Wont Shatter Like Brittle Phenolic Tubes!
Super Smooth Surface With Tight Spirals
Standard LOC Diameters Up To 6 inches
Cut and Slot With Standard Tools
No Fiberglass Wrap Needed
Sands and Paints Easily
Cheaper than Fiber-
glass
www.ApogeeRockets.com/blue_tubes.asp
Page 10 ISSUE 248 NOVEMBER 17, 2009
Continued from page 10
Why Doesnt The Ares 1-X Have Fins? frustrum cone, they are there to ensure that the booster
of the video frame. This is the roll control motor pulsing on. tumbles as it falls back to earth.These motors were actual
It only lasts about a frame or two, so dont blink, or youll live motors and did re on this ight to get the whole rocket
miss it. for tumbling.
Other Rocket Motors On the Ares 1-X Other Ares Rocket Motor Trivia
When I rst saw a picture of the Ares 1-X rocket, I saw Did you know how slow the Ares 1 takes off? The ac-
some rocket motors on the frustrum cone that transitions celeration of the rocket is only 2.48 gees. That is slower
the fat part of the rocket to the smaller diameter of the solid than the Space Shuttles 3g lift-off acceleration and the 4
rocket motor (see Figure 12). I originally thought that these gees that the Saturn V had.
were the roll control motors. I was wrong. Theyre not. I hesitate to mention that piece of information, because
The motors on the side of frustrum are actually the I know what people are going to ask me next... how can I
Booster Tumble Motors (BTM). There are four of them, get that slow realistic lift-off on my models?
and they all point the same direction. They ignite after the The answer is that you need a minimum lift-off speed of
upper section separates from the solid rocket motor. The 30 miles per hour (based on historical data of safe launch-
separation plane is just above the frustrum cone, so the es). The best way to get slower speeds and having it y
BTM are actually attached to the solid rocket motor. For this straight is to use a longer launcher (either a longer rod or a
rst ight, these were actually inert dummy motors. They rail launch pad). I know that is not what you wanted to hear,
didnt actually operate, and were only present to make sure but you have to be safe, right?
that the aerodynami loads were accurate.
Model Rocket Stability Reference Information
But as the
name describes, Fins are a good thing. If you would like to know more
they are there to about stability, see the book Model Rocket Design and
BDMs (4)
create a sideways Construction (www.apogeerockets.com/design_book.asp)
push on the front There are also many articles about rocket stability on
part of the solid the Apogee Components web site at: www.apogeerock-
rocket motor, and ets.com/Peak-of-Flight_index.asp#stability. Pay particular
BDMs (4)
cause it to start attention to the articles on dynamic stability, beginning in
tumbling. This then Newsletter 196.
exposes the side
of the solid motor About The Author:
BTMs (2) to the airstream, Tim Van Milligan (a.k.a. Mr. Rocket) is a real rocket
Figure 13. The motors on the base increasing the scientist who likes helping out other rocketeers. Before he
of the solid rocket motor are to drag and slowing it started writing articles and books about rocketry, he worked
decelerate and cause the stage to down. on the Delta II rocket that launched satellites into orbit. He
tumble. There are also has a B.S. in Aeronautical Engineering from Embry-Riddle
eight rocket motors on the bottom skirt of the solid rocket Aeronautical University in Daytona Beach, Florida, and
motor as shown in Figure 13. These are called Booster has worked toward a M.S. in Space Technology from the
Deceleration Motors (BDM). Florida Institute of Technology in Melbourne, Florida. Cur-
rently, he is the owner of Apogee Components (http://www.
The Booster Deceleration Motors actually re forward,
apogeerockets.com) and the curator of the rocketry educa-
opposite to the direction of travel. They are designed to
tion web site: http://www.apogeerockets.com/education/.
slow the speed of the solid rocket booster so it doesnt ram
He is also the author of the books: Model Rocket Design
into the upper stage after separation. It is kinda cool that
and Construction, 69 Simple Science Fair Projects with
someone had to sit down and think of all the things that
Model Rockets: Aeronautics and publisher of a FREE e-
could go wrong in the ight, and come up with a way to
zine newsletter about model rockets. You can subscribe to
prevent them from happening.
the e-zine at the Apogee Components web site or by send-
And nally, there are also two additional Booster ing an e-mail to: ezine@apogeerockets.com with SUB-
Tumble Motors on the bottom too. Like the ones on the SCRIBE as the subject line of the message.