Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Chapter 6:
Power Flows
Gauss Iteration
There are a number of different iterative methods
we can use. We'll consider two: Gauss and Newton.
Stopping Criteria
A key problem to address is when to stop the
iteration. With the Guass iteration we stop when
x ( v ) with x ( v ) x ( v 1) x ( v )
If x is a scalar this is clear, but if x is a vector we
need to generalize the absolute value by using a norm
x ( v )
j
Two common norms are the Euclidean & infinity
n
x 2 i
x 2
x max i x i
i 1
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 8
Chapter 6: Power Flows
S*i n n
Vi*
YikVk YiiVi YikVk
k 1 k 1,k i
1 S*i n
Vi * YikVk
Yii V k 1,k i
i
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 9
Chapter 6: Power Flows
Slack Bus
In previous example we specified S2 and V1 and then
solved for S1 and V2.
We can not arbitrarily specify S at all buses because total
generation must equal total load + total losses
We also need an angle reference bus.
To solve these problems we define one bus as the "slack"
bus. This bus has a fixed voltage magnitude and angle,
and a varying real/reactive power injection.
1 S*i n
Vi( v 1) ( v )* YikVk( v )
Yii V k 1,k i
i
hi (V1( v ) ,V2( v ) ,...,Vn( v ) )
But after we've determined Vi( v 1) we have a better
estimate of its voltage , so it makes sense to use this
new value. This approach is known as the
Gauss-Seidel iteration.
Gauss-Seidel Iteration
Immediately use the new voltage estimates:
V2( v 1) h2 (V1 ,V2( v ) ,V3( v ) ,,Vn( v ) )
V3( v 1) h2 (V1 ,V2( v 1) ,V3( v ) ,,Vn( v ) )
V4( v 1) h2 (V1 ,V2( v 1) ,V3( v 1) ,V4( v ) ,Vn( v ) )
( v )* n (v)
Hence Qi( v ) Im Vi YikV
k 1
k
In the iteration we use Si( v ) Pi jQi( v )
1 Si(v )* n
Vi( v 1) ( v )* YikVk(v )
Yii V
i k 1, k i
But since Vi is specified, replace Vi( v 1) by Vi
Bus 1 Bus 2
V1 = 1.0 V2 = 1.05
(slack bus)
P2 = 0 MW
Gauss-Seidel Advantages
Each iteration is relatively fast (computational order is
proportional to number of branches + number of buses in
the system
Relatively easy to program
Gauss-Seidel Disadvantages
Tends to converge relatively slowly, although this can be
improved with acceleration
Has tendency to miss solutions, particularly on large
systems
Tends to diverge on cases with negative branch reactances
(common with compensated lines)
Need to program using complex numbers
Newton-Raphson Algorithm
The second major power flow solution method is the
Newton-Raphson algorithm
Key idea behind Newton-Raphson is to use sequential
linearization
Newton-Raphson Example
Use Newton-Raphson to solve f ( x) x 2 - 2 0
The equation we must iteratively solve is
1
df ( x ) (v)
x (v)
f ( x (v)
)
dx
x ( v ) 1 (v) 2
( v ) (( x ) - 2)
2x
x ( v 1) x ( v ) x ( v )
x ( v 1)
x (v) 1 (v) 2
( v ) (( x ) - 2)
2x
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 31
Chapter 6: Power Flows
At each
iteration the
N-R method
uses a linear
approximation
to determine
Function is f(x) = x2 - 2 = 0. the next value
Solutions are points where for x
f(x) intersects f(x) = 0 axis
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 33
Chapter 6: Power Flows
Newton-Raphson Comments
When close to the solution the error decreases quite
quicklymethod has quadratic convergence
f(x(v)) is known as the mismatch, which we would like to
drive to zero
Stopping criteria is when f(x(v)) <
Results are dependent upon the initial guess. What if we
had guessed x(0) = 0, or x (0) = -1?
A solutions region of attraction (ROA) is the set of initial
guesses that converge to the particular solution. The ROA
is often hard to determine
Multivariable Newton-Raphson
Next we generalize to the case where x is an n-
dimension vector, and f (x) is an n-dimension function
x1 f1 (x)
x f ( x)
x 2 f ( x) 2
x f ( x)
n n
Again define the solution x so f (x ) 0 and
x x x
f n ( x) f n ( x)
f n ( x ) f n ( x) x1 x2
x1 x2
f n (x)
xn higher order terms
xn
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 36
Chapter 6: Power Flows
Jacobian Matrix
The n by n matrix of partial derivatives is known
as the Jacobian matrix, J (x)
f1 (x) f1 (x) f1 (x)
x x2 xn
1
f 2 (x) f 2 (x) f 2 (x)
J (x) x1 x2 xn
f (x) f n (x) f n (x)
n
x1 x2 xn
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 38
Multi-Variable N-R Procedure
Derivation of N-R method is similar to the scalar case
f (x ) f (x) J (x) x higher order terms
f (x ) 0 f (x) J (x) x
1
x J ( x) f ( x)
x( v 1) x( v ) x( v )
x( v 1) x( v ) J (x( v ) ) 1 f (x( v ) )
Iterate until f (x( v ) )
fi ( x) n
i
Vi Vk (Gik sin ik Bik cos ik )
k 1
k i
fi ( x)
Vi V j (Gik sin ik Bik cos ik ) ( j i )
j
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 49
Chapter 6: Power Flows
PV Buses
Since the voltage magnitude at PV buses is fixed there is
no need to explicitly include these voltages in x or write
the reactive power balance equations
the reactive power output of the generator varies to
maintain the fixed terminal voltage (within limits)
optionally these variations/equations can be included
by just writing the explicit voltage constraint for the
generator bus
|Vi | Vi setpoint = 0
Line Z = 0.1j
0 MW 200 MW
0 MVR 100 MVR
2 j10 j10
x Ybus
V2 j10 j10
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 51
Chapter 6: Power Flows
10 V2 cos 2 10sin 2
10 V2 sin 2 10 cos 2 20 V2
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 53
Chapter 6: Power Flows
200.0 MW -200.0 MW
168.3 MVR Line Z = 0.1j -100.0 MVR
200.0 MW 200 MW
168.3 MVR 100 MVR
200.0 MW 200 MW
831.7 MVR 100 MVR
MVA
2 1 8 MW
1 .0 2 pu RA Y 3 4 5
sla ck
5 4 M var
A A A
1 .0 3 pu
Using
A
MVA
T IM 1 3 8
MVA
MVA
1 .0 0 pu 3 3 MW A
1 .0 2 pu
1 3 M var MVA
A
A
1 6 .0 M var 1 8 MW
1 .0 2 pu RA Y 6 9
MVA
MVA 5 M var 3 7 MW
A
1 7 MW A
MVA
1 .0 2 pu
2 3 MW
7 M var
T IM 6 9
MVA
A
1 .0 1 pu
P A I6 9
A
1 .0 1 pu
MVA
GRO SS6 9 A
MVA
3 M var
FERNA 6 9
MVA
1 .0 1 pu
1 3 M var
WO LEN6 9
case
2 1 MW
M O RO 1 3 8
A
from
MVA
MVA
H ISKY 6 9 7 M var
A
A
4 .8 M var
1 2 MW MVA
A MVA
5 M var 2 0 MW 1 .0 0 pu MVA
8 M var A
1 .0 0 pu BO B1 3 8
P ET E6 9 A
DEM A R6 9
Example
MVA
1 .0 0 pu A A
H A NNA H 6 9 5 8 MW
MVA
MVA MVA
5 1 MW 4 0 M var
4 5 MW
1 5 M var A
1 .0 2 pu BO B6 9
1 2 M var
2 9 .0 M var MVA
UIUC 6 9 0 .9 9 pu
1 4 .3 M var
1 .0 0 pu 1 4 0 MW 5 6 MW
MVA
A
MVA
5 8 MW
A
MVA
1 2 .8 M var
A
A
MVA
4 5 M var
0 MW
0 M var
A
1 3 M var
1 4 MW
LY NN1 3 8
6.13
0 .9 9 7 pu BLT 1 3 8
3 6 M var MVA 1 .0 0 pu MVA 4 M var
0 .9 9 pu A M A NDA 6 9 A
A
A
SH IM KO 6 9 1 .0 2 pu
H O M ER6 9 3 3 MW
MVA
MVA
7 .4 M var
A
MVA
1 0 M var 1 .0 1 pu A
BLT 6 9 MVA
A 1 .0 1 pu MVA
1 5 MW A MVA
1 5 MW
3 M var H A LE6 9 A 1 0 6 MW 5 M var
MVA
1 .0 0 pu 8 M var A
MVA
3 6 MW
MVA
A
A A
1 .0 1 pu
6 0 MW MVA 1 0 M var 7 .2 M var MVA
A
A
MVA
1 2 M var
1 .0 0 pu 1 .0 0 pu P A T T EN6 9 MVA
0 .0 M var A
MVA
4 5 MW 1 4 MW RO GER6 9
MVA
1 .0 0 pu WEBER6 9 0 M var
LA UF6 9 2 M var
1 .0 2 pu
2 3 MW
2 2 MW 0 MW
A A
6 M var 1 4 MW A
2 0 MW 1 5 M var 0 M var
MVA MVA 3 M var MVA
3 0 M var
1 .0 2 pu JO 1 3 8 JO 3 4 5
LA UF1 3 8 1 .0 2 pu SA V O Y 6 9 4 2 MW
1 .0 0 pu
2 M var
1 .0 1 pu BUC KY 1 3 8 A
A MVA A
1 5 0 MW
MVA 1 .0 1 pu SA V O Y 1 3 8 MVA
A A
0 M var
MVA MVA
1 5 0 MW
A
0 M var
MVA
1 .0 3 pu
1 .0 2 pu A
MVA
0.941 pu
One 1.000 pu Two -7.469 Deg
170.0 MW 200 MW
68.2 MVR 100 MVR
Line Z = 0.1j Line Z = 0.1j
Three 1.000 pu
30 MW
63 MVR
160.0 MW -160.0 MW
120.0 MVR Line Z = 0.1j -80.0 MVR
0.894 pu
One 1.000 pu Two -10.304 Deg
160.0 MW 160 MW
120.0 MVR 80 MVR
Dishonest Newton-Raphson
Since most of the time in the Newton-Raphson iteration
is spent calculating the inverse of the Jacobian, one way
to speed up the iterations is to only calculate/inverse the
Jacobian occasionally
known as the Dishonest Newton-Raphson
an extreme example is to only calculate the Jacobian
for the first iteration
Honest: x( v 1) x( v ) - J (x( v ) )-1 f (x( v ) )
Dishonest: x( v 1) x( v ) - J (x(0) )-1 f (x( v ) )
Both require f (x ) for a solution
(v)
Maximum
of 15
iterations
Decoupling Approximation
P ( v ) Q ( v )
Usually the off-diagonal matrices, and
V
are small. Therefore we approximate them as zero:
P ( v )
0
( v ) P(x( v ) )
f ( x (v)
)
Q V
( v ) ( v )
Q ( x (v )
)
0
V
Then the problem can be decoupled
P ( v ) 1 Q ( v ) 1
(v )
(v)
P (x
(v)
) V Q ( x (v)
)
V
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 75
Chapter 6: Power Flows
FDPF Approximations
The FDPF makes the following approximations:
1. G ij 0
2. Vi 1
3. sin ij 0 cos ij 1
Then
1 P ( x (v)
) ( v ) 1 Q ( x (v)
)
B
(v)
(v)
V B
V V (v)
Where B is just the imaginary part of the Ybus G jB,
except the slack bus row/column are omitted
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 79
Chapter 6: Power Flows
One Two
200 MW
100 MVR
Line Z = j0.05 Line Z = j0.1
Three 1.000 pu
200 MW
34.3 14.3
100 MVR
20
Ybus j 14.3 24.3 10
20 10 30
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 80
Chapter 6: Power Flows
DC Power Flow
The DC power flow makes the most severe
approximations:
completely ignore reactive power, assume all the
voltages are always 1.0 per unit, ignore line
conductance
This makes the power flow a linear set of equations,
which can be solved directly
B 1 P
360 MW 520 MW
MVA MVA
A
0 Mvar
MVA
slack
0 Mvar
1.000 pu 1.000 pu A A
1.000 pu 80 MW
0.000 Deg -4.125 Deg MVA MVA
-1.997 Deg 0 Mvar
1.000 pu
0.524 Deg
1.000 pu Two
-18.695 Deg
800 MW
0 Mvar
131.9 MW
124%
One Two
200.0 MW 200 MW
68.1 MW 68.1 MW
71.0 MVR 100 MVR
0 MW
64 MVR
100%
One Two
105.0 MW 200 MW
3.4 MW 98.4 MW
64.3 MVR 100 MVR
92%
Z for all lines = j0.1
Limit for all lines = 150 MVA
1.000 pu
Three
95 MW
64 MVR
Analytic Sensitivities
From the fast decoupled power flow we know
B 1P (x)
So to get the change in due to a change of
generation at bus k, just set P ( x) equal to
all zeros except a minus one at position k.
0
P 1 Bus k
0
T2
800 MVA
1 T1 5 4 345/15 kV 3 520 MVA
Line 3
345 kV
50 mi
400 MVA 800 MVA
15 kV 15 kV
Line 2
Line 1
400 MVA 345 kV 345 kV 40 Mvar 80 MW
15/345 kV 100 mi 200 mi
2
280 Mvar 800 MW
Single-line diagram
Maximum
R X G B MVA
Bus-to- per unit per unit per unit per unit per unit
Table 2. Bus
Line input data 2-4 0.0090 0.100 0 1.72 12.0
2-5 0.0045 0.050 0 0.88 12.0
4-5 0.00225 0.025 0 0.44 12.0
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 95
Chapter 6: Power Flows
2 P2 = PG2-PL2 = -8 V2, 2
Q2 = QG2-QL2 = -2.8
Table 4. Input data
and unknowns 3 V3 = 1.05 Q3, 3
P3 = PG3-PL3 = 4.4
4 P4 = 0, Q4 = 0 V4, 4
5 P5 = 0, Q5 = 0 V5, 5
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 96
Chapter 6: Power Flows
Ybus Details
Elements of Ybus connected to bus 2
Y21 Y23 0
1 1
Y24 ' 0.89276 j9.91964 per unit
R24 jX 24 0.009 j 0.1
'
1 1
Y25 1.78552 j19.83932 per unit
R25 jX 25 0.0045 j 0.05
' '
' '
1 1 B24 B25
Y22 ' ' j j
R24 jX 24 R25 jX 25
' '
2 2
1.72 0.88
(0.89276 j9.91964) (1.78552 j19.83932) j j
2 2
2.67828 j 28.4590 28.5847 84.624 per unit
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 98
Chapter 6: Power Flows
MVA MVA
395 MW A
520 MW
MVA
1.000 pu 0.974 pu A A
1.019 pu 80 MW
0.000 Deg -4.548 Deg MVA MVA
-2.834 Deg 40 Mvar
1.050 pu
-0.597 Deg
0.834 pu Two
-22.406 Deg
800 MW
280 Mvar
MVA
2 2 0 MW
1 .0 3 pu RA Y 3 4 5
sla ck
5 2 M var
System Losses: 10.70 MW A A A
1 .0 2 pu SLA C K1 3 8
T IM 3 4 5
MVA MVA MVA
1 .0 2 pu RA Y 1 3 8
A A
A
1 .0 3 pu
MVA MVA
T IM 1 3 8 3 3 MW A MVA
1 .0 0 pu 1 .0 3 pu
1 3 M var MVA
1 5 .9 M var 1 8 MW
A 1 .0 2 pu RA Y 6 9
A 5 M var 3 7 MW
MVA A
1 7 MW A
MVA
P A I6 9 1 3 M var
1 .0 1 pu MVA 3 M var MVA
1 .0 2 pu T IM 6 9
A 1 .0 1 pu GRO SS6 9 A
2 3 MW
MVA
MVA
FERNA 6 9
7 M var A
1 .0 1 pu WO LEN6 9
A A
1 2 MW
H ISKY 6 9
MVA
3 M var
MVA MVA
P ET E6 9 A
A
A
4 .9 M var
M O RO 1 3 8 MVA
5 8 MW A MVA
3 9 MW MVA
4 0 M var 1 .0 1 pu MVA
1 3 M var 1 .0 0 pu BO B1 3 8
1 2 MW
A
6 0 MW
MVA
1 9 M var
MVA MVA
1 .0 0 pu 2 0 MW
1 .0 0 pu
A
1 .0 2 pu BO B6 9
1 2 M var
0 .9 9 pu 1 4 .2 M var UIUC 6 9 MVA
1 .0 0 pu
1 2 .8 M var 1 2 4 MW 5 6 MW
KYLE69 A A
4 5 M var
A
MVA MVA 1 3 M var LY NN1 3 8
1 6 MW
MVA
A -1 4 M var
2 5 MW A A
MVA 1 4 MW
3 6 M var BLT 1 3 8
A M A NDA 6 9
MVA
1 .0 0 pu MVA 4 M var
A 0 .9 9 pu A A
BLT 6 9 MVA
A
1 .0 1 pu MVA
A
1 5 MW
2 0 MW
MVA
H A LE6 9 5 5 MW 5 M var
3 M var MVA A
2 5 M var A
1 .0 0 pu MVA
3 6 MW
MVA
A
A A
1 .0 1 pu
6 0 MW MVA 1 0 M var 7 .3 M var MVA
A
A
MVA
1 2 M var
1 .0 0 pu 1 .0 0 pu P A T T EN6 9 MVA
0 .0 M var A
MVA
4 5 MW 1 4 MW RO GER6 9
MVA
1 .0 1 pu WEBER6 9 0 M var
LA UF6 9 2 M var
1 .0 2 pu
2 3 MW
2 2 MW 1 0 MW
A A
6 M var 1 4 MW A
2 0 MW 1 5 M var 5 M var
3 M var
2 8 M var
MVA MVA MVA
1 .0 2 pu JO 1 3 8 JO 3 4 5
LA UF1 3 8 1 .0 2 pu SA V O Y 6 9 3 8 MW
1 .0 0 pu
3 M var
1 .0 1 pu BUC KY 1 3 8 A
A MVA A
1 5 0 MW
MVA 1 .0 1 pu SA V O Y 1 3 8 MVA
A A
0 M var
MVA MVA
1 5 0 MW
A
0 M var
MVA
1 .0 3 pu
1 .0 2 pu A
MVA
MVA
2 2 7 MW
1 .0 3 pu RA Y 3 4 5
sla ck
4 3 M var
System Losses: 17.61 MW A A A
1 .0 2 pu SL A C K1 3 8
T IM 3 4 5
MVA MVA MVA
1 .0 2 pu RA Y 1 3 8
A A
A
1 .0 3 pu
MVA MVA
T IM 1 3 8 3 3 MW A MVA
1 .0 1 pu 1 .0 3 pu
1 3 M var MVA
1 6 .0 M var 1 8 MW
A 1 .0 2 pu RA Y 6 9
A 5 M var 3 7 MW
MVA A
1 7 MW A
MVA
P A I6 9 1 3 M var
1 .0 1 pu MVA 3 M var MVA
1 .0 2 pu T IM 6 9
A 1 .0 1 pu GRO SS6 9 A
2 3 MW
MVA
MVA
FERNA 6 9
7 M var A
1 .0 1 pu WO L EN6 9
A A
1 2 MW
H ISKY 6 9
MVA
3 M var
MVA MVA
P ET E6 9 A
A
4 .9 M var
M O RO 1 3 8 5 8 MW A MVA
3 9 MW MVA
4 0 M var 1 .0 1 pu MVA
1 3 M var 1 .0 0 pu BOB1 3 8
1 2 MW
A
6 0 MW
MVA
1 9 M var
MVA MVA
1 .0 0 pu 2 0 MW
1 .0 0 pu
A
1 .0 2 pu BOB6 9
1 2 M var
0 .9 0 pu 1 1 .6 M var UIUC 6 9 MVA
1 .0 0 pu
1 2 .8 M var 1 2 4 MW 5 6 MW
KYLE69 A A
4 5 M var
A
MVA MVA 1 3 M var L Y NN1 3 8
1 6 MW
MVA
A -1 4 M var
2 5 MW A A
MVA 1 4 MW
3 6 M var BLT 1 3 8
A M A NDA 6 9
MVA
1 .0 0 pu MVA 4 M var
A 0 .9 0 pu A A
BLT 6 9 MVA
A
1 .0 1 pu MVA
A
1 5 MW
2 0 MW 135%
MVA
H A L E6 9 5 5 MW 5 M var
3 M var MVA
A
3 2 M var A
0 .9 4 pu MVA
3 6 MW
MVA
A
A A
1 .0 1 pu
6 0 MW MVA 1 0 M var 7 .2 M var MVA
A
A
MVA
1 2 M var
1 .0 0 pu 1 .0 0 pu P A T T EN6 9 MVA
0 .0 M var A
MVA
4 5 MW 1 4 MW RO GER6 9
MVA
1 .0 0 pu WEB ER6 9 0 M var
L A UF6 9 2 M var
1 .0 1 pu
2 3 MW
A 2 2 MW 1 0 MW
A
6 M var 1 4 MW A
A MVA A
1 5 0 MW
MVA 1 .0 1 pu SA V O Y 1 3 8 MVA
A A
4 M var
MVA MVA
1 5 0 MW
A
4 M var
MVA
1 .0 3 pu
1 .0 2 pu A
MVA
Contingency Analysis
Contingency
analysis provides
an automatic
way of looking
at all the
statistically
likely
contingencies. In
this example the
contingency set
is all the single
line/transformer
outages.
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 106
Chapter 6: Power Flows
An Unreliable Solution
Metropolis Light and Power Electric Design Case 2
A
SLA C K3 4 5
MVA
A
MVA
2 6 9 MW
1 .0 2 pu RA Y 3 4 5
sla ck
6 7 M var
System Losses: 14.49 MW A A A
1 .0 2 pu SLA C K1 3 8
T IM 3 4 5
MVA MVA MVA
1 .0 1 pu RA Y 1 3 8
A A
A
1 .0 3 pu
MVA MVA
T IM 1 3 8 3 3 MW A MVA
0 .9 9 pu 1 .0 2 pu
1 3 M var MVA
1 5 .9 M var 1 8 MW
A 1 .0 2 pu RA Y 6 9
A 5 M var 3 7 MW
MVA A
1 7 MW A
MVA
P A I6 9 1 3 M var
1 .0 1 pu MVA 3 M var MVA
1 .0 2 pu T IM 6 9
A 1 .0 1 pu GRO SS6 9 A
2 3 MW
MVA
MVA
FERNA 6 9
7 M var A
1 .0 1 pu WO LEN6 9
A A
1 2 MW
H ISKY 6 9
MVA
3 M var
MVA A MVA
P ET E6 9 A
A
4 .9 M var
M O RO 1 3 8 96% 5 8 MW A MVA
MVA
3 9 MW MVA
4 0 M var 1 .0 1 pu MVA
1 3 M var 1 .0 0 pu BO B1 3 8
1 2 MW
A
6 0 MW
MVA
1 9 M var
MVA MVA
1 .0 0 pu 2 0 MW
1 .0 0 pu
A
1 .0 2 pu BO B6 9
1 2 M var
0 .9 7 pu 1 3 .6 M var UIUC 6 9 MVA
1 .0 0 pu
1 2 .8 M var 1 2 4 MW 5 6 MW
KYLE69 A A
4 5 M var
A
MVA MVA 1 3 M var LY NN1 3 8
1 6 MW
MVA
A -1 4 M var
2 5 MW A A
MVA 1 4 MW
3 6 M var BLT 1 3 8
MVA
1 .0 0 pu MVA 4 M var
A 0 .9 7 pu A A
A
1 5 MW
2 0 MW
MVA
H A LE6 9 5 5 MW 5 M var
3 M var MVA A
2 8 M var A
0 .9 9 pu MVA
3 6 MW
MVA
A
A A
1 .0 1 pu
6 0 MW MVA 1 0 M var 7 .3 M var MVA
A
A
MVA
1 2 M var
1 .0 0 pu 1 .0 0 pu P A T T EN6 9 MVA
0 .0 M var A
MVA
4 5 MW 1 4 MW RO GER6 9
MVA
1 .0 1 pu WEBER6 9 0 M var
LA UF6 9 2 M var
1 .0 2 pu
2 3 MW
2 2 MW 1 0 MW
A A
6 M var 1 4 MW A
2 0 MW 1 5 M var 5 M var
3 M var
4 0 M var
MVA MVA MVA
1 .0 2 pu JO 1 3 8 JO 3 4 5
LA UF1 3 8 1 .0 2 pu SA V O Y 6 9 3 8 MW
1 .0 0 pu
4 M var
1 .0 1 pu BUC KY 1 3 8 A
A MVA A
1 5 0 MW
MVA 1 .0 1 pu SA V O Y 1 3 8 MVA
A A
1 M var
MVA MVA
1 5 0 MW
A
1 M var
MVA
1 .0 3 pu
1 .0 2 pu A
MVA
A Reliable Solution
Metropolis Light and Power Electric Design Case 2
A
SLA C K3 4 5
MVA
A
MVA
2 6 6 MW
1 .0 2 pu RA Y 3 4 5
sla ck
5 9 M var
System Losses: 11.66 MW A A A
1 .0 2 pu SLA C K1 3 8
T IM 3 4 5
MVA MVA MVA
1 .0 1 pu RA Y 1 3 8
A A
A
1 .0 3 pu
MVA MVA
T IM 1 3 8 3 3 MW A MVA
1 .0 0 pu 1 .0 3 pu
1 3 M var MVA
1 5 .8 M var 1 8 MW
A 1 .0 2 pu RA Y 6 9
A 5 M var 3 7 MW
MVA A
1 7 MW A
MVA
P A I6 9 1 3 M var
1 .0 1 pu MVA 3 M var MVA
1 .0 2 pu T IM 6 9
A 1 .0 1 pu GRO SS6 9 A
2 3 MW
MVA
MVA
FERNA 6 9
7 M var A
1 .0 1 pu WO LEN6 9
A A
1 2 MW
H ISKY 6 9
MVA
3 M var
MVA MVA P ET E6 9 A
A
A
4 .9 M var
M O RO 1 3 8 MVA
5 8 MW A MVA
3 9 MW MVA
4 0 M var 1 .0 1 pu MVA
1 3 M var 1 .0 0 pu BO B1 3 8
1 2 MW
A
6 0 MW
MVA
MVA MVA
1 9 M var
Kyle138 2 0 MW
0 .9 9 pu
A
1 .0 2 pu BO B6 9
1 2 M var
0 .9 9 pu 1 4 .1 M var UIUC 6 9 MVA
A
1 .0 0 pu
1 2 .8 M var 1 2 4 MW 5 6 MW
M VA
KYLE69 A A
4 5 M var
A
MVA MVA 1 3 M var LY NN1 3 8
1 6 MW
MVA
A -1 4 M var
2 5 MW A A
MVA 1 4 MW
3 6 M var BLT 1 3 8
MVA
1 .0 0 pu MVA 4 M var
A 0 .9 9 pu A A
A
1 5 MW
2 0 MW
MVA
H A LE6 9 5 5 MW 5 M var
3 M var MVA A
2 9 M var A
1 .0 0 pu MVA
3 6 MW
MVA
A
A A
1 .0 1 pu
6 0 MW MVA 1 0 M var 7 .3 M var MVA
A
A
MVA
1 2 M var
1 .0 0 pu 1 .0 0 pu P A T T EN6 9 MVA
0 .0 M var A
MVA
4 5 MW 1 4 MW RO GER6 9
MVA
1 .0 1 pu WEBER6 9 0 M var
LA UF6 9 2 M var
1 .0 2 pu
2 3 MW
2 2 MW 1 0 MW
A A
6 M var 1 4 MW A
2 0 MW 1 5 M var 5 M var
3 M var
3 8 M var
MVA MVA MVA
1 .0 2 pu JO 1 3 8 JO 3 4 5
LA UF1 3 8 1 .0 2 pu SA V O Y 6 9 3 8 MW
1 .0 0 pu
4 M var
1 .0 1 pu BUC KY 1 3 8 A
A MVA A
1 5 0 MW
MVA 1 .0 1 pu SA V O Y 1 3 8 MVA
A A
1 M var
MVA MVA
1 5 0 MW
A
1 M var
MVA
1 .0 3 pu
1 .0 2 pu A
MVA
MVA
1 6 2 MW
0 .0 0 pu RA Y 3 4 5
sla ck
3 5 M var
A A A
0 .0 0 pu SL A C K1 3 8
T IM 3 4 5
MVA MVA MVA
-0 .0 1 pu RA Y 1 3 8
A A
A
0 .0 0 pu
MVA
T IM 1 3 8
MVA
0 .0 0 pu 0 MW
A MVA
0 .0 0 pu
0 M var
-0 .1 M var 0 MW
A MVA
A
-0 .0 1 pu RA Y 6 9
MVA
MVA 0 M var 0 MW
A
0 MW A
0 .0 0 pu T IM 6 9 P A I6 9 0 M var
0 .0 0 pu MVA 0 M var MVA
A
0 MW 0 .0 0 pu GRO SS6 9 A
A
0 M var
MVA
A
MVA
FERNA 6 9
MVA 0 .0 0 pu WO L EN6 9
A 0 MW
M O RO 1 3 8
H ISKY 6 9
MVA
0 M var
MVA A
A
-0 .1 M var
0 MW MVA
A MVA
0 M var 0 MW -0 .0 1 pu
MVA
0 M var A
-0 .0 3 pu BOB1 3 8
P ET E6 9 A
DEM A R6 9
0 .0 0 pu
MVA A A
H A NNA H 6 9 0 MW
MVA
0 MW 0 M var
MVA MVA
0 MW
0 M var
A
0 .0 0 pu BOB6 9
0 M var
-0 .2 M var
UIUC 6 9 0 .0 0 pu
MVA
-0 .1 M var
0 .0 0 pu -1 5 7 M W 0 MW
-0 .1 M var
A
-4 5 M var
A
MVA 0 M var L Y NN1 3 8
A
0 MW
MVA
A 0 M var
MVA
A
0 MW A
0 MW
-0 .0 0 2 pu
MVA
BLT 1 3 8
0 M var MVA -0 .0 3 pu MVA 0 M var
0 .0 0 pu A M A NDA 6 9 A
A
A
SH IM KO 6 9 0 .0 0 pu
H O M ER6 9 0 MW
MVA
0 .0 M var
MVA A
MVA
0 M var 0 .0 0 pu A
BLT 6 9 MVA
A -0 .0 1 pu MVA
0 MW A MVA
0 MW
0 M var H A L E6 9 A 0 MW 0 M var
0 .0 0 pu
MVA
5 1 M var
A
MVA
0 MW
MVA
A
A A
0 .0 0 pu
0 MW MVA 0 M var 0 .0 M var MVA A
A
MVA
0 M var
0 .0 0 pu 0 .0 0 pu P A T T EN6 9 MVA
0 .0 M var A
MVA
0 MW 0 MW RO GER6 9
MVA
0 .0 0 pu WEB ER6 9 0 M var
L A UF6 9 0 M var
0 .0 0 pu
0 MW
0 MW 0 MW
A A
0 M var 0 MW A
0 MW 0 M var 0 M var
0 M var
4 M var MVA MVA MVA
0 .0 0 pu JO 1 3 8 JO 3 4 5
L A UF1 3 8 0 .0 0 pu SA V O Y 6 9 0 MW
0 .0 0 pu
3 M var
0 .0 0 pu B UC KY 1 3 8 A
A MVA A
0 MW
MVA 0 .0 0 pu SA V O Y 1 3 8 MVA
A A
2 M var
MVA MVA
0 MW
A
2 M var
MVA
0 .0 0 pu
0 .0 0 pu A
MVA
MVA
0 MW
0 .0 0 pu RA Y 3 4 5
sla ck
3 7 M var
A A A
0 .0 0 pu SLA C K1 3 8
T IM 3 4 5
MVA MVA MVA
-0 .0 1 pu RA Y 1 3 8
A A
A
0 .0 0 pu
MVA
T IM 1 3 8
MVA
0 .0 0 pu 0 MW
A MVA
0 .0 0 pu
0 M var
-0 .1 M var 0 MW
A MVA
A
0 .0 0 pu RA Y 6 9
MVA
MVA 0 M var 0 MW
A
0 MW A
0 .0 0 pu T IM 6 9 P A I6 9 0 M var
0 .0 0 pu MVA 0 M var MVA
A
0 MW 0 .0 0 pu GRO SS6 9 A
A
0 M var
MVA
A
MVA
FERNA 6 9
MVA 0 .0 0 pu WO LEN6 9
A 0 MW
M O RO 1 3 8
H ISKY 6 9
MVA
0 M var
MVA A
A
0 .0 M var
0 MW MVA
A MVA
0 M var 0 MW 0 .0 0 pu
MVA
0 M var A
-0 .0 3 pu BO B1 3 8
P ET E6 9 A
DEM A R6 9
0 .0 0 pu
MVA A A
H A NNA H 6 9 0 MW
MVA
0 MW 0 M var
MVA MVA
0 MW
0 M var
A
0 .0 0 pu BO B6 9
0 M var
-0 .2 M var
UIUC 6 9 0 .0 0 pu
MVA
-0 .1 M var
0 .0 0 pu -1 5 7 M W 0 MW
-0 .1 M var
A
-4 5 M var
A
MVA 0 M var LY NN1 3 8
A
0 MW
MVA
A 0 M var
MVA
A
0 MW A
0 MW
-0 .0 0 3 pu
MVA
BLT 1 3 8
0 M var MVA -0 .0 3 pu MVA 0 M var
0 .0 0 pu A M A NDA 6 9 A
A
A
SH IM KO 6 9 0 .0 0 pu
H O M ER6 9 0 MW
MVA
-0 .1 M var
MVA A
MVA
0 M var -0 .0 1 pu A
BLT 6 9 MVA
A -0 .0 1 pu MVA
0 MW A MVA
0 MW
0 M var H A LE6 9 A 1 9 MW 0 M var
0 .0 0 pu
MVA
5 1 M var
A
MVA
0 MW
MVA
A
A A
0 .0 0 pu
0 MW MVA 0 M var 0 .0 M var MVA A
A
MVA
0 M var
0 .0 0 pu 0 .0 0 pu P A T T EN6 9 MVA
0 .0 M var A
MVA
0 MW 0 MW RO GER6 9
MVA
0 .0 0 pu WEBER6 9 0 M var
LA UF6 9 0 M var
0 .0 0 pu
0 MW
0 MW 0 MW
A A
0 M var 0 MW A
9 9 MW 0 M var 0 M var
0 M var
-2 0 M var MVA MVA MVA
0 .0 0 pu JO 1 3 8 JO 3 4 5
LA UF1 3 8 0 .0 0 pu SA V O Y 6 9 4 2 MW
0 .0 0 pu
-1 4 M var
0 .0 0 pu BUC KY 1 3 8 A
A MVA A
0 MW
MVA 0 .0 0 pu SA V O Y 1 3 8 MVA
A A
0 M var
MVA MVA
0 MW
A
0 M var
MVA
0 .0 0 pu
0 .0 0 pu A
MVA
MVA
2 1 9 MW
1 .0 2 pu RA Y 3 4 5
5 2 M var
System Losses: 11.51 MW A A A
sla ck
1 .0 2 pu SL A C K1 3 8
T IM 3 4 5
MVA MVA MVA
1 .0 1 pu RA Y 1 3 8
A
A
MVA
A
1 .0 3 pu
T IM 1 3 8
MVA
MVA
1 .0 0 pu 3 3 MW A
1 .0 3 pu
1 3 M var
1 5 .9 M var 1 8 MW
A MVA
A
1 .0 2 pu RA Y 6 9
MVA
MVA 5 M var 3 7 MW
A
1 7 MW A
1 .0 2 pu T IM 6 9 P A I6 9 1 3 M var
1 .0 1 pu MVA 3 M var MVA
A
2 3 MW 1 .0 1 pu GRO SS6 9 A
A
7 M var
MVA
MVA
FERNA 6 9
MVA A
1 .0 1 pu WO L EN6 9
2 1 MW
M O RO 1 3 8
A
MVA
MVA
H ISKY 6 9 7 M var
A
A
4 .8 M var
1 2 MW MVA
A MVA
5 M var 2 0 MW 1 .0 0 pu MVA
8 M var A
1 .0 0 pu BO B1 3 8
P ET E6 9 A
MVA DEM A R6 9
1 .0 0 pu A A
MVA
H A NNA H 6 9 5 8 MW
MVA MVA
5 1 MW 4 0 M var
4 5 MW
1 5 M var A
1 .0 2 pu BO B6 9
1 2 M var
2 9 .0 M var
UIUC 6 9 0 .9 9 pu
MVA
1 4 .3 M var
1 .0 0 pu 1 5 7 MW 5 6 MW
1 2 .8 M var A
4 5 M var
A
MVA 1 3 M var L Y NN1 3 8
A
0 MW
MVA
0 M var
A
A
MVA A
MVA
MVA 5 8 MW A
1 4 MW
0 .9 9 7 pu BL T 1 3 8 MVA
3 6 M var MVA 1 .0 0 pu 4 M var
0 .9 9 pu A M A NDA 6 9 A
A
A
3 3 MW SH IM KO 6 9 1 .0 2 pu
H O M ER6 9
MVA
MVA A
MVA
1 0 M var 0.0 Mvar 1 .0 1 pu
BL T 6 9
7 .4 M var
MVA
A 1 .0 1 pu
1 5 MW
3 M var
A
MVA
H A L E6 9
MVA
A 9 2 MW 1.010 pu 1 5 MW
5 M var
1 .0 0 pu 1 0 M var
MVA
A
A
A
3 6 MW A
1 .0 1 pu
6 0 MW MVA 1 0 M var 7 .2 M var MVA
MVA
A
A
MVA
1 2 M var
1 .0 0 pu 1 .0 0 pu P A T T EN6 9 MVA
2 0 .8 M var A
MVA
4 5 MW 1 4 MW RO GER6 9
MVA
1 .0 0 pu WEBER6 9 0 M var
L A UF6 9 2 M var
1 .0 2 pu
2 3 MW
2 2 MW 0 MW
A A
6 M var 1 4 MW A
2 0 MW 1 5 M var 0 M var
MVA MVA 3 M var MVA
9 M var
1 .0 2 pu JO 1 3 8 JO 3 4 5
L A UF1 3 8 1 .0 2 pu SA V O Y 6 9 3 8 MW
1 .0 0 pu
3 M var
1 .0 1 pu BUC KY 1 3 8 A
A MVA A
1 5 0 MW
MVA 1 .0 1 pu SA V O Y 1 3 8 MVA
A A
0 M var
MVA MVA
1 5 0 MW
A
0 M var
MVA
1 .0 3 pu
1 .0 2 pu A
MVA
WH TWTR3
EEN 138 ST RITA
WH TWTR4 M UKWO N GO
SUN 138
TRIPP
WH TWTR5
UN IVRSTY
Raci ne
JAN 138
SGR CK4
LBT 138 UN IV N EU
SGR CK5
RO R 138
N LK GV T
BRLGTN 1
ALBERS-2
Paddock
PO T 138 N O M 138 M RE 138 PARIS WE BAIN 4
TICH IGN
H LM 138
N LG 138
N ED 138
LEN A ; B LEN A ; R
8TH ST. 5 Zi on
Ant i och Zi on (138 kV)
Rockford
LO RE 5
ELERO ; BT ELERO ; RT
ASBURY 5 Wempl eton M cHenr y
SO . GVW. 5 PECAT; B G ur nee
Round Lake
CN TRGRV5 Waukegan
LAN CA; R
JULIAN 5 SALEM N 5
P Val Lakehur st
GALEN A 5 Cr yst al Lake
Sand Park
Pi erpont
Li ber t yvi l l e Li ber t yvi l l e
Si l ver Lake 345 kV 138 kV Nor t h Chi cago
B465 Hunt l ey
FO RD A; R
Al gonqui n
S PEC; R E. Rockf ord
Al pi ne U. S. N Tr ai ni ng
Abbot t Labs Par k
Lest hon
Charl es
B427 ; 1T
Sabrooke
Apt aki si c
Cherry Val l ey O l d El m
Lake Zur i ch
Buf f al o G r oove
Bar r i ngt on
Bl aw khaw k Wheel i ng
Deer f i el d
Pal at i ne
SAVAN N A5 D undee Pr ospect Hei ght s
H 71 ; BT Bel l w ood Cl i nt
H 440 ; RT STEWA; B El ect r i c Junct i on Yor k Cent er
H 71 ; B Y450 Jef f erson
D ekov Tayl or
La G r ange
H 71 ; R STERL; B Ri dgel and Uni versi ty
Li sl e D unacr
H -471 (N W Steel ) M cCook Lasal l e
Fi sk
D799 Washi ngton Park
Craw f ord -1. 1 deg
War r envi l l e D775 State Garf i el d H arbor
D ow ners Groove
Frontenac
Woodri dge Saw yer Q uarry
Wol f Creek Ford Ci ty 0. 6 deg
Q uad Ci ti es Cl earni ng
W600 ( Naper vi l l e)
N el son Wi l l ow Cal umet Chi ave
M ECCO RD 3 W604 H ayf ord 1. 9 deg Babcock
O sw ego Bedf ord Park D amen
Sandw i ch Bur r Ri dge State Li ne
Sayre Wal l ace
Sub 91 W601 W603 Ri ver Shef i el d
Pl ano J307 Evergreen
CO RD O ; N ELSO ; R Bri dgevi ew
M ontgomery Bol i ngbrook Al si p
Z-494
W602
Wi l l Co. Roberts Beverl y
R FAL; B R FAL; R Z-715 Lake George
N ELSO ; RT W507 Romeo G394 G3851 Z-100 Tow er Rd
SB 79 5 Pal os O rl an
SB 49 5 H egew i sch M unster
SBH YC5 G3852
Archer Crestw ood Wi l dw ood Z-524
SB UIC 5 M endota Pl ai nf i el d Burnham
SB 74 5
D avenport SB 90 5 SB 17 5 Lockport
J-332 Bl ue Isl and
Wal cott SUB 77 5 Bel l Road Goodi ngs Grove
Sub 92 SB 71 5
Green Lake
D AVN PRT5 N O RM A; R N O RM A; B
SB 78 5 Kenda Green Acres
H i l l crest Rockdal e J322 Ti nl ey Park
SB 76 5 South H ol l and Sand Ri dge
SB 89 5
SB 88 5 Jo456 H arvey
105%
93%
H EN N EPIN
SB 112 5 Kendra
1556A TP
O TTAWA T
MVA MVA N LASAL
KPECKTP5
WEST 5 Bradl ey
SO . SUB 5 Streator
Br ai dw ood
9 SUB 5
H WY61 5
M IN O N K T
GALESBR5
Kankakee
GALESBRG
RICH LAN D
N EWPO RT5
M O N M O UTH
SPN G BAY
Ponti ac M i dpoi nt
D equi ne
M PWSPLIT
H ALLO CK
ELPASO T
Peoria
WATSEKA 17GO D LN D
GILM AN
FARGO
CAT M O SS
RSW EAST
RAD N O R
CAT SUB1
Power Transactions
Power transactions are contracts between generators and
loads to do power transactions.
Contracts can be for any amount of time at any price for
any amount of power.
Scheduled power transactions are implemented by
modifying the value of Psched used in the ACE calculation
PTDFs
Power transfer distribution factors (PTDFs) show the linear
impact of a transfer of power.
PTDFs calculated using the fast decoupled power flow B
matrix
B 1P (x)
Once we know we can derive the change in
the transmission line flows
Except now we modify several elements in P(x),
in portion to how the specified generators would
participate in the power transfer
2012 Cengage Learning Engineering. All Rights Reserved. 122
Chapter 6: Power Flows
A B 250.0 MW D
10% 71%
71.1 MW C
60% 57%
92% 0.00 deg 64%
55%
11%
G F E
150.0 MW
24%
H I
200.0 MW
150.0 MW
A B 250.0 MW D
43% 30%
71.1 MW C
57% 10%
13% 0.00 deg 20%
35%
2%
G F E
150.0 MW
34%
H I
200.0 MW
150.0 MW
A B 250.0 MW D
6% 18%
71.1 MW C
6% 6%
12% 0.00 deg 12%
61%
19%
G F E
150.0 MW
21%
H I
200.0 MW
150.0 MW
WE to TVA PTDFs
Pl LODFl ,k Pk
Flowgates
The real-time loading of the power grid is accessed via
flowgates
A flowgate flow is the real power flow on one or
more transmission element for either base case
conditions or a single contingency
contingent flows are determined using LODFs
Flowgates are used as proxies for other types of limits,
such as voltage or stability limits
Flowgates are calculated using a spreadsheet
NERC
is the
North
American
Electric
Reliability
Council