Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
(Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background
Kathmandu is one of the fastest growing city, the capital of Nepal. Since the decade of 50,
construction activities have been tremendously increased in Nepal; especially in Kathmandu
valley. Various kinds of complex structures like high rise apartment, hospital buildings, etc. are
being constructed to fulfill the demand of rapidly increasing population.
With the changing living style, increasing population and with more pronounced scarcity of the
land, the demand for multi-storey buildings with larger spans and sizes is soaring day by day. The
studies related with earthquake demand the structures to be stronger and safer. The earthquake,
being inevitable natural catastrophe, safe design should hold the paramount important loss of lives
and properties are unpleasant because of worst scenario it can create.
In the history of Nepal, numerous earthquakes which damaged many lives and infrastructures.
Briefly speaking earthquake of "8 Rector Scale" were in 19th century in 1810, 1833, 1866 and
1934 AD in Nepal. Recently, we faced earthquake of 7.8 Rector Scale in 12, Baisakh, 2072 B.S.
which lead to the tremendous loss of lives and properties. It is the consequences of lack of regular
supervision of the Engineer during the construction. The random and unmonitored construction
without proper design and guidance is one of the factor for the earthquake disaster. Earthquake
can take many lives, destruction of massive structures and create worst scenario as ever. While
designing a structure great emphasis must be given for seismic analysis so that an earthquake of
large intensity cannot destroy the buildings easily or the structure after earthquake must serve for
the purpose.
It is a great challenge to design the structure considering durability, safety, and economic factor at
one attempt. Durability, economy and safety factors are the challenging element for such type of
complex structure.
In addition to this Nepal is located between the Indian and Tibetan plate along which a relative
strain of about 2 cm has been estimated. The Indian plate is also sub-ducting at the rate thought to
be 3 cm per year. The existence of Himalayan range with the world's highest peak is evidence of
high tectonics beneath the country. So, Nepal is seismically very active. As well as Nepal lies in
IVth and Vth zone which is at high risk of vulnerability and this lead people to death, loss of
property, injuries, etc. So the seismic consideration in the design of buildings is the most
important one.
The design provision of high-seismic system are also intended to result in distributed deformation
throughout the frame, rather than the formation of story mechanisms, so as to increase the level of
available every dissipation and corresponding level of ground motion that can be withstood.There
are various types of structure that are subjected to various loads like static load and dynamic loads
(earthquake load). During the design process, the structures are subjected to internal forces like
axial forces, shear forces, bending and torsional moment etc. We have to analyze these internal
forces in the members of the structures and design various sizes of member of structures to resist
these forces during the earthquake. Our project work STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS AND
DESIGN OF MULTI STOREYED APARTMENT BUILDING" deals with multistorey frame
structural building located in the Sukedhara, Kathmandu, Nepal, which lies in the earthquake
1
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
prone zone. So the effect of earthquake load must to be taken into consideration as such the
structures are analyzed for earthquake load as well as lateral load along with vertical load. The
structural analysis is carried out with help of computer program SAP 2000, Microsoft Excel and
AutoCAD draws detail drawings etc.
A structure analysis has to deal with various structures ranging from simple ones like curtain rods
and electric poles to more complex ones like multistoried frame buildings, shell roofs bridges etc.
These structures are subjected to various load like concentrated loads, uniformly distributed loads,
uniformly varying load, live loads, earthquake loads and other dynamic forces. The structure
transfers the loads acting on it to the supports and ultimately to the ground. While transferring the
loads acting on the structures, the members of the structures are subjected to the internal forces
like axial force, shear force, bending and torsion moments.
Structural design deals with sizing of various members of the structures to resist the internal
forces to which they are subjected during their effective life span. Unless the proper structural
detailing method is adopted, the structural design will be no more effective. The IS code of
practice and NBC of Nepal should be thoroughly adopted for proper analysis, design and detailing
with respect to safety, economy, stability and strength.
The project report has been prepared in complete conformity with various stipulations in Indian
standard, Code of practice for plain and reinforced concrete IS 456:2000, Design aids for
reinforced concrete to IS 456:2000(SP16), Criteria for earthquake resistance design structure IS
1893:2000, Ductile detailing of reinforced concrete structure subjected to seismic forces, Code of
practice IS 13920:1993, Hand book on concrete reinforcement and detailing SP 34. Use of these
codes have emphasized on providing sufficient safety, economy, strength and ductility besides
satisfactory serviceability requirements of cracking and deflection in concrete structures. These
codes are based on principles of limit state of design.
The main aim of the project work under the title is to acquire knowledge and skill with an
emphasis of practical application. Besides, the utilization of analytical methods and design
approaches, exposures and application of various available codes of practices are another aim of
the work.
2
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Scopes :
2. Determination of the structural system of the building to undertake the vertical and
horizontal loads.
9. The structural design of the building by sap2000 for different cases of loads.
3
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
(b) Under moderate but occasional shaking, the main members may sustain repairable damage,
while the other parts of the building may be damaged such that they may even have to be replaced
after the earthquake.
(c) Under strong but rare shaking, the main members may sustain severe (even irreparable)
damage, but the building should not collapse.
A typical RC building is made of horizontal members (beams &slabs) and vertical members
(columns &wall), and supported by foundation that rest on ground. The system comprising of RC
columns and connecting beams is called RC frame the RC frame participates in resisting the
earthquake forces. Shaking due to earthquake develops the inertia forces in the building which are
proportioned to the building mass.
Earthquake induced inertia forces preliminary develop at the floor level of these forces travel
downwards through slab and beam to column and walls, & then to the foundation from where
they are dispersed to the ground. Inertia forces accumulate downwards from the top of the
building the columns and wall at the lower storey experience higher earthquake-induced forces &
are therefore designed to be stronger than those in storeys above.
When beams bend in the vertical direction during earthquakes, these thin slabs bend along with
them. When beams move with column in horizontal direction, the slab usually forces the beams to
move together with. This behavior is known as rigid diaphragm action.
4
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
For the building to remain safe during earthquake shaking, columns (which receive forces from
beams) should be stronger than beams, and foundations (which receive forces from columns)
should be stronger than columns. Connections between beams & columns, columns &foundation
should not fail before the failure of beam.
(i) Buildings with large height to base size ratio. Ref fig.1 (a)
(ii) Short height but very long building. Ref fig.1 (b)
(iii) Buildings with large plan area like warehouse. Ref fig.1(c)
(iv) L-shaped buildings
A ductile material is the one that can undergo considerable strains and support loads. The
termsductility term refers the ability to sustain significant inelastic deformations prior to collapse
while brittle material fails suddenly upon attaining maximum load.
5
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
If a structure is ductile, it can be expected to adapt to the unexpected overloads, load reversals,
impact and structural movements due to the foundation settlements and volume change.
Buildings occupant will have sufficient warnings of the impending failure thus reducing the
probability of loss of life in the event of collapse.
Limit state design procedure assumes that all the critical section in the structure will reach
their maximum capacities at design load for the structure. For this to occur, all the joints and
splices must be to withstand forces and deformations corresponding to yielding of the
reinforcement.
2. Location : Kathmandu
18. Soil type : Sandy soil (especially gravel mixed clay assumed)
20. Occupancy of
Basement : 3050 mm
7
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
2.0 METHODOLOGY
2.1 Planning of the Building
Functional Planning of Building is done based on two principles:
a) Client Requirements are the primary governing factor in space requirement calculations. These
requirements are enumerated then planned in the available space with architectural provisions for
space allocation and management.
b) Municipal By-Laws and Guidelines dictate the design of building structures within their
judicial province. At our proposed site in Kathmandu, the building by-laws prepared and
implemented by Kathmandu Metropolitan City is in action.
Thus, with consideration of both the planning features explained above in brief, the planning was
done for maximum benefit of client.
Structural planning: The building is to be designed as earthquake resistant structure, regular
geometrical shape without any abrupt changes in plan are incorporated based on IS1893
(part1):2002.
2.2 Load Assessment and Preliminary Design
a) Gravity Loads (Dead Load and Imposed Load)
Gravity Loads acting on the building are the weight of structural members, floor finishes, partition
walls etc. To assess these loads, the materials to be used are chosen and their weights/density
determined based Indian standard code of practice for design loads (other than earthquake) for
buildings and structures:
Lateral Loads acting on the building as earthquake load over the entire structure. Earthquake load
is based on IS 1893 (part I):2002. Earthquake load is calculated based on this code by Seismic
Coefficient Method which is an approximation of dynamic loading due to earthquake by
equivalent static lateral loads.
Preliminary Design
Preliminary Design of structural member is based on the IS Code provisions for slab, beam,
column of serviceability criteria for deflection control and moment criteria method. Appropriate
sizing is done with consideration to the fact that the preliminary design based on gravity loads is
required to resist the lateral loads acting on the structure. The details of preliminary design
computations for slabs, beams and columns are prepared.
8
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
SAP2000 V15 represents one of the most sophisticated and user-friendly release of SAP series of
computer programs. Creation and modification of the model, execution of the analysis, and
checking and optimization of the design are all done. Graphical displays of the results are easily
produced. The finite element library consists of different elements out of which the three
dimensional FRAME element was used in this analysis. The Frame element uses a general, three
dimensional, beam-column formulation which includes the effects of biaxial bending, torsion,
axial deformation, and biaxial shear deformations. A Frame element is modeled as a straight line
connecting two joints. Each element has its own local coordinate system for defining section
properties and loads, and for interpreting output.
For the purpose of seismic analysis of our building we used the structural analysis program
SAP2000. It has a special option for modeling horizontal rigid floor diaphragm system. A floor
diaphragm is modeled as a rigid horizontal plane parallel to global X-Y plane, so that all points on
any floor diaphragm cannot displace relative to each other in X-Y plane. This type of modeling is
very useful in the lateral dynamic analysis of building. The base shear and earthquake lateral force
are calculated as per code IS 1893 (part1) : 2002 and are applied at each master joint located on
every storey of the building. The building is modeled as a 3D bare frame. Results from analysis
are used in design of beams and columns. Joints are defined with constraints to serve as rigid floor
diaphragm and hence slabs are designed manually as effect of seismic load is not seen on slab..
Material properties are defined for elements in terms of their characteristic strength i.e. M20 for
slabs, beams and M25 for columns. Loading combination based on IS 875 (part V):1987 and IS
1893 (part 1):2002 for ultimate limit state and IS 456:2000 for serviceability limit state is
prepared.
As we are working with a computer based system, the importance of data input is as important as
the result of output derived from analysis. Hence with possibility of garbage-in-garbage-out, we
need to check our input parameters in explicit detail.
9
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Design of Reinforced Concrete Members is done based on the limit state method of design
following IS 456:2000 as the code of practice. The basic philosophy of design is that the structure
is designed for strength at the ultimate limit state of collapse and for performance at limit state of
serviceability. A check for these two limit states is done based on code of practice to achieve safe,
economic and efficient design.
The design principle is based on probabilistic approach that any structural element designed by
limit state will function well during its intended live and not reach the ultimate limit state of
collapse under normal performance conditions.
i. Plane sections normal to the axis of the member remain plane after bending.
ii. The maximum strain in concrete at the outermost compression fiber is 0.0035.
iii. The relationship between the compressive stress distribution in concrete and the
strain in concrete may be assumed to be rectangle, trapezoidal, parabola or any other
shape which results in prediction of strength in substantial agreement with the result
of test. For design purposes, the compressive strength of concrete in the structure
shall be assumed to be 0.67 times the characteristic strength. The partial safety factor
= 1.5 shall be applied in addition to this.
iv. The tensile strength of concrete is ignored.
v. The design stresses in reinforcement are derived from representative stress-strain curve for the
type of steel used. For the design purposes the partial safety factor = 1.15 shall be applied.
vi. The maximum strain in the tension reinforcement in the section at failure shall not be less
than:
Where, fy = characteristic strength of steel
Es = modulus of elasticity of steel
Forces- Code of Practice IS 13920:1993, Handbook on Concrete Reinforcement and Detailing SP-
34. Use of these codes have emphasized on providing sufficient safety, economy, strength and
ductility besides satisfactory serviceability requirements of cracking and deflection in concrete
structures. These codes are based on principles of Limit State of Design.
11
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
3. STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
3.1 Analysis
For the purpose of seismic analysis of our building, we use the structural analysis program
SAP2000 V15. It has a special option for modeling horizontal rigid floor diaphragm system. A
floor diaphragm is modelled as a rigid horizontal plane parallel to global X-Y plane, so that all
points on any floor diaphragm cannot displace relative to each other in X-Y plane.
This type of modeling is very useful in the seismic analysis of building. The base shear and
earthquake lateral force are calculated as per code IS1893(Part I )2002 as calculated before and
are applied at each frame joints in every storey of the building in X-Y direction respectively.
Various load combinations has been adopted as per IS 1893 (part 1):2002, clauses 6.3.1.2. They
are as follows:
i. Dead Load(DL)
ii. Live Load(LL)
iii. Earthquake load in X direction (EQx)
iv. Earthquake load in Y direction (EQy)
Following loads combinations are adopted as per Cl. 6.3.1.2 of IS1893 (Part I):2002
i. 1.5(DL+ LL)
ii. 1.5(DL + EQx)
iii. 1.5(DL - EQx)
iv. 1.5(DL + EQy)
v. 1.5(DL - EQy)
vi. 1.2(DL + LL + EQx)
vii. 1.2(DL + LL - EQx)
viii. 1.2(DL + LL + EQy)
ix. 1.2(DL + LL - EQy)
x. 0.9DL + 1.5 EQx
xi. 0.9DL - 1.5 EQx
xii. 0.9DL + 1.5 EQy
xiii. 0.9DL - 1.5 EQy
12
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
The planning of the building has been done under available of land area, shape, space according
to building-bye-laws and requirement of residential building. The positioning of column,
staircase, toilet, lift etc. is appropriately done and accordingly beam arrangement is carried out so
that the whole building will be aesthetically, functionally, and economically feasible.
The aim of the design is the achievement of an acceptable probability that structures being design
will perform satisfactory during their intended life. With an appropriate degree of safety, they
should sustain all the adequate resistance to the effect of misuse and fire.
4.2 Preliminary Design of RCC Slab, Beam, and Column For the Proposed
Apartment Building
Preliminary Design of RCC Slab Element
For analysis of the building, it requires the rough idea on the member sizes used in the building as
beam, column, and slab. According to which the contributed dead load of the member to the
structure could be estimated. The size of the members is dependent on the limit state of
serviceability on deflection and cracking. For this, the IS code 456-2000 is referred.
The preliminary design of RCC slab for the roof of the proposed building is based on the
fulfillment of deflection control criteria of IS 456-20000 and behavior of floor slab as a rigid
diaphragm in earthquake resistant design based in IS 1893-2002.
Loading pattern from slab to beam is obtained by drawing bisecting angle from each corner. The
obtained triangular or trapezoidal loadings are converted into equivalent uniformly distributed
load in the following way:
13
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
h w
q
L L
Loading intensity per unit length, w=DL or LL of slab per sq. unit*h
Seismic weight is the total dead load plus approximately amount of specified imposed load. While
computing the seismic weight of each floor, the weight of columns and walls in any storey shall
be equally distributed to the floors above and below the storey. The seismic weight of the whole
building is the sum of the seismic weights of all the floors.
Seismic load or earthquake load on the building depends upon its geographical location, lateral
stiffness and mass. A force is defined as the product of mass and acceleration. During an
earthquake, the mass is imparted by building whereas the acceleration is imparted by the ground
disturbance. In order to have minimum force, the mass of the building should be as low as
possible.
The seismic coefficient method is generally applicable to buildings up to 40m in height and those
are more or less symmetrical in plan andelevation.
Response spectrum
The representation of the maximum response of idealized single degree of freedom system having
certain period of vibration and damping during earthquake is referred to as response spectrum.
The maximum response, maximum absolute acceleration, maximum velocity or maximum
relative displacement of the single degree of freedom system is plotted against the un-damped
natural period and for various damping values.
1) Materials used in the column and beam concrete were defined with their corresponding unit
weight and stress as 25Mpa and 20Mpa respectively. Properties of other materials like rebar
used as longitudinal and traverse reinforcement.
14
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
2) Frame section properties were also defined as per the preliminary design with their
dimensions.
3) Coordinate grid system was defined then 3D modeling of the structure was done.
4) Mass source was also defined. The mass multiplier for the loads were defined as 1 for all the
dead loads of the building whereas, it was defined as 0.5 for live loads greater than 3KN/m 2
and 0.25 for live loads less than or equals to 3KN/m2.
5) Load pattern was defined with dead load self weight multiplier as unity and then live load.
Besides load applied, the codal earthquake loads in x and y direction; manual earthquake loads
in x and y direction were also defined.
6) The load combinations were also defined as per IS 1893 (part I):2002. Also the envelope for
the seismic, response spectrum and manual loads combinations were also made to obtain the
required value from the combinations.
7) The model of the structure was made and the loads (live as well as loads) were applied on the
frames.
9) The time period, base shear and mass load participation were made from the analysis output
tables and checked.
The approximate fundamental natural period of vibration (Ta) in seconds of a moment resisting
frame building without brick infill panels may be also obtained by the empirical expressions.
c) Ta=0.1n
Where,
15
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Where,
16
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Center of Rigidity (CR) - A point through which a horizontal force is applied resulting in
translation of the floor without any rotation
17
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
18
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
ly = 6.7m =6700mm (i.e. the largest of the two dimensions of the slab)
6700
= = 1.26 2
5300
Hence the slab is two way continuous slab.
Control of Deflection, we can draw out the following methodical steps to get the thickness of slab.
Here d represents the thickness of the slab
()
()
(As the steel is high strength steel and for continuous slab)
span factor =1 for largest span less than 10m (Ref. IS 456: 2000 Cl. 23.2.1 b.)
= 1.6
= 1 for slab being rectangular section without flange (Ref. IS 456: 2000 Cl. 23.2.1 e)
5300
deff= 111.6132= 103.52mm 110 mm
19
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
A clear cover of 15mm for main bar of diameter 10mm we get the overall depth of slab as:
Overall Depth of Slab (D) = Effective Depth + 0.5x Dia. of main bar + Clear Cover
= deff + 2 +clear cover
D = 130 mm
Load Calculations:
Although only with screed value of =20.4 KN/m3 but with punning =21 KN/m3
DL of Ceiling and Plaster 12.5 mm thick (DLC) =20.4* 0.0125*1= 0.255 KN/m
= 1.5(7.58)
=11.37KN/m
WU=11.00 KN/m
20
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
= .
TYPES OF PANEL
SHORT SPAN LONG SPAN
1.26
Negative moment at 0.0454 0.032
Continuous Edge
Calculation of Moments:
At support
Mux= xwu lx2 = -0.0454*11.37*5.32=-14.5KN-m
At Mid span
Mux= xwu lx2 = 0.0344*11.37*5.32= 10.99~11 KN-m
Along the longer span
At support
Muy= ywu lx2= -0.032*11.37*5.32= -10.22 KN-m
At Mid span
Mux= ywu lx2= 0.024*11.37*5.32 =7.665 KN-m
21
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Now, from flexural considerations, the depth of slab must be enough to ensure under reinforced
behavior for the above load.
..
Where,
, 0.0035
Where = = 0.479 for Fe415 from strain compatibility condition.
0.0035+0.002+0.87
In designing slab, we take unit width of slab for computation. So, b=1m = 1000mm
Mu=14.5x 106Nmm
As the moment for the slab considered is maximum, and since the considered slab is maximum in
the size from the floor plan, a uniform slab thickness of 130 mm when provided.
22
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
PROCEDURE 1
A) DESIGNING BY DEFLECTION CONTROL CRITERIA
The methodical steps in designing the beam element preliminarily with respect to IS 456:2000, IS
1893, IS13920, IS 4326 are same as the slab element.
Hence, from Clause 23.2 Control of Deflection of IS 456:2000 we can draw out the following
methodical steps to get the depth of beam
()
()
Where,
Span (l) = 6.7 m= 6700mm (i.e. the largest available span length from the floor plan.)
span factor =1 for largest span less than 10m (Ref. IS 456: 2000 Cl. 23.2.1 b.)
= 1.4
= 1 for slab being rectangular section without flange (Ref. IS 456: 2000 Cl. 23.2.1 e)
23
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
However as the span of beam is greater than 5m, secondary beam is felt necessary by
experience.
= 0.8 for flange beam assuming = 0.3 (Ref. IS 456: 2000 Fig. 6 Page 39)
6700
deff= 2611.41.250.8= 184.065mm 190 mm
A clear cover of 25mm for main bar of diameter 20 mm we get the overall depth of beam as:
Overall Depth of Beam (D) = Effective Depth + 0.5x Dia. of main bar + Clear Cover
= deff + 2 +clear cover
D = 225 mm 230 mm
PROCEDURE 2
B) DETERMINATION OF DEPTH OF BEAM BY MOMENT CRITERIA:
Area of Influence = 10.770946+10.770946 m2=21.55m2
Load Calculations:
Although only with screed, value of =20.4 KN/m3 but with punning =21 KN/m3(assumed)
24
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Live Load =LL = 3 KN/m2 (Being Apartment building;the Live Load on floors are considered
as LL on Residential Building ) (Ref. 875 Part II Pg. 6)
Wall Load due to partition wall only= 19* 3*.115 *6.7= 43.9185 KN
= 1.5(98.7015+64.65+43.9185)
=310.905 KN
310.905
WU = =46.404 KN/m
6.7
- - 12
+
8 24
46.4046.76.7
Max Moment = 12
= 12
= 173.59KN-m
Assuming b=350 mm
b= 303.499 mm
25
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Overall Depth of Slab (D) = Effective Depth + 0.5x Dia. of main bar + Clear Cover
= deff + 2 +clear cover
D =495 500 mm
500
Therefore, b = = 333.33 340
1.5
Load Calculations:
Although only with screed, value of =20.4 KN/m3 but with punning =21 KN/m3(assumed)
Wall Load due to partition wall only= 19* 3*.115 *5.3= 34.742 KN
= 1.5(61.609+40.17+34.742)
= 204.78 KN
204.78
WU = =38.64 KN/m
5.3
- - 12
+
8 24
38.645.35.3
Max Moment = = = 90.45 KN-m
12 12
Putting d=1.5b
b= 244.214 mm
Overall Depth of Slab (D) = Effective Depth + 0.5x Dia. of main bar + Clear Cover
27
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
= deff + +clear cover
2
D =405 410 mm
410
Therefore, b = = 273.33 280
1.5
28
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
LOAD CALCULATION:
Dead Loads:
= 88.498+6.944+14.296+14.977+44.37+47.9
Hence,
= 1952.865 KN
Live Loads:
29
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Total load=473.802 KN
(For reduction in Live Load for floors, Ref: IS 875, Part-II, Page 12)
(For Live Load on Roof Floor, Ref: IS 875, Part II, Table-2, Page 14)
= 1952.865+494.22
= 2447.085 KN
Factored Load:
= 1.5 x 2447.085
= 3670.6275 KN
Earthquake Load
=3670.6275*1.25
= 4588.28 KN
30
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Ag =533.81mm x533.81mm.
540mm x 540mm
31
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
5. STRUCTURAL DESIGN
The structure should be designed in such a way that it fulfills the targeted requirement throughout
its life. The objective of structural design is to design such kind of building that gives complete
resonance with safety (in terms of strength, stability and structural integrity),adequate
serviceability (in terms of stiffness ,durability etc .) and economy .
It is necessary that reinforced concrete structure should satisfy the serviceability limit state, i.e. if
a section is of sufficient strength to support the design loads, there should not be excessive
deformation, deflection, cracking etc, which may affect its appearance. Safety implies that the
likelihood of (partial or total) collapse of the structure is acceptably low not only under the normal
expected loads (service load) but also under abnormal but probable overloads (such as earthquake
or extreme wind). The objective here is to minimize the likelihood of progressive collapse.
But through the increment of design margins we can resist the problem regarding structural failure
but at the same time cost also increases with the increase in design margins for safety and
serviceability. So, considering overall economy the cost associated with increased safety and
serviceability should be weighed against the potential losses and the best cost is selected.
32
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Where,
fy= characteristics strength of steel
Es = modulus of elasticity of steel
5.2 SLAB
Slabs are plate element forming floors and roofs of buildings carrying distributed loads primarily
by flexure. Inclined slabs may be used as ramps for multistory car parks. A stair case can be
considered to be an inclined slab. A slab may be supported by beams or walls and may be used as
the flange of a T- or L-beam. The slab in which the main reinforcement is to be designed in only
one direction is called one way slab. If the main reinforcement is to be designed in both directions
the slab is called two way slab.
The slab may be simply supported or continuous or may be cantilever. The bending moments at
critical sections are found to be found and reinforcements designed. Slab is usually designed as a
beam of one meter width to carry moment over a strip of 1 meter. Instead of bars, spacing of bars
are to be found. 8mm or 10 mm bars are commonly used.
A slab may have its few or all edges restrained. The degree of restraints may vary depending
whether it is continuous over its supports or cast monolithically with its supporting beams. A
hogging or negative bending moment will develop on the top face of the slab at the supported
sides. In these slabs the corners are prevented from lifting and provision is made for torsion. The
maximum moments Mx and My at the mid-span on strips of unit width for spans lx and ly are
given by:
Mx= ( x) x w x lx2
My= ( y)x w x lx2
Where xand y are given table 26 of IS 456-2000. In table 26 nine separate arrangements of slab
are given. The location and direction of the moment coefficients given in this table are shown in
fig below
33
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
ly
lx
For the purpose of design of slab and provision of the reinforcement, it is divided into middle and
edge strips as shown below in the fig.
Ly/8 Ly ly/8
Lx/8
Lx
Lx/8
Bending moment coefficients are given in table 23 of code IS 456-2000 which are obtained by
using the yield line theory.
The bending moments calculated from the coefficients are assumed to act in the middle strips of
the slab. In the edge strips, the minimum quality of main reinforcement for slabs is sufficient. The
34
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
certain minimum reinforcement is provided to prevent excessive local curvature and provide some
resistance to shear forces. It also helps provide resistance to some unforeseen forces applied
during construction.
For moments at supports where two unequal spans meet or in case where the spans are not equally
loaded, the average of the two values for the negative moment at the support may be taken for the
design. There is no need to modify the mid-span moments.
Design Rules:
1) The maximum positive and negative moments apply only to the middle strips subject to
the requirements for minimum areas of reinforcement. The bars are uniformly spaced in
the middle strips.
2) The rules of curtailment of bars in the middle strip are shown in the fig. below:
4) Minimum tension reinforcement should be provided in the edge strips parallel to that of
the edge.
35
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Start
N
IF ly/lx < 2 One way Slab
36
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Max Spacing,
Calculate Spacing of bars, i. 300 mm
ii. 3d
Whichever is less.
End
37
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
The code considers a slab is divided in each direction into middle strips and edge strips. The
width of middle strip is of the span and that of the edge strip is 1/8th of the span in each
direction.
1. Design data:
Dimension : 4.5 x 3.5m
Lx c/c =3.5m
Ly c/c =4.5m
Edge condition : Interior Panel
Material : Fe 415 Grade Steel
Concrete Grade : M25
3. Allowable stresses :
fy = 415 N/mm2
fck = 25 N/mm2
4. Load calculation :
d=130-15-(10/2) =110 mm
Although only with screed, value of =20.4 KN/m3 but with punning =21 KN/m3(assumed)
38
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
= 1.5(7.55)
=11.325
WU=11.33 KN/m
5. Design:
Lx c/c= 3.5m Lyc/c=6.7m
Lx clear= 3.5-.28=3.22 m
Ly clear= 6.7-.45= 6.25
Lx eff=3.22 + d= 3.22 +0.11=3.33 m
Ly eff=6.36 + d=6.36 +0.11=6.47 m
1 Interior Panel
39
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
y= 0.032
x =0.049
x= 0.065 ly x= 0.065
y=0.024
lx
y= 0.032
1 Interior Panel
14.16106
= 2.761000
=71.62110 (OK)
The length of the middle and the long edge edge strip along are 3lx/4= (3*3.22)/4=2.415m
=2415mm and lx/8= 3.22/8=.4025m= 402.5 mm
40
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
The length of the middle and edge strip along the short edge are are 3ly/4=
(3*6.36)/4=4.77 m=4770 mm and ly/8= 6.36/8=.795 m =795 mm
6. Finding Ast:
=156>Ast (OK)
Corner Reinforcement:
Area of each layer=75% of maximum mid span reinforcement
=0.75*261.799
=196.349
41
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
y= 0.032
x =0.049
+ve -ve
x= 0.065 ly x= 0.065
y=0.024
lx
y= 0.032
-ve
+ve
vve
Hence, safe
42
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Fs=0.58
199.798
=0.58*415* 261.79
=184
Hence, safe in deflection.
43
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
The code considers a slab is divided in each direction into middle strips and edge strips. The
width of middle strip is of the span and that of the edge strip is 1/8 th of the span in each
direction.
11. Relevant Codes : IS : 456- 2000 & IS 875- 1987 (part 1 & 2)
Although only with screed, value of =20.4 KN/m3 but with punning =21 KN/m3(assumed)
DL of Ceiling and Plaster 12.5 mm thick (DLC) =20.4* 0.0125*1= 0.2248 KN/m
44
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
= 1.5*(7.55)
=11.33
WU=11.33 KN/m
14. Design:
Lx c/c= 3.5m Lyc/c=5.3m
Lx clear= 3.5-.28=3.22 m
Ly clear= 5.3-0.45=4.85m
Lx eff=3.22 + d= 3.22 +0.11=3.33 m
Ly eff=5.3 + d=4.85 +0.11=4.96 m
1 2-Edge
Discontinuous
At Negative Moment at 0.075 0.047
support Continuous Edge
At Positive Moment at 0.056 0.035
Mid- mid-span
span
45
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
x =0.056
x= 0.075 ly
y=0.035
lx
y = 0.047
1 2- Edge
Discontinuous
Negative 0.075 0.047 0.047 x 11.33x
Moment at 0.075x11.33x(3. (4.96)2
Continuous Edge 33)2 =13.1 KN-m
= 9.42 KN-m
13.1 106
= 2.761000
=68.89 <110 (OK)
46
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
The length of the middle and edge strip along the long edge are are 3ly/4=
(3*3.33)/4=2.49m =2415mm and lx/8= 3.33/8=.4163m= 416.3 mm
The length of the middle and edge strip along the short edge are are 3ly/4=
(3*4.96)/4=3.75 m=3750 mm and ly/8= 4.96/8=.62 m =620 mm
=156>Ast (OK)
Corner reinforcement:
=0.75*392.69
=294.51mm2
=266.67 mm
So provide10 mm dia @ 250mm
y = 0.047
x =0.056
+ve -ve
x= 0.075 ly x= 0.075
y=0.035
lx
y = 0.047
-ve
+ve
vve
48
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Hence, safe
Fs=0.58
248.87
=0.58*415*392.67
=152.55
Hence, safe in deflection.
49
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
20. Relevant Codes : IS : 456- 2000 & IS 875- 1987 (part 1 & 2)
Although only with screed, value of =20.4 KN/m3 but with punning =21 KN/m3(assumed)
DL of Ceiling and Plaster 12.5 mm thick (DLC) =20.4* 0.0125*1= 0.2248 KN/m
= 1.5*(7.55)
=11.33
WU=11.33 KN/m
23. Design:
Lx c/c= 3.5m Lyc/c=5.3m
Lx clear= 3.5-0.28=3.22 m
Ly clear= 5.3-0.45=4.85m
Lx eff=3.22 + d= 3.22 +0.11=3.33 m
Ly eff=5.3 + d=4.85+0.11= 4.96m
1 1-Edge
Discontinuous
At Negative Moment at 0.067 0.037
support Continuous Edge
At Positive Moment at 0.051 0.028
Mid- mid-span
span
51
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
y = 0.067
x =0.051
x= 0.037 ly x= 0.037
y=0.028
lx
y = 0.067
1 1-Edge
Discontinuous
Negative 0.067 0.037 0.037 x 11.33x
Moment at 0.067x11.33x(3. (4.96)2
Continuous Edge 33)2 =10.31 KN-m
= 8.42 KN-m
10.31106
= 2.761000
=61.1 <110 (OK)
52
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
The length of the middle and edge strip along the long edge are 3lx/4= (3*3.33)/4=2.49m
=2415mm and lx/8= 3.33/8=.4163m= 416.3 mm
The length of the middle and edge strip along the short edge are are 3ly/4=
(3*5.01)/4=3.75 m=3750 mm and ly/8= 5.01/8=.62 m =620 mm
53
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
y = 0.067
x =0.051
+ve -ve
x= 0.037 ly x= 0.037
y=0.028
lx
y = 0.067
-ve
+ve
vve
100 () 100392.7
% of tension steel, Pt = = = 0.357%
1000110
Hence, safe
54
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Fs=0.58
221.35
=0.58*415* 392.7
=135.67
Hence, safe in deflection.
55
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
5.3 Beam
The design of beam requires the determination of steel for the section fixed from the preliminary
design. The design of the section may result as singly or doubly reinforcement which may be
ascertained by comparing the design moment (Mu) with the moment of resistance of balanced
section (Mul) and the section is usually design as under reinforced section.There are two types of
reinforced concrete beams in our case.
In singly reinforced simply supported beams, reinforcing steel bars are placed near the bottom of
the beams, which is the position where they are most effective in resisting the tensile stresses. In
singly reinforced cantilever beams, reinforcing bars are placed near the top of the beam for the
same reason.
If Mu<Mu1, then it is singly reinforced section and the area of steel Ast is determined by
Mu lim
Ast1=
0.87 fyd 0.42 Xu lim
Where, Xu=neutral axis depth
B) Doubly Reinforced Beams: In doubly reinforced concrete section is reinforced in both
compression and tension regions. The section of the beam may be rectangular, T and L
sections. The necessity of using steel in the compression region arises due to two main reasons.
a) When depth of section is restricted, the strength available for the single reinforced section
is inadequate.
b) At a support of a continuous beam where bending moment changes sign, such a situation
may also arise in design of a beam circular in plan.
If Mu> Mu1, then it is doubly reinforced section and the area of tensile reinforcement Ast is
determined as, Ast = (A st1 + A st 2 )
Ast1 =
Mu lim
+
Mu Mu lim
0.87 fyd 0.42 Xu lim 0.87 fy d d '
The area of compression reinforcement (Asc) is determined as,
Mu Mu lim Where, d
Asc = = effective cover to reinforcement
fsc fcc d d '
f sc , f cc = stresses in compression steel and concrete respectively
Corresponding to strain =
M Mu lim = 0.0035(Xu- d)/Xu
fsc fcc d d '
56
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
For Transverse reinforcement (vertical stirrups) :Refer IS: 456-2000, clause 40.3, 40.4&
Table 19
Calculate Mlim
Mlim=0.133fckbd2
Mlim=0.133fckbd2
If Mu<Mlim
Yes No
Over reinforced section
Calcualate M= Mu-Mlim
Ast>Ast min= 0.12%
Under reinforced section
0f bD
Calculate Ast2 by
Ast2=M/(0.87*fy*(d-d))
CalcualteAst from
CalculateAst=Ast1 + Ast2
= Ast/Abar
57
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Calculate % of steel by
p= Ast/ (bd)*100
Mlim=0.133fckbd2
Calculate v by v=
Vu/ (bd)
Mlim=0.133fckbd2
No
If c<v<max Provide minimum shear
reinforcement as per IS
456:2000 clause 26.5.1.6
Yes
Vus= (v-c)*(bd)
Check
M minimum2 spacing as per
lim=0.133fckbd
IS 13920:1993 clause 7.2
Mlim=0.133fckbd2
58
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
59
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
a. From SAP
Beam ID: B-5-5
At Left Span Singly Reinforced
For hogging moment(-ve moment) Section
Mu= 146.96x106 N-mm
Mu<Mulim
So, singly reinforced section.
Ast = 935.44
mm2(Top)
Ast = 0.87(10.42)
Ast = 935.44 mm2
Astmin<Ast<Astm
Provide 20mm dia bars.
935.44
ax
No. of bars = 20 = 2.978=3 (OK)
4
So,provide 3-20mm
Minimum Area=(.85*450*545)/415=502.319
mm2
Maximum Area=(0.04*450*580)=10440 mm2
60
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
0.87 f y A sv
Spacing of stirrups (Sv) = =
0.4b
0.87 0.87415100545
Sv= = =548.127mm>
35.89910^3
200mm(OK)
Ast = 673.51
Ast = 0.87(10.42)
mm2(Bottom)
Ast = 673.51mm2
Provide 20 mm bars.
673.51
No. of bars = 20 = 2.14=3
4
Astmin<Ast<Astm
Minimum Area=(.85*450*545)/415=502.319 ax
mm2
Maximum Area=(0.04*450*580)=10440 mm2
IS456,Table 19
Check for Shear
Tensile reinforcement provided, Ast = 673.51
mm2
Percentage of tensile steel, p c= 0.31 N/mm2
=(100*673.51)/(545* 450)
=.27%
Permissible shear stress of concrete, c = 0.31
N/mm2 Vc=76.03 KN
Design shear strength of concrete, Vc = cbd
/1000
=(.31*450*545)/1000
61
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
=76.03 KN
Vu = 1.923 KN
Here, Vu <Vc, so no shear reinforcement is
required.
Svmax=250 mm
Provide 2-legged 8mm dia. Stirrups @ 250 For minimum
mm c/c requirement
c.
At Right Span From SAP
For hogging moment(-ve moment)
Mu= 149.94x106 N-mm
Mu<Mulim Singly Reinforced
So, singly reinforced section. Section
Ast = 0.87(10.42)
Ast = 1145.71 mm2
Provide 20 mm dia bars.
1145.71
No. of bars = 20 = 3.646 = 4.
4
So,provide 4-20mm
Minimum Area=(.85*450*545)/415=502.319 Astmin<Ast<Astm
mm2 ax
Maximum Area=(0.04*450*580)=10440 mm2 (OK)
62
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Vu = 142.693 KN
Here, Vu >Vc, so shear reinforcement is
required.
63
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
64
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Ast =
0.87(10.42)
Ast = 692.979mm2
Provide 20mm dia bars.
Ast =692.979
692.979
No. of bars = 20 = 2.2069=3 mm2(Top)
4
Provide 3-20mm Astmin<Ast<Astmax
Minimum Area=(.85*280*375)/415=215.06 mm2 (OK)
Maximum Area=(0.04*280*410)=4592mm2
Ast =
0.87(10.42)
Ast = 412.309mm2
Provide 20 mm bars.
412.309
No. of bars = 20 = 1.313=2
4
Astmin<Ast<Astm
2
Minimum Area=(.85*280*375)/415=215.06 mm ax
Maximum Area=(0.04*280*410)=4592mm2
Svmax=250 mm
At Right Span
c For hogging moment(-ve moment)
For minimum
Mu= 121.23x106 N-mm
requirement
Mu<Mulim
So, singly reinforced section.
From SAP
Ast = 0.87(10.42)
Ast = 1121.479 mm2 Singly Reinforced
Provide 20 mm dia bars. Section
1121.479
No. of bars = 20 = 3.571 = 4.
4
Astmin<Ast<Astmax
(OK)
66
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Vu = 113.28 KN
Here, Vu >Vc, so shear reinforcement is required.
From SAP V2
Design of shear reinforcement
Minimum shear reinforcement
Providing 2-legged 8mm stirrups, Asv=4 82 2
= 100mm2
0.87 f y A sv
Spacing of stirrups (Sv) = =
0.4b
0.87 x 415 x100
=
0.4 x 280
Sv= 200.5833 mm
Max spacing = 0.75d = 0.75 x 375 = 281.25 mm or 300
whichever is less
68
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
5.4 Column
5.4.1 Introduction
The column or strut is a vertical compression member, the effective length of which exceeds three
times at least lateral dimension. Reinforced concrete columns are used to transfer the load of the
structure to its main longitudinal bars to resist compression and /or bending; and transverse steel
(ties) to resist bursting force.
b. Diameter
The diameter of the polygonal links or lateral ties shall be not less than one by fourth of
the diameter or 6mm whichever is greater.
69
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
( ) +( ) 1.0
Where,
Mux, Muy are the moments about x and y axes respectively due to design loads, Muxl, Muyl are
the maximum uniaxial moment capacities with an axial load Pu, bending about x and y axes
respectively, and
Where,
= 0.45 + 0.75
Where,
TABLE
Pu/Puz
0.2 1.0
0.8 2.0
For intermediate values, linear interpolation may be done; SP- 16 can be used for evaluating Puz.
For different values of Pu/Puz, the appropriate value of has been taken and curves for the
equation.
( ) +( ) 1.0
1 1
70
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
540mm
14.695KN/m
43.456KN/
m 540mm
Known data:
1.
Overall Depth of Column, D = 540mm
D =540mm
Width of Column, B = 540mm
B =540mm
Height, L = 3.05m
L = 3.05m
Clear cover, d= 50mm
effective cover
d= 50mm
Effective Length, le = 0.65 x L = 0.65 x 3.05 =
le = 1.9825m
1982.5mm
2.
Design:
IS Min. eccentricity:
71
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
1982.5 540
emin= 21.96 20 mm
500 30
As=8748mm2
Using 8 bars:
8*d2/4=8748
Diameter of bar(d)=37.31mm
Take commercially available bar 32mm
72
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
=0.62 ; =0.088
(IS 456-
1978)
From chart -44;
SP16- 1
Chart 44 =0.055
2
1 =216.513KNm
Muxl=216.513 KN m
Similarly,
Muyl =216.513 KN m
1 =216.513Nm
Puz =5182.77 KN
IS456:2000
(1) + (1) 1.0
cl.39.6
Where, =0.667+1.667 n = 2.11
=0.446*25(540*540-
6433.981)+0.75*415*6433.981
=5182.77
=0.667+1.667*(4514.593/5182.77)=2.11
3.
= 0.25*32 =8mm
f ck Ag
A sh 0.18 S h
A 1 Ak = 207936 mm2
fy k
= 146.67 mm
Therefore,
25 540 x540
50.26 0.18 x S x 146.67 1
415 207936
IS or, S= 78.55 mm
13920:1993
Spacing of hoop should be least of
cl.7.4.6 Lo = 540 mm
1 4 of min imum Lateral Dimension 540 4 135
8 mm links @ 300
100 mm
mm c/c
cl.7.4.1
74
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
8 nos
75
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
Column ID: EXTERNAL COLUMN C-B1-2:
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
282.9063KN/m
447.7584KN/m
540mm
1.
Known data:
2.
Design:
Min. eccentricity:
267.51KN/m
439.43KN/m
540mm
Known data:
1.
Overall Depth of Column, D = 540mm
D =540mm
Width of Column, B = 540mm
B =540mm
Height, L = 3.3m
L = 3.3m
Clear cover, d= 50mm
effective cover
Effective Length, le = 0.65 x L = 0.65 x 3.3 =
d= 50mm
2145mm
le = 2.145m
Check for Short and Slender Column:
77
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
2145 540
emin= 22.29 20 mm
500 30
P=3.5%
We have,
100
Pt=
As=10206 mm2
Asc=9852.034 mm2
Assume reinforcement is uniformly distributed on
four sides,
As=16*d2/4=9852.034mm2
Then Pt=3.37%
Now,
50
= =0.1 and fe 415
540
=0.56 ; =0.135
78
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
cl.39.6 Similarly,
1 =551.124 KNm
Muxl=551.124 KN m
(1) + (1) 1.0
Muyl =551.124 KN m
Where, =0.667+1.667
Puz =6207.935 KN
Now, =0.446 Ac+0.75fyAs
=0.446*25(540*540-
9852.034)+0.75*415*9852.034
n = 1.77
=6207.935
=0.667+1.667*(4086.652/6207.935)=1.77
= 0.25*28 =7mm
a) 300
b) D=540
c) 16*28=448
So,pitch =300mm
(540 50 50) 88 mm
5
h= Max of
(540 50 50) 88 mm
5
Ak = 207936 mm2
where 5 is no. of bars in each face of column section
= 88 mm
Therefore,
25 540 x540
50.26 0.18 x S x 88 1
415 207936
or, S= 130.91 mm
IS
Spacing of hoop should be least of
13920:1993
cl.7.4.6
1 4 of min imum Lateral Dimension 540 4 135
100 mm
16 nos
80
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
1. Isolated footing
2. Combined footing
3. Raft or mat footing
4. Pile footing
The type of foundation to be used in a given situation depends on a number of factors:
a) Soil strata
b) Bearing capacity of soil
c) Type of structure
d) Type of load
e) Permissible differential settlement and
f) Economy
Here we define design raft foundation for the building.
Raft foundation is a foundation unit continues in two direction, covering an area equal to or
greater than the base area of the building.
Here we have a design of raft foundation of uniform thickness, considering it as a slab. The
procedure can be summarized as below :
a. First of all , from the sap analysis data , we have transfer reaction forces data to excel.
b. From the plan of the drawings we have calculated CG of the building plan.
c. After inserting each column loads, we have calculated CG of column loads.
d. Then we have calculated ex,ey,Ix,Iy,Mx,My.
e. Soil pressure at different points are calculated by
P Mx My
= y x
A Ix Iy
This pressure should not exceed safe soil bearing pressure.
f. Taking the maximum soil pressure developed , the moment is calculated by :
Mu = wl2/10
82
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Design Constants:
Diameter of bars = 20 mm
Clear cover = 50 mm
Design Forces:
S =31.42 = 5.61 m
Since, the size of the footing is too big to accommodate separately, it is preferred to select the Mat
Foundation encompassing whole of the floor of the building as a block.
According to the preliminary calculation it is preferable to use the mat of size 5.61 m wide from
the centre of the column; hence the mat extends 0.87 m from center of the column outside from
the whole periphery of the building.
83
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
BUILDING PLAN
84
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Eccentricity along x- direction is obtained by taking moment of column loads about the grid A-A.
CMx=
3.5(3048.645+4713.063+3581.884+3590.67+4594.82+2418.406)+4.4(377.736)+9.3(319.086)+10.2(3007.961
+4665.747+3668.456+3680.605+4543.425+2227.531)+13.7(1876.709+2985.626+2458.93+2457.34+2948.798+1842.35)
74742.79
=6.734m
Eccentricity along y-direction is obtained by taking moment of column loads about the grid 7-7.
(2.1(2143.114+2418.406+2227.531+1842.347)+7.4(3213.449+4594.82+4543.425+2948.798)+
12.7(2484.123+3590.67+3680.605+2457.339)+16.4(2487.215+3581.884+3668.456+2458.931)+
21.7(3229.11+4713.063+4665.747+2985.626)+27(2129.932+3048.645+3007.961+1876.709))
CMy = 74742.79
=14.671m
Ix = 19633.334 m4
Iy= 5356.1454m4
A = 467.89m2
P/A = 159.743 m2
= P/A(Myy/Iy)*X(Mxx/Ix)*Y
Corner A-1
=237.284 KN/m2
Corner A-6
85
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Grid D-7
= 90.438 KN/m2
Grid A-3
Grid F-3
Corner F-1
Corner F-6
= 92.757 KN/m2
86
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
GRID X Y s(KN/m2)
In the y-direction, the raft is divided into six strips, that is, six equivalent beams.
87
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
Taking the maximum soil pressure developed, the moment is calculated by:
Mu = wl2/10
In x-direction again the raft is divided into seven strips, i:e seven equivalent beams:
Note: Here the maximum upward soil pressure (237.284kN/m2) is greater than safe bearing
capacity (150 KN/m2) of foundation soil so it is necessary to increase the strength of the
foundation soil by using geotechnical soil stabilizing process like certain depth of granular
material packing.
89
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
1 Known Data
2 Moment Calculation
666.531 10^6
0.138 25 1000
= 439.542 mm
90
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
= 1.25 N/mm2
Perimeter(bo) = 2 x (0.5d+600+540)=2x(0.5d+1140)
Pu 2129.932 x10 3
Nominal Shear Stress v =
bo x d 2(0.5d 1140)d
2129.932 x10 3
1.25=
2(0.5d 1140)d
On solving we get,
.d = 593.074 mm
91
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
c = c = 0.25 f ck
= 0.25 * 25
= 1.25 N/mm2
Pu 3048.645x10 3
v = = 1.25
bo x d (2d 2820) * d
On solving we get,
.d = 605.1462mm
c = c = 0.25 f ck
= 0.25 * 25
= 1.25 N/mm2
Perimeter(bo) = (1140+0.5d)*2+(d+540)
=(2d+2820)
Pu 2985.626 x10 3
v = = 1.25
bo x d (2d 2820) * d
On solving we get,
92
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
.d =595.49 mm
Provide 20 mm bars
415
666.531x106= 0.87x415x Astx800x(1 100080025)
IS 456-
2000 Provide
Ast = 2430.156mm2> Min. Ast. Hence OK
Annex G Ast = 2450 mm2
(G-1.1 b)
So provide Ast = 2450 mm2
Provide 20 mm bars
5
Area of each bar, Ab = 314.159 mm2
Ab
Spacing of Bars , S v x 1000
Ast
Spacing Ok
314.159
x 1000
2450 20mm bar @ 120 mm
c/c
= 128.23 mm
Ab
Act. A st x 1000
Sv
= 2617.99 mm2
93
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
94
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti
B.E. (Civil) - 068 Batch, NCE : Final Year Project on Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Apartment Building at Kathmandu.
95
Prepared By : Damodar Dhungana , Bishnu Dhungana, Sudip Nepal, Prabesh Pandit, Roshan Shrestha, Ashish Bastakoti