Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
1
Assistant Professor, Department of Industrial & Electrical Engineering Technology of South Carolina State
University, U.S.A.
2
Lecturer, Electrical Engineering, department of Michael Okpara University of Agriculture, Umudike, Nigeria
ABSTRACT
Engineering Ethics is a growing concern, especially as interest in public and industrial safety increases. The
knowledge of Engineering Ethics acquired by Engineering students in the Colleges and Universities is not
sufficiently enough to prepare them to handle safety challenges in the industry as pupil Engineers. Knowledge of
Engineering Ethical issues, and how there were solved is very crucial on perspective of industrial and public safety.
The purpose of this project is to identify issues in Engineering Ethics, what caused the problem (s), and the solution
strategy employed in solving the problems. A collection of different failed Engineering projects in the field of
Electrical Engineering are compiled. It is observed that majority of the catastrophic failures, most of which could
have been avoided, were directly attributed to poor ethical decisions or practices. Most of the failure cases found in
the study were at the consumer level- the demographics affected by these failures is more diverse and potentially
more vulnerable than that of a large scale disaster. The majority of the consumer goods related to these cases were
attributed to poor materials used to manufacture them, as well as lack of proper quality tests and validation through
field experimentation. Some of the failures were catastrophic, and resulted in large scale damages. This paper,
therefore, highlights the dangers of lack of proper ethical practices in Electrical Engineering, and further reveals the
need for proper ethical practices and decisions.
Keywords : Safety, Engineering Ethics, Failures, Decisions, Fire, Maintenance.
CSEIT172143 | Received: 20 Feb 2017 | Accepted: 28 Feb 2017 | January-February-2017 [(2)1: 241-248] 241
motor to catch fire. control bit flip could trigger
modules. such an event.
2 Coby The rechargeable [2]
Electronics batteries were flawed in
recalled 19,600 design and could
rechargeable overheat and cause a
batteries sold fire. Coby Electronics 8 2 million The airbag electrical [8]
with portable reported 8 cases of vehicles were control module would
devices. Date: property damage from recalled due to receive interference
2009 fire as a result. faulty airbag from the vehicle and
3 Sayano- Plant maintenance was [3] systems. trigger an airbag
Shushenskaya ignored leading to deployment at any
Hydroelectric severe plant vibrations. time, without a crash.
Power Station It was eventually put Toyota recalled The power window [9]
Accident. under full load despite 9 about 6.5 master switch short-
vibrations and known million vehicles circuiting, resulting in
issues. The turbine due to the the melting of the
exploded, resulting in power window switch and burning of
fires and power loss. master switch. the door panel. Several
4 Soyuz 11 was A design flaw in the [4] cases of minor damages
the first ejection of the descent resulted. Recall was
successful visit module caused a initiated to prevent
to the worlds breathing ventilation further injury or fire
first space value that resulted in from occurring.
station, Salyut the death of all of the 10 Therac-25, was Therac-25 system [10]
1. However the crew members. The a computer relied on circuitry to
mission ended redesign of the next based radiation protect against faults
in disaster when module allowed only machine that and prevent
the crew two astronauts so that overdosed overdosing. Fault
capsule they could be fully patients at least developed in the safety
depressurized, suited during launch 6 times in a circuitry leading to the
killing all crew. and landing. course of two overdosing of some
5 Dells laptop Dell recalled 4.1 [5] years. patients.
battery million laptop batteries 11 Federal Pacific 220V circuit breakers [11]
exploded because the battery had residential have manufacturing
leading to the potential to short circuit breaker error. This caused the
factory recall. internally and explode, panels failed to breakers to fail to trip
Dells poor starting fires and trip causing under excessive load
laptop battery injuring people. fires. causing fire in most
design Someone was injured homes.
contributed to and there were many 12 Flight MD-11 Investigations revealed [12]
property reports of property flying from that arcing caused a
damage and damage. New York to wire to melt, setting
personal injury. Switzerland fire on the insulation,
6 In 1967, Apollo Upon investigation, [6] crashed in the which ignited
1 was the first several electrical arcs Atlantic. All flammable materials on
manned mission and power failures passengers on board. The engineers
to the moon - were discovered. After board died. failed to use very
but the investigation, there efficient over current
command were heavy protection relays. This
module caught modifications to future prompted the FAA to
fire during engineering designs, increase its standards
launch, killing manufacturing, and for flammable
the crew. quality control. materials. US Navy got
7 A court case The throttle control [7] rid of similar wiring in
resulted in the code within the engine their systems.
study, control module could 13 Flight 800 Despite a history of [13]
discovery, and cause the vehicle to combusted in fuel system issues,
recall of certain accelerate out of midair, killing maintenance men
Toyota engine control, even a single all 230 of its overlooked the habitual