Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
ARefresheronCostofCapital
byAmyGallo
APRIL30,2015
BABOSCHOKKER
Youvegotanideaforanewproductline,awaytorevampyourinventorymanagementsystem,orapieceof
equipmentthatwillmakeyourworkeasier.Butbeforeyouspendthecompanyshardearnedmoney,youvegotto
provetoyourcompanysleadersthatitsworththeinvestment.Youlllikelybeaskedtoshowthatthereturnonthe
investmentwillbebetterthanyourcompanyscostofcapital.Butareyousureyouknowexactlywhatthatis?And
howyourcompanyusesit?
Tolearnmoreaboutthiscommonlyusedbusinessterm,IspokewithJoeKnight,authoroftheHBRTOOLS:Return
onInvestmentandcofounderandownerofwww.businessliteracy.com.
Whatisthecostofcapital?
Thecostofcapitalissimplythereturnexpectedbythosewhoprovidecapitalforthebusiness,saysKnight.There
aretwogroupsofpeoplewhomayputupthecapitalneededtorunabusiness:investorswhopurchasestockanddebt
holderswhobuybondsorissuesloanstothecompany.Anyinvestmentacompanymakeshastoearnenoughmoney
thatinvestorsgetthereturntheyexpectanddebtholderscanberepaid.
Youmaybewonderingifthisisthesameasdiscountrateandthetermsaresometimesusedinterchangeably,explains
Knight.Thoughthereistypicallyadistinction.Atmostcompanies,thecostofcapitalisamechanicalcalculation
donebythefinancepeople.Thenthemanagementteamtakesthatnumberanddecidesonthediscountrate,orhurdle
rate,thatyouhavetoexceedtojustifyaninvestment,hesays.
Inmanybusinesses,thecostofcapitalislowerthanthediscountrateortherequiredrateofreturn.Forexample,a
companyscostofcapitalmaybe10%butthefinancedepartmentwillpadthatsomeanduse10.5%or11%asthe
discountrate.Theyrebuildinginacushion,saysKnight,whichisnotabadthing.Andhowmuchtheypaditwill
dependontheirappetiteforrisk.Ariskaversecompanymightraisethediscountrateevenfurther,ashighas1520%.
Butifthebusinessislookingtostimulateinvestments,theymightlowertherate,evenifjustforaperiodoftime.
Whatdocompaniestypicallyuseitfor?
Therearetwowaysthatcostofcapitalistypicallyused.Seniorleadersuseittoevaluateindividualinvestmentsand
investorsuseittoassesstheriskofacompanysequity.
FURTHERREADING Letslookatthatfirstinstance.Awisecompanyonly
HBRTOOLS:Returnon investsinprojectsandinitiativesthatexceedthecostof
Investment capital,saysKnight.Sooncethefinancedepartment,
FINANCE&ACCOUNTINGTOOL
byJoeKnight CFO,ortreasuredepartmenthasdeterminedwhattherate
$29.95 ADDTOCART is,managersknowthatisthenumbertobeatiftheywant
S AV E S H A RE towinsupportfortheirprojectsorproposals.Ifyoumake
investmentsthatdontgetareturnthatexceedsthecostof
capital,youreencouraginginvestorstogoelsewhere,
explainsKnight.Yourebasicallysayingthatwerenot
gettingthereturnyouexpected.Thereforeitsimportant
thatmanagersoftenwiththehelpoffinancetakeacloselookatpotentialprojectstomakesuretheyexceedthe
costofcapital
Nowforthesecondinstance.Althoughthisuseislesscommon,investorswilllookatanaspectofthecostofcapital
thebetaorvolatility(moreonthisinthenextsection)whichwillhelpthemunderstandifastockisarisky
investmentornot.
Howdoyoucalculatethecostofcapital?
Inreality,fewmanagerswillevermakethiscalculation.Thisisthejoboffinanceprofessionals,saysKnight,and
totheaveragemanagerwhatgoesintodeterminingthecostofcapitalcanoftenbeopaque.Heresabriefoverview
(basedontheexampleinKnightsbook,FinancialIntelligence):
Thefirststepistocalculatethecostofdebttothecompany.Thisisprettystraightforward.Youtakeallofthemoney
thatthecompanyhasborrowedandlookattheinterestratesyourepaying.Soifthecompanyhasacreditlinewitha
rateof7%,alongtermloanat5%,andbondsthatitusestomakeacquisitionsat3%,youaddthatallupandcalculate
theaverage.Letssayits6%.Thenbecauseinterestondebtistaxdeductibleyoumultiplyitbythecorporatetaxrate
(whichisusuallyaround30%intheU.S.).Theformulalookslikethis:
Costofdebt=averageinterestcostofdebtx(1taxrate)
Soyoutakeyour6%andmultiplyitby(1.00.30).Inthiscasethecostofdebt=4.3%.
Now,setthatnumberasideandmoveovertotheequitycalculation.Thisisamuchmoretheoreticalnumberandtakes
intoaccountbeta(risk)andprevailinginterestrates.
Theformulalookslikethis:
Costofequity=riskfreeinterestrate+beta(marketrateriskfreerate)
Betameasuresthevolatilityofthecompanysstockcomparedtothemarket.Thehigherthebeta,theriskierthestock
is,accordingtoinvestors.Ifastockrisesandfallsatclosetothesamerateasthemarket,thebetawillbecloseto1.If
ittendstoriseandfallmorethanthemarket,itmighthaveabetacloserto1.5.Andifitdoesntfluctuateasmuchas
themarket,likeautilityforexample,itmightbecloserto0.75.
Themarketrateistheexpectedreturnonthestockmarketrightnow.Thereistypicallylotsofdebateaboutthis
numberbutgenerallyitfallsbetween1012%.Theriskfreerateisthereturnyoudgetonariskfreeinvestment,such
asatreasurybill(somewherebetween13%).Thisfigurecanalsobedebated.
Letsassumethatthatthecompanysbetais1,thatituses2%fortheriskfreerateand11%forthemarketrate,then
youdgetthefollowingcalculation:
2%+1(11%2%)=11%
Notehowimportantthebetacanbe.Forexample,ifthecompanysbetawas2insteadof1,thecostifequitywould
be20%insteadof11%.Thatsquiteadifference.
Nowthenextstepistotakeyourtwopercentagesthecostofdebt(4.3%intheexampleabove)andthecostof
equity(11%)andweightthemaccordingtothepercentageofdebtandequitythecompanyusestofinanceits
operations.Letsassumethecompanyuses30%debtand70%equitytorunitsbusiness.Soyouddothefollowing
finalcalculation:
(0.3x4.3%)+(0.7x11%)=8.99%
ThisisthecompanysWACC.
Keepinmindthatthisisanumberusedtoevaluatefutureinvestmentssothereisalotofprojectinggoingon.Youre
usingthecurrentstructureofinterestratesandbusinessconditionstocalculateafuturereturnandtheresanimplicit
assumptionthatyourcurrentbetawillbethesamegoingforward.Inavolatilemarket,thatsnevertrue,explains
Knight.Itshardlyanexactfigureandis,infact,averytheoreticalcalculation.Likeeverythinginfinanceitsbased
onalotofestimatesandassumptions.Itmaylooklikeahard,fixednumberbutitsfarfromthat.
Whatmistakesdopeoplemakewhenusingcostofcapital?
Thebiggestmistakemanagersmake,accordingtoKnight,istakingthenumberatfacevalue.Sure,somegrouse
aboutthenumber,claimingthatitstoohighanditlimitstheinvestmentsthattheycanreasonablymake,butmostjust
takethefigurehandedtothembyfinance.Thisisproblematicbecausethecostofcapitalhasabiginfluenceonwhat
youreabletodo.Itsnotsomethingyoushouldjustaccept.Youshouldabsolutelychallengeit,saysKnight.
Herecommendsaskingyourcounterpartinfinance:Whatdidyouuseforcostofequity?Howdidyoucomeupwith
costofdebt?Orwhydoweuse12%asthemarketrate?Youcanmissalotofopportunitieswhenyouhavetohita
higherstandard,Knightsays,soitsworthaskingtoughquestionsandseeingifyoucannegotiatetherate.Whatyou
wanttheratetobewilldependonthetypeofprojectyouretakingon.Forexample,ifyoureamanagerproposinga
wholenewR&Dsoftwareforanewproductthatyouveneverdonebefore,youwanttouseahighnumber,probably
higherthanyourWACC,toshowthatthistypeofriskyinvestmentisworthit.Butifyourorderprocessingsystemis
breakingdownandyouneedanewone,youcanusealowerratesincethisispartofthenutsandboltsinfrastructure
forrunningyourbusiness.Afterall,ifyoudonthaveanorderprocessingsystem,youllbeoutofbusiness.
Anothermistakemanagersmakeistopadthenumber.Theyliketobumpituptobesafe,explainsKnight.Ifthe
corporatecostofcapitalis12%,thenamanagermightthink,Imgoingtouse15%tobeonthesafeside.Butthe
numberlikelyalreadyincludesacushion.Dontupitagainoryouwillbemakingthingsunnecessarilyhardon
yourself.
Whenfinancetellsyouthatyournewprojectorinitiativeneedsareturnthatbeatsthecompanyscostofcapital,its
helpfultoknowwhatthatfigureisandhowitscalculated.Armedwiththisinformation,youllbeabletobettermake
thecasethatyourideaisworththecompanysinvestment.
AmyGalloisacontributingeditoratHarvardBusinessReviewandtheauthoroftheHBR
GuidetoManagingConflictatWork.Shewritesandspeaksaboutworkplacedynamics.Follow
heronTwitterat@amyegallo.
ThisarticleisaboutFINANCIALANALYSIS
F OLLOW T HIS TOPIC
Comments
LeaveaComment
POST
5COMMENTS
GustavoAndrade 9monthsago
Verygoodanduseful.Manythanksindeed.
RE PLY 1 0
POSTINGGUIDELINES
WehopetheconversationsthattakeplaceonHBR.orgwillbeenergetic,constructive,andthoughtprovoking.Tocomment,readersmust
signinorregister.Andtoensurethequalityofthediscussion,ourmoderatingteamwillreviewallcommentsandmayeditthemforclarity,
length,andrelevance.Commentsthatareoverlypromotional,meanspirited,orofftopicmaybedeletedperthemoderators'judgment.All
postingsbecomethepropertyofHarvardBusinessPublishing.