Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
1:
IDENTIFICATION
OF
DEAD
BODIES
Sergio
P.
Paguio,MD,LL.B.MMHA,FPSP,FPSO
Iden?ca?on
of
a
dead
person
is
important
in
the
:
1.
prosecu?on
of
criminal
oense
2.
facilita?on
of
seJlement
of
estate
3.
re?rement
4.
insurance
and
other
social
benets
5.
resolving
anxiety
of
rela?ves
and
friends.
Rules
in
Iden?ca?on
1.
The
greater
the
number
of
points
of
similari?es
and
dissimilari?es
of
two
persons
compared,
the
greater
is
the
probability
for
the
conclusion
to
be
the
correct.
the
Law
of
Mul?plicity
of
Evidence
in
iden?ca?on.
Rules
in
Iden?ca?on
2.
The
value
of
the
dierent
points
of
iden?ca?on
varies
in
the
formula?on
of
conclusion.
Posi?ve:
ngerprints
on
le
is
the
same
with
the
dead
body.
Corrobora?ve:
body
marks
(moles,
scars,
complexion,
shape
of
nose,
etc.)
Fingerprints
and
Dental
Records
have
greater
value
compared
with
Visual
recogni?on
by
rela?ves
and
friends
Rules
in
Iden?ca?on
3.
The
longer
the
interval
between
death
and
the
examina?on
of
the
dead
body
for
iden?ca?on,
the
greater
is
the
need
for
experts
in
establishing
the
iden?ty.
It
is
necessary
to
act
in
the
shortest
possible
?me
specially
in
cases
of
mass
disaster.
Methods
of
Iden?ca?on
1.
By
comparison:
Iden?ca?on
criteria
recovered
during
inves?ga?on
are
compared
with
records
available
in
the
le.
Post-mortem
ndings
are
compared
with
ante-mortem
records.
2.
By
exclusion:
If
two
or
more
persons
have
to
be
iden?ed
and
all
but
one
is
not
yet
iden?ed,
then
the
one
whose
iden?ty
has
not
been
established
may
be
known
by
elimina?on
Methods
of
Approxima?ng
the
Height
of
a
Person
A.
Measure
the
distance
between
the
?ps
of
the
middle
nger
of
both
hands
with
the
arms
extended
laterally
=
height.
B.
2
x
length
of
one
arm
+
12
inches
from
the
clavicle
and
1.5
inches
from
the
sternum
=
height.
C.
2
x
length
from
the
vertex
of
the
skull
to
the
pubic
symphysis
=
height.
Methods
of
Approxima?ng
the
Height
of
a
Person
D.
Distance
between
the
supra-sternal
notch
and
the
pubic
symphysis
=
1/3
height.
E.
Distance
from
the
base
of
the
skull
to
the
coccyx
=
44%
of
height
F.
The
length
of
the
forearm
measured
from
the
?p
of
olecranon
process
to
the
?p
of
the
middle
nger
=
5/19
of
height.
G.
8
x
length
of
the
head
=
height
Informa?on
included
in
the
Ber?llon
system
1.
Descrip?ve
data:
color
of
the
hair,
eyes
and
complexion,
shape
of
the
nose,
ear,
etc.
2.
Body
marks
moles,
scars,
taJoo
marks,
deformi?es,
etc
3.
Anthropometrical
measurements:
a.
Body
Measurements
b.
Measurement
of
the
head
c.
Measurement
of
the
limbs
Extrinsic
Factors
in
Iden?ca?on
of
Dead
Body
1.
Ornamenta?ons
rings,
bracelet,
necklace,
hairpin,
earrings,
lapel
pin,
etc.
2.
Personal
belongings
leJers,
wallet,
drivers
license,
residence
cer?cate,
personal
cards,
etc.
3.
Wearing
apparel
tailor
marks,
laundry
mark,
printed
name
of
owner,
size,
style,
and
texture,
footwear,
socks
Extrinsic
Factors
in
Iden?ca?on
of
Dead
Body
4.
Foreign
bodies
dust
in
clothings,
cerumen
in
the
ears,
nail
scrappings
may
show
occupa?on,
place
of
residence
or
work,
habit,
etc.
5.
Iden?ca?on
by
close
friends
and
rela?ves.
6.
Iden?ca?on
record
on
le
at
the
police
department,
immigra?on
bureau,
hospitals,
etc.
7.
Iden?ca?on
photograph.
SCIENTIFIC
METHODS
OF
IDENTIFICATION
OF
A
DEAD
BODY
A.
DNA
TESTING
B.
Fingerprin?ng
C.
Dental
Iden?ca?on
D.
Handwri?ng
E.
Iden?ca?on
of
Skeleton
F.
Determina?on
of
Sex
G.
Determina?on
of
Age
H.
Iden?ca?on
of
Blood
and
Blood
Stains
I.
Iden?ca?on
of
Hair
and
Fibers
Fingerprin?ng
Universally
used
because:
There
are
no
iden?cal
ngerprints.
The
chances
of
two
ngerprints
being
the
same
are
claculated
to
be
1:64
billion.
Fingerprints
are
not
changeable.
Fingerprints
are
formed
in
the
fetus
in
the
4th
month
of
pregnancy.
Fingerprints
are
an
indelible
signature
which
a
person
carries
from
the
cradle
to
the
grave
Prac?cal
Uses
of
Fingerprints
1. Help
establish
iden?ty
in
cases
of
dead
bodies
and
unknown
or
missing
persons.
2. Prints
recovered
from
the
crime
scene
associate
person
or
weapon.
3. Prints
on
le
are
useful
for
compara?ve
purposes
and
for
the
knowledge
of
previous
criminal
records.
4. Among
illiterates,
right
thumbprint
is
recognized
as
a
subs?tute
for
signature
on
legal
documents.
Advantages
of
Using
Fingerprints
As
a
Means
of
Iden?ca?on
1. Not
much
training
is
necessary
for
a
person
to
take,
classify
and
compare
ngerprints.
2. No
expensive
instrument
is
required
in
the
opera?on.
3. The
ngerprint
itself
is
easy
to
classify.
4. Actual
prints
for
compara?ve
purposes
are
always
available
and
suspected
errors
can
easily
be
checked.
Dental
Iden?ca?on
The
role
of
the
teeth
in
human
iden?ca?on
is
important
for
the
following
reasons:
1. The
possibility
of
two
persons
to
have
the
same
den??on
is
quite
remote.
2. The
enamel
of
the
teeth
is
the
hardest
substance
of
the
human
body.
3. The
more
recent
the
ante-mortem
records
of
the
person
to
be
iden?ed,
the
more
reliable
is
the
compara?ve
or
exclusionary
mode
of
iden?ca?on
that
can
be
done.
Handwri?ng
A
person
may
be
iden?ed
through
his
handwri?ng,
hand
prin?ng
and
hand
numbering.
Proven
by:
Statement
of
witness
who
saw
the
wri?ng
made
and
is
able
to
iden?fy
it
as
such.
Opinion
of
persons
who
are
familiar
with
the
handwri?ng
of
the
alleged
writer
Opinion
of
an
expert
who
compares
the
ques?oned
wri?ng
with
that
of
the
other
wri?ngs
which
are
admiJed
or
treated
to
be
genuine
by
the
party
against
whom
the
evidence
is
oered.
Iden?ca?on
of
Skeleton