Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Yes Yes
Yes
Referral for diagnostic workup
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Fig. 1. Evidenced-based guideline for referral of children with HSDS, referral and further investigations should be considered.
short stature and age 010 years. a These referral criteria only ap- c These guidelines are proposed for screening purposes only. In
ply to children with a birth weight 62,500 g. b Children with a individual cases, especially when growth deflection occurred re-
growth disorder and tall parents can be missed if a child is 63 cently: in spite of HSDS, referral and further investigations should
years old and height is 12.5 SD below target height. In spite of be considered. HSDS = Height SDS; THSDS = target height SDS.
height rule and the height deflection rule (an HSDS de- consensus these children would not have been diagnosed
crease 11.0 SD) detected 86% of girls with the Turner syn- at that point, as this consensus recommends a single mea-
drome and 77% of children who were short because of surement at the age of 5 years [13]. On the other hand, the
various disorders. The estimated specificity of this ap- specificity of the UK guideline is considerably higher
proach was 98%. Insufficient data were available to give (99.5 vs. 98%). Validation of these and other guidelines in
evidence-based guidelines for children 110 years. One prospective studies are needed, possibly in combination
might consider referral and diagnostic procedures in this with a cost-benefit analysis, before a definite conclusion
age group if HSDS !2.5. can be drawn.
If one compares the UK consensus guideline and the
recent evidence-based Dutch guideline, it is clear that the
sensitivity of the latter must be higher, and that pathol- Diagnostic Procedures
ogy will be detected at a younger age. For example, based
upon the Dutch evidence-based guidelines a diagnosis Classification of Growth Disorders
would be made before the age of 3 years in 30% of the When a child is referred to a pediatrician, the diag-
children with pathology. In contrast, according to the UK nostic process is aimed at detecting the cause of his/her
A Primary growth disorders B4 Other disorders of the growth hormone-IGF axis (primary
A1 Clinically defined syndromes IGF-I deficiency and resistance)
Turner syndrome Bioinactive growth hormone
Cornelia de Lange syndrome Abnormalities of the growth hormone receptor (growth
DiDeorge syndrome (velocardiofacial syndrome) hormone insensitivity syndrome, Laron syndrome)
Down syndrome Abnormalities of GH signal transduction, e.g. STAT5B
Noonan syndrome defect
Prader-Willi-Labhart syndrome ALS (acid-labile subunit) deficiency
Von Recklinghausens disease (neurofibromatosis type 1) IGF-I deficiency
Silver-Russell syndrome IGF resistance (IGF1R defects, postreceptor defects)
A2 Small for gestational age with failure of catch-up growth B5 Other endocrine disorders
IGF-I deficiency, IGF resistance Cushing syndrome
Due to known cause, e.g. prenatal infections, drugs, Hypothyroidism
smoking, alcohol Leprechaunism
Idiopathic Diabetes mellitus (poorly controlled)
A3 Skeletal dysplasias Short adult stature caused by accelerated bone maturation,
Achondroplasia e.g. precocious puberty, hyperthyroidism, congenital adre-
Hypochondroplasia nal hyperplasia, exogenous estrogens or androgens
Dyschondrosteosis (Leri-Weill and other defects in the B6 Metabolic disorders
SHOX gene) Disorders of calcium and phosphorus metabolism
Osteogenesis imperfecta IVI Disorders of carbohydrate metabolism
Mucopolysaccharidosis (type IH, IS, IIVII) Disorders of lipid metabolism
Mucolipidosis (type II and III) Disorders of protein metabolism
A4 Dysplasias with defective mineralization B7 Psychosocial
Emotional deprivation
B Secondary growth disorders Anorexia nervosa
B1 Insufficient nutrient intake (malnutrition) Depression
B2 Disorders in organ systems B8 Iatrogenic
Cardiac disorders Systemic glucocorticoid therapy
Pulmonary disorders, e.g. cystic fibrosis Local glucocorticoid therapy (inhalation, intestinal, other)
Liver disorders Other medication
Intestinal disorders, e.g. Crohns disease, malabsorption Treatment of childhood malignancy
syndromes Total body irradiation
Short bowel syndrome Chemotherapy
Renal disorders, e.g. Fanconi syndrome, renal acidosis Other specified iatrogenic causes
Chronic anemia
B3 Growth hormone deficiency (secondary IGF-I deficiency) C Idiopathic short stature
Idiopathic C1 Familial (idiopathic) short stature
Genetic (HESX1, PROP1, POU1F1, LHX3, LHX4, C2 Non-familial (idiopathic) short stature
GHRHR, GH)
Associated with syndromes or cerebral or facial malforma-
tions, e.g. septo-optic dysplasia, empty sella syndrome
Associated with prenatal infections, e.g. rubella
Acquired (craniopharyngioma, other pituitary tumors, e.g.
germinoma, hamartoma)
Head trauma
Central nervous system infections
Granulomatous diseases, e.g. histiocytosis
Issue Interpretation
Medical history
Birth length, weight, head circumference, Compare with intrauterine growth standards (SGA or AGA?; proportionate
gestational age or disproportionate?)
Special features regarding pregnancy (intrauterine Fetal (intrauterine) growth retardation can lead to an SGA birth weight, and
growth retardation, drug intoxications, infections) 15% of SGA born children do not catch up in height. Intrauterine
and birth (breech delivery, asphyxia, jaundice) intoxications and infections can lead to diminished fetal growth. Pituitary
dysfunction is associated with breech delivery and prolonged jaundice
Previous growth data A complete growth curve is essential for a good assessment of a growth
disorder
Age at start of pubertal signs (girls: breast Early, normal or delayed pubertal onset
development, boys pubic hair and testicular
enlargement)
Previous diseases and operations, medication Organic or iatrogenic causes
(e.g. inhalation therapy with corticosteroids)
Medical history of the various systems, e.g. Organic causes (e.g. celiac disease). CNS symptoms suggestive of brain tumor.
symptoms suggestive of heart, pulmonary, intestinal Fatigue can be a symptom of anemia, celiac disease, IBD, renal disorder,
(abdominal pain, distended abdomen, diarrhea, hypocortisolism
constipation), kidney, endocrine (fatigue) and
CNS (headache, visual disturbance nausea,
vomiting); fatigue
Hypotonia, snoring Prader-Willi syndrome
Feeding history first year/nutrition (if nutrition is In SGA and Prader-Willi syndrome feeding difficulties in first year frequently
poor, weight is usually affected more than height) occur.
In case of failure to thrive detailed assessment of feeding pattern. In toddlers:
note symptoms of emotional deprivation. In adolescents: note symptoms of
anorexia nervosa
Country of origin, ethnicity This influences the decision about which reference charts will be used
Consanguinity Strongly increases the likelihood of recessive genetic disorders
Parental height (preferably measured, rather than Required for calculating target height
reported)
Global impression of the parents Dysmorphic features (specially facial and hands), body proportions
Tempo of puberty of the mother (age at menarche) To assess likelihood of a familial pattern of delayed puberty
Tempo of puberty of the father (age at start of pubic To assess likelihood of a familial pattern of delayed puberty
hair, age at growth spurt, prolonged growth)
Family history (autoimmune diseases, thyroid To assess likelihood of a genetic cause
disorders, growth disorders, skeletal disorders,
endocrine disorders)
Milestones delayed, intellectual retardation Associated with syndromes, chromosomal disorders, metabolic disorders
Social environment and psychosocial functioning; Neglect, emotional deprivation, undernutrition, depression, anorexia nervosa.
school performance (grade, social behavior, physical Impression of parental concern and support
activities); social contacts; personality development
(self-reliance); vitality (mood, activities, sleeping,
drinking); behavior (mascot, clown, aggressive);
unexplained physical complaints; parental attitude
Issue Interpretation
Physical examination
Length or height, weight, head circumference, sitting A high sitting height/height ratio (or low upper/lower segment ratio) is
height (or lower body segment), span, forearm suggestive of skeletal dysplasia. A low span and short forearm are suggestive
length, weight, weight-for-height, BMI, head of SHOX defect
circumference are compared with reference charts
Underweight Intestinal disorders, hypocortisolism, metabolic disorders, SGA
Overweight, obese (note: children with nutritional Hypothyroidism, Cushings syndrome, GH deficiency,
obesity are often relatively tall for chronological age) pseudohypoparathyroidism
Dysmorphic features Primary growth disorders (syndromes)
Frontal bossing, mid-facial hypoplasia GH deficiency or resistance, IGF-I deficiency
Moon face, facial plethora Cushings syndrome
Inspection of tonsils Watch for tonsillar hypertrophy
Thyroid size Enlarged (or decreased) in Hashimoto thyroiditis
Slow pulse rate, slow relaxation of the Achilles Hypothyroidism
tendon reflex
Hypertension Kidney disease, Cushings syndrome
Lobulated abdominal fat GH deficiency
Abdominal distension Celiac disease
Hepatomegaly, splenomegaly Hepatic or metabolic disorder
Pubertal stage Early, normal or late puberty
Micropenis Hypogonadism, hypopituitarism
Cryptorchidism Hypogonadism
Virilization Cushings syndrome
Muscular hypotonia Muscular disorder
Fundoscopy, vision, visual field defect CNS pathology
Signs of neglect or abuse Emotional deprivation
SGA = Small for gestational age; AGA = appropriate for gestational age.
wrist is useful [1]. On this X-ray, bone age is determined, ever, there is no consensus about which tests should be
which can also be used for adult height prediction with performed [1, 2], and scientific evidence supporting the
one of the available atlases [36, 37]. The degree of bone various proposed lists is scarce. Ideally, the choice of the
age delay is an aid in distinguishing between various laboratory parameters should depend on the prevalence
classes of growth disorders. In addition, on a hand/wrist of the disease, the frequency with which the disease pres-
X-ray, abnormalities associated with SHOX haploinsuf- ents with only growth retardation, the sensitivity and
ficiency can be seen, as well as signs of vitamin D defi- specificity of the test, and the implications for the pa-
ciency [23]. tient.
If there are no signs of any dysmorphic features or dis- We have collected evidence that only for one test the
proportion, nor of any chronic disease, most centers per- evidence should be considered sufficient. In a systematic
form a screening set of laboratory investigations. How- review we found a strong scientific basis to check for CD
Malnutrition
Organic diseases
Endocrine disorders
SGA without catch-up
Metabolic disorders
Psychosocial disturbances
Iatrogenic causes
Fig. 2. Diagnostic approach in children with short stature. TH = Target height; SGA = small for gestational age.
extensive literature search on the prevalence of mono- tals familiar with the Dutch Consensus Guideline [50].
symptomatic short stature at diagnosis in children with Probably the main reason for skipping this test was
liver disorders and further research has to be performed that an extracapillary blood sample is necessary, besides
to collect experimental evidence on the issue. At present, the routine venous blood sample to rule out other dis-
we consider it justified to remove these parameters from eases. Preliminary results of a study on the growth of
the routine diagnostic workup of short stature. infants and children with renal tubular acidosis have
The next category of serum determinations, in com- confirmed previously published data that several pa-
bination with routine screening of a urine sample, is tients with distal renal tubular acidosis often show fail-
aimed at detecting renal diseases, calcium/phosphate ure to thrive as the first and main symptom [5155].
disorders and malabsorption. More than 50% of the However, this diagnosis is rare, and virtually always
countries with guidelines for a diagnostic workup in made in the first 3 years of life. We, therefore, propose
children with short stature recommended that electro- to limit this investigation into growth failure in that age
lytes, albumin and creatinine should be evaluated [1]. group.
This agrees with the literature that shows that several There seems to be international consensus on testing
renal diseases are in fact associated with short stature TSH and free T4 to diagnose or rule out hypothyroidism
and that growth retardation is often present at diagnosis in the diagnostic workup in children with short stature
while other clinical symptoms are still absent [4649]. [1]. Although a systematic literature search has not been
An acid-base equilibrium measurement, an easy and performed, clinical experience combined with the preva-
cheap test to screen for kidney diseases such as renal lence of hypothyroidism is in favor of including these
acidosis, was only recommended in 32% of the countries tests in the diagnostic workup [56].
with guidelines [1] and was seldom done in the hospi-
As growth hormone deficiency is one of the most im- unexplained short stature [60, 61]. Therefore, we believe
portant conditions to be detected by auxological screen- that irrespective of the FSH result, a chromosomal analy-
ing and because of its relatively high prevalence (reported sis should be carried out in each girl in whom the initial
prevalence 1: 2,500 to 1: 6,000) it is obvious that IGF-I laboratory screening has not shown an abnormality.
should be kept in the diagnostic workup [57, 58]. This Thus, we did not include FSH in the recommended list of
opinion is shared by most of the countries with current laboratory investigations.
guidelines [1]. IGFBP-3 adds little to the evaluation of There are some reports suggesting that zinc (Zn) defi-
children with short stature, except in children younger ciency may be a cause of short stature, and that the deter-
than 3 years, where low IGFBP-3 levels are helpful in the mination of Zn might be considered as part of the labora-
diagnosis of growth hormone deficiency [59]. tory screening. Reasons to consider Zn deficiency as
FSH is recommended as a screening tool for Turner cause of short stature are that Zn is essential for somatic
syndrome in the diagnostic workup for short stature in growth in children and that even in developed countries
50% of the countries with guidelines [1]. In our retrospec- marginal to moderate Zn deficiency is not unusual [62].
tive study, FSH was determined in less than a quarter of On the other hand, the prevalence of Zn deficiency in
the girls in the group of children correctly referred to sec- western countries is unknown, and may be very low. Fur-
ondary health care [13]. When the age rules recommend- thermore, there are no data on sensitivity and specificity
ed by pediatric endocrinologists (to measure plasma FSH of the various tests, and apparently the available tests are
only in girls !2 years and 19 years) were applied, the fig- suboptimal [63, 64]. Further research is necessary to find
ures hardly changed. From the literature, as well as from a reliable marker for Zn deficiency, and to collect data
clinical experience, it is known that the diagnosis of on the importance of Zn status for growth in western so-
Turner syndrome should be considered in any girl with cieties.
References
1 Grote FK, Oostdijk W, De Muinck Keizer- 10 Fayter D, Nixon J, Hartley S, Rithalia A, But- 20 Wit JM, Reiter EO, Ross JL, Saenger PH, Sav-
Schrama SM, Dekker FW, Verkerk PH, Wit ler G, Rudolf M, Glasziou P, Bland M, Stirk age MO, Rogol AD, Cohen P: Idiopathic
JM: Growth monitoring and diagnostic L, Westwood M: Effectiveness and cost-ef- short stature: management and growth hor-
work-up of short stature: an international in- fectiveness of height-screening programmes mone treatment. Growth Horm IGF Res
ventorization. J Pediatr Endocrinol Metab during the primary school years: a system- 2008;18:111135.
2005;18:10311038. atic review. Arch Dis Child 2008; 93: 278 21 Cakan N, Kamat D: Short stature in chil-
2 Wit JM, Clayton PE, Rogol AD, Savage MO, 284. dren: a practical approach for primary care
Saenger PH, Cohen P: Idiopathic short stat- 11 Fry T: If its worth doing, lets do it! Arch Dis providers. Clin Pediatr 2007; 46:379385.
ure: definition, epidemiology, and diagnos- Child 2008;93:267268. 22 Simm PJ, Werther GA: Child and adolescent
tic evaluation. Growth Horm IGF Res 2008; 12 Hall D, Cole T, Elliman D, Gibson P, Logan growth disorders. Aust Fam Physician 2005;
18:89110. S, Wales J: Growth monitoring. Arch Dis 34:731736.
3 Cohen P, Rogol AD, Deal CL, Saenger P, Child 2008;93:717718. 23 Rappold G, Blum WF, Shavrikova EP, Crowe
Reiter EO, Ross JL, Chernausek SD, Savage 13 Grote FK, Oostdijk W, De Muinck Keizer- BJ, Roeth R, Quigley CA, Ross JL, Niesler B:
MO, Wit JM: Consensus statement on the Schrama SMPF, van Dommelen P, van Buu- Genotypes and phenotypes in children with
diagnosis and treatment of children with ren S, Dekker FW, Ketel AG, Moll HA, Wit short stature: clinical indicators of SHOX
idiopathic short stature: a summary of the JM: The diagnostic work up of growth failure haploinsufficiency. J Med Genet 2007; 44:
Growth Hormone Research Society, the in secondary health care; an evaluation of 306313.
Lawson Wilkins Pediatric Endocrine Soci- consensus guidelines. BMC Pediatr 2008; 8: 24 Herber SM, Milner RD: Sitting heights
ety, and the European Society for Paediatric 2129. in Sheffield, 1985: have standards changed?
Endocrinology Workshop. J Clin Endocrinol 14 Van Buuren S, Bonnemaijer-Kerckhoffs Acta Paediatr Scand 1987;76:818823.
Metab 2008;93:42104217. DJA, Grote FK, Wit JM, Verkerk PH: Many 25 Hertel NT, Scheike T, Juul A, Main KM,
4 Hermanussen M, Cole J: The calculation of referrals under Dutch short stature guide- Holm K, Bach-Mortensen N, Skakkebaek
target height reconsidered. Horm Res 2003; lines. Arch Dis Child 2004;89:351352. NE, Muller JR: Body proportions of Danish
59:180183. 15 Grote FK, van Dommelen P, Oostdijk W, de children. Curves for sitting height ratio,
5 Sorva R: Growth evaluation: parent and Muinck Keizer-Schrama SMPF, Verkerk PH, subischial length and arm span (in Danish).
child specific height standards. Arch Dis Wit JM, Van Buuren S: Developing evidence- Ugeskr Laeger 1995;157:68766881.
Child 1989;64:14831487. based guidelines for referral for short stat- 26 Tanaka C, Murara M, Homma M, Kawahara
6 Sorva R: Variation of growth in length and ure. Arch Dis Child 2008;93:212217. T: Reference charts of body proportion for
weight of children. I. Years 1 and 2. Acta Pae- 16 Grote FK: Assessment of Short Stature in Japanese girls and boys. Ann Hum Biol 2004;
diatr Scand 1990;79:490497. Children; thesis, Leiden University, 2007. 31:681689.
7 Sorva R: Variation of growth in height and 17 van Dommelen P, Grote F, Oostdijk W, Kei- 27 Fredriks AM, van Buuren S, van Heel WJ,
weight of children. II. After infancy. Acta zer-Schrama S, Boersma B, Damen G, Csiz- Dijkman-Neerincx RH, Verloove-Vanhorick
Paediatr Scand 1990;79:498506. madia C, Verkerk P, Wit J, van Buuren S: SP, Wit JM: Nationwide age references for
8 Hall DM: Growth monitoring. Arch Dis Screening rules for growth to detect celiac sitting height, leg length, and sitting height/
Child 2000;82: 1015. disease: a case-control simulation study. height ratio, and their diagnostic value for
9 De Muinck Keizer-Schrama SMPF: Consen- BMC Pediatr 2008;8:35. disproportionate growth disorders. Arch
sus diagnosis of short stature in children. 18 van Dommelen P: Evidence-Based Referral Dis Child 2005;90:807812.
National Organization for Quality Assur- Criteria in Growth Monitoring; thesis, 28 Turan S, Bereket A, Omar A, Berber M, Ozen
ance in Hospitals (in Dutch). Ned Tijdschr Leiden University, 2008. A, Bekiroglu N: Upper segment/lower seg-
Geneeskd 1998;142:25192525. 19 Wit JM, Ranke M, Kelnar CJH: ESPE Clas- ment ratio and armspan-height difference
sification of Paediatric Endocrine Diagno- in healthy Turkish children. Acta Paediatr
ses. Horm Res 2007;68(suppl 2):1120. 2005;94:407413.