Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Vol. 32 No. 3
eW
A cross
the
Nordic regioN
L`]Z]kloYq
lgkaemdYl]l`]ogjkl%[Yk]k[]fYjag&
Electronic Warfare (EW) threat environments are constantly changing. Northrop Grumman has
developed a system that instills confidence in the warfighter before the battlefield is even seen.
Weve created a reliable, high-quality, realistic IR/EO training solution. Our system provides the very
best in open-air range and battleeld simulated conditions, so pilots can train for real-world threats
in the most realistic environment possible. With realistic training, victory is that much closer.
www.northropgrumman.com
KOR Electronics places its customers ahead of the technology curve through
innovative research on the next generation of Electronic Warfare. Contact
KOR Electronics to learn more about the latest Digital RF Memories for Electronic
Attack, Radar Environment Simulators, and Electronic Warfare Simulators.
March 2009 Vol. 32, No. 3
4
News
The Journal of Electronic Defense | March 2009
The Monitor 15
Jammers Early Development in High Gear.
Washington Report 26
Army Establishes EW Ofcer Career Field.
World Report 30
ROK Selects EW Suite for F/A-50.
Features Departments
EW Across the 6 The View From Here
Nordic Region 32 8 Calendar
Marianne Kunkel and John Knowles
The Nordic region has a long history in EW and 12 From the President
SIGINT. As its members look to increase defense
cooperation in the future, EW will certainly be part 46 New Products
of the mix.
47 EW 101
Case Study:
EW Sustainment 42 50 AOC News
Elaine Richardson
53 JED Sales Ofces
The ALQ-99 Band 4 transmitter was an EW
sustainment problem lurking in the background 53 Index of Advertisers
for decades. Now the US Navy is drawing lessons
from that experience. 54 JED Quick Look
MAN-PORTABLE AIRCRAFT SURVIVABILITY
EQUIPMENT SYSTEM TRAINER (MAST)
aaicorp.com
Innovation That Works is a registered trademark of AAI Corporation.
the view
from he re
I
n late January, the US Army formally established an EW career field for its of- Sales Administration: Esther Biggs
ficers, warrant officers and enlisted personnel. Over the coming months and EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD
Mr. Roy Azevedo
years, it will build a community of nearly 1,600 dedicated EW personnel who can Deputy, Tactical Airborne Systems, and Manager,
EW, Raytheon Space and Airborne Systems
work in the EW discipline throughout their service careers. Eventually, the total Mr. Chris Bernhardt
may grow well beyond 1,600. President, ITT Electronic Systems
Maj Gen Bruno Berthet
Just getting to this point is a remarkable achievement for the Army. Back Dlgation Gnrale pour lArmement (DGA), French MOD
Col Laurie Buckhout
in early 2006, when the Army began to move in this direction, I heard from several Chief, EW Division, Army Asymmetric Warfare Office, USA
Lt Col Dean Ebert
skeptics inside and outside the Washington, DC, beltway who did not think the Army Warfighter Integration, Aviation Weapons Requirements Branch, HQ USMC
Mr. Bjrn Erman
would see this plan through. Some of them dismissed the Armys renewed interest President, Saab Avitronics
Col Tim Freeman
in EW as a politically calibrated response to the growing number of losses from IEDs Commander, 542nd Combat Sustainment Wing, AFMC, USAF
in Iraq and Afghanistan. But, in this case, the skeptics were proven wrong, as the Mr. Gabriele Gambarara
General Manager, Elettronica S.p.A.
Army demonstrated that its EW initiative was far more serious than mere political Mr. Tony Grieco
Former Deputy for Electronic Warfare, OSD
window dressing. The entire Army obviously has learned some tough and enduring Mr. Ron Hahn
Deputy Director, Joint EW Center, US Strategic Command
lessons in Iraq and Afghanistan. The enemy has spent thousands to the Armys bil- Mr. Walt Havenstein
President and CEO, BAE Systems Inc.
6 lions and has used RF-controlled IEDs and Vietnam-era shoulder-launched MANPADS Mr. Jay Kistler
Technical Director, Air Warfare OUSD (AT&L), OSD
to attack lines of communication and supply on the ground and in the air. Current Capt Steve Kochman
Commander, EA-6B Program Office (PMA-234), NAVAIR, USN
and future adversaries (large and small) will continue to challenge the Armys ability
The Journal of Electronic Defense | March 2009
Buckhout and LTC Chip Bircher, whose leadership and vision have helped to open a
new chapter for Army EW. Well done!
John Knowles PUBLISHED MARCH 2009/JED-M0309/8397
c ale ndar c o nfe re n c e s & trad e s h ows
MARCH APRIL FiestaCrow 2009
April 19-23
HPM Weapons Conference Directed Energy Systems Symposium San Antonio, TX
March 3-5 April 6-10 www.bmcaoc.org
Albuquerque, NM Monterey, CA
www.deps.org www.deps.org InfowarCon 2009
April 23-24
Avalon 2009 Emerging EW Technologies Conference Washington, DC
March 10-15 April 14-16 www.infowarcon.com
Geelong, Victoria, Australia Atlanta, GA
www.airshow.net.au/avalon2009 www.myaoc.org MAY
34th Dixie Crow Symposium Latin America Aero & Defence AAAA Annual Convention
March 22-26 (LAAD) 09 May 3-6
Warner Robins, GA April 14-17 Nashville, TN
www.dixiecrow.org Riocentro, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil www.quad-a.org
www.laadexpo.com
Navy League Sea-Air-Space Exposition
May 4-6
National Harbor, MD
Photo courtesy of Lockheed Martin www.seaairspace.org
C4ISR Symposium
May 5-7
San Diego, CA
www.afcea.org
2nd Annual EW Gaps and
Capabilities Conference
May 5-7
Crane, IN
www.myaoc.org
Joint Warghting Conference
and Exposition
May 12-14
Virginia Beach, VA
www.afcea.org
8
AOC/Shephard EW 2009
May 13-15
The Journal of Electronic Defense | March 2009
London, UK
www.shephard.co.uk
JUNE
NSA SIGINT Development Conference
June 3-4
TOUGH DSP SOLUTIONS FOR RUGGED ENVIRONMENTS Ft. Meade, MD
www.fbcinc.com
Todays critical missions demand tough solutions built to XMC-FPGA05D 36th Annual EW Symposium
survive the harshest environments. Todays warfighters rely Adaptable I/O PMC/XMC with a June 9-11
on rugged deployed sensor platforms with sophisticated Xilinx Virtex-5 FPGA NAS Whidbey Island, WA
Clearance: Secret/US only
signal and image processing for vital real-time information.
www.whidbeycrows.org
Curtiss-Wrights CHAMP-FX2 and XMC-FPGA05D provide
system integrators with unprecedented DSP power and Paris Air Show
performance. The CHAMP-FX2 harnesses the computing June 15-21
power of two user programmable Xilinx Virtex-5 FPGAs Le Bourget, France
and a general-purpose Freescale MPC8641D processor
www.paris-air-show.com
with a flexible XMC site. The new XMC-FPGA05D 55th MSS Tri-Service
provides versatile Virtex-5 FPGA processing and I/O Radar Symposium
platform in XMC/PMC. Together with Curtiss-Wrights June 22-26
SBCs, these products form the building blocks for VPX Boulder, CO
system. www.gatech.edu
AOC Kittyhawk Week
CHAMP-FX2 June 23-25
6U VPX Digital Signal Processor with Dayton, OH
dual Xilinx Virtex-5 FPGAs and a Clearance: Secret/US only
Freescale MPC8641D www.kittyhawkaoc.org a
w w w. c w c e m b e d d e d . c o m
sales@cwcembedded.com DSP & FPGA PROCESSING...
For more information on AOC
conferences, visit www.crows.org.
R U G G E D . A D V A NCED. HIGH- PERF ORMING.
A N T E N N A S Y S T EMS F OR EVERY MIS S ION.
ENVIRONMENTS: Air, Sea, Land | High-Power Active and Passive from .2 GHz to 100 GHz
SPECIALIZED PRODUCTS > C 3 ISR > GOVERNMENT SERVICES > AM&M L-3com.com
Randtron Antenna Systems
c ale ndar co u r s es & s e m i na r s
MARCH Radar ESM APRIL
March 30-31
RF Directed Energy Effects Shrivenham, Swindon, UK Radar Countermeasures
March 2 www.craneld.ac.uk April 1-3
Albuquerque, NM Shrivenham, Swindon, UK
www.deps.org Radar EW www.craneld.ac.uk
March 30-April 3
EW Communications Shrivenham, Swindon, UK Directed Energy 101
March 9-11 www.craneld.ac.uk April 6
Shrivenham, Swindon, UK Monterey, CA
www.craneld.ac.uk High-Energy Laser Weapons Systems www.deps.org
Short Course (on-line)
Modeling & Simulation March 30-May 17 Laser-Induced Sensor Effects
of RF EW Systems www.deps.org April 6
March 24-27 Monterey, CA
Atlanta, GA Clearance: Secret
www.pe.gatech.edu www.deps.org
Directed IR Countermeasures:
Technology, Modeling and Testing
April 21-23
Atlanta, GA
www.pe.gatech.edu
Basic RF EW Concepts
April 21-24
Atlanta, GA
www.pe.gatech.edu
Surprise, Deception, Warning,
and War Course
April 22
National Harbor, MD
www.myaoc.org
Intermediate Penetration
Testing Course
April 22
10 National Harbor, MD
www.myaoc.org
Psychological Operations Course
The Journal of Electronic Defense | March 2009
April 22
National Harbor, MD
www.myaoc.org
Directed Energy Weapons Course
April 22
National Harbor, MD
www.myaoc.org
Aircraft Combat Survivability
Short Course
April 28 May 1
Monterey, CA
Clearance: Secret/US Only
www.bahdayton.com/surviac/shortcourse/
MAY
IR Countermeasures
May 12-15
Atlanta, GA
www.pe.gatech.edu
JUNE
Basic RF EW Concepts
June 9-12
Atlanta, GA
www.pe.gatech.edu a
A SMART SECRETARY
Judith Westerheide
TREASURER
EW CUSTOMER
Kenneth Parks
AT LARGE DIRECTORS
Matthew Smith-Meck
CDR Scott Martin, USN
Linda Palmer
Richard Morgan
David Hime
Kenneth Parks
Michael Mick Riley
T
his month, I would like to delve into a topic that is near and dear to me, William Buck Clemons
Steven Umbaugh
and one that I have engaged in for the past 25 years of my career in EW: REGIONAL DIRECTORS
the complexity of buying (and selling) EW systems and capabilities on the Central: Judith Westerheide
Northeastern: Nino Amoroso
international market. To say the least, I have enjoyed an interesting ca- Mountain-Western: Lt Col Jesse Judge
reer working in the world of Foreign Military Sales (FMS) programs of the Bourque, Joint EW Center
Mid-Atlantic: Harvey Dahljelm
US Defense Department and direct commercials sale (DCS) programs of US International I: Col Ren Kaenzig, Swiss Air Force
industry. I also have participated in my share of EW systems exports and I have seen International II: Gerry Whitford
Southern: Col Tim Freeman, USAF
different governments employ many strategies in their quest to understand and man- Northern Pacific: Joe JJ Johnson
age EW acquisitions in an increasingly complex export arena. Southern Pacific: Vince Battaglia
A savvy customer understands his specific EW technical and operational require- APPOINTED DIRECTORS
Mary Ann Tyszko
ments, is knowledgeable about current and emerging EW technologies and capabili- Robert Giesler
12 ties and understands the intricate supply tail required to support these systems IMMEDIATE PAST PRESIDENT
Walter Wolf
over the long-term. On the other hand, customers who do not fully comprehend these
AOC STAFF
issues risk being disappointed to some degree with their acquisition. Don Richetti
The Journal of Electronic Defense | March 2009
EW technology has changed substantially over the past decade, and it will con- Executive Director
richetti@crows.org
tinue to develop rapidly for years to come. The pace of evolving EW technology poses Norman Balchunas
a significant challenge for all EW professionals who must endeavor to stay current Director, Operations
balchunas@crows.org
on the latest radar warning receivers (RWRs), radio frequency (RF) jammers, missile
Carole H. Vann
warners, laser warners, directed infrared countermeasures (DIRCM) systems, flares, Director, Administration
etc. It can be especially daunting for customer nations that are entering the global vann@crows.org
Shelley Frost
EW market for the first time. They must develop and sustain a knowledgeable corps Director, Meeting Services
of EW experts who need to understand and navigate the bureaucracies that manage frost@crows.org
defense exports in various supplier nations. Ken Miller
Director, Government, Industry & Public Relations
The role in selecting and acquiring EW systems, however, is only the first step kmiller@crows.org
in the process. It is quickly followed by managing the support process, training EW Kent Barker
Director, Conferences
users and maintainers and planning and managing sustainment of the EW systems barker@crows.org
throughout their lifecycle. One might say (and I would agree) that acquiring the EW Glorianne ONeilin
system is the easy part in an overall EW program. Director, Membership Operations
oneilin@crows.org
My point here is that it takes a knowledgeable military customer to buy sophis- Joel Harding
ticated EW systems that will meet defined operational requirements. Precious EW Director, Education
harding@crows.org
knowledge is not gained overnight, nor is it acquired in isolation. However, there is
Stew Taylor
a vast pool of EW knowledge that can be learned for very little money, time and com- Director, Marketing
mitment. The process for gaining this advanced level of understanding could begin taylor@crows.org
Jackie Kelly
with a membership in this international association. Those interested in EW instantly Manager, Meeting Services
will be connected with the global EW community and be given the opportunity to kelly@crows.org
learn their trade alongside other EW professionals. The AOC stands ready to educate Tanya Miller
Membership Services
future EW experts and provide valuable knowledge that could go a long way in guar- tmiller@crows.org
anteeing successes in the intricate world of EW systems acquisition, management Jennifer Bahler
Registrar
and sustainment. bahler@crows.org
Kermit Quick Justin ONeilin
IT Manager
joneilin@crows.org
When lives are on the line test equipment from ITT is on the ground. Before crews
ever take to the air, ITT Test & Support Systems rigorously verify all electronic warfare
systems are fully operational. For over twenty years weve been safeguarding the
self-protection equipment onboard strategic, tactical, and special operations aircraft,
so warfighters return home safely. Learn how at: www.es.itt.com.
412106
ITT Electronic Systems Test & Support Systems
fp
CMYK
p. 13
Premium Position
Page 7 if available
Multi-Port Interconnects
38999 size 8, 12; M8; P8; MMP Contacts
Blind-Mating, ARINC, Rack & Panel, Custom Shells
Easy Insertion/Removal, Field Replaceable Contacts
Rugged, Sealed, Extreme Environment Qualified
CMYK
Blind Mate Antenna Solutions
Military Low Smoke Cables p. 14 Antennas to Blind Mate
Convert
Improve Reliability, Maintainability
Ideal for Shipboard, Vehicle,
Manned Area Use
PremiumandPosition
Serviceability
Simplify Mission Equipment
Low Loss, Light Weight, Role Changes
Superior RF Shielding Reduce Loss, Eliminate Cable Loop
Fire Retardant (non-halogen),
Flexible
MIL-DTL-17H Qualified
World Headquarters: 358 Hall Avenue, Wallingford, CT 06492 Tel: 203 -949 -8400, 1-800-867-2629 Fax: 203 -949 -8423
International Sales: 4 School Brae, Dysart, Kirkcaldy, Fife, Scotland KY1 2XB UK Tel: +44(0)1592655428 Fax: +44(0)1592653162
China Sales: 16F, United Plaza, 1468 West Nanjing Road, Shanghai, China 200040 Tel: 86-21-32224506 Fax: 86-21-62898980
www.timesmicrowave.com
th e m o n i t o r
news
JAMMERS EARLY tronic Attack (AEA) Program Office (PMA- to enter an Engineering and Manufac-
DEVELOPMENT IN HIGH GEAR 234) at Naval Air Systems Command (NAS turing Development phase with a single
An Analysis of Alternatives (AoA), Patuxent River, MD). contractor would follow in FY2013.
16
w
The Journal of Electronic Defense | March 2009
w LY
(E
SHEPHARD
w B
AR
Bo ph RA
.sh IR
ok ard TE
e D
on .co AV
lin .u AI
e k/e LA
at v BL
en E
2009 ts )
Keynote Address:
Andrew Brookes, Conference and Exhibition
(covering air, land and sea)
Senior Analyst, International Institute of Strategic Studies, UK
Opening Address:
Air Commodore Sean Bell,
14-15 May 2009
Director Equipment Capability (Theatre Airspace), UK Novotel London West, London
Member of Official Media Supporting Media Official Online Media Partner
Media Partner
To book your delegate place, for partnership and exhibition opportunities, please contact:
SHEPHARD Ana Stratton on +44 (0)1753 727008 or email ams@shephard.co.uk
the-shelf technology; or exploration of
the costs and benefits of a new jamming
system based on a lower TRL that ini-
tially can address the core requirement
currently filled by the ALQ-99.
The solicitation number is AIR410-
NGJ-RFI. The technical point of contact
is Tom Dalheim, the NGJ AoA Technical
IPT Leader at the Naval Surface Weap-
on Center-Crane Division (Crane, IN),
at (812) 854-4886, e-mail thomas.dal-
into legacy systems. the B-52 CCJ will not be funded beyond
the current fiscal year.
The decision leaves a stand-off jam-
ming void for the Air Force. Beginning
later this year, the Navy plans to retire
all of its EA-6B Prowler jamming air-
craft, which also have supported pen-
etration of defended airspace by Air
Dixie C
row Sympo
Force fighters and bombers, and to re-
sium
March place them by the end of 2012 only with
22-26
18 enough new EA-18G Growlers for Navy
fleet missions.
Visit th The Air Force is counting on a jam-
Win a W e CTT Booth an
The Journal of Electronic Defense | March 2009
ild Wease d
l Model! ming variant of its expendable, cruise
Whenever legacy systems are upgraded, whether missile-like Miniature Air-Launched De-
Microwave Technology Leadership
to address new threats or to benefit from improved Low-Noise Amplifiers coy, called MALD-J, to help fill the void
technology, you can count on CTTs twenty-five years of NEW Compact Low-Noise by providing stand-in low-power jam-
experience in microwave amplification and subsystem 0.520 GHz ming in proximity to enemy air defense
integration. Broadband 0.220 GHz
radars. It is slated for initial fielding in
CTT offers not only form, fit, function of Broadband 1740 GHz
microwave amplifier replacements for many mature Narrowband Up to 18 GHz 2012. The basic MALD entered low-rate
systems, but also incorporates leading-edge technology Custom Engineered Options initial production by Raytheon Missile
components such as GaN and SiC. Hi-Reliability Capability Systems (Tucson, AZ) last June. The Air
CTT is well positioned to offer engineering and Power Amplifiers Force awarded Raytheon a two-year $80
production technology solutions including high-rel NEW GaN Broadband USA-based thin-film
manufacturing to infuse new technology into legacy microwave production
million risk-reduction contract in April
Broadband 0.2100W
systems for improved reliability and life cycle costs. Narrowband Up to 100W facility 2008 for MALD-J. This past January, the
Multi-Band Communications Rack-Mount 0.540 GHz Air Force awarded the company a con-
Simulators Special Purpose Amplifiers tract modification to study increasing
Line Test Equipment Equalizer Amplifiers
EW: ECM, ECCM & ESM the radiated power of MALD-Js jamming
Frequency Doubler/Triplers
Jammers: Radar & IEDs Limiting Amplifiers payload and adding a data link to the
Radar Systems Temperature Compensated decoy. With more power, MALD-J could
More than twenty-five years ago CTT, Inc. made Subsystems stand off a little farther from air defens-
a strong commitment to serve the defense electronics Contract Manufacturing es and thus jam a larger target set.
market with a simple goal: quality, performance,
Another platform that will help fill
reliability, service and on-time delivery of our
products. the void in some scenarios is the Air
Give us a call to find out how our commitment Forces turboprop EC-130H Compass Call
can support your success. Its that simple. communications-jamming aircraft, to
which a radar jamming capability is be-
241 East Java Drive Sunnyvale California 94089 ing added. The aircraft are being modi-
Phone: 408-541-0596 Fax: 408-541-0794 www.cttinc.com E-mail: sales@cttinc.com
fied to carry two high-power Special
the mo ni tor | n e w s
GROWLER MAINTENANCE
TRAINER
Boeing (St. Louis, MO) revealed
that it had delivered the first
maintenance trainer for its new US
Navy EA-18G Growler jamming air-
craft to the Navys Whidbey Island
Because tomorrows Naval Air Station, WA, November
platforms 21, two weeks ahead of schedule.
Boeing delivered the first EA-18G
fleet aircraft and first aircrew
trainer to Whidbey last June.
The maintenance trainer is a set
20 of three devices. Two of them are
mockups of aircraft hardware, one
The Journal of Electronic Defense | March 2009
ATK and BAE Systems are world leaders in delivering Aircraft Survivability solutions, with thousands of systems
deployed. Teamed to provide the USN/USMC the right solution to their JATAS program requirements.
www.atk.com
www.symetrics.com www.baesystems.com
t h e m o n it o r | n e ws
NORTHROP GRUMMAN the specific DIRCM installation on the the ALE-47 countermeasures dispenser.
EMPLOYEES CH-53E or CH-46E platforms. JED regrets In a subsequent quarterly financial re-
DIE IN PLANE CRASH any confusion this may have caused. port, Raytheon indicated that the ACES
Four employees of Northrop Grum- contract with Morocco is valued at $127
man Amherst Systems (Buffalo, NY) died Correction: The article, Morocco Selects million. Future versions of ACES are ex-
tragically February 12 when the aircraft F-16 EW Suite (JED, January 2009, Page pected to feature the ALR-69A.
they were traveling in crashed as it ap- 24), erroneously identified a subsystem
proached the airport near Buffalo. The of the Advanced Countermeasures Elec- IN BRIEF
four coworkers were flying home from tronic System (ACES) sold to the gov- Marine Corps Systems Command,
Newark airport after a one-day business ernment of Morocco. Morocco bought on January 30, solicited bids for a Prod-
trip. The victims were Steve Johnson, an ACES comprising the ALR-93 radar uct Support Integrator and Contrac-
LaBarge has worked on the program for The grant specifically will fund second-
nearly a decade. stage activities in the development and
fabrication of highly conductive, high-
aspect-ratio nanomaterials for military Raytheons Laser Centurion Demon-
infrared (IR) obscurants. With an end strator is being tested as an air defense
ITT Electronic Systems (Clifton, NJ) goal of producing materials with an ideal weapon by the Army at the White Sands
announced February 4 that it plans to size and shape for use in advanced IR Missile Range, NM, under the services
establish a new 15,000-square-foot de- countermeasure devices, the project is Laser Area Defense Systems program.
fense avionics repair and testing facility slated to continue through 2010. The trailer-mounted, high-powered,
at the Crane (IN) Naval Surface Warfare solid-state laser works in conjunction
Center. The company said it will begin with a radar-based threat-detection
hiring engineers, technical support system. Initial tests with the demon-
staff and managers next month and it Kilgore Flares Co. (Toone, TN) was strator have been positive, the Army
plans to begin operations at the center awarded a $22.8 million contract by said January 30, with the laser show-
by August. The facility will provide ser- the US Army Field Support Command ing that it can rapidly penetrate armor
vices related to the evaluation and com- (Rock Island, IL) January 30 for 225,800 plating even when not at full power. It
ponent repair of EW equipment for the M206 and 488,580 MJU-7A/B infrared will be tested against mortar rounds in
Department of Defense (DOD). countermeasure flares. Armtec Coun- the coming weeks. The Laser Centurion
termeasures Co. (East Camden, AR), a also could be used against artillery and
division of Esterline Technologies, was rocket rounds, missiles and unmanned
awarded a $20 million contract by the aerial vehicles (UAVs). Unlike a gun, it
Northrop Grumman Electronic Army command for 184,800 M206 and wont run out of ammunition and fires
Systems (Linthicum Heights, MD) was 399,720 MJU-7A/B flares. quietly. The Navy also is participating
awarded a $10.5 million contract by in the program to provide a replace-
Naval Air Systems Command for spares, ment for the 20-mm Gatling gun on its
repairs, upgrades or modifications and shipboard Phalanx system. a
2009 Northrop Grumman Corporation
9eg\mdYjYhhjgY[`
lgZj]Ycl`jgm_`l`afcaf_&
=D=;L GFA;O9 >9 =& It is now possible to accelerate legacy electronic warfare
systems ahead a full generation with a straightforward modular upgrade. Next Generation EW
technologies from Northrop Grumman employ open architecture and digital building blocks to deliver
maximum exibility, accelerating combat capabilities. By mixing and matching components, ghting
capacities are mission customized. With over fty years of experience, backed by legendary support,
Northrop Grumman delivers critical performance advantages in complex frequency environments.
www.northropgrumman.com
w a s hi n g t o n
report
ARMY ESTABLISHES EW OFFICER CAREER FIELD
The US Army approved establishing cadre of full-time EW specialists is a sions and corps and above or was tech-
a new electronic warfare (EW) 29-series critical step in the right direction. nically-oriented. The new doctrine is
career field for officers, warrant offi- Gen Peter W. Chiarelli, the Armys the first effort to build an overarching
cers and enlisted personnel February vice chief of staff, said, One of the en- concept of EW operations that is nested
6. The new career field eventually will during features of any future battlefield in overall operational Army doctrine as
give the Army the largest EW manpow- will be determined [by] resourceful en- described in FM 3-0, Operations.
er force of all the services. Nearly 1,600 emies attempting to undermine our will In 2007, the Army authorized the
EW personnel, serving at every level of by leveraging the electronic spectrum. merging of the CACs Computer Network
command, will be added to the Army Building an EW structure within the Operations (CNO) function with the EW
over the next three years. The Army Army will greatly enhance our ability function and formed what is now the
also is considering adding an addition- to proactively counter these threats. A USACEWP. The joining of the two dis-
al 2,300 personnel to the career field commitment to EW allows us to tightly ciplines grew from the Armys increas-
in the near future as personnel become integrate non-kinetic and kinetic capa- ing need to understand, operate in and
available, officials said. bilities across the Army and as part of manipulate cyberspace. In the opera-
Approval for the career field was joint operations. tional environment, the lines between
26 based on an extensive study conducted The Army is conducting a series of CNO and EW are blurred, Bircher said.
by the Combined Arms Center at Fort pilot EW officer qualification courses at We can use EW to disable our enemies
Leavenworth, KS. The study concluded Fort Sill, OK. Warrant officer and en- cellular phone device or we can use
The Journal of Electronic Defense | March 2009
that Army EW expertise is not only listed pilot courses are expected to be- CNO to deny the devices access to its
necessary for counterinsurgency ef- gin this spring. Its career management network. Do we use CNO or EW to deny
forts such as Operations Iraqi Freedom field identifiers will be Functional Area our adversary, and does it matter to the
and Enduring Freedom, but against the 29 for officers, Military Occupational tactical commander? In our conceptual
full range of potential adversaries and Specialty 290A for warrant officers and research, we found that it didnt mat-
should therefore be institutionalized as Military Occupational Specialty 29E for ter. Whats important is controlling the
an enduring core competency. enlisted personnel. data, the bandwidth and the electro-
Col Laurie Buckhout, chief of the The US Armys Computer Network magnetic spectrum.
Armys EW division, said the services Operations and Electronic Warfare USACEWP will continue to lead the
EW personnel will be experts not only Proponent (USACEWP) at the Com- Armys CNO and EW doctrine and de-
in fighting the threat of improvised bined Arms Center (CAC), Fort velopment but was recently renamed
explosive devices (IEDs), but also will Leavenworth, KS, is responsible Training & Doctrine Commands Ca-
provide commanders and their staffs for providing EW doctrinal guid- pabilities Manager for CNO and EW
with guidance on how the electromag- ance and structure. It was set to as part of an internal refinement of
netic spectrum can impact operations, release Field Manual 3-36, Elec- the Combined Arms Center-Capability
and how friendly EW can be used to gain tronic Warfare in Operations, in Development Integration Directorate
an advantage in support of tactical and late February. Lt Col John Birch- (CAC-CDID) at Fort Leavenworth to
operational objectives across the full er, USACEWPs Deputy Director which it belongs. This refinement will
spectrum of operations. She noted, The for Futures, said FM 3-36 is the distribute CNO and EW expertise, pre-
Army is leaning forward now to address Armys first keystone EW docu- viously restricted just to the USACE-
the very complex challenge of control- ment of its kind, noting that WP, throughout the entire CAC-CDID
ling the electromagnetic environment previous EW doctrine organization, thus making the overall
in land warfare. The creation of a large was localized to divi- development process more efficient,
Bircher said. G. Goodman a
The whole is far greater than the sum of its parts
Cobham Microwave Systems
consists of these groups:
Sensor & Antenna Systems,
Active Microwave Sub-systems,
and Passive Microwave
Sub-systems. For added assur-
ance, all our products, from the
smallest MMIC components to
the largest antenna subsystems,
are designed, manufactured,
tested and inspected to meet
the most stringent customer
specications.
Electronic Warfare Ground & Mobile Communications Homeland Security Search & Surveillance
www.cobhamdes.com
COBHAM DEFENSE COMMUNICATIONS Ltd. www.cobhamdcweb.com +44 0 1254 292020 CONTINENTAL MICROWAVE www.contmicro.com 603.775.5200
Asia / Pacic +81.44.844.8296 NURAD www.nurad.com 410.542.1700 REMEC DEFENSE & SPACE www.remecrds.com 858.560.1301 SIVERS LAB AB www.siverslab.se +46 8 477 6811
w o r l d
report
ROK SELECTS EW SUITE FOR F/A-50 IN BRIEF
Elisra Electronic Systems Ltd. of Is- of the KAI/Lockheed Martin T-50 ad- Three members of the British Ar-
rael announced February 9 that it was vanced jet trainer. The South Korean mys 14 Signal Regiment (Electronic
awarded an initial $7 million contract company received state funding earlier Warfare) were killed in an auto ac-
to supply airborne electronic warfare this year worth more than $300 million cident not far from the Regiments
(EW) systems to Korean Aerospace In- to build four prototypes of the F/A-50 to barracks in Brawdy, Pembrokshire,
dustries (KAI) for use on the F/A-50 be delivered by 2012, and believes the Wales. Killed were Cpl Dan Ginty,
attack jet that KAI is developing for air force will place an initial order for 26; LCpl. Chris Beckett, 25; and Cpl
the Republic of Korea Air Force. The 60 production aircraft to begin replac- Jimmy Luton, 24. Between them,
contract calls for Elisra to develop and ing its oldest F-5 fighters. Elisra is held the men had completed five tours of
build prototypes of the EW system to 70 percent by Elbit Systems Ltd. and 30 duty in Afghanistan. Corporal Ginty
be supplied to KAI over the next two percent by Elta, a subsidiary of Israel was scheduled to return to Afghani-
years. The F/A-50 is a strike variant Aerospace Industries. G. Goodman stan this month.
Allen-Vanguard Corp. (Ottawa,
SELEX GALILEO AND BHARAT SIGN EW MOU Canada) and Tailwind Financial Inc.
(Toronto, Canada) announced Janu-
SELEX Galileo, a subsidiary of Italys manufacturer of EW equipment for the
ary 26 that they plan to merge. The
Finmeccanica, and Bharat Electron- Indian armed forces, is expected to
name of the merged entity will be
30 ics Limited (BEL) of Hyderabad, India, provide significant market opportuni-
Allen-Vanguard Corp. Allen-Van-
signed a memorandum of understanding ties for both companies. SELEX Galileo
guard builds counter radio-con-
(MOU) to jointly explore potential oppor- supplies EW systems for aircraft around
trolled improvised explosive device
The Journal of Electronic Defense | March 2009
tunities in the field of EW in the Indian the world, including the Eurofighter
(RCIED) jammers and other equip-
market, including offset requirements Typhoon fighter and the AgustaWest-
ment providing protection against
and contract manufacturing for export land AW101 and Boeing AH-64D Apache
hazardous materials.
markets. Current opportunities include Longbow helicopters. SELEX Galileo is
offset requirements in Indian programs the name adopted by Galileo Avionica Saab Avitronics (Jrflla, Sweden)
such as the Medium Multi-Role Combat SpA and SELEX Sensors and Airborne was selected by the Italian Air Force
Aircraft (MMRCA) fighter procurement, Systems Ltd., both Finmeccanica com- to provide its BOZ-EC (enhanced ca-
in which SELEX Galileo is participating panies, to present a common identity to pability) countermeasures dispens-
through global aircraft manufacturers. the market. BEL is a government-owned ing pod for use on the countrys
The new partnership between SELEX company with coveted Navratna status. Tornado aircraft. The dispenser uses
Galileo and BEL, a key developer and G. Goodman the companys Compact Integrated
Defence Aids Suite (CIDAS) installed
in a standard BOZ pod and adds
ISRAELI JSF NEGOTIATIONS missile warning, an EW controller
and pyrotechnic countermeasures
Israel had made little or no headway continuing, but US DOD officials have
dispensing.
with its request to install its own EW, ra- stated that Israel will not be allowed to
dar, munitions and command-and-con- install its own hardware boxes on the Lockheed Martin selected Raythe-
trol systems in the Joint Strike Fighters JSFs and that Israeli customization of on to supply the integrated EW suite
(JSFs) it plans to purchase through the the aircraft will be limited to software. for the F-16IN Super Viper it is bid-
US Department of Defense, The Jerusa- Israeli defense firms Elbit, Israel Aero- ding for the Indian Air Forces MMR-
lem Post reported February 16. The tar- space Industries Elta and Rafael have CA fighter competition. Raytheon is
get date for delivery of the Lockheed protested the American stand through offering the Advanced Countermea-
Martin aircraft to Israel is 2014, but this the Israeli Defense Ministry. Israel and sures Electronic System (ACES). The
could slip as a result of the American the United States are scheduled to sign company also is offering the ALR-
position, senior Israeli defense officials a purchase agreement by the end of this 67(V)3 RWR on Boeings F-18E/F bid
told the newspaper. Negotiations are year. G. Goodman to India. a
AOC Award Nominations Due April 15
Any AOC Member can nominate an individual or organization for the
AOC Annual Awards. AOC Awards recognize excellence in the EW
community and are presented during the AOC Annual Convention,
October 18-22 in Washington, DC.
Nominations are being accepted for the following awards.
For a nomination form and other details, visit www.myaoc.org.
ever since. In 1994, it replaced its MiG- FY10 budget planning process, Finlands program to date is the EW suite for its
21bis and Saab 35 Draken fighters with interest could revive. In the meantime, F-16A/B aircraft. These are fitted with
64 F-18C/D aircraft, most of which were Finland has settled on a minor upgrade ALR-69 RWRs, ALQ-131 external jamming
built under license by Patria. The F-18s to its ALR-67(V)2 RWRs. pods, ALQ-162 Shadowbox II jammers
are equipped with Northrop Grummans Another major EW user in the Finnish and ALE-40 chaff/flare dispensers. The
ALR-67(V)2 RWR, ITTs ALQ-165 airborne Defense Forces is the Navy. The Navys suite is controlled by Termas ALQ-213
self-protection jammer (ASPJ) and ALE- Hamina- and Rauma-class missile patrol EW Management System (EWMS). About
47 chaff and flare dispensers. craft are fitted with the Shipborne Inte- 10 years ago, Norway had been consider-
Looking forward, Finland is trying to grated EW System (SIEWS) from Thales ing an EW upgrade program for its F-16s
establish a plan to upgrade the EW on its and the Common Opto-electronic La- but scrapped it in favor of buying a new
Hornets. The US Navy has been slow to ser Detection System Next-Generation fighter, the F-35, which it selected late
upgrade the EW on its F-18C/Ds and this (COLDS NG) from EADS. The Hamina-class last year. If the F-35 program should en-
has left countries like Finland seeking vessels also feature Rheinmetall Waffe counter more substantial delays or if the
an affordable upgrade path. Because the Munitions Multi-Ammunition Softkill unit cost grows too much, Norway could
Finnish Air Force did not install ASPJs System (MASS), which is installed on dust off its plans for F-16 EW upgrades un-
on all of its F-18s during the original the Navys pair of Hameenmaa-class til a longer-term solution is identified.
procurement in the mid-1990s, it consid- mine layers. Norway also is investing in several na-
ered a plan a few years ago to complete Finland buys most of its EW and val EW programs. In June 2000, the Royal
ASPJ installation across the fleet. By SIGINT systems from abroad. The coun- Norwegian Navy acquired five Firdtjof
that time, however, the ASPJ was out of trys major defense manufacturer, Nansen-class ships as part of its Norwe-
production and the cost associated with Patria, has in the past performed a sub- gian Frigate Program and outfitted them
restarting the ASPJ production line was stantial amount of EW platform integra- with ITT RSSs CS-3701 ESM system and
not affordable. tion and sustainment for some of the Termas Soft Kill Weapon Systems (SKWS).
The Finnish Air Force then decided Finnish Defence Forces EW and SIGINT Four years later, Norway procured six ES
to look at a more comprehensive EW up- programs. Recently, the companys 3701 ESM systems from ITT and MASS
grade program for its Hornets that was Aviation Division in Tampere (about decoy launchers for its Skjold-class
M/A-COM
Prospector PRO-8010
Frequency Converter
its National Defence Research Establish- EW programs begin at FOI in support of (thought) and Muninn (memory) after
ment (FOA). In 2001, FOA merged with the Swedish Armed Forces, the Swed- Odins two intelligence-gathering ravens.
another state research agency to form ish Defence Materiel Administration The HMS Orion soon will be replaced by
the Swedish Defence Research Agency (Forsvarets Materielverk FMV) and the the HMS Carlskrona, which is being out-
fitted for SIGINT missions. The Orion was
well-suited to territorial waters, but the
larger Carlskrona is better suited to sup-
porting expeditionary missions.
Much of Swedens EW is manufac-
tured by Saab Avitronics, which is head-
quartered in Jrflla. The companys
history stretches back 50 years to the
early days of Swedish EW. Over the past
decade, Saab has grown its EW capabil-
ity by acquiring EW manufacturers in
Sweden and South Africa. In 1999, Saab
bought Sweden-based CelsiusTech Elec-
tronics, which at the time was the coun-
trys leading EW manufacturer. In 2006,
it bought Eriksson Microwave Systems,
another Swedish company that made
Astor III; ECM-, ESM- and TES system
Astor III is a new EW COTS system with ECM, ESM and Threat Emitter Simulation functions that utilize subsystems like SOR, DRFM,
radar and sensor systems. With these
Predictor and Mode-editor including a built-in GPS-Map. ASTOR III meets different EW Support-, Training- and Threat levels by acquisitions, the company consolidated
being adjustable and responsive to t all situations, from basic to advanced EW Training to Tactical Support scenarios.
Swedens EW industry. Another impor-
tommy.kahlin@mykonsult.com
www.mykonsult.com
tant acquisition was the purchase of
South Africas Grintek Avitronics in
401)*45*$"5&%"11-*$"5*0/4
+"..*/(
$0..6/*$"5*0/4
$04*5&."/"(&.&/5
3&26*3&
401)*45*$"5&%40-65*0/4
.03&108&3
(3&"5&3#"/%8*%5)
-&44-044
4."--&31"$,"(&4
108&3$0.#*/&34%*7*%&34
):#3*%$061-&34
):#3*%+6/$5*0/4
%*3&$5*0/"-$061-&34
%&4*(/&%50.&&55)&.045453*/(&/5
01&3"5*/($0/%*5*0/4
8FSMBUPOF
*OD
3PVUF
10#PY
#SFXTUFS
/:
5
'
TBMFT!XFSMBUPOFDPN
XXXXFSMBU POFDPN
2000. In 2005, Saab bought a major-
ity stake in the Grintek Group, which
gave it ownership of Grintek Ewation,
a division that manufactures commu-
nications intelligence (COMINT) and
communications jamming equipment,
as well as the S/UME-100/200 tactical
ESM/ELINT system and chaff launchers
for ships and submarines.
A decade ago, the future of Swedens
EW industry was uncertain. Today, how-
ever, Saab Avitronics is one of the largest
EW companies in the market. It manufac-
tures EW systems for fighter aircraft, he-
licopters and transports, as well as ships,
submarines and ground vehicles. Its
biggest EW program is the Gripens self-
protection suite, EWS 39. With Gripen
sales to Sweden, South Africa, the Czech
Republic, Hungary and Thailand, Saab Saab has overseen deliveries of its system was soon after put on the Swedish
Avitronics has been able to re-invest Integrated Defensive Aids Suite (IDAS), Navys Visby-class corvettes.
sales revenue into a healthy EW research a self-protection system encompassing
and development program. The result has radar, laser, UV missile approach warn- DENMARK: EXPEDITIONARY OUTLOOK
been a new suite, the EWS39/2, for the ing and countermeasures dispenser func- Arguably the most well-connected
Gripen NG demonstration program. tions, to Spain, Switzerland, South Africa, country in the Nordic region, Denmark
Said Anna Bergenlid, head of com- India, the UAE and Swedish Defense Forc- is a very supportive NATO member that
munications and public relations at es (SDF). Malaysia has bought IDAS for has maintained strong relationships
Saab, of EW capabilities on the Gripen its Su-30MKM fighter aircraft. Saab also with both The Netherlands and Ger-
38 NG, The aircraft will be designed to op- offers a Civil Aircraft Missile Protection many. It has played a behind-the-scenes
erate in threat scenarios beyond 2020, System (CAMPS), anti-Man Portable Air role buying EW products from the United
featuring increased frequency ranges, Defense System (MANPADS) technology States and integrating them onto NATO
The Journal of Electronic Defense | March 2009
improved jamming capabilities, preci- that combines an MAW-300 MWS and BOA aircraft in support of the Global War on
sion direction-finding [DF], full 3D cov- countermeasure dispensing system. De- Terror (GWOT).
erage, a MWS [missile warning system]/ signed for civil aircraft, it can be installed Like Norway, Denmark operates a
LWS, etc. The system will be based on on military aircraft as well. fleet of early model F-16 fighters that
a multi-function architecture, which For ground vehicle self-protection, were acquired in the late 1970s. These
provides seamless integration of radar, Saab produces the Land Electronic Defense F-16s, which have been modernized
communication and EW. System (LEDS), which features softkill over the years with indigenous and US
For the rest of its EW product line, and hardkill capabilities. LEDS currently equipment, remain the Royal Danish Air
Saab is honing in on international cus- is used by the Dutch army and is being Forces primary aircraft. They are in the
tomers. We have the majority of our considered by other countries. Saabs middle of a program under which they
EW business outside Sweden, said Ber- close relationship with Germanys How- will be outfitted with EADS AAR-60(V)2
genlid, and this is where we see the aldtswerke-Deutsche Werft (HDW) ship- MILDS-F missile warning system, which
markets growing. Demand for ESM sys- yard has led to sales of naval ESM systems is integrated into a pylon and linked
tems on maritime patrol aircraft (MPA), to Germany and, in 2008, the company to the aircrafts existing ALQ-213(V)
surveillance and Airborne Early Warn- was contracted by Germanys Rheinmet- EWMS. Denmark also has been seeking
ing and Control (AEW&C) systems has all Waffe Munitions to supply ESM and an RWR upgrade for its F-16s for more
fueled interest in Saabs HES-21 suite, LWS systems for the German Navys mine than a decade. The aircraft currently
which features an RWR/ESM system, a countermeasure vessels (MCMVs). use the ALR-69. If the program moves
laser warning system, a missile warner Although Saab has met most of Swe- forward, Raytheons ALR-69A(V) is a
and BOP-L and BOL countermeasures dis- dens EW needs, the Swedish Defence strong contender.
pensers. BOL has been another successful Forces have occasionally imported EW The Royal Danish Navy, which fre-
product for Saab. First produced in 1993, technology. In fact, the basis for ITT RSSs quently supports operations outside its
it has been installed on US Air Forces (then EDO Corp.) ES-3701 ESM system came home waters, also has bought EW suites
F-15 Eagle, Australias F/A-18C/D Hornet, from a request by Sweden in the mid-1990s that combine local EW systems with im-
both the UKs Harrier GR7 and Tornado, to create a replacement ESM system for its ported equipment. In September 2005,
the Eurofighter Typhoon and the Gripen. Gothenburg and A-17 submarines, and the Denmark selected ITT RSSs (then EDO
Corp.) ES-3701 ESM system for its pair supply its US market and also deliver EW to build their presence in the global EW
of Absalon-class flexible support ships. systems internationally through US For- market, EW manufacturers in Europe and
The ships also were outfitted with four eign Military Sale (FMS) channels. North America will continue to look for
DL-12T and two DL-6T decoy launchers Currently, Terma is developing a new opportunities in the Nordic region.
made by Terma. version of the ALQ-213 for The Nether- In addition, the regions efforts to
Terma A/S Denmarks main indig- lands CH-47 Chinook helicopters. The build a comprehensive defense alliance
enous EW supplier is one of only two ALQ-213A will be a smaller system that will be closely watched. An important
major foreign EW suppliers to the Unit- combines multiple units into a single sign of collaboration came January 21,
ed States (Saab Avitronics, with its BOL box, according to Steen M. Lynenskjold, when a new Nordic defense cooperation
dispenser system, is the other). Terma Termas senior vice president of airborne agency called Nordic Supportive Defence
started its EW business 25 years ago by systems. Were also separating the con- Structures (NORDSUP) held its first
AT SAAB, WE KNOW our customers want BOL has been the choice for the Tornado,
freedom. So thats what we give them. Euroghter Typhoon, Gripen, UK Harrier GR7, DOMAIN AIR OPERATIONS
SUBJECT COUNTERMEASURES DISPENSER
US Navys F-14 Tomcat, US Air Force/Air
Fifteen minutes. In a tube. Thats not just any NAME BOL
National Guards F-15 Eagle and the Royal
tube, of course, but the worlds most renowned
Australian Air Forces F/A-18 Hornet.
countermeasures dispenser. BOL. With ve
times higher capacity than ordinary dispensers,
the BOL system provides unrivalled defensive
capability.
www.saabgroup.com
Dont Miss This Years Most Important
Information Operations Meeting
Keynote Speakers:
LTG Thomas F. Metz, Director, JIEDDO
The Honorable James Glassman, former Undersecretary of
State for Public Diplomacy and Public Affairs
EXCITING AND
INFORMATIVE SESSIONS:
Chinese Information Warfare
Cyberwar 2008 Russian Invasion of Georgia
The Future of IO
Smith-Mundt Act Review
Warfighter IO Perspective
Innovation Beyond the Pillars
The New Arab Information Environment
The Media and Information Dispersal in Afghanistan
RESPECTED SPEAKERS:
BG RALPH O. BAKER, Joint Staff J5
JEFFREY CARR, Principal Investigator, Project Grey Goose
DR. DAN KUEHL, Director, IO Programs, National Defense University
LTGEN RICHARD F. NATONSKI, COMMARFORCOM
RDML GREGORY J. SMITH, CENTCOM
SHEN WEIGUANG, Chinas father of information warfare
HOU YINMING, delegation leader. Former director of the prestigious
Zhang Ya Da Electronic Research Center
White Wolf
Security
APRIL 22-24
Gaylord National Habor Resort and
Convention Center, National Harbor, MD
in partnership with:
Conference Director: Winn Schwartau
IO Professional Development
Courses at InfowarCon 2009:
Surprise, Deception, Warning, and War
Intermediate Penetration Testing
Psychological Operations
Directed Energy Weapons
EW Sustainment
The complicated story of the ALQ-99
Band 4 transmitter upgrade demonstrates
many of the unique and ongoing challenges
faced in the EW sustainment world
By Elaine Richardson
When the ALQ-99 tactical jamming sys- was very low on the production side. You tubes actually were produced. As a stop-
tem began flying aboard US Navy and can live with that for awhile, said CAPT gap, the Navy went to the boneyard at
Marine Corps EA-6B Prowlers in 1971, it Steven Kochman, program manager for Davis-Monthan AFB, AZ, to pick through
was the first fully integrated, comput- the Airborne Electronic Attack/EA-6B the systems left on the Air Forces re-
er-controlled radar jamming system. Program Office (PMA-234) at Naval Air tired EF-111 Ravens.
Developed in the previous decade, the Systems Command. By the mid-1990s, Kochman, who arrived at PMA-234 in
system featured all of the design and though, things got much worse when 2003, recognized the need to deal with
sophistication of the 1960s jammer the Navy went from having a hot, albeit a critical supply issue. For 14 to 15
pods outfitted with an exciter and two low, yield production line to no produc- years, we saw this problem and didnt
transmitters organized by frequency tion at all. address it [from the supply or user
bands. And with a series of upgrades to So how was the production line al- side], Kochman said. We never did
its low- and high-level bands, the sys- lowed to stop completely? After the much to address any of the issues on
tem has remained viable from the 1970s completion of the initial production the user side. If we were doing things
through today. run, there was a natural production through use or maintenance that con-
In the early 1980s, however, the break. Then, the Navy went back to tributed to the failure rate, we never
Navy supply system began to notice its original supplier, L-3 Communica- addressed it because we had a fairly
that the -99s Band 4 transmitter out- tions Electron Devices (San Carlos, consistent failure rate.
put traveling wave tube (OTWT) was CA), to restart the production line. But then this steady failure rate
a fairly difficult component to manu- However, L-3 had some issues recreat- started to increase as missions ac-
facture. And although it wasnt neces- ing the technology. A lot of science celerated and the ALQ-99 usage rate
sarily news the production line for goes into these tubes, but a little bit increased, not to mention the system
the Band 4 OTWT had always yielded of alchemy, too. They just kind of lost was being used in conditions never
fairly low numbers of usable units it the formula, Kochman said. It was before seen. An inability to collect
was the first inkling of what would never very producible, which is why maintenance-related data about the
become an increasingly difficult sus- production yield was so low from the basic ALQ-99 design meant that the
tainment challenge. beginning. service had little information to tell
We kept the production line going as L-3 struggled with the outdated tech- it exactly why the failure rate was so
long as possible, even though the yield nology and, between 1995 and 2002, no significant.
On the supply side, we needed to take
stock of the fact that the supply system
cant buy whats not producible. You have
to develop things for the supply system
to buy, Kochman said. Fortunately,
through congressionally-directed fund-
ing, L-3 had done some analysis on mod-
ernizing the tube. About the same time,
Teledyne MEC (Rancho Cordova, CA) said
that it could develop a solid-state ampli-
fier replacement for this vacuum device.
We went to the Office of Naval Research
(ONR) to request some funding.
By 2004, PMA-234 was developing a
multi-pronged approach to attack Band
4 readiness decline trying to recreate a
consistent production level for the orig-
inal tube, funding tube modernization
with L-3 and working with Teledyne on
a solid-state replacement solution. We
recognized back in 2004 that if these
initiatives dont yield something, were
really in trouble, Kochman said. Were
getting ready to integrate ALQ-99 on
EA-18G and the supply of that one com-
ponent was completely broken. It was
really important that we fix this situ-
ation. But PMA-234 needed to ensure ONRs Manufacturing Technology Pro- produced in terms of the original and
that the Navy wouldnt end up back in gram, industry, NAVAIR and the Ameri- modernized configurations and what 43
the same situation with low production can Competitiveness Institute studied the chokepoints might be on the pro-
yields. A veteran panel put together by how the Band 4 TWT actually could be duction line at L-3.
L-3 production was roughly five
tubes a month among four critical tubes
in the Band 4 and Band 5/6 transmit-
ters, Kochman said. Some test equip-
ment was an absolute chokepoint. We
were able to reduce time on those pieces
of equipment, increase the amount
of equipment inventory and decrease
those chokepoints. Between 2004 and
2008, we were able to facilitate L-3 to
the point where it can now produce 16
to 20 tubes a month.
But the years of delay had a sig-
nificant impact on the situation. The
development process ended up taking
one year longer than expected. Then,
in 2007, the low-band transmitter was
introduced and, some time after this
addition, the Band 4 transmitter suf-
fered a spike in failure rate that may
or may not have been related to the
introduction of the new transmitter. A
paucity of documentation has delayed
detailed engineering analysis, but this
is now underway. Two steps forward,
one step back.
Kochman credits industry for work- in a proactive way. We can put things ware failures by just living with these
ing with the Navy on this process. in place in time so we can stave off problems for so long.
L-3, Teledyne and Triton are the pri- a crisis. One key thing Kochman noted is
mary traveling wave tube producers that components become outdated all
in the United States. Im extremely LESSONS LEARNED of the time, but there are avenues to
pleased with how quickly they stepped Going through the process on the provide funding that might address
up and wanted to help, Kochman said. ALQ-99, both from the user side and the the shortcomings of small compo-
It was impressive to see industry step supply side, there are lessons for others nents. In the case of the ALQ-99 Band
up with energy and innovation to do dealing with sustainment challenges. 4 transmitter OTWT, where the produc-
this. L-3, in particular, was able to You have to take a multifaceted ap- tion formula effectively was lost, the
really do a remarkable redesign not proach and you cant ignore the warning situation became more serious. Some-
only is it more producible and more signs, Kochman said. The tremendous one decades earlier should have start-
reliable, its also a better-performing Aha! moment for me was when I stepped ed asking questions about acceptable
tube. We currently have a steady pro- in I went right to our supply guys to standards. They should have been
duction line for the original Band 4 ask, Why arent you putting them on looking at the fact that they only had
OTWT that nearly meets fleet needs, contract? What I learned was that we 25 to 30 percent yield from the very
but not enough to replenish severely failed to make the investment, so there beginning. Maybe we shouldnt be ac-
depleted supply lines. The modern- was nothing to buy. cepting that as a yield. We had a bad
ized tube is scheduled for production Once I asked for help, there was design and we knew it was a bad de-
in late 2009 and should arrive in the plenty to be had, Kochman said. I sign, Kochman said. If the customer
fleet by the end of the year. Kochman went to ONR one day and said, I need is paying for it, accepting it and youre
anticipates running two production money to modernize tubes. I went back producing three [units] to achieve one
lines for awhile one for the original a week or two later and said, I need [usable unit] you need to take those
and one for the modernized tubes money to fund a solid-state amplifier. warning signs seriously when you en-
as the Navy builds up its supply. The ONR was willing to help out. Without counter them early.
Navy also is continuing to pursue the the Navy supply system and ONRs will- The lessons learned on the ALQ-99
Teledyne solid-state replacement op- ingness to help, this wouldnt have upgrade process also will aid the Navy
tion for the Band 4 TWT. been done. as it undertakes the -99s replacement,
44 With the benefit of hindsight, Id the Next-Generation Jammer (NGJ).
THE NEXT CHALLENGE conclude that with aging avionics like On the -99, we never had any way
The Band 4 OTWT was the pacing this, if you have a shortcoming on the of recording usage data, so we have no
The Journal of Electronic Defense | March 2009
item for ALQ-99 readiness for so many supply side, you cant overestimate how idea how old these components are,
years that now other components are hard its going to be to solve any prob- Kochman said. We know when they
starting to catch up to it, Kochman ex- lem, Kochman said. Take every step were manufactured, but we have no
plained. PMA-234 now is focusing on on the supply side and on the user side idea how much they have been used.
driver TWTs. to actively address it or youre going to Its difficult to track usage data when
For Band 4, it took us roughly 14 find yourself far behind. I continue to things fail. We know how much time a
years to really solve the OTWT issue, believe that we need to work harder on plane has flown, or how much time a
Kochman said, noting that the Navy our user side. If you dont take warn- pod has flown, but we dont know how
started working on making the driver ing signs seriously when you first no- much time a transmitter or exciter was
tube producible in 2007. But, like the tice them, again, its very easy to find operated or even how much time it was
output tube, the driver tube had not yourself in crisis response mode as we powered up. This is problematic from
been in production for a number of were in 2004. If we had taken things the perspective of data programming
years. We were able to make it produc- more seriously and dealt with the user use requirements.
ible by the end of last year, so with les- side problems earlier, we might have Its a lesson learned well, as the NGJ
sons learned from the output tube, it been able to prevent some of the fail- will build in usage and performance
took only two years to solve the driver ures (i.e., pressure on the supply side) data recording that can be used on the
TWT issue and have a production line up weve seen. maintenance and logistics support side.
and running. For example, Kochman noted that Were cognizant of the data issues we
The exciter also needs attention, operators often simply get used to deal- had on the -99 and we wont repeat
Kochman noted. It has an obsolete ing with certain things over time, like that, said Kochman.
component in it so does the test not running the built-in test because I expect, in a year from now, the
equipment for the exciter and some of doing so actually can create additional Band 4 transmitter readiness wont be
the transmitters, he said. The good problems. Operators and maintainers discussed by anyone for the first time
news is, for the first time, theres rec- learn how to make equipment work. Its in many years. We expect to really see
ognition in the program funding sys- something you live with and its possible a turnaround in coming months, Koch-
tem to help us address these things we contributed to some of these hard- man said. Were moving ahead. a
Electronic
Warfare Capability
Gaps & Enabling
Technologies
May 5-7, 2009
Crane, IN
By Dave Adamy
ANALOG SYSTEMS
In analog cell phone systems, du-
plex operation is provided by the as-
signment of two radio frequency (RF)
channels to each cell phone, one from
the tower to the phone (the downlink)
and one from the phone to the tower
(the uplink). One user continuously oc-
cupies two RF channels during a call.
Each channel carries the transmitted
signal most of the time, but interrupts
this signal for short periods to send
digital control data. In some systems,
the control data is modulated onto the
voice signal so that no interruption is
required. Figure 2 shows the way sig-
nals are carried in analog cell phone
channels for a typical system. A few of Figure 2: An analog cell phone system carries one conversation per RF channel. Up and down link
the RF channels carry digital signals channels for one phone are 45 MHz apart.
no channels are available, the system Some of the user time slots in the cell CDMA SYSTEMS
delays by a randomized period before re- system are occupied by control channels Code division multiple access (CDMA)
trying. To prolong cell phone battery life, for paging and assignment of RF chan- cell phone systems use direct sequence
the cell phone transmitter is turned off nels and time slots. spread spectrum (DSSS) modulation as
when the user is not talking. The digital Operation is very similar to that of described in the August 1998 EW 101
control signals in the voice channels al- analog cell systems. When a cell phone is column. Each user voice input signal is
low the system to change the RF chan- activated, it searches control channels to digitized. A high-rate digital modula-
nel assignment and to turn down the nd the strongest tower signal and, after tion carrying a pseudo-random code
transmit power from the cell phone to authorization, enters the idle mode, mon- is applied to each digitized user voice
the minimum acceptable level (to further itoring the control channel for incoming signal in the transmitter. This spreads
prolong battery life). calls. When the cell phone is called or ini- the signal power over a wide frequency
Analog cell systems typically operate tiates a call, the tower sends a control mes- spectrum, thereby reducing its power
at about 900 MHz and can have up to sage assigning a pair of RF channels (one density. When the same pseudo-random
50 Watts of transmit power on each RF each for uplink and downlink). However, code is applied to the received signal at
channel from the cell towers. Cell phones in a GSM system, it also assigns a time slot the receiver, the signal is returned to
have a maximum transmit power of 0.6 in each assigned RF channel. its original form. When passed through
to 15 Watts, but are turned down to a The randomized delay before retry a DAC, the signal can be heard by the
minimum required power by command when no channel/time slot is available user for whom it is intended. If the cor-
from the tower. Minimum cell phone and the control of cell phone trans- rect code is not applied to the received
transmit power is usually 6 milliwatts. mitter power to maximize battery signal, it remains so faint that it cannot
even be detected by a listener. By us-
ing 64 different codes, which have been
selected for optimum signal isolation,
voice signals from 64 different users can
be carried on the same 1.23 MHz wide RF
channel as shown in Figure 4. A CDMA
cell system has multiple RF channels.
Some of the access channels (code and
48 RF channel) in the system are used for
control functions.
Operation is very similar to that of
The Journal of Electronic Defense | March 2009
GSM SYSTEMS
The Global System for Mobile
Communication (GSM) has eight time
slots per 200-MHz-wide RF band, al-
lowing eight users to share the same
RF band. A system will have many RF
bands. Digitized voice data from each Figure 4: CDMA cell phones carry up to 64 digital user signals, each using a different spreading
code, on each RF channel.
user is carried in one bit per frame as
shown in Figure 3. The frame repeats life are the same as described above than time slots. The IS-95 CDMA system
at 33,750 frames per second for a total for analog systems. operates throughout the United States
bit rate per RF channel of 270 kbps. GSM systems operate at 900; 1,800; at 1,900 MHz using tower and cell phone
Some systems operate in half rate and 1,900 MHz. Separate RF channels transmit powers like those described
mode, in which each user occupies the are used for the uplink and downlink above for analog cell phone systems.
assigned bit in every second frame, so to each cell phone for full duplex op-
that 16 users share each frequency eration. Note that different time slots WHATS NEXT
band. At the receiver, the bits in one are used for the uplink and downlink so Next month, we will continue our
time slot are passed through a digital that a cell phone is not transmitting and discussion of jamming cell phones.
to analog converter (DAC) to repro- receiving at the same time. The trans- For your comments and suggestions,
duce the signal that was digitized at mitted power from cell phones and tow- Dave Adamy can be reached at dave@
the transmitter. ers is similar to that in analog systems. lynxpub.com. a
REFER A MEMBER
GET A MEMBER GIFT
Recruit 5 new members and receive a ve-member mug and $20 gift certicate
redeemable for AOC merchandise.
Recruit 25 new members and receive a $50 gift certicate redeemable for AOC
merchandise and a one-year AOC dues credit.
Recruit 50 new members and receive a $75 gift certicate redeemable for AOC
merchandise and a two-year AOC dues credit.
Recruit 100 new members and receive free transportation to the AOC convention,
free registration and a ve-year AOC dues credit.
Your name as the recruiter must appear on the application for the membership to
count toward your recruitment total.
E-Mail ______________________________________________ Contributions or gifts to the AOC Educational Foundation are deductible as
Signature ____________________ Date __________________ charitable contributions for federal income tax purposes. Dues payments
to the AOC are deductible as an ordinary and necessary business
I am a citizen of _______________________________________ expense; however, contributions or gifts to the AOC are not tax deductible.
Recruiter name _______________________________________ Membership dues include subscription to the Journal of Electronic Defense.
a s s oc ia tion
n ew s
AOC AWARD REPRESENTATIVE VISITS CRANE ROOST
NOMINATIONS DUE In December, US Rep. Brad Ells-
APRIL 15 worth (D-8, Indiana) took a break
AOC is taking nominations for from his pre-holiday schedule at the
its annual awards. See the ad on Naval Surface Warfare Center Crane
Page 31 for a list of awards. Division to have lunch with the
For more information and a nom- Crane Roost. Jimmy Hearn, presi-
ination form, visit www.myaoc.org. dent of the Crane Roost, briefed Rep.
Ellsworth and his legislative direc-
tor, Jed DErcole, on the Association
of Old Crows (AOC) and the Crane
ONR EW PROGRAM Roost. Rep. Ellsworth is a member
of the Congressional Electronic War-
MANAGER VISITS fare (EW) Working Group and is con- From left to right: US Rep. Brad Ellsworth,
CHESAPEAKE BAY cerned with capability gaps in EW.
Crane Roost Vice President Carl Lohkamp
and Crane Roost President Jimmy Hearn.
ROOST Following the luncheon, Hearn said,
Dr. Peter Craig, Program Manager It is fantastic for EW to be receiv- vided by EW Director Don Schulte and
for Electronic Warfare at the Office ing this degree of congressional in- the Crane staff.
50 of Naval Research (ONR), was the terest and support! Director White said, NEWTIC is
guest speaker at the Chesapeake Rep. Ellsworth was visiting the Na- part of the renaissance in EW. We
val Surface Warfare Center in south- will be the catalyst for EW technol-
The Journal of Electronic Defense | March 2009
OW
ASS
R
TE
LY
M
HA
P
I TC
Systems Group and the 563 Flying Training Squadron. HE L C L
Stay on Top
12600 Deereld Parkway, Ste. 350
Alpharetta, GA 30004
Toll Free (US): (800) 796-2638
Fax: (770) 810-6995
with eCrow
Senior Project Manager:
Jason White
Direct: (770) 810-6970
Naylor, LLC Florida
5950 NW 1st Place
Gainesville, FL 32607 The newly revamped eCrow now brings you weekly updates
Toll Free (US): (800) 369-6220
Fax: (352) 331-3525 on industry news, AOC events and more. With new content
Sales Manager:
each week, eCrow offers you up-to-date information you
Melissa Zawada
Direct: (352) 333-3407 need to stay relevant in the EW industry.
Advertising Sales Representatives:
Shaun Greyling
Direct: (352) 333-3385
Erik Henson
Direct: (352) 333-3443
Chris Zabel
Direct: (352) 333-3420
Naylor Canada Official eNewsletter
100 Sutherland Ave.
Winnipeg, MB Canada R2W 3C7
Toll Free: (800) 665-2456
Fax: (204) 947-2047
Advertising Sales Representative:
Cheryll Oland
Direct: (204) 975-0451
JED
quick look
Details Page # Details Page #
BAE Systems, RF threat and space warning receiver Next-Generation Jammer (NGJ) program ............................ 15
system for AFRL .......................................................... 24 Nordic region, history of EW and SIGINT in ........................ 32
Bharat Electronics Ltd., agreement with SELEX Galileo ....... 30
Nordic Standard Helicopter Program (NSHP) ....................... 33
Boeing, delivery of Growler maintenance trainer ................ 20
Nordic Supportive Defence Structures (NORDSUP) ............... 39
Boeing, ground-based Laser Avenger.................................. 24
Northrop Grumman, engineering support
CAP Wireless, ultra-broadband amplifier ............................ 46 to Prowlers ALQ-218(V)1 jammer .................................. 24
CAPT Steven Kochman, US Navy ........................................ 42 Northrop Grumman, EW products in Nordic region .............. 34
CDR John Springett, US Navy ............................................ 17 Northrop Grumman, four employees die in plane crash ....... 23
COL Laurie Buckhout, US Army .......................................... 26
Norway, EW activity in ..................................................... 34
Communications EW - Part 22............................................ 47
ONR, BAA for EW Discovery & Invention program................ 19
dB Control, high- and low-band transmitters ...................... 46
ONR, RFP for Integrated Topside (InTop) development ......... 19
Denmark, EW activity in ................................................... 38
Ray Coutley, AoA government team lead for NGJ................. 15
DRS Signal Solutions, miniature portable receivers ............. 46
Raytheon, EW products in Nordic region ............................ 34
EA-6B Program Office (PMA-234) ....................................... 42
Raytheon, Lockheed Martin contract for F-16IN
EADS, EW products in Nordic region ................................... 33 Super Vipers EW suite .................................................. 30
Elisra Electronic Systems Ltd., F/A-50 EW systems
for Korean air force ...................................................... 30 Raytheon, testing of Laser Centurion Demonstrator ............ 24
Joint Aircraft Threat Awareness System (JATAS) RFP due.... 16 US Air Force, decision against B-52 jammer ........................ 18
Kilgore Flares, US Army contract for flares ......................... 24 US Army, Computer Network Operations and Electronic
Warfare Proponent (USACEWP)...................................... 26
Korea, EW system for F/A-50 attack jets ............................. 30
US Army, Combined Arms Center-Capability Development
L-3 Communications Electron Devices, Integration Directorate (CAC-CDID) ............................... 26
ALQ-99 Band 4 upgrade ................................................ 42
US Army, EW Officer career field established ...................... 26
LaBarge, Northrop Grumman contract
for AAQ-24(V) electronics ............................................. 24 US Marine Corps, solicitation for CREW jammer support ...... 23
Link Microtek, successive detection log US Navy, analysis of alternatives (AoA)
video amplifiers (SDLVAs) ............................................. 46 for Next-Generation Jammer (NGJ) ................................ 15
LTC John Bircher, US Army................................................ 26 US Navy, ALQ-99 Band 4 upgrade and sustainment ............. 42
MBDA, EW products in the Nordic region ............................ 33
US Navy, bids for Joint Aircraft Threat Awareness System
Mercury Computer Systems, FPGA-based digital receivers .... 46 (JATAS) program.......................................................... 16
400557
BAE Systems
fp
CMYK
p. 3 IBC
G IBC
U.S. Navy photo, used with permission and without endorsement.
See you at
Dixie Crow Symposium
www.terma.com