Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Sociologists find secondary sources very useful but they have to be treated
with great caution. Their reliability and validity are open to question, and
often they do not provide the exact information required by a sociologist for
their research.
i. Social trends
[2]
1
Information or research is valid if it is true to life. It measures what happens
accurately and reflects reality in some way.
Advantages include:
(c) Give three reasons why sociologists are careful not to use
government statistics uncritically. [6]
Reasons include:
2
(d) Suggest three reasons why newspaper reports may contain bias.
[6]
Advantages include:
3
limitations include:
content may reflect the bias of the writer Personal accounts only
say what the person wanted others to know they do not tell us what
is missed out.
the authenticity may be difficult to establish - if the person is no
longer alive, then there is no way of checking his/her account. For
example, the case of the Hitler diaries that proved to be a hoax.
not always available or appropriate for a particular study - some
documents are in private collections so it may be difficult to get
permission to use them in research. This may also be the case with
government documents that may be subject to laws regarding
confidentiality and time lapses before disclosure.
quantitative sources may be based on unreliable methods
there is no way of checking how the data was collected so it is difficult
to know how accurate the data is
4
Section B: Culture and Socialisation
2. People who are not socialised into the norms and values of society are
almost unrecognisable as humans in their behaviour.
(b) Describe two examples of how people learn the norms and values
of society [4]
Primary Socialisation - children learn from their parents what they should
or shouldnt do in a particular situation for example how to behave at the
table or in other social situations
(c) Explain why the values that people hold may vary from one group to
another. [6]
sub-cultures:
5
Reasons they might vary:
the influence of social class the values of the working class are
different from those of the middle class although the extent of those
differences is a matter of debate. Research has suggested that working
class children are brought up in a more rigid way by their parents and
there is less stress on academic success. Working class children do not
receive as much help with reading and writing as middle class children.
All this has consequences for their future success at school and their
future employment
the influence of ethnicity People from different ethnic groups may
bring up their children to have specific values that may differ from the
mainstream values of British society. For example the children of
Indian immigrants to Britain will most likely follow the Hindu or Muslim
religions. They may have different views about the role of family and
the correct behaviour for females especially in terms of marriage which
may be arranged.
the influence of age a typical example would be a youth
subculture, these subcultures emerge for each generation. In each
generation there is a variety of styles of dress; types of music; special
language and attitudes that distinguish youth from older people and
from children. These values make youth distinct or different from the
rest of society but rarely do they represent a complete rejection of the
overall culture
6
Recent research into genetics has made a strong case for the nature
argument.
Nature
When sociologists talk about nature they are referring to what a person
inherits through their genes. This is the genetic inheritance of a
person. Each individual inherits 50% of their genes from their mother and
7
50% from their father. Genes determine such things as what sex you will be
and the colour of your eyes.
However, biologists have argued that genetic influence can also explain
social behaviour and characteristics. For example, some have argued that
aggression, personality and intelligence are all inherited. If we use the
term, instinct, this means that behaviour is programmed in the genes.
Nurture
When sociologists talk about nurture they are referring to all the behaviours
we learn through the socialisation process. The things we do are a result
of what we have learned. This means that our experiences and our
environment play a large part in shaping our behaviour. Our social
behaviours come from the expectations and guidelines found within each
society and culture.
3. In most societies, there are certain types of behaviour that are regarded
as appropriate for one gender and inappropriate for the other.
Gender refers to the social expectations (or roles) associated with males and
females respectively.
8
(b) Describe two examples of appropriate gender behaviour in your
society [4]
Girls are encouraged to be more nurturing and play a more passive role.
Mothers may encourage their daughters to pay more attention to their
appearance and take an interest in household activities like cooking
Anne Oakley suggests that in the early years of life there are four ways in
which gender socialisation takes place
Manipulation
Parents encourage behaviour which they deem as suitable for their childs
sex and discourage behaviour which is associated with the other sex so girls
may be encouraged to pay more attention to their appearance than boys
Canalisation
Children are often channeled by their parents to do activities or to play with
toys which they think are appropriate for their sex
Girls may be encouraged to play with dolls or household items like irons or
play kitchens these encourage an interest in doing housework and being a
mother
Boys may be given cars/trains/sports equipment and are often encouraged in
active outdoor play
Verbal Appellations
The way that parents talk to their children eg good girl naughty boy - they
then learn from a young age how important gender is
Different Activities
Girls and boys are often socialised differently they are encouraged to play
different kinds of games and with different types of toys
Girls are expected to play indoors and help their mothers
Boys have more freedom to play outdoors and be more active
9
(d) What pressures encourage people to conform to their gender roles?
[8]
Peer Group
Friends of the same age play a big part in establishing gender roles
Children learn from when they are young from their peers what is
appropriate behaviour for their sex
The learn that there are consequence if they play to much with the
other sex or behave too much like them
This can take the form of name calling or bullying
It is worse for boys
Girls are allowed to be tomboys but boys who like more feminine
activities are scorned
Education
Although boys and girls study the same things they learn to behave
differently in the classroom and the playground
Teachers may treat them differently and so reinforce gender roles
The way some subjects are taught and the books that are used may
reinforce this
Children may learn that some subjects are more appropriate for boys
and some for girls
At higher education fewer girls than boys choose to study science
Media images
TV/magazine/books/music all carry representations of gender
according to sociologists
Boys will often be portrayed in stories as adventurous heroes who carry
out brave and heroic deeds
Girls are portrayed as less active and often helpless heroines who need
the help of boys to save them
Parental reaction
Parents have many ways of influencing their childrens behaviour
Children are often rewarded for conforming to the stereotypes that
parents have of them
Parents act as role models their example in terms of gender roles has
a very strong impact on the child who tries to emulate them
10
Section C: Social Stratification
4. Max Weber suggested that there are three factors that divide people in
modern societies: power, status and economic factors.
(b) Describe two ways that economic factors may divide people in
modern societies.
[4]
11
(c) Explain how the working class differs from the middle class [6]
The working class differs from the middle class in a number of ways
loyalty to workmates
a belief in pursuing goals as a group rather than individually
an emphasis on immediate gratification (i.e. enjoy yourself now)
a fatalistic attitude to life believing that life chances depend on luck
a belief in traditional conjugal roles (i.e. roles of husbands and wives)
individualism
a belief in deferred gratification (i.e. planning for the future)
an image of society as a place where there are opportunities for
individuals who work hard
a belief in joint conjugal roles (i.e. roles of husbands and wives)
12
Working class
Working class people experience poorer mortality than the middle class
working class people are more likely to die before retirement of cancer
stroke and heart disease than middle class people
working class people are three times more likely to have a serious
illness
Middle class
Working class
Middle class
Working class
13
Middle class
Are often in professional jobs and so get paid more than the working
class
Have good job security
Get more benefits and perks from their job
Have more contacts which may help with promotion or finding
employment
Media, politicians and even some sociologists suggest that class is dead
or dying.
Class is based on occupation and money people earn from their
occupations.
It is said that class today is less important than what occupation you
have and how much money you spend
Class is not about workers producing things in factories like before but
about buying things
The importance of consumption and the recognition of other aspects of
stratification have changed the way we think about class
Income
Wealth
A network of social connections sometimes known as the old boys
network
The least powerful within society still have few opportunities to escape from
poverty
14
differences in life chances still exist and other aspects of inequality
such as gender and ethnicity have become as important or more
important than class.
For example
the Underclass
Members of the underclass form norms and values that often differ to
the rest of society.
They are caught in a poverty trap (or cycle) from which they find very
difficult to escape from.
This is despite changes to the welfare and benefits system designed to
get welfare claimants into work.
Embourgeoisement
This is a term that means becoming bourgeois or becoming middle class.
The term has been used as the basis of a theory that suggests that the
manual working class are becoming more like the middle class.
The argument is that all industrial societies have seen an increase in
equality and affluence since the end of the Second World War.
For example:
increased salaries
greater job security
higher disposable income
These changes have eroded (worn away/changed) the distinctive values and
lifestyle of the working class.
15
Those who put forward the theory of embourgeoisement argue that
working class people are also adopting middle-class values and
lifestyles to match their incomes.
So
5. The main difference between caste and class societies is that in a class-
based society there is social mobility.
Social mobility means the movement of people up and down the social scale.
(b) Describe two ways in which a person can achieve a higher social
position [4]
Examples:
Job promotion they can work hard and get a better position
in the company that they work in. for example they could start
out on the factory floor but end up in a management position if
they work hard and have talent.
Entrepreneurial success they could start their own company
and through a combination of luck and hard work could become
successful and make a lot of money. They could then achieve a
higher social position
16
(c) Explain the main features of the caste system. [6]
Features:
absence of social mobility the status of an individual is determined
by his birth (ascribed) and not by selection or by accomplishments
(achieved). This is a closed society with little or no chance of upward
mobility
rules against marriage outside of ones caste the caste system
imposes restrictions on marriage - inter-caste marriages are still looked
down upon in traditional Indian society.
status hierarchy certain occupations are very much associated with
the caste system. Each caste has its own specific occupations which are
almost hereditary. Some occupations are considered superior and sacred
while certain others degrading and inferior. There is not much scope for
individual talent, aptitude, enterprise or abilities
underpinned by religious beliefs religion can be seen as a way of
keeping control of people. This is because religion lays down what is right
and wrong and what will happen if the rules are broken. People may be
afraid to break the rules because they will be rejected by other believers
or they may also be afraid they will be punished in the afterlife
the various castes are rigidly separated - Each caste has its own
customs, traditions practices and rituals. It has its own informal rules,
regulations and procedures.
formally legalised the caste rules are enforced strictly through fear of
religious and political authority - there are caste councils to regulate the
conduct of members
(d) Assess how much social mobility there is in modern societies [8]
17
Vertical mobility describes movement between strata both up and down
the stratification system. It can usually be seen as an example of long-
range mobility, displaying a change in class status and can be examined
through:
It might be that social mobility and social closure have been easier for
certain generations depending on the availability of certain types of work
or the conditions of the economy.
Women have not been represented in much of the work done on social
mobility and social closure, despite their presence in the workforce in
small numbers in the past to their present very strong position in the
labour market now.
Sociologists have carried out the following influential studies concerned with
questions of social mobility.
18
The Social Mobility in Britain Study by Glass (1954)
While individuals did move up and down the hierarchy, it was generally
short-range and within certain types of work only, so that few people
broke through from manual work to professional work.
Generally the pattern was of sons taking similar jobs with a similar status
to their father.
Goldthorpe et al. studied only men aged between 20 and 64 years; women
were not included. They found that two-thirds of the sons of unskilled or
semi-skilled workers were in manual occupations. Four percent of blue-collar
workers came from professional backgrounds. Approximately thirty percent
of professionals were from working class backgrounds. Downward mobility
appeared to be declining, but more men from working class backgrounds
were unemployed.
Long-range social mobility rates had increased in the UK since after World
War Two, suggesting that class categories and society had become more
open.
However, it was suggested that this increase could have been due to
changes in the occupational structure of the UK; de-industrialisation had
led to fewer traditional working class jobs.
19
Marshall, Rose, Newby and Vogler, Social Class in Modern Britain
(referred to as the Essex Study) (1988)
This study looked at both male and female rates of mobility. The findings
were based on the class of the respondent (male or female) and the class of
the chief childhood supporter (male or female). The study found high rates
of upward mobility overall, including:
For men, the rates were similar to those found in the Oxford studies.
For women there was evidence of upward and downward mobility into
class 3, that is, routine, non-manual work.
Halsey found that the evidence supported the claim that there was more
upward social mobility in British society over the past century with less
downward social mobility, although some did exist.
These changes in the class system Halsey likened to a shift from a
pyramid to a lemon shape.
The pyramid contained a small number of upper class at the top, a larger
number of middle class in the middle and a disproportionate number of
working class at the bottom.
The lemon shape contained small numbers of upper and working class at
either end with a large middle class in-between.
20
Social closure is a term which is used to explain how people who share
similar life chances as a result of factors such as status and party close
ranks to mark themselves out from other groups.
This leads to questions of inclusion and exclusion.
For example, entry to certain clubs, schools and occupations offer
mutual support through this social network.
This is often referred to as networking or elite self-recruitment.
This can lead to a situation where access to life chances is better for
some than the rest of society and consequently worse for those not
included.
Elite self-recruitment
21