Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
MARC GALANTER, M . D .
OXPORD
UNIVERSITY PRESS
2005
OXFORD
UNIVERSITY PRESS
With offices in
Argentina Austria Brazil Chile Czech Republic France Greece
Guatemala Hungary Italy Japan Poland Portugal Singapore
South Korea Switzerland Thailand Turkey Ukraine Vietnam
9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
viii Prologue
them. Many were searching for something to transform or replace the
personal commitments they had been raised with and had lost track of.
I decided to study one aspect of this transformation while at the
NIMH, the way marijuana, the elixir of that generation, affected people's
thinking. Along with colleagues, I measured physiologic responses in
the lab and social interactions in a group setting.1 As this work pro-
gressed, it became clear that one could systematically research the en-
counter between the science of the brain and people's need to find entry
into their own personal worlds.
Psychiatry at that time was awakening to the need to treat alcohol and
drug problems, and under a grant from the NIMH designated for teach-
ing about addiction treatment, I began to study the nature of conscious-
ness in relation to drug intoxication.2 But when more practical needs in-
tervened it became clear that the spiritual fellowship of AA was the only
tool available at the time to help alcoholic people sustain their recovery.
While I was doing this teaching, a friend suggested I look into the
nature of one of the cultic youth movements that had recently come to
public attention. The results of a series of studies made clear that these
groups drew on recruits' needs for something they could believe in at a
time when they were in a transition that was undermining their tradi-
tional family ties and religious roots. In one study it emerged that the
likelihood of adopting the spiritual philosophy of such movements was
directly proportional to the alienation and unhappiness potential re-
cruits reported before entering the group's workshops.3
In applying a similar methodology to AA members, my colleagues
and I found out how a benign and thoughtfully constructed social
movement could also achieve a degree of transformation in turning
around alcoholics' denial of their addiction.4 It became clear that when
distressed, people have an innate inclination toward accepting some
sort of ideologic or spiritual commitment, one that can transform them
in ways that could be studied in a systematic way. So with colleagues at
New York University (NYU) and its affiliate Bellevue Hospital, I went
on to see if these wellsprings of spirituality and personal meaning could
be drawn on to develop an organized treatment approach to help reha-
bilitate our indigent, addicted patients. We were able to frame a treat-
ment system in which the commitment seen in AA was infused into our
secular hospital-based services for mentally ill addicted patients.5
Prologue ix
We then evaluated these patients , the folks who you could see pan-
handling on the street or dealing drugs to buy whatever alcohol, cocaine,
or heroin they could garner. The results were quite striking.6 The pa-
tients rated spiritual issues more highly in their potential to help them
achieve recovery than they did the practical ones, such as medical, rehab,
and social services. Our staff, on the other hand, whom we studied at the
same time, indicated in their responses that the practical options, not
the spiritual ones, were the most important and thought that the pa-
tients would answer that way as well. It was becoming clear that psychi-
atry might be missing the mark on what people wanted from us. It was
as if we were doling out aspirin to people who wanted redemption.
An irony became evident in the direction psychiatry was going. A
national leader in the mental health field7 had just documented how
psychotherapy of any kind had fallen into a marked decline in psychi-
atric residencies over recent decades. There was even an ongoing debate
over the merit of providing any training at all on how to help psychia-
trists understand and work with their patients' personal conflicts.8
Furthermore, in my division at NYU we were studying how insurance
companies were undermining the provision of all but the most limited
rehabilitative services: in the 1990s there had been a 52% cutback in
available insurance funding for general mental health treatment and a
75% decline in support for addiction rehabilitation.9 It seemed that
psychiatry was moving away from its traditional healing and caring role
and becoming increasingly committed to the pharmacologic advances
and brief therapies it had developed. These latter options were benefi-
cial in their own right, but they did not necessarily help people rebuild
lives that had been compromised by the very problems the profession
was supposed to address. People were now spending more money on
alternative medicinetreatments based on a personal, often spiritual,
commitment to medically unproven techniquesthan on traditional
ambulatory medical care.10
Could some rethinking of this divergence of two important ways of
dealing with people's distresssymptom relief and the pursuit of
what is personally meaningfulbe achieved? Could psychiatry re-
claim some of the immediacy of the healer's relationship with the
healed that physicians had so long employed? This seemed to be an
issue worth considering.
x Prologue
Acknowledgments
Epilogue 247
Notes 253
References 263
Index 279
xiv Contents
Spirituality and the Healthy Mind
This page intentionally left blank
PART I
What Is Spirituality?
P
eople in all cultures seek out meaning beyond the material,
usually within the context of religious practice, but when long-
standing religious traditions are found to be unfulfilling,
marked changes in belief and practice may come about. In the eigh-
teenth century the Great Awakening heralded the emergence of Bap-
tist revivalism throughout the American colonies, as the traditional
churches of Europe came to be seen as lifeless and impersonal. In the
early twentieth century a reaction to the prevailing Christian theology
led to a Fundamentalist revival that embodied the belief that people
could be "born again" in anticipation of the Second Coming.
We may now be in the midst of another transformation, the emer-
gence of spirituality as a way for many people to meet their need for a
meaningful life. The following chapters describe how and why this
cultural transition has taken place. This is considered from a psycho-
logical perspective, since this development has been intertwined with
evolving models of mental function and psychotherapy. And since
mind and brain are not unrelated, it will also be considered in light of
emerging research that sheds light on the neurophysiology that
underlies spiritual experiences.
It might come as a surprise to many psychiatrists that a large ma-
jority (84%) of Americans believe that prayer for others can have a
positive effect on their recovery from illness. Many of the "disorders"
that psychiatry has described in its lexicon would be considered by
these people to reflect a spiritual deficit as much as a problem in the
mental health profession's domain. One psychiatrist, on the other
hand, described for me how he is able to bridge the spiritual and bio-
medical in his work. He said "You might conclude that some larger
hand is operative that makes sense of the mystery of the universe. I
don't necessarily conclude that, but instead I find a pervasive and pro-
found sense of the spiritual in things. That way I can respect the
meaning of a person's experiences, as opposed to just saying they're a
symptom of mental problems, and all we have to do is give some
medicine to get rid of it."
4 What Is Spirituality?
1
Spirituality Emerges
5
the term spirituality in the class of an American professor in Rome while
studying for a doctorate in canon law. He pointed out the personal na-
ture of the word:
Spirituality is a way of life. Actually, there's no definition, and it's
different for each person. The way you have experience, the way
you study, the way you live, the way you understand, and the way
you act; that is called spirituality.
Naomi, a Conservative Jewish rabbi, had served as a chaplain in a
hospice for terminally ill patients and was now apprenticed to train other
chaplains. She thought for a few moments when asked for a definition
and said:
Spirituality is wrestling with and creating meaning in one's life,
and that meaning can be broken at times, or can have a sense of
wholeness at other times. I guess it's kind of existential, and feel-
ing connected to others. If that happens to connect to a belief
or an experience of a transcendent one, that's fine too, but that's
not necessarily better. . . . It's like a community of people all
wrestling together but not necessarily having the same answer.
Members of Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) call their movement a spiri-
tual fellowship, and in AA's Second Step they say they have come "to be-
lieve that a Power greater than ourselves" will help them stop drinking.
So I asked Ann, a 20-year member, what AA's spirituality meant to her.
She pointed to herself and said:
Don't think that it's out there. That if you're good enough, if you're
smart enough, if you do well enough, if you talk loud enough,
you'll feel it because it's in here. I feel like I see things in life now
that I didn't when I was a kid. I'm finding joy with peoplethat's
something I think I probably feel more than almost anything. I
have a hard time with a lot of organized religion. But I feel that
that's a very different thing from a spiritual connection to a Higher
Power.
For these three people, experts in their own right, spirituality is al-
lied to religion, but it is a thing apart, allied to other people but it is also
6 What Is Spirituality?
apart from everyday relationships. Although it was different for each of
them, each knew what it meant to him or her personally. Clearly, spiri-
tuality is not easily encompassed by a singular definition, nor is it eas-
ily parsed and subjected to research, but it is very real for those who ex-
perience it.
Spirituality and religion are deeply rooted in the American ethos. Fully
95% of people respond positively when asked if they believe in "God or
a universal spirit," and this figure has remained almost constant since
Gallup began polling on the issue more than 6 decades ago. A follow-
up question suggests that this belief is an active one that affects the daily
lives of the majority (51%) of Gallup's respondents, who said they had
talked to someone about God or some aspect of their faith or spiritual-
ity within the past 24 hours.1
In addition to this longstanding orientation of the American public,
there has been considerable interest in spiritual approaches to medical
illness in recent years. Attention to Eastern healing practices, such as
acupuncture from China, now entering into the mainstream of medical
practice, and to Ayurvedic medicine from India, which espouses medita-
tion and exotic diets, are examples of this. Holistic medicine reflects this
trend as well, encompassing a variety of spiritually oriented approaches
to the person as a whole, rather than just the carrier of a particular illness.
Spirituality is illustrated as well in the healing of Twelve-Step programs
such as AA. The commitment to espouse these latter spiritual fellow-
ships has had a major impact on the way people have come to view ill-
nesses of compulsive behavior.
Spirituality Emerges 7
which they were born. The trappings of other religious groups were dis-
missed as misguided, even dangerous. "Spirits" were associated with
seances, ghosts, and the netherworld. Nor does spirituality appear in
anthropologic studies. "Spirits" are conjured up as ancestral figures that
wield power in what some might call "primitive" societies. They are as-
sociated with shamanistic practices that we see as being quite different
from our own.
The contemporary perspective on spirituality became evident fol-
lowing the radical cultural transitions that took place in the United States
over the latter part of the twentieth century. Traditional social moor-
ings were shaken and dislodged, and people's need for transcendence
emerged in new form. This took place decade by decade following the
halcyon days of the "Eisenhower Era," on through the dramatic social
changes of the counterculture, and then toward a tentative resolution
on what is meaningful to people in the domain of personal belief.
Consider the changes that disrupted established attitudes over this
period in relation to religion, race, and ethnicity. In the 19505 people
typically identified with their respective religious denominations and
their own ethnic groups. They went to the church of their own histori-
cally defined denomination, almost always segregated by race. The reli-
gious divide between American Protestants and Catholics was clearly
demarcated, and anti-Semitism was embedded in social practice.
The longstanding culture of religious and racial segregation began
to fall apart with struggles to assure the integration of public education
and the voting rights of minorities. In the popular media movies such
as Gentleman's Agreement and Guess Who's Coming to Dinner came to re-
flect a challenge to established religious and ethnically grounded biases.
The American political consensus was falling apart as well. While the
Korean War was being fought to prevent Red Chinese hegemony in Asia,
the legitimacy of anti-Communism was not questioned. The nation's
commitment to anti-Communism, caricatured in the witch hunts of
the McCarthy era, abated. Opposition to the war in Vietnam was now
tearing the country apart. The military draft was called into question by
many American youth, and the collapse of Lyndon Johnson's presi-
dency was followed by antiwar riots at the ensuing Democratic National
Convention.
8 What Is Spirituality?
Gender roles and sexual behaviors were also dramatically transformed.
Widespread access to contraceptives led to the acceptance of premarital
sexual intercourse. The women's movement began to erase distinctions
between the sexes that had defined home life and work life for genera-
tions. The Stonewall Riots in New York's Greenwich Village presaged
the acceptance of diversity in sexual orientation. The very definition of
mom and dad and their kids, Dick and Jane, was now gone.
Another dramatic change had taken place in how people assumed
their identities of mature adults, as the developmental norms for adoles-
cence were evolving. When the twentieth century began, people ended
their education to begin work at a relatively young age. By the latter part
of the century, adolescence was prolonged as parents ceded their chil-
dren to liberal educational institutions where youths could devote them-
selves to contemplating their direction in life, even their life's very pur-
pose. The demands of marriage and child rearing were deferred. Young
people could now take advantage of these opportunities to move away
from their families to other parts of the country and to find cultural
relativism as they traveled across any continent they chose. Alcohol,
America's drug of choice, had previously allowed people to escape by
dulling their senses. Marijuana and the psychotomimetics now came
into widespread use, allowing users to question the nature of their own
perceptions. Drug use validated young people's giving up the accepted
concepts of normalcy, even reality, that their parents had adhered to.
They could now "tune in, turn on, and drop out." All this allowed them
to participate in the social and personal transitions just described, to re-
flect on them, and to question personal values that had previously been
accepted as a matter of course.
This was also embodied in transitions in popular music, which now
became noisy and socially disruptive. Bob Dylan's paean to ending the
separateness among diverse peoples that could lead to war heralded an
initial change: "How many seas must a white dove sail before she sleeps
in the sand. . . . The answer, my friend, is blowin' in the wind." He
soon relinquished his acoustic guitar to accept the electric amplifica-
tion of the new rock music, itself derived from the collapse of tradi-
tional barriers between blacks and whites. His words would now con-
vey the consequences of these cultural transitions for many youths who
Spirituality Emerges 9
were spiritually bereft, whose emergent birthright of "finding oneself"
created an anomie that left them adrift:
You used to laugh about everybody that was hangin' out, but now
you don't talk so loud; now you don't seem so proud. . . . How
does it feel? How does it feel to be on your own with no direction
home, a complete unknown, like a rollin' stone.
10 What Is Spirituality?
that had framed the world view of many who were now seeking some
sense of transcendence. Children of the counterculture generation could
no longer sustain sectarian enmity as a cultural norm; they had seen
and experienced too much. Now they would encompass an ecumenical
view of life's purpose, one that legitimated the diversity their country
now sanctioned. Spirituality, a seemingly vague term for the pursuit of
personal meaning, fit the bill. It became a catchword to embody the
psychological needs that previous generations had addressed under the
banner of traditional religion. It even allowed for mutual respect, or at
least guarded acceptance, of discourse between fundamentalists and
secularists. It thereby provided a large tent that could house diverse views
of transcendence and allow acknowledgment of a certain commonality
across the country's many subcultures.
Spirituality Emerges 11
2
A Psychological Perspective
12
an intense spirituality becomes a central part of their religious life. In
fact, fully 40% of Americans consider themselves born-again Christians.3
Descriptions of religious intensity in the psychological literature date
back to 1902, when William James, considered the father of modern psy-
chology, derided a simplistic medical view of these revelatory phenomena:
A Psychological Perspective 13
As he left the satsang, he turned back and found the illumination still
there. At that moment he decided that the experience could not be dis-
missed and that it would somehow influence the course of his life. He
soon joined the movement and began to build his life around its spiri-
tual orientation. At first he tried to recruit new members in his medical
clinic. He got little response, as people thought his pleas reflected a mea-
sure of derangement more than a spiritual awareness. He then decided
to keep his experience to himself but still kept close ties to the sect, liv-
ing close to other converts but giving no indication to coworkers of the
experience that had changed his life.
The work of psychologist Abraham Maslow,5 who wrote in the mid-
twentieth century, a more secular era than James's, might be drawn on
to shed some light on this physician's experience. Maslow spoke of a hier-
archy of needs that people have, and it is only after safety, belonging-
ness, and self-esteem are achieved that self-actualization, the highest of
these needs, is addressed. This follower of the guru was apparently seek-
ing such actualization, and his vision (as it were) of the Divine Light set
him along such a course.
Maslow considered the intense phenomena described by James and
associated them with "peak experiences," ones which may be unrelated
to formal religious affiliation but are nonetheless marked by feelings of
wholeness of an almost mystical nature. Like James, he related how these
experiences were reported by historical figures who spoke of their per-
sonal illumination, and also interviewed people who he felt had attained
an exceptional degree of self-actualization. He lent a more contempo-
rary credibility to the perspective that intense spirituality need not
be characterized by visions or paranormal phenomena, but more by a
heightened sense of fulfillment. He was also quite comfortable with a
secular humanism that many contemporary devout Christians now
find unappealing.
14 What Is Spirituality?
ingfulness of religious experience, Freud, himself experienced in physio-
logic research, was inclined to invalidate spirituality and religion as
having no part in a healthy and mature adaptation. He ascribed religion
to a neurotic perspective rooted in unresolved childlike fixations.6
We can only speculate as to why he was adamant on this issue: per-
haps because of his orientation toward biologic science, perhaps be-
cause of his reaction to the anti-Semitism he encountered in his native
Vienna, or maybe because of the antireligious philosophical writings of
Central European philosophers such as Hegel and Schopenhauer. In
any case, he spoke of religion as an illusion that operated outside em-
pirical observation, even as a mass delusion, and his strongly held views
were instrumental in the disavowal of religious experience within the
psychoanalytic movement.
Early on, however, views were expressed within the psychoanalytic
mainstream that ran counter to Freud's bias. Oskar Pfister, a Lutheran
pastor and psychoanalyst, was a longtime friend of Freud's. He empha-
sized the meaningful nature of religion as a unifying vision of the world,
one that transcended the uncertainties of life and encouraged ethical
responsibility.7 But the most elaborately thought out and well-developed
psychoanalytic alternative to the established Freudian view emerged in
the writings of Carl Gustav Jung.
Jung was the son of a parson in the Swiss Reformed Church and
studied psychiatry so that he could combine both his spiritual and sci-
entific interests. He was 19 years Freud's junior and was allied with him
early in his career, even becoming a leader among Freud's followers. He
later parted ways with Freud, having come to differ with his mentor's
stark empiricism and emphasis on sexuality rather than people's higher
spiritual values. He accepted the concept of an irrational personal un-
conscious but came to believe in a collective unconscious, positing the
existence of innate mental constructs, archetypesprimordial images
that existed in all individuals. These serve as the basis for elaborating
the diverse religious imagery and myths that arise across different cul-
tures.8 Jung did not ascribe validity to a particular creed or to member-
ship in any specific organized religion, but instead believed that his
perspective took into account the full range of spiritual experiences, in-
cluding people's acceptance of a godhead. He viewed the self as lying
midway between the unconscious and consciousness and pointed out
A Psychological Perspective 15
that a person has to make peace with his or her spiritual nature in order
to establish meaning and find comfort in life.
Both Freud and Jung considered spirituality relative to people's psy-
chological makeup. For Freud this was based on instinctually grounded,
infantile drives that were biologically based. A person had to overcome
these drives with the competency acquired during maturation and with
the acquisition of the civilizing values of a culture that governs beha-
vior. Psychoanalysis would liberate people from the neurotic views fueled
by these drives. Jung's model, on the other hand, posited a collective un-
conscious that could mature into a constructive spiritual orientation.
He saw psychotherapy as the means of helping people achieve this
enlightenment.
Another perspective, one that emerged in the second half of the
twentieth century, emphasized the role of interpersonal relationships
in shaping human experience. These object relations were understood
to originate in the interaction between infant and mother and eventu-
ally evolve into the basis of relating to other people in an independent
way. D. W. Winnicott, a psychoanalyst who began his medical career as
a pediatrician, spoke of transitional objects, such as a baby's security
blanket, that bridge the infant's fixation on the maternal breast to an
engagement with the world at large.9 Such transitional objects embody
the magical relationship between infant and feeding mother, given an
implicit understanding that the literal breast will be there when the in-
fant needs fulfillment.
In coping with the demands of adaptation, the infant, and later the
adult, subjects his or her perceptions to reality testing, logic we define
as objective and valid. This entails measuring distances, obtaining ma-
terial needs, even judging other people's motives. For Winnicott, an-
other domain emerges in the infant and is later transformed in adult
life. It is in the transitional divide between reality and subjectivity where
the objectivity of photographs and micrometers do not apply. An artis-
tic imagea floating angel, the spirit of a voodoo maskthese have
reality in this domain, even if they are not seen in nature. This transi-
tional divide, Winnicott wrote, matures into the domain in which the
arts and creativityas well as religionemerge.
Winnicott's conception was later elaborated on in a way that is rele-
vant to our thinking about spirituality by Ana-Maria Rizzuto, a psycho-
16 What Is Spirituality?
analyst and a religious woman as well.10 She focused on qualities in this
transitional realm, pointing out that people's conception of God and
spirituality emerged from that transitional domain. She emphasized
that the acceptance of this perspective implies neither the existence nor
the nonexistence of an actual deity, but only a psychological realm in
which people's spiritual nature operates.
One of her case histories illustrates this well. She described her psycho-
analysis of Laura, who grew up in an entirely nonreligious family and
suffered greatly from a troubled relationship with her parents. Her
mother humiliated her, deriding her appearance and poor school per-
formance. Her father slighted her and was involved mainly with her
mother in a glamorous social milieu. Although Laura was 2i-years-old
when she entered analysis, the parents tried to control the treatment,
even to the point of hiring an investigator to ferret out anything that
might be compromising to Rizzuto herself.
As Laura progressed in her treatment, she was able to resolve the
stormy parental transference she felt toward Rizzuto and achieved an
emotional distance from her parents. At the same time she began to de-
clare a belief in God, something that had been alien to her and her fam-
ily before, and started practicing rituals from her family's Jewish back-
ground. Rizzuto pointed out that Laura's case illustrated the opening
up of the "transitional space" created upon Laura's separation from her
parents, into which a belief in God as a vibrant force could find its way.
This space had been created within her much as the infant experiences
a space for nascent illusionary experience in separating from its mother.
A Values Orientation
A Psychological Perspective 17
I could turn and live with animals, they are so placid and self-
contained,
I stand and look at them long and long;
They do not sweat and whine about their condition.
They do not lie awake in the dark and weep for their sins.
Not one is dissatisfied, not one is demented with the mania of
owning things,
Not one kneels to another, nor to his kind that lived thousands
of years ago,
Not one is respectable or unhappy over the whole earth.
James goes on to cite R. M. Bucke, an early biographer of Whitman,
to clarify the nature of the poet's "natural religion":
The only sentiments he allowed himself to express were of the ex-
pansive order; and he expressed these in the first person, not as
your mere monstrously conceited individual might express them,
but vicariously for all men, so that a passionate and mystic onto-
logical emotion suffuses his words, and ends by persuading the
reader that men and women, life and death, and all things are di-
vinely good.11
In Whitman's time a puritanical American society found him highly
controversial for his exaltation of the body and sexual love. He was, in
fact, discharged from a job he had held for a time as a clerk in the U.S.
Department of the Interior, as many people considered his work im-
moral. But Whitman's humanistic brand of natural religion came to be
much more acceptable as the twentieth century progressed, when it was
understood by many that spirituality need not be rooted in denomina-
tional religion dominated by doctrine.
Two examples of this trend emerged in rather different contexts. One
is illustrated in the approach of Eric Fromm, a psychoanalytic writer,
and the other in the empirically driven, quantitative research of Gor-
don Allport, a university-based psychologist. Fromm was born into an
orthodox Jewish family and witnessed World War I as a young man in
his native Germany and World War II as a philosopher and psycho-
analyst in the United States. These experiences and his understanding
of existentialism and social psychology led him to a secularized view of
18 What Is Spirituality?
religion as a way of life.12 He described two types of religious orienta-
tion. The first promotes a respect for humanity, allowing the individual
to achieve self-realization. It stands in contrast to an authoritarian reli-
gious outlook that demands obedience to achieve its politically oriented
goals. Fromm supported the importance of a meaningful life imbued
with the first of these orientations, one that allows a person to over-
come the limitations of egotism and thereby feel love and exercise hu-
mility. This clearly brought him close to a humanistic spiritual view.
Around the same time, Gordon Allport, respectful of the introspec-
tive approach of William James, tried to infuse his scientific approach
to the measurement of personality traits with an understanding of the
role of personal values in shaping the diversity of people's beliefs. All-
port came from a Midwestern Protestant background and drew on both
his deeply felt religious background and the academic psychology he
espoused while teaching.
Allport was critical of the psychological model based only on ob-
served behavior that had taken hold among academics but avowed that
research based on standardized questionnaires and statistical analysis
could yield a valid way of understanding people's spiritual or religious
values.13 He was able to demonstrate that his students at Harvard main-
tained a lasting religious orientation that reflected their family back-
grounds. He measured the distinction between an intrinsic religious ori-
entation, in which the individual employs internalized beliefs to achieve
personal fulfillment, and an extrinsic one, whereby religion is employed
to accomplish more practical ends, such as providing self-justification
and social acceptance. For him, the mature individual has incorporated
religious values and diverse elements of human experience into an in-
trinsically felt sense of purpose, one that that lends meaning to life. All-
port observed that individuals' values are inevitably expressed in their
respective approaches to treatment.
Allen Bergin carried this further while teaching psychology at Brigham
Young University, an institution affiliated with the Mormon Church. He
has called for a restoration of a spiritual, or theistic, orientation in psycho-
therapy. He emphasizes the importance of recognizing that psycho-
therapy is not value-free and points out that acknowledgment of this
can free psychology from a historic bias against religious and spiritual
A Psychological Perspective 19
values. In this manner, he writes, an acknowledgment of the impor-
tance of issues such as people's spiritual needs can be used as a resource
for psychotherapy.14
Airport's values-oriented view has been extended into a biological
model by Daniel Batson,15 who had formal training in both theology
and psychology. He writes of the pursuit of existential meaning leading
people to join in religiously grounded communities, thereby support-
ing mutuality and altruism. He points out that this aspect of altruism is
adaptive for the survival of a social group and has therefore been sus-
tained over the course of evolution. This relates to the sociobiological
model we shall consider soon, which posits that many behavioral traits
are rooted in biology. This extension of the psychological perspective is
quite important, because if there is a biological basis for humans' spiri-
tual quest, we may then ask how it relates to the brain's operation. For
now, it leads us to look at some aspects of group psychology.
20 What Is Spirituality?
remarkable opportunity to learn about the impact of a spiritual sub-
culture on people's thinking. In the mid-1970s and 19808 cults that at-
tracted teenagers and young adults were much in the public eye and
highly controversial. People could not understand how they could engage
these youths, typically drawn from the American mainstream. Further-
more, the tenacious commitment that the inductees sustained was in-
scrutable to their parents, who would usually grieve the loss of their
children to what appeared to be a bizarre and alien culture. For me, ac-
cess to this group represented a unique opportunity to study how social
influence was generated in the context of a group's system of beliefs.
This venture began when Beth, a physician friend of mine, called me
one day while I was working at the National Institute of Mental Health
in Washington. She invited me to go to a public event to hear a lecture
from a 13-year-old guru she had adopted as a sacred teacher. After em-
igrating from India some years before, the guru had established the U.S.
branch of the Divine Light Mission, a sect that his father led back home.
Beth was unusually enthusiastic and said that the group's work would
be of great relevance to psychiatry, so I decided to go. Although some of
the guru's lieutenants spoke at the conclave, Maharaj-ji, the guru, did
not appear. It was later reported that he had overslept while he and his
mother were staying in a Washington suburb. A year later I had moved
back to New York, and Beth again tried to enlist my interest. She invited
me to one of the group's ashrams, or ritual residences, which was actu-
ally in a Manhattan apartment not far from my home. She was now
serving as the guru's physician, and because she had issued the invita-
tion, I was warmly received.
At the ashram the intensity of the members' involvement was strik-
ing. One person, Janet, was most intriguing. She had been hospitalized
a number of times for schizophrenia and had a history of agitated and
disruptive behavior. On one occasion before encountering the mission
she had actually blinded herself with her own hands. In the ashram she
was sitting quietly next to some of the members, with her sunken eyes
quite apparent. One member was engaged in quiet conversation with her
while holding her hand as if to console her. Janet described how the group
had been successful in steadying her over the course of her membership.
I was later told other stories of disturbed and addicted young people
responding to the beneficial influence of the mission and was able to
A Psychological Perspective 21
interview a number of very troubled people who supported these ob-
servations. It did seem, as Beth had said, that there were psychological
forces operating within this spiritually oriented group that could have a
material effect on the distress members had experienced before joining.
Given my interest in social psychology, it was appealing to consider
how the phenomena that took place in this group might be examined
in a systematic way. I wanted to test two hypotheses. The first was that
there would be a measurable decrease in both distress symptoms and
ongoing substance abuse when people became engaged in this move-
ment. The second was that the intensity of a given member's ties to the
group would be correlated with the degree of improvement that they
experienced. After some time in the library dedicated to developing a
battery of appropriate psychological measures, I was able to frame a struc-
tured questionnaire designed to test these hypotheses.
Beth secured an agreement with the mission's hierarchy so that, along
with a colleague, Peter Buckley, I could apply the questionnaire to a
sample of the sect's members who were meeting at its national conclave
in Orlando, Florida.16 After some lengthy negotiations, I selected 137
members at random at the Orlando site to complete the questionnaire.
Their responses were compelling. Most members used alcohol and mari-
juana before they joined, and about half of them had stopped since then.
Heavy use of alcohol and marijuana was also assessed, and it had gone
down dramatically. I was well aware that treatment programs were hav-
ing trouble achieving a high level of success with young people at that
time. In addition, the number of respondents who reported symptoms
of psychological distress, such as anxiety and depression, had also de-
clined by half since they had joined (from 71% to 37%).
The degree of improvement in substance use and distress was signifi-
cantly correlated with the respondents' scores on a scale for social co-
hesiveness in the questionnaire. For example, their scores on this scale
accounted for 37% of the variance (statistical variability) in their de-
cline in distress symptoms, a high figure for a psychological study. Ap-
parently, the closer a given member felt to the group, the more relief
they achieved in these symptom areas. This cultic movement appeared
to be effective in curbing distress and substance abuse insofar as it suc-
ceeded in engaging recruits into close ties to other members.
22 What Is Spirituality?
A colleague, Richard Rabkin, was later approached by members of the
Unification Church (the "Moonies") after giving a lecture on cults at a
local church. They apparently hoped to reach out to professionals in the
mental health field to try to soften their public image. This initial con-
tact served as a basis for my later negotiating a relationship with the group
to study the psychology of membership. In time, several studies ensued.
Some of the Moonie recruitment took place in informal ways, such
as meetings on college campuses, often under the guise of generic causes
including ecology and the pursuit of world peace. Other techniques
were carried out in well-structured, systematic workshops, providing an
unusual opportunity to study the psychology of engagement at such a
group. After a lengthy negotiation, I was allowed to evaluate the progress
of young adults as they passed through a series of the group's recruit-
ment workshops at a remote California site. These reflected a sophisti-
cated technique for framing communication in the groups they ran and
maximizing its psychological impact on potential recruits.
The series began with a weekend-long retreat, followed by an invita-
tion to stay for further enlightenment, a process that ultimately extended
over three weeks.17 Of 109 young people who began the series I studied,
seventy-seven left after the first weekend, having rejected offers to re-
main longer. Of the remaining thirty-two, seventeen left after a week,
and of those who remained through the entire 3-week sequence, nine
agreed to join. All members who stayed beyond the first weekend re-
sponded with high scores on both cohesiveness to the attendees and be-
lief in the Moonie ideology.
I had applied a measure of psychological well-being to all parties at
the outset of the induction sequence. Their responses were highly pre-
dictive of who would actually stay on through each of the stages. Those
who felt most comfortable with their lives left first, and those who
scored lower on well-being stayed on through the first week and the
following weekend. The nine who actually remained for 3 weeks and
agreed to join were highly distressed in comparison to all the others
who had left before them and to a matched sample from the population
overall. The need for relief from emotional distress clearly provided
pressure for affiliating. Significantly, once established in membership,
general well-being scores moved up, back toward those of a nonmember
A Psychological Perspective 23
sample from the general community.18 These latter scores were not based
on retrospective self-assessments, so they were not subject to the dis-
tortion that might take place when answers to before and after items
were given at the same sitting.
24 What Is Spirituality?
2. There should be a direct relationship between affiliation with
the group and the degree of symptom relief. This finding emerged
in both sects. It is clearly illustrated among the Moonies, where
members' scores on the general well-being scale were highly cor-
related with the degree of their religious belief and their cohesive-
ness toward church members. Items that were most highly cor-
related with general well-being were "my religious beliefs give
me comfort," and "I like being part of their [the members']
activities."
3. The relief effect should not depend on a poor adaptation to life's
tasks, because this would operate against the survival of this trait
over the course of evolution. That is to say, if this trait were asso-
ciated with maladaptive behavior, people who had it would be
less likely to survive and reproduce, and the trait would not have
persisted in subsequent generations. So what actually was the
case? When Divine Light respondents were asked whether emo-
tional problems had interfered with their adjustment to life, 39%
responded that they had. The degree of symptom relief and the
likelihood of experiencing cohesive feelings toward the group
were, however, the same for members who reported disruptive
emotional problems and those who did not.
A Psychological Perspective 25
studies and posits that people are most likely to adopt a new or unusual
explanation for their situation (such as an illness) when they encounter
problems they cannot solve, feel they are not getting enough support,
or lose confidence in themselves.22 After this takes place, they undergo
a reordering of how they attribute meaning to later experiences. They
will then explain new observations by recourse to the explanatory model
they adopted, thereby placing them in a coherent, internally consistent
perspective.
A patient with an anxiety disorder due to a general medical condi-
tion may feel helpless and may despair of receiving help from her physi-
cians. Because of this distressed state, she may be open to considering
an alternative spiritual explanation for her illness and a related "treat-
ment" regimen. On adopting this explanation, she will be inclined to
accept a whole constellation of ideas related to the new perspective and
will attribute the meaning of future health issues to the associated "spiri-
tual" explanation. Sometimes this engagement into a new perspective
and set of beliefs can occur quite rapidly. This is evident in the dramatic
conversion experiences that take place among distressed people exposed
to Fundamentalist religious preaching.23
Cognitive dissonance theory is relevant as well. This perspective was
popularized by the social psychologist Leon Festinger, who sent his gradu-
ate students to join a doomsday cult whose members believed that the
world would come to an end on a specific upcoming day.24 The students
were to see how members of the cult would react when the world (pre-
sumably) did not come to an end. After the day came and went, most
of the cult members constructed elaborate rationalizations for why the
anticipated event had not taken place, and many assumed that a new
date was now set. They could not reconcile their belief in the cult with
the reality they observed, namely, that it was wrong in its core belief,
and were driven to construct a new, more acceptable reality.
Festinger attributed such a resolution to the cognitive dissonance
that people may encounter in experiencing circumstances contradic-
tory to their established views, as did the members of the doomsday
cult when the fateful day came and went uneventfully. The clash between
these conflicting circumstances and the cognitive dissonance it produces
lead to a state of arousal that is inherently unpleasant, one that people
26 What Is Spirituality?
are implicitly driven to avert. They do this unwittingly by changing or
distorting their understanding of the circumstances, even to the point
of compromising their common-sense views.
In the realm of illness, consider the onset of a severe and prolonged
episode of pain due to an unanticipated illness. People generally have a
sense of security about their physical well-being, but an experience of
unremitting pain and even threatened loss of life runs counter to that
sense. This results in a conflict between their usual perspective on them-
selves and the newly perceived physical state and creates a potentially
troubling sense of arousal. Given the pressure generated by this cogni-
tive dissonance, the distressed sick person will be open to seeking out
or responding positively to an explanatory model for the illness avail-
able in their environment.
If they become engaged in conventional care, the model offered will
be based on available biomedical mechanisms. My friend Charles Gerson,
an internist, tells me about patients referred to him who are plagued by
seemingly unresponsive gastrointestinal symptoms. Often their symp-
toms remit when he clearly explains to them their underlying physiol-
ogy. On the other hand, some people may encounter and accept a spiri-
tually grounded, nonscientific perspective, even if it has limited credibility.
As in the psychology of the Moonie induction process, the likelihood of
acceptance increases if it is made further acceptable by some friends or
true believers who support the perspective.
A Psychological Perspective 27
bear this out as well; radiographic imaging of brain function of depressed
patients shows it to be markedly different from normal.26 Additionally,
a variety of neurochemical and hormonal markers have been found to
differentiate people who are depressed from people who are not.
On the other hand, it has long been known that patients given placebo
antidepressants experience symptom relief greater than do patients put
on waiting lists for treatment, even though neither group has received
an active drug. The difference in outcome apparently derives from the
fact that the placebo patients believe that they should be getting better
from the pills they take. The psychologist Irving Kirsch points out that
both serotonin reuptake inhibitor antidepressants such as fluoxitine
(Prozac) and other types of antidepressants show about the same level
of effectiveness as placebos, even though they have different mecha-
nisms of action. In addition, some active drugs not considered to be anti-
depressants show much the same effect on depression as that produced
by those formally designated antidepressants.27
So we can ask: Why should seemingly inactive pills change a syndrome
embroiled in physiology? A careful analysis of head-to-head, controlled
comparisons of antidepressants against placebos is quite revealing in
this regard.28 The portion of patients who showed material improve-
ment in their depression on both active drugs and placebos increased
appreciably over the period from the early 19805 to the year 2000. When
the 2o-year course of both was graphed out for this period, the response
to active drugs was seen to rise from about 40% to 55%, and for place-
bos the rise was from 25% to 37%. Thus, by the year 2000, the number
of placebos responders was close to the same as that of patients who
took the active drugs in the early 1980$. Symptomatic response to place-
bos has been found quite effective for the long term as well. One study
maintained patients on pills for 2 years. While 91% of the patients who
responded to active drugs did not relapse over the treatment period,
72% of the placebo patients avoided relapse as well.29
The medications tested over the 20 years of review were not materi-
ally different, nor was the physiology associated with depression. There
was, however, a change in the attitudes of people taking the drugs, which
likely led to this altered effect over the years. People have increasingly
come to believe that antidepressants work, as bolstered by studies re-
28 What Is Spirituality?
ported in the media and in popular books, such as Listening to Prozac,30
and more recently, advertisements. People have increasingly accepted
the culture of science as a belief system rather than as a convenient tool
for testing hypotheses.
As with shamanic potions, the placebo response is effective when
both the treater and treated believe in the effectiveness of what is being
administered. This was illustrated in the case of a surgical procedure.
Arthroscopic surgery of the knee to relieve arthritic disease had been
reported by patients and physicians alike to relieve both pain and func-
tional limitations. Until recently the procedure had been applied more
than 650,000 times a year. At a cost of roughly $5,000 for each opera-
tion, this came to more than $3 billion annually. The credibility of this
was called into question when Dr. Bruce Moseley, chief surgeon for the
basketball team the Houston Rockets, was carrying out the procedure
in his teaching hospital and had a question posed to him: How did
he know the surgery's apparent success was not due to a placebo effect?
This seemed to fly in the face of received knowledge, since it was as-
sumed that the arthroscopic intervention worked by removing painful
debris and flaps of torn cartilage as well as inflammatory enzymes.
Moseley put a small number of patients through a "placebo" surgi-
cal procedure, one in which he prepared them for surgery as usual and
made incisions in the skin that produced surgical-like scars. He found
that these patients responded with relief in their symptoms. He then
conducted a large-scale controlled study and found that the placebo
procedures resulted in relief over the ensuing 2 years equal to that pro-
duced by the actual surgery.31 Clearly, both physicians and patients had
come to believe in this widely used approach, another illustration of the
impact of belief in contemporary medical culture. The expensive sur-
gical ritual would have been maintained in practice for this placebo
effect if not for Walsh's initiative.
To put these reports into context, we can consider the role of ritual-
ized belief embedded in the mythology of one spiritually oriented cul-
ture, the Navajo Indians of the Southwest United States In the 19508 the
anthropologist Robin Fox32 described a typical healing carried out in a
Cochiti pueblo near the Rio Grande River in New Mexico. Following
her mother's death, a woman in the tribe experienced an onset of symp-
A Psychological Perspective 29
toms like those we currently attribute to the psychiatric diagnosis of
major depression: insomnia, fatigue, social withdrawal, and anorexia to
the point of severe weight loss.
Fox described how a ritualized readoption into the clan brought
these symptoms to an end: The clan's sanctity was understood to derive
from mothers, and a mythic mother figure, mother of the people, was
embodied in corn-ear fetishes that represented her power. The cere-
mony he observed was announced by relaying a pinch of cornmeal to
all of the woman's close relatives, and she was then given a new name,
and her head was washed with an herbal solution, the traditional
method of sanctifying adoptions. The sanctification of her readoption
into the tribe was understood to yield curative ritual healing, and her
symptoms abated after the ceremony. Fox reported that the symptoms
did not return during the seven years following the healing until the
time of his writing.
In this case, a consensually supported belief in the effectiveness of re-
newal was followed by relief from the symptoms of depression. This
parallels the contemporary response to antidepressant placebos that re-
news today's depressed people. Members of both the Navajo and science-
oriented cultures respond to the belief in the transcendent powers of
their totemic entities, the mythic mother figure on the one hand and
medically generated pills on the other.
We are inclined to dismiss the healing practices in societies whose
cures rely on trappings of belief that are different from our own. Often
the healers are called witch doctors. But the very same psychological
mechanisms operating there may allow psychiatrists and even surgeons
to generate healing in their patients in many cases. The limits of spiri-
tual renewal and associated rituals for the treatment of mentally medi-
ated symptoms clearly need to be further explored.
Our entry into the domain of psychology began with the work of
scholars and clinicians who studied the nature of intense spiritual ex-
perience, and then moved on to the way these experiences can be gen-
erated in group settings. The placebo effect shows how the plasticity of
these experiences rests on the culture in which they reside. If belief in a
placebo can revive the spirit, we might now choose to look at how this
relates to what happens in the brain.
30 What Is Spirituality?
3
3i
Broadly stated, this suggests how our understanding of what we expe-
rience can be driven in rather different ways, each generated out of a
need to bridge the inner workings of our brain and the experiences we
encounter. One might draw an analogy. The agitation of a person aroused
in a crowd can be directed toward a spiritual interpretation of their
place in life, or alternatively, toward scapegoating an innocent minority
group: transcendence or anger, depending on the social input.
Another very different study illustrated the relationship between bio-
logic function and the mental connotations attached to an ambiguous
experience. Michael Gazzaniga2 studied people whose corpus callosum,
which connects the right and left cerebral hemispheres, had been sur-
gically severed to treat their severe epilepsy. He introduced a variety of
stimuli to the motor areas of their right hemispheres that produced
body movements, and then asked the person, who was awake at the time,
to explain these movements. The left hemisphere is responsible for
speech, but it was no longer connected to the hemisphere on the right.
So it now had to come up with an explanation on its own of what it saw
the right hemisphere produce, but with no communication from that
right side.
He stimulated one subject's right cerebral hemisphere electrically to
make him wave his hand. When asked to explain the hand movement,
hethat is, his left hemispheregave a fabricated explanation of see-
ing someone he knew at whom he had waved. When stimulated in the
right hemisphere to laugh, he said he was responding to the joking ap-
proaches of the experimenters. Neither of these fabricated experiences
had actually taken place, but the left brain had needed to make sense as
best it could of what the body had done. As with the adrenalin experi-
ment, an explanation of reality and its meaning was created by a person
to cope with a physiologic nonspecific stimulus.
32 What Is Spirituality?
Here are some questions to start with: Where does this emotional en-
ergy originate in the absence of environmental input? How does it get
infused into our abstract thinking to cause us to make up an explana-
tory reality?
A model of brain function introduced by Paul MacLean3 gets us
closer to the biology of this process. He conceived of an integration of
certain lower brain centers that lie deep below the cerebral hemispheres
and called this set of centers the limbic system. He described this sys-
tem as a motor for emotionality, to which meaning is then ascribed by
the cerebral cortex. MacLean wrote of the coordination among limbic
structures, namely the hippocampus, the hypothalamus, the cingulate
gyrus, and other related structures, yielding this integrated, functional
network that generates primitive emotional drives. He even suggested
that this system was responsible for the functions that Freud referred to
as "id" drives in his metapsychology.
Freud described the infantlike, primitive id, which can produce un-
fettered anger or dependency, but he did not localize it in a specific
brain site. In his "structural" model of mental function, he posited that
the id drove people to be instinctively motivated. In a manner of speak-
ing, these feelings might now be seen to be driven by the limbic system.
Freud's model can be reinterpreted to posit that the ego and superego
operate within the cerebral cortex to modulate these id drives and to
bring them into conformity with external reality and acquired stan-
dards for behavior. The neocortex, the brain's highest center for com-
plex thought, became larger late in mammalian evolution and can as-
cribe complex interpretations to intense emotional needs. This search
for meaning can be conceived as drawing on a person's own mentation
and the environmental input that he or she encounters.
There are neuronal projections among components of the limbic
system and many cortical areas, and these allow for communication be-
tween the brain's emotional driver and its component part that con-
ducts conceptual thinking. Further interconnections with the limbic
hippocampus, which is associated with long-term memory, can play a
role in the relationship between emotional drives and past experience.
One illustration of these interconnections is evident in studies on
the biology of dreaming. In relation to our topic at hand, dream sym-
bolism is often associated with people's spiritual side. Interaction be-
34 What Is Spirituality?
This suggests an interesting issue. Transcendental Meditation, popu-
larized by Maharishi Mahesh Yogi in the 19705, became quite popular
among many educated members of the lay public. At one point, some
of them, deeply involved in that movement, were giving apparently
bizarre reports of their experiences during meditation. They said they
were able to float above a bed on which they were lying while meditat-
ing. Reports such as these were seemingly laughable. Were these medi-
tators deluding themselves? On the other hand, they might have ac-
quired a capacity to prolong and intensify spontaneous activity in the
angular gyrus, activity that we now know can be accomplished by di-
rect stimulation to the brain. Clearly, more needs to be learned about
the nexus between experiences associated with spirituality and verifi-
able brain-based events.
36 What Is Spirituality?
activities early in life, say by people who acknowledge and support its
discussion, he or she may continue to be interested in spiritual issues
and perhaps seek related enlightenment, even long after the original re-
warding situations.
The physiologic psychologist Joseph LeDoux7 has described the way
certain conditional responses can become fixed in a person's brain. He
wanted to explain how memories of a given event, particularly ones as-
sociated with intense emotional experience, become embedded in the
brain on a neuronal level. He drew on the concept of "cell assemblies,"8
in which irreversible connections between neurons can be established
through experience. These cell assemblies effectively hold memories
in place long after a person has encountered the external triggers that
precipitated them. This neuronal process of learning can then engage
subcortical limbic pathways that operate in the absence of conscious
recognition of the origin of the associated memory. LeDoux suggested
that this may help explain the development of syndromes such as post-
traumatic stress disorder, lingering reactions ensuing from highly trau-
matic experiences.
Intense spiritual encounters might also become consolidated in one's
memory this way. This would happen when an emotionally charged
spiritual experience becomes fixed in a person's mental apparatus, later
reverberating in her thinking to trigger a complex set of spiritually ori-
ented ideas and feelings. A religious experience at a church service may
be automatically recalled when certain emotional stimuli are intro-
duced. An encounter with the Dalai Lama may come up in one's mem-
ory at times when one experiences spiritual renewal.
Meditation
38 What Is Spirituality?
sion and even improved their perspectives on what was meaningful to
them in life.
Around this time the growing interest in Eastern religions led many
seekers of existential meaning to explore a variety of more exotic medi-
tative techniques. Many of them revered Hindu and Buddhist holy men
who could draw on intense and mysteriousbut apparently credible
capacities for achieving transcendence. Exotic practices studied in labo-
ratories ranged from Tibetan Buddhist meditation,12 to Indian Tantric,13
and Kundalini14 techniques, to Qigong15 from China. These techniques
were hard to master, and physiologic distinctions were found between
the few practitioners with years of experience and relative novices. Tan-
tric yoga, for example, involves intense concentration of attention and
total absorption, with an end-point being Samadhi. Indian yogis who
achieved this state through Raj yoga maintained that they were oblivi-
ous to external stimulation. They were found to produce high intensity
alpha activity on EEGs that could not be blocked by various sensory
stimuli but nonetheless appeared quite relaxed to the observer.
Observers were, in fact, impressed: the Raj yogis in Samadhi were
able to keep a hand in near-freezing water for almost an hour without
experiencing discomfort.16 A Tantric yoga practitioner stopped breath-
ing for nearly 2 minutes during a state of "near Samadhi" after experi-
encing a marked acceleration in heart and breathing rates.17
Andrew Newberg and his collaborators took advantage of the brain
imaging technique SPECT and studied Tibetan Buddhist meditators.
They found an increase in blood flow in the frontal cortex relative to the
parietal lobes during meditation and inferred that this was likely asso-
ciated with intense attention to visual images by these meditators and
with their loss of a sense of space and time. The nature of these physio-
logic relationships, however, is far from clear. Thus, Newberg found
that attempts to define the subjective states associated with these tech-
niques left them "impossible to quantitate or analyze in a useful man-
ner."18 Nonetheless, it is clear that the mind can direct the brain to alter
its usual function and generate experiences in the spiritual domain.
Are some people more physiologically disposed to such transcen-
dent phenomena? One group of investigators19 used positron emission
tomography to ascertain the density of serotonin receptors in various
brain sites of their subjects. They then gave them a personality survey
40 What Is Spirituality?
3-week period. The infant monkeys experienced responses much like
those of the human infants: initial agitation followed by lethargy and
withdrawal. From a physiologic standpoint, marked changes took place
in their sympathetic nervous systems, with abnormalities evident in the
hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis and ovarian systems.
The social and biological equivalence of these phenomena was high-
lighted by Stephen Suomi, who undertook studies that extended the
work of Harlow to see whether it was possible to "treat" the infant mon-
keys' depression. He first tried to do this by introducing socially normal
age-mates into cages with the depressed infant monkeys but found that
the hostility directed by the healthy ones toward the frightened, de-
pressed monkeys did not help at all to revive them. He then struck on
the idea of putting the depressed infant monkeys in cages with ones that
could offer more supportive social input. These were only 3 months old,
too young to exhibit aggressive responses or adult social interactions,
but instead they clung to their unhappy cagemates and began some
simple play. These 3-month-old creatures, he found, became effective
"monkey psychiatrists." They revived their depressed cagemates from
their isolated stance and, over time, moved them to recovery.22 Suomi
found that this social repair could be achieved by a pharmacologic in-
tervention as well,23 by administering an antidepressant. The two sets
of "therapy" studies, the social and the pharmacologic, were an early
indication of physiologic and social equivalency in the remediation of
depression.
The monkey findings parallel my own observations on the impact of
social support on depressed people who become engaged in the close-
knit social environment of religious cults. In these adult humans, co-
hesiveness in the group augmented by a spiritual orientation served as
a basis for their experiencing remission from their distressed states.
The physiology underlying such social phenomena was also revealed
in the genetic studies of the psychiatrist Kenneth Kendler.24 He contacted
identical and fraternal twins who had been recorded in the Virginia
Twin Registry when they were infants. He was then able to distinguish
between genetic and environmental factors associated with the degree
of social support these twins felt using questionnaires that tapped into
their social attitudes and the nature of their social environments. By
42 What Is Spirituality?
Evolutionary Adaptation
44 What Is Spirituality?
creation of a mutually acceptable mythology. Interestingly, in consider-
ing the psychology of spirituality, this perspective is similar in some
ways to the innate religious archetypes we considered previously in re-
lation to the psychology of spirituality. Carl Jung elaborated on an
allied concept in his psychoanalytic model of spiritually oriented beha-
vior, and it was picked up by Daniel Batson32 more recently, who asso-
ciated it with the quest for religious fulfillment.
It is not that the particulars of religious practice are innate in human
biology, but rather that the impulse toward a spiritual or religious ori-
entation may exist across all cultures, and that it has persisted because
of its adaptive nature. The same is certainly said about innate inclina-
tions toward sexual behavior and aggressiveness, which, in different set-
tings, acquire ritual trappings particular to a given culture. The sexual
inclination, for example, biologically grounded, may be ritualized in
one culture by monogamous marriage and in another by polygamy.
The impulse toward adaptive behavior that is understood by a person
as spiritual in nature may be seen in one culture in the worship of an-
cestors and in another as commitment to the Twelve-Step process of
addiction recovery. By this reckoning, we would say that a spiritual ori-
entation, like human sexuality and aggressiveness, may be rooted in
people's innate biological complement.
Our Forebears
46 What Is Spirituality?
PART II
I
t would be nice if there were a pill for every mental ill that plagues
people. Some in the biomedical world anticipate this eventuality.
Although this may seem something of a caricature, it was clearly
implied by a prominent neuroscientist who asked me how I antici-
pated that my addiction programs would evolve toward the time ten
years hence when neuroscience provided an answer to the problems
of addiction. I said that many important advances had been made in
that field and some indeed were being translated into useful medica-
tions, but it was important to understand that even after fifty years of
antipsychotic medications, the wards of our psychiatric services had
hardly been emptied out.
His was one culture. Another culture is that of the increasing popu-
larity of alternative medicine, with well-trained physicians writing
books, running workshops, and appearing on television touting
herbal medicines and meditative techniques to address emotional
problems that may or may not respond to them. The lines and even
the enmities between the two cultures are often highlighted by
believers on both sides, sometimes with unfortunate consequences.
Psychiatrists encounter their own problems in this domain. They
have increasingly fallen prey to curtailing the relationship between
the healer and the healed in the midst of this culture clash. Psycho-
pharmacology replaces relationship, and managed care undermines
the opportunity for an empathic exchange. Many people continue to
experience a nagging despair over the uncertainty of what to do with
their lives, even after psychiatric care has done all it can for them.
Other people may turn to cultic beliefs to salve their unhappiness, ac-
quiring bizarre lifestyles that for all intents look like the trappings of
mental illness. These next chapters examine the nature of the cultural
divide between bioscience and spirituality and illustrate the problems
that must be overcome when either psychiatric reductionism or spiri-
tual excess causes people to get less-than-effective treatment or lose
out on it entirely.
49
derstandably have problems integrating what spiritual leaders describe
as existentially meaningful into what the research community views as
scientifically based. Psychiatrists are increasingly captive to biology and
observable behavior, and their patients are left uncertain over their need
to experience effective help. Psychiatrists (and other mental health work-
ers) who fail to integrate the subjective and observational approaches
will fall short in addressing the suffering they hope to resolve.
Two Protagonists
I saw one example of this conflict play out in the opposing orientations
of the two principal medical organizations that deal with addiction.
One was the American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM) and the
other, the American Academy of Addiction Psychiatry (AAAP). ASAM
was established in 1954, when there were few approaches to the treat-
ment of addiction available to the physician other than Alcoholics Anony-
mous (AA). At its inception many of its physician members were re-
covering from alcoholism through AA spirituality and had decided to
dedicate their careers to others who suffered as they had. The other mem-
bers had come to treat alcoholic patients based on the nature of their
clinical practices, but they also relied on AA's spiritual commitment to
move their patients toward recovery. In those days ASAM's meetings
were imbued with the twelfth of the AA Steps, a commitment "to carry
this message to alcoholics and practice these principles [the Twelve
Steps] in all our affairs." Members sustained a remarkable degree of fi-
delity to the society because of the mutuality inherent in this approach.
The intense influence of AA's spiritual grounding often played out in
paradoxical ways. In conducting a survey of the ASAM membership31
hesitated to ask whether a given member had joined in the context of
his or her own recovery, as the question might be seen to violate AA's
unbreachable tradition of anonymity. On the other hand, I was later
able to collaborate with the society's president in studying recovering
physicians, most of them ASAM members, who had returned to a re-
treat sponsored by his treatment program to bolster their own AA com-
mitments and get together with their compatriots. Responses to this sur-
vey indicated that most were working at least part-time treating other
R esearch into the human genome has sparked enthusiasm for basic
biomedical research while undercutting the glamour of clinical,
and certainly spiritual, issues, but an overextension of this zeal is be-
coming evident in the common culture, with the use of the gene as a
metaphor for a variety of issues that have nothing to do with biology. A
profile in the New York Times on a young man, the son of a filmmaker
and grandson of the Hollywood screenwriter Herman Mankiewicz,
refers to him as entering the screen-writing field because he has "the
genes for his genre"; what about the culture of his upbringing? The
Range Rover SUV is described as "an Anglo aristocrat with German
A Historical Perspective
Psychiatry in Devolution
68
staring at the treacherous pointer, and with his hands lifted as
though to ward off the lethal medium, which he imagines is pour-
ing into his body.1
After trembling, gyrations, and a fall to the ground, the victim crawls
into his hut, refuses to eat or drink, and withdraws from the daily affairs
of the tribe, making a pariah of himself. Only a medicine man can re-
verse this process by producing a small stick or pebble and saying that
it was taken from the bonepointed man; otherwise, the ritual results in
the victim's death. He is not physically coerced by those around him,
and it is the tribe's spiritual beliefs and his response to the sorcery that
produce this outcome.
Cannon drew on a variety of studies on the sympathetic nervous sys-
tem to define a cascade of events that could lead to this dramatic out-
come. He pointed out that an excitatory response could be generated in
experimental animals that were stimulated physiologically to a high
level of agitation comparable to the response of a terrorized human. A
vascular constriction takes place that shunts blood away from the mus-
culature and abdominal viscera toward the heart and the brain. By pre-
serving these most vital organs, this shift ensures the animal'sand, by
inference, a human'scapacity to survive in the face of continuing
threat. The heightened stimulation that results from terror, however,
cannot be sustained and is followed by an adaptive response as the body
reinstates its homeostasis. If the threat continues, the oxygen-starved
vessels of the viscera eventually become permeable to plasma and, as in
surgical shock, this leads to a fall in blood pressure and a reduction in
the volume of circulating blood. In time this results in dehydration and
ultimately cardiovascular collapse. In humans this series of events can
be promoted by a social response. In a bonepointed person, for ex-
ample, dehydration is augmented by withdrawal from food and drink
as the ritual wreaks its social impact. In such cases it is clear that the in-
tense sympathetic activation within the bonepointed person could not
take place without the spiritual overlay of the culture.
Cannon pointed out that a similar process can take place in people
as a consequence of other experiences of terror. It had been reported in
sudden death after apparently trivial wounds experienced during war.
It had also been known in some patients who were profoundly anxious
Thought Control
O n the heels of World War II, many social psychologists were greatly
concerned by the way apparently civilized people had relinquished
their autonomy and humane values under the impact of group influ-
ence. Social psychology had evolved into an experimental science by
that time, and two classical studies in that discipline were designed to
ascertain how deviant behaviors could be generated under social influ-
ence. Although they were both carried out in laboratory settings re-
moved from the actualities of everyday life, they had a material effect
on how psychologists, and the public as well, came to see people as vul-
nerable to social influence. For our purposes we shall consider how those
studies help to explain the way intense group influence augmented by
the claim to spirituality can transform people's values.2
In the first of the studies, Solomon Asch illustrated how people are
vulnerable to accept distorted perceptions under group influence. He had
experimental subjects report which of three lines on a large white card
Emotional Conflict
Narcissism
This can be seen among people suffering from the malaise and loss of
spiritual roots that primed young people to join cults and left the stu-
dent at Stanford vulnerable to the psychological pressures in her en-
counter group.
People can seek relief and an illusion of transcendence in a transient
commitment to a conveniently available ad hoc tradition without rela-
tion to an abiding spiritual affiliation. This can allow for filling a void
caused by anxiety or a sense of inadequacy but may address only the
uneasiness of the moment. In this situation the self may predominate
over the other, whether the other is one's fellow man or woman or the
embodiment of one's historically valid religious ties.
This issue can be considered in relation to the conception put for-
ward by Gordon Allport's14 distinction between an extrinsic and in-
trinsic religious orientation. From his perspective the extrinsic orienta-
tion is characteristic of people who
are disposed to use religion for their own ends. . . .Persons with
this orientation may find religion useful in a variety of waysto
Other needs, strong as they may be, are regarded as of less ulti-
mate significance. . . . Having embraced a creed the individual
endeavors to internalize it and follow it fully. It is in this sense that
he lives his religion.
In retrospect I am not quite sure what she meant by this latter state-
ment. At least it seems clear that she had met some personal need with
all her spiritually related experiences. She was in no way depressed or
emotionally needy but had apparently fulfilled herself by touching down
at each of these subcultures as way stations that addressed some narcis-
sistically grounded need of the moment.
Many of these new pursuits, representing people's grasping at spiri-
tual fulfillment, are promoted on the basis of their celebrity followers.
The cult of the individual as model for narcissism promotes this. The
Scientologists have their "Celebrity Centers," where the names of Holly-
wood figures such as John Travolta, Tom Cruise, and Lisa Marie Presley
implicitly justify adherence to this dubious cultic movement. Madonna
touts her commitment to Kabbalah, and this seems to confer a degree
of legitimacy on this derivative of medieval Jewish mysticism.
The recent popularity of Kabbalah illustrated the intersection of the
need for spiritual fulfillment and the need to meet unrequited narcis-
sistic needs. Admittedly, Kabbalah represents a long-standing tradition
of arcane Jewish mysticism dating back to the Zohar, a dense and lengthy
treatise written in the thirteenth century by a Castilian rabbi. In recent
years, however, it has been promoted as a commercial product. One advo-
cate of this is Michael Berg, who opened Kabbalah Centres in Los An-
geles, New York, and London, and attracted a following (for whatever
reason, mostly women) including the likes of Elizabeth Taylor, Court-
ney Love, Diane Keaton, Roseanne Barr, and Madonna. As described in
the brochure of New York's Kabbalah Centre, evening programs offered
a measure of redemption in a series of several sessions, wedding the He-
brew calendar to the astrological signs and pointing out that "when a
new month begins, we have an opportunity to tap into all the positive
aspects of the astral powers that govern the upcoming month, and
to protect ourselves against the negative aspects." Thus, the first day of
each Hebrew calendar month was wedded to one of these signs: "rosh
chodesh nissanAries," "lyarTaurus," and so on. Benefits of this
movement could be derived from purchases of Kabbalah mineral water
and by wearing a red string around one's wrist (as Winona Ryder, in a
Life's Transitions
E ven the most resilient of people may need help with their emotional
distress when they come upon difficulties they cannot surmount.
In psychiatry's diagnostic manual, such troubles are encompassed in a
neatly framed chapter on Phase of Life Problems (62.89), which can
be diagnosed
Not all people, however, conclude that the "clinical attention" cited
in this APA nomenclature will give them the relief they want, as they have
a wide range of options to choose from. Jim, for example, had spent a
year abroad as a college sophomore, living the last three months in a
fishing village on an island off the African coast. He had learned to con-
verse in Swahili and found a congenial existence among the people
there, unfettered by pressures back home, but when he returned to col-
lege he found the trappings of materialism in the United States disillu-
94
sioning. The impersonal nature and sameness of the shopping malls,
with their GAP stores and supermarkets, stood in striking contrast to
the comfortable familiarity he experienced on the island back in Kenya.
He became depressed and was looking for something to make up for
"the happiest I'd ever been" only a short time before.
Jim went into therapy for a while but found that it offered him little
in the way of comfort, so he decided to try to achieve some clarity on
the meaning of his life and began by taking up a major in comparative
religion. He remembered some visits with a friend to Quaker services
while he was still in high school and recalled that the silent reflection in
their meeting houses had given him a sense of comfort and certitude.
So given what he was now learning about Eastern religions, he decided
to go on a week-long retreat at a Zen Buddhist monastery, where he was
expected to remain silent except for a brief encounter with the abbott
each day. Much time was spent in meditation, which brought him into
the state that he was seeking:
I think bliss and union are built into the very nature of every-
thing. Our cells align in incredible ways. We have 1,500 processes
aligned before our heart beats once. We are the ultimate epiphany
of alignment, and we merely have to take it to the next stage and
say, "it is there all the time."
her way of honoring ancient schools across the world and across
history where women and men gather to explore and decipher
the great mysteries and their resonance and application in order
to live more freely and fully. The weekends are designed to pro-
vide rich experiences embracing sacred psychology: a synthesis of
As in youth cults and, for that matter, in many church parishes, so-
cial engagement combined with a quasi-spiritual revival is influential in
the school's attraction. Liz illustrated this point:
She also has a global agenda, where everybody has to reach out
and join hands or we're all going to annihilate each other. I guess
she feels that if we are all on a level of higher consciousness it
wouldn't be such a big problem for us all to live together.
She gave the example of her friend who had told Jean that she
wanted a stable relationship with a man. Two years later she found a
"soul-mate." Mara explained that "by making the request I think it
opens up new options in a person. I don't think there's anything genie-
like or anything mystical." Nonetheless, as she described her friend's
finding the soul-mate, she implied that without Houston it might have
never happened. (It seemed to me that Houston's benediction might
have worn out after 2 years, and other circumstances would have brought
about this outcome. It is an open question.)
Parallels between the Gifting and other personal encounters with
spiritual figures underline the importance of such meetings. Examples
abound: a young woman who was "deeply consoled" by a female Hindu
guru who hugs each of the hundreds of people who attend her services,
the chaplain who told me of an experience of illumination upon greet-
ing Mother Theresa, the psychiatric resident who described the bright
halo that appeared around a woman who was giving a religious ser-
mon. Such encounters seem to embody an air of transcendence, im-
plicitly conveying the spiritual message of the emotional healer.
We see with Jim and Mara that there are alternatives to therapy, as cur-
rently practiced, when life's circumstances leave a person in need of some-
thing more than the relief of "target symptoms." Our culture has achieved
a degree of ecumenism that offers alternatives to what traditional reli-
gion, psychoanalysis, or a comfortable family life once provided. Per-
haps these options reflect the secular spirituality of our time. These al-
ternatives provide a grounding, at least for a time, that people living in
this era of ongoing social transition may turn to when the need arises.
The moment she would live in, that community she joined, clearly had
a cultlike quality, and she described how members' assets were handed
over to the group's leaders and used to purchase real estate. Members
were then expected to spend long hours renovating the buildings and
tending to the surrounding gardens. Soon they were required to get up
at 5:00 in the morning to meditate for 30 minutes. And as if these de-
mands on her were not enough, Corrie began a course in homeopathic,
nontraditional medicine, which took up even more of her time.
After 5 years at the school, she realized that she could no longer sus-
tain herself on this spiritual treadmill:
You know what I did after coming out of the school? I said to the
cosmos, if I ever get a teacher again I want one on a different level
than I've met until now. And I don't know why, but at that mo-
ment I asked for a teacher in the spirit world, not someone walk-
ing on this earth, because I didn't really believe that there was an
inspiring source for me on this earth. So that's what I got within
a year. A woman I really trusted started channeling a guide in the
spirit world and she taught me a lot for another 6 years.
No, he had never lived on this earth. You know, it's amazing that
I got there to be in contact with him. If someone had asked me
five years before, I would have said, "Bullshit." But I came to a chan-
neling when this woman, a professional woman, gave one of her
first channelings of this guide, and felt an energy coming into the
room, and it was pure love and pure light. So I could do nothing
else but believe that there was truth in there. The funny thing was
that what he taught me was that I was worthy as a human being,
whatever my personality might be. I didn't expect that this could
come from a spirit from the other side.
A Psychological Perspective
T
he attempt to put the encounter between psychiatry and spiri-
tuality in perspective is quite daunting. We have looked at psy-
chological, biological, cultural, and even some economic as-
pects of it, but as any anthropologist can tell you, our examination,
restricted as it is to the Western secular setting, can be narrow, simply
by inadvertence. So it is useful to look at the issues in some different
cultures to lend depth to our understanding. This is amateur anthro-
pology at best, but hopefully it conveys a sense of how the issue of
spirituality is more universal than that which we have discussed in
secular Western culture.
In India psychiatrists practice a sophisticated brand of psycho-
therapy and pharmacotherapy while still making use of the relief a
patient finds in having his or her family protected by the goddess
Durga. In Egypt, where the Al-Azhar is the seat of centuries-long
study of the Koran, it is acceptable for Muslims troubled by emotional
problems to seek counsel from a Coptic Christian cleric without vio-
lating their own religious traditions. In America people trained for
hospital-based chaplaincy, because of the mantle of spiritual legitima-
tion they bear, can address the fears and anxieties of those who are
morally ill. And within the culture of Fundamentalists Christian psy-
chiatrists, attitudes range from sensitivity to what is meaningful in
people's lives, religiously related or not, to healing that involves chan-
neling the Spirit of Christ.
Each of these traditions can anoint a healer to address certain is-
sues of emotional import, ones that contemporary psychotherapy
sometimes addresses at length and with less success. In each of these
settings, what is spiritual can therefore illuminate our own sense of
how psychiatry and spirituality intersect and shed light on some of
the biases that each culture holds.
Christian Psychiatry
113
bers' complaints over problems with some small inpatient psychiatric
services that had become "Christian-oriented." It turned out that Chris-
tian Fundamentalist psychiatrists had taken over management of some
hospital facilities and were favoring practitioners of their own religious
orientation to the exclusion of others.
After we responded to these concerns, I became curious as to how
the religious orientation of the devout Christian practitioners related to
their clinical work. The Christian Medical Association had a member-
ship of 7,500, 5% of whom were psychiatrists. Their membership ap-
plication gave a sense of who might join the CMA, and it was quite
explicit. Applicants had to sign a statement acknowledging "the final
authority of the Bible as the word of God . . . the presence and power
of the Holy Spirit and the work of regeneration . . . the everlasting
blessedness of the saved and the everlasting punishment of the lost."
The work done by these "Christian psychiatrists" was of interest to
me as theirs was the only organization in which psychiatrists were mak-
ing an explicit attempt to integrate a spiritual orientation into clinical
practice. Dr. David Larson, who was active in the group, had helped es-
tablish a liaison with them, and I was able to obtain survey responses
from 74% of their members to study the nature of their beliefs and work.1
Mainstream psychiatrists typically divest their clinical practices of
any religious orientation or spiritual content, but when I compared the
available Gallup polling data2 to the results to the survey, it turned out
that most Americans espouse a religious orientation similar to that of
these Fundamentalist practitioners. A majority of both the Christian
psychiatrists and the public at large indicated that they believed in a
personal God who "rewards and punishes" them for their actions (78%
and 69%, respectively). Almost all the psychiatrists surveyed stated that
they believed in the devil, as does the large majority of the general popu-
lation (98% and 78%). Almost all the psychiatrists said they had been
"born again" and had "encouraged someone to accept Jesus as Savior,"
and about half the overall population had done so as well (96%, 40%,
and, respectively 45%). In many respects these psychiatrists were not
out of keeping with the American mainstream.
The survey illustrated the considerable degree to which these Chris-
tian psychiatrists felt that the Bible and prayer should play a role in
Without faith I'm left alone with fate . . . when I finally invite
Jesus into the now of my pain, emptiness, and loneliness (or, more
realistically, every time I "finally" do that), I hear Him gently invit-
ing me into the now of His presence and joy.
So, you are ready now to let Jesus into your pain? If you are ready
you may want to pray something like this:
Very often people with depression come in one way or other ex-
pressing "What's the point?" My response is "Wonderful question.
What is the point? Let's find out. Let's talk about it. Let's under-
stand what endows your life with some meaning." So spirituality
to me may be God talk but it can also be about meaning and pur-
pose and finding a reason for whatever is one's next action.
Even if they have some kind of religion that's not strictly Chris-
tian, they will very often believe in some kind of a God, and the
question about whether He is good or evil or capricious is not
hard for me to ask at some pointand just kind of gently nudge
them forward and inquire. If someone keeps coming up with a
punitive, angry, capricious, tormenting kind of God, I will try to
get them to understand: Is that necessarily the reality?
ask the patient "Why did this happen to you? Why has your life
been like this? And what is valuable to you, important to you that
you would want to get clean and sober now? What do you think
can allow that to happen?" And those sort of connections to a pa-
tient's own story allow for making meaning, to gain a sense of
purpose, their own sense of causation, their own sense of why
they're on the planet. These are questions that I'm going to look
for, to just kind of nudge and inquire about, and to endow with
some importance and value.
So I asked him, how would Christ want you to relate to your wife
and to your children? So using that overall standard as a point of
reference, the patient was able to come up with an appropriate
answer.
The one thing that I try virtually never to do is to use the Bible or
spiritual principles as a club. I think that's bad psychiatry. It's just
not the way to influence people. So I'd be very, very careful about
saying anything along those lines. It would be much more along
the line of a question, you know, what do you think would be
helpful to your wife? What do you think would be appropriate?
Do you think God would have any input on how you might relate
to her? In this way, it would be much more open-ended. . . . So
at times we would refer to specific portions of the Scriptures,
whether it's Beatitudes or some verses in Philippians that talk
about behavior.
The Scriptures can certainly carry weight but also a potentially heavy
sanction. I wondered, does their evocation add credence and deft ap-
plication of benign influence, or do they elicit undue guilt? When one
of the participants in the Christian psychiatry meeting at the APA had
distinguished between "boundary crossings" and "boundary violations,"
I must deal with the sinful choices and behaviors through confes-
sion and restitution as needed. . . . If I only addressed the sin
and never deal with the lies behind my sinful choices I am doomed
to a perpetual cycle of sin, confession, repentance, performance-
based-spirituality and eventual defeat . . . I may still walk in
defeat until my experiential lies are displaced with experiential
Divinely provided truth. . . . Theophostic Ministry releases the
experiential shackles and chains that hold me.
At this end of the spectrum, the psychiatrist Enoch and his mentor on
the Internet make no compromise with the "everlasting punishment of
the lost" (as stated in the membership application of the Christian
Medical Association).
And so, as with many religious denominations, there is a range of
views articulated, from the tolerant to the severe; from the literal inter-
pretation of the sacred document to a flexible expression of its spirit;
Spirituality in India
128
dial in Mumbai (Bombay), with its steeple modeled after the one at
Canterbury, was completed in the mid-nineteenth century, only a mo-
ment ago relative to the long history of India. These enduring artifacts
validate the abiding nature of India's spiritual heritage and suggest that
we should not ignore it as we consider the way psychotherapy can be
practiced.
The Hindu religion, with its hundreds of gods and demigods, pre-
dates Christianity by a millennium and retains elaborate myths and cus-
toms that must be respected, if not fully understood, in order to appre-
ciate the spiritual ethos of contemporary India. Nirad Chaudhury,1 a
scholar of the culture, pointed out that because of its complexity, India's
cultural iconography can be an obstacle to understanding Hinduism, as
it is typically equated with the religion itself. This iconography is elabo-
rated in the Mahabharata, an epic poem of more than 220,000 lines
that tells the story of Rama, who along with Krishna is one of the nine
avatars, or incarnations, of the Hindu god Vishnu. This poem, in turn,
contains within it the Hindu epic the Ramayana, which is introduced
with this: "He who reads and repeats this holy life-giving Ramayana is
liberated from all his sins and exalted with all his posterity to the high-
est heaven."
India evidenced an ability to absorb contemporary trends as well. As
elsewhere in the world, the information age has had a profound impact
on its educated classes and even on its rural population. Movies from
"Bollywood," the country's cinema production center in Mumbai, have
been widely watched in its cities for half a century, but the widespread
availability of television has brought them to an ever-growing portion
of the country's rural population. Cars have replaced motorcycles, motor-
cycles are replacing bicycles, and bicycles, in turn, take countless Indi-
ans to their colleges and workplaces. Western slacks and shirts are now
generally seen instead of the dhoti, the traditional garb for men, and,
of course, India's competency in adopting electronic technology is un-
arguable. Nonetheless, the grand architectural monuments remain, the
temples are well populated, and, of some irony, Western interest in tradi-
tional Indian values and practices has aroused a reciprocal interest in the
Indian middle class. Networks of well-educated philosopher-teachers
such as those touted in the glossy brochures of the Chinmaya Mission
proclaim that they can "provide to individuals from any background
Liberal Islam
143
tenth and eleventh centuries, including Omar Khayyam and Jalal ad-
Din Rumi, played a role in the emergence of Sufism, a semimonastic Is-
lamic sect. Sufism carries on its own independent tradition that is Islamic
but apart from the religion's mainstream. It incorporates Buddhist and
Christian ideas and introduced a mystical element into the country's
culture, emphasizing an immediate and personal relationship of one's
soul with God. Another tradition that bears on spiritual values in con-
temporary Iran derives from the Shahnameh, a poetic work embodied
in pre-Islamic traditional Persian mythology. It describes the heroic and
physically powerful Rostam. As Mohit said, "like Hercules, he fights gi-
ants and wild lions, but at the same time embodies the concept of great
wisdom" and can guide people through their personal conflicts. Both of
these traditions come into play in the role of the Pir, understood in con-
temporary Iran as a wise person with great insight who can be relied on
for spiritual guidance. Such a figure reflects an Iranian archetype, much
like a Hindu guru, who can be at a person's side as a guide, "wanting
good for him. He could be a teacher, a family member, a Sufi or a reli-
gious leadera cultural model typical of Eastern rather than Occi-
dental traditions."
Mohit further pointed out how the spoken word of such a person
carries great weight, "much more than that of a cognitive behavioral
therapist," as he put it. People will turn to the Pirfor advice infused with
spiritual import. This does not carry a religious connotation per se, but
can be highly influential in addressing issues in the psychiatric domain.
Cairo is the intellectual capital of Islam, in large part because of the
role of its Al-Azhar mosque, which dates back more than a millennium.
It now embodies both the office of the mufti, its religious leader, and its
university, to which youths come from all across the Islamic world to
study. The mufti at Al-Azhar interprets the Koran and provides Islamic
rulings on all aspects of life, from marriage and divorce to the final de-
cision on execution of criminals. I met with Shaikh Gamal Kotb, who is
on the mufti's council, head of publication at Al-Azhar University, and
a member of parliament as well. He has taken a particular interest in the
problems of the addicted and the mentally ill. He appeared in his cler-
ical robe, striking the dignified pose of his position.
Souad Moussa translated his Arabic into English. She had spent 3
years practicing psychiatry at a teaching hospital in London and is now
Given his interest in psychiatric issues, I asked him how this perspec-
tive related to mental illness. Through Moussa, he replied
Hospital Chaplaincy:
Confronting Illness and Death
149
exchange from a theological perspective. A discussion ensued that
dealt with some of the psychological and spiritual conflicts raised by
the encounter but skirted any focus on formal psychiatric diagnosis or
evaluation.
I was impressed by Jared's decency and concern for the patient's well-
being and asked if I could speak with him later to help with our studies
on spirituality. In the comfort of my office it became clear that a desire
to draw on his own religious background had led him to dedicate him-
self to the chaplaincy. As a young man he had considered the priest-
hood but before ordination concluded that he could not accept a life of
celibacy. He turned instead to social work and later became a deacon in
the church. After we had spoken for an hour, he described one particu-
lar event that made clear how psychiatrists could distance themselves
from the emotional needs of their patients.
Jared had encountered a good deal of suffering in his own family.
His wife had died of a brain tumor after a long illness, after which his
daughter, a college student, became increasingly depressed. She was
treated by a psychiatrist, but her depression continued unabated; she
was found dead of an overdose in her dormitory room with her mother's
picture on her chest and a tape of her mother's favorite song lying at her
side. Jared was first told of the death by her psychiatrist. He was over-
whelmed with grief and did not know how to respond. Looking hope-
less and distraught even now, he told me he said, "This must be God's
will." He could not forget the response of the psychiatrist, who said coldly
that "It's magical thinking like that that led to your daughter's suicide."
I wondered how far removed the psychiatrist could have been from
compassion that he could make such a statement. Or was this a reflec-
tion of the level of training my profession offered in religious tolerance?
The opportunity to speak with other chaplaincy trainees in the pro-
gram allowed for exploring the ecumenical and spiritual orientation of
their approach. Although their goal was to allow the hospital's many
patients to confront illness, even mortality, with a measure of equanim-
ity, the trainees had to struggle with issues that would carry an emo-
tional burden for themselves.
Harry served as a pastor in the Church of the Nazarene while en-
rolled in the chaplaincy program, and he described how his views had
During his life I think he had many other women. And I think he
never respected his wife, who was some years older than him, and
who he married when he was 17. When he was small, his mother
died, and I think he wanted to have a relationship with an older
woman. I think she gave him motherly love when he got married,
but he became bitter after a time.
When I first went to him I said, "Hello, can you tell me some-
thing about yourself?" He said, "Father, I am all right. I do not have
anything to say." But he was in the last stage before death, and it
One of the basic things is the listening style. I had a tendency not
to listen, but to talk, and by not listening I misunderstood. Some-
times I would think that I am better than the people I tend to. So
the day I started listening I started to reflect. And if you reflect and
then give a response it has some weight, it has some understand-
ing, that I was not getting before. And the second thing is that I
had the tendency to always look good. Nobody challenged my life,
and here I was challenged. This challenge made me aware that
priesthood is not an easy life. My vocation is not easy. It is a chal-
lenge and I have to improve a lot. My ministry was challenged.
And the third thing I came to know about myself was that
chaplaincy is a multinational religious education. It is not an evan-
gelizing agenda. It is to heal the suffering of the patients in the
face of their sicknesses, and to give value to their own religious re-
O
n June 10,1935, two chronic alcoholics, Bill Wilson and Bob
Smith, sat together in Akron, Ohio, in the hope of staving off
their craving for alcohol. Over the ensuing days they were
somehow able to avoid taking a drink. Heartened by that success, they
decided that other people suffering from their seemingly incurable
illness could work together to overcome their compulsion to drink.
Bill W went on from there to frame an ideology and movement for
which Aldous Huxley described him as "the greatest social architect of
the twentieth century."
The AA fellowship that emerged from this effort illustrates the re-
markable capacity of people to join together under the banner of a
movement for recovery from illnesses that have left them dejected
and seemingly helpless. This psychological phenomenon takes place
within a social structure whose members share a bond of affiliation
enhanced by an earnestly held set of beliefs. Engagement can then
lead to experiences that transform their members' thinking, feelings
and behavior.
This section of the book examines the ways such movements can
relieve the symptoms of psychiatric disorders and infuse a culture
with a redemptive ideologyas they have done in different ways for
many compulsive behaviors and even for major mental illness. It is a
phenomenon studied systematically, and it sheds light on a number of
issues implicit in this book. Among them is the popularity of alterna-
tive medicineoften the embodiment of techniques devoid of scien-
tific validationand its historical origins in shamanic healing. With a
better understanding of such spiritually oriented movements, the
mainstream mental health profession can consider ways of making
use of their transformative powers.
Alternative Medicine
159
and perhaps strengthen their minds and bodies. Both the sick and the
healthy may oscillate between the options of spiritual healing and con-
ventional medical approaches.
Among the severely ill this was illustrated by a patient who was suf-
fering from a neurodegenerative disease. After a series of metabolic stud-
ies, he was told that his malady had yet to leave anyone alive for more
than 10 years. The physicians gave him and his wife little emotional sup-
port, and certainly no hope. Soon the couple found that his body and
mind were in decline, with modest relief provided by analgesics that
would mute his pain and disability while he continued to suffer from a
depressing transition to helplessness. Neither he nor his wife, sophisti-
cated New Yorkers on any count, had contemplated any medical treat-
ment other than top-flight management at a university medical center,
but racked by anxiety and looking for any help they might find, they
went to a traditional healer in the city's Chinatown whom they hoped
would help fight off the problem that conventional medicine could not
resolve. In their case the exploration of this option offered little credible
assistance, and they did not return. Others in their place might have re-
sponded differently and stayed on with an alternative healer.
Among the healthy some people tailor their diets to conform to ex-
otic and ill-founded theories that are remotely related to primitive cul-
tures predating the emergence of modern medical science. They may
begin to speak in terms drawn from ancient India and China and avoid
conventional physicians, whom they distrust. When confronted with
the flu or a minor health problem, they may turn to unconventional
medical techniques recommended by a friend. With luck, they will get
a treatment based in scientific medicine if they encounter serious illness.
The Movements
Subcultures
Do No Harm?
Alcoholics Anonymous
171
Later I asked him about AA, which he had encountered in one of his
many hospital detox admissions. He said he would try to go to a meet-
ing whenever he could, which meant maybe once a week.
"Has AA been helpful to you?"
"The meetings are the only thing that have kept me alive. I had a place.
Maybe some hope. Otherwise I would have killed myself long ago."
The paradox of one hand grasping onto the lifeline of AA and the
other seemingly forced to take a drink is not uncommon among our
patients. They often find themselves with nothing else to hold on to but
their belief in AA's higher power and its fellowship of people with simi-
lar troubles. They may sit in the back of an AA meeting room in the
Times Square area. Often they are intoxicated and speak to no one there.
They had no other source of respite and no other place where they were
made to feel that their lives might have some legitimacy.
Even so, AA, of course, is not only for helpless loners. Harry was a
successful businessman whose drinking had brought a relationship with
a woman whom he cared for to an end. His experience illustrates the
profound impact of the kindness engendered by AA's Twelfth Step, "to
carry this message to [other] alcoholics" and help them to overcome
their helplessness in the face of addiction. He had been sober for several
years when he told me about the last time he had taken a drink.
He had befriended another alcoholic man while they were both in a re-
hab center, but neither of them found the idea of accepting AA particu-
larly appealing. Knowing Harry, this was hardly a surprise, as he had suf-
fered a good deal of abuse from his alcoholic father in his youth, trusted
very few people, and had recounted his many difficulties with teachers
and even police over the course of his high school and college years. He
had, in fact, ousted his father from the family business after he had man-
aged to assume a controlling interest in it some years before. It was un-
settling to hear how Harry was always ready to vindictively compromise
a competitor in business while at the same time placing his trust in me; on
one level he clearly wanted to find respite from the suspicions he lived with.
Harry told me that he had managed to avoid drinking the week after
discharge from rehab and was curious to see how his friend from that
program was doing. He called the man's house and was told by his dis-
traught wife that the friend had died of an overdose of pills 2 days be-
fore. Harry was shocked and dismayed and could think of nothing else
Y ou sometimes see a car labeled with "A friend of Bill W." bumper
sticker. It is more than a catch phrase alluding to Bill Wilson, AA's
founder. For many members identification with Bill W.'s spirituality de-
fines a moral code that originated in an intense religious experience re-
counted in the movement's book Alcoholics Anonymous Comes of Age.1
In it the charismatic founder of AA recounted a dramatic conversion he
experienced after many unsuccessful episodes of detoxification, as one
night his despair was transformed into transcendence:
All at once I found myself crying out, "If there is a God, let Him
show himself! I am ready to do anything, anything!"
Evaluating AA Participation
It was my son's first week at the rehab and I was at a family meet-
ing, a very emotional meeting. They asked everyone to say some-
thing and all I could say was "I should be in AA, too," and a few
days later I went to my first meeting.
It now seemed clear that Ron's guilt over his impact on his son's
prior refusal of treatment had driven him to confess his alcoholism at
the hospital's family meeting. He knew implicitly that he had been liv-
ing a lie, one that might have cost his son greatly. He had become the
sinner, much like one who could not help but stand up at a religious re-
vival meeting begging forgiveness of the Lord.
So what you do is you turn your life and your will over to the care
of this Higher Power, and whatever happens, from the moment
you wake up in the morning until you go to the wrong exit, get off
on the wrong floor, if a person is not on the other end of the tele-
phone, that's God's plan for you. In turning your will over to God,
that's really the concept of powerlessness.
In Relation to Professionals
M
any innovations have emerged within the practice of
psychotherapy over the last half century, illustrating the
flexibility of the therapeutic encounter in incorporating
new approaches to treatment. In the 19405 and 19505 psychoanalysts
displaced organically oriented, hospital-based psychiatry at the helm
of the APA. In the 19608 psychiatrists demonstrated how a commu-
nity's social resources can be organized to address mental illness among
its residents. Cognitive approaches, interpersonal therapy, and group
therapy had become widely accepted as the century came to an end.
But what about a psychotherapy that draws on people's innate
spiritual resources? Such an option now lingers outside the main-
stream of the mental health field and is not yet actively considered.
This section of the book is intended to introduce some ways that the
human spirit can serve as an instrument for recovery from psychologi-
cally grounded disorders. The approaches discussed here, quite differ-
ent in nature, illustrate that people have within them the ability to ac-
complish more in such ways than is usually realized.
In the psychiatric hospital management of patients with major
mental illness can be augmented by approaches analogous to those
used in AA. In the therapist's office we can learn from a diverse set of
examples. We can see how one doctor of rehabilitation medicine fa-
cilitates the relief of physical pain in his patients by giving them an ex-
planation for it that he himself believes. Mindful meditation has been
shown to relieve the burdens of anxiety and depression by drawing on
people's ability to take distance in their minds from distressing feel-
ings and by employing innate resources long associated with spiritual
experience. Many people who harbor capabilities compromised by
emotional disorders can be helped to reap greater joy and comfort by
drawing on values that are truly meaningful to them. This section of
the book therefore gives some indication of how psychotherapy can
gain effectiveness from the many resources available within people,
ones that often go untapped.
The Problem
189
terized it typically resulted from the isolation from normal social con-
tact that such people were subjected to, either in attics at home or back
wards of state hospitals.
Sociologists have raised the issue of labeling of the mentally ill, which
is thought to be responsible for many of the behaviors observed in these
patients. Kai Erikson emphasized how many of the institutions that so-
ciety has constructed to inhibit deviance actually operate to perpetuate
it. Marginal people segregated in such settings are labeled mentally ill
and learn from one another how their deviancy is to appear by observ-
ing one another's behaviors.3 They thereby acquire a career of deviancy,
reinforcing their sense of alienation from the rest of society.
Erving Goffman brought this issue home quite clearly. He spent a
year as a participant-observer among patients at St. Elizabeth's Hospi-
tal in Washington, DC, and described the dehumanizing effects of life
in the mental hospital, which he described as having in common traits
with other "total institutions" such as penitentiaries and the army, which
fully take over the lives and identities of their members. Goffman made
a convincing argument that the identity of mental patients could be
formed as much by life in an institution as by the innate illnesses they
suffer.4
Interesting evidence of this emerged from a study conducted by David
Rosenhan, a professor of psychology and law, who dispatched people
who were quite sane to a variety of mental hospitals around the coun-
try to feign mental illness in order to gain admission.5 These pseudo-
patients were instructed to arrive at the respective admission offices
complaining of hearing voices but otherwise to present their life histo-
ries as they actually had lived them. All were admitted immediately, but
upon entry they stopped simulating any symptoms of mental illness
and asked to be discharged. Despite repeated requests to leave the hos-
pital, they were unable to get out until an average of nineteen days had
passed, and each was given a diagnosis of schizophrenia on departure.
The pseudo-patients spent much of their time taking notes on the
experiences of their hospital stay, and their writing was presumed by
the staff to be an aspect of their pathology. Their personal histories,
which were actually unremarkable except for the "recent onset" of hal-
lucinations, were reinterpreted by staff to validate the origins of their
mental illness. Notes such as this framed the staffs understanding: "While
Now that you're ready to leave the hospital, can you tell me
what brought you here?
I was having trouble sleeping because I had a headache.
But why did they bring you to the emergency room?
They were helping me out. I needed a good night's rest.
He had, in fact, been brought to our emergency service by the police after
ranting at commuters taking their trains home from Grand Central
Station. He had struggled with them, pleading that devils were trying to
take over his body, and he was also clearly drunk: for the public, quite a
nuisance; for us, a man whose illness we could only partly address. He
could not bear to face the shame and stigma he had acquired while in
the hospital, so he had to create a false reality to justify the admission.
Other patients would explain that their hospitalizations were caused
by a bad backache, or by neighbors who had been jealous of them, or
by a mother who had felt they were not eating enough. They were clearly
unable to deal with what they feared most: despair over a brain and
mind that had created overwhelming anxiety and that became their own
demonic enemy.
As if psychosis and addictive drugs were not enough, we found that
AIDS was becoming increasingly prevalent among these patients: 23%
were infected with the HIV virus,15 and transmission took place pri-
marily through promiscuous sexual activity. At low doses of crack, two
Deinstitutionalization
A Sense of Community
The staff was therefore intent not to invalidate the psychotic experience
but to regard it instead as a transformative life event; they saw it as an
opportunity to initiate personal growth.
B ellevue Hospital began serving the poor and alienated of New York
in 1736, when it occupied a room on the upper floor of the city's
"Publick Workhouse" and was staffed by one physician who supplied his
own medications. Cells for the pauper insane were first noted in its re-
ports in 1825, and an alcoholic pavilion was built in i892.35 More recently,
its large psychiatry building, with some 900 beds, was featured in the
film The Lost Weekend, which won the Academy Award for best picture
in 1945. It tells the tale of a hapless alcoholic whose delirium tremens
was treated at Bellevue but whose recovery would come through AA.
On coming to NYU's School of Medicine to teach at Bellevue, I
offered to take on patients admitted to the psychiatry service for gen-
eral psychiatric disorders plus substance abuse. The plus made these pa-
tients a double headache, and the hospital's psychiatrists were pleased
to see someone else relieve them of tailoring a program for this difficult
population.
Over the next several years my colleagues and I developed a program
for the dually diagnosed in which acute patients were admitted from the
My name is Carl and I'm from the MICA [Mental Illness and
Chemical Addiction] program at the Greenhouse. Francis and
Luis and I are here to answer all your questions about what you
might want to know about the program and what it has to offer
you. We give you room and board, but with that we give you
treatment. We're considered to be a family: we're all together. It's
a safe environment.
Mental illness is a big part of our addiction, and the stigma-
tism [sic] that goes behind it is important too. I don't know about
you but I am an alcoholic and an addict, which is very easy for me
to say, but when I say mental illness it gets tough for me because
of the stigmatism out there.
Patients were watched over by their peers to assure they stayed away
from alcohol and drugs.
Over the course of their 6 months of induction into the program's
philosophy (the belief system, if you will), patients come to adopt a
more constructive attitude and assume increasing responsibilities, after
which they could move into community-based housing and attend our
full-day Recovery Clinic. This clinic is also peer-led and is based on in-
tensive group exchanges among the patients. As in the Greenhouse, most
meetings in the clinic involve all the patients to strengthen the sense of
community and create the atmosphere of a "movement," much as cul-
tic groups increase validation of their beliefs by generating a sense of
And later:
JUAN: I got a lot out of this group, the way to express myself.
I'm getting to where I'm suppose to be, but I still have to make
sure to not let my ego or my self-esteem get too built up, because
it's how we fall down hard. I'm trying not to fall back down, I'm
trying to keep myself clean.
214
We do well to remember that "nonspecific factors" of many different
schools of psychotherapy are often more effective than the particulars
employed in each of them. According to Jerome Frank,3 these include
issues such as a confiding relationship, the expectation of help, and pro-
viding meaning to symptomsissues not unlike those inherent in
shamanic rituals. We should also not forget that in the domain of
psychopharmacology, Walsh evaluated placebo-controlled studies on
antidepressants. He found that for every hundred patients responding
to an active medication in clinical trials, more than 60% of patients
given the placebos for that drug achieved relief as well.4 He warned of
the dangers of lending credence to antidepressant studies that evaluate
active drugs alone. Not all drug effects are based on seeming "evidence"
of biomedical effect.
Given these observations, might there be ways in which a shamanic
role of spiritual orientation could be applied within the medical main-
stream? Or, put another way, could some of the more elaborate proce-
dures undertaken by physicians be replaced by shamanlike rituals that
are effective and perhaps more efficient?
In addressing this question, we can consider one physician embed-
ded in the medical establishment who has practiced an approach that
looks as if it has some of the trappings of shamanism; in many ways, in
fact, it is preferable to those of his colleagues. His story illustrates the
difficulty that empirical medicine has in accommodating a technique
that some would consider spiritualized hogwash because it does not
conform to traditional, evidence-based practice.
The reputation of John Sarno, a physician and professor of rehabili-
tation medicine at NYU, had preceded him long before we met. I first
heard of him from Adam, a patient of mine and a pragmatic and suc-
cessful owner of his own business. Adam was free of the symptoms for
which he originally entered treatment but came by intermittently to put
a perspective on ongoing problems he was having in his marriage. Dur-
ing periods of difficulty, he tended to suffer from headaches rather than
from anxiety and depression. He had long experienced these head-
aches, for which he had gone to a number of physicians, was evaluated
at some length at a clinic dedicated to the medical nature of such prob-
lems at a local teaching hospital, but had received no relief. I remember
He then described for me his model for why so many people suffer from
problems, ascribing the pain to tension from the "unconscious anger"
that people live with nowadays. He said this stemmed from three sources.
The first was the burden of inferiority that people feel due to mental
Meditation
223
Zach had become interested in meditation while practicing psychol-
ogy before he was aware of Maharaj Ji. On one occasion he had called a
cleaning service for his office and was visited by members of the Divine
Light Mission, who were supporting themselves by working in office
maintenance. On hearing of his interest in meditation, they invited him
to go to one of Maharaj Ji's festivals, and he went, "just to be involved
with people who are on a spiritual path in that kind of consciousness."
Soon thereafter, though, he became intrigued by the guru, who said of
the Mission's meditative practices, as Zach recalled,
I'm not supposed to tell you, but I can say what the meditation is
like. There are four experiences: light, music, holy name, and nec-
tar. The nectar involves taste, for example. To see light within you,
you have to have your eyes closed. It's encompassing. It feels really
wonderful and it's within you. You feel like you're in a very peace-
ful place.
Meditation 225
hoping to show me what he was like. His devotees kissed his feet, but
since this did not seem appealing, I moved by quickly, hoping to get on
with the study I had planned. It was clearly different from what Zach
had experienced.
Zach further described how the guru's movement had become more
secularized, how the guru now used videos to instruct on meditation,
and how he had renamed the mission Elan Vitale. After all, he had
moved to Pacific Palisades with his American wife, a former stewardess.
The guru still gives talks that attract his followers, and Zach had gone
as far as Australia to join in with others of the enlightened followers.
I asked how all this affected his practice of psychotherapy, and his re-
sponse illustrated the way a mental health professional, even one fol-
lowing a guru, may be reluctant to veer away from what is considered
proper practice:
"Does your own spiritual experience play any role in your clinical
practice?"
Mindfulness Meditation
Meditation 227
as popular options during the 19708. Maharishi Mahesh Yogi, who in-
sisted that his TM meditators keep their mantra secret, wrote that, "With
more and more practice, the ability of the mind [expands] to maintain
its essential nature while experiencing objects through the senses in-
creases. When this happens the mind and its essential nature, the state
of transcendental Being, become one."1 TM gained wide popularity,
with training centers across the country, but its most devoted adherents
moved increasingly into a circumscribed subculture looking for "cos-
mic consciousness." Some established a residential community of their
own in Fairfield, Iowa, with their own university, and raised their chil-
dren as devotees to their philosophy. Given all this, TM may be too cul-
tic in orientation to be acceptable to a medical-scientific community.
On the other hand, Herbert Benson at Harvard was popularizing
"the relaxation response" as a fully secular approach with no spiritual
trappings around the same time that TM was flourishing.2 People who
applied Benson's approach were encouraged to pick a word of their
choosing, assume a comfortable posture in a quiet setting, and repeat
that word in their mind while gaining a feeling of relaxation. There was
no guru and no spiritual overlay. Researchers on this approach found
that it provided relief from tension and that hypertensive patients who
applied it achieved a lower blood pressure, even after their original
training.3 The relaxation response, however, devoid as it is of an associ-
ated philosophy, did not engage converts the way a spiritually oriented
movement can.
Is there an intermediate option between the cultic and the coldly
clinical? A format acceptable to health professionals would have to ap-
proximate the standards for treatment that empirical researchers es-
pouse but would also touch on people's spiritual inclinations. To illus-
trate this we can consider the technique of "mindfulness meditation." It
is reasonably well defined and is applicable in the context of a conven-
tional clinical setting.
Although it draws on both Hindu and Buddhist traditions, it reflects
work in academic medicine as well, such as the work of Arthur Deik-
man, a professor of psychiatry at the University of California in San
Francisco. During the height of the counterculture period, Deikman
drew on an understanding of Eastern thought and a range of mystical
and cultic phenomena to put issues related to meditation into a formal
Meditation 229
These findings suggest that mindfulness meditation might also help
with physically grounded disorders that are influenced by stress, and
some studies illustrate just that. Pain, for example, is materially affected
by a person's psychological state. Kabat-Zinn's group9 has trained pa-
tients suffering from medically grounded chronic pain in mindfulness
meditation to help them acknowledge their pain but detach themselves
from it. By paying careful attention to the pain and distinguishing mo-
mentary sensations as separate events, the patients could stand apart
from their experience of it and be less troubled, much as did those who
were suffering from anxiety and depression. The investigators reported
a high degree of compliance with the meditation practice and a mate-
rial improvement in the patients' distress and pointed out the impor-
tance of uncoupling the sensory component from its cognitive and emo-
tional dimensions. They also emphasized the value of patients' active
participation in the meditative process, thereby promoting a sense of
self-mastery.
Another study dealt with fibromyalgia, a chronic illness character-
ized by widespread moderate pain, fatigue, and sleep disturbance. Al-
though psychological factors are thought to play a role in the distress it
causes, it can lead to limitations comparable to those of rheumatoid
arthritis. The syndrome is being reported with increasing frequency,
with as many as 10 million Americans meeting its formal diagnostic cri-
teria.10 Treatment approaches based on somatic interventions, however,
are generally unsuccessful and have ranged from cardiofitness training
to hypnotherapy as well as various somatic interventions. One group of
investigators11 found a material resolution in these symptoms when pa-
tients applied a mindfulness meditation regimen. Similar success has
been achieved12 in treating patients with psoriasis, another physical syn-
drome known to be affected by psychological factors. When patients
were given a standard regimen of phototherapy and chemotherapy,
those who also received an audiotape-based mindfulness stress reduc-
tion regimen achieved considerably greater clearing of their skin rashes.
This meditation technique may also be able to change physiologic
responses to infection, since stress can affect susceptibility to infection.
One compelling study on the relationship between stress and infection
was completed at the Common Cold Unit Research Center in Great
Britain. Subjects indicated the number of experiences they had en-
Meditation 231
16
232
the concentration camps of Nazi Germany, and he himself endured the
brutality of Auschwitz and Dachau. He emerged somehow strength-
ened by the realization that it is personal meaning, even if derived from
suffering, that can have redemptive value. Frankl pointed out that for
the psychiatrist, emotional distress is a legitimate issue when it derives
from existential needs, even if it does not conform to our models of
"mental disease." He had a talent for refraining the very ideas that under-
lay patients' pain to offer them relief. As he said, "In some way, suffer-
ing ceases to be suffering at the moment it finds meaning, such as the
meaning of sacrifice." His approach, logotherapy, was designed to help
people find meaning in their lives and to release what he regarded as a
natural will to achieve that end, rather than find mere gratification of
emotional drives alone.
He gave the example of a depressed woman who was admitted to the
hospital after a suicide attempt she had made after one of her two sons
died. The boy's death had left her alone with her second son, who was
crippled and confined to a wheelchair. Frankl asked her to contrast her
life with that of a woman who might have lived to eighty in great wealth
and comfort with no child at all. She then spoke of her remaining son
and burst into tears, realizing that at 80 she could say that her life had
been meaningful: "'I have done my bestI have done the best for my
son. My life was no failure!'" She had come to see the justification for
her living despite the suffering she had gone through.
One issue that detracts from psychiatrists' acting on Frankl's therapeu-
tic philosophy is a narrow focus in their lexicon of symptoms, namely,
a focus on those that are held in common by groups of people rather
than meaningful to the individual. All too often psychiatrists are taught
these days to look at diagnostic problems as if scanning x-rays and lab
results, but not to search for a basis for emotional fulfillment. Such an
approach can be quite limited in its value, sometimes even fruitless.
Marilyn became tearful over the thought of losing a relic she held in
common with her deceased mother. It would not have seemed as im-
portant to the frightened shelter staff, or as relevant to the resident, as a
policemen's gun and the raft of medications that we hoped would ad-
dress her depressed state, but indeed that was what was worrying her
most. It was easily lost under the pressure of the presumably larger is-
sues that her hospital-based psychiatrists had come to see as part of an
effective "work-up."
Marilyn returned to the ward, and the staff and I discussed this issue.
We would see how we could work out a way for the crisis in storage pay-
ment to be addressed with some help from the local welfare office. We
could now address what Marilyn regarded as most meaningful to her.
She had been allowed to express it, rather than our assuming that more
medication and time for it to work was the immediate issue at hand,
and we would avert having an angry and resistant patient.
A psychiatrist can sometimes make the mistake of relying on more
medicine to solve a problem, and this can be unproductive, if not com-
promising. Often an intervention in a family situation is essential to
247
acquire knowledge of psychopharmacology from sources such as the
American Psychiatric Association's weighty 1,248-page textbook on that
subject.1 To be certified they interview patients to test their skills in
handling the current lexicon of symptoms, interviews they must struc-
ture along relatively narrow lines, but their own patients will not "get
better" solely by removing items from symptom lists; they also need to
aspire to what they would like for themselves in a positive way.
The quandary of introducing spirituality into clinical practice is not
restricted to psychiatry. University-based departments of psychology, for
example, are increasingly pressured to demonstrate their legitimacy as
science-based by carrying out NIH-sanctioned research, which is usually
physiologically or cognitively oriented. In fact, cognitive-behavioral
therapy, based on paradigms drawn from academic psychology, is be-
ginning to look like that profession's clinical hallmark, but like psycho-
pharmacology, it is a structured approach that addresses specific prob-
lems, one that was initially directed at phobic anxiety, later at depressive
thinking, and more recently at drinking problems, as well. At its heart
the approach circumvents the need for considering what is meaningful
in a person's life.
Mental health professionals, who have such compelling entree into
people's deepest concerns, are being painted into a corner and are in
danger of losing their chance to help their patients in a very important
way. Hence, they will either engage them on issues that lend meaning to
life or be superseded in this domain by people who claim to heal and
offer succor but answer only to idiosyncratic groups or to themselves
alone. Here are some messages relative to this quandary for the people
who deal with it: clinicians, researchers, and patients themselves.
For Clinicians
I t may not be easy to get at what can be meaningful in the lives of your
patients. Many have had their ability to explore their inner worlds
and their initiative to look forward compromised by their emotional
difficulties, if not by a lifetime of problems. Others have even lost track
of the rudiments of "self care"2discerning the realities they confront,
248 Epilogue
exercising good judgment, and avoiding harmful situations. All this is
a problem even before you have had to contend with the pressures of
economics and managed care. An amalgam of these problems can de-
limit what journey, hidden from expression, they may undertake to find
validation, but each patient deserves the opportunity toat least
consider that journey. Consequently, it will take a good deal of creativ-
ity and commitment to frame a meaningful course with your patients
that they can pursue.
However troubled they may be, the people you treat can still be
asked what they consider most important in their lives: family, friends,
some interest that has engaged them. You can ask them if they have had
religious or spiritual experiences, even moments of epiphany, that in-
spired them.3 If they have trouble coming up with answers, they may be
able to think of something that they found interesting or enjoyable, that
broke through the unhappiness they may have experienced. As soon as
they have become engaged in therapy, you can ask them for some goals
they would like to attain in a few years. Then weave all these answers
into the fabric of their treatment and bring up the goals they initially
mentioned over the course of your work with them to help them set a
course for themselves.
The guidelines for clinical care published by the American Psychi-
atric Association have been detailed and revised in compendia4 totaling
more than 2,000 pages. No mention is made in them of the importance
of the hopes and aspirations of patients and of how they should be
helped to lead more meaningful lives. Perhaps a modest addendum to
this detailed body of work is in order.
Epilogue 249
that can define the identity of a given unique person. In any case, it is
not possible to conduct randomized, controlled clinical trialsthe dar-
lings of treatment researchon the issue of spiritual meaning.
A more hopeful note derives from the trajectory of scientific inves-
tigation over the long haul. Thomas Kuhn5 pointed out that "normal
science" embodies the established model of research at a given time.
The practitioners who apply this model garner support for their work
because it generates useful answers to the questions it poses. New par-
adigms of research do not necessarily arise because they prove estab-
lished ones wrong, but often just because the established techniques
employed in the normal science run out of useful questions to be an-
swered. A newly emerging paradigm is then accepted because it can
raise challenging issues and produce answers to a flurry of new ques-
tions. People's pursuit of alternative medicine and of spirituality sug-
gests that with all our medical advances, many important questions are
left unanswered, even unasked. Hence, we now have the option of ap-
plying a new research paradigm, one for understanding spiritually re-
lated issues such as the motivating role of personal values, the intensity
of subjective experience, and revelatory influences in group settings.
Approaches to research in this domain may be developed. They may
constitute a paradigm for posing new and compelling questions to be
answered.
And what questions might be asked within that paradigm? One was
posed at the outset of this treatise: what is the nature of spirituality, and
how does it intersect with psychiatry? We have examined a variety of
approaches to this question, including the integration of psychological
and biological models, and how this phenomenon is expressed in dif-
ferent cultures. What is needed now is an approach that integrates a
large variety of observations like these in a creative manner. No scien-
tific discipline will lay claim to having the one valid perspective on this
issue. Physiology can give us lessons about those aspects of brain func-
tion that support the spiritual experience. Social psychology can be used
to examine the way related movements and the cultures they are em-
bedded in can shape people's experiences, and so on for cultural an-
thropology, psychodynamic and cognitive psychology, and the like. We
will need researchers who understand these disciplines well enough to
integrate their respective findings.
250 Epilogue
For the Patient
A fter reading this book, you can see that there can be a unique and
./^individual path for each person to take toward recovery from his
or her emotional problems. Your own choice may be determined by the
immediate concerns that brought you to treatment: depression, loneli-
ness, anxiety, or trouble harnessing a compulsive habit. You may have
even come largely at the behest of others. It is first important that you
choose a clinician to help you whose practices and competency are rec-
ognized by a well-established professional organization to assure that
you receive the benefits that medicine and psychology have drawn on
from carefully constructed research, but your spiritual needs should be
addressed as well, so that you can achieve a well-supported recovery
and attain goals that are meaningful to you.
Spirituality is an option for pursuing this, but you should know that
it has a fairly narrow window of applicability in your treatment. It is de-
limited by the domain of formal religious practice, on the one hand,
and by the constraints of scientifically validated treatments, on the other.
It is also important that your therapist be sensitive to your spiritual ori-
entation, even though it may be different from hers or his own.
So what remains at the intersection of the spiritual and the scientific
aspects of treatment? Here is one option: you can draw help from a
therapy that is secular in nature, but one that also addresses what is
meaningful in your own unique life. Your recovery can go beyond what
is purely pragmatic, beyond issues of physical and economic comfort,
and even beyond emotional comfort. It can transcend the dictates of
other people and the surrounding society and help you seek out the op-
portunity to pursue the fruits of your own individuality. So while your
acute symptoms are being addressed, even before you feel a full sense of
recovery, consider these questions:
Epilogue 251
After you have considered these questions, ask yourself:
What are some goals you would like to achieve in a few years
once your current problem is addressed?
What could you see, read, or visit to pursue these goals?
If you have a therapist who can understand the quest embodied in
these questions, raise these issues in your treatment, although your thera-
pist may have neither the time nor the inclination to address these ques-
tions. The fact is that many people in the mental health profession are
not prepared to see such issues as relevant to their work, but that does
not have to mean these issues are unimportant to you. Remember, re-
covery from pain, trauma, distress, and even the harshest of symptoms
can carry with it a unique gift: the opportunity to look into the mirror
and ask yourself if there are some aspects of your life that you can start
anew. In answering this question, you can then look beyond that mir-
ror and see what lies on the other side.
252 Epilogue
Notes
PROLOGUE
CHAPTER 1. S P I R I T U A L I T Y E M E R G E S
C H A P T E R 2. A P S Y C H O L O G I C A L P E R S P E C T I V E
253
5. A.H. Maslow 1964.
6. S. Freud in Strachey J. (ed) 1955
7. O. Pfister 1948.
8. C.G. Jung 1936.
9. D.W. Winnicott 1971.
10. A-M. Rizzuto 1979.
11. W. James 1929, p. 32.
12. E. Fromm 1947.
13. G.W. Allport 1961; 1967.
14. A.E. Bergin 1980.
15. CD. Batson 1983.
16. M. Galanter and P. Buckley 1978.
17. M. Galanter 1980.
18. M. Galanter 1980.
19. M. Galanter 1978.
20. M. Galanter 1978,1980,19833.
21. M. Galanter 19831?.
22. H.H. Kelley 1967.
23. W. Proudfoot and P. Shaver 1975.
24. L. Festinger 1957.
25. M.T.Tsuang 1996, p. 79-109.
26. J.C. Scares and J.J. Mann 1997.
27. I. Kirsch 1999, pp. 303-320.
28. B.T. Walsh et al. 2002.
29. S.A. Montgomery, P.E. Reimitz, and M. Zivko 1998.
30. P. Kramer 1993.
31. J.B. Moseley et al. 2002.
32. J.R. Fox 1964.
254 Notes
12. A. Newberg et al. 2001.
13. J.C. Corby et al. 1978.
14. C-K. Peng et al. 1999.
15. C-K. Peng et al. 1999.
16. B.K. Anand, G-S. Chhina, and B. Singh 1961.
17. J.C. Corby et al. 1978.
18. A. Newberg et al. 2001.
19. J. Borg et al. 2003.
20. J. Bowlby 1973; R.A. Spitz 1946.
21. B.M. Seay, E.W. Hansen, and H.R Harlow 1962.
22. S.J. Suomi, H.R Harlow, and W.T. McKinney 1972.
23. S.J. Suomi et al. 1978.
24. K. Kendler 1997.
25. American Psychiatric Association 1994.
26. A.D. Solomon and D.M. Johnson 2002.
27. C.R. Brewin, B.Andrews, and J.D. Valentine 2000.
28. N. Tinbergen 1951.
29. K. Lorenz 1966.
30. R.L. Trivers 1971.
31. E.O. Wilson 1975; 1978.
32. C.D. Batson 1983.
33. D.S. Wilson 2002.
34. A.R. Radcliffe-Brown 1939.
35. S. Freud 1961.
1. W. James 1929.
2. C.P. Snow 1993.
3. M. Galanter, S. Blume, and L. Bissell 1983.
4. M. Galanter and D. Talbott 1990.
5. L.E. DeLisi et al. 2002.
6. H. Begleiter et al. 1984.
7. S. Brown, R.L. Steinberg, and H.M. van Praag 1994.
8. L. Leibovici 2001.
9. D.M. Eisenberg et al. 1993.
10. R.C. Kessler et al. 20013.
11. K.M. Fairneld et al. 1998.
12. R.C. Kessler et al. 20Oib.
13. B.T. Walsh et al. 2002.
14. N.K. Choudhry 2002.
15. M.B. Rosenthal et al. 2002.
Notes 255
16. M. Olfson et al. 2002.
17. J. Wesley 1960.
18. P. Starr 1982.
19. A. Flexner 1910.
20. Thomson Financial Datastream 2002.
21. M.B. Rosenthal et al. 2002.
22. KG. Alexander and and S.T. Selesnick 1966.
23. P. Starr 1982.
24. J.P. Feighner et al. 1972.
25. Washington Post 2002.
26. M. Galanter et al. 2000.
27. M. Galanter 1999.
1. T. Pettersson 2000.
2. G.H. Gallup 2002.
256 Notes
3. V. DeMarinis 2003.
4. G. Andrews and S. Vinkenoog 1967.
5. American Psychiatric Association 1994.
6. T.H. Holmes and R. Rahe 1967.
7. E. Salib 2003.
8. M.J. Horowitz 1986.
9. I. Skre et al. 1993.
C H A P T E R 7. C H R I S T I A N PSYCHIATRY
C H A P T E R 11. A L T E R N A T I V E M E D I C I N E
Notes 257
15. R. Glaser et al. 1985.
16. D. Russell et al. 1980.
17. J.T. Cacioppo 1994.
18. J.M. McGinnis and W.H. Foege 1993.
19. D.M. Eisenberg et al. 2001.
20. A.A. Skolnick 1991.
21. W. Parry-Jones 1981.
22. E. Roosens 1979.
23. Project MATCH Research Group 1997.
24. A. Kleinman 1980.
25. A. Leighton and D. Leighton 1941.
26. J.G. Kennedy 1967.
27. J.A. Adetunji 1992.
28. M. Singer and M.G. Borrero 1984.
29. T.A. Maugans and W.C. Wadland 1991.
30. K.K. Trier and A. Shupe 1991.
31. M. Galanter et al. 1991.
32. B.R. Cassileth et al. 1984; F.S. Bagenal et al. 1990.
33. I.D. Yalom and M.A. Lieberman 1971.
34. I.J. Lerner and B.J. Kennedy 1992.
35. M.B. Eddy 1989.
36. E.M. Pattison et al. 1973.
37. C.K. Hofling et al. 1996.
38. A. Bandura 1986.
39. A.T. Beck 1976.
40. M. Galanter et al. 1993.
41. B.S. Siegel 1990.
258 Notes
12. C.D. Emrick and J.T. Tonigan 2004.
13. Physicians' Desk Reference 2004.
Notes 259
36. Gold Award 1993.
37. H. Franco 1995.
38. H. Dermatis et al. 2004.
39. D. Mierlak et al. 1998.
40. M. Galanter et al. 1998.
41. S. Gilman, M. Galanter and H. Dermatis 2001.
C H A P T E R 15. M E D I T A T I O N
260 Notes
CHAPTER 16. PSYCHOTHERAPY FOR P E R S O N A L M E A N I N G
1. V. Frankl 1984.
2. L. Luborsky et al. 1985.
3. H.A. Murray 1938.
4. B. A. Johnson et al. 2000.
5. A.E. Bergin 1980; 1991.
6. K.S. Kendler et al. 2003
7. R. Sturm 1997.
8. U.S. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration 2000.
9. R.C. Page and J.B. Bailey 1991.
10. M. Margolis 2001.
EPILOGUE
Notes 261
This page intentionally left blank
References
263
Psychiatric Disorders. Compendium 2004. Washington, DC: American Psy-
chiatric Association, 2004.
Anand, B.K., Chhina, G.S., Singh, B. Some aspects of electroencephalographic
studies in yogis. Electroencephalographical Clinical Neurophysiology 13:
452-456,1961.
Andrews, G., Vinkenoog, S., eds. The Book of Grass: An Anthology of Indian
Hemp. New York: Grove Press, 1967.
Asch, S.E. Studies of independence and conformity: a minority of one against
unanimous majority. Psychological Monographs 70 (No. 416), 1956.
Associated Press Report of 2002. Cited in USAToday.com.
Bagenal, F.S., Easton, D.F., Harris, E., Chilvers, C.E.D., McElwain, T.J. Survival
of patients with breast cancer attending Bristol Cancer Help Centre. Lan-
cet: 336:606-610,1990.
Bandura, A. Social Foundations of Thought and Action: A Social Cognitive
Theory. Englewood, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1986.
Batson, C.D. Sociobiology and the role of religion in promoting pro-social be-
havior: an alternative view. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
45:1380-1385,1983.
Beck, A.T. Cognitive Therapy and the Emotional Disorders. New York: Inter-
national Universities Press, 1976.
Begleiter, H., Porjesz, B., Bihari, B., Kissin, B. Event-related brain potentials in
boys at risk for alcoholism. Science 225:1493-1496,1984.
Benson, H. The Relaxation Response. New York: William Morrow, 1975.
Berg, M. The Secret: Unlocking the Source of Joy and Fulfillment. New York:
Kabbalah Centre, 2002.
Bergin, A.E. Psychotherapy and religious values. Journal of Consulting and
Clinical Psychology 48:95-105,1980.
Bergin, A.E. Values and religious issues in psychotherapy and mental health.
American Psychologist 46:394-403,1991.
Berkman, L.F. Social networks, host resistance, and mortality: a nine-year
follow-up study of Alameda County residents. American Journal of Epi-
demiology 109:186-204,1979.
Biebel, D. Why Do I Hurt So Bad? Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Book House, 1998,
pp. 33,115,131-132.
Bion, W.R. Experiences in Groups. New York: Basic Books, 1959, p. 39.
Blanke, O., Ortigue, S., Landis, T, Seeck, M. Stimulating illusory own-body
perceptions. Nature:4i8:269-270, 2002.
Borg, J., Bengt, A., Soderstrom, H., Farde, L. The serotonin system and spiritual
experiences. American Journal of Psychiatry 160:1965-1969,2003.
Bowlby, J. Separation: Anxiety and Anger. New York: Basic Books, 1973.
Brewin, C.R., Andrews, B., Valentine, J.D.. Meta-analysis of risk factors for
posttraumatic stress disorder in trauma-exposed adults. Journal of Con-
sulting & Clinical Psychology 68:748-766,2000.
264 References
Brown, G.W. Birley, J.L., Wing, J.K. Influence of family life on the course of
schizophrenic disorders: a replication. British Journal of Psychiatry 121:241-
258,1972.
Brown, S., Steinberg, R.L., van Praag, H.M. The pathogenesis of depression. In
den Boer, J.A.,
Sitsent, J.M.A. Handbook of Depression and Anxiety. New York: Marcel
Dekker, 1994, pp. 31/-347-
Cacioppo, J.T. Social neuroscience: autonomic, neuroendocrine, and immune
responses to stress. Psychophysiology 31:113-128,1994.
Cannon, W.B. Bodily Changes in Fear, Hunger and Rage, Second edition. New
York: Appleton & Co., 1929.
Carlson, D. Why Do Christians Shoot Their Wounded? Downers Grove, IL:
InterVarsity Press, 1984.
Cassilem, B.R., Lusk, E.J., Strouse, T.B. and Bodenheimer, B.A. Contemporary
unorthodox treatments in cancer medicine: a study of patients, treatments,
and practitioners. Annals of Internal Medicine 101:105-112,1984.
Castaneda, R., Galanter, M., Franco, H. Self-medication among addicts with
primary psychiatric disorders. Comprehensive Psychiatry 30:80-83,1989.
Chappel, J.N. Long-term recovery from alcoholism. Psychiatric Clinics of North
America 16:177-187,1993.
Chaudhury, N.C. Hinduism: A Religion to Live By. New Delhi: Oxford Univer-
sity Press, 1979.
Chopra, D. Perfect Health: The Complete Mind/Body Guide. New York: Har-
mony Books, 1989.
Choudhry, N.K., Stelfox, H.T., Detsky, A.S. Relationships between authors of
clinical practice guidelines and the pharmaceutical industry. Journal of
the American Medical Association 287:612-617,2002.
Cohen, S., Tyrell, D.A.J., Smith, A.P. Psychological stress and susceptibility to
the common cold. New England Journal of Medicine 325:606-612,1991.
Corby, J.C., Roth, W.T., Zarcone, V.P., Kopell, B.S. Psychological correlates of
the practice of Tantric yoga meditation. Archives of General Psychiatry
35:5/1-577,1978.
Davidson, R.J., Kabat-Zinn, J., Schumacher, J., Rosenkranz, M., Muller, D., San-
torelli, S.F., Urbanowski, R, Harrington, A., Bonus, K., Sheridan, J.F. Al-
terations in brain and immune function produced by mindfulness medi-
tation. Psychosomatic Medicine 65:564- 570,2003.
De Leon, G. (ed.). Community as Method. Westport, CT: Praeger, 1997.
Deikman, A.J. T awareness. Journal of Consciousness Studies 3:350-356,1996.
DeLisi, L.E, Shaw, S.H., Crow, T.J., Shields, G., Smith, A.B., Larach, V.W., Well-
man, N., Loftus, J., Nanthakumar, B., Razi, K., Stewart, J, Comazzi, M., Vita,
A., Heffner, T, Sherrington, R. A genome-wide scan for linkage to chro-
mosomal regions in 382 sibling pairs with schizophrenia or schizoaffective
disorder. American Journal of Psychiatry 159:803-812,2002.
References 265
DeMarinis, V. Pastoral Care, Existential Health, and Existential Epidemiology:
A Swedish Postmodern Case Study. Stockholm: Verbum, 2003.
Dermatis, H., Galanter, M., Rahman-Dujarric, C., Brady, N., Ramaglia, K., La-
Gressa, D., Trujillo, M. Retention in aftercare among dually diagnosed pa-
tients following integrated and standard inpatient treatment. Congress on
Problems of Drug Dependence (Abstract), 2004.
Dvorak, J., Gauchat, M., Valach, L. The outcome of surgery for lumbar disc her-
niation: I. A 4-17 years' follow-up with emphasis on somatic aspects. Spine
13:1418-1422,1988.
Eddy, M.B. Science and Health. Pasadena, CA: Pasadena Press, 1989.
Edwards, G., Kissin, G. Alcoholism: a controlled trial of "treatment" and ad-
vice. Journal of Studies on Alcohol 38:1004-1031,1977.
Eisenberg, D.M., Kessler, R.C., Foster, C., Norlock, F.E., Calkins, D.R., Delbanco,
T.L. Unconventional medicine in the United States: prevalence, costs, and
patterns of use. New England Journal of Medicine 328:246-252,1993.
Eisenberg, D.M., Davis, R.B., Ettner, S.L., Appel, S., Wilkey S., Van Rompay, M.,
Kessler, R.C. Trends in alternative medicine use in the United States, 1990-
1997: results of a follow- up national survey. Journal of the American Medi-
cal Association 280:1569-1575,1998.
Eisenberg, D.M., Kessler, R.C., Van Rompay, M.I., Kaptchuk, T.J., Wilkey, S.A.,
Appel, S., Davis, R.B. Perceptions about complementary therapies relative
to conventional therapies among adults who use both: results from a na-
tional survey. Annals of Internal Medicine 135:344-351,2001.
Emrick, C.D., Tonigan, J.T. Alcoholics Anonymous and other Twelve Step groups.
In Galanter, M., Kleber, H.D. Textbook of Substance Abuse Treatment.
Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Publishing, 2004.
Epstein, M. Thoughts Without A Thinker. New York: Basic Books, 1995.
Erikson, K.T. Notes on the sociology of deviance. In Thomas J. Scheff (ed.)
Mental Illness and Social Process. New York: Harper & Row, 1967, p. 300.
Fan-field, K.M., Eisenberg, D.M., Davis, R.B., Libman, H., Phillips, R.S. Patterns
of use, expenditures, and perceived efficacy of complementary and alter-
native therapies in HIV-infected patients. Archives of Internal Medicine
158:2257-2264,1998.
Feighner, J.P., Robins, E., Guze, S.B., Woodruff, R.A., Winokur, G., Munoz, R..
Diagnostic criteria for use in psychiatric research. Archives of General
Psychiatry 26:57-63,1972.
Festinger, L. A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance. Stanford, CA: Stanford Uni-
versity Press, 1957.
Fintel, W.A., McDermott, G.R. A Medical and Spiritual Guide to Living with
Cancer. Dallas, TX: Word, 1993.
Flexner, A. Medical Education in the United States and Canada, Bulletin no. 4.
New York: Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching, 1910.
266 References
Fox, A.J., Lin, J.P., Pinto, R.S., Kricheff, I.I. Myelographic cervical nerve root de-
formities. Radiology 116:355-361,1975.
Fox, J.R. Witchcraft and clanship in Cochiti therapy. In Kiev, A. Magic, Faith
and Healing. New York: Free Press, 1964, p. 174-200.
Franco, H., Galanter, M., Castaneda, R., Patterson, }. Combining behavioral
and self-help approaches in the management of dually diagnosed patients.
Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment 12:227-232,1995.
Frank, J., Frank, J.B. Persuasion and Healing: A Comparative Study of Psycho-
therapy. Third edition. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press,
1961, p. 33.
Frank, J.D. Therapeutic factors in psychotherapy. American Journal of Psycho-
therapy 25:350-361,1971.
Frankl, V. Man's Search for Meaning. Third edition. New York: Touchstone,
Simon & Schuster, 1984.
Franklin, G.M., Haug, J., Heyer, N.J., McKeefrey, S.P., Picciano, J.F. Outcome of
lumbar fusion in Washington State Workers' Compensation. Spine 20:
1213-1215,1995.
Freud, S. Group psychology and the analysis of the ego. In Strachey, J. (ed) The
Complete Psychological Works, Standard Ed., Vol. 18. London: Hogarth
Press, 1955.
Freud, S. Civilization and Its Discontents. In Strachey J (ed) The Standard Edi-
tion of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Vol. 21. Lon-
don: Hogarth Press, 1961.
Fromm, E. Man for Himself: An Inquiry Into the Psychology of Ethics. New
York: Reinhart, 1947.
Gabbard, G.O. The evolving role of the psychiatrist from the perspective of
psychotherapy. In Menninger, R.W. and Nemiah, J.C. (eds) Washington,
DC: American Psychiatric Press, 2000. pp. 103-123
Galanter, M. The "intoxication state of consciousness": a model for alcohol and
drug abuse. American Journal of Psychiatry 133:635-640,1976.
Galanter, M: The "relief effect": a sociobiologic model for neurotic distress and
large-group therapy. American Journal of Psychiatry 135:588-591,1978.
Galanter, M. Psychological induction into the large group: findings from a con-
temporary religious sect. American Journal of Psychiatry 137:1574-1579,
1980.
Galanter, M. Engaged members of the Unification Church. Archives of General
Psychiatry 40:1197-1202,1983(3).
Galanter, M. Unification Church ("Moonie") dropouts: psychological readjust-
ment after leaving a charismatic religious group. American Journal of Psy-
chiatry 140:984-988,1983b.
Galanter, M. Moonies get married: psychiatric follow-up study of a charismatic
religious sect. American Journal of Psychiatry 143:1245-1249,1986.
References 267
Galanter, M. (chair). Task Force on Combined Psychiatric and Addictive Dis-
orders. Albany, New York: Office of Mental Health, 19893.
Galanter, M. (ed) Cults and New Religious Movements. A Report of the Ameri-
can Psychiatric Association. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Asso-
ciation, I989b.
Galanter, M. Cults and zealous self-help movements: a psychiatric perspective.
American Journal of Psychiatry: 147:543-551,1990.
Galanter, M. Network Therapy for Alcohol and Drug Abuse. Expanded edition.
New York: Guilford Press, 19993.
Galanter, M. The impact of managed care on substance abuse treatment: scope
of the problem. Journal of Addictive Diseases, 18:117-119, i999b.
Galanter, M. Self-help treatment for combined addiction and mental illness.
Psychiatric Services 51:977-979,2000.
Galanter, M., Blume, S., Bissell, L. Physicians in alcoholism: a study of current
status and future needs. Alcohol: Clinical and Experimental Research, 7:
389-392,1983.
Galanter, M., Buckley, P. Evangelical religion and meditation: psychotherapeutic
effects. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 166:685-691,1978.
Galanter, M., Buckley, P. Large group influence for decreased drug use: findings
from two contemporary religious sects. American Journal of Drug and
Alcohol Abuse 7:291-304,1980.
Galanter, M., Dermatis, H., Egelko, S., De Leon, G. Homelessness and mental
illness in a professional and peer-led cocaine treatment clinic. Psychiatric
Services 49:533~535> 1998.
Galanter, M., Egelko, and Edwards, H. Rational Recovery: alternative to AA
for addiction? American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 19:499-510,
1993-
Galanter, M., Egelko, S., De Leon, G., Rohrs, C., Franco, H. "Crack'Vcocaine in
the general hospital. American Journal of Psychiatry 149:810815,1992.
Galanter, M., Egelko, S., Edwards, H., Vergaray, M. A treatment system for com-
bined psychiatric and addictive illness. Addiction 89:1227-1235,1994.
Galanter, M., Keller, D.S., Dermatis, H., Egelko, S. The impact of managed care
on substance abuse treatment: a report of the American Society of Addic-
tion Medicine. Journal of Addictive Diseases 19:13-34,2000.
Galanter, M., Larson, D., and Rubenstone, E. Christian psychiatry: the impact
of evangelical belief on clinical practice. American Journal of Psychiatry:
148:90-95,1991.
Galanter, M., Rabkin, R., Rabkin, J., Deutsch, A. The "Moonies": a psychologi-
cal study. American Journal of Psychiatry 136:165-170,1979.
Galanter, M., Stillman, R., Wyatt, R.J., Vaughan, T.B., Weingartner, H., Nurn-
berg, F. Marihuana and social behavior: a controlled study. Archives of
General Psychiatry 30:518-521,1974.
Galanter, M., Talbott, D., Gallegos, K., Rubenstone, E. Combined Alcoholics
268 References
Anonymous and professional care for addicted physicians. American Jour-
nal of Psychiatry 147:46-48,1990.
Galanter, M., Weingartner, H., Vaughan, T.B., Roth, W.T., Wyatt, R.J. Delta-9-
trans-tetrahydrocannabinol and natural marihuana: a controlled com-
parison. Archives of General Psychiatry 28:278-281,1973.
Galanter, M., Wyatt, R.J., Lemberger, L, Weingartner, H., Vaughan, T.B., Roth,
W.T: Effects in humans of Delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol administered by
smoking. Science 176:934-936,1972.
Gallup, G.H. Religion in America 2002. Princeton, NJ: Princeton Religious Re-
search Center, 2002.
Gazzaniga, M.S. The Bisected Brain. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1970.
Gilman, S., Galanter, M., Dermatis, H. Methadone Anonymous: a Twelve-Step
program for methadone maintained heroin addicts. Substance Abuse 22:
247-256,2001.
Glaser, R., Kiecolt-Glaser, J.K., Stout, J.C., Tarr, K.L., Speicher, C.E., and Holli-
day, J.E. Stress-related impairments in cellular immunity. Psychiatry Re-
search 16:233-239,1985.
Goffman, E. Asylums: Essays on the Social Situation of Mental Patients and
Other Inmates. New York: Anchor Books, 1961.
Goffman, E. Stigma. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1963.
Gold Award: Comprehensive clinical services for substance abuse treatment in
an inner-city general hospital. Hospital and Community Psychiatry 44:
991-994,1993.
Goldenberg, D.L. Fibromyalgia syndrome. Journal of the American Medical
Association 257:2782-2787,1987.
Goldfarb, L., McDowell, D., Galanter, M., Lifshutz, H., Dermatis, H. Medical
student and patient attitudes toward religion and spirituality in the recov-
ery process. American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 22:549-561,1996.
Goodwin, D.W. Alcoholism and genetics: the sins of the fathers. Archives of
General Psychiatry 42:171-174,1985.
Gordon, J.S. Holistic medicine and mental health practice: toward a new syn-
thesis. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry 60:359-370,1990.
Guze, S.B., Robbins, E. Suicide and primary affective disorders. British Journal
of Psychiatry 117:437-438,1970.
Hales, R.T., Yudofsky, S.C. (eds.) Essentials of Clinical Psychiatry. Washington,
DC: American Psychiatric Press, 1999.
Haugland, G., Siegel, C., Alexander, M.J., Galanter, M. A survey of hospitals in
New York State treating psychiatric patients with chemical abuse disor-
ders. Hospital and Community Psychiatry 42:1215-1220,1991.
Hausman, K. Need to prove psychotherapy competence fuels heated debate.
Psychiatric News, June 4,2004. p. 2 ff.
Hebb, D.O. Emotion in man and animal: an analysis of the intuitive processes
of recognition. Psychological Review 53:88-106,1949.
References 269
Hobson, J.A., Pace-Schott, E.F., Stickgold, R. Dreaming and the brain: toward
a cognitive neuroscience of conscious states. Behavioral and Brain Sci-
ences 23:793-1121,2000.
Hofling, C.K., Brotzman, S.C., Graves, N., and Pierce, C.M. An experimental
study in nurse-physician relationships. Journal of Nervous and Mental
Disease 143:171-180,1996.
Holmes, T.H., Rahe, R. The social adjustment rating scale. Journal of Psycho-
somatic Research 11:213-218,1967.
Horowitz, M. J. Stress Response Syndromes. New York: Jason Aronson, 1986.
Humphreys, K., Moos, R.H., Cohen, C. Social and community resources and
long-term recovery from treated and untreated alcoholism. Journal of
Studies on Alcohol 58:231-238,1997.
James, W. The Varieties of Religious Experience. New York: Modern Library, 1929.
Jamison, K.R. An Unquiet Mind. New York: Random House, 1996.
Jarvik, J.G., Hollingworth, W., Martin, B., Emerson, S.S., Gray, D.T., Overman,
S., Robinson, D., Staiger, T, Wessbecher, R, Sullivan, S.D., Kreuter, W.,
Deyo, R.A. Rapid magnetic resonance imaging vs. radiographs for pa-
tients with low back pain. Journal of the American Medical Association
289: 2810-2818,2003.
Johnson, B.A., Roache, J.D., Javors, M.A., DiClemente, C.C., Cloninger, C.R.,
Prihoda, T.J., Bordnick, P.S., Ait-Daoud, N., Hensler, J. Ondansetron for
reduction of drinking among biologically predisposed alcoholic patients:
a randomized controlled trial. Journal of the American Medical Associa-
tion 284:963-971,2000.
Jones, M. The Therapeutic Community: A New Treatment Method In Psychia-
try. New York: Basic Books, 1953.
Jung, C.G. The Concept of the Collective Unconscious. In The Collected Works
of C.J. Jung. Reade, H., Fordham, M., and Adler, G. eds. Princeton, NJ:
Princeton University, 1936.
Kabat-Zinn, J., Lipworth, L, Burney, R. The clinical use of mindfulness medi-
tation for the self-regulation of chronic pain. Journal of Behavioral Medi-
cine. 8:163-90,1985.
Kabat-Zinn, J., Massion, A.O., Kristeller, J.; Peterson, L.G., Fletcher, K.E., Pbert,
L., Lenderking, W.R., Santorelli, S.F. Effectiveness of a meditation-based
stress reduction program in the treatment of anxiety disorders. American
Journal of Psychiatry 149:936-1943,1992
Kabat-Zinn, J., Wheeler, E., Light, T., Skillings, A., Scharf, M.J., Cropley, T.G.
Hosmer, D., Bernhard, J.D. Influence of a mindfulness meditation-based
stress reduction intervention on rates of skin clearing in patients with
moderate to severe psoriasis undergoing phototherapy (UVB) and photo-
chemotherapy (PUVA). Psychosomatic Medicine 60:625-632,1998.
Kaplan, K.H., Goldenberg, D.L., Galvin-Nadeau, M. The impact of a meditation-
270 References
based stress reduction program on fibromyalgia. General Hospital Psy-
chiatry 15:284-289,1993.
Kelley, H.H. Attribution theory in social psychology. In Levine, D. (ed), Ne-
braska Symposium on Motivation, vol. 15, pp.192-238. Lincoln: Univer-
sity of Nebraska Press, 1967.
Kendler, K.S. Social support: a genetic-epidemiologic analysis. American Jour-
nal of Psychiatry. 154:1398-1404,1997.
Kendler, K.S., Hettema, J. M., Butera, R, Gardner, C. O., Prescott, C. A. Life
event dimensions of loss, humiliation, entrapment, and danger in the
prediction of onsets of major depression and generalized anxiety.
Archives of General Psychiatry 60:789-796,2003.
Kennedy, J.G. Nubian Zar ceremonies and psychotherapy. Human Organiza-
tion 4:185-192,1967.
Kessler, R.C., Davis, R.B., Foster, D.F., Van Rompay, M.I., Walters, E.E., Wilkey,
S.A., Kaptchuk, T.J., Eisenberg, D.M. Long-term trends in the use of com-
plementary and alternative medical therapies in the United States. Annals
of Internal Medicine 135:262-268,2ooia.
Kessler, R.C., Soukup, J., Davis, R.B., Foster, D.F., Wilkey, S.A., Van Rompay,
M.I., Eisenberg, D.M. The use of complementary and alternative thera-
pies to treat anxiety and depression in the United States. American Jour-
nal of Psychiatry 158:289-294,2OOib.
Khantzian, E.J., Halliday, K.S., McAuliffe, WE. Addiction and the Vulnerable
Self. New York: Guilford Press, 1990.
Kleinman, A. Patients and Healers in the Context of Culture. Berkeley: Univer-
sity of California Press, 1980.
Kim, A., Galanter, M., Castaneda, R., Lifshutz, H., Franco, H. Crack use and
sexual behavior among psychiatric inpatients. American Journal of Drug
and Alcohol Abuse 18:235-246,1992.
Kirsch, I., Sapirstein, G. Listening to prozac but hearing placebo: a meta-analysis
of anti-depressant medication. In Kirsch, I. (ed.) How Expectancy Shapes
Behavior. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association, 1999,
pp. 303-320.
Kramer, P. Listening to Prozac. New York: Viking, 1993.
Krippner, S.C. Conflicting perspectives on shamans and shamanism: points
and counterpoints. American Psychologist 57:962-977, 2002.
Kuhn, T. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago, IL: University of
Chicago Press, 1962.
Laing, R.D. The Politics of Experience. New York: Pantheon Books, 1967.
Lasch, C. The Culture of Narcissism: American Life in the Age of Expectations.
New York: Norton, 1979.
LeDoux, J. The Emotional Brain. New York: Touchstone, 1996.
Leibovici, L. Effects of remote, retroactive intercessory prayer on outcomes in
References 271
patients with bloodstream infection: randomized controlled trial. British
Medical Journal 323:14501451, 2001.
Leighton, A., and Leighton, D. Elements of psychotherapy in Navajo religion.
Psychiatry 4:515-523,1941.
Lerner, I.J., and Kennedy, B.J. The prevalence of questionable methods of cancer
treatment in the United States. CA-Cancer Journal Clinical 42:181-191,1992.
Leuchter, A.F., Cook, I.A., Witte, E.A., Morgan, M., Abrams, M. Changes in
brain function of depressed subjects during treatment with placebo.
American Journal of Psychiatry 159:122-129,2002.
Lorenz, K. On Aggression. New York: Harcourt Brace, 1966.
Luborsky, L, McLellan, A.T., Woody, G.E., O'Brien, C.P., Auerbach, A. Thera-
pist success and its determinants. Archives of General Psychiatry 42:602-
611,1985.
Ma, S.H., Teasdale, J.D. Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy for depression:
replication and exploration of differential relapse prevention effects.
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 72:31-40,2004.
MacLean, P.D. The Triune Brain In Evolution: Role In Paleocerebral Functions.
New York: Plenum, 1990.
Madden, M.A. Out of Bedlam. New York: Basic Books, 1990.
Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. The Science of Being and the Art of Living. Los Ange-
les: SRM Publications, 1966.
Margolis, M. The American Psychoanalytic Association: a decade of change.
Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 49:11-25,2001.
Maslow, A.H. Religious Values and Peak Experiences. Columbus, OH: Ohio
State University Press, 1964.
Maugans, T.A., Wadland, W.C. Religion and family medicine: a survey of physi-
cians and patients. Journal of Family Practice 32:210-213,1991.
McDowell, D., Galanter, M., Goldfarb, L., Lifshutz, H. Spirituality and the
treatment of the dually diagnosed: an investigation of patient and staff at-
titudes. Journal of Addictive Disease 15:55-68,1996.
McGinnis, J.M., Foege, W.H. Actual causes of death in the United States. Jour-
nal of the American Medical Association 270:2207-2212,1993.
McRae, D.L. Asymptomatic intervertebral disc protrusions. Acta Radiol 46:9-
27,1956.
Mierlak, D., Spivak, N., Dermatis, H., Jurewicz, E., De Leon, G. Modified thera-
peutic community treatment for homeless dually diagnosed men: who com-
pletes treatment? Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment 15:117-121,1998.
Milgram, S. Obedience To Authority. New York: Harper, 1974.
Miller, J.J., Fletcher, K., Kabat-Zinn, J. Three-year follow-up and clinical implica-
tions of a mindfulness meditation-based stress reduction intervention in the
treatment of anxiety disorders. General Hospital Psychiatry 17:192-200,1995.
Miller, R.M. (ed). Integrating Spirituality into Treatment. Washington, DC:
American Psychological Association, 1999.
272 References
Montgomery, S.A., Reimitz, P.E., Zivko, M. Mitrazapine vs. amitriptyline and
the long-term treatment of depression: a double-blind placebo-controlled
study. International Clinics of Psychopharmacology 13:63-73,1998.
Moseley, J. B., O'Malley, K., Peterson, N.J., Menke, T.J., Brody, B.A., Kuykendall,
D.H., Hollingsworth, J.C., Ashton, C.M., Wray, N.P. A controlled trial of
arthroscopic surgery for osteoarthritis of the knee. New England Journal
of Medicine 347:81-88,2002.
Mosher, L.R., Menn, A.Z. Community residential treatment for schizophrenia:
two-year follow-up, Hospital & Community Psychiatry 29:715-723,1978.
Murphy, G.E., Wetzel, R.D. The lifetime risk of suicide in alcoholism. Archives
of General Psychiatry 47:383-392,1990.
Murray, H.A. Explorations In Personality. New York: Oxford University Press, 1938.
National Center for Health Statistics. 1997 National Hospital Discharge Survey.
Series 13, no. 144. Washington, DC: U.S. Dept. of Health and Human Ser-
vices, Center for Disease Control, 1997.
New York Open Center, Winter/Spring 2003.
New York Times, Falun Gong articles: July 22,1999; July 27,1999; April 21,2000;
April 26,2001; July 5,2001; March 5,2002; December 22,2002.
New York Times, February 9,2004, page i (re: figures for back pain in the U.S.)
New York Times 2002 Almanac. New York: Penguin Books, 2002.
New York Times. Judge bars statements made in AA. August 2,2001, page Bi.
Newberg, A., Alavi, A., Baime, M., Pourdehnad, M., Santanna, J., d'Aquili, E.
The measurement of cerebral blood flow during the complex cognitive
task of meditation: a preliminary SPECT study. Psychiatry Research Neuro-
imaging 106:113-122,2001.
Olfson, M., Marcus, S.C., Druss, B., Pincus, H.A. National trends in the use of
outpatient psychiatry. American Journal of Psychiatry 159:1914-1920,2002.
Opler, M.E. Some points of comparison and contrast between the treatment of
functional disorders by Apache shamans and modern psychiatric prac-
tice. American Journal of Psychiatry 92:1371-1387,1936.
Page, R.C., Bailey, J.B. Addictions Counseling certification: an emerging coun-
seling specialty. Journal of Counseling and Development 74:167,1991.
Pakaslahti, A. Family-centered treatment of mental health problems at the Balaji
Temple in Rajasthan. In Parpola, A. and Tenhunen, S. (eds.) Changing
Patterns of Family and Kinship in South Asia. Helsinki: Finnish Oriental
Society, 1998. pp 130-166.
Parry-Jones, W. The model of the Geel Lunatic Colony and its influence on the
nineteenth century asylum system in Britain. In Scull, A. (ed.) Madhouses,
Mad-Doctors, and Madmen. The Social History of Psychiatry in the Vic-
torian Era. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1981.
Patel, C., Marmot, M.G., Terry, D.J., Carruthers, M., Hunt, B. Patel, M. Trial of
relaxation in reducing coronary risk: four year follow up. British Medical
Journal Clinical Research Ed. 290:1103-1106,1985.
References 273
Pattison, E.M., Lapins, N., Doerr, H.A. Faith healing: a study of personality and
function. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 157:397-409,1973.
Peck, M. S. The Road Less Traveled. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1985.
Peng, C.-K., Mietus, J.E., Liu, Y., Khalsa, G., Douglas, P.S., Benson, H., Gold-
berger, A.L. Exaggerated heart rate oscillations during two meditation
techniques. International Journal of Cardiology 70:101107,1999.
Pennebaker, J.W., Kiecolt-Glaser, J.K., Glaser, R. Disclosure of traumas and
immune function: health implications for psychotherapy. Journal of Con-
sulting Clinical Psycholology 56:239-245,1988.
Peterson, M. Making drugs, shaping the rules. New York Times, section 3, page
iff. February i, 2004.
Pettersson, T. Svensken och Religion. In Lewin, L. (ed.) Svenskt kynne. Uppsala:
Acta Universitatis Upsaliensis, 2000.
Pfister, O. Christianity and Fear: A Study in History and the Psychology and
Hygiene of Religion. Translated by W.H. Johnston, London: George, Allen
& Unwin, 1948.
Physicians' Desk Reference, Montvale, NJ: Thomson PDR, 2004.
Project MATCH Research Group. Project MATCH secondary a priori hy-
potheses. Addiction 92:1671-1698,1997.
Proudfoot, W., Shaver, P. Attribution theory and the psychology of religion.
Journal of the Scientific Study of Religion 14:317-330,1975.
Quart, A. Branded: The Buying and Selling of Teenagers. Cambridge, MA:
Perseus Publishing, 2003.
Radcliffe-Brown, A.R. Taboo. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1939.
Rizzuto, A-M. The Birth of the Living God: A Psychoanalytic Study. Chicago:
University of Chicago Press, 1979.
Robinson, A. Spirituality and risk: toward an understanding. Holistic Nurse
Practitioner 8:1-7,1994-
Rochester, D. From Poorhouses to Homeless. Second edition. Westport, CT:
Greenwood Publishing Group, 1997.
Rokeach, M. The Three Christs of Ypsilanti. New York: Random House, 1964.
Roosens, E. Mental Patients in Town Life: GeelEurope's First Therapeutic
Community. Beverly Hills: Sage Publications, 1979.
Rosenhan, D.L. On being sane in insane places. Science 179:250-258,1973.
Rosenthal, M.B., Berndt, E.R., Donohue, J.M., Frank, R.G., Epstein, A.M. Pro-
motion of prescription drugs to consumers. New England Journal of Medi-
cine 346:498,2002.
Ross, S., Dermatis, H., Levounis, P., Galanter, M. A comparison between dually
diagnosed inpatients with and without axis II comorbidity and the rela-
tionship to treatment outcome. American Journal of Drug & Alcohol
Abuse 29:263-279,2003
Russell, D., Peplau, L.A., Cutrona, C.E. The revised UCLA Loneliness Scale:
274 References
concurrent and discriminant validity evidence. Journal of Personality and
Social Psychology 39:472-480,1980.
Sackeim, H.A. Functional brain circuits in major depression and remission.
Archives of General Psychiatry 58:649-650,2001.
Saferparks Database, www.saferparks.org, 2003.
Salib, E. Effect of 11 September 2001 on suicide and homicide in England and
Wales. British Journal of Psychiatry 183:207-212,2003.
Sarno, J. Mind Over Back Pain. New York: William Morrow, 1982.
Schachter, S., Singer, J.E. Cognitive, social and physiological determinants of
emotional state. Psychological Review 69:379-399,1962.
Schatzberg, A.F., Nemeroff, C.B. (eds) The American Psychiatric Publishing
Textbook of Psychopharmacology. Third edition. Washington, DC: Ameri-
can Psychiatric Publishing, 2002.
Schrader, H. Obelieniene, D., Bovim, G., Surkiene, D., Mickeviciene, D., Sand,
T. Natural evolution of late whiplash syndrome outside the medicolegal
context. Lancet 347:1207-1211,1996.
Searles, H.E Collected Papers on Schizophrenia and Related Subjects. New York,
International Universities Press, 1965.
Seay, B.M., Hansen, E.W., Harlow, H.E Mother-infant separation in monkeys.
Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 3:123-132,1962.
Sharma, I. Treatment of neurotic illness by yogic techniques. Indian Journal of
Medical Sciences 3:76-79,1989.
Siegel, B.S. Exceptional patients live long and live well. Maryland Medical
Journal 39:181-182,1990.
Sifton, E. The Serenity Prayer: Faith in Politics in Time of Peace and War. New
York: W.W. Norton, 2003.
Silberstein, C., Galanter, M., Marmor, M., Lifshutz, H., Krasinski, K., Franco, H.
HIV-i among inner-city dually diagnosed inpatients. American Journal of
Drug and Alcohol Abuse 20:101-113,1994
Singer, M., Borrero, M.G. Indigenous treatment for alcoholism: the case of
Puerto Rican spiritualism. Medical Anthropology: Cross-Cultural Studies
in Health and Illness 8:246-273,1984.
Siegel, B.S. Love, Medicine & Miracles: Lessons Learned About Self-Healing
from a Surgeon's Experience with Exceptional Patients. New York: Harper
& Row, 1936.
Skolnick, A.A. Maharishi Ayur-Veda: guru's marketing scheme promises the
world eternal "perfect health." Journal of the American Medical Associa-
tion 226:1741-1750,1991.
Skre, I., Onstad, S., Torgersen, S., Lygren, S., Kringlen, E. A twin study of
DSM-III-R anxiety disorders. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 88:85-92,
1993-
Snow, C.P. The Two Cultures. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993.
References 275
Scares, J.C., Mann, J.J. The anatomy of mood disordersreview of structural
neuro-imaging studies. Biological Psychiatry 41:86-106,1997.
Solomon, S.D., Johnson, D.M. Psychosocial treatment of posttraumatic stress
disorder: a practice-friendly review of outcome research. Journal of Clini-
cal Psychology 58:947-959,2002.
Sperry, R.W. A modified concept of consciousness. Psychological Review 76:
532-536,1969.
Spitz, R.A. Anaclitic depression. Psychoanalytic Study of the Child 2:313-347,
1946.
Starr, P. The Social Transformation of American Medicine. New York: Basic
Books, 1982.
Sturm, R. How expensive is unlimited health care coverage under managed
care? Journal of the American Medical Association 278:1533-1534,1997.
Suomi, S.J., Harlow, H.F., McKinney, W.T. Monkey psychiatrists. American
Journal of Psychiatry 128:927-932,1972.
Suomi, S.J., Seaman, S.F., Lewis, J.K., DeLizio, R.D., McKinney, W.T. Effects of
imipramine treatment of separation-induced social disorders in rhesus
monkeys. Archives of General Psychiatry 35:321-325,1978.
Thomas, B., ed. India. Hawthorn, Australia: Lonely Planet Publications, 1997.
Thomson Financial Datastream. Bitter pill: top five pharmaceutical firms ranked
by market value. 2002.
Time Magazine, Inside Business: Bonus Section, August 2003.
Time Asia. July 11,2003.
Tinbergen, N. The Study of Instinct. London: Oxford University Press, 1951.
Tota-Faucette, M.E., Gil, K.M., Williams, D.A., Keefe, F.J., Goli, V. Predictors of
response to pain management treatment: the role of family environment
and changes in cognitive processes. Clinical Journal of Pain 9:115-123,1993.
Trier, K.K., Shupe, A. Prayer, religiosity, and healing in the heartland, USA: a re-
search note. Review of Religious Research 32:351-358,1991.
Trivers, R.L. The evaluation of reciprocal altruism. Quarterly Review of Biol-
ogy 46:35-37,1971-
Tsuang, M.T. Suicide in schizophrenics, manics, and surgical controls. Archives
of General Psychiatry 35:153-155,1978.
Tsuang, M.T., Faraone, S.V. The inheritance of mood disorders. In Hall, L.L.
(ed.) Genetics and Mental Illness: Evolving Issues for Research And Soci-
ety. New York: Plenum, 1996, pp. 79-109.
Turkington, D., Kindon, D.G., Turner, T. Effectiveness of a brief cognitive-
behavioral therapy intervention in the treatment of schizophrenia. British
Journal of Psychiatry 180:523-527,2002.
U.S. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, 2000, cited
at www.socialworkers.org.
Volinn, E. The epidemiology of low back pain in the rest of the world: a review
of surveys in low- and middle-income countries. Spine 22:1747-1754,1997.
276 References
Waldfogel, S., Root Wolpe, P. Using awareness of religious factors to enhance
interventions in consultation-liaison psychiatry. Hospital & Community
Psychiatry 44:473-477,1993.
Walsh, B.T., Seidman, S.N., Sysko, R., Gould, M. Placebo response in studies of
major depression. Journal of the American Medical Association 287:1840-
1847,2002.
washingtonpost.com. Industry Role in Medical Meeting Decried. Washington
Post, May 26, 2002, p. Aio.
Weightman, J.M. Making Sense of the Jonestown Suicides. New York: Edwin
Mellon Press, 1983.
Wesley, J. Primitive Physic: Or an Easy and Natural Method of Curing Most
Diseases. London: Epworth Press, 1960.
Wilson, D.S. Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion and the Nature of Soci-
ety. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2002.
Wilson, E.O. Sociobiology: The New Synthesis. Cambridge, MA: Belknap
Press, 1975.
Wilson, E.O. On Human Nature. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press,
1978.
Williams, D.R., Larson, D.B., Buckler, R.E., Heckmann, R.C., Pyle, C.M. Reli-
gion and psychological distress in a community sample. Social Science
Medicine 32:1257-1262,1991.
Winnicott, D.W. Playing and Reality. London: Tavistock, 1971.
World Health Organization. World Report on Violence and Health. Geneva:
World Health Organization, 2002.
Yalom, I.D., Lieberman, M.A. A study of encounter group casualties. Archives
of General Psychiatry 25:16-30,1971.
References 277
This page intentionally left blank
Index
279
Altruism, 20, 43-45 Asanas, 132
AMA (American Medical Association), Asch, Solomon, 70-72
59-60 Astanga yoga, 132
American Academy of Addiction Psychi- Attention-deficit/hyperactiivty disorder,
atry (AAAP), 50-52 243
American Board of Medical Specialties, Attribution theory, 25-26
60 Aum Shinrikyu, 20
American Journal of Psychiatry, drug Australopithecus, 46
manufacturer advertising rev- Authoritarian religious viewpoint, 19
enues and, 57 Autonomy, 89
American Medical Association (AMA), Awareness, 229
59-60 Ayurvedic medicine, 7,132-134
American Psychiatric Association (APA)
annual meeting, 64-65,113 Back pain treatment, 217-218
clinical care guidelines, 249 Balaji, religious/spiritual commitment
Group for Advancement of Psychiatry in, 134-136,221
and, 63 Batson, Daniel, 20
pharmaceutical companies and, 57 Beatitudes, 124
psychopharmacology and, 248 Behavior, evolutionary basis of, 43-45
American Society of Addiction Medi- Behavioral traits, biological factors
cine (ASAM), 50-52,65,66,186 and, 20
Anger Bellevue Hospital, New York, evolution
against God, 151-152 of mental health program,
intense, 79 204-213
toward father, 236-237 Benares Hindu University, 131
unconscious, 218-219 Bergin, Allen, 19,239
Anthropology, 46 Bernard, Claude, 189
Antibiotics, 133 Bible, 114-115,153
Anti-Communism, 8 Biomedicine
Antidepressants metaphor of, 56-58
for depression, 117,118,197, 241-242 research, 63-64
effectiveness of, 170 Bion,W.R., 81-82
meaning to life and, 96 Biopsychiatry, vs. problems of daily
placebo-controlled studies, 28-29, 215 living, 64
sales of, 64 Blue Cross and Blue Shield, 61
vs. social support for depression, 41 "Bollywood," 129
Antipsychotic drugs, 195, 201-203 Bone pointing, 68-70
Anti-Semitism, 8,15 Borderline personality disorder, 238
Anxiety disorders "Born again" Christians, 12-13,114,115
cultic religious sects and, 162 Bottoming out, 180-181
curbing, cults and, 22 Boundary crossings, 116-117,124-125
meditation for, 229 Boundary violations, 116,124-125
spiritual explanation of, 26 Brain
APA. See American Psychiatric electroencephalography of placebo
Association effect, 37-38
Apache shamans. See Shamans, Apache emotional energy and, 32-35
Applewhite, Marshall "Bo," 108-109 evolutionary adaptation of, 43-46
Archetypes, 15 meditation and, 38-40
Arthroscopic surgery, 29 memories and, 35-37
ASAM (American Society of Addiction metabolism, transcendence experi-
Medicine), 50-52,65,66,186 ence and, 177-178
280 Index
nonspecific stimuli and, 31-32 Christian Science, 166
social support and, 40-42 Church attendance, 161
Brainomed, 169-170 Cingulate gyrus, 33
Branch Davidians, 20 Classical conditioning, 36
Buddha, 130 Clerical collar, 154,155
Buddhism, 128, 229 Clinical practice, introducing spiritual-
ity in, 247-248
CAM (complementary and alternative Clinicians, spiritually oriented recovery
medicine), 55 and, 248-249
Cancer patients CMA (Christian Medical Association),
alternative treatments for, 163, 165-166 113-118
religious healing for, 161 Cocaine, 192-193
Cannon, Walter, 68-70 Codependency, 162
Cardiovascular system, psychosocial Cognitive-behavioral therapy, 248
factors and, 162-163 Cognitive dissonance theory, 26
Caregiver, judgment of, 166 Collective unconscious, 15-16
Catechisms, as "cultural genomes," 45 Community
Catecholamine hypothesis, for sense of, 109-110
depression, 52-53 support from, 162
Catholics, 8 Complementary and alternative
Cell assemblies, 37 medicine (CAM), 55
Cerebral cortex, 34 Compulsive eating, Christian psychiatry
Chaplaincy for, 122
clerical collar and, 154,155 Conditioned response, 35-37
dealing with anger against God, Conflict, in mental health field, 49-52
151-152 Conformity, 71
demands of, 76-77 Contraceptives, 9
listening style and, 155-156 Conversion symptoms, 138-139
therapeutic tools for, 152-153 Coordination, in religious groups, 45
therapist-spiritual mentor relation- Corpus callosum, severed, 32
ship and, 155 Corticotropin-releasing factor, 42
trainees, 149-151 Cortisol, 42
Charismatic groups Crack cocaine, 192,193-194
definition of, 83 Creative visualization, 162
psychological well-being of members Cremations, Manika, 130
and, 84,86 Cults
Children, praying with, 154-155 decreased stress in, 162
Chlorpromazine (Thorazine), 195,202 disasters, 108-109
Christian Medical and Dental group affiliation and, 44
Association, 77,161 leaders of, 74
Christian Medical Association (CMA), mass poisoning incident, 74-75
113-118 problems associated with, 82-86
Christian psychiatrists spiritually oriented perspective of,
with Fundamentalist orientation, 20-23
122-125 Cultural reintegration, beginning of,
literal role of Jesus and, 125-127 10-11
working with, example of, 118-122 Culture
Christians distortion of reality and, 72
beliefs of, return to, 10 impact of, 47-48
"born again," 12-13, n4> 115 sexual inclination and, 45
Second Advent, 59 Cupping, 161
Index 281
"Daily affirmations," 7-8 Eastern spirituality, 7,159,161,223,227
Darshan ceremony, 225-226 Economics, of medical practice, 61
Daytop Village, 204 Eddy, Mary Baker, 166
Deikman, Arthur, 228-229 EEC (electroencephalography), 37-38,53
Deinstitutionalization, mental illness Egotism, 19
and, 194-196 Egypt, spirituality in, 144-145
Dementia praecox, 189 Electroencephalography (EEC), 37-38,
Demonic possession, 165 53
Denial, of mental illness, 193 Emotion, perception and, 32-35
Depression Emotional control, 75-79
catecholamine hypothesis for, 52-53 Emotional distancing, 76-77
Christian psychiatry for, 117-118,122 Emotional distress, dealing with,
cognitive approach for, 199 Muslim religious persons and,
cultic religious sects and, 162 146-147
dealing with, hospital chaplaincy Emotional support, 160
training for, 150 Encounter groups, 80-81
drug therapy for. See Anti- Engagement, in cults, 23,25
depressants Enlightenment, 96-97
etiological factors, 27-28 Environment, in schizophrenia, 189-190
humiliating experiences and, 242 Ephedra, 166
management, cults and, 22 Epilepsy, 32,34
placebo treatment for, 28-29 Epistemiology, 91-92
psychotherapy for, 241 Epstein, Mark, 229
social support and, 40-41 Ethnicity, religion and, 8
treatment, integrating tradition into, Evidence-based medicine, 184-185
139-142 Evolution, 45-46
Dexamethasone suppression test, 53 "Experience of significance," 107
Diet therapy, 160,161
Distress, psychological Faith clinics, 165
cult members and, 96 Falun Gong, 20,86-87
improvement, social cohesiveness Family
and, 22 childhood interactions with, 239
relief effect, 24-27 transcendence of, 136-139
Divine Light Mission FDA (Food and Drug Administration),
meditation and, 223 56
"receiving knowledge" and, 224-225 "Feighner" criteria, for psychiatric
relief effect and, 24, 25 diagnosis, 64
Satsang, 13-14,108 Festinger, Leon, 26-27
spiritually oriented perspective of, Fibromyalgia, mindfulness meditation
20-22 for, 230
Do no harm concept, 165-167 "Finding oneself," 10
Dream imagery, importance/meaning Fluoxitine (Prozac), 28
of, 36-37 Food and Drug Administration (FDA),
Dreaming, biology of, 33-34 56
Drug culture, 101 Forgiveness, Christian, 117,123-124
Drug marketing, to physicians, 61-62 Frank!, Viktor, 232-233,240
Drug use, illegal, 9,22,192-193 Freud, Sigmund, 14-15,16
Dual diagnosis, 192-193,197,204-205 Fromm, Eric, 18
Dymphna, 163-164 Fulfillment, spiritual, 92-93
Dysfunctional parents, recovering Fundamentalist religion
from, 162 beliefs in, 10
282 Index
Christian Medical and Dental Society Herd instinct, 46
and, 77 Heroin, 175
Christian psychiatrists and, 111-112, Higher power, belief in, 6,182
122-125 Hindu spirituality, 108,128-129,135
conversion experiences and, 26 Hippocampus, 33
HIV/AIDS, 193-194
Gandhi, 140 Holistic medicine, 7,161
Ganges, ritual immersion in, 130 Homeopathic medicine, 59-60
GAP (Group for Advancement of Homicide, 191
Psychiatry), 63 Homo erectus, 46
Gautama, Siddhartha, 130 Hopelessness, mental illness and, 191,193
Gender roles, 9 Hormones, stress and, 163
Genetic studies, of social support, 41-42 Hospitals. See also Mental hospitals
Gifting, 98-99 historical overview of, 60-61
God Humanity, respect for, 19
anger against, 151-152 Hypersexuality, 116
belief in, 17,114,161,182 Hypothalmus, 33
conception of, 17
Grief, hospital chaplaincy training for, Id, 33
150 Immune system, psychosocial factors
Group for Advancement of Psychiatry and, 162-163
(GAP), 63 Inadequacy, sense of, 242
Groups, spiritually oriented, 20-24. India
See also specific groups Ayurvedic medicine in, 132-134
affiliation intensity, 85 contemporary trends in, 129-130
affiliation with, 25,168 Hinduism in, 108,128-129
charismatic, 83 integrating tradition into therapy,
disruptive life events and, 85 139-142
harm to participants and, 80 psychiatrists in, 111
induction process, 85 spiritual center of, 130-134
intense experiences in, 79-82 trance states and, 134-136
intense influence from, 68 transcendence of family in, 136-139
leadership of, 80-82 yoga in, 131-132
prayer in, 154-155 Individual identity, 100
Infantile drives, 16
Halfway house, 205,208 In-laws, 138-139
Hare Krishnas, 20 Inspirational books, 161
Healing, spiritually oriented, 25-26 Integrative psychiatry training program,
HealthCare Chaplaincy Program. 147
See Chaplaincy Integrity, 100
Health-related products, medical claims Intensity, of spiritual experiences, 13
for, 56 Interpersonal relationships, in shaping
Health status, psychological impact on, human experience, 16
162-163 Irrational personal unconscious, 15
Heaven's Gate, 108-109 Islam
Hebephrenia, 189-190 addiction treatment program and, 147
Heisenberg effect, 221-222 clergy, 146
Herbal remedies culture and, 143-144
Brainomed, 169-170 importance of "the word" in spiritual
for HIV, 55 discourse, 153,222
toxic, 166 intellectual capital of, 144
Index 283
Islam (continued) Maslow, Abraham, 14
prayer and, 145-146 Materialism, 89-90,94-95
radical terrorism and, 148 Maturation, 16
spiritual figures in, 144 Meaningful life, moving toward,
Sufism and, 144,147-148 245-246
suicide and, 147 Meaning of life
responding to spiritual void and,
James, William, 14-15,17-18,49 99-107
Jellinek Clinic, 102-103 search for, 95-99,100
Jesus, literal role of, 125-127 A Medical and Spiritual Guide to Living
Jews, 152 with Cancer, 161
Joint Commission on Accreditation Medical illness, spiritual approaches
of Health Organizations to, 7
(JCAHO), 61 Medical materialism, 13
Jones, Jim, 74-75 Medicine, scientifically grounded,
Jonestown poisonings, 74 59-60
Journal of Addictive Diseases, 57 Meditation
Jung, Carl Gustav, 15-16 brain during, 38-40
mindfulness, 188,227-231
Kabat-Zinn, Jon, 229 mystification process, 224-225
Kabbalah, 92 Transcendental Meditation, 35,38,
Kaiser-Permanente network, 61 227-228
Kendler, Kenneth, 239-240 Memory
Koran, 145,146 long-term, 33
Kotb, Shaikh Gamal, 144 of spiritual experiences, 35
Mental health field, conflict in, 49-50
Laboratory-based findings, over-reliance Mental hospitals
on, 53-54 deinstitutionalization and, 194-196
Last rites, 152 pseudo-patient experience in,
Leaders 190-191
of charismatic groups, 83 Mental hygiene concept, 194
group, vulnerability of, 80 Mental illness
omniscient, 82-83 belief issue and, 199-203
Lewin, Kurt, 80 deinstitutionalization and, 194-196
Life events, disruptive, 109 denial of, 193
Life transitions, 94-99 historical treatment of, 62-63
Limbic system, 33,34 hospital-based program evolution
Logic, definition of, 16 of, 204-213
Lord's Prayer, 178 interest in redemption and, 203-204
labeling of, 190,203
Macrobiotic diet, 161 program evolution, 204-213
Mahabharata, 129 substance abuse and, 192
Making-meaning, of life, 100-101 therapeutic community and,
Maladaptation syndromes, 238 196-199
Maladaptive behavior, 25 Mental state, neural stimuli and, 31-32
Malpractice, orthopedic procedure, 218, Methadone, 175
220 Methodism, 58
Managed care programs, 66-67, *59 Methodology fallacy, 53-54
"Marathon" groups, 79-80 Milgram, Stanley, 72-73
Marijuana, 9,100-101,104 Mind-body connection, 215-216
Marriage, support from, 162 Mindfulness meditation, 188,227-231
284 Index
Minnesota model, for addiction "Peak experiences," 14
treatment, 65-66 Perception, emotion and, 32-35
Mohit, Ahmed, 143-144 Perfection, need for, 219
Moonies. See Unification Church Persecution, living with, 86-87
Mother-in-law, 138-139 Personal change encounters, 80
Moussa, Souad, 144-145 Personal conflicts, dealing with,
Moxibustion, 161 maintaining spiritual role
Music, popular, 9-10 during, 76-77
Muslim Brotherhood, 148 Personality, biology and, 239-240
Muslims, 111 Personality disorders, 108,197,238
Mystery School, Houston's, 96-9 Personality traits
measurement of, 19
Narcissism, 87-93 of religiosity, 40
National Institute of Mental Health Personal meaning
(NIMH), 63-64 promise of, 96
National Institutes of Health (NIH), psychotherapy for, 232-246
63-64 spirituality and, 11
Navajo Indians, ritualized beliefs of, Personology, 238
29-30 PET (positron emission tomography),
Needs, hierarchy of, 14 39-40
Neocortex, 33 Pfister, Oskar, 15
Netherlands, absence of spirituality in, Pharmaceutical companies
101,102-103 drug advertisements, 57
Neurodegenerative disease, 160 drug marketing to physicians, 61-62
Neuroleptic drugs, 195 influence of, 57
New Age philosophies, 90-91,159 promotion of new drugs, 58
New Age programs, 96-97 Pharmaceutical sales, economics of, 57
NIH (National Institutes of Health), Pharmacological treatment, 141-142
63-64 Physicians
NIMH (National Institute of Mental drug marketing to, 61-62
Health), 63-64 as purveyor of unitary spiritual
Obedience, 19 message, 60
Ojha, 139 role, historical perspective of, 58-62
Operant conditioning, 36 underestimation of spiritual
Oppression, in close-knit family, 138 orientation, 186
Out-of-body experience, 141 Pinel, Philippe, 194
Oxford Movement, 174 Pir, 144
Placebo effect
Pain, somatic alternative medicine and, 55
alternative healing techniques for, description of, 27-30
167-170 electroencephalography of, 37-38
backache, 216-218 Hindu spiritualism and, 135
cultic religious sects and, 162 Positron emission tomography (PET),
illness and, 27 39-40
mindfulness meditation for, 230 Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD),
Panic disorder, 229 37,42,121
Parents, mate selection for children, 138 Practice guidelines, 57
Pastoral care, 149 Practitioners, definition of, 247-248
Patient, spiritually oriented recovery Pranayama, 132
and, 251-252 Prayer
Pavlov, Ivan, 35-36 in Alcoholics Anonymous, 175
Index 285
Prayer (continued) Racial segregation, 8
in avoiding conflict, 76 Ramadan, 146
in emotional healing, 114-115 Ramayana, 129
group, 154-155 Rational Recovery, for alcoholics, 169
Islamic, 145-146 Reality
power of, 53-54 denial of, belief in spiritual recovery
spontaneous, 152,156 and, 166
Premarital sexual intercourse, 9 vs. subjectivity, 16
Prescription drugs, direct-to-consumer Reciprocal altruism, 43
advertising of, 57-58 Redemption, 203-204
Primitive societies, spirits and, 8 Redemptive experience, belief in,
Problems of daily living, 247-248 199-203
Professional relationships, Alcoholics Redirection, need for, 109
Anonymous and, 184-186 Reframing, 233
Project MATCH, 180 Relaxation response, 227-228
Prostitution, mental illness and, 194 Relief effect, 24-27,168-169
Protestants, 8 Religion
Provo movement, 101 ethnicity and, 8
Prozac (fluoxitine), 28 secular viewpoint of, 17-19
Psychiatric disorders, with substance spirituality and, 165
abuse, 204-205 trance and, 134-136
Psychiatric hospitals, 63 vs. spirituality, 6-7,175
Psychiatrists Religious, as "cultural genomes,"
Christian, 114-115,116 45-46
community-based practice, 63 Religious awakening, 119
devoutly religious, 77 Religious experience
Fundamentalist Christian, 111-112 disavowal in psychoanalytic move-
in India, in ment, 15
Psychiatry meaningfulness of, 14-15
biology of, 52 Religious faith, psychological validity
spiritual perspective and, 149-150 of, 13
Psychoanalysis, 14-17,16 Religious groups, coordination in, 45
Psychoanalytic practitioners, 245-246 Religious intensity, 13,77-78
Psychodynamic psychology, 239 Religious orientations
Psychological damage, from group altruism and, 44-45
experience, 81 extrinsic vs. intrinsic, 88-89
Psychological perspective, 20,107-110 impulse toward, 45
Psychological well-being, measure of, intrinsic, 19
23-24 sanction of, 117
Psychopharmacology, 47,202 types of, 19
Psychosis, 107,193,200,201 Religious view, of spirituality, 17
Psychosocial factors Renewal, spiritual, 109
cardiovascular system and, 162-163 Research
immune system and, 162-163 biomedical, 56-58
Psychotherapy community, spiritually oriented
with medications, 147 recovery and, 249-250
nonspecific factors in, 214-215 Resiliency, no
for personal meaning, 232-246 Rights, individual, 89
spiritual experience and, 19-20,226 Ritualized beliefs, 29-30
therapeutic alliance and, 233-240 Rizzuto, Ana-Maria, 16-17
Psychotomimetics, 9 The Road Less Traveled (Peck), 161
286 Index
Rostam, 144 Spiritual experiences
Rush, Benjamin, 62-63 intense, 37
varieties of, 111-112
Samadhi, 39,132 Spiritual healers, 139
Sarno, John, 215-221 Spiritual healing, placebo effect and, 29-30
Satsang, 13-14,108 Spirituality
Schizophrenia brain and. See Brain
environmental factors, 189-190 contemporary perspective, 8
historical aspects, 189 definition of, 5-6
offering of prayers for, 140-141 in India. See India
recovery from, 202 as intense personal experience, 12-14
suicide attempts and, 191 origin of, 7-10
symptoms of, 21 personal nature of, 5-6
Schizotypal personality, 238 problems with, 68-93
Scientific research, validity of, 72 cults. See Cults
Scientology, 10,166-167 emotional control, 75-79
Second Advent Christians, 59 in groups oriented to professional
Secular viewpoint, 17-19 growth, 79-82
Self-absorption, 88 narcissism, 87-93
Self-actualization, 14 persecution, 86-87
Self-analysis, 140 thought control, 70-75
Self-care, 248-249 "voodoo death," 68-70
Self-efficacy, 168 religion and, 165
Self-justification, 19 in Sweden, 100
Self-liberating approaches, 161-162 vs. religion, 6-7,175
Self-realization, 19 Spiritually oriented recovery
Serenity Prayer, 175 clinicians and, 248-249
Serotonin binding potential, 40 patient and, 251-252
Serotonin reuptake inhibitor anti- research community and, 249-250
depressants, 28 Spiritual needs, validation of, 105-107
Sexual inclination, culture and, 45 Spiritual orientation
Sexual orientation, 9 evolution of brain and, 43-45
Sexual practices, 9,116 impulse toward, 45
Shahnameh, 144 Spiritual perspective, psychiatry and,
Shaikh, 145,146 149-150
Shamans, Apache, 214-222 Spiritual recovery movements, 157-158.
Sin, 126 See also specific spiritual recovery
Skinner, B.F., 36 movements
Social cohesiveness, distress improve- acceptance of, 164-165
ment and, 22 belief in, denial of reality and, 166
Social support caregiver's judgment and, 166
brain and, 40-42 characteristics of, 160-162
personal meaning from, 162 extreme, 20-21
Sociobiological model, 20 psychological engagement in, 167-170
Somatic approach, 217-218 subjective experience and, 177-178
Somatic hallucinations, 34 validation of, 185
Soteria program, 201 Spiritual renewal, 37
SPECT, during meditation, 39 Spiritual subcultures, 20-21
Spinal nerve root pressure, 219 Spiritual void, responding to, 99-107
Spirits, primitive societies and, 8 Spontaneous prayer, 152,156
Spiritual Exercises in Everyday Life, 119 Steinke, Paul, 149
Index 287
Stomach cancer, dealing with, 153-154 Transcendental Meditation (TM), 35,38,
Stress, hormones and, 163 227-228
Subcultures, spiritually oriented, 163-165 Transcendent experience, functional
conflicting messages in, 78-79 anatomy and, 34
reality, distortion of, 72 Transitional objects, 16
value distortions and, 72-73 Treatment, spiritually oriented, 159
Subjectivity, vs. reality, 16 Twelve-Step process. See also Alcoholics
Substance abuse, 9,22,192-193 Anonymous
Sufism, 144,147-148 adaptive behavior and, 45
Suicide belief in, 179
borderline personality disorder and, 238 at Hazelden Foundation, Minnesota,
hopelessness and, 191 102-103
Islam and, 147 liberal Islam and, 147
schizophrenia and, 191 spirituality in, 7,50-52,159,162
Suppression, as defense mechanism, 102
Surgery Unification Church (Moonies)
for back pain, 218 conformity and, 71
placebo, 29 group affiliation and, 44
Sweden, formal religion in, 100 induction process, 27,71-72,74,108
marital engagement ceremonies,
Tng-ki healers, 165 83-84, 86
Target symptoms, 206 mental health professionals and, 23
TC (therapeutic community), 196-199, relief effect and, 24,25
204, 208, 210, 212 Reverand Moon and, 83
Temporal lobe epilepsy, seizure locus, 34 spiritual orientation of, 20
Ten Commandments, 46 Universal spirit, belief in, 161
Terminal illness, 152 An Unquiet Mind (Jamison), 141-142
Terror experiences, 68-70
"T group," 79 Validation, of spiritual needs, 105-107,185
Theophostic Ministry, 125-127 Values distortion, by prevailing sub-
Therapeutic alliance, 233-240 culture, 72-73
Therapeutic community (TC), 196-199, Values orientation, 17-20
204, 208, 210, 212 Varanasi, India, 130-131,169
Therapeutic relationship, effect of reli- Varieties of Religious Experience
gious intensity on, 77-78 (James), 49
Thomsonians, 59-60 Visual hallucinations, 34
Thorazine (chlorpromazine), 195, 202 "Voodoo death," 68-70
Thought control, 70-75
Thoughts Without a Thinker, 229 Wesley, John, 58
Tiananmen Square suicides, 87 Whitman, Walt, 17-18
TM (Transcendental Meditation), 35,38, WHO (World Health Organization), 143
227-228 Winnicott, D.W., 16
Token economy, 208 Witch doctors, 30
Traditional values, without spiritual ties, World Health Organization (WHO), 143
101-102 World Trade Center disaster, 109-110
Tranquilizers, overreliance on, 235-236
Transcendence, spiritual Yoga, 131-132
belief in, 169 Yoga Sutras, 132
escape from worldly pressure and, 175 Yogi, Maharishi Mahesh, 228
feelings of, 40,141 Yoruba rituals, 165
illusion of, 88
need for, 8,10-11 Zakad, 146
288 Index