Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
www.nature.com/clinicalpractice/cardio
S U M M A RY INTRODUCTION
A large body of evidence has emerged from
Excessive salt intake exacerbates hypertension and further increases
clinical epidemiological and interventional
left-ventricular mass in clinical essential and experimental hypertension.
investigations as well as experimental studies
Additionally, a growing body of evidence strongly suggests that high
that have repeatedly identified a positive rela-
dietary salt loading exerts detrimental cardiac effects independently of
tionship between salt and hypertension. The
its hemodynamic load. The clinical evidence of cardiac structural and
multinational Intersalt study1,2 clearly related
functional alterations associated with salt is, however, scarce. In order to
dietary sodium and blood pressure across
explore the purported beliefs in humans, in this review we draw on our
many populations and, even more difficult to
experimental studies in naturally occurring hypertension and discuss the
demonstrate, within populations. In support of
clinical implications of the nonhemodynamic mechanisms underlying
these epidemiological findings, well-controlled
these salt-related changes.
clinical trials have provided strong evidence
KEYWORDS dietary salt loading, hypertension, left-ventricular hypertrophy,
ventricular dysfunction, ventricular fibrosis
that reduction of sodium intake lowers arte-
rial pressure in both hypertensive and normo-
REVIEW CRITERIA tensive people.3,4
We searched the National Library of Medicine MEDLINE database using following In addition to elevated arterial pressure, left-
keywords: hypertension, salt, left ventricle, hypertrophy, fibrosis, and left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH) is an independ-
ventricular function. Only English-language articles were obtained, all of them
in extensor, which were searched to identify other relevant articles. ent cardiovascular risk factor in hypertension
in association with impaired coronary hemo-
dynamics, ventricular fibrosis and dysfunction,
and apoptosis.57 Over many years, clinical and
experimental studies have demonstrated the
additional potential of salt to adversely affect
cardiac structure and function independ-
ently of its influence on arterial pressure.811
This finding is exceedingly important since
only a small fraction of hypertensive patients
are said to demonstrate SODIUM-SENSITIVE
HYPERTENSION. In some large epidemiological
studies,12,13 but not in others,14 high sodium
intake has notably been indicated as a strong
and independent contributor to increased
cardiovascular risks and mortality.
This review summarizes the increasing
strong clinical and experimental evidence that
supports the concept that sodium, rather than
simply elevating arterial pressure, has a far
ED Frohlich is the Alton Ochsner Distinguished Scientist and Jasmina Varagic more complex role in hypertension. Although
is a staff scientist at the Oschner Clinic Foundation, New Orleans, LA, USA. not comprehensive, we present compelling
evidence for a pattern of cardiac structural
Correspondence
*Ochsner Clinic Foundation, 1514 Jefferson Highway, New Orleans, LA 70121, USA
and functional changes that accounts for the
efrohlich@ochsner.org observed cardiovascular risk of increased
sodium consumption. Where clinical evidence
Received 2 July 2004 Accepted 11 September 2004
www.nature.com/clinicalpractice
is less strong, we add our experience from
doi:10.1038/ncpcardio0025 studies with experimental naturally occurring
300 - 8- GLOSSARY
Systolic arterial pressure (mmHg)
ab SODIUM-SENSITIVE
7-
a a HYPERTENSION
1-
100 - 0-
0.22 - 0.90 -
a ab
0.21 - a 0.85 -
a
0.20 - 0.80 -
0.19 - 0.75 -
0.18 - 0.70 -
0.17 - 0.65 -
0.16 - 0.60 -
Control Salt Salt Control Salt Control Salt Salt Control Salt
without with without with
CHF CHF CHF CHF
Young SHR Old SHR Young SHR Old SHR
Figure 1 Systolic arterial pressure and left-ventricular geometry in salt-loaded younger (16 weeks) and
older (52 weeks) adult spontaneously hypertensive rats. Data are presented as mean value 1 SEM.
aP <0.05 vs respective control group. bP <0.05 vs salt without congestive heart failure. CHF, congestive
heart failure; SHR, spontaneously hypertensive rats.
hypertension to provide important clinical rel- In the adult spontaneously hypertensive rat,
evance and to establish the validity for further which is the best experimental model of natu-
clinical investigation. rally occurring hypertension, we have deter-
mined the cardiac response to different levels
SALT AND ALTERED LEFT-VENTRICULAR of dietary salt excess.21,8 Rats were given 8%
STRUCTURE salt in food, roughly corresponding to twice
Salt and left-ventricular mass the salt intake in human societies with the
Excess dietary salt exacerbates hypertensive higher salt consumption. Younger rats started
disease14 and further increases LV mass in their high-salt diet at 8 weeks of age and older
clinical essential and experimental hyper- rats began salt loading at 20 weeks. The groups
tension. 811,1517 Although an expanded were studied echocardographically at age
intravascular volume in response to high salt 16 weeks in the younger and 52 weeks in the
intake may also occur, sodium intake in hyper- older group. In most rats, salt excess induced
tensive patients correlates more strongly with concentric LVH associated with impaired
LV wall thickness than with LV end-diastolic ventricular relaxation and increased arte-
diameters.17,18 Furthermore, a growing body rial pressure. Of the younger group, however,
of clinical and experimental evidence also sug- 25% developed OVERT CARDIAC FAILURE; and
gests an important interaction between salt and these were the only rats in which LV diastolic
myocardial mass that may be independent of diameter increased significantly with sodium
hemodynamic overload. Thus, increased salt loading, reflecting impaired ventricular func-
intake is a critical independent predictor of tion (Figure 1). Notably, sustained salt excess
LV enlargement in patients with essential elevated arterial pressure only slightly (17%)
hypertension.11,1720 in younger and older adult spontaneously
NOVEMBER 2004 VOL 1 NO 1 FROHLICH AND VARAGIC NATURE CLINICAL PRACTICE CARDIOVASCULAR MEDICINE 25
REVIEW
www.nature.com/clinicalpractice/cardio
concentration (mg/g)
macromolecules that
a
LV hydroxyproline
surrounds cells in the
6.5 -
salt to exaggerate collagen deposition has been
ventricular interstitium
recognized. In stroke-prone spontaneously hyper-
6.0 - a tensive rats, 6 weeks of 1% salt in drinking water
increased collagen mRNA in the left ventricu-
5.5 -
lum.25 Increased LV hydroxyproline concentra-
4.5 -
tion (an index of ventricular collagen content)
can be seen in response to dietary salt excess in
4.0 -
Control Salt Salt Control Salt
younger and older adult spontaneously hyperten-
without with sive rats (Figure 2). Fibrosis was also more prom-
CHF CHF
inent in younger rats that developed heart
Young SHR Old SHR
failure.21 Furthermore, in a morphological study,
Figure 2 Left-ventricular hydroxyproline
increased interstitial as well as perivascular col-
concentration in spontaneously hypertensive lagen deposition was demonstrated in Wistar
rats receiving high-salt diet. Data are presented Kyoto and spontaneously hypertensive rats receiv-
as mean value 1 SEM. aP <0.05 vs respective ing a high-salt diet.9 Although the profibrotic
control group. bP <0.05 vs salt without congestive effect of salt has usually been coupled with
heart failure. CHF, congestive heart failure; SHR, elevated blood pressure, an increasing body of
spontaneously hypertensive rats.
experimental evidence supports the concept of a
pressure-independent link between salt and the
hypertensive rats, but it substantially increased EXTRACELLULAR MATRIX. Indeed, the Wistar
LV-mass index in young adult rats (88%) as Kyoto rats receiving salt excess developed cardiac
compared with the older rats (25%).21 We also fibrosis to a similar extent as the untreated spon-
demonstrated that the correlation between the taneously hypertensive rats, and their systolic
level of sodium-intake and cardiac mass was pressure was much lower.9 Additionally, a calcium
stronger than between mean arterial pres- antagonist reduced the degree of salt-induced col-
sure and cardiac mass.8 Even in normoten- lagen deposition in stroke-prone spontaneously
sive Wistar Kyoto control rats receiving excess hypertensive rats in the absence of blood-pressure
dietary salt, LV mass increased without hemo- changes, providing further evidence for a
dynamic changes.8,10 On the other hand, there pressure-independent effect of salt.25
is increasing evidence from clinical as well
as experimental studies demonstrating that EFFECTS OF SALT EXCESS ON
reduction in salt intake diminishes LV mass LEFT-VENTRICULAR FUNCTION
independently of arterial pressure changes.22,23 As suggested above, LVH has been recognized
These findings provide further support to the for many years as a major risk factor for cardiac
concept that increased LV mass associated failure, ventricular dysrhythmias and coronary
with sodium excess may not totally reflect the arterial disease. Moreover, increasing evidence
pressure overload. It seems, therefore, that indicates that, in hypertension, salt excess
in hypertension, dietary sodium overload further increases LV mass and fibrosis out of
exacerbates cardiac hypertrophic response to proportion to any rise in arterial pressure; this
pressure increase. finding has major implications concerning
cardiovascular risk.
Salt and myocardial fibrosis The possible relationship between salt and
Although ventricular fibrosis frequently com- LV functional changes has rarely been tested
plicates hypertensive LVH clinically and experi- clinically. Two reports have demonstrated that
mentally,6 few clinical studies have addressed impaired LV diastolic filling was positively cor-
the role of salt as a mediator of cardiac fibro- related with sodium excretion or blood-pressure
sis. Serum carboxy-terminal propeptide of sodium sensitivity.26,27 For example, a reduced
procollagen type I and carboxy-terminal telo- maximum of early diastolic filling velocity (VE) as
peptide of collagen type I have been shown clin- well as an early to atrial (VA) filling velocity ratio
ically to be useful markers of collagen turnover (VE/VA) were demonstrated in sodium-sensitive
in the myocardium,24 and these surrogates may essential hypertensive patients but not in sodium-
26 NATURE CLINICAL PRACTICE CARDIOVASCULAR MEDICINE FROHLICH AND VARAGIC NOVEMBER 2004 VOL 1 NO 1
REVIEW
www.nature.com/clinicalpractice/cardio
55 - 0.06 - GLOSSARY
DIASTOLIC
a DYSFUNCTION
50 -
a Inability of heart to fill with
ab
0.04 - blood during diastole
IVRT (s)
45 -
FS (%)
ISOVOLUMIC
RELAXATION TIME
Echocardiographically
40 -
0.02 - determined time interval
ab between aortic-valve
35 - closure and the start of
mitral flow
30 - 0- DECELERATION TIME
OF E
Echocardiographically
3.0 - 30 - determined time interval
between the peak of early
2.5 - b diastolic filling velocity
a
25 - a and the intersection of the
deceleration of flow with the
2.0 -
baseline
VP (cm/s)
VE /VA
1.5 - a 20 -
1.0 -
15 -
0.5 -
0- 10 -
Control Salt Salt Control Salt Control Salt Salt Control Salt
without with without with
CHF CHF CHF CHF
Young SHR Old SHR Young SHR Old SHR
Figure 3 Echocardiografically measured systolic and diastolic function in spontaneously hypertensive rats
fed with an 8% salt diet. Data are presented as mean value 1 SEM. aP < 0.05 vs respective control group.
bP <0.05 vs salt without congestive heart failure. CHF, congestive heart failure; FS, fractional shortening;
IVRT, isovolumic relaxation time; SHR, spontaneously hypertensive rats; VE/VA, early and atrial filling
velocity ratio; Vp, propagation velocity of early filling.
resistant patients whose arterial pressure was Thus, salt-induced myocytic hypertrophy and
comparable.26 accumulated fibrillar collagen within the extra-
In our studies of spontaneously hypertensive cellular matrix seems to promote LV functional
rats, dietary salt excess increased arterial pressure alterations clinically and experimentally. It has
more than in rats receiving normal salt diets and been suggested that diffuse interstitial fibrosis
promoted DIASTOLIC DYSFUNCTION manifested interferes with ventricular relaxation and con-
by extended ISOVOLUMIC RELAXATION TIME, tributes importantly to abnormal ventricular
decreased VE/VA ratio and slower propagation stiffness.28 Additionally, perivascular fibrosis
velocity of early filling (VP , Figure 3).21 These might restrict coronary vasodilation, thereby
echocardiographically measured ventricular relax- diminishing blood supply to the hypertrophic
ation abnormalities were associated with a further LV, having increased oxygen demand.2931 We
increase in LV mass and hydroxyproline concen- demonstrated profound impairment in LV
tration. Moreover, the subgroup of younger salt- coronary vasodilatory reserve response (to
loaded spontaneously hypertensive rats developed dipyridamole) in salt-loaded young adult spon-
heart failure with impaired systolic (decreased taneously hypertensive rats as compared with
fractional shortening) and diastolic function asso- untreated rats of the same age (ED Frohlich,
ciated with a still greater LV mass and myocardial unpublished data). Therefore, sodium-loading
fibrosis. The significantly increased VE /Vp ratio in such rats seems to be manifested not only by
(an index of LV filling pressure) and restrictive fill- further elevated pressure but also by significant
ing pattern (shorter DECELERATION TIME OF E) LV functional impairment related to enhanced
clearly indicated a stiffer chamber (Figure 4). ventricular fibrosis.
NOVEMBER 2004 VOL 1 NO 1 FROHLICH AND VARAGIC NATURE CLINICAL PRACTICE CARDIOVASCULAR MEDICINE 27
REVIEW
www.nature.com/clinicalpractice/cardio
DTE (s)
with respect to inflammation
and fibrosis ble to cardiac damage when high dietary salt is
introduced earlier in life.21 Therefore, a care-
0.03 -
ful evaluation of cardiovascular consequences
of salt excess at a young age is also strongly
recommended.
0.02 -
28 NATURE CLINICAL PRACTICE CARDIOVASCULAR MEDICINE FROHLICH AND VARAGIC NOVEMBER 2004 VOL 1 NO 1
REVIEW
www.nature.com/clinicalpractice/cardio
and vascular myocytes by promoting protein 11 du Cailar G et al. (2002) Dietary sodium and target
organ damage in essential hypertension. Am J
synthesis and impeding protein degradation. Hypertens 15: 222229
It appears, therefore, that excessive salt intake, 12 He J et al. (1999) Dietary sodium intake and
in addition to increasing arterial pressure, may subsequent risk of cardiovascular disease in
overweight adults. JAMA 282: 20272034
adversely affect cardiovascular structure and 13 Tuomilehto J et al. (2001) Urinary sodium excretion
function directly or through the local interplay and cardiovascular mortality in Finland: a
with various growth hormones and factors. prospective study. Lancet 357: 848851
14 Tunstall-Pedoe H et al. (1997) Comparison of
the prediction by 27 different factors of coronary
CONCLUSIONS heart disease and death in men and women of the
Cardiovascular effects due to salt loading in Scottish heart health study: cohort study. BMJ 315:
722729
hypertensive patients, independent of salt- 15 Chrysant SG et al. (1979) Hemodynamic
increased blood pressure, are becoming increas- and metabolic evidence of salt sensitivity in
ingly defined. Excessive salt intake, directly or spontaneously hypertensive rats. Kidney Int 15:
3337
through locally activated growth hormones and 16 Lindpaintner K and Sen S (1985) Role of sodium
factors, increases LV mass and extracellular col- in hypertensive cardiac hypertrophy. Circ Res 57:
lagen deposition and, in that way, aggravates 610617
17 du Cailar G et al. (1989) Influence of sodium intake
hypertension-related LV functional distur- on left ventricular structure in untreated essential
bances. A more comprehensive recognition of hypertensives. J Hypertens 7: S258S259
the underlying pathophysiologic cardiovascular 18 Fields NG et al. (1991) Sodium-induced cardiac
hypertrophy: cardiac sympathetic activity versus
mechanisms will clarify more effective long- volume load. Circ Res 68: 745755
term management of hypertensive patients and 19 du Cailar G et al. (1992) Sodium and left ventricular
reduce cardiovascular morbidity and mortality mass in untreated hypertensive and normotensive
subjects. Am J Physiol 263: H177H181
related to that disease. 20 de la Sierra A et al. (1996) Increased left ventricular
mass in salt-sensitive hypertensive patients. J Hum
Hypertens 10: 795799
References 21 Ahn J et al. (2004) Cardiac structural and functional
1 Elliott P et al. (1996) Intersalt revisited: further responses to salt loading in SHR. Am J Physiol 287:
analysis of 24 hour sodium excretion and blood H767H772
pressure within and across populations: Intersalt 22 Meggs LG et al. (1988) Myocardial hypertrophy: the
Cooperative Research Group. BMJ 312: effect of sodium and the role of sympathetic nervous
12491253 system activity. Am J Hypertens 1: 1115
2 Stamler J (1997) The Intersalt Study: background, 23 Liebson PR et al. (1995) Comparison of five
methods, findings, and implications. Am J Clin Nutr antihypertensive monotherapies and placebo for
65 (suppl): 626642 change in left ventricular mass in patients receiving
3 Sacks FM et al. for the DASH-Sodium Collaborative nutritional-hygienic therapy in the Treatment of
Research Group (2001) Effects on blood pressure of Mild Hypertension Study (TOMHS). Circulation 91:
reduced dietary sodium and the Dietary Approaches 698706
to Stop Hypertension (DASH) diet. N Engl J Med 24 Querejeta R et al. (2000) Serum carboxy-terminal
344: 310 propeptide of procollagen type I is marker of
4 Whelton PK et al. (1998) Sodium reduction and myocardial fibrosis in hypertensive heart disease.
weight loss in the treatment of hypertension in Circulation 101: 17291735
older persons: a randomized controlled trial of 25 Kyselovic J et al. (1998) Prevention of salt-
nonpharmacologic interventions in the elderly dependent cardiac remodeling and enhanced gene
(TONE): TONE Collaborative Research Group. JAMA expression in stroke-prone hypertensive rats by the
279: 839846 long-acting calcium channel blocker lacidipine.
5 Frohlich ED (1999) Risk mechanisms in hypertensive J Hypertens 16: 15151522
heart disease. Hypertension 34: 782789 26 Musiari L et al. (1999) Early abnormalities in left
6 Frohlich ED et al. (1992) The heart in hypertension. ventricular diastolic function of sodium-sensitive
N Engl J Med 327: 9981008 hypertensive patients. J Hum Hypertens 13:
7 Frohlich ED and Re R (1998) Pathophysiology of 711716.
systemic arterial hypertension. In Hursts The Heart, 27 Langenfeld MR et al. (1998) Impact of dietary sodium
16351650 (Eds, Schlant RC et al.) New York: intake on left ventricular diastolic filling in early
McGraw-Hill essential hypertension. Eur Heart J 19: 951958
8 Frohlich ED et al. (1993) Relationship between 28 Brilla CG et al. (1991) Impaired diastolic function
dietary sodium intake, hemodynamics, and cardiac and coronary reserve in genetic hypertension:
mass in SHR and WKY rats. Am J Physiol 264: role of interstitial fibrosis and medial thickening
R3034 of intramyocardial coronary arteries. Circ Res 69:
9 Yu HC et al. (1998) Salt induces myocardial and 107115
renal fibrosis in normotensive and hypertensive rats. 29 Susic D et al. (1998) Coronary hemodynamics in
Circulation 98: 26212628 aging spontaneously hypertensive and normotensive
10 Leenen FHH and Yuan B (1998) Dietary-sodium- Wistar-Kyoto rats. J Hypertens 16: 231237
induced cardiac remodeling in spontaneously 30 Brilla CG et al. (2000) Lisinopril-mediated regression
hypertensive rat versus Wistar-Kyoto rat. of myocardial fibrosis in patients with hypertensive
J Hypertens 16: 885892 heart disease. Circulation 102: 13881393
NOVEMBER 2004 VOL 1 NO 1 FROHLICH AND VARAGIC NATURE CLINICAL PRACTICE CARDIOVASCULAR MEDICINE 29
REVIEW
www.nature.com/clinicalpractice/cardio
Acknowledgments 31 Schwartzkopff B et al. (2000) Repair of coronary among treated hypertensive men. Hypertension 25:
This work was supported arterioles after treatment with perindopril in 11441152
by an award from the hypertensive heart disease. Hypertension 36: 42 Alderman MH et al. (1998) Dietary sodium intake and
American Heart Association, 220225 mortality; the National Health and Nutrition Examination
Southeast Affiliate. 32 Pomeranz A et al. (2002) Increased sodium Survey (NHANES 1). Lancet 351: 781785
concentration in drinking water increase blood 43 de Wardener HE (1999) Salt reduction and
Competing interests pressure in neonates. J Hypertens 20: 203207 cardiovascular risk: the anatomy of a myth. J Hum
The authors declared 33 Yuan B and Leenen FHH (1991) Dietary sodium intake Hypertens 13: 14
they have no competing and left ventricular hypertrophy in normotensive rats. 44 Kumanyika SK and Cutler JA (1997) Dietary sodium
interests. Am J Physiol 261: H1397H1401 reduction: is there cause for concern? J Am Coll Nutr
34 Sen S and Young DR (1986) Role of sodium in 16: 192203
modulation of myocardial hypertrophy in renal 45 Schmieder RA et al. (1996) Angiotensin II related to
hypertensive rats. Hypertension 8: 918924 sodium excretion modulates left ventricular structure
35 Skrabal F et al. (1981) Low sodium/high potassium in human essential patients. Circulation 94:
diet for prevention of hypertension: possible 13041309
mechanisms of action. Lancet 2: 895900 46 de la Sierra A et al. (1996) Fluid, ionic and hormonal
36 Limas C and Limas CJ (1985) Cardiac beta- changes induced by high salt intake in salt-sensitive
adrenergic receptors in salt-dependent genetic and salt-resistant hypertensive patients. Clin Sci 91:
hypertension. Hypertension 7: 760766 155161
37 MacPhee AA et al. (1980) Altered cardiac beta- 47 Hodge G et al. (2002) Dysregulation of angiotensin II
adrenoreceptors in spontaneously hypertensive rats is associated with salt sensitivity in the spontaneous
receiving salt excess. Clin Sci 59: 169s170s hypertensive rat. Acta Physiol Scand 174: 209215
38 Partovian C et al. (1998) Effects of a chronic high-salt 48 Takeda Y et al. (2001) Effects of high sodium intake
diet on large artery structure: role of endogenous on cardiovascular aldosterone synthesis in stroke-
bradykinin. Am J Physiol 274: H14231428 prone spontaneously hypertensive rats. J Hypertens
39 Nicholls MG et al. (1980). Plasma norepinephrine 19: 635639
variations with dietary sodium intake. Hypertension 2: 49 Feron O et al. (1995) Influence of salt loading
2932 on the cardiac and renal preproendothelin-1
40 Grassi G et al. (2002) Short- and long-term mRNA expression in stroke-prone spontaneously
neuroadrenergic effects of moderate dietary sodium hypertensive rats. Biochem Biophys Res Commun
restriction in essential hypertension. Circulation 106: 209: 161166
19571961 50 Gu J-W et al. (1998) Sodium induces hypertrophy of
41 Alderman MH et al. (1995) Low urinary sodium is cultured myocardial myoblasts and vascular smooth
associated with greater risk of myocardial infarction muscle cells. Hypertension 31: 10831087
30 NATURE CLINICAL PRACTICE CARDIOVASCULAR MEDICINE FROHLICH AND VARAGIC NOVEMBER 2004 VOL 1 NO 1