Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Abstract A new kinetic model for commercial unit of toluene disproportionation and C9-armatiocs transalkylation
is developed based on the reported reaction scheme. A time based catalyst deactivation function taking weight
hourly space velocity (WHSV) into account is incorporated into the model, which reasonably accounts for the loss
in activity because of coke deposition on the surface of catalyst during long-term operation. The kinetic parameters
are benchmarked with several sets of balanced plant data and estimated by the differential variable metric optimiza-
tion method. Sets of plant data at different operating conditions are applied to make sure validation of the model
and the results show a good agreement between the model predictions and plant observations. The simulation
analysis of key variables such as temperature and WHSV affecting process performance is discussed in detail, giv-
ing the guidance to select suitable operating conditions.
Keywords toluene disproportionation and C9-armatiocs transalkylation, kinetic model, catalyst deactivation func-
tion, parameter estimation, simulation analysis
Main reactions: tivation function was not taken into account. In this
paper, the catalyst decaying function is incorporated
into the kinetic model and the net rate equations are
expressed as follows. A more detailed description of
kinetic modeling approach used in this work can be
(1) found in the reported paper[9].
Toluene disproportionation (reversible):
2 a a
r1 = k1 aTol B X (9)
K1
(2) 2 a a
r2 = k2 aTol B EB (10)
K2
Transalkylation of toluene with trimethyleben-
zenes (reversible):
a a
(3) r3 = k3 aTol aTMB X X (11)
K3
a a
r4 = k4 aTol aTMB EB EB (12)
K4
Dealkylation (irreversible):
(4) r5 = k5 aMEB (13)
r6 = k6 aPB (14)
Side reactions: Trimethylebenzenes diproportionation (reversi-
ble):
2 aX aC10 A
r7 = k7 aTMB (15)
K7
(5)
Hence the net rate equations of the key composi-
tions such as benzene (B), toluene (Tol), propylbenze
(PB), methylethylbenzene (MEB), trimethylbenzenes
(TMB), ethylbenzene (EB), xylenes (X), and C10A are
given by
(6) rB = 0.5r1 + 0.5r2 + r6 (16)
rTol = r1 + r2 + r3 + r4 r5 (17)
rPB = r6 (18)
rMEB = r5 (19)
(7) rTMB = r3 + r4 + r7 (20)
rEB = 0.5r2 + 2r4 (21)
Isomerization reactions of xylenes: rX = 0.5r1 + 2r3 + 0.5r7 (22)
rC10 A = 0.5r7 (23)
where r is reaction rate; a is mass fraction, %; is
catalyst deactivation function assumed to be uniform
for all reactions; k is reaction rate constant; and K is
chemical equilibrium constant.
(8) Catalysts for hydrocarbons catalysis are inevita-
bly deactivated by the coke deposition. In fact catalyst
decay has been widely discussed in many processes
such as catalytic cracking and catalytic reforming. A
time-based model was proposed by Jacob et al.[16]
A kinetic model for toluene disproportionation accounting for catalyst fouling in residue oil catalytic
and C9-aromatics transalkylation has been developed cracking. Taskar and Riggs[17] applied another model
by Liu[8] and Xu et al.[9], but unfortunately the deac- related to the amount of coke deposited on the surface
Chin. J. Ch. E. 15(3) 326 (2007)
328 Chin. J. Ch. E. (Vol. 15, No.3)
Ph =
(mH 2 / HC ) P
t
(25)
the axial fixed-bed reactor and the reactor model
derivation can be seen in Xu et al.[9].
1 + (mH 2 / HC )Y H2 da j Rb2 da j
= , a j (0) = a j 0 (39)
whre mH 2 HC is molar ratio of hydrogen-to-hydrocarbons, dl WHSV Vc L c dt
1
molmol ; Pt is total pressure at reactor inlet, kPa; where Rb is radius of catalyst bed, m; l is dimen-
and YH 2 is purity of cycle hydrogen based on molar, %. sionless length of bed; L is length of catalyst bed, m;
Vc is catalyst volume, m3; is feedstock density,
The temperature dependence of the rate constant, kgm 3; c is catalyst density in the bed, kgm 3. Eq.(39)
k, is described by the Arrhenius equation as are solved by numerical algorithm of fourth-fifth order
E Runge-Kutta.
ki = k0i exp ai , ( i = 17) (26) Because of the huge pressure drop in the axial
RT fixed bed, the Ergun equation[20] is added with these
where k0 represents frequency factor; Ea represents equations
activation energy, kJmol 1; R represents gas constant,
1 1
8.314Jmol K ; and T is reaction temperature, K. dP (1 ) 2 (1 )
= 1.75105 3 G + 1.50103 3 G
And for chemical equilibrium constant K, dz g d p g d p
M M
K1 = K ep1 B 2 X (27) (40)
M Tol
where is bed void fraction; is viscosity of gas
M B M EB passing through the bed, Pas; g is density of gaseous
K 2 = K ep2 2
(28) mixture through the reactor, kgm 3; dp diameter of
M Tol
catalyst particle, m; G is superficial mass velocity of
gases, kgm 2s 1.
M X2
K3 = K ep3 (29)
M Tol M TMB
2
3 MODEL PARAMETERS ESTIMATION
M EB 3.1 Catalyst deactivation parameters estimation
K 4 = K ep4 (30)
M Tol M TMB In the commercial operation of catalytic reactors,
the effects of catalyst inactivation are often encoun-
M X2 M C10 A tered by increasing the catalyst temperature with time
K 7 = K ep7 2
(31) on stream in order to achieve a constant conversion of
M TMB
reactant to products[21]. Hence the loss of catalyst
where M denotes molecular weight, gmol 1; Kep de-
activity is compensated by the raised reaction tem-
notes thermodynamic constant, and is determined by perature during long-term operation. In this case, Sz
G pe and Levenspie[22] derived an important condition
K epi = exp i , ( i = 14,7) (32) for the extremal policy as follows:
RT
where G is Gibbs free energy, kJmol 1.
d (k )
=0 (41)
As to PX isomerization, the concentration of iso- dt
mers [PX (p-xylene), MX (m-xylene), OX (o-xylene)]
which means that the effective rate constant should be
can be determined by the following:
kept unchanged during the entire process.
y As mentioned earlier, rate constants obey Ar-
K ep5 = OX (33)
yMX rhenius law and Eq.(41) can be rewritten as
y E
K ep6 = PX (34) k0 exp a = C (42)
yMX RT
June, 2007
Kinetic Model and Simulation Analysis for Toluene Disproportionation and C9-Aromatics Transalkylation 329
The deactivation function is assumed to be in- k0 and parts of them are shown in Table 1. The fre-
variable in a certain day. This is absolutely reasonable quency factors are optimized by the differential vari-
because of the catalysts stable performance during able metric optimization method and the estimated
long-term operation. The function is supposed to be results are listed in Table 2. The detail procedures
1 at the conditions of t = 0 and T0 = 614.53K , then about parameter estimation can be found in Xu et al.[9].
E
k0 exp a = C (43) Table 2 Kinetic parameters of the model
RT0 Reaction ki, s1 k0i, s1 Eai, kJmol1
Substituting Eq.(24) into Eq.(42) and combining 1 326.222 9.1061010 102
Eq.(43), then rearranging, leads to the following 13
relationship 2 36.221 9.53410 150
3 554.664 5.7121010 96.77
1 1
Ea
t + ln Ph + ln WHSV = (44) 4 22.799 6.0011013 150
R
T0 T 5 227.994 6.1261010 101.8
Parameters can be estimated by the least square
6 381.221 3.2631010 95.8
method with large number of data from commercial
unit. In this case, the deactivation function becomes 7 5.369 3.213109 106
model. The advantages of the model considering Table 3. As shown in the plot, toluene disproportiona-
catalyst fouling can also be seen from average abso- tion and C9-aromatics transalkylation result in de-
lute errors. Details are shown in Table 3. crease of feedstock, and at the same time lead to the
The simulation result of composition profile increase in products such as benzene and xylenes,
through the reactor is shown in Fig.1. The plot is based which agrees with the tendency observed in the com-
on the operating conditions from date of 20051004 in mercial unit quite well.
Obser. 10.76 40.15 0.02 4.60 8.72 2.35 6.76 15.50 6.56 2.70 1.90 0.029
20050701 Ref.[9] 9.39 38.53 0.27 4.74 9.73 2.25 7.06 15.75 6.72 3.12 2.45 0.26
This
work 9.76 38.30 0.36 4.60 10.09 2.25 7.03 15.69 6.69 3.13 2.10 0.23 0.032
Obser. 9.36 38.38 0.02 4.52 10.72 2.12 7.20 16.00 6.75 3.00 1.92 0.029
20051004 Ref.[9] 9.33 38.28 0.26 4.55 9.80 2.38 7.07 15.77 6.73 3.47 2.38 0.52
This
work 9.40 38.13 0.46 5.37 10.86 2.13 6.70 14.96 6.38 3.50 2.11 0.60 0.037
Obser. 8.58 37.53 0.02 4.09 10.86 2.01 7.50 16.75 7.06 3.43 2.15 0.029
Note: Obser. represents plant observations.
June, 2007
Kinetic Model and Simulation Analysis for Toluene Disproportionation and C9-Aromatics Transalkylation 331
fouling; hence, balance between conversion and reac- K chemical equilibrium constant
tion temperature should be kept during operation. Kep thermodynamic constant
reaction rate constant, s 1
k
k0 frequency factor, s1
L length of catalyst bed, m
l dimensionless length of bed
mH 2 HC molar ratio of hydrogen-to-hydrocarbons
Ph hydrogen pressure , kPa
Pt total pressure at reactor inlet , kPa
gas constant, 8.314Jmol 1K 1
R
Rb radius of catalyst bed, m
r reaction rate , h1
T reaction temperature, K
t on stream time, d
Figure 2 Effect of reaction temperature on Vc catalyst volume, m3
total conversion WHSV weight hourly space velocity, h1
w eomponents in feedstock, %
WHSV affecting the reaction severity is relative w1 components in reactant, %
to the residence time with catalyst. The higher WHSV YH 2 purity of cycle hydrogen based on molar, %
results in the less severity of reaction and more depo- y mole fraction, %
sition of coke on the catalyst, which means that the catalyst deactivation constant, d1
total conservation will be reduced. But fortunately it pressure exponent
will be compensated by increased reaction tempera- space velocity exponent
bed void fraction
ture. The typical relationship between temperature,
viscosity of gas passing through the bed, Pas
deactivation function and WHSV is shown in Fig.3. feedstock density, kgm3
As observed, deactivation function is decreased c catalyst density in the bed, kgm3
markedly from 0.98 to 0.73 with WHSV varying from g density of gaseous mixture through the reactor, kgm3
1.04 to 1.29. At the same time, temperature is in- catalyst deactivation function
creased to 358.03 from 341.38. Gain about 1 is
provided when 1t of feedstock is introduced.
REFERENCES
1 Aneke, L.E., Gerritsen, L.A., van den Berg, P.J., de Jong,
W.A., The disproportion of toluene over a HY/-AlF3/Cu
catalyst (1) Preparation and characterization, J. Catal.,
59, 2636(1979).
2 Borgna, A., Sepulveda, J., Magni, S.I., Apesteguia, C.R.,
Active sites in the alkylation of toluene with methanol:
A study by selective acid-base poisoning, Appl. Catal.
A : Gen., 276, 207215(2004).
3 Das, J., Bhat, Y.S., Bhardwaj, A.I., Halgeri, A.B., Zeo-
lite beta catalyzed C7 and C9 aromatics transformation,
Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 116, 7179(1994).
4 Aneke, L.E., Gerritsen, L.A., Eilers, J., Trion, R., The
disproportion of toluene over a HY/-AlF3/Cu catalyst
Figure 3 Relationship between temperature, (2). Kineitcs, J. Catal., 59, 3744(1979).
deactivation function and WHSV
5 Bhavikattl, S.S., Patwardhan, S.R., Toluene dispropor- P., Disproportionation of toluene over HZSM-5 zeo-
tionation over nickel-loaded aluminum-deficient mor- lites, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 8, 359367(1983).
denite (2) Kinetics, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 20(1), 106 14 Bharati, S.P., Bhatia, S., Deactivation kinetics of toluene
109(1981). disproportionation over hydrogen mordenite catalyst,
6 Bhaskar, G.V., Do, D.D., Toluene disproportionantion re- Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 26(9), 18541860(1987).
action over HZSM-5 zeolites: Kinetics and mechanism, 15 Uguina, M.A., Sotelo, J.L., Serrano, D.P., Valverde, J.L.,
Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 29(3), 355361(1990). Deactivation kinetics of para-selective toluene dispro-
7 Tsai, T.C., Chen, W.H., Lai, C.S., Liu, S.B., Wang, I., Ku, portionation over modified ZSM-5, Ind. Eng. Chem.
C.S., Kinetics of toluene disproportionation over fresh Res., 33(1), 2631(1994).
and coked H-mordenite, Catal. Today, 97, 297 16 Jacob, S.M., Gross, B., Weekman, Jr. V.W., A lumping
302(2004). and reaction scheme for catalytic cracking, AIChE J.,
8 Liu, H.X., Reaction characteristics and kinetic study for 22(4), 701713(1976).
toluene disproportionation and C9-araomatics transalky- 17 Taskar. U., Riggs, J.B., Modeling and optimization of a
lation over zeolites, Master Thesis, East China Uni- semiregenerative catalytic naphtha reformer, AIChE J.,
versity of Science & Technology, Shanghai(2001). (in 43(3), 740753(1997).
Chinese) 18 van Trimpont, P.A., Marin, G.B., Froment, G.F., Reform-
9 Xu, O.G., Su, H.Y., Jin, X.M., Chu, J., Kinetic model for ing of C7 hydrocarbons on sulfided commercial Pt/Al2O3
toluene disproportionation and transalkylation with catalyst, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 27(1), 5157(1988).
C9-Aromatics, Journal of Chemical Industry and Engi- 19 Al-Khattaf, S., Tukur, N.M., Al-Amer, A., Modeling
neering (China), 58(3), 630637(2007). (in Chinese) xylene reactions over ZSM-5 zeolite in a riser simulator:
10 Das, J., Bhat, Y.S., Halgeri, A.B., Transalkylation and 1,2-versus 1,2-Methyl Shift, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res.,
disproportionation of toluene and C9 aromatics over zeo- 44(21), 79577968(2005).
lite beta, Catal. Lett., 23, 161168(1994). 20 Froment, G.F., Bischoff, K.B., Chemical Reactor Analy-
11 Dumitriu, E., Guimon, C., Hulea, V., Lutic, D., Fechete, sis and Design, 2nd edition., Prentice Hall, NJ (1992).
I., Transalkylation of toluene with trimethylbenzenes 21 Krishnaswamy, S., Kittrell, J.R., Impact of diffusional
catalyzed by various AFI catalysts, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., limitations on temperature-time profiles for deactivating
237, 211221(2002). catalysts, Ind. Eng. Chem. Fundam., 21, 9597(1982).
12 Bibby, D.M., Howe, R.F., McLellan, G.D., Coke forma- 22 Szpe, S., Levenspie, O., Optimal temperature policies
tion in high-silica zeolites, Appl. Catal. A: Gen., 93(1), for reactors subject to catalyst deactivation () Batch
134(1992). reactor, Chem. Eng. Sci., 23, 881894(1968).
13 Meshram, N.R., Hegde, S.G., Kulkarmi, S.B., Ratnasamy,
June, 2007