Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
2
AS TO FORM Ex: the statement of the insured of his
age, purpose for which property is
Written on the face of May be written in a totally insured is used for dwelling, etc.
the policy, actually or disconnected paper or may be oral
by reference Where statement in the nature of an opinion.-
a statement in the policy which, from the very
AS TO MATERIALITY nature of the subject matter of the inquiry,
can only be an expression of an opinion is not
Presumed material Must be proved to be material strictly speaking, a warranty of its
truthfulness.
AS TO COMPLIANCE
Ex. Where the answers in an application are
Must be strictly Requires only substantial compliance qualified by the words, the above is near
complied with correct as I remember, to the best of my
knowledge and belief etc.
AS TO EFFECT OF FALSITY/NON-FULFILLMENT
Sec. 72. A statement in a policy which
Falsity or non-fulfillment Falsity renders the policy void on the imparts that it is intended to do or not to do
operates as a breach of ground of fraud a thing which materially affects the risk, is a
contract warranty that such act or omission shall take
place.
Sec. 70. Without prejudice to section 51,
every express warranty, made at or before Sec. 72 refers to a promissory
the execution of a policy, must be contained warranty. Breach of promises or
in the policy itself, or in another instrument agreement as to future acts will not
signed by the insured and referred to in the avoid a policy unless the promises are
policy as making a part of it. material to the risk
3
to fulfill the warranty does not avoid the Sec. 74. The violation of a material warranty,
policy. or other material provision of a policy, on the
part of either party thereto, entitles the
When breach of warranty does not avoid
other to rescind.
policy.
Effects of Breach of Warranty If Material :
General Rule: Violation of a warranty avoids
a contract of insurance. General Rule- The violation of the
terms of a contract of insurance
Exception: Section 73 which refers to those
entitles either party to terminate the
warranties relating to the future provides 3
contractual relations.
exceptions:
Recission by the insured- Thus, the
a) When loss occurs before time for
insured can sue for recission for
performance
breach of contract due to the refusal
Ex. If the insured warrants that within five (5) of the insurer to grant a loan applied
days after the execution of the contract he will for although this was expressly agreed
install fire extinguishers in the insured upon in the policy and he can recover
premises and the loss occurs on the second full amount of the premiums paid by
day without insured having complied with the him
warranty, the policy is not avoided by the
Recission by the insurer- Under Sec.
failure to perform said warranty.
74, the insurer is entitled to rescind
b) When performance becomes unlawful the contract of insurance for violation
of a warranty only if said warranty is
Ex. The policy contains an express warranty
MATERIAL; otherwise, the breach
that the insured house which at the time was
thereof will no avoid policy (Sec. 75).
rented to tenants shall cease to be rented and
The right of the insurer to rescind
shall be used as private dwelling for the family
exists even though the violation was
of the insured within 3 months from the date
not the direct cause of the loss.
of the policy. Subsequently, a law was passed
prohibiting the ejectment of tenants without Ex. Where a fire policy requires the
fixed period of lease within a period of one (1) insured to give notice of the existence
year in view of an existing emergency. When of other insurance policies over the
the loss occurs after three (3) months, the same property insured, the non-
insured has not yet complied with the disclosure thereof is a violation of a
warranty. In this case, the omission to fulfil material warranty which entitles the
said warranty does not avoid the policy. insurer to rescind.
c) When performance becomes impossible Sec. 75. A policy may declare that a
failure to comply with a promissory warranty violation of specified provisions thereof
may be due not only to legal impossibility but shall avoid it, otherwise the breach of an
also to physical impossibility. immaterial provision does not avoid the
policy.
Ex. If the insured warrants to change the party
wall of his house to concrete within a certain Violation of Immaterial Provision
period and before the date arrives, no cement
is available for private use without the fault of General Rule: The breach of any
the insured and subsequently the loss provision which is not material will
happens, the non-performance of the not avoid the policy
warranty does not also avoid the policy.
4
Exception: When the policy expressly To all the premiums if it is
provides or declares that a violation broken during the inception of
thereof will avoid it. the contract. In this case, the
contract is void ab initio
Ex. A stipulation against procuring
additional insurance without insurers Effect if with Fraud the policy is
consent although immaterial to risk avoided ab initio, and the insured is
insured against (such as fire not entitled to the return of the
insurance) will avoid a fire insurance premium paid.
policy which declares that such
Ex. Suppose the warranty stipulates
violation shall avoid it. Provided same
that the insured will not store
subject matter, same interest and
inflammable materials in the building
same risk.
insured. If the policy was issued on
Example: Fire insurance. Even if the June 10, 2014 and the insured violates
cause of the fire is faulty wiring, the the warranty on June 25, 2014, the
insurance company may deny the insurer is exonerated only from June
claim on the grounds that the policy is 25, 2014. Consequently, the insurer is
avoided because the policy expressly liable for any loss arising before June
declares that a violation thereof will 25 but not as to a loss occurring
avoid it. thereafter. In this case, the insurer is
entitled to retain the premium up to
But, if there are no such stipulations,
June 25, 2014 the time of the breach
the policy remains since there are no
specific provisions stated. If the insured, without fraud, makes a
false warranty at the time he signs the
Sec. 76. A breach of warranty without fraud
contract, he cannot recover for any
merely exonerates an insurer from the time
loss arising thereafter because the
that it occurs, or where it is broken in its
breach prevents the policy from
inception, prevents the policy from attaching
attaching the risk. The contract is void
to the risk.
ab initio but all the premiums should
Effect of Breach of Warranty By the Insured be returned to the insured.
5
Ex. Condition that the policy which the insurer declares himself
shall not take effect until the unwilling to undertake.
delivery and payment of the
Exception vs. Warranties & Conditions
first premium during the good
health of the applicant Illustration:
b) Condition subsequent pertains to the If the policy contains a warranted
contract of insurance after the risk has statement the insured building is
attached and during the existence thereof. occupied, the said statement is
WARRANTY.
Example: Condition requiring
notice and proof of loss in If the policy states that this entire
case of loss upon an insurance policy shall be void if the insured
against fire. building be or becomes vacant or
unoccupied and so remained for more
Condition vs. Warranty
than 10 days, the statement is
Condition Warranty CONDITION.
As to Effects of Breach
Exception- it is a provision in an
insurance policy that indicates what is
denied coverage