Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Phoebe Shively
Expository Writing
December 7, 2016
Explanations shape our sense of reality by allowing people to choose how they perceive
the world. In Daniel Gilberts Immune to Reality, he discusses the way in which people use
explanations to warp their sense of reality to make themselves feel happy. Karen Hos
and as a tool to justify discriminatory behaviors and beliefs. In Andrew Solomons piece, Son,
the author describes his own experience as a homosexual man whose reality is changed when he
chooses to accept an alternative explanation of his homosexuality that differs from that of his
parents and society. Society pressures people to conform to the beliefs of the majority. When
someone doesnt conform, these explanations can be used by society as tools to justify
explanations; however, these alternative explanations are often chosen anyways because it makes
those people happier. By choosing which explanations to believe, we shape our identities as well
as the lenses through which we view the world. Reality is formed by the explanations that one
perceives to be true.
Biographies of Hegemony, Karen Ho explains how Wall Street justifies hiring from only a select
group of people, smartness must be represented and reinforced by a specific appearance and
Shively 2
bodily technique that dominantly signals that impressiveness; not surprisingly, such
investment bankers (Ho, 167). Wall Street justifies only hiring white males who are graduates
of ivy league institutions through the explanation that those physical traits equate to smartness.
This explanation is used by Wall Street to discriminate against anyone who isnt a white male
Ivy League graduate. In his book, Son, Andrew Solomon recalls a similar example of
discrimination that he faced as a child because of his homosexuality. Young Solomon was
called faggot on the bus and at school, often within hearing distance of teachers who raised no
objections (Solomon 377). The homophobic students at Solomons school justified their
discriminatory behaviors through the explanation that homosexuality is a negative trait. Since
this was the explanation that the majority of society chose to accept, students and teachers used it
to justify their actions. Actions such as discrimination and bullying are used to pressure outsiders
Opinions of the majority pressure people to conform to their beliefs and accept their
explanations. In Immune to Reality, Daniel Gilbert cites a study in which one group of people
recorded their level of happiness after being rejected by a single judge, while another group of
people recorded their level of happiness after being rejected by a diverse jury group. The results
of the study revealed that the volunteers who were rejected by the judge were happier than the
volunteers who were rejected by the jury group. Gilbert explains how people value the opinion of
a group over the opinion of an individual, Being rejected by a large and diverse group of people
for the psychological immune system to find a way to think about it that is both positive and
credible (Gilbert 134). In other words, rejection from a group is more difficult to handle
Shively 3
because its easier to find fault in an individual than it is to find fault in a large and diverse
undergraduate students at Ivy League universities are taught to believe that the only suitable jobs
for them after graduation are on Wall Street, Implicit in this transformation from undergraduate
to investment banker is Wall Streets notion that if students do not choose Wall Street
postgraduation, they are somehow less smart (Ho, 180). Wall Street pressures students to
conform and choose careers as investment bankers by using the explanation that Wall Street is
the smart choice, and anyone who does not choose Wall Street is making a poor decision.
Similarly, Solomon describes how some religious groups use reform camps to pressure
religious reform camps and in the offices of unscrupulous or misguided psychiatrists (Solomon,
382). Religious reform camps try to force homosexuals to conform and fix their sexuality
because some religious groups accept the explanation that homosexuality is a sin. It is much
easier to find flaws in a single person than in a large group. However, when people strongly
disagree with the explanation that the majority accepts and the behaviors that the explanation
On the other hand, sometimes people make the choice to ignore pressures to conform and
choose their own explanations and beliefs. When this happens, people find alternative
explanations that make them feel happier. For example, Andrew Solomon chooses to reject his
parents explanation that being gay must be a negative thing. Instead, Solomon chooses to accept
his homosexuality and view it as a positive trait, While I might have had an easier life if I had
been straight, I am now wedded to the idea that without my struggles, I would not be myself, and
that I like being myself better than I like the idea of being someone else (Solomon 383).
Shively 4
Andrew Solomon determines that he was happy to accept his homosexuality and the difficulties
that come along with it. Happiness is the driving force for non-conformity and choosing
explanations that go against the majority. Solomon chose his own explanation of homosexuality
over societys explanation that homosexuality is a bad choice that should be changed. Solomons
choice to view homosexuality as a positive trait rather than a negative trait can be explained by
Daniel Gilbert when he states, When the experience we are having is not the experience we
want to be having, our first reaction is to go out and have a different one (Gilbert 138). In other
words, people are more likely to choose a positive explanation of their experiences rather than a
negative explanation. Andrew Solomon chose to view his homosexuality as a positive attribute
rather than societys view that homosexuality is a negative trait that should be changed.
Explanations shape our sense of reality by allowing people to have a choice in how they perceive
the world.
The explanations that people choose to believe shape their identity and therefore the lens
through which they view the world. By shaping our perspectives, we not only shaping our own
perceived reality, but we are also affecting the reality of those around us. The explanations that
one chooses to accept as truth can impact a multitude of people, as Gilbert states, Civilized
people have learned the hard way that a handful of iniquitous individuals can often cause more
death and destruction than an invading army (Gilbert 135). Sometimes small groups of people
can have a lot of power and influence. When the majority chooses to accept sexist or racist
community to which someone belongs, they can change their sense of reality. Communities form
when there are several people who accept the same explanations and thus have similar
perspectives, as Andrew Solomon explains, Difference unites us. While each of these
Shively 5
experiences can isolate those who are affected, together they compose an aggregate of millions
whose struggles connect them profoundly (Solomon, 371). In other words, differences can be
isolating, but they allow individuals who shared similar struggles to come together and create a
community in which they can be themselves. Simply put, alternative explanations will act as
forces of isolation unless one finds a community of like-minded individuals who share the same
perspective. When communities force conformity, anyone who doesnt conform will be excluded
and create their own smaller community, which is based off of differences from the original
community.
Explanations are powerful tools that can be both isolating and unifying. Oftentimes,
people use explanations to justify discriminatory actions and behaviors, such as the sexist and
racist policies of Wall Street as well as bullying in schools. People often face pressure to accept
certain explanations and conform to the beliefs of the majority. This conformity can be seen in
Ivy League institutions, where students are pressured to become investment bankers. It can also
be found in religious reform camps, where homosexuals are forced to act heterosexual. In some
cases, explanations can be a powerful tool used for good, such as when people make the choice
to oppose conformity and find alternative explanations that make them feel better. Happiness is
the driving force for explanations, which shape identities and therefore the lenses through which
people view the world. When a group of people agree on an explanation, they often form
communities where their differences from society unites them together. By forming communities
and groups where people accept similar explanations, ones reality can be altered. In conclusion,
explanations have some positive impacts such as helping people discover their own identities and
form communities, but they also have numerous negative impacts such as the promotion of
Works Cited
Gilbert, Daniel. Immune to Reality. The New Humanities Reader. Ed. Richard E. Miller and
Ho, Karen. Biographies of Hegemony. The New Humanities Reader. Ed. Richard E. Miller and
Solomon, Andrew. Son. The New Humanities Reader. Ed. Richard E. Miller and Kurt