Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
INTERNATIONAL
PRODUCTION COST
COMPARISON
2014
Spinning/Texturing/Weaving/Knitting
When reading the report, the objectives of the study - as outlined above -
must constantly be borne in mind. It should also be noted that international
competition takes place between a much wider array of producers working
not only with the most modern and highly capital intensive equipment of the
type assumed in this study, but with depreciated old or second-hand machin-
ery, leading to wide variations in manufacturing costs.
Attention is furthermore drawn to the fact that the cost pattern as emerging
from this report reflects but one of the elements entering into the calculation
of the final sales price for yarns and fabrics, others being overheads, incentive
schemes, transport and insurance, import and export duties, etc. Moreover,
competitiveness is determined increasingly by such factors as quality and
style, reliability, promptness of delivery, flexibility, etc., which fall outside the
scope of this study. An international comparison of this order can therefore
never be more than an approximation to the real market situation.
December 2014
4 Acknowledgements
Basis of Calculation
5 Scope and Coverage
6 Exchange Rates
7 Raw Material Costs
8 Definition of Cost Factors
Calculated Costs
15 Definition of Cost Elements
31 Annex
How to calculate company-specific depreciation
and interest costs
Oerlikon Barmag Zweigniederlassung der Oerlikon Textile GmbH & Co. KG, Remscheid, Germany
Geographically, the study covers Brazil, China, Egypt, India, Indonesia, Italy, Korea, Turkey and Geographical
the USA. These countries all actively participate in international textile trade as exporters and/or Coverage
importers.
Every year, the machinery manufacturers on whose equipment the present study is based are Methodology
conducting numerous cost calculations for prospective clients around the world. Based on factors
supplied by these clients, manufacturing costs are calculated and enter as an important element
into the evaluation process of a given investment project. By using the same approach, ITMFs
International Production Cost Comparison attempts to simulate reality within the limits outlined
in the study. Cost factors for the participating countries are supplied by individual companies,
consultants and textile trade associations. They are carefully reviewed by the four machinery
manufacturers cooperating in the study, with a view to arriving at representative average factors
for the country concerned. The results are presented in a way enabling the reader to see the
repercussions on the costing structure of diverging factors (e.g. labour and capital costs).
The product base in spinning is a Ne 30 (Nm 50 / 20 tex) combed yarn made of 100% cotton of Product
1-1/8" staple length and a Ne 20 (Nm 33 / 30 tex) carded yarn made of 100% cotton of 1-1/16 Coverage
staple length. In texturing, it is a 100% polyester POY 75 f72 den textured yarn. The cotton yarns
are woven into a "print cloth" fabric of 27.6/27.6 threads per cm (ring yarn) and a print cloth
fabric of 24.0/24.0 threads per cm (rotor yarn), and a textured fabric of 38.0/31.0 threads per cm.
Fabric dimensions are 168 cm grey width (cotton ring and rotor yarn), and 177 cm grey width
(textured yarn). In knitting, the fabric constructions are of the Single Jersey type, 192 cm
unfinished width (cotton ring) and of the Lapique type, 224 cm (cotton rotor) and of the Interlock
type, 190 cm unfinished width (textured yarn), resp.
The cost calculations are based on the assumption that the cotton yarn is spun in a new mill equipped Mill Type
with 16,320 Rieter ring spindles and 1,380 Rieter open-end rotors producing 400 kg per hour while and Size
the textured yarn is produced on 10 Barmag eFK with an output of 800 metres per machine and
minute, or 2,000 kg of yarn per day (95% machine efficiency). In weaving, 96 Picanol air-jet weaving
machines OMNIplus Summum-2-P-190 produce 19.4 meters of fabric per machine and hour (94%
machine efficiency), 72 Picanol air-jet weaving machines OMNIplus Summum-2-P-190 produce
22.3 meters of fabric per machine and hour (94% machine efficiency) while 60 Picanol rapier
weaving machines OptiMax-4-R-190 have an output of 12 meters per machine and hour (95%
machine efficiency). For knitting Single Jersey (Lapique), 17 (13) circular knitting machines of Mayer
& Cie, type Relanit 3.2 II, 30 inch diameter, gg 24, 96 feeders, with an output of 25.3 kg (31.4 kg)
per machine and hour (85% machine efficiency) are assumed, while for knitting Interlock, 8 circular
knitting machines of Mayer & Cie, type OV 3.2 QC, 30 inch diameter, gg 28, 96 feeders, producing
10.7 kg per machine and hour (85% machine efficiency), are needed.
Rates of output are assumed to be identical for all 9 countries concerned. The different Efficiency
efficiency standards prevailing in the countries have been taken into consideration by v arying Standards
the number of workers required to obtain the output levels indicated.
The calculations are based on cost factors that prevailed in the 1st quarter of 2014. Reference
Cotton/polyester prices are those of the last week of May and June, respectively. Period
In view of rapidly changing currency relationships, especially vis--vis the US dollar (USD),
production cost factors are surveyed in domestic currencies, and converted to USD for ease
of comparison. Average exchange rates for Q1/2014 were employed, as outlined below:
All values appearing in the tables detailing Cost Factors, Manufacturing (Conversion) and
Total Costs are expressed in USD.
Manufacturing costs relate to the production area only, i.e. excluding overheads. Reference Area
Wages include social charges, fringe benefits and shift work premiums. Note that the study Wages
is based on expenditure in the production area only and therefore excludes overheads
(management, accounting, sales). Since, from experience, this cost factor differs widely from
one company to the other, its impact on the total costing structure may clearly be consider-
able.
The number of operatives required are determined by work-study methods. The individual Operating
times are according to Mayer, Oerlikon Barmag, Picanol and Rieter standards. Overlookers Personnel
and supervisors, as well as staff for laboratories, workshops, despatch, etc. are not included.
The requirements of skilled and unskilled workers for machine maintenance are determined Overhauling and
according to Mayer, Oerlikon Barmag, Picanol and Rieter standards for the overhaul and Maintenance
maintenance of their machines. The values indicated give the requirements per shift, similar Personnel
to those for operatives.
The necessary average floor space for machines, gangways and reserve (can space etc.) Floor Space
was evaluated on the basis of a great number of spinning, texturing, weaving and knitting
mill layouts. Certain alterations may arise, according to specific machinery layouts.
The cost of the buildings refers to the production area only and includes the costs of the air Building Costs
conditioning ducts for supply and recycled air; the lighting system; the installations for high
and low voltage electricity supply; fire protection; etc. The dimension of the air conditioning
installation is in direct relation to the specific climatic conditions in the respective countries.
The straight-line method (as against the degressive method) was used to calculate depre- Depreciation
ciation costs which are based on the period most commonly applied in the countries
concerned (as against those provided for in tax laws). Where depreciation rates differ from
those assumed, the company-specific depreciation costs may be re-calculated using the
formula in the Annex.
Interest rates vary not only from country to country but also from company to company within Interest Rates
one single country. In this study the average interest rates that prevailed in the first quarter
of the reference year were assumed.
Hourly wage for skilled personnel 6.55 3.25 1.90 1.10 2.05 31.90 19.057 7.40 17.8010/11
Hourly wage for machine tenders 3.45 2.80 1.50 0.70 1.20 25.60 9.757 4.25 14.5511
Hourly wage for unskilled personnel 2.75 2.30 1.15 0.55 0.80 25.05 8.657 3.20 11.8511
Operating hours
8,600 8,400 7,700 8,400 8,600 5,500 8,400 7,800 7,800
(per year)
Cost of electric power
0.121 0.132 0.04 0.09 0.08 0.22 0.09 0.08 0.0512
(per kwh )
Cost of buildings
394 261 231 175 154 1,370 583 181 1,128
(per m2)
Annual building maintenance
1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
(%)
Depreciation period for machinery
10 10 12 10 12 8 8 10 714
(years)
Depreciation period for accessories
8 6 5 5 5 5 5 7 514
(years)
Depreciation period of buildings
20 20 30 29 20 30 32 39 39
(years)
Customs, import tax, etc.
17.5 21.03 0.05 13.0 5.0 0.0 5.0 0.0 0.0
(% of machinery price)
Capital interest rate
14.24 6.154 10.40 12.80 11.00 4.00 4.80 9.30 4.2515
(%)
Raw material costs (Ring)
1.940 2.856 3.847 2.060 2.040 2.000 2.060 2.205 1.809
(per kg of cotton 1-1/8)
Raw material costs (Rotor)
1.863 2.812 3.780 1.983 1.962 1.923 1.984 2.150 1.732
(per kg of cotton 1-1/16)
Notes
See page 13
Type Rieter ring spinning Yarn Data Raw material - 100% cotton
(incl. winding) Staple length - 1-1/8 inches
Yarn count - Ne 30 combed
Rate of Output 400 kg per hour
Type Rieter rotor spinning Yarn Data Raw material - 100% cotton
Staple length - 1-1/16 inches
Yarn count - Ne 20 carded
Hourly wage for skilled personnel 6.35 3.95 1.80 1.40 2.10 32.00 19.057 8.50 18.7010/11
Hourly wage for machine tenders 4.25 2.55 1.35 0.90 1.35 27.00 9.757 6.80 15.2511
Hourly wage for unskilled personnel 3.40 1.65 1.00 0.80 0.90 23.00 8.657 6.00 12.4511
Operating hours
8,200 7,400 7,700 8,400 8,600 8,000 8,000 7,800 8,300
(per year)
Cost of electric power
0.121 0.132 0.04 0.09 0.08 0.16 0.09 0.09 0.0512
(per kwh )
Cost of buildings
421 228 202 175 154 1,000 613 226 1,250
(per m2)
Annual building maintenance
1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
(%)
Depreciation period for machinery
10 10 12 10 12 8 8 10 514
(years)
Depreciation period for accessories
10 8 5 6 5 5 8 7 514
(years)
Depreciation period of buildings
20 20 30 29 20 30 32 39 39
(years)
Customs, import tax, etc.
15.0 17.03 15.05 13.0 5.0 0.0 7.0 4.08 0.0
(% of machinery price)
Capital interest rate
14.24 6.154 10.4 12.00 11.00 4.20 4.80 9.30 4.2515
(%)
Raw material costs
1.75 1.72 1.93 1.706 1.66 1.98 1.80 1.75 2.1016
(per kg polyester POY)
Notes
See page 13
Size of Mill 10 Barmag eFK, 240 positions Yarn Data Raw material - 100% polyester POY
Yarn count - 75 den textured
(India: 85 den)
- Cotton 1-1/8 0.369 0.543 0.731 0.391 0.388 0.380 0.391 0.419 0.344
- Cotton 1-1/16 0.462 0.697 0.938 0.492 0.487 0.477 0.492 0.533 0.430
- Polyester POY 0.185 0.182 0.205 0.1806 0.176 0.210 0.191 0.185 0.22316
Notes
See page 13
Hourly wage for skilled personnel 6.80 3.35 1.15 0.80 2.15 25.90 19.057 4.25 17.8010/11
Hourly wage for machine tenders 3.40 2.80 0.95 0.70 1.30 24.80 9.757 3.35 15.2511
Hourly wage for unskilled personnel 2.95 2.30 0.80 0.65 0.85 23.55 8.657 2.70 11.8511
Operating hours
6,500 8,200 4,800 8,400 8,600 4,000 6,624 8,100 7,800
(per year)
Cost of electric power
0.121 0.132 0.04 0.09 0.08 0.22 0.09 0.08 0.0512
(per kwh )
Cost of buildings
339 229 202 171 154 1,370 557 183 1,128
(per m2)
Annual building maintenance
1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
(%)
Depreciation period for machinery
10 10 8 10 12 8 8 10 714
(years)
Depreciation period for accessories
10 5 5 6 5 5 5 9 514
(years)
Depreciation period of buildings
20 20 30 29 20 30 32 39 39
(years)
Customs, import tax, etc.
19.0 23.03 0.05 13.0 5.0 0.0 7.0 0.0 0.0
(% of machinery price)
Capital interest rate
14.24 6.154 10.40 12.80 11.00 4.00 4.80 9.30 4.2515
(%)
Raw material costs
(per meter of knitted fabric)
- ring yarn (Single Jersey) 0.446 0.657 0.885 0.474 0.469 0.460 0.474 0.507 0.416
- rotor yarn (Lapique) 0.667 1.007 1.353 0.710 0.702 0.689 0.710 0.770 0.620
- textured yarn (Interlock) 0.366 0.359 0.403 0.3556 0.347 0.414 0.376 0.366 0.43916
Notes
1
Spread from 0.26 0.30 BRL
2
Average for Provinces Jiangsu, Zhejiang and Fujian
3
Only VAT of 17% (local) + import duty
4
1-3 years long term benchmark interest rate for loans
5
Country of origin = EU
6
85 den
7
Remark: Wages in the IPCC 2012 were too low
8
In some regions the VAT is 0%
9
Based on conditions in south-eastern United States
10
Rate for loom technician
11
Includes 25% fringe benefits
12
Average rate for industrial user in South Carolina for 12 month ending 12/31/13
13
Including 70% waste water treatment. For industrial user in Greenville County, S.C.
14
Recovery period (in years) GDS (MACRS)
15
Defined as prime plus 1%. Current as of April 2014. Prime rate effective since Dec 16, 2008
16
115 den POY feed yarn drawn down to 70 den finished yarn
In spinning, revenue from the sale of waste (waste from slivers, filters, flats and grid Waste
droppings, etc.) is considered when calculating waste costs.
Wage costs are calculated on the basis of the wages paid to operatives and to skilled and Labour
unskilled labour for maintenance work. All social charges and shift-work premiums are
included. For reserve personnel a percentage figure is added.
Energy costs include the costs relating to the actual power consumption of the machines, Power
the illumination and the air conditioning (in weaving, also steam and heating). It is assumed
that the mill is lit for the entire production time.
The costs for spare parts, lubricants, cleaning materials and maintenance work on the Auxiliary Material
buildings represent the costs for auxiliary material (in weaving this includes preparation
costs).
This element includes depreciation of machines, accessories and buildings. Machinery costs Depreciation
include free delivery to the mill, erection and - where applic-able - customs duty and taxes.
The sum of the above group of costs gives the total manufacturing costs. Total Manuf. Costs
The sum of the above group of costs gives the total yarn or fabric costs. With regard to total Total Costs
fabric costs one has to bear in mind that these consist of manufacturing costs both in
spinning/texturing and weaving/knitting of one meter fabric plus the respective raw material
costs.
Total manufacturing costs 1.730 1.654 1.498 1.459 1.292 2.866 1.649 1.472 1.700
(USD per kg of yarn)
Index (Italy: 100) (60) (58) (52) (51) (45) (100) (58) (51) (59)
Total manufacturing costs 0.722 0.712 0.653 0.623 0.557 1.107 0.656 0.610 0.662
(USD per kg of yarn)
Index (Italy: 100) (65) (64) (59) (56) (50) (100) (59) (55) (60)
Total manufacturing costs 0.490 0.400 0.340 0.410 0.400 0.860 0.550 0.520 0.550
(USD per kg)
Index (Italy: 100) (57) (47) (38) (46) (45) (100) (64) (60) (64)
Total manufacturing costs 0.312 0.274 0.198 0.235 0.186 0.665 0.326 0.268 0.342
(USD per meter of fabric)
Index (Italy: 100) (47) (41) (30) (35) (28) (100) (49) (40) (51)
Total manufacturing costs 0.301 0.264 0.197 0.227 0.174 0.636 0.338 0.274 0.337
(USD per meter of fabric)
Index (Italy: 100) (47) (42) (31) (36) (27) (100) (53) (43) (53)
Total manufacturing costs 0.430 0.352 0.242 0.298 0.256 0.831 0.402 0.325 0.501
(USD per meter of fabric)
Index (Italy: 100) (52) (42) (29) (36) (31) (100) (49) (39) (60)
Total manufacturing costs 0.039 0.029 0.036 0.025 0.022 0.098 0.045 0.027 0.049
(USD per meter of fabric)
Index (Italy: 100) (40) (30) (37) (26) (22) (100) (46) (28) (50)
Total manufacturing costs 0.049 0.035 0.045 0.031 0.025 0.122 0.056 0.033 0.061
(USD per meter of fabric)
Index (Italy: 100) (40) (29) (37) (25) (20) (100) (46) (27) (50)
Total manufacturing costs 0.096 0.068 0.098 0.063 0.053 0.202 0.099 0.063 0.103
(USD per meter of fabric)
Index (Italy: 100) (47) (34) (49) (31) (26) (100) (49) (31) (51)
Total yarn costs 3.670 4.510 5.345 3.519 3.332 4.866 3.708 3.677 3.509
(per kg of yarn)
Index (Italy: 100) (75) (93) (110) (72) (68) (100) (76) (76) (72)
Total yarn costs 2.586 3.523 4.433 2.607 2.519 3.030 2.640 2.760 2.393
(per kg of yarn)
Index (Italy: 100) (85) (116) (146) (86) (83) (100) (87) (91) (79)
Total yarn costs 2.240 2.120 2.270 2.110 2.060 2.840 2.350 2.270 2.650
(per kg of yarn)
Index (Italy: 100) (79) (74) (79) (74) (72) (100) (83) (80) (93)
Total fabric costs 1.010 1.132 1.214 0.904 0.819 1.589 1.031 0.967 1.009
(USD per meter of fabric)
Index (Italy: 100) (64) (71) (76) (57) (52) (100) (65) (61) (63)
Total fabric costs 0.942 1.137 1.297 0.874 0.840 1.387 0.992 0.957 0.931
(USD per meter of fabric)
Index (Italy: 100) (68) (82) (93) (63) (61) (100) (72) (69) (67)
Total fabric costs 0.667 0.576 0.482 0.523 0.474 1.135 0.653 0.567 0.782
(USD per meter of fabric)
Index (Italy: 100) (59) (51) (42) (46) (42) (100) (57) (50) (69)
Total fabric costs 0.883 1.067 1.266 0.834 0.788 1.217 0.898 0.873 0.856
(USD per meter of fabric)
Index (Italy: 100) (73) (88) (104) (69) (65) (100) (74) (72) (70)
Total fabric costs 0.974 1.297 1.632 0.964 0.926 1.207 1.001 1.021 0.918
(USD per meter of fabric)
Index (Italy: 100) (81) (107) (135) (80) (77) (100) (83) (85) (76)
Total fabric costs 0.564 0.511 0.570 0.502 0.484 0.796 0.590 0.537 0.657
(USD per meter of fabric)
Index (Italy: 100) (70) (64) (71) (63) (60) (100) (73) (67) (82)
The separate presentation in this study of depreciation and interest costs makes it
possible to calculate company-specific capital costs. Note that the share of machinery in
total depreciation in spinning varies from 85% - 95% in the different countries and that
for weaving from 80% - 90%, whereas the machinery part makes up more than 95% of
total depreciation in knitting. The remainder is for accessories and buildings.
Interest Costs
Weaving Ring Yarn
Company-specific interest costs per meter/fabric: USD 0.022 x 9.0 / 4.25 = USD 0.047