Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
(12) E U R O P E A N PATENT S P E C I F I C A T I O N
(54) METHOD AND DISPERSANTS FOR PRODUCTION OF HIGH SOLIDS AQUEOUS CALCIUM
CARBONATE SUSPENSIONS
VERFAHREN UND DISPERGIERMITTEL FUR DIE HERSTELLUNG VON WASSRIGEN
KALZIUMKARBONATSUSPENSIONEN MIT HOHEM FESTSTOFFGEHALT
PROCEDE ET DISPERSANTS SERVANT A LA PRODUCTION DE SUSPENSIONS AQUEUSES DE
CARBONATES DE CALCIUM A HAUTE TENEUR EN MATIERES SOLIDES
DO
CO
00
o
00
^>
lO Note: Within nine months from the publication of the mention of the grant of the European patent, any person may give
notice to the European Patent Office of opposition to the European patent granted. Notice of opposition shall be filed in
o
a written reasoned statement. It shall not be deemed to have been filed until the opposition fee has been paid. (Art.
a.
99(1) European Patent Convention).
LU
Printed byJouve, 75001 PARIS(FR)
1 EP 0 548 086 B1 2
2
3 EP 0 548 086 B1 4
mally associated with slurry aging is avoided. pane sulfonic acid) and 99 to 25% by weight acrylic acid,
It is a further object of the invention, to provide a having a molecular weight in the range 1,000 to 20,000
method of the foregoing character wherein the disper- (preferably 2,000 to 6,000). Dispersant polymers of this
sant utilized is such that in practice of the method, the type are more fully described in European Patent Pub-
same outstanding results are achieved at lower dosage 5 lications Nos. 0.129329, 0.108842, and U.S. Patent No.
rates, and without undue sensitivity to excess dosage 4,509,987. Also see Japanese Patent Publication
levels. 160062/80 (Application 54274/79). Such an unneutral-
A yet further object of the invention, is to provide ized acidic starting polymer, in accordance with the
new dispersing compositions which are highly useful in present invention, is partially neutralized with monova-
producing high solids slurries of mineral particles, such 10 lent cations, such that 50 to 70% of the carboxylic acid
as a calcium carbonate slurry, which slurries are stable sites are neutralized. Thereafter, the remaining such
over very long periods of time. carboxylic acid sites are neutralized with polyvalent cat-
ion. Such a product of the invention will from time to time
Summary of Invention in this specification be referred to as a sulfonated mixed
is cation carboxylic acid group neutralized dispersant (or
Now in accordance with the present invention, the briefly an "SMC" dispersant).
foregoing objects and others as will become apparent In a typical procedure in accordance with the inven-
in the course of the ensuing specification, are achieved tion, a coarse natural calcium carbonate (e.g. one which
in a method for producing a stable, high solids aqueous has been classified to 60% < 2u.m) is wet sand ground
slurry of a fine particle sized particulate mineral, such 20 at high solids, in the presence of the SMC dispersant,
as a calcium carbonate. According to the method, aslur- to 90% < 2u.m, after which the sand is removed by
ry is formed by dispersing in water at least 70% by screening. Depending upon the solids content during
weight of a finely divided mineral particulate, utilizing as grinding, a filtration step may be used to achieve the
a dispersing agent from 8,93 to 15, 18 kg/t (20 to 34 lbs/ final desired high solids slurry.
ton) dry mineral (expressed on the basis of 40% ac- 25 The SMC dispersant used in the media grinding is
tives), and preferably from 9,82 to 10,71 kg/t (22 to 24 previously prepared by reacting the selected polyvalent
lbs/ton) dry mineral (expressed on the basis of 40% ac- and monovalent cation with the free acid sulfonated co-
tives), of a water soluble copolymer of acrylic acid and polymer described above, in ratios appropriate to yield
a sulfonated vinyl monomer, which polymer is converted a carboxylic acid group neutralized copolymer, with 50
to the salt form by from about 30 to 50% by weight of its 30 to 70% of the carboxyl groups being converted to salt
carboxylic acid sites being neutralized by a polyvalent form by monovalent cation, and the balance of the car-
cation, with substantially the balance of the said carbox- boxyl groups being converted by polyvalent cation.
ylic acid sites being neutralized with a monovalent cat- The dispersants of the invention can be used to ef-
ion. The carboxylic acid sites of the resulting copolymer fectively and stably disperse other fine particle sized
are therefore fully neutralized. The polyvalent cation can 35 mineral particulates in addition to calcium carbonates,
be calcium, aluminum or magnesium, and preferably is including, for example, kaolins, talcs and gypsum.
calcium. Preferably from about 35 to 45% of the carbox-
ylic acid sites are neutralized with the polyvalent cation. Brief Description of the Drawings
The monovalent cation is preferably sodium; but other
monovalent cations can be utilized. To achieve these 40 In the drawings herein:
purposes, such compounds as calcium hydroxide and
sodium hydroxide may be used. FIGURE 1 is a graph of viscosity as a function of
Where the method is used to prepare high solids time for a high solids calcium carbonate slurry pre-
(greater than 70%) slurries of calcium carbonates, the pared according to the present invention, utilizing
dispersed material will have a PSD (particle size distri- 45 various dosage levels of an SMC dispersant;
bution) such that at least 90% by weight of the particles FIGURE 2 is a graph similar to Figure 1, showing
have an ESD (equivalent spherical diameter) of less corresponding data for a further SMC dispersant;
than 2um The slurry of such a particulate can be formed FIGURE 3 is a graph similar to Figures 1 and 2, but
by wet media grinding a relatively coarse feed calcium depicting viscosities achieved in high solids calcium
carbonate in the presence of the dispersant; the grinding 50 so carbonate slurries for three different SMC disper-
can be accomplished at a wide range of solids, e.g. as sants as a function of time, with the dosage level
low as 15%, with the solids being adjusted by filtration being fixed;
to the desired final product requirements. FIGURES 4 and 5 are graphs similar to Figure 3,
The sulfonated dispersing agent used in this inven- but showing viscosities achieved where the prod-
tion, is prepared from a starting sulfonated copolymer 55 ucts of the invention are used, as compared to use
of the type mentioned above, which more specifically of prior art products; and
comprises a copolymer of from 1 to 75% (preferably 5 FIGURE 6 is a graph similar to Figure 4, showing
to 10%) by weight AMPS (2-acrylamido 2-methyl pro- the viscosities achieved where the same series of
3
5 EP 0 548 086 B1 6
products are evaluated for 21 day stability over a ages as low as 8,93 kg/t (20 lbs/ton). In fact, highly sta-
range of dosage levels. ble slurries were obtained for the four tests shown at
8,93 kg/t, 9,82 kg/t, 10,71 kg/t, and 12,50 kg/t (20 lbs/
Description of Preferred Embodiment ton, 22 lbs/ton, 24 lbs/ton, and 28 lbs/ton). Only the 8,04
5 kg/t (18 lbs/ton) dosage rate yielded viscosities outside
The invention is further illustrated by the following the desirable range, i.e. less than 20,000 CPS. The
examples. SMC 60/20 dispersant is considered relatively optimal
for use in the present invention.
Example I
10 Example IV
Three different SMC dispersants were prepared by
dissolving the unneutralized acidic sulfonated copoly- In this Example, the three dispersants prepared in
mer in water and adding NaOH and Ca(OH)2 in ratios Example I were used in preparation of a series of 75%
to result in products which contain respectively 50, 60, solids calcium carbonate aqueous slurries using in each
and 70% carboxylic acid groups that are neutralized with is instance a dosage of 9,82 kg/t (22 lbs/ton). The Helipath
sodium, with the remaining carboxylic acid groups neu- viscosity in CPS was evaluated for each of the slurries
tralized with calcium. These will be referred to in the en- as a function of aging. The results are shown in Figure
suing Examples as SMC 50/25, SMC 60/20, and SMC 3. It will be seen that only the SMC 60/20 in this instance
70/1 5. The starting polymer in this example was the so- yielded viscosities in the desired range, in fact an out-
dium neutralized DP 2020 product of Allied Colloids of 20 standingly stable product over the entire 21 day period,
Great Britain, which was converted to the acid form by with virtually no increase in viscosity.
ion exchange. This copolymer contained 8% sulfonate
groups (AMPS) and 92% acrylic groups in the copoly- Example V
mer backbone as determined by Carbon - 13 nuclear
magnetic resonance studies. 25 In this Example, a series of five different disper-
sants, including the SMC 60/20 product of the present
Exemple II invention were evaluated at 9,82 kg/t (22 lbs/ton) dos-
age in 75% solids calcium carbonate slurries prepared
The SMC 50/25 dispersant of Example I was used as in Example II. All five dispersants included 40% ac-
in the preparation of a series of 75% solids calcium car- 30 fives. Stability in terms of viscosities was evaluated over
bonate aqueous slurries in which the dosage rate was a 21 day period for each of the five products. The five
varied from 8,04 kg/t to 12,50 kg/t (18 lbs/ton to 28 lbs/ dispersants, identified as Nos. 1-5, are as follows: Dis-
ton) based on dry carbonate solids. The dispersant dose persant No. 1 is the Dispex N40 product of Allied Col-
levels include 40% active polymer and 60% water. All loids, of Great Britain, being the conventional water sol-
dosage levels in this specification are based on this ra- 35 uble salts of polyacrylic or polymethacrylic acid or de-
tio. The slurries were prepared by sand media grinding rivatives, of the type described e.g. in British Patent
of a 60% < 2u.m calcium carbonate to 90% < 2u.m in the Specification No. 1,414,964. Dispersant 2 is an im-
presence of the SMC dispersant. The resultant proved product of Allied Colloids understood to be of the
screened (to remove sand) slurries were evaluated for type described in European Patent Publication No.
slurry stability over a 21 day period. Stability was deter- 40 0129329 (discussed previously herein). Dispersant 3 is
mined by measuring viscosities using a Brookfield Heli- a product of Coatex S.A. of Caluire, France, believed to
path Viscometer fitted with a T-bar. The resulting data be of the type described in U.S. Patent No. 4,775,420,
is shown in Figure 1 which plots viscosity in CPS against previously discussed herein. Dispersant No. 4 is a fully
days of aging. In general, a viscosity above 20,000 CPS neutralized sulfonated polymer (i.e. neutralized with so-
is unacceptable for shipping purposes. Accordingly, it 45 dium cation only) as described in U.S. Patent No.
will be seen that only the 10,71 kg/t (24 lbs/ton) and 4,509,987. Dispersant No. 5 is the SMC 60/20 product
12,50 kg/t (28 lbs/ton) dosage levels are acceptable. of the present invention, previously referred to. The re-
However, these are seen to produce virtually flat curves sults of these tests are shown in Figures 4 and 5. The
over the entire 21 day period, an outstanding result. use of the prior art products of dispersants 1 and 3 yield
so
50 results that are completely unacceptable over the entire
Example III period of evaluation. Dispersants 2, 4 and 5 are all found
to yield acceptable results up to 14 days. However, of
The SMC 60/20 dispersant of Example I was used the entire group of dispersants evaluated, only the prod-
in the preparation of a further series of 75% solids cal- uct of the invention, i.e. dispersant 5, is found to yield
cium carbonate aqueous slurries as described in Exam- 55 an entirely acceptable, indeed remarkably outstanding
ple II. The resulting data is shown in Figure 2 which plots result, over the entire period extending up to 21 days.
viscosity as in Example I. It will be seen that in this in-
stance a highly time-stable slurry was obtained for dos-
4
7 EP 0 548 086 B1 8
5
9 EP 0 548 086 B1 10
gen waBrigen Schlammung aus teilchenformigem gangsmaterial zu mindestens 60% kleiner als 2u.m
Calciumcarbonat, die eine gro(3e Alterungsbestan- ist.
digkeit zeigt, umfassend das Dispergieren von fein
zerteiltem, teilchenformigem Calciumcarbonat in 13. Polymeres Dispersionsmittel zur Herstellung von
Wasser mit einer Feststoffkonzentration von minde- 5 hoch feststoffhaltigen, alterungsbestandigen
stens 70 Gew.%, wobei pro Tonne trockener Car- waBrigen Aufschlammungen von fein bemessenen
bonate als Dispersionsmittel 8,93 bis 15,18 kg (20 Mineralteilchen, umfassend ein Copolymer aus
bis 34 lbs - bezogen auf das Wirkmaterial) eines Co- Acrylsaure und sulfoniertem Vinylmonomer, bei
polymers aus Acrylsaure und sulfoniertem Vinylmo- dem 30 bis 50% der sauren Carboxylstellen in die
nomer verwandt wird, in dem 30 bis 50% der sauren 10 Salzform umgewandelt sind durch Neutralisation
Carboxylstellen durch Neutralisation mit einem po- mit einem polyvalenten Kation und die restlichen
lyvalenten Kation in die Salzform umgewandelt sind Carboxylstellen im wesentlichen neutralisiert sind
und die restlichen Carboxylstellen im wesentlichen durch ein monovalentes Kation.
neutralisiert sind mit einem monovalenten Kation .
is 14. Dispersionsmittel nach Anspruch 13, wobei das Co-
2. Verfahren nach Anspruch 1, wobei das Copolymer polymer ein Polymerisationsprodukt ist aus 1 bis 75
ein Polymerisationsprodukt ist aus 1 bis 75 Gew.%, Gew.% AMPS und 99 bis 25 Gew.% Acrylsaure und
2-Acrylamid-2-methylpropan-sulfonsaure (AMPS) ein Molekulargewicht im Bereich von 2000 bis 6000
und 99 bis 25 Gew.% Acrylsaure und ein Moleku- hat.
largewicht hat im Bereich von 1000 bis 20000. 20
15. Dispersionsmittel nach Anspruch 14, das 5 bis 10%
3. Verfahren nach Anspruch 2, wobei 5 bis 10% AMPS AMPS enthalt.
enthalten sind.
6. Verfahren nach Anspruch 1, wobei das polyvalente disperser dans I'eau du carbonate de calcium
Kation Calcium ist und 35 bis 45% der sauren Stel- particulaire finement divise de facon a atteindre
len durch Calcium neutralisiert sind. 35 une concentration en matieres solides d'au
moins 70% en poids, en utilisant en tant
7. Verfahren nach Anspruch 2, wobei das polyvalente qu'agent de dispersion de 8,93 a 15,18 kg (20
Kation Calcium ist und 35 bis 45% der sauren Stel- a 34 lbs exprime sur la base d'une activite de
len durch Calcium neutralisiert sind. 40%) par tonne (ton) de carbonates sees, d'un
40 copolymere d'acide acrylique et d'un monome-
8. Verfahren nach Anspruch 1, wobei das monovalen- re vinylique sulfone, qui est converti sous forme
te Kation Natrium ist. de sel, de 30 a 50% de ses sites acides car-
boxyliques etant neutralises par un cation po-
9. Verfahren nach Anspruch 2, wobei das monovalen- lyvalent, et le reste desdits sites acides car-
te Kation Natrium ist. 45 boxyliques etant essentiellement neutralise par
un cation monovalent.
10. Verfahren nach Anspruch 1, wobei das teilchenfor-
mige Calciumcarbonat einen solchen PSD hat, dal3 2. Procede selon la revendication 1 dans lequel ledit
mindestens 90 Gew.% der Teilchen kleiner sind als copolymere est un produit de polymerisation de 1 a
2u.m Kugelaquivalentdurchmesser. so 75% en poids d'acide 2-acrylamido-2-methylpropa-
ne sulfonique (AMPS) et de 99 a 25% en poids
11. Verfahren nach Anspruch 10, wobei die Schlam- d'acide acrylique, ledit copolymere presentant une
mung durch Mahlen eines anfanglich groben Aus- masse moleculaire comprise entre 1000 et 20 000.
gangs-Calciumcarbonats in Gegenwart des Disper-
sionsmittels hergestellt wird, urn ein fein zerteiltes 55 3. Procede selon la revendication 2, dans lequel on
Teilchenmaterial zu erhalten. utilise de 5 a 10% dudit AMPS.
12. Verfahren nach Anspruch 11 , wobei das grobe Aus- 4. Procede selon la revendication 1, dans lequel ledit
6
11 EP 0 548 086 B1 12
cation polyvalent est choisi dans le groupe consti- 5 a 10% dudit AMPS,
tue du calcium, de I'aluminium et du magnesium.
7
: :' :'
i \ i i i i i
: :\ -I : : ;\ : <^ & !
: i \: : : : \ : H
M K m n \ i
; j i i j ; i ^35
l-L-U-t--l o
o o o o o
i o o
o o o o o
o o <3
5 O O O O O O
; o" o o o o o
o <N
b ^ CM O CD UD
8
"1
I \ \ \ ! i l l 11
] j
i
: ra
O r
3 ; 1 T :
? ;
(N
_ 10 in
M M M M
*.
t4 : :
* .'
H I
\ :
. :
:
* ; :
: \ :
: :
* : :
* :
: ^
\
' ;
i $ M
'. '\
t \ :
: * :
: *
: :
:> *:
t: t
: *5
:
I I k
: : \\
;
: \i
L_J o
D O
D
D
D
N
: : : : : : : : : : *n
: : : : : : : : : : : : : :
: : : : : : : : : : : : T
M M M M M s j i S
M M \ h \
M M M /ill -
M M M M M / I \i i s 10
: : : : : : : : : : / : : :<i -53
i : : : : j : : : : / : :\ :! ^- COT
^~
M i i M M ! f i h/i H . q 1
M M M i M j | jii j i ^ Z
N N N i U / 1 ! M n f
s =
: : : : H :*:
l: i - :**:i l : :: 1 m i i n m
M M : \: :\ \: : : : : : : : / : ' LL- K) :
: : : : : : i/: : : : j/ : ^ :
! ! : : : : / ; i : i U l ' Q_(7)
I U ' 1 M M \ x
i : : : i i i 0 ! ; ; j ; i i f cm _ _ J
^
i : M i iM i iM M : ; :
M U W l i l / /i
M ^ ^ i
: : i : :: : : : : :: : : M>'': : X
^ : :; : /'/ : *o"
o . !
: : i i : K : : : : / : , ,
Q-<fl
i M M U " n l / H j j : 22T
: i ! j j ! ! M ! i : j i T3T J .
: : : : j : j : : :: :: : : j :: : j : : : : : j: : : o" 'xT~*
~
i : : : : : : : : j : : : : :
M M M M M M I M L ^ n
! j : : j : j j j m 1 : :
.. j : j_ CO
j : : i: M : ! |j j! i i! ;: :i :1 :i ! i! !i i! ^ Q
: : : : : : : : : : :: : :: : : : : : : -c
! : ! j j j j j\ j : : :j j : j j : : H-
i . i . i . :? M . : . : ,M: ,| ;i M M , i ., M i i : i ;: i : iI : il : m t : il : iill r -
o o o oo oo oo oo oo oo oo oo oo oo oo o o o o Y
o o o oo oo oo oo oo oo oo oo oo oo oo o o o o u
o o o oo oo oo o o o o o o o o o o o o ^ oo o^ oo oo oo o
o " > o " o "o~ , o o~
" d ,o" d ' do~> oo~" ocd' , oo"" oo o o o o o o
o "o~
S ^ C M OOr C a ^O -Ut D
C -Mt CONCj O O lCDO^LCDM ^ COM C OO CLODU^ ^C^ N
Oj
r 0 ^ r O r O CrN
Ol<CNVCj CVMj CCNM | <CNMC,Nr ~j ,Tr ~ , ^ " ,"
- T, r~",,r, ' r"
13