Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Oxidation of Manganese(II)
by Ozone and Reduction of
Manganese(III) by
Hydrogen Peroxide in
Acidic Solution
FRANK JACOBSEN, JERZY HOLCMAN, KNUD SEHESTED
Chemical Reactivity, bld. 313, Ris National Laboratory, DK-4000 Roskilde, Denmark
Received 6 February 1997; accepted 6 July 1997
tron transfer reaction producing Mn(III) and free OH high pressure cell [17] was used at pH 0 1 with
radicals. In all three studies bubbling of oxygen-ozone 30 40 atm O2 pressure. In all pulse radiolysis exper-
mixture in a reactor was applied. Opposite to this view, iments the dose was measured using the hexacyano-
Andreozzi et al. [11,12] claim, based on the study of ferrate(II) dosimeter, (G 5 5.9 and e420 5 1000 M21
Mn catalyzed chain ozonation of oxalic and malonic cm21), containing (2 5) 3 1023 M Fe(CN)62 4.
acid, that no OH radicals are produced in Mn(II) ox-
idation by ozone.
The present article concerns the mechanism of the
reaction between manganese(II) and ozone, the for-
mation of the manganyl ion (MnO21), and the reduc- RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
tion of manganese(III) by hydrogen peroxide in acidic
solution studied by stopped-flow and pulse-radiolysis Experiments with Excess Mn21
techniques. The oxidation of Mn21 by ozone in acid solution (pH
0 2), was investigated by observing the absorption/
time profiles at 200 310 nm, (Fig. 1). The absorption
EXPERIMENTAL spectrum (Fig. 2), obtained in 0.1 M HClO4 with
[Mn21] 5 2.5 3 1022 M and [O3] 5 6.5 3 1025 M at
Materials 257C, is in good agreement with previously published
spectra of Mn(III) [18,19]. The most recent estimate
All solutions were prepared using triply-distilled wa-
[20] of the pK for the first step of Mn(III) hydrolysis
ter. Mn(ClO4)2 hexahydrate (Fluka), MnSO4 mono-
(Mn31 1 H2O : Mn(OH)21 1 H1) is 0.4, hence,
hydrate (BDH Analar), and H2O2 (perhydrol Merck
Mn(OH)21 is the dominant form of Mn(III) in the acid-
p.a.) were of analytical grade and used as supplied.
ity range pH 0 2. Although at stronger acidity a sub-
None of the compounds contained more than 0.005%
stantial part of the Mn(III) is present as Mn31, the ob-
trace metals (Fe, Cu). Perchloric acid (double distilled
served absorption spectra were independent of acidity,
from Vycor, G. Frederick Smith Co.), sulfuric acid and
clearly due to the similarity of the absorption spectra
t-butanol (Merck p.a.), N2O (N40), Ar (N48), and O2
of Mn31 and Mn(OH)21 species [18].
(Dansk Ilt og Brint) were used as supplied.
The absorption spectrum of Mn(III) in H2SO4
solutions (e220 5 5000 6 300 M21 cm21) was not
O3 Measurements significantly different from that in HClO4 solu-
Apparatus
A Hi-tech SF 51 Stopped-flow spectrophotometer
(SFS) with UV and VIS lamps was used. The data
were recorded on a LeCroy 9400 A dual 175 MHz
oscilloscope and analyzed on an on-line IBM PC sys-
tem equipped with a software package for simulation
and analysis [14,15]. The pulse radiolysis set-up con-
sists of a 10 MeV HRC Linac delivering 0.5 3.0 ms
electron pulses into a quartz cell [16]. The optical
detection system was comprised of a 150 W Varian
xenon lamp, a 5.1 cm light-path cell, a Perkin-
Elmer double quartz prism monochromator, a 1P28
photomultiplier, and a LeCroy 9400 digital oscil-
Figure 1 Absorption/time profiles of Mn(III) formation at
loscope. An IBM PC/AT3 computer was used for 240 nm in 0.1 M perchloric acid solution at 257C with var-
data processing. A dose of 10 Gy in a 1ms pulse ious O3 and Mn21 concentrations. (A) [Mn21] 5 1.0 3
was usually applied, but 10 120 Gy in a 1ms pulse 1022 M, [O3] 5 1.05 3 1024 M; (B) [Mn21] 5 1.0 3 short
was used occasionally. To avoid the formation 1022 M, [O3] 5 5.4 3 1025 M, and (C) [Mn21] 5 5.0 3 standard
of Mn(I), by reaction of H atoms with Mn22, the 1023 M, [O3] 5 3.8 3 1025 M. Stopped-flow experiments. long
JCK(Wiley) INTERACTIVE
diated with a 1 ms 10.0 Gy pulse, no formation of Mn(III) ions disproportionate according to reaction
Mn(III) was observed, but the spectrum of the t-bu- (4) [26], and eventually precipitates as MnO2, reaction
tylperoxy radical was obtained. A slow second order (5). The rate of nucleation of MnO2 depends on the
decay of the t-butylperoxy radical by radical-radical Mn21 concentration relative to [Mn(III)], according to:
self reaction was detected (Fig. 3(b)).
These observations clearly demonstrate that the re- 2Mn(III) ;: Mn21 1 Mn(IV) (4)
action between Mn21 and O3 does not involve free OH
radicals and that the t-butylperoxy radical does not Mn(IV) !: MnO2 (5)
react with Mn21 to form Mn(III). We therefore pro-
pose a mechanism based on an oxygen atom transfer The nucleation of colloidal MnO2(s) is seen as an in-
from O3 to Mn21, forming the manganyl ion, crease in absorption above 300 nm. This increase in
MnO21, in analogy to the oxidation of ferrous by absorption is most likely due to light scattering by col-
ozone in which iron(IV), the ferryl ion FeO21, is loidal MnO2 as the spectrum is very broad and shifts
formed [24,25]. A fast reaction of the manganyl ion to the red with time. At higher pH increased rate of
with Mn21 results in Mn(III) as the only product: nucleation was observed in accordance with ref. [23].
At pH . 3.0 in HClO4 solutions, reactions (2) and
Mn21 1 O3 !: MnO21 1 O2 (2) (3) are kinetically inseparable from the precipitation
of MnO2(s) reaction (5), but in H2SO4 solutions at pH
MnO21 1 Mn21 1 2H1 !: 2Mn(III) 1 H2O (3) 3 the precipitation is less advanced as a consequence
of SO422 being a stronger complexing ligand than
In the stopped-flow experiments the apparent pseudo- ClO42 .
first-order rate constant of reaction (2) was pro-
portional to the manganese(II) concentrations,
[Mn21]0 5 (1.0 50.0) 3 1023 M. We ascribe the Experiments with Excess O3
transient buildup of Mn(III) absorption to the consec- When ozone concentrations exceeded stoichiometric
utive reactions (2) and (3). A stoichiometry of 1:2 for amounts, [O3]0 . 0.5 3 [Mn21]0, manganese was ox-
O3 and Mn(III) was obtained from the absorbance idized both to Mn(III) and to Mn(VII), permanganate,
changes at 240 nm. the latter observed at 525 nm. No intermediate step of
From absorption/time profiles at 200 310 nm in the Mn(VII) formation could be detected, which in-
stopped-flow experiments a rate constant k2 5 dicates that one of the initial reactions:
(1.5 6 0.2) 3 103 M21 s21 was determined in HClO4
solution under pseudo-first-order conditions with ex- Mn(III) 1 O3 !: product (6)
cess of Mn21. The rate constant in H2SO4 solution was
not significantly different and k2 5 (1.8 6 0.2) 3 or
103 M21 s21 as measured under pseudo-first-order
conditions. The ratio [Mn21]/[O3] . 10 was kept in Mn(IV) 1 O3 !: product (7)
all experiments. The value of k2 is somewhat lower
than the value k(Mn21 1 O3) 5 3.6 3 103 M21 s21
is the rate determining step. An upper limit for the
obtained by Tyupalo et al. [8] in 11.5 M H2SO4.
overall rate constant k6 # 50 M21 s21 was obtained
The end absorption of the absorption/time profiles
from the buildup of absorption at 525 nm.
of Mn(III) formation, was insensitive to variations in
the initial Mn21 concentration (1.2 100) 3 1024 M at
all wavelengths. On the assumption that the manganyl Activation Energy
ion spectrum is not identical to that of the Mn(III) in
the observed wavelength range or that its extinction The activation energy for reaction (2) was determined
coefficient is significantly different from that of the in HClO4 solutions at pH 0 2, in the temperature
Mn(III), no more than 1 2% of the end-absorption range 0.5 40.07C. The activation energy Ea 5
could be ascribed to manganyl ions in the solution. (39.5 6 4.0) kJ/mol was independent of pH within
Based on this assumption the lowest limit of the sec- this region. From a weighted linear fit of the measure-
ond-order rate constant for reaction (3) is of the order ments over the temperature range, the temperature-de-
of ca. 105 M21 s21. This estimate is in good agreement pendent rate constant may be described by:
with the rate constant measured for the iron analogue,
the ferryl ion in reaction with ferrous, k(FeO21 1 k2 5 (1.2 6 0.1) 3 1010 short
Fe21) 5 (0.9 6 0.1) 3 105 M21 s21 [24,25]. 3 exp((2 39.5 6 4.0)/RT) (Eq. 1) standard
long
JCK(Wiley) INTERACTIVE
Table I The Second-Order Rate Constant k(Mn(III) 1 The authors wish to thank Torben Johansen for skillful op-
H2O2) as a Function of pH in Perchloric Acid Solutions eration of the linear accelerator. Financial support from the
at 257C Commission of the European Communities within the En-
vironmental research program (contract RINOXA EV-ct93-
pH k(Mn(III) 1 H2O2) 3 1024 M21 s21
0317) is gratefully acknowledged.
0 0.25
0.4 0.3*
1.0 0.28 BIBLIOGRAPHY
2.0 0.3
2.9 4.8
1. T. E. Graedel, M. L. Mandich, and C. L. Weschler, J.
3.2 4.5
Geophys. Res., 91, D4. 5205 (1986).
3.4 5.5
2. C. Brandt and R. Eldik, Chem. Rev., 95, 119 (1995).
3.85 6.7
3. J. Berglund, L. I. Elding, G. V. Buxton, S. McGowan
4.85 8.4
and G. A. Salmon, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 90,
10.0*
3309 (1994).
5.2 11.0
4. C. S. Loranger and J. Zayed, J. Atmos. Environ., 28,
* In H2SO4 . 1645 (1994).
5. D. L. Lenane, B. F. Fort, G. L. Terhaar, D. R. Lynam,
and G. D. Pfeifer, Sci. Tot. Environ., 147, 245 (1994);
D. R. Lynam, G. D. Pfeifer, B. F. Fort, G. L. Ter Haar,
of magnitude higher than our value of k(Mn(III) 1 and D. P. Hollrah, Sci. Tot. Environ., 147, 103 (1994);
H2O2). This discrepancy can be explained by the fact USEPA (1990) Office of research and development, En-
that Davies et al. [29] obtained both rate constants as vironmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle
forward rates of the assumed equilibrium in reaction Park, North Carolina, U.S.A.
(8) and that the [Mn(III)]0/[Mn21]0 ratio used is more 6. S. Joselow, E. Tobias, R. Koehler, J. Bogden and D.
than an order of magnitude higher than ours. Gause, Am. J. Public. Hlth., 68, 557 (1978).
At higher pHs the Mn(III) 1 H2O2 reaction rate 7. G. L. Ter Haar, M. E. Griffing, M. Brandt, D. G. Ob-
became independent of the dose or of initial ozone erding and M. Kapron, J. Air. Pollut. Control. Ass., 25,
concentration and the kinetics comply closely to first- 858 (1975).
8. N. F. Tyuopalo and V. A. Yakobi, Russian Journal of
order kinetics. The rate constant increases with pH and
Inorganic Chemistry., 26, 6 (1980).
is a factor of about 30 higher at pH 5 (Table I). This
9. H. L. Sheng, J. Chem. Tech. Biotechnol., 56, 163
increase is ascribed to a shift in the Mn(III) hydrolysis (1993).
from Mn(OH)21 to Mn(OH)12 where the latter reacts 10. A. A. Grinberg, E. A. Shashukov, N. N. Popova and V.
much faster with H2O2 and possibly also influences E. Vyatkin, Kinet. Catal., 12, 489 (1977).
the equilibrium reaction (4). 11. R. Andreozzi, V. Caprio, M. G. DAmore and A. Insola,
Oxid. Commun., 16, 96 (1993).
12. R. Andreozzi, V. Caprio, M. G. DAmore, and A. In-
sola. Wat. Res., 26, 917 (1992).
13. E. J. Hart, K. Sehested, and J. Holcman, J. Anal. Chem.,
55, 46 (1983).
CONCLUSION 14. O. Rasmussen and E. Bjergbakke, Ris-R-395; Ris
National Laboratory: Roskilde, Denmark. 1984.
Manganese(II) reacts with ozone via an oxygen-atom 15. E. Bjergbakke, K. Sehested, O. Rasmussen, and H.
transfer forming the manganyl ion without formation Christensen, Ris-m-2430; Ris National Laboratory:
of free OH radicals. If Mn21, O3 and H2O2 are simul- Roskilde, Denmark. 1984.
taneously present, ozone oxidizes Mn21 to Mn(III) by 16. K. Sehested, H. Corfitzen, H. Christensen and E. J. Hart,
reaction (2) and (3), while H2O2 reduces Mn(III) back J. Phys. Chem., 79, 310 (1975).
17. H. Christensen and K. Sehested, Radiat. Phys. Chem.,
to Mn21, reaction (8). An otherwise slow and pH de-
16, 183 (1980).
pendent reaction O3 1 H2O2, is, in the presence of
18. G. Davies, Coord. Chem. Rev., 4, 199 (1969).
Mn21, accelerated by a catalytic chain destruction of 19. D. E. Cabelli and B. H. J. Bielski, J. Phys. Chem., 88,
ozone and hydrogen peroxide which will proceeds un- 3111 (1984).
til one of the oxidants is practically exhausted. Thus, 20. G. Bidermann and R. Palombari, Acta Chem. Scand., A
the presence of manganese in the tropospheric liquid 32, 381. (1978).
phase can result in a reduction of the oxidation capac- 21. F. Jacobsen, J. Holcman and K. Sehested, J. Phys.
ity of the troposphere. Chem. A, 101, 1324 (1997). short
standard
long
JCK(Wiley) INTERACTIVE
22. M. Pick-Kaplan and J. Rabani, J. Phys. Chem., 80, 1840 26. J. Berglund, S. Fronaeus and L. I. Elding, Inorg. Chem.,
(1976). 32, 4527 (1993).
23. S. Baral, C. Lumee-Pereira, E. Janata and A. Henglein, 27. B. H. J. Bielski, D. E. Cabelli and A. Ross, J. Phys.
J. Phys. Chem., 90, 6025 (1986). Chem. Ref. Data., 14, 4 (1985).
24. T. Lgager, J. Holcman, K. Sehested and T. Pedersen, 28. H. Diebler and N. Sutin. J. Phys. Chem. 68 174 (1964).
Inorg. Chem., 31, 3523 (1992). 29. G. Davies, L. J. Kirschenbaum and K. Kustin, Inorg.
25. F. Jacobsen, J. Holcman and K. Sehested, J. Chem. Ki- Chem, 7, 146 (1976).
net., 29, 17 (1997).
short
standard
long