Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/280733652
READS
61
3 authors, including:
All in-text references underlined in blue are linked to publications on ResearchGate, Available from: Sang D. Choi
letting you access and read them immediately. Retrieved on: 07 June 2016
Literature Review
Peer-Reviewed
Musculoskeletal
Disorders
in Construction
Practical Solutions From the Literature
By Sang D. Choi, Lu Yuan and James G. Borchardt
C
onstruction is one of the largest indus- on body tissues; vibration from tools and machin-
tries in the U.S. and it is a vital part of the ery; and environmental factors such as extreme
nations economy. Construction employment temperatures and humidity. Laborers Health &
is expected to grow by approximately 2 million wage- Safety Fund of North America (LHSFNA, 2006)
and-salary jobs between 2010 and 2020, more than reports that 40% of construction workers surveyed
double the growth rate projected for the overall U.S. said working while hurt reduces productivity and
economy (CPWR, 2013). The industry results in disabling injuries. Sprains/strains, low
IN BRIEF consistently ranks among the most haz- back pain, and neck/shoulder and knee injuries are
This review study addresses ardous occupations and it accounts for a common MSDs in the construction industry.
work-related musculoskeletal disproportionately large percentage of Contractors and workers are searching for evi-
injuries and disorders and all work-related injuries and illnesses. dence of potential, cost-effective solutions that do
practical solutions in seven Work-related musculoskeletal disor- not slow the job or reduce productivity (Schneider,
construction trades/occupa- ders (WMSDs) and injuries are among 2012). Protecting construction workers from ergo-
tions (carpenters, masons, the most frequently reported causes of nomic hazards that contribute to WMSDs is a grow-
electricians, sheet metal lost or restricted work time, accounting ing concern. In 2007, ANSI/ASSE A10.40, Reduction
workers, roofers, ironworkers, for 33% of all injury and illness cases of Musculoskeletal Problems in Construction, was
plumbers). (OSHA, 2015). MSDs involve the mus- adopted; it was reaffirmed in 2013. NIOSHs Nation-
By identifying risk factors for cles, nerves, tendons, joints, cartilage al Occupational Research Agenda (NORA) began in
these injuries and disorders, and supporting structures of the upper 1996 and the Construction Agenda was established
OSH professionals can offer and lower limbs, neck and lower back; in 2008. Its Strategic Goal 7.0 is to reduce the in-
effective interventions to meet they are caused, precipitated or exacer- cidence and severity of work-related MSDs among
the challenges that contrac- bated by sudden exertion or prolonged construction workers in the U.S. (NORA, 2014).
tors face in the field. exposure to physical factors such as Each construction trade utilizes different skills
The simple good practices high force, repetition, awkward body and completes different tasks. Some jobs/tasks
solutions summarized can help posture or vibration (NIOSH, 2015). require employees to work close to the ground or
mitigate potential ergonomic Construction work often involves floor, while others require performing overhead
hazards and increase produc- forceful exertions that are excessive or tasks. The nature of physical work and character-
tivity at construction job sites. prolonged, such as heavy manual lift- istics of the specific job sites or trades can expose
ing or prolonged grasping; awkward employees to various ergonomic risks and hazards
body postures maintained for extended that could result in different WMSDs and injuries.
periods; pressure from hard surfaces or sharp edges This article reviews and synthesizes the findings of
Sang D. Choi, Ph.D., CSP, CPE, is a professor and director of the Ergonomics and Safety from University of Massachusetts Lowell. He
graduate program in University of Wisconsin-Whitewaters Depart- is a professional member of ASSEs Greater Baton Rouge and New Or-
ment of occupational and environmental safety and health. He holds leans chapters and a member of ASSEs Academics Practice Specialty.
a Ph.D. in Industrial Engineering from Western Michigan University. He was named ASSEs Outstanding Safety Educator in 2015.
Choi is a professional member of ASSEs Wisconsin Chapter and he
is the editor of the Journal of Safety, Health and Environmental Research, James G. Borchardt, CSP, CPE, CRIS, CPSM, has 45 years OSH
published by ASSEs Academics Practice Specialty. experience in industrial settings and the construction insurance in-
dustry. He has been home office technical advisor of construction and
Lu Yuan, Sc.D., CSP, is an associate professor at and coordinator of industrial risk control services for a national insurance company. He is
the occupational safety, health and environment program in South- also principal/managing consultant for Construction Ergonomics LLC.
eastern Louisiana Universitys Department of Computer Science He is a professional member of ASSEs Quad Cities Chapter and a
and Industrial Technology. Yuan holds an Sc.D. in Occupational member of several ASSE practice specialties.
Construction-Related
Musculoskeletal Problems
Following is a summary of MSD hazards and
risks faced by workers in seven construction trades/
occupations 1) carpenters; 2) cement masons and
terrazzo workers; 3) electricians; 4) sheet metal
workers; 5) roofers; 6) ironworkers;
and 7) plumbers/pipefitters/steam-
fitters. These trades conduct tasks
that pose well-documented risks of
WMSDs and injuries.
Carpenters
Carpenters make up the
largest proportion of build-
ing trades occupations. They
work both indoors and out-
doors, and are involved
in many types of con-
struction, from building
highways and bridges to
installing kitchen cabinets.
Carpenters have a higher
rate of injury and illness
istockphoto.com/Catalin205
Table 1
Work-Related Musculoskeletal
Problems & Solutions in Construction
Trade/
occupation
Task
condition
WMSD
risk
Body
part
affected
Practical
solutions
Carpenters
Overhead
work
Forceful
exertion
Back
Pneumatic
drywall
finishing
system,
Ground/floor-level
work
Awkward
body
postures
Neck
T-brace
or
panel
lift
Hand-intensive
work
Pressure/pinch
points
Shoulders
Power
vacuum
lifter
Manual
material
handling
Hot/cold
temperatures
Fingers/hands/wrists
Ergonomic
hand
tools
(e.g.,
easy-
Knees
hold
glove
attached
to
the
mud
pan;
screw
gun
with
an
extension)
Store
materials
off
the
ground
between
knee
and
chest
height
Work
site
stretch
and
flex
exercise
Masons
Ground/floor-level
work
Force
Back
(low
back)
Split-level
adjustable
scaffolding
Manual
material
handling
Awkward
postures
Legs/knees
Limiting
the
weight
of
items
or
team
Work
in
static
position
Neck
lifting
Pressure/pinch
points
Shoulders
Ergonomic
tools
(e.g.,
kneeling
Hot/cold
temperatures
creeper)
Work
site
stretch
and
flex
exercise
Lightweight
concrete
block
Skid
plates
(hose
placing
discs)
Electricians
Overhead
work
Force
(pushing/pulling
wires,
Back
Mechanical
lifting
equipment
or
Ground/floor-level
work
bending
conduits)
Neck/shoulders
transport
devices
Hand-intensive
work
Awkward
body
postures
Wrists/hands/wrists
Ergonomic
hand
tools
(powered
or
Manual
material
handling
Pressure/pinch
points
ratcheting
tools)
Hot/cold
temperatures
Lightweight
material
or
team
lifting
Mechanical
wire
puller
Work
site
stretching
program
Sheet
metal
Overhead
work
Force
Back
Using
powered
vacuum
lift
workers
Ground/floor-level
work
Awkward
postures
Wrists/hands
Use
the
right
size
and
type
of
snip
Hand-intensive
work
Work
in
static
position
Knees
(e.g.,
tapping
into
duct
using
upright
Manual
material
handling
Pressure/pinch
points
Neck/shoulders
snip)
Hot/cold
temperatures
Ergonomic
hand
tools
(e.g.,
a
bit
extension
shaft
or
an
extension
pole)
Work
site
stretch
and
flex
exercise
Roofers
Sloped/elevated-level
work
Force
Back
Limiting
the
weight
of
materials
or
Manual
material
handling
Awkward
body
postures
Neck/shoulders
team
lifting
Pressure/pinch
points
Fingers/hands/wrists
Ergonomic
hand
tools
(e.g.,
reduced
Hot/cold
temperatures
Knees
vibration
power
tools
with
Vibration
Ankles/feet
antivibration
gloves)
Work
site
stretch
and
flex
exercise
Ironworkers
Ground/floor-
or
elevated-level
work
Awkward
body
postures
Back
Power
rebar
tiers
Hand-intensive
work
Force
Neck/shoulders
Site-specific
ergonomics
programs
Manual
material
handling
Work
in
static
position
Elbows
Ergonomic
hand
tools
(e.g.,
rebar-
Hot/cold
temperatures
Wrists/hands
tying
tool)
Knees
Work
site
stretch
and
flex
exercise
Plumbers,
Ground/floor-level
work
Force
(upper
extremities)
Back
Use
a
bit
extension
shaft
pipefitters,
Overhead
work
Awkward
postures
Neck/shoulders
Ergonomic
hand
tools
steamfitters
Hand-intensive
work
Work
in
same
(static)
position
Elbows
Work
site
stretch
and
flex
exercise
Manual
material
handling
Pressure/pinch
points
Wrists/hands
Hot/cold
temperatures
Knees
30 ProfessionalSafety JANUARY 2016 www.asse.org
ger. Activating a larger trigger requires the worker practices (Borchardt & Choi, 2012; Choi, Borchardt
to use multiple fingers, which reduces stress on any & Proksch, 2012; NIOSH, 2007, 2013a, b).
one finger. More efforts to translate research into practice are
Changing the design of the tools handle can needed in order to examine the effectiveness of solu-
help prevent ergonomic injuries as well (Choi, et al., tions (including productivity and cost savings). This
2007; LHSFNA, 2006). For example, drywall work- might involve, for example, executing a pilot cam-
ers can use easy-hold gloves attached to mud pans. paign in one trade, developing contractor success
These are not just any type of gloves; they are two stories, and increasing education and awareness. In
specific gloves. The first glove helps hold a mud pan the Netherlands, a 2-year follow-up study on a na-
while an employee is applying drywall compound tional ergonomics campaign found an increased use
(Albers & Estill, 2007). The second glove is a full- of ergonomic measures for reducing physical loads.
finger antivibration glove that meets ISO 10819 re- The study highlighted the need to improve the avail-
quirements; it helps absorb some of the vibrations ability of ergonomic equipment, along with indi-
caused by a power tool (Albers & Estill, 2007). vidualized advice and training, to increase the use of
ergonomic measures among construction workers
Stretching & Exercise Program (Boschman, Frings-Dresen & van der Molen, 2015).
Athletes often stretch before and after exercise to All in all, construction-trade-specific MSD injury
reduce injury and increase performance. Stretching prevention programs can be a valuable way to im-
is now being applied on construction sites as well prove ergonomics and worker morale, and reduce
(Choi & Rajendran, 2014). Site exercise programs workers compensation costs, while increasing
have been suggested and implemented as preven- productivity and profitability. PS
tive measures against upper extremity MSDs (Mc-
Gorry & Courtney, 2006). Holmstrm and Ahlborg
(2005) evaluated the effects of morning warm-up References
exercise (a 10-minute exercise every morning at
the building site) on musculoskeletal fitness in Albers, J.T. & Estill, C.F. (2007).Simple solutions:
construction workers. They found a significant in- Ergonomics for construction workers (NIOSH Publica-
crease of thoracic and lower back mobility, increase tion No. 2007-122). Retrieved from www.cdc.gov/niosh/
of hamstring and thigh muscle stretchability in the docs/2007-122/pdfs/2007-122.pdf
Albers, J.T., & Hudock, S.D. (2007). Biomechanical
morning warm-up exercise group. assessment of three rebar tying techniques. International
Ludewig and Borstad (2003) studied the effects Journal of Occupational Safety and Ergonomics, 13, 279-289.
of a home exercise program (five shoulder stretch- ANSI/ASSE. (2013). Reduction of musculoskeletal
ing exercise with two stretches for 30 seconds, problems in construction [ANSI/ASSE A10.40-2007
each repetition) on shoulder pain and functional (R2013)]. Park Ridge, IL: Author.
status in construction workers. Participants who Batson, R.G. (2012, Sept.). Masonry construction: Rec-
performed the stretching and strengthening exer- ognizing and controlling ergonomic hazards. Professional
cises showed significantly greater improvements in Safety, 57(9), 44-49.
shoulder function and satisfaction. Borchardt, J. & Choi, S.D. (2012). B-Factor and its im-
portance to HFE practitioners: Applying NIOSHs 1991
OSHA (2014) recommends that when working in
Revised Lifting Equation and its derivatives. Proceedings of
a bent-over position, employees should take short the HFES 56th Annual Meeting.
and frequent breaks to stretch the back muscles. Boschman, J.S., Frings-Dresen, M.H.W. & van der
Construction companies are now taking this a step Molen, H.F. (2015). Use of ergonomic measures related
further by having workers stretch before beginning to musculoskeletal complaints among construction work-
work to loosen their muscles. For the best results, ers: A 2-year follow-up study. Safety and Health at Work,
stretching sessions and prejob safety/ergonom- 6, 90-96.
ics planning (e.g., preshift huddles, toolbox safety Buchholz, B., Paquet, V., Wellman H., et al. (2003).
talks) may be implemented as part of a comprehen- Quantification of ergonomic hazards for ironworkers
sive ergonomics program to control WMSDs. performing concrete reinforcement tasks during heavy
highway construction. AIHA Journal, 64, 243-250.
Table 1 provides a summary of work-related Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). (2015a). Occupational
musculoskeletal problems and recommended outlook handbook: Carpenters. Retrieved from www.bls
practical solutions associated with the seven con- .gov/ooh/construction-and-extraction/carpenters.htm
struction trades/occupations. BLS. (2015b). Occupational outlook handbook: Ce-
ment masons and terrazzo workers. Retrieved from
Conclusion www.bls.gov/ooh/construction-and-extraction/cement
WMSDs and injuries can cause workers pain, suf- -mason-and-terrazzo-workers.htm
fering and lost income as well as restrict non-work BLS. (2015c). Occupational outlook handbook: Electri-
activity such as sports and hobbies. Costs to employ- cians. Retrieved from www.bls.gov/ooh/construction
-and-extraction/electricians.htm
ers can include reduced productivity and increased
BLS. (2015d). Occupational outlook handbook:
workers compensation premiums (NIOSH, 2013b). Plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters. Retrieved from
The literature contains information on various in- www.bls.gov/ooh/construction-and-extraction/plumb
jury prevention strategies. Employers and joint la- ers-pipefitters-and-steamfitters.htm
bor-management groups should develop their own BLS. (2015e). Occupational outlook handbook: Roof-
initiatives to analyze ergonomic hazards and imple- ers. Retrieved from www.bls.gov/ooh/construction-and
ment site-specific MSD prevention strategies and -extraction/roofers.htm
www.asse.org JANUARY 2016 ProfessionalSafety 31
BLS. (2015f). Occupational outlook handbook: Sheet Jensen, L.K., Mikkelsen, S., Loft, I.P., et al. (2000).
metal workers. Retrieved from www.bls.gov/ooh/con Work-related knee disorders in floor layers and carpen-
struction-and-extraction/sheet-metal-workers.htm ters. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine,
BLS. (2015g). Occupational outlook handbook: Struc- 42(8), 835-842.
tural iron and steel workers. Retrieved from www Kirkeskov, J.L. & Eenberg,W. (1996). Occupation as
.bls.gov/ooh/construction-and-extraction/structural-iron a risk factor for knee disorders. Scandinavian Journal of
-and-steel-workers.htm Work Environment and Health, 22, 165-175.
Bust, P.D., Gibb, A.G.F. & Haslam, R.A. (2005). Laborers Health and Safety Fund of North America
Manual handling of highway kerbs: Focus group find- (LHSFNA). (2006). The smart move: Back, shoulder,
ings. Applied Ergonomics, 36, 417-425. knee and other musculoskeletal problems. Retrieved
Cheung, Z., Hight, R., Hurley, F., et al. (2009a). from www.lhsfna.org/index.cfm/occupational-safety
Ergonomic survival guide for carpenters and framers. -and-health/ergonomics/ergonomics-the-smart-move
Retrieved from www.dir.ca.gov/dosh/dosh_publications/ Lipscomb, H.J., Dement, J.M., Gaal, J.S., et al. (2000).
erg_CarpFramer.html Work-related injuries in drywall installation. Applied Oc-
Cheung, Z., Hight, R., Hurley, F., et al. (2009b). Ergo- cupational and Environmental Hygiene, 15, 794-802.
nomic survival guide for cement masons. Retrieved from Ludewig, P.M. & Borstad, J.D. (2003). Effects of a
www.dir.ca.gov/dosh/dosh_publications/CErg_Cement home exercise program on shoulder pain and functional
Masons.pdf status in construction workers. Occupational and Environ-
Cheung, Z., Hight, R., Hurley, F., et al. (2009c). Ergo- mental Medicine, 60(11), 841-849.
nomic survival guide for electricians. Retrieved from www McGorry, R. & Courtney, T.K. (2006, April). Work site
.dir.ca.gov/dosh/dosh_publications/ElectriciansErgo.html exercise programs: Are they an effective control for mus-
Cheung, Z., Hight, R., Hurley, F., et al. (2009d). Ergo- culoskeletal disorders of the upper extremities? Profes-
nomic survival guide for sheet metal workers. Retrieved sional Safety, 51(4), 25-30.
from www.dir.ca.gov/dosh/dosh_publications/CErg Merlino, L.A., Rosecrance, J.C., Anton, D., et al. (2003).
_SheetMetal.pdf Symptoms of musculoskeletal disorders among ap-
Choi, S.D. (2007). Evaluation of rebar-tying operations prentice construction workers. Applied Occupational and
in highway construction: A field study. Proceedings of the Environmental Hygiene, 18(1), 57-64.
12th Annual International Conference on Industrial Engineer- NIOSH. (2011). Prevention through design: Plan for the
ing: Theory, Applications and Practice. national initiative (NIOSH Publication No. 2011-121).
Choi, S.D. (2008a). Investigation of ergonomic issues Retrieved from www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2011-121/
in the Wisconsin construction industry. Journal of Safety, pdfs/2011-121.pdf
Health and Environmental Research, 5(1), 1-19. NIOSH. (2013a). NIOSH program portfolio: Con-
Choi, S.D. (2008b). Postural balance and adaptations struction program. Retrieved from www.cdc.gov/niosh/
in transitioning sloped surfaces. International Journal of programs/const
Construction Education and Research, 4(3), 189-199. NIOSH. (2013b). Simple solutions for home building
Choi, S.D., Borchardt, J. & Proksch, T. (2012). Translat- workers (NIOSH Publication Number 2013-111). Re-
ing academic research on manual lifting tasks observa- trieved from www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2013-111
tions into construction workplace good practices. Journal NIOSH. (2014). National Occupational Research
of Safety, Health and Environmental Research, 8(1), 3-10. Agenda: Construction. Retrieved from www.cdc.gov/
Choi, S.D., Hudson, L., Kangas, P., et al. (2007). Occu- niosh/nora/comment/agendas/construction/default.html
pational ergonomics issues in highway construction sur- NIOSH. (2015). NIOSH program portfolio: Musculo-
veyed in Wisconsin. U.S. Industrial Health, 45, 487-493. skeletal disorders. Retrieved from www.cdc.gov/niosh/
Choi, S.D. & Rajendran, S. (2014). Construction work- programs/msd/default.html
ers perception of stretch and flex program effectiveness OSHA (2014). Ergonomics eTool: Solutions for electri-
in preventing work-related musculoskeletal disorders. cal contractors. Retrieved from www.osha.gov/SLTC/
Proceedings of the XXVI Occupational Ergonomics and Safety etools/electricalcontractors/index.html
Conference. OSHA. (2015). Ergonomics: Prevention of musculo-
CPWRThe Center for Construction Research and skeletal disorders in the workplace. Retrieved from www
Training. (2013). The construction chart book: The U.S. con- .osha.gov/SLTC/ergonomics/
struction industry and its workers (5th ed.). Silver Spring, Schneider, S. (2012). Preventing sprains and strains in
MD: Author. construction. Retrieved from www.lhsfna.org/index.cfm/
Forde, M.S., Punnett, L. & Wegman, D.H. (2005). lifelines/march-2012/preventing-sprains-and-strains-in
Prevalence of musculoskeletal disorders in union -construction
ironworkers. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Village, J., Morrison, J.B. & Leyland, A. (1993). Bio-
Hygiene, 2, 203-212. mechanical comparison of carpet-stretching devices.
Fredericks, T.K., Abudayyeh, O., Choi, S.D., et al. Ergonomics, 36(8), 899-909.
(2005). Occupational injuries and fatalities in the roofing Welch, L.S., Hunting, K.L. & Kellogg, J. (1995). Work-
contracting industry. Journal of Construction Engineering related musculoskeletal symptoms among sheet metal
and Management, 131(11), 1233-1240. workers. American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 27(6),
Health and Safety Executive (HSE). Musculoskeletal 783-791.
disorders: Manual handling and labeling loads. Retrieved Yuan L. & Buchholz, B. (2014). The effects of posi-
from www.hse.gov.uk/msd/faq-manhand.htm#manual tion and size of drywall on the physical demands for
Holmstrm, E. & Ahlborg, B. (2005). Morning installers. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics
warming-up exerciseEffects on musculoskeletal fitness Society 58th Annual Meeting. Retrieved from http://pro
in construction workers. Applied Ergonomics, 36, 513-519. .sagepub.com/content/58/1/1612.full.pdf+html
Hunting, K.L., Welch, L.S., Nessel-Stephens, L., et al.
(1999). Surveillance of construction worker injuries: The
utility of trade-specific analysis. Applied Occupational and
Environmental Hygiene, 14(7), 459-470.
32 ProfessionalSafety JANUARY 2016 www.asse.org