Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
editorial panel
M. Lynn Breyfogle, Bucknell University, Lewisburg, Pennsylvania;
Chair
Ruth Harbin Miles, Falmouth Elementary School, Stafford, Virginia;
advertising staff
Jennifer J. Johnson, Senior Director of Member Services, Marketing,
and Business Development
Tom Pearson, Sales Manager
news
&views
Board of Directors Liaison Kim Kelemen, National Sales Manager, The Townsend Group
Judith Quander, University of HoustonDowntown, Texas Kkelemen@townsend-group.com; (301) 215-6710, ex. 103
468 April 2014 teaching children mathematics | Vol. 20, No. 8 www.nctm.org www.nctm.org Vol. 20, No. 8 | teaching children mathematics April 2014 469
news
&views
holds, the greater potential he or she Timed tests most severe anxiety, talking about being essence of math. Students also suffer achievers in mathematics (Gray and Tall reason for quiet thumbs rather than
has for academic success (Engle 2002). in the United States scared when they were asked to take from one of the most damaging myths 1994, Boaler 2009). Pedagogical strate- raised hands is to keep students from
Beilock and her colleagues found that Many school districts across the United the test (see responses from fourth and that pervades U.S. math classrooms: gies called number talks (Parker 1993, feeling intimidated or rushed when they
when people are stressed, the pressure States use timed tests as a regular part of second graders in the sidebar below). the belief that good math performance Richardson 2011), also sometimes see other students waving hands to show
blocks their working memory, and facts instruction. Starting in first grade in my Some students cope with the pressure is fast math performance. Award-win- called math talks, help students develop they have solved the problem. When the
with which people are familiar cannot be local school district, students receive a created by timed tests, but for a sig- ning mathematician Laurent Schwartz math fluency and number sense at the teacher sees the majority of thumbs up,
recalled. Readers may recognize this pro- fifty-question test to complete in three nificant number of high and low achiev- reflected in his 2001 autobiography same time. Importantly, they do so she asks students to share their answers.
cess from any stressful or public situation minutes. The district requires the tests ers, timed tests create fear, stress, and that he often felt he was unintelligent while showing students the flexibility If more than one students answers,
when they have had to work with familiar to be given once per term, but some anxiety. when he was in school because he was and creativity within mathematics. teachers typically record the different
math but found that their mind has teachers give them weekly. One teacher In addition to the powerful negative one of the slower students: In a typical number talk, teachers give answers without passing judgment on
gone blank. This is the impact of stress explained that she does so because the emotions that timed tests cause, they all students a number problem, such the correctness of the answers. Teach-
blocking the working memory. Impor- first time she gave the test, many of her At the end of the eleventh grade, I as 25+35, 23 15, or 185. Problems ers then ask students to show how they
tantly, Beilock and her colleagues found
that math anxiety influences those with
students cried; she now wants to get her
students used to them.
Its too much took the measure of the situation, and
came to the conclusion that rapid-
can involve any number operations
addition, subtraction, multiplication,
have arrived at their answer. When I have
taught middle school using number
high rather than low amounts of working
memoryprecisely those students who
I asked teachers of the second- and
fourth-grade students in one school to
answer time ity doesnt have a precise relation to
intelligence. What is important is to
or divisionand they can be posed at
any level of difficulty. The problems
talks, students typically share six to eight
different ways of arriving at the correct
have the greatest potential to take mathe-
matics to high levels. When students who
have students write about how the tests
made them feel. The students reflec-
and not enough deeply understand things and their
relations to each other. This is where
chosen should be those that generate
many different solution paths. After the
answer (see Boaler 2009). As students
share their thinking, teachers record
experience stress in timed conditions
find that they cannot access their work-
tions showed that the test prompted
anxiety in at least one-quarter of each
learning time. intelligence lies. The fact of being
quick or slow isnt really relevant.
teacher poses the problem, he or she
asks students to think of ways to solve it
all their different methods next to one
another on the board and ask students
ing memory, they underachieve, which class and that anxiety did not correlate in their heads and to show their thumb, by using such prompts as the follow-
causes them to question their math abil- with test success. Indeed, some stu- give students a strong message about Unfortunately, many students across privately, when they have a solution. The ingto reflect on the different methods:
ity and, in many cases, develop further dents who completed all fifty questions maththat it is a performance subject, the United States come to believe that
stress and anxiety. correctly were those who indicated the the main purpose of which is to order fast students are those who have the
and categorize students, rather than a most potential, meaning that many
rich and diverse subject that students slower but deep thinkers turn away
should enjoy (Boaler 2009). In too many from math. The hallmark of high-level
Fourth and second graders math classrooms, students believe that mathematical thinking, as Schwartz
views of timed tests their role is to performto show they reflects, is working in depth, not work-
Fourth graders responded in the following manner to the request to complete this
know math and can answer questions
correctlyrather than to learn. I was
reminded of this recently when a col-
Look Whos
ing at speed. Timed tests as well as other
speed-related materials (such as flash
Talking...
cards) cause slow, strong mathematical
Look Whos Talking...
Join your fellow readers
sentence: This test made me feel league of mine reported that her first- thinkers to become discouraged in class,
grade son came home and complained develop math anxiety, and turn away
Worried that I wont finish.
Join your
from fellow readers
Nervous. I know my facts well, but it just scares me that I might get a
badscore.
about his math class. When she asked
what was wrong, he replied, Its too
the subject.
on TCMs new blog: on TCMs new blog:
I feel nervous because I dont like tests that much.
much answer time and not enough Encouraging number sense
Nervous because I am afraid I will not finish, or [I will] make a mistake.
I feel nervous. I know my facts, but it just scares me.
learning time (Lambert 2013).In a sep-
arate publication outlining the impor- Math
and automaticity
Tasks
Some districts use timed tests because Math Tasks to Talk
I feel pressured.
tance of students developing a growth
mindset (Boaler 2013), I describe to new
Talk
of words such as automaticity in the
Common Core State Standards for
About
Second graders responded with these phrases:
ways in which open tasks encourage
the opportunity for important learning About
Mathematics (CCSSM) (CCSSI 2010).
But much better methods of teaching
Not grat [great] and for viewing math as a learning sub- automaticity exist that also help stu- Ralph Connelly, a TCM panel member, shares his
Upset ject, whereas narrow and closed tasks dents develop the conceptual under- different perspective on the Handshake Problem.
Nrvis [nervous]
encourage students to develop harmful, standing of mathematics that they Have you used it another way? Share with other
fixed mindsets. urgently need (Boaler 2009). Number TCM readers!
Mad
The impact of taking a timed test is sensethe ability to work flexibly with
Nevis [nervous]
sufficiently powerful that students also www.nctm.org/
numbers, decomposing and regroup-
That Im terribul [terrible] at math
Unhappy
frequently come to believe that memo- ing them with confidenceis so criti-
TCMblog/MathTasks www.nctm.org/TCMblog/MathTasks
rizing math facts is the most impor- cal to young children that it is known
tant part of mathematicsreally the to separate high achievers from low
470 April 2014 teaching children mathematics | Vol. 20, No. 8 www.nctm.org www.nctm.org Vol. 20, No. 8 | teaching children mathematics April 2014 471
news
&views
in our sister journals
Which ones are similar?
Could we use the same method with
One teacher FIGURE 1 mathematics
MIDDLE SCHOOL
teaching in the
The Cartoon Corner department in the April issue of MTMS features Play Ball! by David B.
Spangler and A. Katie Hendrickson, an exploration of odds and probabilities related to baseball.
A full-page activity sheet is included.
different numbers?
Would this method always work?
explained that Out of the Park: Using the Mean in Sports appears in the March SEM, an online resource
472 April 2014 teaching children mathematics | Vol. 20, No. 8 www.nctm.org www.nctm.org Vol. 20, No. 8 | teaching children mathematics April 2014 473
Coaches Corner
New from NCTM!
M AT H I S A L L A R O U N D U S M AT H I S A L L A R O U N D U S M AT H I S A L L A R O U N D U S M AT H I S A L L A R O U N D U S M AT H I S
Physiological Reactivity in Mathematics
Anxiety. Ph.D. diss. Bowling Green
State University, Ohio. A critical Common Success from the Start:
Core tool: Progressions Your First Years Teaching
Gray, Eddie M., and David O. Tall. 1994.
Duality, Ambiguity, and Flexibility: A
Proceptual View of Simple Arithme-
tic. Journal for Research in Mathemat- documents Elementary Mathematics
ics Education 25 (March): 11640. BY ROBYN SILBEY, PD AND CAMPUS CONSULTANT BY KATHY ERNST AND SARAH RYAN
Harris, Pamela W. 2001. Building (Power-
ful) Numeracy for Middle and High The Progressions documents, funded by the Brookhill Foundation, preceded
School Students. Portsmouth NH: the Common Core State Standards in Mathematics (CCSSM) (CCSSI 2010) and
Success from the start means being prepared from
Heinemann. provided its foundation. The Progressions describe the conceptual develop-
Hembree, Ray. 1990. The Nature, Effects, ment of a topic strand across several grade levels. Once completed, each strand
the start: An essential guide for new or beginning
and Relief of Mathematics Anxiety. was sliced into grade-level standards, on the basis of the logical structure and elementary mathematics teachers
Journal for Research in Mathematics sequence of mathematics and childrens cognitive development.
Education 21 (January): 3346. The Progressions documents explain why standards are sequenced the way This book presents both the challenges and the opportunities inherent
@2014, Stock #13954
Kazemi, Elham, Magdalene Lampert, they are, call attention to areas in which misunderstandings are common, and in developing mathematical thinkers and will help you transform the
List price: $41.95 SAVE 25%!: $31.46
and Hala Ghousseini. 2007. offer suggestions and pedagogical solutions. They provide a critical tool (a) as a challenges into opportunities for rich learning.
Conceptualizing and Using Routines mechanism between mathematics education research and the standards, (b) to
of Practice in Mathematics Teaching assist in long-range, unit, weekly, and daily planning, and (c) for math leaders As a beginning elementary mathematics teacher you might already be TABLE OF CONTENTS
to Advance Professional Education. and coaches to share with classroom teachers. Each Progressions document asking yourself these questions: I. Mathematics Teaching and Learning
Report to the Spencer Foundation. contains the following: 1. How Should Elementary Math Class
AnnArbor, Michigan, 2007. How can I differentiate my teaching to meet the diverse needs of Look and Sound?
Lambert, R. 2013. Pers. Communication. An overview 2. Learning Mathematics with
my students? Understanding
Parker, Ruth. 1993. Mathematical Power: A detailed discussion of the work in each grade level
II. Laying the Groundwork
Lessons from a Classroom. Heinemann Connections to the Standards for Mathematical Practice What assessments best advance student learning? 3. Preparing for a Successful Beginning
Press. Concrete examples that may be used for instruction 4. Setting Up Your Classroom
Parrish, Sherry. 2010. Number Talks, How can students understand math if I do not show them
5. Building a Supportive Learning
Grades K5: Helping Children Build The Progressions document should be considered by every district, school, different strategies and tell them about the underlying Community
Mental Math and Computation and teacher as one of the most useful tools for professional development and mathematical structures and properties? 6. Establishing Routines to Support
Strategies. Math Solutions: Sausalito. curriculum design. The documents can be found at http://ime.math.arizona Mathematics Learning
Ramirez, Gerardo, Elizabeth A. .edu/progressions/. On the home page, simply click on a link that describes the What advice do I give parents about how to support their 7. Developing Computational Fluency
Gunderson, Susan C. Levine, progression of any content strand and grade-level band, such as the Draft K6 III. The Lesson Cycle
childrens math learning? 8. Tasks That Promote Learning Math
and Sian L. Beilock. 2013. Math Progression on Geometry, the Draft K5 Progression on Number and Operations
with Understanding
Anxiety, Working Memory and Math in Base Ten, or the Draft Grades 35 Progression on Number and Operations This book suggests ways to address such questions as you support your 9. Lesson Planning
Achievement in Early Elementary Fractions. You can also find additional information about the Progressions students development of mathematical ideas. 10. Lesson Enactment
School. Journal of Cognition and project and its brilliant working team. 11. Lesson Reflection
Development 14 (2): 187202. Direct questions and comments about this article to rsilbey@hotmail.com. Rather than focusing on math activities, the book highlights how IV. Essential Elements of Effective
Richardson, Frank C., and Robert L. students learn math and the pedagogy behind it. Using vignettes, all Mathematics
Woolfolk. 1980. Mathematics 12. Mathematical Discourse
based on real classroom discussions, the authors illustrate effective
Anxiety. In Test Anxiety: Theory, 13. Assessment and Feedback
teaching practices to support math learning. Chapters about the lesson 14. Differentiation: Meeting the Needs
Research, and Application, edited by Seeley, Cathy. 2009.Faster Isnt Smarter. founded www.youcubed.org
cycle come from conversations teachers had when they planned, of Diverse Learners
Irwin G. Sarason, pp.27188. Hillsdale, Sausalito, CA: Math Solutions to give teachers and parents the
15. Homework
NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Publications. resources and ideas they need to enacted, and reflected on a lesson. The book will act as a supportive
References
Richardson, Kathy. 2011. What Is the Young, C.B., Sarah Wu, and Vinod Menon. inspire and excite students about and reassuring companion that you can return to throughout your Index
Distinction between a Lesson and a 2012. The Neurodevelopmental math. Among many other accomplishments, journey as an elementary mathematics teacher. Technology
Number Talk? http://mathperspectives Basis of Math Anxiety. Psychological she is the editor for the Research Commentary Family Engagement
.com/pdf_docs/mp_lesson_ntalks_ Science Online First. March 20, 2012. Section of The Journal for Research in
distinction.pdf doi:10.1177/0956797611429134 Mathematics Education (JRME), an analyst
Schwartz, Laurent. 2001. A Mathemati- for PISA testing in the OECD, and author of SAVE 25% on this and ALL NCTM publications.
cian Grappling with His Century. Bern: Jo Boaler, www.joboaler.com, a Professor of the first MOOC on mathematics teaching Use code TCM425 when placing order. Offer expires 5/31/14. *This offer reflects an additional 5%
Birkhuser Basel. Mathematics Education at Stanford University, andlearning. savings off list price, in addition to your regular 20% member discount.
For more information or to place an order, please call (800) 235-7566 or visit www.nctm.org/catalog.
474 April 2014 teaching children mathematics | Vol. 20, No. 8 www.nctm.org