Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
7: 187197 (2006)
Published online in Wiley InterScience
(www.interscience.wiley.com) DOI: 10.1002/shi.252
Tarot as a projective
technique
Inna Semetsky
Abstract
This paper presents Tarot readings from the perspective of projective hypothesis.
Rorschach Inkblot Method and Jungian Sandplay provide some compatible frameworks
for analysing the phenomenon of Tarot and its practical application as a counselling
tool that may full some clinically relevant assessments tasks. The feeling of the
relatedness of the reader provides the necessary support for the client and brings
congruence into the therapeutic relationship; especially when in this interaction the
clients unspoken, yet projected in the layout, view of herself becomes validated. The
paper presents the actual reading for Sam whose Tarot spread functions as a
projection of a series of psychic events and experiences that create a dynamic process
of self-expression. Further, the paper asserts that projection has another meaning,
namely: when functioning as the archetype of the Shadow, the dark side of oneself,
which can easily possess ones psyche. Importantly, the Shadow can often become
projected onto others, and one may attribute to signicant others those qualities that
one is tempted to deny in oneself. The integration of the Shadow, by means of
becoming aware of its effects via Tarot readings, leads to therapeutic change. Copyright
2006 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Key words: consciousness and the unconscious, individuation, psyche, sandplay, the Shadow
state, in which the client may be stuck, but the unconscious, but it is her territory, the
when projected through the mages of the privacy of which is to be respected. The Tarot
cards (the threads of the story) it becomes spread is only a map, and as Gregory
an aid in a therapeutic process to free a Bateson (1979) famously reminded us the
client from some present xation. map is not the territory. A therapist reads this
Tarot goes beyond such a projective map to nd a proper way, road or path for
method as word association. There is no the ego to reach the Self in the process called
persistent questioning that may be perceived by Jung individuation. Sure, the maps symbolic
by a client as threatening and only elevate language the knowledge of its legend is to
her level of anxiety and accordingly her be mastered by a therapist so as to translate it
resistance. During counselling sessions, into words capable of reaching the clients
havent we ever encountered that dissonance, level of cognitive abilities and emotional
when something rings a bell for us and we strength. As Ryce-Menuhin put it, The psyche
rush to ask a client a seemingly appropriate naked may need to be only observed at
and timely question . . . only to get in rst, never interpreted irrevocably (1992,
response her activated defences and denials: p. 15). A somewhat premature
Resistance never yields profound results therapeutic interpretation may be quite
(Roberts, 1987, p. 5). The Jungian counterproductive. During readings, however,
transcendent function of bringing the the probability of such a danger is greatly
unconscious into consciousness operates by reduced. Cards that fall into a spread are
projection of archetypal images through selected by the collective unconscious, and
cards, and a readers task is the same as that their timing and dosage (the crucial elements
of the analyst, that is, according to Jung . . . in the analytic process), are not affected by
to mediate the symbolic function for the the personal choice or an individual
patient . . . As archetype per se is so deeply judgement call but manifest the re-enactment
buried in the collective unconscious at its leading to the ego experiencing itself in a
very bedrock level, we can never perceive it process that may be called, following
as such. It can be known only through its Whitmont (1985), the full, authentic
images in consciousness, e.g. as portrayed in experience. When a reader interprets the
sandplays (Ryce-Menuhin, 1992, pp. 2022) meaning of a sequence of cards, the client
or as projected in the cards layout. Tarot does experience certain affect and emotion.
cards are aligned with the Jungian collective Her feedback, triggered by the associative
unconscious, and the power of symbols is process, becomes a means of reality checking
such that images transcend, or move through, at the elevated level of consciousness, along
existing blocks, challenges and defences. the aforementioned road to individuation. The
As various themes emerge, therapeutic reading thus is a projection of both mental
material is being created. Overview of the events and concrete life experiences, which
total spread may direct attention to the are lived and reality-tested: as such, readings
particular card, providing insight into an represent an example of psychotherapy that
important part of the whole. A sequence of not only facilitates understanding but is
images is like a video-recording of psychic experiential as well (cf. Whitmont, 1985).
content in a dynamic process. It is important The reading is an intuitive and
during a reading to secure a permanent inspirational process: in order to pick up the
connection with this content. This is the clients projections the therapist must attune
clients ego, which may be quite infantile, to that hypothetical subtle frequency that is
fragile and immature, hidden in the depth of being used by the collective unconscious to
transmit the information it holds (Semetsky, through the therapists body language or facial
1998; in press). It proceeds in a genuinely expression that may provoke certain
sharing environment when the spiritual world responses. The client is not being asked a
of the psyche participates in the inward and series of questions; she is not expected to
outward experience of the reading. Readings come up with answers: by presenting her
are quite ritualistic: a nite number of cards, problem literally to herself it is she that posits
a certain sequence of operations, a specic questions bothering her, which prompted her
structure of a spread; all this creates a holding to seek counselling, and the collective
environment. Together sharing and holding unconscious is eager to respond via Tarot
do contribute to a healing effect. The therapist images. The layout in its symbolic content
is not a power gure: a reader and a client may manifest the presence of pathology,
are equally parts of the system of certainly not necessarily and not always in a
synchronistic regulation with Tarot framework of the DSM classication but
performing a feedback function (Semetsky, rather indicating some areas of sensitivity: if
2001). Both the reader and the client you prick it, it hurts. It is precisely the what,
concentrate on shufing cards, both focus on where, how and why it hurts that is projected
a layout; the spread does connect both people, into the cards. Among the 56 minor cards
being almost a physical link; metaphysically there are those carrying the messages of grief,
the connection is created by the collective anger, frustration, depression, pain in the
unconscious; therapeutically the connection neck, inability to carry on, indecisiveness,
is secured through a relationship which in fantasizing, insecurity, anxiety, confusion,
turn is supported by the said physical and exhaustion etc., and a reading process brings
metaphysical means. Jung was saying that he those issues and affects into sharp focus and
does not simply provide his patients with an leads to the instant expression of the problem
opportunity to nd free associations to their areas at a pre-verbal level. Predominance of
dreams; this prerogative is equally shared any one suit (how many cups cards, or
by the analyst whose ideas, opinions and wands, or swords, or pentacles) in the spread
interpretations supplement analysands own may indicate the general mental status of a
associations. The same principle can be client. What is a dominant affect? Is she
applied to Tarot readings. In this respect the emotional? Is she at her intellectual best or
personality of a reader is but one big worst? What are her perceptions? Is she in
situational variable that may affect a reading. touch with her feelings? What mood does she
A reader is not an examiner who is supposed demonstrate? Does she have any insight?
simply to interpret a projective test and What bothers her most: the earthy practical
involuntarily may put her subjective material matter or the heavy emotional burden? These
into an interpretation; a reader must and other questions cannot be answered
continuously work on herself for the purpose by a layout simultaneously but a spread
of expanding her own consciousness (and not nevertheless provides complementary material
forgetting the dangerous possibility of her that can be used in conjunction with other
own ego becoming inated!). clinical data. This sensibility allows a therapist
Other factors that may affect projective to understand a clients typology, to level
testing are, however, absent in a reading: with her, to join her through a function or
there is no expectation on the side of the attitude the client is projecting. This feeling of
therapist that a client may pick up on, there the relatedness of the reader provides the
are no subtle reinforcement cues (Cohen necessary support for the client and brings
et al,, 1992, p. 480) or inuences on a client congruence into the therapeutic relationship;
especially when in this interaction the clients widening the boundaries of individual
unspoken view of herself becomes validated. consciousness. Apart from the compensatory
Rapport thus is being established, and from it mode, Jung . . . acknowledged that many
grows trust: one cannot doubt ones mirror re dreams function in other ways, such as
ection. . . . This reminds me of a paradoxical prospectively, that is anticipating a
though typical situation. I had a reading once psychological direction or development
for a client whose main concern and extrasensorily, affording one information
disappointment were connected to the way about an occurrence outside of the awareness
her business was going. The session revealed of ones ve senses; and prophetically,
that she simply lacked proper training in the predicting a future occurrence (Hopcke,
know-how of running it. However, at the 1992, p. 26). Descriptions of the cards
deeper level of the unconscious she projected positions in the layout (Semetsky, 2005)
an inated ego and over-condence well on conrm just that: there is a progressive,
the way to a grandiosity complex. Her prospective development and trend in the
reaction to the cards pointing towards the direction of the psychological outcome. The
desirability of opening a couple of books or collective unconscious communicates with us
attending refresher courses was negative: she in its projective format both through dreams
dismissed the suggestion, arguing that she and through Tarot. Jung emphasized the
knew better thus ironically conrming the importance of a series of dreams; as for Tarot,
cards message of being too self-centred and a spread is a projection of a series of events
over-condent. . . . whereby various cards interact and interplay
If and when the archetypal patterns are with each other, creating a dynamic process
projected into the cards, understanding of the by means of which the individual psyche
current situation may be assisted by the fact expresses itself. The reading process is
that, despite similar behavioural or emotional not a shortcut; each cards position and,
symptoms, the client might presently be accordingly, information provided by its
affected by the completely different symbolism, becoming a focus for the
archetypal constellation and hence would be consequent reading thus offering an
unable to avoid the repetition of past actions additional dimension of exploration (cf.
or mistakes. Counselling and facilitating the Whitmont, 1985). The reason a certain card
clients awareness of such a possibility would appears in a particular position may seem
eliminate or reduce guilt or shame, contribute both rational and irrational at the same time.
to an increase in a clients condence and The collective unconscious uses whatever
feeling of self-worth; in short, would promote means are available to attract our attention
psychological healing. In this respect Tarot to the specic problem areas. Or, to put it
may be considered as performing a Jungian another way: the clients personal
compensatory function, similar to dreams in unconscious demands attention, it is reaching
the analytic process. Projection of out (toward consciousness?); this is an
unconscious material in the spread does important matter right now otherwise this
compensate for whatever is yet missing, is out card would not fall into a spread. Why now,
of the clients conscious awareness. The we may want to ask, and thus begin a
unconscious is capable of spontaneously dialogue with the client. Or some
producing images irrespective of wishes and surrounding cards may provide a valuable
fears of the conscious mind (Jung, Collected insight as past inuences, present concerns
Works, Vol. 11, p. 745). The reading brings this and future possibilities are all projected
material to the clients cognitive level, hence into a layout waiting to be explored and
briey address the whole layout representing being buried alive. Subconsciously Sam
the projection of Sams unspoken concerns wanted to move in the direction where his
and then focus on the Devil card as the professional abilities and talents pointed to
projected Shadow.3 by the Magician would be rewarded. The
The Knight of Cups in the rst position past energies surrounding Sam were not
indicated that things in Sams life were not supportive, however. The seven of swords in
progressing currently as swiftly as he would the fourth position indicated that Sams
have liked them to be. Sams aspirations were present stagnation had been inuenced by a
possibly connected with the eld of arts. To feeling of defeat or perhaps deception. Sam
this Sam commented that he was an actor but said at this point that, yes, he felt cheated
earning his living by means of various because somebody did not keep his promise
unrelated occupations. Yet, Sam heard the regarding a career offer.
symbolic sounds of the trumpet (The Were there any psychological reasons
Judgment card in the third position) that has beside circumstantial ones for Sam not
apparently awakened him from the feeling of having been able to get the promised
contract? The eight of swords pointed to a supported at home but he accepted it and had
longstanding trait: Sam was quite unaware of learned to live with it. Such was the Devil in
how his own power was being suppressed, the action: this image took away Sams self-
at either personal or professional levels. esteem; it imprisoned Sam, making him
According to this card, his usual mode of repress his strong emotions and exist in a
existence resembled a sleepwalker who was state of denial of the actual state of affairs.
moving around as though blindfolded and The three of swords provided further insight
stepping on his own repressed feelings and into the Empress. Sam, who was governed
unexpressed emotions. The Empress in the by the activated Mother archetype into the
second position told me that Sams psyche behavioural pattern of giving love, attention
was overtaken by the archetype of the and support to others, was not getting the
Mother. The crossing position of the Empress reciprocal qualities in return and his energy
was a clear indication that this otherwise thereby depleted he was unable to get a
positive force was quite counterproductive desired job in his professional eld. Sam was
to Sams own personal and professional a slave of emotional and, quite possibly,
development. Sam was explicitly focusing on sexual dependency, as depicted by the Devil;
the well-being of his family and children (the he was immobile, as if chained by his
Page of Cups in the position of Sams mental feelings towards his wife, who, however, was
outlook) at the expense of devoting some not giving him any support so as to keep his
time and emotional strength to pursuing his psyche in balance.
own interests. The balance between The Devil indicated that although Sam was
conicting concerns had thereby been convinced that, as he said, he had learned to
destroyed. live with a total lack of emotional support or
The cluster of three cards in the fth love, as if having made a conscious choice, he
position pointed to Sams current inability to was in fact driven by unconscious instincts
undertake clear and focused decision-making. and co-dependent character traits. The
Sam literally uctuated between his vocational symbolism of the Devil carried connotations
calling (The Magician) and the Shadow part of those traits functioning as chains that were
of his nature (The Devil) that was keeping Sam in the underworld of denial and
progressively making him a dependent dependency. To win over the polarity of
personality unable to move forward. At this opposites in his personality (the Magician and
point Sam said that I was wrong and he did the Devil) Sam would have to use the help of
not depend on anyone: just the opposite, he the Chariot (the overall card), that is, make a
was working at a job that hed rather give up conscious effort to move forward and learn to
because he was currently supporting his wife control his presently unrecognized impulses.
nancially through law school. So in Sams From the inertia, idealism and immaturity of
mind it was his wife who was dependent on the Knight of Cups, Sam would be carried by
him and not he himself who was chained by the Chariot into the new life cycle, his next
the Devil: such was the projection! The three step to individuation represented by the
of swords in the position of signicant others equally noble yet wise King of Cups
indicated that Sams role in the family was (in the position of hopes and fears, not
not appreciated at all. Before interpreting incidentally) as a symbol of personal
the meaning of this card, since it was such development and growth. The Chariot
a sensitive issue, I asked Sam if he felt signied that Sam denitely had the potential
supported; he said that he never felt energy he needed to accomplish a desired
goal. An image, when purposively interpreted they are imprisoned by their own repressions
. . . seems like a symbol, seeking to and denials. However, human development
characterize a denite goal with the help of is impossible without recognition of the
the material at hand, or trace out a line of bondage that might have created an obstacle
future psychological development (Jung, to the journey ahead. Due to this reading,
Collected Works, Vol. 6, p. 720), such future Sam was given an opportunity to start the
development culminating for Sam in the process of understanding some aspects of
Death card representing transformative, even himself that kept him in an emotionally
if painful, change in his whole character and destructive pattern of behaviour. Sams
attitude. On the everyday level, the Queen reading represented a path towards his
of Wands in the sixth position indicated individuation, seen as a process of integrating
supportive energies belonging to the woman, the unconscious aspects of ones self into
perhaps Sams business associate, who would consciousness for the achievement of a
not only be affected by Sams positive greater personality (Jung, Collected Works, Vol.
qualities but was also herself capable of 7, p. 136). The integration of the Shadow, by
affecting his future. Sam said at this point means of becoming aware of its projective
that he wanted to contact an agent. Indeed, effects via Tarot readings, leads to potential
The Queen of Wands promised enthusiastic change in self-destructive ways of thinking,
assistance from a concrete person. Sam then feeling and behaving. To achieve mental
asked a question regarding the state of his health means to work continuously on
health (thus conrming the layouts statement expanding the boundaries of individual
that his energy had been overused). He consciousness, and Tarot readings serve as a
picked up a card, which happened to be the tool that helps in achieving this purpose. The
Ace of Swords. Sams physical health had been extra, spiritual dimension brought within
damaged to the point where it needed to be reach by virtue of Tarot has profound
watched continuously and protected, his life therapeutic implications for the subject of the
thus being a constant battle to overcome reading. It enables a critical and self-reexive
obstacles pertaining to his health. Assisted by look at oneself and empowers one with the
determination, though, the upright sword ability to make sense of conicting
promised to win against the illness, especially experiences, thereby providing a timely
should Sams emotional and mental heath intervention that contributes to the healing of
start improving as a result of the insights the psyche. As Roberts (1987, p. 4) said, it is
provided by this reading. wilful change, conscious evolution, spiritual
When I nished interpreting the layout, growth that become attributes of those who
Sam said that it had made him nervous when choose the road to individuation marked by
it hit emotional nerves. Well, thus spike the Tarot images.
Devil: the stripping of old outgrown feelings
and thoughts that were about to be discarded
as broken chains can be. The poisonous
quality of the shadow must be recognized;
otherwise, it will fall into the depths of the Inna Semetsky, PhD, Postdoctoral
unconscious while being projected into actual Research Fellow, Faculty of Education,
life events. Often people almost deliberately Monash University, Australia.
create an illusion of being free and self- Inna.Semetsky@education.monash.edu.au
conscious when in fact, and similar to Sam,
Notes
1. The Rorschach Inkblot Method originated in 1921, with the publication of Hermann Rorschachs
Psychodiagnostics. It fulls such clinically relevant assessments tasks as personality description,
personality structure and personality dynamics, and provides a differential diagnosis.
2. The illustrations in Figure 1 and Figure 2 are from the Rider-Waite Tarot Deck, known also as the
Rider Tarot and the Waite Tarot. Reproduced by permission of US Games Systems Inc., Stamford, CT
06902, USA. Copyright 1971 by US Games Systems, Inc. Further reproduction prohibited.
3. This section is a reworked excerpt from my article What evil lurks in the hearts of men? The
Shadow!, Tricksters Way, 1(3), 15 July 2002, available online at: http://www.trinity.edu/org/
tricksters/TrixWay/
References
Bateson G (1979) Mind and Nature: A Necessary Unity. Toronto and New York: Bantam Books.
Bergin AE (1988) Three contributions of a spiritual perspective to counseling, psychotherapy, and
behavioral change. Counseling and Values 33: 2131.
Cohen RJ, Swerdlik ME and Smith DK (1992) Psychlogical Testing and Assessment: an Introduction to Tests and
Measurements, 2nd edn. Mountain View, CA: Mayeld Publishing Company.
Corey G (1991) Theory and Practice of Counseling and Psychotherapy, 4th edn. Pacic Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole
Publishing Company.
DeCosta J and Stewart T (1994) Story weaving: a therapeutic technique for resistance to change. The
California Therapist 6(MayJune): 5254.
Deleuze G and Guattari F (1987) A Thousand Plateaus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia, trans. Brian Massumi.
Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Frank LK (1939) Projective methods for the study of personality. Journal of Psychology 8: 389413.
Hopcke RH (1992) A Guided Tour of the Collected Works of C.G. Jung. Boston and London: Shambhala.
Jung CG (195379) Collected Works, Vols IXX, ed. H. Read, trans. R. Hull, M. Fordham, G. Adler and
W. McGuire. Bollingen Series. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Jung CG (1959) The Archetypes of the Collective Unconscious. London: Routledge.
Miller WR (1988) Including clients spiritual perspectives in cognitive-behavioral therapy. In WR Miller
and JE Martin (eds) Behavior Therapy and Religion: Integrating Spiritual and Behavioral Approaches to Change.
Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications, pp 4355.
Roberts R (1987) The Original Tarot & You. San Anselmo, CA: Vernal Equinox Press.
Ryce-Menuhin J (1992) Jungian Sandplay: The Wonderful Therapy. London and New York: Routledge.
Semetsky I (1998) On the nature of Tarot. Frontier Perspectives 7(l): 5866 [Centre for Frontier Sciences,
Temple University, PA].
Semetsky I (2001) Signs in action: Tarot as a self-organized system. Cybernetics & Human Knowing 8(12):
111132 [Imprint Academic, UK].
Semetsky I (2002) Deleuze and Guattaris a-signifying semiotics and cartographies of the unconscious:
Tarot reconceptualized. Synthesis Philosophica 34(2): 297316 [Zagreb, Croatia].
Semetsky I (2005) Integrating Tarot readings into counselling and psychotherapy. Spirituality and Health
International 6: 8194.
Semetsky I (in press) The language of signs: semiosis and the memories of the future. SOPHIA: International
Journal for Philosophy of Religion, Metaphysical Theology and Ethics. Aldershot: Ashgate.
Whitmont EC (1985) Recent Inuences on the Practice of Jungian Analysis. In M Stein (ed.) Jungian
Analysis. Boston and London: Shambhala, pp 335364.