Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Susanne Beydoun
My student, Farah, is in fifth grade and is a native Arabic speaker. She came to America
from Jordan in January. I conducted five assessments with her for my case study. The first
assessment was a listening assessment to assess phonemic pairs and consonant verse vowel
recognition. Next, I conducted a speaking assessment that allowed for open ended responses. I
did a very informal running record to asses her reading. For her writing assessment, I printed off
pictures I knew she would be familiar with in English and asked her to write them out. Last, I
The assessment instrument used for the listening assessment was based off of the
assessment offered in the text book on page 165. I used the format of the phonemic pair,
consonants and vowels. I included my own creations of consonant and vowel sounds. I had
printed off a sheet of the assessment that just included the items the test takers read. I read off
what needed to be heard while she read and circled the corresponding sentence. I typed up
the assessment I gave to my student and highlighted her responses. To understand the outline
Listening Assessment
Test-takers read: Hes from New York. 3. Test-takers hear: This is mine.
5. Test-takers hear: Walk to the park. Test-takers read: Chare your food.
It appears that Farah struggles with phoneme vowel sounds. With the items that assess
consonant sounds she was able to appropriately identify them. For example, she is able to hear
and identify the sh sound. Her vowel recognition is a little off. She hears I and e
The speaking assessment for Farah was designed as questions that would entail open
ended responses. The reason behind doing this is because I know that Farah prefers to respond
in her native language whenever she can. She understands when I give the class directives in
English, however, she does not initiate talking in English unless I specifically ask her to. I wanted
the assessment to be conversational. Normally, when I meet with her during reading groups, I
always converse with her and if she does not know how to respond, I tell her to respond in
Arabic. Afterwards, I translate into English and have her repeat. For this assessment, I recorded
her responses. If I had translate the question I did, and made note of it. The intent was to assess
4
ASSESSMENT CASE STUDY OF AN ELL STUDENT
her speaking so I did not mind if I translated in order for her to understand the meaning. I asked
Speaking Assesment
Hi, good.
Math
4. What do you do to help you learn English? (Had to translate into native language)
5. Have you ever been to the United States before? (Had to translate into native language)
6. What country did you come from? (Had to translate into native language)
7. What did you like about your country? (Had to translate into native language)
8. If you could go back, what would you like to do? (Had to translate into native language)
9. What country would you like to visit next, and why? (Had to translate into native
language)
5
ASSESSMENT CASE STUDY OF AN ELL STUDENT
Farah was only able to answer the greeting question in English. Her speaking skills are
very weak. She is limited on her ability to understand meaning of words. I had to translate the
questions. After translating, she would give very short simple responses.
To assess reading, I designed an informal running records. My school uses NWEA and
DRA scores to assess reading. Farah is not required to take the NWEA because she has not been
in school for a whole year. DRA tests are given three times, in the fall, winter, and spring. In
between those times, I informally do DRAs through running records. I typed out the script for
the book, Maria Goes to School, and noted what Farah could not pronounce or struggled with.
I get my lunch.
I get my hug.
Looking over the results, Farah seems to have a habit of not reading the ending sound.
The words: I, get, and my, are all sight words she is familiar with. She does a good job
The writing assessment was designed as a picture cued word writing. I selected pictures
that I knew Farah would be familiar with in English. I printed them off on a paper and had her
identify what they were in writing. This would allow me to see what she could spell correctly.
After assessing her I could clearly see that she is able to correctly spell the short three
letter words with one vowel sound. She only needed me to remind her what a star was. Again, I
am noticing that vowel recognition and endings of the words are weaknesses.
To assess grammar and vocabulary, I designed a multiple choice task test. I read aloud a
sentence. Farah was able to see in front of her and select the corresponding sentence that
grammatically matched. I highlighted her responses below and outlined the assessment. The
Test taker sees: I is happy. 3. Test taker hears: I see the sky.
5. Test taker hears: He loves her. Test taker sees: I seen him.
I noticed that Farah is applying the verb rules in her native language as she listens and
reads through the answer choices. Singular, plural, and possessives are mixed up for her. This is
understandable because in Arabic, the grammar rules are very different than in English.
According to the assessment items I tested Farah in, she is at a different level in each
skill area. Also, each skill area I tested her in was designed differently and had different
objectives. I cannot say that she does better in writing than in reading, for example. However,
each assessment allows me to profile Farah in her ability to perform at each specific skill area.
When it comes to listening, Farah is able to identify consonant phonemes. She can hear
consonant sounds such as Sh or h and be able to decipher between the two. Not only can
she hear the difference, but she can also see the difference. She can attach meaning sound
Farah is able to speak and respond to simple everyday questions such as: good morning,
how are you, etc. When the questions ask of her opinion or include a heightened vocabulary
that is not part of simple greeting talk, she needs translation, visuals, etc. When the visuals and
translation is offered, she sometimes can respond in English. For example, when I asked her
8
ASSESSMENT CASE STUDY OF AN ELL STUDENT
what her favorite subject was, she knew how to say math. However, her responses were
really brief.
When reading, Farah can fluently read sight words. Three letter words with one vowel
sound are her strengths when it comes to reading. She can fluently read words that contain
short vowels. She struggles with accuracy and pronunciation of ending sounds.
Farahs writing level is pretty aligned to her reading level. She can easily write those
short three letter words with short vowel sounds. She struggles when there is more than one
vowel sound. She can write on the line and observes lower case letters properly. What would
help her next is to form simple subject-verb-object sentences. She is now ready for that.
Based on the assessment delivered to Farah on grammar and vocabulary, Farah can
match the verb correctly to the object in some cases. It seems she is unclear about how to
Due to the fact that Farah can attach sound recognition to written recognition, it would
be a good idea to assess whether she can attach written to the sounds. Of course, this
assessment will no longer be a listening assessment, but it will really help me see if she could
attach phoneme sounds to their meanings. Another directions I would take to help Farah get
better is to focus on vowel recognition. I would try including words with short and long vowels
and correlate them to reading books in order to increase her recognition of vowel phonemes.
Farahs results during the speaking assessment show me I need to expose her to
vocabulary. A lot of word work can be done to help her expand her vocabulary. I need to make
sure I provide visuals for words. What can really help, is if she can get on a chrome book and
9
ASSESSMENT CASE STUDY OF AN ELL STUDENT
listen to readings that I select. The readings can be listened to and provide visuals at the same
time.
Since Farah can fluently read sight words, the next step is for her to fluently read all
words. I will begin moving her up to the first grade Dolce list. From there, I will align books that
match the list, incorporate them into her spelling packet and word work for the day.
For writing, I would challenge Farah to take her sight words that she is so familiar with
and form complete thoughts. What would help her next is to form simple subject-verb-object
sentences. She is now ready for that. This will help me introduce her to becoming aware of
In grammar and vocabulary, it would be helpful to provide Farah with sentence stems.
Sentence stems will provide models and show her how to set up a sentence. She can receive
practice with verbs by using word cards to build sentences based on the sentence stems as
well.
Next Step
Based on my findings, I see that there is a reoccurring weakness. Farah needs instruction
on vowel phonemes and ending sounds. The way she speaks also affects her writing. She is very
comfortable responding in her native language. When it came to grammar and vocabulary, it is
clear she uses the grammar rules of her native language. She is very strong in recognizing sight
My plan for instruction based on these results is to focus on exposing her to new
vocabulary. She has the basic sight words down, but now she is ready for larger words. Using
task cards and word cards with endings will help her visually and kinesthetically become
10
ASSESSMENT CASE STUDY OF AN ELL STUDENT
familiar with ending sounds. I will pull books that include more dialogue so that she get
exposed to conversational speaking. Getting her on a chrome book to listen to read alouds will
help her with her fluency and accuracy. For writing, my hope is to transition her into writing
Since Farah is comfortable speaking in her native language, I need to use her comfort to
ease her into English usage. I will have to take what she knows and expand it. What she knows
will be my foundation. According to Learning from ELL Kids: How to Teach Writing by, Jeffrey D
Wilhelm (2004), he supports and advocates using an ELLs first language as a tool to expand word
vocabulary. Even though every assessment in this case study assesses a different skill, over all Farah
needs more exposure to culture and names so that she can identify and speak comfortably. Wilhelm
says: The most immediate way to improve ELL composing skills is to increase word knowledge, and the
best way to do that is to use their "primary discourse" (i.e., their first language, cultural knowledge, and
sense of identity) as a resource to learn the "secondary discourse" of English This is very beneficial
information for me in my next step because it is evident in Farah. She already uses her primary
I felt that Farah needs more motivation to speak in English. I came across an article that
gave me an idea for my next step for Farah in building her vocabulary to help her speak in
English more. The article talks about how an ESL student emailed their teacher throughout the
year and was used as way to assess writing and vocabulary over time. The article, "My heart
want to say something": exploring ELL vocabulary use through e-mail by Sung-On Hwang (2004)
suggests: E-mailing offered real purposes for vocabulary use and thus offered engagement and
motivation. Every student in my district has a google email and account. Every teacher is
required to keep a blog. I encourage my students to leave me messages and comments because
11
ASSESSMENT CASE STUDY OF AN ELL STUDENT
it builds community and writing skills. Through email or leaving me messages, Farah can begin
All accept the reading assessment instrument formats came from Language Assessment
by Douglas H. Brown and Priyanvada Abeywickrama (2010). When conducting the listening
assessment, I implemented an intensive listening test (Brown 166). The spoken stimulus was
either a phoneme consonant or vowel sound. Farah had to choose the corresponding answer
choice by reading. Even though it has no context for her to refer to, she still has the entirety of
the sentence. This assessment narrows in on what Farah really knows in terms of specific
sounds. What could have hindered her from preforming well is her ability to read. When she
read the word leaving as living that tells me her vowel sounds are attached to wrong
symbol. I would conduct another test in different form to check to make sure her vowel
Using almost nothing but her words, the speaking test instrument fell mostly upon me. I
was recording her responses to the questions I read off to her. I felt that this was a very easy
going assessment for Farah compared to all the others. It was very conversational. I was typing
her responses because it is faster for me to type. For next time, I would suggest recording the
speaking test. That way I could really analyze her word choice, parts of speech, and sentence
structures. Her English is very limited, I had a hard time figuring out what testing instrument to
use. I decided the open ended questions would best meet her needs because she is able to
respond to short greetings. Even though I did have to translate a little, she was able to respond
in English. She struggled, but managed to do a good job. The casualty made her feel at ease.
12
ASSESSMENT CASE STUDY OF AN ELL STUDENT
The running record assessment is a great instrument because it based on levels and
really tells you where the student is at in terms of accuracy, fluency, and comprehension. With
Farah, I was not so concerned with comprehension. I wanted to assess more for accuracy and
fluency. The instrument of having the script in front of me while she read made it very simple
for me to keep track as she read. I checked off what she knew and made notes on any words
she struggled to read or missed. I conducted a very informal running record. For next time, I
would suggest timing her reading as well so that I could track her progress.
Again, because her English is so limited, I had a hard time trying to assess Farahs
writing. After reading through the assessment types in the text book, I decided that the picture-
queued writing items would be the best (Brown 269). I thought of included a word bank, but I
really wanted to see just how much she could do. That is what led me to try choosing pictures I
knew she would be familiar with in English. What went well was I was able to see how she
spells and identifies the picture. She is not at the point where she could write complete
sentences and thoughts. She can verbalize them, but cannot put words to them. This
assessment tool is open ended. There are so many cues I can give and assessing what she
When choosing an instrument for grammar and vocabulary, I needed to make sure that
is was basic. Farah has only been exposed to so much in the English language that it was hard to
really find an instrument that would work. I know that verb noun agreement is very different in
Arabic than in English, so I decided to use a tool that will help me identify where Farah stands
when placing verbs and nouns in English. The fact that the instrument was a multiple choice
assessment allows her options (Brown 295). The only thing that got me weary of the results was
13
ASSESSMENT CASE STUDY OF AN ELL STUDENT
because it was multiple choice. Her answers were mixed. Sometimes she would hear and
identify the appropriate verb correctly, while other times she would not. It made me wonder
References
Brown, H. D., & Abeywickrama, P. (2010). Language assessment: Principles and classroom
Sung-on Hwang, Piazza, C. L., Pierce, M. J., & Bryce, S. M. (2011). "My heart want to say
something": Exploring ELL vocabulary use through e-mail. Multicultural Education &
doi:http://dx.doi.org.arbor.idm.oclc.org/10.1108/17504971111121900
Wilhelm, J. D. (2004). Learning from ELL kids: How to teach writing. Voices from the Middle,
http://arbor.idm.oclc.org/login?url=http://search.proquest.com.arbor.idm.oclc.org/doc
view/213931165?accountid=13998
15
ASSESSMENT CASE STUDY OF AN ELL STUDENT
Appendix