1

of

Victims
of

Atlantis
John Richardson

2
 Foreword

By Nigel Lawrence, Editor of Shipping Today and Yesterday.

When we think of the dangers and perils that were posed to the Merchant Navy during World
War II, we may tend to think of U-Boats attacking North Atlantic convoys, German Pocket
Battleships sinking poorly armed merchant vessels, the Luftwaffe bombing coastal shipping, and
sea mines in their many forms that were laid around the British coast. But there was yet another
threat to the merchant ships of the Allies, one that had been quite successful during the conflict of
WW1, a threat that was the notoriously feared German Surface Raiders.
In all there were nine German Raiders in WW2, ordinary looking merchant ships that accounted
for the staggering total of over 800,000 gross tons, these were ships that were sunk or captured,
as well as those that were mined both in home waters or abroad.
Those Axis Surface Raiders were quite autonomous as they roamed the oceans alone, and very
often they were disguised as non-combatant ships flying neutral flags. Armed with six cleverly
concealed 5. 9 inch guns there were also those of smaller calibre, as well as torpedoes and
reconnaissance seaplanes. Some carried mines that were laid with great success, and often
operated in waters where merchant vessels sailed alone and unescorted.
Much has been written about the Surface Raider Kormoran, and of her legendary battle on 19th
November 1941 with the light cruiser HMAS Sydney. That action off Western Australia
resulted in the sinking of the Australian warship with all hands. Kormoran was also sunk in the
conflict but 318 of her 399 crew survived. Before Komoran's own demise shed sunk more than
68,000 tons of Allied shipping. However, there were only four of the nine German Raiders that
accounted for over 100,000 gross tons of Allied shipping. The notorious Michel, Thor and
Pinguin achieved that total, but the one that stood out with the highest amount of tonnage was
Atlantis, with 145,960 tons.
Those German Surface Raiders certainly did capture the imagination, and none more so than
Atlantis. That 7,862 ton ship known as Schiff 16 to the Germans, and Raider-C to the Royal
Navy, had been built by Bremer Vulkan at Vegesack as the Goldenfels. She was one of seven
sister ships built in 1938 for the DDG Hansa Line of Bremen. Atlantis was the first of the

3
Raiders to be commissioned on 19th December 1939, her commander was Kapitan Bernhard
Rogge. Disguised as the Russian freighter Krim, the Atlantis sailed through the Kiel Canal and
into the North Sea on 31st March 1940; she was accompanied by the Raiders W idder and Orion.
On 3rd May 1940 Atlantis sank her first victim, the SS Scientist of Liverpool in the Atlantic. On
board that ship making his first trip to sea was Cadet Graeme Cubbin, and it is from his memoirs
that John Richardson the author of this book, has skilfully recounted the story of the capture and
sinking of the Raiders first 9 victims. At that point Cadet Cubbin left the A tlantis to be
imprisoned as a POW in Italian Somaliland but the author has gone on to describe the Raiders
13 other victims.
The ability of Atlantis to disguise herself so convincingly is surely one of the captivating features
of this remarkable vessel. Another appealing aspect of the ship was the manner in which Kapitan
Rogge carried out his duties. As a German officer he knew his job was to sink Allied ships, and
this he did with great efficiency. Indeed, he played strictly by the rules of the Geneva Convention
and treated his prisoners in exactly the same manner as he did his own crew. The captain of the
British vessel, City of Bagdad, J. Armstrong White, which was sunk by Atlantis sunk on 11th
July 1941, stated, "His treatment of prisoners left respect, instead of hatred".
Due to the honourable way in which he carried out his duties, Kapitan Rogge was one of the few
German officers of flag rank who was not arrested by the Allies after the war. Indeed, many of
his former captives visited him at his nautical instrument shop in Hamburg during the post-war
years.
Emperor Hirohito of Japan awarded just three ceremonial swords to officers of the German
Military. One was to Hermann Goering in his capacity as commanding officer of the Luftwaffe,
one was to Field Marshall Irwin Rommel, while the other was to Kapitan Bernhard Rogge. That
alone shows the esteem in which he was held by ally and foe alike. He was also awarded the Oak
Leaves to the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross. The Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross being the
highest German award as recognition for extreme battlefield bravery or successful military
leadership during the War.
What makes all this more surprising is that Rogge was one quarter Jewish. He was one of the
many German officers who were forced to apply for a German Blood Certificate to allow their
racial background to be overlooked.

Victims of Atlantis' is a superb account of the birth, life and eventual demise of the
Atlantis, a story that will captivate us all for many years to come.

Nigel Lawrence January 2113

4
 The 22 Ships that were captured or sunk by Atlantis

Scientist United Kingdom 3 May 1940 6,200 GRT

Tirrana Norway 10 June 1940 7,230 t

City of Baghdad United Kingdom 11 July 1940 7,505 t

Kemmendine United Kingdom 13 July 1940 7,770 t

Talleyrand Norway 2 August 1940 6,730 t

King City United Kingdom 24 August 1940 4,745 t

Athelking United Kingdom 9 September 1940 9,550 t

Benarty United Kingdom 10 September 1940 5,800 t

Commissaire Ramel France 20 September 1940 10,060 t

Durmitor Yugoslavia 22 October 1940 5,620 t

Teddy Norway 9 November 1940 6,750 t

Ole Jacob Norway 10 November 1940 8,305 t

Automedon United Kingdom 11 November 1940 7,530 t

Mandasor United Kingdom 24 January 1941 5,145 t

Speybank United Kingdom 31 January 1941 5,150 t

Ketty Brvig Norway 2 February 1941 7,300 t

Zamzam Egypt 17 April 1941 8,300 t

Rabaul United Kingdom 14 May 1941 6,810 t

Trafalgar United Kingdom 24 May 1941 4,530 t

Tottenham United Kingdom 17 June 1941 4,760 t

Balzac United Kingdom 23 June 1941 5,375 t

Silvaplana Norway 10 Sept 1941 4,790 t

5
 156 Mentioned Ships including 96 Ship Illustrations
Abbekerk Hessen KMS Queen Mary
Admiral. Graf Spee KMS
Admiral Hipper KMS Interpreter Rabaul
Admiral. Scheer KMS Inventor Renown HMS
Anglo Saxon Iron Duke HMS
Albert Leo Schlageter Sagres
Antenor AMC Kandenfels Scientist
Argus HMS Kashii Maru Scholar
Ark Royal HMS Kassos Sheffield HMS
Athelking Karlsrhue KMS Silvaplana
Atlantis Kemmendine Speaker
Aubrieta HMS Ketty Brovig Speybank
Author King City Storstad
Automedon King George V - HMS Strategist
Knute Nelson Strathaird
Babitonga Kota Nopan Statesman
Barrister Kormoran Successor
Balzac Krim Suffolk HMS
Benarty Swiftsure HMS
Benno Lancashire Sydney HMAS
Bismarck KMS Leander HMNZS
Black Ranger RFA Leopard KMS Tactician
Broadway HMS Leicestershire Tafelberg SAS
Brastagi Linguist Tallyrand
Bulldog HMS Lusitania Tamesis
Tannenfels
Canberra HMAS Maharonda Tarifa
Ceres HMS Malakand Teddy
Commissaire Ramel Maoma Tirranna
Charlotte Sleimnan Mandasor Tottenham
Charles H Crump Manxman HMS Trafalgar
City of Baghdad Montana Troilus
City of Exeter Master Elias Kulukundis Twickenham
Coburg Munsterland Tuna HMS
Cornwall HMS
Craftsman Nelson HMS U-A
Nea Hellas U-68
Deutschland KMS Norfolk HMS U-126
Devonshire HMS Novelist U129
Director Nowshera U124
Doggerbank Uckermark
Dorsetshire HMS Ole Jacob Virginia HMS
Dresden Orion
Duquesa Oxfordshire War Genista
Durmitor Warhew
Patrician
Eagle HMS Pelorus HMS Warspite HMS
Esso Hamburg Philosopher Widder
Excellent HMS Pietermaritzburg SAS Wolf
Pinguin
Forester Plutarch Zamzam
Freya Polyphemus
Furious HMS Port Brisbane
Port Wellington
Glasgow HMS President Pretorious SAS
Gloucestershire President Kruger SAS
Goldenfels President Steyn SAS
Governor Prinz Eugen KMS
Python 6
 British Naval Strength in 1939

It has been said by many, if not most, that at the start of WW2 when Great Britain had
the largest navy in the world, the Royal Navy was far below its required strength. All
due of course, to government financial restraints after recovering from WW1.
Of the 15 battleships and battle cruisers the RN possessed only two were post WW1, the
other 13 that were of pre WW1 vintage were regarded as being old and obsolete. Indeed,
had not WW2 been looming since Hitler came to power, it has been widely viewed that
those latter 13 ships would have been scrapped before 1939.
Even the so called Mighty Hood of 1918 had been patched up to such a great extent,
that with 3,000 tons of extra deck armour, as well as her age old boilers, her speed was
down by quite a few knots from her original 32.
The modern battleships HMS Rodney and Nelson also had their misgivings. Their
building being curtailed by the Versailles agreement; their original main armament of
fifteen 16 inch guns was reduced to nine, as well as their hull lengths and speed being
reduced from a designed 30 to 23 knots. So in effect, the Royal Navy had no modern
battleships to begin the war with; just five of the King George V class that were under
construction. The RN had seven aircraft carriers as well as five more being built; how-
ever, as the war progressed a number of merchant ships were converted with flight
decks and referred to as being Woolworth Carriers; while some passenger ships were
converted to Armed Merchant Cruisers - or AMCs.
The 66 cruisers the RN had were also mostly pre WW1. The exceptions to those being
the County Class of heavy cruisers, the Town Class and Leander light cruisers; after the
outstanding County Class, Great Britain never built any more heavy cruisers.
There were also 23 new cruisers which had been laid down by 1939, the main bulk of
them being Colony Class light cruisers. In the destroyer group of ships there were 184,
half of which were pre WW1, while 32 fast 37 knot fleet escorts and Hunt Class were
soon under construction. There were 60 submarines in the service with nine under con-
struction. In all there were 200,000 officers and men in the Royal Navy at the start of
WW2; a figure rose to over 800,000 for Dominion Navies before the war ended.
7
 Picture caption
Top - HMS King George V was one of five sister ships that were laid down before WW2 be-
gan. Due to the Versailles treaty to which Great Britain abided, those five ships were limited
to 35,000 displacement tons. Their main armament being ten fourteen inch guns. The above
photo taken at Reykjavik after a Russian Convoy, shows the huge gash in her bows after a col-
lision in the fog with one of her ill fated escorts HMS Punjabi.

Below - HMS Rodney and her sister ship Nelson had been designed as 50,000 tonners, but due
to the Versailles Treaty their building was altered during construction. Instead of having fif-
teen 16 inch guns they were completed with just nine in A,B, and C turrets. Because the area
abaft the mast had been reduced by 200 feet, where X and Y turrets were to be positioned,
those two ships were completed with an odd appearance. Both HMS King George V above,
and HMS Rodney below, played the major role in the battle against the Bismarck.

8
 The Author

After a year in the sea cadets and then two years in a sea school, it was at the age of 16
that I joined the Merchant Navy at South Shields in May 1953. I was so impressed with
my new way of life on board the MV Willesden of London, that for seven months
during two voyages I kept a diary of the ships daily activities - Willesden was a WW2
Empire Boat, and I was the sailors mess boy or peggy.
The rather uneducated scribbling of my diary was accompanied with my feeble attempts
at drawing ships; but the biggest problem I had in my attempts to be become an artist
was obtaining suitable paper. Paper never went to waste in the 1950s, it was hard to
come by, and especially on a ship at sea. In a stationary shop ashore, paper for drawing
and sketching was most expensive, and on a deck boys wages of 10 a month, those
sketch books with all their added requirements were out of my financial reach.
But most fortunately for me in those long gone days, just about everybody on board
smoked cigarettes which came in packets or flat boxes of 50. Therefore, as the sailors
peggy I was able to collect plenty of the empty 9 x 6 inch ( 21x 15 cm) cardboard
cigarette boxes, and after cutting off the backs, I could use them for both writing and
drawing on. When I paid off after seven months I had scores of those backs with my
writings and dawdling efforts at drawing on them. Unfortunately they were all in pencil,
and with the passage of time my writings and drawings began to fade away, but before
theyd done so, I had them typed out and published in 1999 as A Deck Boys Diary.
After serving on various Red Ensign ships on deck, I joined the South African Navy in
1976 and served on supply ships and latterly Ton Class minesweepers. What a
marvellous difference there was between some of the old Red Ensign tramps Id served
on and the SA grey navy, where although the humour and comraderie of the Red
Ensign sailor could never be replaced, the pay, leave and conditions in the SAN were a
vast improvement. By that time Id been pursuing my hobby of drawing and painting
ever since my first ship, and as can be expected Id somewhat improved. Indeed, after a
few years in the SAN, one of the added responsibilities or privileges I was given, was to

9
be handed the prestigious but unpaid part time post of Marine Artist for the SA Navy.
When Id been the sailors peggy, or mess boy, on my first ship in 1953, I was of course
the youngest on board. But on the Ton Class minesweeper SAS Kimberley 37 years
later, I was by far the oldest and the old man of the ship. At 53 the young ratings in
their good humour called me uncle, but thanks to my Old Man the captain, not only
did he encourage me to have my 1953 diaries published, after hed read them, but also
gave me the inspiration I needed to write about the sailing ships Id painted as well as
writing other articles on maritime history.
At that particular time I had always been under the impression that only the educated
and well to do wrote books, and I really thought it was beyond me to do such things.
Indeed, during my days at school, which I left at 14, I didnt exactly shine at maths,
English, grammar or much else for that matter, but have since come to realise that just
about anybody of what ever age they are, can write about anything they choose, and
within reason, can achieve anything they want.
But that wasnt all! After leaving the SAN and on arriving back at Liverpool in 1992, it
was while I was searching for information on a certain sailing ship of T&J Harrisons,
that I was advised to contact Captain Graeme Cubbin. He wrote that magnificent book
titled Harrisons of Liverpool and was at the time the curator of the T&J Harrison Lines
Museum. We met, and have since established a friendship that is second to none.
Indeed, even though he is presently in his 90th year, he still reads through all my
writings, makes corrections, proof reads my work, and gives me his years of priceless
experience and advice. Furthermore, after reading the diary of my first ship, Captain
Cubbin gave me the diary of his first ship, it was the SS Scientist of Liverpool, a vessel
that was sunk by A tlantis in May 1940. As a company midshipman on board he spent
165 days on the German Raider. Therefore, and as a consequence, his diaries are the
main theme for this publication titled Victims of Atlantis.

John Richardson 2012

10
 SS Scientist

This story had its beginnings on 29 June 1923 at Kensington, Liverpool, when Graeme
Cubbin the eldest of four children, was born to the master grocer and provision
merchant William Alfred Cubbin and his wife Elsie. In those years most people in
Liverpool had some kind of connection with the sea, and in just about every household
of the city, there always seemed to be someone or other who was serving in either the
Royal or Merchant Navy, or else they were dock workers, ships riggers, shipping clerks
or many of the other professions and trades that were connected with ships and the sea.
Indeed, Graemes grandfather, a Manxman, had been a master mariner in the service of
M Langlands, a shipping company which was later to become the Coast Lines of
Liverpool; he also had an uncle and two cousins in the service of T&J Harrison Lines.
The parents of Graeme Cubbin knew the importance of their son having a good
education, so at the age of five his schooling began at the Upper Park Street Board
School of Liverpool. On reaching the age of eleven he transferred to the Oulton High
School in Clarence Street, where his father paid fees of 2.10 .0 a term for his
education.
In the 1930s the objective of many young men was to pursue a life at sea, and although
it became the dream of Graeme Cubbin in 1937, his sentiments were not shared by his
parents, because like so many others, they could quite clearly see that war was imminent
and life at sea held many perils. Indeed, the year of 1937 was one of great significance
to the 14 year old Graeme Cubbin. In Bremen, Germany, a motor-ship named
Goldenfels had recently been launched by Bremer Vulkan for the DDG Hansa Line,
whilst at the end of the same year, a steamer to be later named Scientist, was laid down
as yard number 911 at Lithgows of Port Glasgow for T&J Harrison Lines of Liverpool.
Built at 6,199 gross and 3,794 nett tons, the future Scientists deadweight tons would be
9,000; other dimensions were 435 x 56 x 32 feet with an international code of GNGR.
As a coal burner her engines were triple expansion with a Baur Wach exhaust turbine
which gave the ship a service speed of 14 knots with an extra three or four knots up

11
her sleeve. Two masted with five cargo hatches, she had a deep tank in number four hold; that
tank could be used for either water ballast or as cargo space. The building costs of the SS
Scientist eventually amounted to 192,330.
In the following two years there were further developments with regard to the two ships
mentioned. The first named Goldenfels which had been in service for the DDG Hansa Line for a
year had already made a few short voyages, but because her capabilities as an armed merchant
raider were noted, she was commandeered by the Nazi Government of Germany in November
1939; while Scientist, the second of the two, had been completed and after having made five
short voyages was currently in service for Harrison Lines. Although those two ships were in no
way connected, they were to be highly significant in the early sea career of Graeme Cubbin.
After obtaining his School Certificate at the age of 16 in August 1939, it was in the following
month of September, prior to beginning his career at sea, that Graeme attended the Liverpool
Nautical College in Byrom Street. In the meantime Germany cast the first stone by invading
Poland, which in turn started off WW2 on 3 September 1939.
After completing his nautical studies in January 1940, and because he wanted to be a deck officer,
applications were made by Graeme Cubbin to various shipping companies for employment -
either as an apprentice, a cadet or a midshipman. But even though WW2 had already begun, when
life at sea offered great dangers for all at sea, jobs on ships of any description were generally hard
to come by. However, the Liverpool ship owners Thos & Jas Harrison, managers of the Charente
Steamship Company, gave Graeme his first and only job in life, a job that was to span for over 46
years from February 1940 until April 1986.
After the normal medicals and interviews Graeme was accepted as a company cadet; his wages
were to be 10/- per month or 6 per annum; a sum which in our modern day terms of 2012,
equates to a daily wage of 4d in old money or 1 New Pence - per day. He also received a
2.10.0 monthly war bonus or danger money allowance from his most benevolent government.
The bond of 50 paid to T&J Harrisons by Graemes father was an enormous amount of money to
pay, and in reality of the times, that 50 was a years wages for many of the working class.
Indeed, the school leaving age in those pre war days was 14, and any boy or girl who earned a
pound a week, or 50 a year, was said to be extremely well paid. Moreover, on top of the 50
bond payment to his employers, Graeme like all other cadets had to rig himself out with a
company uniform and many other requirements, items such as an expensive sextant, books, tables
and many other necessities for his navigational studies. The cost of those extras which was also
paid by Graemes father, probably amounted to the same as his bond payment of 50.

12
 SS Scientist

During his 160 day incarceration on board the German Raider Atlantis, 16 year old
Cadet Graeme Cubbin made the above pastel drawing of his first ship SS Scientist.
The scene represents the passing of North Foreland on 3 March 1940.

At that time the two white bands on the funnel had been over-painted red; note the
paravane on the focsle head, and the four inch anti-submarine gun on the poop
deck.

13
After being launched by Lithgows at Port Glasgow on 30 May 1938, and completed ten weeks
later on 12 August, the coal-burning Scientist filled her deep tanks and left the Clyde in ballast
for Liverpool on 18 August 1938. Loading a general cargo she sailed on 26 August to begin her
maiden voyage under the command of Captain George R Windsor OBE. That voyage took the
ship to Kingston, Colon, Belize, Havana, and Newport News, before returning to her home port
of Liverpool on 1 November after a two months and five day voyage.
After discharging at Liverpool, and then on her arrival at the Bristol Channel port of Newport on
30 November, Scientist left for Glasgow then back to Liverpool. Sailing on 17 December for
Cape Town she arrived there on 5 January 1939
The rest of the voyage took the SS Scientist to Mossel Bay, Port Elizabeth, East London and
Durban; coaling at Dakar whilst homeward bound, she paid off on 20 February 1939 at Hull, thus
completing a two months and four day voyage.
On spending two days in a Middlesbrough dry-dock before loading at the same port, the ships
third voyage which began on the Tees on 9 February, took her to Antwerp, London, Durban,
Lourenco Marques, Beira, Mombasa and back to Lourenco Marques, before completing a four
month voyage at Liverpool on 9 June 1939.
Voyage Number 4 for the SS Scientist began on 26 June from Middlesbrough for another run to
South and East Africa. On the way home, however, and although war had not yet been declared,
the signs were already there. In view of the impending conflict, the ship was obliged to anchor at
Freetown on 7 August to join a homeward bound convoy. Three days later the escorted convoy
sailed. But due to it being a slow 7-9 knot convoy the passage took 20 days and Scientist did not
pay off until 4 October 1939 at Liverpool. Leaving the Mersey port on 1 November 1939 her next
voyage was to Durban, Lourenco Marques and back to Durban before joining a Freetown convoy
and then paying off at Liverpool on 27 January 1940; it was there that the diarist of this story,
Cadet Graeme Cubbin, signed on a joined his first ship the SS Scientist on 13 February 1940. At
the Herculaneum Dock at the South end of Liverpool, where the SS Scientist was coaling, Cadet
Cubbin who was proudly wearing his new uniform stopped momentarily on the quayside to
glance up at his first ship. Harrisons of Liverpool named each of their ships after a profession,
and this one, his first ship, was named Scientist. She was riding high out of the water, light ship
so to speak, which quite simply meant that her holds were empty, and also meant a longer than
normal walk up the extended gangway with his bags.
But there was something unusual about Scientists appearance! Harrison Boats are
affectionately known as being Two of Fat and One of Lean. Inasmuch, that their funnels are

14
painted black with a single red band between two white bands. Therefore, the appellation given to
Harrisons of Liverpool has always been Two of Fat and One of Lean.
But quite strangely there were no white bands on the funnel markings - just one enlarged broad
red band. Graeme was later to learn that the painting out of the two white bands had been some
kind of a ploy to confuse the enemy. Another thing he noticed was a four inch gun being mounted
on the poop deck. Such a piece of artillery known as an anti submarine gun is primarily used as a
defensive weapon if attacked by a surfaced submarine or any other more powerful enemy. On the
focsle head paravanes were being installed by Royal Navy fitters. Later on after the ship had
sailed, Graeme was employed as a sight setter on the four inch gun; while his boat station was at
number two boat.
Leaving Liverpool on 20 February 1940 in ballast, the SS Scientist joined a London bound
convoy at the Bar Light Ship in Liverpool Bay. In his convoy duties Cadet Cubbin worked four
on and four off with his cabin mate Sam Ellman, a South African who was a SATS General Botha
protg in the fourth and final year of his apprenticeship. Anchoring at Tilbury on 23 February,
the ship moved into the South West India Dock on the following day. After a ten day stay at the
Capital City, Scientist had loaded a general cargo for Cape Town, Port Elizabeth, East London,
Durban, Lourenco Marques and Beira. On 6 March the steamer anchored off Southend to form
up in a convoy which sailed on the following morning.
A week later on 14 March when the convoy was abeam of Gibraltar, Scientist detached from the
main group and proceeded independently towards Cape Town.
The 78 man crew for Scientists Voyage Number 6, was compiled by Quartermaster W Whiteside
for the benefit of Cadet Graeme Cubbins diary (while they were captives on board Atlantis) Mr
Whiteside was one of Scientists four quartermasters. The 19 Europeans and one passenger on
board are listed below. The other members of the crew were Lascars but their names did not
become available at the time. For the records, however, there were 20 Lascars on deck, 33
greasers, firemen and trimmers in the engine room with 8 cooks and stewards.
After an uneventful passage to South Africa the SS Scientist discharged at Durban; she left there
on 10 April for Lourenco Marques, then Beira, back to Lourenco Marques and then on to Durban
where on embarking a passenger named Mr C Chicken, she left unescorted on 27 April 1940.
After rounding the Cape of Good Hope on 30 April, a course was set towards Freetown, a Sierra
Leone anchorage port where on her arrival, she would form up with a homeward bound convoy.

15
SCIENTISTS EUROPEAN CREW MEMBERS FOR VOYAGE NUMBER SIX
Supplied by Cadet Graeme Cubbin.

Master, GR Windsor OBE 1st Mate A Watson, 2nd TW Anderson, 3rd RJ

Connolly Cadets, SE Ellman, G Cubbin. -

Chief Engineer R Skarrow 2nd JV Cubbon 3rd D Foulis 4th W Grainger 5th G
McConnell - Radio Officer FCH Compton

Carpenter W Raw Gunner C Burns.- Quartermasters: W Whiteside, R Evans,

P Cooper, R Barrow.

Chief Steward Mr Howarth, - Passenger Mr C Chicken who joined at Durban.

16
 Kapitan zur See Bernhard Rogge

Kapitan zur See Bernhard Rogge, commander of A tlantis, was born on 4 November1899 at Schleswig.
At the age of 16 he joined the Imperial Navy as Fahnrich zur See (Midshipman) on 13 December 1915.
(The zur See was given on being commissioned into the German Navy)
10 January 1919 he was promoted to Oberleutenant zur See.
1 January 1928 to Kapitanleutenant.
1 October 1934 to Korvettankapitan -Fregattankapitan
1 November 1937 to Kapitan Leutenant zur See
1 November 1939 - Kapitan zur See
1 March 1943 Konteradmiral
1 March 1945 Vizeadmiral

The ships on which Bernhard Rogge served.

Heavy cruiser Freya 1915

Heavy cruiser Moltke 1915 - 1916
Light cruiser Stralsund 1916
Light cruiser Pillau 1916 - 1918
Retired 1919, reactivated 1920 in coastal defence.
Light cruiser A mazone 1924 - 1926 -
Sailing Yacht Asta 1928 -
Passenger ship Schleiswig Holstein 1928 -
Sail training ship Niobe 1928 - 1930 -
Light cruiser Emden 1930 - 1931 -
Light cruiser Karlsruhe 1935 - 1936 -
O/C Sail training ship Gorch Foch 1936 - 1938
O/C Sail training ship Albert Leo Schalgeter 1939.

17
The ram bowed armoured cruiser Freya, was Fahnrich (Midshipman) Bernhard Rogges first
ship in 1915.Armoured cruisers were referred to as heavy cruisers after 1930.

Presently sailing as the Portuguese Sagres, the above barque was built as the Albert Leo
Schlageter. Kapitan Bernhard Rogge was her commander at the outbreak of WW2.

18
 Goldenfels

In the last quarter of the nineteenth century a large number of merchant ships were
sailing under the German flag, but many of them were sailing vessels that were regarded
as being slow and unreliable. But the merchants of Bremen wanted a better reliability
combined with greater speed for the transportation of their goods. They therefore
formulated a plan for change which did not include ships of sail. On 3 December 1881, a
new company to be known as Deutschen Dampfschiffahrts Gesselschaft Hansa,
otherwise known as DDG Hansa was formed. The managers of that new company knew
only too well, that to enter the world of shipping and capture new markets abroad,
bigger, better and faster steam ships were the future.
DDG Hansa quickly acquired an auxiliary steamer as their first ship and named her
Stolzenfels. That sail assisted vessel which was bought on the stocks, had been built on
speculation by Charles Mitchell of Newcastle in 1881 (Lost in a collision at Saigon in
1884 with the P&O Lines SS Canton.) Stolzenfels was followed in 1882 by the auxiliary
steamers Drachenfels, Ehrenfels, Rola1ndsdeck, Lahnech, Rheinsrein and Liebenstein.
None of those seven pioneering ships lasted for very long, but what they did achieve,
was to set the foundations of a strong and reliable DDG Hansa, a company that soon
opened trading links from Germany to the Middle East, East Africa, Madagascar, India,
Burma and the United States.
For the following 33 years under sound management the company grew at an
astounding rate. At the beginning of WW1 in 1914, DDG Hansa owned 67 steam ships
with 14 more under construction; but at the end of that Great War, the entire fleet
except for the SS Sonneck had been lost, either through enemy action or as war
reparations. But the SS Trostenberg of 1920 began the re-birth of the company, while
fast ships combined with quick turn arounds became the company hallmark.
On 16 December 1937 a large and powerful new motor ship named Goldenfels later to
be known as A tlantis, was added to the ranks of DDG Hansa. One of seven sister ships
she was named after a castle in Stromberg. Another of those seven sisters was named

19
Tannenfels, a ship which during WW2 became a supply ship closely associated with Atlantis.
While yet another was the Kandenfels, renamed Pinguin, a ship that was to become equally as
notorious as Atlantis. The MS Goldenfels and her sisters were the ultimate in the latest of
merchant ship requirements; indeed, she offered everything that any cargo ship owner could ever
wish for. At 7,862 gross tons she could carry 11,000 tons of cargo, had a 488 foot length, a beam
of 61 feet and a depth of 31 feet. In her engine room, both a port and starboard six cylinder two
stroke Mann diesel engine were coupled to one shaft, and they comfortably gave her a service
speed of 15 and a maximum of 17.5 knots.
After Hitler had come to power in 1933, Germany openly flouted the Versailles convention by
building warships much larger than the regulations allowed. But the building of large and fast
merchant ships like Goldenfels was quite legal. A warship such as a light cruiser would normally
take two years or more to build, but a big and fast cargo ship like Goldenfels could be constructed
in just a few months, and then if required, could be quickly converted to have the same armament
as a light cruiser in just a few weeks. As a destructive Q ship, she could then roam the oceans of
the world resembling an innocent looking merchantman, and indeed, Goldenfels became one of
those converted ships.
It had been done before with great success. In the previous war a humble little sailing ship named
Seadler had caused mayhem in both the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans. She sank over 30,000 tons
of shipping and kept the Royal Navy on its toes for long periods in wide expanses. There was also
the converted steamer W olf, an innocent looking ship which accounted for the sinking of 13
ships totalling 80,594 tons, while the SS Moew which was the most successful of all, sank 34
ships amounting to 174,900 tons, plus the mining of the 17,000 ton battleship HMS King Edward
V11 in the Pentland Firth. Therefore, Surface Raiders Commerce Raiders Auxiliary Raiders
or just plain Raiders, call them what you will, were the type of ships in which the Germans
were very interested in and well acquainted with. Being ideally suited for use as an armed
merchant raider, and with the war having already begun, it was in November 1939 that the motor
ship Goldenfels was requisitioned by the Kriegsmarine with the title of Schiff 16. Under the
direction of Kapitan zur See Bernhard Rogge, top secret work began on the ship at the Deutche
Schiff - Und de Masch A G Bremen as Yard No 2 - for conversion to an armed merchant raider.
That work involved the strengthening of her hull for the mounting of Six 5.9 inch, one 75 mm,
one twin 37 mm, and four 20 mm guns; there were also four single 21 inch waterline torpedoes, a
92 mine stowage and two Heinkel 114 aircraft But although the 5.9 or 150 mm guns were of
WW1 vintage, they were nevertheless more than good enough for their intended purpose with a
maximum eight mile range. They were mounted on the upper deck concealed behind flaps that
20
looked like so many garage doors that could be raised in just a few seconds. To assist in the
accuracy of the guns, a range finder disguised as a water tank was positioned on the roof of the
bridge on the Monkey Island. Furthermore, on the tall foremast table was a crows nest, so
characteristic on German merchant ships, periscopes were also fitted near the truck to enable the
lookouts in the crows nest to see even further. The tall funnel of Schiff 16 could be quickly
shortened , or lengthened, by unbolting and sending up or down the top portion.
Photographic evidence of A tlantis shows that in all of her different 27 disguises, she at times had
a large crows nest, and in this observation post there were probably two, three or even four
lookouts one for each quadrant - and a PO to supervise. Entry into the nest was up through the
hollow foremast. There was also a crows nest at the after end of the main-mast, as well as there
being a lookout on each wing of the bridge. So in all the raider had plenty of eyes, as well as her
seaplane.
The ships main armament was similar to that of a small light cruiser, and although she lacked a
cruisers speed, she offered something more Surprise of disguise! The conversion of Goldenfels
under the direction of Kapitan Rogge included accommodation and storage layouts in the holds.
Because as well as carrying a 349 handpicked crew of 21 officers and 328 ratings, there was also
accommodation for 350 or more future prisoners. When hed been given his complement, Kapitan
Rogge personally interviewed each and every man. He knew the voyage which lay ahead was
going to last for at least 12 months, and he wanted men of the highest calibre who could stand up
to great strains and stresses, and for that reason he dismissed more than half of the 214 ratings
hed been assigned. He told the drafting officer whod first supplied him with his crew, that not
only did he want replacements for the men hed dismissed, he also wanted 12 of the senior ratings
from his last ship; the sail trainer Albert Leo Schlageter. It was only after much difficulty
however, that Kapitan Rogge got the twelve from his last ship which eventually made his
complement up.
The Kriegsmarine commandeered a fleet of ten of those modern merchant ships; all of which
were fast enough to outpace most normal cargo ships, and even many a passenger or troop ship.
After having been taken over by the Kriegsmarine in November 1939, the name Goldenfels was
changed to Schiff Number 2 in the Bremen dockyard and then to HSK Schiff 16 by the
Kriegsmarine, but when she was commissioned on 21 December 1939 at Kiel, and on the
direction of her new commander, who had the privilege of choosing a name for his ship, she
discarded her three previous identities and became the KMS (Kriegs Marine Schiff) Atlantis.

Prior to joining Goldenfels, Kapitan zur See Rogge who had always been a great lover of sail had
21
commanded the sail training ship A lbert Leo Schlageter. Rogge was not a member of the ruling
Nazi Party, but because he had a Jewish grandmother, and like so many other naval officers, he
was compelled to sign a blood clearance certificate to overlook his Jewish blood line.
Working up trials on A tlantis began soon after she was commissioned into the Kriegsmarine, but
the vicious winter of 1939-40 played a big part in her sea trials. The handpicked crew were put
through their paces in no small manner, and all at a time when below zero temperatures and
blizzards had beset the Kiel Canal and its surrounds. On 11 March 1940 A tlantis passed through
the Kiel Canal and into the Baltic where was assisted in breaking out through the ice by the
converted ice breaking WW1 battleship Hessen.
During her working up trials A tlantis adopted a large number of disguises with differing colour
schemes,. She had telescopic masts to aid her in the 27 differing disguises, a number of height
extensions to her funnel, and even had a dummy canvas funnel to be placed just abaft the bridge.
For the benefit of any spies watching from ashore, her disguise as a minesweeper showed a false
wooden gun on the focsle head. On her passage through the ice for gunnery practice in the North
Sea, A tlantis was accompanied by the raiders W idder, Korvettan Kapitan Helmuth von
Ruckterschell, and Orion, Kapitan zur See Kurt Weyher. So intense were the gunnery trials of
those three ships off the Jade Inlet, that signals were flashed from shore stations to the SKS
authorities (Seekriegslietung) reporting that a full scale naval battle was in progress. During the
hours of darkness on 19 March 1940, after a hectic week of trials, the dummy canvas funnel was
stowed away; the ships side colour changed from grey to green, and when daylight arrived,
Atlantis had become the Norwegian motor ship Knute Nelson. But after all that work of
disguising the ship as a Norwegian had been completed, it was then erroneously discovered, that
the MS Knute Nelson had recently been sunk. Therefore, another disguise was implemented on
31 March 1940; Atlantis then sailed in a break out attempt under the name of a Russian Fleet
Auxiliary ship named Kim; complete with a hammer and sickle on her funnel, and although she
only had one screw, a warning in Russian at both sides of her stern read Twin Screws Beware of
Propellers.
Her escorts were the torpedo boats Leopard, (Kapitan Hans Trummer,) W olf, (Leutenant S
Broder Peters,) and the U Boat U37 (Korvettan Kapitan Werner Hartman.) (For the sinking of so
many allied ships in the North Atlantic, Kapitan Hartman and his submarine U 337 were to gain
great acclaim in Germany at a later date.)
Ships captains would normally hope for good weather on any given day, and especially on
sailing day; but in order to keep himself hidden from the view of the blockading British warships,
Kapitan Rogge did the opposite and waited a whole week for the weather to deteriorate.
22
 Ship Disguises

Minelaying, Minesweeping

Refuelling at Sea

and Reconnaissance Planes

23
The general purpose of A tlantis was threefold. First as an ocean raider, secondly as a
supply ship, and thirdly as a minelayer. Indeed, before she left Germany shed been
loaded with 92 contact mines with the object of laying them off Cape Aghulas. The
laying of such mines on this cruise was in fact the priority of A tlantis. To sew 92 mines
and get half a dozen or so hits would have made the cruise more than worthwhile. But in
the meantime, whilst she was on her way to the promontory of Africa, the plan was if
she did get the chance to sink any Allied shipping on the way then she should do so, and
such was the case of the SS Scientist being sunk.
Atlantis was not built as a minelayer; she was a merchant ship which had temporarily
been converted to Minelaying. In the after holds where the mines were stowed on
bogeys, those holds had been specially prepared with rail tracks on which the mines
were positioned for bringing them up on deck. On being brought up they could placed
in position for dropping them over the stern and sewn at the desired intervals, or simply
dropped over the side with the use of derricks. On the previous page Cadet Cubbin tells
of A tlantis slowing down when the ship was thought to be off Cape Aghulas. It was
indeed a correct assumption.
While steaming at about six knots, in the darkness, A tlantis was able to lay her mines
with great precision to make the desired grid formation. That grid would be made to
suit the circumstances of where enemy ships would pass through. However, if a ship
master suspected that such a minefield was in operation off Cape Aghulas, he would
give the area a wide berth - but not all did so and although some hits were recorded
whether they were from Atlantis mines or not could not be recorded. Incidentally, the SS
City of Lincoln hit a mine in 1946.
The three main types of sea mines during WW2 were contact mines, magnetic mines
and acoustic mines. On being brought up on deck they could be dropped overboard
using a derrick, or rolled aft on what looked like a small railway line forming a line as
shown on the photograph. To be jettisoned, the mine laying officer with watch in hand,
would give the order to launch, depending on the speed of the ship and the grid graph,
the time distance to launch may be between 10 - 20 seconds from either side of the
stern. Many types of ships were used as minelayers, even trawlers and drifters. But the
most noted purpose built minelayers were those of the Abdiel Class of which HMS
Manxman was one.

24
Eventually he got his wish and the weather turned most unpleasant with poor visibility, and that
was just what Rogge had been waiting for. To mark the start of a historic voyage, A tlantis was
assisted into the North Sea by the ice-breaker Hessen, a former battleship of WW1.
Because he was playing the role of the Russian Krim, he set a course that would appear as
though he was heading towards Murmansk in neutral Russia. But on reaching the North Sea it
became an extremely rough ride, because as well as force 10-12 gales and mountainous seas;
Atlantis was chased by two unidentified warships between the Shetlands and the coast of
Norway. The torpedo boats had returned to base in the heavy weather, but U377 which stayed on
was faring so badly she had to dive and follow the propellers of Atlantis. Eventually the U Boat
surfaced when the weather somewhat improved; she was then re-fuelled by A tlantis and
dismissed to return to her patrol. Escaping in the increasingly heavy weather, the raiders Chief
Engineer Wilhelm Kielhorn harboured great fears as to the engines which were being driven flat
out in the heavy seas, and also for the ships hull which was being battered.
Kapitan Rogge who had vast experience in sail turned a blind eye to such a ship when an
unidentified three masted barque was sighted near the Denmark Straits. She was heading East and
probably bound for Scandinavia. He had a great love for any kind of sailing ship and decided not
to attack her. His excuse at the time being that the little barque was not worth the effort and it
may give him away, as well as the fact that he didnt want to house any prisoners at such an early
time in his cruise. Indeed, stowed in number five hold there were 92 mines; his first task before
attacking any Allied ships was to lay those mines, the proposed area for their laying was to be off
Cape Aghulas. So Kapitan Rogge didnt really want any interferences until theyd been laid.
After passing through the Denmark Straits, it was on 8 April 1940 that the raiders Navigation
Officer Kamenz reported to his captain that A tlantis was clear and in the North Atlantic. The Line
was crossed on 22 April when a new disguise was adopted. Work went on all night with paint
being slapped onto every part of the ship. As a result it was at first light of 23 April that the
Russian Krim became the Japanese 8,400 ton Kashii Maru of the Kokuai Kisen Line. Complete
with the Rising Sun on both her sides she had a black funnel and a white letter K painted on a
red top.
On 2 May 1940, smoke coming from the 9,654 ton Ellerman passenger ship City of Exeter was
sighted off the port bow. A signal was sent from the raider asking for identification but no reply
was given. Kapitan Rogge decided not to attack the British ship because the probability of having
a large number of passengers, as prisoners, was one thing he did not want to accommodate so
early in his cruise; so he passed her by and continued heading South to lay his 92 mines off Cape

25
Aghulas. But photographs were taken by the Ellerman vessels captain, who later reported that
the so called Kashii Maru was a suspicious ship.
Atlantis had a Heinkel seaplane that was stowed in number two hold but it did not have a steam
catapult. After being assembled in the hold that seaplane had to be lifted out with two derricks in
a union purchase before being lowered into the water. But because the plane was light and flimsy
such an operation could only be achieved in calm waters. The Heinkel was referred to as the eyes
of the ship, and that valuable piece of spotting equipment could quickly and easily be stowed
away into its crate to save space; once airborne any ship 50 or 60 miles away could be seen on a
clear horizon.
After the City of Exeter sighting on 2 May 1940, it was on the following day of 3 May when
Atlantis which was still on a Southerly course sighted smoke in the afternoon watch. It was the
lookouts who reported the smoke, because with the sea being too choppy the seaplane could not
be launched. The distant ship was heading in a Northerly direction, while the so called Kashii
Maru was heading South. Kapitan Rogge therefore decided to turn his ship 180 degrees, slow
down to six or seven knots to allow the oncoming ship catch him up. Needless to say, on the first
sighting of the distant steamer Action Stations were sounded on board the commerce raider.

Due to the so called K asii Maru passing the SS City of Exeter on 2 May 1940, the Ellerman
Line captain was highly suspicious of the Japanese ship, and as a result, his suspicions were
passed on to the admiralty. But that information was picked up by the SKL, which in turn
relayed it to Kapitan Rogge on 21 May, warning him that the British were aware of his
Japanese masquerading, and he should change his appearance as soon as possible. A new
disguise was needed, and fast!
After searching the ship profiles once more, it was decided that Atlantis should become the
Dutch motor ship Abbekerk of the Vereenigge Nederlandsche Scheep Vaart. For the rest of
that day and night while the ship was stopped, paint was slapped on under red lights, both
over the side, the funnel and some parts of the superstructure.
The result being that on the following morning of 22 May, the Japanese K ashii Maru was no
more and the Dutch Abbekerk had taken her place. It later came to light, however, that the
Abbekerk had been reported by the American press to have been sunk on 21 May. All that
work for nothing? But Rogge decided to keep the disguise; indeed, there were one or two
other Dutch ships that resembled Abbekerk, and if need be, all he would have to do was
change the name on the bows.
26
Atlantis was caught in the ice at Kiel during her working up trials. In the picture above where
an officer walks across the ice, the false forward dummy funnel is being rigged at Number 3
hatch.

Adopting 27 different disguises during her 622 day cruise, the picture below was taken in the ice
shortly before she left Germany in March 1940. It shows her with a dummy forward funnel.
Note also the quickly rigged temporary crows nest on the after side of her main-mast.

27
The above picture was taken in the Baltic Sea when Atlantis was engaged in her working up
trials; she is without a dummy funnel as well as her main-mast crows nest, but has two
dummy samson posts on her focsle head and at the poop. Note the forward and after well
decks, before the 5.9 guns and their flaps were fitted.

The photo below shows her with a dummy forward funnel, while the crows nest is
positioned half way up the lower foremast, no dummy Samson posts at her focsle head,
while her newly erected forward well deck bulwarks are hiding her two port side150 mm
guns.

28
Innocent looking deck cargo to look at on the after deck, but when action stations were sounded
on A tlantis, the dummy vents would be unshipped and the same innocent looking packing cases
opened up; a 5.9 inch gun would then appear. There were two of those 5.9s on the after deck
which had more than a 180 degree arc of fire. The port and starboard batteries had a smaller arc,
each shell from a 5.9 weighed 100 pounds and had a maximum range of eight sea miles.

29
The two port side 5. 9 inch guns of A tlantis. That armament on both sides, as well as the gun
flaps, left the ship without its forward well deck. Two more 5.9s were disguised as crates on
the after deck

The starboard side showing a 5. 9 gun with its flap raised. Two sailors on a stage are
painting the ships side.

30
Top - The first disguise A tlantis assumed was that of the Japanese Kashii Maru

It must have been a general procedure to regularly change the dummy samson posts around on
Atlantis. The picture below shows the Dutch Abbekerk. Despite her 12 Samson posts, the raider
Atlantis adopted the disguise of this ship on more than one occasion

31
The fastest ships in the Royal Navy. HMS Manxman was one of six sister ships. Her builders
trials speed was 38.5 knots but she could make more, those purpose built minelaying cruisers
had the ability to race to an area at top speed, lay their mines and depart at top speed. The
disadvantage of their high speed was a reduction in their range to 1,000 sea miles when
steaming at top speed.
The picture below is the same ship with her stern Minelaying doors clearly visible.

32
The Algerine Class minesweeper HMS Pelorus built by Lobnitz of Renfrew was commissioned
into the Royal Navy in 1943. She was one of 110 sister ships, 98 for the RN and 12 for the
RCN. During Operation Overlord HMS Pelorus was one of 30 ships that swept the English
Channel for mines where over 3,000 ships that took part. HMS Pelorus had the distinction of
being the mine sweeper that led the 3,000 allied ships of the channel invasion.

HMS Pelorus was sold to South Africa in 1947, re-numbered M291 and renamed as SAS
Maritzbug, and later to SAS Pietermaritzburg. After a collision with HMS Leopard during
exercises, she was damaged at her keel and was used thereafter as a training ship. The author
served on SAS Pietermaritzburg when she was an accommodation and training ship 1988 - 90
but the 51 year old ship was sunk off Simonstown as a conservation reef in 1994.

33
There were three main types of
sea mines during WW2; Contact
mines, as laid by Atlantis,
Magnetic mines and Acoustic
mines. On ships like Atlantis,
contact mines were stowed in the
after hold. Lifted on deck they
were jettisoned complete with
their bogeys which detached
itself.
This picture shows a contact mine
being rolled into position from a
small mine laying vessel. The
man nearest on the right is the
timekeeper. The other two men
await his signal to jettison.

Mines are laid out along

the deck on rails and
jettisoned at precise
intervals with their bogeys.
The box on the bottom
contains the depth and
brake register, a concrete
anchor weight, and the
required length of wire
rope to moor the mine to
the seabed.

34
 A crated Arado seaplane

An assembled Arado seaplane. Its main disadvantage was the position of the engine being too near the
water; it was liable to get swamped in choppy seas. At times it led to the cylinder head getting cracked on a
hot engine.

35
An Arado of the heavy cruiser Admiral Hipper on its steam catapult.

The Heinkel was not as nimble or as fuel efficient as the Arado.

36
Top - The Supermarine Walrus seaplane which was used on British capital ships and cruisers.
The high engine facing aft, allowed the craft to alight in choppy waters much easier and safer
than their German counterparts could.

A Supermarine Walrus being launched from the battleship HMS W arspite, the aircraft carrier
in the distance is HMS Ark Royal

37
Right - A Supermarine Walrus being catapulted from the cruiser HMS Glasgow.

38
 Refuelling at Sea

The author served as AB on the RFA Black Ranger. She was typical of the ships used
for refuelling warships in port or at sea during the years of WW2.
Two derricks are used to lift the hose line and swing it over either side to either one
or two receiving ships.

Six of those Ranger Class ships were built at the beginning of WW2 and did sterling
work as replenishment ships in the Russian convoys.

The funnel of each ship was offset by three feet from the centreline to port. Such a
manoeuvre was intended to disrupt the fore and aft centreline from a bomber that
attacked the ship from right ahead Photo - RFA Association

39
But refuelling at sea adopted a different approach after WW2.With the use of cranes
instead of derricks, two ships could be refuelled at the same time.

In the above photo, the South African replenishment ship Tafelberg , on which the
author served as CPO, supplies fuel to the Type 12 frigates President Kruger on her
port side, and the President Pretorious to her starboard.
Photo SA Navy

40
 The Sinking of the SS Scientist
From the Diary of Cadet Graeme Cubbin - 03 May 1940

At 3.15 pm I climbed the bridge ladder to continue my watch after completing a job aft. The day
was fine with light winds and a moderate sea. While restoring the gear to the bridge-box I noticed
a ship about 3 points off our port bow that was steering a parallel course with us. The stranger
was a large powerful looking motor ship, and at the time I thought it strange that we should be
overhauling such a fast looking vessel. Her hull was black, and as was the normal thing for
neutral vessels, her national colours showed the Rising Sun of Japan painted on her ships side.
With upper works painted white her funnel was situated at the after end of the midship
accommodation. The funnel was black with a white "K" painted on a red top; such were the
marks of a well-known Japanese line.
All unsuspecting, the 2nd Officer Mr Anderson who had sighted the Jap earlier on in the watch,
asked me to take the long glass and see what I could make of her, while casually saying Make
sure she has no guns mounted, to which I reported, ironically enough, No guns Sir. But my
statement came a moment too soon, for I had scarcely spoken when I observed the strange vessel
altering course to starboard and crossing our bows, while simultaneously, three flag signals
fluttered at her triatic stay - two 3 flag hoists and one 2 flag hoist. After reading out the letters to
the 2nd Officer, I entered the chart room to get the Code Book. While turning up the signals
(which were apparently meaningless), I heard the unmistakable report of a gun which was closely
followed by a second. At Mr Anderson's bidding I dropped the Code Book and ran out to the
bridge and hoisted the answering pennant at the dip.
Meanwhile the rest of the crew were waking up from their afternoon siesta. On hearing the alarm
and with appropriate initiative, they dashed to their stations and stood by awaiting orders.
Thinking that our own gun was firing, Captain Windsor in his shirt sleeves ran on to the bridge
demanding to know who was playing about with that damned gun. Sighting the Jap which was
by then flying the German Ensign at the stern; and sizing up the situation, he was determined to
transmit a wireless message and ordered "Hard-a-starboard" and "Full ahead". The captain then
sent me along to the wireless cabin with a message QQQQ GNGR - . 1920' S - 0415' E.
No sooner had I delivered the message and regained the bridge when the wireless room was hit
which left the Radio Officer Mr Compton seriously injured. Seeing it was useless to resist any
further, Captain Windsor ordered "Stop engines and abandon ship." He with Mr Watson the chief
officer then went to his cabin to collect the ship's papers. The bridge and chart room were cleared
41
of all Code Books etc and taken to the captain's room preparatory to dumping them overboard. In
the meantime the injured Sparks had managed to dump his Admiralty books. The raider had by
that time ceased firing and was lying off our starboard beam while the Scientist burned fiercely.
The raider's "warning shot" had carried away the log boom, and several subsequent salvoes had
found their billet in Numbers 4 and 5 hatches setting the hatch boards on fire.
Several of the Lascars who were accommodated aft were injured. The Lascar look-out man was
mortally wounded in the stomach while he was on his way down from the crow's nest; he died
later on board the raider. The wheelhouse was hit soon after the order to abandon ship had been
given; luckily there was no one there except QM Barrow who had returned for his dungaree
jacket and fortunately escaped without injury. In all, the Germans fired 19 salvoes of four at the
Scientist hitting her only 15 times - but every shot, without a doubt, was meant to hit her.
Meanwhile everyone was at their boat stations; but on seeing they were on the side of the ship
exposed to the raider, and fearing she may open fire again, those on the starboard side left en
masse for Numbers 2 and 4 boats on the port side. I was in No.2 boat, and while waiting for the
rest of the crew to muster, I went along to Mr Watsons cabin to get his life jacket. On my return,
the 3rd Officer Mr Connolly who was on the lower bridge awaiting further orders from the
captain, sent me below to remind Chief Steward Howarth to collect the tobacco accounts etc.
After delivering my message to the chief steward, I entered the cadets cabin which was next door
to the chief stewards to collect a few belongings and some tobacco for my mate Sam Ellman who
was still at his station. Returning to the lower bridge as quickly as possible, I found that the
Lascars -who without any orders, were lowering their boat. Some of them were highly excited,
and as the boat touched the water the bow-man safely unhooked his fall, but the man in the stern
failed to unhook his in time. As a result the boat was left hanging by the stern and shipping water
with every swell.
The boat was in great danger of being swamped, and as the Tindal seemed unable to do anything
but argue with the men in the boat, I arrived on the scene and let go the after boat falls altogether.
The boat was then safe although an amount water was swishing about her bottom boards. I
followed Mr Chicken the passenger into the boat and was followed by the 2nd and 5th Engineers.
Mr Watson sent a message to say he was going with the Captain in No. 1 boat so we pushed off.
The raider was coming closer, and we could read her name below the Japanese characters Kasii
Maru, at any rate such was the name I read, for there are a few versions viz Kaki Maru, Saki
Maru while QM Whiteside who passed round her stern in No. 1 boat asserted that the name was
Ashira Maru. However, that was a mere detail, and no one was particularly interested for we were
now close enough to see machine guns mounted on her bridge and after deck; the visions we had
42
of being mowed down without mercy did nothing to soothe the Lascars' excitement.
Our fears were quickly allayed, however, when we heard a voice hailing us in perfect
English to Come alongside. At this the poor Lascars pulled with a will and we quickly
brought her alongside the raiders after well-deck.
Bewildered, we looked up at the grinning triumphant faces of the German sailors, it was
only at that moment that I for one realised I was a prisoner in the hands of the German
Navy. An hour previously we were a homeward bound British Merchantman, and now,
by a thousand to one chance, we were the prisoners of the German Reich!
The Germans lowered a stretcher into the boat, and two sailors who came down the pilot
ladder efficiently strapped up our wounded radio officer who was by that time
unconscious. He was gently hoisted aboard, and then rushed to the raider's well-
equipped hospital where he was given immediate and expert attention.
Meanwhile, we had been taken on to the boat deck where we were searched and
interviewed by several smartly dressed officers - most of whom spoke excellent English.
After being interviewed we were allowed to go to the rail and watch proceedings. The
Germans were busily stoving in the air tanks of the two boats that were alongside. They
were clothed only in bathing slips, and if I am to be unbiased in this account, I must say
they were men of splendid physique. The afternoon sun glinted on their shining bodies
and rippling muscles as those sailors swung their axes, and I must admit that we who
were watching were visibly impressed with their state of fitness.
Besides stoving in the boats, the Germans were also sending aboard the medical kits,
wine bottles, compasses and lanterns etc with which the boats were supplied. Our
attention was then focussed on our comrades in the remaining two boats; No. 3 with its
full complement was towing No.1 which contained Captain Windsor, Chief Officer
Watson, Quarter Master Whiteside, and the badly wounded look-out man. Quickly they
came alongside and their occupants clambered aboard the raider. Following the two
boats was the raiders white launch which was hoisted aboard and the so called Jap
began making way.
The Scientist looking very forlorn and blazing fiercely was lying on the raider's
starboard side about a mile away. The Germans then informed us of their intention to
sink her by gunfire. Choosing her position carefully the raider opened fire. Round after
round slammed into the bridge and accommodation setting her on fire in several places,

43
but not once did the German gunners succeed in hitting her waterline. It was by that time getting
dark, and the burning Scientist presented an excellent beacon to any vessel, naval or otherwise,
which may have been in the vicinity. On realising this the Germans decided to despatch the ship
as quickly as possible by means of a torpedo.
Carefully manoeuvering to obtain every possible advantage, the raider let go a torpedo from her
port tube. A minute passed. Had the tin-fish missed its mark? No! For suddenly a huge column
of white water shot 200 feet skywards from a point on the ship's waterline just abaft her midship
mark. The force of the explosion, coupled no doubt with the spray extinguished the fires, and so
we left her silhouetted against the dark Eastern horizon with the dull thunder of the explosion still
reverberating in our ears.
The raider sped on through the night. We estimated she was heading North West at about 18
knots. It was a cold evening, and the majority of us were left on deck while the mates and
engineers were interviewed by the raider's commander, whose name we learnt later was Rogge
or Rogge the Rogue which became the rather apt appellation we used when referring to him
later on. At about 7-30 p.m. we were led below to our quarters. We were agreeably surprised on
beholding our new home. Instead of the rat-infested hold of our imaginations, we entered a small
almost cosy, specially prepared room that was roughly 15 feet athwartships and 12 feet fore and
aft. It was furnished with three long tables, half a dozen basket chairs, while several lockers
adorned the bulkhead. The deck was laid with mats, while from the deck-head several gaily
shaded electric lamps were suspended. Leading off from the living room as we learnt to call it,
were the bed rooms. The QM's Chippy and the Gunner were allocated bunks on the starboard
side, the rest of us on the port side. The bunks were quite comfortable, each one complete with
straw mattress and pillow, blankets and bed-linen.

A few minutes after being shown to our quarters a German sailor brought us various culinary
utensils - basins, crockery, cutlery, kettles, jugs and a big dixie, and I was sent along to the galley
for our evening meal. Following my guide up ladders and along dark alleyways, I gave my
imagination full play, recalling to mind all the stories of "Hunnish atrocities" I had heard. What
was my fate to be? A stab in the back, or a shot from one of those shadowy ports, which were I
noticed, just head high. And so my conscious mind played havoc with my imagination, until with
relief, my guide ushered me into a pitch black room and shut the door behind him. As the door
clanged to the lights came on, and I found myself in a small but well stocked pantry. Here two
young sailors laughed together, and asked me questions of my station aboard the Scientist while
plying me the with ham sandwiches. Soon my guide, who had been to the galley for a
44
kettle of tea, returned and with my basin loaded with black bread, black sausage ("Vorst"), ham
and butter, I followed my guide along more alleyways to the "Gefangenen Raum." The men had
by now sorted themselves out and set out two of the three tables.
Discussing our various experiences we settled down to this our first meal aboard the raider. It was
welcome, undoubtedly, but I cannot say that anyone enjoyed the unfamiliar black bread, vorst and
raw ham from a palatable point of view. Finishing the meal we washed up and after separating in
little groups, some round the tables and some in their bunks, recalling to mind the packed
incidents of the afternoon, and offering various theories and time limits regarding our forced stay
aboard the raider. And so we went tour our bunks. .
During the week which followed the Germans installed a loud speaker in our quarters. Then came
a large variety of music from some sensual Vienese waltzes to modern bizarre Nazi marches;
many popular English airs were also relayed from the saloon for specified periods during the day.
German news bulletins in English were also relayed and later bulletins from San Francisco, USA.
Also during two actions at a later date, (King City and A thel King) one of the German officers
had the gall to "broadcast" a running commentary! Besides being used for musical programmes,
news bulletins, running commentaries and weather forecasts, the "radio" was used as a "knocker
up". It was a habit of the Germans to start the day with a rousing march.
At 7.00 am the stirring notes of "Sieg Heil" or "Marching through Georgia" would belch forth at
full blast from the loud speaker, while we poor prisoners slept, or tried to sleep, on. It was only
then that the "wireless" became unpopular to us. The Germans also gave us several packs of
cards, and the games of bridge and cribbage passed many a long hour. Books were few until the
capture of the Tirranna when we were almost snowed under with Australian magazines,
periodicals and novels.
A great surprise to us all was the canteen list which is printed on the following page, showing
items we were allowed to purchase.

45
 Note:

The object of rescuing the account books from a sinking ship is for them to be returned to
the company, and any person who has made a purchase from the bond or slop chest will be
held to account for the goods he has received and will have to pay for them, if and when he
pays off. If on the other hand those account books are lost with the ship, then there is no
proof of a purchase. Under normal circumstances, the wages of all ranks comes to a halt on
the day their ship is sunk.
Shipping companies which traded regularly to the Sub Continent, the West Indies or the
Far East were obliged to employ a certain amount of indigenous labour on their ships.
Those ratings who were employed in the deck, engine or catering departments were paid
much less than their European counterparts. As a result of that cheap labour, twice and
sometimes three times the number of men could be employed to do the same amount of
work as one European. T&J Harrison, Clan Line, Ellerman, P&O, Henderson and
Brocklebank were amongst those who were mainly involved. However, the post war new
NMB Rules decreed that the same rates and conditions must be applied to West Indies
seamen as UK crews. By that time, however, T&J Harrisons no longer employed Lascars.

For British seamen it must be interesting to note, the many different items on the canteen
list which is otherwise known to us as the bond; it must be agreed that the variety and
fullness of the German ships, in comparison to British, was very much better and most
remarkable for a ship at sea. We were allowed 0.40 Marks or 40 Pfennigs spending money
per day; this equates in British money at the 1940 rate to 9.2 pence, or four new pence per
day; the rate of exchange before the war started was 10 Marks to 1.
For the first week we were allowed both a beer and a lemonade every three days;
afterwards we had a beer and lemonade every night. Each Saturday, our Chief Officer Mr
Watson sent a list into the canteen for items we needed, things like tobacco, cigarettes,
chocolate and toothpaste.
The food we were given may have been plain, but was nevertheless wholesome nutritious
and plentiful, it was indeed the same as what the German sailors were given. Although
things changed from time to time, the following lists overleaf are typical examples of the
menus we received during our first six weeks on board.

46
 CANTEEN LIST

Tobacco 100 gm. pkt. 0.70 Marks

Cigarettes per " 0.35
Cig. Papers " 0.10
Cigarillos (12) 1.50
Chew Tobacco plug 0.25
Pipes per 0.60 - 0.80 - 1.00
Beer bottle 0.15
Soda Water ,,,,,,, 0.10
Whiskey ,,,,,,, 4.00
Schlicte Gin ,,,,,,, 4.00`
Chocolate pkt. 0.30
Cream Choc. bar 0.10
Mints pkt. 0.10
Fruit Drops 0.10
Caramels 10 0.15
Note Books each 0.60
Pencils
India Rubbers 0.10
Razors 1. 75
Razor Blades
Toothbrushes 0.60
Toothpaste per tube 0.40 - 0.75
Boot Polish tin 0.20
Boot Brushes each 0.20
Nail Brushes 0.25
Shoe Laces per pair 0.10
Boot Laces 0.20
Combs each 0.50
Hair Oil per bottle 0.85
Manicure Set each 1.50
Sun Glasses 1.00
Kriegsmarine Ribbon 1.00
Haircuts 0.30

47
 There were no separate menus on board Atlantis, from the saloon down to the junior mess
deck, everybody ate and drank the same.

BREAKFAST
Black Bread
Black Acorn Coffee, Butter Substitute, "Vorst" Sausage.
Cheese)
Jam )
Honey )

DINNER
Fresh Potatoes when available, Meat (Pork or Beef)
Asparagus Soup, Macaroni, Veg
Stewed Fruit, Custard
Also during the week, Macaroni, Sauce, Fish Mash.
Twice a week -Curry and Rice with Vegetables.

TEA
Black Bread, Butter Substitute and Tea which was an
Alleged product of strawberry leaves
Cheese (three varieties) Raw Ham
Hot Stews.

48
Water was supplied at mid-day when we received as much as we needed for drinking,
washing and cleaning teeth etc. During the hot weather, lime juice was supplied with the
water. Washing water was supplied in tubs each morning, but this commodity was the least
plentiful. Soap which was supplied each month was also scarce.
Each day we were allowed on deck for two hours from 11.00 am - 12.00 and 4.30 pm - 5.30
pm. A portion of the boat deck a little longer than a cricket pitch was roped off where we
walked and conversed, sometimes with the German officers. It was during one of these
conversations that Gunnery Officer Kasch who in wishing to discuss the Scientists capture,
remarked that it was their first action - perhaps he wanted us to congratulate him on his
good shooting.

Never shall I forget the congenial companionship of "Sleepy Valley". In this secluded
corner of the "bedroom", we gathered together each evening to swap yarns and jokes,
Joining in impromptu concerts, debates and sing-songs I can see them now, The Champ,
Joe, Mac, Tommy, Cocky, Jock and later Sparks, all comfortably seated on four bunks,
smoking luxuriously, laughing and joking as only British sailors could in such times of
trouble and adversity. I took no active part in these well remembered discussions, but I was
an interested listener taking comfort in these jocular and sometimes serious conversations.
Another favourite retreat of mine was "The Boudoir", a name bestowed by Dick Barrow to
the room where the men lived. Many a happy hour did I spend talking and listening to the
men - Bill Whiteside in particular, who, on our arrival wrote out the 31 Articles for my own
personal benefit.

Looking back over the road of events - the ethereal promises of Mogadiscio, the weary,
blighted desert of the SS Durmitor days, and the crammed discomfort of the last weeks
aboard the raider, I think I can be forgiven when I say these opening days of our captivity
were almost happy ones - happy, but with a subtle discontent, and an atmosphere of distrust
in our captors, not to mention the feeling of impending danger, which was ever present.

49
After the steamer Scientist had been sunk, A tlantis steamed North West for about thirty six hours
before altering course to the Southward. Where was he off to now? South America, the Pacific,
South Africa, or possibly the Indian Ocean? As the days went by our skipper declared that the
raider was easting considerably. Then on the night of 10 May our prison door was locked and all
became quiet - even the engines seemed to be turning more slowly. On one occasion several
German sailors with strained expressions and dressed in oilskins were admitted to our quarters,
and without saying a word they each helped themselves to a life jacket and left.
While on deck that afternoon, we had noticed we were steaming approximately North East, and
Captain Windsor who had kept track of our movements with the instinct and knowledge of a born
seaman, said we could not be far away from the Cape of Good Hope. Perhaps the raider intended
to bombard one of the Cape ports, but a much more acceptable theory was that she was about to
lay mines. Such was the case, for we learned at a much later date that magnetic mines had indeed
been laid off Cape Agulhas.
All night long the raider crept towards the land while sowing her deadly seeds as she went along.
At one point her siren bellowed three times. Had she been discovered? Minutes passed and
nothing happened. It was probably misty on deck, and with an ironical audacity the German
raider was actually warning any approaching ship o f her presence!
Disappointed we turned in, and then on going up on deck next morning, we found that most of the
mess deck above our quarters was effectively screened off from our curious eyes. The raider was
steaming Southward at a good speed, and the weather was already much cooler than it had been.
Kapitan Rogge was on deck walking his Scotch Terrier. That dog was known to us as "Scottie."
Scotties German name however was "Ferry." I'm afraid he was a bad tempered little dog when
thwarted, but normally he was as gay as any other puppy. He enjoyed a game with anyone,
particularly his countrymen who seemed to understand his disposition best!
After the usual exchange of pleasantries, Captain Windsor remarked to Rogge "I expect the shore
lights were bright last night, eh, Captain?" Rogge blustered and fumed for a moment, and
excused himself as he went to his room. Captain Windsor grinned and continued his morning
stroll with his chief engineer. One in the eye for the Jerry said Captain Windsor, in thinking that
Rogge wanted to keep his position secret.
Monday,10 June 10th 1940. We have by now been aboard the raider for nearly six weeks, and
nothing has happened to break the monotony of our lives. But something seems about to happen
now. The door of our quarters has been locked, the sailors in the flat above have been unusually
quiet, and the raider is pulsating with power as she slides through the water at her utmost speed.
Certainly she's sighted something. Having arrived at this conclusion, our next question is What
50
has she seen ? Perhaps its a British warship - we hope so, but even the bravest of us realise that
we are in a tough spot. Suppose it is the Royal Navy and they defeat the raider, will the Germans
panic and leave us to drown like rats in a trap? Will she be struck in her magazine? If we have to
take to the water shall we be attacked by sharks? It was a subject that didn't bear thinking about.
Then with a shrill decadent whine, the forced draught faded away and everything became deathly
quiet, the silence being broken only by the swish of water against the ship's side. Quite suddenly,
as a sledge hammer would shatter a pane of glass, the still electric silence in that room was
smashed as the gun-flaps were released and the raider opened fire. For twelve minutes that small
room became an inferno of sound as salvo after salvo was poured into the raider's target. Plaster
splashed down upon us from the deck-head above, and choking cordite fumes found its way
through the ventilation system. Between the deafening roars of the 5.9 -inch guns could be heard
the hoarse shouts of the gunners, the whine of the ammunition hoist, and the persistent thumping
of the deadly shrapnel gun mounted in the raider's bows.
After three hours of what seemed to be maximum speed, when salvo after salvo from the 5.9s the
ordeal was over and all was quiet again. With a cynical smile playing about his thin lips,
Leutenant Strekker entered our room to tell us - "Eet ees a Norvegian merchant sheep ve haf
captured and Tirranna ees her name." With a smart salute and a bow he departed and left us to
discuss the report, but no one knew anything of the captured ship, except that she was a motor
ship of the Wilhelmsen Line of Tonsberg.

The 7,230 GRT motor ship Tirranna had been built in Germany and was handed over to
her Norwegian owners in 1938; with the same engines she was equal in speed to Atlantis.
When Captain Gundersen met up with Rogge he complained bitterly, saying that Norway
had capitulated and made peace with Germany just a few hours earlier on that very day,
and that he had quite unnecessarily killed five of his men and badly injured a dozen more.
A 27 man prize crew were sent to Tirranna, but on discovering there was only 200 tons of
diesel left in her bunker tanks, which was insufficient for the ship to make it as far as
Europe, she was ordered to proceed South and await further orders.

Meanwhile back on board A tlantis, it was about 1.00 pm and we were feeling hungry. But
because there was no sign of any food arriving from the galley, we opened some spare tins of
sardines and mashed the contents with butter. We had some bread left from breakfast and it all
made a satisfying meal. All that day we did not breathe any fresh air, and neither did we see the
Norwegians. We were kept below in that stuffy cordite filled room until about six o'clock when
51
two of us were led up to the galley for Essen. Up on deck in the gathering dusk we noticed that
the raider was steaming South Eastward with her new prize steaming along about 2 points off her
port bow.
Morning dawned bright and clear, while a slight ground swell caused an uncomfortable half roll,
a half pitch which was peculiar to A tlantis as she lay hove-to. On her starboard bow, about half a
mile away lay the Tirranna. She was a motor ship very similar in design to A tlantis; but several of
the German officers declared she was a better ship than their own. Her well decks were filled with
field Ambulances, Army trucks, cars and vans.
On her poop a six-inch gun was mounted. Apparently she had been chartered by the British
Government in Freemantle and was bound for Mombasa loaded with stores, mails, comforts and
equipment for the Imperial Forces in East Africa. Except for a large hole in her stern and twisted
rails and wreckage on her boat deck, she showed little signs of damage, despite the fact that the
raider had fired nearly sixty rounds at her. Evidently the German gunners were still in need of a
bit of practice.
I thought the days of piracy were over, I had in fact reached the stage when I considered a pirate
story to be nothing more than a literary delight for boys rather younger than myself, but as I
looked upon this modern pirate scene, I felt as if Id been drawn back through time to an age
when swash-buckling sea robbers were the vogue. Between the buccaneer and its victim, lifeboats
loaded with every conceivable commodity from crates of beer to mail bags and boxes of
margarine were being towed by the raider's motor launches. Derricks were swung outboard, and
sling after sling of crates, bags and boxes were lowered swiftly into the raiders' gaping hatches.
Except for those on practical duties, Kapitan Rogge assembled the whole of his complement on
deck and gave them a severe warning as to their treatment of the prisoners, as well as collecting
souvenirs from their ships. Looking around at his officers and senior rates he said there would be
no exceptions. Indeed, boarding parties sent to captured ships had been helping themselves to the
cargoes and the contents of the bonded store rooms. On 14 June 1940 Atlantis took on another
disguise. This time she was to be the Tarifa, which was another of the Wilhelmsen Line ships,
which like Tirranna was also supposed to be on charter for the British Government.

52
 Crew List of the MS Tirranna,
Supplied by the Norwegian Archives

Captain Edvard Hauff Gundersen 1st Mate Thorof Holst, 2nd Nils A Nilsen, 3rd Sven
Bjornby 4th, Leif Holberg Andersen Radio Officer Johny Haaland Electrician Otto
Kristensen Carpenter Johan Johansen Bosun Ole Paulsen ABs Hilmar Engelsen,
Robert Fuglevik, Floor Anderson, Kristian Kristensen Ordinary Seaman, Alf Sverra
Hansen Deck Boys, Einar Olsen, Johan Jacobsen Chief Engineer, Johannes Knudsrod.
2nd, Hartvig Kristiansen, 3rd Rolf Andersen 4th Einar Christensen Mechanics, Erling
Olsen, Leonard Hilland, Thomas Berg, Leif Henriksen, David Johansen, Kjell Gundersen,
Oilers Ragnar Andersen, Gunnar Nystrom Engine Room Boy, James Andersen Steward,
Frithjof Gundersen, Cook Olaf Eliasen, Galley Boy, Einar Jacobsen, Mess Boy,
Hakon Serensen, Saloon Boy, John Ronning Saloon Girl, Jenny Jensen
Passengers, Odd Nyrud, Peder Groderlund, Karl Fause, Charles Mikkelsen, Sigurd Vaage
Rasmussen, Thor Haugen, Leif Barto, Birgur Bjornsby, Trond Larsen, Ole Herman
Andersen. Passengers, Odd Nyrud, Peder Groderlund, Karl Fause, Charles Mikkelsen,
Sigurd Vaage Rasmussen, Thor Haugen, Leif Barto, Birgur Bjornsby, Trond Larsen, Ole
Herman Andersen. Hakon Serensen, Saloon Boy, John Ronning Saloon Girl, Jenny Jensen

For the following week work went on until the raider had taken in sufficient fuel, water and
vittles from her victim. A German prize crew under the charge of Leutenants Waldemann and
Muntz together with enough Norwegian sailors to man the ship, were then sent to the Tirranna.
When we came on deck on the following morning we found that the Tirranna had disappeared,
and A tlantis, which was presently disguised as the A bbekerk, was steaming Northward at a steady
twelve knots.
After several surreptitious meetings had been wangled it was two days after the capture of
Tirranna that we were allowed to mix with the Norwegians. Most of them spoke perfect English,
and it was with great interest that we listened to the latest British news of the fighting in Norway
and the reasons for the collapse of France. They were quite a decent crowd and very much like
ourselves, although there were one or two who were
53
suspected of being other. Quite a number of
them were working their passage home from Australia. They did so in order to join up
and help put a spoke in the wheel of the Nazi War machine; several had lost their
families in the German bombing raids. Five of their comrades had been killed by the
German gunners, another died later in the hospital of Atlantis and several lay wounded
and helpless in the care of the German doctors.
The Norwegians had of course got all their belongings, and much of their spare clothing
was given to us as ours was rather scanty with the weather being uncertain. Indeed it
was winter where we were in the Southern hemisphere, and when walking the decks for
our allotted exercise it could become quite chilly. They also shared their books and
playing cards with us, and in general we all got on quite well with each other. I
remember Anderson, or Andy as we called him; he was a typical Norseman and as
unconventional and adventurous as his famous forefathers the Vikings.
Andy moved in an atmosphere of romance, a romance that was toned to perfection by
years of hard and strenuous living. I see him now - his tanned features shaded by his
wide-brimmed Stetson - his wiry form poised athletically upon two self-shod feet;
entrancing his English audience with tales of the Australian bush and of the South
American Pampas. Andy knew the world and its people as well as a gamekeeper
understood the creatures of his forests. He seemed to have settled down for some years
on a sheep farm in Australia, until the rodents of Nazi Germany reared their ugly heads,
it was then that he decided to return to his native Norway in order to help exterminate
the plague of rats.
More than likely I was the youngest person on board A tlantis by being 16 years of age,
but 29 June 1940 marked my17th birthday. Despite being wished all the best, and a
hand shake or a pat on the back from his ship mates, as well as being presented with a
fizzy drink and a cake, there were to be no great celebrations. Indeed, I was not the only
one having a birthday, because with there being 365 days in the year, and about 730
people on board Atlantis, it would have meant on average that two people were having a
birthday every single day.
The noble art of boxing was as popular with the Germans as it was with us. A full sized
ring was roped off on No.2 hatch and several sets of gloves were provided for our use.
Then with much gasping (for we were well out of condition), we pummelled and
pounded each other with the ardour, if not the vigour, of a crowd of lads at the local

54
Boys' Club. The Germans were to hold a Boxing Tournament and various messes were hard at it
bringing their "hopefuls" up to standard.
The day came - a lovely day in early July. The ship was steaming on a Northerly course at a
steady ten knots. The sea was slight, and the almost imperceptible roll would not have any
appreciable effect on the footwork of the contestants. The boxing ring was bordered on each side
by rows of enthusiastic Germans, eagerly speculating as to what the result of the tournament
would be. In splendid isolation at the foot of the foremast sat the German officers. The prisoners
were clustered in the background with some sitting astride derricks and ventilator cowls. All the
Germans were dressed in spotless tropical uniforms - the scene reminding one of a function at an
English Garden Party - with a crowd of nondescript tramps craning their necks from various
points of vantage to obtain a glimpse of what was going on.
The judges were already in their seats, and the commentator was adjusting the "mike" to his
liking, when Kapitan Rogge came in from the starboard alleyway accompanied by one or two
senior officers. The Germans sprang - the prisoners shuffled to attention as that representative of
German naval might was ushered to his seat. He was a large man about six feet tall and broad in
proportion. He was rather dark, with a permanent thin-lipped smile which seemed to convey to
one's mind the three conflicting qualities of geniality - anxiety -and ruthlessness.
He held two Iron Crosses, a Life-Saving medal, and several medals from the last war. Although
his face was quite young and free from wrinkles, his head was partly bald, thus making it rather
difficult to estimate his age. He spoke sharply in his peculiar high-pitched voice - his crew
answered with a deep throated "Heil" The first combatants came smartly into the ring, and
Leutenant Bohle the referee introduced them to the spectators and delivered the usual caution and
address.
The round lasted two minutes, in which short space of time blood began to gush from Fritz's nose,
and his opponent's left eye soon succumbed to the violence of Fritz's attack.
The end of a round came, and the fighters staggered back to their corners to recuperate. The bell
went a minute later, and the two battle-scarred fighters returned to the struggle with renewed
vigour. Both men were too exhausted during the third and last round to inflict much damage on
his opponent, though I must say that each tried his best, judging by the wild swings and lunges
they made which provoked roars of merriment from the watching sailors.
The boxing tournament lasted all day, when during which time we witnessed many forms of
boxing from the hammer-and-tongs schoolboy fight briefly described above, to scientific boxing
of the approved style. There were one or two novel bouts fought - one of which is worthy of
mention. The largest man in the ship was matched against the smallest, and it was truly funny to
55
watch their antics in the ring and out. Ellman, my mate, and a keen boxer in his training-ship days
offered to meet one of the Tirranna men. The challenge was accepted, and they both disported
themselves valiantly, much gore being shed on both sides. It was a good fight, the decision given
being in favour of the Norwegian champion. A challenge was also issued to the Germans - a
chance to pay off old scores! As we expected, the challenge was refused as, owing to the -er --
international situation between the two countries, tempers might be strained, and the noble art
may lose some of its sporting significance and no doubt it would!
And all this while the special duty men were at their posts; those on the bridge navigating and
steering the ship, those in both crows nests with eyes peeled hoping they didnt see the dreaded
British cruiser, and those in the engine room awaiting the jangling sound of the telegraph. Indeed,
all it took was a single shrill whistle from the officer of the watch to denote the sighting of a ship;
that would result in State One action stations, and the decks of Atlantis would be cleared in a
flash.
At the end of the day, the final bout was held with both fighters demonstrating a great deal of
skill and resource. It was entrancing to watch the footwork of these champions; the rhythmic
sway of their bodies, the neat sliding stepping motion when avoiding a graceful, but deadly right
or a dainty left hook. In fact it was the nearest thing to dancing I have ever seen in a boxing ring.
One could almost hear the music! The next item on the agenda was the presentation of the prizes.
After a brief speech, in which he no doubt expressed his pleasure at witnessing such a display of
skill and endurance, Kapitan Rogge asked the victors to step up and receive their rewards. And
what rewards! Tins of jam and fruit, bars of chocolate, and other comestibles pilfered from the
Tirranna.
One young sailor was immensely proud of a huge German sausage which Kapitan Rogge had
bestowed upon him with his blessing! How we British managed to repress our mirth when we
saw this budding follower of the Fuehrer, a serious scowl on his broad countenance - his right
arm raised in the Nazi salute and his colossal German sausage tucked under his arm, I know not!
I smile now at the recollection.
One of the basic principles upon which our modern civilisation has been founded, is the
contention that business always follows pleasure. Therefore, it was in accordance with this rule
that we found ourselves rudely forced from the soft silkiness of a deep sleep by the strident sound
of the Klaxon sounding "Action Stations."

56
 Crew List of the MS Tirranna,
Supplied by the Norwegian Archives

Captain Edvard Hauff Gundersen 1st Mate Thorof Holst, 2nd Nils A Nilsen, 3rd Sven

Bjornby 4th, Leif Holberg Andersen Radio Officer Johny Haaland Electrician Otto

Kristensen Carpenter Johan Johansen Bosun Ole Paulsen ABs Hilmar Engelsen,

Robert Fuglevik, Floor Anderson, Kristian Kristensen Ordinary Seaman, Alf Sverra

Hansen Deck Boys, Einar Olsen, Johan Jacobsen Chief Engineer, Johannes Knudsrod.

2nd, Hartvig Kristiansen, 3rd Rolf Andersen 4th Einar Christensen Mechanics, Erling

Olsen, Leonard Hilland, Thomas Berg, Leif Henriksen, David Johansen, Kjell Gundersen,

Oilers Ragnar Andersen, Gunnar Nystrom Engine Room Boy, James Andersen Steward,

Frithjof Gundersen, Cook Olaf Eliasen, Galley Boy, Einar Jacobsen.

57
The time was 0700 and the day was Saturday 11th July 1940. Half awake we scrambled into our
clothes and made sure our life-jackets were handy - just in case. Our prison door was clanged to,
the scamper of feet and the clacking of breeches on the gun-flat above suddenly ceased; the roar
of the forced draught gradually died away like the cry of mortally stricken lion. We prisoners took
out our books, pencils and playing cards, and in that close silence we waited for - we knew not
what.
More than two hours later, the raider began pulsating with renewed vigour, and soon we heard the
dull boom of the gun flaps as they were drawn up on their pivots. Closely following were the
resounding crashes of the two six inch guns above our heads; echoed by the more distant sound of
the after guns. Little flakes of plaster fluttered down from the deck-head. Again the guns crashed
out, belching forth their missiles of death from flaming, reeking muzzles. Again the little room
resounded to that awful message of destruction. Again and yet again, until eventually all was
quiet.
In silence we watched the gay-curling waves of cordite smoke that irritated our nostrils and
wondered at the fate of our fellow seamen aboard this new victim of Nazi piracy, which we soon
learned, was the Ellerman steamer City of Baghdad of 5,800 tons.
Towards noon we were allowed on deck where we saw the City of Baghdad hove to a little abaft
our port beam. The two ships rose and fell lazily on the gentle swell, while the raider's launches
chugged to and fro between them. The City of Baghdads lifeboats had been hoisted aboard, and
were now lying on the raider's fore-deck, we therefore presumed that the City Boat men had also
been safely taken aboard.
The glaring sun poured its merciless rays upon the steel deck causing the paint to blister, thus
making the deck uncomfortably hot beneath our inadequately shod feet. Sharks abounded in the
tepid water, their dorsal fins making a sliver of white foam on the blue surface of the sea, as they
nosed their way through offal and refuse in search of food.
Occasionally the staccato crack of a rifle would break the still silence, and the marksman on the
bridge would grunt with satisfaction as a swirl of foam, and a darkening of the water gradually
told him that another shark had tasted the accuracy of his shooting. It soon became evident to us
that the raider was waiting for something to happen. The sailors lined the rails and bulwarks,
regarding their victim with intent expressions creasing their features. The officers were clustered
in expectant groups, on both the lower and navigating bridges with binoculars and cameras ready
for use at a moment's notice The raider's white motor-launch lay waiting between the two vessels,
her engine running, and her neat stem pointing towards the City of Baghdad.
Suddenly, several white-uniformed figures appeared on the Ellerman steamer's after well deck;
58
and almost simultaneously with the appearance of the Germans, the City of Baghdad blew up. A
blinding flash, a deafening roar, a column of black smoke, a momentary vision of machinery and
deck fittings hurled scores of feet skywards, then the pitter-patter of falling debris. Again the
blinding flash, the roar, and the falling debris as a second explosion shook the very foundations of
the ether.
Then as the smoke cleared we perceived as the beginning of the last act of a drama is seen beyond
the lifting curtain, the stricken British Merchantman, settling swiftly by the stern, her upper works
and funnel twisted into fantastic shapes, and burning with an all-consuming fire. Then we saw
something else; the sight of horrified Germans on the decks of the City of Baghdad, scurrying
with rats for company in an effort to reach the forward end of the sinking ship.
The City of Baghdad with her bottom blown out and her holds chock full of steel rails and
machinery, was doing her best to reach Davy Jones's Locker without any delay whatsoever.
Water was already swishing about her after-well deck as the terrified boarding party reached the
forward well-deck and flung over the pilot ladder. Scrambling down as far as they dared, they
shouted hoarsely for the launch to come alongside. The leading seaman in charge of the boat
seemed very reluctant to venture any nearer to the sinking ship, as he probably expected a third
explosion.
However, in obedience to the commands and entreaties of his comrades, he put his engine into
gear and swiftly went alongside the City of Baghdad. The wretched Germans tumbled thankfully
into the boat which dashed away at full speed to a safer area. Two minutes later, the City of
Baghdad, which was in fact a captured DDG Hansa Line steamer of the last war, gave a lurch,
and then shuddered violently, as though at some final reflection upon Nazi frightfulness, and then,
as water spouted from her after ventilators and samson posts, she slid swiftly towards her last
resting place.
As her bow lifted, the crews of the forward 75 mm opened fire on their fallen victim with all the
callous indifference of base-born serfs of their Nazi War Lord. The action may have been
regarded by them as being in the nature of a salute, a gesture of respect, but judging by their
expressions of fiendish delight, I would condemn such an action merely as an obdurate, but novel
diversion from target practice.
We were never told the true facts of the case, or any other facts for that matter, but our theory was
the bomb fuses had been mis-timed and the City of Baghdad had blown up prematurely.
Certainly, the officer in charge, Leutenant Fehler, was wounded in the arm, and they may have
left some dead behind them. Such a possibility is not unlikely, but is only conjecture on my part.
Soon we were ordered below where we prepared our mid-day meal, and then waited impatiently
59
for our new mess-mates to come below to join us. At last they came, some in uniform,
some in everyday working clothes, a few bandaged, several haggard and weary, but all
dirty and wonderfully cheerful.
We welcomed them, almost literally with open arms, and listened as only we, who had
not heard such music for ten weeks to the harmony of the pleasant North Country burr,
mingled with unintelligible Highland accents as several voices were raised in greeting.
We listened sympathetically to the story they had to tell us. They were bound from the
Dutch East Indies towards Colombo when the raider caught them.
The German opened fire without warning, killing two Lascars and severely wounding a
quartermaster and the senior radio officer, who was at his wireless post calling for
assistance. They abandoned ship and were picked up by the raider, where they were
treated courteously by their captors. The injured had their wounds dressed, and the
others were given cups of strong tea to revive them after their experience. They then
witnessed the destruction of their ship from the raider's boat deck.
The Baghdad crowd as we collectively called the crew gave us all the recent news, most
of which we had heard, with embellishments, on the American radio; we in our turn
gave them our story and also many things we had found out concerning the internal
management and tactics of our commerce captors.

Crew List of the SS City of Baghdad,

Supplied by Cadet Graeme Cubbin.

Captain J Armstrong-White 1st Mate W Piercy - 2nd Mate G Stuart - 3rd Mate H

Steele Chief Engineer R Jack - 2nd J Carneigie 3rd J Lowrie 4th P Grimes 5th

W Skilling Apprentices G Treasurer and W Paton Cadet JN Robinson

Carpenter W McKinnon Gunner J Stamper RN Radio Officers W Brett and J

Earp Quartermasters E Langrick, H McKay, S Tilney, R Graham.

60
 SS Kemmendine

All that night and the following day, the raider steamed in a South Westerly direction at full
speed, while the morning of Monday 13th July found us taking our morning exercise on the fore-
deck. Towards eleven o'clock, we were disturbed by a voice from the bridge ordering us below.
All the look-outs were focussing their powerful glasses on some distant object on our port-bow,
and several of our men who had jumped up onto the hatch, declared they could see a smudge of
smoke on the horizon.
The Klaxons then began to blare forth their message of alarm and we were herded below, moving
as slowly as possible and doing our best to block the narrow ladders and alleyways, often
incurring a most edifying flow of Germanic vituperation from excited sailors whose right of way
we obstructed. Entering our quarters the door was locked and we were left to talk and meditate as
we would. Twenty minutes later, the raider opened fire, and our quarters seemed to become part
of that universe of sound with which we (and no doubt the reader) had already become so
accustomed. Some minutes later the bombardment ceased, only to break out anew five minutes
later.
This was something new in our experience, and the incident occasioned us a certain degree of
hope, coupled with a little anxiety. It was as though the raider's victim was a decoy which had
returned her fire that percolated our brains. If such was the case the time had come for us to don
our life-jackets, and so, with mixed feelings, we strapped on our "petticoats", prepared for the
worst but hoping for the best.
However despite the fact that one chap swore he heard the sound of a direct hit somewhere above,
the firing ceased as suddenly as it began; the doctor then came below to tell us that the new prize
was the Henderson liner Kemmendine (7,700 tons) of Glasgow. She had fired back at the raider
after surrendering, thus causing the raider to open fire on her for a second time.
There was a bit of a stink about this infringement of International Law and common decency, and
Gunners McDonald and Riley were the victims of a stormy interview with Kapitan Rogge. It was
however, all due to a misunderstanding caused no doubt by the excitement of the chase. It
appeared that after the raider had opened fire, the Kemmendines gunners ran and loaded their
weapon without waiting for the arrival of the gun's crew.
By not hearing any word from the bridge, and in61thinking that the telephone communication had
been damaged, the two men opened fire at the now quiescent raider, little knowing that
their ship had already surrendered. Of course the raider answered. It was only then on
the orders of their captain, that Gunners A McDonald and R Riley left the gun-platform
and went to their boat stations. Incredible as it sounds, no one was either killed or
injured, even though the raider had hit her about thirty times and set her on fire.
The radio officer had a very narrow escape, one of the Lascar sailors jammed his fingers
in the boat lowering tackle, the fifth engineer got thoroughly soaked when he fell into
the sea, and two cats were killed by shell splinters. That was the sum total of the
Kemmendines casualties. Yet in a later action, and although the ship was hit no more
than three or four times, six good men lost their lives and several others were badly
injured. But more about that later.
At about one clock we were allowed on deck where we could see the Kemmendine
blazing furiously on our starboard quarter. Her eight life-boats were alongside the raider,
and German sailors were busy lashing them together. Hearing a cheery Glasgow-
cultured voice above us, we looked up towards the saloon deck and beheld with interest
an ancient mariner, a man who between the puffs of his old pipe remarked quite
composedly "Every doggie will hae it's day!" He was soon joined by several of his
comrades - also Scotsmen - who soon got into noisy conversation with our Scots. Soon
there was a confused babble of unintelligible sounds, punctuated with roars of laughter
as someone cracked an unfathomable Scottish joke. Words which I could grasp, such as
Saughiehall Street, Rangers, Tail O the Bank and Broomielaw emerged from the
perplexing jumble of phrases, like sparks leaping out from a red-hot jumble of metal ore.
And all telling my English mind that these Scottish barbarians were comparing notes as
to the achievements of the local football teams; and also their home address relative to
that of the "Towny", and so on; very confusing I know, but with all due respect I
maintain that Scotsmen, and particularly the species from Glasgow, are extremely
confusing to the English intellect. Then mingling with the noise of gay and careless
laugher, we heard an altogether new sound, a sound which many of us had not heard for
several months, the sound of children at play. It was almost as though in response to a
given signal, the men became silent as two children accompanied by their mother
emerged on to the fore-deck. They looked about them rather shyly, and at the sight of so
many bearded uncouth looking men, the little girl instinctively caught her brother's hand

62
and hugged her rag-doll closer. After the first momentary pause (during which, I am
sure, every heart went out to these innocent victims of oppression, every mind moulded
a curse on the heads of those beings who had brought about their misery), we found our
voices and the children soon lost their shyness. We learnt that their names were Robin
and Sally Swan. Robin was the eldest being a year older than his sister who was scarcely
three years old. They soon found that the tawniest beard could not hide a British sailor's
heart. In fact, they took great pleasure in tugging at a "set" occasionally much to the
delight of its proud owner. Robin even announced his intention to grow a "set" some
day. Despite the calamity which had befallen her and her children, the mother still wore
a brave charming smile and allowed no vestige of the truth to reach the ears of her
children. They were still confident in their own minds that they were going to Rangoon
to see Daddy, and only a contrary word from Mummy could shake that confidence.
Something inexplicable had happened to the Kemmendine. She had been fired upon
(Sally placed her little hands over her ears at the recollection) and set afire. They had
left the ship in the life-boats (poor Pussy had been left behind) They had then been taken
on board this other ship where they were greeted by strange men in clean white suits
who spoke English in a strange voice, and offered them lemonade and tea and chocolate.
They were not hurt and neither was Mummy or anyone else, everything was all right,
and they would be seeing Daddy in a few days time. But why had the Kemmendine been
fired upon? Their young minds refused to answer this question, but they soon forgot
their worries while playing with us. Also among the newcomers were four other women;
Mrs Blanchard and her sixteen year old daughter Joan, Mrs Hilton, and red-haired Miss
Botfield. They were all Brits and faced the uncertain future with a degree of courage and
fortitude that won the admiration of us all.
Our attention was next drawn to the following events. A German officer courteously
requested Mrs Swan to take the children inside their cabin as the guns were about to be
used. The Kemmendines life-boats which were by then securely lashed together were
allowed to drift as the raider got under way. A few moments later, at a range of about
2000 yards, the raider's after six-inch guns opened fire on the drifting boats. Several hits
were scored, and at least one boat was seen to be burning. Another was still afloat and
seemed, at that distance, to be still in good shape. The raider ceased fire; our attention
was then transferred to the blazing Kemmendine We then learned it was the Germans

63
intention to sink the doomed vessel by torpedo. Carefully the raider manoeuvred into the
most favourable position; a pause, then the sudden hiss of compressed air as the torpedo
sped on its way. Something must have happened to the depth mechanism, for we could
see the deadly "fish" leaping from one wave to another on the way to its target. Half a
minute passed and then the torpedo, despite the erratic course it had steered, found its
billet on the waterline of No. 2 hold a little forward of the bridge. A huge column of
water leapt to a point well above the Kemmendines foremast, but not a murmur of an
explosion did we hear as we were lying well to windward.
Minutes passed but that stout ship underwent no noticeable change. Half an hour later
the Kemmendine was still floating serenely and blazing furiously but still showed no
signs of sinking, and so the Germans decided to launch another torpedo. Again the sharp
hiss of compressed air, the splash, the long pause, and again the column of white water
as the episode reached its climax. The "tin fish" found its billet in almost the same place
as its predecessor. Nothing seemed to happen, and then a minute or two after the torpedo
had found its mark, we observed the Kemmendine slowly breaking in two. We could
imagine the creaking beams and groaning frames, all twisting in an effort to resist the
inexorable weight of the Kemmendine as she strove to break asunder.
The struggle lasted several minutes, and then the inevitable happened. With a final
rending of tortured steel, and like two wrestlers breaking from a deadly embrace, the
two halves drifted slowly apart. Swiftly, the Kemmendines after-end slid beneath the
heaving expanse of water, to be closely followed by the fore-part. A cloud of steam
drifted over the spot like a pall. On the raider's fore-deck we stood in silence. A
telegraph clanged blatantly, foam churned under the ship's trim stern as she pointed her
bows to the South. The guard cried "Unterdeck" and we filed below.

64
 Crew of the SS Kemmendine
Supplied by Cadet Graeme Cubbin

Captain R Reid, --1st Mate M Ramsay, 2nd J Whitehead, 3rd K Macleod, 4th A

McCulloch. Cadets, RE Skivington, J Park, L Brown Chief Engineer J Fisher

2nd T Frame 3rd J Gibson 4th R King 5th A Ross Radio Officers W Clark, R

McEwan Gunners R Riley, A McDonald Quartermasters, J Holland, A Clarke,

A Campbell, D Craig Chief Steward R Paterson 2nd J Holland Doctor J

McGowan Passengers, Miss Botfield, Mrs Hilton, Mrs Blanchard, Miss

Blanchard, Mrs Swan, Robin and Sally Swan.

Owing to the sudden increase in numbers it became necessary to re-arrange the living
quarters. Previous to the capture of the City of Baghdad we, the crew of the Scientist
who in being the privileged first-comers, had lived in the smaller but more comfortable
room next to the "hanger" of No. 2 hatch. The Norwegians had lived "next door" in what
had been No. 3 hatch. It was decided that the senior officers should live in the small
room (which was fitted out with 30 to 40 bunks) and junior officers and men should
move into the large room which had about 200 bunks. And so it was that 'Sleepy Valley'
and the "Boudoir" were broken up; only to assemble again in corners of the "place next
door".
New friends were found, new cliques formed, and beer-parties became a regular feature.
How or why our captors could allow such extravagance I cannot hazard a guess, but the
fact remains that crates of beer, bottles of whiskey and gin played a conspicuous part in
the evening's entertainment for many days to come. Whist drives and cribbage contests
were carefully planned, and even prizes awarded to successful players. The occasional
cinema show given by Leutenant Strekker was always looked forward to. The films
65
were usually comical and pointless with very little serious drama in them, and although
the dialogue was in German we could follow the trend of events quite well. Several
films showed peaceful English rural scenes and we also obtained glimpses of familiar
parts of the London which was so far away.
As you may guess, there was much theatrical and musical talent amongst us. Someone
had a mouth-organ and this remarkable instrument did wonders in leading choruses and
accompanying soloists, besides doing a bit of solo work on its own account. Once, at a
special "command" concert, one enterprising person asked Dr Sprung for the loan of his
piano-accordion; and what is more, he got it! At that, another enterprising chap offered
to go and borrow a fiddle and flute, and start a quartet, but he was promptly sat upon.
There were several comedians among us, but the best ones never realised how funny
they were until they were unceremoniously howled off the stage!
Our library had now achieved prodigious proportions. Besides an enormous amount of
magazines, ranging from Detective Weekly (10 cts.) to "Peg's Paper" (on sale
everywhere) we had quite an appreciable amount of serious reading matter, several
Bibles and testaments, a Church of England Prayer book, many of the approved classics,
novels and short stories. A librarian was appointed and books were loaned
systematically so that each man had something to read. We also had several technical
books on engineering, seamanship and navigation. A class for cadets was started, and
much of our time was spent in studying. We asked Leutenant Mohr, the officer in charge
of the prisoners, for volumes of Nautical Tables, Almanacs, etc. and we got them,
together with a chart, a pair of parallel rules, compasses, pencils, paper and work-books.
Every few weeks our instructors used to set examination papers, and the cadets (there
were seven of us at that time) were forced to go through all the sweat and labour of a
typical Second Mate's examination. Results, very insignificant at first, but became more
remarkable as time went on as our able tutors drilled the necessary knowledge into our
resilient minds.
Yes! The Cadets certainly have reason to be grateful to Joe Connolly of the Scientist
and Ken Macleod of the Kemmendine for the patience and broad-mindedness they
showed while successfully drumming into our heads the rudiments of our future work.
However, not all of our spare time was spent below decks; indeed, as much as six hours
a day was spent up above in the fresh air - usually on the boat-deck but sometimes on

66
the fore-deck. Each morning we had breakfast at 7.30, and at about 8.15 those of us
who wished to see the doctor were conducted to the dispensary. At 9 o'clock in response
to a shrill whistle and a gutteral command, we rushed up the ladders to the sunlit deck
where we spread blankets in the cosiest corners (usually in the lee of the boats) where
we either talked, read or played chess or even went to sleep. If we felt energetic we
paced up and down the space allotted to us, or played quoits, and sometimes, in bursts of
super-het energy, we even hurled medicine balls at each other, tumbled about on a large
wrestling mat, or tried to break our necks on a horizontal bar which had been erected for
the use of the more active of the Germans. We must not forget the children. A swing
was slung from one of No. 3 derricks, and the false coaming of No.3 hatch was turned
into a sand pit. Buckets and spades were conjured from somewhere and Robin and Sally
amused themselves at the seaside. Despite the fact that the raider had recently run out of
fresh potatoes, feeding at this period was at its best. Perhaps it was propaganda for the
benefit of the women, but the fact remains that luxuries such as tins of milk, white
bread, cocoa, and jam appeared more frequently on our meal tables. We missed the fresh
potatoes very much, their substitute being a brown, tasteless apology that had once,
many moons ago, been sliced, dried and preserved in the approved German fashion. We
disliked them, and I for one never got used to them, although I think however, that later
on we would have welcomed them in Somaliland, where potatoes were only half
preserved (and consequently half rotten) in the approved Italian fashion. However, apart
from the potatoes, food was good, declining in quality and quantity only after the
Tirranna had left for Germany and the raider had became more and more congested
with prisoners.
Modern Day Piracy ?
The salvaging of stores and equipment from a sinking ship may seem appropriate
as there is no need to let such items go to waste. But such a liberty does not apply
within the Rules of War when one ship purposefully sinks another. Indeed, there is
nothing in the same rules that says any attacking ship is allowed to plunder goods
from stricken ships and act as a parasite. Even though some German surface
raiders did feed their captives on the same ration scale as their own crews, the
removal of food, water, fuel or any other items from a sinking ship can only be
described as piracy.
67
When victuals in the store-rooms ran low shark
meat was often on the menu. Unfortunately
such fare was a last resort, shark meat tastes of
an oily disinfectant.
On board Atlantis sharks were quite often
caught for consumption.

The picture to the left shows a U-Boat crew

who are also short of vittles.

Above - Stewards from Atlantis pirating the

stores from one of their victims.

68
For a fortnight the raider zig-zagged Southward, but to us her intentions were evident.
She meant to rendezvous with the Tirranna and disembark the women and children.
Perhaps some of us would go along with them. We hoped so, for the chances of being
intercepted by a British Man O War were much greater than if we remained on the
raider. On the morning of 27 July the breakfast Peggies reported that as they went up
to the galley, they had seen Tirranna on the raider's port side,
At 9 o'clock, when we went up on deck, the raider was hove to, and the Tirranna with all
traces of damage removed, was lifting to the gentle swell on our starboard beam. Motor
launches, towing clumsy pitching lifeboats were already chugging to and fro with stores.
We were told that the provisioning of the Tirranna would be accomplished in four or
five days. In the meantime, a decision would be arrived at as to our future.
The next day we learned our fate, those that were to go in Tirranna consisted of women
and children, all the Indian passengers, all men over 50 years of age. (One man declined
the offer) and boys under 16. Mr Chicken the Scientist passenger was allowed to go,
also the wounded and men with uncertain constitutions whom the doctors believed
would receive better treatment in Germany. The remainder including the captains would
be obliged to accept the trend of circumstances and be the guests of Kapitan Rogge for a
while longer. Captain Windsor with the very best intentions, appealed to Kapitan Rogge
to allow his passenger (who was a non-combatant) to go, and also his wounded wireless
operator and junior cadet. He succeeded in Mr Chicken's case, but references to my
youth, my first voyage, and my future career, only made me blush, and as a result of my
captains efforts, Kapitan Rogge more determined to retain me. As for the wireless
operator, his wounds had healed, and he was obviously too resourceful to be allowed to
run the risk of falling into British hands. "No! Captain Windsor, you haf heard my
decision, I vish you gut morgen," and there the matter rested.
For the next few days the ships lay idle owing to the stress of bad weather, and the work
was recommenced on 1 August. On the following morning Friday 4 August, we said
goodbye to those whod been our companions during the last three months. Of the
Scientist we parted with Mr Skarrow the Chief Engineer, Mr Howarth the Chief
Steward, Dave Foulis our Third, old Barrow the QM, and the passenger Mr Chicken.
Nothing much was said; just a quick handclasp all round, a grin, the word Good Luck
and they were off. We watched them climb down the pilot ladder, clasping their pitiful

69
bundles of possessions, and their life-jackets. They took their seats in the boat, and
waved cheerfully as the engine woke into life. On the boat-deck someone called for
three cheers; they were given, and answered with a wi11. As we watched the boat rise
and fall over the rolling swell, someone began singing "Auld Lang Syne". It was taken
up immediately and kept up until the boat drew alongside the Tirranna and its occupants
clambered aboard. Their subsequent adventures are re-counted elsewhere.
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
It is enough to say here, that Tirranna was torpedoed by the British submarine
HMS Tuna in the Gironde Estuary. 83 of her passengers and crew were drowned
while the remainder of her prisoner passengers finally arrived in Vichy France and
sent to prison camps in Germany.

70
 MS Talleyrand

For the purpose of effect in the next account, I will imagine myself as a witness of
events on the raider's navigation bridge on 2 August 1940.
It was one of those dull days which occur periodically in all parts of the globe. The sea
was of a dullish grey colour, meeting the equally sombre sky in the vague, indefinite
line which warned us to expect rain. Indeed, here and there white patches of mist
indicated the rain-squalls were already scurrying over the blank surface of the sea.
Occasionally a watery sun peeped cautiously from behind a grey curtain of
cloud only to withdraw again as though in dismay, at the prospect of shining on such a
drab scene. The morning had been fine, Tirrannas passengers had been embarked
without incident with many of the officers and men on board; the officers at a farewell
lunch and the men working. At noon the weather had become cold and damp. Visibility
was poor and the officer of the Watch had given orders for an extra sharp look-out to be
kept. An unusually thick squall was just passing over, and eyes were straining to pierce
the rising mist, and then several lookouts saw it at the same instant. With anxious hails
they pointed. There, silently gliding towards us was the vague outline of a long lean
grey shape. For several seconds, the officer of the watch stared at the apparition, and in
that few seconds that lean grey shape glided closer. With an oath, the German recovered
something of his habitual composure. Shouting an order to the helmsman he frantically
sounded the alarm. Telegraphs clanged and the raider got under way.
Down in the prisoners quarters the men leapt hurriedly out of their bunks. (It was a
recognised item of routine to turn in for a siesta after lunch). Something told them that
this was not an ordinary action. Instead of the rhythmic alarm signal to which we were
by that time accustomed, the Klaxons sounded jerky and incoherent - panic personified
in sound. The persistent whining of forced draught had not been shut down, and the
loud-speaker was still blaring forth some sentimental homeland ballad.
At the first strident blast from the Klaxons, there was a clatter of tables and benches
overhead as the sailors dashed to their stations. Several passed our door (which was
open) and judging by the white tense faces, none of them was happy. After some delay
the guard materialised and tried to lock our door. But his trembling fingers dropped the
key as he was pulling the door to and he had some difficulty in retrieving it (I think it
was one of the passengers who put his foot on it.) Two minutes after the alarm had gone
the raider opened fire - three shots and all was silent. What had happened? We were all
certain that the raider had encountered a British warship. Had she surrendered without
giving fight? As if in answer to our questions, the door was opened and in stepped Dr
Riel to tell us, much to our chagrin, and no doubt to that of the reader, that the raider had
unexpectedly captured another Norwegian merchant ship. He wiped a little perspiration
from his forehead, and with a rueful grin, admitted that events had occurred too
suddenly for comfort. The Tallyrand was painted a deluding Admiralty grey (an
unusual colour for merchant ships then) and was a sister ship belonging to the same
company as the raider's earlier prize Tirranna.
Some time later we were allowed on deck. The Tirranna was lying hove to on our
starboard quarter, close enough for us to see her passengers who waved reassuringly as
we emerged on deck. The Tallyrand was close on our port bow, and already had a pipe
line connecting her fuel tanks with those of the raider. Dirty streaks of oil on the surface
of the water told us that pumping operations were now in progress. Instead of coming
aboard the raider and being taken prisoner, the crew of the Tallyrand was immediately
put aboard the Tirranna.
The evening of the 4th August found the work of preparing the Tirranna for her long
voyage fully completed. The Germans had also methodically deprived the Tallyrand of a
useful portion of her cargo and stores, some of which, together with her lifeboats and
rafts, had been placed at the disposal of the Tirrannas complement. The task of
destroying the Tallyrand now confronted the Germans. This they decided to do by
means of time-bombs placed in her engine room. We were brought on deck in time to
see the raider's smart white launch leaving the side of the doomed vessel. Withdrawing
to a safe distance, the launch stopped, while her occupants watched the Tallyrand
intently.
Evidently the Germans had learnt the lesson so drastically demonstrated by the City of
Baghdad during her destruction. For twenty minutes we watched and waited, while the
blood-red sun sank lower in the heavens. The scene was one I shall never forget. Sun,

72
sea and sky were so artistically blended together that no humble words of mine could
possibly serve to transfer that beauteous picture from its setting to your imagination.
High above, fluffy white clouds chased each other like first year lambs in a meadow of
blue. A gentle breeze ruffled the heaving bosom of the ocean, while occasionally the
declining sun glinted on silver wings as a shoal of flying-fish shimmered across the
water. Overhead a splendid albatross circled, her mighty wings scarcely trembling as she
glided gracefully between the idly floating ships. On our starboard side lay the
Tallyrand, every detail clearly outlined in the concentrated, fiery glare of the sun, while
beyond her lay the shadowy silhouette of Tirranna enveloped in the slight haze of the
eastern sky-line.
By this time we were beginning to think the explosives officer had been too cautious in
setting the fuses, but our doubts were rudely cast aside as the Tallyrand with a shattering
roar, seemed to split in twain amidships. A second explosion, further aft this time,
seemed to crumble her hull like matchwood. The black smoke drifted rapidly to
leeward, leaving the Tallyrand sinking by the stern. She was blazing furiously, the
flames un-dulled by smoke, were intensified to an infernal brilliancy by the blood-red
orb of the setting sun. For perhaps ten minutes this awe-inspiring picture thrilled the
most adamantine soul, and then like a startled horse, she reared her head delicately for a
moment with her decks perpendicular to the sea with more than half her length pointing
skywards.
Then she slid swiftly to her last resting place, the dull rumble of her
tumbling cargo sounding like the muffled roll of many drums. In silence we regarded
the disturbed mass of water which had closed over the Tallyrand shutting her off for
ever from the sight of man. How fervently we all hoped to be witnesses of the raider's
own demise in her last dive. Meanwhile, we took a last look at the Tirranna before being
marshalled below. We could see her vaguely silhouetted against the eastern sky-line,
and wishing our friends the very best of good fortune, we silently bid her adieu, and
filed below.

73
 Crew List for the MS Tallyrand
Supplied by the Norwegian Archives.

Captain. Mathias Foyne First Mate, Per Baero 2nd Thor Thoresen 3rd Finn

Bjorneby -- 4th Bjornes Olsen Radio Officer Pedar Haus Carpenter Hans

Brufold -- Bosun Nils Hansen -- ABs Harald Andersen, Ole Evensen, -- Ordinary

Seamen, Hans Maras, Andor Dass, -- Gunnar Hjerpekjonn, Helge Oseberg,Deck

Boys, Johny Karlsen, Just Jaren Chief Engineer, Lars Bjorneseth, 2nd Anker

Tvete, 3rd Olaf Brunsted, 4th Otto Paulsen Stewardess, Sigrid Olsen Electrician,

Asbjorn Foss Haneborg Mechanics, Haakon Quistgaard, Fritz Axelsen, Sverre

Svendsen, Pedar Saalar, Thomas Larsen, Olaf Simonsen, -- Oilers, Eigil Jensen,

Arnt Olsen, Erling Mork, Gustav Soli, Karl Ohlsen Cook, Ashborn Bjornsen

Galley Boy, Erling Andersen Mess Boy, Gustaf Jansson-- Jugman Jens Bang.

74
 The Tragedy of the SS King City

Two days after the MS Tirranna had escaped the clutches of Atlantis, the raider hung
around Mozambique. Rogge was hoping to intercept allied merchantmen coming from
the Far East and the Sub-Continent on their way to the Cape of Good Hope. Despite the
fact that Kapitan Rogge was highly regarded for his fair play and acts of humanity, it
was when the SS King City became his latest victim that he lost some of that respect.
The incident took place in the middle watch of 24 August 1940, when the A tlantis was
off Madagascar in 16.30 S - 65.30 E.
Ugh! A beastly night if ever there was one. Mr Robson the mate chewed at the stem of
his empty pipe to show his disgust. He paced the wing of his inhospitable bridge for a
few moments, and then snuggled into the lee of the wheelhouse as an extra heavy squall
overtook the ship. Beastly weather! Still, it wasnt as bad as it had been, and the
morning should see the wind and sea easing somewhat. Steaming without lights the
officer peered grimly into the black obscurity of the night. Not that peering did any
good; it was too dark for him to see his own ships foredeck, let alone a lurking
submarine. But it was nevertheless, the duty of all good watch-keeping officers to peer,
and so Mr Mate peered. He relieved the strain of his concentrated gaze by taking a few
perfunctory paces to the wing of the bridge. As he did so, he reflected bitterly on the
perversity of fate which had maliciously engineered a break down in the engine room in
this wild godforsaken part of the ocean. Here they were, merely drifting along at barely
two knots, with raiders and U Boats being reported in the vicinity. Once again the mate
peered anxiously into the blackness of the night. Two blooming knots! The old tub
could never do more than eight in any case, but even that was better than a two knot
crawl. Bah! The mate bit deeply into his long suffering pipe stem.
Down below, the engineers sweated freely as they toiled at the recalcitrant engines. A
wheezy antiquated maze of machinery it was too. Second Engineer West removed his
greasy cap and scratched his head in bewilderment. Not that he didnt know what the
problem was with the engines; he did; and it was that knowledge which caused the

75
irritation of his scalp. Why on earth he thought to himself, was an ancient craft such as
this ever allowed to put to sea in the first place? Everything on it that was touched
rattled and threatened to carry away.
Meanwhile in the galley, the cook was hastily chasing pots and pans as they careered
wildly across his coal burning range without range bars. Why didnt somebody invent a
galley on gimbals enquired Taylor the second cook to his boss, as he deftly prevented a
huge kettle from dousing the fires. Mr Ferreira the cooks reply need not be mentioned.
What a night! Or morning rather, the time was nearly five oclock. Such was the state of
affairs on board the SS King City during the morning watch of 24 August 1940; or at
any rate that is how my imagination portrayed it on the subsequent accounts Id been
given.
At five oclock the engineers came to realise that their efforts had all been in vain.
Having had little sleep in the preceding days, they wearily laid down their tools, and
then watched as the pistons moved slower and slower in their cylinders. Then stopped!
The vast hall of machinery became silent, a silence broken only by the occasional clatter
of a coal shovel and the hissing of escaping steam.
Up on the bridge the First Mate Mr Robson had halted his regular pacing. He missed the
wheezing throb of the triple expansion engines, and on looking over the bridge wing
noticed that his ship was moving even slower. His jaws clamped over his pipe stem as
he grunted his annoyance. What the devil were those so called engineers playing at?
Removing his pipe he blew impatiently down the engine room voice pipe and opened
his mouth to let fly a carefully chosen expletive. But what he said will never be known,
because from that moment on all hell broke loose.
A vivid orange flash from seaward was followed by a deafening roar from somewhere
beneath him. For a second and third time the phenomenon was repeated. The acrid taint
of cordite fumes attacked the officers nostrils. Another explosion - internal this time.
What was to be done? A searchlight dazzled him for a moment, and then shifted slightly
to light up the scene with a cold clear light. The Reardon Smith ship King City of
Cardiff was wallowing awkwardly in the rough sea; she was ablaze in the midship
accommodation, and flames poured out from what had once been the officers cabins.
The bewildered expression of the mate changed to one of horror, as out of the blackened
wreckage crawled the pitiable figure of the Second Mate Mr Gasgarth. Behind him he

76
dragged the pulp of what had once been his left leg. The wounded man gave a weak cry
for help, a cry that despite his weakness, was one resounding with that of pain and
despair. On seeing him in his plight, the watch on deck ran to his assistance, and
between them they helped him into the nearest boat which by that time was being
prepared for lowering. Slowly the searchlight focussed on another part of the doomed
vessel, where sailors were making a valiant attempt to enter a burning cabin.
Looking like monsters from another world in the combined glare of the flames and the
searchlight, they toiled to liberate the four apprentices from the terrible inferno of the
cabin in which they were trapped. The rescuers could see one of them badly caught
beneath a pile of twisted metal debris; they knew he was conscious as they could hear
his screams. As they toiled away a heavy beam fell with a crash and the screams
stopped. Nothing more could be done for those four teenaged boys, so the men hastened
to their boat stations.
Meanwhile below decks on the raider, we heaved a sigh of relief when we realised that
the last shot had been fired. The raucous clamour of the klaxons had tumbled each of us
from our bunks at the unheard of time of 3 am. Half an hour later we were told not to
expect an attack until daybreak in two hours time. Therefore, many of us turned in
again, only to be rudely awakened a short time later by the thunder of the A tlantis guns.
In just thirty seconds the action was over. It was only when we met the survivors of the
King City some time later, that the full horror of the tragedy was brought home to us. It
seemed quite unbelievable, that just three shots in such a short space of time had killed
six good men and injured many more. Those of you who have read thus far will realise
that such a casualty list is not formidable; but in comparison to the earlier actions, when
casualties had been relatively light, the SS King Citys list of dead and injured was
indeed a heavy one. In comparison, when A tlantis captured the faster Norwegian
Tirranna, after a three hour long chase, an estimated sixty 5.9 inch shells had been fired
at her. The fleeing Norseman was actually outstripping the raider with her 18 knots, but
from 8,000 yards one of those shells hit the poop deck killing all five of the gunners, and
only that caused her devastated captain to surrender.
What was even more surprising, was the fact that of the 200 souls aboard the SS
Kemmendine, and the heavy bombardment they had been through, there were no
injuries or loss of life whatsoever. Nevertheless, us prisoners on board Atlantis were all

77
deeply touched by the grief which filled the men of the King City, and as on most tramp
steamers the crew is normally a large and happy family; but the sudden death of six of
their comrades filled the survivors with a bitter hatred towards the perpetrators of the
outrage. There was little we could say or do, except to mourn with them.

Crew list of SS King City

Supplied by Cadet G Cubbin

Master H Marshall 1st Mate K Robson 2nd T Gasgarth 3rd F Johns

Apprentices H Davison, L Bailey, L Thomas, A Radford - Radio Officer S Law -

Carpenter A Knight Gunner J Dial Bosun A Doyle ABs J McNair, A

Wiseman, G McIntyre, D McClean Firemen - R Hardy, R Hall, E Jones, J

Bushel, A Potts, A Buggs Chief Engineer, P Lashford 2nd R West, 3rd N Kemp,

4th J Mosey, 5th W Taylor, 6th H Dunn Chief Steward V Priern, 2nd, GL Beattie,

3rd SM McCarthy Chief Cook, V Ferreira, 2nd L Taylor.

Total Crew 34, Survivors 28.

On board Atlantis we did not actually see the sinking of the King City, but after the
survivors had been rescued and incarcerated with the rest of us, her crew were able to
give us both a verbal and graphic description of the horrific events theyd encountered.
The surprise attack occurred when the middle watch had just turned in and the morning
watch had turned to, with the ship waking up shortly before 5 am to begin another day.
It was then that flashes of gunfire came from out of the miserable weather, followed
almost immediately by direct hits on their little coal carrying tramp steamer. Then came
the explosions, clouds of smoke and steam, with coal pouring out of the ruptured
78
number four hold and into the sea. Quite naturally there was an amount of excusable
panic on the Cardiff registered ship, as those who were turned in quickly turned out, in
horror, shock and surprise.
It is here that we can introduce a certain character, whose genius for drawing and
sketching, as well as his passion for acrimonious arguments made him most popular
amongst his shipmates. His name was Cyril Burns, a gunner from our own ship
Scientist. With infinite patience combined with his natural genius, and despite the fact
that paper of any description was hard to come by, Burns drew many vigorous scenes
with regard to the German raiders actions. These included vivid little sketches of our
ship Scientist being torpedoed, the sinking of the City of Baghdad, and the blazing
Kemmendine.
At times he would combine his ability to sketch with a dry, almost cynical sense of
humour, and produce a cartoon of Kapitan Rogge with his terrier cowering at his feet.
Another was of the German captain cordially welcoming a Royal Navy boarding party
aboard his ship.
On other occasions a bridge party would be the subject of Cyril Burns artistic skills,
while the characters displayed would be surprised, if not a little sheepish, to see their
portraits true to life, with their expressions cunningly disfigured and exaggerated, with
regard to their more prominent physical features, these caricatures were openly
displayed for all on board to see.
Then again Cyril had a powerful flair for observation; his plans and diagrams that were
made on board the raider, earned him the whole hearted admiration of all on board, and
later, that of the Royal Navy to whom such documents were deemed to be most
valuable. Although he had not seen the King City, it was after hed been given a
description of the ship from various members of the crew, that Cyril our gunner was
able to add yet another set of drawings to his extensive series.

79
 Note

With regard to the unfortunate tramp steamer K ing City, it must be said that quite unlike
some of the more illustrious shipping companies like Cunard, Blue Funnel, NZSC and a
few more which had regular and profitable trading routes, the K ing Citys owner Sir
William Reardon Smith had to rely on scraps and charters for his company to survive.
There were a large number of such tramping companies sailing under the Red Ensign,
and those ill found firms were given the appellation of being hungry by the deck and
engine crowds, combined with one or two other unprintable expletives. But in order to
survive the rigours of business, those so called hungry companies had to be parsimonious
as they carefully counted their pennies. Although the rates of pay were the same on all
foreign going ships under the Red Ensign, it was the food, conditions and overtime that
were the main items of attraction for the sailors, firemen and stewards.
For more than a hundred years there were ships that carried as many apprentices as they
could, quite simply because their wages were so low they were almost none existent. An
example of this was the wages of Cadet Graeme Cubbin of the SS Scientist; his wages
began at 6 per annum, rising by annual increments of 6 to 24 in his final year. His
bond payment had been 50, so after four years of almost free labour it was returned to
his father. In other words it was four years of almost free labour for the ship owner.
Cadets, midshipmen and apprentices in this respect were all in the same boat.
Due to its tonnage, each ship sailing under the Red Ensign had to ship a given number of
able seamen when the ship opened her articles. In the case of K ing City that number
would have been eight, but only four ABs were signed on. Indeed, clever Captain
Marshall had counted himself and his three mates as able seamen to bring the required
number up to eight. Those four aforesaid officers all had an able seamans certificate; it
was a requirement they needed before sitting their second mates ticket; the result being
that Captain Marshall had saved four ABs wages by replacing them with four free labour
apprentices. Just a small point of the path those so called hungry outfits had to take in
order to survive. The quantity and quality of the food was something else, and so was the
accommodation. Nevertheless, whether hungry or not, those tramp steamers provided
work which in hard times was often gratefully taken by the sailors, firemen and stewards.

Author

80
It was just after breakfast on 9 September 1940, when the klaxons heralded the doom of
yet another unsuspecting vessel. A tanker this time, or so we were informed by the
commentator speaking through the medium of the loudspeaker. The rhythmic thudding
of the raiders engines subsided to a dull throbbing noise, which made us
realise that the tanker was in range of the raiders guns. Through the inspection port of
our locked door, we could see the sentry puffing away spasmodically at his cigarette.
We spoke little, and even then it was in awed whispers.
Suddenly, the resounding boom of the gun flaps was followed by the crash of the first
salvo bringing flakes of plaster fluttering down from the deck-head. Crash ... Crash ...
Crash ... It was all over! Half an hour passed before the sentry opened the door. But no
sooner had he hooked it back onto its clip than the staccato crack of pom-poms and the
rattle of machine guns startled us all. It startled the sentry as well as ourselves,
whereupon our door was locked shut again. More machine gun bursts. Later on we
learned that those machine guns had been trained on the tankers life boats, the reason
being as follows. Quite recently the admiralty had issued orders to the effect, that British
merchant ships should repeat all SOS messages.
The latest victim of the A tlantis turned out to be the 9,557 GRT Athel King of
Liverpool who had sent out her distress call before surrendering and abandoning ship.
But the tankers message had been picked up by another ship which must have been
close by over the horizon. Some time after the tankers crew had abandoned their ship,
the nearby ship Benarty had repeated the SOS message, but the telegraphists of Atlantis
had intercepted it and must have thought that the A thel King was still sending.
It was at this point when conflicting reports of murder were made. One account states
that the enraged Kapitan Rogge was under the impression the A thel Kings sparky had
stayed on board, and that he was still sending raider warnings after the tankers captain
had surrendered and abandoned ship. As a result of that, the unfounded rumour goes,
the supposedly livid Kapitan Rogge ordered the shelling of the A thel King and set her
ablaze before machine gunning the manned lifeboats boats in the water. That unfounded
story was later given to the British authorities where it was believed in wide circles.
This was probably because in August 1940, The German raider W idder had intercepted
the British SS A nglo Saxon in the Atlantic when she was taking coal from Newport
Mon. To Bahia Blanca. Sunk without warning Kapitan Ruckteschell of the W idder had

81
ordered the machine gunning and killing of 34 survivors in the open lifeboats. But after
having been in a jolly boat for 71 days, two men survived to tell the tale and gave their
account to the British authorities. The story then went around that all German raiders
machine gun survivors of sunken ships.
Kapitan Rogges account of the A thel Kings sinking was quite different even though
there were casualties on board the tanker. Some of the survivors were heavily bloodied
as a result of their injuries, and the boats in which they embarked were covered in blood.
After having taken the A thel Kings survivors on board Atlantis, and then on sinking the
tanker, he set about destroying the empty lifeboats with machine gun fire. However,
one of those boats remained afloat, and some time later when that empty lifeboat was
discovered and identified as being from the A thel King, the blood which still stained the
boat started the story that the survivors of A thel King had met the same fate as those on
the A nglo Saxon.
With regard to the SS A nglo Saxon, Korvettankapitan Ruckteschell of the W idder was
convicted of war crimes in 1946. His crime amongst others had been the murdering of
34 crew men of the SS A nglo Saxon in August 1940. One source states that
Ruckteschell was given a life sentence and sent to prison in 1947, shortly afterwards he
was pardoned through lack of sufficient evidence; but the day before his release he died
in the prison; whereas Kapitan Rogge was never accused of any of War Crimes.
Shortly after the machine gunning episode from A tlantis, we were herded on deck to
witness the all conquering Hun administer the coup de gras to the Athel King. We lined
the rail of the boat deck and studied the molasses tanker intently. She seemed to be a
ship of about 8,000 tons, her grey hull standing out sombrely against the blue of the sea,
while her yellow funnel added a dash of colour to her appearance. A thel King was riding
high out of the water, and we could quite clearly see the black oil dribbling like blood
from the gaping wounds in her red boot topping. Her six inch gun which had been fired
twice in self defence was still pointing menacingly in our direction. A fire which had
started near the funnel increased until the after end of the ship became a raging inferno.
As we watched the flames reached the gun platform where the ready-use shells exploded
with loud cracks in a last gesture of defiance. The raider drew off and out of the way.
Steering around to windward the raider opened fire on the hapless ship with her main
armament. We watched in fascination as shell after shell tore gaping holes in the Athel

82
Kings shell plating. She began to settle by the stern while the German gunners
concentrated their fire on her engine space. She was sinking fast now. Swiftly her bows
rose from out of the swirling water in an ever increasing arc towards the sky. They rose
until the ships stem was well above the sea, rising above the billowing steam like the
peak of a mighty mountain above a stratum cloud.
For several moments she poised hesitating before taking the plunge. Swiftly she began
to slide beneath the waves, but instead of her sinking with increasing speed, she
slackened her pace as though checked by some mighty hand. With the water lapping
against the break of her focsle head she stopped and then most amazingly she began
to rise again! I recalled a film I had one seen, a film in which Frankensteins monster
climbs slowly and remorselessly from his steamy reeking cell. It was an uncanny but
awesome sight. But to see the bows of the tanker rising from the maelstrom of steam
and sea was indeed like the same great monster. A ship sailing upwards no less!
Nevertheless, the A thel King was a great tribute to those whod built her.
But there is a limit even to the strength of a Clyde built ship, and at last her bulkheads
gave way to the tremendous pressure surrounding them. As the ship sank she seemed to
writhe like a living creature in the relentless grip of unseen forces. Later on we met the
dishevelled crew of the tanker. From them we learned that their captain had been killed.
But there were those who said he had merely been wounded, and had then deliberately
been shot by the German boarding party when they ascertained that he was a Jew. The
carpenter and an apprentice had also lost their lives while the chief officer and several of
the crew were receiving treatment for wounds suffered from shrapnel. The A thel Kings
gun crew had fired two shots at A tlantis but recorded no hits.

83
 SS Athel King Crew List
Supplied by Cadet G Cubbin

Captain AE Tomkins - 1st Mate, W Meneight, 2nd J Tharm, 3rd K Gorrie -

Apprentices H Sutcliffe, R Reece Heal - Radio Officer H Coates - Carpenter R

Davies - Bosun J Doherty - ABs, J Solomon, W Chamberlain, J Morris, A Ferret -

Ordinary Seamen W Williams, S Bates, W Davies, D Ralph, Jennings, Boden -

Chief Engineer C Hutton, Snr 2nd W Winn, Jnr 2nd S Fisk, Snr 3rd J Wilson, Jnr

3rd E Bain, Snr 4th W Prendergast, Jnr 4th PF Malpas - Donkeyman T Winters -

Firemen, A Grant, J Farrel, P Larrisy, J Goliath, G Allenson, J Brown - Chief

Steward WJ Smith 2nd AThornton - Cook A Martin 2nd G Bosman - Mess Room

K Roberts, W Smith.

84
 SS Benarty

The raider signals that were sent out on the previous day by A thel King had been
intercepted by the nearby SS Benarty. They in turn were re-transmitted by the Ben Line
steamer in the hope that a British warship was close by and could deal with the situation.
But most unfortunately, the only ship in the vicinity was the A tlantis, and it was her
CPO radio operator Willie Krooss who intercepted the signal.
On the following morning while searching for the ship that repeated the raider signal, a
tiny smudge of smoke from an obvious coal burner, was sighted by the A tlantis crows
nest lookouts. The sea was flat calm, and Kapitan Rogge who decided to keep his ship
well out of sight sent up the seaplane to find out more about the distant ship. Rogge had
to be careful, indeed, it so happened that Atlantiss fellow raider and sister ship Pinguin
(ex Kandenfels) was operating in the same area, and in being aware of this, Rogge
didnt want any errors of one ship attacking the other. Therefore, in position 18 S and
54 E, A tlantis stopped to lower her seaplane over the side from number two hold.
Flying Officer Bulla and Leutenant Bouchert his observer knew their drill, in that, if it
was an Allied ship, they were to fly low over her from out of the sun, bring down her
radio aerial with a grapnel and rough her up a bit.
Sure enough it was an Allied ship and one that went by the name of Benarty, registered
in Leith and under the ownership of William Thompson; completed by Charles Connell
of Scotstoun in 1926, she was 5,880 GRT and on passage Rangoon towards Liverpool
via Durban; she was carrying a valuable cargo of tin, rubber and zinc.
As a result of that the seaplane approached from out of the sun, streamed her grapnel
and successfully ripped the out radio aerial. With the aerial having been brought down,
the ship from Leith went flat out at 13 knots to escape. But it was all to no avail as
Atlantis easily caught up with her. On closing to within range, the usual warning shots
were fired by the raiders focsle head gun, but there was no immediate surrender from
the fleeing Ben Line ship. On failing to stop when ordered , Gunnery Officer Kasch was
directed to hit Benarty on the bridge, a salvo that quickly brought the British ship to a

85
halt. Needless to say the ship was soon ablaze fore and aft, despite the fact that Rogge
wanted to keep her intact.
The white launch was quickly despatched, and Mohr its officer in charge, ordered the
crew who were taking to the boats to get back on board again and put the fire out. But
too many shells had needlessly been fired at the ship. Amidst the raging fires the Ben
Liners radio office was quickly plundered by the Germans who retrieved valuable
admiralty codes that should have been jettisoned in weighted bags. They contained the
latest British codes which were later transmitted to the Berlin code breakers; there were
also 30 bags of mail. The crew were unable to contain the fires on board Benarty so the
raiders 5.9s finished her off.
The SS Benarty carried a crew of 49, of which 21 were European with the rest being
Chinese, but quite amazingly none of them were killed or even injured. Later on Captain
J Watt admitted to Rogge that hed been completely fooled by the disguise of A tlantis.

SS Benarty European crew list

Supplied by Cadet Graeme Cubbin

Master J Watt 1st Mate G Sinclair, 2nd, J Keith, 3rd DB Ross. Cadets, J Goodlet,

J Fyffe Radio Officers, A Porteous, EE du V Gout Chief Engineer C Hutton, 2nd

HM McPherson, 3rd CE Steele, 4th D Hepburn - Carpenter J Henderson Bosun J

Coole Gunner H Mullins ABs A Sanderson, G Bruce, D Wallace, G Irvine, J

Johnson, R Unstead.

86
 SS Commissaire Ramel

During the month of September1940, Kapitan Rogge who was fully aware that his
fellow raider Pinguin was operating in and around the Mozambique Channel area didnt
want to overlap him. However, while he was cruising around at slow speed, and even
drifting from time to time in order to conserve fuel; at the same time engine room
maintenance was being carried out on her twin diesel engines. In the gloom of the 8-12
night-watch on 19 September, when Atlantis was moving slowly ahead, the after
lookout in the main-mast crows nest saw against the moonlight, the silhouette of a
darkened ship coming up from astern. She was emitting heavy palls of smoke and was
identified as a single funnelled passenger ship.
The engines of Atlantis were quickly brought to life and her captain closed in to signal
the darkened ship to stop - maintain radio silence and then receive a boarding party.
No warning shots were required as the ship quickly signalled her agreement. She then
identified herself as the SS Commissaire Ramel, a cargo passenger ship which had
previously been owned by the French Services Contractuals de Messagaries Maritimes
Line. However, after surrendering and turning her lights on, the captive ship began
sending distress calls. Quite enraged at her breaking the agreement of surrender, Kapitan
Rogge ordered his 5.9s into action and sent 56 shells into the ship which set her
uncontrollably ablaze.So fierce did the fires on the victim ship become, that the heat did
not allow any rescuers from A tlantis to get close enough to take her crew off. With five
members of the victim crew unaccounted for in the bombardment, the other 54 of the
ships company had already managed to take to the boats and were subsequently taken
aboard the German raider. They joined the 230 prisoners already there, but because
there was no chance of keeping her afloat, a resumption of gunfire sent the ship to the
bottom. Once the survivors were safely on board, Kapitan Rogge demanded an
explanation from Captain McKenzie as to why he transmitted distress calls after
surrendering. The reply being, that on hearing his ship was under attack he hurried to
the bridge, and while he was on his way he ordered the radio officer to send the distress
call, little knowing that the French officer of the watch had already surrendered. Kapitan
Rogge rued the fact that such a ship had been sent to the bottom, indeed, she would have

87
made an ideal prison ship and was also carrying a worthwhile cargo of steel, wheat, soap
and leather. While further engine maintenance was being carried out, with Atlantis being
stopped and drifting, it was during that period of maintenance on 27 September when
news reached the raider that Tirranna had been sunk by a British submarine. There were
87 fatalities amongst the passengers and prize crew, all of whom had been well known
to the sailors of Atlantis. Most popular on board Atlantis were Mrs Swann and her two
children Robin and Sally, but they were three of the fatal casualties. Moreover, after
having been at sea for over six months, a quantity of mail sent by the raiders crew to
their homes in Germany had been lost with Tirranna. Kapitan Rogge was by then
becoming increasingly desperate to capture another ship in order to offload his 293
prisoners.

NOTE
The SS Commissaire Ramel was built in 1920 at La Ciotat, France, as the
8,308GRT General Duchesne. Rebuilt as a cargo passenger ship between 1926-27,
with an increase in her GRT to 10,061, she was re-named Commissaire Ramel. The
steamer was then used to transport passengers and goods to Australia and the East
Indies, a role she continued in until the ship was seized by the Ministry of War
Transport under the Australian authorities in Fiji following the fall of France.
Captain Sabouret and 25 others of his French crew decided to stay in the ship
which was later managed by Shaw Saville & Albion. After her capture she sailed to
Noumea and then on to Sydney where she loaded wool. But because a crew was
extremely difficult to find, due to most of the French crew paying off, when even
her French master Captain Sabouret resigned to travel back to Europe as a
passenger on the ship, a crew was eventually found and increased by Australians to
59; the ship sailed for the UK via Fremantle leaving there on 3 September 1940.

88
 SS Commissaire Ramel crew list
Supplied by Cadet G Cubbin

Master - RM McKenzie Supernumery Master, R Sabouret 1st Mate C

Jennings, 2nd RS McKenzie, 3rd F Stewart, 4th G Clousten. Radio Officer, G

Brown, 2nd, R Chapman. Chief Steward, R Longsdale. Assistant Stewards, E

Gills, A Walkten, H Chidlow, T Hyland, G Turner, A Carter, A Kennington, F Le

Page, M Susine, R Hervas, R Wolfe, H Antikadjin. - Maitre de Hotel,L Logier. -

Chief Cook, R Hunt, 2nd R Baker. Scullery C Jefferys. Carpenter H Mason

Bosun, C Ecklund. - Lamp trimmer, A Taylor. - ABs and OS, R Kennedy, A

Carruthers, W Welsh, F Harris, J Creagh, C Bellingford, J Grosvenor, P Dunne,

M Keeley, E Johnson, b Logan, A La Crampe, F Fravallo, F Letyran, M Malfatti,

R Rello, W Quayle. Gunner C Brooks. Engine Room, L Combet, G Pionel.

Fridge Engineers, J Pierre, V Trisot. Chief Engineer, J Highet, 2nd A Leslie, 3rd, M

Crosier, 4th H Hewson, 5th, A Denholm, 6th A Gillies, 7th, D Sinclair. Elec, J

Warren.

89
The Hell Ship SS Durmitor

90
The photo of the SS Durmitor above, was taken shortly after shed been sold by Lamport &
Holt Lines in 1931and painted in her new livery. But since those times the ship had fallen
into gross disrepair and neglect. On being captured by A tlantis she was used to ferry its
prisoners to Italian Somaliland. At the time of her being commandeered, the old steamer was
in a severe state of neglect and was short of both fuel and food. Poorly equipped for such a
task, the six knot Durmitor proved to be an absolute Hell Ship for the crew, guards and
prisoners alike.

91
On 3rd May 1940, the Harrison vessel Scientist in which I was serving as a cadet had
been on passage Durban to Freetown. She was to join a homeward bound convoy when
she was intercepted by the German commerce raider A tlantis disguised as a neutral
Japanese NKK ship. After a one-sided action our next move on this occasion was
limited to turning away in a futile attempt to outrun the 5.9 inch shells which were soon
screaming overhead and slamming into the ship - as I say, a one-sided action in which
one of our men was killed and several wounded, the Scientists crew were taken
prisoner, the ship was sunk by gunfire and torpedo, and the raider headed for hunting
grounds in the Indian Ocean.
During the next five months a further eight such actions took place. But the raider's
commander, the humane and respected Kapitan Bernhard Rogge, was hard pressed to
know what to do with the multitude of prisoners hed acquired as a result of his
depredations. In August of 1940, a captured Norwegian ship named Tirranna had been
loaded with prisoners - the elderly, sick, women and children - and despatched to
German-occupied Europe, a move which relieved the overcrowding somewhat.
Unfortunately, Tirranna never made it - but that is another story.
By October, 1940 however, the housing problem was again becoming acute, and
another prison-ship had to be found. The SS Commissaire Ramel, a 10,000 ton Vichy
French passenger vessel requisitioned and operated by the Shaw Saville & Albion
Company would have been ideal, but to the Germans annoyance, the initial action
started a blaze which quickly got out of control and the ship had to be sunk. That was in
September, and it wasnt until late October before another ship was sighted.
There she was, in the first light of dawn, the SS Durmitor of Dubrovnik; creaming along
at all of seven knots, a pillar of smoke pouring from a rusty stack, and one that would
have prompted expressions of awe and reverence from an ancient tribe of Hebrews in
the Wilderness of Sin. Her buff funnel was surmounted with a black top, while the red,
white and pale blue emblem of Yugoslavia was painted conspicuously on her rusty
black sides for all the world to see. But such badges of neutrality did not deter Kapitan
Rogge in his hour of need, and a shot across her bows soon brought the ancient vessel to
an indignant halt. (You could almost hear the wheezy old engines heaving a sigh of
relief!).
The ship was duly captured (or commandeered, since she was a neutral!) nevertheless,

92
for the next four days Rogge cruised about hoping to come across something better.
Nothing materialised, however, and with a commiserative shake of the head he told us
she would have to do. We were not unduly perturbed because getting off the raider
was undeniably a step in the right direction. However, had we known what was in store
for us we might not have been so keen. With his mind made up, Rogge put his men to
work on the 26th October ferrying about 260 prisoners, with their few belongings and
some meager stores across to the SS Durmitor.
We watched her resignedly as we waited our turn in the boats, while at the same time
wondering where we could all be accommodated in this dowdy old tramp. The Germans
had a short answer for that one: In numbers 1 and 2 tween-decks! The fact that these
tween-decks were full of rock salt, trimmed and levelled in a lumpy, hummocky sort of
way, with scarcely any head-room, did not lend any lustre to the prospect of a prolonged
existence in such troglodytic conditions. But we had to make the best of it. Tarpaulins
were procured and spread over the salt; plenty of blankets were available thanks to the
thoughtful looting by the Germans of their previous victims. A piece of sage advice
lingered in my mind from my fairly recent Boy Scouting days: Make a hollow for your
hip, and you'll sleep like a top. This is what Id been told and this is what I did - and it
worked!
We were intrigued to discover that the SS Durmitor was formerly the Lamport & Holt
ship Plutarch of Liverpool built by Russells of Glasgow in 1913. Here was a link with
the Mersey and home. We gazed nostalgically at the name engraved on her unpolished
greenish looking brass bell. She had been sold to the Yugoslavs nine years previously
and was presently on a voyage from Spain to Japan with 8,200 tons of salt. Or at least
she had been - because she was now on a voyage to goodness-knows-where with a
motley crew of Germans, with Yugoslavs and British as prisoners. It was Rogge's
intention to send the ship to Mogadiscio in Italian Somaliland and gave his orders
accordingly to Leutenant Zur See Emil Dehnel who was the officer in charge of the
prize-crew; a stockily built blonde Imperial man who was a former merchant service
officer, and a man who was well qualified to navigate the ancient Durmitor to
Somaliland. Nevertheless, this was his first command; the firm step, crisp manner, and
the glint of steel in his eyes, gave a fair indication that he was determined not to make a
botch of his first chance at being a ship master. We, of course, were quite unaware of

93
the ship's destination when we joined the Durmitor on the Eastern side of the Indian
Ocean, some 400 miles South of the Sunda Straits.
So excluding the Dutch East Indies, there were only two likely possibilities: Italian
Somaliland, Vichy Madagascar - or of course, an unscheduled rendezvous with an
Allied cruiser. That wistful option was always at the forefront of our minds. However,
as the days passed by it became clear that Somaliland was indeed our destination.
Indeed, and quite unknown to our captors, we were able to plot our position with
reasonable accuracy by using the considerable amount of navigational expertise within
our ranks. An assortment of navigational tables, an almanac, an atlas, some practice
charts, one or two good time-pieces, and a simple home-made instrument, whimsically
christened the Shadow-angle; an innovation which had been invented on the raider
many weeks ago.
This device consisted of a two-foot rod mounted vertically on a four-foot baseboard,
marked along its length in degrees of altitude. Thus, to find the sun's altitude at noon, we
set our Shadow-angle in the right direction, and watched the German officers shooting
the sun. When they all stood in solemn conclave reading the micrometers on their
modern sextants, we noted the angle cast by the shadow of the rod on the baseboard of
our more primitive instrument. But it took a bit of practice. The rod had to be vertical in
relation to the horizon, so it was fortunate that the ship was steady in those calm
latitudes After a few inconclusive attempts we were able to read the Shadow-angle to
within a quarter of a degree. From the almanac which had been released to us by the
Germans in response to a request to further the Cadets and Apprentices' training and
education. It was a simple matter to extract the sun's declination; the outcome was a
latitude at noon accurate to w thin 15 miles - an acceptable error in our situation in such
a large ocean.
Longitude gave us a problem at first, but we quickly realized that the sun, being close to
the zenith in those Latitudes, was moving rapidly across the meridian at noon.
Navigators (if they still use sextants in these days of electronic wizardry) will
understand what I mean when I say we watched the German officers swing rapidly as
they chased the sun across the meridian. That instant was to us, as near as dammit,
1200 hrs apparent time. Our almanac gave us the Equation of Time for that date, hence,
Mean Time at ship. All we needed then was a good time-piece with a second hand (and
94
there were several available) to give us Greenwich Mean Time.
The difference between SMT and GMT is, when converted to degrees of arc of the
Longitude of the observer. We were able to check the accuracy of our chronometers
almost daily, for it was Leutenant Dehnel' s custom (as it had been Kapitan Rogge's
custom on the raider) to invite senior prisoners to their quarters to listen to the ship's
broadcast receiver tuned into Treasure Island Radio at San Francisco - usually to hear
accounts of new German victories. The BBC was taboo, of course, and the Germans
were sensitive enough to realise that we would place no credence on English-Language
broadcasts from Berlin. But the important thing was the time-signal which invariably
preceded the news-broadcast -and what more natural reaction can there be than to glance
at one's watch at the sound of a time-signal? The Germans, however, never realised the
true significance of our interest in the time.
Meanwhile, we kept a dead-reckoning, estimating the ship's speed by surreptitiously
dropping a piece of dunnage over the bow, and then counting the seconds until it passed
a measured point, somewhere down the foredeck. The course was estimated at least
twice a day, by gauging the angle between the ship's head and the rising or setting sun
using an ordinary protractor. Knowing our Latitude and the sun's declination, it was a
simple matter to calculate the true bearing, or amplitude, and hence our course.
So we plotted our course daily, and it was due to skill, not chance, which told us on the
final day, that the ship had veered away from the obvious landfall at Mogadiscio, and
was heading for the reefs off Warshieik! We heard later that Dehnel's hurried change of
plan was prompted by the fact that British cruisers were shelling targets in the capital.
Dehnel had plenty of problems of course.
Nearly 300 prisoners to guard and feed; a ship of doubtful reliability, a Yugoslav crew
of dubious loyalty, a wide ocean to cross, and only his twelve Germans to maintain
order and discipline. We were allowed the freedom of the foredeck -just so long as we
stayed put. Guards were mounted at the top of the ladders leading to the bridge deck,
and also in the wing cabs on the bridge. They were armed to the teeth with pistols,
grenades and mounted machine guns which were fired from time to time, just to let us
know they were loaded. Furthermore, we were warned in the strongest terms that
explosive charges had been laid below the water line, and these would be activated (In
the name of the Reich) should there be any serious insurrection. But, if we behaved

95
ourselves we would be treated fairly, and any privations would be suffered equally by
captors and captives alike.
We were suitably convinced that any attempt at Hollywood-style heroics would be
bloodily suppressed, so we kept to our own end of the foredeck and waited for that
British cruiser which never came. It wasnt long before Leutenant Dehnel was
confronted unexpectedly by the spectre of failure. A survey of the bunkers when the
Yugoslav Chief Engineer revealed a huge deficiency in the amount of coal that was
supposed to be there. Someone had made a packet! The Chief Engineer just shrugged
uncomprehendingly.
Dehnel made a hasty calculation and came up with the stark truth that Durmitor could
not possibly reach her destination with the coal stocks available. He therefore reduced
speed to five knots. But food and water were also in short supply, and the reduction in
speed, though it might save fuel, would extend the passage by another week or more.
Our meagre rations were reduced by half. The prisoners grumbled, but somehow or
other we all survived.
Conditions were grim in the tween-decks, where we had plenty of equally hungry rats
for company, so it was quite natural for us to spend as much time as possible up on
deck. The Germans raised no objection to our camping out at night - keeping the
prisoners happy seemed to be their motto. Washing, of course, was done in saltwater. A
three-inch pipe drilled full of holes and connected to the deck-service line was our
shower and a marvellous German product called Seewasser soap lathered beautifully
in the salt water, but it was inclined to be rather rough in sensitive areas of the body,
and quite ruined one's complexion. From time to time heavy rain squalls were
encountered and these were occasions of great rejoicing.
The Seewasser soap was cast aside and out came the rare Lifebuoy Camay, and
Lux toilet soaps, all of which had been looted from the ANZAC store ship Tirranna.
We all showered in the rain like a lot of kids, while at the same time we collected as
much rain water as possible to supplement our water ration. Two latrines under the
foc'sle head (which would not be likely to win the Kings award for design), were of the
squatting variety and these provided the usual offices.

96
According to Cadet Cubbin, the Yugoslav ship SS Durmitor was full of rats when
he boarded her from the Atlantis. Those rodents had actually burrowed their way
through the salt cargo leaving vast honey combings. It so happened that on another
occasion when Durmitor was trading as Lamport & Holts SS Plutarch of
Liverpool, she was the subject of parliamentary debate on 18 July 1927. Indeed,
after arriving at Liverpool with a cargo of wheat from the River Plate, the ship was
so heavily infested with rats, that after being discharged she had to anchor in the
River Mersey for a week long fumigation programme.

With the lack of accommodation space being a major problem, vast quantities of salt
were dumped overboard from the tween decks of numbers one and two holds.
Tarpaulins stretched across the derricks provided welcome shade from the tropical sun,
but how we managed to pass the 28 days of our journey without anyone losing his
marbles is hard to explain. The sense of comradeship was strong, and so far as I can
recall there were no serious or acrimonious disputes among those companions of
adversity. On the contrary there was a great deal of laughter, and anyone seeming about
to give way to despair was invariably rallied by the attentions sometimes clumsy, of a
sympathetic comrade. Card games were popular, played for fantastic stakes, chess found
its devotees as well. But through all the anxious waiting, the boredom, the hunger, and
alternating emotions of hope and despair, ran the thought like a scarlet thread through a
sombre blackcloth, that - We should be doing something! But what? Open
insurrection or a direct frontal assault were ruled out, so only the stealthy surreptitious
option remained.
There was some excitement, and some satisfaction, when one brave soul clambered over
the bow, and, clinging to the anchor flukes, scrawled the letters, SOS on the bow in a
mixture of grease and lime, a broad enough hint to any passing craft, if we ever saw one
- which we never did. Then there were the artistic souls amongst us, those that put
together several portfolios of drawings and sketches of the German raider in her many
disguises; with other intelligence details such as her armament, her tactics, the fact that
she carried a sea-plane, the characteristics of her officers and crew, and many, many
more. These gems of intelligence were carefully wrapped in oilskin, and stowed in
empty paint drums, jauntily decorated with bunting attached to a makeshift flag pole,

97
and hopefully cast adrift one dark night. Whether they ever landed on a friendly shore or
not we never did find out, but at least we had tried to do something.
Meanwhile, Leutenant Dehnel was still pouring over his logistic problems. There was
not much he could do about the food situation but he could do something about the fuel.
First of all, he ordered a tarpaulin to be rigged as a sail on the mainmast to take
advantage of the following trade winds. Then he ordered all unwanted timber on the
ship - furniture, dunnage, even deck planks and hatch boards, to be systematically
collected and cut up for the stokehold fires. He devised a sort of brickette known as a
Dehnel's Fireball, concocted from coal dust, ashes and sawdust, and all bound together
with grease and paint. Every other day he reported the ship's good progress, and
sought to amuse us with such diversions as lining up his sailors like a firing-squad, and
then firing shots into the air while we watched apprehensively. These demonstrations
were organised to mark such milestones as passing the half way point to our destination,
or crossing the Line. On Monday, 11th November 1940 at 1100 hours, a similar
ceremony marked the beginning and end of a two-minute silence, in which German and
British nationals remembered the dead of the First World War.
And so the days wore on, until the afternoon of 22nd November when we were aroused
from our siesta - an honoured institution revered by all on board - to see a "G" flag
fluttering at the triatic stay: I Require a Pilot. We must be approaching somewhere at
last! Knowing it could not be Mogadiscio it turned out to be the little village of
Warshiek, some 50 miles North-East of the capital. Hour succeeded hour as Dehnel
stood off waiting for a pilot. He had no large scale chart of the coast, and at five o'clock
with his patience exhausted he headed in - only to be brought up all standing on the reef
which barred the approaches.
The prisoners did not know whether to laugh or cry while the Germans looked angry
and flustered. After some discussion in which we took no part, a boat was lowered and a
recce party of Germans was rowed ashore by the Yugoslavs. Meanwhile, the ship was
grinding ominously on the coral; a number of black dorsal fins then appeared in the
close vicinity of the ship - porpoise - or sharks? No one was prepared to hazard a guess,
but the unspoken fear was there. Obviously, if the ship broke up, there would be no
room in the lifeboats for everyone, so the need for rafts was suddenly pressing. Some
empty paint drums were found, and the carpenters set to work constructing several rafts

98
from hatch-boards and empty drums, using improvised nails and scraps of cordage.
Dusk was closing in and the boat returned, minus the recce party, which, the Yugoslavs
reported had made contact with an Italian patrol. The order was given to abandon ship;
all four boats were launched, and these were used to ferry parties of prisoners ashore in
steady succession. The ship was lying quietly now, and the immediate danger had
receded giving no cause to take to our improvised rafts. I went ashore in the third wave
it was not surprising to learn that certain Italian elements believed an allied invasion was
in progress, and by which time it was pitch dark. As we approached the beach through a
rough surf, we suddenly became aware that armed Askari soldiers were deployed facing
our boat, all of whom appeared to be extremely nervous. Indeed, one false move could
have brought a fusillade of shots. We quickly made it clear in sign language of our being
unarmed, after that we were marched off to the village under guard, while volunteers
stayed with the boat and pulled it back to the ship which was stranded over a mile away.
The small party of Italians had not an inkling of what was going on, but to the credit of
the young Leutenant in command they did not panic, but simply contented themselves
by arresting everyone who stepped ashore, including, to our unqualified delight,
Leutenant Dehnel and his German crew!

99
Top - One of the four lifeboats which was apparently from the SS Scientist, pulls alongside the
Atlantis and captivity. Most of the crew were unidentified Lascars.

Bottom - Survivors from a different ship row towards Atlantis after their ship had been sunk.

100
Top: The 1926 built 5,840 GRT steamer Benarty, she was owned by William Thompson of Leith.
Her triple expansion engines fired by coal gave her a service speed of ten knots.

Bottom: The 10,600 GRT steamer Commisaire Ramel was under the French flag.

101
 SS Scientist

SS City of Exeter

102
SS City of Baghdad

SS Kemmendine
103
 Tirranna

SS King City

104
Top: The Athel Lines 9,550 GRT molasses tanker A thel King of Liverpool.

But because distress signals were inadvertently transmitted from another ship the A thel King was
shelled and set ablaze.

105
Top : Despite the vast difference in their appearances, Kapitan Rogge purported that his ship
Atlantis was the Blue Funnel Liner Antenor. - Albeit in the darkness.

Below : HMS Tuna sank the Tirranna in the Gironde Estuary.

106
The motor ship Talleyrand
had enough speed to outrun
Atlantis. But with no chance
of escaping
she was caught close to the
raider by accident in the poor
visibility After being
plundered of her stores she
too was shelled and set
ablaze.

107
 Italian Interlude

It is only now when I look back that I realise what a close call it must have been,
because just a few days earlier, a British cruiser had shelled the capital Mogadiscio, and
the whole coast was on the alert with speculation about an invasion being at the
forefront of Italian minds. Yet, when the anticipated landing occurred towards dusk,
on a beach only 50 miles from the capital, not a shot was fired.
It must be said, however, that a less likely looking force of assault troops would be
difficult to imagine - we were such an unkempt and half-starved bunch of castaways,
that our wretched appearance could only reassure the Italian Command that this could
not be a real invasion. In charge of the local garrison of native troops was an Italian
Lieutenant. His wife could speak and understand a little English - but evidently no
German. It was only after our senior captains had explained the situation, that Leutenant
Dehnel and his party somewhat huffily accepted the return of their weapons from their
Italian allies. Meanwhile, the Lieutenant's wife was moved with compassion and
contemplated with concern the state of the motley throng which had so suddenly landed
on her doorstep. Her store of provisions must have been meagre, indeed, food rationing
was tight in the province, but she nevertheless ordered her staff to set up cooking fires in
the village square. She then commandeered a sack of rice, and signed the death warrants
of several kid-goats. These animals, all bleating in protest, were herded into the village
square where the local butcher deftly slaughtered them by cutting their throats in
accordance with the Moslem practice.
However, it was not a pretty sight, and almost ruined the appetites of many prisoners.
But only momentarily, because that night we dined, like never before on goats meat, rice
and vegetable stew, and all washed down with generous measures of a rather harsh
Chianti and fragrant coffee. Perhaps we over-indulged; our contracted stomachs were
not capable of digesting this sudden influx of rich fare, and protested painfully. Next day
many were acutely ill, and we remained quietly .in our mud-hut prisons, pondering on
our recent gluttony and somewhat uncertain future.

108
The next delicacy was treated with cautious respect, if at all, but we awoke at dawn on
the third day to the whine and clatter of Army .trucks entering the village. There were
about eight of them, and they had been assigned by the local Army Command to
transport us to more suitable quarters near the capital, fifty miles away. We, and our
erstwhile German captors, were crammed into the open trucks which promptly headed
South West, following a desert track which was barely discernible from the surrounding
sand and scrub. After nearly four hours, with the sun beating down rather forcibly upon
our unprotected heads, the convoy entered the leafy suburbs of Mogadiscio. Soon we
were in the town itself, our transport vehicles lumbering along broad tree-lined avenues;
the Italian populace, in white suits and flowery print dresses, turned to stare. It was
strongly rumored that an attempted invasion had been heroically repelled, and these
scarecrows were captured enemy troops! Some of our sailors waved cheerfully, and
whistled at the girls, but received only puzzled glances in return. Nobody cheered;
nobody jeered; and, fortunately for us, nobody threw anything. The convoy wound its
way through the streets and cleared the other side of town, eventually drawing up to a
large barracks square. Buildings built mainly of coral overlooked the square on three
sides whence from one of them, tumbled a squad of soldiers. They rounded us up as we
jumped down from the trucks and chivvied us into some semblance of order before
leading us in groups into the barracks buildings. The cool interior housed several
dormitories to which we were assigned in groups of twenty or so. Each man was
allocated a small cot, mattress, pillow, blanket and a so-called cholera belt of some felt
-like material. Apparently, this latter item was standard Army issue designed to be worn
around the middle like an apron to keep the chill night airs at bay. Thus we settled down
into what we came to call home for the next two months. Life in a prison camp is the
essence of boredom- boring to write about, even more boring to read of. So, just for the
record, I'll kindle a few highlights. Books in English were, after the basics of food and
water, our most pressing need. Aboard the raider there was no shortage; in fact, when
they looted a prize, the Germans made a point of rifling as much of the ship's library as
they could carry for their prisoners' benefit. Some of these books found their way on
board Durmitor, but our hurried departure from that vessel resulted in most of them
being abandoned.
However, the book famine was greatly alleviated by an unknown English lady, the wife

109
of a local Italian businessman, who intuitively came to realise our need in that respect.
She canvassed her friends, and between them they filled several boxes with novels and
even text-books to suit every taste. I remember well Mrs Beeton's Cookery and
Housekeeping for the Family, which was a warm favourite! We were touched and
extremely grateful for the gesture and wished to express our appreciation, but the
benevolent lady, for obvious reasons, preferred to remain anonymous. I hope the priest
who acted as her agent in this matter, was able to convey to her some inkling of our
delight in this, her own humanitarian contribution to the war effort.
Food and medical supplies were in very short supply. We subsisted for the most part on
rice, interspersed with varieties of pasta, served with meagre amounts of meat or
chicken and locally grown vegetables such as tired lettuce, pallid tomatoes, tasteless
onions and woody turnips. Those who had to suffer a period in hospital may have been
very well cared for by the nuns, but the ration scale was even less than in the camp.
Drugs and medicines were almost non-existent, the universal panacea being fresh goat's
milk and Epsom Salts administered alternately. Since most of our ailments were related
to the alimentary system, the rudimentary treatment seemed to work! Not always,
however. At least three of our comrades died and were buried here.
At the camp coffee was our most popular fare. Jet-black Mocha taken without milk or
sugar, it had a dream-like aromatic flavour which could only have been fully appreciated
after months of imbibing that "ersatz" apology for coffee served on the raider! On
Sundays and Saints days (which occurred quite frequently), the coffee was laced with
brandy. Some would say that in the war-torn world of rationing and shortages, the
Italians of Somaliland had their priorities just about right!
There was no contact with the International Red Cross, although the Camp Commandant
Captain Bracco mendaciously assured us that Geneva had been informed of our arrival.
However, no such luxury as a Red Cross parcel ever entered our camp, and the many
letters that we were encouraged to write home, care of the Red Cross, were all found in
sacks in Bracco's office on the day we were liberated.
It couldnt have been a better time to give up smoking, simply because there were no
cigarettes available. However, in being a non smoker such a pastime didnt affect me.
But many of the captives did give up; while others, impressed by the depression and
other withdrawal symptoms manifested by the addicts, vowed never to start the smoking

110
habit. Of course, they could always turn to the vile Twists manufactured by an Aussie
gunner AB named Solomon. Strangely s it may seem we were in a tobacco growing
area, but the nearest processing plants were in faraway South Africa.
However, for a few cents from our meager funds, the Native guards were only too
pleased to bring raw tobacco leaves to our enterprising Digger. But not even he could
smoke the stuff in its raw state. So he resolved to cure it, and devised what he was
pleased to call his maturing process.
One of the frequent supplements to our daily diet was dried banana soaked in molasses.
Boiling them produced a sweet and sticky liquor, which Digger found ideal for
marinating his raw tobacco leaves in. The marinating process lasted a week, after which
the leaves were drained and then twisted together into a short rope bound with twine
and hung up to dry in the sun for another week. The maturing process was then
complete, and as Digger claimed, Guaranteed his customers a cooler, smoother smoke.
Or, as he called it, Fair Dinkum.
The innovative Aussie was not without customers, because for a small consideration like
a tot of vino, he would chop off and deliver a couple of ounces from the end of the twist.
Those who still had pipes were then in business. But cigarette smokers had to find a
suitable paper, something that was similar to Rizla cigarette paper to roll their cigarette
in, and I regret to say that one or two Bibles that matched those requirements perished
in this way, the Minor Prophets being among the first to make the sacrifice.
Tobacco manufacture was not the only enterprise entered into by the prisoners. Indeed,
Wully Grainger from Glasgow, and an erstwhile 4th Engineer from our ship Scientist,
was the acknowledged expert in the manufacture of the more potent and exotic
beverages ever to be found in odd corners of the world. In fact, had there been a chair at
Glasgow University in Crapulous Zymology, Wully Grainger would have been a
Professor. He was not greatly enamoured with the rough but un-stimulating Chianti
which was issued from time to time, so he devised a means of pepping it up. Once
again the ubiquitous bananas-in-molasses was the essential ingredient with the following
recipe. Stuff them into a Chianti bottle, on a one to one ratio of banana and vino, cork
the bottle well, and then leave it to stand for some time (preferably till Hogmanay).
By barter and bribery Wully managed to lay down quite a respectable cellar. No one was
allowed to touch a drop of his hooch at Christmas, a time that was marked by the

111
Italians giving an extra ration of brandy, and a rare slice of bread-and-jam. Boxing Day
came and went with Wully's plonk continuing to ferment nicely.
However, two nights later on 27 December 1940, we were aroused from our slumbers
by a series of shots. Rifle fire! We tumbled out in alarm. Had someone tried to escape?
Another fusillade! Had British forces landed? To which some joker even exclaimed,
The Navy's here!
We were then conscious of an evil-smelling odour - Gas! ... with not a single respirator
between us! Slowly it dawned on us, that the Chianti bottles containing Wully
Grainger's plonk had succumbed to the strain and burst with the most devastating of
effects in spraying walls, floor, ceiling, and bedding with the moisome fluid. The
coming Hogmanay was a very dull affair after that! Early in the New Year we were told
we would be moving to a new camp. Army reinforcements were being sent from
Ethiopia, and they would be moving into our barracks. Somewhat grudgingly and
because wed grown accustomed to the place; we vacated our quarters and assembled in
the square to await the trucks that would take us to our new abode. I suppose we were
lucky. If we had been left alive, the Japanese's in similar circumstances would have
made us walk.
Our new camp was situated near the town of Merca which is about 40 miles South West
along the coast from Mogadiscio. It consisted of half a dozen large wooden huts
surrounded by a barbed wire fence. Those huts had once been used to store sterns of
bananas awaiting shipment, but that lucrative trade had long since been halted. We
suspected we might be sharing our quarters with a colony of tarantulas which, in the
minds of seamen, are always associated with bananas. But if there were any they never
showed up. They were probably afraid of being eaten!
If the Mogadiscio barracks was our town house then Merca was our place in the
country. Here our stultifying leisure was enlivened by a weekly swim at the nearby
beach. The inmates of each hut were marched down to the beach each day under the
watchful gaze of a couple of armed Askaris, who were plainly amused by the childish
antics of so many naked white men disporting themselves in the gentle surf. They shook
their heads in complete lack of comprehension, seeming to dislike the water and
disdaining to even to wet their sandalled feet. Perhaps they hailed from the remote
Ogaden Desert, where water of any kind is scarce and precious and used only for

112
drinking. And they couldn't even drink this ocean stuff! The food too was a little better;
those with the means could even buy or barter fresh fruit and vegetables to supplement
the monotonous pasta diet. News from the outside world filtered through to our anxious
ears. It seemed that the Italians in North Africa had suffered a severe defeat; the Navy
had once again shelled targets in Mogadiscio and Kismayu; and there was apparently
increased activity on the Kenyan border, some 300 miles to the Southwest which was
causing the local Italians some disquiet. The feeling grew that, one way or another, the
status quo was about to be disrupted.
No prison camp history would be complete without a stirring escape story. Alas, I am in
no position to lend lustre to my narrative by any such diversion. There were no
tunnelling episodes, or vaulting-horse dramas, which uplifted the spirits of the inmates
of Colditz and the Stalags, to catch the imagination of the press. It was in fact absurdly
easy to get clear of the wire at Merca, but the hostile desert environment which
surrounded the camp and the town was sufficient deterrent to the majority.
A select few to their eternal credit made the attempt: two got as far as the town and had
a wonderful binge, but were returned to the camp on the next day rather the worse for
wear. Another pair skirted the town but they were picked up a week later by a group of
Somali Nomads who handed them over to the authorities. They too were returned to the
camp, blistered by the sun, and even more worse for wear than their fun-loving
comrades. A third pair was not so lucky because they were never heard of again.
Meanwhile, whatever had happened to the Germans? We left them, you remember,
somewhat dishevelled and disillusioned as fellow-prisoners of the Italian forces in
Mogadiscio. Frantic communication with the German Embassy in Addis Ababa
eventually established their bona fides, and they were put at liberty.
But apparently their presence was not popular, as most citizens believed that a squad of
German Naval personnel on their territory would inevitably bring down on their heads
another naval bombardment. So they were ushered down to Kismayu where the old
Durmitor which having been re-floated by her Yugoslav crew was presently lying. But
the ship was no longer viable as a sea-going proposition. Damaged when she struck the
reef off Warshiek, she was leaking badly. Her boilers which were leaking badly were
suffering from the inevitable consequences of the infusions of sea water which had been
resorted to on her voyage across the Indian Ocean. She was clearly in no position to put

113
to sea and rendezvous with A tlantis. Besides, in spite of their protests of neutrality, the
Yugoslav crew had been interned by the Italians, and were now residing with us in our
prison-camp at Merca.
There were a dozen or so Italian ships in Kismayu as well as one or two Germans, quite
content apparently, to sit out the war in comparative seclusion. Leutenant Dehnel,
however, had different ideas. Through the German Embassy at Addis Ababa he
contacted the German Naval High Command in Hamburg; he then obtained authority to
commandeer one of the German ships and her crew, and then load her with as much
stores and fuel as he could squeeze out of the Italians before meeting up with Atlantis at
a pre-arranged position. Dehnel selected the cargo vessel Tannenfels which was part
loaded with jute, and at once set about preparing the ship for sea. The former prize-crew
of Durmitor gave the German merchant seamen every moral, and no doubt physical
encouragement to overcome their inertia. Fortune favoured Dehnel's enterprise, and he
successfully evaded the British blockade to accomplish the rendezvous with A tlantis
safely on 8th February, 1941.
Eventually, after meeting up with Atlantis again, as well as the A dmiral Scheer, the
Tannenfels was despatched to German-occupied Europe with 100 prisoners on board,
and, according to German sources she arrived at Bordeaux without incident on 19th
April 1941. Meanwhile, back at the camp, a new feeling of optimism was growing in
substance as more and more signs indicated, that a profound change of our
circumstances was imminent. Commandant Bracco, wearing a worried frown was taking
pains to be more affable, and one day he was seen burning papers in the cookhouse.
Rumour had it that Kismayu had fallen, and South African troops were across the Juba
River. Then one day a flight of Hurricanes flew over our camp, and we were sure help
was at hand. Prudently, just in case the Hurricane pilots did not realise that the cheering
mob in the old banana complex was composed of British and Allied prisoners-of-war,
and might return with a load of bombs next time, we hurriedly took steps to make our
presence known by collecting white stones, and placing them in the compound, spelling
the message, POWs - HELP. Bracco raised no objection; in fact our initiative was
silently applauded.
As February drew to a close the persistent rumours clamoured for recognition as fact.
There came a day when we found ourselves completely deserted by our guards - Bracco,

114
the soldiers, and the Askaris had all fled. About four hours later a South African patrol
appeared at the compound gates. They looked bewildered as well they might, because
instead of finding the enemy they found themselves surrounded by a wildly cheering
mob of happy Rooineks, For a while chaos reigned, until some semblance of order was
restored by the senior POW' s. Our presence was duly explained to the astonished patrol
Commander who at once contacted his base by radio. He begged us to remain in our
compound until someone from Company H.Q. arrived. He then unloaded several
cartons of cigarettes from his vehicle and sped away in a cloud of dust to resume his
patrol. Obediently, we stayed in our compound, as it was vaguely assumed there would
be a good chance of us being shot if we strayed outside. In due course, a South African
Major arrived with an escort armed to the teeth. He engaged our elders in serious
discussion and was given a list of names of personnel and ships which had fallen victim
to the raider, a list which had been lovingly prepared against such an event as this. The
Major promised to get in touch with his Brigade where he had reason to believe there
was a Naval Liaison Officer. Meanwhile, supplies would be sent to the camp as quickly
as possible. Italian forces were retreating Northwards, and he saw no reason why we
should not exercise our new found freedom in whatever way we pleased - within reason.
He warned us all that the Military Police were patrolling the town, and if there were any
unwarranted disturbances, the perpetrators would find them a much tougher proposition
than our erstwhile captors - or words to that effect. We believed him.
The Major was true to his word; an hour or two later an Army truck arrived, driven by
the most fearsome squad of KAR 's you ever saw. The truck was laden with rice, newly
baked bread, cheese - and the inevitable cigarettes. It was a pleasure to unload it! Our
next visitors comprised a Rhodesian Signals Unit, who began setting up a
communications centre in Bracco's office. We looked on and marvelled, chatting
amiably to our multinational liberators, and watching an Army advance. That evening
most of us advanced on the town - and the good Major need not have worried. Whether
it was out of respect or for the reputation of the South African Military Police, or sheer
joie de vivre, no one had any intention of being a nuisance to anyone. In a way we
were all disciplined too. I remember having a game of billiards in one tavern, while a
burly quartermaster was detailed off by Captain Windsor to make sure those boys
drank only fizzy lemonade! I don't think anyone paid for much - we didn't have the

115
resources in any case but the Italian proprietors in defeat were only too pleased,
apparently to lavish simple hospitality on their potentially volatile customers and
encourage good relations. In a way they too were celebrating, because for them the war
was over as far as they were concerned.
As I recall it the following day was spent in camp, leisurely swimming at the beach, or
concocting exotic dishes using our newly-acquired stores. Idly we pondered the next
move, which, as we had grown to realise was completely out of our hands. We did not
have long to wait. That South African Major was as good as his word, because on the
next morning we awoke to see a lean grey shape standing off shore. A cruiser no less!
HMS Ceres had been detached from her squadron apparently for the sole purpose of
shipping some 260 POW 's down the coast to Mombasa. Towards noon a platoon of
soldiers and M P 's arrived at the camp to organise the march down to the harbour. We
gathered our pathetic belongings, and in feeling no regrets we shook the dust of Merca
Camp from our feet. The march, you may surmise was a triumphant one, far different
from the defiant parade through Mogadiscio three months ago. The lads were in high
spirits, and did not even complain about the rusty, filthy banana barges which were to
convey us to the waiting cruiser. We embarked and set off on what must have been the
most hair-raising sea passage of my life. Our barge and two others were being towed by
an ancient motor-launch which was doing no more than two knots. The men, consistent
with the practice of all deep-water seamen embarked in small boats, were perched
nonchalantly along the gun-whales. No sooner had our little armada cleared the point
than the 10 foot swell took over! The launch buried its prow in green water; the barges
wallowing in its wake lurched alarmingly; water poured inboard while the startled
seamen hung on for dear life. Captain Marshall (ex King City) firmly grasping the tiller
and with having belated thoughts about metacentric stability, ordered everyone into the
hold of the barge. We needed no prompting, and having sustained nothing worse than a
thorough soaking and a few bruises, huddled together amongst the rotting banana debris
in the hold for the best part of an hour until we reached the lee of the cruiser. We
bumped alongside and leapt or fell on board assisted by grinning matelots. At last! The
Navy really was here.
I found myself with a group of other lads in the POs Mess. It was lunchtime, and a
genial Chief Buffer was inviting us to sit down, and, with his own gnarled hands began

116
serving us with a dream-like meal of roast lamb, mint sauce, green peas, and roast
potatoes. Nothing could have been more redolent of home and Sunday lunch. Even
today, whenever we have roast lamb, I still think of that meal on board HMS Ceres and
the friendly hospitality of the POs Mess. We arrived back in the free world on 1st
March,1941, no longer POW 's but DBS 's Distressed British Seamen, and perhaps
my narrative should end here. The many months of captivity were behind us; wed been
liberated in rather dramatic circumstances and were now on friendly soil, and welcomed
by our own kind. But we were not out of the woods and heading for home just yet. Our
next taste of freedom seemed depressingly familiar in an Army transit camp just outside
Mombasa. Here again was the communal living style, the patient queuing at the
cookhouse, the aimless wandering about with little or nothing to do.
It was certainly a life of luxury compared with our previous existence, but it was not
freedom as we remembered it. Many were fortunate, however, for our shipmasters
quickly descended on the various Shipping Agencies, where, of course, they were well
known. The agents in turn contacted their principals in the United Kingdom, and those
companies promptly assumed responsibility for their own staff, informing next-of-kin,
arranging cash withdrawals and clothing allowances.
They also authorised our accommodation in several excellent local hotels. The rest of
the ex-prisoners Pool-men to a man - became the joint responsibility of the
Mercantile Marine Office and the Royal Navy. Most remained in the transit camp, but
the sick and elderly were cared for by the Missions to Seamen of all denominations,
whose priestly incumbents strove manfully for their welfare by organising local support
which was generously forthcoming. An early disappointment was the news that no
suitable transport bound for the United Kingdom would be calling at Mombasa for
several weeks, or even months.
But, the Royal Navy had an alternative solution, (and here one suspected that the
alacrity with which we had been lifted out of Merca, may not have been altogether
without motive!). Indeed, up the creek at Port Reitz lay half a dozen merchant ships
captured from the Italians and Vichy French. Their crews had been interned, and now
allied crews were needed to transport the ships to India, South Africa, and perhaps even
the United Kingdom. How about some volunteers?
This merry suggestion was greeted at first with hilarity, and then with alarm. The

117
thought of Kapitan Rogge still prowling about the Indian Ocean in his formidable
Atlantis was all too real, and too recent to be recalled with composure; indeed, the idea
of risking a second encounter with him and his ship so soon was daunting to say the
least.
The RN Captain who chaired the stormy meeting at the MM Office was patient,
perceptive and reasonable. He was also persuasive. To give him his due he insisted on
enrolling volunteers only for this service, when undoubtedly he could have used his
emergency powers to press-gang the lot of us, had he so wished. He got his volunteers -
but only to take ships to South Africa or Britain. - India was out! Launches were
organised and teams of engineers and deck officers went Up the Creek on a tour of
inspection. All ships were in a sad state of neglect sporting long, feathery tresses of
weed at the waterline, their main engines and auxiliaries in disrepair.
There was also evidence of sabotage committed by the departed crews. One ship
boarded by Harrison line men looked familiar, indeed, she was the old SS Patrician,
built in 1917 for Rankin Gilmour as the Saint Jerome, and acquired by Harrisons in
1918. After serving the company for 20 years she was sold to an Italian firm and
renamed Ermina Mazzilla; and here she was in Mombasa Harbour awaiting adoption
like a forlorn puppy in the dogs home. Most of the ships were declared unseaworthy,
but one or two were adequately patched up for the passage to Durban and duly manned.
However, I dont think there was any prospect of a Lloyds certificate being issued to
any of them under the circumstances.
Meanwhile, those of us who found we were not required resumed the waiting game,
waiting impatiently for the ship which would eventually take us home. But it could
hardly be described as a time of trial and tribulation. There were the bars and clubs
(Yacht, Golf and Country etc) which made us welcome, cinemas, restaurants and
beautiful beaches for al fresco picnics. However, through the medium of the Daily
Mirror, copies of which were available at the Seamens Club, we became anxiously
aware of the air raids on London, Coventry, Liverpool and other cities, and feared for
the safety of our families.
Our sybaritic existence soon became unbearable. One day in April 1941 however, our
ship at last came in. She was a troop ship named Nea Hellas which was formerly the
Anchor Lines, Tuscania, and presently commanded by Captain David W Bone the well

118
known author. At the age of 70 he had come out of retirement To do something about
the war! Joyfully we packed up, bade hasty farewells to our newly found friends, and
hastened down to Kilini to lay claim to a bunk in one of the six berth cabins on Nea
Hellas. By this time the sea time I needed for my BOT certificate was sadly in arrears,
so I volunteered my service as a watch keeper for the passage home in the hope of
earning a watch keeping certificate from Captain Bone. The ship called at Durban for
bunkers, where we found the RN seeking crews for captured enemy ships. There was
better stock on offer here and the response was more enthusiastic. Most of the
Scientists officers volunteered and left the trooper to man a former Vichy French ship
which was reported to be in good nick!! She was to be commanded by our own Alec
Watson, formerly the chief officer of the Scientist for the passage to the UK.
Of the crowd which had left Merca Camp, there now remained only elderly masters and
engineers, cadets and apprentices left aboard the troop ship. The Nea Hellas made a
further call at Cape Town to embark a contingent of convalescent troops, and eventually
sailed for Gibraltar with the aircraft carriers HMS Furious and Argus.
The passage passed without incident, but we were perturbed to hear of the German
landings in Crete that were taking place at the time. Our stay in Gibraltar was brief, but
twenty-four hours after leaving for home, and whilst we were counting the few
remaining hundreds of ocean miles which separated us from the shores of England, we
were astonished, and not a little disturbed, to observe our ship suddenly making a 180
degree turn under full helm, while our Royal Navy consorts veered off to the Northwest
at full speed. We were not kept in ignorance of the reasons
for this manoeuvre for long however. Indeed, the word on everyone's lips was The
BISMARK is out! This is not the place to describe the action which ended with the
demise of one of the finest battleships ever built, but we kept an extremely good lookout
to avoid any involvement. And so we returned to Gibraltar to anxiously wait for news.
Ten days or so later, Force H consisting of HM ships Renown, A rk Royal, Sheffield,
and six destroyers entered harbour, whereupon our captain was told it was now safe to
proceed. And so it was. We reached the Clyde on 14 June 1941, vaguely wondering
what to do with all the surplus docking bottles of Van der Hum and cakes of Main
Line plug tobacco and cigarettes which we had somehow accumulated. We need not
have worried, because the Glasgow Customs Officers were on strike! So we packed our

119
spoils and headed for Glasgow Central and the trains which would take us to the four
corners of the United Kingdom. The night train to Liverpool was crowded with service
men and women, and we were lucky to find a corner of the passageway in which to
squat uncomfortably and while away the hours in desultory conversation and fitful
sleep. The journey seemed endless, with numerous inscrutable time-laden halts in the
wild countryside, but eventually the train coasted into Lime. Street Station. It was 6 am
on a Sunday morning and the streets were deserted. Opposite the station the old familiar
buildings had been reduced to rubble during the May blitz. The classic bulk of St.
George's Hall still stood but was blackened and pockmarked with shrapnel. Its Lion
Guard of Honour, defiant as ever, gazed out over the cratered Lime Street.
We stared at the scene in awe for several minutes, then said a last goodbye, and went
our several ways. My route led South but it was no use waiting for a tram, so I trudged
along the torn-up streets, sick at heart to see further evidence of those vicious and
indiscriminate air attacks. A passing motorist drew up and offered me a lift. I accepted
gratefully while my benefactor proceeded to give me details on the latest air raids. At
Princes Avenue I asked him to drop me off at the Church - then realised that the Church
was not there any more. With some trepidation I walked up our street, past the broken
houses, the sightless windows until there, on the corner and still standing, was the home
I had left one year and four months ago. The steps were gleaming white, the door freshly
painted, and a Union Jack hung proudly from a bedroom window. I rang the bell; I had
come home.

120
Above: Liverpool city centre looking South.

Middle: Liverpools South End

Below; Liverpool city centre looking North

121
 Epilogue to the Diary of Graeme Cubbin

The last piece of information concerning my first ship Scientist didnt come to light until ten
months after her sinking; that was when messages started humming across the world from
Mombasa care of Cable & Wireless. The ship had quite simply failed to arrive at Freetown in
May 1940, and, in due course she was officially presumed lost. There was no great mystery
about it because after all a war was on; ships were disappearing every day of the week with or
without trace. Moreover, reports had come in about mines being laid on the Agulhas Bank, and it
appeared that our ship Scientist had struck one of those mines and was lost with all hands.
Such was the theory in Naval Circles. Consequently, throughout the shipping offices of
Liverpool, London, Glasgow and Cardiff, the wage accounts of the missing seamen were made
up and their money passed on to their next-of-kin. Women whod been widowed nursed their
grief, and they quite rightly applied for their statutory pension. Some might have married again -
I know of no specific case, but it was an obvious possibility. My parents had received a gently-
worded letter of condolence from Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth. But my mother never gave up
hope, fervently believing that one day I would turn up like the proverbial bad penny.
Those at home suffered the greater ordeal in not knowing what had happened - or when to
abandon hope. Therefore, when the all is well messages began arriving from Mombasa, to be
delivered to families all over Britain, there was unconfined joy, relief and not a little
consternation throughout the land! Locally on Merseyside it was as though Everton or Liverpool
had won the Big Double!
If I may quote from my family's traditional version of events, Dad was out delivering provisions
in Liverpool's suburbia when the momentous cable arrived. My deliriously happy mother at once
discarded her apron, donned her best coat, pinned on her hat, and set off by foot and tram in
search of Dad, even though she knew that he would be home in a couple of hours. She just
couldn't wait to break the news to him!
She ran him to earth in distant Childwall, (I think) just as he was completing his round. She then
triumphantly waved the fabled cable in front of his nose to the amusement of a curious and
interested customer! Then she boarded a tram to return home while Dad trundled his tricycle van
to the same place. According to him, the going seemed downhill all the way. When the euphoria
had subsided a few unpalatable situations had to be faced. The widows whod been awarded a

122
widows pension were obliged to refund all the pension money theyd received back to the State.
Company accountants and balances of wages had to be re-calculated (and in my case it was
found that I was 4.11.3d in the red! Moreover my father was obliged to repay my premium ie,
the sum payable to the employer on becoming a cadet or apprentice which was 50 in those
days, and money which had been refunded on my decease. But, in the eyes of our kith and kin it
was but a small price to pay for the miracle of deliverance.
What remains to be said of the main protagonists of this story? Kapitan Bernhard Rogge survived
the war, and after the German Navy had been disarmed he opened a nautical instrument business
in Hamburg. A number of his ex-prisoners called on him during the fifties and sixties. Our own
Captain Windsor died soon after his return home; Chief Officer Alex Watson relinquished his
new command to the Ministry of War Transport on arrival in the United Kingdom; he left
Harrisons for the remainder of the war to work as a Sea Transport Officer for the Royal Navy.
After the war he returned to Harrisons and worked as a relief officer, notably on the Manchester
Ship Canal and in Manchester Dock. He died in 1976. Joe Connolly the Scientists Third Officer
left Harrisons to join the RAF Sea Rescue Service on the Yorkshire coast.
Thanks to information received from The SATS General Botha in Cape Town, Intake No 843
Samuel Ellman 1935-36, my fellow cadet, was commissioned into the Royal Navy on our arrival
back at the UK. On being sent to Sicily he was appointed as the Beach Master for the Salerno
landings; he later ended up commanding HMS V irginia in Burma. After the war he went to the
Northern Rhodesia copper mines before retiring to Port Alfred, after that he had an enjoyable life
painting and playing golf. Sam Ellman died in 1990 at the age of 70. Victor Cubbon the Second
Engineer left T&J Harrisons to work for the Mersey Docks and Harbour Board; and Wully
Grainger, of Merca Camp 'plonk' fame, was killed in a tragic accident some years ago. Bob
Skarrow the Chief Engineer was lost when the prize-ship Tirranna was sunk off the Gironde by
the British submarine HMS Tuna. Dave Foulis the Third Engineer survived that disaster only to
spend the rest of the War in a German Prison Camp. On his release he returned to Harrisons,
serving the Company until his early death in 1965. Old Mr Barrow the Quartermaster was last
seen in the late forties manning an Isle of Man Ferry out of Heysham. He must have been 70 by
then! I have lost trace of the others, but you will gather from this little roll call that there are not
many of us left to tell the tale.

Graeme Cubbin.

123
Further to the diary of Cadet Graeme Cubbin, it should be borne in mind that as a 16
year old, and despite his best efforts, he was after all a first tripper. Therefore, he could
hardly be expected to give a full account of everything that occurred during his ten
week stay aboard the Scientist, and his five and a half month incarceration on A tlantis.
Indeed, when his ship Scientist had been attacked on 3 May 1940, that period in time
was referred to as being the Phony War. It wasnt thought of by most people that the
war was going to last any further than a few months. However, there was nothing at all
phony about the war at sea. The battle of the Atlantic began on Day 1 when the A thenia
was sunk without warning on 3 September 1939. During the next eight months of the so
called phony war 428 British and Allied ships totaling 1.4million gross tons were sunk
by U-Boat, mines, aircraft and surface raiders.
Nevertheless, most ships sailed in their company colours, they didnt have their boats
swung out; and many thought the so called war was going to die with a whimper and
would be over quickly. Therefore, when the SS Scientist was heading towards Freetown
she was at a virtual state of ease. Second Mate Anderson paid little attention when the
lookout reported a ship ahead; it was not unusual, passing ships of all types and nations
were a regular occurrence on the SS Scientist. Steaming at her service speed of 14 knots,
the Scientist soon came up on the ship, that an hour or so earlier had been reported fine
on the port bow; a ship which quite unknown to the navigation officer Mr Anderson,
had altered course 180 degrees and slowed down to six knots in order to be caught up.
The ship being overtaken was of course the German raider A tlantis; her crew had been
at action stations for over an hour. She had in fact seen the Scientist before being seen
herself. Indeed, her lookouts were higher up the mast with the added advantage of
having mast head periscopes and extremely powerful binoculars. Therefore, as well as
the giveaway smoke from the British ship, they would have been able to see three or
four miles further than Scientists lookout. A tlantis had been on a southerly course
heading towards Cape Aghulas to lay her mines, but on seeing the Scientist, she
obviously turned 180 degrees to head North and slowed down.
When Kapitan Rogge observed the Scientist as she came within range of his guns, he
was under the impression that with her tall smoke-belching funnel, his prey was a coal
burner of ancient vintage. But that coal-burning Scientist was in fact less than two years
old, and as well as being faster, was in effect a year younger than Atlantis was.

124
After A tlantis had fired her warning shot across the bows of her victim Captain Windsor came
running up to the bridge, his first thoughts being that his own four inch gun on the poop had been
fired without his knowledge or instruction. But by that time it was all too late. The second mate
had been duped into thinking his much faster ship was quite simply overtaking a slower one. But
Captain Windsor had a suspicious mind with regard to disguised Q Ships. Hed been through the
previous war of 1914-18, and during those years the Germans had proved to be past masters in
the art of operating Q ships.
At 14.5 knots the SS Scientist was indeed a fast ship and overtook most ships going the same way
as herself. When the livid Captain Windsor was in conversation with Kapitan Rogge aboard
Atlantis later on, he claimed that if hed been informed of A tlantis when shed first been sighted,
the raider would have been given a wide berth and the raider would never have caught his ship.
The A tlantis may well have been capable of 17 knots when flat out, but so too was the Scientist
with her three cylinder triple expansion engines coupled to a booster turbine. Indeed, she was a
new ship and her boilers were capable of maximum pressure. Moreover, had the raider turned
around and given chase to the fleeing out of range Scientist on first sighting, Radio Officer
Compton would have had time to send distress calls, and Rogge would have soon called off the
chase.
In the months preceding the breaking of the British blockade by A tlantis, Kapitan Rogge and his
aides in Germany had examined the profiles of just about every ship afloat in order to find a
match similar to Atlantis, so that she could assume that ships identity when needed. There were
just 26 ships that fitted the required profile. The features a ship needed for A tlantis for
impersonation, were a cruiser stern, two masts, a tall funnel and five cargo hatches. And there she
was right in front of him, the SS Scientist. Similar in size and appearance she had the all
important cruiser stern. But more than likely this fact was not picked up by Kapitan Rogge,
because as A tlantis went across her victims bows, and because of the usual palls of smoke from
her funnel, Rogge must have thought that as a coal-burner she had an old fashioned counter stern.

125
Teddy; Leutenant Mohr then reached inside his coat and took out his German Navy
officers cap, throwing aside the RN cap he donned his uniform headgear and declared
that Teddy was now a prize of Germany. He then took charge of the bridge. Captain
Thor Lutken and his crew had been taken completely by surprise! Not a shot had been
fired nor had a drop of blood been spilt in the ships capture. The Teddys top secret
routing plans were seized, but while all that was going on in the chartroom, the mate on
watch went to the offside wing of the bridge and managed to dump the rest of the codes
overboard. During the rest of the middle watch of 8 November, Teddys 32 crew
members - of whom four were Australian , named as HH Burgoyne, CM Lacey, AD
Juniper and DP Dwyer, were taken aboard A tlantis with the Norwegians; those four
Aussies had signed on at Brisbane in Australia. As well as her cargo Teddy had 500 tons
of diesel in her bunker tanks, and that was exactly what Kapitan Rogge wanted.
A prize crew under the command of Leutenant Breuers was then sent to the Teddy and
ordered to proceed to a point 500 miles South, just off Christmas Island, and await
further orders. Once there in that more remote place, Atlantis would be able to off load
Teddys 500 tons of diesel bunkers for her own use; thus adding an extra two months to
her cruise requirements.

Crew List of the Norwegian ship Teddy.

Supplied by The Norwegian Archives.

Captain Thor Lutken - First Mate Josef Monsen, 2nd Trygve Nilsen, 3rd Hans
Svenhlt - Carpenter, Bror Lindstrom - Bosun, Thoralf Larson - Able Seamen, Olav
Bernsten, John Gislefoss - Ordinary Seamen, Edvard Hansen, Thoraf Gjesdal,
Erik Gustafsson, Erik Eriksen - Deck Boys, Hubert Burgoyne, Sixten Persson -
Chief Engineer, Herman Jansen, 2nd Finn Lindhjem, 3rd Alf Somoe, Assistant
Engineer, Harry Hansen - Electrician, Clas Collberg - ER Mechanics, Torsten
Dalen, Albert Akelsen, Nils Moller, Johny Hollquist - Pump-man Magnus Fossum -
Stokers, Daniel Dwyer, Albert Juniper. Engine Boy, Charles Lacey - Steward
Thoralf Ekenes - Cook Christian Talleksen - Galley Boy Olaf Eithum - Mess Boy,
Thorlf Elholm. Total crew survived.

126
 The Tanker Ole Jacob

Searches by the two man seaplane of A tlantis were regular occurrences; those flights
served two purposes, the first being to see if there were any British warships around,
while the second was to search for any merchant ship victims. But those Arado and
Heinkel seaplanes were rather flimsy, they could only be operated in good weather and
on a flat sea. Indeed, as well as getting tossed around in a choppy sea, which could
damage their floats and wings, their engines were placed too low and in line with the
pilot. On alighting back in the water of a choppy sea, the cold spray was quite liable to
hit the low slung engine. That in turn could crack the cylinder head of the engine and
render it useless. Such a turn of events occurred on the German heavy cruiser (pocket
battleship) A dmiral Graf Spee during her cruise of 1939.
After having run out of spare Arado engines, due to their cylinder heads cracking on
hitting the cold sea water, she eventually had no eyes. As a consequence of having no
seaplane, A dmiral Graf Spee was engaged on 13 December 1939 with three British
warships, and although those British cruisers could only inflict slight damage, the fact
that the German ship had no seaplane led to her eventual demise. In contrast the Royal
Navy used Albatross seaplanes on their battleships and cruisers to do similar
reconnaissance. The engines on the British ships were placed much higher and well
above the pilots eye line and did not get swamped or drenched.
However, on the following afternoon of 9 November 1940, Leutenant. Bulla and his
observer took their sea plane up and sighted another tanker. Proposing to catch her in the
same manner as he had the Teddy, Kapitan Rogge decided to shadow the new sighting
from a distance, and wait until the darkness before making his attack. But in the
darkness of the night watch later on, and on sighting A tlantis coming up fast from
astern, the tanker which was the Norwegian Ole Jacob under the command of Captain
Leif Christian Krogh altered course, increased her speed to maximum while sending
RRR signals to signify she was being attacked by a raider. Once again Kapitan Rogge
identified himself as the armed merchant cruiser HMS A ntenor, and once again his ploy
brought him fruition as the 8,306 GRT Ole Jacob ceased transmitting and hove to for a

127
 From Johnathon Parkinson of HMS Dorsetshire - rank not given.

Further back in the diary of Cadet Cubbin, when the SS Durmitor had arrived at
Warshiek, Italian Somaliland, it was stated that a British cruiser had shelled Dante
and the surrounding areas. Shortly before that bombardment, HMS Dorsetshire
(Captain Pincher Martin) had been part of WS3, a fast convoy escort for ten
troopships, a hospital ship and others from Singapore to the Red Sea. On arrival
back at Aden on Friday 15 November 1940, and due to intelligence reports, HMS
Dorsetshire was despatched from Aden to Durban on Sunday 17th. But during her
passage the cruiser was ordered by Vice Admiral Leatham C in C East Indies, to
bombard an installation at Dante. The principal target was a salt works complete
with a jetty and loading facilities. At 1402 hrs on 18 November Dorsetshire went to
action stations and at 1429 hrs flew off her Walrus seaplane to spot. The aircraft
also carried bombs to drop on oil tanks which were known to be in the vicinity. At
1441 hrs it was observed that the bombs had been dropped; the cruiser then
opened fire with her main eight inch armament.
Various targets were hit which resulted in clouds of smoke and flames being
observed. At 1526 hrs a torpedo was fired at the salt loading jetty and one of the
pylons was destroyed. The Walrus was recovered at 1555 hrs and re-loaded; at
1650 hrs the seaplane was catapulted once more to continue bombing the oil tanks.
At 1737 hrs the Walrus was hoisted on board again, and, in case of any Italian
counter attack from the air, the ship withdrew to defence stations and departed at
25 knots. When all was clear at 2056 hrs speed was reduced to 17 knots. The
exercise proved to be little more than target practice and was considered as being
not very satisfactory. Altogether we had fired 64 x 8 inch high explosive, 130 x 8
inch semi armour piercing, 36 x 4 inch high explosive, one torpedo, and 1,160
pounds of bombs. Military objectives of oil installations and a wireless station were
left untouched. Lack of both spectacular result and oppositions made the whole
affair rather disappointing. Bad drill and material defects caused several mis-haps.

128
 Capture of the SS Teddy

At 2300 hrs on 7 November 1940, the silhouette of a darkened ship was sighted by the A tlantis
lookouts in 05.30 N - 86.30 E. That ship without lights was a tanker which later proved to be the
6,047 GRT motor ship Teddy, she was owned by A/S Golden West and managed by Klaveness
& Co of Oslo. The ship was loaded with 10,300 tons of fuel oil (FFO) and at the time she was on
charter for the British Tanker Company of London; she had left Abadan on 26 October under the
command of Captain Thor Kristian Lutken and was bound for Singapore.
In order to make an identification in the darkness, the raider passed Teddy on a parallel course on
her starboard side at full speed. Because WW2 was not yet in full swing, America, Russia and
Japan amongst many others were neutrals, and the area around 5 N - 86 E, where A tlantis was
operating was a busy shipping lane for many nationalities. Captain Lutken of the Teddy took the
darkened ship passing him to be a ship of the P&O Line, while Kapitan Rogge had to be very sure
that any ships he attacked were from the Allies and sinking a neutral would spark the fury of the
victims government, which in turn would exacerbate Germanys present unpopular stance even
further. Moreover, even if Rogge did confront a neutral ship, and then had to let it go, that neutral
would no doubt alert the allies of a raider at large, so he had to make sure that any ships he did
approach were from the Allies.
However, once Atlantis was well ahead of her prey and after having ascertained that the darkened
ship was a Norwegian, she turned 360 degrees in a circle, and so as not to be seen in silhouette
against the moonlight she came up 500 yards away on the tankers port side. Searchlights from
Atlantis then swept the Teddys decks, blinding those on the bridge and the poop where a gun was
mounted. A Morse signal from A tlantis stated that she was the armed merchant cruiser HMS
Antenor, and asked the tanker for her identification, that she should heave to for an examination
of her papers, and must not use her radio. But if Captain Lutken of the Teddy had been aware of
his ship silhouettes, he would have known immediately, that the so called HMS A ntenor asking
all the questions, did not resemble the real A ntenor in the slightest.
With both ships stopped the raiders launch was soon on its way; Leutenant Ulrich Mohr dressed
in a Royal Navy uniform was in charge of the apparent 3 man boarding party. On the launch s
deck a hatch tarpaulin was spread over the forepart, but instead of covering a hatch it was hiding
ten armed sailors from A tlantis. With her low freeboard the invaders quickly climbed aboard the

129
boarding party. The same procedure of men under a tarp was carried out by Leutenant
Mohr and his boarding party were soon on the deck of their prey. After having taken
charge of the radio shack, his own telegraphist in the boarding party reversed the
distress calls stating that the raider alert was a false alarm. When this new German ruse
of cancelling RRR warnings came to light, the admiralty issued warnings regarding the
ploy to all ships.)
Ole Jacob was a tanker of 8,306 GRT, built in 1939 and registered in Oslo and on her
maiden voyage. After arriving at Wellington in the evening of 31 July 1940, she
discharged part of her cargo before going to Lyttelton to complete discharging. A few
hours later off Cape Campbell, she collided with the 4,066 GRT motor-ship A rmadale
on passage Lyttelton to Sydney. Both ships were badly damaged, and whereas the
Armadale put into Wellington for repairs, the Ole Jacob went to Auckland for hers; Ole
Jacob later proceeded to Palembang, Sumatra where she loaded 11,000 tons of high
octane spirit. On being captured by A tlantis it was determined that Ole Jacobs cargo of
11,000 tons of high octane spirit was of no use whatsoever to the raider. The tanker was
at the time bound for Alexandria via the Suez Canal. None of Ole Jacobs diesel oil was
taken from her bunker tanks at that point, as plans were already being made with regard
to the Ole Jacobs cargo. After the tanker was stripped of as much fresh water and dry
stores as possible, Kapitan Leutenant Paul Kamenz was given command of Ole Jacob,
and told to make for the same point to which Teddy had been sent, and where A tlantis
would make a rendezvous with both ships on 15 November. Before the war Kapitan
Leutenant zur See Kamenz had been the commanding officer of a training ship at
Porsgrund. Kamenz took all the Norwegian prisoners already on board A tlantis with
him; those men would eventually be handed over to the Norwegian Consulate in Kobe,
Japan. By this time, the Atlantis had been in the water for a year since coming out of dry
-dock. The fronds of seaweed were beginning to show on and below the waterline, and
such growth could only slow the ship down. That point was made by Captain Lutken of
Ole Jacob when hed been in conversation with Kapitan Rogge; the German captain
replied saying he was fully aware of his barnacle bottom, and a knot or so was missing
from his speed. Captain Lutken also commented on the circle of eyebolts around the
fidley, so positioned to support a dummy funnel. (All these small but significant points
were later passed on to the Norwegian Consul in Kobe by Captain Lutken, who in turn

130
passed the same information on to the British Admiralty.) It was also a fact that with the
crew of A tlantis having been on board for a year; eight months of which had been at sea,
tempers were becoming frayed with indiscipline being noticed. The quality of the food
on board A tlantis had deteriorated greatly, water was severely rationed and black bread
was the order of the day. The younger and junior members of the crew were not used to
it and showed their dissent. Kapitan Rogge said he knew all about the crew being
unsettled, but also claimed that his senior ratings were managing any subversive
tendencies amongst the youngsters quite well, and never once had a man had to stand on
the carpet before him to be disciplined. To counteract the threat of indiscipline as best he
could, Rogge gave his crew leave at sea, inasmuch, that a weeks unrecorded leave
could be taken by the restless sailors in order to relax from their grueling, mundane and
monotonous work; such leave at sea would only be brought to a halt when action
stations were sounded.

Crew list of the Norwegian Ole Jacob.

Supplied by The Norwegian Archives.

Captain, Lief Christian Krogh - First Mate, Julius Falch, 2nd and radio operator,
Johan Henry Jacobsen, Third Mate Sverre Rovig - Carpenter, Frithjof Monsen . -
Bosun Johannes Andreassen. - Able Seamen, Leif Svenungsen, Karlow Johansen,
Sigurd Mork. - Ordinary Seamen, Karl Overdal, Malmin Gundersen, John Holm,
Holgar Andersen. - Deck Boy, Marthon Hulback. - Chief |Engineer, Nils
Thomasgaard, 2nd Olaf Vaerstad, 3rd, Asbjorn Flakstad, Asst Engineer, Ellef
Torjesen RodElectrician, Thoralf Kjell Fromyhr - Mechanics, Emrik
Hammarlund, Kare Hesthagen, Magne Forre Pump-man, Harald Johannesen -
Greasers, Ola Remme, John Loberg, William Toftesund, Alfred Gundersen -
Steward, Henry Mosberg - Cook Sigurd Magnussen - Mess Boys, Oskar
Mathisen, Odgar Hoganhaug, Arne Hellerod.

131
 Loss of the Automedon

Monday 11 November 1940 was Armistice Day; a day of remembrance when the
warring sides of WW1 ceased hostilities and came to peace. On board A tlantis a service
was held at 0800 in honour of all those men and women whod lost their lives in the
conflict. However, while that service was in progress, the lookout in the crows nest at
the after end the mainmast saw smoke on the horizon astern and action stations were
sounded. Observing the approaching ships speed and direction, Kapitan Rogge altered
course to fall in with the ship, and then used his favourite tactic of reducing speed so as
to be caught up. After an hour or so, the overtaking ship which came up on the
starboard quarter of Atlantis turned out to be a Blue Funnel Line cargo ship . She was
the SS A utomedon of Liverpool, most prominent with her tall blue funnel and black top
she was steering a course towards Singapore. The SS A utomedon (Captain WB
McEwan) after having left Liverpool on August 24, and on rounding the Cape of Good
Hope, had been at sea for 79 days.
At the appropriate time when he was a mile or so ahead of the SS A utomedon, Rogge
increased his speed to maximum; fired a warning shot then went across the bows of
Automedon in the same manner he had adopted with the Scientist six months earlier.
The German battle ensign was hoisted while a signal hoist went up ordering
Automedon to heave to and not use her radio. But that did not happen!
Indeed, the only response by A utomedon was to transmit a distress signal, but her radio
officer only managed to get - RRR- A utomedon 04.16 - away before the Germans
picked up the wave length and jammed the signal. The result being that just the ships
name and its latitude had been sent. As a result of not following the raiders orders, it
was from 2,000 yards that four 5.9 inch salvos smashed into the bridge and radio shack
of the Liverpool ship with heavy loss of life. Badly damaged, out of control and not
under command, A utomedon continued at her speed of 14 knots as 11 more shells
reduced the whole of the midship section to a mass of twisted steel. At the same time her
lifeboats were smashed to smithereens. The shelling lasted for just three minutes. The
burning and shattered ship then came to a halt. Captain WB McEwan, the second and
third mates, the radio officer and the helmsman were all killed in the bombardment. The
132
1st mate who was not on the bridge at the time was the only deck officer to survive. One
of A utomedons crew had been seen running towards the gun on the poop deck, but
before he could do anything the gun was destroyed by a 5.9 inch shell and the gunner
lost his life. As well as those six fatalities, there were twelve others on board who
suffered varying degrees of injuries.
When Leutenant Ulrich Mohr climbed aboard the shattered A utomedon later on, he said
he was horrified to see all the death, bloodshed and mangled remains of the ships
superstructure, all of which had been caused by just a few minutes of shelling at almost
point blank range. Amongst the flames and smoke a search of A utomedon began, she
had a handsome general cargo consisting of crated aircraft with spare parts, motor
vehicles, bicycles, copper sheeting, 550 cases of whisky, a large quantity of beer, 2
million cigarettes and 120 bags of mail for the serving armed forces at Singapore. But
the only things taken off the ship for use on A tlantis, were the 550 cases of whisky, a
large quantity of cigarettes, the contents of the freezers and the victual store rooms.
At that particular time, an unidentified ship that was stopped some miles away was
observing the burning A utomedon; and also the crew of A tlantis removing a variety of
items from her with their own boats. That caused Kapitan Rogge some consternation as
he was bang in the middle of a busy shipping lane. Indeed, a signal from the distant ship
may alert a British warship to the scene. He therefore told Leutenant Fehler and his
demolition party to make haste, plant charges in the engine room, set them for 1500 hrs
and return to Atlantis. In the meantime the strong rooms of A utomedon were located
and blown open. Inside were found 15 bags of top secret government mail. Then they
found a single eyeleted green bag in what had once been the chart-room. It later turned
out that those mail bags contained some of the most significant items to be captured
during the whole of WW2. Indeed, what was discovered were the Allied military
strengths in the Far East of the Army, Navy and Air Force, port layouts, charts,
decoding tables, ciphers and much, much more. The RRR signal from A utomedon had
in fact been picked up by the SS Helenus, (Captain PW Savery) which was ironically
enough, a ship from the same Blue Funnel Line. That message was immediately sent on
to Colombo in Ceylon, but due to the ineptitude of the radio operators there, the
message was not read or attended to until 90 minutes later.

133
It has been asked by many people over the years, as to why a ship like the SS
Automedon had been entrusted to carry such top secret mails. But the fact remains
she had, and no blame can be placed upon her captain or any other member of his
crew. Indeed, even though Captain McEwan must have known the mail bags in his
strong room were top secret, he would never have known what secrets they held.
They were all weighted bags, weighted so that they could be thrown overboard in
an emergency, but he hardly had a chance to jettison them.
Had he been properly briefed before the passage from Liverpool began, and told
that the mail bags were of ultra importance, he would have dumped the weighted
mail bags over the side, and then sent an RRR message, and not the other way
around; but it would appear that no such briefing had taken place, and Captain
McEwan was simply following the normal procedure laid down by the Admiralty
of sending the RRR message. Under those circumstances no blame should be
placed on Captain McEwan.
Neither can any blame for loss of life be apportioned to Kapitan Rogge. The
conventions of war made at the Versailles Treaty, stated that a warning shot and
the appropriate signals to surrender are to be made when one ship attacks another.
Such a procedure would give the victim ships crew time to abandon ship and take
to the boats. If however, those warnings are not carried out, and the ship being
attacked steams away and uses her radio, the attacking ship can then use the
necessary force to stop or sink that ship. In the case of the SS Automedon, Kapitan
Rogge had been obeying the Rules of War.
At that particular time Winston Churchill was trying to get the USA on the side of
Britain into the war, and whereas Roosevelt wanted to enter and support Britain
and its Allies, public opinion in America was strongly against him doing so.
However, the loss of the top secret mails from Automedon to the Atlantis did have
a twist in the tail. Indeed, when Japan got a copy of those documents, which gave
the USA naval strengths in the Pacific, as well as the weaknesses of the British
forces at Singapore, they took great heart and made plans to attack both Singapore
and Pearl Harbour. So when Japan attacked Pearl Harbour and Singapore,
America joined in the war, Churchill got his wish, and in the long run both
Germany and Japan were defeated.

134
The blame for using the SS A utomedon as the bearer of such important mails, instead of
employing a fast warship, was later laid at the feet of a certain person in the War Office.
But it was all too late, those misappropriated top secret documents assisted in the fall of
Singapore. The inadvertent loss of the capital ships HMS Repulse and Prince of W ales,
costing Britain and its allies many, many thousands of lives and valuable territories.
The remaining crew and passengers from A utomedon which consisted of 31 British and
56 Chinese, were allowed to pack their gear before being taken to the A tlantis. They
were so surprised and grateful at this unexpected gesture, they even helped the German
sailors transfer the meat and other vittles from the freezer and store rooms from their
old home A utomedon to their new one A tlantis. In total eighty seven survivors from the
Automedon were taken aboard the German raider, apparently, some of them. Were
survivors from the SS Anglo Saxon that had been sunk by the Raider Widder four
months earlier. At 1507 hrs on 11 November 1940, the charges that were laid in the
Automedons engine room took effect and sank the ship. To escape from the area
Kapitan Rogge then made a dash to the South to rendezvous with Teddy and Ole Jacob.
It should be stated that although Germany had invaded Norway on 9 April 1940, ships
of that defeated nation were in effect under the invaders rule. Therefore, if any
Norwegian ships carried cargoes for Germanys enemies, they were deemed to be aiding
and abetting an enemy of Germany, and could in effect have their ship and its cargo
confiscated. The crews of those ships would then be repatriated via their nearest Consul.
On the other hand, British and Allied seamen would be made prisoners of war.
It was while he was on the way to his rendezvous point off Christmas Island, that Rogge
who was most fluent in the English language went through the top secret documents
from A utomedon. He was quite surprised at the importance of his catch, and decided
therefore, that such priceless information must be sent to Berlin as quickly as possible.
At a later date Japan was given all the information on those captured top secret files; the
Japanese then realised that Singapore, their dearest and most cherished goal, could be
captured from the British with relative ease.
After the Teddy had been sent South, and Ole Jacob loaded with the Norwegian
survivors had followed her to a position just off Christmas island, the raider made her
rendezvous with those two ships on 15 November 1940. A tlantis removed the diesel oil
and everything else they could from Teddy, and then placed bombs in both her pump

135
and engine rooms. But they failed to detonate at the appointed time.
After an agonising wait for his bombs to explode, Leutenant Fehler the demolition
officer whose nick-name was dynamite had to go back with his team, and in a nerve
wracking hurry up job, in case the original bombs belatedly did explode, he and his team
had to do it all over again; this time they placed charges on the ships sides. On
returning safely to A tlantis and moving well clear, a terrific explosion sent a huge
fireball into the sky with an equally huge cloud of smoke that must have been visible
from well over the horizon. Due to the huge smoke cloud, Rogge once again departed at
speed. At a later date Kapitan Rogge was strongly censured by his superiors in Berlin
for the waste of Teddys 10,000 tons of oil; indeed, that tanker could have been sent to
the far South, and then used to supply the German oil burning ships in the area for quite
some months, or even sent it to their friends in Japan. Rogges reply was that to
contact SKL under such circumstances, he ran a big risk of being detected on RDF and
therefore chose the safety first rule. There was also the problem Rogge had of
continually supplying prize crews, and was presently at a bare working minimum.
After the whole contingent of Norwegian survivors had been embarked on the Ole
Jacob, that ship was also stripped of her diesel, water and food leaving just enough to
make the passage to Kobe, Japan. With her went all the top secret documents from
Automedon under the charge of Kapitan Leutenant Paul Kamenz and six armed German
sailors
After having delivered Automedons top secret documents to his masters in Berlin,
Kamenz then travelled to Lorient and joined the U 106 (Kapitan Leutenant
Jurgen Oesten) he then transferred to the supply ship Nordmark, before eventually
getting back on Atlantis in April 1941.
The Ole Jacob departed the area on 16 November 1940 and arrived at Kobe on 6
December. At first Captain Krogh and his crew were sent to the German passenger ship
Scharnhorst at Kobe. They were released after three days, whereupon the captain went
straight to the Norwegian Consul to make his report. Ole Jacob was then sailed to he
Mariana Islands, where the high octane fuel was exchanged with the Japanese for a
similar amount of diesel oil. Ole Jacob then had a name change to Benno, that name
being a diminutive of Bernhard, a name which Rogge was referred to by his close
friends. The Benno was then used as a supply ship for the German raider Orion. The

136
The French possession of the Kerguelen Islands was more a base for whaling ships.
When the Atlantis went there to replenish her water supplies, she anchored in the unin-
habited Gazelle Bay of Port Couveraux which is in Whalers Bay.
The islands are on the same latitude as the Falkland Isles and have the same climate.

137
 The Ole Jacob under Esso colours

On arrival at Couvereux Bay in the Kerguelen Islands, Atlantis suffered damage to her
underwater hull by hitting a submerged rock. So severe was the damage it almost spelt the end
for the German raider. The dummy Samson posts have been removed.

138
Benno arrived at Bordeaux in July 1941, but six months later on 23 December 1941, she
was sunk by the RAF off the Spanish coast .
Kapitan Rogge had a problem with his reserves of fresh water, and despite the fact that
some of his men had been sent away as prize crews, he usually had over 300 of his own
complement, and also the burden of prisoners if and when they were on board. The
Atlantis had a seawater distilling plant; but because it was ancient and coal fired, its
output was little or no better than the sailing passenger ships of the 1890s. Moreover, the
coal used to fire the distillery was presently being used as ballast.
Because water was strictly rationed on board Atlantis, and with it being summertime in
the Southern hemisphere, Rogge decided that at the earliest opportunity, A tlantis would
make a landfall at the Kerguelans Islands in 50 S -70 E. There was plenty of water on
those islands, but with them being ice bound for part of the year, it made December to
May the best time to go there. (The Kerguelans Islands are almost on the same latitude
as the Falkland Islands, and have a climate similar to the North of Scotland.) It is not its
latitude that makes the Kerguelens icy cold, but the prevailing South Westerly winds
that come up from the South Pole. However, once A tlantis was in that remote part of the
world, which was lavishly endowed with mountains, waterfalls, rivers and streams, the
ships fresh water tanks could be filled to capacity; while at the same time a major
overhaul of the ships two diesel engines could take place. Furthermore, the crew could
step ashore for the first time in almost a year, and experience once more the strange
feeling of having dry land beneath their feet.
However, shortly before Rogges planned departure for the Kerguelens, the raider
Pinguin, (Kapitan zur See Ernst Felix Kruder) which was one of Atlantiss six sister
ships, had captured the Norwegian tanker Storstad, of 8,900 GRT.
That motor tanker commanded by Captain Egil Wilhemsen had loaded 11,800 ton of
diesel cargo, and 500 tons of bunkers at Borneo before sailing on 30 September 1940.
She was captured by Pinguin a week later on 7 October in 24 S - 51 E which is about
200 miles to the South East of Madagascar. Five from her engine room staff and the
carpenter from her 31 crew were forced to stay on board to work ship; the remainder
were sent to Pinguin as prisoners. A prize crew under the command of Kapitanlieutenant
Erich Warning was sent to the Norwegian tanker, and in the darkness of 7 October,
1,200 tons of Storstads cargo was transferred to Pinguins large bunker tanks. The

139
captured ship was re-named Passat and shortly afterwards she was sent to the Bass Strait
where she laid 70 mines between 29-31 October 1940. Returning to the Indian Ocean
she topped up the bunker tanks of A tlantis, Pinguin and Orion, and then between 8-10
December she took the 405 prisoners from Pinguin and headed for Bordeaux.
Those 405 prisoners included the crews from the Nowshera, Maoma, Port Brisbane and
Port Wellington. When Storstad sailed she had 524 people on board. After rounding
the Cape of Good Hope it was on 6 January 1941, in position 27 South - 12 West that
she met up with the heavy cruiser A dmiral Scheer, the raider Thor, and the supply ship
Nordmark. With them they had the captured British ship Duquesa Those four were all
motor ships and between them they took 6,500 tons of diesel from Storstads cargo tanks.
Duquesa was a refrigerated ship which from Australia had 3,500 tons of meat in her
freezers as well as 15 million eggs. Needless to say the German ships took their fill from
the reefer. Storstad sailed for the Gironde in what was to be the most trying of passages.
Water was strictly rationed, food was extremely scarce, and conditions with all those
people on board were appalling. However, she reached her destination on 4 February
1941. With A tlantis steaming South towards the ice the temperature dropped rapidly,
and whereas her sailors had been working in shorts and sandals on 10 December, it was
on their arrival at 50 S on 14 December, that they had to dig deep and find their cold
weather gear. (At the same time Pinguin went further South to the whaling areas and
captured the whole of the Norwegian whaling fleet which consisted of two factory ships
a supply tanker and 11 whale catchers.)
Rogge was armed with the knowledge that Port Couvreux in the Kerguelen Islands had
once been a whaling and sealing station, and he hoped it was uninhabited. He harboured
fears that the British may already be there ,and they were using Port Couvreux as an
observation post with a radio transmitter installed; for that reason A tlantis went to action
stations as she made her approach to Port Couvreux. When she dropped her anchor in
the bay, it was the first time in nine months that A tlantis had become moored to the
land. The scintillating air was fresh and chilly while the snow capped mountains could
only add to the picturesque beauty of the islands. Kapitan Leutenant Mohr and a small
heavily armed party went ashore in the launch on a reconnaissance mission. An hour or
so later he returned to report that all there was on the island were a few deserted shacks.

140
The A tlantis lays at anchor in Gazelle Bay while her crew set up hose lines for
replenishing the ships water tanks. It took two days to set the hose lines up, and a
further two days to get the required amount of water on board the ship. It was estimated
that 1,200 feet of connected hose line was needed to complete the operation.

141
But one of those shacks had a 1936 French calendar on the wall, thus giving a clue as to
the last time anybody had lived there. The boats were launched, the lead was swung and
soundings were taken to mark out a channel for Atlantis to follow; the ship then
weighed and crept slowly and carefully along the recently buoyed path towards a pre-
planned anchorage in Gazelle Bay. As A tlantis went slow ahead, with barely enough
speed for steerage way, she had two boats under oars spread out ahead of her taking
soundings. Those soundings were being hailed back to the ship intermittently by each
boat which were moving at two to three knots. But because of her slow speed the helm
on A tlantis suddenly wouldnt answer and she began to drift to port. The boats ahead
were sent clear, and half ahead was rung down to regain steerage. But after all those
preliminaries of setting buoys and taking soundings, A tlantis hit an under water rock
which brought the ship to a grinding and shuddering halt. It was later established that the
rock shed hit was tall and needle shaped, and the two boats that were spread apart
when taking their soundings had passed on each side of it.
Moments passed before the realisation of what had happened registered in the minds of
those on the bridge, and full astern was rung down in an attempt to release the ship from
the undetected menace. As the engines went full astern the churning boiling water
turned green as it surged far past the focsle, but there was no movement of the ship, just
a heavy vibration that rattled the masts. Rogge then asked those in the engine room if
there was any water coming in, to which the answer was in the negative. It later
transpired, however, that the double bottoms in the forepart of the ship had taken the
brunt. An 18 x 6 foot hole had been ripped out of the hull breeching the double bottoms
and the forepeak area, thus flooding the fresh water tanks situated there.
Everything that could be done was being done, and all in an attempt to release the ship
from the clutches of the rock that held her in its grip. Half ahead to full ahead was
followed by half astern and full astern; but there was no response, except to widen the
hole and extend the damage.
A diver was sent down. He came back up saying the situation was hopeless, that the ship
was skewered inescapably on a jagged dagger of a rock. Soundings were taken with the
lead being hove from both sides of the focsle head; the depth was ten fathoms, but right
in the middle of the marked out channel was that undetected 40 foot pinnacle of rock
pointing skywards, and just 20 feet or so from the surface..

142
But whether the divers report to his captain may - or may not - have been true, Rogge
didnt want to believe it - and refused to believe it. He therefore decided to go down
and see the damage for himself. Never in his life had he dived, but after getting some
instructions and tips from the diver, he donned the heavy and cumbersome divers suit
and went over the side to assess the damage for himself. Half an hour later he came back
up to be greeted by a respectful and anxious audience. His findings being that although
the rupture in the ships bottom really was bad, it wasnt something that would beat him.
It was going be rectified, one way or another! After a meeting with his officers and
senior ratings, it was decided that the anchoring arrangements were to be switched from
forrard to aft, the bower anchors would be led to the mid-ship section, and the kedge
anchor which was smaller, would be laid 50 fathoms astern attached to the ships
towing wire. The object being to go full astern, while at the same time hauling in the
bower anchors on the focsle head windlass and the kedge on the after capstan.
However, the operation which took the rest of the daylight hours was a failure!
The next thing was to note the rise and fall of the tide and use the high water mark when
going full astern. Therefore, a man was sent ashore to record the times and heights of the
tides. But that didnt bear any fruit either. Another plan was implemented, in that every
available piece of gear in the forepart of the ship would be moved aft to bring her stern
down and her head up, a turn of events which only served to increase the misery of the
Atlantis sailors. Indeed, it was hard, cold and unrelenting graft
Sailors on any ship seldom if ever wear gloves, or indeed, any other encumbrances such
rings, bracelets or amulets on their wrists, hands or fingers. Nevertheless, despite their
frozen purpled hands and fingers, every spare man formed a chain gang to carry and
pass anything and everything they could from forrard to the poop and the after well
deck. A seemingly never ending pile of 5.9 inch shells, each weighing 100 lbs, tins of
paint from the paint locker, coils of wire rope, and even the permanent sand ballast
from around the fore peak went aft.
The transfer of gear went on by day and by night, while morale on board A tlantis went
lower and lower in the bitterly cold and windy conditions. Eventually, both the poop and
the after well deck were packed, the result being that the ships head rose a few feet. But
it all counted for nought; because when she went full astern and then full ahead at high
water, the impaled ship still refused to move.

143
Dynamite Fehler suggested blowing the rock out with explosives, but his notion was
quickly rejected as the explosion may well break the ships back, which in turn would
damage the ship beyond repair. On the third day however, after every conceivable idea
had been tried and tested, it was when a stiff icy cold wind was blowing that a new
tactic was employed. Every available man was positioned on the starboard side of the
foredeck, the after well deck, the poop and even the focsle head.
At the pip of the bosuns whistle, those men would all rush over to the port side, and
with the aid of the wind it was hoped that such a jogging might release the ship off the
pinnacle of rock. The men went back and forth to cause a slight roll, while the cold and
chilly springtime wind increased in strength. But yet again nothing! Quite possibly one
or more of those frozen wretches running over from port to starboard must have said a
prayer. Because all of a sudden something began to happen! The strong icy wind
increased, and that, combined with the movement of the men rushing over from side to
side began to turn the ship on its rocky needle like pivot.
It was quite noticeable to the crew that something was beginning to happen. Slowly the
wind blew the ship around until it had turned by some 90 degrees. Then something else
happened as the running across the deck continued. Quite suddenly there was a loud
grating rending noise; the ship slid off the accursed rock and floated free. Everybody on
board rejoiced in loud cheers but danger still lurked. It was by that time dark, the watch
on deck couldnt use cluster light to work with in case the enemy were around. The
wire rope on the kedge anchor then had to be shortened, just in case the ship slewed
back onto the same rock that had caused all the trouble.
Under normal circumstances the captain of A tlantis liked to operate in the dark; daylight
was not always so welcome as the ship could be seen, but on this occasion when
daylight did arrive, during the morning watch of 17 December it was gratefully
accepted. The ship could at last weigh anchor and motor in towards her anchorage;
while everything on the poop and after well deck could be stowed back to their original
places up forrard. But after all that work had been completed there was more gruelling
work to be done, let alone the task of repairing the keel and double bottoms. After
considering anchoring in one of the inlets, and taking the risk of hitting another rock,
Kapitan Rogge decided to stay in the clear but ice cold waters of Couvreux Bay.
Christmas Day was getting closer, but in view of the tremendous workload for all on

144
board, that day of celebration was going to be little or no different from any other.
Nevertheless, some allowance for religious observance for the day was made, and after a
religious service, 900 pints of Punch were downed by the ratings as a reward for their
recent efforts. The damage to the outer skin of the double bottom had taken three days to
assess, but repairs may well take a lot longer. The riveted plates had sprung and were
partly bent back at right angles to the keel, and that had left a huge cavernous hole
which was almost big enough to drive a motor car through.
Nevertheless, the task of repairing that gaping hole at the fore peak had to be completed,
and who best to do it than the two divers with their under water acetylene torches and
welding gear. When theyd done what they could in cutting away the bent and twisted
plates, and after patching up the damage to make it watertight, four brave men
volunteered to go into the double bottom to work two at a time and were sealed in. With
enough food and water to last them in their enclosed cramped space, they blew out the
seawater with compressed air, and then after sealing the repaired starboard garboard
plate with shored up cement boxes and concrete, they had to wait for two days and
nights for those cement boxes to set hard before tapping on the tank top above for them
to be released. Temporarily it worked!
The real test at full speed would come later on. Atlantis then motored slow ahead into
Gazelle Bay and anchored between the mountains in a spot where she could not be seen
from outside; her crew then made preparations for the water tanks to be filled. While all
that was going on, plans were being made by Rogge the Rogue and his hierarchy, as to
the ships future raiding plans and the next disguise to be used. Whereupon, it was
decided, that if the repairs to the underwater hull were found to be successful, and on
leaving the Kerguelen Islands, A tlantis would become the Norwegian Tamesis
registered at Tonsberg. Therefore, the funnel markings would have to be changed.
But during the forenoon watch of Tuesday 24 December 1940 when this new disguise
was being implemented, Leading Seaman Bernhard Herrmann who was working in a
bosuns chair with the funnel painting party, fell to the deck and was fatally injured. It
can quite easily happen! One report by a journalist who helped in writing a book on
Atlantis, stated that Herrmanns gantline was severed by a funnel exhaust; but such a
mis-hap cannot be the case. Because when a crew is painting a ships funnel, the
bosuns chair gantline of each seaman, would not, or could not, be anywhere near any of

145
the funnel exhausts. Indeed, those of us who have worked on painting a funnel, will
know, that the gantlines hang down from outer rim of the funnel to the deck.
Moreover, to make an awkward and cumbersome bosuns chair hitch can be quite
dangerous. After being hauled up to the funnel top by another sailor, the seaman painter
has to grasp the two gantline parts in one hand and momentarily hold his own weight,
whilst at the same time he passes a bight of rope over his head and beneath his two feet
with the other hand; quite simple when working in good weather in shorts and shirt, but
this funnel painting occurred in very cold conditions. Indeed, it would appear to the
author, that when L/S Herrmann was attempting to make himself fast, with his
obviously chilled and gloveless hands, and in being well wrapped up with a heavy coat,
it must have been, that when he held both gantline parts in one hand he lost his grip with
his numbed fingers. In training ships the pupils are always taught to secure the two
gantline parts with a temporary seizing whilst making the bosuns chair hitch. But
trusting in their own strength and the belief that they can hold their own weight for a
short time - seamen always by-pass that simple rule! It must also be added, as previously
stated, that purely for safety reasons, seamen of all nations never wear gloves, watches,
rings or any other amulets whilst on deck working with their hands.
Bernhard Herrmann who broke both legs in his fall died five days later. He was buried
ashore with full military honours in a service conducted by Kapitan Rogge with the
whole ships company in attendance. His grave was marked with a wooden cross on a
cairn of stones. Bernhard Herrmann was the one and only accidental death on board
Atlantis; his final resting place became the most Southern of all German Forces graves
during WW2.
But work on board A tlantis had to continue. Indeed, the main reason for the ships visit
to the Kerguelens had primarily been to replenish her fresh water tanks. There was
indeed an abundance of waterfalls and streams in the vicinity, but transporting the water
from the mountain sides to the ship was another problem. The ship came in as close as
she could. The distance from the selected waterfall to the ship was estimated to be about
1,200 yards. The fresh water had to be either carried in buckets and drums, or else by
connecting all the ships fire hoses together as far as the waterfall. But when all those
fire hoses were connected there was still some way to go; therefore the fuel lines were
used to make the distance up. The required distance was eventually made up with the

146
last length of hose being made up from a bolt of canvas. The next problem was getting
the water from the waterfall and into the hose line. Various ideas were put forward
before the problem was solved. The eventual idea was to put a hole in the bottom of a
top-less 40 gallon oil-drum, that hole had to be just big enough for a canvas hose line to
pass through it. The barrel was suspended to catch the water from the waterfall with the
use of a barrel hitch on the oil-drum, then stretched over the waterfall from one side to
the other on a jack stay.
When this contraption was guyed off into the waterfall, the simple force of gravity was
used and the water flowed into the oil-drum and then through the hose lines at great
speed. Nevertheless, with all the adjustments required, it took a further two days to get
the water on the move. But on the third day every tank on the ship was full of sparkling
and clear fresh mountain water. Although the patched up work on the hull was holding,
there was still quite a bit more work to be done on those repairs to make her fully
seaworthy. Christmas week was when the crew were allowed ashore. There was plenty
of wildlife on the island, with seals, penguins, sea lions, rabbits and many other species
for the crew to admire.
However, on 11 January 1941, after 26 days of so called rest and recuperation for the
men of A tlantis, the time finally arrived for them to continue their raiding activities.
Besides, the glass was falling alarmingly, and the icy hurricane force winds that came
from the South Pole had prevailed for a week. Leaving the Kerguelen Islands was the
first step to test the repairs to the underwater hull; as anxious eyes were kept focused on
the repaired area of the forepart, a speed of seven knots was increased to ten and
eventually fourteen. No faults were found, but just to be as sure as he could be, Kapitan
Rogge ordered a broadside to be fired as the ship went at her maximum speed which
was then down to 14 knots. Success! Kapitan Rogge then set a course towards the Cape
to India sea lane.

147
 The End of the SS Mandasor

Kapitan Rogge wanted to continue his raiding in and around the Sumatra area, but during his
absence at the Kerguelans, one of his fellow raiders began operating on his patch, so SKL ordered
Rogge to patrol the Arabian Sea area instead. However, in the scorching hot cloudless weather,
it was not until 12 days after departing the Kerguelans on 23 January that a victim was sighted.
Indeed, after having taken off at first light in his Heinkel seaplane, Leutenant Bulla and his
observer saw heavy palls of smoke some 60 miles to the North of Atlantis.
Full ahead was ordered, Atlantis went at her top speed, and before the end of the forenoon watch
the reported smoke was sighted fine on the starboard bow. The distant ships course was noted
while her speed was estimated to be about ten knots and she was assumed to be British a coal-
burner. It was when she saw A tlantis from 10 miles away, however, that the prospective victim
turned away to starboard, while at the same time the raider turned to port. The reason for both
ships turning away from each other was because quite recently, a communiqu from the British
Admiralty had ordered all merchant ships to turn away on sighting any other ship. If that ship
followed in a belligerent or aggressive manner, then the British ship should send out a QQQ
signal and give her position. Then again if the same ship attacked, the RRR signal should be sent.
But thanks to the SKL, Rogge knew all about that latest Admiralty instruction, and by turning
away to port, Rogge left his victim thinking he was another British ship following the same
Admiralty instructions. Soon afterwards both ships were out of each others sight, but Rogge the
Rogue plotted her course and speed so that he could make an approach in the darkness. But when
darkness fell the intended victim could not be found! On the next morning as the sun rose,
Leutenant Bullas seaplane also rose, and within just a few minutes he found what was to be a
British ship some 30 miles away.
On returning to A tlantis for further instructions, Bulla was told to rip out the radio aerial, strafe
her with machine gun fire, bomb the ship with his two 110 pound bombs, and then replenish his
fuel, bombs and ammunition from the launch. Bulla attacked from out of the sun in his HE 114 -
Heinkel, this was the third instance in which Bulla had found a ship for A tlantis to capture, while
soon afterwards when he trailed his grapnel, it became the first time he successfully managed to
rip out an aerial with it.
The fuel capacity of the Heinkel gave it a range of about 100 miles or about one hours flying
time while keeping A tlantis in sight. For rearming and refuelling in fine weather, the seaplane
148
could alight near the launch and prepare for her next flight.
The British ship turned out to be the 5,144 GRT SS Mandasor of Liverpool. Built by Wm
Hamilton of Port Glasgow in 1919 as the SS W ar Genista, she was transferred to T&J
Brocklebank as a war replacement just as hostilities ended. From then on, and for the next 20
years, Mandasor was a regular visitor to India. On this her final and fatal passage she was bound
from Calcutta towards the UK and commanded by Captain Alfred Hill OBE; her cargo consisted
of pig iron, tea and jute. Mandasors crew numbered 88, of which 19 were Europeans while the
remainder were Lascars. Captain Hill had purposefully kept well away from the normal shipping
lane; he thought that by adopting such a tactic, hed have a better chance of keeping clear of any
raiders which he knew were loitering with intent in the Indian Ocean.
In the meantime, A tlantis which had given chase to the Mandasor had stopped, loaded its launch
with aviation spirit, bullets and bombs, and then lowered it into the water to await Bullas return
for re-arming. But by that time another aerial had been rigged on Mandasor, and her radio officer
had continued sending out RRR signals, giving the ships name and position, as well as stating
that she was being bombed by a seaplane. Moreover, while Bulla had been re-fuelling and re-
arming alongside A tlantis, two 0.5 Machine guns had been set up on the Mandasors bridge
wings, and when Bulla returned to strafe the merchant ship again, her gunners had managed to
reply to his next attack. Apparently, one or more of those 0.5 bullets hit the port float on the
Heinkel, and when it tried to alight on the water later on, where the armed launch was stopped
waiting for it, the float collapsed and the Heinkel capsised in the choppy water. Bulla and his
observer were compelled to abandon their craft and were picked up by the launch. But when that
launch re-started its engine, and tried to heave to in the choppy sea to lessen its rolling, its engine
cut out. Caught beam on to the sea the launch rolled violently, and as a result, the occupants of
both the launch and the Heinkel suffered horrendously from the effects of sea-sickness.
Meanwhile, A tlantis came within range of the zig-sagging Mandasor and opened fire with a
broadside from 8,500 yards. The first salvo straddled the target, while a shell from the second hit
the midship section, the radio shack was destroyed and the ship was set on fire. Of over 60 rounds
of 5.9 shells, eight hits were recorded. Three Europeans and three Indians were killed while the
other 82 took to the boats. Ulrich Mohr who was in charge of the boarding party, picked up a
large number of survivors and put them on board A tlantis which by that time had stopped. Mohr
and his party then went aboard the blazing Mandasor and took away as much fresh and canned
food as they could, as well as what was left on the bridge including charts, documents and
weapons. The codes and other secret documents had been jettisoned in a weighted bag.
Meanwhile the 82 survivors were embarked on board A tlantis.
149
Dynamite Fehler then arrived on the burning ship with his demolition squad. Fuses
were set and timed for 30 minutes. When the charges blew it took just five minutes for
the 22 year old ship to go down stern first. Her grave was marked with tea chests and
large patches of loose tea. By that time it was beginning to go dark, while for some
hours nothing had been seen or heard of either the Heinkel or the launch which was
without a radio. By the time they were located and picked up they had been getting
thrown around in their nauseous state for six hours. The broken down launch was
hoisted aboard A tlantis, while the broken down Heinkel which lay upside down in the
water was deemed as being beyond repair and used as target practice. The great loss of
his Heinkel left Kapitan Rogge without an eye in the sky. Indeed, not only was he
unable to search for merchant ships to sink; but more importantly, neither was he able to
see whether his feared nemesis of a British cruiser was around.

150
 MV Speybank, One of Eighteen Sister Ships

Both the holiday and the change of routine at the Kerguelens had come and gone. The
boredom combined with frustration was once more creeping in, and especially amongst
the younger and less experienced sailors of A tlantis. At times the capture of an enemy
ship broke the monotony, but it soon passed by and drudgery prevailed once again. For
almost a year the men of Atlantis had been cooped up on a ship that was ill fitted to
carry so many; the food was generally poor, the weather for the most part was
extremely hot, and the stuffy accommodation was cramped with some mess decks
housing as many as 20 ratings. No doubt many of them must have thought their
prisoners were better off than they were.
Those who were lucky enough to have portholes in their mess could only open them
during the hours of daylight for fresh air; after sunset it was always darken ship when
both portholes and deadlights were battened down. There was of course no air
conditioning, and except for the meat freezer and a fridge in the officers pantry, where a
small quantity of water could be kept cool for the officers, there were no other fridges
on the ship. Other than the officers, the rest of the crew had to drink their meagre
allowance of water hot. On top of those facts mentioned, and although the temperature
in the Indian Ocean is always high where A tlantis was operating, the month of January
around Mozambique is amongst the hottest of the year.
At one point one of the officers saw a rating pouring his daily bottle of beer over the
side. Empty bottles or other waste had to be placed into a special bag for organised
sinking, and could not be allowed to float on the water; therefore, the rating was
following standing orders. On being questioned as to the wastage of his beer, the rating
told the officer that the daily beer issue was pointless. It was hot, unpalatable, and
couldnt even be drunk let alone be enjoyed. The sympathetic officer informed Kapitan
Rogge of the incident; a new rule regarding cold drinks from the refrigerator for officers
and himself came to an end. What is good for one must be good for all, he said.
However, a week after Mandasor had been sent to the bottom, a time when all hands felt
as though their presence on board really was appreciated, action stations were sounded

151
four days later on 27 January 1941. The ships broadcast stated that the three funnelled
81,000 ton Queen Mary had been sighted. But whereas it might have sent the adrenalin
racing through the veins of those bored youngsters, it didnt have the same effect on
Kapitan Rogge, or those in the A tlantis hierarchy. Indeed, that huge ship would be more
heavily armed than his own and would probably have a number of six inchers. She
could steam at 32 knots, twice the speed of Atlantis, and more than likely shed have a
cruiser or two around as an escort.
Therefore, in knowing that even if he could make an attack on the huge troop ship, it
would be both pointless and suicidal, so Rogge, much to the disappointment of his crew,
copied the British Admiralty instruction of turning away. Much later on however,
Kapitan Rogge was to learn that the three funnelled ship was in fact the unescorted
troop ship Strathaird; she had left Bombay on 24 January 1941 bound for Cape Town.
Four days later on 31 January 1941, which is summertime if the Southern Hemisphere,
action stations sounded once again. At that time A tlantis was prowling in and around the
Seychelles area, hoping to apprehend a tanker on the Persian Gulf to the Cape of Good
Hope sea route. In the second dog watch shortly after 1800 hrs, Matrose Freiwald the
lookout in the foremast crows nest reported an object two points on the port bow. Those
of the crew who had been sitting around playing cards or doing something else to pass
the time away suddenly sprang into life when action stations were sounded.
The lookout further reported that because there was no smoke, he deemed the distant
ship to be a motor vessel. However, because he wanted to remain unobserved, Rogge
decided to track the sighting until the arrival of darkness before he announced himself.
The target was not a tanker but a cargo ship, and dawdling along at about nine knots she
had all the attributes of being British. Rogge knew it was not an Axis ship, SKL would
have told him that such a ship was in the area, so he kept A tlantis barely within sighting
distance of 17 miles. On the approach of darkness however, Rogge slowly crept up and
positioned himself a few miles directly astern of his proposed victim. Indeed, Kapitan
Rogge knew that on such a merchant ship, the last place her lookout would be
concentrating his eyesight on would be abaft the beam. By that time and due to the ever
increasing barnacles, and the Kerguelen repair damage to her underwater hull, the speed
of A tlantis was down by two or three knots to a flat out maximum of fourteen. So
following in her victims wake it took until 2130 hrs before the raider came up on the

152
unsuspecting merchant ships port quarter. As the warning shots were fired across the
merchantmans bow, the brilliance of a searchlight lit her up from stem to stern. - Do
not use your radio - What ship? - Stop your engines - Prepare to receive a boarding
party. came the Aldis Lamp message from the raider.
After having been taken completely by surprise, no radio transmissions were sent, the
ship stopped, gave her name as Speybank, and in an act of surrender she hove to for a
boarding party; her captain did not have the slightest inclination as to what nation the
warship belonged. But as Kapitan Rogge stood waiting on his bridge for further
developments, he saw a lone man on Speybank working at the four inch gun on the poop
deck. Rogge thought he was attempting to load and open fire on A tlantis - after his ship
had already surrendered! - it was Rogge himself who ordered the 75mm gun on his own
focsle head to bring the would be gunner down.

It later transpired however, that the Australian gunner, Able Seaman Bailey, was not
attempting to open fire on the raider at all, he knew his ship had been captured and was
trying to remove the breech block from the four inch gun and dump it overboard. By
doing that, the gun which could easily have been un-shipped and taken back to the raider
would be useless without its breechblock. The first 75 mm shell from A tlantis missed,
but the second hit the stern near the gun and knocked Bailey unconscious. At a later date
the gunner finished up in a POW camp, but continued to suffer from his injuries.
When the first shell hit the stern of Speybank, the mixed race panic stricken crew of
Lascars and Chinese made for the boats with their own personal belongings and threw
them in. Swinging out the boats and manning the falls in an attempt to lower the boats,
they were brought to a halt when a burst of machine gun fire from A tlantis was
accompanied with an order by megaphone which ordered them to remain on board.
When the boarders arrived at the Speybank in their white launch, Captain Morrow was
to learn that his ship had been captured by an armed raider. On examining the manifest
it was soon learned by the boarding party officer Adjutant Mohr, that the MV Speybank
of Glasgows Bank Line had been bound from Cochin towards New York, with a
valuable and worthwhile mixed cargo which included a large amount of tin and rubber.
With Captain Morrow looking on Mohr ransacked his safe looking for codes, ciphers or
any other valuable communication papers. Except for the gunner trying to man the

153
Speybanks anti submarine gun, the capture of the Glasgow ship was just the way
Kapitan Rogge liked to impose himself and his ship. Obey the Rules of War and avoid
any bloodshed! Indeed, except for the SS King City which he had thought was an armed
merchant cruiser, and a ship hed attacked without warning, every other ship hed
approached had immediately operated its radio and sent out distress calls; an action
which compelled him to open fire - but even if his previous actions did result in
fatalities, they were all within the Rules of War. Kapitan Rogge was well aware that
Speybank was one of 18 sister ships owned by Andrew Weirs Bank Line of Glasgow.
With that in mind he had already decided not to sink her, he would keep her as a prize,
despite the fact that he was desperately short of a prize crew to man her.
Built in 1926 at Glasgow, Speybank had a GRT of 5,150 while her diesel engines and
twin screws gave her a service speed of 11 knots. Kapitan Rogge also realised that not
only did Speybank have a valuable mixed cargo, but the ship itself would be ideally
suited for use as an auxiliary. Indeed, because she had so many sister ships which
looked exactly the same, she would suit the role of a supply ship or a minelayer
perfectly. The time taken to complete the whole operation of capturing the MV
Speybank had taken just over one hour.
On leaving Cochin, China, the captured ship had been well stocked with provisions of
water and diesel for her 60 to70 day passage to New York; but Rogge thought a passage
to the Gironde and Bordeaux would suit Germany much better. Therefore, Leutenant
Breuers accompanied by ten armed men, formed a prize crew for the Speybank and told
to proceed to the Saya de Malha Bank in 10S - 63E and await further instructions.

154
The picture above of the MV Speybank was taken before the start of WW2. After her capture by
Atlantis she was converted to a mine layer at La Pallice. Renamed as Doggerbank by the Ger-
mans, her first task was to lay mines in Table Bay. In 1943 she was mistakenly sunk by a U-Boat
with heavy loss of life of her German crew and large number of POWs.

Taken from Atlantis - furthest away Charlotte Schlieman, nearest on the right is the Doggerbank
after she had laid mines in Table Bay, she was formerly the Speybank.

155
Above - From 18 miles away, the SS Strathaird was mistaken for the 81,000 ton Queen Mary.

Below - The real Queen Mary with degaussing gear on her ships side.

156
157
The pictures on this and the following page give an insight as to what Graeme Cubbin came
home to after the May Blitz of Liverpool in 1941.

During the month of May of 1941 Liverpool was heavily bombed by the Luftwaffe, and such a
month has gone down in history as the infamous May Blitz.
But in the previous month of April, the SS Malakand of T&J Brocklebank Lines pictured above,
blew up in the most devastating of circumstances. The steamer was alongside in the Huskisson
Dock with 1,000 tons of munitions in her holds; it was said afterwards, that an anti aircraft
barrage balloon had caught fire in an air raid, crashed onto the ship, and as the picture below
shows she blew the SS Malakand and the surrounding dock installations to smithereens.
The Huskisson Dock is pictured below after the devastating explosion.

158
The troopship Nea Hellas. In order for him to make up for some of his lost apprenticeship time,
Captain Bone employed Graeme Cubbin as a watch keeper when the ship was homeward bound.

A pre-war photo of the Norwegian Teddy at anchor in the River Mersey.

159
Above: HMS Argus was one of the many light aircraft carriers of WW2 that was converted from
fast merchant ships such as banana boats.
They were given the appellation of Woolworth Carriers. but filled a most important role.
HMS Argus was part Nea Hellass escort.

Above: HMS Furious which accompanied HMS Argus, had originally been a battle cruiser.
Laid down During WW1, she was the only British warship ever, to mount 18 inch guns. They
were found to be unsuitable and were removed after trials.

160
Top: The light cruiser HMS Ceres. She took the British prisoners from Merca to Mombasa.

Bottom: The Norwegian Tamesis was a ship A tlantis impersonated on more than one occasion.

161
The SS A utomedon above and Troilus below both had a service speed of over 14 knots; but when
challenged by Atlantis, the Troilus increased speed to her absolute maximum and soon left the
forced draught diesel engined Atlantis in her wake. Indeed, the tall funnels of the Blue Funnel
ships were not built for style or appearance; but their extra height created a tremendous natural
draught, which in turn helped her coal fired triple expansion engines to a few extra knots.

162
Top - The Sunderland built
SS Montana of 1917

Centre - But 24 years

later when she was the
Norwegian Ketty Brovig,
she was scuttled rather
than be captured by
HMNZS Leander.

With a charge in her en-

gine room the 24 year old
ship goes down by the
stern.

Bottom - In the
belief that the
Coburg was a
heavily armed
AMC,
HMAS Canberra
shelled and sunk
her from nine miles
away

163
HMNZS Leander

HMAS Canberra

164
 Ketty Brovig

In the afternoon watch of 2 February with Atlantis disguised as the Norwegian Tamesis,
a distant ship heading South was spotted in the haze in 04.30 S and 50.30 E. Kapitan
Rogge decided to track her from a distance in order to make an identification after dark,
and then follow up with a possible attack. Coming up from astern at her best speed of
14 knots during the night watch, Atlantis approached and overhauled her much slower
victim. When she came abeam of what was a tanker, a salvo was fired across her bows;
while at the same time she was illuminated by searchlight. Of the three warning shots
fired, one 5.9 shell hit the funnel casing and went through bursting a steam pipe. The
noise from the escaping steam was a deafening roar. Simultaneously a banner that was
lit up and hung over the side of A tlantis read - Stop - Do not use your wireless. The
unarmed tanker was a Norwegian named Ketty Brovig, registered at Farsund and under
the command of Captain Erling Moller. No radio signals had been transmitted and the
tanker surrendered without any trouble. The ships company consisted of 11
Norwegians and 32 Chinese. That was the first un-armed ship A tlantis had encountered.
The 7,031 GRT Ketty Brovig had loaded at Bahrain, and sailed on 21 January towards
Lourenco Marques with 6,300 tons of fuel oil and 4,100 tons of diesel. It was an
absolutely first class catch for Kapitan Rogge, indeed, he now had much needed
supplies for the German ships in the area whether they were steam or diesel.
The Ketty Brovigs deck lights were turned on, and to say that her crew were in a state
of panic would be an understatement. The Chinese contingent who thought they were
about to be machine gunned rushed to the life-boats; the radial davits were swung out
and an attempt was made to lower the boats. By that time the ship had stopped, but in
the panic of the situation the forrard falls of number four boat were let go and allowed to
run right through the three fold blocks before the after falls had even been manned.
The result being that the boat was left upended head down in the water and held up by
the after radial davit. As the boat had nosedived into the water its occupants fell out and
were swimming around screaming for help. Almost the same thing happened to number
three boat on the other side. In the pandemonium the terrified and panic stricken

165
Chinese were throwing their bags and other possessions into the lob-sided boat. But as it
came down all askew it overturned. A number of them jumped into the water, climbed
onto the upturned boat, and later decided to get back aboard their low free-boarded ship.
When shed been built at Sunderland as the Montana in 1917, the Ketty Brovigs top
speed then - in good weather - was just ten knots; and now 24 years later when she was
at the end of her tether, the triple expansion steam engine which drove her was
seemingly failing fast.

Crew List of Ketty Brovig - Supplied by the Norwegian Archives

Captain, Erling Moller, First Mate, Martin Ramsland, Second Mate Jens Egulund
Arnes, Third Mate Olaf Knudsen Chief Engineer, Abraham Abrahamsen Second
Engineer Alfred Larsen, Third Engineer Daniel Nedrebo Fourth Engineer
Gudmund Listeid Pump man, Gudmund Harlof Sakiarssen Chief Steward, Jon
Tonnesen.
Well away from land in the Indian Ocean on 4 March 1941, the tanker Ketty Brovig was
alongside the supply ship Coburg while being supplied with stores. But in the broad
daylight both ships were spotted by the Walrus seaplane from the Australian heavy
cruiser Canberra - Captain Francombe. The two ships separated with one going North
and the other South. The Walrus bombed the Ketty Brovig, while the HMAS Canberra
in thinking her prey was a heavily armed raider, shelled the Coburg from the safe
distance of ten miles. Severely damaged the Coburg scuttled. Meanwhile, the bombs
from the Walrus damaged the Ketty Brovig and she too scuttled, but while she was
going down by the stern, and with the crew having abandoned ship, the Walrus put
down in the water close to the sinking ship. The seaplanes observer dived in and
boarded the sinking ship, went up to the bridge and managed to retrieve all the latest
signal codes. On the information received from the Walrus, Captain Francombe of
HMAS Canberra had thought that the Coburg was a raider with six 5.9 guns, so he had
kept well clear of his adversary. He was, however, later censured for using up over 200
expensive 8 inch shells on a virtually unarmed ship.

166
 Admiral Scheer

Kapitan Rogge advised SKL that he presently held two captured ships. He then
suggested that he send Speybank from Saya de Mahala Bank to Bordeaux with her
valuable cargo; also, because Speybank had so many look alike sister ships, the motor
ship should be fitted out as an auxiliary minelayer. He further advised that Ketty Brovig
with her abundance of both fuel oil and diesel should be used as a floating oil depot
ship. The tanker could then be used to replenish the bunkers of the heavy cruiser
Admiral Scheer, and any others that wanted to take their fill. However, he was ordered
to make a rendezvous with Ketty Brovig, the supply ship Tannenfels and the Italian
submarine Perla, the latter two which were running low on diesel. He was further
ordered to meet up with the A dmiral Scheer and supply her with diesel from his own
bunkers, and not from Ketty Brovig, whose cargo had not been tested to the required
standards and may be inferior.
On 10 February 1941 the Tannenfels met up with A tlantis, she looked much the worse
for wear after having been bottled up in Somaliland for so many months. After having
taken passage on the Tannenfels, Leutenant Dehnel and his prize crew whod taken the
SS Durmitor to Somaliland were returned to Atlantis. Rogge then took the opportunity
to transfer his new arrival prisoners to Tannenfels, and ordered Fehler and his
demolition party to return to A tlantis, while Leutenant Emil Dehnel took his place
aboard Ketty Brovig with his own prize crew; plus the Norwegians and Chinese who
had been retained on board. However, during Kapitan Rogges conversation with Lt.
Dehnel, he learned with no surprise, that conditions in Kismayu, Somaliland, under the
Italians were absolutely atrocious. There was no order, discipline or composure of any
kind anywhere, while every obstacle possible had been placed in front of the Germans
by the Italians; as a result Dehnel and his prize crew ended up taking refuge on the
moored Tannenfels. Moreover, he went on, there were about 15 ships at Kismayu,
theyd been interned at the outbreak of war, but because Italy had gone onto the side of
Germany, those ships could all be pressed into service and used as auxiliary ships, and

167
especially a fast banana boat which was laid up without a crew. He also told of a British
- South African expeditionary force which had arrived, and the shelling of the area by
British cruisers.
On 12 February 1941, Atlantis proceeded to a predetermined point to refuel A dmiral
Scheer, with her went the Ketty Brovig, Speybank and Tannenfels. Those four ships had
recently undertaken a major redistribution of their stores and all four were equally
balanced. The rendezvous with the Scheer was of course a top secret manoevoeur, and
that meeting was carried out on a strict need to know basis. Therefore, except for a
small number of men on A tlantis who needed to know, the rest of her crew and her
consorts were quite unaware that a meeting was to take place with the heavy cruiser.
Two days later on 14 February, amidst heavy seas, high winds and fleeting ragged
nimbus clouds, the excited and obviously fearful lookouts of A tlantis reported a large
warship in sight. Their relief can only be imagined when they discovered it was one of
their own, and not one of those much dreaded Allied cruisers. Indeed, it was the
incumbent A dmiral Scheer, resplendent with her imposing pocket battleship upper
works, a gunnery control tower, wide range finders and massive eleven inch gun turrets.
The weather was quite heavy however, and with the big seas breaking over the Scheers
foredeck, a proposed refuelling from abeam was out of the question.
Ketty Brovig had experienced great difficulty in managing the heavy seas on her way to
the point of rendezvous, and because of her breakdowns and slow speed, she was left
behind like a lame dog, but she was given a position for joining up with the other three
ships as soon as possible. Indeed when shed been built at Sunderland as the Montana in
1917, that tankers top speed then - in good weather - was just ten knots; and now 24
years later when she was at the end of her tether, the triple expansion steam engine
which drove her was seemingly failing fast.
Meanwhile on board A dmiral Scheer, where the same protocol of a need to know
basis was also being implemented, those in the crows nest who saw the approaching
three ships Atlantis, Speybank and Tannenfels in the grey and heavy weather, must have
thought theyd stumbled on a British convoy and they were in for a field day. But they
soon found out the reality of the situation, and such rich pickings were not to be.
In the meantime, Chief Engineer Kielhorn of A tlantis had run a series of tests on the
diesel oil from Ketty Brovig and found it to be of excellent quality. As a result of his

168
Above - HMS Glasgow. No match for the Admiral Scheer. But in thinking that a much larger
RN force was near at hand, Glasgows presence caused the heavy cruiser to leave the area.

Sister ship to Atlantis and Pinguin - the motor ship Tannenfels pictured below would most
certainly have been a surface raider as well. But shed been trapped in Mogadishu from the
beginning of hostilities in September 1939. Left almost crewless at her moorings for over a year,
the ship was neglected to such an extent that barnacles and seaweed were abundant on her hull.

169
Above: Admiral Scheer, a heavy cruiser with six 11 inch guns. Except for HM ships Hood, Re-
nown and Repulse, she had the ability to outrun any RN ship with heavier armament, and outgun
anything fast enough to catch her. Due to heavy armouring her maximum speed was 26 knots.

Below: Admiral Graf Spee was a sister ship to Admiral Scheer and Deutschland , the latter which
was later renamed Lutzow. Graf Spee scuttled at the Battle of the River Plate in December 1939.
On the day of her engagement with three British cruisers, her eye in the sky Arado seaplanes
were broken down due to cracked cylinder heads with no spares.

170
KMS Deutschland was the first of three heavy cruisers (better known to as Pocket Battleships)
that was completed in April 1933, her sister ships being Admiral Graf Spee and Admiral Scheer.
Those three ships were the first ever to be constructed all welded. For fear of being sunk under
her proud name of Deutschland, after Graf Spees demise, she was renamed as Lutzow in 1940.
Her career was most unspectacular by only accounting for three allied merchant ships. Sunk in
the Kaiserfahrt in April 1945 by the RAF, she was raised by the Russians and used for target
practice.

Below - the tanker Ketty Brovig on the right, supplies Atlantis with diesel in a stern RAS.
(Refuelling At Sea) In the far distance is the Tannenfels. Note - the wind sail ventilator over the
tankers fidley, photo taken from Doggerbank (ex Speybank. )

171
After the heavy cruiser Admiral Scheer had captured the Houlder Brothers ship Duquesa in
December 1940, the British reefer was found to have vast quantities of food in her freezers. She
was then used as a store ship for the German ships in the South Atlantic. After having been
stripped bare by numerous German ships, she was sunk by Pinguin in Feb. 1941.

Formerly the Kandenfels of the DDG Hansa Line, Pinguin was a sister to Atlantis.

172
Above -After Duquesa had been stripped of her cargo and other equipment, She was sunk by Pinguin in
the South Atlantic in February 1941. Pinguin is disguised here as the Greek ship Kassos.
Photo taken from a U-Boat approaching for supplies

Below - HMS Cornwall sank the Pinguin

173
Above - Kapitan zur see Theodore Kranke of the heavy cruiser A dmiral Scheer.

Below - Kapitan zur see Bernhard Rogge furthest away, with his senior officers.

174
findings, the orders from SKL regarding A tlantis refuelling A dmiral Scheer were
ignored. Ketty Brovig then arrived at the scene after a struggle 18 hours later.
When Refuelling At Sea takes place, in good weather, it is known as doing a RAS; it
is ideal for both the supply tanker and the warship to steam alongside each other 150
feet apart at a speed of between 10 and 15 knots. In heavy weather this is hardly
possible because of yawing, ie, when both ships may either collide with each other, or
else drift apart too far and carry away the fuel line. In such cases of heavy weather a
stern RAS has to be carried out, where the receiving ship follows at a speed of seven to
ten knots. Therefore, because of the heavy seas and Ketty Brovigs slow speed, a stern
RAS to A dmiral Scheer became both appropriate and necessary.
When the fuel hose line was connected in the RAS, 1,200 tons of diesel were pumped
into the bunker tanks of A dmiral Scheer to top her up. Amidst the heavy weather when
the RAS was taking place, Scheer and Atlantis were at all times at action stations, while
much needed stores were transferred from the four ships to the heavy cruiser; first with
jack stays, which didnt materialise because of both ships yawing, and finally by boats.
While all that was going on, Kapitan zur See Theodore Krancke of A dmiral Scheer -
invited Kapitan zur See Bernhard Rogge of A tlantis - to come aboard his pocket
battleship for a meeting. If and when the sea went down! Rogge accepted the invitation,
and when the sea did go down to more acceptable levels, he brought his adjutant Ulrich
Mohr along with him. The crossing by launch was uncomfortable to say the least, but
the meeting was held in great celebration. Stories of both captains exploits were
exchanged and plans for the future were made. One of them being that on their breaking
off, Atlantis should cover the area South of the Seychelles for a week and meet up again
with Scheer on 25 February.
The crew of Atlantis hadnt tasted an egg for over three months; indeed, theyd ate
nothing but the basics which in the main consisted of black bread and ersatz coffee; that
famished crew had probably forgotten what an egg tasted like. But from the spoils of the
Houlder Brothers refrigerated ship SS Duquesa, captured by A dmiral Scheer on 18
December 1940, there was presently an abundance of eggs on board the heavy cruiser.
As a consequence 150,000 eggs were sent over to Atlantis. On breaking off Tannenfels
sailed to the Saya de Mahala Bank with A tlantiss prisoners; (that Bank is roughly
between Mauritius and the Seychelles.) Command of the Tannenfels then went to

175
Leutenant Paul Scheidewind who had previously been the first mate on the ship before
the war, while Leutenant Breuers returned to A tlantis. One of Kapitan Rogges growing
problems was his crew was diminishing due to him supplying prize crews. So with the
emergence of First Mate Paul Scheidewind, who with his Tannenfels crew could make
up a crew for their own ship, he would still be one officer down. That was because Paul
Schneidewind was a merchant seaman and not one of the Kriegsmarine breed -and there
was a difference!
Indeed, whereas First Mate Scheidewind was undoubtedly well suited to his work as 1st
mate on the Tannenfels, things were very different on her sister ship Goldenfels, (which
was of course A tlantis.) There were now many anomalies between the ships and their
crews with one being their manning. In peace time Goldenfels would have had a crew of
about 40, but as a Kriegsmarine ship it had been increased nine fold to 361.That was due
to the type of seamen required. Many specialists such as Communications or radio
operators, gunners, torpedo men, mine specialists, medics as well as their many spares,
just in case some were killed.
It may be pointed out that the general duties of the merchant seamen of Tannenfels,
consisted of deck work; cargo hatch work, raising and lowering derricks, working
winches, maintenance of deck gear, painting, cleaning, steering the ship, and much,
much more.
Tannenfels was later despatched to Bordeaux where she arrived on 12 May 1941 with
the prisoners from Atlantis. Leutenant Dehnel who was then appointed as captain of
Ketty Brovig and was sent to Saya de Malha with a prize crew of 12, and the captured
Norwegian crew members. His orders were to join up with the 8,000 GRT Nord
Deutche Lloyd Line supply ship Cobourg. But by that time the Allies had broken the
German signal codes, and on Ketty Brovigs arrival at the given point on 4 March
1941, HMAS Canberra and HMNZS Leander were awaiting their arrival. Needless to
say both German ships were sunk, Coburg by shell fire from nine miles away, while
Ketty Brovig opened the sea cocks in the engine room and scuttled. Those two ships
crews were rescued by the cruisers.
Kapitan Rogge kept his appointment with the Italian submarine Perla when both ships
met. The oil reserves, food and other supplies on the submarine were extremely low,
while the morale of her crew was even lower. Most reluctantly Kapitan Rogge supplied

176
the much needed commodities to the Italian, but later remarked that it was nothing more than a
waste of time and valuable war commodities. Indeed the condition of the Perla and her crew
could only be described as parlous. Nevertheless he was under orders, so the required food, water
and fuel from A tlantis was transferred before another rendezvous with her was made. Indeed, the
submarines captain was most brazen in his demands, but Rogge was under orders to supply him
with his needs.
But the rendezvous with Admiral Scheer had to be called off; The cruiser HMS Glasgow which
was in the area had been transmitting, and her signals were so strong that she couldnt be far
away. Indeed, Scheers radio operator had to temporarily remove his head set because the
transmissions were so loud. Suspecting that other units of the Royal Navy were nearby, the battle
cruiser departed at speed.
It was by that time 12 months since Atlantis had left Germany, and 18 months since shed been
out of the water in dry-dock - the barnacles, fronds of seaweed and other under hull growth were
in the thoughts of Kapitan Rogge, because as well as the damage to the underwater hull that hed
suffered at Kerguelen, the ever growing undergrowth did nothing to enhance his ships speed. For
the following month while patrolling the
area between the Seychelles and Mauritius A tlantis drew a blank; just three ships that
were neutral, and all in the scorching hot Indian Ocean weather. His crew were well and truly
suffering through it all, and he knew morale was not what it should be.
But as well as good and bad people in this world; there are also good and bad captains. Kapitan
Rogge was a good captain, so good in fact, that hed personally handpicked his crew. He had
rejected more than half of the 214 men assigned to him when the ship was commissioned; he
wanted men who could stand the utmost of strain, and to a large extent he got those men, but after
16 months at sea he knew they were drained and he no doubt felt for them. SKL ordered Rogge
to the South Atlantic where she was to meet up with the supply ship Alsterufer for some much
needed fresh fruit, vegetables and other victuals. He was also to rendezvous with the U boat
supply tanker Nordmark, in order to pick up Navigating Officer Paul Kamenz, who by that time
had fulfilled his duty of delivering A utomedons top secret papers to Berlin.
But thirdly and most importantly for Kapitan Rogge, there would be no fresh food for his ship. It
so happened that a gigantic bureaucratic blunder had been made by the German Naval Attach in
Santos, Brazil. The result of it all being, that instead of Dresden delivering the fresh food to
Atlantis, the Attach had changed things around. In the first instance the food had been loaded on
board Dresden, but then on the orders of the Attach it was taken off again and loaded on to the
Babitonga. Most unfortunately that ship had no freezers or refrigerators, and when the much
177
needed victuals arrived at A tlantis most of it had been spoilt by the excessive temperatures.
Kapitan Rogge was absolutely livid. His crew had suffered long and hard in the past with poor
food, and now their sufferings were to be prolonged indefinitely. He demanded from his SKL
superiors in Germany, that those officials in Santos who were responsible for such a catastrophic
error, should be heavily punished and relieved of their duties. Kapitan Walter Jager of the
Dresden explained to his counterpart and close friend Bernhard Rogge, that he had indeed
followed his instructions of loading the fresh food. That food included sides of beef and other
perishables for A tlantis, but he was then told by the Attach in Santos to unload it all and place it
on the Babitonga which would deliver the stores to A tlantis instead. Jager tried his best to explain
to the Attach that Babitonga had no freezers or refrigerators to store the food, that the
temperature in the hold would be 105 degrees Fahrenheit, and by the time it got to A tlantis it
would all be ruined. But the Attach told Kapitan Jager, in no uncertain terms, that he had to
obey his orders. But that error of administration and all the apologies in the world had done
nothing for the already famished and worn out crew of A tlantis. Because as they were all
expecting some decent food for a change, and then on discovering the shabby delivery, their
misery and frustration was exacerbated in no small manner. However, Kapitan Jager did the best
he could for his long time friend by giving him as much of Dresdens victuals as he could. But his
gift was no more than a few sacks of potatoes, lubricating oil and timber.
In the meantime two experienced petty officers who had served on board the A dmiral Graf Spee
during her demise at the River Plate, were transferred from Dresden to A tlantis. Those two men
had been away from Germany without a break since Graf Spee had sailed from Wilhelmshaven in
August 1939, and it was at their own request that they be drafted to A tlantis, rather than stay
aboard the homeward bound Dresden.

178
 Captain Graeme Cubbin of T & J Harrison Lines.
In recognition for his 46 years service at sea, and his contribution towards maritime
history in keeping an Atlantis diary, the following pages show the 17 ships that Captain
Graeme Cubbin served on between 1940 and 1986. Photo taken on MV Statesman.

179
After being sunk on the SS Scientist, and then after his five and a half months ordeal of
incarceration on Atlantis, the next ship of Cadet Cubbin was the SS Barrister pictured above, a
ship on which he continued his apprentice studies from 07- 08 - 41, until 4 -1-43. But when she
was steaming light ship on passage Algiers to the Clyde, the SS Barrister was wrecked in the fog
on 04-01-43 off Inishshark Island, County Galway. All hands survived.

Next came the SS Governor on which he stayed for five months. SS Governor was built by
Hendersons of Glasgow in 1918 and served the company until 1950.

180
1938 - SS Scientist - 1940
Liverpool

181
The steamer Director was built by DW Henderson of Glasgow in 1926. Graeme Cubbin was first
acting - and then 3rd mate on this ship between 12-07-43 until 31-03-44. But on the following
voyage after he had left the ship, she was torpedoed and sunk on 15 July 1944.

3rd Mate Graeme Cubbin signed on Strategist on 3-08-1944 but left as 2nd mate on 28-09-1947.

182
The 1947 built SS Craftsman. Graeme Cubbin was 2nd Mate on this ship which stayed in the
company until 1967.

The Liberty Ships Successor and Speaker were the next two ships Graeme Cubin served on as
2nd mate between May 1950 and April 1952. On 3 Nov.55 he was 1st mate on the Liberty Ship
SS Scholar until 16-09-56 and again as 1st mate on the same ship from 22-10-63 to 07-04-64.

183
From 26-04-52 until 11-10-54, Graeme Cubbin was the chief officer of the SS Inventor.

His next ship for one voyage to the Spanish Main and the USA, was the SS Novelist, a ship on
which he served as chief officer from 12-12-54 until 08-01-55.

184
Above - From 10-01-55 until 25-10-55, Graeme Cubbin served as the chief officer on the MV
Interpreter. But ten years later he returned as her master from 09-04-65 until 18-07-66.

Below - SS Forester was another ship on which Graeme Cubbin served. Firstly as her chief of-
ficer from 24-11-58 until 26-04-60, and later as her master from 29-907-66 until 26-06-67.

185
As her chief officer, Graeme Cubbin served on the MV Author from 27 04 60 until 5-10-63

The SS Linguist became Graeme Cubbins first command on 21 August 1964

186
Another command for
Captain Cubbin was
a run up the
Manchester Ship
Canal on the MV
Governor; although
the author of this
book served on the
same ship, it was at a
different time to
Captain Cubbin.

Captain Cubbin was master

of MV Barrister for a single
voyage from 15-07-67 until
31-01-69.

The 1964 Swedish built MV Statesman became the command of Captain Cubbin between
15-8-69 and 04-02-71. Statesman was sold to the Chinese in 1977.

187
The 1964 Swedish built MV Statesman became the command of Captain Cubbin between
15-8-69 and 04-02-71. Statesman was sold to the Chinese in 1977.

The heavy lift ship MV Tactician was the last of Captain Cubbins ships. He joined her on
19-05-1972 and left on 15-09-72.
He then became the Assistant Marine Superintendent for the company before taking his retire-
ment on 1 April 1986 after over 46 years service for T&J Harrison Lines.
During his retirement he wrote a 1,700 page manuscript on the Harrison Line from its earliest
beginnings right up to the day the company ceased to exist.

188
 SS Zamzam

Atlantis and Dresden parted company at the start of the middle watch on 17 April 1941.
Dresdens captain who was homeward bound was told by Kapitan Rogge to hang
around and await the arrival of Kormoran; if that ship had any prisoners he could take
them to Germany or France with him. A tlantis headed East, but just an hour after
leaving Dresden, and whilst still in the same middle watch, a four masted ship was
sighted. She was on a South Easterly course and silhouetted against the moonlight.
Kapitan Rogge needed no list of ship profiles to identify the ship steaming without
lights. She was British, and one that was owned by the Bibby Line of Liverpool. - Or so
he thought!
Indeed, when Kapitan Rogge had represented Germany in 1937 at the Coronation of
King George V1, hed taken part in some yacht races at Dartmouth. Due to the
continuing recession there were a number of laid up ships in the River Dart, and one of
them in particular caught his eye. Elegantly built she was one of the older type, and one
that really stood out from the rest. On questioning his guide, he was informed that the
four masted ship he so admired, was one of the Leicestershire Class of passenger ships
owned by the Bibby Line of Liverpool; she was easily identifiable by her straight
steamer stem, old fashioned sailing ship counter stern, four beautifully raked masts and
a single raked funnel to match. His guide told him that during the Great War those
Bibby Line passenger ships had been used as troopers, and due to the huge movements
of army personnel abroad at present, they were still being used as troop ships and
carriers of military equipment.
Kapitan Rogge needed no second telling, that the ship steaming without lights was the
same 9,350 GRT ship hed seen in 1937. She was five miles away and steaming at about
12 knots. By now she would be a British trooper he thought, and one that would be
heavily armed. But what he didnt know, was that the ship he was examining through
his binoculars was one of five identical sister ships; those steamers were, Leicestershire,
Gloucestershire, Oxfordshire, Lancashire and Yorkshire. Coming off the stocks in that
order, theyd all been built by Harland & Wolff at Belfast between 1909 and 1920.
189
What Rogge was also unaware of, was the fact that the ship hed seen at Dartmouth
four years previously, could not possibly be the one he was presently looking at.
Indeed, the ship on his port side had once been the Leicestershire, the first of the class of
five, and one that had been renamed British Exhibitor in 1930. On 28 September 1933
during the depression, she was sold to an Egyptian company, which in turn sold her to
the Transport and Navigation Company of Cairo. Therefore, the ship that Kapitan Rogge
was about to sink - without warning - was a neutral which at the time went by her new
name of Zamzam - the name of a holy well in Mecca. Her new role in life was not as a
trooper - but that of an Egyptian pilgrim ship.
After having put into Baltimore in March 1941to load cargo and embark 150
missionaries including clerics and preachers of 20 different religious sects, there were
also 24 ambulance drivers. Before boarding the Zamzam, the huge contingent of
religious persuasions, plus passengers, gathered on the jetty and recited prayers and
hymns, while the mirthful ambulance drivers did their best to drown out their singing
with their own type of bar-room songs. While at he same time they made reference to
those religious people as being bible punchers and sky pilots. Moving to New York
for more cargo the 32 year old Zamzam sailed on 21 March for Recife (Pernambuco)
Brazil where more cargo, as well as two passengers were embarked. On 9 April the SS
Zamzam under the command of Scotsman Captain Charles Gray-Smith, sailed towards
Cape Town en route to Alexandria via the Suez Canal. With Kapitan Rogge looking
through his binoculars from the wing of the bridge, A tlantis followed in the ex Bibby
Liners wake; Rogge was under the impression that she was zig-zagging, and that only
increased his suspicions that the ship ahead was a troopship. It was just turning daylight
and by that time hed been tracking the old passenger ship for two hours. Rogge
increased speed and came up on his intended victims port side.
When it came to 0545 hours, A tlantis opened fire without warning at a range of five
miles. The weather was fine with hardly a breeze, and with no wind deflection the target
was hard to miss from such a close range. However, the first salvo did miss by going
over, but the range had been found and the second salvo found its target. Within minutes
the ship was ablaze, the radio shack had been reduced to a mass of twisted steel, and
panic reigned upon the decks, while a number of life boats on the port side had been
reduced to matchwood. The deck lights of Zamzam were turned on, and scores of

190
day with all their embroideries and exaggerations. Indeed, those past masters of the
media in the US made the most of the incident like only they can.
In those writings, Kapitan Rogge was termed as being a modern day pirate, stealing
food, cargo and mail from unarmed neutral ships, and then murdering ships crews like a
butcher. There were a number of photographs, but to the Allies, the most important one
that Scherman had taken, was the one of the A tlantis disguised as the Temesis, an
extremely important piece of graphical information for the Allies indeed. The RN and
the RAF were quickly furnished with the ships different profile as well as her new
operating area. It has been said and written, that the photographs taken by David
Scherman helped leading to the final demise of Atlantis.
The Zamzam was slowly sinking, and that gave the A tlantis sailors time to rescue as
many people as they could from both the decks and from the water; But then in their
usual piratical fashion, with so many mouths to feed, they stripped bare the ships
freezers, fridges, store-rooms, pantries, paint locker and even the bar. Indeed, they
loaded everything they could from the sinking steamer into their boats. All of which was
carefully recorded on camera and the memories of the two American journalists.
To hasten her demise Leutenant Fehler and his demolition party placed three charges on
the slowly sinking ships waterline. From the time the first shell struck Zamzam at 0545
hours, it took five hours for the 32 year old ship to finally founder. But during that time,
and to appease the survivors, as much baggage and personal belongings as possible was
salvaged. It wasnt the first time that Kapitan Rogge had fired on a ship without
warning, and he knew hed made a huge mistake by doing so on the latter occasion. The
first was the SS King City, he thought she was an AMC but it wasnt - and now this, the
Zamzam, a ship he thought was a trooper, - but also wasnt. His errors on those two
occasions had cost 30 lives.
The only thing Rogge could do, would be to gather as much evidence as he could to
justify his actions, the first of which had been prompted by the ships British captain
having flouted the Rules of War in steaming without lights. Kapitan Rogge invited a
number of leading representatives from the sunken ship into his cabin. They included
Murphy and Scherman. In his address Kapitan Rogge apologised for the sinking but
claimed that he was following the Rules of War; that Zamzam was steaming without

191
Built at Belfast in 1909, The Bibby Liner SS Leicestershire pictured in 1931 as a cruise liner.
She later became the Egyptian pilgrim ship Zamzam.

Identical to Leicestershire was the Oxfordshire, she served as a hospital ship during WW2.

192
people could be seen making for what was left of the boats on the starboard side.
In all 55 shells of 5.9 calibre had been fired at the mistakenly identified troopship, there
were only nine direct hits but 24 people had been killed in the bombardment. Zamzam
stopped while what was left of her boats were swung out and lowered. But instead of
attending to the passengers, which included 73 women and 35 children, the 127 sailors,
firemen and stewards, consisting mainly of Egyptians, with a few Sudanese, Turks and
Greeks panicked, and to save their own skins they saw to themselves first.
The passenger list included 138 Americans, 26 Canadians, 25 Britons 5 South Africans
4 Belgians, 2 Greeks, and 1 Italian. The Scottish captain and his chief engineer were the
only two in the ships company who were British.
Kapitan Rogge had made an enormous mistake in attacking the Zamzam - and he must
have known it when he found out that the ship hed attacked was sailing under the
Egyptian flag. The repercussions and ramifications would be intense, and his wilful
attack against an unarmed neutral ship, with so many passengers on board, without
warning, would attract world wide condemnation. - And especially with so many
Americans on board! The crew of the stricken ship did nothing to enhance their
reputation in abiding by that well renowned phrase from HMS Birkenhead of Women
and Children First. Indeed, they adopted another for a sinking ship Every Man for
Himself. Kapitan Bernhard Rogge who was by that time close up, was astounded and
horrified as he watched the cowardly crew leaving the ships passengers to their own
devices. They manned the boats and pulled away, seemingly uncaring and quite
oblivious as to whether there were any passengers in the boats or not. In fact, most of
them were still on the burning decks; they didnt know how to lower the last of the boats
or throw the rafts over!
Some of the crew swam over towards A tlantis which by that time was close by. Guest
Warps for Zam Zam's life-boats had been laid along the raiders side from the focsle to
the midship section;. But one member of the crew in particular, whose thoughts must
have been Stuff you Jack, Im inboard (or words to that effect - as it were) - dived
from a lifeboat, swam over to A tlantis, hauled himself up the guest warp, over the rail
and up onto the deck. With a huge smile of victory on his face he held his arms aloft in
a show of victory; he had escaped the burning ship and was probably looking for
accolades and glorification. But Kapitan Rogge was so infuriated and enraged at his

193
selfish and cowardly actions, that he called out for someone to bring him his pistol in
order to deal with the grinning recalcitrant Zamzam survivor; but whether anybody
handed him his pistol or whether he did anything thereafter is unknown. However, the
irate Kapitan Rogge ordered his sailors to shake the cowardly crew who had left the
passengers to their fate, and shake them off the guest warps and back into the water, and
then await their turn to board A tlantis.
Amongst the Zamzam passengers were Charles Murphy, editor of the magazine
Fortune. Mr Murphy was also a major contributor to both the Time magazine as well
as the Life magazine, and his colleague David Scherman who was a prominent
photographer. To join Zamzam those two men had flown down from New York to
Recife in order to save time at sea. Scherman was apprehended by one of the A tlantis
guards as he took photographs on the deck of the raider. The guard took the camera
from the American and handed it to an officer, but Kapitan Rogge who was present
gave the camera back to its owner. He could hardly halt the pictures being taken by Mr
Scherman, he was a neutral, an American, and if there was one country in the world that
Kapitan Rogge did not want to antagonise - it was the United States of America!
It so happened that when Mr Scherman was later taken to France on the Dresden, as a
survivor, most of the pictures hed taken were confiscated - but not all! Indeed, while he
was being transferred by boat from the sinking Zamzam to A tlantis, he had taken a roll
of photographs of his host ship and secreted it away; those photographs were to have a
devastating and most significant effect on both Atlantis and Germany at a later date.
The pictures of A tlantis portrayed her when she was still disguised as the Norwegian
Tamesis. But when Kapitan Rogge like a gentleman gave Scherman his camera back, as
they stood together on the raiders deck, both the ungrateful photographer and his
associate Murphy repaid his honesty and kindness by besmirching him as best they
could in their June 1941 magazine article.
Shortly afterwards the newspapers were full of the Zamzam sinking incident, while
Murphy and Scherman made huge editorial and photographic scoops. The incident
quickly prompted the re-surfacing of the RMS Lusitania story from the last war, when
so many neutral Americans had lost their lives to a German torpedo. This story on
Zamzam was on similar lines, except for the fact that there were even more Americans
on the neutral Egyptian ship than there had been on Lusitania. The media had a field

194
Above - Survivors from the stricken Zam Zam take to the boats.
Below - Atlantis as seen from the Zam Zam. Photos on this page by David Scherman

195
The photo above shows an overladen lifeboat in the foreground making its way towards Atlan-
tis as the SS Zamzam goes down on her portside;
the photo below is of Zam Zam taking the final plunge.

196
lights, she was zig sagging while claiming to be neutral and was in fact carrying a cargo
for an enemy of Germany - and was under orders from the British Admiralty! That
cargo consisted of 10,000 barrels of oil, radios, steel and 150 army trucks. At the end of
Kapitan Rogges explanation as to why the Zamzam had been sunk, Captain Gray-Smith
approached Kapitan Rogge and said his ship was not zig zagging. Rogge said it was! He
had seen it with his own eyes. Gray Smith replied with a frown saying it was quite
normal for his inexperienced helmsmen who couldnt even box the compass, didnt
know their quarter points to steer in such a way; moreover, he went on, there were four
or five slack spokes on the huge 48 inch wheel, and such steering cost him upwards of
50 miles a day. There was no answer from Rogge with regard to the seamanship
qualities of his crew; just a nod of agreement and a forlorn shake of his head.
On the following day Dresden arrived and took off Zam Zam's survivors. Those ships
were joined by the raider Kormoran, and the supply ship A lsterufer, the latter supplying
Atlantis with an abundance of food for her hungry crew; as well as a crated Arado
AR196 seaplane for Leutenant Bulla. Meanwhile SKL ordered Dresden to proceed to St
Jean de Luz to land the Zamzam survivors where she arrived on 20 May 1941.
On leaving the Dresden, Murphy and Scherman first went to Spain and then on to
Portugal; there they boarded a plane and in due course arrived back in the USA where
the LIFE magazine was first to get the full story.
Atlantis and Alsterufer remained in position until the supply tanker Nordmark 10,800
GRT arrived to top up their bunkers. Those three ships stopped and remained together
until 27 April. It was then that Rogge decided to venture into the West African area to
see what was on offer regarding Allied ships. Indeed, SKL had informed him that the
tanker route between Cape Town and Freetown was poorly defended by the Allies. Two
days later, Rogge who thought his luck in posing as the Tamesis might be running out,
thought of adopting a new name for his ship. Atlantis had been sailing as Tamesis for
four months; Rogges ship needed a change of appearance, so both he and Leutenant
Erich Kuhn, decided on an overnight change to the Dutch 9,246 GRT motor ship
Brastagi of the Ruys & Zonen Rotterdamsche Lloyd NV Line. Work began immediately
and as a result of working through the night, with pirated paint and brushes from many
different ships, Tamesis was no more, and on the following morning she became the MS
Brastagi of Rotterdam.

197
On 1 May 1941, the crated Arado seaplane delivered by A lsterufa to A tlantis, was
assembled in the tween deck of number two hold and made ready for its eye in the
sky service; it then took off with the previously out of work Leutenant Bulla at the
controls. During the first flight in his new toy, Bulla and his observer Bouchert saw a
steamer heading South and identified it as an Allied ship. Returning to A tlantis, and just
like a Pointer Dog wagging its tail, after sniffing out some game for its master, Bulla
wagged his wings to signify the fact that an Allied ship had been sighted. Atlantis
stopped - the seaplane was quickly loaded, and the raider was soon up to her best speed
to close the sighted ship. But she was unable to catch up with her Rogge was forced to
abandon the chase. However, Flight Leutenant Bulla was extremely pleased with his
new aircraft; he said it was both smaller, lighter and had more manoeuvrability than the
clumsy Heinkel; furthermore, it took up less space in the hold and was easier to load and
unload. On 4 May A tlantis once again met up for supplies; this was the same ship that
had no cold storage - the very ship which had caused Kapitan Rogge and his crew so
much despair and annoyance; Babitonga was at the time disguised as the Dutch Jaspara.
After the stores transfer the supply ship was despatched by Rogge to a code named area
where she was to await further instructions. On 7 May while still on the Freetown to
Cape sea lane, Atlantis apprehended the Vichy French steamer Lieutenant de la Tour,
but let her go after an inspection of her papers.
News then came of the sinking of A tlantiss sister ship Pinguin by HMS Cornwall on 8
May. There was heavy loss of life on Pinguin where over 400 of her crew and over 200
prisoners had been killed; Pinguin had tried to put up a fight but was no match for the
heavy cruiser. However, one shell from the raider did find its mark on the British
warship at a range of 8,000 yards, thus causing some damage that necessitated repairs
and a dry docking at Durban. One British sailor lost his life during the action which took
place in the area around the Seychelles - the very area where A tlantis had recently been
operating.
On 13 May A tlantis was in exactly the same Atlantic position where the Scientist had
been sunk a year and ten days previously. Maybe Rogge the Rogue was wondering what
had happened to the surviving members of her crew. From Leutenant Dehnel however,
he learned that theyd all been rescued by a joint British and South African force, and
were once again free to join other British ships. But what he didnt know, was the

198
German codes were being read by the British at Bletchley Park. Indeed, they had
captured the German trawler Krebs acting as a weather ship in December 1940,
removing the December signal codes, Bletchley Park were for a while able to read the
German signals. But shortly afterwards the Germans added another wheel to their
enigma transmitter which left the British once again unable to read their signals.
However, on 7 May 1941 another German weather ship named Munchen and then
Lohenburg were captured near Iceland, this valuable catch had all the latest codes of
the latest enigma machine settings, and those at Bletchley Park could once again read
the German signals. Then on 9 May, the U-110 was captured by HMS Bulldog in the
North Atlantic, complete with her Enigma machine, codes, ciphers, and the whole of
the submarines crew. It so happened that U-110 had been depth charged by HM ships
Aubretia, Broadway and Bulldog before being forced to the surface. Thinking his
damaged submarine was going to founder, Kapitanleutenant Fritz-Julius Lemp ordered
Abandon Ship. With 15 men having already been killed, the remaining 32 of her crew
were all picked up from the water. But because she was still afloat, a boarding party led
by Lieutenant David Balme from HMS Bulldog boarded the damaged U Boat. It later
emerged that although the submarine may have been damaged she was not in any
immediate danger of sinking. In the meantime, and not even knowing what is was,
Lieutenant Balme and his party removed her Enigma machine, ciphers and all the
relative codes. At first it was decided to tow the U-110 to the UK and a tow line was set
up; but later in the day, the Admiralty made a signal stating that to conserve secrecy, the
U-Boat should be allowed to sink, or be sunk on, 10 May 1941.
Each and everyone of those captured submariners were incarcerated in the strictest
confinement; not to stop them going back to sea again, but to let the Germans think their
U-110 had been lost with all hands - together with her Enigma machine! The British
code breakers at Bletchley Park were able to read all Axis signals, and from that point
on were able to deduce U-Boats deployment to such an extent that merchant ship
convoys could keep clear of the German Wolf Packs.
Then in December 1942 the U-559 was attacked by HMS Petard near Alexandria. As
the U-Boat was foundering she was boarded by a party from the destroyer and her
enigma codes removed. But two men from the boarding party lost their lives when the
badly damaged, U-559 broke up and went under.

199
 The Sinking of SS Trafalgar

On 24 May 1941, the 1924 built SS Trafalgar of 4,530 GRT belonging to the Glen Line
(Scottish Navigation Company of Glasgow) was steaming at 10 knots from the UK
towards Alexandria via Cape Town. Her cargo consisted of 4,500 tons of coal, some
general in the tween decks, and two crated aircraft as deck cargo. She was spotted by
the seaplane of Atlantis in the afternoon and stalked until darkness fell. At the
appropriate time in the night watch, the raider came up from astern and ordered
Trafalgar to stop and not to use her wireless.
The request was not carried out and A tlantis opened fire. The funnel was shot away
completely and went over the side, the mainmast came down, the lifeboats were
splintered and the deck cargo of crated planes caught fire. It all happened so quickly that
the ship began to sink. With the lifeboats having been reduced to matchwood, the crew
had to take to the water.
Thanks to the red lights attached to their life jackets, 33 men were picked up by the
raiders launch in the darkness. But the ship was still burning and provided a beacon to
attract Allied warships, so two torpedoes were fired from the raiders starboard tubes at
Trafalgar to hasten her departure to the bottom, but they malfunctioned and missed
their target. The raider then went around the burning ship and fired a further two
torpedoes from her port tubes. That resulted in one hit being registered while the other
went wide; the latter coming around Trafalgars stern could have hit Atlantis as it veered
off course and came back toward the raider, but she was making good way and was able
to steer clear of it. There were 12 members of Trafalgars crew that were un-accounted
for who were either killed in the action, drowned, or went down with the ship.
Earlier in the same day of 24 May 1941, news came through that HMS Hood had been
sunk by the battleship Bismarck. Just three survivors from a crew of 1,418 were picked
up by the destroyer HMS Electra. But whereas Goebels in Berlin made the most of it
with his propaganda, the news was not greeted with the same enthusiasm on A tlantis,
because those men knew, that the British would stop at nothing to avenge the loss of the
200
pride of their fleet, even if she was old and obsolete. Indeed, just three days later on 27 May, the
honours were reversed when the British Home Fleet led by the battleships HMS King George V
and HMS Rodney battered the Bismarck to a standstill; it was the cruiser HMS Dorsetshire which
finished the German battleship off with torpedoes. In all there were 28 British ships which played
some part or other in the German battleships demise; from a crew of 2,200 there were just 115
survivors from Bismarck.
Atlantis then made a rendezvous with her supply ship Babitonga on 30 May 1941 and took stores
and armaments before transferring her prisoners. Babitonga in turn transferred the prisoners to the
supply tanker Esso Hamburg which was homeward bound. The raider was then instructed by SKL
to patrol the area between Freetown, Rio and Cape Town. It was during that time that the raider
broke the record set by W olf during the 1914 -18 war, by serving 445 days at sea. The month of
June saw an increasing number of German supply ships being apprehended or sunk.
One of those ships was the 4,422 GRT Babitonga, which on 21 June 1941 was challenged by
HMS London near St Pauls Rock in 02 N - 27 W. Rather than being captured, and as was the
standard procedure for German ships that were going to be sunk, Babitongas captain decided to
scuttle his ship, so as not to give the Allies the honour of claiming a kill.
From June 1941 onwards, more and more merchant ships were sailing in escorted convoys, and
that led to fewer and fewer ships being sunk. Indeed, those code breakers at Bletchley Park were
intercepting a tremendous amount of the Germans radio traffic, and thanks to the captured
Enigma machine, they were deciphering their messages with great effect.
The unsuspecting Axis were under the impression that their codes could never be broken, and put
they their recent high casualties down to their ships radio signals being intercepted and
pinpointed with great accuracy by an improved High Frequency Direction Finder (Huff Duff)
system. Those systems were fitted to escort vessels in 1942.)

201
Rabaul

Dresden

202
 Balzac

Tottenham

203
Top: The Norwegian MV Storstad was captured by the raider Pinguin with a cargo of 11,800
tons of diesel. Atlantis and the pocket battleship Admiral Scheer were amongst the ships which
helped themselves by filling their bunker tanks from her. Re-named Passat she loaded mines and
laid them off the Australian coast and Bass Strait. Sunk by the RAF in 1942 she was refloated
after the war.

204
Top: SS Mandasor of T&J Brocklebank Lines was sunk by Atlantis.

Below: Also of T&J Brocklebank Lines is the SS Maharonda in the River Mersey. She picked up
the 11 survivors from the SS Tottenham.

205
HMS Eagle : Almost chanced having an encounter with Atlantis.

HMS Nelson firing a nine gun 16 inch broadside. She was in company with HMS Eagle when
they were both on the wrong side of the moon light and missed Atlantis.

206
 Rabaul

In the middle watch of 14 May 1941 a ship steaming without lights was sighted by the
Atlantis lookouts. A warning shot from the raiders 75 mm focsle head gun was sent
over her bows but the ship continued on her way. A Morse signal ordering her to stop
had no effect, so the searchlight from the raider illuminated the steamer and that made
her turn to starboard in an attempt to escape. A tlantis opened fire, two shells hit the
darkened ship with such a devastating effect, that within minutes she had split open and
began to sink. Fires raged on the decks and the crew were soon lowering the boats. Nine
of the 54 man crew were killed and a dozen more injured. As well as her crew she
carried four passengers. The ship went under in less than 30 minutes.
That steamer was later identified as the 5,618 GRT Rabaul of the WR Carpenter
Overseas Shipping Company of Sydney, Australia. Registered at Suva, Fiji, she was
carrying coal from South Wales to Cape Town on an Admiralty charter. On being
questioned by Kapitan Rogge, the 64 year old second mate who was on watch at the
time of her being challenged, said he saw the signal to stop but didnt bother answering.
He went on to say that he thought if he ignored the Morse signal, its sender would soon
get fed up and go away. Kapitan Rogge informed the second mate, that his couldnt
care less attitude had resulted in the loss of nine lives.

The Closest of Shaves ?

On Saturday 17 May 1941 Kapitan Rogge had some good luck, and undoubtedly the
best of his present 14 month cruise, and probably the best hed ever had in the whole of
his life. Steaming slowly Southwards on the Freetown - Cape sea lane, he was in his
cabin when through the voice pipe the officer of the watch informed him of two distant
ships in silhouette on the port side. Hurriedly making his way to the bridge, and peering
through his binoculars, Kapitan Rogges first thoughts were they might be merchant
ships, but wondered why they were together. Nevertheless he must have rubbed his
hands as action stations were sounded. But as those ships quickly came closer, between

207
the moon and himself, with their silhouettes sharp and clear, he soon realised they were
not merchant ships at all, indeed, their pyramid shaping indicated that they were
warships. Those of the British variety! One an aircraft carrier while the other was a
battleship of the Nelson class; both were steaming in line ahead at twenty knots.
Kapitan Rogges good luck could not have been bettered, inasmuch that he was in the
right position relative to the moon. Indeed, if hed been on the other side, it would have
been A tlantis that was silhouetted against the moon instead of the British warships. Just
one shell from that battleships 16 inch guns, each weighing 2,048 lbs, or just short of
one ton, would have been more than enough to herald the end of A tlantis forever - even
the battleships secondary armament would have been enough to finish her off.
Nevertheless both engines on A tlantis were stopped so as not to stir up a phosphorescent
wake. As the British ships drew nearer, Kapitan Rogge must have been more
apprehensive than hed ever been in his life as he awaited the battleships searchlights to
illuminate him. But when they were just 7,500 yards away, both ships suddenly turned
to starboard in one of their predetermined zigs or zags, and in doing so they went
around the raiders stern. With hearts in mouths that move must have brought a huge
sigh of relief from those on the raiders bridge.
From time to time rust sparks had been blowing from out of the raiders funnel, and
especially when she was starting up or going full ahead. Therefore, in order not to make
any sparks at all, Kapitan Rogge ordered slow ahead and carefully steered a course to
port to keep even further away from the enemy ships. In what seemed an age the two
warships drew away to be almost out of sight. But just as they were diminishing on the
horizon, a brilliant myriad of sparks burst forth from the raiders funnel. The immediate
order from bridge to engine room was to stop both engines. But even then the sparks
continued to erupt. Indeed, if those sparks had been seen by the lookouts of the British
ships, they would have turned back towards them. But Rogges luck, and that of the rest
of his crew held out. On the following morning which happened to be a Sunday, a divine
service was held on the after deck. No doubt the sermon and prayers centred on what
had happened - or what didnt happen - during the anxious watches of the night before.
Except for watch keepers and essential duty-men, Make and Mend was ordered. A
day off as it were for the crew to relax a little, darn their socks, wash and iron their
clothes and perform any other menial little tasks that were outstanding.

208
There was however, another aspect as to A tlantis not being spotted by the two British
warships. Indeed, it so happened that the two allied ships were on their way to join
Force H. The Bismarck had left Germany and was making for the North Atlantic. She
had to be engaged. Had the British ships known for certain that it was the raider Atlantis
things may well have been different; but to lose such priceless time in stopping to
identify a darkened merchant ship, whilst on a mission of such paramount proportions,
would have been out of the question because of valuable time being lost. So it was quite
possible that the raider had been seen the darkened merchant ship, and on given it the
benefit of doubt was given it a blind eye.
It later came to light that the two British warships that had given the Atlantis crew the
fright of their lives, were the battleship HMS Nelson and the aircraft carrier HMS Eagle;
those two ships had left Walvis Bay and were steaming at their best speed towards
Gibraltar. But those same two ships never had the speed they needed. HMS Nelson had
with her sister ship HMS Rodney, originally been designed as 50,000 ton battleships
with fifteen 16 inch guns and a speed of 30 knots. But during their building, the
Versailles Treaty ruled that 36,000 tons was the limit. As a result the ships tonnage,
engines, length and armament was drastically reduced; eventually all the HMS Nelson
could make was 22 knots.
On 22 May a ship that looked British was sighted by Bulla in his new Arado AR 196.
Rogge the Rogue waited until darkness descended before he showed his hand. The usual
warning shot and an order for her not to use her wireless was obeyed, and shortly
afterwards the raiders launch was on its way. But the ship was not British at all, she
was a Greek named Master Elias Kulukundis of 5,548 GRT. She was travelling in
ballast from Lisbon towards Madras under a Swiss government charter. She had some
English passengers on board; because of her being neutral Kapitan Rogge decided to let
her go, but only after her captain had promised not to alert the Allies of the incident.
Another neutral ship was sighted on 23 May, she was an American named Charles H
Crump.
Activity was much higher in the South Atlantic than it had been in the Indian Ocean,
much cooler as well. But with the Atlantic area being much narrower, there was also a
higher concentration of Allied warships.

209
 The Loss of SS Tottenham

After being launched in March 1940, and completed three months later, by the Caledon Ship
Building Company of Dundee for the Ministry of War Transport; the 4,760 GRT SS Tottenham
went under the management of Watts, Watts & Company of London. Tottenham had a 3 cylinder
triple expansion steam engine which gave her a service speed of 10 knots. She was one of three
sister ships, the other two being Twickenham and Teddington.
However, on 17 June 1941 when she was just one year old, the SS Tottenham was travelling
unescorted from the UK towards Alexandria via the Cape; she had a mixed cargo of war materials
for the British Forces in Palestine. But when she was in 7 South and 19 West, she was spotted
by the seaplane of A tlantis during the afternoon watch. After loading her seaplane back on board,
the raider tracked her prospected victim until dusk; she then came up from astern and fired a
warning shot across the bows of the outward bound Tottenham.
The response from the steamer was to turn away and send a series of quadrupled RRRR signals,
but they were quickly picked up by the A tlantis W/T office and promptly jammed at full power.
From a distance of 8,000 yards the raider opened fire with a salvo from her starboard battery. Due
to the damage of her underwater hull sustained at the Kerguelans, plus engines desperately in
need of an overhaul, as well as all the undergrowth and barnacles below the waterline, the speed
of Atlantis was little more than 12 knots. The speed of the SS Tottenham when opened up was
probably the same 12 knots, but the British captain was not to know this
Salvo after salvo was directed at the fleeing Red Ensign ship, but after a number of shells had
been fired from the two forward guns, they overheated and their recoil systems failed. They had
to be hosed down to keep them cool as the inaccurate firing went on. Then the after 5.9 gun
developed the same problem, and that had to be similarly attended to with the fire hoses. Atlantis
then went around to bring her port battery to bear. However, after 150 rounds of 5.9 shells had
been fired, Rogge had witnessed just one hit. There had in fact been four, and that prompted
Tottenhams captain to give the dreaded order of Abandon Ship, little knowing that because of
his greatly reduced speed Kapitan Rogge was himself about to give up the chase. But as the men
of the Tottenham took to the boats the stricken ship still had way on her, and with her two boats
being lowered too quickly, they became swamped as soon as they hit the water and had to be
baled out.

210
In the gathering darkness 29 men from one boat were picked up and taken aboard A tlantis.
Kapitan Rogge wanted to sink the ship as quickly as possible and escape the area. Indeed, he
knew that those RRRR signals sent by Tottenham would most certainly have been picked up, by
both Ascension Island and Walvis Bay W/T stations. Once again torpedoes from the raider failed
to explode on impact, and once again gunfire was used to finish the Tottenham off. But Rogge
the Rogue didnt want to hang around to see if the ship actually went down and departed the
scene at his greatest speed.
Tottenhams captain complained to Rogge that 11 of his crew were unaccounted for and asked
him to return and make a search for them. But the raiders captain replied saying that he himself
had followed the Rules of War, and if Tottenham had stopped when ordered, and hadnt used her
radio, his crew would be safely on board Atlantis with him.
But quite unknown to anybody, the 11missing crew men had taken to the boat on the other side.
The second mate who was amongst them took charge; his thoughts being that if the launch from
Atlantis found them theyd be taken on board the raider where anything could happen. Therefore,
he kept his boat well clear of the raiders launch that was searching for survivors in the dark, he
rowed away as far as possible and hid in the darkness. The second mate thought they would have
a much better chance if they stayed in the boat rather than be captured and become prisoners of
war on A tlantis. He knew the raider was being hunted by the Royal Navy - with the sole object of
destroying her with or without any warning - and he didnt want to be locked up as a prisoner if
and when that happened!
Because there were just 11 men in the boat, there was plenty of lifeboat provisions in it, so all he
wanted was good weather until a ship was sighted. With her red sail set and lookouts posted by
day and by night, it was after spending 11 days in the boat, that the second mates analyses of the
situation proved to be correct when a ship was sighted. Fortunately it was the SS Maharonda of
the T&J Brocklebank Line that came into view. With the second mate using the boats heliograph
the boat was sighted. The 11survivors were taken on board the outward bound steamer on 28 June
- bound for Calcutta!!
Because Maharonda may have had a deck cargo, the empty lifeboat was not picked up but
allowed to drift. Nevertheless, that boat was washed up ashore two months later at the Copa
Cabana beach, Rio de Janeiro, on 22 August 1941. The empty boat was identified as that from
the SS Tottenham by her name and port of registry on its bow and stern. The sinking of
Tottenham by Atlantis was by that time a well known fact, and once again Kapitan Rogge was
castigated for the murder of the eleven crew-men - who had by that time been safely landed,
probably in India.
211
Varying reports as to the fate of the Tottenham then began to circulate. Adjutant Officer Mohr of
Atlantis said that after the raider had departed at speed, the sinking ships ammunition cargo
must have caught fire; he said he saw the British ship erupting in a ball of flame. Others say she
was scuttled as her crew took to the boats.

It might be noted that of all the British ships that fell into the hands of Atlantis, most of
them were tramps that could make little or no more than 10 knots. Even the SS Tottenham
and her two sister ships which were barely a year old, could make little more than ten knots.
Such snail like ships must have made life so much easier for U-Boats and pursuing raider
captains.
Whereas, the six ships under the Norwegian flag that were captured or sunk by the raider,
were all 15-17 knot motor ships. Maybe such slow ships had something to do with the UK
being overtaken in the maritime trade. Indeed, even as late as 1960, there were still many
UK ships that were still 10 or 11 knotters.
At the same time it may be asked why was it, that all German captains scuttled their ships
so as not to let them fall into their enemies hands; neither as a prize or to deny the Allies the
honour of a sinking. As can be seen in this book, the Allied ships never had any plans to
scuttle, and many ships with their cargoes were gratefully accepted by the Axis.

212
 The Last of the SS Balzac

Five days after the sinking of the SS Tottenham, the German raider went on to claim her 20th
and penultimate victim. That ship was the SS Balzac of 5,372 GRT, owned by the Lamport &
Holt Line of Liverpool. With a triple expansion steam engine her speed was 10 knots - but that
was when shed been a new ship 22 years previously! The ship had been completed in 1919 as
the W arhew, but before making a voyage she was purchased from the Shipping Controller in
1920 and renamed Balzac by her new owners. On 22 June 1941 when she was in 15 S - 27 W,
Balzac was homeward bound towards her home port from Rangoon. She had a cargo of 4,200
tons of rice, and a mixed cargo of beeswax, rubber and other commodities from the East.
Once again it was Leutenant Bulla flying his Arado who sighted the palls of smoke coming from
the coal burning ship. Identifying her as being a typically built British ship, he was having much
better luck in his Arado than hed had in the Heinkel. However, it wasnt long before he was
back on board the raider making his report to Kapitan Rogge. The British ship was pursued and
the usual warnings were given for it to heave to and refrain from using her radio; but Balzacs
captain was yet another who failed to agree to the raiders demands. Balzac had a crew of 51 but
three of them were killed in the ensuing bombardment, while another died later in the raiders
hospital
As usual, the ship was looted of all her water, food and other commodities, with mail being
amongst items that were removed from special lockers, store rooms, freezer and the paint locker -
which were all stripped bare - the 22 year old ship was then sent to the bottom. At first torpedoes
were used but once again they failed and proved to be from a faulty batch
Rogge was quite annoyed about that, and could only blame a consignment of torpedoes hed
taken from his supply ship Babitonga two months previously. The accuracy of his guns had
always been a problem; they had in fact been manufactured long before the 1914-18 war, and
although they were probably effective when new, they had at the present time been in use for
almost two years. Moreover, they may well have been used extensively before being fitted to
Schiff 16 in December 1939, and more than likely their barrels needed re-rifling.
After the Balzac action SKL ordered Atlantis to rendezvous with her fellow raider Orion (Schiff
36)on 27 June and supply her with 700 tons of fuel oil for her triple expansion steam engine. At
the appointed time and place both ships met. The last time the two ships had been together was

213
during their gunnery trials off the Jade Inlet before their cruises started. Korvettankapitan Kurt
Weyher was Orions Commanding Officer, and just like Rogge, hed been the captain of a sail
training ship before the war had started.
There was however, a vast difference between Rogge and Weyher, and between A tlantis and
Orion, as well as the number of ships each of them had captured or sunk.
Up until that time A tlantis had accounted for 20 ships totalling 139,591 gross tons, while Weyher
in his Orion had accounted for just nine ships and some 60,000 tons. His last kill had taken
place eight months previously in October 1940, and he was quite frustrated by the extensive time
and success gap.
Moreover, because Orion was an oil burner, and quite unlike the more economical motor ship that
Rogge had, she consumed vast amounts of fuel oil and used more fuel in one week than Atlantis
used in eight, furthermore she could barely make 12 knots. It was due to Orions heavy fuel
consumption, therefore, as well as the fact that his supply ships disappeared and failed to
rendezvous with him, that Weyher asked Rogge to supply him with an extra 500 tons of oil and
bring the total up to 1,200 tons. Such an increase would allow him to remain at large until
September. But Kapitan Rogge refused his former sailing companion on the grounds that due to
his poor success rate, his ship was hardly worth the expense, and instead of giving him the
proposed 700 tons of fuel oil gave him 580 tons instead. Nevertheless both ships parted
company on 6 July with their captains still the best of friends.

214
 Captured Intact, the MS Silvaplana

Atlantis then set a course for the Pacific via the Cape of Good Hope, and by passing Gough
Island on 9 July, it became the third time in her cruise that shed passed around the Cape, even
though she was 900 miles to the South of it. In the Roaring Forties where the howling South
Westerly's lived up to their reputation, the sailors caught an albatross with a wing span of over
six feet. Like all those seabirds do, it waddled clumsily around the deck in a most ungainly
fashion before being seasick. But it quickly recovered when it was put back into the water, before
taking off on the crest of a wave to resume its gliding flight - whilst never once flapping its
wings. The Prince Edward, and St Paul Islands came into view in the ice cold weather, before
New Amsterdam Island stood before the raider. But not a ship was sighted in the Roaring Forties.
Something strange was happening with the coded signals from Germany! It was as though the
Allies were able to read them.
Therefore, SKL instructed the raiders and supply ships, that when they sent their coded signals,
they should keep them to a maximum of 12 digits. However, after Atlantis had sent a large
number of these short signals to SKL there was never any reply, and Rogge wondered if SKL was
receiving them. But the British at Bletchley Park were picking them up, with the result that within
a short space of time the Admiralty was reporting to its ships that a German ship, probably a
raider, was present in the Kerguelans Islands area. Atlantis celebrated her 500th day at sea when
she was off the Crozets.
Day after day went by but A tlantis sighted no ships. Therefore, as well as the increasing boredom
and frustration amongst the crew, as well as the longer than expected cruise, even Rogges
officers were showing signs of strain. But Kapitan Rogge was well aware of it all and addressed
his complement. Consequently, a weeks unrecorded interspersed leave at sea was given to all on
board; that meant a weeks complete relaxation with no duties, rounds or inspections whatsoever -
except for action stations!
Rogge took his ship well to the South of Australia, Tasmania and new Zealand before heading
North. The International Date Line was crossed on 6 September 1941.
It was when he was North of New Zealand in 26 S - 164 W on 10 September, that in the evening
watch a ship was sighted without navigation lights; but because of a single white light showing,
it might be assumed that somebody had failed to215
batten down his deadlight. Rogge approached
the ship while ordering her to heave to and not to use her wireless, but that order which was not
obeyed resulted in a string of quadruple RRRRs being transmitted from the ship which also gave
her position. But a fault in the W/T office equipment of A tlantis failed to jam those signals.
Because Rogge wanted to keep the attractive looking ship intact as a prize, he fired a three gun
salvo as a warning. The ship which turned out to be the Silvaplana of Norway stopped
transmitting immediately and hove to for a boarding party. She was the sixth Norwegian ship
Atlantis had apprehended. Her manifest revealed her cargo was of immense value, consisting of
400 tons of rubber, fifty tons of coffee beans, hides, tin, a full deck cargo of teak and many other
valuable mixed cargo items.
The 4,793 GRT Silvaplana was under the command of Captain Neils Stange Nielsen. She was a
new 17 knot motors ship owned by Tschudi & Eitzen of Norway and bound from Singapore
towards New York via the Panama Canal. However, due to a diesel fuel shortage, Rogge could
not send her to France as was the custom, because that would have necessitated a passage around
Cape Horn. With a prize crew on board he had to hide her away further South until he could
procure more diesel from a supply ship - or some unfortunate captured vessel on which he could
once more demonstrate his skills as a pirate! Due to Captain Neilsen surrendering his ship there
were no deaths or injuries amongst Silvaplanas crew.
But before the Norwegian ship could be sent South, a message was received by A tlantis from
SKL, stating that Silvaplanas RRRR signal had been received by an Allied shore station in
Australia. Almar Nilsen the radio officer who had sent those RRRR signal, was ordered to cancel
it, stating that his signals had been a false alarm and all was well. But the Allies had been caught
out by that ruse before, and suspected that Silvaplanas captain and his radio officer had been
coerced into sending the message -and they were right! In their reply 12 hours later, the highly
suspicious Australian W/T station asked for the same RRRR signal to be repeated - in code! But
as expected that request could not be met, the code books of Silvaplana had been dumped
overboard, which quite simply meant that Rogge the Rogue would have to depart the area before
he was paid a visit by an Australian cruiser. Both ships then departed at speed to the next
rendezvous point. During an unforeseen wait for the supply ship Munsterland, which had been
loaded with oil and stores by their friends in Japan, Rogge decided to transfer some of the
rubber cargo from Silvaplana onto his own ship between 20-21 September. Indeed, since her last
meeting with Babitonga the raider had been left in good trim, but since then she had supplied
Orion with 580 tons of oil and others, plus her own usage of diesel, water and other stores.
Therefore, the rubber from the Norwegian ship was for use as ballast in order to regain the ship's
trim. Due to the yawing between the two ships, however, a derrick transfer of the rubber between
216
the two ships could not be used and it had to be transported by the raiders boats, in what turned
out to be a most strenuous and arduous task in the choppy seas.
But their efforts were brought to a close when after having transferred 120 tons in two days, the
6,315 GRT supply ship Munsterland under Kapitan Uebel hove into view. She was accompanied
by the raider Komet - which had as a prize the 7,325 Dutch motor ship Kota Nopan. It so
happened that on her passage from Japan, the supply ship had been held up by heavy weather, and
due to a directive imposing silence, there was no way Kapitan Uebel could inform Rogge of his
unintentional late arrival. After the required fuel and stores had been transferred, Silvaplana with
Leutenant Dittmann and his prize crew was sent to Bordeaux via Cape Horn. But due to heavy
weather for much of the passage Dittmann didnt arrive at his destination until 17
November1941.
Komets commander was flag officer Konteradmiral Robert Eyssen who had recently been
promoted a few days earlier. In order for him to meet Rogge and discuss tactics, he was piped
aboard A tlantis in true naval fashion. On the admirals departure the four ships Komet, A tlantis,
Munsterland and Kota Nopan, stayed together for four days before going their different ways.
After discharging at Bordeaux Silvaplana's name was changed to Irene in 1942; under that
name she became a supply ship and made another voyage to the Far East. But whilst
homeward bound to Germany with a valuable cargo of rubber and tin, Irene made an
attempt to run the British blockade. Intercepted by the mine laying cruiser HMS
Adventure on 4 October 1943, her German crew scuttled rather than let the ship and its
valuable cargo fall into enemy hands.
Thanks to his meeting with Munsterland, Kapitan Rogge was well endowed with stores, water
and fuel at the end of September, indeed, he had enough to continue his cruise for another year.
But he also knew that both his crew and his ship had been through an arduous 18 months and
neither could last indefinitely. A tlantis badly needed a major refit, her guns were worn out and
required replacing, her engines demanded a complete overhaul, she was badly in want of a dry-
docking to repair the damage caused at the Kerguelens, as well as having a good bottom scrape -
to name just a few of the things the ship needed - but even more important was his complements
state of mind -after having been cooped up like tinned sardines for the past 18 months the strain
on them was telling by the day. Therefore, Kapitan Rogge instructed Adjutant Mohr to inform the
ships company that A tlantis was from that day homeward bound, with a provisional date being
set for 23 December 1941. Quite naturally the crew were ecstatic when they received the news.

217
 Crew List of the MS Silvaplana
Supplied by the Norwegian Archives

Captain Niels Stange Nielsen - 1st Mate Aage Magnus Olsen, 2nd Hjalmar

Skjervik, 3rd Magne Bakkevik - Radio Officer, Almar Nilsen - Carpenter,

Abraham Abrahamsen - Bosun Nils Totland -ABs Sverre Bruknapp, Erling

Engennes, Halvor Halvesen, Aage Bakkevik, Olaf Hernes, Sverre Jakobsen, Helge

Sorensen, Ludvik Wallasik - Chief Engineer, Reider Tharaldsen, 2nd, Einar Naess,

3rd Ragnar Hoff, Assistant, Rolf Magnussen. Electrician, Trygve Halberg.

Mechanics, Sigurd Jacobsen, Erik Carlsen, Nils Strand, Greasers - Folke

,
Markstrom, Erik Salander Sven Skreros, Johan Hansen.- Steward Fritjof Nostdal

-Cook T Jakobsen. Boys, Magnus Espeland, Halvor Ellingsen, Rolf Kristensen.

218
 When Atlantis was sunk by HMS Devonshire, she was posing as the Dutch Polyphemus.

Disguised as the Dutch Polyphemus, this photograph which was taken from the conning tower
of the U126 was one of the last photos taken of Atlantis. Note the10 foot extension to her fun-
nel, the dummy Samson posts and the enlarged crows nest on the foremast table.

219
 Atlantis Homeward Bound

The first step on the passage home to Germany was to ensure the ship could safely get there
without mishap or break downs. Therefore, in one of their morning discussions, Kapitan Rogge
and Adjutant Mohr decided to drop anchor in some remote place that was similar to the
Kerguelens; but much warmer and with a bit more scenery so that the crew could stretch their
legs ashore; and also to give the engines and any other equipment on the ship an overhaul. The
place chosen for the sojourn was a small bay on Vana-Vana, a Polynesian atoll in the Tuamotu
Archipelago situated in 17 S, 144W.
While proceeding to the atoll the seaplane was sent up two or three times a day in search of prey,
but due to the area being a seldom used shipping lane no ships were sighted. On arrival at the
raiders destination a few days later anchor was dropped in October 1941. The ship was moored
to two anchors just 50 yards away from the beach which was very steep. In the initial stages an
armed party was sent ashore to make a survey of the situation, but it was soon learned that the
inhabitants were a group of shy and timid people with no thoughts of repelling the visitors. After
that the islanders gave the raiders crew a warm welcome with lots of fruit being offered as gifts.
In return a fair sized quantity of flour was sent ashore. It was indeed a welcome and much needed
exchange; the islands supply vessel which was a sailing schooner only came twice a year at
most.
It was the first time in 10 months the sailors of A tlantis had stepped ashore; the last time being at
the Kerguelens. In a show of gratitude for being made so welcome, Doctor Riel and his medical
staff treated the islanders minor illnesses as best they could, which were in the main eye
infections. At the same time the crew enjoyed two days of absolute bliss, swimming and fishing
in the crystal clear lagoon, as well as trying their hand at climbing the tall palm trees set in the
beautiful sun whitened sands.
Even while the raider was moored in the lagoon bay, the Arado seaplane was sent up on regular
excursions but nothing was ever sighted. After two days of heaven on earth for the worn out and
mind wearied sailors of A tlantis, both anchors were weighed and the raider sailed towards the
Pitcairn Islands - whilst still on the search for Allied ships. But nothing was ever sighted on the
way to that lonely patch of the Pacific Ocean.
Dropping anchor at the uninhabited Henderson Island, a hundred miles or so to the North East of
220
the Pitcairns on 23 October, the crew were once again allowed to enjoy themselves by
swimming ashore and exploring. But it was a much different scenario than that of Vana-Vana.
The volcanic island was completely uninhabited by either human or animal life; all that was there
were rocks and dense inedible foliage. Amongst their discoveries, however, a wooden plaque
was found on which there was a barely readable yet faint inscription which read. This Island
belongs to King George V. Which quite simply meant, that some colonial minded captain of a
British warship had been there some 25 years previously. Whilst at Henderson Island the ships
disguise was altered, assuming the identity of the Dutch 6,269 GRT motor vessel Polyphemus
being adopted. That ship in reality belonged to the Nedernandsche Stoomboot Maatschappij
Ocean of Rotterdam; a company that was affiliated to the Blue Funnel Line of Liverpool; the
ship itself had been built by Scotts of Greenock in 1930.
Two days later with her new Dutch, Blue Funnel Line markings, A tlantis weighed at first light
and headed towards Cape Horn. It was there that news came through of the sinking of the supply
ship which tended the U-Boats in the South Atlantic. While off Cape Horn on 1 November 1941,
the moment marked the 600th day of operational duty for Atlantis. Thanks to the supply ship
Munsterland, Kapitan Rogge who had plenty of fuel and stores, with much to spare, offered his
services to Naval Command in order to make up for the loss of the supply ship.
With Bernhard Rogge having been born into a family of privilege, there was no reason
whatsoever as to why he had to pursue a life at sea - where life for all was often hard and
dangerous. But hed always been a great lover of the sea, of sailing ships, and a sailors ways of
life. As he stood on the bridge of his ship during a snowstorm in the cold grey seas off the bitterly
cold Cape Horn on 29 October 1941, many thoughts must have crossed his mind as he reflected
on those sailing ships of the past. Because even as little as two years ago, in 1939, those big
windjammers were still taking part in the famous Australian Grain Races.
As a result of his offer to be used as a supply ship, it was on 8 November, when after having
rounded the famous landmark of Cape Horn, that Naval Command took up Rogges offer. As a
result Atlantis was ordered to rendezvous with U-68 and supply her with fuel, water and other
necessary stores. The crew of A tlantis went about their tasks grudgingly - all of them under the
impression that they were homeward bound, and not to be there hanging around as a supply ship
with all its dangers. When A tlantis arrived at the rendezvous she met up with U-68 under the
command of Leutenantkapitan Merten, an old friend of Bernhard Rogge, and a man whod once
been one of his great competitors during their pre-war sailing regattas.
On the U-Boats departure Rogges intention was to carry on hunting Allied ships while his own
ship was on the way home to Germany. Bulla in his Arado spotted a ship on 18 November but it
221
turned out to be neutral. On the following day he reported another, but after giving chase the
raider had to concede defeat when the ship outpaced him. At that time the top speed of A tlantis
was down to a maximum of little more than 10 knots. There was a problem with a piston on the
port engine, as well as the ever increasing barnacles and undergrowth which also helped to slow
the ship down. .
Then came a problem with Bullas Arado. Because on trying to alight onto the water which
appeared to be a flat sea, his port float hit a larger than normal precipitous wave as he turned and
the seaplane finished upside down - with Bulla and his observer Bouchert sitting on the wings.
The Arado was hoisted aboard for the necessary repairs, but despite the ship-wright's best efforts
to repair the wrecked Arado, the plane was deemed as being beyond hope. That left Rogge the
Rogue without his highly valued eye in the sky, a tremendous blow, and one that he was soon to
deeply regret.
In their discussions with regard to the engines, and the run home to Germany, Chief Engineer
Kielhorn told Kapitan Rogge that the rings of one particular piston were giving him trouble and
that piston needed replacing. The chase of the ship which had recently escaped from the raider
only highlighted the situation; the chief engineer said the ship might not make it back home if the
problem was not resolved.
Then came orders from SKL to carry out another refuelling job. The rendezvous was 350 miles
Northwest of Ascension Island, where during the morning watch of 22 November 1941, A tlantis
stopped to await the U-Boats arrival. After that last run on his engines, however, it was a worried
looking Kielhorn who approached Rogge while he ruefully shook his head, The chief engineer
went onto say that the sooner the piston in the port engine was replaced the better. It was now
overheating and beginning to smoke. Therefore, due to the fact that Atlantis and U-126 would be
idle for a few hours, Rogge gave his permission for the port engine to be shut down and the
faulty piston replaced.
Soon afterwards at 0600 hrs, at the break of dawn on 22 November, the lean grey shape of U-126
broke surface. Coming alongside the raider, the bearded Leutenantkapitan Ernst Bauer and seven
of his equally bearded crew were invited aboard Atlantis for a long overdue hot shower, and an
equally long slap up breakfast. Whereupon those men went aboard the raider and soon got stuck
into the promised meal; while with them the U-Boat men brought a change of clothing. One at a
time they went for a shower - a shower being an absolute luxury for any submariner. Meanwhile,
on board the submarine, the young and inexperienced 1st Leutenant Neubert had been left to
guard the fort as it were. It may have been the normal and accepted thing for a submariner to
board a supply ship and take a shower - but there was nothing within ships rules to say he could.
222
The fuel hose line was paid out over the raiders side, connected to the U-Boats deck manifold
and pumping began. The raiders launch then chugged back and forth with dry stores and other
equipment and loaded them onto the submarines casing. After having showered and dressed and
feeling like spring lambs the U-126 guests went for their breakfast. Bauer and Rogge had a good
talk before the U-Boat commander himself went for his much wanted shower, while Rogge in his
anxiety to get the supply job finished went up to the bridge. On making enquiries to the engine
room at 0800, he was told that the faulty piston had been disconnected while its replacement was
about to take place.

223
 A Taste of Devonshire Cream

Rogge was a worried man, his ship was in a most dangerous position in being right in the middle
of a busy shipping lane, disabled and stopped in broad daylight. Why hadnt SKL arranged the
rendezvous for twelve hours earlier - or twelve hours later? The refuelling could just as easily
have been carried out in the dark using dimmed lights! But by that time, and quite unknown to
the German raiders captain, his ship was already under surveillance, and had been for half an
hour!
Whenever Atlantis was at sea there were always at the very least, five lookouts on duty at any one
time; focsle head, foremast crows nest, mainmast crows nest and both bridge wings. At 0820
hrs on 22 November 1941, on a clear day with good visibility, one of the foremast crows nest
lookouts sighted and reported a ship. Indeed, it was a report that was to become the most
significant and disastrous in the career of the German raider, and also the last time such a report
would ever be made aboard A tlantis. The initial report was a ship bearing two points on the port
bow - a mere speck on the horizon. But as that distant ship came quickly closer, she turned
broadside on to reveal her profile. The next report from the excited lookout stated that his sighting
was a three funnelled cruiser, and one that was zig-zagging at high speed.
With not a moment to spare, the re-fuelling hose line was disconnected simultaneously on both
the U-126 and her supply ship - but instead of being hauled back aboard the raider, that hose line
in desperation was dropped into the sea, and that left a huge oil slick. The U-Boat dived, just as
her freshly showered commander and his men came running out on deck Too late! All that could
be seen of Bauers charge was a patch of swirling jade green water accompanied by a white
boiling foam, all of which marked the spot where Ernst Bauers submarine had recently been
loading her stores and bunkers.
Leutenant Neubert was of course, the subject of a verbal roasting by Kapitan Bauer for leaving
him, and the other seven men marooned and embarrassed on the deck of a common merchant
ship. The unrepeatable oath spat out by Kapitan Bauer, referred pointedly to his Number Ones
facial appearance and the doubts he had about his parenthood; but the most severe of re-dresses
for the unfortunate officer would come at a later date. The truth of the matter was, however, that
Kapitan Bauer had left his post, he should have been supervising the refuelling operation, and not
engaged in taking a shower. Indeed, if and when there was a Court Martial regarding the incident,
224
he himself would have been charged with either Desertion of Post or Dereliction of
Duty, while his 1st Leutenant would have been commended and told that he had adopted
the correct procedure under the circumstances.
Note - Under the command of Ernst Baur U-126 was commissioned in February
1941; prior to her meeting with Atlantis, she had already sank eight allied
ships, and heavily damaged the Canadian Star. U-126 eventually sank or damaged
31 allied ships before she herself was bombed by the RAF. She was picked up on
radar at 0230 hrs on 3 June 1943 whilst returning to her base at Lorient under the
command of Siegfried Keitz. There were no survivors.
Kapitan Rogge raised his binoculars to examine the reported ship. It was indeed a three
funnelled cruiser, and one which was the Dorsetshire or one of her class. And he should
know! Because when Rogge had been the 1st Leutenant of the cruiser Karlsruhe, in
1936, five years previously, his ship had been at Hong Kong. At that time the KMS
Karlsruhe of Germany, had been moored alongside HMS Dorsetshire of Britain.
The lookout then reported a seaplane. Rogge identified that too, it was a Walrus, the
type used extensively on British cruisers and capital ships, and capable of being
launched by means of a steam catapult. The raiders captain wondered how the British
ship had detected him. Was it through their advanced radio signal detection, or their new
technique known as radar, or was it just bad luck on his part? At a much later date,
however, he was to find out that the Enigma code was no longer unbreakable.
It so happened, however, that on 22 November at first light, the Walrus from HMS
Devonshire (for such was her name) had been catapulted off to make her routine early
morning search. It was known to the British that U-Boats and a German commerce
raider were in the area, and because such U-Boats cannot operate alone, her supply ship
could not be far away. At that time the cruiser was zig-zagging at 18 knots, an
appropriate and tactical speed to lessen the chance of a submarines torpedo striking
her. After flying 10 miles to the South, the observer of the seaplane sighted a ship that
was stopped 40 miles further to the South. The observer of the Walrus then sent a lamp
signal to Devonshire, reporting a suspicious ship stopped 50 miles to her South.
Whereupon the cruiser headed towards the reported sighting and increased speed to 25
knots. At the same time the Walrus was ordered to make further identifications of the
ship and report back. An hour later HMS Devonshire under the command of 46 year old

225
Captain Robert Don Oliver RN, was in clear sight of the German raider; it was then, that
a look-out aboard Atlantis saw and reported the British cruiser. It was only then that the
Walrus was sighted by the raiders lookouts. It was also the time when the hose line
between the U-Boat and Atlantis was hurriedly disconnected, and also the time when U
-126 took her emergency dive. Flying over and around the supposedly innocent looking
merchant ship, whose crew were all waving up at the pilot in a false show of greeting,
the Walrus observer saw the hose line floating adrift as well as the oil slick which
accompanied it. On examining his ship profiles he also noticed that the ship below him
matched that of the so called Tamesis, otherwise known to the RN as Ship C - the
notorious Schiff 16 - or A tlantis! Those photographs of the ship that the Walrus observer
had in his possession, had been taken by David Scherman, a survivor of the SS Zamzam,
and photos that had five months previously, been published in the LIFE Magazines
June 1941 issue.
Taking into account the fact that the ship below him was stopped, and a hose line was
floating adrift in an oil slick, it didnt need much imagination for the Walrus observer to
conclude that a submarine had been in the process of re-fuelling, and the operation had
to be abandoned due to the approach of the cruiser and its seaplane.
Flying back towards the Devonshire which at the time was zig zagging intermittently at
between 25 - 30 knots, 12 miles away, the Walrus observer sent a lamp signal with a
series of S-S-SS-S-SS-S-S , a message which signified that a submarine was in the
area. Devonshire then sent an 8 inch warning shot over the raider. A simple but polite
warning which meant. - If you are a raider take to the boats and save lives - The Walrus
then approached the so called Polyphemus and asked for identification, despite the fact
that on the ships side in bold lettering, was the ships name and nationality,
POLYPHEMUS - HOLLAND.
For Kapitan Rogge the game was up, his ship was no match for the heavy cruiser zig
zagging on the distant horizon - and he knew it. His only chance, albeit a slim one, was
to delay for as long as possible an answer to the demands of the Walrus, and then hope
and pray, that U-126 might get into a position where she could use her torpedoes. But
the U-126s captain who was standing alongside the raiders captain appeared to have
little faith in his junior - and he was right! It so happened that when the eight inch shells
from Devonshire hit the water and exploded, the temporary captain of U-126 thought he

226
was being depth charged; so he took his new command down to 300 feet - and stayed
there until it was all over.
Meanwhile, on board HMS Devonshire which was weaving around at speed, Captain
Oliver made sure he kept his cruiser out of the distant ships eight mile maximum gun
range. He was well aware, and quite convinced by then, that the ship on his horizon was
a surface raider, and one that had six 5.9 inch guns as well as four water line torpedo
tubes. He was also aware of the fact that just six months previously, Devonshires sister
ship Cornwall, had ventured too close to a surface raider named Pinguin. Indeed, from
8,000 yards the German raider scored a direct hit on the heavy cruiser which knocked
out her communication systems, fire control, and killed one seaman; there were also a
few near misses which caused quite some damage to the County Class Cruiser.
Pinguin had acquired her armament from the 1906 battleship Schleisen of pre WW1
vintage; but those guns, however old, were still accurate, and their gun crews were well
trained. However, after steaming away to lick her wounds and make repairs, HMS
Cornwall returned and gave chase to the fleeing raider; from a 10 mile range she sank
the Pinguin later in the day. That action resulted in the deaths of 639 men from the
raider, 401 who were crew while 238 were prisoners from Allied ships. There were just
82 survivors, 28 who were prisoners from British ships and 54 German crew.
Moreover, and probably unknown to Captain Oliver at that particular time, it was just
three days previously, on 19 November 1941, that the Australian light cruiser HMAS
Sydney had allowed the raider Kormoran to get too close to her. Using delaying tactics
of Morse signalling, the German raider got within 2,000 yards and then opened fire on
the cruiser. Although both ships sank each other, Captain Burnett of the Sydney was by
far the big loser in suffering the loss of his ship, himself, and the whole of his 645 man
Australian crew. But whether or not Captain Oliver was aware of the HMAS Sidneys
demise, the wily Scotsman had no intention of getting any closer to his adversary than
18,000 yards - or about nine miles.
Studying the British cruiser from 10 miles away through his binoculars, it was in his
own words that Kapitan Rogge described the ship that he thought was HMS Dorsetshire.
An object of maritime beauty he said, tearing through the sea, bows up and stern down
at over 30 knots she made huge bow waves, while from astern she left a boiling white
wake from her four propellers. As time went by the crew of A tlantis must have had their

227
hearts in their mouths, as from afar they watched the cruiser steaming in continuing
wide sweeps making things extremely difficult for any U-Boat to launch a torpedo
attack. They must have known that their captain was trying to bluff his way out of the
problem with the signals to the seaplane - but it wasnt exactly like that at all. Indeed,
the cruiser was double checking up on the so called Polyphemus, just to ensure she was
genuine - but the waiting for identification continued for an hour!
In the meantime the Walrus kept on asking the raider for identification. But the raiders
signalman in his replies, a man who had been well groomed in such procedures, was
operating a Merchant Navy Aldis lamp. His signals of reply were poor and
unintelligible, all planned of course, but every second gained in such a delay meant that
U-126 might have a chance of torpedoing the cruiser. But it was not to be! The U-126
was still 300 feet below the surface. In another effort to gain as much time as possible,
Atlantis which was claiming to be Polyphemus, sent a string of raider alarm signals.
But quite unknown to Kapitan Rogge or his wireless operators, the series of three, RRR
signals had recently been changed, to a four RRRR signal; whereupon the use of the
outdated three RRR signal only heightened the cruiser captains suspicions.
Furthermore, from HMS Devonshire a signal had been sent to the C in C South Atlantic
asking for information on the Dutch ship Polyphemus. The waiting on both sides
dragged on. Eventually, however, the reply came back to the cruiser. It stated that the
Dutch ship Polyphemus had last been reported at Bilbao, Panama, and that gave strong
support to the suspicion that the ship in question was an imposter. Indeed, the way back
home to Europe from Panama was not via the Ascension Isles. To save life and limb
Captain Oliver had given Kapitan Rogge every chance to take to the boats and scuttle -
but the opportunity was not taken.
From the bridge of Atlantis, the orange flash of gunfire from the cruiser told Rogge
there was no hope whatsoever. Just 30 seconds it would take for the cruisers 250 pound
projectiles to reach him. Despite the fact that his port engine was still out of use, he
started his starboard and went full ahead - a speed which was a little more than his
normal half ahead. But he knew that even if both engines were running flat out it
wouldnt have made the slightest bit of difference. HMS Devonshire which was intent
on the destruction of A tlantis could steam at over 32 knots, she had eight, eight inch
guns and eight torpedoes tubes, and even in the smoke screen that Rogge had laid,

228
Devonshires Walrus seaplane, if need be, could see over and around it and quite easily
direct the cruisers gunfire.
At that particular time radar was still in its infancy and smoke screens were quite
effective, but when radar reached its full potential, and was fitted to ships of all
nations, smoke screens lost their usefulness. In foggy conditions, however, the
British County Class cruisers HMS Norfolk and Suffolk, had used radar to quite
some effect when shadowing the German battleship Bismarck in May 1941.
The flash of gunfire Rogge had recently seen, resulted in two eight inch shells straddling
Atlantis, - one ahead and one astern. The warning was over. Devonshire had her range,
and shelling into the smoke screen then began. A tlantis turned and went back into her
white smoke screen, creeping along at dead slow ahead which gave her just enough
way to manage the helm and get her boats over. Hits and near misses began registering.
The engine room crowd were still down below; they wouldnt leave until they were told
to. But quite soon there were no internal phone lines left on the ship, and even the voice
pipe to the engine room had been shot away; Kapitan Rogge had to send the bridge
messenger down to the engine room to verbally give the order to stop engines - for the
last time - and forever! In a last act of escape, survival or vengeful tactic - with the
possible help of U-126 - Rogge continued making smoke for as long as the smoke cans
lasted; while at the same time he ordered Dynamite Fehler to place his scuttling
charges.
From then on, and from 10 miles away, eight inch shells rained down into the
disappearing smoke screen. Some went over giving off a high pitched droning noise
like an express train, while others were falling close to the ship sending up huge
fountains of water. Despite the fact that Captain Oliver on Devonshire was firing blind
into the mile long smoke screen, hits were taken on the raider which left the mainmast at
a crazy angle, splintered some of the boats and tore up the well scrubbed wooden decks
like cardboard. Derricks were strewn all over the decks and hatches, while their topping
lift wires, guys and blocks were in an almighty tangle. The stage props on deck
consisting of dummy ventilators, samson posts, deck cargo and other items to falsify the
ships appearance, were blown away as though a Force 20 hurricane had hit the ship.
Indeed, what had just minutes previously been a trim and orderly ship, had been
reduced to an absolute shambles.

229
Despite the fact that everything on and around the decks was an absolute mess
accompanied by smoke and flames, there was no panic whatsoever amongst the crew as
they carried on in an orderly fashion. Indeed one of the sailors was carrying the
captains yelping dog Ferry to one of the boats.
Because of the communications failure, the order of Abandon Ship had to be relayed
verbally throughout the ship. A direct hit and its blast on number two hold, blew out
every window on the forepart of the bridge, while another hit the after end and started
more fires. In the melee ships boats and rafts that were crammed with men pulled
away from the maritime home theyd shared for the past 622 days. Kapitan Rogge must
have been grateful there were no prisoners on board. Indeed, there was hardly enough
room for his own men in the boats, let alone any passengers; he must also have been
grateful for the fact that he had pirated a few of those boats in his travels.
Finally, there were just Kapitan Bernhard Rogge, Adjutant Ulrich Mohr, Leutenant
Johann Fehler, his demolition party, and the CPO Coxwain Wilhelm Pigors left on
board. Rogge ordered those men who were with him to leave the ship. But with the
exception of Adjutant Mohr and Chief Petty Officer Pigors the coxwain, they all
obeyed. Rogge then ordered Pigors and Mohr off the ship, but Pigors his coxwain and
former shipmate from their last ship, the Albert Leo Schlageter refused. He knew that
Rogge would rather go down with his ship, and told his captain that he would not leave
the dying A tlantis without him. He added that his complement of men in the boats
needed him to guide them. Pigors then asked his captain to leave the ship and only then
would he leave. Pigors got his way.
As the smoke dissipated from around the burning A tlantis, the ship was clearly visible
from the British cruiser which had kept on firing. In the continuing bombardment two
men were killed while attempting to swim away from the ship.
However, Kapitan Rogge gratefully appreciated the fact that his counterpart on the
cruiser had used base fuse delayed action shells to sink the raider, instead of the dreaded
nose cone fuses. Indeed, if cone fuses had been used, those shells would have exploded
on impact and turned into shrapnel resulting in heavy loss of life for those in the boats,
on deck or in the water. On the other hand - the base fuse shells are designed to
penetrate the ship and explode inside the hull, or go a little way underwater before
exploding.

230
Kapitan Rogge took to the water followed by his adjutant and coxwain. Those three men
thought they were the last to leave the ship - but not so! It so happened that one of the
radio operators, Oberfunkgefreiter Heinz Muller, whose action station was at an
emergency W/T station in number one hold tween deck, had not been made aware of
the Abandon Ship order, and although he knew the ship was doomed he stayed at his
post. With the ship listing to port and down by the stern, it was only then that the valiant
seaman left his post. Emerging from beneath the focsle head, he saw those in the
crowded boats and realised that the order of Abandon Ship had been given. Taking the
plunge he was the last man to leave A tlantis. The charges in the raiders engine room
and the magazine exploded in a fireball. The raider which flew no flag went deeper
down by the stern to follow the same path as her victims. As the stern went under her
bows lifted up in defiance to reveal the ugly scar near her keel that shed sustained at the
Kerguelens; no need to fix it now! As the four year old ship went under, the unfortunate
Heinz Muller, who was the last man off the ship, was sucked down with it.

The time 1004 hrs 22 November 1941 - Position 04 20' S - 18 35' W.

In 622 days of operational duty, Atlantis had steamed 102,000 miles.

HMS Devonshire hauled down her battle ensign. Her job done she departed the scene at
speed and steered a course for Freetown. Because he knew there was a submarine in the
area, Captain Oliver was unable to search for and rescue A tlantis survivors.
It must be stated at this point, that Kapitan Rogge of A tlantis, and Captain Oliver of
Devonshire both shared the same honourable beliefs in performing their respective
duties. Those two men each had a job to do by sinking enemy ships, whilst at the same
time theyd both refrained from needlessly taking lives. That fact had been demonstrated
on numerous occasions within these pages, when Rogge the Rogue as he was
affectionately known by his prisoners, always gave a ships captain the chance to
surrender his ship before making an attack. Indeed, Kapitan Rogge had at all times
followed the Rules of War. Captain Oliver of HMS Devonshire followed in the same
path of moral decency. He gave ample warning for Kapitan Rogge to take to the boats
and scuttle his ship; he also used base fused shells to sink the raider, which in itself
saved many lives.

231
Top; HMS Devonshire on being commissioned in March 1929.

Below - The camouflaged HMS Devonshire at Lagos in 1941.

232
233
 The Scuttling of Python

After the cruiser Devonshire had departed, and the raider A tlantis had gone beneath the
waves, it took two hours for the survivors to sort themselves out getting aboard the rafts
and boats. In the calm water they mustered together to hear their captain give an
address. A count of heads revealed that in the British cruisers bombardment, five men
had been killed while two had died of their injuries when they were in the boats.
Meanwhile U-126 had surfaced, Kapitan Baur returned to his post, and Kapitan Rogge
had an open discussion with his officers across the boats. They spoke of either going
towards the much closer Freetown - Cape Town sea lane, or take a submarine tow
towards Brazil. General opinion amongst them being, that if they were apprehended by
the British off the West African coast, they would end up in Freetown as POWs.
Eventually a decision was made to take a 950 mile tow by U-126 to Pernambuco,
Brazil, (Now Recife) where during the course of the tow, a supply ship might possibly
be sent to pick them up.
Needless to say there were just a few berthing ropes on the U-126; the only other things
that could be used for the tow were the boats painters. During its raids on allied
shipping A tlantis had taken the motor boat from the Norwegian Teddy, and as long as
the fuel lasted, that craft as well as their own powered life-boat proved most valuable in
shuttling around between the uneven assortment of boats and rafts. !
To lessen the overcrowding in the boats and rafts, U -126 embarked a number of
Atlantiss specialist men aboard. Indeed, if the boats and their survivors were captured
by the Allies, those highly trained men would have been lost to Germany for the
duration of the war. Those men consisted of ten officers, six chief petty officers, 16
petty officers, 23 ratings and the injured.
There were also 52 men wearing life-jackets who were sat on the deck casing of the
submarine; their orders, or advice being, that if the U-126 was compelled to dive, then
they should swim away as fast as possible to evade being sucked down in the U-Boats
dive. After the transfer of personnel to U-126, the make shift rafts were allowed to drift

234
away. In the meantime one of the boats which had gone down with A tlantis when she
had sunk, bobbed back up to the surface and was baled out. That boat was towed astern
of theU-126 as a back up for the men who were stationed on her decks; should the U-
Boat be forced to dive they would man that towed boat. U-126 towed the crowded boats
at about six knots at first, but even though the sea was relatively calm, the bumping of
the boats into the slight swell caused the tow line to carry away on numerous occasions.
There was also the problem of the continuous baling out of the boats. That was due to
when A tlantis had been operational, the wooden boats had been allowed to dry out. As a
result, when the boats hit the water their planks started. But after a few hours in the
water when they had received good soaking the leaks stopped.
With a following sea to help, one hundred and fifty sea miles were covered in the first
36 hours, an average of over four knots; at that rate it would take another week or so to
make Pernambuco - if the good weather held out! Needless to say food and especially
water, had to be rationed to the absolute limit, but another growing problem was that the
sea swell had increased, and on shipping water it caused the heavily overcrowded boats
to at times fill to the thwarts.
The water coming aboard the boats was cold, everybody was soaked through, and what
little warmth there could be had was by huddling together. But nobody complained, they
all knew that things could have been worse - an awful lot worse! Late in he afternoon of
the second day came the welcome news from U-126, that SKL had ordered the supply
ship Python under the command of Kapitan Lueders to come to their assistance. In
peacetime the Python had been a fruit boat from the African Fruit Company that carried
about 12 passengers. On the following morning Python arrived, the boats were hoisted
aboard, and soon afterwards the survivors of A tlantis were eating their first meal in
days. Because the peace time passenger accommodation on Python was already in use,
the only accommodation for the A tlantis men was to use make shift mattresses in the
number two hold; while the crew of the Python gave up as much of their clothing and
bedding as they could to make their counterparts as comfortable as possible. Kapitan
Rogge had sailed on the Python before; indeed, during the coronation year of 1937, he
had taken passage on the ship to the UK when she was owned by the African Fruit
Company. He even got his old cabin back. But worse was to come for the A tlantis men!
On 30 November 1941 Python was ordered to replenish U-68 (Commander Merten) and

235
U-A (Commander Eckerman) in position 23-57' S and 3-55'W. After that she was to
return to Germany with her survivors. Although U-68 arrived on time the other U-Boat
U-A was 24 hours late. That late arrival was something which later led to dire
consequences and the loss of Python.
During the afternoon watch on 1 December 1941, U-68 was in the process of completing
the belated loading of her stores, when the mast-head lookout of Python reported a three
funnelled cruiser nineteen miles distant. That ship which later turned out to be HMS
Dorsetshire was in fact a sister ship to Devonshire! Operations were suspended between
Python and U-68, the hose lines retrieved, and because there wasnt time to load them
back on board, the boats in the water were cast off. At that particular time U-68 had her
hatch open and the last torpedo to be loaded was halfway in; a scrambled effort was
made to complete its loading before the U-Boat could make an emergency dive, and that
left an amount of stores on its casing to be lost. The U-A which was loading fuel on the
other side dived. Python steered a course to the North East at her maximum speed. But
on opening up with her engines flat out, huge palls of smoke emitted from the former
fruit boats funnel. On seeing the smoke the moderately moving cruiser quickly became
a fast moving cruiser, altered course towards the smoke and closed the scene at speed.
Pythons captain steered a deliberate course in order for the submarines to get into a
position where they could fire torpedoes at the approaching cruiser - it was part of their
training! But Dorsetshires Captain Augustus Agar had received the same training, and
while he was out of any 5.9 guns he circled the suspicious ship in varying figures of
eight at top speed while keeping well out of range. Having a shot in the dark the U-A did
manage to fire five torpedoes at the distant cruiser in a spread. Those tin fish travel at
44 knots,12 knots more than their intended target, but they all missed or were dodged.
From a range of eleven miles two eight inch shells fired from Dorsetshire immediately
found their range, one ahead and one astern. It was more or less a call for identification,
or a directive which quite simply meant, If you are an Axis ship - scuttle now to save
life and limb - or be sunk. To heighten Dorsetshires suspicions, a smoke screen can
was inadvertently set off on Python, and the cruiser sent her Walrus up to make further
investigations. But on seeing the two eight inch shells hit the water, it was one of the
Python ratings who started the smoke screen without being given an order from the
bridge, and that was what aroused HMS Dorsetshires captain suspicions even further.

236
When a smoke screen is laid it is usually made by a warship, which via the bridge
telegraph, orders the engine room to make smoke. The smoke comes out through
the funnel. But in the case of Python the smoke canisters were on the after deck.

Nevertheless there was no point in arguing as far as the German ship was concerned and
the two shell message was heeded. It wasnt long before the Walrus which was buzzing
around Python, reported that after scuttling her crew had taken to the boats, and their
ship with a port list was going down by the stern . Without any further ado, Dorsetshire
departed as quickly as she had arrived and was seen no more.
The 414 man crews of both Python and A tlantis took refuge in eleven boats of varying
sizes plus seven rafts. U-A which had been watching helpless was the first to surface
and was quickly followed by U-68. But both had to dive when the cruisers Walrus
returned to investigate the situation, and probably to count how many boats were in the
water. After that nothing more was seen of the cruiser or its seaplane. A roll call
revealed that in the sinking of Python not a single man was missing. Because he was the
senior officer Kapitan Rogge assumed command of the situation and boarded U-68.
The rafts were placed on the submarines decks, 100 men were assigned to each U-Boat,
while both subs towed five boats each. The galleys on both subs were going non stop,
and one of the motor boats was continuously buzzing around with food for the men in
the boats. Once again the towing lines were problematic with them carrying away in the
swell as the flotilla made for land.
On the following day of 2 December U-68 sighted a merchant ship, but Kapitan Merten
decided to take no action due to his enlarged compliment. But when Kapitan Eckerman
of U-A saw a loaded tanker he couldnt resist. Casting off the boats he gave chase, but
later in the afternoon came back empty handed. On hearing of the catastrophe SKL
ordered U-129 (Kapitan Leutenant Nico Clausen) and U-124 (Kapitan Leutenant
Jochen Mohr) to the scene in order to help out in whatever way they could. As a result
the men were transferred from the boats into the submarines while the life rafts and
boats were scuttled. On 6 December 1941 a course was set for France.
Needless to say, all four submarines which were packed to the limit, were quite unable
to carry out the duties for which they were designed. It was a most laborious passage,
and conditions for all aboard the four submarines were unbearable as men who were
237
packed to the limit had to sleep standing up. Between 13 and 17 December when all four
U-Boats had reached the Cape Verdes, they were met by four Italian submarines which
were sent to assist. Between them they took 260 passengers from the grossly
overcrowded U-Boats. The eight submarines then headed for St Nazaire where they
arrived between 25 and 29 December 1941.

On New Years Day1942 the crew of A tlantis, who had by that time been completely
kitted out, mustered before Grand Admiral Erich Raeder at St Nazaire. In that parade he
personally decorated each and every member of the Atlantis crew. The ceremony was
ended when Kapitan Rogge addressed his men for the last time. Needless to say, he
thanked them all for their valiant service of almost two years in the most harrowing of
circumstances. They were all awarded two months leave, and told to report to Naval HQ
Wilhelmshaven when their leave had ended. His final order which did indeed end the
career of A tlantis, was with his men fell in three deep before him, Kapitan Rogge
brought them to attention and gave them that final and almost forlorn order -
Atlantis ships company - Dismiss. - It was the end!
Such an order from their valiant captain must have left a lump in the throat of every
man present. For their they stood amidst a group of equally valiant men, men with
whom theyd been ship-mates through the most trying of circumstances in a two year
ordeal. Indeed, each and every member of the crew had suffered the great hardships of
excessive heat, cold, hunger and great privation but now they were ship-mates no more.
Two months later when their leave had ended every man of the crew was promoted up
one notch; most of whom became petty officers. Kapitan Rogge was promoted to
Konteradmiral Rogge (rear admiral) and two years later on 1 March 1943 he attained
the rank of vise admiral. On 7 May 1945 when the war had ended, and with regard to
Germanys surrender terms, Vizeadmiral Rogge was at Copenhagen with his flag flying
on board the heavy cruiser Prinz Eugen. On 8 May two British warships arrived at
Copenhagen to accept the surrender and take control of the heavy cruiser. One of them
was HMS Devonshire.!!!
.

238
 Sister Ships of Atlantis

Before the start of WW2, Goldenfels was one of seven newly built sister ships, with
another of those ships being the Kandenfels, a similar15 knot motor vessel which to the
Germans, became the heroic and much acclaimed surface raider Pinguin. While yet
another of those fast modern motor ships under the command of Kapitan Steuer had
been named Tannenfels. But that latter ship had not joined Goldenfels or Kandenfels in
being converted to surface raiders, shed been holed up at Kismayu, Somaliland since
the war began.
Shortly before the outbreak of WW2 all German merchant ships had been ordered to
return home with their cargoes; if that was not possible due to a shortage of fuel or being
blockaded, they were to seek sanctuary in a neutral port. Therefore, Tannenfels and the
cargo ship Uckermark which were two of those blockaded ships, had been lying idle and
empty for 16 months at the neutral port of Kismayu in Italian Somaliland. When the war
began Italian Somaliland was neutral. But Mussolini must have been contemplating on
which side to give his support. Italy had been on the side of Britain in the previous war,
but with the fall of France in June 1940, it looked increasingly likely that the Germans
who held the upper hand would quickly win the war. Therefore, because he wanted to be
on the winning side and win great acclaim from his people, Mussolini, or El Duce as
he called himself, chose to side up with the Axis - little realising that three years later in
July 1943, his own people would have removed him from power, and less than two
years after that, in April 1945, those same people would have executed him by hanging
him upside down from a lamp post. Indeed, the cowardly Benito Mussolini had backed
the wrong horse!
However, at Somaliland in 1941, the authorities looked at Germany with great disdain.
They didnt want to be part of any war no matter who was winning, and that point was
proved when they treated Leutenant Dehnel and his prize crew from the SS Durmitor
like prisoners; and neither did the Somalis offer any special preferences to the crews of
the blockaded German ships. The crews of Tannenfels and Uckermark felt the same

239
for the Italians who ruled Somaliland; they would much rather have sailed away from
the place and chance their luck by running the British blockade.
But because Tannenfels had been moored idle for 16 months, shed been slowly
growing an accumulation of weeds and barnacles on her underwater hull. Sixteen
months in Kismayu, and a further fourteen months before that since her last dry-
docking, meant it had been two and a half years since shed had a bottom scrape.
If and when she did get out to sea her speed would be greatly reduced; that large
expanse of weed on her bottom would act like a huge sponge, because as well as its own
weight and the friction it would cause, it would also hold many tons of water - all extra
weight for the ship to drag around with it. However, because the Allied forces were
closing in on Kismayu, and if the German ships did not sail soon, they would either
have to scuttle or be captured. In view of any future adversity, it was on 30 January
1941 that Kapitan Steuer of Tannenfels received orders from SKL to leave Kismayu and
rendezvous with A tlantis in the Indian Ocean. By that time Leutenant Dehnel and his
prize crew from the SS Durmitor had taken refuge aboard the Tannenfels.
Kapitan Steuer had no armament on his ship whatsoever, so in order to make it look like
he was an AMC, and hopefully deter any British AMCs from approaching him with
menace, he instructed his First Mate Paul Schneidewind, to manufacture a number of
make believe guns out of timber and tarpaulins then dot them around the ship. Quite
unlike A tlantis or Pinguin which had their guns concealed, the dummy guns of
Tannenfels when fitted, were quite openly displayed for any Allied ships to see.
During the hours of darkness on 31 January 1941, Tannenfels slipped out of Kismayu to
link up with A tlantis in a predetermined coded area of the Arabian Sea. Due to some
unforeseen problem in her engine room, the cargo ship Uckermark did not leave
Kismayu for another fourteen days. But on board Tannenfels, it so happened that during
the following ten days while he was on his way to meet A tlantis, the only ships that
Kapitan Steuer saw were a tanker and an AMC escort, so without any fuss he slid away
from them. In the meantime, Leutenant Breuers accompanied by ten armed men formed
a prize crew for the Speybank; Breuers was told to proceed to the Saya de Malha Bank
in 10 S - 63 E and await further instructions. Arriving in the South Atlantic at the
required position to pick up her fresh food supplies on 16 April 1941, it was then
discovered that things had not gone to plan.

240
Top; the German Kormoran, she sank HMAS Sydney with the loss of the cruisers 645 crew

Bottom; HMAS Sydney sank the Kormoran in the same engagement.

241
Some views of HMS Devonshire and her crew.

242
There were fifty A tlantis survivors inside the U-126, and a further fifty that can be seen
on the casing The rest were being towed in the boats and rafts. The motor boats were
kept busy shuttling between them with food.

243
Top - After the boats had been assembled the tow began with 100 survivors boarding
U-126. The boats that had sails used them as umbrellas as protection from the sun.
The U-Boat towed eight boats on makeshift painter ropes, but the sudden jerking in the
light swell caused many of those towropes to carry away.

244
After Atlantis had been sunk, the survivors had to fend for themselves in boats and
rafts. It took two hours for them all to assemble, whereupon Kapitan Rogge addressed
them all and conducted a head count. After a consultation it was decided that they
should take a tow from U-126 to Pernambuco which was an estimated 950 miles to the
west.

245
 Top - Admiral Lindau addresses the
survivors who arrived on one of the
submarines

Left - On arrival at St Nazaire, Ulrich

Mohr on the left bids farewell to two of
the Italian submariners. Theyd been his
ship mates in cramped conditions for
three weeks.

246
Kapitan Rogge addressing his crew at St Nazaire

As the Atlantis sank and the crew took to the boats, there was neither the time nor
the space in the boats for anyone to collect any of their belongings. As a result of
that, and as the above photograph shows, they survived the ordeal in just what they
were wearing at the time. Even their captain who stands before them on the deck
of U-68, is still dressed in his normal bridge gear. The crew were all given two
months leave, when during which time the survivors were kitted out.

247
But at a later date when the survivors had been re-supplied with uniforms, Kapitan
Rogge pins medals to the chests of his crew.

Kapitan Rogge addresses his crew for

the last time before he gives them his
final order.

Atlantis ships company dismiss.

248
Robert Don Oliver Captain of HMS Devonshire, Born at Linton Roxburghshire 17 March
1895 he joined the RN in 1912. As a midshipman he took part in the Battle of the Falklands
in 1914 and at Gallipoli in 1915.
Promoted to Captain 1939 he commanded HM Ships Iron Duke, Devonshire, Excellent and
Swiftsure. Awards - CB, CBE, DSC, DL - Retired as Vice Admiral in 1948. At the age of 85,
Admiral Oliver died at Kelso, Roxburghshire, on 6 October 1980.
249
Bernhard Rogge the Commander of the Atlantis. Promoted to the rank of Vise
Admiral in 1945 he later became a senior figure in NATO.

After the war he opened a nautical instrument shop in Hamburg where he was often
visited by both his former crew and prisoners.

250
Kapitan Bernhard Rogge was treated with the greatest of respect by the
Allies. It was because he abided by the Rules of War that he never faced any
war crimes.

251
 Atlantis Casualties

One remarkable aspect about the raider Atlantis, was of all the men who served in her
for the best part of two years, and despite the many trials and tribulations they had gone
through, there were only eleven men on the ship who lost their lives.

Martin Jester - who died of heat exhaustion in the Indian Ocean.

Bernhard Herrmannwho died after an on board accident at the Kerguelans Islands.

Karl Seeger - killed on board the captured Norwegian ship Tirranna, when that ship was
torpedoed by the British submarine HMS Tuna.

Tonni Dettenhofer - Horst Gerstenhauer - Willi Krooss - and Johan Schafer, all of
whom were killed when A tlantis was shelled and sunk by HMS Devonshire.

Heinz Muller - Sucked down with Atlantis when she sank.

Otto Vorwergk - Lost overboard from one of the life boats.

Erst Felchner and Emil Buhrle - Died from their injuries whilst they were in the life
boats.

252
253