6/5/2017 Whenscholarsofcoloraren'tconsideredexpertsonissuesfacingblackAmerica|EducationDive

RIF

Whencholarofcoloraren't

conideredexpertoniue

facinglackAmerica

AutumnA.ArnettMa31,2017

Diverief:

TheJournalofPoliticalPhilosophrecentlpulisheda60-
page,three-authorarticleonthelackLivesMatter
movementutnoneoftheauthorswerelack,accordingto
reportingInsideHigherd.

OpenlettershavesurfacedfromprofessorsatYaleandUCLA
decringthe"distaste"ofthejournal'sdecisiontopulishthe
"smposium"withouthavinganlackscholarsinvolvedwho
couldproperlcontextualizethemovementandits
surroundingethicalprinciples.

AfurtherinvestigationYale'sChristopherLeronfoundthe
journalhasnotinitshistorpulishedanarticlesonraceor
otherwisepulishedworkslackauthors.

DiveInsight:

Thisdevelopmentisareminderthatpoliciesstillremaininmanareasof
higheredthatpreventscholarsofcolorfromadvancingthroughthe
academrecentdatahasshownonl6%offacultnationwideare
lack,4%Hispanicand10%AsianorPacicIslander.Amongfull-time
facult,onl3%arelack,3%Hispanic,and9%Asian/PacicIslander.

http://www.educationdive.com/news/whenscholarsofcolorarentconsideredexpertsonissuesfacingblackame/443883/ 1/3
6/5/2017 Whenscholarsofcoloraren'tconsideredexpertsonissuesfacingblackAmerica|EducationDive

utevenmorethanthat,itisareminderthatatalllevelsofschooling,
populationsoftenmostaectedareleftoutofconversationsaouthow
tosolveprolemstheface.Onissuesofraceandculturalcompetenc,
toooftenitisexpertsofothercultureswhoareroughtintoconsultand
provideexpertcommentarandtraining,whilethevoicesofstudents,
staandadministratorsofcolorremainsilenced.Discussionsaout
what'sestforschoolsandlearningoftenhappenwaaovethe
individualschoollevelanddon'tincludeteachers.Increasingl,facult
memers,fewerandfewerofwhomarefull-timeortenure-track,areleft
outofdiscussionsaoutcurriculum.

Theiggesttakeawafromthisjournalfauxpasistheneedtoensure
thatawiderangeofvoicesnotonlhaveaseatatthetalewhere
discussionsareeinghad,uttheirvoicesareheardandrespected.And
eondthat,toresisttheurgetorelsolelontheexpertiseof
individualswhomahavestudiedanissueutwholackthelived
experiencesoftheindividualsaected.

RecommendedReading:

InsideHigherd
AnalzinglackLiveMa erwithoutlackpeopleinvolved

FollowAutumnA.ArnettonTwitter

MOTPOPULAR

1 CollegepresidentspledgetoupholdParisClimate
Agreement
June05

2 Connectingstudentstotheinstitutionthroughmentors
oostssuccess
June05

3 Whenscholarsofcoloraren'tconsideredexpertson
issuesfacinglackAmerica
Ma31

http://www.educationdive.com/news/whenscholarsofcolorarentconsideredexpertsonissuesfacingblackame/443883/ 2/3
6/5/2017 Whenscholarsofcoloraren'tconsideredexpertsonissuesfacingblackAmerica|EducationDive

4 FATUR
ArmedForcesseeTMeducationasensuringa
rightfuture
Ma30

5 Howshouldeducatorseginuildingtheschoolsof
thefuture?
June02

TAFFPICK

The2016DiveAwardsforhighereducation

The2016DiveAwardsforK-12education

potlightonliterac:Whateducatorsneedtoknow

uccessionplanningandtheexecutivesearch:A'oth-and'
proposition

These7trendsareshapingpersonalizedlearning

http://www.educationdive.com/news/whenscholarsofcolorarentconsideredexpertsonissuesfacingblackame/443883/ 3/3