Sei sulla pagina 1di 14

Sedimentology (1995) 42, 147-160

Stable isotope evidence for the origin of diagenetic carbonate


minerals from the Lower Jurassic Inmar Formation, southern
Israel
AVNER AYALON" and FRED J . L O N G S T A F F E t
*Geological Survey of Israel, 30 Malkhe Yisrael Street, Jerusalem 95501, Israel
?Department of Earth Sciences, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada N6A 5B7

ABSTRACT
The oxygen isotope compositions of diagenetic carbonate minerals from the Lower
Jurassic Inmar Formation, southern Israel, have been used to identify porewater
types during diagenesis. Changes in porewater composition can be related to major
geological events within southern Israel. In particular, saline brines played an
important role in late (Pliocene-Pleistocene) dolomitization of these rocks.
Diagenetic carbonates included early siderite (6180,Mow= + 24.4 to + 26-5%0;
613CpD13= - 1-1to +0.8%0),late dolomite, ferroan dolomite and ankerite
(6180sMOW=+18.4 to +25.8%,,;613CpDB= - 2 - 1 to +o.z%~),and calcite
(6180sM,w=+21~3 to +32.6%0; S13CpDB=- 4.2 to +3.2%0). The petrographic and
isotopic results suggest that siderite formed early in the diagenetic history at
shallow depths. The dolomitic phases formed at greater depths late in diagenesis.
Crystallization of secondary calcite spans early to late diagenesis, consistent with
its large range in isotopic values.
A strong negative correlation exists between burial depth (temperature) and the
oxygen isotopic compositions of the dolomitic cements. In addition, the 6l80 values
of the dolomitic phases in the northern Negev and Judea Mountains are in isotopic
equilibrium with present formation waters. This behaviour suggests that formation
of secondary dolomite post-dates the tectonic activity responsible for the present
relief of southern Israel (Upper Miocene to Pliocene) and that the dolomite
crystallized from present formation waters. Such is not the case in the Central
Negev. In that locality, present formation waters have much lower salinities and
6 l 8 0 values, indicating invasion of freshwater, and are out of isotopic equilibrium
with secondary dolomite. Recharge of the Inmar Formation by meteoric water in the
Central Negev occurred in the Pleistocene, and halted formation of dolomite.

INTRODUCTION Diagenetic minerals normally acquire oxygen


isotope compositions that reflect the temperature
This paper presents mineralogical, petrographic and porewater involved in their crystallization.
and oxygen and carbon isotope data for diagenetic At temperatures typical of sedimentary environ-
carbonate minerals from the Lower Jurassic Inmar ments, most minerals retain this isotopic signa-
Formation in southern Israel, and interprets these ture because significant post-crystallization,
results in terms of the burial history and pore- isotopic exchange with water is uncommon
water evolution experienced by these rocks. In (Longstaffe, 1983; O'Neil, 1987). However, be-
particular, we address the origin and evolution of cause of its greater susceptibility to recrystalliza-
secondary dolomite, which is the most pervasive tion, calcite [and, to a lesser extent, dolomite) can
and abundant carbonate cement in subsurface be affected by post-formational isotopic exchange
sandstones of the Inmar Formation. at lower temperatures than silicate minerals
147
148 A. Ayulon and F. J. Longstaffe

- 31 30'

, 31

- 3030'

I I
m
m 1
m
I I
I
II I
I
I Fig. 1. Map of sampling locations
34O 34030' 35O 35O30' and study area.

(Clayton, 1959). Nevertheless, in most sedimen- (mostly clastic sedimentary rocks up to 337 m
tary systems, diagenetic carbonate minerals still thick; Goldberg, 1970). The formation thickens
retain a valuable isotopic record of the porewater towards the north-western Negev Desert, and
origin, the source of carbon and the temperature at wedges out eastward. Near the Dead Sea, the
that stage of diagenesis, all of which are useful Inmar Formation is absent, either as a result of
insights into the geological and hydrogeological non-deposition or because of later erosion
history of the basin. (Goldberg & Friedman, 1974).
The Lower and Upper members consist of inter-
bedded sandstone, siltstone, shale, limestone and
GEOLOGICAL B A C K G R O U N D dolomite. Sandstone, ranging in grain size from
very fine sand to fine gravel, is the dominant rock
type. On the whole, the Lower Member tends to
Stratigraphy and sedimentology
be finer grained than the Upper Member. Organic
The Lower Jurassic (Middle Liassic to Early matter and carbonaceous plant remains can be
Bajocian) Inmar Formation occurs in outcrops in abundant. Pyrite and siderite are ubiquitous, and
the northern Sinai (Gebel Maghara) and the are particularly abundant where associated with
Central Negev (Makhtesh Ramon), and subsurface shaley portions of the Inmar Formation. Besides
sections in southern Israel (Negev region) the abundant diagenetic carbonate minerals that
(Goldberg, 1970; Fig. I). It overlies the Upper are the focus of this paper, sandstones from both
Carbonate Member of the Ardon Formation the Upper and Lower members contain many
(Lower Liassic) and is overlain by the Daya other diagenetic phases, including clay minerals,
Formation (Bajocian; Fig. 2). The Inmar For- silica, evaporites, oxides and hydroxides (Ayalon
mation consists of three members: the Lower & Longstaffe, in prep.).
Member (mostly clastic sedimentary rocks up to The Qeren Member, which separates the Lower
1 4 0 m thick); the Qeren Member (mostly lime- and Upper members, is composed mostly of lime-
stone up to 157 m thick) and the Upper Member stones (low-energy pelmicrites). Dolomites and
Carbonate minerals, southern Israel 149

LITHOLOGY Member limestone, and in particular the pelmi-


crite that dominates this unit, has been inter-
preted as a transgressive event during which
shallow-shelf carbonates were deposited in a low-
energy environment on top of the fluvial-deltaic
clastic sequence. Subsequent deposition of the
clastic rocks of the Upper Member represents a
return to dominantly fluvial-deltaic conditions
(Goldberg & Friedman, 1974). Post-Inmar For-
mation deposition was dominated by limestones,
intercalated with lesser amounts of sandstones
and shale (Fig. 2).

Tectonic and thermal history


During the Jurassic, the continental margin of the
Tethyan Sea (including the study area) was
IMMISHHoR F'.Ih
h h h h h h h h h h h h h h h h L h h h
h h h h h h h k h h Lh 4 h h L h h L 1 affected by block faulting and tensional tectonic
movements that were probably related to active
-
a 1 1 MOHILA F M . rifting and spreading of the central portions of the
Tethys Sea (Bernoulli, 1972). Freund et al. (1975)
K
L I A h h A h A h h h A h A h A h h A h h A
A h A h h h A A A h A h A h h h h A h h
suggested that this extensional structural regime
persisted until the Late Cretaceous. Extensional
regimes are commonly associated with high heat
Fig. 2. Schematic section of the Jurassic in southern flow (e.g. Spohn & Schubert, 1982), perhaps
Israel (modified after Goldberg & Friedman, 1974). explaining the high geothermal gradients reported
Legend: 1, limestone; 2 , dolostone; 3, evaporites; 4 , for the study area at that time. For example,
shale; 5, sandstone; 6, palaeosol.
Jurassic and Cretaceous 'thermal events' of short
duration (5-25 Myr), characterized by a high
terrigenous sediments (mainly sandstones) are thermal gradient (45-55"C km l), were postu-
~

uncommon within this unit. lated for the study area by Feinstein (1985),based
Deep weathering of Triassic evaporites and on vitrinite-reflectance measurements.
dolomites that had formed in a broad, sea- Orogenic activity responsible for uplift and
marginal flat began in the Jurassic. During subse- folding in the study area began in the Late
quent subsidence, the ensuing shallow shelf Cretaceous and culminated during the Late
conditions allowed widespread development of Tertiary (Bentor & Vroman, 1954; Picard, 1959;
sabkhas and, in places, deposition of lagoonal Freund et al., 1975). This transition from a
sediments (Ardon Formation; Fig. 2) under arid, regional, extensional regime to a compressional
tropical conditions (Goldberg & Friedman, 1974). regime led to the development of the Syrian Arc,
Inmar sedimentation was initiated by a marked and was also manifested by a change from high to
progradation during which the shallow shelf low geothermal gradients (max. 22C km ') ~

deposits of the Ardon Formation were buried within the study area (De Sitter, 1962; Freund et
beneath a continental, fluvial-deltaic complex. al., 1975; Erickson et al., 1977; Garfunkel, 1981;
These sands were derived from the Arabo-Nubian Feinstein, 1985). Vitrinite reflectance and fission
shield, south of the Negev. Despite minor fluctua- track data suggest that this gradient persisted
tions in sea level during deposition, the rocks of throughout the Tertiary to the present time
the Lower Member were deposited almost exclu- (Feinstein, 1985). Such values are characteristic
sively under fluvial conditions. The occurrence of of present-day southern Israel and the eastern
large tree trunks, the widespread distribution of Mediterranean in general (Erickson et al., 1977).
plant remains and carbonaceous organic matter, Erosion has variably reduced the thickness of
and the cycles of alternating shale and sandstone the sedimentary section since post-Jurassic time.
beds suggest that swamps and small lakes were The Jurassic-Cretaceous unconformity represents
part of this fluvial system, and that humid, tropi- erosion of several hundreds of metres of Jurassic
cal conditions prevailed at that time (Goldberg through Cambrian sediments in some localities
& Friedman, 1974). Deposition of the Qeren (Zak, 1957; Bentor, 1960; Druckman, 1974).
150 A. Ayalon and F. J. Longstaffe

Garfunkel & Derin (1988) reported that Early brines are saturated with respect to dolomite
Cretaceous erosion removed at least 500-700 m (Starinsky, 1974). However, because critical data
of section in Makhtesh Ramon (Fig. l),a c. 15-km- for the brines are lacking (e.g. pCO,, alkalinity),
wide domal uplift associated with Early this cannot be properly tested using geochemical
Cretaceous intrusive magmatism in the Negev modelling.
Desert. Miocene or post-Miocene erosion varying Nativ (1984) found no correlations among salin-
from 600m at the Northern Negev to 2400m at ity, isotopic composition of formation water,
the Central Negev has been suggested by Petersen depth, lithology or formation within the Jurassic
( 1980). aquifer. Instead, the prevailing factor dictating
water composition was geographical location.
Ca-chloride brines (30 000-130 000 mg C11- ')
Chemistry of formation waters in Jurassic
enriched in l80are present in the Negev to the
units
west; fresher water (800-10 000 mg C11- I),
The chemistry and Sr, H and 0 isotopic composi- depleted of '*O, is present to the east.
tions of formation waters contained in Jurassic
rocks of southern Israel (the 'Jurassic aquifer')
have been studied by Bentor (1969), Starinsky ANALYTICAL METHODS
(1974), Fleischer et al. (1977), Starinsky &
Katz (1978), Sass & Starinsky (1979), Issar (1979, Fifteen outcrop samples from the Gebel Maghara
1981), Starinsky et al. (1983) and Nativ (1984). area (northern Sinai) and 31 core-samples from
These formation waters are characterized by Negev boreholes have been examined (Fig. 1).
Ca/(HCO,- +SO,2 - ) > I and Na/C1<1 (equiva- Subsurface material has been analysed from the
lents), and can be classified as Ca-chloride brines following boreholes: Qeren 1,Hazerim 1 and Beer
(Lerman, 1970; Levy, 1972). Chemical, isotopic Sheva 1 in the northern Negev; Dabeshet 1 and
and temperature data available for waters from Tsia 1 in the Judea Mountains; Daya 1 and Barbur
boreholes studied in the present work are sum- 1in the Central Negev; and Makhtesh Qatan 1 and
marized in Table 1 from Starinsky (1974), Makhtesh Qatan 2 in the South-Central Negev
Fleischer et al. (1977), Starinsky & Katz (1978) (Fig. 1). The mineralogy and petrology of the
and Nativ (1984). samples were studied using optical microscopy,
Starinsky (1974) defined two major groups of scanning electron microscopy, energy-dispersive
these Ca-chloride brines, C and R, in southern spectrometry and X-ray diffraction (XRD). Oxygen
Israel. Group C has an mNalmC1 ratio similar to and carbon isotope analyses of the carbonate
seawater (c. 0.86) and is present to depths of minerals were also completed.
about 1-2 km. Group R, the deeper formation The carbonate mineralogy is summarized in
waters, consists of brines whose mNalmC1 ratio is Table 2. Carbonate mineral abundances were cal-
lower than that of seawater. Starinsky (1974) culated using CO,, Mg and XRD measurements.
suggested that the Ca-chloride brines developed Carbon (and total CO,) contents were determined
in three stages: (i) surface evaporation of seawater for c. 250-mg powder samples using a LECO
(the Na/Cl ratio was used to assume that evapora- carbon analyser furnace with 0, flow and an
tion of group R exceeded halite saturation infra-red (IR) detector, calibrated using a CaCO,
whereas group C remained below halite satura- standard. Mg content was determined by atomic
tion); (ii) brine-sediment reactions, migration of absorption spectrometry (AAS) following dissolu-
brine into surrounding rocks and dolomitization tion in hot 1:1 HC1. Given the value for total
of calcite and aragonite (see also Sass 8 Starinsky, carbonate, XRD calibration curves for calcite and
1979); and (iii) dilution of the brines by fresh- dolomite/ankerite were then used to determine
water and(or) seawater. Starinksy & Katz (1978) the relative abundance of each phase.
proposed that Group R brines evolved from The stable isotope data are presented in Table 3
Pliocene seawater (in the vicinity of the Dead using the normal &notation relative to SMOW for
Sea). Prior to Pliocene-Pleistocene tectonic uplift, oxygen (Craig, 1961) and PDB for carbon (Craig,
they migrated into deeper portions of the geologi- 1957). An oxygen isotope C0,-H,O fractionation
cal section in a westerly direction, at least as far factor of 1-0412 at 25C was used to calibrate the
as the present coast of the Mediterranean Sea. mass-spectrometer working gas. To calculate the
This stage of fluid migration was driven by the oxygen isotope results for calcite and dolomite,
Messinian dessication of the Mediterranean Sea. values of 1.01025 and 1.01110, respectively, were
It is reasonable to assume that these Ca-chloride employed for the total carbonate C0,-phosphoric
Table 1. Composition of waters in Jurassic formations.
Depth Na K Ca c1 SO, HCO, Br TDS 6D 6'*O Tem erature Refer-
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I)
Well (m) Stratigraphy (mg 1 '1 (mg 1 - '1 ( m p '1 (mg 1 '1 (mg 1 ') (mg 1 '1 (mg 1 - ') (mg 1 (g 1 I ) (%o)* (%)* ?C)t enceS

Beer-Sheva 1 2740-2782 Inmar Fm. 41400 705 2190 14400 91194 530 214 690 151 - 10.6 0.47 75.6 1
Qeren 1 2463-2501 Inmar Fm. 40900 774 1890 14400 94100 464 102 153 67 1
Qeren 1 2503-2520 Inmar Fm. 44400 615 1732 15150 99264 500 115 756 162 79 1
Qeren 1 2520-2 534 Inmar Fm. 44400 598 1730 15050 98867 502 64 750 161 68 1
Qeren 1 2541-2 566 Inmar Fm. 42792 946 1462 15610 98210 515 158 802 160 69 1
Qeren 1 2566-2567 Inmar Fm. 39123 665 1338 14380 89582 624 61 146 - 4.5 0.49 2
Qeren 1 2689-2700 Inmar Fm. 41634 992 1585 15407 96327 494 152 745 157 1
Qeren 1 2700-2708 Inmar Fm. 41256 988 1587 15204 95414 491 131 719 155 84 1
Qeren 1 2708-2719 Inmar Fm. 41256 1012 1585 15407 95764 497 158 733 156 84 1
~
Qeren 1 2845-2846 Inmar Fm. 39928 805 1277 15560 92454 528 61 151 0.96 104 2
Qeren 1 291 9-2935 Inmar Fm. 42676 1080 2094 15570 99627 505 146 816 162 100 1
Qeren 1 2972-2992 Inmar Fm. 46199 2149 16580 105283 461 195 171 104 1
Hazerim 1 3146-3165 Inmar Fm. 21050 640 865 7830 53680 361 84 4
~
Tsia 1 1638 Zohar Fm. 12949 137 280 740 22050 1104 122 38 3.93
~
Tsia 1 1665 Zohar Fm. 10304 117 109 180 16484 1152 183 29 - 20.4 3.71
Tsia 1 1790 Sherif Fin. 6680 117 213 1127 11470 1609 210 21 1
Tsia 1 2441 Inmar Fm. 70
Daya 1 1080-1083 Zohar Fm. 10380 99 219 1600 18490 165 31 - 45.0 - 5.26
~
Daya 1 1 333-1 354 Sherif Fm. 2208 36 160 2198 1776 427 7 - 53.0 8.12
~
Daya 1 1422-1444 Sherif Fm. 2829 12 80 2162 2400 1037 8 - 45.8 8.45
Daya 1 1844-1856 Inmar Fm. 805 85 580 1170 1584 305 4 - 7.73 60 2
~
Barbur 1 1299-1335 Sherif Fm. 1794 47 24 20 2021 1056 366 5 4.76 46 2
Barbur 1 1407-1446 Sherif Fm. 1288 63 49 20 1276 1200 122 4 - 5.22 2
Barbur 1 1452-1482 Daya Fm. 1725 59 36 40 1489 1680 61 5 - 45.8 - 6.82 2
~
Barbur 1 1517-1562 Daya Fm. 1081 63 12 460 1347 1488 183 5 - 39.8 6.04 2
Barbur 1 1778-1780 Inmar Fm. 2100 56 3

*The isotopic compositions of the formation waters are taken from Fleischer et al. (1977).
tBorehole measurements of groundwater temperatures are unreliable, mainly because of thermal disequilibrium in the borehole durin the measurement, and the cooling effects of the
drilling mud and filtrate. Usually the measured temperatures are lower than those existing in the aquifer (Eckstein, 1975) and they siould be considered as minimum temperatures.
$1, Starinsky (1974); 2, Fleischer et al. (1977); 3, Nativ (1984); 4 , Starinsky L Katz (1978).
152 A. Ayalon and F. J. Longstaffe
Table 2. Percentage of carbonate minerals, Inmar Formation.
Dolomite
Sample Depth Rock Calcite + ankerite Siderite
No. Well (4 Member type (% 1 (%I (%I
Al-1 Barbur 1 1588 Upper Mbr. Csst 0.5 2-9
A1-2 Barbur 1 1589 Upper Mbr. Msst 0.7 4.2
A1-3 Barbur 1 1624 Upper Mbr. Csst 11.5
A1-4 Barbur 1 1625 Upper Mbr. Msst 7.9
Al-5 Barbur 1 1683 Upper Mbr. Msst <0.2 18.6
A1-6 Barbur 1 1695 Upper Mbr. Fsst 0.2 4.2
A1-7 Barbur 1 1786 Lower Mbr. Msst
A1-8 Qeren 1 2567 Upper Mbr. Msst 1.8
A1-9 Qeren 1 2571 Upper Mbr. Fsst, shale >5
A1-10 Qeren 1 2881 Qeren Msst 2.7
Al-11 Qeren 1 2986 Lower Mbr. Msst 7.9
A1-12 Qeren 1 3007 Lower Mbr. Csst 3.8
A1-13 Hazerim 1 2740 Upper Mbr. Msst 12.5
A1-14 Hazerim 1 2742 Upper Mbr. Shale 10 to 20 (?) >5
A]-15 Hazerim 1 2927 Qeren Marine Lst 84.0 8.0 (An)
A]-16 Hazerim 1 3068 Lower Mbr. Msst 1.3
A]-17 Daya 1 1644 Upper Mbr. Shale >5
A1-18 Daya 1 1653 Upper Mbr. Msst 3.4
A1-19 Daya 1 1735 Upper Mbr. Csst 1.1
A1-20 Daya 1 1827 Lower Mbr. Msst
A1-24 Beer-Sheva 1 2634 Upper Mbr. Fsst 0.5 9.5 (An)
A1-25 Beer-Sheva 1 2705 Upper Mbr. Shale >5
A1-26 Beer-Sheva 1 2750 Upper Mbr. Msst <0.5
A]-27 Beer-Sheva 1 2794 Upper Mbr. Msst 0.5 40.0 (An)
A1-28 Dabeshet 1 2049 Upper Mbr. Shale
A1-29 Dabeshet 1 2048 Upper Mbr. Fsst 10.0
A1-30 Tsia 1 2454 Qeren Msst 2.1
A1-31 Tsia 1 2466 Lower Mbr. Shale 2 20 -4.0 (An)
A1-32 Makhtesh Qatan 1 651 Qeren Msst 5.4
A1-33 Makhtesh Qatan 2 484 Upper Mbr. Msst 3.8
A1-34 Makhtesh Qatan 2 488 Upper Mbr. Shale
A]-35 Gebel Maghara Upper Mbr. Fsst
A1-36
AI-37
Gebel Maghara
Gebel Maghara
Upper Mbr.
Upper Mbr.
Msst
Fsst
--0.4
0.4
36-0
A1-38 Gebel Maghara Upper Mbr. Msst 3.1
A1-39 Gebel Maghara Upper Mbr. Csst 21.8 33.4 (An)
A1-40 Gebel Maghara Upper Mbr. Msst 11.4
A1-41 Gebel Maghara Upper Mbr. Msst 13.6
A]-42 Gebel Maghara Qeren Sslst 56.3
A]-43 Gebel Maghara Qeren Vfsslst 85.8
A]-44 Gebel Maghara Qeren Cmsst 23.3 10.9 [An)
A1-45 Gebel Maghara Lower Mbr. Csst 2.0
AI-46
A1-47
Gebel Maghara
Gebel Maghara
Lower Mbr.
Lower Mbr.
Csst
Csst
-5
0.7
- 27.0 (?)(An)
A]-49 Gebel Maghara Lower Mbr. Msst % 20.0

~ ~~

An, mostly ankerite; Fsst, fine-grained sandstone; Msst, medium-grained sandstone; Csst, coarse-grained sandstone;
Lst, limestone; Sslst, sandy limestone - abundant fossil debris and faecal pellets; Vfsslst, very fine-grained sandy
limestone; Cmsst, calcareous, medium-grained sandstone.

acid extracted CO, fractionation factor (u) at not affect the discussion and conclusions that
25C (after Sharma & Clayton, 1965). The calcite (I follow.
was used in all calculations for siderite; the dolo- Carbonate minerals were prepared for isotopic
mite Q was used in all calculations for ankerite. analysis by reacting organic-free powdered rock
Using the siderite and ankerite values for Q samples (<44-pm size fraction) in anhydrous
reported by Rosenbaum & Sheppard (1986)would H,PO, at 25"C, following procedures described by
slightly lower the values reported here, but would Walters et al. (1972), modified after McCrea
Carbonate minerals, southern Israel 153
Table 3. Oxygen a n d carbon isotope compositions of diagenetic carbonate minerals, Inmar Formation.
Calcite Dolomitic phases" Siderite
Sample Depth d'80 61C P O 61C P O 613C
No. (4 (%o SMOW) (%o PDB) (%o SMOW) (%o PDB) (%o SMOW) (%oPDB)

Upper Mbr.
Al-1 1588 25.03 0.38 23.46 - 0.78
A1-2 1589 24.67 0.24 23.46 - 1.00
A1-3 1624 22.70 - 0.87
A1-4 1625 22.67 - 1.00
A1-5 1683 24.18 - 0.55 23.80 - 0.61
A1-6 1695 23.42 - 0.56
A1-8 2567 21.76 - 2.02
A1-9 2571 25.35 - 0.72
A1-13 2740 21.02 - 1.39
A1-14 2742 27.98 2.76 26.51 0.82
Al-17 1644
A1-18 1653 22.90 - 1.18
A1-19 1735 23.53 - 0.88
A1-24 2634 21.03 - 0.97
A1-25 2705 24.37 - 1.12
A1-26 2750 20.68 - 0.87
A1-27 2 794 21.46 - 1.23 20.37 - 1.37
A1-29 2048 21.78 0.20
A1-33 484 25.58 - 0.71
A1-35 29.23 0.00
A1-36 32.59 1-56
A1-3 7 24.09 - 0.64
A1-38 24.66 0.62
A1-39 26.80 - 0.91 21.08 - 0.92
A1-40 23.71 - 1.94
Al-41 22.30 - 4.21

Qeren Mbr.
Al-10 2881 19.80 0.06
A1-15 2927 23.07 1.12
A1-30 2454 21-07 - 0.68
A1-32 651 25.82 - 0.61
A1-42 23.13 - 1.31
A1-43 20.89 0.80
A]-44 23.54 - 0.04

Lower Mbr.
Al-11 2986 19.90 - 1.36
A1-12 3007 19.98 - 1.43
A1-16 3068 20.58 - 0.32
A1-31 2466 26.88 - 0-06
A1-45 32.10 2.53
A1-46 21.34 - 1.82 18.41 - 2.09
A1-4 7 29.96 3.18
A1-49 26.12 - 0.88

*Dolomite, ferroan dolomite and ankerite.

(1950) and Epstein et al. (1964), and using the dolomite-ankerite ratio in the sample was greater
following reaction times: calcite, 1 h; dolomite than 0.5. Results for dolomite and ankerite are
and ankerite, 10 days; siderite, 2 1 days. Because reported only when the calcite/dolomite-ankerite
of possible cross contamination of CO, gas pro- ratio was less than 0.7. NBS-20 gave an average
duced from calcite and dolomite/ankerite, results 6180sMOW= +26.50%0 and 613CpDB=- 1-17%0
for calcite are presented only when the calcite/ during these analyses.
154 A. Ayalon and F. J. Longstaffe

Fig. 3. SEM photomicrographs of diagenetic calcite cements from the Inmar Formation. (a) Late Mg- and Fe-rich
calcite (Gebel Maghara, Lower Member, A1-47). Such radiating aggregates of calcite crystals have partially filled
secondary porosity in earlier carbonate. Each calcite crystal is composed of fibrous crystallites, a texture typical of
Mg- and Fe-rich calcite. This is the last generation of secondary calcite observed in these rocks. (b) Dissolution of
early, massive calcite cement (Gebel Maghara, Lower Member, A1-49). The pitted surface of the calcite is not present
on later anhydrite (smooth crystal surfaces to the left and bottom of the photomicrograph, surrounding the calcite).
This episode of anhydrite crystallization post-dated calcite dissolution. (c) Massive, early, sparry calcite cementing
quartz grains (Gebel Maghara, Qeren Member, A1-44). Precompaction textures have been preserved among quartz
grains where this cement has persisted. (d) Later diagenetic, idiomorphic, low-Mg (and low-Fe) calcite piercing
earlier, fine-grained, calcite matrix (Hazerim 1, Qeren Member, A1-15). This calcite pre-dates the final calcite
generation illustrated in (a).

RESULTS (alunite, jarosite, anhydrite/gypsum, bassanite).


These minerals formed (or are forming) over the
The Inmar Formation has experienced a complex wide range of temperatures, burial depths and
diagenetic history, producing a wide range of formation water compositions that now character-
minerals whose presence and abundance vary ize different portions of the Inmar Formation.
widely depending on sample locality and burial Calcite and dolomite are the most abundant
depth (Ayalon & Longstaffe, in prep.). Siderite, carbonate cements in the Inmar Formation sand-
pyrite, calcite, chlorite, anhydrite and ankerite stones. Calcite is most common in outcrop
formed early in diagenesis, at shallow depths. samples whereas dolomite, ferroan dolomite and
Later, burial diagenetic phases include kaolinite, ankerite are most abundant in subsurface samples
quartz, dolomite, calcite, smectite, halloysite, (Table 2). In the sandstones, diagenetic calcite
illite and illitelsmectite. The latest diagenetic commonly occurs as a partial to complete replace-
minerals are calcite, ankerite, pyrite, Ti-, Fe- and ment of detrital grains, and also fills fractures in
Mn-oxides and hydroxides, halite and sulphates some clasts. Calcite also fills pores (Fig. 3a), in
Carbonate minerals. southern Israel 155
many cases coating previously crystallized diage- dolomite occurs with increasing burial depth and
netic clay minerals. In some samples, calcite with temperature from south-eastern to north-western
or without anhydrite are the final diagenetic Israel. Only the (early) ankerite from Gebel
phases, and completely occlude remaining poros- Maghara does not fit this pattern (Fig. 5).
ity. In other samples, dissolution of diagenetic
calcite and creation of secondary porosity have
been observed (Fig. 3b). The 6l80 values of the DISCUSSION
diagenetic calcite show considerable variation
and extend to significantly higher values than the Marine carbonate rocks normally have 613C
other carbonate minerals analysed (+21.3 to compositions of about O f 3 % 0 , as do cements
+32-6%,; Table 3). The 613C values for these derived by dissolution of pre-existing carbonate
samples range from - 4.2 to +3.2%0(Table 3). (Longstaffe, 1983,1989;Lundegard & Land, 1986).
The carbonates of the Qeren Member are domi- The 6C values of most carbonate minerals from
nated by fine-grained calcite, although dolomite the Inmar Formation ( - 4.2 to +3.2%0, average
can be important locally (e.g. sample A1-32, Table - 0.5%0for 47 samples, Table 3) suggest such an
2). Minor quantities of sparry (Fig. 3c) and origin, i.e. dominantly normal marine carbon res-
coarsely crystalline, late diagenetic (Fig. 3d) cal- ervoirs were involved in carbonate precipitation,
cite are also present in many samples. Compared especially for the marine calcite of the Qeren
with diagenetic calcite from the sandstones, the Member ( - 1.3 to + l . l % ) , the dolomitic cements
Qeren Member calcite has a relatively narrow ( - 2 - 1 to +0-2"/,) and siderite [ - 1.1 to +0.8%0).
range of 6l80 (+20.9 to +23.5%0)and dI3C ( - 1.3 However, the larger range obtained for diagenetic
to +l.l%O)values (Table 3). calcite from the Lower and Upper members of the
Diagenetic siderite is common only in shales of Inmar Formation ( - 4.2 to +3.2%0)suggests that a
the Inmar Formation, where it occurs together variable contribution was also made by carbon
with pyrite. Three samples from the northern derived from degradation of organic matter during
Negev have 6l80 and 6I3C values of +24.4 to burial.
+26-5%0and - 1.1 to +0.8%", respectively (Table The dl80 values of the siderite [+24.4 to
3). +26.5%0)from Inmar Formation shales are typical
Dolomite and ferroan dolomite/ankerite are of crystallization from evolved seawater at rela-
very common late diagenetic cements in subsur- tively low temperatures, after pyrite, early in the
face samples of the Inmar Formation sandstone, diagenetic history. By comparison, the wide range
occurring as pore-filling cement (Fig. 4a,b) and as in dl'O values of diagenetic calcite from both the
replacement of detrital grains (Fig. 4c) or pre- Upper and the Lower members requires a pro-
existing calcite. The dolomitic cements are some- longed interval of crystallization, consistent with
times coated by later anhydrite (Fig. 4d) and the range in carbon isotope compositions
calcite. By comparison, dolomitic cement is rare described earlier. Calcite formation began very
in outcrop samples from Gebel Maghara, and was early and continued throughout diagenesis, both
not observed in outcrop samples from Makhtesh before and after dolomite crystallization. The
Ramon (Summers, pers. comm.). Moreover, the highest values (up to +32.6%0)could reflect early
ankeritic cement that is locally abundant at Gebel calcite formation from evaporated seawater at low
Maghara is texturally very early, and unlike the temperatures (e.g. 6 ' ' 0 ~ , , . , ~up
~ ~to +3.7%0 at
late massive dolomitization that characterizes 25C). The lowest 6l80 values (+21.3%0)are com-
subsurface samples. patible with later calcite crystallization from
A narrow range of 613C values was obtained for brines of similar composition at the maximum
the dolomitic samples ( - 2 - 1 to +0.2%0; Table 3), temperatures recorded for current formation
regardless of sample location. In contrast, the 6 l 8 0 waters in the Inmar Formation (e.g. 104"C, Table
values of the late dolomitic cements (+18.4 to 1).Most calcite probably formed at intermediate
+25.8%0; Table 3) vary systematically with temperatures. For example, present formation
present burial depth and borehole temperature water at 2567 m depth in the Beer Sheva 1 bore-
(Fig. 5): South-Central Negev (30-35"C), +25.6
to +25.8%0;Central Negev (55-65"C), + 2 2 - 7 to
-
hole has a temperature of 76C and a 6'*0 value
of 0.47% (Table 1). Calcite from near this interval
+23.8'X0; Judea Mountains (65-75"C), +21.1 to has a 6l80 value of +21.5"/00(sample A1-27, Table
+21.8%0; northern Negev (80-100C), +19.8 3), consistent with oxygen isotopic equilibration
to +21.8%0. Figure 5 shows that a near linear under similar conditions. The d l 8 0 values of cal-
decrease in the oxygen isotope composition of cite from the limestones of the Qeren Member
156 A. Ayalon and F. J. Longstaffe

Fig. 4.Diagenetic dolomitic cements from the Inmar Formation. (a) Pore-filling, sparry, ferroan dolomite cementing
detrital quartz (Barbur 1,Upper Member, A1-5). The SEM photomicrograph illustrates the highly corroded surface of
quartz grains (lower left) in contact with dolomite cement, a feature that is typical of subsurface samples. (b) SEM
photomicrograph of sparry, massive, ferroan dolomite/ankerite (Qeren 1, Upper Member, A1-8). This dolomitic
cement typically fills pores and/or replaces earlier carbonates (both calcite and dolomite). (c) Thin-section
photomicrograph (cross-polarized light) of dolomite (Do) replacing quartz (Qz) (Barbur 1, Upper Member, A1-5). The
surfaces of detrital quartz grains have been highly corroded. Dolomitizing fluids also have penetrated grain centres
along microfractures (centre of photomicrograph). Quartz overgrowths (lowermost left hand corner) also have been
partially dissolved and replaced by secondary dolomite. Width of view=5 mm. (d) SEM photomicrograph of a
complex mixture of diagenetic cements replacing grains and filling pores (Barbur 1,Upper Member, A1-4): kaolinite,
upper right hand corner: ferroan dolomite (DO) overlying earlier mat of illite/smectite, centre; anhydrite (AN),centre
and left. This generation of anhydrite coats the secondary dolomite.

(+20.9 to +23.5'XU) are far too low to reflect pri- face temperatures and the dolomite-water oxygen
mary crystallization from seawater. Instead, these isotope geothermometer of Land (1983). Figure 6
results indicate that re-equilibration of calcite has shows that in the northern Negev (boreholes
occurred at higher temperatures during burial, Qeren 1, Hazerim 1, Beer-Sheva 1)and the Judea
and that substantial erosion has occurred to Mountains (boreholes Dabeshet 1, Tsia l ) , the
expose Qeren Member limestones at Gebel diagenetic dolomites are in oxygen isotopic equi-
Maghara (Fig. 1). librium with existing formation waters. The mod-
The inverse relationship between burial depth erately high Ca/Mg ratios of formation waters in
and 6l80 value of the late dolomitic cements (Fig. southern Israel (Table 1) have been previously
5) is explored further in Fig. 6 by a comparison attributed to dolomitization (Bentor, 1961;
between present formation water 6l80 values and Starinsky, 1974; Starinsky et al., 1983). Together,
those that can be calculated using the spread of these isotopic and chemical data provide strong
secondary dolomite 6' '0values, current subsur- evidence that the dolomite crystallized from these
Carbonate minerals, southern Israel 157

South-Central
Nezev
30-G"C
(boreholes 1 & 2)

Fig. 5. Burial depth versus 8'0


-- E 1500 Central Negev
55-65C
values of dolomite, ferroan 5n (boreholes 3 & 4
dolomite and ankerite, Inmar a" 2000
Formation. Sample localities are Judea Mountains
also given: boreholes 1 & 65-75OC
2=Makhtesh Qatan 1 & 2; (boreholes 5 & 6)
boreholes 3 & 4=Daya 1 & Barbar 1;
boreholes 5 & 6=Tsia 1 & Dabeshet Northern Negev
1;boreholes 7, 8 & 9=Qeren 1, 3000 80-1000c
(boreholes 7, 8 & 9)
Hazerim 1 & Beer Sheva 1. The
range of borehole temperatures
(calculated from downhole electric 3500 I . " ' I " " I " . ' I ' ' . a I . ' . ' I " ' -

logs) at sample depths for these 18 20 21 22 23 24 25 6


localities is also given. &I *O Ro (SMOW) of Dolomite

0-
Fig. 6. Comparison between the
oxygen isotope composition of
present formation water and the
fluid involved in dolomitization. 20 -
The shaded areas show the
measured range of formation water
6'"O values and the spread of
temperatures for the Inmar
-
E 40 -
Formation in the Northern Negev, E
the Judea Mountains and the *
Central Negev (from Fleischer et 2 Central Negev
a]., 1977; Nativ, 1984). The areas
enclosed by heavy lines indicate,
z
G
60-
+23.8) Judea
for current borehole temperatures, Mountains
the range of formation water P O 80 -
values calculated using the
maximum and minimum oxygen
isotope values obtained for
secondary dolomite (shown in 100 -
parentheses) from each locality.
The P O values for the
dolomitizing fluid were calculated 120 I 1 I
using the dolomite-water equation -10 -5 0 5
of Land (1983):
1000 lna=3.14 x (10'T ") - 2.0. 6' '0 760 (SMOW) of Formation Water

brines at or near current burial temperatures; conclusions are consistent with the petrographic
hence dolomitization must have occurred after observations that most dolomite formed late.
the Upper Miocene to Pliocene culmination of Figure 6 also illustrates that formation waters in
orogenic activity. More specifically, because late the Central Negev (boreholes Daya 1 and Barbur
dolomite is virtually absent from outcrop in I) have P O values that are 3 4 % " lower than
the Gebel Maghara and Makhtesh Ramon areas those predicted for dolomitization at these sites at
(Fig. I), it seems that the present topography of present subsurface temperatures. The formation
southern Israel and northern Sinai was largely waters also contain much lower total dissolved
established prior to dolomitization. All of these solids than the brines sampled at the Qeren 1,
158 A. Ayalon and F. J. Longstaffe

Hazerim 1 and Beer-Sheva 1 boreholes (Table 1). In contrast to the Northern Negev and the Judea
These data indicate a significant contribution of Mountains, Inmar Formation waters from bore-
meteoric water to the Inmar Formation after the holes in the Central Negev region are substantially
post-Upper Miocene to Pliocene dolomitization. depleted of l80relative to values predicted for
However, the secondary dolomite has retained the isotopic equilibrium with the secondary dolo-
oxygen isotope signature of the brine from which mite. This change in composition reflects post-
it formed; isotopic exchange with later fluids has Pliocene (Pleistocene?) influx of meteoric water.
not been important. This water mixed with, and(or) partially flushed,
A Pleistocene timing for the influx of meteoric pre-existing brines from the Inmar sandstones
water has been previously indicated by Starinsky in this region, and is probably responsible for
& Katz (1978) and Ilani et al. (1988). Outflow of halting dolomitization.
pressurized brines from the Jurassic aquifer first
occurred during the Late Miocene because of the
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
opening of the Dead Sea Graben (Steinitz et al.,
1978; Ilani et al., 1988). However, brine discharge
We thank M. Goldberg for outcrop samples used
again was activated in the Pleistocene because of
in this study, D. Caird for her assistance in the
the downfaulting of the Dead Sea Rift (Ilani et a].,
laboratory and M. Dvorachek for his technical
1988). In the latter case, substantial infiltration of
assistance with the SEM. Special thanks go to M.
meteoric water into the Jurassic aquifer was made
Matthews and I. Perath for their critical reading of
possible by the long periods of humid climate that
the manuscript. Portions of this research were
characterized the Pleistocene in this area (Issar,
made possible through the financial support of
1979, 1981).
the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research
It is conceivable that the lack of agreement
Council of Canada (F.J.L.). We also thank Drs
between calculated and measured formation
Christoph Spot1 and Mark Wilkinson for their
water 6l80 values in the Central Negev resulted
reviews of an earlier version of this paper.
from a significant change in temperature, rather
than water composition, since dolomitization.
However, we consider this possibility to be REFERENCES
unlikely. The present geothermal gradient has
prevailed in the area since the Early Tertiary, and Bentor, Y.K. (1960) Israel. Lexique Stratigraphique
International, Vol. III [Asie), Fasc 10 C.2. Paris:
gradients before that time were higher, not lower CNRS.
(Feinstein, 1985). Bentor, Y.K. (1961) Some geochemical aspects of the
Dead Sea and the question of its age. Geochim.
Cosmochim. Acta, 25, 239-260.
SUMMARY Bentor, Y.K. (1969) On the evolution of subsurface
brines in Israel. Chem. Geol., 4,83-110.
Late diagenetic, dolomitic cements from Lower Bentor, Y.K. and Vroman, A. (1954) Structural contour
map of Israel (1:250,000)with remarks on its dynami-
Jurassic sandstones of the Inmar Formation are in cal interpretation. Israel geol. S u m . Bull., 7.
isotopic equilibrium with present brines in sev- Bernoulli, D. (1972) North Atlantic and Mediterranean.
eral deep boreholes situated in the northern Mesozoic facies: a comparison. Deep Sea Drilling
Negev and Judea Mountains of southern Israel. Project, Initial Report, 11, 801-822.
The 6l80 values of the secondary dolomite Clayton, R.N. (1959) Oxygen isotope fractionation in
decrease systematically with increasing tempera- the system calcium carbonate-water. J. chem. Phys.,
ture (and depth in the borehole). This behaviour 30, 1246-1250.
Craig, H. (1957) Isotopic standards for carbon and
suggests that dolomitization post-dated the main oxygen and correction factors for mass-spectrometric
tectonic activity (Late Miocene-Pliocene) in analysis of carbon dioxide. Geochim. Cosmochim.
southern Israel. Because of the scarcity of late Acta, 12, 133-149.
dolomite in outcrops of the Inmar Formation, we Craig, H. (1961) Standards for reporting concentrations
also conclude that the present topography of of deuterium and oxygen-18 in natural waters.
southern Israel and northern Sinai was estab- Science, 133, 1833-1834.
lished prior to dolomitization. We can further De Sitter, L.V. (1962) Structural developments of
the Arabian Shield in Palestine. Geol. Mijnb., 41C,
speculate that the westward (Pliocene?) migration 116-124.
of the brines responsible for the late dolomitiza- Druckman, Y. (1974) The stratigraphy of the Triassic
tion displaced any liquid hydrocarbons that sequence in southern Israel. Israel geol. S u m . Bull.,
might have been present in the Negev. 64.
Carbonate minerals. southern Israel 159
Eckstein. Y. (1975) The measurements and interpreta- Levy, Y. (1972) Interaction between brines and sedi-
tion of terrestrial heat p o w in Israel. PhD thesis, ments in the Bardawil area - northern Sinai. PhD
Hebrew University of Jerusalem (in Hebrew, English thesis, Hebrew University of Jerusalem (in Hebrew,
abstract). English abstract).
Epstein, S., Graf, D.L. and Degens, E.T. (1964) Oxygen Longstaffe, F.J. (1983) Diagenesis, IV. Stable isotope
isotope studies on the origin of dolomite. In: Iso- studies of diagenesis in clastic rocks. Geosci. Can.,
topic and Cosmic Chemistry (Ed. by H. Craig), 10,44-58.
pp. 169-180. North Holland Publishing Company, Longstaffe, F.J. (1989). Stable isotopes as tracers in
Amsterdam. clastic diagenesis. In: Short Course in Burial Dia-
Erickson, A.J., Simmons, G. and Ryan, W.B.F. (1977) genesis (Ed. by I. E. Hutcheon), Miner. Ass. Canada
Review of heat flow data from the Mediterranean and Short Course, 15, 201-277.
Aegean seas. In: International Symposium on the Lundegard, P.D. and Land, L.S. (1986) Carbon dioxide
Structural History of the Mediterranean Basins (Ed. and organic acids: their role in porosity enhancement
by B. Biju-Duval and L. Montadert), pp. 95-110. and cementation, Paleogene of the Texas Gulf Coast.
Split, Croatia. In: The Roles of Organic Matter in Diagenesis (Ed. by
Feinstein, S. (1985) Coal rank and the thermal history D. L. Gautier), Spec. Publ. SOC.econ. Paleont. Miner.,
of the sedimentary section in the southern Israel. 38, 129-146.
PhD thesis, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, McCrea, J.M. (1950) On the isotopic chemistry of car-
Beer Sheva (in Hebrew plus extended English bonates and a paleotemperature scale. /. Chem. Phys.,
abstract). 18, 849-857.
Fleischer, E., Goldberg, M., Gat, J.R. and Magaritz, M. Nativ, R. (1984) The water potential ofthe deep Jurassic
(1977) Isotope composition of formation waters from to Paleozoic aquifers in the Negev, Israel. PhD thesis,
deep drillings in southern Israel. Geochim. Cosmo- Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Beer Sheva (in
chim. Acta, 41, 511-525. Hebrew, English abstract).
Freund, R., Goldberg, M., Weissbrod, T., Druckman, Y. O'Neil, J.R. (1987) Preservation of H, C, and 0 isotopic
and Derin, B. (1975) The Triassic-Jurassic structure of ratios in the low temperature environment. In: Stable
Israel and its relation to the origin of the eastern Isotope Geochemistry of Low Temperature Fluids
Mediterranean. Israel geol. Sum. Bull., 65, 1-26. (Ed. by T. K. Kyser), Miner. Ass. Canada Short
Garfunkel, Z . (1981) Internal structure of the Dead Sea Course, 13, 85-128.
leaky transform (rift) in relation to plate kinematics. Petersen, N.F. (1980) Regional Petroleum Geochemical
Tectonophysics, 80, 81-108. Assessment of Israel: Initial Report. Geoscience
Garfunkel, Z . and Derin, B. (1988) Reevaluation of Center, Superior Oil Company, Houston, Texas.
latest Jurassic-Early Cretaceous history of the Negev Picard, L. (1959) Geology and oil exploration of Israel.
and the role of magmatic activity. Israel J. Earth Sci., Bull. Res. Council Israel, 8G, 1-30.
37,43-52. Rosenbaum, J. and Sheppard, S.M.F. (1986) An isotopic
Goldberg, M. (1970) The lithostratigraphy of the Arad study of siderites, dolomites and ankerites at high
Group (Jurassic) in the northern Negev. Israel geol. temperatures. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 50, 1147-
Sum. Report, MM/3/70 (in Hebrew]. 1150.
Goldberg, M. and Friedman, G.M. (1974) Paleo- Sass, E. and Starinsky, A. (1979). Behaviour of stron-
environments and paleogeographic evolution of the tium in subsurface calcium chloride brines: southern
Jurassic system in southern Israel. Israel geol. Sum. Israel and Dead Sea rift valley. Geochim. Cosmochim.
Bull., 61. Acta, 43, 885-895.
Ilani, S., Rosenthal, E., Kronfeld, J. and Flexer, A. Sharma, T. and Clayton, R.N. (1965) Measurements of
(1988) Epigenetic dolomitization and iron mineral- 01"/01" ratios of total oxygen of carbonates.
ization along faults and their possible relations to the Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 29, 1347-1353.
paleohydrology of southern Israel. Appl. Geochem., Spohn, T. and Schubert, G. (1982) Convective thinning
3, 487-498. of the lithosphere: a mechanism for the initiation of
Issar, A. (1979) The paleohydrology of southern Israel continental rifting. J. geophys. Res., 87/B6, 4669-
and its influence on the flushing of the Kurnub and 4681.
Arad groups (Lower Cretaceous and Jurassic). /. Starinsky, A. (1974) Relationship between Ca-chloride
Hydrol., 44, 289-303. brines and sedimentary rocks in Israel. PhD thesis,
Issar, A. (1981) The rate of flushing as a major factor in Hebrew University of Jerusalem (in Hebrew, English
determining the chemistry of water in fossil aquifers abstract).
in southern Israel. J. Hydrol., 54, 285-296. Starinsky, A,, Bielski, M., Lazar, B., Steinitz, G. and
Land, L.S. (1983) The application of stable isotopes to Raab, M. (1983) Strontium isotope evidence on
studies of the origin of dolomite and to problems of the history of oilfield brines. Mediterranean coastal
diagenesis of clastic sediments. In: Stable Isotopes in plain, Israel. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 47, 687-
Sedimentary Geology, SOC. econ. Paleontol. Miner. 695.
Short Course, 10,4.1-4.22. Starinsky, A. and Katz, A. (1978) Tracing brine move-
Lerman, A. (1970) Chemical equilibria and evolution of ment in the subsurface as a tool for oil exploration.
chloride brines. Spec. Paper Miner. SOC. A m . 3, Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Department of
291-306. Geology, Internal Report (in Hebrew).
160 A. Ayalon and F. J. Longstaffe
Steinitz, G., Bartov, Y. and Hunziker, J.C. (1978) K-Ar Zak, I. (1957) The Triassic in Makhtesh Ramon. MSC
age determination of some Miocene-Pliocene basalts thesis, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem (in
in Israel: their significance to the tectonics of the Rift Hebrew, English abstract).
Valley. Geol. Mag., 115, 329-340.
Walters, L.J. Jr, Claypool, G.E. and Choquette, P.W.
(1972) Reaction rates and 6180 variation for the
carbonate-phosphoric acid preparation method. Manuscript received 28 February 1994; revision
Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 36, 129-140. accepted 27 June 1994

Potrebbero piacerti anche