Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Mathematical model for a straight grate iron ore pellet induration process
of industrial scale
S.K. Sadrnezhaad *, A. Ferdowsi, H. Payab
Materials and Energy Research Center, P.O. Box 14155-4777, Tehran, Iran
Center of Excellence for Advanced Processes of Production of Materials, Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Sharif University of Technology,
P.O. Box 11365-9466, Tehran, Iran
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: A mathematical model is developed for induration of the iron-ore pellets in an industrial-scale plant
Received 1 April 2007 based on the laws of mass, heat and momentum transfer. Physicochemical processes occurring during
Received in revised form 7 March 2008 the induration of pellets such as drying of moisture, calcination of limestone and coke-magnetite reaction
Accepted 19 March 2008
are considered to evaluate the gradient of temperature within the pellets. Differential equations describ-
Available online 9 May 2008
ing transport phenomena in a grate bed are simultaneously solved by dividing the space in both x- and
z- directions and numerically solving the phenomenological equations. A kinetic model is used for esti-
Keywords:
mation of the change of the strength of the pellets due to ring. The model involves gas-ow through dif-
Mathematical modeling
Straight grate
ferent zones of a typical industrial plant. Different conditions are used for determination of the effect of
Induration process addition of carbon to the green pellets on performance of the induration process. The optimum carbon
Iron ore pellet content is determined to be 0.75% for green pellets. This results in a productivity enhancement of 20%,
Fuel consumption an N.G. fuel consumption decrease of 17% and an electrical power saving of 17%. Based on the model
Greenhouse gases calculations, the volumes of the wasted greenhouse gases diminish with addition of the carbon content
of the pellets.
2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction process, the green pellets are charged onto the grate to form a
bed of 180 mm depth. In this process, the bottom of the bed does
Pelletizing is a common process used usually for upgrading of not heat-up so much to damage the grate bars. No hearth layer is,
the iron-ore raw nes [1]. Green pellets are made of concentrates therefore, required in this process. Pellets charged onto the grate
continuously rolled over in rotary discs with moisture, bentonite, are subject to up-draft drying, down-draft drying and preheating
limestone, coke breeze, etc. These pellets are loaded onto a travel- with streams of the gases. The pellets discharged onto the rotary
ing grate where they are dried and red to increase their strength. kiln furnace are red and then transferred into the annular cooler
They form a packed-bed that is subsequently air-cooled to recycle to form a deep-packed bed. Ambient air is blown through the bed
the heat and to obtain an appropriate temperature for further to abstract heat from the pellets.
handling. This article focuses on the straight grate type of the pellet indu-
Two types of systems are usually used for induration of the ration process. In industrial plants, the moving grate is divided into
iron-ore pellets: (a) straight-grate and (b) grate-kiln process. A several zones such as those of KSC (Kouzestan Steel Company of
hearth layer of red pellets is used in the former to protect grate Iran) shown in Fig. 1: (a) up-draft drying (UDD); (b) down-draft
bars from excessive heating. Fresh pellets are charged onto a drying (DDD); (c) preheating (PH); (d) rst ring (F1); (e) second
hearth layer of the red ones. Hot gas is blown through the layer ring (F2) (f) after-ring (AF); (g) rst cooling (C1) and (h) second
to dry-out and re the pellets at about 1300 C. In the grate-kiln cooling (C2) zones. In drying zones, gas stream is used to dry the
pellets at 200300 C. That why most processes use a combination
of up-draft/down-draft drying is for prevention of decrepitation of
* Corresponding author. Address: Center of Excellence for Advanced Processes of the pellets under a combination of the gravity forces, the pressure
Production of Materials, Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Sharif drop generated to pull back the gases trough the bed and the mois-
University of Technology, P.O. Box 11365-9466, Tehran, Iran, Tel.: +98 2166165215;
fax: +98 2166005717.
ture re-condensation process.
E-mail addresses: sadrnezh@sharif.edu, sadrnezh@yahoo.com (S.K. Sadrnez- Off-gases of the second cooling stage are used in the drying
haad). zone. This zone does not have any burner. In PH, F1 and F2 zones,
0927-0256/$ - see front matter 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2008.03.024
S.K. Sadrnezhaad et al. / Computational Materials Science 44 (2008) 296302 297
Nomenclature
A surface area of pellets per m3 pellet bed (m2 m3) R gas constant (m3 atm K1)
Cg, Cs heat capacity of gas, pellets (J kg1 K1) Ri reaction rate of component i (mol m3 s1)
Ci concentration of component i (mol m1) t time (s)
Di diffusion coefcient of component i (m2 s1) Tg, Tp temperature of gas, pellet (C)
d pellet diameter (m) T sp surface temperature of pellet (C)
G gas ow rate (kg m2 s1) W g ; W eq
g gas humidity (kg m3)
h convection heat transfer coefcient (J m2 s1 K1) W p ; W pc pellet humidity (kg m3)
k thermal conductivity of pellet (J m1 K1 s1) x length in furnace (m)
Kl equilibrium constant of limestone reaction (atm) z bed height (m)
kg mass transfer coefcient (m s1) DHi enthalpy of reaction of the component i of the pellet
kl, kr,c, kr,m chemical reaction rate of limestone, carbon, magne- (J kg1)
tite (m s1) DHv enthalpy of vaporization of the moisture of the pellet
M supercial pellet ow (kg m2 s1) (J kg1)
m_ mass ow of gas (kg s1) u void fraction of pellet bed
P pressure (Pa) l viscosity (kg m1 s1)
r0 radius of pellet (m) qg ; qp density of gas, pellet (kg m3)
r distance from the center of pellet (m)
rw rm, rl, rc radius of moisture, magnetite, limestone, carbon core
(m)
off-gases of the rst cooling zone are heated under burner hoods to tion from one stage to the other, (c) temperature gradient within
raise their temperatures up to about 800, 1200 and 1300 C, the pellets and (d) industrial scale geometry for simulation of the
respectively. Since the AF zone has no burner, the off-gases coming induration process. The model is eventually assessed by applica-
from C1 zone having a temperature of 1000 C is directly em- tion the industrial data obtained from KSC plant being currently
ployed to stabilize the temperature of the bed. Energy consump- operated for production of the iron ore pellets.
tion by the induration machine is, thus, related to the
performance of the cooling zones [2]. 2. Modeling
Due to the high energy consumption, the induration of the iron
ore pellets is a relatively expensive process. Empirical studies have Thurlby et al. [14] have comparatively examined the effect of
so far been made to optimize the operation with respect to both radiation and found that its effect is negligible. Mitterlehner
fuel efciency and materials productivity [35]. Strong coupling ef- et al. [17], Pomerleau et al. [5] and other investigators have, there-
fects of the counter-current gas and solid materials moving fore, ignored the radiation in their plant simulation. Because of the
through the system makes the mathematics more confusing to small difference between the gas and wall temperatures, this
be treated in a traditional way [68]. Assessment of the effect of seems to be a valid assumption and therefore transfer of heat by
an individual change even if it is too small and takes place at a spe- radiation and within the bed can be neglected. The process is as-
cic location is not too simple. Application of a trial and error tech- sumed to occur at the steady state. The model includes drying of
nique for identication of the concentration, temperature and the pellets and reactions of the limestone, magnetite and carbon
velocity proles of the solid materials moving on the grate is being contained in the pellets.
expensive especially with poor quality pellets. Results depend on
the specic machine used and the operational conditions. 2.1. Energy balance
For induration of the iron-ore pellets, a number of models have
been presented in the literature [2,6,7,915]. Hasenack et al. [9] To model the iron-ore induration process, lets assume that the
and Voskamp and Brasz [10] have presented the rst models. Thur- bed voidage and height during sintering is constant. Consider a cell
lby [3,11,12] and Young et al. [13] have proposed models devoted having the height dz and ignoring the change of gas temperature
to the grate-kiln systems. Thurlby et al. [14] have developed a with time, the gaseous phase energy balance can be written as1
model for the moving grate iron-ore induration of the pellets. A
oGC g T g
mathematical model for a pilot scale induration furnace for iron- haT g T sp 0 1
oz
ore pellets has been presented by Kucukada et al. [15]. Cross and
Blot [6] have used the induration process model to evaluate the The energy balance for the same cell with a length dx is
suitability of the rst drying zone with the updraft or downdraft oMC s T s dW p X
gas ow streams. They have optimized the gas temperature prole haT g T sp 1 eDHv 1 eRi DHi
ox dt
in the hood of PH, F, and AF zones to reduce the burner fuel. Hamidi
0 2
and Payab [7] have presented a mathematical model for pilot-scale
iron ore induration furnace and have determined energy savings by It has previously been reported that the temperature gradient with-
coke addition to the pellet and oxygen injection to the furnace. in the pellets plays an important role in the determination of the
Pomerleau et al. [16] have used a mathematical model for optimi- minimum ring time [1]. Since the heat transfer within the pellets
zation of the operating conditions in a straight grate furnace. They takes place by conduction, the energy balance for an individual pel-
have discussed the conditions for decrease of the fuel consumption let can be expressed by the following equation [18]:
and increase of the production rate.
The present study utilizes a more sophisticated model than
those developed before by considering (a) gas-composition varia-
tion along the bed of the pellets, (b) changing of the gas-concentra- 1
All symbols are given in Nomenclature.
298 S.K. Sadrnezhaad et al. / Computational Materials Science 44 (2008) 296302
Stack
UDD DDD PH F1 F2 AF C1 C2
1 o 2 oT p X dW p oT p 4Fe3 O4 s O2 g ! 6Fe2 O3 s
k r DHi Ri DHv qp C p 3
r2 or or dt ot
oT oT 16pr20 C Oeq;m C O2
B.C.1: k orp hT g T p B.C.2: orp 0 In this equation a Rmag 2
8
rd=2 r0 1
rmr0t 2 kr;m
1
r0rrm0tD
r m t
homogeneous pore/different-phases distribution is assumed for kgO
2 O 2
At least three reactions take place within the hot pellets. Three Both temperature and composition of the inlet gases are deter-
controlling steps (lm diffusion, pore diffusion and chemical reac- mined in order to solve the equations describing the state of the
tion) are considered by previous authors to control the rate of the bed of the pellets. These parameters depend on the processes
reactions according to the shrinking core regime [13] occurring elsewhere. Fig. 1 shows the inter-effect between differ-
CaCO3 s CaOs CO2 g ent zones of the straight grate furnace used in KSC. This furnace
uses natural gas as its fuel. Mass and energy balances established
4pr20 C eq between different zones must be developed to obtain temperature
CO2 C CO2
Rlim 7 and composition of the inlet gases. Mass balance for the Firing zone
1
kgCO
r rt
0
2 k1KRT
1
r0r rtD
0 r l t
m _ C1!F m
_Fm _ air m
_ N:G: 14 1400
h=5cm
Energy balance for the ring zone can also be written as follows: h=15cm
1200
Z TF Z TF Z TF h=30cm
The temperature dependent rate parameter, w, can be represented Fig. 2. Comparison of the simulation results (solid lines) with the experimental
by an Arrhenius type expression: data obtained from pot grate measurements (dotted lines).
A0 E
w exp 17
T RT
In order to dene an appropriate form of Qf (the nal quality 1400
that would be attained after a long period of sintering at tempera-
ture T), it is necessary to account for rapid rise in the red quality 1200
that occurs once T exceeds a specied value T0. A suitable form is Present work
Q f a bT T 0 T > T0 1000
18 Ref.3
Pellet Temperature (C)
Qf a T 6 T0
Ref.7
The nal equation has, therefore, ve adjustable parameters: A0, E, 800
a, b and T0. These parameters vary with the nature and amount of
the additives, the ore-type and the balling conditions. Once these
600
parameters are determined, the state equation can be used to inte-
grate along any time-temperature prole by solving
Z 400
t
dQ
Qp dt 19
0 dt
200
where Qp is the product quality at the end of the induration process.
The model developed does not consider decreasing of the pellet
0
quality that occurs above a critical temperature due to verication 0 5 10 15 20
phenomenon. Although the quality parameter Qp has industrially Time (min)
been unspecied, the JIS abrasion index AI, is commonly used.
Fig. 3. Comparison of the temperature of the pellets calculated in this work with
The quality parameter is related to the abrasion index according
those of previous investigators [10,13].
to the following equation:
100 AI
Qp 20 Table 1
AI
Comparison of the model data with those obtained from tests in the plant
Table 2 1350
Carbon content of the green pellets and grate speeds
Table 3
1150
0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1
Composition of green pellets
Carbon (%)
Constituent Mass (%)
Fig. 4. Maximum temperature of the pellets that lay in height 11 cm from the rst
Fe2O3 63.6 layer of the green pellets.
Fe3O4 25.5
SiO2 0.7
Al2O3 0.9
CaO 0.4 4
MgO 0.4
Moisture 8.5
Abrasion Index
3
Table 4
2
Burner zone temperatures
22
N.G. Consumption (Nm3/ton)
N.G. Consumption
Firing zones of the agglomeration plants are usually divided 16
into several sections. These sections are called burner zones. This
Electrical Energy
work focuses on pellettizing plant of Khouzestan Steel Company
which has eight different burner zones. Separate control of the 14 20
temperature in each burner zone is necessary. Other specications 0 0.5 1
of the plant are represented in Appendix 1. Set-points of all burner Carbon (%)
zones categorized under Conditions 15 are all the same. A lower Fig. 6. Effects of the carbon content on the N.G. fuel consumption and the electrical
temperature is used for the burner zones 38 of those under Con- power utilization in the induration process.
dition 6. Specications of the pellets used in KSC straight grate bed
are demonstrated in Table 5.
Combustion of carbon in the pellets causes the formation of car- zation are shown in Fig. 6. The effect of carbon content on the
bon monoxide and carbon dioxide, which heats up the pellets. As production rate of the straight grate is shown in Fig. 7. It is seen
gas passes across the bed, its temperature increases. Fig. 4 shows from these gures that adding 1% carbon to pellets can result in
the maximum temperature of the pellets that lay in height 11 cm the following changes: (1) decrease of the fuel consumption by
from rst layer of the green pellets. An increase in the temperature 24%, (2) increase of the production rate by 30% and (c) decrease
of the pellets causes the quality of the red pellets to improve. Var- of the electrical power by 23%.
iation in the abrasion index of the red pellets is illustrated in Carbon contents of more than 1% may cause, however, exceed-
Fig. 5. ing of the pellet temperature from a critical value, TC. The pellet
N.G. fuel consumption and electrical power utilization by the quality may hence decrease due to the vitrication phenomenon
process can be decreased by adding carbon to the green pellets. Ef- described elsewhere [16]. Thermal prole of the pellets listed un-
fect of carbon on N.G. fuel consumption and electrical power utili- der Condition 5 (pellets having 1.25% carbon) is illustrated in
S.K. Sadrnezhaad et al. / Computational Materials Science 44 (2008) 296302 301
600
6
h=11cm
h=20cm
Production rate (ton/h)
550 5
h=30cm
450
2
400 1
0 0.25 0.5 0. 75 1
Carbon (%)
0
8 12 16 20 24
Fig. 7. Effect of the carbon content on the production rate of the induration process.
Time (min)
1000 h=40cm
600
800
Tp (C)
400 600
200 400
0 200
0 4 8 12 16 20 24 28
Time (min)
0
Fig. 8. Thermal prole of the pellets under Condition 5. 0 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 32
Time (min)
1400
Acknowledgements
Fig. 12. Effect of carbon on the volume of the waste gases. Characteristics of induration furnace: there are eight zones in
each induration furnace of Khouzestan Steel Company (KSC). The
bed of the pellets in the induration furnace is 3.3 m wide and
300 3 m long. Numbers of wind boxes in each zone are as indicated
in Table A1.
CO2, H2O (Nm3/ton)
200
References
CO2
H2O [1] K. Meyer, Pelletizing of Iron Ores, Sprinter, Berlin, 1980.
100
[2] D. Pomerleau, A. Pomerleau, D. Hodouin, E. Poulin, Computers and Chemical
Engineering 27 (2003) 217233.
[3] J.A. Thurlby, Metallurgical Transaction B 19B (February) (1988) 122132.
0 [4] R.J. Batterham, J.A. Thurlby, G.J. Thornton, The Chemical Engineer 55 (1977)
0 0.25 0.5 0.75 629632.
Carbon (%) [5] D. Pomerleau, A. Desbiens, D. Hodouin, Optimization of a simulated iron-oxide
pellets induration furnace, in: 11th Mediterranean Conference on Control and
Automation, 2003.
Fig. 13. Effect of carbon on the volume of the greenhouse gases.
[6] M. Cross, P. Blot, Metallurgical and Materials Transactions B 30B (August)
(1999) 803813.
[7] A.A. Hamidi, H. Payab, IJE Transactions B 16 (3) (2003) 265278.
Table A1
[8] L. Price, J. Sinton, Energy 27 (2002) 426429.
Number of wind boxes in each zone of an induration furnace located in KSC [9] N.A. Hasenack, P.A.M. Lebelle, J.J. Kooy, Induration process for pellets on a
moving stand, in: Congress Proceedings Mathematical Process Models in Iron
Zone UDD DDD PH F1 F2 AF C1 C2
and Steelmaking, Metal Society, London (1975) 616.
Number of wind boxes 5 3 3 3 9 2 8 4 [10] J.H. Voskamp, J. Brasz, Measurement and Control 8 (January) (1975).
[11] J.A. Thurlby, Metallurgical Transactions B 19B (February) (1988) 103112.
[12] J.A. Thurlby, Metallurgical Transaction B 19B (February) (1988) 113121.
[13] R.W. Young, M. Cross, R.D. Gibson, Ironmaking and Steelmaking 6 (1) (1979)
shown in Fig. 12. It is shown that under Condition 3 as compared to 113.
Condition 1, the volume of the waste gases decreases by 16.8%. [14] J.A. Thurlby, R.J. Batterham, R.E. Turner, International Journal of Mineral
Processing 6 (6) (1979) 4364.
Fig. 13 shows effect of carbon on the volume of the greenhouse [15] K. Kucukada, J. Thibault, D. Hodouin, G. Paquet, S. Caron, Canadian
gas concentrations that goes to stack. Metallurgical Quarterly 33 (1) (1994) 112.
The highly integrated nature of the pellets and the gas ow [16] D. Pomerleau, D. Hodouin, E. Poulin, Canadian Metallurgical Quarterly 44 (4)
(2005) 571582.
throughout the straight grate induration system means that small [17] J. Mitterlehner, G. Loefer, F. Winter, H. Hofbauer, H. Schmid, E. Zwittag, H.
changes in the process conditions are reected throughout the Buergler, O. Pammer, H. Stiasny;, ISIJ International 44 (1) (2004) 1120.
whole operation [4]. The main usefulness of the developed model [18] R.B. Bird, W.E. Stewart, E.N. Lightfoot, Transport Phenomena, John Wiley, New
York, 2002.
over a range of the operating conditions should thus be in assess- [19] R.J. Battreham, Metallurgical Transactions B 17B (1986) 479485.
ing of the fuel required to satisfactorily re the system with model [20] D. Cang, Y. Guan, H. Bai, Y. Zong, Y. Mao, X. Che, ISIJ International 42
estimation of the heat distributed throughout the furnace. (Supplement) (2002) S1S4.