Sei sulla pagina 1di 3

CRITICAL APPRAISAL WORKSHEET 3

AN ARTICLE ON PROGNOSIS OR HARM


This worksheet should be submitted along with the completed Submission Form to your supervisor. It is based
on the articles on prognosis and harm from the JAMA series on Users Guides to the Medical Literature.
Reading thesearticles should be helpful to you in working through this worksheet as it pertains to your key
article(s). Feel free to make photocopies. You can also print off additional copies from the CFPC Web Site
(www.cfpc.ca/cme/pearls/pearlsmain.asp ).

Author(s): Tae-yon sun, Yu-mi Lee, Jong Ho Yoon, Ki-Wook Chung,and Suck joon Hong

Short title: Long Term Effect of Surgery in Graves Desease : 20 Year Experience in a Single Institution

Journal/Year/Volume/ Pages: International Journal of Endocrinology / 2015 / 138 -736

A. ARE THE STUDY RESULTS VALID?

1. Was there a representative and well-defined sample of patients at a similar point in the Yes
course of the disease?
No
Jumlah sampel cukup tidak representatif dengan jumlah sampel 30 pasien

Cant
tell

2. Was follow-up sufficiently long and complete? Yes

Merupakan suatu studi prospektif dengan follow up satu tahun dimana dilakukan follow
No
up pada bulan kedua, ke enam dan kedua belas

Cant
tell

3. Were objective and unbiased outcome criteria used? Yes

Penelitian ini dilakukan sangat objectif sesuai mandat FBA dalam pengambilan sampel No
dan tidak menimbulkan bias.

Cant
tell

4. Was there adjustment for important prognostic factors Yes

No

Cant
tell
B. WHAT WERE THE RESULTS?

1. How large is the likelihood of the outcome event(s) in a specific period of time?

Outcomenya setelah dilakukan penelitian selama satu tahun didapatkan hasil pada penyuntikan ACP lebih baik
nilai WOMAC yang lebih baik dibandingkan plasebo

2. How Precise Are the estimates of likelihood? (Consider 95% CI)

Estimasi pada penelitian ini cukup akurat dimana pasien

C. CAN THE RESULTS BE APPLIED TO YOUR PATIENT(S)?

1. Were the study patients similar to my own? Yes

.Di RSUZA sendiri metode ini belum dapat dilakukan.


No

Cant
tell

2. Are the result useful for reassuring or counselling patients? Yes

No

Cant
tell

CONCLUSIONS
The results or recommendations are valid (from A)l Yes No Cant Tell

The results are clinically important (from B). Yes No Cant Tell

The results are relevant to my practice (from C). Yes No Cant Tell

Kesimpulan :

Potrebbero piacerti anche