Sei sulla pagina 1di 10

The Head Case

Fixing the NFL Concussion Crisis


By JACOB LEIBOWITZ

O N A WARM FLORIDA EVENING IN


February, 2011, Dave Duerson, a
fifty-year-old retired NFL safety,
climbed into bed. Sitting on a table across the room were
the helmets of the three teams he had played for during
Duerson had always enjoyed surrounding
himself with reminders of his success. That night,
however, he wasnt thinking about his two Super Bowl
rings, which he had won in 1985 and 1990, or his Walter
Payton Man of the Year Award presented to him for his
his eleven-year careerthe Chicago Bears, the New charity work. Duerson had something else on his mind:
York Giants, and the Arizona Cardinals. the loaded, .38 caliber handgun that he held to his chest.
Seconds later, Dave Duerson pulled the trigger.
Among the hand-written letters that he had left for his
family, one included a slightly different message:
Please, see that my brain is given to the NFLs
brain bank.[1]
Duersons death shocked the football
world. Even long after his retirement from
the game, Duerson had a stable income and
a wide support system. Many of his friends
and family were left pondering the same
question: what could have caused such a
loved, successful man to find himself in
such a dark place?
A few months later, an autopsy
provided some answers. As per Duersons
request, researchers at the Boston
University School of Medicine were given
his brain to examine. They found
evidence of chronic


traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), the same degenerative Tech with sensor-equipped helmets, measuring the
brain disease that doctors found in the brains of other magnitude, location, and angle of each hit over the
former NFL players that also took their own lives.2] course of an entire season.
Their findings were shocking: some of the
athletes studied received close to 1,500 hits to the head
The Impact of Concussions per season, which rounds out to about 6 per practice and
14 per game, on average. Lineman and linebackers
Discovered by Dr. Bennett Omalu in 2002, CTE would typically receive more hits per game, and running
develops most commonly in the brains of athletes after backs were hit less often but with greater magnitudes for
they experience repeated blows to the head. This brain each impact.[6]
trauma eventually begins to damage nerve fibers, These results expose a much-overlooked
consequently triggering the release of a protein called tau problem. The NFL primarily focuses on serious blows
that pools in the brain and destroys cells. to the head, but these skull-cracking hits are just the tip
These changes dont necessarily happen of the iceberg. Football players receive just as much if
immediately after the last significant impact to the head, not more damage from small, successive hits that
howeverthey can begin months, years, or even accumulate over time to cause trauma. These repeated
decades later.[3] Symptoms of CTE include memory loss, small impacts are almost entirely ignored by medical
confusion, impaired judgment, impulse control staff.
problems, aggression, depression, and, eventually, So when the NFL reported in 2015 that the
progressive dementia.[4] league saw 271 concussions[7] throughout the course of
While also found in the brains of boxers and the season, that number dramatically fails to quantify the
other contact sport athletes, CTE has become infamous real harm done.
for its link to professional football players. A 2015 study Far too frequently, players get hit hard during a
performed by the Department of Veterans Affairs and game, stumble off the field, and then, almost
Boston University found that 96% of deceased NFL miraculously, return on the very next play. As long as the
players examined by researchers (87 out of 91) tested requirements for a medical evaluation remain
positive for CTE.[5] Permanent damage caused by brain inadequately defined, coaches can continue to keep their
trauma in football doesnt just appear in isolated cases starters in the game after a blow to the head. No
its widespread, and its dangerous. diagnosis, no problem.
Whether competing in practices or games, Clearly, concussions are a serious dilemma,
professional football players receive a concerning threatening the very livelihood of each and every player
number of blows to the head. From the full-speed long after they hang up their cleats. Thankfully the
collisions that make highlight reels to the celebratory league has begun to recognize this problem and has
smacks on the head from teammates, football players get taken steps to make the game safer for its players.
hit in the head far too often. However, it took decades for NFL executives to even
In fact, researchers funded by the National admit that concussions pose a major threat to the game
Institutes of Health set their sights on quantifying of football and the players.
exactly how often. They outfitted football teams from
Dartmouth College, Brown University, and Virginia


Visible Damage
A normal, healthy brain (left)
compared to a brain with advanced
levels of CTE (right). Since its
discovery in 2002 by Dr. Bennett
Omalu, CTE has been found in the
brain of football players as young as
17 years old.
(Photo courtesy of Frontline)

to this day have no recollection of ever having played in
The Backstory that game.[10]
The NFL began to examine the issue of Brain trauma cases as serious as these should
concussions in 1994 when it established the Mild have been identified and treated immediately. Instead,
Traumatic Brain Injury (MTBI) committee. During the NFL executives ignored them and, therefore, ignored
first few weeks of the committees existence, its the health of the very people that keep the league alive.
chairman, Dr. Elliot Pellman, publicly announced that In fact, Dr. Ann McKee, a neuropathologist at
concussions posed only a minor threat: We think the Boston University School of Medicine, went as far as
issue of knees, of drugs, and of steroids and drinking is likening the NFLs handling of the concussion issue to
a far greater problem [than concussions]. At the time, the way the tobacco industry suppressed the link
nobody comprehended the impact that repeated blows between smoking and lung cancer.[11]
to a players head could have on his brain. Most NFL In 2011, former Atlanta Falcons safety Ray
executives just considered concussions, as Pellman put Easterling decided to fight back against the NFLs
it, part of the profession, an occupational risk.[8] mistreatment of its players. He filed a lawsuit against the

300

250
No End in Sight
Number of Concussions

200
Over the last seven NFL
150 seasons, the league has not
seen any significant signs of
100
progress towards better
50 protecting its players.
(Data courtesy of CNN)
0
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Year of Season Start

It took the NFL fifteen years to finally admit that NFL, on which he later gained the support of 4,500
concussions pose a long-term threat to players health. other players, claiming that the league engaged in a
Until then, the MTBI committee continued to deny all concerted effort of deception and denial in its
research suggesting that playing professional football handling of concussion and brain trauma research. Two
can lead to brain damage and disease. They instead years later, the NFL agreed to pay $765 million as part
published their own research that attempted to discredit of the settlement but did not admit any wrongdoing.
the studies performed by renowned neuroscientists. Although Commissioner Roger Goodell
However, a 2016 confidential study performed reiterated that there was no admission that anything
by the New York Times revealed that the research was caused by football, the NFL did acknowledge in
released by the NFL was far more flawed than previously federal court documents that nearly one-third of former
known, suggesting that the league cared more about NFL players developed long-term cognitive problems at
protecting their revenue than their players health. The a younger age that the general population.[12]
Times claimed that more than 100 concussion Since the settlement, the NFL has shown much
diagnoses were omitted from the studies, including improvement in its attempts to alleviate the concussion
serious ones to stars like quarterbacks Steve Young and crisis. Players have begun receiving fines ranging from
Troy Aikman.[9] just over $9,000 to just under $50,000 for each
Even more concerningYoungs concussion dangerous football play. In 2013, the NFL began placing
ended his career, and Aikman stated after his own independent neurologists on the sidelines for every
concussion, I didnt know what planet I was onI still game[13] to objectively evaluate each player suspected of
a possible concussion. The NFL has even moved


kickoffs up 5 yards (encouraging touchbacks instead of toward certain programs that will remodel the
returns that involve full-speed collisions), agreed to the foundations of American football with time. In order to
new labor contracts reduction of contact allowed in mitigate the dangers of concussions from professional
practice, and sponsored numerous research projects football, the NFL, with the support of the NFLPA,
themselves. should do three things: better identify concussions, fund
No matter the efforts made by the NFL and the high school programs, and research safer helmets.
calls for better protection from the NFL Players
Association (NFLPA), the concussion crisis lives on. Identifying Concussions
Between the 2014 and 2015 seasons, the league saw a
32% increase in diagnosed concussions[14], and that When discussing concussions, researchers
number could even be understated. mention many technical terms: head trauma, linear
In a series of interviews with the Associated acceleration, brain deformation, impact velocity, CTE.
Press, 23 of 44 NFL players said they would rather However, those commonly used terms are not broadly
conceal a possible concussion than pull themselves out understood. While progress has been made, doctors still
of the game, indicating that they feel obligated to return dont know the exact causes, distinguishing features, and
to the field even if they suspect a head injury. The exact outcomes of a concussionin fact, nobody does.
bottom line is: you have to be able to put food on the Currently, there exists no standardized criteria
table, said former for diagnosing a
Jacksonville Jaguars
running back Maurice
Jones-Drew. Injuries
This is the only concussion or any type of
head injury for that
matter.[16] Researchers
place where you
are part of the game. If are trying to establish
you dont want to get hit, some type of clear-cut
then you shouldnt be system, but little progress
playing.
Other players can Actually has been made.
Dr. Jamshid
expressed even more

legally assault
Ghajar, a neurosurgeon
morbid sentiments. and director of the
Stanford Routt, a former Stanford Concussion and
cornerback for the
people.
Brain Performance
Oakland Raiders, stated Center, even claimed that
in an interview, Youre most doctors accept a
never going to be totally -Stanford Routt headache after a potential
safe from concussions in head injury as a
this game. This is the only place where you can actually concussion. [17]
Since a headache may not appear until
legally assault people.[15] hours or even days after the initial trauma, this criterion
for diagnosis seems altogether inadequate.
Steps Toward Safety If the NFL and its players ever want to see a
game of football with fewer concussions, then they must
work towards better defining and identifying
Obviously, the players need better protection. concussions. The steps towards this goal arent entirely
They should not have to risk their mental health in order well-defined, but the Simbex Head Impact Telemetry
to make a living. The NFL neglected its athletes for years (HIT) System provides a promising starting point.
when they deserved betterDave Duerson and many Designed by Simbex, a biomechanical
others deserved better. That leaves one simple question: engineering firm, the HIT System uses small sensors
what more can be done to prevent concussions in installed in a players helmet to analytically monitor the
football? severity of impacts taken by a player. The sensors record
Unfortunately, that simple question doesnt impact data and have the capability of forwarding the
come with a simple answer. The NFL cant rid football results to an external computer in real time.[18]
of concussions by merely tweaking the rules or issuing
five-digit fines. Instead, the league should shift its efforts


A FORGETTABLE GAME
During the 1994 NFC Championship game, Dallas Cowboys starting quarterback Troy Aikman suffered a concussion
after receiving a knee to the head. Medical staff removed Aikman from the game, which Dallas won regardless. In the following
week, doctors tested Aikman and ultimately cleared him to return for the next gamethe Super Bowl, where he led the
Cowboys to their fourth championship.
However, the severity of Aikmans concussion went almost unknown until Frontlines program League of Denial
conducted an interview with Leigh Steinberg, Aikmans agent at the time.
Steinberg recounted his first interaction with Aikman after the concussion. He walked into a pitch-black hospital room,
where the Cowboys quarterback lay motionless. When Aikman saw Steinberg, he immediately asked him, Leigh, what am I
doing here? Steinberg informed Aikman that he was in the hospital after suffering a concussion. Aikman then asked, Did we
win? Yes, you won. What does that mean? It means youre headed to the Super Bowl.
Five minutes later, Aikman looked back at Steinberg and asked again, What am I doing here? That pattern of
forgetting cycled on for the next two hours.
When asked to describe how he felt after seeing Aikman in the hospital that day, Steinberg responded, It terrified me
to see how tender the bond was between sentient consciousness and potential dementia.[19]

The HIT system is a powerful tool that could High School Programs
potentially evolve into a standardized method of
diagnosing concussions on the sidelines of football Most NFL players can probably track the roots
games. However, some doctors have found that the HIT of their passion for the game back to high school. They
System is not entirely accurate. Specifically, a 2009 study participated in daily practices, played in front of their
performed by Steven Broglio, a kinesiology professor at fellow classmates on Friday nights, and got recruited by
the University of Michigan, found that the HIT System collegiate teams. High school football sets the stage for
correctly diagnosed only 1.4% (5 of 349) of measured those that will continue to play later in life, but it also
impacts exceeding the concussion threshold of 70 G of incorporates an added level of danger when it comes to
linear acceleration.[20] Broglio concluded that the HIT head injuries.
System should only function in research and not in the According to Northeastern University, these
real world. teenagers are under-developed and play with improper
Not all hope is lost, however. The Simbex HIT mechanics, which increases their risk of injury.[21] A 2009
System has received vast upgrades since Broglios study study conducted at a central Illinois high school actually
in 2009, and with an investment from the NFL it can found that high school athletes generally experienced
become even more reliable. Eventually, doctors on the greater post-impact acceleration to their heads than the
sidelines could use the HIT System as a method of accelerations collegiate players endured. The researchers
accurately diagnosing concussions by tracking the data speculated that high schoolers weaker muscle structure
in each players helmets during every play and promptly was not as effective in controlling their heads after
determining when a player should exit the game. impact.[22] But how does any of this relate to the problem
If the NFL wants to solve the concussion crisis of concussions with adult, professional football players?
once and for all, it has to first accurately identify the A football players mechanics habituated during
occurrence of concussions. Developing and imple- his high school years will most likely stick with him the
menting a method similar to the HIT System that clearly rest of his career. If a high school football player doesnt
defines and measures the criteria for a proper diagnosis learn how to properly tackle, or protect himself, or even
is crucial to taking players out of the game before they strap his helmet on correctly, he will be less likely to
can receive another damaging blow to the head. repeat those same correct behaviors when facing more
Standardizing concussions is the first steppreventing demanding competition.
them entirely is a completely different challenge.


96%
of deceased football players tested
167
is the average number of
52%
of players wouldnt leave the game
With additional funding, high school football inside. Some use more advanced material designs than
programs can invest in more advanced education for others, resulting in a spectrum of capabilities when it
their students on safer mechanics and proper comes to concussion prevention.
fundamentals. Such education could also include helpful Riddell, the largest helmet manufacturer and
lessons on the importance of wearing custom-made official helmet sponsor of the NFL, develops one of the
mouth guards, which have been found to cut the most commonly used and highest rated helmets on the
frequency of traumatic brain injuries suffered in half,[26] market: the Revolution Speed. This system utilizes a
and the benefits of helmetless training, which sounds custom inflated high-density vinyl nitrile foam for better
contradictory but can actually reduce the number of energy absorption, a specialized facemask that contorts
head impacts by forcing players to feel more to take some of the impact, and a larger shell to encase
vulnerable.[27] additional padding.[30]
Just two years ago, five high school football Currently, there are numerous studies in the
players died from head injuries.[28] In a time when the works that are searching for better answers to the
sport of football continues to receive less and less engineering design of helmets. For example, researchers
support (25% of parents wouldnt allow their children to at UCLA have developed an energy-absorbing micro
play some contact sports due to concussion risks[29]) lattice material, which they call architected lattice, that
because of its arguably life-threatening consequences, reduces the peak impact force of a head-to-head blow by
there exists a tremendous need to make the game of about 26% compared to conventional foam.[31] These
football safer in high school to ensure its existence at the researchers hope that one day their architected lattice
professional level in the future. could replace the padding inside football helmets.
If the NFL and the NFLPA want to exist in fifty All of these advancements in helmet research
years, let alone exist with fewer concussions, their have occurred in the last five years. With the proper
executives should certainly consider investing in high funding, what could the players expect to change when
school programs. it comes to helmets in the next five years?
First of all, the helmet approval process needs to
Improving Helmets see changes that account for more realistic conditions.
Currently, the National Operating Committee on
When asked to address the concussion crisis in Standards for Athletic Equipment (NOCSAE) has the
the NFL, most people would probably point to the responsibility of administering a test to approve helmets
helmets right off the bat. Clearly, the one piece of for use in the NFL based on certain safety standards. For
equipment that protects the brain most directly must each helmet in question, NOCSAE performs a drop test
play a major role in preventing concussions. Perfect the from a height of 1.5 meters and measures its impact
helmet, eliminate traumatic brain injuries. Its as simple velocity in 6 different locations on the crown of the
as that, right? helmet.[32] Somehow, NOCSAE has managed to squeak
Alas, therein lies one of the most over-simplified by NFL standards with this primitive testing system for
notions in all of professional sports. Helmets, even the last 40 years.
though visibly simple from the outside, are complex NOCSAEs drop test method only checks for
pieces of technology that scientists continue to research protection against linear acceleration, which comes from
and develop every single day. The flashy helmets that powerful, centered impacts.[33] If linear acceleration was
footballers use today have come a long way from the truly the only source of head trauma, helmet
optional leather helmets first developed in 1896. Even manufacturers could simply stuff their products with
more can be done to make helmets saferits just a more padding and solve the concussion problem then
matter of funding the appropriate research. and there. Where the drop test method falls short is
Modern helmets consist of a rigid, polycarbonate measuring the effectiveness of each helmets ability to
shell, a steel facemask, a chinstrap, and padding on the prevent off-axis impacts and rotational acceleration
the type of motion that researchers from the University


1 in 3
former NFL players developed signs
$125k
is the total value in fines that James
19
times more likely that an NFL player
of Ottawa and the University of Dublin deemed as accelerates could help prevent concussions.[39] Currently,
more associated with brain deformation impacts.[37] only a handful of NFL players (mostly linebackers or
In order to construct an accurate list of defensive lineman) wear some type of neck stabilization
approved, adequately-protective helmets, NOCSAE in the form of dense padding that rises above their
must alter its testing system to also consider the factor shoulder pads to reduce the effects of whiplash.
of rotational acceleration. Without that adjustment, Building upon the idea of NASCARs Head and
helmet manufacturers will continue to set their ceilings Neck Support device, the United States Army Research
at NOCSAEs lower standards, and, as a consequence, Lab has begun working on an elastic tether system that
the players will continue to suffer. could reduce sudden head motion. The straps, filled with
When it comes to the helmets themselves, some fluid that becomes increasingly solid when stressed,
current developments suggest massive upgrades in the would attach from a lightweight harness around a
players waist to the bottom of his helmet, acting like a
shock absorber.[40]
With so many advancements in the past few

Its time for the


years and so much more to discover, football helmet
research must receive funding to continue finding better
ways to keep players safe. As the last line of defense
between a charging 250-pound linebacker and the fragile
players to human brain, helmets must receive more attention if the
NFL and its players want to improve safety in the sport
they love.

stand up for Looking Ahead


their right to a The NFL has found itself on a precarious and
dangerous path, one that has taken human lives with it.

healthy future
Without some course of action, the concussion and
brain disease trend will continue. Active players will
continue to do their jobs and receive permanent damage

and demand
to their brains and, ultimately, their lives. Retired players
will continue to show signs of CTE and suffer the tragic
yet inevitable consequences. And the NFL will continue
to profit.

changes. Looking past the multi-million dollar contracts,


wide-scale commercialization, and celebrity status of the
athletes, theyre no different from any other member of
the American workforce. Why, then, are they not
protected under the same federal laws established by the
United States Department of Labor that entitles every
future of helmet safety. In addition to the designs employee to a safe and hazard-free workplace?[41] Why
created by startup companies, other fresh designs can professional football players legally work in a life-
include a bristly foam with spring-like fibers, an internal threatening environment?
suspension system that would create two independently Its time for the players to stand up for their right
moving layers inside the helmet, and an outer material to a healthy future and demand changes. By investing in
covering the polycarbonate shell that has the consistency programs similar to the ones suggested above, the NFL
of dried tar.[38] may one day be able to tell their players that they no
Neck stabilization devices are another promising longer have to suffer the consequences of concussions.
addition to future helmets that could eventually be seen Thats the style of football that the NFL and its players
as a requirement on game days. According to Dr. must strive to achieveand the one that the players and
Jamshid Ghajar, reducing how quickly the flexible neck their loved ones deserve.


Notes

1. Garcia-Roberts, Gus. "Dave Duerson's Secret Life and Tragic End." Miami New Times.
Miami New Times, 02 Apr. 2016. Web. 06 Apr. 2017.
2. Ezell, Lauren. "Timeline: The NFL's Concussion Crisis." FRONTLINE. Public Broadcasting
Service, 8 Oct. 2013. Web. 1 Apr. 2017.
3. O'keeffe, Michael. "Study Finds 96 Percent of Former NFL Players Had CTE." Daily News:
Sports. New York Daily News, 18 Sept. 2015. Web. 13 Apr. 2017.
4. "What Is CTE?" CTE Center. Boston University, n.d. Web. 9 Apr. 2017.
5. O'keeffe, Michael. "Study Finds 96 Percent of Former NFL Players Had CTE." Daily News:
Sports. New York Daily News, 18 Sept. 2015. Web. 13 Apr. 2017.
6. Polnerow, Don. "Solving Football's Concussion Problem." Northeastern's Undergraduate
Writing Program Journal. Northeastern University, n.d. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
7. "NFL Concussions Fast Facts." CNN. Cable News Network, 01 Aug. 2016. Web. 06 Apr.
2017.
8. Ezell, Lauren. "Timeline: The NFL's Concussion Crisis." FRONTLINE. Public Broadcasting
Service, 8 Oct. 2013. Web. 1 Apr. 2017.
9. Schwarz, Alan, Walt Bodanich, and Jacqueline Williams. "N.F.L.'s Flawed Concussion
Research and Ties to Tobacco Industry." The New York Times. The New York Times, 24
Mar. 2016. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
10. Ezell, Lauren. "Timeline: The NFL's Concussion Crisis." FRONTLINE. Public Broadcasting
Service, 8 Oct. 2013. Web. 1 Apr. 2017.
11. Schwarz, Alan, Walt Bodanich, and Jacqueline Williams. "N.F.L.'s Flawed Concussion
Research and Ties to Tobacco Industry." The New York Times. The New York Times, 24
Mar. 2016. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
12. "Late Appeal Will Delay Payouts in NFLs $1 Billion Concussion Lawsuit
Settlement." Sports Illustrated. Sports Illustrated, 31 Aug. 2016. Web. 9 Apr. 2017.
13. Durando, Stu. "Is Pro Football Too Dangerous?" Professional Athletes, edited by Margaret
Haerens and Lynn M. Zott, Greenhaven Press, 2014. Opposing Viewpoints. Opposing
Viewpoints in Context. Originally published in St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 12 Dec. 2010.
14. "NFL Concussions Fast Facts." CNN. Cable News Network, 01 Aug. 2016. Web. 06 Apr.
2017.
15. Fendrich, Howard. "Some NFL Players Still Willing to Hide Concussions." Professional
Athletes, edited by Margaret Haerens and Lynn M. Zott, Greenhaven Press, 2014. Opposing
Viewpoints. Opposing Viewpoints in Context. Accessed 27 Mar. 2017. Originally published
in USA Today, 26 Dec. 2011.
16. Kubota, Taylor. "5 Ways Science Could Make Football Safer." LiveScience. Purch, 30 Mar.
2016. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
17. Kubota, Taylor. "5 Ways Science Could Make Football Safer." LiveScience. Purch, 30 Mar.
2016. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
18. Polnerow, Don. "Solving Football's Concussion Problem." Northeastern's Undergraduate
Writing Program Journal. Northeastern University, n.d. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
19. Football, Violence, and Troy Aikman's Concussion: League of Denial. FRONTLINE. Public
Broadcasting Service, 30 Sept. 2013. Web. 14 Apr. 2017.
20. Broglio, Steven P., Brock Schnebel, Jacob J. Sosnoff, Sunghoon Shin, Xingdong Feng,
Xuming He, and Jerrad Zimmerman. "The Biomechanical Properties of Concussions in High


School Football." (n.d.): n. pag. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise. U.S. National
Library of Medicine, 1 Nov. 2010. Web. 13 Apr. 2017.
21. Polnerow, Don. "Solving Football's Concussion Problem." Northeastern's Undergraduate
Writing Program Journal. Northeastern University, n.d. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
22. Broglio, Steven P., Brock Schnebel, Jacob J. Sosnoff, Sunghoon Shin, Xingdong Feng,
Xuming He, and Jerrad Zimmerman. "The Biomechanical Properties of Concussions in High
School Football." (n.d.): n. pag. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise. U.S. National
Library of Medicine, 1 Nov. 2010. Web. 13 Apr. 2017.
23. O'keeffe, Michael. "Study Finds 96 Percent of Former NFL Players Had CTE." Daily News:
Sports. New York Daily News, 18 Sept. 2015. Web. 13 Apr. 2017.
24. Lehrman, Ryan. "9 NFL Concussion Statistics You'll Want to Know." FanSided. FanSided,
17 Jan. 2015. Web. 15 Apr. 2017.
25. Fendrich, Howard. "Some NFL Players Still Willing to Hide Concussions." Professional
Athletes, edited by Margaret Haerens and Lynn M. Zott, Greenhaven Press, 2014. Opposing
Viewpoints. Opposing Viewpoints in Context. Accessed 27 Mar. 2017. Originally published
in USA Today, 26 Dec. 2011.
26. Kubota, Taylor. "5 Ways Science Could Make Football Safer." LiveScience. Purch, 30 Mar.
2016. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
27. Kubota, Taylor. "5 Ways Science Could Make Football Safer." LiveScience. Purch, 30 Mar.
2016. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
28. Taylor, Tom. "How Will NFL Improve Concussion Problem over the next 50 Years?" Sports
Illustrated. Sports Illustrated, 8 Dec. 2015. Web. 1 Apr. 2017.
29. Taylor, Tom. "How Will NFL Improve Concussion Problem over the next 50 Years?" Sports
Illustrated. Sports Illustrated, 8 Dec. 2015. Web. 1 Apr. 2017.
30. Polnerow, Don. "Solving Football's Concussion Problem." Northeastern's Undergraduate
Writing Program Journal. Northeastern University, n.d. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
31. Kubota, Taylor. "5 Ways Science Could Make Football Safer." LiveScience. Purch, 30 Mar.
2016. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
32. Standard Performance Specification for Newly Manufactured Football Helmets. Rep. no.
002. National Operating Committee for Standards on Athletic Equipment, Feb. 2017. Web.
13 Apr. 2017.
33. Polnerow, Don. "Solving Football's Concussion Problem." Northeastern's Undergraduate
Writing Program Journal. Northeastern University, n.d. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
34. "Late Appeal Will Delay Payouts in NFLs $1 Billion Concussion Lawsuit
Settlement." Sports Illustrated. Sports Illustrated, 31 Aug. 2016. Web. 9 Apr. 2017.
35. Fendrich, Howard. "Some NFL Players Still Willing to Hide Concussions." Professional
Athletes, edited by Margaret Haerens and Lynn M. Zott, Greenhaven Press, 2014. Opposing
Viewpoints. Opposing Viewpoints in Context. Accessed 27 Mar. 2017. Originally published
in USA Today, 26 Dec. 2011.
36. Ezell, Lauren. "Timeline: The NFL's Concussion Crisis." FRONTLINE. Public Broadcasting
Service, 8 Oct. 2013. Web. 1 Apr. 2017.
37. Polnerow, Don. "Solving Football's Concussion Problem." Northeastern's Undergraduate
Writing Program Journal. Northeastern University, n.d. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
38. Polnerow, Don. "Solving Football's Concussion Problem." Northeastern's Undergraduate
Writing Program Journal. Northeastern University, n.d. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.


39. Kubota, Taylor. "5 Ways Science Could Make Football Safer." LiveScience. Purch, 30 Mar.
2016. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
40. Kubota, Taylor. "5 Ways Science Could Make Football Safer." LiveScience. Purch, 30 Mar.
2016. Web. 01 Apr. 2017.
41. United States of America. Department of Labor. Workplace Safety & Health. United States
Department of Labor. N.p., 15 July 2016. Web. 15 Apr. 2017.

Potrebbero piacerti anche