Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
1
Basic Information about HPLC
O U T L I N E
Flow Flow
Time 1 Time 2
Stationary phase Stationary phase
FIGURE 1.1.1 Simplified illustration of the separation process in chromatography (the black and white stars indicate two
different molecular species).
1.1. INTRODUCTION TO HPLC 3
Intensity units
600
1.13
500
400 5.12
300
200
3.03 4.33
4.61
100
0
1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0
Time min -->
FIGURE 1.1.2 Picture of a chromatogram indicating the retention time for some of the peaks.
In HPLC the analytes are separated from each analytes, the separation process is achieved
other and from the matrix as well as possible. depending on the choice of a chromatographic
The zones occupied by a specific analyte when column and a specific mobile phase. The detec-
it is eluted from the chromatographic column tion step is achieved using one or more detec-
(peak width in a chromatogram) can be nar- tors, and the sensitivity, selectivity, and stability
rower or wider. The width of these zones affects of these detectors is essential for the success of
the separation, and for two analytes with the HPLC analysis. The present text does not
different retention times, the separation is better include a detailed discussion of detection and
when the elution zones are narrower. measurement of the analytes, and focuses
The peaks in the chromatogram may have mainly on their separation.
different heights (and peak areas) depending Separation by HPLC can also be used for
on a number of factors such as the amount of semipreparative or preparative purposes, some
compound in the mixture, amount of sample with industrial applications. In this case, the
injected, and sensitivity of the detection proce- separated compounds of interest are collected
dure. Since peak areas are dependent on the for further utilization. However, the main focus
amount of the compound, HPLC can be used of the present volume is analytical HPLC, and
for quantitation after a proper calibration. In semipreparative and preparative HPLC are
this way, HPLC became an excellent technique beyond the scope of this work.
for separation and quantitation of compounds
even in very complex mixtures and is currently
Types of Equilibria in HPLC
the most widely used analytical technique ever
practiced. The separation process in HPLC is based on
As the previous short description of HPLC an equilibrium established between the mole-
shows, the technique has two distinct parts: cules present in the mobile phase and those
(1) separation of the analytes and of the matrix, retained in the stationary phase. The difference
(2) detection and measurement of the analytes. in the concentration of a molecular species in
The discussion about the separation is the main one phase and in another determines whether
subject of this book. Based on the nature of the the species is retained or eluted with the mobile
4 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
Mobile phase
phase. When the concentration of the solute
Analyte
(analyte) is higher in the mobile phase than in
the stationary phase, the solute is eluted faster
Liquid
from the chromatographic column. The oppo-
stationary
site happens when the concentration of the
phase
solute is higher in the stationary phase. In this
case, the solute is more strongly retained and
the elution takes place after a longer period of Solid support
time.
Common types of equilibria for a molecular FIGURE 1.1.3 Schematic description of partition
equilibrium.
species between two phases include, for example,
the distribution of a compound between two
immiscible solvents. Another common type takes
phases. A schematic description of the parti-
place during the retention of a compound from
tion chromatography process is shown in
a fluid on an adsorbing material such as charcoal.
Figure 1.1.3. In partition chromatography, the
Chemical equilibrium in a solution, for example,
concept of immobile liquid is commonly
between two ionic compounds, is also a known
approached in a loose manner. For example,
type. The main types of equilibria encountered
a layer of adsorbed water on the surface of
in chromatography can be summarized as
a silica solid support, or a layer of bonded
follows:
organic chains on a silica surface (such as in
1) Partition equilibrium. This type of equilibrium the common C18 chromatographic columns),
takes place when the molecules of the solute or a layer of mechanically held polymer on
are distributed between two liquid phases. In an inert core are all considered liquid station-
HPLC, one liquid phase is kept immobile on ary phases for partition chromatography. The
a solid material, and the other is mobile (the possibility of performing chromatography
eluent). The immobilization of the liquid to using two liquid phases without having one
become a stationary phase in partition chroma- liquid phase immobilized is exploited in coun-
tography is achieved, for example, when the tercurrent chromatography. However, this
liquid is highly polar and can establish subject is beyond the purpose of the present
hydrogen bonds with the solid support. One book (for details see, e.g., [2]).
such example is water on a silica surface. In 2) Adsorption equilibrium. This type of equilibrium
this case, the mobile phase should consist of takes place when molecules are exchanged
a liquid less polar than water. However, the between a solid surface and a liquid mobile
partition equilibrium can also be applied for phase. Assuming that the stationary phase is
a nonpolar stationary phase and a more polar very polar compared to the mobile phase, the
mobile phase. The theory of separation in polar molecules from the mobile phase are
partition chromatography is based on liquid/ adsorbed on the solid stationary phase surface,
liquid extraction principles. The different while the less polar molecules are kept mainly
molecular species, being in continuous equi- in the mobile phase. Being in equilibrium
librium between the mobile and stationary between the solid and the liquid, the more
phase, will be separated based on their polar molecules also elute from the chromato-
tendency to exist in higher concentration in graphic column, but later than the less polar
the mobile liquid or in the stationary liquid, compounds. A schematic description of the
in accordance with their affinity for these adsorption chromatography process is shown
1.1. INTRODUCTION TO HPLC 5
Mobile phase Mobile phase
Analyte Ionic
analyte
FIGURE 1.1.4 Schematic description of adsorption FIGURE 1.1.5 Schematic description of ion exchange
equilibrium. proces.
in Figure 1.1.4. The partition and the adsorp- a porous structure in which small molecules
tion are utilized basically as models for can penetrate and spend time passing
describing the type of equilibrium, but a differ- through the long channels of the solid mate-
ence between the two processes is not com- rial, while large molecules cannot penetrate
monly apparent from a thermodynamic point the pore system of the stationary phase and
of view [3]. Also, in many instances the separa- are not retained. Applied in HPLC, the large
tion can be viewed either as a partition or as an molecules elute earlier, while the small mole-
adsorption, the differentiation being made cules are retained longer. An equilibrium can
only with the purpose of estimating differently be envisioned between molecules in the
the separation parameters, while the classifica- mobile phase and those partly trapped in
tion has no effect on the real process. the solid matrix. A schematic description of
3) Equilibria involving ions. Equilibria between the size exclusion process is shown in
ions in solutions take place in numerous Figure 1.1.6.
chemical reactions. For applications in 5) Affinity interactions. This type of interaction is
HPLC, one ionic species must be immobi- typical for protein binding and leads to equi-
lized, for example, by being connected libria that allow very specific separations.
through a covalent bond to a solid matrix. Examples of such interactions are protein-
One example of this type of ion can be
a sulfonic group connected to polystyrene.
Small Mobile phase
The ions in solution can be bound by ionic
molecule
interactions to the immobilized counterion analyte
or may remain in solution. The equilibrium
between solid phase and mobile phase, Large
depending on the strength of the bond molecule
to the stationary phase, may provide analyte
a means for separation. A schematic
description of the interactions in the ion-
Porous gel
exchange chromatography process is shown
stationary phase
in Figure 1.1.5.
4) Equilibria based on size exclusion. Size exclu- FIGURE 1.1.6 Schematic description of size exclusion
sion uses a stationary phase that consists of process.
6 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
antibody and avidin-biotin. Affinity chroma- while that performed with a mobile phase
tography is widely used at low pressure for that changes in composition during the separa-
protein purification. tion is known as gradient HPLC. Gradient
HPLC allows a change in the polarity and/or
in the pH of the mobile phase during the sepa-
Criteria for the Classification of HPLC ration and significantly increases the versatility
of HPLC. When a sample contains solutes with
Procedures
very different properties and when a constant
HPLC comprises several similar techniques, composition of the mobile phase (isocratic
all of which use a liquid mobile phase passing conditions) is used, the solutes may leave the
a stationary phase with the result of a high- chromatographic column at very different
performance separation of a mixture of times. This may be seen as an advantage for
compounds. Various versions of HPLC have the separation, but when the retention time of
specific differences and different applications. some of the solutes becomes unacceptably
For this reason, the HPLC techniques are long, the change in the solvent composition
classified in various types; the classification is (by using gradients) is necessary to speed up
based on a number of criteria, such as the sepa- the separation.
ration principle (in some separations more than The differences in the size of the particles
one principle of separation may have a contribu- used in the chromatographic column offer one
tion) or the scale of the utilization. Additional more criterion for HPLC classification. The
differences have been used to distinguish more size of the particles that fill the chromato-
types of HPLC (see Section 1.2). This may graphic column affect the peak width and
include the nature of the stationary phase and therefore the separation. In common HPLC
mobile phase and/or the type of interactions the size of the particles in the chromatographic
(mechanism) that describe the energetics of column is usually 3 to 10 mm. The HPLC tech-
the process. It should be noted that the classifi- niques that use very small particles (e.g., with
cation based on the separation mechanism a diameter below 2.5 mm) in the chromato-
indirectly includes differences in the stationary graphic column (or cartridge) are usually
and mobile phase. For example, ion-exchange referred to as ultra performance liquid chromatog-
chromatography is practiced specifically on an raphy or UPLC. The very small particles require
ion-exchange stationary phase and not on additional modifications in the UPLC tech-
a reversed or a bioaffinity phase. However, the nique, such as significantly higher operation
mechanism alone was not viewed as sufficient pressure for the mobile phase. The use of small
for differentiation of some types of HPLC. particles in the columns can lead not only to
Based on the nature of the stationary phase better separations, but also to faster ones, and
and mobile phase, several types of HPLC can is one of the modern developments of HPLC.
be differentiated and are discussed further in Another development in HPLC is the use of
Section 1.2. monolithic columns made of a single piece of
Other HPLC characteristics are also used for a solid porous material.
differentiating the HPLC types. One such char- Temperature can be another criterion to
acteristic is related to the composition of the differentiate HPLC processes. Based on this
mobile phase, which can be kept constant parameter, the HPLC types are classified as:
during the separation or can be modified. The (1) low temperature (below freezing point
HPLC performed at a constant composition of of water, down to 10 C), (2) usual range temper-
the mobile phase is known as isocratic HPLC, ature (20e60 C), and (3) high temperature (up to
1.1. INTRODUCTION TO HPLC 7
250 C). Most separations are performed at distribution in a molecule, is usually a difficult
usual temperatures. Low-temperature tech- task. Also, polarity can refer to the analytes, to
niques are applied, especially for certain chiral the mobile phase or to the stationary phase. The
separations. High temperature separations can compounds are typically indicated as polar
be used for a number of applications, taking when opposite partial charges are known to
advantage of the modification of solvents prop- be present in the molecule, when specific phys-
erties as temperature increases. Water, for ical properties such as water solubility or solu-
example, shows a decrease in polarity at bility on solvents miscible with water are
temperatures between 100 and 250 C and can known, or when specific functional groups
be used as solvent in RP-HPLC. This particular known to be polar such as eCOOH, or
mode of separation has been denoted as super- eNH2 are present in the molecule. In addition,
heated water, pressurized water, or subcritical during molecular interactions the charge distri-
water chromatography (as the temperatures bution of the molecules suffers changes
used are lower than the critical temperature of (expressed by polarizability). In any interaction,
water at 374 C) [4]. The use of water as a mobile the polarizability affects the charge distribution
phase can provide an environmentally friendly of the molecules. For these reasons, comparing
green method of chromatographic analysis. molecules or phases as more polar or less
A different classification, important for prac- polar is not a quantitative assessment. The
tical purposes, is based on the scale of the opposite to the polar character is the hydro-
HPLC equipment. Three general types of chro- phobic character (lipophilic character). Nonpolar
matography can be distinguished in this way: compounds that do not have polar groups
(1) analytical HPLC, (2) semipreparative HPLC, and are not water soluble, or materials on
and (3) preparative (large scale) HPLC. Each of which surface the water does not adhere are
these types covers in fact a range of dimensions. commonly indicated as hydrophobic. Both the
For example, analytical HPLC can be further polar and the hydrophobic character of
differentiated based on the dimensions of the a compound are reasonably described by the
HPLC column in the following subtypes: partition constant (also indicated as partition
conventional, narrowbore, microbore, micro coefficient) between octanol and water Kow (or
LC-capillary, and nano LC-capillary. In the Pow). This parameter represents the ratio of
present book, most discussions will refer to concentrations of a (not ionized) compound
conventional, narrowbore, and microbore between two phases, one being octanol and
analytical HPLC. Analytical HPLC performed the other water, and is described by the formula
using microcapillary and nanoscale columns (square brackets indicate molar concentra-
(still filled with a bed of particles) are less used tions):
in practice and require specialized equipment.
soluteoctanol
Kow (1.1.1)
solutewater
Role of Polarity in HPLC
One common concept related to HPLC sepa- Positive values for log Kow indicate some
rations is that of polarity. Polarity refers to an hydrophobic character, and larger values show
asymmetrical charge distribution in a molecule, more hydrophobicity. Molecules with low or
which causes the molecule to act as an electric negative values for log Kow are frequently indi-
dipole. However, charge distribution is a very cated as polar, although there is not a direct
complex concept, and calculation of the values relation between Kow and the charge distribution
for charge density, used to characterize charge in the molecule.
8 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
The experimental values for Kow are known generating the peak. Some detectors are
for many compounds, and several computer universal, and either they provide no qualita-
programs are available for their evaluation tive information (such as refractive index detec-
(e.g., MarvinSketch 5.4.0.1, ChemAxon Ltd. [5], tors) or they provide only partial information
EPI Suite [6]) as well as extensive tables [7, 8]. that is not in itself sufficient for positive identi-
In the present text, some of these concepts fication of an analyte (e.g., UV absorption). In
will be further discussed and clarified. such cases, the chemical nature of the analyte
However, the concept of polar and nonpolar must be known, and its peak in the chromato-
(hydrophobic) compounds or materials will be gram is identified based on its retention time
frequently used in an imprecise manner. For established using standards that were previ-
mobile phases, the extension of the concept of ously analyzed. For this reason, the stability
polarity is immediate, being based on the (reproducibility) of the retention time in a chro-
polarity of the molecules of the phase. For matogram (obtained in identical conditions) is
stationary phases, the polarity refers to the very important.
nature of the stationary phase surface or of Other detectors such as mass spectrometers
phase active moiety. (MS) or MS/MS offer more detailed insight
As a conclusion, HPLC techniques can be into qualitative peak identification. However,
differentiated based on a number of criteria. the dependence on operational conditions of
Each selected criterion has advantages and the mass spectra obtained using LC/MS or
disadvantages. For example, the mechanism LC/MS/MS instrumentation makes the process
for a particular separation is not always well of compound identification quite difficult even
understood, and the polar or nonpolar when using these techniques. Progress in MS
nature of the stationary and mobile phase is identification of unknown compounds has
sometimes difficult to quantify. The physical been done, for example, by using very high
criteria such as particle dimension in the chro- accuracy in mass measurement for the parent
matographic column or the scale of the HPLC ion of the analyte and for its fragments (e.g.,
equipment are available in a range and the using Orbitrap or cyclotron technologies).
limits used for the classification are subjective. Also, specific computer programs (Mass Fron-
For this reason, the HPLC classifications should tier, SmileMS) provide help in identifying
be viewed mainly as an attempt to have models, unknown compounds. However, in most cases,
and sometimes a particular HPLC type can be the compound identification capability, even
classified in more than one way. using MS or MS/MS detection, is not used for
discovery of the composition of an unknown
compound, but for positive identification of
Qualitative Analysis and HPLC Main a known analyte, corroborated with the reten-
Use as a Quantitative Analytical tion time of its standard, previously analyzed.
The confirmation of the peak for a specific ana-
Technique
lyte in a chromatogram (typically using MS
HPLC analysis starts with a separation of and three confirmation ions) is an important
components of interest from a sample. The sepa- and common element in HPLC practice. The
rated analytes are represented by the peaks in use of standards with labeled isotopes for the
the chromatogram. The analyte detection can analytes (e.g., deuterated analyte) spiked in
be performed using a variety of instrumental the sample is also a common practice for peak
devices (detectors), some of which provide identification in LC/MS and LC/MS/MS.
qualitative information for the compound Although the retention time of the isotope
1.2. MAIN TYPES OF HPLC 9
labeled standards may vary slightly from that of classification of the main types of HPLC.
the analyte itself, peak identification is signifi- Because different HPLC types have different
cantly facilitated using this technique. characteristics and applications, it is important
Quantitave analysis is the main use of HPLC. to understand these differences and select the
Once separated, the concentration of the analy- appropriate HPLC type for solving a specific
tes in the sample can be obtained from the chro- separation/analysis problem.
matographic peak area (or height).
Peak areas (or peak heights) in the chromato- 1) Reversed-phase HPLC (or RP-HPLC) is the
gram are proportional to the concentration of most common HPLC technique, and
the analytes, and quantitation is done using cali- a very large number of compounds can be
bration curves with standards, or other proce- separated by RP-HPLC. This type of chro-
dures. Depending on the detection technique matography is performed on a nonpolar
and the analyte properties, some HPLC analyses stationary phase with a polar mobile phase.
can provide results even for ultra-low traces of A wide variety of nonpolar stationary
a compound (below ng/mL level). The versa- phases is available, and RP-HPLC is very
tility and high sensitivity of HPLC have contrib- likely the most common type of chromatog-
uted to its success and widespread use. raphy used in practice. The stationary
An exceptionally large number of methods phase for RP-HPLC can be obtained, for
using HPLC quantitation procedures has example, by chemically bonding long
been published. These methods can be found hydrocarbon chains on a solid surface
in a variety of sources, including papers in such as silica. The most common chain
scientific journals, books, web articles, and bound to silica is C18 (it contains 18 carbon
proceedings of conferences. The goal of this atoms), which has a high hydrophobic
book is to describe the principles used for character. The bonded phase hydropho-
developing HPLC methods and to provide bicity may vary depending on the nature
information for potential improvements of the substituent. For example, C18
regarding these techniques; detailed descrip- bonded phase has a higher hydrophobicity
tions of analytical methods are beyond its than C8 bonded phases. Polymeric mate-
purpose. rials are also used as the RP-HPLC
stationary phase. The mobile phase in RP-
HPLC is typically a mixture of an organic
solvent (CH3CN, CH3OH, isopropanol,
1.2. MAIN TYPES OF HPLC
etc.) and water, with a range of content in
the organic solvent. Small amounts of
A Classification of HPLC Types buffers can also be added to the mobile
A variety of HPLC types have been differen- phase in RP-HPLC. The interactions in
tiated in the literature; some of these types are RP-HPLC are considered to be the hydro-
similar, and others exhibit significant differ- phobic forces. These forces are caused by
ences. The differentiation was based not only the energies resulting from the disturbance
on various criteria such as the nature of the of the dipolar structure of the solvent. The
stationary and mobile phases and the type of so called solvophobic effect is caused by
interactions assumed to lead to the separation, the force of cavity-reduction in water
but also on the range of concentration of specific around the analyte and the nonpolar
solvents in the mobile phase (e.g., of water) stationary phase when the two are interact-
and so on. This section presents a common ing. The retention of the analyte on the
10 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
R e X substrate is replaced by a stronger liquid inside the resin and the mobile phase.
cationic species (e.g,. M) such that M is (The Donnan effect or Gibbs-Donnan effect
retained from the solution, while C passes describes the distribution of ions in solution
into the mobile phase. Two different in two compartments separated by a semi-
cations from solution, M
1 and M2 , can be permeable membrane).
separated based on their retention 12) Ligand-exchange chromatography is a type of
strength. chromatography in which the stationary
9) Anion-exchange chromatography is a type of phase is a cation-exchange resin loaded
HPLC used for the separation of anions (inor- with a metal ion (e.g., of a transitional
ganic or organic). This HPLC is similar in metal) that is able to form coordinative
principle to the cation-exchange type, but bonds with the molecules from the mobile
the anionic species B from solution are phase. The elution is done with a mobile
retained by covalently bonded ionic groups phase able to displace the analyte from
of the type R Y. Similarly to cation the bond with the metal, and the separa-
exchange stationary phases, an anion tion is based on the differences in the
exchange is initially in the form R Y A. strength of the interaction (of coordinative
For an anion-exchange material the anion type) of these solutes with the bonded
A previously bound is replaced on the resin metal ion.
by the anion B, and two different anions B 1
and B 13) Immobilized metal affinity chromatography is
2 are separated based on their different
retention strengths. The mobile phase in ion- closely related to ligand-exchange chroma-
exchange chromatography frequently con- tography and uses a resin-containing
sists of buffer solutions. chelating groups that can form complexes
with metals such as Cu2, Ni2, and Zn2.
10) Ion-exchange on amphoteric or zwitterionic
The metal ions loaded on the resin still
phases is a type of IEC that is very similar
have coordinative capability for other elec-
in principle to the cation-exchange or
tron donor molecules such as proteins. The
anion-exchange IEC. The stationary phase retained analytes can be eluted by destabi-
of this type of IEC contains groups that
lizing the complex with the metal, for
have an amphoteric character or, in the
example, by pH changes or addition of a dis-
case of zwitterionic phases, both anionic
placing agent such as ammonia in the
and cationic groups. The mobile phase in
mobile phase.
these types of chromatography also consists
of buffer solutions. 14) Ion-moderated chromatography is an HPLC
technique similar to ligand-exchange chro-
11) Ion-exclusion chromatography is an HPLC
matography, with the difference that the
technique in which an ion-exchange resin
stationary phase loaded with the metal ion
is used for the separation of neutral species
(e.g., Ca2, Na, K, Ag, or even H)
between them and from ionic species. In
does not form coordinative bonds with the
this technique, ionic compounds from the
analyte, the interactions being based mainly
solution are rejected by the selected resin
on polarity.
(through the so-called Donnan effect), and
they are eluted as nonretained compounds. 15) Gel filtration chromatography (GFC) is a type
Nonionic or weakly ionic compounds pene- of size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) in
trate the pores of the resin and are retained which the molecules are separated based
selectively as they partition between the on their size (more correctly, their
1.2. MAIN TYPES OF HPLC 13
hydrodynamic volume). In gel filtration an phase is passed through the column and
aqueous (mostly aqueous) solution is used elutes the specific retained molecule. The
to transport the sample through the method is more frequently applied as
column and is applied to molecules that a preparative chromatographic technique
are soluble in water and polar solvents. than as a HPLC analytical method.
Size-exclusion chromatography uses 18) Affinity chromatography is a liquid chro-
porous particles with a variety of pore matographic technique typically used for
sizes to separate molecules. Molecules protein and other bio-molecule separation
that are smaller than the pore size of the and commonly indicated as bioaffinity chro-
stationary phase enter the porous particles matography. It can be practiced on a variety
during the separation and flow through of specifically made stationary phases that
the intricate channels of the stationary allow selective retention of the analytes
phase. Small molecules have a long path based on affinity interactions.
through the column and therefore a long
transit time. Some very large molecules 19) Chiral chromatography on chiral stationary
cannot enter the pores at all and elute phases is a type of HPLC used to separate
without retention (total exclusion). Mole- chiral compounds. Only specific applica-
cules of medium size enter only some tions require the separation of chiral
larger pores and not the small ones, and compounds, and regular chromatography
are only partly retained, eluting faster is much more common than chiral chroma-
than small molecules and slower than the tography. Chiral chromatography still has
very large ones. The separation of small numerous applications, particularly in the
molecules between themselves is not typi- analysis of pharmaceutical compounds.
cally achieved, and the technique is The technique typically requires chiral
utilized mainly for the separation of stationary phases containing chiral selector
macromolecules and of macromolecules groups.
from small molecules. GFC is sometimes 20) Chiral chromatography on achiral stationary
indicated as aqueous SEC. phases is also possible for some chiral solutes
16) Gel permeation chromatography (GPC) is by using chiral modifiers in the mobile
another type of size-exclusion chromatog- phase, although the stationary phase is not
raphy (SEC), the only difference from chiral.
gel filtration being the mobile phase, which 21) Multimode HPLC is a type of chromatog-
in this case is an organic solvent. The tech- raphy in which the column contains by
nique is used mainly for the separation of purpose more than one type of stationary
hydrophobic macromolecules (such as phase, for example, some with bonded
solutions of certain synthetic polymers). nonpolar groups (e.g. C18), and some with
GPC is sometimes indicated as nonaqueous ionic groups (e.g., SO-3). This type of char-
SEC. acter can be encountered unintentionally
17) Displacement chromatography is a chromato- on columns made using as a stationary
graphic technique where all the molecules phase a silica support covered with silanol
of a sample are initially retained on a chro- groups, and also with hydrophobic groups
matographic column (loading phase). (such as C18). In most cases, the presence
After the sample is loaded, a displace- of two types of interactions (e.g., polar and
ment reagent dissolved in the mobile hydrophobic) is not desirable, but in some
14 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
TABLE 1.2.1 Separation Principle and Main Types etc.) for each type of HPLC is not a straightfor-
of HPLC ward subject. It is possible that more than one
Separation mechanism Types of HPLC
such mechanism takes place in a specific
HPLC type, and in some cases it is difficult to
Hydrophobic forces 1) Reversed phase (RP) decide, based on experimental data, which
2) Ion pair equilibrium mechanism is involved in the sepa-
ration. However, an association between
3) HIC
different types of HPLC and different equilib-
4) Non-aqueous reversed phase rium mechanisms can be observed. The main
(NARP)
separation principles and the corresponding
Difference in polarity 5) HILIC HPLC types are summarized in Table 1.2.1.
6) Normal phase (NPC) The relation between the HPLC main groups
and the equilibrium mechanism should not be
7) Aqueous normal phase (ANP)
viewed as rigid, and more than one type of
Ion interaction 8) Cation exchange equilibrium may take place in a specific type
9) Anion exchange
of HPLC.
10) Ion exchange on amphoteric
and zwitterionic phases
with the sample preparation, in accord with order to obtain better properties for the chro-
the selected analysis type. Again, numerous matographic analysis. The process of sample
procedures are described in the literature for preparation is schematically shown in
sample preparation [1]. Sample preparation Figure 1.3.1. Sample preparation is usually
may target the matrix of the sample, the ana- described for each HPLC analytical procedure
lytes, or both. One common operation in when applied for a practical analysis and
sample preparation is the dissolution of the covers a large part of the published literature
sample if the sample is solid. Then, the matrix on HPLC. Several books describing the
is usually modified during cleanup, fraction- general principles and various aspects of
ation, and concentration of the sample. Proper sample preparation for chromatography also
processing of the sample may have consider- have been published (see, e.g., [1, 10]).
able importance for the success of the HPLC
analysis. A sample that contains a dirty
matrix, having numerous other solutes that Injection
can impede the separation or destroy the Sample delivery for analysis in HPLC is
chromatographic column must be avoided as achieved using injection. This is done with the
much as possible. Also, the sample prepara- purpose of introducing in the mobile phase the
tion may have a considerable part in sample containing the analytes and matrix that
increasing the analytes concentration. The are going to be separated and analyzed. The
increase in the concentration of the analytes sample is dissolved in a solvent, and the choice
is very important especially when traces of of this solvent in connection with the volume of
specific compounds must be quantitated, as sample volume may have an effect on HPLC
is necessary in many practical applications. separation. The sample solvent must be soluble
This concentration can be done by a variety in the mobile phase. Larger volumes of the
of procedures such as solid-phase extraction sample solvent may affect for a short period of
(SPE) and liquid-liquid extraction (LLE) [1]. time the composition of the mobile phase, influ-
The analytes can also be modified by encing the separation, in particular the peak
chemical reactions (derivatization, etc.) in shape. For this reason, a sample volume is
Modification
Sample Modification
of the sample HPLC
collection of the analytes
matrix
Dissolution
Preparation for
derivatization Processed
Initial Sample sample
sample cleanup and
fractionation
Derivatization
Sample
concentration
FIGURE 1.3.1 Diagram of a sample preparation involving dissolution, cleanup, fractionation, concentration, and
derivatization.
1.3. PRACTICE OF HPLC 17
usually limited to the range of 5 to 25 mL for in HPLC can be pure compounds such as
common HPLC techniques. Smaller injection water, methanol, ethanol, acetonitrile, tetrahy-
volumes can be used for mini or micro HPLC, drofuran, hexane, or methylene chloride.
and larger volumes than typical are sometimes However, more commonly solvent mixtures
used in order to obtain better sensitivity for are used, and in some separations various
the analysis. For semipreparative or preparative additives are present in the mobile phase
HPLC the injection volume is much larger. More such as salts, acids, and bases (at low concen-
details regarding sample injection are given in trations) that provide a specific pH and ionic
Section 9.2. strength of the mobile phase. The separations
can be performed in isocratic conditions, but
gradient separations are very common, in
Column Selection in HPLC
particular in RP-HPLC, HILIC, and NPC.
The column is a major component for the Chiral and size-exclusion separations are typi-
HPLC separation, and its selection is critical cally not performed with gradient elution.
for the success of the analysis. Numerous types Gradients (solvent composition modifications
of columns are commercially available. during the separation) are usually achieved
Columns may be different regarding: (1) the by mixing two solutions with different compo-
nature of the active stationary phase (RP, sition. Gradients can also be achieved by mix-
HILIC, IEC, SEC, bioaffinity, etc.), (2) the type ing more than two solutions, but three or four
of phase (porous particles, superficially porous solvent gradients are not common. The role of
particles, monoliths, etc.), (3) physical charac- gradient is to increase certain components of
teristics of particles (dimension, porosity, the mobile phase, for example, an organic
strength, etc.), (4) column dimensions (length, solvent in a partially aqueous solution.
diameter), (5) mechanical construction Solvent/solvent composition is selected with
(columns, cartridges, compressible columns), the purpose of (1) achieving separation, (2)
etc. The column is basically selected in agree- achieving a fast separation, and (3) delivering
ment with the type of separation that was the analytes to the detection without inter-
chosen, equipment availability, analysis fering with measurement. Mobile phase capa-
requirements, and external information avail- bility to elute an analyte at shorter retention
able. Column choice has a significant effect in times compared to other solvents is typically
achieving a desired separation, and a detailed referred to as solvent strength. In RP-HPLC,
discussion about chromatographic columns the increase in the concentration of organic
and their separating capabilities is given in solvent in the mobile phase leads to faster
Chapter 6. elution of the analytes. The nature of the mobile
phase also affects other parameters of
the HPLC process, such as the selection of
Mobile Phase Selection the detector or the acceptable flow rate in the
In all HPLC analyses, the choice of mobile HPLC system. The chromatographic column
phase is another critical step for effecting generates backpressure during the mobile
a successful separation. The solvents are phase flow, and this backpressure is related to
selected depending on the type of HPLC, the the mobile phase viscosity. The mobile phase
nature of the analytes, the choice of the nature and properties, as well as its delivery
stationary phase, and also the type of detection conditions as isocratic or gradient, are further
used for the analyte measurement. The solvents discussed in Chapter 7.
18 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
peak area A)is of the internal standard and the a signal proportional with the analyte concen-
peak area A)x of the compound to be analyzed, tration. Using calibrations, the concentration of
both of which are added to a blank sample in the analytes can be determined. This process
equal amounts (concentration). The ratio of the can be achieved using a large number of models
two areas, usually obtained as an average of of HPLC systems. The construction of these
several measurements, gives the response instruments depends significantly on the
factor: intended function and size of the HPLC separa-
tion. Modern HPLC instrumentation is sophisti-
Fx Ais =Ax (1.3.7)
cated and is in continuous development [11].
For this reason, this section is intended only to
Ideally, the value for Fx remains constant for
give a basic and simplified view regarding the
an interval of values for the pair of concentra-
HPLC equipment.
tions of the standard and the sample. The
concentration of the unknown is then obtained
by measuring in the same run the peak area of Schematic Description of an HPLC
the compound to be analyzed (at unknown Instrument
concentration) and the peak area of the standard
When used for analytical purposes, an
using the formula:
example of an HPLC instrument consists of
cx Fx Ax =Ais cis (1.3.8) several components that are schematically
where Ax is the area of the compound x at shown in Figure 1.4.1. The system may include:
unknown concentration, Ais is the area of the stan- (1) a solvent supply system (solvent container
dard at the concentration cis, and Fx is the response and degasser), (2) a high-pressure pumping
factor. In order to achieve a constant value for the system (shown as a dual piston mechanical
response factor Fx in a range of concentrations, it pump), (3) an injector (shown with a syringe
is recommended that the two compounds, the containing the sample that can be loaded in
internal standard and the analyte, be chemically a loop, and a switching valve in two positions
similar or even identical except for use of a labeled A load loop with sample, B connect loop in
compound for the standard. circuit flow to inject sample), (4) a chromato-
graphic column (possibly with a guard column
or precolumn), (5) one or more detectors (a spec-
trophotometric detector is schematized), and (6)
1.4. OVERVIEW OF HPLC
a controller/data processing unit.
INSTRUMENTATION
Some details on each component of an HPLC
system are further discussed in this section.
General Comments However, the description of HPLC instrumenta-
The HPLC instrument physically separates tion is not the main goal of this book, and more
the components of a sample, typically in solu- information on the subject can be obtained from
tion, and provides information about the various other sources such as instrument
concentration of each separated component. manuals (e.g. [12, 13]) or from other dedicated
For this purpose, the instruments allow the publications (e.g. [14]).
injection of a measured small volume of sample
in a mobile phase. This mobile phase flows
through a chromatographic column where the
Solvent Supply Systems
separation takes place, and further through The solvent supply provides the solvent(s)
a detector (or detectors) capable of generating necessary as a mobile phase for the HPLC.
1.4. OVERVIEW OF HPLC INSTRUMENTATION 21
Solvent A
Syringe
1
Injector
(load)
Degasser Pump Loop
Motor
Mixing T
Control and
2 Switching Sample
data system
valve
Motor
3A
Waste
Detector Injector
6 Chromatographic (inject)
column Precolumn
Flow cell 4
Waste
3B
FIGURE 1.4.1 Schematic description of a simple HPLC system. 1) A solvent supply system (solvent container and degasser),
2) a high pressure pumping system (a dual piston mechanical pump is pictured), 3) an injector (a syringe with the sample
and a switching valve in two positions A load loop, B inject), 4) a chromatographic column (possibly with a precolumn or
guard column), 5) one or more detectors (a spectrophotometric detector is schematized), 6) a controller/data processing unit.
Some solvent supply systems may also have the use gradient separations, or to use an isocratic
capability to remove the gasses dissolved in separation but to generate the mixture of
solvents (the degassing capability). The solvents using the pumps. In this case, two (or
solvent(s) are transferred through low pressure more) solvents that are mixed with the pumping
tubing to the pumping system. The tubes used system in variable proportions are required. For
for passing the mobile phase through the system this reason, two or more solvent reservoirs are
need to fulfill mainly the requirement of being common in modern HPLC instruments. The
inert to the utilized solvents and to stand pres- reservoirs must be clean and inert to the
sures up to about 50 psi (1 psi 6.89476 kPa solvents they contain. The solvents from
6.89476 10-2 bar 6.80460 10-2 atm; 1 bar the reservoirs must be free of particles, and
14.5037738 psi). Fluorocarbon polymers such they are either purchased as HPLC grade or/
as Teflon are common materials used for this and filtered through 0.45 mm filters before use.
type of tubing, but polypropylene is also some- The filter selected for the filtration must be inert
times used. The solvent supply system of an to the solvent. In the case of solvent mixtures
HPLC has one or more reservoirs for the containing a buffer, the general rule indicates
solvents used as the mobile phase. For HPLC that the buffer solution is made in water, then
performed in isocratic conditions and using filtered, and only then mixed with the organic
a pure or a premixed solvent, only one reservoir solvent (assuming correct concentrations and
is necessary. However, it is common in HPLC to no precipitation after organic solvent addition).
22 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
The tubing transferring the liquid to the polymeric tubing placed in a vacuum chamber.
pump(s) typically has a frit at its mouth. The tubing material (membrane) has selective
Degassing in HPLC systems is necessary permeability to gasses, and the vacuum created
because even very pure solvents may have small by a small pump reduces the content of the
quantities of oxygen dissolved in them. This gasses from the solvent. The degassers, although
oxygen may be released in the form of very popular in HPLC equipment, also may pose
small bubbles in the HPLC system when problems in specific applications. The polymeric
a drop in pressure occurs (e.g., between the tubing may absorb selectively specific compo-
chromatographic column and the detector), or nents from the solvents and may be a source of
when a solvent with high solubility for oxygen contamination when changing from one solvent
(e.g., water) is mixed with another solvent to another. It should also be noted that large
with low solubility for this gas. When this mix- bubbles coming from the solvent reservoir
ing is done before the high-pressure pump, the cannot be eliminated by the degasser apparatus;
gas bubbles may lead to variations in the pres- these bubbles make their way into the pumps,
sure of the liquid delivered by the pump affecting their function.
(pressure fluctuations). Dissolved gasses in the
mobile phase may also influence the injection
Pumping Systems
volume when small sample volumes (e.g.,
2 mL) are injected. Also, the reading of the detec- The main pumping system consists of
tors can be perturbed by dissolved gasses. For pump(s) able to deliver a constant flow of
example, oxygen may affect the reading of elec- solvent through the injector, chromatographic
trochemical detectors, the fluorescence intensity column, and through the detector(s). The
of certain compounds, and the UV absorption at pumps must be able to generate a high pressure,
very low wavelength range. The elimination of which is needed mainly to overcome the resis-
gasses dissolved in solvents is accomplished tance to flow of the chromatographic column.
through two common procedures: helium This flow is characterized by the volumetric
sparging and use of a degasser apparatus. flow rate U. In conventional HPLC systems, the
Helium sparging consists of passing a small pumps are usually capable of delivering U
flow of helium through the solvent. Although between 0.1 mL/min and 10 mL/min fluid
this procedure is useful for reducing the oxygen and can generate up to 6000 psi (about 400
content, it poses a problem in the case of pre- bar). New developments in using very fine
mixed solvents. Premixed solvents are particles in the chromatographic column require
frequently used as one of the mobile phase higher pressure and sometimes capability to
components in HPLC. If the premixed solvent produce flows at less than 0.1 mL/min. These
contains a volatile component, the solvent instruments can generate up to 8500 psi (about
composition may be changed in time by the 600 bar) or higher (e.g., 1200 bar for a flow up
preferential evaporation of the volatile compo- to 5 mL/min) and are indicated as UPLC or
nent due to sparging. In particular, when U-HPLC. For the HPLC systems used for other
ammonia is used in a mobile phase to adjust purposes than analytical, pumping parameters
the pH of the solution, sparging is not recom- can vary significantly. The flow from the pumps
mended since drastic changes in the pH occur (volumetric flow rate U) must be constant,
in time by the preferential elimination of without fluctuations or only with very small
ammonia from the solution. ones. This requirement is necessary mainly for
A degasser apparatus is a device in which the the detectors, where the signal may fluctuate
solvent passes through a piece of a special when the flow rate varies.
1.4. OVERVIEW OF HPLC INSTRUMENTATION 23
forward stroke suction stroke forward stroke suction stroke
100
75
Flow %
50
25
0
0 1 2 3 4
Time
FIGURE 1.4.2 Flow from a single piston reciprocating pump when the piston is moved by a circular motion of a driving
cam.
Most high-pressure pumps used in analytical are able to generate flow with only one zero
HPLC are reciprocating pumps. A single-piston flow point per cycle. However, with this setup
reciprocating pump consists of a cylinder with the flow is still fluctuating. The use of specially
a reciprocating plunger in it, together with two shaped driving cams or of stepper-driven
valves mounted in the head of the cylinder. motors allows the generation of an almost
The liquid enters the cylinder through an inlet continuous flow of liquid. The dual-piston
(suction) valve and is pushed through pumps may be connected in parallel or in series.
a discharge valve. During the suction the A dual-piston design working in parallel was
plunger retracts and the inlet valve opens, already schematically shown in Figure 1.4.1.
causing the admission of fluid into the cylinder, An accumulator-piston design with the pumps
while the discharge valve is closed. In the in series is shown schematically in Figure 1.4.3.
forward stroke, the plunger pushes the liquid This type of system also requires two pistons
out through the discharge valve while the inlet but only three valves in order to achieve the
valve is closed. However, the fluid flow from task of generating a continuous flow.
a single-piston reciprocating pump (and there- Modern systems are able to deliver flow with
fore the pressure in the system) has a pulsating a precision of about 0.07% relative standard
profile. When the piston is moved by a circular deviation (RSD%) and a flow accuracy of less
motion of a driving cam, the flow rate has than 1% from the nominal value. Because the
a half sinusoid shape, as shown in Figure 1.4.2. pumps must deliver flow at high or very high
This type of flow is not suitable for HPLC. pressure, their construction requires special
Dual-piston pumps consisting of two recipro- materials such as inert steel body, sapphire or
cating pumps that alternate the forward stoke ceramic pistons, high-precision valves that do
Motor
1 forward stroke 1 forward stroke 2 forward stroke 1 forward stroke 2
100
75
Flow %
Motor
2 50
25
0
Solvent 1 0 1 2 3 4
Time
FIGURE 1.4.3 Flow from a dual accumulator-piston reciprocating pump when the pistons are moved by stepper-driven
motors that allows low pulsation.
24 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
not have any leaks, special polymeric seals, and with several proportioning inlet valves
the like. For ion chromatography, the whole controlled by a computer. The valves open
pumping system (except the piston) is typically repeatedly for a short period of time (typically
made of strong polymeric materials such as pol- less than one second); the duration of time the
yetheretherketone (PEEK). valve is opened is proportional to the desired
In addition to the specially designed mobile phase composition. The mixed solvents
pumps and valves, the flow without fluctua- are delivered further to one (dual-piston) high-
tions from the pumping system can be pressure pump. Low-pressure mixing has the
achieved using a pressure pulsation damper. advantage of using a single high-pressure
Pressure dampening is done, for example, pump (that is typically expensive), and has
by passing the fluid through a cell with a dia- more flexibility in choosing a variety of solvents
phragm wall that compensates the pressure (in systems with four proportioning valves).
variation. The pulsation with dampening can However, the changes in the mobile phase
be reduced to less than 2% variation in pres- composition when using a low-pressure mixing
sure. Various models of dampers are avail- system are taking place more gradually than for
able, and most of them have a volume of the other systems (the change in composition is
around 500 mL, in order to assure a small not instantaneous). Also, low-pressure mixing
delay volume in the delivered fluid. Other may be prone to the formation of small bubbles
sources of delay volumes, beside the damper, of gas in the mixed solvent, when the solubility
are present in an HPLC system. of oxygen, for example, is higher in one solvent
A dual-piston pump can handle only one than in the mixture. These bubbles may enter
solvent and can be applied for isocratic separa- the high-pressure pump and generate flow
tions that use a pure or a premixed solvent. fluctuations.
However, since in HPLC it is frequently neces- In high-pressure mixing, two high-pressure
sary to use gradient separation, instruments (dual-piston) pumps are used, and the ratio of
that handle more than one solvent have been solvents in the mobile phase is controlled by
developed. This type of instrument is also the flow rate of the high-pressure pumps. The
frequently used to generate a solvent mixture mixing of the two solvents A and B can be
of a desired composition, even when this achieved either in a specially designed mixer
composition is not changed during the separa- (typically with volume of less than 500 mL) or
tion (isocratic conditions). There are three basic in a mixing T (with virtually zero volume).
procedures to physically achieve the mixing of High-pressure mixing is thought to provide
solvents: (1) low-pressure mixing, where the a more precise control of the composition of
solvents necessary for the gradient are premixed the mobile phase (with a typical composition
with a low-pressure pump connected in front of precision of less than 0.15% RSD% at 1 mL/
the high-pressure pump, (2) high-pressure mix- min flow) and does not have the problem of
ing that uses two (or more) high-pressure formation of bubbles caused by the difference
pumps, with each one dedicated to one solvent in solubility of oxygen in the mixed solvent
and with the mixing of the flows in a low- compared to that in one of the components.
volume mixer, and (3) hybrid mixing that uses However, the cost of high-pressure pumps is
a high-pressure pump with two or three propor- a disadvantage for this type of mixing. Most
tioning inlet valves. modern HPLC systems with high-pressure mix-
In low-pressure mixing, two or more (usually ing have two pumps as well as the capability of
four) solvents can be blended at the desired switching between two solvent pairs (A1, B1,
composition by using a low-pressure pump and A2, B2).
1.4. OVERVIEW OF HPLC INSTRUMENTATION 25
Since instruments with low-pressure and diminished. The formation of precipitates
high-pressure mixing are common in laborato- following the mixing must be carefully avoided
ries, when transferring an established analytical and only buffers at low concentration of salts
technique from one instrument to another, (typically less than 100 mmol) should be used
attention should be paid to the type of instru- when organic solvents are to be added to the
ment. In both types of chromatographic aqueous buffer.
systems, there is a specific volume passing the During the separation, the composition of the
system from the point at which the mobile phase mobile phase can be kept constant for some inter-
solvents are mixed until they reach the head of vals of time and modified for other periods of
the chromatographic column. This volume is time. The modern instruments are commonly
known as dwell volume VD. The dwell volume controlled using a computer with a dedicated
is typically different in low-pressure mixing program that assists in generating a specific
systems (2e4 mL) and in high-pressure mixing gradient using a gradient time table. Based on the
systems (1e3 mL). Special instruments, such gradient timetable, the computer controls the
those used in microscale HPLC may have pumping system that physically generates
smaller dwell volumes (less than 300 mL). For the desired mobile phase composition by mixing
certain applications using gradient separations in the correct proportion of the solvents from the
on common HPLC systems, differences can be solvent supply system. The gradient starts when
seen when working with one type of instrument the sample is injected. After the gradient ends,
or with the other, although the gradient the HPLC chromatograph is made ready for the
program is the same. This is in particular caused next injection. The total runtime of the chromato-
by the differences in the dwell volume from one gram, starting with the moment of injection until
system to another. the end of the chromatographic run, is some-
Hybrid mixing uses a system of two recipro- times referred to as total cycle time. In a gradient
cating high-pressure pumps with proportioning separation, the dwell volume VD of the system
inlet (suction) valves. Low-pressure mixing creates a dwell time tD. Because of the dwell
systems with four proportioning valves and time, there is a delay between the change of
one dual-piston high-pressure pump, as well composition at the point of solvent mixing (set
as high-pressure mixing systems with two in the time table) and the change in composition
high-pressure pumps (each one dual piston), at the head of chromatographic column. There-
are much more common than hybrid systems. fore, when attempting to modify the retention
To modify the composition of the mobile time of a peak by using a stronger solvent,
phase in gradient HPLC, the solvents that are this change should be done in the gradient time-
blended in specified proportions should be table ahead of the peak retention time.
perfectly miscible. Particular care must be paid The modification in concentration between
to the solubility differences of certain additives two changing points of the gradient can be
present in one solvent when another solvent is linear. For a gradient starting at time t1 with
added. For example, it is common in HPLC to the concentration c1 of component A and ending
use buffer solutions. These solutions can be at time t2 with the concentration c2, at an inter-
easily made in water by adding mixtures of salts mediate point at time t the concentration of
and acids or salts and bases. When a water solu- component A can be obtained using the
tion containing these types of additives is mixed formula:
with an organic solvent (such as CH3OH or
t t1
CH3CN), the solubility of the additives in the ct c1 c2 c1 (1.4.1)
mixed organic/aqueous solution is drastically t2 t1
26 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
In most HPLC separations the mobile phase a variation in concentration with a function
is changed from one content in an organic modi- given by the formula:
fier to another one. The change in the concentra-
tion of the organic modifier in a period of time is t t1 n
ct c1 1 1 c2 c1
indicated as gradient slope. For a linear change in t2 t1
concentration, the gradient slope can be defined (1.4.4)
by the expression:
c2 c1 When n is larger than 1, the curve of increase
D (1.4.2) does not hold water, and when n is between
t2 t1
0 and 1, the curve of increase holds water.
Some HPLC pumping systems allow both This type of gradient variation is illustrated in
a linear change in the gradient and a nonlinear Figure 1.4.5 for t1 0, c1 0 and t2 2,
modification of the concentration (see, e.g., c2 100 and n values higher than 1.
[15]). This change can be achieved using a varia- Much less frequently than reciprocating
tion in concentration as a function of time given pumps, syringe pumps are sometimes used in
by the formula: HPLC. Only the recent developments in UPLC
made the syringe pumps more attractive.
t t1 n UPLC requires low flow rates (of the order of
ct c1 c2 c1 (1.4.3)
t2 t1 0.1 mL/min) and less solvent compared to
conventional HPLC. In syringe pumps,
where n is larger than 1 for curves of increase a cylinder is loaded with the mobile phase that
that hold water and is between 0 and 1 for is delivered at a specified flow rate by the move-
the does not hold water type of curve. This ment of a piston. The flow from a syringe high
type of gradient variation is illustrated in pressure pump can be virtually fluctuation
Figure 1.4.4 for t1 0, c1 0 and t2 2, free as compared to that from a reciprocating
c2 100 and different n values. A different pump. The price of a syringe pump can also
type of nonlinear curve can be obtained using be lower.
100%
100%
80% n = 1/4 n=4
Component A %
n = 1/3 80%
Component A %
n=3
60% n = 1/2 n=2
60%
n=1 n=1
40% n=2 40%
n=3
20% n=4 20%
0% 0%
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 0 0.5 1 1.5 2
Time (min) Time (min)
FIGURE 1.4.4 Non-linear gradient variation using FIGURE 1.4.5 Non-linear gradient variation using
formula 1.4.3. formula 1.4.4.
1.4. OVERVIEW OF HPLC INSTRUMENTATION 27
volume loops. The sample volume is typically
Injectors
controlled using a computer. For UPLC, the
The role of the injector is to add in the mobile injection volumes can be between 20 and
phase a small, precisely measured volume of 500 nL, which is significantly smaller than for
a solution containing the sample. The injection common analytical HPLC; for semipreparative
must be done reproducibly and accurately. or preparative HPLC, the volumes can be
Reproducibility of injection is of particular much larger. These systems may need specially
importance, and modern injectors typically designed injectors.
show less than 0.5% RSD% in the injected The sample is ideally introduced in the
volume. The accuracy errors in injection volume mobile phase flow as a zone (plug) with the con-
are important mainly when comparing different centration of the sample following a perfectly
instruments since for the same instrument the rectangular profile. The force pushing the fluid
use of standards for quantitation may compen- through the tube is given by the cross-sectional
sate small variations from a nominal volume. area of the tube multiplied by the pressure drop
However, for a specific method it is recommen- Dp, or pr2t Dp (where rt is the tube radius). In
ded to keep the same injection volume when a laminar flow, the layer adjacent to the wall is
injecting different samples in order to avoid held virtually stationary by adhesion, and the
accuracy problems. inner fluid layers slide over the ones closer to
Figure 1.4.1 shows one of many possible the wall creating a shear force. This force is
injection systems in which a loop of a precise given by the formula:
volume is filled first with the sample and then
connected to the flow circuit using a switching Fh h A du=dr (1.4.5)
valve. This system allows only the injection of
a fixed volume of sample, equal with the loop where h is the liquid viscosity, u is the fluid
volume. However, the volume of sample solu- linear velocity, dr is the infinitesimal distance
tion to be injected in different analyses may between the layers, and A is the area of contact
need to be varied. For example, for a very between the layers of the fluid [16]. Since the
diluted sample, or for detection that is not two forces are equal in a steady flow, at
very sensitive, a larger volume of sample may a distance r from the center of the tube, and
be necessary in order to assure a good measure- taking A 2 p r L (L is the length of contact
ment. Samples that generate a high detector between layers), the following relation should
signal need to be injected at lower volumes. be satisfied:
Conventional HPLC systems have injectors Dp
capable to inject between 1 mL up to 100 mL pr2 Dp 2 p r L h du=dr or du rdr
2Lh
sample solution (or even up to 1000 mL in special
systems), typical volumes being between 2 mL (1.4.6)
and 20 mL. Injection of different sample volumes
By integration, rel. 1.4.6 gives the fluid
can be achieved using a larger loop (e.g. of
velocity at any point at distance r from the
100 mL) that is only partially filled with sample
tube center:
(partial loop injection). The loop is typically
filled initially with the mobile phase, and then Dp 2
ur r r2 (1.4.7)
the sample is introduced in the loop, occupying 4Lh t
only a small portion of its volume. The placing
of the loop in the mobile phase main circuit is Relation 1.4.7 shows that due to the friction
then done in a similar manner as for fixed with the tubing walls of a viscous fluid,
28 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
downstream of injector (in a laminar flow), the sample vial from a tray, and to repeat the injec-
shape of the sample plug is changing and gener- tion at a specified time or upon receiving an
ates a parabolic profile. This process, as well as electrical signal from the computer. In autosam-
the diffusion and other convection effects, plers, since several samples are injected one
contribute to deviations of the chromatographic after the other, it is possible to see carryover
peak from the ideal Gaussian shape, intro- effects. Carryover effects represent the contami-
ducing tailing and asymmetry. nation of a sample with small amounts of
Two important parameters must be selected components from the previous sample that
by the operator regarding injection: (1) the remained in the autosampler after an injection.
nature of the solvent for the sample, and (2) This problem is typically solved using a needle
the injection volume. Besides the obvious wash. Some autoinjectors have the capability
requirement that the solvent for the sample of mixing the sample with specific reagents
should dissolve the sample completely, this from different vials, in the event derivatization
solvent must also be soluble in the mobile is necessary before the separation and detection
phase. The injection volume is selected depend- of analytes. Also, cooling and heating capability
ing on a number of factors, including the type of is frequently present in modern autoinjectors.
instrumentation (HPLC, UPLC, detector type, The injection operation is usually unselective.
etc.), the sensitivity of the detector, the loading However, special online sample preparation
capacity of the column (maximum amount of methods require more special injection tech-
sample that still allows separation), and the niques. In case of a multidimensional HPLC,
effect of sample solvent on peak shape. Both for example, a fraction from eluted sample
too small volumes and too large volumes of from a first column can be transferred by an
injection pose a number of problems. Too small interface to become an injected sample to
volumes may lead to problems with injection a second column. Injection devices normally
reproducibility, sensitivity of the detector, or do not affect retention parameters unless opera-
sample loss in the chromatographic column, tion problems occur (see, e.g., [17e19]). Also, in
but they offer better peak shape, sometimes most HPLC applications, there is one injection
resulting in better separation. Too large volumes for each chromatographic run. However,
may affect the peak shape (broadened, with flat multiple injections in a single run (MISER) are
top, asymmetrical) that affects separation. possible for specific analyses, such that a larger
A large volume of sample does not necessarily number of samples can be analyzed within
mean a large amount of analyte (e.g., when the a specific interval of time and with a lower
sample is very diluted), but when the large solvent usage [20].
volume is also associated with too much ana-
lyte, this can be associated with an overload of
Tubing and Connectors
the column (problems with the separation) and
of the detector (leading to a nonlinear response). The tubing used after the high-pressure
(Further discussion on injection volume will be pumps must be inert and amust also be able
presented in connection with the nature of to withstand the high pressure generated by
sample solvent in Section 9.2.) the pumps. Typical materials for the tubing
Injector systems with automation capability are stainless steel (316 stainless steel) and poly-
are common. From a large number of samples etheretherketone (PEEK). Stainless steel is inert
in different vials (or well plates), these auto- in most solvents, while PEEK may become very
matic systems (computer-controlled autosam- stiff after using solvents such as tetrahydro-
plers) have the capability to select the desired furan or dimethylsulfoxide. Also, stainless steel
1.4. OVERVIEW OF HPLC INSTRUMENTATION 29
FIGURE 1.4.6 Tubing connection to a port, correct fitting, and incorrect fitting with a void space.
tubing can be used even at very high pressure, properties are related to various subjects dis-
while some restrictions to pressure are applied cussed in this book; the present section gives
to the PEEK tubing (as a function of internal only a simplified overview of the subject (see
diameter). However, for IC chromatography, Chapter 6). The column typically consists of
PEEK is the material of choice for tubes a tube made from metal (stainless steel) or
and connectors. Tubes of several internal diam- plastic (e.g., polyetheretherketone, PEEK) that
eters (i.d.) are available, such as 0.12 mm i.d. is filled with a stationary phase. At the two
(0.005 in.), 0.17 mm i.d. (0.007 in.), 0.25 mm ends inside the column are special frits that
i.d. (0.010 in.), 0.50 mm i.d (0.020 in.), and so keep the stationary phase from moving, and
on (for both stainless steel tubing and PEEK outside are fittings that allow the connection
tubing a color code is available to designate with high-pressure tubing. The physical dimen-
the i.d.). The choice of the tubing after the sions of common analytical chromatographic
injector starts to play a role in the shape of the columns vary, and values for length (internal)
sample plug. Tubing with 0.12 mm i.d. (0.005 L can be between 30 mm and 250 mm (the
in) is in general recommended to connect the common length being 50, 100, 150, or 250 mm),
injector with the chromatographic column. and internal diameters d can be between 1 mm
This tubing has a volume of about 0.13 mL/ and 10 mm (the common diameters being 2.1,
cm such that a sample of 5 mL will spread 3.0, or 4.6 mm). Other dimensions are possible,
over about 38 cm, diminishing the effects of particularly when the column is designed for
sample plug shape modifications. Another special tasks. The newer columns tend to be
factor contributing to dilution and modifica- shorter and narrower, as the solid particles
tions in sample plug shape are the void that form the stationary phase are made smaller.
spaces in fittings that connect the injector Special cartridges (microfluidic chips) are also
and the chromatographic column. Loss of reso- available as containers for the stationary phase.
lution by peak broadening due to large void Based on the internal diameter of the analytical
spaces and to turbulent flow either along the column, they are sometimes classified in the
tubing or in fittings must be avoided. The literature as (1) standard (3.0e4.6 mm i.d.), (2)
fittings typically use a nut that connects to minibore (2.0e3.0 mm i.d.), (3) microbore
a port, and a ferule secures the end of the (0.5e2.0 mm i.d.), (4) capillary (0.2e0.5 mm
tubing in the fitting port. Common connector i.d.), and (5) nanoscale (0.05e0.2 mm i.d.).
parts, correct fitting, and incorrect fitting of Larger columns are used for semipreparative
tubing with formation of a void volume are and preparative purposes. The empty volume
shown in Figure 1.4.6. of the column can be easily calculated as V
(p/4) d 2 L (volume of a cylinder), and for
analytical columns V ranges between 0.02 mL
Chromatographic Columns and 20 mL.
The chromatographic column is designed for The nature of the stationary phase is selected
performing the separation in HPLC. Its role and based on the type of chromatography utilized
30 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
for the separation (normal phase, reversed be made in various forms. For example, ion-
phase, ion exchange, size exclusion, etc.). exchange HPLC can use particles from
A large assortment of types of stationary phases a substrate inert material that are covered with
(column packings) are available. The stationary the active phase but also various types of ion-
phase usually consists of small, solid particles exchange polymers. Size-exclusion chromatog-
with special properties. Besides small particles, raphy typically uses perfusion particles made
porous polymeric materials and monolithic from silica or special types of polymers. These
materials can be used as the stationary phase. particles contain very large pores (400e800
When the stationary phase is made from small nm) connected with a network of smaller pores
particles, the particles should have specific (30e100 nm). The structural rigidity of these
physical and chemical characteristics to serve particles is not as good as that of common
as a stationary phase. The surface area of parti- porous particles made from silica, and restric-
cles is one of the most important physical char- tions to the maximum pressure that can be
acteristics, being directly related to the retention used with the columns made with these parti-
in the column of the compounds to be sepa- cles are typically indicated by manufacturer.
rated. The effect on separation of the particle At higher pressures than recommended, the
size is also important. Particle size influences stationary phase may collapse and the
in particular the eddy diffusion, which appears column can be damaged.
when local small streams of liquid follow The chemical properties of the particles form-
different channels in the column. The effect is ing the stationary phase include (1) the chemical
common within porous particles. This generates nature of the active surface, (2) chemical
a broadening of the chromatographic bands stability, (3) surface reactivity, and (4) density
(discussed in Section 2.2), which is not a desired and distribution of surface reactive centers.
feature. When the stationary phase is made from The nature of stationary phases used in various
small porous particles, these particles are analyses is fully discussed further in this book
frequently obtained from an inert substrate (see Chapter 6). In some systems, more than
material (such as silica) that is covered with one chromatographic column is necessary for
the active phase. The particles can be of three achieving the desired separation. In size exclu-
main types: porous, superficially porous (core- sion chromatography, for example, two to four
shell), and pellicular. Porous particles are still columns may be connected in series. In other
the most common type of stationary phase types of separation, the use of more than one
used in HPLC. They are made from particles column is less common. The nature of the
that are usually of 3e5 mm diameter, with columns used in series may be the same or
a specific porous structure (e.g. of silica) and may be different. More than one column is
with the surface of this structure covered with also used in multidimensional HPLC, where
an active constituent. This constituent can be a portion of the initial separation is further
physically or chemically bonded on the solid submitted for a second separation in a different
inert support, the bonded phases being the column.
most common type. Since reverse-phase (RP- Some chromatographic columns require
HPLC) is the most utilized technique, the largest a specific temperature for performing a good
variety of columns is of RP type. These columns separation, and for this purpose special column
have a hydrophobic active phase, for example, ovens are used. Common column ovens have
with octadecyl groups (C18), or with octyl the capability to control the column temperature
groups (C8) bonded on silica. For other types in a range from about 10 oC below ambient
of chromatography, the stationary phase may to 80e100 oC. Higher temperatures can be
1.4. OVERVIEW OF HPLC INSTRUMENTATION 31
achieved with special ovens used in high- or they can be different and can be generated
temperature HPLC. In addition to heating the using the second pump. The schematic diagram
column, the ovens typically are able to heat the of a heart-cut system working in three stages is
solvent entering the column, since peak shape shown in Figure 1.4.7. In stage A the flow
distortions may be noticed when the column from Pump 1 (isocratic or gradient) containing
and the entering solvent have different the sample goes into column 1 and into the
temperatures. detector. At a certain desired time the heart-cut
In order to protect the stationary phase from is taken by switching to stage B where the
the analytical HPLC column, it is common to flow from Pump 1 goes into column 1, then
use small pore frits (e.g., with 0.45 mm pores) into column 2, and then into the detector. After
as well as guard columns (cartridges) in the the heart-cut is taken, the system is switched
path of the mobile phase before the column. to stage C where the flow from Pump 2
The frits have the capability of mechanical filtra- (isocratic or gradient) goes into column 2 and
tion of the mobile phase. For column protection, then into the detector.
more important than frits are the guard More complicated setups for achieving
columns. The guard (cartridge) columns are multidimensional separations are reported in
selected to match the stationary phase of the the literature [21]. For example, the collection
analytical column (the same active material), of the heart-cut can be done in a loop, after
but their length is much shorter (e.g., a few the solution passes the detector. After the
mm), and in some cases their stationary phase collection of the heart-cut, this is submitted
has larger particle size. In the analyzed samples, into the second column and into the detector,
there are sometimes components that are very such that the detector will respond to both
strongly retained by a specific stationary phase. unseparated and separated compounds in the
These components do not elute and tend to heart-cut. The choice of columns for multidi-
accumulate at the head of the column, deterio- mensional separation is typically done so that
rating its performance in time. The use of they have very different selectivity. The HPLC
a guard column allows selective retention of separations performed on different types of
these components without affecting the effi- column and using different solvents that lead
ciency of the column, retention time, backpres- to a different separation are referred to as
sure, or the level of analytes. Guard columns orthogonal.
are changed from time to time, while the analyt-
ical columns have longer service life (see Other Devices that are Part of the HPLC
Section 6.3).
System
The multiple use of HPLC has promoted
Setups for Multidimensional Separations
a variety of instrumental setups and develop-
Some separations are performed in bidi- ments. For example, the capability of column
mensional mode. For such separations, switch- switching (sometimes part of the column oven)
ing devices are used to divert, for a specific time is a relatively common feature of HPLC instru-
interval, the eluent from the first column into mentation. The switching valves can be used
the second column. The volume of diverted only for selecting one of several columns by
eluent from the first column containing the changing the flow to the desired one. Another
unseparated analytes of interest is indicated as common use of column switching is that of
a heart-cut. The mobile phase from the first sample enrichment and cleanup. In this use,
column can be the same in the second column, the flow with the sample is sent to a column
32 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
Waste
Pump 1 Injector Column 1
(a)
Column 2
Pump 2
Detector
Waste
(b)
Pump 1 Injector Column 1
Column 2
Pump 2
Detector
Pump 2
Detector
where the analytes are strongly retained for the analytes are eluted from the head of the first
specific solvent composition. The flow to this column and sent to a different column where
column may carry a large volume of a diluted the separation takes place. The flow from this
sample. While the analytes are accumulated second (analytical) column goes to the detec-
(usually at the head of the column), the flow tors. This setup is schematically shown in
from this column is typically sent to waste. Figure 1.4.8.
After enough analytes are accumulated, the Also, a specific sample derivatization may
flow in the column is reversed (with a switching be selected for the increase in detection capa-
valve), and the solvent is changed such that the bility. When this derivatization must be done
Waste Waste
FIGURE 1.4.8 HPLC setup with two columns allowing enrichment of diluted samples.
1.4. OVERVIEW OF HPLC INSTRUMENTATION 33
after the separation of the analytes, post- used for the analysis. Some detectors have
column derivatization techniques are utilized. specific requirements for the nature of mobile
In this type of technique, reagents are added phase, selection of isocratic or gradient separa-
to the flow emerging from the analytical tion, selection of a specific temperature for the
column. These reagents need thorough mixing column and mobile phase, and other.
with the analytes flow, which can be achieved The detection of the molecular species eluted
in a mixing T. In some instances, where the from the chromatographic column can be done
reaction with the derivatization reagent is not using a variety of principles and techniques.
instantaneous or may need heating, reactors Among these detection techniques are (1) UV-
or mixing/reacting coils are added in the flow Vis absorption, (2) fluorescence, (3) refractive
circuit after the analytical column. The reacting index (RI), (4) chemiluminescence, (5) various
coils are sometimes heated or UV irradiated. types of electrochemical detection, (6) mass
The volume as well as the delay time in the spectrometry (MS), (7) evaporative light-
coil must be adjusted depending on reaction scattering (ELS), and (8) other detection tech-
requirements. niques. The qualities of the detectors should
Another device sometimes used in HPLC is include (1) sensitivity, (2) reproducibility of the
a flow splitter. This device is necessary when response, (3) linearity in a wide range of concen-
the flow from a conventional HPLC pump is trations of sample, (4) capability for detection in
too high to be used with either a capillary LC a small volume of sample (5) capability of not
column or a specific detector (such as a mass contributing to peak broadening, and (6)
spectrometer). A flow setting below a specific stability to changes in flow and environmental
limit at a conventional HPLC pump may lead parameters. Some detectors are designed to
to undesirable fluctuations or to a difficult to respond to all analytes (such as the RI detector)
control gradient program. The flow splitter and are indicated as universal detectors.
allows the selection of a desired fraction from Other detectors can be compound type selective
the total flow from the pump by using a waste or even specific compound selective, or they can
outlet with controllable backpressure. have settings that make them compound selec-
tive. Some detectors can generate only quantita-
tive information, while others offer both
General Comments on Detectors
qualitative and quantitative information, such
In HPLC, the mobile phase passes through as the MS detectors.
a detector capable of performing measure- Modern HPLC systems commonly have more
ments. The detection is based on the fact that than one detector available. For example, UV-
the molecules of the sample have physicochem- Vis and fluorescence detectors are frequently
ical properties different from those of the coupled in series, although they are not neces-
mobile phase. The measured properties are sarily used simultaneously. Since the flow
determined by the nature of the compound to through a detector may pose some backpressure,
be analyzed and that of the mobile phase. The when using detectors coupled in series, it should
choice of a specific property for detection be verified that the flow-cell of the detector
depends on factors such as the extent of differ- upstream can handle the backpressure gener-
ence in a property from that of the mobile ated by the second detector. For the detector
phase, sensitivity of the detector to downstream it should be verified that undesir-
the specific property, and availability of the able peak broadening does not occur because
detector. The selection of a specific detector is of the upstream detector. The coupling of detec-
also correlated with the separation conditions tors in parallel is also possible, but care must be
34 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
8000 B
7000
Response 6000
5000 A Signal
Signal
4000 Noise
3000
2000
FIGURE 1.4.9 Detector response showing the measurement of noise and of two signals (A and B).
taken to ensure that appropriate flow goes Figure 1.4.9 shows the measurement of the noise,
through all the detectors. Since different detec- which is done on a flat area of the chromatogram
tors may pose different backpressures to the (baseline) close to the place of a peak, and the
flow, the risk exists that most (or even all) of measurement of the signal from the middle of
the flow goes to a single detector. baseline noise to the top of the peak.
Detector sensitivity is a very important factor A signal is typically considered usable for
in HPLC analysis. This sensitivity depends detection when the value of the signal S is at
on several factors such as analyte properties, least three times larger than the value for the
sample matrix, mobile phase properties, noise N (S/N > 3). In Figure 1.4.9, the signal
detector settings, and detector manufacturer. for the peak B is usable for detection, while
Therefore, it is difficult to present a specific that for peak A is not. Other disturbances in
discussion on detector sensitivity. For these the detector signal may include long-term noise
reasons, in analytical methods using HPLC, and the drift. The long-term noise appears as
parameters such as limit of detection (LOD) a fluctuation of the signal with a wider
and limit of quantitation (LOQ) are reported. frequency. The drift is a continuous variation
They characterize globally the sensitivity of the (increase or decrease) of the signal for a period
method, and they consider a number of factors, of time comparable with the length of the chro-
including detector sensitivity [22]. matogram. Drift may be caused not by the
The detector response (output) is typically detector itself, but by changes, for example, in
dependent on the instantaneous concentration the composition of the mobile phase during
of the detected species, and for this reason gradient elution.
quantitation is based on the area of the
chromatographic peak. The output appears as
Spectrophotometric Detectors
an electrical signal recorded in the form of a chro-
matogram. In addition to the signal, all detectors Spectrophotometric HPLC detectors are basi-
are affected by the noise, which is the random cally UV-Vis spectrophotometers equipped with
oscillation of the detector (electric) output. a flowthrough cell. In these instruments, a beam
1.4. OVERVIEW OF HPLC INSTRUMENTATION 35
of monochromatic light (more correctly a beam at specific (small) time intervals (not continu-
of light with a narrow wavelength range) is ously), generating points that form the chromato-
sent through the eluent flowing through a cell gram. The peaks in the chromatogram indicate an
of small volume (e.g., 1 mL for a micro cell, increase in the absorbance Al when an absorbing
5 mL for a semi-micro, and 14 mL for a standard species elutes from the chromatographic column.
cell, with path length of 5 mm to 10 mm depend- For variable-wavelength detectors, the wave-
ing on the cell, some cells having a conical length can be selected (by rotating a grating inside
shape). The monochromatic beam is split (using the spectrophotometer) and is usually set where
a beam splitter), one part going through the cell a strong absorption of light by the analyte occurs
with the sample and to the detector, and the (possibly at the maximum). This type of detector
other to a reference detector. The baseline is is one of the most commonly used in HPLC. Older
obtained from the reading for the eluate when detectors were made to measure the absorbance
no solute is emerging from the column. at a fixed wavelength such as 254 nm. This wave-
Two related quantities, transmittance T and length corresponds to the maximum emission
absorbance A, are measurable for the light (253.7 nm) of a mercury lamp that has been
passing through the solution. Transmittance is used as a UV source in simpler spectrophotome-
defined as follows: ters. The area under the chromatographic peak
of the analyte is proportional to the analyte
T I1 =I0 (1.4.8)
amount injected into the column and it is used
In rel. 1.4.8, Io is the intensity of the radiant for quantitation with the help of a (linear) calibra-
energy incoming to the sample and I1 is the tion curve, or a response factor between peak area
intensity of the emerging light (T can also be and the analyte concentration. The peak height
expressed as percent). As expected, T is a func- can also be used for quantitation, assuming equal
tion of the wavelength l (or of frequency n peak widths for all concentrations. Some UV-Vis
clight / l, where clight is the speed of light) of detectors have the capability to capture the absor-
the radiation that is absorbed. Absorbance is bance for a whole spectrum range (UV-Vis diode
defined by the logarithm in base 10 of the array detectors or DAD). If the entire UV-Vis spec-
inverse of transmittance as follows: trum is measured in different points across a chro-
matographic peak, this can be used for evaluating
A log 1=T log I0 =I1 (1.4.9) peak purity and can also be a guide for qualitative
identification of the analyte, although UV-Vis
Absorbance is related to the molar concentra- spectra are very seldom sufficient for compound
tion [X] of the absorbing species X by the identification. The UV region of spectrum starts
Lambert-Beer law: at about 190 nm, and modern UV-Vis instruments
(1.4.10) have a typical working range between 190 nm
and 600 nm. However, the common range of prac-
where l is the molar absorption (absorbance) tical utility in UV spectrophotometric measure-
coefficient at the specific wavelength l and is ments starts at about 205 nm or higher. At lower
the path length of the light through the sample. values than this wavelength, a strong light
For quantitation purposes, the absorbance is absorption usually takes place because the
commonly used because it is proportional with solvents used as the mobile phase start absorbing.
the concentration. The quantitation can be done The wavelength cutoff of various solvents can be
using calibration curves or standard addition found in tables (see for example, [23]). Depending
method [1]. The absorbance of the liquid eluting on the nature of the analyzed material, the detec-
from the separation system is typically measured tion limit of the UV-Vis detection in HPLC can be
36 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
(a) (b)
excited
electronic state 2 } vibrational levels
not shown
nonradiative
excited excited
electronic state 1 electronic state 1 } vibrational
levels
absorption fluorescence
E absorption fluorescence
1= E1/h 2= E2/h
1= E1/h 2= E2/h
ground ground
electronic state } vibrational
electronic state levels
FIGURE 1.4.10 (a) Simplified scheme of electronic transitions during fluorescence. Vibrational energetic levels not
shown. (b) Simplified scheme of electronic transitions during fluorescence. The difference in emission comes from differ-
ences in vibrational levels.
0.1e1.0 ng, with a linear range of five orders of cases, the fluorescence radiation has a lower
magnitude. With an appropriate solvent that frequency than the excitation radiation. These
does not absorb in the range of UV-Vis measure- two processes are pictured in Figures 1.4.10a
ment, the use of elution gradient can be applied and 1.4.10b.
for separation. Fluorescence by emission of radiation at
higher frequency than the absorbed one is also
Fluorescence and Chemiluminescence possible (anti-Stokes radiation), but it is
Detectors uncommon. The average lifetime of an excited
state of a molecule M) undisturbed by collisions
Fluorescence (FL) is the process of emission is about 108 s, and fluorescence can take place
of light by a molecule after absorbing an initial within this length of time. For some special
radiation (excitation light). A molecule M goes compounds, the molecules can remain for
from a lower energetic state (commonly ground a longer time in a metastable excited state. In
state) to an excited state M) by absorbing this case fluorescence can be observed long after
energy. The emission process may take place the initial radiation is interrupted. This type of
by the molecule bouncing back to the initial fluorescence is commonly called phosphores-
state without the change in the wavelength of cence. Fluorescence is less frequently observed
the absorbed light. In this case, the process is than expected because it is very common that
difficult to use for analytical applications. only nonradiative loss of energy takes place.
However, it is possible that part of the energy The theory of fluorescence emission shows that
of the excited molecule M) is lost by nonradia- the intensity of fluorescence Fint at the emission
tive processes such as collisions with other wavelength l2 can be expressed as a function of
molecules. In this case, the electron may go to the intensity Io of the excitation radiant energy
another excited electronic state with lower with wavelength l1 incoming into the sample,
energy and then, emitting a photon, reach the by the expression:
ground state. It is also possible that no interme-
diate electronic state is present, but the molecule (1.4.11)
acquires a lower vibrational energetic level and
jumps to the ground state by emitting a photon In rel. 1.4.11, F is the (quantum) fluorescence
of lower energy than the absorbed one. In both yield of the process, the other parameters being
1.4. OVERVIEW OF HPLC INSTRUMENTATION 37
the same as defined for UV-Vis. For low concen- at a specific number of times per second (e.g.,
trations, , and 296 times in an Agilent 1200 Ser. detector),
the intensity of fluorescence Fint l2 is related to such that the signal is modulated in time.
the concentration [X] by the approximation Also, the systems typically have a reference
relation: detector that measures the excitation light and
corrects the flash lamp fluctuations. The detec-
(1.4.12) tion in fluorescence methods encounters several
difficulties because of nonlinearity of fluores-
In reality, only a part of emitted fluorescence
cence due to self-absorption effects, difficulty
is measured in the analytical instrument, and
in discriminating between overlapping broad
the intensity of this measured fluorescence Fint
spectra of interfering molecules, quenching
l2 is given by the expression:
produced by oxygen dissolved with the solvent,
F0int a Io X (1.4.13) and so on. Because the intensity of fluorescence
l2
increases linearly with the intensity of the initial
where a is a constant coefficient that incorpo- radiation, laser-induced fluorescence (LIF)
rates all the constants, including the losses due detection is a successful technique applied in
to partial fluorescence measurement. Measure- HPLC. For HPLC, lasers are a convenient excita-
ment of fluorescence intensity (usually at the tion source because they have intense light
maximum of the emission band) is the base of focused onto a small volume, they are highly
quantitation of the fluorescent species. In prac- monochromatic, and the associated Raman light
tice, the fluorescence intensity is measured has a well-defined wavelength that can be
using sensitive fluorescence light detectors avoided with the monochromator used for
(FLD) that generate an electrical signal of inten- observing fluorescence. However, laser-induced
sity depending on a calibration constant for the fluorescence is still affected by background
instrument. The output is given in luminescence interference commonly arising from the Raman
(or light) units (LU) that are arbitrary units effect in the blank (molecular scattering) or from
proportional with the fluorescence intensity, the low level of solid impurities in the solvent
but specific for the measuring instrument [24]. producing Rayleigh light scattering. Use of fluo-
Similar to UV-Vis detection in HPLC, the rescence detection (FLD) in HPLC is common.
fluorescence is measured in a flowthrough cell Detectors with constant excitation wavelength
that is connected to the flow of the eluent and variable absorption or with variable wave-
incoming from the chromatographic column. length excitation and absorption are commer-
Modern fluorescence detectors may have the cially available. Depending on the nature of
capability of recording a tridimensional emis- the analyzed material, the detection limit using
sion spectrum of the analyte by stopping the FLD can be as sensitive as 102 e 103 ng/mL,
mobile phase flow at a chosen retention time with a linear range of four orders of magnitude.
(selected for the analyte) and performing When appropriately selected, the use of elution
a scan of the entire UV range used for excitation gradient can be applied for separation without
and for the entire emission band. In this way, interfering with the fluorescence. Different
the tridimensional fluorescence spectrum is factors related to the mobile phase influence
displayed as a dependence of fluorescence fluorescence such as pH, solvent nature,
intensity on emission wavelength and excitation temperature (as much as 2%), presence of impu-
wavelength. It is common in modern fluores- rities, as well as the flow rate.
cence HPLC detectors that the excitation beam Chemiluminescence (CL), another technique
is generated by a high power lamp that flashes used for HPLC detection, is the emission of light
38 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
the oxidant initially present in the solution, the flow electrode in steady-state laminar flow with
variation of the current intensity i as a function the working electrode at one wall, the limiting
of the working electrode potential E follows an current intensity is given by the relation:
equation of the form:
ilim 1:467 n F c A D b1 2=3 U 1=3 (1.4.15)
RT ilim i )
where c is the bulk concentration of the analyte,
E E1=2 ln (1.4.14)
nF i A is the electrode area, D is the diffusion coeffi-
cient of the analyte, b is the channel height, and
In rel. 1.4.14, E1/2 is a potential dependent on U is the volumetric flow rate [27e29]. For
the nature of the oxidant and reduced molecules different channel and electrode shapes, the
and is indicated as half-wave potential, R is the expression for the current intensity is different
gas constant (R 8.31451 J deg1 mol1 1.987 [30, 31]. In amperometric detection, the current
cal deg1 mol1), T is temperature (in K deg.), n passing through the cell is measured at a fixed
is the number of electrons involved in the electro- potential E, commonly chosen higher in absolute
chemical reaction, F is the Faraday constant value than E1/2 specific for the analyte. In these
(9.6485309 104 C mol1; C coulomb), and i lim conditions, the desired electrochemical process
is the limiting current intensity, which is a value takes place, but also all other species present in
determined by the largest rate of mass transfer solution and having E1/2 lower (in absolute
to the electrode for the Ox species. The graph of value) than the chosen E value can become elec-
expression 1.4.14 for a hypothetical reduction trochemically active species. This may include
with E1/2 0.5 V is shown in Figure 1.4.13. even the solvent if the working potential E is
For the case of the electrochemically active very high. For eliminating this type of interfer-
species flowing over the surface of an electrode, ence, compounds with low electrochemical
which is the case of electrochemical detection in potentials (in absolute value) are preferred for
HPLC, the current-potential dependence is deter- electrochemical detection. In HPLC, ampero-
mined by a convective diffusion process (not only metric detection is frequently used for oxidation
by diffusion). This makes the limiting current reactions. The quantitation can be done by cali-
intensity for a Nernstian process dependent on bration of the measured current i lim versus
the mobile phase flow rate and on channel and different concentrations of analyte while main-
electrode geometry. For a rectangular channel taining strictly controlled flow conditions. Also,
instead of a constant oxidation potential, a pulsed
amperometric detection (PAD) can be used,
alternating the oxidation analytical potential
with a reducing pulse used for cleaning the elec-
trode (depositions on the electrode may modify
the nature of its surface and therefore the cell
potential). The application of different working
potentials is done at specific time intervals, and
the measurement is made only when the active
species are oxidized.
In coulometric detection, the amount of elec-
tricity (in coulombs) is measured during
FIGURE 1.4.13 The current-potential curve of a Nerns- the electrochemical process. Potentiometric
tian reaction involving two soluble species and only with measurement can be applied, for example, in the
the oxidant present initially. In this example, E1/2 0.5 V. case of ion concentration gradients across
1.4. OVERVIEW OF HPLC INSTRUMENTATION 41
a semipermeable membrane. In this case the Two general types of suppressors are commonly
measured potential E is given by an expression used for IC, one being based on the addition in
of the form: the flow of an ion-exchange cartridge (e.g.,
commercially available from Metrohm or Altech
RT Co.) that eliminates the conductive ions of the
E Const: lncX (1.4.16) mobile phase, and the other is based on semiper-
nF
meable membranes. Special devices are commer-
The concentration cX can be obtained by cially available that use a pair of ion-exchange
measuring the potential E (following expression cartridges used alternatively in the eluent flow.
1.4.16) and using previously generated calibra- One cartridge is used for suppressing the eluent
tion curves. ions while the other is regenerated, such that no
The conductivity detectors are used for the interruption in the operation is incurred. Various
measurement of concentrations of electrolytes models of suppressors based on semipermeable
in aqueous solutions. The molar concentration membrane technology are available (e.g., self-
can be obtained based on the formula: regenerating suppressor SRS, micromembrane
suppressor MMS, capillary electrolytic
1 1
c Ccell (1.4.17) suppressor CES, or Atlas electrolytic suppressor
Lm R AES, which are commercially available from
where Ccell is a constant depending of the Dionex/Thermo Scientific [32]).
measuring cell, R is the electrical resistance In a separation where the eluent is, for
measured with the instrument from Ohms example, a solution of NaOH or KOH, the sup-
law R I/V, and Lm is the equivalent conduc- pressor (a resin or a semipermeable membrane)
tivity for the ionic species. Although Lm can be provides immobilized R-SO3H groups. In this
approximated for practical purposes as case, the reaction of the NaOH from the eluent
constant, it varies with the concentration p through the suppressor is described by the
following Kohlrauschs law Lm L0m A c, following scheme:
where A is a constant and L0m is the limiting SO3H SO3Na + H2O
NaOH +
molar conductivity specific for each ion and
temperature dependent. Values for limiting mobile phase with R R mobile phase with
high conductivity low conductivity
molar conductivities can be found tabulated.
In ion chromatography, the mobile phase (1.4.18a)
frequently contains acids, bases, or salts (such At the same time, an analyte in the form of
as carbonates) that may interfere with the elec- a Na salt (e.g., a chloride) passing through the
trochemical detection. Bases such as KOH or suppressor undergoes the following change:
acids such as methanesulfonic acid can be gener-
ated electrochemically (see Section 7.9). Eluent NaX + SO3H SO3Na + HX
NaHCO3 and Na2CO3 are also frequently used analyte from the mobile phase of the LC into
as eluents. The conductivity caused by gas-phase ions that are further analyzed with
such buffers is eliminated using a chemical the mass analyzer. LC-MS and LC-MS/MS can
suppressor by transforming the alkaline carbon- provide exceptional sensitivity and selectivity
ates into H2CO3 that decomposes into H2O and compared to other detection techniques. The
CO2. Other anions (e.g., F, Cl, SO2 4 ) generate capability to easily measure ng/mL levels of
strong acids that are easily detected based on compounds in the sample and to differentiate
conductivity. Various other suppression between molecules with different mass and frag-
techniques are used in practice [33]), including mentation patterns, as well as the potential iden-
electrolytic suppressors used in anion LC. tification capability, makes LC-MS and LC-MS/
Similar to a resin, this type of suppressor elimi- MS invaluable techniques. The good resolving
nates cations such as K or Na from the eluent power required for the separation in other detec-
by replacing them with H formed by electrol- tion techniques can become less necessary with
ysis of water. The hydroxides from the mobile MS detection when coeluting compounds can
phase are transformed into water, while other be differentiated by their MS signal.
salts (Cl, F, etc.) form strong acids. Two main techniques for ion formation in
In the case of a cation analysis, suppression LC/MS are electrospray ionization (ESI) and
can be achieved with a resin in OH- form. For atmospheric pressure chemical ionization
example, metanesulfonic acid (MSA) used as (APCI). In these techniques, the goal is to
an additive to the mobile phase can be retained generate charged molecules of the analyte,
by an anion-exchange resin with the formation while the molecules of the solvent remain
of H2O in the solution. At the same time, a salt neutral. The charged molecules are further
(e.g., of an alkaline ion) passing through the resin attracted to the ion mass analyzer entrance,
can generate a strong base with high conductiv- while the solvent is eliminated as much as
ity. Semipermeable membrane suppressors for possible. The ionization process in LC-MS is
cation exchange separations may contain tetra- mild compared to electron impact (EI) ioniza-
butyl-ammonium hydroxide that reacts with tion typically used in GC-MS, and it is similar
mobile phase acids such as H2SO4 or CH3SO3H. to CI ionization. The ionization in LC-MS can
By the interaction with the OH groups of the be conducted to form either positive ions or
reagent in the semipermeable membrane, negative ions from the analyte neutral mole-
the SO2- 4 ions, for example, are removed from cules. The choice between the positive and
the eluent and replaced by OH- (to form water negative ionization mode depends on the
with the H of sulfuric acid), while other ions nature of the compounds to be analyzed. Mole-
(e.g., Na, K, etc.) form hydroxides (e.g., cules with a basic character (e.g., amines,
NaOH, KOH) that have high conductivity. heterocycles containing nitrogen, etc.) have
a tendency to form positive ions and are typi-
cally analyzed in positive mode. Other mole-
Mass Spectrometric Detectors
cules such as acids and some oxygenated
Liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry compounds (e.g., carbohydrates) are typically
(LC-MS) and liquid chromatography-mass spec- analyzed in negative mode in which better
trometry/mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) are sensitivity for the analysis is obtained. A sche-
two techniques that are becoming more and matic drawing of an electrospray source is
more common [33e37]. This was possible mainly shown in Figure 1.4.14.
due to the progress made in developing LC-MS In the ESI source, the HPLC effluent is intro-
interfaces able to convert efficiently the dissolved duced through a capillary at 3e5 kV potential.
1.4. OVERVIEW OF HPLC INSTRUMENTATION 43
FIGURE 1.4.14 Schematic diagram of an electrospray ionization (ESI) inlet for a LC/MS instrument (positive ion mode).
The decrease in electrical potential and in pressure are also indicated on the diagram.
The spray is changed into small droplets, and by free enthalpy of formation DG0GPB given by
some of the solvent is vaporized using a current the expression:
of heated gas. The heated droplets are charged
and eliminate most of the solvent. Due to ionic DGoGPB DGo M H DGo M
repulsion the droplets generate individual
ions, most of them still solvated. Since water DGo H (1.4.20)
is typically present in the HPLC effluent and
H ions are abundant, the formation of positive Similar to the formation of positive ions,
ions is the result of formation of molecular ions molecules of the type MH can be ionized to
of the type [MH] where M are the molecules generate negative ions in a reaction as follows:
of the analyte. The ionization process with the
formation of positive ions can be written in MH / M H (1.4.21)
the form (not indicating the solvation
Reaction 1.4.21 is related to the tendency to
molecules):
lose a proton, a property also known as gas
phase acidity (GPA), described by the variation
M H / M H (1.4.19) of free enthalpy, DG0GPA:
Multiple charged molecules can also be DGoGPA DGo M DGo MH DGo H
formed in this process, in particular for
(1.4.22)
compounds such as peptides. Reaction 1.4.19
is related to the tendency of a compound to Usually, DG0GPB for most organic compounds
bind a proton. This property is also known as lies between 500 and 1000 kJ mol1, while DG0GPA
gas phase basicity (GPB). This is characterized is situated between 1300 and 1650 kJ mol1.
44 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
These values can be useful in predicting ioniza- A similar type of reaction may take place in
tion and fragmentation under CI-like conditions, negative ionization mode, when the reaction
and can explain why more compounds form can be written as follows:
positive ions more easily than negative ions in
MH Solv 5M--Solv --H 5M Solv H
LC/MS [38].
The difference in the polarity between the (1.4.24)
solvent and the analyte molecules favors the Reactions 1.4.23 and 1.4.24 show that the
formation of positive ions (or negative ions solvent has an important role in the ionization
when working in negative mode), particularly process, and the adducts can be seen in the
from the analyte and much less from the mass spectrum instead of the analyte molecular
solvent. A volatile acid such as HCOOH is ion. These equilibria are influenced by DG0GPB,
typically added in the mobile phase to favor or DG0GPA values for the analytes and the
the process of positive ion formation. The solvents and by the concentration of [Solv--H],
positive ions are attracted to the curtain or [Solv]e, the electric fields applied into the
plate in the ion source, while the solvent mole- source, and so on.
cules that are not charged are not attracted. Besides adducts with solvent molecules,
Further desolvation and elimination of solvent other adducts can be formed between the ana-
molecules occur as the positive ions are lyte M and other species in the eluted material.
directed toward the skimmer and further into For example, in positive ionization mode, ions
the ion mass analyzer. For negative ion forma- such as [M--Na], [M--K], [M--NH4],
tion, salts such as HCOONH4 or CH3COONH4 [M--H2O--Na], [M--Solv--Na], [M--2Solv--
are added to favor the ionization of the Na] can be seen. Negative ionization is less
analyte. favorable to adduct formation, but is still
Adducts between analyte molecule and possible with ions of the following types:
different ions reaching the MS interface are [2M]e, [3M]e, [2M--Na]e [39].
often observed in LC-MS. They are formed by In atmospheric pressure chemical ionization
ion-dipole, ion-induced dipole, hydrogen (APCI), the effluent from the HPLC is sent
bonds, and even by van der Waals interactions. through a capillary that is heated and in a flow
In the adduct formation, the molecules of the of gas, but not under an electrical potential. The
solvent Solv are frequently involved. Due to their jet of molecules of solvent and analyte in gas
high concentration, it is common that solvent form, and those of an added gas (N2, O2) flow
molecules are initially ionized to form in posi- by (close to) a needle charged at a high voltage
tive mode, for example, [Solv--H] ions. Further (3e5 kV) that generates a corona discharge.
ionization of the analyte can be described as Some of the molecules are being loaded with posi-
a proton transfer from species [Solv--H] to the tive charges (when working in positive mode).
molecule of the analyte, by a reaction shown Due to the difference in polarity between the
as follows [38]: molecules of the analyte on one hand and those
of solvent and gasses on the other, the charges
M Solv --H 5M--H--Solv 5M--H tend to migrate to the analyte molecules. These
Solv charged molecules are attracted to the curtain
(1.4.23) plate of the ion source and further into the ion
mass analyzer, as previously described for the
The intermediate positive ion [M--H--Solv] is ESI source.
sometimes stable enough to be seen in the MS Both ESI and APCI ionization techniques offer
spectrum. very reproducible generation of ions; they can be
1.4. OVERVIEW OF HPLC INSTRUMENTATION 45
used with a wide range of solvents as HPLC as 2000 Dalton, but common commercial quad-
eluent, they can work in a range of flow rates rupole instruments have a mass range between
(e.g., 0.05 to 1.0 mL/min), and they do not 2 and 1100. The mass analyzers in LC can be
involve problems with capillary plugging. utilized as a detector providing a very sensitive
Other procedures used to form ions from means for analyte measurement. The abun-
the analyte molecule include the use of an dance of ions of a measured analyte is propor-
intense beam of UV light for the analyte ioni- tional to the analyte concentration, and the MS
zation instead of a corona discharge. This tech- response can be calibrated for quantitative
nique is known as atmospheric pressure measurements. However, the formation of
photoionization (APPI). Older techniques that molecular ions in the ionization source and the
interface an LC with a mass spectrometer absence of molecular fragments limis the identi-
include: (1) the particle beam (PB), which fication capability of LC/MS.
consists of an aerosol generator from the LC Very useful in the analysis of eluates in LC are
flow (at 0.1e1 mL/min) followed by a desolva- the MS/MS analyzers. Triple quadrupole
tion chamber and a separator that directs the systems are common MS/MS detectors. In
aerosols through a series of apertures sepa- a triple quadrupole, the first quadrupole (Q1)
rating the volatile compounds including the has the role of separating the (parent) ions
solvent from the solid aerosols, (2) continuous generated in the ion source. These ions (usually
flow FAB, where the effluent is introduced molecular ions) are selected for further interac-
directly into a vacuum region (with a flow tions in the collision cell (Q2) where they can
rate of 5e10 mL/min) mixed with a matrix be fragmented. For this purpose, a gas (such as
material such as glycerol, and the ionization N2 or Ar) is introduced in the cell, and a specific
is achieved using a beam of ions at 5e8 keV. voltage is applied to the Q2 quadrupole (or
The ions generated in the source are further hexapole in some instruments). Depending
separated by mass and measured using a on the collision gas pressure and on the
mass analyzer. Mass separation is usually voltage applied to the collision cell, the
achieved using either a quadrupole or an ion parent ions undergo different degrees of
trap. Quadrupole type mass spectrometers fragmentation (fragmentation by collisionally
separate the ions by passing them along the activated dissociationdCAD). The fragmenta-
central axis of four parallel equidistant rods tion strongly depends on the structural charac-
that have a fixed voltage (DC) and an alter- teristics of the analyte. When adducts are
nating (RF) voltage applied to them. The field formed during the ionization process, the ability
strengths (voltage) can be set such that only of adducts to be fragmented also depends on
ions of one selected mass can pass through the their structure. The stability of cation adducts
quadrupole, while all other ions are deflected decreases in the following order: [MH] ~
to strike the rods. By varying (with a precise [MNH4] > [MLi] > [MNa] >[MK] >
rate) the strength and frequencies of the electric [MCs] [40]. The third quadrupole Q3 is used
fields, different masses can be filtered through for the separation of the resulting (daughter)
the quadrupole. ions following fragmentation in the collision
With the quadrupole instruments, a low- cell. Several utilization techniques are common
resolution type spectrum is obtained. For a m/ for MS/MS analyzers, such as (1) the product
z 200, for example, the minimum mass ion scan, when the whole range of ions gener-
difference that can be separated could be ated by fragmentation of the precursor ions
around 0.2 mass unit (resolution 1000). The (parent ions) is analyzed, (2) the precursor ion
mass range for the quadrupoles can go as high scan, when only one ion is selected for the
46 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
detector by Q3, while Q1 is scanning the whole concentration (within a certain range of concen-
range of ions produced by the source, (3) the trations since the linearity is not followed for
neutral loss scan, when the instrument scans a wide range). This detector has the advantage
for a specific mass difference between the ions over the RI of being usable with gradient elution.
from Q1 and Q3, and (4) multiple reaction moni- However, the presence of any salts or nonvolatile
toring (or MRM) where a specific ion is selected materials in the mobile phase disturbs the
by Q1 and a specific fragment is detected by Q3 measurements. Also, changes in the temperature
(more than one pair of ions can be analyzed by of the eluent do not affect ELSD, while with RI
MRM at the same time). Qualitative information detectors a careful temperature control must be
from LC/MS/MS can be generated based on applied since the refractive index varies with
fragmentation of the parent ions. However, temperature. ELSD can be more sensitive than
LC/MS/MS is more frequently used for highly RI in specific applications. Modifications of
selective quantitative analysis. Quantitative ELSD were attempted to further improve its
information using the MRM mode is also char- sensitivity, such as by adding a saturated stream
acterized by exceptional sensitivity (as low as of solvent to the mist of the analyte in order to
fmol/mL concentration). Other instrument grow the particles by condensation nucleation
developments are continuously made in the and detect them better (the technique is known
field of LC-MS/MS. Examples are coupling an as CNLSD) or to use lasers as light source
ion trap with a collision cell and a quadrupole, (LLSD). Light scattering can also be used for
coupling a triple quadrupole with a fourth ion detection directly on the liquid effluent when
analyzer such as an Orbitrap (see, e.g., [41]) the analytes are polymers.
that achieves high sensitivity and also high reso- An alternative to light-scattering detection is
lution (e.g,. DM/M z 60,000 for m/z 400 or a corona-charged aerosol detector (CAD or
even up to 100.000), or using special techniques cCAD). This detector is also based on nebuliza-
such as Fourier transform ion cyclotron reso- tion of column effluent (e.g., with N2) and on
nance (FT-ICR-MS) capable of 1,000,000 drying of resulted droplets to remove the mobile
resolution. phase components, producing analyte particles.
A secondary stream of N2 is made positively
charged by passing it by a high-voltage plat-
Other Types of Detectors inum corona wire, which is sent to the opposing
One other detector utilized in HPLC, in partic- stream of analyte particles. The charged parti-
ular for compounds that do not have good light cles are detected, generating an electric signal
absorbance in UV, are not fluorescent, and may with the intensity proportional to the amount
be difficult to ionize, is the evaporative light-scat- of analyte eluted from the column. The CAD is
tering detector (ELSD) [42,43]. In this technique, more sensitive than ELSD and has a wider
the eluent is injected in the form of a spray from dynamic range [44].
a nebulizer into a drift tube where a nebulizer gas For the target compounds that contain at least
is also introduced. The drift tube is heated and one nitrogen atom, the chemiluminescent
the solvent is evaporated, forming a fine mist nitrogen detector (CLND) can be employed.
from the nonvolatile molecules. This mist passes The principle of this detector relies on the
through a cell, where the scattered light from combustion of the column effluent in a high-
a beam that illuminates the cell is recorded. temperature furnace that converts the N-
The gas generated from the solvent does not containing compounds into NO. The dried gas
influence light scattering. The intensity of the stream is passed into a chamber where it reacts
scattered light is dependent on the analyte with O3, a reaction that is associated with
1.4. OVERVIEW OF HPLC INSTRUMENTATION 47
chemiluminescence (measured by a photomulti- 2) The purpose of analysis is essential in the
plier). This detector has a high sensitivity but is detector selection. All detectors are designed
not compatible with acetonitrile in the mobile to allow quantitative measurements, but
phase [45]. some are not meant to provide any qualita-
Other known detection techniques include tive information, such as refractive index
Fourier-transform infrared spectrometry (FTIR) (RI) detectors, others give some hints on
[46, 47], nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) qualitative nature of the analytes, such as
[48], inductively coupled plasma-mass spec- ultraviolet (UV) detectors, and others
trometry (ICP-MS) [49], circular dicroism, optical provide good information that can be used
rotary dispersion, polarimetry, and radioactivity. for compound identification such as mass
spectrometric (MS) detectors. Therefore,
when only a quantitative analysis is neces-
Selection of a Detector for the HPLC sary and the nature of the analyte is known,
Separation the peak identification for the known
compound can be done based on the reten-
Specific properties of detectors impose some tion time alone, the only concern being an
restrictions on their selection for analyzing efficient chromatographic separation with
a given sample. Among the criteria used in no interference. The selection of the detection
selecting a detector for a particular application type in such cases should consider criteria
are the following: (1) availability of the detector, other than qualitative identification capa-
(2) purpose of analysis, (3) capabilities of the bility. For qualitative analysis of samples con-
detector, (4) properties of the analyte, (5) type taining a mixture of compounds with
of elution (isocratic or gradient), (6) properties a suspected structure that require only confir-
of the mobile phase used in separation, mation, techniques such as mass spectrom-
(7) stability/reliability of the detector, and etry MS or MS/MS must be used, working
(8) ease of maintenance/ operation. Besides in specific modes (e.g., MRM). Also, specific
the choice of a specific detector depending on fluorescence properties or UV absorption
the analysis, the selection of a specific method wavelength can be used to enhance the detec-
is sometimes decided based on the properties tors selectivity.
of the available or optimum detector. When For qualitative analysis of a sample with
changes other than that of the detection type unknown composition, even with mass spec-
are easier to make (e.g., mobile phase composi- tral detection, HPLC is not always very infor-
tion), it is common to modify the method mative. The mass spectra in LC, when using
instead of selecting a different detector. More a single mass spectrometer as a detector, do
than one detector can be present in an HPLC not offer much information about the frag-
system. When several detectors are used, they ments of an analyzed molecule, typically
are usually connected in series, although indicating only the molecular ion. Better
parallel connection is also possible. information is obtained with the use of MS/
MS instruments, but the fragmentation
1) Availability of the detector is a straight- provided can vary considerably depending
forward requirement. Some detectors are on the instrument and acquisition method.
more expensive than others, and even if all Although some library searches are available
are available, some consideration regarding (e.g., SmileMS) as well as some mass spectral
their cost and cost of maintenance may play libraries for LC, the qualitative information
a role in their selection. on unknown compounds is not always easy
48 1. BASIC INFORMATION ABOUT HPLC
simple to operate and require virtually no the user to further process the data and interpret
adjustments. The advantages of such detec- the result. This part may include peak recogni-
tors must be weighed versus their disadvan- tion to generate retention times, area measure-
tages, such as loss of sensitivity or lack of ment, data averaging, calibrations, peak shape,
qualitative information. and other peak parameters characterization,
and in the case of detectors that give qualitative
information in the form of spectra, the computer
Fraction Collectors
may contain spectral libraries helping with
In some instances, in particular when the compound identification.
HPLC separation is performed for semiprepara-
tive or preparative purposes, some fractions of References
interest need to be collected as the effluent exits
[1] Moldoveanu SC, David V. Sample Preparation in
the detectors. This collection can be done using Chromatography. Amsterdam: Elsevier; 2002.
a fraction collector. Automated systems for frac- [2] Ito Y, Bowman RL. Countercurrent chromatography:
tion collection are available. They direct the flow Liquid-liquid partition chromatography without solid
emerging from the last detector to specified support. Science 1970;167:281e3.
vials either at a given time or upon receiving [3] Vailaya A, Horvath C. Retention in reversed-phase
chromatography: Partition or adsorption? J. Chroma-
a signal from the detector (indicating an eluting togr. A 1998;829:1e27.
peak) [51]. [4] Smith RM. Superheated water chromatographyda
green technology for the future. J. Chromatogr. A
2008;1184:441e5.
Controlling and Data Processing Units [5] http://www.chemaxon.com
[6] http://www.epa.gov/oppt/exposure/pubs/
The controlling and data system in HPLC is episuite.htm
a computer with data acquisition capability and [7] Hansch C, Leo A. Exploring QSAR, Fundamentals
with a program package that allows the user to and Applications in Chemistry and Biology.
perform (1) control of the hardware and (2) Washington, DC: ACS; 1995.
data acquisition and processing. In older [8] Hansch C, Leo A, Hoekman D. Exploring QSAR,
Hydrophobic, Electronic and Steric Constants.
systems, these functions could be performed Washington, DC: ACS; 1995.
manually/mechanically, without the use of [9] Baiulescu GE, Dumitrescu P, Zugravescu PG.
a computer. However, new instruments have Sampling. E Horwood, Chicester 1991.
extensive capability of computer control for func- [10] Lunn G, Hellwig LC. Handbook of Derivatization
tions such as: flow rate and gradient composition Reactions for HPLC. New York: John Wiley; 1998.
[11] http://www.hplcweb.com/HPLC_Equipment/
generated by the pumps, maximum pressure HPLC_Manufacturers/
that should be delivered by the pumps, vial [12] Agilent 1200 Series. User Manuals. Agilent Technol-
from where the injection must be made (in case ogies 2006.
of autosamplers), volume of the sample injection, [13] http://www.waters.com
timing of the sample injection, reagent mixing [14] Snyder LR, Kirkland JJ, Dolan JW. Introduction to
Modern Liquid Chromatography. 3rd ed. Hoboken,
with the sample (if desired), temperatures in NJ: John Wiley; 2010.
the autoinjector storing the samples, temperature [15] Haky JE. Gradient Elution. In: Cazes J, editor. Ency-
of the column, tracking of column usage, and clopedia of Chromatography. Marcel Dekker; 2002.
parameters for the detector(s). The other function [16] Giddings JC. Unified Separation Science. New York:
of the computer is the capture, signal processing, John Wiley; 1991.
[17] Dolan JW. Autosampler carryover. LCGC
and storing of the data generated by the detec- 2001;19:164e8.
tor(s). The program packages also offer a user [18] Dolan JW. Autosamplers, Part IdDesign features.
interface (sometimes very complex) allowing LCGC 2001;19:386e91.
REFERENCES 51
[19] Dolan JW. Autosamplers, Part II dProblems and [35] Niessen WMA. Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spec-
solutions. LCGC 2001;19:478e82. trometry. Weinheim: John Wiley-VCH; 2009. 206.
[20] Welch CJ, Gong X, Schafer W, Pratt EC, Birkovic T, [36] Willooughby R, Sheehan E, Mitrovich S. A Global View
Pirzada Z, et al. MISER chromatography (multiple of LC/M: How to Solve Your Most Challenging
injections in a single experimental run): The chro- Analytical Problems. Pittsburgh: Global View Pub.; 2002.
matogram is the graph,. Tetrahedron: Assim [37] Ardrey RE. Liquid ChromatographydMass Spec-
2010;21:1674e81. trometry: An Introduction. Chichester: John Wiley;
[21] Sheldon EM. Development of a LC-LC-MS complete 2003.
heart-cut approach for the characterization of phar- [38] van Baar BLM. Ionization methods in LC-MS and LC-
maceutical compounds using standard instrumenta- MS-MS (TSP), APCI, ESP, and cf-FAB, in Application
tion. J Pharm Biomed Anal 2003;31:1153e66. of LC-MS in Environmental Chemistry. In: Barcelo D,
[22] Mitchell CR, Bao Y, Benz NJ, Zhang S. Compar- editor. Journal of Chromatography Library Series, vol.
ison of the sensitivity of evaporative universal 59; 1996. p. 71e126. Amsterdam.
detectors and LC/MS in the HILIC and the [39] Schug K, McNair HM. Adduct formation in electro-
reversed-phase HPLC modes. J. Chromatogr. B spray ionization. Part 1: Common acidic pharmaceu-
2009;877:4133e9. ticals. J. Sep. Sci. 2002;25:759e66.
[23] Sadek PG. The HPLC Solvent Guide. New York: John [40] Medvedovici A, Albu F, David V. Handling draw-
Wiley; 1996. backs of mass spectrometric detection coupled to
[24] Gaigalas AK, Li L, Henderson O, Vogt R, Barr J, liquid chromatography in bioanalysis. J. Liq. Chro-
Marti G, et al. The development of fluorescence matogr. Rel. Technol. 2010;33:1255e86.
intensity standards,. J. Res. Nat. Inst. Standards [41] LTQ XL. Orbitrap Operation Manual. Thermo-Fisher
Technol 2001;106:381e9. Scientific; 2009.
[25] Novak TJ, Grayeski ML. Acridinium-based chem- [42] Bunger H, Kaufner L, Pison U. Quantitative analysis
iluminescence for high-performance liquid chroma- of hydrophobic pulmonary surfactant proteins by
tography detection of chlorophenols. Microchemical J. high-performance liquid chromatography with light-
1994;50:151e60. scattering detection. J. Chromatogr. A 2000;870:363e9.
[26] Erickson BE. Electrochemical detectors for liquid [43] Voress L, editor. Instrumentation in Analytical
chromatography. Anal. Chem. 2000;72:353Ae7A. Chemistry 1988-1991. Washington, DC: ACS; 1992.
[27] Matsuda H. Zur theorie der stationaren strom-span- [44] Gorecki T, Lynen F, Szucs R, Sandra P. Universal
nunos-kurven von redox-elektrodenreaktionen in response in liquid chromatography using charged
hydrodynamischer voltammetrie: II. laminare rohr- aerosol detection. Anal. Chem. 2006;78:3186e92.
und kanalstkomungen. J. Electroanal. Chem. Interf. [45] Fujinari EM, Courthaudon LO. Nitrogen-specific
Elect. 1967;15:325e36. liquid chromatography detector based on chem-
[28] Moldoveanu S, Anderson JL. Amperometric response iluminescence: Application to the analysis of ammo-
of a rectangular channel electrode. J. Electroanal. nium nitrogen in waste water. J. Chromatogr. A
Chem. Interf. Elect. 1984;175:67e77. 1992;592:209e14.
[29] Moldoveanu S, Handler GS, Anderson JL. On [46] Norton KL, Lange AJ, Griffiths PR. A unified approach
convective mass transfer in laminar flow between two to the chromatography-FTIR interface: GC-FTIR, SFC-
parallel electrodes in a rectangular channel. J. Elec- FTIR, and HPLC-FTIR with subnanogram detection
troanal. Chem. Interf. Elect. 1984;179:119e30. limits,. J. High. Res. Chromatogr. 1991;14:225e9.
[30] Yamada J, Matsuda H. Limiting diffusion currents in [47] Somsen GW, Gooijer C, Th UA. Brinkman, Liquid
hydrodynamic voltammetry: III. Wall jet electrodes. chromatography-Fourier-transform infrared spec-
J. Electroanal. Chem. 1973;44:189e98. trometry. J. Chromatogr. A 1999;856:213e42.
[31] Moldoveanu S, Anderson JL. Numerical simulation of [48] Albert K. Liquid chromatography-nuclear magnetic
convective diffusion at a microarray channel elec- resonance spectroscopy. J. Chromatogr. A 1999;
trode. J Electroanal Chem 1985;185:239e52. 856:199e211.
[32] http://www.dionex.com/en-us/webdocs/4270-DS- [49] Sutton LK, Caruso JA. Liquid chromatography-
Eluent_Suppressors-23Nov10-LPN1290-10.pdf inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry.
[33] Fritz JS, Gjerde DT. Ion Chromatography. Weinheim: J. Chromatogr. 1999;856:243e58.
John Wiley-VCH; 2009. [50] Zhang B, Li X, Yan B. Advances in HPLC detec-
[34] Niessen WMA. State-of-the-art in liquid chromatog- tiondTowards universal detection. Anal Bioanal
raphyemass spectrometry. J. Chromatogr. A 1999; Chem 2008;390:299e301.
856:179e97. [51] http://www.labx.com