Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Comparison of pre-conquest and contemporary Andean llama and alpaca phenotypes suggeststhat a breakdown in
specialized breeding took place after European contact which led to the disappearance of fine fibre producing alpaca
and llama breeds. The causesof this loss ultimately lie in the decimation of native Andean herds and herders during the
Spanish conquest. The heterogeneous characteristics of todays animals can be attributed to extensivehybridization and
a possible genetic bottle neck during the 16th century. 0 1995 Academic Press Limited
Table 1. El Yaral alpacas and llamas (specinterr nwnber, ses and age irr nrontlrs): fibre diameter in rnicrorm, by satuple sire. n.s. =no sample
Alpacas Llamas
119d 317$ 314s 2283 2436 2733 2488 2378 2318 247d
Site -24m 9 m <lSm 21 m <lSm >9m 69 111 25-9 m 3m
2: 16.0
17.2 17.7
17.9 23.0
21.5 21.7
22.7 18.2
19.7 21.2
22.3 22.0
21.4 23.4
28.4 20.4
27.2 31.9
29.6
A4 17.1 17.5 21.2 22.1 19.5 20.7 24.1 21.9 19.7 29.3
A: 19.1
17.7 17.5
18.8 24.0
23.0 24.5
25.6 25.1
23.9 21.8
22.1 21.6
n.s. 23.5
23.2 22.4
22.8 3;:;,
B3 17.0 16.5 27.6 26.2 ns. 20.4 22.5 25.9 22.4 34.3
B4 17.2 19.5 22.7 24.0 I%8 225 21.6 24.4 26.5
B5 IS.6 ns. 21.4 23.6 n.s. 23.4 23.9 21.7 3:; 39.6
B6 19.3 IS.8 21.0 26.3 n.s. 24.5 20.6 21.0 23.4 30.5
:i 29.5
30.1 21.3
20.5 44.2
36.6 29.8
26.7 n.s. 28.5
43.9 45.4
25.7 30.1
n.s. 30.8
ns. ns.
royal armies and alpaca fibre for textile production, offerings of guinea-pigs, coca leaves, thread wrapped
while shrine herds produced high quality animals of sticks, turquoise and marine shell beads, small silver
pure colour required for ritual sacrifice. Responsibility plaques, feathers, fish, maize and burnt charcoal, as
for these animals rested with hereditary specialists, the well as sacrificial alpacas and llamas. These animals
llama camayoc. Communal and individually owned had been killed by a massive blow between the ears and
herds also existed. rapidly interred. The sand in which they were buried
Within a century of the Spanish conquest of Cuzco and the extreme aridity of the climate produced
in 1532, administrative and taxation records document exceptionally well preserved specimens (Figure 1).
the precipitous decline and virtual disappearance of Contemporary llamas and alpacas are classified on
previously extensive herds throughout the Andes. It is the basis of fibre characteristics and physical appear-
estimated that up to 90% of all llamas and alpacas ance. Following the traditionally used Ouechua classi-
disappeared during this short period (Flores Ochoa, fication (Flores Ochoa, 1986), recognized llama
1977, 1982) together with approximately 80% of the phenotypes include the hairy, coarse, sparsely fibred
human population (Wachtel, 1977), leading to the ccara; the coarse, more densely fibred clzaku; and
economic and social disintegration of native society. animals with an intermediate fibre type. Most alpacas
Although considerable research has been devoted to exhibit dense, crimped huacaya fleeces, but a small
the disastrous effects of these events upon Andean number ( - 10%) are distinguished by long, wavy suri
peoples, the impact of such catastrophic mortality fibre. Intermediate alpaca fleece types also exist but are
upon camelid genetic diversity and breeding practices not a recognized phenotype. Virtually all llamas and
has yet to be fully explored. 75% of all alpacas are held by traditional herders who
The recent discovery of 26 perfectly preserved, natu- do not consistently breed for selected phenotypes
rally desiccated alpaca and llama mummies at the (Novoa, 1981, 1989). Both inbreeding and hybridiz-
pre-Inca Late Intermediate (AD 950-l 350) Chiribaya ation between llamas and alpacas commonly occur.
culture site of El Yaral (Rice, 1993) provides a first None the less, elaborate classification systems based on
ever view of naturally preserved pre-conquest animals. colour and conformation characteristics exist among
Located in the extremely arid coastal desert of south- Quechua (Flores Ochoa, 1986) and Aymara (Dransart,
ern Peru (17Ol south latitude, 71OO west longitude), 19916) herders, suggesting that earlier management
the site lies 50 km inland at an elevation of 1000 m strategies selectively bred for fibre characteristics in
above sea level. Covering approximately 12.3 ha, and both alpacas and llamas. Although written records
containing more than 330 elongated residential ter- were not part of Andean civilization, detailed data on
races, El Yaral rises 120 m up the barren hillside at the size and colour of flocks were kept utilizing the quipu,
extreme south-western end of the Moquegua valley. It a mnemonic device made of camelid fibre. Under Inca
overlooks a natural corral, 6 ha in extent, which is rule, an annual census was taken of the state and shrine
enclosed by sand covered hills and watered by the herds (Murra, 1978). Special emphasis was placed on
Osmore river. Extensive river bottom agricultural land breeding pure brown, black and white animals for
lies immediately to the north of the site. The El Yaral sacrifice to specific deities, as well as on quality fibre
structures were built of cane walls with wooden sup- production for the state controlled textile industry and
port posts for cane mat roofs, and subdivided by rows the production of sturdy pack llamas for the Inca army
of vertical canes into from two to eight rooms which (Murra, 1978). Given such rigorous demands, it is
were used for storage, cooking, chicha (a fermented likely that specific llama and alpaca breeds were main-
beverage) preparation, sleeping and ritual activities. tained which subsequently disappeared during the
Compacted floors of fine gravel, sand and clay covered Spanish conquest. The data from El Yaral, presented
Pre- and Post-conquest Llamas and Alpacas 835
Table 2. Menu fleece diameter (tm) of nncienr and contemporary South American cam&is. All figures represenl
coriiplelejleece counts excepr where noted u (rrrictercoat), ti (hair)
Prehispanic
Contemporary C. AD 1000
here, suggest that the origin of such breeds may on glass slides with Euparal (R.I. 1.485). Fibre diam-
predate the Inca empire. eter measurements were recorded for 200 fibres per
sample utilizing a projection microscope, IWTO stan-
dards and the Macaulay Land Use Research Institute
Pre-conquest breeds GWBASIC FIBRE 2 programme.
The El Yaral llamas and alpacas were identified on the Concern that desiccation and/or rehydration during
basis of phenotypic attributes (conformation, fibre sample preparation may have altered the dimensions of
distribution) and confirmed by incisor morphology the El Yaral specimens was addressed through a series
(Wheeler, 1991). The age and sex of each specimen of experiments utilizing fibre from a fresh llama x
were determined, when possible, on the basis of dental guanaco specimen. Batches, each of 10 samples, were
eruption (Wheeler, in press) and preserved genitalia. dried under varying conditions, and statistical analysis
Observations on fleece type and colour were recorded, of the results revealed no significant alteration in fibre
and evaluation of the fibre producing qualities of six diameter during these processes. Additionally it was
llamas and four alpacas from the site was undertaken. possible to observe under the microscope that the
Samples of skin with attached fibre (1.5 x 1.5 cm) were medullary cavity of almost all specimens remained
taken when possible, at 11 standardized sites on the left intact and was not penetrated by the mounting fluid. In
side of the animals: on the neck (A2), at equidistant the few cases where this had occurred, it was obvious
points from the fore to hind legs at the level of the that the cuticle had broken down exposing the fibril
sacral tuberosity (A3-A6) and mid-way between the bundles of the cortex. Such fibres were eliminated from
dorsal and ventral surfaces (B3-B6) and at the tops of the study.
the fore (C3) and hind (C6) legs. Fibre length was Fibre diameter measurements from the El Yaral
recorded, and N 1 mm segments of 300 to 500 fibres alpacas and llamas (Table 1) revealed the existence of
were cut from next to the skin of each sample, washed four distinct groups of animals (Table 2). The data
on filter paper with 2 x 50 ml aliquots of BDH petro- show evidence of natural variation in fibre diameter
leum spirit 60-80, left to dry overnight, and mounted across the body, with coarser/hairier samples coming
836 J. C. Wheeler et ul.
Figure 1. El Yaral mummies preserved by natural desiccation. (a) Alpaca 119, a -24 month old male, (b) llama 237, a 6-9 month c)Id male,
note szIcrificial blow between the ears. Scale interval is 5 cm.
from the neck (site A2) and legs (sites C3, C6). The at mid-rib height (sites B3-6). Taken together, thre eight
finest fibre is located along the back (sites A3-A6), samples from sites A3-6 and B3-6 correspond to the
with i3 tendency towards a gradual increase in diameter fleece, and represent that portion of the fibre wrhich is
Pre- and Post-conquest Llamas and Alpacas 837
goal of breeding is for fibre production. None the less, Gloria Salinas (Proyecto Contisuyu) and Dr Sonia
it should be observed that a good plane of nutrition is Guitlen (Proyecto Contisuyu) for making research on
also required in order to sustain such growth. Unfor- the mummies possible; Drs R.W.J. McHardy and
tunately, all four alpacas had been shorn prior to Pamela Dicks of the Macaulay Land Use Research
sacrifice, so comparable data are lacking. Institute for assistance in the analysis; and Dr Raul
Clearly the coastal desert was not such a bad place to Rosadio (Facultad de Medicina Veterinaria, Lima) for
raise llamas and alpacas: fleece fineness and uniform- his constant support. Excavations at El Yaral were
ity, accelerated fibre growth, uniform colouration, and supported by US National Science Foundation grants
the existence of a single coat llama, all point to line BNS85-10877 and BNS89-20769.
breeding, and the probable existence of breeds. The
skill of the Chiribaya culture herders is recorded in the
mummified alpacas and llamas from El Yaral, and References
further confirmed by the fauna1 assemblage from Brotherston, G. (1989). Andean pastoralism and Inca idealogy. In
Chiribaya Alta, a nearby, contemporary site (Wheeler, IJ. Glutton-Brock. Ed.) The Walkinn Larder Patterns of Dome&
in press). Examination of 140 sacrificial llamas from carion, Pastorialish arid Predatiotr. London: Unwin Himan Ltd,
intact burials revealed that they had been selected in pp. 240-255.
accordance with herd management priorities. Only Bustinzd, V. (1991). Mejoramiento Gen&ico. In (C. Novoa & A.
Florez, Eds) Prohccidrr de Ruminantes Menores: Alpacas. Lima:
12.9% of the llamas sacrificed were of prime breeding Rerumen, pp. 113-128.
age (>24 months), and 3 (or 2.1%) of these had Cardozo, A. (1982). Avarices en el conociomiento de la Libra de
dental pathologies which would have been cause for Llama. Cuardernos de la Acadhnia National de Ciencias de Bolivia
slaughter. Of the remaining 122 animals, 69.6% were 60,25-36.
culled before first breeding at 21 months; 15.7% were Carpio, M. (1991). La fibra de Camtlidos. In (C. Novoa &A. Florez,
Eds) Produccidu de Rumianres Menores: Alpacas. Lima: Rerumen,
killed after the first and before the end of the second pp. 295-359.
breeding season at 21-42 months, and 2.9% were old Carpio, M. & Arana, L. (1975). Variaci6n del diBmetro de fibra en el
adults probably past reproductive age. Such a pattern vell6n de las alpacas de Huanacavelica. Anales Cien@cos U.N.A.
would be produced by the elimination of undesirable 13, 79-82.
and infertile animals from the herd which was raised Carpio, M., Leyva, C., Solari, Z., Santana, P. & Sumar, J. (1990).
Diameter and length variations in different types of alpaca fibre,
locally under a controlled breeding programme. The and fleeces of llama, vicuna and pace-vicuna in Peru. Schrifren-
end products of their efforts were fibre producing reilre des Deuhclren WalljbrscAungsinsli~utes an der Teclmischen
alpacas and llamas of unparalleled quality. Hoclrsclutle Aaclren 106, 7690.
ChBvez, J. (1991). Mejoramiento genttico de alpacas y llamas. In
(S. FernBndez-Baca, Ed.) Avarices y Perspectivas del Conocimienro
de /OS Cam&lidos Sudamericanos. Santiago: FAO, pp. 151-190.
Implications Dransart, P. Z. (1991a). Llamas, herders and the exploitation of raw
materials in the Atacama Desert. World Archaeology 22, 304-319.
In contrast to the pre-conquest alpacas and llamas Dransart, P. Z. (199lb). Fibre to Fabric: The Role ofFibre in Camelid
from El Yaral, todays animals are characterized by a Economies in Prehispanic and Contemporary Chile. Oxford:
lack of uniformity. Coarsening of the fibre, increased Linacre College, D.Phil dissertation.
hairiness and the increased variation in fibre diameter Duga, L. (1985). Caracteristicas m&s importantes de las fibras de 10s
across the fleece of huacnya and suri alpacas, as well as camdlidos. In (J. L. Cajal & J. N. Amaya, Eds) Estado Acrual de
Las Investigaciones Sobre Camelidos en la Repptjblicu Argentina.
the apparent disappearance of fine fibre llamas, can Buenos Aires: Ministerio de Educaci6n y Justicia, pp. 129-132.
almost certainly be explained by a breakdown in Flores Ochoa, J. A. (1977). Pastores de Alpacas de 10s Andes. In
controlled breeding accompanied by extensive hybrid- (J. A. Flores Ochoa, Ed.) Pasfores de Puna. Lima: Instituto de
ization produced by events of the conquest. Taken Estudios Peruanos, pp. 15-52.
together, the four pre-conquest breeds cover the range Flores Ochoa, J. A. (1982). Causas que Originaron la Actual
Distribucibn Espacial de las Alpacas y Llamas. In (L. Millones &
of fibre diameter measurements in todays animals, and H. Tomoeda, Eds) El Hombre ~1 su Ambiente eu 10s Andes
crossing with the hairy Chiribaya coarse fibre llama Centrakes. Osaka: National Museum of Ethnology, Semi
could have produced this result. The probable role of Ethnological Studies 10, 63-92.
hybridization in the evolution of todays llamas and Flores Ochoa, J. A. (1986). The classification and naming of South
alpacas remains to be studied, as does the possibility American camelids. InqJ. V. Murra, N. Wachtel & J. Revel,
Eds) Anthropological History of Andean Politics. Cambridge:
that a genetic bottle neck occurred with the massive Cambridge University Press, pp. 137-148.
destruction of native Andean livestock during the 16th Frank, E. N. & Wehbe, V. E. (1994). Primer informe de Avance del
century. There is a clear and urgent need to locate and Componente CmmYidos Domhticos. Cordoba, Acuerdo Republica
protect possible relict populations of pre-conquest Argentina-Uni6n Europea para el Programa de Apoyo para la
alpaca and llama phenotypes. Mejora en la Producci6n de Pelos finos en Cam&idos Argentinos.
Hesse, B. (1982a). Archaelogical evidence for camelid exploitation in
the Chilean Andes. Siiugetierkundliche Miltelhgen 30, 201-211.
Hesse, B. (19826). Animal domestication and oscillating climates.
Acknowledgements Journal of Ehobiology 2, I-15.
Macquera, E. (1991). Persisfencia fenotipica JJ caracterizacion de 10s
We wish to thank Dr Jane Buikstra (University of fipos de llama Kara JJ Lam&a, Thesis, Universidad National
Chicago), Dr Don Rice (Southern Illinois University), Agraria La Molina, Lima, Peru.
840 J. C. Wheeler et al.
Miller, G. R. & Gill, A. L. (1990). Zooarchaeology at Pirincay, a Verscheure, H. & Garcia, G. (1980). El Guanaco (Lama quanicoe
formative period site in highland Ecuador. Journal oj Field Muller) coma recurse natural renovable. I. Algunas caracteristicas
Archaeology 17, 49-68. lanimetricas sus fibras. Avarices en Produccidn Animal (Chile) 5,
Murra, J. V. (1965). Herds and herders in the Inca State. In: 15-22.
(A. Leeds & A.P. Vayda, Eds) I&II, Culture and Animals. Von Bergen, W. (Ed.) (1963). Wool Handbook. New York, NY:
Washington, DC: American Association for the Advancement of Interscience.
Science, pp. 185-215. Wachtel, N. (1977). The Vision of the Vanquished. New York, NY:
Murra, J. V. (1975). Formaciones Economicas y Politicas de1 Mundo Barnes and Noble.
Andino. Lima: Instituto de Estudios Peruanos. Webb, S. D. (1974). Pleistocens llamas of Florida, with a brief review
Murra, J. V. (1978). La Organizarion Economica del Estado Inca. of the lamina. In (S. D. Webb, Ed.) Pleisfocene Mammals
Mexico: Siglo Veniuno. of Florida. Gainesville: The University Presses of Florida,
Novoa, C. (1981). La conservaci6n de especies nativas en America pp. 170-213.
Latina. In Animal Genetic Resources Conservation and Manage-
Wheeler, J. C. (1984). On the origin and early development of
ment. Rome: FAO Animal Production and Health Paper No 24, camelid pastoralism in the Andes. In (J. Clutton-Brock & C.
pp. 349-363. Grigson, Eds) Animals and Archaeology, Vol. 3, Early Herders and
Novoa, C. (1989). Genetic improvement of South American rheir Flocks. Oxford: BAR International Series 202, pp. 395410.
camelids. Revista Brasileira de Genetica 12, 123-135. Wheeler, J. C. (1956). De la chasse a Ielevage. In (D. Lavalloe, M.
Novoa, C. & Wheeler, J. C. (1984). Llama and alpaca. In (I. L. Julien, J. C. Wheeler & C. Karlin, Eds) Telarmachay Chasseurs et
Mason, Ed.) Evolution of Domesticated Animals. London: Pasfeurs Prehistoriques des Andes I. Paris: Editions Recherches sur
Longman, pp. 116-128. les Civilisations, ADPF, pp. 21-59.
Pozorski, S. (I 979). Late prehistoric llama remains from the Moche
Valley, Peru. Annals of Carnegie Museron 48,139-l 70. Wheeler, J. C. (1991). Origen, evolution y satus actual. In (S.
Reigadas, M. C. (1992). La punta del ovillo: determination de Fernandez-Baca, Ed.) Avarices y Perspectivas del Conocimienfo de
domestication y pastoreo a partir del analisis microscopico de 10s Camelidos Sudamericanos. Santiago: FAO, pp. I l-48.
fibras y foliculos pilosos de camelidos. Arqueologia 2, 9-52. Wheeler, J. C. (1995). Evolution and present situation of the South
Rice, D. S. (1993). Late intermediate period domestic architecture American camelidae. Biological Journal of the Lim?aen Society 54,
and residential organization at La Yaral, Peru. In (M. S. 271-295.
Aldenderfer, Ed.) Andean Domestic Architecture. Iowa City: Wheeler, J. C. (in press). Fauna1 remains from the Chiribaya
University of Iowa Press, pp. 66-82. Alta Tombs. In (S. Williams & J. Buikstra, Eds) Chiribaya: a
Shimada, M. (1985). Continuities and changes in pattern of fauna1 Biocuhurol Approach to fhe Study of a Prehistoric Andean Policy.
resource utilization: formative through Cajamarca periods. In (K. Wheeler, J. C., Pires Ferreira, E. & Kaulicke, P. (1976). Preceramic
Terada & D. Onuki, Eds) Excavations at Huacaloma in the animal utilization in the central Peruvian Andes. Science 194,
Cajamarca Valley, Peru, 1979. Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press, 483-490.
pp. 303-336. Wheeler, J. C., Russel, A. J. F. & Stanley, H. F. (1992). A measure
Shimada, M. & Shimada, I. (1985). Prehistoric llama breeding and of loss: prehispanic llama and alpaca breeds. Archives de
herding on the north coast of Peru. American Amiquity 50, 3-26. Zootecnia (Cordoba) 41, 467475.
Shimada, M. & Shimada, I. (1987). Comment on the functions and Wing, E. S. (1977). Animal domestication in the Andes. In
husbandry of alpaca. American Antiquity 52, 836-839. (C. A. Roed, Ed.) Origins of Agriculture. The Hague: Mouton,
Solari, Z. & Carpio, M. (1981). Dicimetro de la Fibra en el Vellon de pp. 387-859.
la Vicuna. Lima: Universidad National Agraria, La Molina. Wing, E. S. (1986). Domestication of Andean mammals. In (F.
Stahl, P. W. (1988). Prehistoric camelids in the Lowlands of Western Vuilleumier & M. Monasterio, Eds) High Alfifude Biogeography.
Ecuador. Journal of Archaeological Science 1.5, 355-365. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 246-264.
Stanley, H. F., Kadwell, M. & Wheeler, J. C. (1994). Molecular Yacobaccio, H. D. & Madero, C. M. (1992). Zooarqueologia de
evolution of the family camelidae-a mitochondrial DNA study. huachichocana III (Jujuy, Argentina). Arqueologio 2, 149-188.
Proceedings of the Royal Society London B 256, pp. 1-6.