Digitally signed

by Joseph Zernik
DN: cn=Joseph
Zernik, o, ou,

Joseph Zernik DMD PhD email=jz12345@

earthlink.net,
c=US
Fax: (801) 998-0917 Email: jz12345@earthlink.net; PO Box 526, La Verne, CA 91750 Date: 2010.07.16
05:19:06 +03'00'

09-08-04 Minute Orders, Orders, Judgments from Justice James A Richman in Sturgeon v
County of Los Angeles

In this collection are minute orders, written orders, and judgments mailed by Justice
Richman to parties.
1. NOTICE of LODGING PROPOSED JUDGMENT --------------------------------- 2
a. Stamped FILED January 16, 2007,
b. by JONES DAY
2. ORDER GRANTING MSJ --------------------------------- 4
a. by Justice Richman's.
b. Above order executed by Justice Richman January 8, 2007 ---------- 31
3. POS of NOTICE OF LODGING OF PROPOSED JUDGMENT
a. By JONES DAY ------------- 32
4. Jan 9, 2007 MINUTE ORDER IN RE: COURT ORDER GRANTING MSJ
a. Order was issued this date.
b. Minute Order was presumably prepared by Martin Godderz,. Dept 1 (Judge
Berle), missing clerk’s name under the signature line ------------ 33
5. Feb 7, 2007 JUDGMENT. ------------------------------- 35
a. Above judgment verified by Justice Richman Feb 7, 2007 _______ 36
b. Jan 16, 2007 POS PROPOSED JUDGMENT ------------- 37
6. Feb 7, 2007 MINUTE ORDER RE: JUDGMENT
7. Feb 7, 2007 NOTICE OF ENTRY OF JUDGMENT---------------------------- 45
8. Feb 7, 2007 POS of NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER --------------------- 46
a. JONES DAY
9. July 27, 2009 ORDER -------------- 47
a. Above order was verified by Justice Richman July 27, 2009 -------------- 63
10. July 30, 2009 MINUTE ORDER in re: RULING ON MSJ. ------------------------- 64
a. With defective certificate by clerk.
11. Divider page: Comparable Minute Orders from another case
12. Sept 20 MINUTE ORDER Samaan v Zernik ------------ 68
13. Oct 10-2007 MINUTE ORDER Samaan v Zernik ------------ 71
2/76
page # added-jhz
3/76
page # added-jhz
4/76
page # added-jhz
5/76
page # added-jhz
6/76
page # added-jhz
7/76
page # added-jhz
8/76
page # added-jhz
9/76
page # added-jhz
10/76
page # added-jhz
11/76
page # added-jhz
12/76
page # added-jhz
13/76
page # added-jhz
14/76
page # added-jhz
15/76
page # added-jhz
16/76
page # added-jhz
17/76
page # added-jhz
18/76
page # added-jhz
19/76
page # added-jhz
20/76
page # added-jhz
21/76
page # added-jhz
22/76
page # added-jhz
23/76
page # added-jhz
24/76
page # added-jhz
25/76
page # added-jhz
26/76
page # added-jhz
27/76
page # added-jhz
28/76
page # added-jhz
29/76
page # added-jhz
30/76
page # added-jhz
31/76
page # added-jhz
32/76
page # added-jhz
33/76
page # added-jhz
34/76
page # added-jhz
35/76
page # added-jhz
36/76
page # added-jhz
37/76
page # added-jhz
38/76
page # added-jhz
39/76
page # added-jhz
40/76
page # added-jhz
41/76
page # added-jhz
42/76
page # added-jhz
43/76
page # added-jhz
44/76
page # added-jhz
45/76
page # added-jhz
46/76
page # added-jhz
47/76
page # added-jhz
48/76
page # added-jhz
49/76
page # added-jhz
50/76
page # added-jhz
51/76
page # added-jhz
52/76
page # added-jhz
53/76
page # added-jhz
54/76
page # added-jhz
55/76
page # added-jhz
56/76
page # added-jhz
57/76
page # added-jhz
58/76
page # added-jhz
59/76
page # added-jhz
60/76
page # added-jhz
61/76
page # added-jhz
62/76
page # added-jhz
63/76
page # added-jhz
64/76
page # added-jhz
65/76
page # added-jhz
66/76
page # added-jhz
 67/76
page # added-jhz

SERVICE LIST FOR COURT OF APPEAL:

1) LA SUPERIOR COURT, CLERK

West District
Santa Monica Courthouse
1725 Main Street
Santa Monica, California 90401

2) Real Party in Interest - Nivie Samaan

Att Keshavarzi
Sheppard Mullin, Lip
333 South Hope Street
48 th Floor
Los Angeles, Ca 90071

3) Real Parties in Interest: Coldwell Banker and Michael Libow

Att Shulkin
Coldwell Banker Law Dept
11611 San Vicente Blvd 9th
Los Angeles, Ca 90049
 68/76
page # added-jhz

SUPERIOR
SUPERIOR COURT
COURT OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY
OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF
OF LOS
LOS ANGELES
ANGELES

D.-HE::: ':':;1 // 220/07

D.-\TE:::: 0 / 07 II'~ DEPT. ,('-,lEH
DEPT, '\"lEH

HOl\·OP~.l,8LE
HOi\"OPu .l.8LE Allan J, Goodma::l.
All2.n J, Goodma::1 JUDGE
JUDGE D. SA~:SBURY
SA~:SBURY DEFlTY ClERK
DEnTY Cl ERK
9.
S" F.A::"'L,
F-.A=-.L, CSL.
CSL,
HOI\ORABLE
HOKORA.BLE PRO, TEM
JUDGE PRO TEM_I II'II'
ELECTRO:\,C RECORDJ~G :WJ:'-'ITOR
ELECTRO'\JC REC0RD'~G \-((j:,'ITOR
O?DER
O;:'DER
DepU() ::;h~rlf;
DepU[) S h~ri ff III Rrron~r

~,~ L-'
~Il I ..............
8 "3 0 a-' C . J.
.........., _ ,~, l.'"'
v Plaimiff
Plaimifi
CQunsel
Counsel
~IVIE
~IVIE SA~~1
SA~~1 NO
NC APPEAmL~C~S
APPEA~~C~S
VS
VS Dt·~TldJm
Dt·~Tldam
JCjSEP:-J:
JOSE P:;-l ZE:;:(NIJ::::
ZE:;:(NI Ie C{'"J1>~1
C{'"J'I,~1
c::-"""'ED ~r
_.r<__ c2-,--,RnED
'T'P·..
'T',....·...
_I",_"~'f' ~,...
J. 0
.I.:,) ·,·-A-T:E'i)'T'
·'-A
,r..
.~.J:' r-.,..
nEiJ'T'
VL..J -,---, _ UU CN 9/-­
ON 9/--;
_",­
! . . . . )~
. _ .~.,
• • ", _~

-I?ECUSAL
'I?ECUSAL - JACQCEL:NE CCNNC~, CU
CONNO~, CD
CC? 170.6 - JC~GE NE:~OR? NE=~CR?

.'lATl"RE OF PROCEEDINGS:

IMIKCTE ORD2P RE PLAIKTIFF'S P20?OSED OR=EP PE

I
iAPPC=N~ME~T OF REFEREE;

10::1 September 11, 2007 ~he Co~rt ~eceiv2d a 11 [Proposed]

Oroer Re AppGi~tDe~t 2~ referee", The Co~r= ~skeG
t~e parties about t~e source of this documen= w~en
t~e pa~t ie s '1.'12::'12 i" _~C'ur~ ,en SepteT.:oer 17, 20 0 -~ .
Counse_ for pla~~t~II lnQlc2.=ed he had preparec ~t.
reviewi::19 t~e
In reviewi::l.g t~E: =ile, t~e t~~ Co~rt ~oca~ed
~ocased an OroE:r
Or6er
Appoi::l.t:"Eg
Appoi::1ting Re=e:r.-ee,
Re~eree, :ileo. ~ileG August 30, 2007, signed by
signed b\'
::he judae th':''.
~he ju6ce 2.ssignei to
th~n 2.ssigr.e5 to:; =his
::his case. AsJ1.s no
EO pa::.ty
pa:cty
~2.S explair.ec.
:tas explai,.ec.. '1,'1:',-"
'!.'.l:y a ce
r_c'..-.'
l i.' order
crder is needed, -:he ::he Court
Court
will not sign P~QP8Sc~ order ~odged
s~g::1 t~e p~Gpose6 ~odged on Sep~e~er
Se~~e~er
14, C'7. P. copy of the Augus-:
2 l' C'I.
l,J, 2C'[o7. Aug-us:: 30, 22C'C'7
C' C'I Order isis
attached
att~ched fo~ t~e pa:ct:"es' pa::.ties' ease of reference.
2'nTE RE
;-,TOTE EE NO'='ICE OF IN'='ENTIO::--J
NO':'ICE OF IN':'ENTIO:'J TO :'10\7E ?OE
:'<10VE ?OR
::COR NETtJ TRIAL;
TRIAL:

?laintiff filed
?16.intiff f~led a Not:"ce
Notice o~ 0= In~enticn
In~ention ~o ~c Move forfor
Ne',','
Nel,'.' 0::1 Septe:"ilbe:.-:
Trial O::l. Septe:"nbe:-: ::"9,
=- 9, ::::007. I. The C'sur=
0 i) 7. :sur: h2-s
he_s
calendered the deadli::l.e
deadli::1e fo:-: fo:c ~ilinq
=ilinq of cf -:he
~he
::he reoui~ed
reoui:.-:ed
rtemcrand'xT. and the permittee.
r.lemcrandu'i'. perm':"ttE:c c.ff.ids.vi-::,s
aff.id3.vi'::s or -­
c:.cclarations in sJpport of tr.a-:
c.eclarations t:ta:: mo-:icr.
tr.a-= mc::ien fer October
mo~icr. October
20~1 as the 10th day falls 2n
1, 2C<)7 =he preceoi~g
':he preceoi~g
.:n -=he ;:r~ce8.ir~g
'",'eekend.
'1,'eekend.
=c give notice.
Clerk ':c
CEET:?=CA~E OF
CLER~'S CERT:::C:CA'='E OF MAILI~G/
MAILI~G/

Page 1 of DE?? T,'iK-l

MIWJTES
MINUTES ENTERED
ENTERED ll
3 1.'iK-I 03/20/07
C'3/20/07 II
COUNTY
COUNTY CLERK
CLERK .

I
 ,. 69/76
page # added-jhz
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES
ANGELES

DA1'E' 09/ L 0 Ii,i ::."7

DATE: 09/LO/':·, ~. f \·<lEE
DEPT. \-'lEE
DEPT.

HO~OR",BLE .F.ll';1~_
HO~OR",BLE
HO:-<OMBLE 1'.11';1:_ C. c. Goodman JlDGE,
llDGE
llDGE!
",
=-.
~. S.:lI..LL3BTJR':!
SALI.:3BUR~
SALI.:3BTjR~ DEpr;n: CLERK
E. HALL, CS~.
p es~.
HOl\OR..-'lBLE
HOt'OR..-\BLE
HOI"OR..-\BLE JCDGE TE.\J II
leDGE PRO l'E,\J
l'f,\J _. ELECTRO:-<IC RECORDI"G
ELECTRO~IC RECORDI"G \to~nOR
\lOKITOR
ORDE?
Depu\>
DepUlY Sh~rjffIL;J::J~
Sh~[jffIL;J)J~
38:: :332·
2· ar:tll
ap.lli sec
SCC87!,OO
8 7':' 0(I Plaimifl'
Plaimifl-
Coun,d
COUf"d
I ~rnE
~rJIE SAiV'AA1\)"
SAtVAAN :NO A??EARANCES
Dcf;td.lm
D~b,j.lm
Dcf;;/,j.lm
. .T
I .... .TOSEPH
. OSEPH ZERKle<:
ZERKI?:: C0unsel
CQunsel
CQullsel
TRNSFRRED TO WLA-DEPT.H.OK 9/11 9 11
RECUSAL JACQ~ELIKE COKKOR,
RECTjSAL - JACQ~ELlKE
JACQ~ELIKE COKKOR,' JC
CCP ~'0.6~70.6 - JUDGE ~EIDORF
~ElDORF

~-A HIRE or PROCEEDI:'\GS:

:\-AHIRE PROCEEDI~GS:

NCTICE O?
NCT:CE EN=~~
EN=~':!
EN=~~ OF 0RD~R
GRD~R

_I
_I '::he
~he beL)"I'.'
below DC'-med Execut.ive Of~ice~/Cle~k
named Executive Of=i·.:::::e:::-/Cle:::-k of the
a::Jove-ent':"tlec.
a~ove-ent~tled cour=, ccur-::, de hereby ce~t~fy
ce:::t::.fy that I:: ~m ~rn n~­
n~­
a parry
parLy to tG t~e cause ~erein, and t~at this da~e da~e I
serveci ~c~ice of
served ~c':i::::>2: af K'1tr'y
E~try o~ 0:: ~he a::Jove Tin~~e
'[he a~ove :r.in'Jt.e order of of
9/20/97,upo~
9!20/97,upo~
9/20/07 upon each ~a~tY,G~
pa:::-tv or counse~,~aTed
ccunse~ na:r.ed below by
de?csiti~g
de?Cs~tl~g in ~he unltea
In ':he
=he Cnit~d
Lnltea Staces Tai~ ~=
~taces Tal_ ~~ ~he courthouse
a': ~he ccurthous8
in w. ~os Angeles, Ca~ifo~~ial
Ca~ifo~~iaf one co~y copy
cc~y cf ~he
-::he
2f =he
crigi:-tal entered
origi:-tal
crigi~al herein i::1
er.tered hel-ein separa-::e seale::i
seoc:,r2,:E:
i~ a sepc:,r2.=e seale~ er_velope
er~velope
~cr eac~, addressed as show::1
=cr shOW::1 below
show~ belo~ wit~ ~it~ the postage
:he~eo~ fully pre}aid.
-::he::ceor:. prepaid.
Da~e: Septerlber
Date: Septerber 20, 2007
A,
A. C~3~ke,
C~a~ke,
C~a~kel Exec~tive Office~/Clerk
Exec~tive Office~/Clerk
Office:::-/Clerk

Mulli~ Rich=er
2heppar6 Mullin
Shepparo Rich~er &
Rich-::er 3amptG~ LLP
Kest.3varzi
Kesl':.avarzi
Moe Ke:sl':.avarzi
~8t~ Flo'::J:::­
48t~
48L'1 F1Q:J~
SOLt~ Eope St~eet
333 SOLt~
333
Les
La sAng
Los e ~ c SICA.
Ange~~SI
Angeles, 9 CC7 ~ -. 1.4 4 8
CA. 9CC7~-1448
9CC7~-·l448

L:oseph ZerniJ.::
..::'"osePh ZerniJ.:
Zernik
~:l~ lr\C\~l;~'.'~e
~:l~
~:l~
lII
l~-\\t;~')~eqo212
lr'\l~v~eqo212qo212 r --
,- ---------
--
r----------~ --
----,
MINUTES ENTERED
ENTERED
?ace 2 of 3 =:EPT. \'JEH 9 / ::: ,~,,~, / c: 7
::;,::;-:'9/2'~'/C7
COUNTY
COUNTY CLERK
CLERK
 70/76
page # added-jhz

SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES

DATE
DATE C9/2G/07
C9/20/07 DEPT. ".J3H
JUDGE
JUDGE
JlTDGE S3CRY
D. SALI S3T;RY DEPlllY CLERK
DEPllT'l- CLERX
B. HAIJIJ,
B. CSL.
HAI.J~, CSL.
HALL,
Wj~jORAELE
Wj~iORAELE
Wj~iORAELE JlTDGE PRO TEt-.1
JLTDGE T£l>l ELECTRO:-JIC
ELECTRO~lC
ELECTRO~lC RECORVI:\'G \lOJ\lTOR
RECORDI:\'G \lOJ\lTOR
O?.L'SP
CJ?.L'SP
Depmy Sheriff
Depury :-JO:-J:=:
)JO)J:=:
)JO::-J:=:

2~30 anlSC087400
2:30 <:1818<:027400
aniSCOS7400 Plaimiff
Plalnri
Plalnrifi
ff
Counsel
~HV::r:E
~HV::r:E SAf'I"JlI.A....'J
SAVJlI...A...'J
;JS
'1S
'JS Defendam
Defendarn
Defendam
JOSEP:~·1
JOSEP~ ZERNIK Counsel
Counsel
~R~SFRRE~
~K~SFRRE~ ~O W~A-DE?~.E.ON
~R~SFRRE~ W~A-DE?~.E.ON
WLA-DE?~.E.ON 9/11
~~C0SAL
~~C~SAL - ~ACQUE~INE
~ACQUEIJINE CONNO:::<', JU
c::'"ACQUELINE CONNO~,
:~::J="J"SAL
CCP 170.6 - CUDGE NEIDO~F
NEIDO:::<.F
NATl:RL
NATllIT OF PROCEEDl\"GS:
PROCEEDI~'GS:

3eve~J_~'
3ev~::1~' Hills, CA.
C."A... 30212
90212

MINUTES ENTERED
ENTERED
g~~~~C~LERK
g~~~~C6LERK
g~~i~C~LERK ~
Page 3 of
 71/76
page # added-jhz
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES

DATE: 10/10/07 DEPT. WEO

HONORABLE JOHN L. SEGAL JUDGE ELMA MORA DEPUTY CLERK
AVA FRASER CRT ASST
HONORABLE JUDGE PRO TEM ELECTRONIC RECORDING MONITOR

NONE Deputy Sheriffll NONE Reporter

10:30 am SC087400 Plaintiff

Counsel
NIVIE SAMAAN no appearances
VS Defendant
JOSEPH ZERNIK Counsel
RECUSAL - JUDGES A.GOODMAN; J.
BIDERMAN; & J. CONNOR;
CCP 170.6 - JUDGE NEIDORF
NATlIRE OF PROCEEDINGS:

The Court now rules on Defendant/Cross-Complainant's

ex parte application to restore and safeguard due
process rights argued and taken under submission on
October 10, 2007 as follows:

Defendant/Cross-complainant's ex parte application

to restore and safeguard due process rights is
denied.
Clerk to give notice via U.S. Mail.
CLERK'S CERTIFICATE OF MAILING/
NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER
I, the below named Executive Officer/Clerk of the
above-entitled court, do hereby certify that I am not
a party to the cause herein, and that this date I
served Notice of Entry of the above minute order of
10/10/07 upon each party or counsel named below by
depositing in the United States mail at the courthouse
in Los Angeles, California, one copy of the
original entered herein in a separate sealed envelope
for each, addressed as shown below with the postage
thereon fully prepaid.
Date: October 11, 2007
John A. Clarke, Executive Officer/Clerk

MINUTES ENTERED
Page 1 of 3 DEPT. WEO 10/10/07
COUNTY CLERK
 72/76
page # added-jhz
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES

DATE 10/10/07 DEPT. WEO

HONORABLE JOHN L. SEGAL JUDGE ELMA MORA DEPUTY CLERK

AVA FRASER
FRASER CRT ASST
HONORABLE JUDGE PRO TEM ELECTRONIC
ELECTRONIC RECORDING MONITOR

NONE Deputy Sheriff NONE Reporter

II

10:30 am SC087400 Plaintiff

Plaintiff
Counsel
NIVIE SAMAAN no appearances
VS Defendant
Defendant
JOSEPH ZERNIK Coomd
RECUSAL - JUDGES A.GOODMAN; J.
BIDERMAN; & J. CONNOR;
CCP 170.6 - JUDGE NEIDORF
NATllRE OF PROCEEDINGS:

By:
ELMA MORA
SULLIVAN, WORKMAN & DEE, LLP
ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT
CHARLES D. CUMMINGS
800 SOUTH FIGUEROA STREET., TWELFTH FLOOR
LOS ANGELES, CA 90017-2521
THE LAW DEPT. OF COLDWELL BANKER RESIDENT
ROBERT J. SHULKIN
11611 SAN VICENTE BLVD., NINTH FLOOR
LOS ANGELES, CA 90049-6510
SHEPPARD, MULLIN, RICHTER & HAMPTON
ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF
333 SOUTH HOPE STREET, 48TH FLOOR
LOS ANGELES, CA 90071-1448
JOSEPH ZERNIK
DEFENDANT, & DEFENDANT IN PRO PER
320 SOUTH PECK DRIVE
BEVERLY HILLS, CA 90212
BRYAN CAVE
ATTORNEY FOR INTERVENOR
120 BROADWAY
SUITE 300
Sm~TA MONICA,
Sm~TA CA 90401-2305
EDWARD A. HOFFMAN

MINUTES ENTERED
Page 2 of 3 DEPT. WEO 10/10/07
COUNTY CLERK
 73/76
page # added-jhz
LOS ANGELES
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES

DATE: 10/10/07 DEPT.

DEPT. WEO
WEO
HONORABLE JOHN L. SEGAL JUDGE
JUDGE MORA
ELMA MORA DEPUTY
DEPUTY CLERK
CLERK
AVA FRASER
FRASER CRT
CRT ASST
ASST
HONORABLE JUDGE
JUDGE PRO
PRO TEM
TEM ELECTRONIC
ELECTRONIC RECORDING
RECORDING MONITOR
MONITOR

NONE Deputy
Deputy Sheriff
Sheriff NONE Reporter
Reporter

10:30 am SC087400 Plaintiff

Plaintiff
Counsel
Counsel
NIVIE SAMAAN no
no appearances
appearances
VS Defendant
Defendant
JOSEPH ZERNI K Counsel
Counsel
RECUSAL - JUDGES A.GOODMAN; J.
BIDERMAN; & J. CONNOR;
CCP 170.6 - JUDGE NEIDORF
NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS:

ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT

11620 WILSHIRE BLVD.
SUITE 340
LOS ANGELES, CA 90025

INUTES ENTERED
INUTES ENTERED II

Page 3 of 33 DEPT.
DEPT. WEO
WEO
I11 10/11/07
10/11/07
COUNTY
COUNTY CLERK
CLERK